Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
1
CVNG 3016 DESIGN OF ENVIRONMENTAL SYSTEMS
TOPIC: Design of Reinforced Concrete Liquid Retaining Structures
LECTURER: Dr.WilliamWilson
DESIGNOFREINFORCEDCONCRETETANKS(ACI318/ACI350)
Recommended Reading:
A. Codes
1. ASCE7-05 - Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and other Structures
2. ACI 318-06 Building Code requirements for Reinforced Concrete
3. ACI 350R 06 Environmental Engineering Concrete Structures.
B. Technical Literature
1. Munshi, Javeed A. Rectangular Concrete Tanks (Rev. 5
th
Ed.), Portland Cement
Association, 1998.
2. Portland Cement Association, 1992. Underground Concrete Tanks
3. Portland Cement Association, 1993. Circular Concrete Tanks without prestressing
RECTANGULARTANKS
DesignConsiderations
Flexure bendinginwallsandbase
Shear - wall-to-base, wall-to-wall junctions
Tension - horizontal tension in walls, base
Deflection vertical/ horizontal deflections of wall
Cracking - thermal, flexural, tension cracks
Flotation - when base is located below water table level
Base Fixity - (i) Fixed (ii) Pinned
LoadingConditions
Condition 1 - Internal Water Pressure only (before backfilling, i.e. leakage test)
Condition 2 - External Earth Pressure only (before filling tank)
Condition 3 - Tank full and Soil backfilled (resistance provided by soil is ignored)
in reality neither of these
conditions may actually exist
Both may need to be investigated
UWU/Civil&EnvironmentalEngineeringCVNG3016DesignofEnvironmentalEngineeringSystems 2010
2
M (-)
M
M M (-)
F
t
F
t
F
t
F
t
F
v
F
v
F
v
F
v
(shear)
+
-
(b) Vertical Forces
(a) Liquid pressure in Tank
(c) Horizontal Forces
F
v
F
v
F
v
F
v
M (+)
Moments
pinned base
fixed base
FIGURE 1 FORCES IN RECTANGULAR TANK WALLS
UWU/Civil&EnvironmentalEngineeringCVNG3016DesignofEnvironmentalEngineeringSystems 2010
3
STRENGTHDESIGNMETHOD
Basic Requirement:
Design Strength Required Strength
(Nominal Strength) U
n
R U
(ACI 318 Sect. 9.2) U = 1.4 (D + F) (2.1)
(ACI 350 cl. 2.6.5) U = 1.7 (D + F) (2.2)
D = dead load
F = liquid pressure
Sanitary Durability Factors - ACI 350 applies sanitary durability factors (based on crack width
calculations) to obtain the Required Strength
Required Strength = Sanitary Coefficient x U
U
r
= C
s
x U (2.3)
Sanitary Coefficients are:
C
s
= 1.3 (bending)
C
s
= 1.65 (direct tension / hoop tension)
C
s
= 1.3 (shear beyond shear capacity of concrete stirrup design)
C
s
= 1.0 (concrete shear)
Strength Design Requirements
(a) Flexural Reinforcement
Design Strength 1.3U
M
n
1.3(1.4M
D
+ 1.7 M
L
+1.7 M
F
) (2.4)
(b) Direct Tension Reinforcement
Design Strength 1.65U
N
n
1.65(1.4N
D
+ 1.7N
L
+1.7N
F
) (2.6)
UWU/Civil&EnvironmentalEngineeringCVNG3016DesignofEnvironmentalEngineeringSystems 2010
4
(c) Stirrup Shear Reinforcement
Design Strength 1.3 (V
c
- V
c
)
V
s
1.3 (V
u
- V
c
) (2.7)
(d) Concrete Shear and Compression Reinforcement
Design Strength 1.0 U
V
n
1.0V
u
(2.8)
(e) Minimum reinforcement (ACI 318-05 cl. 10.5)
3
c
w
s, min w
y y
f
b d
A b d 200
f f
=
(2.9)
(f) Minimum cover = 2 in.
(g) Minimum thickness for walls over 10 ft. high = 12 ins.
Serviceability for Normal Sanitary Exposure (ACI 350, cl. 2.6.6)
Crack Control
Maximum Design crack width
Severe exposure = 0.010 in.
Aesthetics = 0.008 in.
Crack width calculation is based on the following equation:
3
s c
z=f d A
(2.10)
Where,
Z is a quantity limiting distribution of flexural reinforcement
(ACI 350 limits)
z 115 kips/in (crack width = 0.010 in)
z 95 kips/in (crack width = 0.008 in)
Concrete sections with t 24 use
minimum temperature and
shrinkage reinforcement at each
face based on 12 thickness.
Size of rebar #11
Max. spacing of rebar 12
Minimum cover in tank walls = 2
UWU/Civil&EnvironmentalEngineeringCVNG3016DesignofEnvironmentalEngineeringSystems 2010
5
f
s
= calculated stress in reinforcement at service loads, ksi
d
c
= concrete cover to centroid of closest rebar
A = effective area of concrete surrounding flexural reinforcement with same
centroid divided by the number of bars, in
2
.
The maximum spacing it given by,
3
w 2 3
c s
Z
b
2d f
=
(2.11)
t
b
w
d
c
A= 2d
c
b
w
Fig. 1.0 - Calculation of A
UWU/Civil&EnvironmentalEngineeringCVNG3016DesignofEnvironmentalEngineeringSystems 2010
6
EXAMPLE 1 RectangularTank
Design Data
Weight of Liquid, w = 70 lbs/ft
3
Weight of Soil,
s
= 100 lbs/ft
3
k
a
= 0.3
'
c
f = 4000 psi
f
y
= 60,000 psi
Wall thickness, t = 18 in.
Base slab projection beyond wall = 2.5 ft.
Water pressure at base, p = wa = 70 x 10 = 700 lbs/ft
2
Longitudinal Section
Cross Section
Plan
30'-0
2
0
'
-
0
20'-0
1
0
'
-
0
3
5
0
2.5'
Fig. E1 Plan and sections of Tank
30'-0
UWU/Civil&EnvironmentalEngineeringCVNG3016DesignofEnvironmentalEngineeringSystems 2010
7
DesignforVerticalBendingMoments
Wall considered fixed at base and free at top
Using PCA Charts to calculate moments (Table 3-29: case 3 Long side)
Ratio of length/height = b/a = 30/10 = 3.0 (long side)
Ratio of width/height = c/a = 20/10 = 2.0 (short side)
M
x
= C
Mx
x pa
2
/1000
= C
Mx
x 700 x 10
2
/ 1000
= C
Mx
x 70 ft-lbs
= C
Mx
x 0.84 in-kips
For sanitary structures - M
u
= Sanitary coef x 1.7 x M
M
ux
= 1.3 x 1.7 x M
x
M
ux
= 1.3 x 1.7 x C
Mx
x 0.84 in-kips
= 1.86 x C
Mx
Maximum positive moment at 0.7 a (C
Mx
= +10) M
ux
= +18.6 kips-in
Maximum negative moment at bottom (C
Mx
= -129) M
ux
= -239.9 kips-in
Assuming No. 5 bars at 12in. c/c
Cover = 2 in.
Wall thickness = 18 in.
d = 18 2 5/16 = 15.7 in. (d
b
= 5/8 in.)
M = + 18.6 kips-in
M = - 239.9 kips-in
Fig E2 Vertical Moments at mid-length
a = 10'
V = 3500 lbs
UWU/Civil&EnvironmentalEngineeringCVNG3016DesignofEnvironmentalEngineeringSystems 2010
8
(From Appendix A) = 0.023
'
2 c
s
y
f 4
A =bd 0.023x12x15.7x 0.29in
f 60
= =
Checkminimumsteel (ACI 318-05 cl. 10.5)
'
3 3
c 2
smin w
y
f
4000
A = b d= x12x15.7=0.595in
f 60000
200 b
w
d/f
y
2 w
y
200b d 200x12x15.7
= = =0.628in
f 60,000
(governs)
(ACI 318 -05 cl. 10.5.3) Use 4/3 of A
s
required by analysis
A
s
= 4/3 x 0.29 = 0.39in
2
Provide No. 5 @ 9 in c/c on inside face (A
s
=0.41 in
2
)
DesignforHorizontalBendingMoments
Fig. E3- Horizontal Forces (un-factored) at mid-height of tank)
NB: Shear Forces calculations on Page 9 below
+35.93 in-kip
+35.93
1890 lbs
1890 lbs
-65.6 in-kip
-65.6 -65.6
-65.6
2590 lbs
2590
1890 1890
1890
2590
2590
2
5
9
0
2
5
9
0
1890
( )
2
2
c
M 239.9
=0.0225
f bd 0.9x4x12x 15.7
=
UWU/Civil&EnvironmentalEngineeringCVNG3016DesignofEnvironmentalEngineeringSystems 2010
9
(a) At Corner - Horizontal Moment Steel
M
uy
= 1.3 x 1.7 x 65.66
M
uy
= 145.1 in-kips
u
1 2 2
c
M 145.1
= =0.0136
f bd 0.9x4x12x15.7
(From Appendix A)
= 0.014
'
2 c
s
y
f 4
A =bd =0.014x12x15.7x =0.18in
f 60
(b) Steel required for Direct Tension in Long Wall
Factored tension N
u
= 1.65 x 3213 = 5301 lbs/ft width
2 u
s
y
N 5301
A = = =0.1in
0.9f 0.9x60,000
Direct tension steel is equally distributed on inside and outside faces of wall.
Total steel required on inside face =
2
0.1
0.18+ =0.23in
2
2 w
s,min
y
200b d
A = =0.625in
f
(governs)
4/3 of A
s
required by analysis = 4/3 x 0.23 = 0.31 in
2
Provide No.5 @ 12 in (A
s
= 0.31 in
2
) horizontal steel on inside face of long walls.
UWU/Civil&EnvironmentalEngineeringCVNG3016DesignofEnvironmentalEngineeringSystems 2010
10
(c) Horizontal steel near centre of outside face of wall
Design for M = 40.91 in-kips
(d) CrackControl - Check Maximum Spacing of bars
Maximum un-factored moment
( )
239.9
M= =108.6in-kips
1.7x1.3
Stress in steel reinforcement
s
s
M
f =
A jd
A
s
= 0.41 in
2
/ft d = 15.7 in
( )
29,000
n= = 8
57 4000
( )
0.41
0.00218
12 x 15.7
= =
( )
2
2 0.17 k n n n = + =
j = 1 k/3 = 0.94
s
108.6
f = =17.95ksi
0.41x0.94x15.7
( )
3
max
2 3
c s
z
s =
2xd xf
d
c
= cover + 2 0.313=2.313in
2
= +
z = 115 kips/in
f
s
= 17.95 ksi
3
max
2 3
115
s = =24.6in>9in
2x2.313 x17.95
OK
UWU/Civil&EnvironmentalEngineeringCVNG3016DesignofEnvironmentalEngineeringSystems 2010
11
DesignforShearForces
Using PCA Charts to calculate moments (Table 2-17: CASE 3 Long side)
Ratio of length/height = b/a = 30/10 = 3.0 (long side)
Ratio of width/height = c/a = 20/10 = 2.0 (short side)
Shear, V = C
s
x p x a
(a) Check Shear at bottom of Wall
Maximum shear at bottom of long wall,
V = 0.50 x 700 x 10 = 3500 lbs
u
V =1.7x3500=5950 lbs
Since tensile force from adjacent wall is small
'
c c
V =2 f bd
=2 4000x12x15.7 = 23,831 lbs
OK
1
0
'
P
3500 lbs
k
3500 lbs
2500 lbs
2500 lbs M
ls
= 8497 ft-lb
M
ss
= 15,413 ft-lb
Vls
V
s
=
4150 lbs
Fig E4 Forces on Base Slab
UWU/Civil&EnvironmentalEngineeringCVNG3016DesignofEnvironmentalEngineeringSystems 2010
14
( ) ( ) ( )
( )
2
Wall Dead load 150 2 x 1.5 x 10 x 30 + 0.75 + 20+0.75 = 231,750 lbs
Factored DL = 1.4(231,750) = 324,450 lbs
324,450
= 509 lbs/ft
30.75 x 20.75
p
=
=
Using PCA Tables
M
ss
(short span) = 78 x 509 x 20
2
/1000 = 15,881 ft-lb = 191 in-k
M
ls
(long span) = 43 x 509 x 20
2
/ 1000 = 8755 ft-lb = 105in-k
V
ss
= 0.24 x 509 x 20 = 2443 lbs = 2.4 k
V
ls
= 0.42 x 509 x 20 = 4276 lbs = 4.3 k
F
t
(long span) = 0.4 x 700 x 10 = 2800 lbs
Design of Short Span
Assume slab thickness, h = 12 ins.
For #6 bars and 2 cover
d = 12 2 0.75/2 = 9.625 ins.
Short Span
(a) Mid-span Moment Steel
(NB: ACI 350 is silent on use of sanitary coefficient for slabs, but we will apply
same here)
M
uy
= 1.3 x 191
M
uy
= 248.3 in-kips
u
' 2 2
c
M 248.3
= = 0.062
f bd 0.9 x 4 x 12 (9.625)
(From Appendix A)
3.5 k
191 in-k
2.4k
1
2
UWU/Civil&EnvironmentalEngineeringCVNG3016DesignofEnvironmentalEngineeringSystems 2010
15
= 0.064
'
2 c
s
y
f 4
A =bd =0.064 x 12 x 9.7x = 0.49in
f 60
(b) Steel required for Direct Tension in short span
Factored tension N
u
= 1.65 x 3500 = 5775 lbs/ft width
2 u
s
y
N 5775
A = = =0.11in
0.9f 0.9x60,000
Direct tension steel is equally distributed on inside and outside faces of slab.
Total steel required on top face =
2
0.11
0.49+ =0.55 in
2
( )
2 w
s,min
y
200 12 x 9.7
200b d
A = = = 0.39 in
f 60000
4/3 of A
s
required by analysis = 4/3 x 0.55 = 0.73 in
2
Provide No.6 @ 7 in crs. (A
s
= 0.75 in
2
) steel on top face of slab in short
direction.
(c) Long Span
M
uy
= 1.3 x 105 in-kips
M
uy
= 136.5 in-kips
d = 12 -2 -0.625- 0.625/2 = 9.0625
u
1 2 2
c
M 136.5
= = 0.0385
f bd 0.9 x 4 x 12 x 9.0625
(From Appendix A)
= 0.039
UWU/Civil&EnvironmentalEngineeringCVNG3016DesignofEnvironmentalEngineeringSystems 2010
16
'
2 c
s
y
f 4
A =bd =0.039 x 12 x 9.0625x = 0.283 in
f 60
Steel required for Direct Tension in long span
Factored tension N
u
= 1.65 x 2800 = 4620 lbs/ft width
2 u
s
y
N 4620
A = = =0.085in
0.9f 0.9x60,000
Direct tension steel is equally distributed on inside and outside faces of slab.
Total steel required on top face =
2
0.085
0.283+ =0.326 in
2
( )
2 w
s,min
y
200 12 x 9.7
200b d
A = = = 0.39 in
f 60000
(governs)
4/3 of A
s
required by analysis = 4/3 x 0.31 = 0.41 in
2
Provide No.5 @ 8 in crs