Running head: ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 1
Assistive Technology Device: The Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat
Hayley J. Meredith Touro University Nevada
ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 2
The Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat This adaptive device was designed to benefit people with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) who participate in yoga. The Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat assists in rolling the yoga mat up, replaces repetitive hand movements, and encourages engagement in yoga as both an occupation and exercise program. Yoga has many health related benefits for people with RA which will be explained later in detail later. There is evidence-based research to support the purpose of the Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat, and how it can enhance function performance of this population. There is no other product available for purchase like this adaptive device. A consultation with Caren Strait, a gentle yoga instructor in Henderson, Nevada, was conducted for project and she showed support the potential for this device with her yoga students. The Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat is a practical solution to ensure continued engagement in yoga for clients with RA without fear of generating pain when operating their yoga mat. Introduction to Rheumatoid Arthritis RA is a chronic condition which is often unpredictable and may lead to long term disability. RA is the most common type of autoimmune arthritis and affects at least 1.3 million adults in the United States (Rheumatoid Arthritis, 2014). About 75% of those affected are women and the disease most often begins in the fourth and sixth decades of life (Rheumatoid Arthritis, 2014). However, RA can begin at any age. Being an autoimmune disease, RA causes cells of the bodys immune system to dysfunction and attack healthy tissue in the joints (rheumatology.org). In RA, the focus of inflammation is in the tissue that lines the joint, known as the synovium (Rheumatoid Arthritis, 2014). The immune cells release inflammation-causing chemical which damage the joint cartilage which cushions the joint between the bones ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 3
(Rheumatoid Arthritis, 2014). The ultimate result is a disabling and painful condition which can lead to the loss of functioning and mobility if left untreated. Treatment for Rheumatoid Arthritis Pharmacological and non-pharmacological are current treatment options for those suffering from RA. There is no cure for RA, but treatments are accomplished to improve symptoms and slow the progression of the disease. Goals of treatment are to minimize experienced symptoms such as pain and swelling, to prevent bone deformity, and to maintain daily functioning. Medicinal treatment can be achieved by analgesics and disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs (Lifestyle and Home Remedies, 2013). However, management of RA also includes lifestyle changes, complementary alternative medicine, dietary supplements, and surgery (Lifestyle and Home Remedies, 2013). Regular exercise, a healthy diet, and good stress management are golden rules that can benefit everyone. However for clients with RA, these lifestyle changes can help manage a chronic disease. Lifestyle Remedies There are several self-care measures that client can use along with RA medication to manage their symptoms at home. Regular exercise and relaxation are recommended by the Arthritis Foundation (2014). They suggest that an exercise regime may be just what a client needs to ease their pain and improve their energy level. Studies show that regular RA exercise may help to reduce joint pain and stiffness, increase joint mobility and muscle strength, and improve psychological well-being (Rheumatoid Arthritis, 2014). Yoga is a practice of exercises, breathing techniques, and meditation that began in ancient India 5,000 years ago, and is proven to help people with arthritis improve many of their physical and psychological symptoms (Rheumatoid Arthritis, 2014). Gentle yoga for clients with arthritis includes slow and gentle ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 4
poses, which help to spread lubrication like synovial fluid and the nutrients around the joints in the body (C. Strait, personal communication, 2014). Innovation of the Device & Clientele The Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat is an assistive device designed to accommodate the needs of clients with RA, specifically adults. This idea for this device was conceived during a yoga class at Trufusion Yoga studio in Las Vegas after a woman was struggling to roll up her yoga mat after a class. Caren Strait, a gentle yoga instructor in Henderson, Nevada was contacted for consultation on this project. In an interview, she stated, I do have students with arthritis and other issues in the hands. It can make it tough to roll a [yoga] mat; especially on the bad days (C. Strait, personal communication, 2014). There are many adults who are involved with yoga as a means of exercise and relaxation to maintain their RA symptoms who could benefit from an assistive yoga mat. Caren Strait also defends how RA can affect the clients participation in their program, Some people would have to skip class, or have a private lesson where the teacher sets up the mat and props (C. Strait, personal communication, 2014). When asked if she believed this assistive device would benefit her clients with RA she stated, I think this has promise, not just for arthritis, but for amputees, persons recovering from stroke or traumatic brain injury, persons with multiple sclerosis, and many more! ... they could sit in the chair or use it for more stability while picking up the mat and using the self-rolling feature (C. Strait, personal communication, 2014). Purpose of Assistive Device This adapted device was developed to assist adults with RA who participate in yoga, so that they no longer struggle rolling up their mat or flare up their hand and wrist pain by trying to do so. Pain and reduced grip are major symptoms in RA (Nordenskild and Grimby, 1996), and ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 5
clients would experience difficulty rolling up the yoga mat because of painful inflammation in joints, and muscle weakness. Activity demands are specific features that influence the type and amount of effort required to perform an activity (Occupational Therapy Practice Framework, 2014). The activity demands required to roll up a yoga mat in the tradition way include particular body functions. These required body functions are neuromusculoskeletal and movement-related functions of joints and bones, such as joint stability and mobility. Muscle functions like strength and endurance are also required. To roll a classic yoga mat, the client must then perform repetitive fine motor movements of the fingers, hands, and wrists to wind up one end of the mat, and then continue rolling it tightly to the other end. It is difficult to roll a yoga mat without telescoping to one side and requires bilateral fine motor movements and adjustments to roll it properly. A typical yoga mat is 68 inches and such a distance may become strenuous for a person with RA. Enhanced Functional Performance The Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat requires the use of both upper extremities to coordinate the device. One hand manipulates the mat, while the other stabilizes the frame. Once in a c-shaped grasp at the base of the mat, the client is required to perform a single wrist flexion movement to roll up their mat. Caren Strait enforced the importance of limiting repetitive movements while doing gentle yoga, We don't do a lot of repetitions or high stress movements, which can cause more inflammation (C. Strait, personal communication, 2014). There is added foam padding around the frame of the device which promotes comfort in the opposite hand while opposite hand holds the strap. The device, including the yoga mat, weighs a total of three pounds which is a feasible load for a client with RA to carry on their own. After timing the performance of the device, the spring-loaded mechanism generates the mat to easily roll up in less than 2 seconds. A ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 6
strap is attached to the frame so that the client eliminates the added task of adjusting a strap around the yoga mat before and after each session. Caren Strait spoke positively of the strap and padding in her interview, The padding will also make it more comfortable when carrying with the strap so the wood doesn't bump sensitive or inflamed areas (C. Strait, personal communication, 2014). Construction of the Device The construction of the Roll & Wrap Yoga Mat began at Home Depot where the roller window shade was cut to fit the width of the yoga mat, two feet wide. At home the wooden frame was first assembled. Wooden Frame A wooden one inch squared dowel was sawed into three portions. Two short four and a half inch sections, and one long twenty-six and a half piece. The ends of the two small rectangular pieces were attached perpendicularly with two screws each to each end of the longer portion. The hinges for the roller curtain shade were screwed in to the inside of the short legs of the wooden frame. Yoga Mat The curtain of the roller window shade was removed from the spring loaded roller mechanism. The yoga mat was then attached at one end to the cylindrical spring mechanism permanently with a staple gun. The yoga mat was then rolled by hand and placed into the hinges of the wooden frame. The device was tested and determined to be operational. Comfort and Aesthetics The long handle of the wooden frame was covered permanently with foam and fabric to add padding and comfort. Two eyelet screws were attached to the top of the short legs of the ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 7
frame so that a strap could be fixed. A small foam and fabric pad was sewn around the strap, and could be moved freely to adjust for comfort. Similar Devices & Vendors There are two known adapted yoga mats advertised on the internet, the Iku Mat and the Nadi Yoga Mat. Both were developed in 2012, but are each patent pending and not available for purchase. Although each of these mats provides an increased level of assistance than the classic yoga mat, neither was created with a specific diagnosis or disabled population in mind. Photographs are available in Appendix A. Iku Mat This mat was created with snap-bracelet- like technology. Creators used bi-stable spring material reengineered on a larger scale to incorporate it onto a yoga mat. To roll out the Iku Mat one end is dropped to the ground and it snaps flat. To roll it up it is flipped over and one end is lifted, or snapped (IKU MAT, 2012), up using a lateral pinch of the hand. The mat then rolls up onto itself without telescoping. The Iku Mat is advertised online, however it is not available to purchase. Nadi Yoga Mat This yoga mat is less assistive than the Iku Mat because it required more manual manipulation to operate. The Nadi mat uses magnets embedded in the cord of the foam in the yoga mat to reduce the frustration of using a yoga mat (Magnetized Exercise Mats, 2012). Tiny neodymium magnets are placed along the long edges of the mat at specific points. The additional weight of the magnets helps the mat to stay flat after unrolling, and when done practicing yoga the unobtrusive magnets aid in the rolling up of the mat and keeping the mat together during ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 8
transportation without a bag or strap (Magnetized Exercise Mats, 2012). This mat does require the client to manually roll up the mat but with more ease and in any hand position they choose. Comparable Cost Analysis Neither the Iku Mat nor Nadi Yoga Mat is available for purchase, so the cost analysis will compare the Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat to a classic single yoga mat. A classic yoga mat may be purchased for starting around $9.00 and can exceed $100.00 for elite models. The Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat is adapted specifically for clients with RA, includes a carrying strap, added padding, and cost less than $60.00 to construct. The cost analysis of the Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat is addressed in Table B of the appendix. Evidence-Based Research Women were the primary gender addressed in the literature review because they account for 75% of the RA population in the United States. Nordenskild and Grimby (1996) assessed the disability in women with RA in relation to their grip force and pain. The researchers used the Health Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ) to evaluate the relationship between grip force and pain, and the consequences to daily activities (Nordenskild and Grimby, 1996). Twenty women with RA that were assessed used various adaptive devices at home for activities such as eating, grip, and hygiene (Nordenskild and Grimby, 1996). The results showed that the participants had the most difficulty with hygiene activities like taking a shower or bath (Nordenskild and Grimby, 1996). The majority of women also answered unable to do for other activities like vacuuming, shopping, reaching, and opening jars (Nordenskild and Grimby, 1996). On average, each woman owned 15 adaptive devices, and 91 percent of those devices were used to complete daily activities. This proves that women with RA are utilizing adaptive equipment which allows them to participate in their desired occupations. ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 9
Results showed a large variation in the grip force, although there was significantly lower grip force for peak and average values than the control group (Nordenskild and Grimby, 1996). In fact, the average peak grip force value over 10 seconds in the RA participants was only 22% of the control groups values. While, the average grip forces value over 10 seconds was only 19% of the control values (Nordenskild and Grimby, 1996). These results represent the need for adaptation to support the 80% of omitted grip force of women with RA. Overall, there were significant correlations between pain, grip force, and the HAQ disability index. All women in the study reported pain with a large range of variation, and pain increased significantly after the grip force test (Nordenskild and Grimby, 1996). This indicates that pain in RA patients within the small joints of the hand and wrist, partially depends on circumstances. It is a practical solution to introduce more adaptive devices to this population to ensure continued engagement in occupations without fear of generating pain. The Roll & Wrap Yoga Mat is a perfect example of how this could be achieved with female clients who wish to easily utilize their yoga mat before and after their exercise programs. Evans, et al. (2013) from University of California at Los Angeles Medical Center conducted a six-week study of the effects of Iyengar yoga on a group of women with RA. The aim of this study was to assess the impact of a 6-week bi-weekly yoga program on quality of young adults with RA compared with a usual-care waitlist control group (Evans, et al., 2013). The participants were all women suffering with RA with a mean age of 28 (Evans, et al., 2013). This is a younger population to utilize as evidence; however RA treatment is focused on prevention and management. This younger population of women is significant because early diagnosis and prompt treatment is the key to preventing joint destruction and organ damage (Rheumatoid Arthritis, 2014). Researcher recorded weekly ratings of anxiety, depression, pain, ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 10
and sleep. On average there was 96 percent attendance rate to the yoga classes, and women assigned to the yoga program showed significantly greater improvement post treatment (Evans, et al., 2013). The results showed an immediate, positive impact on the participants after they completed questionnaires to measure pain, disability, mood, and function. There were significant improvements in standardized measures of quality of life, pain disability, general health, mood, fatigue, acceptance of chronic pain, and self-efficacy regarding pain (Evans, et al., 2013). Participants also sat for interviews where many explained that their day-to-day levels of pain had not changed, but their relationship to the pain had changed (Evans, et al., 2013). Almost half of the yoga group reported clinically meaningful symptom improvement and continued process at their two-month check-up. This evidence confirms that yoga should be encouraged as an intervention because it is an achievable and safe exercise-based treatment for women with RA. Conclusion The Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat provides enhanced functional performance for clients with RA who wish to participate in yoga classes. Occupational therapists should encourage yoga as an occupation for women with RA because it is an exercised-based program that may reduce joint pain and stiffness, increase joint mobility and muscle strength, and improve psychological well- being (Rheumatoid Arthritis, 2014). Caren Strait explained the importance of participation, One of the most important things people learn in Gentle Yoga is to honor the body, being aware of sensations present and listening to what the body needs in each moment of the practice. When people begin to learn to adjust their movements based on what they feel, they are more likely to take that into daily life (C. Strait, personal communication, 2014). Construction of the Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat consisted of three phases. There are two adapted yoga mats advertised the internet. However, The Iku Mat and Nadi Yoga Mat are not ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 11
available for purchase, and neither was created to assist a specific diagnosis or disabled population in mind. The evidence-based research review proved that yoga is a feasible and safe exercise-based treatment program for women with RA. Women with RA suffer from decreased grip force and increased pain in their hands and wrists that affect their functional daily activities. Furthermore, the Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat is a practical solution to ensure continued engagement in yoga for clients with RA without fear of generating pain when operating their yoga mat.
ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 12
Appendix A Table A Similar Devices and Vendors Comparision Type of Yoga Mat
Picture of Yoga Mat Price of Yoga Mat Where to Purchase
Rolling Yoga Mat
$56.76
Constructed by Hayley Meredith
Iku Mat
Not for sale
Not available for purchase
Nadi Yoga Mat
Not for sale
Not available for purchase
Classic Lotus Yoga Mat
$8.97
WalMart
ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 13
Appendix B Table B1 - Cost Analysis for the Rolling Yoga Mat - Essentials Item Cost Lotus Yoga Mat Classic 3mm $8.97 White Blackout Roller Shade $21.25 1 x 36 Hardwood Square $3.42 Inside Mount Roller Shade Bracket $0.98 4 Wood Screws $0.40 Staples $0.50
Total = $35.52
Table B2 - Cost Analysis for the Rolling Yoga Mat - Comfort and Aesthetics Item Cost 2 Eyelet Screws $0.59 Fabric $9.37 Foam Padding $4.32 Cotton Webbing Shoulder Strap $6.99
Total = $21.27
Total Price of the Roll and Wrap Yoga Mat = $56.76
ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY ROLL AND WRAP YOGA MAT 14
References AOTA. (2014). Occupational therapy practice framework: Domain and process (3rd ed.). American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 68(Suppl. 1), S1-S48. http://dx .doi .org/10 .5014/ajot .2014 .682006 Evans, S., Moieni, M., Lung, K., Tsao, J., Sternlieb, B., Taylor, M., et al. (2013). Impact of Iyengar Yoga on Quality of Life in Young Women With Rheumatoid Arthritis. The Clinical Journal of pain, 29(11), 988-997. Retrieved from http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/AJP.0b013e31827da381 IKU MATS. (2012). IKU MATS. Retrieved from http://ikumats.com/index.htm Magnetized Exercise Mats. (2012). TrendHunter.com. Retrieved from http://www.trendhunter.com/trends/nadi-yoga-mats Nordenskild, U., & Grimby, G. (1997). Assessments of disability in women with rheumatoid arthritis in relation to grip force and pain. Disability & Rehabilitation,19(1), 13-19. Retrieved from: http://web.b.ebscohost.com/ehost/detail?sid=f67d8ca5-b49c-4573-b594 efa10ae737df%40sessionmgr111&vid=9&hid=126 Rheumatoid arthritis. (2013). Lifestyle and home remedies. Retrieved from http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/rheumatoid-arthritis/basics/lifestyle- home-remedies/con-20014868 Rheumatoid Arthritis. (2014). Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA): Treatment Programs for Rheumatoid Arthritis Pain. Retrieved from http://www.arthritis.org/conditions-treatments/disease- center/rheumatoid-arthritis/ Personal Interview by Email Strait, C. (2014, May 22). Email interview.