Fact Finding Committee Report

REPORT OF THE FACT FINDING COMMITTEE (Gazetted Probationers Group A ! "##$% "###% &''( !
at)*es+
INTROD,CTION
This is the Report of the Fact Finding Committee (hereinafter referred to as the Committee) constituted by the Honble High Court of Karnataka ide order dated
!"#"$#!"%& in '( )o#!*+*,-!"%! c-. '( )o#,%&++-!"%!/ '( )o#!**&"-!"%!/ '( )o#,&*%0-!"%! 1 '( )os#,&*!"2*&!-!"%!/ '( )o#,!$*-!"%& and '( )o#%*&&-!"%&#
3n the allegations of illegalities and irregularities in the selection process for 4a5etted 4roup 6 1 7 posts in the three batches i5 %$$0/ %$$$ 1 !"",/ made in the '#(#
)o# %%88"-!""0 C-. '#(# )o# $"$0-!""$/ the Honble High Court of Karnataka had ordered a C9: en;uiry# The C9: submitted its report# <ome of the (etitioners in the
aforesaid petitions sought for further action on the C9: report by giing a representation to the 4oernment of Karnataka/ .hich .as not acceded to# 6ggrieed by this/
.rit petitions (as mentioned in the =rst paragraph/ aboe) came to be =led#
:uring the pendency of the proceedings in the aforesaid petitions/ the Karnataka (ublic <erice Commission (hereinafter referred to as the K(<C) =led a statement
before the Honble High Court indicating its stand on each of the =ndings gien in the C9: Report# 9n the said statement/ K(<C has indicated that a fe. of the =ndings are
correct and had also indicated that the remaining =ndings are incorrect#
>nder these circumstances/ the Honble High Court constituted a Fact Finding Committee (for short Committee)/ ide order dated !"#"$#!"%&/ for the purpose of
collecting and analy5ing the data maintained by the K(<C .ith regard to the selection process in the three batches i5 %$$0/ %$$$ 1 !"", 4a5etted 4roup 6 1 7 posts
and to submit report on the conclusions arried at on the analysis of the data#
(ursuant to the said order/ the Committee/ consisting of the Counsel for the (etitioners/ Counsel for the 4oernment/ Counsel for the K(<C and the Counsel on behalf of
the <elected Candidates/ .ith the assistance of the persons permitted ide the said order/ sought for information and data from the K(<C/ .ith regard to the said batches
of selection#
The First ?eeting .as called by the <ecretary of K(<C and the o@cials of K(<C .ere instructed to proide the information and data re;uested by the members of the
Committee#
The Committee has shifted the information and dataA the Committee has made an endeaor to =nd out the true facts .ith regard to the said selection process and on the
basis of the information and data proided/ the Committee has analy5ed the same and has come to certain conclusions/ .hich is the content of this Report#
6nneBures 29/ 99 and 999 of this report consists of & tabulated statements containing the particulars of all the selected candidates in all the & batches of 4a5etted
(robationers %$$0/ %$$$ and !"", 4roup 6 1 7 (osts# The Committee had occasion to erify all the ans.er scripts of each of the <elected Candidates in respect of %$$0
NOTE-T./ THIRD .A0,ATION%A./A.ERAGE .ARIATION% ORC/ORIGINA0 RE1ER.ATION CERTIFICATE% PT/PER1ONA0IT2 TE1T3
Pa4e "
REPORT OF THE FACT FINDING COMMITTEE (Gazetted Probationers Group A ! "##$% "###% &''( !at)*es+
and !"", batch and upon such eri=cation the committee has noticed certain facts (.hich include discrepancies)/ .hich hae been noted in the remarks column# These
are bare facts and all the members of the Committee are in agreement in respect of the remarks contained in the said & tabulated statements#
The Report consists of separate chapters .ith regard to the three batches along .ith anneBures containing tables/ documents and releant information# 'hereer the
members of the Committee do not agree/ respectie opinions hae also been incorporated#
Pa4e &
CHAPTER 5 "- "##$ !ATCH
I+ Ano6a7ies in t*e Moderation pro)essC
A3 Issue no3"- Annu77ed Mar8s ta8en into )onsideration 9or 6oderation
Analysis and conclusions drawn by Petitioner Members:
The (etitioner ?embers .ent into the aspect of the K(<C taking into account the marks a.arded by the Head - Chief DBaminer/ .hich had already been annulled by the
orders of this Honble Court in '#(# )o# %!8,0280$-!""!/ (the said '#(s .ere =led challenging the order dated "+2"!2!""! of K6T in 6pplication )os *$"%2*$"0-!""%)# The
order in the said #(# )o# %!8,0280$-!""!/ came to be con=rmed by the Honble <upreme Court in Ciil 6ppeal )os# +!!&2+&%!-!""8/ ide order dated "+-%"-!""8# The true
copy of the K6T order dated "+#"!#!""! is here .ith produced as Anne:ure- A/"3 True copy of the order of the Honble High Court in the said '#(s is produced here.ith
as Anne:ure- A/&# The true copy of the order dated "+#%"#!""8 of the Honble <upreme Court is produced here.ith as Anne:ure- A/;#
The (etitioner ?embers hae come to the conclusion that the conclusion - =ndings arried by the C9: in its report and also accepted by the K(<C ide a@dait
dated %0-$-!"%& =led on !"-"$-!"%& are correct# Thereby meaning that the K(<C ought not to hae taken into account the marks a.arded by Head DBaminer - Chief
DBaminer/ .hich .as one of the sources for discrepancies (into .hich the said '#(# )o# %!8,0280$-!""! took note of)#
First of all/ it .as total dis2regard and non2compliance of the order of the Honble High Court# <econdly/ anything Eo.ing from a contaminated source results in
further itiating the process/ .hich .as actually ordered to be recti=ed ide order of the Honble High Court# )on2compliance of the order of the Honble Court has itiated
the selection as the entire list has got aFected# 9t lead to unscienti=c and illogical increase or decrease of marks to all the candidates .hose ans.er scripts .ere subGected
for moderation and scaling and it defeated the ery purpose for .hich the order of moderation and scaling .as made by the Honble High Court# The (etitioner ?embers
endorse the table submitted in the C9: Report on this matter# 9t is gien to understand that the K(<C is in the process of rectifying this by complying .ith the order of the
Honble High Court and it .ould present the same before the Honble Court#
Analysis and conclusion of the KPSC Member:
The K(<C in its statement dated %02"$2!"%& =led before this Honble Court in '#(#)o#!*+*,-!"%! and connected matters/ .hich statement .as =led by the K(<C
indicating its stand on the =ndings of the C9: Report/ K(<C has admitted the =nding in the C9: Report that the annulled marks a.arded by the Head-Chief DBaminers hae
been taken into consideration for the purpose of moderation and scaling .hich .as done in pursuance of the order dated %%2%"2!""! passed in '#(#)o#%!8,0280$- !""!#
To .hat eBtent the said error .ould tilt the marks and ultimately the results .ould hae to be .orked out by the K(<C and in fact in the said statements the K(<C has
stated that it is redoing the eBercise of moderation and scaling by taking into consideration the marks a.arded by the original eBaminers# The result of such eBercise
carried on by the K(<C .ould be =led before this Honble Court#
Pa4e ;
!3 Issue No3 &- Ot*er <io7ations o9 t*e Order o9 t*e Honb7e Hi4* Court =it* re4ard to 6oderation pro)ess-
a+6s per the order of the Honble High Court (on the basis of the method suggested by the K(<C/ at (ara &$(b) of the order of the Honble High court in '#(# )o#
%!8,0280$-!""!) for the process of moderation/ ans.er scripts had to be picked in the follo.ing manner- %"H of the ans.er scripts in the subGects subGected to
moderation had to be picked up and in this %"H/ 8H of the ans.er scripts .ere to be the top leel ans.er scripts and the rest of the 8H randomly# 9t .as the duty of
the K(<C to comply .ith this direction and do the moderation and scaling process# The (etitioner ?embers found that this picking of the %"H ans.er scripts .as not
done as stated aboe# 9n many cases the top 8H of the ans.er scripts .ere not taken# The table gien belo. indicates this aspect#
1OME OF THE E>AMP0E1 ARE 1ET IN THE FO00O?ING TO I11,1TRATE THAT THE @A OF TOP AN1?ER 1CRIPT1 ?A1 AR!RITRIA02 PICBED ,P AND
.A0,ED THE AN1?ER 1CRIPT1 AND A1 A RE1,0T H,GE A.ERAGE .ARIATION I1 ARRI.ED AND THE !AD EFFECT OF THE ACTION RE1,0TED IN .ITIATION
OF ENTIRE 1E0ECTION3
TA!0E 1HO?ING (FE? E>AMP0E1+ THE TOP @A OF AN1?ER 1CRIPT1 NOT PICBED FOR MODERATION IN THE FO00O?ING E>AMINER ?I1E MODERATION C
1CA0ING DONE IN G3P/"##$ AN1?ER 1CRIPT13
TA!0E / A;
10
NO
E>AMINER NAME 1,!DECTCPAPER MARB1 PICBED A1 TOP TOP MARB1 IGNORED PAGE NO
A.ERAGE
.ARIATION OF
THE
E>AMINER
" 1H20ADA31 1OCIO0OG2/II "@"%"@E%"E"% "F' "$'%"#' "F /&'3F@
& MOHANOR GANTE ECNOMIC1/I "$@% &''%&"@ "@ /FF3F@
; M3DA2A1HANBAR RAO ECNOMIC1/II &&'% &&E & /"'&3@'
( HITTA0 MANE 13. ANTHROPO0OG2/I "F$%"$F "#"%"#&%&'& "(& /($3$;
@ A3B3BAMATE PH21IC1/I ";#%"('% "E(% " G("3EF
E PATI0 !3M GEOGRAPH2/I &"$%&&E% &(" "$ /$&
F CHIBBA1IDDA GO?DA GEOGRAPH2/II "F'%"F& "F(%"F$%"$"%"$'%"$E && /@'3EF
$ B,NDA3B3P P,!0IC ADMINI1TRATION/I "@&% "@@%"#E @& /@#
# 0INGARAD!31 GENERA0 1T,DIE1/I ";&%";#%"(( "@'%"E"%"$F "@E /('3&'
Pa4e (
"' MOHAMMED DAFR,00A GENERA0 1T,DIE1/& "&&%";;%";@% &''% ";; G&E3;;
"" 1HRIBANTAIAH3M3B 1OCIO0OG2/I ""&%""@%"&" "@(% (; /F3E
"& PARAME1H?ARAPPA A3! 1OCIO0OG2HII ";(%";E%"(@%"($%"@$ "@#%"EE%"E$%"E#% E /""3@E
"; NAGRAD3 ECONOMIC1/I "EE%"F@% &';% F G;
"( N3R 1HI.AM,RTH2 ECONOMIC1/I "@"%"@F "$' $ /3F@
"@ .ENBAT RAO P ANTRO/II "@;%"@@%"F'% "F&%"F$%"$&% "@%"E% /"F3F@
"E 0I0ATAMMA R,RA0DE.E0OPMENT/I $;%$@ $F%$#%"";% " G&E
"F DHA0APPA R3H R,RA0DE.E0OPMENT/II "@(%"@@%"E( "E$%"F'%"F@%&'F $ /"'
"$ DR313RAGH, I2ENGAR PH21IC1/I "E&%"$&%&"$% &&;% & /""3&@
"# 2! !A1A.ANNA PH21IC1/I "@F%"E@% &$@% F /"#3@'
&' DR3.3A3HERAMATH MATHEMATHI1/I &"$%&&@% &;'% @ G&"
&" NAGEGO?DA P,!0IC ADMINI1TRATION I "('%"F(% "F$%"$'%"$F% ;E I&'3"F
&& H3M3!A1A.ARAD, P,!0IC ADMINI1TRATION I ";@%";$%"(( "(@%"(E%"(F%"(#%"@E%"@#% @; /;3('
&; .EERA!HADRAIAH P,!0IC ADMINI1TRATION II "E$%"F;%"#$ "F'%"F@%"$'%"$#%&'& "$%"# G&3&'
&( MA00A1HAPPA!3C P,!0IC ADMINI1TRATION II ";&%"@"%"@E "@F%"E(%"EF%"F' &F%&$ /"$3&'
&@ 1HI.AM,RTH2 M GENERA0 1T,DIE1/" ";F%";#%"(@ "@@% && /"'3$'
&E RAMBRI1HNA3 GENERA0 1T,DIE1/" "&#% "($ (' /"#3@'
&$ RADAGO?DA GENERA0 1T,DIE1/" "&E%";E%"(E "E' &"" /F3;;
&# HOTAPETI3D3B GENERA0 1T,DIE1/" ";(%";@%"F@% &'' "'F /&(3(;
;' !A0A1HANTHA M,RTH2 GENERA0 1T,DIE1/" ""F%""$% "&F% "&#% G";3E'
;" RAMABRI1HNA 31 GENERA0 1T,DIE1/II "'E%""&% ""(%"&'%"&&%";( "'" G"#3EF
;& MARI1?AMM2 GENERA0 1T,DIE1/II "'F%""E%""$ "&'%"&;%";"%"&@% ";@% ""$ /"F3E
;; RADE GO?DA GENERA0 1T,DIE1/II "@(%"@@%"E'%"E& "E(%"#&% &'E /F3"(
;( !A1A.ARAD3M GENERA0 1T,DIE1/II "&$%";&%";E ";F%"('%"(@%"@& "@" /3&'
'hen it .as en;uired by the (etitioner ?embers as to the details of moderation/ method and process of picking ans.er scripts/ it .as disclosed by the BP1C (<ide 7etter
no- E("+ &;$(C";/"(CP1C% dated (C"&C&'";+ that this Gob of picking up the ans.er script .as outsourced to a priate company kno.n as MCs Co6at/ by the then
Pa4e @
<ecretary# 9t .as also disclosed by the K(<C in the said letter that K(<C is una.are as to the method adopted by the said Company in picking up the ans.er scripts for
moderation and scaling process# The releant eBtract of the said letter of K(<C is as follo.sC The process of picking 1! of scripts for moderation was entrusted
to M"s Comat by the then secretary and method adopted by them for picking the scripts for moderation is not known#$The said letter is enclosed along .ith
this report as Anne:ure- A/(3
T*e Petitioner Me6bers )on)7ude t*at-
i3 The K(<C has not complied .ith the order of this Honble Court een in this aspect of moderation/ resulting in tilting of the aerage ariation and thereby tilting
of total marks and therefore itiation of the process#
ii3 The K(<C should hae personally done its duty as an 6uthority entrusted .ith the Gob/ not only constitutionally/ but also upon the order of the Honble High Court
of Karnataka speci=cally in this matter#
iii3 K(<C ought to hae at least attempted to monitor that the order of the Honble Court is complied .ith strictly#
i<3 3utsourcing and non2monitoring of such a ital aspect of the process resulted in the itiation of the process#

6s per the guidelines the percentage of papers .hich are to be subGected to reie. by the Head DBaminer-Chief DBaminers is 8H of the top leel ans.er scripts and
oerall random reie. of %"H# 8H reie. prescribed is of the top leel ans.er scripts and not of the top 8H ans.er scripts# The petitioner members hae proceeded
on the assumption that the reie. is of the top 8H ans.er scripts and not the 8H of the top leel ans.er scripts# 9n my opinion in picking up the 8H of the top leel
ans.er scripts any ans.er script in the top leel (haing secured more than the aerage marks a.arded by a particular eBaminer being an aerage of the highest and
the lo.est marks a.arded by the particular eBaminer) can be picked and it is not necessary that the 8H of the top scoring candidates should be picked up for
aluation by the Head DBaminer-Chief DBaminer# Hence/ in my opinion/ the aforesaid analysis and conclusion on 9ssue )o#, arried at by the (etitioner members is
incorrect and based on a .rong premise#
b+ 6s per the order of the Honble High Court of Karnataka in '#(# )o# %!8,0280$-!""! Ikindly refer &$(b)J .hereer the aerage ariation arried at/ after moderation/
is less than plus or minus !" but indiidually if the ans.er script subGected for moderation and the diFerence of marks arried during realuation for moderation
Pa4e E
process is more than plus or minus !" than the DBaminers marks/ then such ans.er script should be subGected for Third Kaluation and t*e 6ar8s a=arded in t*ird
<a7uation *as to be )onsidered Jna77K3 Ho=e<er% t*is =as not ad*ered to3 T*e 9o77o=in4 tab7es i77ustrate t*isC
Mar8s o9 T*ird .a7uation not ta8en as Jna7 6ar8s =it* re4ard to t*e 9o77o=in4 se7e)ted )andidates to beneJt t*e6 (As T*ird .a7uation 6ar8s =as
7esser t*an t*e 6ar8s Jna77K a=arded+
TA!0E 5 A(3
<L#)3 Reg# )o )ame Remarks (3<T <DLDCTD:
% %"*000 43(6L KR9<H)6 H )
4< 92 6K(2%*)/ indiidual ariation (M&&)/ TK %!$
marks T6KD) %8+/ !* marks bene=t
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR
! %!!%,& <H9K6 <H6)K6R )
4< 99 6K(M%8)/ indiidual ariation (,8) TK marks
%,"/ a.arded %8"/ %" marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR
& %""+0! LDDL6K6THN K
His29 6K (M&) indiidual ariation (+%) TK marks %&0/
a.arded %+%/ !& marks 7ene=t#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR
, %%"8&% (D::6((696H R <
4eo 9 6K(2%&) indiidual Kariation (M!")/ 2&rd Kal
%&$/ marks taken %*,/ &8 marks bene=t(6lso scaling
bene=t 8, marks) totally 0$mrks bene=ted#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR
8 %!!,8% <R9K6)TH R63 K
Cri29 6K (2%$) indiidual Kariation (2,+) &rd Kal done
%"*/ marks taken %*8/ +0 marks 7ene=t#(6lso scaling
bene=t %% marks)Totally ** marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
+ %%&,8! RDK6))6 R
4<29 6K (2!)/ indiidual Kariation (2!8) &rd Kal %,"/
marks a.arded %++/ !+ marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
* %"$880 ?6H6)TD<H <
Kan 99 6K (M,) indiidual ariation (2,8) TK done !8%/
marks taken !"$/ ,! marks less# 4s 9 6K (28)
indiidual Kariation (M!!) TK done %&$/ marks taken
%,%/ ! marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
0 !"&!!8 <H6)TH6KK6K6:9
His299 &rd Kal %,%/ marks taken %8*/ %+ marks
7ene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
$ ,"",&0 <HDDL6 TH3?6<
Dng 9 6K (2%!) indiidual Kariation (2&$) TK done %*+
?arks taken !&!# 7ene=t of 8+ marks#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%" %%+%"8 R6K9K>?6R (
Kan 99 6K (M%+) indiidual ariation (2&%) TK done
%0+/ marks taken %+&/ !& marks less# 4s 99 6K (2
%%)indiidual Kariation (2,") TK done %,!/ marks
taken %*8/ && marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%% %!!%&, KDDR643>: (6T9L
R: 99 6K (M%)indiidual Kariation (2!") TK done %8+
marks /taken %+0/ %! marks 7ene=t##
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%! %""0+, L6K<H?9K6)TH 7
4s 9 6K (2%!) indiidual Kariation (2,+) TK done %!*/
marks taken %+!/ &8 marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%& &"**00 7H6R6TH9
(6296K (M!) indiidual Kariation (28%) TK done %8,/
marks taken %*$/ !8 marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%, %"!&0" <>)9TH6 ?
(6 99 6K (M*) indiidual Kariation (2&") TK done +%/
marks taken %,%/ 0" marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%8 !"",,, 46)O9 :6TT6TR6N6
Kan 99 6K (2%")indiidual Kariation (2,+) TK done %0$/
marks taken %$,/ 8 marks 7ene=t#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR C3??DRC96L T6P
Pa4e F
%+ %%%**8 N6<H3:H6 K
4< 99 6K (20) indiidual ariation (M&*) TK done %8"/
marks taken %&,/ %+ marks less#(6 9 6K (20)
indiidual Kariation (20*) TK done %$8/ marks taken
!!+/ &% marks 7ene=t#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR C3??DRC96L T6P
%* %"8*%* >?6 K 6
(6 9 6K (M,) indiidual Kariation (M&0) TK done %8"
marks taken %08 marks/ &8 marks 7ene=t#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR C3??DRC96L T6P
%0 !%0&** <H6?7H> 7H6T :
<oc 99 6K (2%!) indiidual Kariation (M!0) TK done
%8!/ marks taken %+0/ %+ marks 7ene=ted#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR C3??DRC96L T6P
%$ ,%&&"+ :R >?6K6)TH R <
4s 99 6K (2+) indiidual Kariation (2!$) TK done %,,/
marks taken %*&/ !$ marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR C3??DRC96L T6P
!" ,%80$! <6T9<H 767> H <
R: 9 6K (2%") indiidual ariation (2!+) TK done %0+/
marks taken %+8/ !% marks less# 4s 99 6K (M,)
indiidual Kariation (2!") TK done %8*/ marks taken
%*,/ %* marks bene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
!% %"8%++ >:6N6 K>?6R
(6 992 6K (2*)no scaling/ not to be &rd alued/ but
deliberately &rd Kal done/ %+$ a.arded# 8 marks
bene=t# 4<299 Correct marks !""#
T6H6<9L:6R
!! ,"+*"& 76L6KR9<H)6 C H
4s 99 6K (M$) indiidual Kariation (M,&) TK done %,%/
marks taken %,$/ 0 marks bene=t#
6<<T#L673>R C3??9<<93)DR
!& %%"%$* CH9:6)6):6 ? <
His 9 6K (28)indiidual Kariation (2&+) TK done %+!/
marks taken %*%/ $ marks 7ene=t#
6<<T#L673>R C3??9<<93)DR
!, ,"*0+& ?6H6:DK6 ? ?>R>49
His 99 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (2*%) TK done %,*/
?arks taken %8"/ & marks 7ene=ted
T6H6<9L:6R
!8 !"&*%$ R6K9 ? T9RL6(>R
4< 9 6K (2%!)indiidual Kariation (M8&) TK done %!8/
?arks taken %!0/ & marks 7ene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
!+ %"$+&! O6N6?6:H6K6 (
(sy 99 6K (20)indiidual Kariation (2+$) TK done $$/
?arks taken %**/ *0 marks bene=t #
T6H6<9L:6R
!* ,"*"&+ K6K9TH6 R6O6R6?
His 99 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (2+*) TK done
%"$/ marks taken %8+/ ,* marks 7ene=ted#
T6H6<9L:6R
!0 %""!*& R6<H?9 4
(sy 9 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (2++) TK done %%"
marks taken %!,/ %, marks 7ene=t# 4< 99 6K (2%,)
indiidual ariation (M&") TK done %,0/ marks taken
%!8/ !& marks less#
T6H6<9L:6R
!$ %%&&%& KD)K6TD<H6 ?>RTHN K
His 9 6K (2&)indiidual Kariation (28&) TK done %!%/
marks taken %0+/ +8 marks 7ene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
&" %&&!&$ R6)46)6TH6
4eo 99 6K (M!)indiidual Kariation (2&!) TK done
%&+/ marks taken %*!/ &+ marks bene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
&% !"!,*" <H6<H9:6R 6 764L9
4< 9 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (2!+) TK done %,+/
?arks taken %8&/ * marks bene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
&! ,"&0"& R33(6 R
4< 9 6K (2%!)indiidual Kariation (2&$) TK done 0$/
?arks taken %,+/ 8* marks bene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
Pa4e $
&& %"*,8* ?6)O>)6TH6 4 )
His 9 6K (M&) indiidual Kariation (M88) TK done %&,/
?arks taken %8%/ %* marks bene=t# His 99 6K (2
%!)indiidual Kariation (M!8) TK done %8,/ ?arks
taken %%+/ &0 marks less# 4< 99 6K (2%) indiidual
Kariation (2!,) TK done %,$/ ?arks taken %8+/ *
marks bene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
&, ,%&+** R33(6 7 R
Kan 99 6K (2%)indiidual Kariation (2!") TK done %,0/
marks taken %*+/ !0 marks 7ene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
&8 %"%,!$ 46)6(6TH9 K6TT9)6KDRD
<oc 9 6K (2%&) indiidual Kariation (2&8) TK done *+/
marks taken %!0/ 8! marks 7ene=ted#
T6H6<9L:6R
&+ %!!8+* <>?6)6
Kan 99 6K (2!) indiidual Kariation (2!*) TK done %*!/
?arks taken %*+/ , marks bene=t#
C3??DRC96L T6P 3FF9CDR
&* %""%*% H6R<H6K6R:H6) 7 K
6nth 9 6K (2%$) indiidual Kariation (2&$) TK done
%,+/ %80/ marks taken %+%/ & marks 7ene=t#
&0 %"8"+* ?6)O>)6TH6 7 )
<oc 99 6K (20) indiidual Kariation (2!!) TK done
%!$/ marks taken %8"/ !% marks 7ene=t # 4< 99 6K
(M+) indiidual Kariation (M&%) TK done %!8/ ?arks
taken %!%/ , marks less#
&$ ,%"$*& L3KD<H6 7 <
His 9 6K (2%0) indiidual Kariation (2,&) TK done
%%0/ marks taken %08/ +* marks 7ene=ted#
," !"&&%% FDR3QKH6) ? K9LLD:6R
His 99 6K (2%!) indiidual Kariation (2,8) TK done
%%,/ marks taken %8"/ &+ marks bene=t#
,% &""0%, 43(6L O6:H6K
4eo 9 6K (2%&) indiidual Kariation (28%) TK done $%/
marks taken %*,/ 0& marks bene=t# 4< 9 6K
(M%")indiidual Kariation (M&!) TK done %%%/ ?arks
taken 88/ 8+ marks less
,! %!+"8, 4>R>(R6<6: H L
Dco 9 6K (2%8) indiidual Kariation (2&0) TK done
%&$/ marks taken !"8/ ++ marks bene=t#
6:?9)9<TR6T9KD L673>R 3FF9CDR
,& !!"8+! ?6LL6((6 <HDLL9KDR9 (
His 9 6K (20) indiidual Kariation (2!%) TK done %&%/
?arks taken %8*/ !+ marks bene=t#
6ssistant Registrar Co2op <ociety
,, &"+0$, 6))6(>R6)6 CH3>R
His 99 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (M!") TK done
%08/ ?arks taken %8!/ && marks less#4< 99 6K (2
+)indiidual Kariation (2&+) TK done %%&/ ?arks
taken %,&/ &" marks bene=t#
,8 ,%!%+$ K9O6N6K>?6R 4 R
<oc 9 6K (M8) indiidual Kariation (M&+) TK done
%!!/ ?arks taken %!0/ + marks bene=t#
,+ !%0!80 K6LL6((6 376))643L
(69 6K (M+) indiidual Kariation (M!,) TK done %8,/
?arks taken marks taken %+8# %% marks bene=t#
,* %&,8&8 >?6 ? )
His 9 6K (M!) indiidual Kariation (2,") TK done %*+/
?arks taken %$+/ !" marks bene=t#
,0 ,%8&&+ K>?>:6 49R9<H
His 9 6K (M&) indiidual Kariation (2&+) TK done %&*/
?arks taken %*,/ &* marks bene=t#
,$ %!%*80 43(6L6 RD::N K
4< 92 6K (M%*)/ 1 indiidual is diF (M%0)/ yet/ sent
for &rd al/ 1 a.arded %&& marks#
Pa4e #
8" %&!&"8 R6O6))6 (
4< 9 6K (2%,) indiidual Kariation (2%!) TK not
re;uired/ but TK done and a.arded %,0/ %% marks
bene=t#
Dmployment 3@cers
8% ,"%00" <>O6T6 C D
Dng 99 6K (28) indiidual Kariation (280) TK done %0"/
?arks taken !%8/ &8 marks bene=t#
Dmployment 3@cers
8! !"""$& <>CHDT6 ? )DL6K949
(sy 9 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (2&+) TK done $%/
?arks taken %,"/ ,$ marks bene=t#
6<<T#:9RDCT3R 3F N3>TH <DRK9CD<
8& !"8&"+ ?>K6((6 K6R67H9?6))6K6R
His 9 6K (2%) indiidual Kariation (2!,) TK done %&$/
?arks taken %,8/ + marks bene=t# His 99 6K (2%&)
indiidual Kariation (2!,) TK done %!,/ ?arks taken
&&/ $ marks bene=t# Kan299 6K (2,) indiidual
Kariation (") CD DBaminer marks %*8/ but marks
taken %$8/ !" ?arks 7ene=t#(T3T6LLN +M$M!"R&8
?RK< 7D)DF9T)
CH9DF 3FF9CDR
8, %"0%*$ O6N6?6L6 (
(6 9 6K (2&) indiidual Kariation (M!,) TK done $0/
?arks taken %,$/ 8% marks bene=t# (699 6K (2$)
indiidual Kariation (288) TK done %&8/ ?arks taken
%*!/ &* marks bene=t#
CH9DF 3FF9CDR
88 %!%8*+ ?6)O>)6TH6 <'6?N
His 9 6K (") indiidual Kariation (2&+) TK done %&&/
?arks taken %&*/ , marks bene=t#
6<<T#TRD6<>RN 3FF9CDR
8+ &"*%*0 :DD(6K
His 99 6K (2%0) indiidual Kariation (M!%) TK done
%!,/ ?arks taken %&8/ %% marks bene=t#
8* %%&8*$ KD)K6TD<H6((6 )
4< 9 6K (2%,) indiidual Kariation (2&!) TK done %!+/
?arks taken %!*/ % mark bene=t#
80 %"!,," 7D)6K6 (R6<6:
His 9 6K (M*) indiidual Kariation (2!%) TK done %!*/
marks taken %*,/ ,* marks bene=t#
8$ ,%!&88 RDK6TH9 769 <
(6 9 6K (2+) indiidual Kariation (2*8) TK done
%,*/marks taken %$"/ ,& marks bene=t# 4< 9 6K (2
%$)indiidual Kariation (2&+) TK done +0/ ?arks
taken %"*/ &$ marks bene=t#(T3T6LLN ,&M&$R0!
?6RK< 7D)DF9T)
+" %%*$+$ R>K?6)9 :DK9 )
Kan 99 6K (2!) indiidual Kariation (2,+) TK done
%,!/marks taken %80/ %+ marks bene=t#
+% !"&*!+
<3?6<HDKH6R )N6?643>:6
76<6((6
4eo 99 6K (20) indiidual Kariation (28$) TK done
%!&/?arks taken %0,/ +% ?arks 7ene=t# 4< 9 6K (2%!)
indiidual Kariation (2&") TK done %!%/ ?arks taken
%%%/ %" marks less# 4< 99 6K (2%!) indiidual Kariation
(M!0) TK done %!"/ ?arks taken %%"/ %" marks
less#
:9<T2?6RKDT9)4 3FF9CDR
+! ,%8",% K9)D<H6 R O
4< 9 6K (2%,) indiidual Kariation (2!") TK done %""/
?arks taken %%*/ %* marks bene=t#
+& %!8,$+ R6?D<H K
His 99 6K (2%0) indiidual Kariation (2,$) TK done
%,*/marks taken %$%/,, marks bene=t#
+, %&"%8, H3L676<6((6 76LD46R
Kan 99 6K (M%+) indiidual Kariation (2&0) TK done
$*/marks taken %%%/%, marks bene=t#
Pa4e "'
+8 %%$"%, R6O6))6 K
Dco 9 6K (2%+)indiidual Kariation (2&8) TK done
%%8/marks taken %+,/ ,$ marks bene=t#4< 99 6K (2
*)indiidual Kariation (M!!) TK done %!8/ ?arks
taken %%$/ + ?arks less
++ ,"%*,& ?3H6) C H
<oc 9 6K (M0) indiidual Kariation (M&") TK done $!
marks taken %%8/!& marks bene=t#4< 9 6K
(M+)indiidual Kariation (M,%) TK done %&$/ ?arks
taken $"/ ,$ marks less#
+* ,"$**% R6)9 H C ?
(sy 99 6K (M%+) indiidual Kariation (2&8) TK done
0$/marks taken %8!/ +& marks bene=t# <oc29 6K (2
%0) indiidual Kariation (M+,) TK done 0+/ marks
taken %""/%, marks 7ene=t# <oc 99 6K (2*)indiidual
Kariation (M*") TK done %8&/ marks taken 0,/+$
marks less#
+0 %%,+!% D<H'6R6 )
(6 99 6K (2%&) indiidual Kariation (2,+) TK done %!"
marks taken %+, ,, marks 7ene=t# 4< 99 6K (M%8)
indiidual Kariation (M!8) TK done %,%/marks taken
%!"/ &% marks less#
+$ %%8+,& <HNL6O6 ? K
4< 99 6K (M0) indiidual Kariation (2,$) TK done
%%%/marks taken %,&/ &! marks bene=t#
*" %%8!&+ )6R6<9?6 ?>RTHN K
4< 99 6K (2%&)indiidual Kariation (2&+) TK done %&,/
marks taken %80/ !, marks bene=t#
6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
*% %%*8*& ?6HD<H'6R6((6 K
4< 9 6K (2%+)indiidual Kariation (M&0) TK done %,$/
marks taken %8%/ ! marks bene=t#
6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
*! %%$!%& <H6<H9:6R6 O D
4eo 99 6K (M%") indiidual Kariation (2&&) TK done
%&%/ marks taken %88/ !, 7ene=t#
6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
*& ,"%!*+ <NDD:6 6)ODD:6 (6RKDD)
4eo 9 6K (20) indiidual Kariation (2!+) TK done %,,/
marks taken %+"/ %+ marks bene=t#
6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
*, %!,+*0 KDD)6 R
<oc 9 6K (2%!) indiidual Kariation (2&&) TK done %,8/
marks taken %8"/ 8 marks bene=t#
6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
*8 %!!!*$ RDKH6 : 4< 92 DBaminer marks %0%/ actual marks %&0# 6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
*+ %%+&0* <H6)T6 K>?6R9 4 7
<oc 9 6K (2%0) indiidual Kariation (2&!) TK done %"&/
marks taken %%0/ %8 marks bene=t/ R: 99 6K
(M%)indiidual Kariation (2!&) TK done %&!/ marks
taken %%0/ %, marks less#
6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
Re4ardin4 t*ird <a7uation 6ar8s% =*i)* ou4*t to *a<e been% but not ta8en into )onsideration-
The (etitioner members hae furnished a tabulated statement sho.ing the particulars of the selected candidates .hose indiidual papers .ere sent for third aluation
and .hich marks hae not been taken into consideration for =nal selections/ though they ought to hae been taken into consideration# The remarks in the said tabulated
Pa4e ""
statement to the eBtent they tally .ith the remarks in the tabulated statement at 6nneBure29 are correct# Ho.eer/ the fact .hether it .as a uniform mistake across the
board has to be eri=ed as the said statements hae been prepared only on the basis of the eBamination of the ans.er scripts of the selected candidates# <imilarly the
ans.ers scripts of the non2selected candidates hae to be eri=ed to determine .hether the said error has occurred een in respect of the non2selected candidates# 9n the
=nal analysis if the said errors .ould in fact tilt the results of the said selection has to be eri=ed#
)+ As per t*e order o9 t*e Honb7e Hi4* Court =*ere t*e a<era4e <ariation in 6ar8s is not 6ore t*an p7us or 6inus &' t*en t*e 6ar8s a=arded bK
t*e e:a6iner *as to be retained3 Ho=e<er% in t*e 9o77o=in4 instan)es% a7t*ou4* t*e a<era4e <ariation is not 6ore t*an p7us or 6inus &' t*e 6ar8s
a=arded bK t*e e:a6iner =as not retained but 6ar8s =*i)* =ou7d beneJt t*e )andidate =as )onsidered as Jna7 6ar8s-
Tab7e / A@
<l#)3# Reg# )o )ame
<cript <elected Re2Kaluation ?arks
?arks
:iFerence
6g#
Final
?arks
Taken
)ame 1 DBaminer 1
Code
(aper Top Random
% !%+$+&
:>R46((6
K6)6K6((696H
4#< S 9 %&0 2 %!0 2%" 2%"#0 %&+
K#H# (6R6?6<H9K69H6
("02"0)
! %!%*80
43(6L RD::N #K 6RC<
(4?)
4#< S 9 $$ 2 %%* M%0 M%* %&&
6<'6TH6?)6 ("02!!)
& %""0!8
(>):6L9K #C <6:>RD/
CT3 (<C)
4#< S 9 2 $0 %%* M%$ 0#+ %,!
<H6)T9 262%&2*&
, %&!&"8
R6O6))6 #((<C) D#3
4#< S 9 %&* 2 %!8 2%! 2%,#%* %,0
7#7# 79R6:6R %&20+
8 %%"%$*
CH9:6)6):6 )#< / 6LL
4#< S 9 %!! 2 %,% M%$ 2$#! %+%
<#<#?6K6L 2 %020!
+ %%8!+,
?6:H>KD<H'6R6 (4?)
T6H <<
4#< S 99 %+* 2 %88 2%! 2%&#! %$&
7#7# 79R6:6R %&20+
* !""8$*
(R67H6K6TH9 #<(C6T29)
6T3
His S 9 %*& 2 %8% 2!! " %8%
)646K6)6O6 K# %&2%%8
0 ,"%*,&
?3H6) C#H (C6T29) :?3
His S 9 %8, 2 %&0 2%+ 2&#! %8&
O3<D(H 4H3<H6LD %&2
8&
$ %%*,++ <R9)9K6< ?>RTHN
7#K(C6T29)CH9DF 3FF9CDR
His S 9 %0% 2 %0+ M8 2%*#8 %+"
<6K6)T# ?#N# %&2$!
Pa4e "&
%" %%"!%0 <R9)9K6<6 <#? (4?)
6CCT
Kan S 9 !"& 2 %0, 2%$ 2%! !%%
(R6<6))6 K>?6R )#
!02+8
%% %""0!8
(>):6L9K #L/ <6:>RD/
CT3 (<C)
Kan S 99 %%* 2 %"+ 2%% 20 %!%
T#R# ?6)O>)6TH !02%"&
%! !""8&$
<H6K67D):R696H /
:?3
Kan S 99 !,$ 2 !+% M%! 2%"#&& !+"
:R# )# :6?3:6R6
<HDTTN !02$&
%& %""*+0
K6)9#7 (4?) T6H
R: S 9 !%* 2 !"* 2%" M8#," %0$
?:# :6<T649R !,2%,
%, %%!$8+
6RCH6)6 N#7 (&6) :37C
R: S 99 2 %,$ %,, 28 2&#!8 %+!
7H64N6??6 !,2%%
%8 %!$!$*
K6RDD43':6 (&6) 6C
R: S 99 %08 2 %$! M* 2&#*8 %+%
R37DRT CL9KD 4# !,2%&
%+ %""*+0
K6)9#7 (4?) T6H
R: S 99 !"& 2 !"" 2& "#+ %*8
?:# :6<T649R !,2%,
%* &"%"&%
?DDR6 R6CH6((6
6L>R(4?)
(6 S 9 !%8 2 %$$ 2%+ 2$ !",
<H9K6R6?6 RD::N %02
+&
%0 %"8%++
>:6N6 K>?6R
<HDTTN(4?)
(6 S 99 %+, 2 %*0 M%, +#8 %+$
K9R>(6K<H6((6 4#T#
%02!,
Re4ardin4 t*e retention o9 6ar8s a=arded bK t*e E:a6iner% =*ere <ariation is 7ess t*an GC/ &'-
The (etitioner members hae furnished a tabulated statement sho.ing the particulars of the selected candidates .hose indiidual papers .ere picked up for re2aluation
and the ariation .as found to less than M-2 !" and instead of retaining the marks of the eBaminer/ diFerent marks hae been taken into consideration# The (etitioner
members hae in their analysis stated that the marks that hae bene=tted the said candidates hae been taken into consideration# 6 perusal of the said statement
indicates that in case of some candidates less marks hae been taken into consideration and in some cases more marks hae been taken into consideration# 9n some
cases pointed out therein the diFerence is marginal# Ho.eer/ the fact .hether it .as a uniform mistake across the board has to be eri=ed as the said statements hae
been prepared only on the basis of the eBamination of the ans.er scripts of the selected candidates# <imilarly the ans.ers scripts of the non2selected candidates hae to
be eri=ed to determine .hether the said error has occurred een in respect of the non2selected candidates# 9n the =nal analysis if the said errors .ould in fact tilt the
results of the said selection has to be eri=ed#
Pa4e ";
d+ 9n the memo dated %0-"$-!"%&- a@dait dated !"-"$-!"%& submitted to the Honble High Court in the present proceedings/ the K(<C has stated that during the
moderation process $ papers in , subGects remained and moderation .ould be done .ith regard to the same and a ne. list .ould be prepared# 'hen the (etitioner
?embers sought for information regarding the said $ papers/ the K(<C failed to proide the said information and also did not share any information as to .hether such
moderation .as done# The K(<C has also not disclosed .hether it has done re2moderation and scaling as per the order of this Honble Court in '#(# )o# %!8,02
80$-!""!# <uch non disclosure does not infuse con=dence and the (etitioner ?embers refrains from making any further comment on the same#
The K(<C in its statement dated %02"$2!"%& =led before this Honble Court in '#(#)o#!*+*,-!"%! and connected matters/ .hich statement .as =led by the K(<C
indicating its stand on the =ndings of the C9: Report/ has admitted the =nding in the C9: Report that the annulled marks a.arded by the Head-Chief DBaminers hae been
taken into consideration for the purpose of moderation and scaling .hich .as done in pursuance of the order dated %%2%"2!""! passed in '#(#)o#%!8,0280$- !""!# To
.hat eBtent the said error .ould tilt the marks and ultimately the results .ould hae to be .orked out by the K(<C and in fact in the said statements the K(<C has stated
that it is re2doing the eBercise of moderation and scaling by taking into consideration the marks a.arded by the original eBaminers# The result of such eBercise carried on
by the K(<C .ould be =led by the K(<C before this Honble Court#
e+ The (etitioner ?embers sought details of the moderation process# The follo.ing chart is the gist of the information made aailable in terms of numbers of ans.er
scripts subGected for moderation# The Honble High Court of Karnataka in its order dated %%-%"-!""! had directed that the ans.er scripts of the subGects enumerated in
the table belo. had to be subGected for moderation process# Ho.eer/ as per the information gathered by the (etitioner ?embers/ moderation process .as not done
fully - completely# The second column of the table sho.s the name of the subGect/ the third column sho.s the total number of ans.er scripts in each subGect (as per
the information gien by K(<C to the (etitioner ?embers as .ell as to the Honble High Court)/ the fourth column sho.s the number of ans.er scripts actually
subGected to moderation/ the =fth column sho.s the diFerence (bet.een columns & and ,)/ the siBth column is the percentage of ans.er scripts subGected to
moderation in each subGect and the last column i#e# the seen column sho.s the percentage of ans.er scripts not subGected for moderation process# In tota7 "#%$F&
i3e "C; of the ans.er scripts .ere not subGected to moderation process# This is non2compliance of the order of this Honble Court .ith regard to the moderation
process#
TA!0E / A&
Pa4e "(
173 No3 1ubLe)tCpaper
No3 o9 ans=er
s)ripts as
stated be9ore
HC
No3 o9 s)ripts
subLe)ted 9or
6oderation
DiMeren)e
Ao9 s)ripts
6oderated bK BP1C
(A+
Ao9 s)ripts not
6oderated bK BP1C
(A+
% 641 ?ktg# <eri (aper % !!! %+8 8* *,#&! !8#+*
! 641 ?ktg# <eri (aper! !%$ %+! 8* *,#"" !+#""
& 6) H><7 1 K#sc (aper % *0 8$ %$ *8#+, !,#&8
, 6) H><7 1 K#sc (aper ! ** 8$ %0 *+#+! !&#&*
8 73T6)N % +8, 8"! %8! *+#*8 !&#!,
+ 73T6)N ! +8! 8"! %8" **#"" !&#""
* C3??DRCD % !8+ !%& ,& 0&#"" %+#*$
0 C3??DRCD ! !8+ !%! ,! 0!#0% %+#,"
$ CR9?9)3L34N % 0&! +%, !%0 *,#"" !+#""
%" CR9?9)3L34N ! 0!+ +%% !%8 *,#"" !+#""
%% DC3)3?9C< % $$0 ++8 &&& ++#+& &&#&+
%! DC3)3?9C< ! $$8 ++, &&% ++#*& &&#!+
%& 4D34R6(HN % %%&8 *0" &88 +0#*! &%#!*
%, 4D34R6(HN ! %%&! **0 &8, +0#*! &%#!*
%8 ?6THD?6T9C< % !!% %+0 8& *+#"" !,#""
%+ ?6THD?6T9C< ! !!! %+* 88 *8#!! !,#**
%* H9<T3RN % ,&0$ !++8 %*!, +"#*% &$#!0
%0 H9<T3RN ! ,&0+ !++" %*!+ +"#+, &$#&8
%$ 4D3L34N % %"+ ** !$ *!#+, !*#&8
!" 4D3L34N ! %"+ ** !$ *!#+, !*#&8
!% (HN<9C< % &!& !,8 *0 *8#08 !,#%,
!! (HN<9C< % &!! !,& *$ *8#,+ !,#8&
!& (3L2<C9D)CD% %,+! 0+0 8$, 8$#&* ,"#+!
!, (3L2<C9D)CD! %,80 0+* 8$% 8$#,+ ,"#8&
!8 (<NCH3L34N % &&+ !+" *+ **#&0 !!#+%
!+ (<NCH3L34N! &&* !+" ** **#%8 !!#0,
!* (>726:?9)<TR6T93)% !!+ %8$+ +*" *"#,& !$#8+
!0 (>726:?9)<TR6T93)! !!8! %8$" ++! *"#+" !$#&$
!$ <3C93L34N% !8*! %88, %"%0 +"#,% &$#80
&" <3C93L34N! !888 %8,8 %"%" +"#,+ &$#8&
&% Q33L34N% 8"$ ,"" %"$ *0#80 !%#,%
&! Q33L34N! 8"0 &$0 %%" *0#&, !%#+8
&& R>R6L :K(2?D)T% 8+8 &0" %08 +*#!8 &!#*!
&, R>R6L :K(2?D)T! 8+, &*$ %08 +*#%% &!#0"
&8 6)THR3(3L34N% *!$ 800 %,% 0"#+8 %$#&,
&+ 6)THR3(3L34N! *!% 80" %,% 0"#,, %$#88
&* K6))6:6% %&,0 *$8 88& 80#$* ,%#"&
&0 K6))6:6! %&,! *$& &,$ 8$#"$ ,"#$"
&$ D)4L9<H% !%, %*, ," 0%#&" %0#+$
," D)4L9<H! !%, %*, ," 0%#&" %0#+$
,% 4D)2<T>:9D<2% %",$& +$*" &8!& ++#,! &&#8*
Pa4e "@
,! 4D)2<T>:9D<2! %",!8 +$,+ &,*$ ++#+! &&#8*
# TOTA0 @#&FF ;#('@ "#$F& EE3(F ;;3@&
TOTA0 NO OF AN1?ER 1CRIPT1 IN
A00 ;' OPTIONA0 1,!DECT1 G31
PAPER1 F,RNI1HED !2 BP1C TO
THE HON!0E HIGH CO,RT E"&$; ;#('@ "#$F&
////// ///////
6t (age %%& of the 3rder dated %%2%"2!""! passed in '#(#)o#%!8,0280$-!""! a tabulated column is eBtracted/ .herein the total number of ans.er scripts has been
indicated in each of the ,! papers directed to be subGected for fresh moderation and scaling by the said order# The (etitioner members state that all the said papers
should hae been subGected to fresh moderation and scaling/ but ho.eer the actual number of ans.er scripts subGected to fresh moderation and scaling by the K(<C is
less as stated in the tabulated statement aboe# 9t is to be noted that in 4eneral <tudies (aper29 and (aper299 the ans.er scripts that .ere not moderated .ere &8!& and
&,*$ respectiely# 9n that regard a clari=cation is sought by the K(<C and a list has been furnished by the K(<C of the said candidates .hose ans.er scripts .ere not
moderated after the order dated %%2%"2!""!# From a perusal of the said lists/ it is eident that %" candidates .ere debarred permanently# 6part from the said %"
candidates the ans.er scripts of the other candidates .ere not moderated as they .ere not ;uali=ed or their candidature .as reGected or they .ere candidates .ho .ere
permitted to take the main eBamination on the basis of .eightage of %"H marks to Rural Candidates/ .hich .eightage .as subse;uently struck do.n by this Honble
Court in '#(#)o#%&%8*-%$$0 by order dated %%2%%2%$$0# Hence the total =gure of +%/!0& is of the total number of ans.er scripts in the said ,! papers and the =gure of
&$,"8 is that of the ans.er scripts .hich .ere moderated afresh as per the order dated %%2%"2!""! passed in '#(#)o#%!8,0280$-!""!# The remaining %$0*! ans.er
scripts .ere of those candidates .hose candidature either .as reGected-not ;uali=ed-fell in the Rural 'eightage Category/ .hose ans.er scripts .ere not re;uired to be
moderated afresh as their candidature .as reGected for one of the aforesaid reasons# 9t is also pertinent to state that the order dated %%2%%2%$$0 passed in
'#(#)o#%&%8*-%$$0 .as con=rmed by the Honble <upreme Court only on %,2"!2!""" in <L( (Ciil) )os#!"+82!"0,-!""" and only thereafter the candidature of those
candidates .ho .ere allo.ed to take the main eBamination on the basis of Rural 'eightage .as reGected# 9t can at best be said that it .as only due to inadertence that
K(<C did not mention the lesser number of &$,"8 ans.er scripts that .ere re;uired to be moderated in the said ,! papers# Hence/ in my opinion/ the aforesaid analysis
and conclusion on 9ssue )o#! arried at by the (etitioner members is incorrect and based on a .rong premise#
99+ Ano6a7ies in t*e e<a7uation sta4e o9 t*e ans=er s)riptsC
a+ Re4ardin4 t*e 6et*od and pro)edure adopted 9or e<a7uation-
The (etitioner ?embers hae tried to ascertain .hether there is some regular practice/ procedure or guidelines follo.ed in the ealuation of ans.er scripts# The
(etitioner ?embers sought from the BP1C t*e 6et*od or pro)edure adopted 9or e<a7uation or pra)ti)e 9o77o=ed3 Ho=e<er% t*e BP1C *as not pro<ided
anK =ritten 4uide7ines or a pro)edure )*art t*at 4uides t*e persons underta8in4 t*e e<a7uation# The (etitioner ?embers also tried to ascertain .hether
Pa4e "E
there is such a common practice regarding the ealuation process from the actual scrutiny of ans.er scripts and actual methods used in ealuation# The (etitioner
?embers found the follo.ingC
i# There are no .ritten guidelines or procedures handed out to the persons undertaking the ealuation .ork (.hich results in arbitrary and ad hoc methods being used
during ealuation and moderation and .hich in this case has resulted so)A
ii# There has been .rong totaling of marks/ .hich has had huge cascading eFects during the moderation and scaling process as one .rong totaling leads to change in
the aerage ariation and thereby aFecting the marks of all the candidates .ho hae been ealuated by the same DBaminer#
iii# There has been no consistent practice or procedure in the ealuation process and it is undertaken as per the oral instructions issued by .hoeer is in2charge at that
moment of ealuation/ .hich does not bode .ell/ especially .hen public o@ces are at stake#
i# There hae been diFerent yardsticks used in the three batches regarding moderation# 9n the %$$0 batch/ third aluation is supposed to hae been done .here
aerage ariation is more than plus or minus !" marks# 9n the %$$$ batch/ third aluation is supposed to hae been done .here aerage ariation is more than plus
or minus &! marks# 9n the !"", batch/ third aluation is supposed to hae been done .here the aerage ariation is more than plus or minus ,8 marks# )o reason
or rationale is supplied for the diFerent yardsticks# 9mportantly/ een these yardsticks hae not been consistently used een in the particular batches concerned#
'hereer the said yardsticks are found inconenient (i#e is not to the liking of the Chairman or the ?embers) the ealuation has dierted from applying the yardstick
(as is eident from the arious tables gien in this report)# The third aluation tool has been used to .reck inGustice#
Re4ardin4 t*e 6et*od and pro)edure adopted 9or e<a7uation-
The details of the procedure adopted by the K(<C for ealuation of ans.er scripts hae been proided to the (etitioner members under a letter2dated %"#"%#!"%,#
6long .ith the said letter dated %"#"%#!"%, the scheme of aluation follo.ed in respect of the %$$0 batch main eBamination (aluation done in the year %$$$) has
been proided/ .hich document is titled as Central aluation of the 6ns.er scripts of the 4a5etted (robationers (main) eBamination %$$$/ .hich proides the
scheme of aluation that has .as follo.ed for the %$$0 batch main eBamination# <imilar document is also proided in respect of the !"", batch# For eery
subse;uent batch of recruitments the manner of ealuation may be changed in order to improe the earlier system# This can be done only/ if any mandatory
procedure is not proided in any Rules goerning the particular recruitment# 9f a procedure is prescribed in the concerned Rules/ the same is re;uired to be follo.ed#
9n the absence of any speci=c procedure contemplated in the Rules/ the commission is free to adopt a suitable procedure#
b+?RONG TOTA0ING OF MARB1% RE1,0TING IN HA.ING A CA1CADING EFFECT ON THE MARB1 OF OTHER CANDIDATE1- 6t the stage of initial ealuation
itself there has been .rong totaling of marks/ .hich has had a cascading eFect during the time of moderation# 'here eer there is .rong totaling of a higher
degree/ there has been a corresponding eFect on the aerage ariation and higher the aerage ariation greater is the eFect on other candidates# The follo.ing
table sho.s instances .herein there has been .rong totaling of marks# (This table has been prepared on actual eri=cation of the ans.er scripts of the selected
Pa4e "F
candidates# This may be regarded only as a sample and not coering the .hole as only the ans.er scripts of the selected candidates hae been scrutini5ed# 6ns.er
scripts of non2selected candidates could not be done due to its enormity i#e running into tens of thousands of ans.er scripts# Hence/ the belo. table is only
representatie in character and is not eBhaustie#)
Tab7e 5 AE
17 no Na6e o9 t*e E:a6iner 1ubLe)t Paper Code Na6e o9 Candidate Re43 No
Mar8s
A=arded
6ctual ?arks
.ariatio
n
% (R3F#:6N6<H6)K6RR63 4<29 8"+$0+ )646R6O># )#R %!!!"& !%* %,8 *!
! <#K# H9TTL6?6)D 6ntro 29 *8"8!! K6?76))6#: %"&8*8 !"% %80 ,&
& (R3F#:6N6<H6)K6RR63 4<29 8"+$0+ RDKH6#: %!!!*$ %0% %&0 ,&
, 43':6 C#6 4<29 8"*0"% )9R6)O6)#R %""&&+ %0" %*" %"
8 ?#:#Q6FR>LL6 4<29 8"!0++ K9O6NK>?6R 7#C ,"%,"! %"8 $8 %"
+ <H6?76))6K6R#7#4 4<29 8"*$0& >R9?9L6#7 %"!*,$ 08 0& !
* 79R6:6R 7#7 4<29 8"808$ >?6 K#6 %"8*%* %!8 %&8 2%"
0 <H6)K6R6((6#? 4<29 8"80!8 <6L?6 F9R:3<D %"8&!! %"% %"8 2,
$ K6LN6)9 )#6 4<29 8",&+& KR9<H)6 (R6<6: ?#< ,"$80* %,$ %8! 2&
%" <H6)TH9#6 History299 0"+0*$ R6ODD?64H6KDDR#K %%$,00 +$ +& +
%% ?6)4<>L9 <#K Criminology29 %8"&&+ )646R6O6((6#T %"+,+! %+" %+& 2&
%! T6??6))6 43':6 #7#H 4<299 8%0+&* K9O6NK>?6R <HDTTN %"8%++ !%" !"" M%"
Analysis and conclusion of the KPSC Member: Re4ardin4 =ron4 tota7in4 o9 6ar8s- The (etitioner members hae furnished a tabulated statement sho.ing the
particulars of the selected candidates in .hich cases there hae been totaling errors# The remarks in the said tabulated statement to the eBtent they tally .ith the
remarks in the tabulated statement at 6nneBure29 are correct#
)+ T*ird <a7uation not done- 6s per the order of the Honble High Court/ .hereer the ariation is more than plus or minus t.enty marks (but the aerage ariation
is not so)/ such indiidual ans.er scripts should be subGected to third aluation and the marks a.arded in third aluation has to be considered .hile calculating =nal
marks# Ho.eer in the follo.ing instances the ans.er scripts .hich ought to hae been subGected for third aluation/ they hae not been so subGected (this list is
not eBhaustie as scrutiny is done only .ith regard to ans.er scripts of selected candidates)-
Tab7e / AF
<L )3# RD4 )3# )6?D RD?6RK<
% %"$%*8 (6RK6TH9 H 7 4s 99 6K (M%%) indiidual Kariation (M%%$) &rd al not done#
Pa4e "$
! !"&!!8 <H6)T6KK6 K6:9 Kan 99 6K (2%,) indiidual Kariation (M&*) / not sent for &rd al#
& %"8*%* >?6 K 6 Com 99 6K (M%+) indiidual Kariation (M*8) not sent for &rd al#
, ,""%"! KH6:6R (6<H6 4<29 6K(2%*)/ R2al done scored 0!/ 9ndiidual Kariation (2,*)/ not sent for &rd al#
8 %&!&** <HD9KH L6T9F Com299 6K (2%$) indiidual Kariation (8&) not sent for &rd al#
+ ,"!0,8 46)46:H6R6 7 K 4s 9 6K (M%*) indiidual Kariation (M&$) / not sent for &rd al#
* ,%8*,* <6()6 ? 6 4s 9 6K (2%8) indiidual Kariation (M!$) / not sent for &rd al#
0 %%%$$* 7DD)6 K (6 9 6K (20) indiidual Kariation (2!,) should hae gone for &rd al#
$ %!*08+ 6)O6)DN6 T (6 99 6K (2%%) indiidual Kariation (M+!) not sent for &rd al#
%" ,%80$! <6T9<H 767> H < His 99 6K (2%&) indiidual Kariation (2+&) not sent for &rd al#
%% %&&",$ )646H6)>?696H Kan 99 6K (2%,) indiidual Kariation (2!&) but not sent for &rd al#
%! %!"$8& :H6)6L6K<H?9 Kan 99 6K (2%!) indiidual Kariation (28%) not sent for &rd al#
%, %"*"$! RDKH6 T <oc 99 6K (2%%) indiidual Kariation (M!*) not sent for &rd al#
%8 ,%"$*& L3KD<H6 7 < Dco 9 6K (2%+) indiidual Kariation (2&+) not sent for &rd al#
%+ &"+&$% <6T9<H ) Kan 99 6K (2%&) indiidual Kariation (2&8) not sent for &rd al#
%* %&8"%" <6THN6K6TH9 ? 7ot 9 6K (2%$) indiidual Kariation (28*) not sent for &rd al #
d+T*ird <a7uation done% but 6ar8s not ta8en 9or )onsideration- 9n certain cases third aluation .as done Ias .as re;uired .heneer indiidual ans.er scripts
marks .ere more than plus or minus t.enty on moderation/ but .here the aerage ariation .as less than plus or minus t.enty/ (as per the order of this Honble
Court in '#(# )o# T Honble Court in '#(# )o# %!8,0280$-!""! .hich is con=rmed by the <upreme Court in Ciil 6ppeals )os +!!&2+&%!-!""8 6rising out of <L((c)
)os +%"2+$$ of !"",)# Ho.eer/ the third aluation results are not sho.n on the records of the K(<C and the third aluation marks are not considered# 9n certain
cases third aluation .as not re;uired at all/ but still it .as got done# These illegal practices .ere detected on the scrutiny of ans.er scripts of selected candidates
and hence is only indicatie and not eBhaustie#
Tab7e / A$
<l#)3# Reg# )o )ame
<ubGect -
paper
Daluation
?arks
:iFerence
6rried
<caled - =nal
?arks
Considered
TK 7ene=t
(D) (RK)
% %""&$*
:R# 6R>:6)TH9
CH6):R6<HDK6R
4#< 2 9 %%, %8% 2&* %%, $$ %8 ?arks (6erage 0#%,)
Pa4e "#
! %!!,8% <R9K6)TH R63 4#< 2 9 %&+ %&" + %%$ %"+ %& ?arks (6erage 2!*#+")
& %%+%"8 R6K9 K>?6R #( 4#< 2 99 %*8 %&8 ," %*8 %,! && ?arks (6erage 2%%#!)
, ,%&&"+ :R#>?6K6)TH 4#< 2 99 %*& %,, !$ %*& %,, !$ ?arks (6erage 2+#!$)
8 !%!+,8 K>?6R )69K #4 4#< 2 99 %,! %*+ 2&, %,! %+0 !+ ?arks loss
$ ,"+*"& 76L6KR9<H)6 C#H 4#< 2 99 %,$ %$! 2,& %,$ %,% 0 ?arks (6g# 0#0&)
%" !""$&* CH6):R6 )69K #) 4#< 2 99 %"$($$) $$ %" 0* ** %" ?arks (6g# 2!!#!")
%% ,%80$! <6T9<H767> H#< 4#< 2 99 %*, %8! !! %*, %8* %* ?arks (6g# ,#"")
%! !"&*%$ R6K9 ? T9RL6(>R 4#< 2 99 %!0 %0% 28& %!0 %!8 & ?arks (6g# 2%!#,")
%& %""*+0 K6)9 #7 4#< 2 9 %&* $! ,8 %&* %&, & ?arks (6g# 2%,#+")
%, %""!*& R6<H?9 #4 4#< 2 99 %!8 %88 2&" %!8 %,0 !& ?arks loss ( 2%&#0+)
%8 %"*,8* ?6)O>)6TH 4#) 4#< 2 99 %8+ %0" 2!, %8+ %,$ * ?arks (6g# 2"#0+)
%+ %"%,00 K9R>(6K<H6 K#? 4#< 2 99 %$0 %*% !* %*+ %,+ &" ?arks (6g# 2!!#!")
%* %""0!8 (>):6L9P L < 4#s 2 9 $* %%* 2!" %
%* %"%&$$ 6)9LK>?6R K#) 4#< 2 9 %!% %*% 28" %!% %%+ 8 ?arks ("#%* 6g)
%0 %"%&$$ 6)9LK>?6R K#) 4#< 2 99 %$" %$* 2* %$" %0* & ?arks (+#!$ 6g)
%$ %!"*%+ R64H>)6TH K#R 4#< 2 99 %+$ %&8 &, %+$ %++ & ?arks (!#,& 6g)
!" %"8&!! <6L?6 F9R:3<D 4#< 2 99 %"+ %8, 2,0 0! %,8 &$ ?arks Loss (6g 2!&#+")
!% %"%!*& KDD)6 #R 4#< 2 99 0* %+% 2*, 0* %+$
0! ?arks Loss (6g 2%!#,")
!! %",*+* ?>)9<H6?646((6 #K 4#< 2 99 %+%
%%+(2
,8)
,8 %&+ %," (!,#*8 6g) 2 , ?arks Loss
!& %%&8*$ KD)K6TD<H6((6 ) 4#< 2 99 %,! %0& 2,% %%* %!% (!,#*8 6g) 2 , ?arks Loss
!, !""8&$ <H6R67D):R696H 4#< 2 99 %%, 0! &! %%, %%& % ?ark bene=t (2*#"" 6g)
!8 %%$"%, R6O6))6 K 4#< 2 99 %%$ %,% 2!! %%$ %!8 + ?arks Loss (2+#0" 6g)
!+ %%8+,& <HNL6O6 ?#K 4#< 2 99 %,& $, ,$ %,& %%% (&! marks bene=t) (0#!8 6g)
Re4ardin4 )ases =*ere t*ird <a7uation =as )arried out% but 6ar8s not ta8en into )onsideration-
The (etitioner members hae furnished a tabulated statement sho.ing the particulars of the selected candidates in .hich cases the papers .ere sent for third aluation/
but the third aluation marks hae not been taken into consideration# The sampling is done in respect of the only the papers of the selected candidates# 9t is obsered that
in some cases more marks hae been taken into consideration and in some cases less marks# Ho.eer in most of the cases the marks of the original eBaminer hae been
taken into consideration and the said mistake seems to be an error rather than a deliberate illegal practice as sought to be analy5ed by the (etitioner members#
e+ T*e T*ird .a7uation pro)ess *as been 4ross7K abusedC The marks a.arded in Third aluation .as not taken in some of the cases 1 the marks .hich hae been
taken as =nal marks are actually not the correct marks# Rampant arbitrariness is eident# <ome of the eBamples are as belo.C
Pa4e &'
TA!0E 5 A#
Pa4e &"
<L#)3 Reg )o )ame Remarks (3<T <DLDCTD:
% %"*000 43(6L KR9<H)6 H )
4< 92 6K(2%*)/ indiidual ariation (M&&) TK %!$
marksA T6KD) %8+/ !* marks bene=t
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR
! %!!%,& <H9K6 <H6)K6R )
4< 99 6K(M%8)/ indiidual ariation (,8) TK marks %,"/
a.arded %8"/ %" marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR
& %""+0! LDDL6K6THN K
His29 6K (M&) indiidual ariation (+%) TK marks %&0/
a.arded %+%/ !& marks 7ene=t#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR
, %%"8&% (D::6((696H R <
4eo 9 6K(2%&) indiidual Kariation (M!")/ 2&rd al %&$/
marks taken %*,/ &8 marks bene=t(6lso scaling benift 8,
mrks) totally 0$mrks bene=ted#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR
8 %"+8*, <9:R6?D<H'6R >KK6L9
(6299 6K (2$) indiidual Kariation (M&&)/ &rd Kal %0+/
marks taken %8,/ &! marks less# 4< 9 6K (M%, ) indiidual
Kariation (M8!)/ TK %&+/ a.rded %!8/ $ marks less#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
+ %!!,8% <R9K6)TH R63 K
Cri29 6K (2%$) indiidual Kariation (2,+) &rd Kal done %"*/
marks taken %*8/ +0 marks 7ene=t#(6lso scaling benift
%% mrks)Totally ** mrksbnftd#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
* %"8*%8 K6<6)TH6 K>?6R 7 K
Hist29 6K (M&) indiidual Kariation (M&!)&rd Kal %*"
marks/ taken %+, + marks Less# Kan299 6K (M%!)
indiidual Kariation (M!,)&rd Kal %$8 marks taken %$"/ 8
marks Less#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%%&,8! RDK6))6 R
4<29 6K(2!)/indiidual Kariation (2!8) &rd Kal %,"/ marks
a.arded %++/ !+ marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
0 %"$880 ?6H6)TD<H <
Kan299 6K (M,)indiidual Kariation (M,8) TK done !8%
marks taken !"$/ ,! marks Less# 4s 9 6K (28)indiidual
Kariation (M!!) TK done %&$/ marks taken %,% / ! marks
bene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
$ %&"+&8 R33(6<HRDD 7 K
4s 99 6K (3)indiidual Kariation (2&&) TK done %,&/ marks
taken %&0/ 8 marks less# 4<29 6K(M%*) 9ndidual 6K(M&,)
&rd al %8,/ marks taken 00/ ++ marks less#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%" !"&!!8 <H6)TH6KK6K6:9 His299 &rd Kal %,%/ marks taken %8*/ %+ marks 7ene=t# 6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%% ,"",&0 <HDDL6 TH3?6<
Dng 9 6K (2%!)indiidual Kariation (2&$) TK done %*+
?arks taken !&!# 7ene=t of 8+ marks#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%! %%+%"8 R6K9K>?6R (
Kan299 6K (M%+)indiidual Kariation (2&%) TK done %0+/
marks taken %+&/ !& marks Less#4s 99 6K (2%%)indiidual
Kariation (2,") TK done %,!/ marks taken %*8/ && marks
bene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%& %!!%&, KDDR643>: (6T9L
R: 99 6K (M%)indiidual Kariation (2!") TK done %8+
marks /taken %+0/ %! marks 7ene=t##
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%, %""0+, L6K<H?9K6)TH 7
4s 9 6K (2%!)indiidual Kariation (2,+) TK done %!* /
marks taken %+!/ &8 marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%8 &"**00 7H6R6TH9
(6296K (M!)indiidual Kariation (28%) TK done %8,/ marks
taken %*$/ !8 marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%+ ,%!,%" ?9L6) < ?>R43:
(6 99 6K (2%!)indiidual Kariation (M&,) TK done %*!/
marks taken %80/ %, marks less#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
Pa4e &&
%* %!&!&0 3)K6R6((6 K H
Kan299 6K (2!)indiidual Kariation (M!!) TK done !!$
marks taken %$0/ &% marks Less#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%0 %"!&0" <>)9TH6 ?
(6 99 6K (M*)indiidual Kariation (2&") TK done +%/
marks taken %,%/ 0" marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
%$ !"",,, 46)O9 :6TT6TR6N6
Kan99 6K (2%")indiidual Kariation (2,+) TK done %0$/
marks taken %$,/ 8 marks 7ene=t#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR C3??DRC96L T6P
!" !""8%$ N6<?9) 7D4>? '6L9K6R
Kan 99 6K (2%")indiidual Kariation (2,+) TK done %**/
marks taken %+"# %* marks Less#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR C3??DRC96L T6P
!% %%%**8 N6<H3:H6 K
4s 99 6K (20)indiidual Kariation (M&*) TK done %8"/
marks taken %&,/ %+ marks less#(6 9 6K (20)indiidual
Kariation (20*) TK done %$8/ marks taken !!+/ &% marks
7ene=t#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR C3??DRC96L T6P
!! !"!+&& <H677DDR 76<H6 46)T9
His 9 6K (M%&)indiidual Kariation (M&") TK done %0%/
marks taken %&8/ ,+ marks Less# (6 99 6K (2
%!)indiidual Kariation (M++) TK done %+%/ marks taken
%,8/ %+ marks less#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR C3??DRC96L T6P
!& %%"!%0 <R9)9K6< < ?
His 9 6K (28)indiidual Kariation (2&%) TK done %+,/
marks taken %8+/ %! marks Less#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR C3??DRC96L T6P
!, %"8*%* >?6 K 6
(6 9 6K (M,)indiidual Kariation (M&0) TK done %8"
marks taken %08 marks/ &8 marks 7ene=t#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR C3??DRC96L T6P
!8 !%0&** <H6?7H> 7H6T :
<oc 99 6K (2%!)indiidual Kariation (M!0) TK done %8!/
marks taken %+0/ %+ marks 7ene=ted#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR C3??DRC96L T6P
!+ ,%&&"+ :R >?6K6)TH R <
4s 99 6K (2+)indiidual Kariation (2!$) TK done %,,/ marks
taken %*&/ !$ marks bene=t#
6<<T#C3??9<<93)DR C3??DRC96L T6P
!* ,"!!0* (6):>R6)46 6 R
His 9 6K (20)indiidual Kariation (M!*) TK done %,0/
marks taken %&8/ %& marks Less#
:9<T 2TRD6<>RN 3FF9CDR
!0 ,%80$! <6T9<H 767> H <
R: 9 6K (2%")indiidual Kariation (2!+) TK done %0+/
marks taken %+8/ !% marks Less# 4s 99 6K (M,)indiidual
Kariation (2!") TK done %8*/ marks taken %*,/ %* marks
bene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
!$ %"8%++ >:6N6 K>?6R
(6 992 6K(2*)no scaling/ not to be &rd alued/ but
deliberately &rd al done/ %+$ a.arded# 8 marks bene=t#
4<299 Correct marks !""#
T6H6<9L:6R
&" ,"+*"& 76L6KR9<H)6 C H
4s 99 6K (M$)indiidual Kariation (M,&) TK done %,%/
marks taken %,$/ 0 marks bene=t#
6<<T#L673>R C3??9<<93)DR
&% %%"%$* CH9:6)6):6 ? <
His 9 6K (28)indiidual Kariation (2&+) TK done %+!/
marks taken %*%/ $ marks 7ene=t#
6<<T#L673>R C3??9<<93)DR
&! ,"*0+& ?6H6:DK6 ? ?>R>49
His 99 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (2*%) TK done %,*/
?arks taken %8"/ & marks 7ene=t
T6H6<9L:6R
&& !%+!," (R6KDD) ( 764D'6:9
(6 99 6K (M0)indiidual Kariation (M!*) %0*/ marks taken
%*!/ %8 marks Less#
T6H6<9L:6R
&, !"&*%$ R6K9 ? T9RL6(>R
4< 9 6K (2%!)indiidual Kariation (M8&) TK done %!8/
?arks taken %!0/ & marks 7ene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
Pa4e &;
&8 %"$+&! O6N6?6:H6K6 (
(sy 99 6K (20)indiidual Kariation (2+$) TK done $$/ ?arks
taken %**/ *0 marks bene=t #
T6H6<9L:6R
&+ ,"*"&+ K6K9TH6 R6O6R6?
His 99 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (2+*) TK done %"$/
marks taken %8+/ ,* marks 7ene=ted#
T6H6<9L:6R
&* %""!*& R6<H?9 4
(sy 9 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (2++) TK done %%"
marks taken %!,/ %, marks 7ene=t# 4< 99 6K (2
%,)indiidual Kariation (M&") TK done %,0/ ?arks taken
%!8/ !& marks less#
T6H6<9L:6R
&0 %%&&%& KD)K6TD<H6 ?>RTHN K
His 9 6K (2&)indiidual Kariation (28&) TK done %!%/
marks taken %0+/ +8 marks 7ene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
&$ %&&!&$ R6)46)6TH6
4eo 99 6K (M!)indiidual Kariation (2&!) TK done %&+/
marks taken %*!/ &+ marks bene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
," %"*00+ R6CH6((6 ?
His 9 6K (2%8)indiidual Kariation (M&8) TK done %8$/
marks taken %8,/ 8 marks Less#
T6H6<9L:6R
,% !%8$&* K9O6NK>?6R H3)6KDR9
4< 99 6K (2!)indiidual Kariation (M8*) TK done %"!/
?arks taken %""/ ! marks less#
T6H6<9L:6R
,! !"!,*" <H6<H9:6R 6 764L9
4< 9 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (2!+) TK done %,+/
?arks taken %8&/ * maks bene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
,& ,"&0"& R33(6 R
4< 9 6K (2%!)indiidual Kariation (2&$) TK done 0$/ ?arks
taken %,+/ 8* marks bene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
,, %"*,8* ?6)O>)6TH6 4 )
His 9 6K (M&)indiidual Kariation (M88) TK done %&,/
?arks taken %8%/ %* marks bene=t# His 99 6K (2
%!)indiidual Kariation (M!8) TK done %8,/ ?arks taken
%%+/ &0 marks less# 4< 99 6K (2%)indiidual Kariation (2
!,) TK done %,$/ ?arks taken %8+/ * maks bene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
,8 ,%&+** R33(6 7 R
Kan 99 6K (2%)indiidual Kariation (2!") TK done %,0/
marks taken %*+/ !0 marks 7ene=t#
T6H6<9L:6R
,+ %"%,!$ 46)6(6TH9 K6TT9)6KDRD
<oc 9 6K (2%&)indiidual Kariation (2&8) TK done *+/
marks taken %!0/ 8! marks 7ene=ted#
T6H6<9L:6R
,* %%,+%+ K><>?6 K>?6R9 <
4< 996K (M%!)indiidual Kariation (M&0) TK done %,8/
?arks taken %"+/ &$ marks less#
T6H6<9L:6R
,0 %!&*88 N346)6):6 H 4
(6 99 6K (2+)indiidual Kariation (M,*) TK done %+*/
marks taken %,"/ !* marks less#
,$ %!!8+* <>?6)6
Kan 99 6K (2!)indiidual Kariation (2!*) TK done %*!/
?arks taken %*+/ , marks bene=t#
8" %""%*% H6R<H6K6R:H6) 7 K
6nth 9 6K (2%$)indiidual Kariation (2&$) TK done %,+/
%80/ marks taken %+%/ & marks 7ene=t#
8% %"8"+* ?6)O>)6TH6 7 )
<oc 99 6K (20)indiidual Kariation (2!!) TK done %!$/
marks taken %8"/ !% marks 7ene=t # 4< 99 6K
(M+)indiidual Kariation (M&%) TK done %!8/ ?arks
taken %!%/ , marks less#
8! %""*$8 76L6CH6):R6 ( ?
Kan 99 6K (M0)indiidual Kariation (2!") TK done !",/
marks taken %*&/ &% marks Less#
Pa4e &(
8& ,%"$*& L3KD<H6 7 <
His 9 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (2,&) TK done %%0/
marks taken %08/ +* marks 7ene=ted#
8, !"&&%% FDR3QKH6) ? K9LLD:6R
His99 6K (2%! )indiidual Kariation (2,8) TK done %%,/
marks taken %8"/ &+ marks bene=t#
88 &""0%, 43(6L O6:H6K
4eo 9 6K (2%&)indiidual Kariation (28%) TK done $%/
marks taken %*,/ 0& marks bene=t# 4< 9 6K
(M%")indiidual Kariation (M&!) TK done %%%/ ?arks
taken 88/ 8+ marks less
8+ %!+"8, 4>R>(R6<6: H L
Dco 9 6K (2%8)indiidual Kariation (2&0) TK done %&$/
marks taken !"8/ ++ marks bene=t#
6:?9)9<TR6T9KD L673>R 3FF9CDR
8* %"8!!! R6K9K>?6R 4 (
His 99 6K (M8)indiidual Kariation (M!$) TK done %+%/
?arks taken %&*/ !, marks less#
6<<T#RD49<T6R C323( <3C9T9D<
80 !!"8+! ?6LL6((6 <HDLL9KDR9 (
His 9 6K (20)indiidual Kariation (2!%) TK done %&%/
?arks taken %8*/ !+ marks bene=t#
8$ &"+0$, 6))6(>R6)6 CH3>R
His 99 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (M!") TK done %08/
?arks taken %8!/ && marks less#4< 99 6K (2+)indiidual
Kariation (2&+) TK done %%&/ ?arks taken %,&/ &" marks
bene=t#
+" ,%!%+$ K9O6N6K>?6R 4 R
<oc 9 6K (M8)indiidual Kariation (M&+) TK done %!!/
?arks taken %!0/ + marks bene=t#
+% !%0!80 K6LL6((6 376))643L
(69 6K (M+)indiidual Kariation (M!,) TK done %8,/
?arks taken marks taken %+8# %% marks bene=t#
+! %&,8&8 >?6 ? )
His 9 6K (M!)indiidual Kariation (2,") TK done %*+/
?arks taken %$+/ !" marks bene=t#
+& ,%8&&+ K>?>:6 49R9<H
His 9 6K (M&)indiidual Kariation (2&+) TK done %&*/
?arks taken %*,/ &* marks bene=t#
+, %!%*80 43(6L6 RD::N K
4< 92 6K (M%*)/ 1 indiidual is diF (M%0)/ yet/ sent for
&rd al/ 1 a.arded %&& marks#
+8 %&!&"8 R6O6))6 (
4< 9 6K (2%,)indiidual Kariation (2%!) TK not re;uired/
but TK done and a.arded %,0/ %% marks bene=t#
Dmployment 3@cers
++ ,"%00" <>O6T6 C D
Dng 99 6K (28)indiidual Kariation (280) TK done %0"/
?arks taken !%8/ &8 marks bene=t#
Dmployment 3@cers
+* !"""$& <>CHDT6 ? )DL6K949
(sy 9 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (2&+) TK done $%/
?arks taken %,"/ ,$ marks bene=t#
6<<T#:9RDCT3R 3F N3>TH <DRK9CD<
+0 !"8&"+ ?>K6((6 K6R67H9?6))6K6R
His 9 6K (2%)indiidual Kariation (2!,) TK done %&$/
?arks taken %,8/ + marks bene=t# His 99 6K (2
%&)indiidual Kariation (2!,) TK done %!,/ ?arks taken
&&/ $ marks bene=t#Kan299 6K (2,) indiidual Kariation (")
CD DBaminer marks %*8/ but marks taken %$8/ !" ?arks
7ene=t#(T3T6LLN +M$M!"R&8 ?RK< 7D)DF9T)
CH9DF 3FF9CDR
+$ %"0%*$ O6N6?6L6 (
(6 9 6K (2&)indiidual Kariation (M!,) TK done $0/ ?arks
taken %,$/ 8% marks bene=t#(699 6K (2$)indiidual
Kariation (288) TK done %&8/ ?arks taken %*!/ &*
marks bene=t#
CH9DF 3FF9CDR
Pa4e &@
*" %!%8*+ ?6)O>)6TH6 <'6?N
His 9 6K (")indiidual Kariation (2&+) TK done %&&/ ?arks
taken %&*/ , marks bene=t#
*% &"*%*0 :DD(6K
His 99 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (M!%) TK done %!,/
?arks taken %&8/ %% marks bene=t#
*! %%&8*$ KD)K6TD<H6((6 )
4< 9 6K (2%,)indiidual Kariation (2&!) TK done %!+/
?arks taken %!*/ % mark bene=t#
*& %"!,," 7D)6K6 (R6<6:
His 9 6K (M*)indiidual Kariation (2!%) TK done %!*/
marks taken %*,/ ,* marks bene=t#
*, ,%!&88 RDK6TH9 769 <
(6 9 6K (2+)indiidual Kariation (2*8) TK done %,*/marks
taken %$"/ ,& marks bene=t# 4< 9 6K (2%$)indiidual
Kariation (2&+) TK done +0/ ?arks taken %"*/ &$ marks
bene=t#(T3T6LLN ,&M&$R0! ?6RK< 7D)DF9T)
*8 %%*$+$ R>K?6)9 :DK9 )
Kan 99 6K (2!)indiidual Kariation (2,+) TK done
%,!/marks taken %80/ %+ marks bene=t#
*+ !"&*!+
<3?6<HDKH6R )N6?643>:6
76<6((6
4eo 99 6K (20)indiidual Kariation (28$) TK done
%!&/?arks taken %0,/ +% ?arks 7ene=t# 4< 9 6K (2
%!)indiidual Kariation (2&") TK done %!%/ ?arks taken
%%%/ %" marks less# 4< 99 6K (2%!)indiidual Kariation
(M!0) TK done %!"/ ?arks taken %%"/ %" marks less#
** ,%8",% K9)D<H6 R O
4< 9 6K (2%,)indiidual Kariation (2!") TK done %""/
?arks taken %%*/ %* marks bene=t#
*0 %!8,$+ R6?D<H K
His 99 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (2,$) TK done
%,*/marks taken %$%/,, marks bene=t#
*$ %&"%8, H3L676<6((6 76LD46R
Kan 99 6K (M%+)indiidual Kariation (2&0) TK done
$*/marks taken %%%/%, marks bene=t#
0" %%$"%, R6O6))6 K
Dco 9 6K (2%+)indiidual Kariation (2&8) TK done
%%8/marks taken %+,/ ,$ maks bene=t#4< 99 6K (2
*)indiidual Kariation (M!!) TK done %!8/ ?arks taken
%%$/ + ?arks less
0% ,"%*,& ?3H6) C H
<oc 9 6K (M0)indiidual Kariation (M&") TK done $!
marks taken %%8/!& marks bene=t#4< 9 6K (M+)indiidual
Kariation (M,%) TK done %&$/ ?arks taken $"/ ,$ marks
less#
0! ,"$**% R6)9 H C ?
(sy 99 6K (M%+)indiidual Kariation (2&8) TK done
0$/marks taken %8!/ +& marks benift# <oc29 6K (2
%0)indiidual Kariation (M+,) TK done 0+/ marks taken
%""/%, marks 7enift# <oc 99 6K (2*)indiidual Kariation
(M*") TK done %8&/ marks taken 0,/+$ marks less#
0& %%,+!% D<H'6R6 )
(6 99 6K (2%&)indiidual Kariation (2,+) TK done %!"
marks taken %+, ,, marks 7ene=t# 4< 99 6K
(M%8)indiidual Kariation (M!8) TK done %,%/marks
taken %!"/ &% marks less#
0, %%8+,& <HNL6O6 ? K
4< 99 6K (M0) indiidual Kariation (2,$) TK done
%%%/marks taken %,&/ &! marks bene=t#
Pa4e &E
08 %%8!&+ )6R6<9?6 ?>RTHN K
4< 99 6K (2%&)indiidual Kariation (2&+) TK done %&,/
marks taken %80/ !, marks bene=t#
6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
0+ %%*8*& ?6HD<H'6R6((6 K
4< 9 6K (2%+)indiidual Kariation (M&0) TK done %,$/
marks taken %8%/ ! marks bene=t#
6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
0* %%$!%& <H6<H9:6R6 O D
4eo 99 6K (M%")indiidual Kariation (2&&) TK done %&%/
marks taken %88/ !, 7ene=t#
6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
00 ,"%!*+ <NDD:6 6)ODD:6 (6RKDD)
4eo 9 6K (20)indiidual Kariation (2!+) TK done %,,/
marks taken %+"/ %+ marks bene=t#
6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
0$ %!,+*0 KDD)6 R
<oc 9 6K (2%!)indiidual Kariation (2&&) TK done %,8/
marks taken %8"/ 8 marks bene=t#
6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
$" %!!!*$ RDKH6 : 4< 92 DBaminer marks %0%/ actual marks %&0# 6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
$% %%+&0* <H6)T6 K>?6R9 4 7
<oc 9 6K (2%0)indiidual Kariation (2&!) TK done %"&/
marks taken %%0/ %8 marks bene=t/ R: 99 6K
(M%)indiidual Kariation (2!&) TK done %&!/ marks taken
%%0/ %, marks less#
6<<T CH9DF 6>:9T3R<
Re4ardin4 a77e4ed abuse o9 t*e t*ird <a7uation pro)ess-
The (etitioner members hae furnished a tabulated statement sho.ing the particulars of the certain selected candidates in .hich cases mistakes in respect of third
aluation marks are pointed out# The remarks in the said tabulated statement to the eBtent they tally .ith the remarks in the tabulated statement at 6nneBure29 are
correct# Ho.eer/ a perusal of the said table indicates that in certain cases more marks and in certain cases fe.er marks hae been taken into consideration#
f)# 9n some cases/ ariation in marks hae not been taken into consideration at the time of moderation (.hich is an illegality i#e# non2compliance of the order of this
Honble Court .ith regard to moderation)# The said diFerences hae been totally ignored# <ome of eBamples are as follo.s#
Tab7e / A"'
Reg no )ame <ubGect DBaminer marks
(aper picked for
random reie.
Real2 marks ?arks :iFerence
%"$%*8 (6RK6TH9# H#7 4<299 $& ND< !%! %%*
,%88** :DKR6O> #6 History299 %+" T3( 8, %"+
%"$+&! O6N6?6:H6K6 (sychology %** T3( %"0 +$
%!8&*& K3:943':6 64#1 ?KT4/<DR9#2% !!* T3( %&, $&
Re4ardin4 <ariation in 6ar8s not ta8en into )onsideration-
Pa4e &F
The said sub2heading is already coered under 9ssue )o &-c aboe#
9+ Errati) .a7uationC The (etitioner ?embers/ after reie.ing the ans.er scripts made aailable to it/ has ascertained that there has been a lot of erratic aluation#
6ns.er scripts hae been arbitrarily and negligently ealuated# 9n some instances .here the DBaminers hae a.arded 5ero marks/ on realuation/ the same
ans.ers hae been gien high marks# The instances gien the tables belo. indicate this# Ho.eer/ the said tables are not eBhaustie/ for the reasons stated earlier#
Tab7e / A""
<l )o <ubGect -(aper )ame of DBaminer 1 Code Reg# no#
3ld
marks
<cript <elected
for Kaluation as
Top-Random
)e. marks-
Realuation
?arks arried
:iFerence of
marks
% "&-% 73T6)N S % "&2%, - ?#<#(><H(6L6TH6 ,%"++% !+, Top %,* ""F
! "&-! 73T6)N S ! "&2"0 -(R3F#?#KD<H6K6 ?69N6 %!+8," !%" Top %%! /#$
& "&-! 73T6)N S ! "&2%, - ?#<#(><H(6L6TH6 %""0"! !%8 Random %"$ /"'E
, "&-! 73T6)N S ! "&2%, - ?#<#(><H(6L6TH6 %!,&%% !8% Top %!, /"&F
8 "&-! 73T6)N S ! "&2%, - ?#<#(><H(6L6TH6 %!,,%$ !*% Top %!$ /"(&
+ "&-! 73T6)N S ! "&2%8 - (R3F#KH>R<H9: N6<?9)#K ,%,&*8 !!% Top %%! /"'#
* "&-! 73T6)N S ! "&2!* - K#(R6T97H6 %!0!08 %$$ Random *% / "&$
0 "&-! 73T6)N S ! "&2!$ - (R3F#)6NDD? >LL6KH6) %%$*+& !!" Top %%8 /"'@
$ "&-! 73T6)N S ! "&2&& - :R#<#R#6?79K6 ,"!!8% !%! Top 00 /"&(
%" "&-! 73T6)N S ! "&2&& - :R#<#R#6?79K6 ,%8%"! !," Top %!% /""#
%% "+-% C3??DRCD S % "+2"0 - R64H>R6?6 6 %%+,%8 !"! Top *% /";"
%! "+-% C3??DRCD S % "+2"0 - R64H>R6?6 6 %"!,*& %*+ Top 80 /""$
Pa4e &$
%& "+-% C3??DRCD S % "+2"0 - R64H>R6?6 6 %"!0&0 %$, Top $! /"'&
%, "*-% CR9?9)3L34N S % "*2"& - KD)CH6) < C %%!$8+ !&0 Top %&! "'E
%8 "*-% CR9?9)3L34N S % "*2%" - '6::9) K N %!++%+ %$$ Top 8+ "(;
%+ "*-! CR9?9)3L34N S ! "*2"& - KD)CH6) < C !"%$&8 !,, Random %"$ ";@
%* "*-! CR9?9)3L34N S ! "*2"& - KD)CH6) < C ,%%++& !," Top %!% ""#
%0
"0-% DC3)3?9C< S %
"02!! - 6<'6TH6??6 H < ,"!8"! !", Top $% /"";
%$
"0-% DC3)3?9C< S %
"02!& - ?6)3H6R 46)TD %"+!!* %08 Top %!, E"
!" "0-! DC3)3?9C< S ! "02%" - (R3F#?#:6N6<H6)K6R6R63 ,%!8$! !!" Top %"* "";
!% "0-! DC3)3?9C< S ! "02!& - ?6)3H6R 46)TD %"0%!8 !%$ Top %"$ ""'
!! "0-! DC3)3?9C< S ! "02&8 - 46:'6L C 6 !"8&&0 %$+ Top 0% ""@
!& %"-% 4D34R6(HN S % %"2!! - :DK6R6O> ) ,"8088 !%8 Top %%8 "''
!, %"-% 4D34R6(HN S % %"2!8 - (6T9L 7 ? ,"$%!& !%0 Top %%! "'E
!8 %"-% 4D34R6(HN S % %"2!* - ?>RTHN < 4 %!+*&& !"* Top %"% "'E
!+ %"-% 4D34R6(HN S %
Re4 ardin4 Errati) .a7uation-
The(etitioner members hae furnished a tabulated statement sho.ing the particulars of some of the selected candidates in .hich cases there hae been large diFerence
in marks from the original eBaminer to the realuation marks#The method of moderation-random reie. has been adopted in the aluation process as a measure to check
any erratic aluation and it .as only on account of the comparison .ith the realuation marks that the (etitioner members hae dra.n an inference that the aluation is
erratic# 7ig diFerence in marks in the original aluation and re2aluation cannot by itself be termed as arbitrary and negligent aluation# 9t is necessary to be noted that
.hen large number of ans.er scripts are alued there is a chance of human error and therefore the system of realuation/ moderation and scaling has been adopted in
order to oFset any such errors# 7ecause of the adoption of the process of realuation/ moderation and scaling the said errors hae been identi=ed and therefore/ it .ould
Pa4e &#
not be appropriate to dra. any aderse inference on the basis of the said data# Furthermore/ it .as in respect of the aluation in these ery subGects that this Honble High
Court in order dated %%#%"#!""! passed in '#(#)o# %!8,0-!""!has gien certain =ndings/ .hich order has become =nal#
III+ Ano6a7ies durin4 in t*e sta4e o9 Persona7itK Test-
The basic Ea. of the K(<C in these selection processes is that it has failed to properly/ logically and consistently apply the reseration policy is a is the "-&' ratio (for
?ain DBamination) and "-@ ratio (for (ersonality Test)# 6s per the Karnataka Recruitment of 4a5etted (robationers (appointment by Competitie DBaminations) Rules# The
copy of said rules is here.ith produced as ide Anne:ure 5 A/E% as per the rules there are t.o stages before actual selection i#e# after the preliminary eBamination .hen
candidates are chosen to .rite the main eBamination it has to be in the ratio of %C!" i#e# if there is one post resered for a particular category then !" candidates from
that category are eligible to .rite the main eBamination# The same holds good for personality test/ but the ratio is %C8# 3nly after the (ersonality Test/ .hen the marks in
the ?ain DBamination and the (ersonality Test are added/ a merit list (irrespectie of the category-caste) on the basis of the total marks is prepared# Then the =rst 8"H of
posts are =lled in the 4? category and only thereafter the reseration sets in# 6ny candidate .ho is from 4?/ .ho is not in the =rst 8"H of the merit list/ .ill not get any
post een though he may hae scored more than others .ho hae the bene=t of reseration#
The K(<C has ho.eer faltered in this# 'hat the K(<C has done is thisC after the preliminary eBamination instead of calling the candidates in the %C!" ratio .ith regard to
their particular category claimed by them/ K(<C has sent candidates from the category pool the 4? pool on the premise that they hae scored higher marks# 6s in =nal
selection a process of cut2oF for 4? is =rst made and candidates aboe that marks/ irrespectie of their category/ are =rst sent into the 4? pool and later on %C!" ratio
non24? candidates are short2listed and called for main eBaminations# 6fter the main eBamination/ the same eBercise is repeated by the K(<C to call for (ersonality Test/
but in %C8 ratio# 6ny person .ho is in the 4? pool .hile .riting the main eBamination (although claiming category-caste bene=t/ but in the 4? pool on the basis of the
aforesaid method of K(<C) can get into the category - caste pool based on his marks in the main eBamination/ for being considered to (ersonality Test# This eBercise is
faulty for the reason that this is not .hat is enisaged# This process adopted by the K(<C is selection at eery stage/ .hich actually had to be only in the =nal stage i#e#
after the totaling of marks in main eBamination and personality test# This process adopted by the K(<C has resulted in actually depriing the 4? candidates of their
rightful entitlement as per the ratio and has placed in the hands of the K(<C an all encompassing po.er to change the categories as per its .hims and fancies#
'ith this background the follo.ing tables make it clear as to .hat this has resulted inC
Pa4e ;'
Ratio .io7ation- 3n the basis of the detailed information proided to the (etitioner ?embers/ the (etitioner ?embers has come to =nding .ith regard to the proportional
ratio at the stage of (ersonality Test# The complete list of candidates and their categories/ .ho .ere called for the personality test is gien in tables put in is here .ith
produced as ide Anne:ure 5 A/@3
TA!0E 5A"&
173 No3 Cate4orK
Nu6ber o9 posts
a77otted to ea)*
)ate4orK
Nu6ber to be
)a77ed IN "-@ RATIO
Nu6ber a)tua77K
)a77ed
DiMeren)e in t*e
nu6ber
Ratio DiMeren)e
" GM GMC>MP "$F #;@ @&" /("( "-&3F$
& 1C E( ;&' ;#; GF; "-E3"(
; 1T "# #@ ""( G"# "-E
( C/" && ""' "(& G;& "-E3(@
@ &A @& &E' ;@( G#( "-E3$'
E &! "F $@ ""( G&# "-E3F'
F ;A "" @@ "E# G""( "-"@3;E
$ ;! "" @@ ""E GE" "-"'3@(
TOTA0 ;$; "#"@ "#&;
3n perusal of the aboe table/ it is clear that the ratio policy of %C8 for (ersonality Test has been iolated and disproportionate number of candidates are made eligible# 9t
may also be seen that there is gross disproportion in 4?/ .hich resulted in disadantage to 4? candidates and contrarily there is gross disproportion .ith regard to &6
candidates/ .hich resulted in disproportionate adantage to the said category/ at the cost of the 4?# 9n this regard many aspiring 4eneral ?erit candidates right to
selection .as denied and is unconstitutional/ iolating 6rticles %, and %+#
Pa4e ;"
a+ 'ith regard to category &6/ the posts noti=ed .ere %% and 88 persons had to be called for (T# Ho.eer/ as per the information proided by the K(<C %+$ candidates
belonging to &6 .ere called for the interie.# The follo.ing 0 candidates .ho had secured less marks than the =rst 88 of &6 category .ere also called for (T and
.ere selected#
TA!0E 5 A";
THE DETAI01 OF ;A CANDIDATE1 1E0ECTED IN .IO0ATION OF THE GP "##F RECR,ITMENT R,0E1 OF 1CH,DE0E/II OF PART C/PER1ONA0IT2 TE1T (O,T
OF "-@ RATIO + G3P/"##$3
103
NO3
103 NO3
IN PT
0I1T
REG3 NO3
NAME OF THE
CANDIDATE
?RITTEN
MARB1
CATEGOR2
C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION
PO1T 1E0ECTEDCCATEGOR2
1HO?N IN FINA0 0I1T
MARB1 A?ARDED IN
INTER.IE?
% +! %!%0*$ ?6:D43':6 H ? 0,, &6 6<<T# CH9DF 6>:9T3R-4?-&6
%88
! +& ,%%!&& L3KD<H 4 6 0,& &6 6<<T#TRD6<>RN 3FFR#-4?-&6
%8"
& *" %&8%08 L6K6)N6 < 0&, &6 6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR-4?-&6
%88
, 08 ,%&+** R33(6 7 R 0%0 &6 T6H<9L:6R-4?-&6
%88
8 0$ %"&0"! (><H(6 : R 0%8 &6 :9<T#?6RKDT9)4 3FFR-4?-&6
%88
+ $! ,%,$80 HD?6K6TH9 ? ) 0%% &6 6<<T# CH9DF 6>:9T3R-4?-&6
%88
* %"% ,",**+ K9O6N6L6K<H?9 O 7 0", &6 D?(L3N?D)T 3FFR#4?-&6
%8"
0 %!" %%0$*, <>?6 ? K *0! &6 :9<T#?6RKDT9)4 3FFR-4?-&6
%8&
Ratio .io7ation-
3n the basis of the data furnished by the K(<C as eBtracted in Table 62%!/ inference is dra.n by the (etitioner ?embers that there has been iolation of ratio of %C!" and
%C8 at the stage of calling the candidates for main eBamination as .ell personality test respectiely# The petitioner members hae correctly stated in their analysis as to
ho. the ratio of %C!" and %C8 has been actually applied# 7ut they hae ho.eer opined that the said eBercise as carried out by the K(<C is faulty for the reason that the
said procedure follo.ed by the K(<C is not as enisaged# Ho.eer/ the said analysis of the (etitioner ?embers is incorrect in as much as/ there is no basis for the
purported procedure suggested by the (etitioner members in any Rules or 4oernment 3rders relating to reseration and selection# The analysis by the petitioner
members that this process adopted by the K(<C has actually depried the 4? candidates of their rightful entitlement as per the ratio is also incorrect/ in ie. of the fact
Pa4e ;&
that it is .ell settled legal position that a candidate claiming reseration is also entitled to compete in the 4eneral ?erit (ool and if the method as stated by the (etitioner
?embers .ere to be adopted/ it .ould in fact result in depriation of meritorious candidates an opportunity from being considered in the 4? (ool# The (etitioner ?embers
hae mis2read the data at TableC 62%! in as much as the number of candidates .ho .ere called for personality test in the ratio of %C8 also includes those persons from the
said category .ho .ere eligible for personality test on the basis of their merit also (i#e#/ under 4?)# Hence/ the said analysis of the (etitioner ?embers is incorrect and
there is no iolation as sought to be made out by the (etitioner ?embers#
b+Findin4 =it* re4ard to t*e a)tua7 pro)ess o9 inter<ie= and a=ard o9 6ar8sC 3n the basis of the records proided to the (etitioner ?embers/ the (etitioner
?embers has made the follo.ing =ndings/ enumerated under diFerent headings/ as belo.#
i3 Candidates absent =ere a=arded Mar8s Mar8s a=arded Candidates 6ade absent3
TA!0E 5A"(
103 NO3 NAME OF CANDIDATE REG3 NO3 CATEGOR2 PO1T 1E0ECTED FINDING1
%
)9R?6L6 )
%"8+!&
!6-F
(9nterie. book no#
88)
:D(>TN <>(T:# 3F
DPC9<D
:r H ) Krishna marked as 67<D)T again oer
.ritten as %!" marks# (7oth in .ords and in
=gures)
H < (atilmarked as 67<D)T again oer .ritten as
%%" (7oth in .ords and in =gures)
:asaiah marked as 67<D)T and a.arded %!"
marks
!
K><>?6 K>?6R9 <
%%,+%+
<T-F (9nterie. book
no# 8&)
T6H6<9L:H6R
:asaiah marked as 67<D)T and a.arded ,"
marks only#
&
R64H> 4 (
%"8+$*
4? 6<<T# C3)TR#
:asaiah marked 67<D)T oer .ritten as %88
marks#
,
R6O> ?34H6KDDR6 K
%%$,00
C6T2% T6H6<9L:H6R
H < (atil marked as 67<D)T and oer .ritten %,&
marks#
8
L6L9TH6??6 ?
%&&%!0
:asaiah a.arded *" marks and oer .ritten as
67<D)T#
+
<>7R6H?6)N6 R63 ? <
,%,,,8
4?
Kenkatas.amy a.arded *" marks and marked
as 67<D)T#
Pa4e ;;
Candidates =*o =ere absent =ere a=arded 6ar8s and 6ar8s a=arded )andidates =ere 6ade absent3
The (etitioner ?embers hae pointed siB instances/ .herein they hae found that in the interie. records maintained by the K(<C initially though a candidate .as
marked as absent/ =nally he .as been a.arded marks by oer .riting and in t.o cases .here one member has a.arded marks/ it .as oer .ritten as absent# The fact
that in some cases initially though there is a marking as absent and by oer2.riting marks hae been a.arded .ould not in any .ay proe that an absent candidate .as
a.arded marks# ?arks .ere a.arded manually and any mistake can al.ays be corrected by oer2.riting# There is no allegation of tampering by the ?ember .ho has
a.arded the marks# Therefore only on the basis of the said facts/ an inference cannot be dra.n that absent candidates .as a.arded marks# Furthermore in respect of the
conclusion that candidates .ho had attended the personality test .ere made absent/ Gust on the basis of the fact that there .as oer2.riting .ould be far2fetched
conclusion#
ii3 I.+3 1in47e Me6ber a=arded t*e 6ar8s and on t*e basis t*e )andidates =ere se7e)ted- 9t has come to the kno.ledge of the (etitioner ?embers
that on "%-"!-!""+ at &#"" pm the interie. .as conducted by a single member i#e# <ri# Kenkatas.amy# ?arks .ere a.arded by this member alone# This is in
iolation of the rule (Rule %& of K(<C Conduct of 6dditional 7usiness 1 Function Rules) that there should be a minimum of t.o members in the panel of
interie.# !" candidates .ere interie.ed by the said person# Clari=cation .as sought from the K(<C# The K(<C proided a photo copy of a paper .herein it is
sho.n that another member <mt# Lilian Paier has a.arded marks# Ho.eer/ the (etitioner ?embers notes that this photo copy is only subse;uently
produced and .as not in the bundle relating to that particular days interie. records# The K(<C also has failed to proide any original document in this
regard# The follo.ing candidates .ere selected on the basis of the interie. done by the said single member#
TA!0E 5 A"@
<l no )ame of the Candidate Reg#)o Category claimed
Mar8s a=arded in
Inter<ie=
(ost <elected
% <hianandaKapashi ,""*!0 &7 %8" 6sst# Commissioner
! <hiananda 4# )ai !%$,80 &7 %,8 6sst# Controller
A=ardin4 o9 6ar8s bK a 1in47e Me6ber in Persona7itK Test% in <io7ation o9 1e)tion "; o9 t*e BP1C (Condu)t o9 !usiness and Additiona7 Fun)tions+A)t%
"#@# and 1e7e)tion o9 Candidates on t*e basis o9 su)* persona7itK test3
The (etitioner ?embers hae stated that after haing found that a single member of the Commission has a.arded marks/ they hae sought for clari=cation from the K(<C
and .ere proided .ith (hotocopy of a paper .herein it is sho.n that another ?ember <mt# LilianQaier has a.arded marks# The (etitioner ?embers hae opined that
the said photocopy is only subse;uently produced and .as not in the bundle relating to that particular days interie. record and that K(<C has failed to proide any
original documents in this regard# The (etitioner ?embers hae also pointed out that the said single member has a.arded to certain candidates/ out of .hich t.o hae
Pa4e ;(
been selected# 9t is to be noted that the recruitment is of the year %$$0/ .hich .as completed in the year !""+/ and all aailable records in the o@ce of K(<C hae been
made aailable# The fact that the photocopy is furnished .ithout furnishing the original .ould not in any .ay proe that <mt# LilianQaier has not a.arded marks# There
is no allegation that the said (hoto Copy seems to be a created document# Hence/ the documents made aailable by the K(<C accepted on the face alue .ould in fact
go to sho. that the interie. committee consisted of t.o members as per the section referred to supra#
iii3 A77 Me6bers a=arded sa6eCeNua7 Mar8sC 6fter the perusal of the interie. documents reeals that maGority of the selected candidates .ere a.arded e;ual
?arks or similar ?arks to suit group 6 1 7 posts# 9t is indicatie of the fact that marks had been pre2determined# The follo.ing are some of the instancesC
TA!0E / A"E
<l# no# )6?D RD4 )3# (3<T <DLDCTD: )6?D 3F THD ?D?7DR ?6RK< 6'6R:D:
6KDR64D 3F
?6RK<#
% 76<6K6R6OD):R6 #H %"&08! 6<<T#C3??R# :r#H) KR9<H)6 %,8 %,8
L9LL96) P6K9DR %,8
:6<696H %,8
KD)K6T<'6?N %,8
! 43(6LKR9<H)6 H ) %"*00+ 6<<T#C3??R# :r#H) KR9<H)6 %88 %88
L9LL96) P6K9DR %88
:6<696H %88
KD)K6T<'6?N %88
(6T9L H < %88
& L9)46))6 K>CH676L %",*!! 6CCT %8"
L9LL96) P6K9DR %8"
KD)K6T<'6?N %8"
(6T9L H < %8"
, R6K9 ?R %"!+$+ 6<<T#C3??R# (6T9L H < %!" %!"
:6<696H %!"
8 CH6):R6 )69K > !""$&* :3 <C-<T :6<696H %!" %!"
KD)K6T<'6?N %!"
(6T9L H < %!"
+ L3KD<H6 46 ,%%!&& T6H<9L:6R L9LL96) P6K9DR %8" %8"
(6T9L H < %8"
KD)K6T<'6?N %8"
* )6ODD7>LL6H KH6) %&%$"& 6<<T TRN 3FF9CDR :r H ) KR9<H)6 %"8 %"8
(6T9L %"8
:6<696H %"8
0 ?>)9 RD::N 7 ? %"80%* 6<<T TRN 3FF9CDR L9LL96) P6K9DR %8" %8"
KD)K6T<'6?N %8"
$ <6KDDTHR9 7 K6:9 !"+&** 6RC< :r H ) KR9<H)6 %8"
H < (6T9L %8"
:6<696H %8" %8"
%" )9R6)O6) R %""&&+ 6:LR :r H ) KR9<H)6 %8"
Pa4e ;@
H < (6T9L %8"
%% R64H> 4 ( %"8+$* 6<<T# C3)TR# :r H ) KR9<H)6 %88
H < (6T9L %88
:6<696H %88
A77 t*e 6e6bers o9 t*e inter<ie= )o66ittee *a<e a=arded sa6eCeNua7 6ar8s-
There is legal bar for all the members of the interie. committee to a.ard e;ual marks# 9t cannot also be concluded that Gust because all the members of the interie.
committee hae a.arded e;ual marks to a candidate/ the same is pre2determined#
i<+3 Candidates )onsidered under GM 9or not possessin4 Caste In)o6e CertiJ)ates- Candidates .ho did not produce caste and income certi=cates at
the time of interie. .ere considered under 4?/ after taking a representation from them# They had been considered under their respectie categories all along i#e
during the preliminary eBam and main eBamination and during the short listing for (ersonality Test# They got the bene=t of being considered in their respectie
categories all along and later they are considered under 4? for (ersonality Test at the time of the interie.# This is a gross iolation of the rules specifying that
candidates .ho do not produce the releant certi=cates shall not be considered for selection#
Tab7e 5 A"F
10
NO
NAME REG NO3
NOTING OF THE P E IN THE
ATTENDENCE
REMARB OF THE COMMN
IN THE IN THE PT
1TATEMENT
REMARB OF THE !RANCH
ORDER
OF THE
COMMN3
PO1T 1E0ECTED
"
1313MADH,BE1H?AR
""@&E(
OOOOO33
NOT PROD,CED ORC
,NDER GM
D,RING PT CANDT FAI01 TO
PROD,CE ORIGN0 CA1TE %ICC
CERTIFCT31CORED #;E
MARB1 %A01O ?CI AGE 0IMIT%
E0IGI!0E TO PT ,NDER
GM %COMMN CON1ENT
1O,GHT3
OB TAH1I0DAR
&
MEEREA RACHAPPA
A0,R
;'"';"
ORGN0 CERTFCT NOT
PROD,CED FOR ORDER1%
E0IGI!0E ,NDER GM
ORC NOT PROD,CED
%INTER.IE?ED ,NDER GM
PROD,CE ;! ORIGN0
CA1TE %ICC CERTIFCT31CORED
"';F MARB1 %A01O ?CI AGE
0IMIT% E0IGI!0E TO PT
,NDER GM %COMMN
CON1ENT 1O,GHT3
OB (ACCT+
; NAGA HAN,MAIAH G3H
";;'(#
;A CON1IDERD%ORG ;A
DTD3E3(3"##$ NOT
PRO,D,CED%MARB1 1EC,RED
THE ORGINA0 ;A
CERTIFICATE NOT
PRO,D,CED AT THE TIME
PROD,CE ;A ORIGN0 CA1TE
%ICC CERTIFCTDATED
OB THA1I0DAR3
Pa4e ;E
#(&%C,T/OF FOR
GM(MA0E+$"&%E0EGI!0E ,NDER
46%
OF INTR.3%!,T
CON1IDEARD
INTER.IE?ED ,NDER
GM CATEGOR23
E3(3"##$31CORED
#($&MARB1 %A01O ?CI AGE
,NDER GM %COMMN
CON1ENT 1O,GHT
(
NIRANDAN 3R3
"'';;E
;A CON1IDERD%ORG ;A
DTD";3;3"##$ NOT
PRO,D,CED%MARB1 1EC,RED
$F@%C,T/OF FOR
GM(MA0E+$"&%E0EGI!0E ,NDER
46%
;A ORC NOT PROD,CED
,NDER GM%
%ICC
CERTIFCTDATED";3;3"##$
OB AD0R
@
HAN,MANTE GO?DA T
1
"'(E($
;A CERTIFICATE NOT PROD,CED
E0IGI!0E ,NDER GM%FOR
ORDER1
ORC NOT PROD,CED
%,NDER GM
PROD,CE ORIGN0 CA1TE %ICC
R0 CERTIFCT31CORED ##$
MARB1 A01O ?CI AGE 0IMIT%
E0IGI!0E TO PT ,NDER GM
COMMN CON1ENT 1O,GHT3
OB
A11T3
CONTRO00ER
E
DEETENDRA 1HETT2
(''$;F
ORGN0 ;! CERTIFICATE NOT
PROD,CED E0IGI!0E ,NDER
GM%FOR ORDER1
ORC NOT PROD,CED
%INTER.IE?ED ,NDER GM
PROD,CE ORIGN0 ;!
CA1TE %ICC R0
CERTIFCT31CORED $F&
MARB1 A01O ?CI AGE 0IMIT
%E0IGI!0E TO PT ,NDER GM
OB AD21
F
BA.ITHA 1 MANNIBERI
"'@E$#
(a+&A DEC0RN3 PORTION I1 THE
APP0N3
(b+NOC FRM DDPI% I1 PROD,CED
OOOO33
a+&A DEC0RN3 PORTION I1
THE APP0N3
(b+NOC FRM DDPI% I1
PROD,CED
OB
AC
$
0A.AN2A 1
";@"$@
NOC COPIE1 OF ENC01 GI.EN OOOO
CANDT ?ORBING A1
1ECTION OFFR IN AG OFF
NOCFRM 1ENIOR A,DIT
OFFR HA1 !EEN PROD,CED3
COMMN CON1ENT 1O,GHT
OB
A11T3
CONTRO00ER
#
MAND,NATH P31
""&EF#
ORIGINA0 ;! CRTFT NOT
PRO,D,CED MARB1 OPTAINED
#($ !ECOME1 E0EGI!0E ,NDER
GM3%FOR ORDER13
NOT POD,CED ORG ;!
CERTIFICATE AT THE TIME
OF INTR.IE?3THERE FORE
INTR.IED ,NDER GM3
PROD,CE ;! ORIGN0
CA1TE %ICC CERTIFCT31CORED
#($ MARB1 %A01O ?CI AGE
,NDER GM %COMMN
CON1ENT 1O,GHT3
OB TAH1I0DAR
"'
PAR.ATHI 3H3!3
"'#"F@
//////////////////////////////
ANOTHER 1ET OF
ENC0O1ER1 GI.EN %
D,RING PT CANDT
PROD,CED ANOTHER 1ET
OF DOC,MENT13 % COMMN
CON1ENT 1O,GHT3
OB
A11T3
CONTRO00ER
"" ROOPA 3!R THE ORGINA0 ;A CERTIFICATE ////////////////////// D,RING PT CANDT FAI01 TO OB TAHA1I0DAR
Pa4e ;F
(";EFF
NOT PRO,D,CED % PRO,D,CED
INCOM CA1TE CRTFT%DATED
E3("##$ I1 FOR PER1,A0
ORDER1%COP2 OF ?HICH I1 IN
THE APP0ICATION%
PROD,CE ;A ORIGN0 CA1TE%
ICC CERTIFCT% PROD,CED
ON02 INCOME CA1TE
CERTIFICATE DATED
E3(3"##$3 FOR ORDER13
"&
1A.ITHRI3!3BADI
&';&&@
THE ORGINA0 ;A CERTIFICATE
NOT PRO,D,CED %
DATED3&"3;3"##$3FOR
.ARIFICATION%MARB1 1C,RED
$(E%E0EGI!0E ,NDER G M% FOR
ORDER1%
THE ORGINA0 CERTIFICATE
NOT
PRO,D,CED%INTER.ED
,NDER G M%
%ICC CERTIFCTDATED
&"3';3"##$31CORED
$(EMARB1 %A01O ?CI AGE
,NDER GM %COMMN
CON1ENT 1O,GHT
OB ARC1
";
1HAI0ADA3A3BOTE
"'$E(E
"+ COP2 OF DEGREE CRTFITE
I1 ?ITH THE APP0ICATION
&+ DEC0ARATION PORTION OF
;A GI.EN%
///////////////////////
CANDIDATE PROD,CED
ON02 DEC0ARATION
PORTION OF ;A
RE1ER.ATION3 COMMN
CON1ENT 1O,GHT
OB D21E
"(
1HANTHA..A BADI
&';'&@
THE ORGINA0 ;!
CERTIFICATE NOT
PRO,D,CED%E0EGI!0E
,NDER G M%
THE ORGINA0 CERTIFICATE
NOT
PRO,D,CED%INTER.ED
,NDER G M%
PROD,CE ;A! ORIGN0
CA1TE %ICC CERTIFCTDATED
&"3';3"##$31CORED #"'
MARB1 %A01O ?CI AGE 0IMIT%
E0IGI!0E TO PT ,NDER
GM %COMMN CON1ENT
1O,GHT
OB
A11T3
CONTRO00ER
"@
1HI.ANANDA G3 NA.I
&"#(@$
THE ORGINA0 ;!
DT"$3';3#$ CERTIFICATE
NOT PRO,D,CED%?RITTEN
E>AM MRB #F#%E0EGI!0E
,NDER G M% FOR ORDE1
THE ORGINA0 ;!
CERTIFICATE NOT
PROD,CED 1INCE HE I1
E0IGI!0E ,NDER
GM%INTER.ED ,NDER G M%
THE ORGINA0 ;! DT"$3';3#$
CERTIFICATE NOT
PRO,D,CED%?RITTEN E>AM
MRB #F#%?CI AGE 0IMIT
%E0EGI!0E ,NDER G M% FOR
ORDE1
OB
A11T3
CONTRO00ER
"E
1IDDA0INGPPA NR
('"&&(
THE ORGINA0 ;! DT
&E3';3#$ CERTIFICATE NOT
PRO,D,CED%?RITTEN
E>AM MRB #""%C,T OFF
$"&%E0EGI!0E ,NDER G M%
FOR ORDE1
THE ORGINA0 ;!
CERTIFICATE NOT
OF INTR.3%!,T
CON1IDEARD
INTER.IE?ED ,NDER
GM CATEGOR23
THE ORGINA0 ;! DT
&E3';3#$CERTIFICATE NOT
MRB #""%C,T OFF $"&% ?CI
AGE 0IMIT %E0EGI!0E ,NDER
G M% FOR ORDE1
OB CTO
"F 1IDDANAG?DA N
NEE0PPANA.AR
&"#(@#
THE ORGINA0 ;A DT
";3'(3#$ CERTIFICATE
NOT PRO,D,CED%?RITTEN
E>AM MRB #""%C,T OFF
$$( COT OFF $"& E0EGI!0E
,NDER G M% FOR ORDE1
THE ORGINA0 ;!
CERTIFICATE NOT
OF INTR.3%!,T
CON1IDEARD
INTER.IE?ED ,NDER
THE ORGINA0 ;!
CERTIFICATE NOT
OF INTR.3%!,T CON1IDEARD
INTER.IE?ED ,NDER GM
OB ACA
Pa4e ;$
GM CATEGOR23 CATEGOR23 FOR ORDE1
"$
1,MA M .
""$#F(
ORIGN0 ;A .ERIFN
PORTION NOT PROD,CED
MRB1 1EC,RED F$&
%E0IGI!0E ,NDER EMA0E
GM3
;A ORC NOT PROD,CED
ORIGN0 ;A .ERIFN PORTION
NOT PROD,CED MRB1
1EC,RED F$& ?CI AGE
0IMIT%E0IGI!0E ,NDER
EMA0E GM3 COMMN
CON1ENT 1O,GHT
OB DMO
"#
R3D3.INE1H
("@'("
THE ORGINA0 ;! DT
""3'(3#$ CERTIFICATE NOT
PRO,D,CED%?RITTEN
E>AM MRB $FF%C,T OFF
$"&%E0EGI!0E ,NDER G M%
;! ORC NOT PROD,CED
THE ORGINA0 ;! DT
MRB $FF%C,T OFF $"&% ?CI
AGE 0IMIT E0EGI!0E ,NDER
G M% COMMN CON1ENT
1O,GHT
OB DMO
&'
2OGANANDA HG
"&;F@@
THE ORGINA0 ;A DT
PRO,D,CED%?RITTEN
E>AM MRB #E#%C,T OFF
$"&%E0EGI!0E ,NDER G
M%FOR ORDER1
THE ORGINA0 ;A DT
""3'(3#$ CERTIFICATE
NOT
PRO,D,CED%?RITTEN
E>AM MRB #E#%C,T OFF
$"&%E0EGI!0E ,NDER G
M%FOR ORDER1
THE ORGINA0 ;A DT
MRB #E#%C,T OFF $"&%?CI
AGE 0IMIT E0EGI!0E ,NDER
G M%FOR ORDER1
OB CTO
&"
A1HA PAR.EEN 1M
"";F;&
OOO
CANDIDT3 C0AIM1 &!
1HE HA1
PROD,CED ORC OF &!
CON1IDRD ,NDER &!
CANDIDT3 C0AIM1 &! 1HE
HA1
PROD,CED ORC OF &!
CON1IDRD ,NDER
&!31O,GHT COMMN
CON1ENT
OB
TAH1I0DAR
&&
ARCHANA 2 !
""&#@E
1A21 1E0ECTED CANDT3 ORGN0
;A CERTI DT &;/;/#$%1ENT TO
GET .A0IDIT2 CERTIFICATE
OOO
CANDT 1A21 1HE HA1
A0READ2 1,!MITTED
.A0IDIT2 CERTIFCT3IN1TEAD
OF ;A CATEGOR2
CERTIFICT3COMMN CON1ENT
I1 1O,GHT
OB
DI1T OFFR
1CC1T
&;
GOPA0 REDD2 B
"&"F@$
NOC GI.EN OOO33
CANDT HA1 NOT 1,!MITTED
APP0N THR, PROPER
CHANNE0 !,T NOC I11,ED
!2 A11T3 DIR3 OCO PO1T
M1TR GEN I1 1,!MITTED
OB ARC1
Tab7e/ A"$
Pa4e ;#
DETAI01 OF CANDIDATEP1 RE1ER.ATION CATEGOR2 MANIP0ATED A1 GM CANDIDATE1 IN THE PREPARATION OF E0IGI!I0IT2 0I1T OF PER1ONA0IT2 TE1T
IN THE RATIO OF "-@
103 NO REG NO3 NAME OF THE CANDIDATE1
?RITTEN
MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION (!ot*
Pre7i6s Mains+
CATEGOR2
P,RPO1F,002
MAN,PI0ATED
PO1T 1E00ECTED
% !%$,80 <H9K6)6):6 )6K9 $*$ &7 4? 6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
! !"&!!8 <H6)TH6KK6 K6:9 $%" &7 4? 6<<T#C3)TR3LLDR
& &"%"&% ?DDR6 R6CH6((6 6L>R %"&* &7 4? 6CCT
, %%!+*$ ?6)O>)6TH6 ( < $,0 &7 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
8 ,"%!!, <9::6L9)46((6 ) R $%% &7 4? CT3
+ ,"&8*& K9<H'6)6TH6 4 $8+ &7 4? CT3
* %"%"!* 76<6K6R6O> 6:6(6:6 &7 4? 6:N<
0 ,""0&* O9TD):R6 <HDTTN 0*! &7 4? 6:N<
$ %!8$0% 76<6((6 7 0*$ &7 4? CH9DF 3FF9CDR
%" ,%8",% K9)D<H R O 0** &7 4? :?3
%% %",+,0 H6)>?6)THD43':6 T < $$0 &6 4? 6<<T# C3)TR#
%! %!&*88 N346)6):6 H 4 $+$ &6 4? CT3
%& %&&",$ )646H6)>?696H 4 H $,! &6 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%, %%8!+, ?6:H>KD<H'6R6 < < $&+ &6 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%8 !%$,8$ <9::6)643>: ) )DDL6((6)6K6R 00, &6 4? 6C6
%+ %""&&+ )9R6)O6) R 0*8 &6 4? 6:LR
%* %%0$*, <>?6 ? K *0! &6 4? :?3
%0 %!!%,& <H9K6<H6)K6R6 ) %"%, &6-RL 4? 6C
%$ %"&+!, ?DD)6 )646R6O C ) $*, &6 4? 6C
!" %!!+!% (R67H>:DK 7 0$0 &6 4? CT3
!% !"+&** <6KDDTHR9 7 K6:9 0,+ &6 4? 6RC<
Pa4e ('
Candidates )onsidered under GM 9or not possessin4 Caste and In)o6e CertiJ)ates-
9n all selections .here a candidate does not produce caste and income certi=cate at the time of personality test/ his candidature is considered under 4eneral ?erit# There
is no absolute Rule that/ if a candidate does not produce caste and income certi=cate either along .ith his application or at the stage of personality test his candidature
should be totally reGected# 9n such cases the common procedure adopted is that a candidate on failure to produce Caste and 9ncome Certi=cates .ould be considered
under the 4eneral ?erit (ool as eery candidate irrespectie of his category is al.ays entitled to consideration under 4eneral ?erit purely on the basis of merit alone# 9n
Table 62%0/ the (etitioner ?embers hae furnish a list of !% candidates .ith a caption :etails of CandidatesC Reseration Category manipulated as 4? Candidate in the
preparation eligibility list of personality test in the ratio %C8# 9n one of the columns to the said table/ the heading gien by the petitioner members is category
purposefully manipulated/ .herein it is sho.n as 4?# 9n my opinion the use of the .ords purposefully manipulated is misleading/ in as much as/ it is a fact that the said
candidates had also claimed a particular category and had been =nally selected under 4?/ .hich is permissible in la./ in the eent of the said candidates being eligible to
be selected on the basis of merit under 4eneral ?erit# 9n my opinion/ there is no material to indicate that there .as any purposeful manipulation#
i<3 A=ardin4 o9 unusua77K *i4* 6ar8s bK t*e t*en C*air6an o9 BP1C- The (etitioner ?embers has obsered that the then Chairman of K(<C/ :r# H# )#
Krishna has a.arded unusually high marks to certain candidates (in comparison .ith other members)# The follo.ing table is placed in this regard#
TA!0E 5 A"#
103 NO3
NAME OF CANDIDATE
REG3 NO3
MARB1 A?ARDED !2
DR H3N3
BRI1HNA
Mar8s A=arded bK t*e ot*er 6e6bers
!OOB CDate o9 PT
Test
"
ROOPA ! R
(";EFF
"E@
"@' M&
"@' M( &FC'"C'E
&
PRA!H, DE. !
"&&E&"
"E@
"@& M&
"@' M(
&;C'"C'E
;
1ATHEE1HA H 2
"'E$;"
"E;
"@' M&
"@& M(
;'C'"C'E
(
MAD,BE1H?ARA 11
""@&E(
"E' "@' M( "$C'"C'E
@
BRI1HNAM,RTH2 HE
"&#"('
"E' "@' M( "FC'"C'E
E
GOPA0A REDD2 B
"&"F@$
"E'
"@' M"
"@@ M&
"@@ M;
"@@ M(
"'C'"C'E
F
1H20ADA A BHOTE
"'$E(E
"@$
"@' M&
"@" M(
;'C'"C'E
Pa4e ("
A=ardin4 o9 unusua77K Hi4* Mar8s bK t*e t*en C*air6an o9 t*e BP1C-
The (etitioner members under the said head hae gien particulars of * candidates in TableS6%$ indicating the marks a.arded by the other members and the chairman
and on a perusal of the table/ 9 do not =nd that the marks a.arded by the chairman are unusually high as opined by the (etitioner members#
<3 Ta6perin4 o9 inter<ie= 6ar8s bK t*e t*en )*air6an 6e6bers o9 BP1C- The (etitioner ?embers/ on the perusal of the records of the interie./ has
found that marks of some of the candidates .ere altered# The statements gien by the then members/ under <ection %+, of Cr#(#C/ during the en;uiry of C9:/
also gies reasons for such alterations# The tabular columns belo. illustrate the same#
Tab7e 5A&'
103
NO
NAME OF THE
BP1C MEM!ER
?HO MADE
1TATEMENT
,NDER
1ECTION
"E(OF CRPC
103O
NAME OF THE
CANDIDATE AND REG
N,M!ER
RE1ER.ATION
CAREGOR23
PO1T 1E00ECTED3
O!1ER.ATION
MADE3
REA1ONCRIP02
GI.EN !2 THE
BP1C MEM!ER3
.IDE PAGE
N,M!ER OF
THE
1TATEMENT
I DR3H313PATI03 "
1HARADA C3 BO0BAR
REG3"&"@('3
1CCF TAHA1I0DAR
MARB1 A0TERED
FROM "@' TO
"@&
DOE1 NOT
REMEM!ER
P/E
&
G,R,PRA1AD3H30
REGNO3"&E'@(
&A 0A!O,R OFFICER
MARB1 A0TERED
FROM "(' TO
"(@
D,E TO THE
IN1TR,CTION1
FROM CHAIR H3
N3 BRI1HNA3
P/E
II
1MT30I0IAN
>A.IER3
;
!EENA3B3
REGNO3"""##F3
GM A11T3CONTRO0AR
MARB1 A0TERED
FROM "@' TO
"@@
!2 O.ER 1IGHT3 P/E
(
0I0A.ATH23B3
REGNO3"''E$&
C/I A11T3COMMI11IONER3
MARB1
A0TERERD FROM
" (' TO "(@
CANDIDATE
DE1ER.ED THE
INCREA1E OF
MARB13
P/E
@
MANDANATH3!3N3
REGNO3"'@'EF
IIIA
COMMERCIA0 TA>
OFFICER3
MARB1
A0TERERED
FROM @' TO
"@'
A1 PER THE
DIRECTION OF
H3N3 BRI1HNA3
P/E
E
1HA1HIBA0A3M3
""&;F&
C/I
MARB1 A0TERED
( NOT 1HO?N+
!2 O.ER 1IGHT P/E
F
1ANGAP,R3M313
REGNO "&$'#$
1C A11T3TREA1,R2 OFFICER
MARB1
A0TERERED
FROM @' TO
"@'
A1 PER THE
DIRECTION1 OF
DR3 H3N3
BRI1HNA3
P/E
$ HEMA.ATHI3M3N3 GMCIIIACF A3C3A MARB1
Pa4e (&
REGNO3("(#@$
(!OOBNO3&F+
A0TERERED
FROM "@' TO
"@@
III
1RI .ENBATA
1?AMM2
#
G,NABAR31
REG3('&''(
C/" A3D3231
MARB1
A0TERERED
FROM @@TO @'
DOE1 NOT
REMEM!ER
P/E
"'
1IDDA0INGAPPA3N3R3
REGNO3 ('"&&(
III!CGM ATO
MARB1
A0TERERED
FROM "(# TO
"@'
//////
""
G,R,NATH3!ADIGAIR3
REGNO &"(#EE
IIA /////////
MARB1
A0TERERED
FROM E'TO $'
DOE1 NOT
REMEM!ER3
///////
I. 1RI DA1AIAH3 "&
ANANTHA RAMA ARA0I3
REGNO3""&(';
IIIA /////////
MARB1
A0TERERED
FROM @' TO
"@@
!2 O.ER 1IGHT
RE
1TATEMENT
PAGE/"
";
RE1HAMA TAHA1IN
REGNO3";";E&///
(!OOBNOQE$+
GMCF TAHA1I0DAR
MARB1
A0TERERED
FROM ";'TO
"&'
///////// ///
Ta6perin4 o9 inter<ie= 6ar8s bK t*e t*en )*air6an and 6e6bers o9 t*e BP1C-
The fact that there .as alteration of marks in respect of the candidates as per Table26!" is not disputed# 'hether the said alteration .as a proper one or tampered one
.as inestigated by the C9: and statement of the concerned members hae been recorded and in that regard prosecution is pending as on today# Ho.eer/ only on the
basis of perusal of the said alterations/ it cannot be opined that the same is tampered and not genuine alteration#
<i3 A))eptan)e o9 )ertiJ)ates at PT sta4e -6s per the instructions to candidates the photocopy of degree certi=cates and marks cards had to be submitted at
the time of =ling application for main eBamination# Ho.eer/ in the follo.ing instances/ candidates had not submitted the said documents along .ith
application for main eBamination# They .ere allo.ed to .rite the main eBamination in iolation of instructions and at the time of interie. the said
documents .ere receied#
TA!0E / &"
Pa4e (;
<l# )o# Reg# )o# )ame
<election Category
Last date =Bed for
submission of :egree
certi=cates- ?arks cards#
The date on .hich the
candidate submitted the
:egree certi=cates-
?arks cards and
considered by the K(<C#
(ost <elected
% %"*",& O646:9<H )69K !6 %82%!2%$$$ %$2"!2%$$$ :N<D
! !%0!80 K6LL6(6 376))643L !6 %82%!2%$$$ 6t the time of (T 6RC<
& %"+,+! )646R6O6((6 T 4? %82%!2%$$$ 6t the time of (T :N<D
, &"8"!$ )646R6O6 K7 % %82%!2%$$$ 6t the time of (T 6L3
8 %!0"$0 <6)46(>R ?< <C %82%!2%$$$ 6t the time of (T 6T3
+ !""+$+ 6LL676K<H6 79O6(>R !7 %82%!2%$$$ 6t the time of (T 6C6
* ,"*0+& ?6H6:DK6 6 ?>R649 4? %82%!2%$$$ 6t the Time of (T Tahashildar
0 %""!00 ?DR>)6):6) K7 4? %82%!2%$$$ 6t the Time of (T :N<D
$ !"&!+8 R6O> 76K9H6LL9 !7 %82%!2%$$$
(:C <ubmitted 6t the
Time of (T
6:N<
%" %"0"*8 R>:R6))643':6 4O 4? %82%!2%$$$ 6t the Time of (T D3
%% %&"%+, (R6K6<H 4 <C %82%!2%$$$ 6t the Time of (T 6RC<
%! %%&$$$ R>:R6?>)N 7K 4? %82%!2%$$$ 6t the Time of (T 6C6
T*e 9o77o=in4 se79/i77ustrati<e tab7es are p7a)ed on re)ord% as part o9 data ana7Ksis-
Tab7e / A&&
Pa4e ((
Nu6ber o9 1C Candidates (1e7e)ted+ Pus*ed to GM Cate4orK
(Ot*er t*an t*ose =*o =ere not se7e)ted but pus*ed to GM+
103 NO REG NO3
NAME OF THE
CANDIDATE1
?RITTEN MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% !%+!," (R6KDD) ( 764D'6:9 $&* <C T6H6<9L:H6R
%,8
Tab7e 5A&;
Nu6ber o9 &A Candidates (1e7e)ted+ Pus*ed to GM Cate4orK
103 NO REG NO3 NAME OF THE CANDIDATE1 ?RITTEN MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% %%&,8! RDK6))6 R $,8 !6 6<<T# C3)TR#
%,"
! %"8*%8 K6<6)TH6K>?6R 7 K $,& !6 6<<T# C3)TR#
%,8
& %%"&!% <6)46((6 >(6<D $&& !6 6<<T# C3)TR#
%,*#8
Tab7e 5 A&(
Nu6ber o9 &A Candidates (1e7e)ted+ Pus*ed to GM Cate4orK 9or not produ)in4 ORC
103 NO REG NO3
NAME OF THE
CANDIDATE1
?RITTEN MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED
IN APP0ICATION
(!ot* Pre7i6s
Mains+
CATEGOR2
CHANGED
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% %&&%&& K6)6K6R6O> : $++ !6 4?
6<<T#
C3)TR3LLDR
%8"
Tab7e 5A&@
Nu6ber o9 ;A Candidates (1e7e)ted+ Pus*ed to GM Cate4orK
Pa4e (@
103
NO
REG NO3 NAME OF THE CANDIDATE1 ?RITTEN MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED
IN APP0ICATION
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% %%&"0* ?6)O>)6TH6 <'6?N 4 ) $&+ &6 6<<T# C3)TR#
%8"
! ,%80$! <6T9< 767> H < $!$ &6 T6H6<9L:H6R
%88
& %!!0%! R6?D<H6 RD::N 7 $!! &6 6<<T# C3)TR#
%8"
, %"8"+* ?6)O>)6TH6 7 ) $", &6 CT3
%8"
8 ,"%+88 ?6HD<H6 T 6 0$, &6 :?3
%,8
+ %%!$8+ 6RCH6)6 N 7 0$% &6 :3 <C-<T
%8"
* %%%!&* <6T9<H ? K 0$% &6 :?3
%8"
0 %"!8*, K6)TH6R6O> R O 00* &6 6RC<
%,8
$ ,%"$+$ 43(6L <'6?N 7 ) 0*$ &6 6T3
%8"
%" %!%8*+ ?6)O>)6TH6 <'6?N 0** &6 6T3
%8"
%% %&&"*8 6<'6TH6)6R6N6) 0** &6 6RC<
%8"
%! %!,%," )6)O>):D 43':6 K ) 0** &6 6RC<
%8"
%& %"*0!0 L6K<H?9(6TH696H 0*& &6 6RC<
%8"
%, %!8&*& K3:9 43':6 K 0*" &6 :?3
%8"
%8 ,"0""& K>?6R6 H ( 0+0 &6 6RC<
%88
%+ %%&8*$ KD)K6TD<H6((6 ) 0+! &6 6T3
%,8
%* ,"!,8+ CH9KK6<'6?N 0+% &6 D3
%8"
%0 %"*8%+ ?6)O>)6TH6 7 0+% &6 D3
%8"
%$ %"+0&% <6TDD<H6 H N 08* &6 6T3
%88
!" %!,$+0 N6<H3:H6 ? 08+ &6 6C6
+*#8
!% %!$%," KR9<H)6 ?>RTHN H D 08, &6 6C6
%88
!! %"80%* ?>)9RD::N 7 ? 08% &6 6T3
%8"
!& %"0+,+ <H69L6O6 KH3TD 0,* &6 :N<D
%8&
!, %!%0*$ ?6:D43':6 H ? 0,, &6 6C6
%88
!8 %"&0"! (><H(6 : R 0%8 &6 :?3
%88
!+ ,%,$80 HD?6K6TH9 ? ) 0%% &6 6C6
%88
!* ,",**+ K9O6N6L6K<H?9 O 7 0", &6 D3
%8"
Tab7e 5 A&E
Pa4e (E
Nu6ber o9 ;A Candidates (1e7e)ted+ Pus*ed to GM Cate4orK 9or not produ)in4 ORC
103
NO
REG NO3 NAME OF THE CANDIDATE1
?RITTEN
MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED
IN APP0ICATION
(!ot* Pre7i6s
Mains+
CATEGOR2 CHANGED PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% %",+,0 H6)>?6)THD43':6 T < $$0 &6 4? 6<<T# C3)TR#
%,$
! %!&*88 N346)6):6 H 4 $+$ &6 4? CT3
%8"
& %&&",$ )646H6)>?696H 4 H $,! &6 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%&"
, %%8!+, ?6:H>KD<H'6R6 < < $&+ &6 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%88
8 !%$,8$ <9::6)643>: ) )DDL6((6)6K6R 00, &6 4? 6C6
%&"
+ %""&&+ )9R6)O6) R 0*8 &6 4? 6:LR
%8"
* %%0$*, <>?6 ? K *0! &6 4? :?3
%8&
0 %!!%,& <H9K6<H6)K6R6 ) %"%, &6-RL 4? 6C
%8+
$ %"&+!, ?DD)6 )646R6O C ) $*, &6 4? 6C
%88
%" %!!+!% (R67H>:DK 7 0$0 &6 4? CT3
%88
%% !"+&** <6KDDTHR9 7 K6:9 0,+ &6 4? 6RC<
%8"
Tab7e 5 A&F
Pa4e (F
Nu6ber o9 ;! Candidates (1e7e)ted+ Pus*ed to GM Cate4orK For Not produ)in4 ORC
103
NO
?RITTEN
MARB1
CATEGOR2
C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION (!ot*
Pre7i6s Mains+
CATEGOR2
P,RPO1F,002
MAN,PI0ATED
PO1T
1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% !%$,80 <H9K6)6):6 )6K9 $*$ &7 4? <6:
%,8
! !"&!!8 <H6)TH6KK6 K6:9 $%" &7 4? <6:
%8"
& &"%"&% ?DDR6 R6CH6((6 6L>R %"&* &7 4? 6CCT
*&#&&
, %%!+*$ ?6)O>)6TH6 ( < $,0 &7 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%8"
8 ,"%!!, <9::6L9)46((6 ) R $%% &7 4? CT3
%8"
+ ,"&8*& K9<H'6)6TH6 4 $8+ &7 4? CT3
%""
* %"%"!* 76<6K6R6O> 6:6(6:6 &7 4? 6:N<
%&8
0 ,""0&* O9TD):R6 <HDTTN 0*! &7 4? 6:N<
%88
$ %!8$0% 76<6((6 7 &7 4? C3
%8"
%" ,%8",% K9)D<H R O 0** &7 4? :?3
%8"
On t*e basis o9 t*e ana7Ksis o9 t*e data% t*e Petitioner Me6bers *as obser<ed t*at a parti)u7ar )ate4orK )andidates =ere 9a<oured% abo<e a77 ot*ers% in
t*e se7e)tion pro)ess3 T*e 9o77o=in4 se79/i77ustrati<e tab7e is p7a)ed =it* re4ard to t*e sa6eC
TA!0E 5 A&$
Pa4e ($
10 NO3 CATEGOR2
NO3 OF PO1T1
RE1ER.ED A1
PER
AD.ERTI1EMENT
NO OF
PER1ON1
ACT,A002
CA00ED FOR
PT IN
.IO0ATION
OF "-@ RATIO
NO3 OF
CANDIDATE1
1E0ECTED
A1
CATEGOR2
CANDIDATE1
A1 PER
RE1ER.ATIO
N
NO3 OF
CANDIDATE1
P,1HED TO
GM CATEGOR2
NO3 OF
CANDIDATE1
RE1ER.ATION
CATEGOR2
CHANGED A1
GM D,E TO
NOT
PROD,CING
ORIGINA0
RE1ER.ATION
CERTIFICATE1
(ORCP1+ !2
O!TAINING
?RITTEN
0ETTER1
FROM
CANDIDATE1
D,RING
INTER.IE?
TOTA0 NO3 OF
CANDIDATE1
1E0ECTED
(in)7udes (
persons in ;A
and " person
in ;!
)onsidered in
GM% a7t*ou4*
o<er/a4ed 9or
GM+
PERCENT
AGE OF
INCREA1E
1C E( ;#"
E(
"
NI0
E@ "'&
& 1T "# ""(
"#
NI0
NI0
"# "''
; CAT /I && "("
&&
NI0
NI0
&& "''
( &A @& ;@;
@&
;
"
@E "'$
@ &! "F ""(
"F
NI0
NI0
"F "''
E ;A "" "@E
""
&F "" @; ($&
F ;! "" "'F
""
NI0
"'
&& &''
TOTA0 "#E ";FE "#E ;" && &@( ";'
A))eptan)e o9 )ertiJ)ates at Persona7itK Test sta4e-
3n ;ueries being raised by the concerned branches handling the scrutiny of applications the Commission has by decision taken in its proceedings held on %"#"&#%$$$
relaB certain conditions and in respect of the candidates .ho had not produced the caste and income certi=cate/ the candidates .ere permitted to take the eBamination
Pa4e (#
subGect to production of the original of the caste and income certi=cates at the time of personality test and accordingly the said certi=cates hae been accepted at the
stage of personality tests# Further the petitioner members hae gien certain particulars in tabulated statements in Tables 62!! to 6!0 opining that the said candidates
hae been push to 4?# ?y conclusion on 9ssue )oC +aboe holds good for the conclusions dra.n in the said Tables 62!! to 62!0#
I.3 Findin4s re4ardin4 )aste and in)o6e )ertiJ)ates and ot*er do)u6ents-
For claiming the bene=t of reseration/ proof of caste-tribe and for some categories of reseration caste and income proof are necessary# Caste and income certi=cates/ in
the prescribed forms and .ithin the prescribed time limits had been made mandatory during the selection process for candidates claiming the reseration bene=t# :uring
the course of ascertaining facts/ it has come to the kno.ledge of the (etitioner ?embers that there has been manipulations and large discrepancies/ resulting in itiation
of the process# The follo.ing paragraphs and tables bring out the factual aspect of these#
a+ In)o6p7ete CertiJ)atesC For categories !6/ !7/ &6 1 &7/ caste along .ith income certi=cates are necessary for claiming reseration bene=ts/ in order
to preent the creamy layer from garnering reseration# 9n the follo.ing instances of selected candidates/ incomplete certi=cates hae been submitted (although
.hich is initially noted by K(<C/ but later the said incomplete certi=cates hae been accepted)#
Tab7e 5A&#
<l# )o#
Reg# )o# )ame
Cate4orK C7ai6ed bK
t*e Candidates
in)o6p7ete
)ertiJ)ate sub6itted
Cate4orK Considered and
1e7e)ted bK t*e BP1C
(ost <elected
% %%0$*, <>?6 ? K &6 4?-F :9<TR9CT ?6RKDT9)4 3FF9CDR
! %"&+!, ?DD)6 )646R6O &6 4?-F 6<<9<T6)T C3??9<<93)DR
& %&8%08 L6K6)N6 < &6 &6 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
, %!!%,& <H9K6<H6)K6R6 ) &6 4? 6<<9<T6)T C3??9<<93)DR
8 %"0+,+ <H69L6O6 KH3TD &6 4?-&6 :N< DPC9<D
+ %&%&+! RD<H?6 T6H<DD) !7 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
* %%&*&! 6<H6 (6RKDD) < ? !7 !7-F T6H6<9L:H6R
0 ,"&0"& R33(6 R !6 !6-F T6H6<9L:H6R
$ %"8+0% R6K9):R6 ( ) !6 !6 6<<9<T6)T C3??9<<93)DR
%" %"&&&$ 6KR6? (6<H6 !7 !7 6<<9<T6)T C3??9<<93)DR
%% %""+0! LDDL6K6THN K % % 6<<9<T6)T C3??9<<93)DR
Pa4e @'
%! ,""*!0 <H9K6)6):6 K6(6<H9 &7 &7 6<<9<T6)T C3??9<<93)DR
%& %%&"0* ?6)O>)6TH <'6?N 4 ) &6 4?-&6 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
%, %%"&!% <6)46((6 >(6<D !6 4?-!6 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
%8 %&!&** <HD9K L6TH9DF !7 4?-!7 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
%+ %"++%% ?3H6??D: 9U76L ? ?9RQ6 !7 !7 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
%* %!80!" CH6))6((6 6 &7 &7 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
%0 ,%!,%" ?9L6) < ?>R43: &7 &7 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
%$ %"$%*8 (6RK6TH9 H 7 &7 &7-F 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
!" &"%"&% ?DDR6 R6CH6((6 6L>R &7 4?-F 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
!% %",*!! L9)46))6 K>CH676L !6 !6 6CCT
!! ,%88,8 )646 <'6?N !6 !6 6CCT
!& %"8*%* >?6 K 6 !6 !6-F 6CCT
!, %%!$8+ 6RCH6)6 N 7 &6 4?-&6-F :3 <C-<T
!8 %%!+*$ ?6)O>)6TH6 ( < &7 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
!+ ,%80$! <6TH9< 767> H < &6 4?-&6 T6H6<9L:H6R
!* ,""*"+ O6K6RD43':6 T &6 &6 T6H6<9L:H6R
!0 !"!,*" <H6<H9:H6R 7646L9 &7 &7 T6H6<9L:H6R
!$ %"$+&! O6N6?6:H6K6 ( !6 !6 T6H6<9L:H6R
&" %&&!&$ R6)46)6TH6 !6 !6 T6H6<9L:H6R
&% %"*00+ R6CH6((6 ? !6 !6 T6H6<9L:H6R
&! %"*,8* ?6)O>)6TH6 4 ) !6 !6 T6H6<9L:H6R
&& ,"&8*& K9<H'6)6TH6 4 &7 4? CT3
&, %"+&*% CH3':696H &6-P?( 4?-&6-P?( CT3
&8 %&&"*8 6<H'6TH )6R6N6) &6 4?-&6 6RC<
&+ %!,%," )6)O>):D43':6 K ) &6 4?-&6 6RC<
&* %"*0!0 L6K<H?9(6TH696H &6 4?-&6 6RC<
Pa4e @"
&0 !%0!80 K6LL6((6 376))643L !6 !6 6RC<
&$ %"8&!! <6L?6 F9R:3<D !7 !7-F 6RC<
," %"8+!& )9R?6L6 ) !6 !6-F :N<D
,% %"0"*8 R>:R6))6 43':6 4 O &7 4? D3
,! ,"!,8+ CH9KK6<'6?N &6 4?-&6 D3
,& %"*8%+ ?6)O>)6TH6 7 &6 4?-&6 D3
,, %"8**" O646))6TH6 C !6 !6 D3
,8 ,",**+ K9O6N6L6K<H?9 O 7 &6 4?-&6-F D3
,+ ,%,$"8 >?6 C ? !6 !6-F D3
,* %&,*!! <6TDD<H <6OO6)6R !6 !6 6:N<
,0 %!%8*+ ?6)O>)6TH6 <'6?N &6 4?-&6 6T3
,$ %"+0&% <6TDD<H6 H N &6 4?-&6 6T3
8" %"80%* ?>)9RD::N 7 ? &6 4?-&6 6T3
8% ,%%!&& L3KD<H 4 6 &6 &6 6T3
8! ,%%88+ <9::6L9)46<'6?N K 7 &7 &7 6T3
8& %"8!,& ?66Q>::9) KH6) !7 !7 6T3
8, ,"*080 O646:DD<H6 ? % % 6T3
88 &"%&+8 ?6H673377DD !7 !7-F 6T3
8+ %%%!&* <6T9<H ? K &6 4?-&6 :?3
8* %",+"% K>?6R6<'6?N R ? &7 &7 :?3
80 %&,!%$ KH6LDDL <67 4 !7 !7 :?3
8$ ,"%,"% )64D<H K ? !6 !6 :?3
+" %"&0"! (><H(6 : R &6 4?-&6-F :?3
+% !%$,8$ <9::6)643>: ) )DDL6((6)6K6R &6 4? 6C6
+! %!$%," KR9<H)6 ?>RTHN H D &6 4?-&6 6C6
+& !%""&& <R9:H6R6 T &6 &6 6C6
Pa4e @&
+, !""+$+ 6LL676K<H6 79O6(>R !7 !7 6C6
+8 %!,$+0 N6<H3:H6 ? &6 4? 6C6
++ %!,+*0 KDD)6 R !6 !6-F 6C6
b+Reser<ation CertiJ)ate not en)7osed a7on4 =it* t*e app7i)ation- 9n the follo.ing instances/ the selected candidates had not submitted the certi=cates
eidencing their caste#
Tab7e 5 A;'
173 No3 Re43 No3 Na6e
Cate4orK C7ai6ed bK
t*e Candidates
Cate4orK
Considered and
1e7e)ted bK t*e
BP1C
Post 1e7e)ted
% %""&&+ )9R6)O6) R &6 4? 6:LR
! ,"%+8& H6R9)6TH 767> !6 !6 6T3
& ,"$**% R6)9 H ? !6 !6 :?3
, %%++$* 7H64N6L6TH6 <C <C 6T3
8 %"!&0" <>)9TH6 ? <C <C 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
)+ As per t*e notiJ)ation )a77in4 9or app7i)ations 9or t*e ad<ertised posts it *ad been spe)iJed t*at t*e )andidates )7ai6in4 reser<ation under &A%
&!% ;A ;! )ate4ories *a<e to obtain and sub6it t*e )aste and in)o6e )ertiJ)ates =*i)* are issued on or a9ter '#3';3"##$ and be9ore
Pa4e @;
"E3'(3"##$3 Ho=e<er% in t*e 9o77o=in4 instan)es t*e se7e)ted )andidates did not sub6it t*e )ertiJ)ates o9 t*e period spe)iJed3 A7t*ou4* t*is
dis)repan)K =as noted initia77K =*i7e s)rutinizin4 t*e app7i)ations% t*is reNuire6ent =as 7ater on disre4arded3
Tab7e 5A;"
Cate4orK C7ai6ed bK
t*e Candidates
Cate4orK Considered
and 1e7e)ted bK t*e
BP1C
Post 1e7e)ted
Caste CIn)o6e CertiJ)ate
Date
% %!!%,& <H9K6<H6)K6R6 ) &6 4? 6<<9<T6)T C3??9<<93)DR
K(<C 37<DRKD: TH6T
%*-%-%$$0 ((R9L?<) S THDR
6FTDR D)CL3<D: THD C6<T
CDRT9F9C6TD :6TD: %+2,2
%$$0#
! %"&+!, ?DD)6 )646R6O &6 4?-F 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
T.o certi=cates .ere
submitted *-&-%$$0 1
!"-0-%$$0
& %&&%&& K6)6K6R6O#: !6 4? 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR !,-"!-%$$0
, %!!%&, KDDR6)643>:6 (6T9L !6 !6 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR ,-&-%$$0
8 %&%&+! RD<H?6 T6H<DD) !7 4? T6H6<9L:H6R %!-%!-$*
+ %%&*&! 6<H6 (6RKDD) < ? !7 !7 T6H6<9L:H6R !0-"&-%$$+
* %!!+!% (R67H>:DK 7 &6 &6 CT3 !8-%%-%$$*
0 %"0"*8 R>:R6))6 43':6 4 O &7 4? D3 ",-"*-%$$*
$ %"%"!* 76<6K6R6O6 H6:6(6:6 &7 4? 6:N< %&-"0-%$$*
%" %!8$0% 76<6((6 7 &7 4? C3 !,-!-%$$0
d+CertiJ)ates not issued bK t*e Co6petent Aut*oritK- The (etitioner ?embers has obsered that Caste and 9ncome Certi=cates had to be issued by Tahsildars/
but in the follo.ing cases they hae not been issued by Tahsildars/ but by <pecial Tahsildars - 6dditional Tahsildars#
Tab7e 5 A;&
173 No3 Re43 No3 Na6e Cate4orK C7ai6ed
bK t*e Candidates
t*e Reser<ation
CertiJ)ates si4ned
bK 1p73Tas*i7dar C
Cate4orK Considered Post 1e7e)ted
Pa4e @(
Additiona73Ta*asi7da
r
% %&&%&& K6)6K6R6O6 : !6 4? 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
! %&8%08 L6K6)N6 < &6 &6 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
& %%88"& <H37H6 T R !6 !6 6<<9<T6)T C3)TR3LLDR
, ,%&&"+ >?6K6)TH R < !6 !6 6CCT
8 %!+8"* RD)>K6)6):6 &7 &7 6CCT
+ %%!$8+ 6RCH6)6 N 7 &6 4?-&6 :3 <C-<T
* %%*8%0 <R9:H6R R % % :3 <C-<T
0 %&%&+! RD<H?6 T6H<DD) !7 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
$ ,"&0"& R33(6 R !6 !6-F T6H6<9L:H6R
%" %%&*&! 6<H6 (6RKDD) !7 !7 T6H6<9L:H6R
%% %!,%"8 6)9TH6 7 K % %-F CT3
%! ,%!,0$ 9)4>L6?79K6 K <6R3:D !6 !6-F 6RC<
%& %"8&!! <6L?6 F9R:3<D !7 !7-F 6RC<
%, %"8+!& )9R?6L6 ) !6 !6-F :N<D
%8 %"*8%+ ?6)O>)6TH6 7 &6 4?-&6 D3
%+ ,%!&88 RDK6TH9 769 !6 !6 6T3
%* ,%8",% K9)D<H R O &7 4? :?3
%0 %!8,$+ R6?D<H6 K &6 &6 :?3
%$ %"&0"! (><H(6 : R &6 4?-&6 6C6
!" %!,$+0 N6<H3:H6 ? &6 4?-&6-F 6C6
!% ,"%!*+ <ND: 6)OD):6 (6RKDD) !7 !7 6C6
!! %!,+*0 KDD)6 R !6 !6 6C6
!& %!&0"! RD)>K6 4 % % 6C6
Pa4e @@
e+ Co6petent Aut*oritKs si4nature 6issin4 in t*e CertiJ)ates - 9n the follo.ing instances/ the Tahsildars signature are missing from the certi=cates#
Tab7e 5A;;
Category Claimed by
the Candidates
Category Considered
and <elected by the
K(<C
(ost <elected
% ,"%,"! K9O6N6K>?6R 7 C &6 &6 6CCT
! %"0+,+ <H69L6O6 KH3TD &6 4?-&6 :N<D
& %&",,0 ?6)O>)6TH6 <'6?N 7 ? <C <C CT3
9+I6proper )ertiJ)ates -6s per 43 )o <'L !%& <6: 08 :atedC !&2"&2%$0*/ the candidates claiming reseration under <C - <T ;uota hae to submit certi=cates in the
format of 6ppendiB29/ anneBed to 4#3 )o <'L !%& <6: 08 :atedC !&2"&2%$0*# 9n the follo.ing instances this has not been follo.edC
Tab7e 5 A;(
<l#
)o
Reg#
)o
)ame
Category Claimed by the
Candidates
Category Considered and
<elected by the K(<C
(ost
<elected
Form Type 1 :ate
%
%!%8,
"
<H6R6:6 C# K3LK6R <C <C-F Tahashildar
F3R? 2% KDR9F9C6T93) CDRT9F9C6TD :6TD: S
"0-%%-%$$&#
F3R? 2 : 2 :6TD:2 %+2%"2!""%
!
%"++$
*
(33R)9?6 #< <C <C-F 6RC<
6((D):9P 2& Form2% <6THN6 <3:H6)6 (6THR6
:6TD:C %"2"+2%$$&
&
&"0"8
"
6R>)K>?6R<6)46K9 <C <C 6: FC
Form2% Keri=cation Certi=cate "%2"$2%$$0
,
!!"0,
!
<H69LD):R6<6OO6))6K6R <C <C 6C6
<6THN6 <3:H6)6 (6THR6 %+2"&2%$$%
Pa4e @E
FINDING1 ?ITH REGARD TO THE CA1TE AND INCOME CERTIFICATE1 AND OTHER DOC,MENT1-
The (etitioner members hae recorded their conclusions on the said issue under sub2headings (a) to (f)# 9n my opinion the terms of reference to this committee as stated
in introduction aboe/ do not encompass these matters and hence/ 9 refrain from making any comments on the said aspects#
9K# 1e7e)tion 1ta4eC
a+ Pre9eren)e not 4i<enC 6s per the Rules goerning the selection IRule ,(&) of 4a5etted (robationers Recruitment Rules%$$* (6ppointment by Competitie DBaminations)
RulesJ/ it is mandatory for the candidates to gie preferences of posts# Ho.eer/ in the follo.ing instances the selected candidates had not indicated their preferences/
but still .ere selected to certain posts#
TA!0E 5 A;@
10NO3 NAME OF THE CANDIDATE REGNO PO1T 1E00ECTED REMARB13
" H303G,R,PRA1AD "&E'@( 0A!O,R OFFICER RCONCERNED PO1T PREFERENCE I1 NOT MENTIONEDS IN THE
PREFERENCE 0I1T3
& .EERANAGO?DAPATE0 "&&";( A11T CONTR0 PREFERENCE 0I1T OF THE CANDIDATE I1S NOT 1INGNEDS3
; PRABA1H3G ";'"E( ARC1 PREFERENCE ?RITTEN A1
RA G OF CO/OPARATI.E 1OCIET2S ?ITCH I1 NOT E>I1T1 IN
NOTIFICATION3
( RAGA.ENDRA3.3 "'''"E A11T CONTR0 CADRECPO1T MENTIONED A1 RA11I1TANT CO00ECTORS ?ITCH
I1 NOT E>I1T1 IN NOTIFICATION3
@ .ANI "&E#"' A11T CONTR0 CADRECPO1T MENTIONED A1 RA11I1TANT CO00ECTORS ?ITCH
I1 NOT E>I1T1 IN NOTIFICATION3
E RADI.!A.IHA00I &';&E@ AD21 PO1T PREFERENCE I1 O.ER ?RITTEN AND CORRECTED3THI1 I1
Pa4e @F
ACCEPTED !2 BP1C AGAIN1T PRE1CRI!ED R,0E13
F R,DRAM,NI3!3B "";### ACA PREFERENCE OF PO1T I1S IN1ERTED AFTER 1,!MI11IONS OF THE
APPA0ICATION3
$ DAGADEE1H3M ('F$@$ ATO PREFERENCE ?RITTEN A1 ON02 RASAND R!S 3
# PRABA1H3B (O$$#@ CTO CADRECPO1T CO0,MN I1 FI00ED A1 1ERA0 N,M!ER OF PO1T1 AND
RGRO,P A AND !S
b+3Kalidity Certi=cates not obtained before declaration of =nal select listC 6s per 4#3 )3 <': %&* 7C6 $& 76)46L3RD/ :6TD: ,
th
)3K %$$& it is mandatory to
obtain alidity certi=cates (alidating the caste of candidates .ho are in the proisional select list) before the declaration of =nal select list# Ho.eer/ during the
%$$0 selection not een a single alidity certi=cate .as obtained by the K(<C before declaration of =nal select list on !0#"&#!""+# 9t indicates that the personnel at
the helm at that time .ere in a haste to =nali5e the selection .ithout proper procedure#
FINDING1 ?ITH REGARD TO THE 1E0ECTION 1TAGE-
The (etitioner members hae recorded their conclusions on the said issue under sub2headings (a) and (b)# 9n my opinion the terms of reference to this committee as
stated in introduction aboe/ do not encompass these matters and hence/ 9 refrain from making any comments on the said aspects#
Mis)e77aneous - Certain app7i)ations =*i)* =ere 7iab7e to be reLe)ted on t*e 9a)e o9 it due to in*erent 7a)una o9 bein4 in)o6p7ete % =ere a))epted % T*e
9o77o=in4 tab7e i77ustrates t*e sa6e3
A+T*e detai7s o9 )andidates =*ose reser<ation and t*e )andidature )onsidered bK t*e BP1C t*ou4* t*e sa6e not )7ai6ed bK t*e )andidates
and not ad*erin4 t*e instru)tions 4i<en in t*e ad<ertise6ent 7isted as Fo77o=sT
TA!0E - A;E
Cate4orK C7ai6ed bK t*e Candidates Cate4orK Considered
and 1e7e)ted bK t*e
BP1C
Post 1e7e)ted
PRE0IM1 MAIN1
% %""%0, 6R6K9):6 6 )3T CL69?D: )3T CL69?D: 4? 6:N<
! %"+,+! )646R6O6((6 T )3T CL69?D: 4? 4? :N<D
& %&&88* R6?6(R6<6: T )3T CL69?D: )3T CL69?D: 4? 6T3
, ,"8*8! <>?6 T < )3T CL69?D: )3T CL69?D: 4? 6T3
8 &"8!8! F6RDD: >))9<6 7D4>? )3T CL69?D: 4? 4? :?3
Pa4e @$
+ %%8!&+ )6R6<9?H6 ?>RTHN K )3T CL69?D: 4? 4? 6C6
* !"!%%8 <6))6T6)49N6K6R6 76<6K6)643':6R )3T CL69?D: 4? 4? 6C6
0 ,""%&8 <6)4DDTH6 46O6)6)6 7H6T )3T CL69?D: 4? 4? 6ssistant Controller
$ ,"&"&8 KR9<H)6K>?6R TR )3T CL69?D: 4? 4? 6C CT
%" %%%**8 N6<H3:H6 K )3T CL69?D: )ot Claimed 4? 6C CT
%% %""$%0 K6THN6N6)9:DK9 < )3T CL69?D: )ot Claimed 4? Tahashildar
%! ,"%%8+ :6<D43':6 ? )3T CL69?D: 4? 4? Tahashildar
%& %",&!% ?6)O>)6TH6<'6?N 7< )3T CL69?D: 4? 4? Tahashildar
%, %!&0%, H6R9<H9L(6 )3T CL69?D: 4? 4? Tahashildar
%8 %"%,00 K9R>(6K<H6 K) )3T CL69?D: 4? 4? CT3
%+ %!,%$$ ?6)>TH>R <6):HN6R6)9 )3T CL69?D: )ot Claimed 4? CT3
%* %"%&$$ 6)9LK>?6R K) )3T 6((L9C67LD 4? 4? 6RC<
%0 %&",&, (R6<6: RD::N C )3T CL69?D: )ot Claimed 4? 6RC<
!" %%%!&* <6TH9<H ?K )3T CL69?D: )ot Claimed 4? :?3
!, %%8!0& R><H67HD):R6 ?>RTHN 4#C &7-4?-P?( 4?-P?( 4?-P?(
6ssistant
Commissioner
!8 %!!,8% <HR9K6)THR63 #K 4? )ot Claimed 4? 6ssistant Controller
!* %%%$$* 7DD)6 #K 4? )ot Claimed 4?-F 6ssistant Controller
!0 !%$!*, R6?6((6 H6TT9 &7-P?( 4?-P?( 4?-P?( 6ssistant Controller
!$ !"%"&+ KDDR67H6:R6 H6)CH9)6L 4? )ot Claimed 4? 6C CT
&" %"%,0, K9R>(6K<H6 K#C 4? &7 4? 6C CT
&! !""8%$ N6<?9) 7D4>? '6L9K6R 4? )ot Claimed 4? 6C CT
&, %"!*,$ >R?9L6 7 4? )ot Claimed 4? :3 <C-<T
&* !"&*%$ R6K9 ? T9RL6(>R 4? )ot Claimed 4? Tahashildar
&$ %""*+0 K6)9 7 4? )ot Claimed 4?-F Tahashildar
,% %"%,!$ 46)6(6TH9 K6TT9)6KDRD P?(-4? P?( 4?-P?( Tahashildar
,, %&&+!8 R6OD<H'6R9 K6<TH>R9 4? )ot Claimed 4?-F CT3
Pa4e @#
,8 ,%!8%! <H69L6O6 ?K 4? )ot Claimed 4? CT3
,* %"*8$8 ?DD)6 < )69K 4? )ot Claimed 4?-F 6RC<
Not 6entioned t*e Nua7iJ)ations
Tab7e / A;F
Category Claimed by
the Candidates
Category Considered
and <elected by the
K(<C
(ost <elected
% %%,+%+ K><>?6 K>?6R9 ? <T <T-F T6H6<9L:H6R
! &"8"!$ )646R6O K 7 % % L673>R 3FF9CDR
& %!$%," KR9<H)6 ?>RTHN H#D &6 4?-&6 6<<T#CH9DF 6>:9T3R
FINDING1 ON MI1CE00ANEO,1 MATTER1-
The (etitioner members hae recorded their conclusions on the said issue under sub2headings (6) and (7) and in Tables 62&+/ 62&* and 62&0# 9n my opinion the terms of
reference to this committee as stated in introduction aboe/ do not encompass these matters and hence/ 9 refrain from making any comments on the said aspects#
CHAPTER 5 &- "### !ATCH
Analysis and conclusion of the Petitioner Members:
Pa4e E'
The K(<C has informed the (etitioner members that all the ans.er scripts of the %$$$ 7atch hae been destroyed# Hence/ the (etitioner members did not get the
opportunity of looking into the original ans.er scripts of the candidates# Ho.eer/ it is pertinent to mention here that although there .ere more than %", cases
pending before arious Courts - Tribunal/ .ith regard to the %$$$ 7atch list of cases as furnished by the K(<C is produced here.ith as Anne:ure- !"3 The K(<C
destroyed the ans.er scripts on "+-%!-!""*# 9n the opinion of the (etitioner members/ it .as neither proper nor prudent on the part of the K(<C to destroy the
ans.er scripts .hen a number of cases .ere pending in respect of the same batch# The (etitioner members opine that destruction of ans.er scripts/ .hich are one
of the primary materials/ amounts to destruction of eidence#
I+ E<a7uation 1ta4e-
3n the basis of computer generated data made aailable to the (etitioner members .ith regard to the %$$$ 7atch/ the (etitioner ?embers hae found that a
system of three2tier ealuation of ans.er scripts had been adopted# Daluation by =rst DBaminer/ then random picking and ealuation by a second DBaminer and if
the marks diFerence is more than &! then a third ealuation .as supposed to hae been done# 9t is also informed by the K(<C that the aerage of the best of t.o
scores (as bet.een the three ealuations) .ould be taken as the Final ?arks# Ho.eer/ this procedure has no basis in the form of Rules or 4uidelines# Ho.eer/ as
per the obseration of the (etitioner members there hae been discrepancies in taking the aerage and in some cases only the marks of one ealuation is taken and
the aerage is not taken at all# The policy said to hae been follo.ed in ealuation is not consistently practiced/ but is done arbitrarily# The self2illustratie tables
.ould thro. more light on this aspect#
TA!0E 5 !"
17
No
Na6e Re4 No
1ubLe)t
CPaper
E:a6i
ner I
E:a6i
ner II
E:a6in
er III
A)tua7
A<era4e
6ar8s
Mar8s
A=arded
DiMere
n)e
Tota7 Mar8s
!eneJtC 0oss
Post 1e7e)ted
% <9R943'R9#:#R 8"&8&& 4<29 %!" %%* %%0#8 %%* 2%#8 /"3@ :N#<>(T: 3F (3L9CD
! )6T6R6O> H 8"!$$& 4<29 *8 *8 ** ! &
:9<T#3FF9CDR F3R <C1 <T
'DLF6RD
&
?6N6:DK9
46L646L9
+"&$+& 4<299 %&% $* %"8 %"% $" 2%% /""
:9<T#3FF9CDR F3R <C1 <T
'DLF6RD
,
<H6)K6RD((6
'6)9KN6L
+"!"$0 4<299 %&, %8$ %,+#8 %8! 8#8 @3@ T6H6<9L:6R
8 43K9):6 RD::N +",,0% 4<29 %+! %+* %+,#8 %+! 2!#8 /&3@ T6H6<9L:6R
+ R6?D<H :D<69 8"$%0, 4<299 %8$ %&$ %,$ %8" % " T6H6<9L:6R
* <H376 T R 8%*!&& 4<299 %!* %!* %!$ ! & T6H6<9L:6R
0 )6)O>):D 43':6 8+&0*+ 4<299 %8* %!+ %%% %%$ %,! !& &; T6H6<9L:6R
$ 4DDT6 K3>L49
+"$*,& 4<29 0& 0+ 08 %"+ !%
;"
T6H6<9L:6R
4<299 %!$ %!8 %!* %&* %"
%" (33R)9?6 ( K 8"$!"" 4<29 %"0 %%! %"0 , ( T6H6<9L:6R
%% K6<6)TH6 K>?6R ( 8"",*$ 4<29 $0 $0 %"& 8 @ T6H6<9L:6R
%! )646R6O6 <DTTN R 8%+$"8 4<299 %%" %%" %%& & ; T6H6<9L:6R
Pa4e E"
%& K><>?6 L6TH6 ( < 8"&!0& H9<2% %", %", %&% !* &F
6<<T#:9RDCT3R 3F L6):
RDC3R:<
%, K><>?6 L6TH6 ( < 8"&!0& 4<299 %,+ %!% %&&#8 %&8 %#8 "3@
6<<T#:9RDCT3R 3F L6):
RDC3R:<
%8 R6)46)6TH6 T 8!,*!& %"% %%" %"8#8 %"0 !#8 &3@ C3??DRC96LT6P 3FF9CDR

NoteC :uring the =nal selection/ ariation of een half a mark .ould make a diFerence as to the allocation of posts# Hence/ een a minor discrepancy .ould result in
inGustice#
Ana7Ksis and )on)7usion o9 t*e BP1C 6e6ber-
The procedure follo.ed in the %$$$ batch recruitment is a ariation of the %$$0 batch recruitment# 6s stated aboe by the (etitioner members/ it seen that the aerage of
the marks is taken into consideration in the eent of an ans.er script being ealuated by more than one member and the aerage of the best of t.o scores in the eent of
the ealuation by & eBaminers haing alued a particular papers# 9n my opinion/ it .as an improed ersion of the %$$0 scheme of aluation# Ho.eer/ the (etitioner
members hae pointed out certain discrepancies/ .hich at best can be described as errors and the same are not indicatie of a general faulty system of ealuation/ but/
at best could be instances of faulty ealuation in a particular case#
II+ Ano6a7ies durin4 in t*e sta4e o9 Persona7itK Test
The basic Ea. of the K(<C in these selection processes is that it has failed to properly/ logically and consistently apply the reseration policy is a is the %C!" ratio (for
?ain DBamination) and %C8 ratio (for (ersonality Test)# There are t.o stages before actual selection i#e# after the preliminary eBamination .hen candidates are chosen to
.rite the main eBamination it has to be in the ratio of %C!" i#e# if there is one post resered for a particular category then !" candidates from that category are eligible to
.rite the main eBamination# The same holds good for personality test/ but the ratio is %C8# 3nly after the (ersonality Test/ .hen the marks in the ?ain DBamination and the
(ersonality Test are added/ a merit list (irrespectie of the category-caste) on the basis of the total marks is prepared# Then the =rst 8"H of posts are =lled in the 4?
category and only thereafter the reseration sets in# 6ny candidate .ho is from 4?/ .ho is not in the =rst 8"H of the merit list/ .ill not get any post een though he may
hae scored more than others .ho hae the bene=t of reseration#
Pa4e E&
a+ Ratio .io7ation- 3n the basis of the information proided to the (etitioner ?embers/ the (etitioner ?embers hae come to =nding .ith regard to the proportional
ratio at the stage of (ersonality TestC The complete list of candidates and their categories/ .ho .ere called for the personality test is gien in tables put in is
produced here.ith as Anne:ure- !/&
TA!0E 5 !&
173 No3 Cate4orK
Nu6ber o9 posts
a77otted to ea)*
)ate4orK
Nu6ber to be
)a77ed IN "-@
RATIO
Nu6ber a)tua77K )a77ed 9or
persona7itK test
DiMeren)e in t*e nu6ber Ratio DiMeren)e
" GM GMC>MP #E ($' &F@ /&'@ "-&3$E
& 1C1C/>MP ;& "E' &'" G(" "-$3@E
; 1T '# (@ @( G'# "-E
( C/" 'F ;@ @F G&& "-$3"(
@ &A&A/>MP &$ "(' "$& G(& "-E3@'
E &! '$ (' @" G"" "-E3;$
F ;A '@ &@ @; G&$ "-"'3E'
$ ;! 'E ;' E$ G;$ "-""3;;
TOTA0 "#" #@@ #(" /"(
('ith regard to category &6/ the posts noti=ed .ere 8 and !8 persons had to be called for (T# Ho.eer/ as per the information proided by the K(<C 8& candidates belonging
to &6 .ere called for the interie.# 3ne candidate by name <ri# Karee 4o.da/ Reg# )o# 8%+&$,/ had secured less marks than the !8
th
candidate in &6# 7ut he .as called for
the (ersonality Test/ .as a.arded %8" mark and .as selected as Tahsildar# 'ith regard to &7/ the posts noti=ed .ere + and &" persons had to be called for (T# Ho.eer/ as
per the information proided by the K(<C +0 candidates belonging to &7 .ere called for the interie.#)
3n perusal of the aboe table/ it is clear that the ratio policy of %C8 for (ersonality Test has been iolated and disproportionate number of candidates are made eligible# 9t may
also be seen that there is gross disproportion in 4?/ .hich resulted in disadantage to 4? candidates and contrarily there is gross disproportion .ith regard to &6 1 &7
candidates/ .hich resulted in disproportionate adantage to the said categories/ at the cost of the 4?# 9n this regard many aspiring 4eneral ?erit candidates right to selection
.as denied and is unconstitutional/ iolating 6rticles %, and %+#
Pa4e E;
b+Findin4 =it* re4ard to t*e a)tua7 pro)ess o9 inter<ie= and a=ard o9 6ar8sC 3n the basis of the records proided to the (etitioner ?embers/ the (etitioner
?embers hae made the follo.ing =ndings/ enumerated under diFerent headings/ as belo.#
i3 A77 Me6bers a=arded sa6eCeNua7 Mar8sC 6fter the perusal of the interie. documents reeals that maGority of the selected candidates .ere a.arded e;ual
?arks or similar ?arks to suit group 6 1 7 posts# 9t is indicatie of the fact that marks had been pre2determined# The follo.ing are some of the instancesC
TA!0E 5 !;
% R6K9 ?K 8+&0,, :r H ) KR9<H)6 %8" %8"
L9LL96) P6K9DR %8"
:6<696H %8"
KD)K6T<'6?N %8"
(6T9L H < %8"
! KR9<H)6 K>?6R 8!&8+, 6<<T# <>(:T#3F (R9<3) :r H ) KR9<H)6 %8" %8"
L9LL96) P6K9DR %8"
:6<696H %8"
KD)K6T<'6?N %8"
(6T9L H < %8"
?d# 6L9 KH6) %8"
& 7 ) 4D<>:6R6Q :3 <C-<T :r H ) KR9<H)6 %8" %8"
L9LL96) P6K9DR %8"
:6<696H %8"
KD)K6T<'6?N %8"
(6T9L H < %8"
?d# 6L9 KH6) %8"
, :DKR6O> : 8"!%0% :N <( :r H) KR9<H)6 %8" %8"
:6<696H %8"
KD)K6T<'6?N %8"
L P6K9DR F'
TAMPERED
A1 "@'
8 ?6)O>)6TH K : 8+!*00 D?(L3N?D)T 3FF9CDR ?d# 6L9 KH6) %8" %8"
:r H ) KR9<H)6 %8"
:6<696H %8"
KD)K6T<'6?N %8"
L P6K9DR %8"
ii3 Candidates absent =ere a=arded Mar8s Mar8s a=arded Candidates 6ade absent3
TA!0E 5 !(
Pa4e E(
"
1HAI0ADA H R
@';E;F
"3 0i77ian >a<ier a=arded "@' 6ar8s and
6ar8ed as A!1ENT3
&3 Dasaia* 6ar8ed as A!1ENT and
a=arded "@' 6ar8s3
&
1IDDAPPA !
@'';&$
"3 0i77ian >a<ier a=arded @@ 6ar8s and
6ar8ed Ine7i4ib7e (ICE+3
&3 Mo*a66ed A7i B*an a=arded @'
6ar8s and 6ar8ed Ine7i4ib7e (ICE+3
;3 Dr H 1 Pati7 a=arded @' 6ar8s and
(3 .en8atas=a6K a=arded @' 6ar8s and
@3 Dasaia* a=arded @' 6ar8s and
iii3 In t*e 9o77o=in4 instan)es a77 t*e 6e6bers =*o =ere present at t*e inter<ie= did not a=ard t*e 6ar8s- 6erage of marks a.arded by the members of the
interie. panel is to be considered# 9f the members .ho are present at the interie. do not a.ard marks/ then there .ould be ariation in the aerage marks#
Tab7e 5 !@
103 NO3
NAME OF CANDIDATE
REG3 NO3
Na6e o9 t*e Me6bers
Present in t*e )o66ittee
and not a=arded 6ar8s
Date o9 PT Test
Ot*er 6e6bers A=arded
6ar8s
Re6ar8s
%#
RaGesh 4o.da ?#7
8"0%0$
Lilian Paier
H#< (atil
Kenkatas.my
?ohd 6li Khan
%&202!""8
%8" marks by H#)#Krishna
%8" marks by :asaiah
Den though the candidate
selected 6sst Commissioner by
ignoring the marks of other
members# 9f the member a.arded
the marks to the candidate/ it .ill
be eFected the 6g marks taken in
consideration
! 7anashankari H#)#Krishna 02*2!""8 %#?ohd 6li Khan a.arded :o
Pa4e E@
8%&!%+
20" marks
!#H#< (atil a.arded 20!
marks#
&#Kenkatas.amy a.arded
$8 marks#
,#:asaiah a.arded $8
marks
&
7asaaraGu 4
8%%"0$
H#)#Krishna 02*2!""8
%#?ohd 6li Khan a.arded
288 marks
!#H#< (atil a.arded 2*"
marks#
&#Kenkatas.amy a.arded
88 marks#
,#:asaiah a.arded +"
marks
2:o2
,
Krishna RaGendra 7harath
8+&8%+
?ohd 6li Khan %82*2!""8
%#:r#H#)#Krishna a.arded
2*8 marks
!# Lilian Paier a.ardrd %!"
marks
&#H#< (atil a.arded 2*8
marks#
,#Kenkatas.amy a.arded
*8 marks#
8#:asaiah a.arded *8marks
:o
8
Krishnakumar 7akale
+"!$!"
?ohd 6li Khan %82*2!""8
288 marks
!# Lilian Paier a.ardrd 8"
marks
&#H#< (atil a.arded 280
marks#
8" marks#
8#:asaiah a.arded 8"
marks
2:32
+
Krishnamurthy 4
8"$,$&
:o :o
2+" marks
!# Lilian Paier a.ardrd +"
marks
&#H#< (atil a.arded 2+"
marks#
+" marks#
8#:asaiah a.arded +"
marks
2:32
* Kumaras.amy R#?
8"%$0*
:3 :3 %#:r#H#)#Krishna a.arded
2*" marks
2:32
Pa4e EE
!# Lilian Paier a.ardrd +"
marks
&#H#< (atil a.arded 2*"
marks#
+" marks#
8#:asaiah a.arded +"
marks
i<3 Candidates )onsidered under GM 9or not produ)in4 Caste In)o6e CertiJ)ates- Candidates .ho did not produce caste and income certi=cates at the time
of interie. .ere considered under 4?/ after taking a representation from them# They had been considered under their respectie categories all along i#e during the
preliminary eBam and main eBamination and during the short listing for (ersonality Test# They got the bene=t of being considered in their respectie categories all
along and later they are considered under 4? for (ersonality Test at the time of the interie.# This is a gross iolation of the rules specifying that candidates .ho do
not produce the releant certi=cates shall not be considered for selection (Rule TTTTTTTTTTTTTTT)
Tab7e 5 !E
<L )3 )6?D 1 RD4 )3 )3T9)4 3F THD ( D 9) THD
6TTD):D)CD
RD?6RK 3F THD
C3??9<<93) 9) THD (T
<T6TD?D)T
RD?6RK 3F THD
7R6)CH
3R:DR 3F THD
C3??9<<93)
(3<T <DLDCTD:
% 76):D )6'6Q
4D<>:6R6Q +8,*8%
C6):T# RD(RD<D)T6T93) D)CL# 3RC )3T (R3:>CD:
/9)TDRK9D'D: >):DR 4?
3R4)L !7 CDRT9FCT
:T %0#%!#$$ )3T
(R3:>CD: C3)<9:R:
>):DR 4?
F3R 3R:DR<#
3K :3 <C-<T
! ?6)O>)6TH #K#:#
8*%%,,
VVVV# 9)TDRK9D'D: >):DR 4? 3R4)L &6 CDRT9FCT
:T !"#%!#$$ )3T
(R3:>CD: C3)<9:R:
>):DR 4?
F3R 3R:DR<#
3K D3
& (H6)9R6O #:#6
8&%$*&
VVVV# 3RC )3T (R3:>CD:
/9)TDRK9D'D: >):DR 4?
3R4)L &7 CDRT9FCT
:T %*#"%#!""" )3T
(R3:>CD: C3)<9:R:
>):DR 4?
F3R 3R:DR<#
3K CT3
, R6?D<H :D<69
8"$%0,
VVVV 3RC )3T (R3:>CD:
/9)TDRK9D'D: >):DR 4?
3R4)L &7 CDRT9FCT
)3T (R3:>CD:
C3)<9:R: >):DR 4?
F3R 3R:DR<#
3K T6H<9L:6R
8 <H69L6O6 KR
8+!,8%
##################### 3RC )3T (R3:>CD:
/9)TDRK9D'D: >):DR 4?
3R4)L C6<TD
CDRT9FCT :T
%&#"%!""" )3T
(R3:>CD: C3)<9:R:
3K T6H<9L:6R
Pa4e EF
>):DR 4?
F3R 3R:DR<#
<3 A=ardin4 o9 unusua77K *i4* 6ar8s bK t*e t*en C*air6an o9 BP1C- The (etitioner ?embers hae obsered that the then Chairman of K(<C/ :r# H# )# Krishna has
a.arded unusually high marks to certain candidates (in comparison .ith other members)# The follo.ing table is placed in this regard#
Tab7e 5 !F
103 NO3
NAME OF CANDIDATE
REG3 NO3
MARB1 A?ARDED !2
DR H3N3
BRI1HNA
Mar8s A=arded bK t*e ot*er 6e6bers Date o9 PT Test
%
RaGendra K
8""%0!
%$,
?% S %!8
?! S %%"
?& 2 %+8
?, S %""
?8 2 %8"
%&202!""8
!
?adhu Chandra TeGasi
8""0$&
%0"
?% S %8"
?! S %8"
?& 2 %8"
?, S %8"
?8 2 %8"
%02*2!""8
&
Raghu 4#(#
8",%8%
%*,
?% S %8"
?! S %8"
?& 2 %8"
?, S %8"
?8 2 %8"
%&202!""8
,
(ushpa :#R
8"08*!
%+0
?% S %8"
?! S %8"
?& 2 %8"
?, S %8"
?8 2 %8"
%&202!""8
Pa4e E$
8
<6TN6 7H6?6
8%$,+,
%+!
?% S %8+
?! S %8+
?& 2 %8+
?, S %8+
?8 2 %8"
%$202!""8
+
<6K9TH6 <
8"+%%*
%,,
?% S %!"
?! S %!"
?& 2 %!"
?, S %!"
?8 2 %!"
%$202!""8
<i3 Ta6perin4 o9 inter<ie= 6ar8s bK t*e t*en )*air6an 6e6bers o9 BP1C- The (etitioner ?embers/ on the perusal of the records of the interie./ hae found that
marks of some of the candidates .ere altered# The statements gien by the then members/ under <ection %+, of Cr#(#C/ during the en;uiry of C9:/ also gies reasons for
such alterations# The tabular columns belo. illustrate the same#
Tab7e 5!$
<L#
)3
)6?D 3F THD K(<C
?D?7DR 'H3 ?6:D
<T6TD?D)T >):DR
6RT9CLD %+,3F
CR(C
<L#3
)?D 3F THD C6):9:6TD 6):
RD4 )3# 'H3 9LL946LLN
7D)DF9TD: 7N THD 6CT 3F K(<C
?D?7DR#
RD<DRK6T93)
C6RD43RN#
(3<T
<DLLDCTD:#
37<DRK6T93)
?6:D#
RD6<3)-RD(LN
49KD) 7N THD
K(<C ?D?7DR#
K9:D (64D
)>?7DR 3F H9<
<T6TD?D)T#
9 :R# H#<# (6TDL# %
6R6T9#
RD4)3 +8*$"8
996 L673>R 3FF9CDR
?6RK<
6LTDRDRD: FR3?
%!8T3 %8"
TH9< 9< :>D T3
9)<TR>CT93)<
FR3? THD
CH69R?6) H#)#
KR9<H)6#
(2+
KR9<H)6?>RTHN#H#K#
RD4)3#8",&&%#
(733K)3#%$)
!6 T6H6<9L:6R
?6RK<
6LTDRDRD: FR3?
8"T3 %!"
222222 2222
Pa4e E#
!
(6T9L N6L643>:6
<H9K6)643>:6
RD4 )3 +"$"8"
(733K )3 &,)
4? 6<<T#C3??R#
?6RK<
6LTDRDRD: FR3?
%"" T3 %!"
99 <?T#L9L96) P6K9DR &
67H96)L6<H K6RT9KDN# :#
RD4)3#8%*0,&
9996 22222222
?6RK< 49KD)
(3KDR 'R9TTD)) #
C3RRDCT93) 9<
?6:D T3 <>9T
?6RK< 9)
'R9TTD)#
(2+
222222 ,
6)9TH6#T#
RD4)3#8&&+8*#
4? 222222222
?6RK<
6LTDRDRD: FR3?
88 T3 8"
T3 <>9T ?6RK<
'R9TTD) 9)
F94>RD<#
(2+
2222222 8
7H646N6#7#R#
RD4)3#8%&$!,
4? 222222222
?6RK<
6LTDRDRD:
'R9TTT9)4
7R6KDT 9)
'R3)4 (L6CD#
(2+
2222222 +
6?6R)6TH#T#
RD4)3#8"%$$8
<C D#3 #9)<DRTD: F9KD
6< (DR THD
:9RDCT93) FR3?
THD :R# H/)#
KR9<H)6#
(2+
22222222 *
:DKDR6O#:# RD4#)3#8"!%&%
9996 :N<(
?6RK<
6LTDRDRD: FR3?
*" T3 %8"
#
6< (DR THD
:9RDCT93) FR3?
THD :R#
H/)# KR9<H)6#
2222222222 0
:DK6R> <H6)T6 R6? HD4:D
RD4#+"&+!&
4?-P?( 222
?6RK< 3KDR
'R9TTD)#
7N 3KDR <9TD#
999 <R9 :6<696H $
R6?6)>O696H
RD4)3#8""88*
<C 6CCT #
9 H6KD )3T 49KD)
6)N ?6RK< 9)
9)TDRK9D'
(2!
22222222 %"
R6?6)O6)696H#
RD4)3#8",$*%
2222 222222 #222222 22222:"22222 (22!
%%
KD?(696H#R#K#
RD4)3#8+!*00#
996 222
?6RK<
6LTDRDRD: FR3?
8" T3 %""6):
6469) T6?(RD:
6< %8"
2222222
9K
:R# ?3H6??D: 6L9
KH6)
%!
O6N6))6#
RD4#8+%"+,
9997
?6RK<
6LTDRDRD: FR3?
%"" T3 %&"
9 :3)T
RD?D?7DR THD
RD6<3)#
(20
22222222 %&
?>R<H6:>::9)#L#K9LL6:6R#
RD4)3#+""$%,
997 T6H6<9L:6R
?6RK<
6LTDRDRD: FR3?
%"" T3 %8"
9 :3)T
RD?D?7DR THD
RD6<3)#
2222222222 %,
3?K6R#K#7#
RD4)3#+,,%,
996
?6RK<
6LTDRDRD: FR3?
%!8 T3 %&,
9 :3)T
RD?D?7DR THD
RD6<3)#
Pa4e F'
On t*e basis o9 t*e ana7Ksis o9 t*e data% t*e Petitioner Me6bers *a<e obser<ed t*at a )andidates o9 t=o parti)u7ar )ate4ories =ere abnor6a77K
9a<ored% abo<e a77 ot*ers% in t*e se7e)tion pro)ess3 T*e 9o77o=in4 se79/i77ustrati<e tab7e is p7a)ed =it* re4ard to t*e sa6eC
Tab7e/!#
COMPARATI.E 1TATEMENT 1HO?ING THE CANDIDATE1 1E0ECTED FOR "### GAUETTED PRO!PR1 GRO,P A ! PO1T1 ,NDER .ARIO,1 METHOD1 OF
1E0ECTION ?HO HAD C0AIMED RE1ER.ATION
10
NO3
CATEGOR
2
NO3 OF PO1T1
RE1ER.ED A1
PER
AD.ERTI1EMEN
T
NO OF
PER1ON1
ACT,A002
CA00ED FOR
PT IN
.IO0ATION
OF "-@
RATIO
NO3 OF
CANDIDATE
1 1E0ECTED
A1
CATEGOR2
CANDIDATE
1
NO3OF
CANDIDATE1
P,1HED TO GM
CATEGOR2
NO3 OF
CANDIDATEP1
RE1ER.ATION
CATEGOR2
CHANGED A1 GM
D,E TO NOT
PROD,CING
ORIGINA0
RE1ER.ATION
CERTIFICATE1
(ORCP1+ D,RING
INTER.IE?
NO3OF CATEGOR2
CANDIDATE1
1E0ECTED A1 GM
CANDIDATE1 !2
MANIP,0ATING THE
CANIDAT,RE D,RING
PREPARATION OF "-@
E0IGI!I0IT2 0I1T OF
INTER.IE?
TOTA0 NO3
OF
CANDIDATE
1 1E0ECTED
PERCENTAG
E OF
INCREA1E
" 1C ;' "#F ;' NI0 NI0 NI0 ;' "''
& 1T # @( # NI0 NI0 NI0 # "''
; CAT /I F @F F " NI0 NI0 $ ""(
( &A &E "F@ &E NI0 NI0 NI0 &E "''
@ &! $ @" $ & NI0 NI0 "' "&@
Pa4e F"
E ;A @ @; @ ( & & "; &E'
F ;! E E$ E ; ; NI0 "& &''
TOTA0 #" #" "'$

T*e 9o77o=in4 se79/i77ustrati<e tab7es are p7a)ed on re)ord% as part o9 data ana7Ksis-
Tab7e 5 !"'
Nu6ber o9 Cate4orK I Candidates (1e7e)ted+ Pus*ed to GM
(Ot*er t*an t*ose =*o =ere not se7e)ted+
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% +""%,, )64D):R6 F H3))6LL9 %"08 % T6H6<9L:H6R
0"
! 8%%,,% KD)K6TD<H696H $0+ % T6H6<9L:H6R
%8"
Tab7e 5 !""
Nu6ber o9 &! Candidates (1e7e)ted+ Pus*ed to GM
103 NO REG NO3
NAME OF THE
CANDIDATE1
?RITTEN MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% 8!"08" 6LL676K6<H ? < %"8+ !7 :3 <C-<T
%8"
! +%"$+$ 9L9N6< 6H?D: 9<6?6:9 $0+ !7 T6H6<9L:H6R
%8"
Pa4e F&
Tab7e 5 !"&
Nu6ber o9 &! CANDIDATE1 RE1ER.ATION CATEGOR2 CHANGED A1 GM D,E TO NOT PROD,CING ORIGINA0 RE1ER.ATION CERTIFICATE1 (ORCs+
D,RING INTER.IE?
103
NO
REG NO3
NAME OF THE
CANDIDATE1
?RITTENMARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION (!ot* Pre7i6s
Mains+
CATEGOR2
P,RPO1F,002
MAN,PI0ATED
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% 8+,*8%
76):D )6'6Q
4D<>:6R6Q
!7 4? :3 <C-<T
TA!0E / !";
Nu6ber o9 ;A CANDIDATE1 P,1HED TO GM CATEGOR2
103
NO
REG NO3
NAME OF THE
CANDIDATE1
?RITTEN
MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION
PO1T
1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% 8"0!*" )646R6O> 7 ? %"*& &6 6CCT
%8"
! 8"!%0% :DK6R6O6 : %"&, &6 :N<(
%8"
& +",,0% 43K9):6 RD::N %"!0 &6 T6H6<9L:H6R
%&,#%*
, 8%","& (6TH6R6O> K %"%* &6 T6H6<9L:H6R
%8"
Tab7e 5 !"(
NO3 OF ;A CANDIDATE1 RE1ER.ATION CATEGOR2 CHANGED A1 GM D,E TO NOT PROD,CING ORIGINA0 RE1ER.ATION
CERTIFICATE1 (ORCs+ D,RING INTER.IE?
103
NO
REG NO3
NAME OF THE
CANDIDATE1
?RITTEN
MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED
IN APP0ICATION (!ot*
Pre7i6s Mains+
CATEGOR2
P,RPO1F,002
MAN,PI0ATED
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% 8+!,8% <HNL6O6 K R $00 &6 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%%8
Pa4e F;
! 8*%%,, ?6)O>)6TH K : $*, &6 4? D3
%8"
% 8+88+0 T6??6))6 6 C $** &6 4? L3
%8"
! 8"&8&& <9R9 43'R9 : R $8* )3T ?D)T93)D: 4? :N<(
%8"
Tab7e/!"@
NO3OF ;! CANDIDATE1 P,1HED TO GM CATEGOR2
103
NO
?RITTENMARB
1
CATEGOR2
C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION
(!ot* Pre7i6s
Mains+
CATEGOR2 P,1HED
TO
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% 8+**0! R6K9K>?6R < 7 %"+, &7 4? 6LC
%8"
! +8&"0" H6)>?6)TH6R6N6 %"&* &7 4? :N<(
%8"
& +8&%%% <H6R6)676<6((6 K3TD((643L %"%& &7 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%8"
Tab7e 5!"E
)3# 3F &7 C6):9:6TD< RD<DRK6T93) C6TD43RN CH6)4D: 6< 4? :>D T3 )3T (R3:>C9)4 3R949)6L RD<DRK6T93) CDRT9F9C6TD< (3RCs) :>R9)4 9)TDRK9D'
103
NO
REG NO3
NAME OF THE
CANDIDATE1
?RITTEN
MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED
Pre7i6s Mains+
CATEGOR2
P,RPO1F,002
MAN,PI0ATED
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% 8&%$*0 (6)9R6O> : 6 $$0 &7 4? CT3 %&+#+*
! 8"$%0, R6?D<H :D<69 $$& &7 4? T6H<9L:6R
%8"
Pa4e F(
& 8!0&,, <H6R6:6 < O %"!0 &7 4? CT3
+8
Ana7Ksis and )on)7usion o9 t*e BP1C 6e6ber in respe)t o9 a77 sub/*eads under t*e 6ain *eadin4 o9 Ano6a7ies durin4 t*e sta4e o9 Persona7itK Test-
6ll the instances of the irregularities pointed out by the (etitioner members under arious sub2headings under the main head of 6nomalies during the stage of
(ersonality Test is a repetition of the =ndings recorded by the (etitioner members under similar head in respect of %$$0 batch and only the eBamples of the candidates
diFer and hence my analysis and conclusion that 9 hae furnished in respect of the %$$0 batch under similar heads .ould also ans.er the aforesaid analysis and
conclusion of the (etitioner members#
)+ Findin4s re4ardin4 )aste and in)o6e )ertiJ)ates and ot*er do)u6ents-
For claiming the bene=t of reseration/ proof of caste - tribe and for some categories of reseration caste and income proof are necessary# Caste and income certi=cates/
in the prescribed forms and .ithin the prescribed time limits had been made mandatory during the selection process for candidates claiming the reseration bene=t#
:uring the course of ascertaining facts/ it has come to the kno.ledge of the (etitioner ?embers that there has been manipulations and large discrepancies/ resulting in
itiation of the process# The follo.ing paragraphs and tables bring out the factual aspect of these#
i# In)o6p7ete )ertiJ)atesC 3nly eri=cation portion of the Caste and income certi=cates of the follo.ing candidates are produced# The said certi=cates are
incomplete#
Tab7e 5!"F
Cate4orK C7ai6ed
bK t*e Candidates
Cate4orK Considered
and 1e7e)ted bK t*e
BP1C
Post 1e7e)ted
% 8%+0,8 :6N6)6):6 #K#6 !6 !6 6<<T C3??9<<93)DR
! 8"0%*% <6)46((6 !6 !6 6<<T C3??9<<93)DR
& 8"0!*" )646R6O>#7#? &6 4?-&6 6<<T#C3?)<R 3F C3?RCL T6P
, +"+$+& <>K6)N6 )6N6K !6 !6-F 6CCT
8 8+**0! R6K9 K>?6R#<#7# &7 4?-&7 6LC
+ 8%+,$" CH6):R6K6)TH#?#K !6 !6 :N<(
* +",,88 ?>LL6 <679R 6H?D: !7 !7 :3#<C-<T
0 +"&$+& ?6N6:6K9 46L646L9 !6 !6-F :3#<C-<T
$ +8&%%% <H6R6)676<6((6 K3T6((643L &7 &7 T6H6<9L:6R
Pa4e F@
%" +",,0% 43K9):6 RD::N &6 4?-&6 T6H6<9L:6R
%% +8!&*8 <HDDLK6)TH <H9K6K>?6R !6 !6 T6H6<9L:6R
%! +%,!,& (>O6R KDDR6?6LL6((6 &7 &7 T6H6<9L:6R
%& +",,8+ <H9:R6?6((6 79R6:6R &7 &7 T6H6<9L:6R
%, +%0$$0 KR9<H)6 K>?6R#C#O# !6 !6 T6H6<9L:6R
%8 8+&0*+ )6)O>):6 43':6# !6 !6 T6H6<9L:6R
%+ 8!&8%8# ?6)O6)6TH6#C#) !6 !6 T6H6<9L:6R
%* 8%+&!, K6RDD 43':6 &6 &6 T6H6<9L:6R
%0 8%80%+ 6<H6#<# &7 &7-F T6H6<9L:6R
%$ 8&"%8" ?3H6??D: Q>7DR6#) !7 !7 T6H6<9L:6R
!" 8%8++& T6776<>? Q6HDR6# !7 !7 T6H6<9L:6R
!% +8!%!, <6)46((6<9:6((6 H>LL>R !6-P?( !6-P?( T6H6<9L:6R
!! 8%+%$% L9)46))6 K>CH76L !6 !6 CT3
!& 8"&08& O646:DD<H# C !6 !6 :N<D
!, 8"%,!8 ?3H6??D:76<HDDR 6)<6R9# !7 !7 L3
!8 +8*$"8 6R6T9# !6 !6-F L3
!+ 8"&%$& (R6KDD)#7#)6N6K !6 !6 6RC<
ii# As per t*e notiJ)ation )a77in4 9or app7i)ations 9or t*e ad<ertised posts it *ad been spe)iJed t*at t*e )andidates )7ai6in4 reser<ation under
&A% &!% ;A ;! )ate4ories *a<e to obtain and sub6it t*e )aste and in)o6e )ertiJ)ates =*i)* are issued on or a9ter "@3"&3"### and be9ore
&&3'"3&'''3 Ho=e<er% in t*e 9o77o=in4 instan)es t*e se7e)ted )andidates did not sub6it t*e )ertiJ)ates o9 t*e period spe)iJed3 A7t*ou4* t*is
dis)repan)K =as noted initia77K =*i7e s)rutinizin4 t*e app7i)ations% t*is reNuire6ent =as 7ater on disre4arded3
Tab7e 5 !"$
Cate4orK C7ai6ed bK t*e
Candidates
Cate4orK Considered
and 1e7e)ted bK t*e
BP1C
Post 1e7e)ted
Pa4e FE
% +""%,, )64D):R6# F#H3))6LL9 C2%
Caste Certi=cate :ated#%$#&#%$$0
4?-% T6H6<9L:6R
! 8%%,,% KD)K6TD<H696H C2%
Caste Certi=cate :ated#%8#,#%$$$
C2%-4? T6H6<9L:6R
& 8%,,"+ 76L6KR9<H)6((6#D# C2%
:ated#%8#%%#%$$$
C2% T6H6<9L:6R
, 8"8,!+ R6K9K>?6R#? C2%
:ated #!8#&#%$$0
C2% T6H6<9L:6R
8 8+88+0 T6??6))6#6#C# 9996
:ated !%#+#%$$$
4? L673>R 3FF9CDR
iii# CertiJ)ates not issued bK t*e Co6petent Aut*oritK- The (etitioner ?embers hae obsered that Caste and 9ncome Certi=cates had to be issued by
Tahsildars/ but in the follo.ing cases they hae not been issued by Tahsildars/ but by <pecial Tahsildars - 6dditional Tahsildars#
Tab7e 5!"#
Cate4orK C7ai6ed bK
t*e Candidates
Post 1e7e)ted
% 8+,$,0 <H9K6 <'6?N#7# !6 !6 T6H6<9L:6R
! 8%+%*0 )646R6O>#4#K &6 &6 T6H6<9L:6R
& 8%"*0% KR9<H)6K6)9# C2% C2%-F T6H6<9L:6R
, 8",8"* ><H6R6)9#)#C !6 !6-F T6H6<9L:6R
8 8"&08& O646:DD<H#C# !6 !6 :N<D
Pa4e FF
i# In t*e 9o77o=in4 )ases )aste and in)o6e )ertiJ)ates *ad not been en)7osed a7on4 =it* t*e App7i)ations-
Tab7e 5 !&'
1L)3 RD4)3 )6?D
C6TD43RN CL6?D: 7N
C6):9:6TD
C6TD43RNC3)C9:DR: ): <DLLDCTD: 7N THD
K(<C
(3<T <DLLDCTD:#
% +8+!+, QDHDR6 )6<DD? !7 !7-F 6C
! 8!&+," 6))6((6#D# <C <C :N<D
& 8"!,0! KDD)6#<#R <C <C L673>R 3FF9CDR
# I6proper )ertiJ)ates -6s per 43 )o <'L !%& <6: 08 :atedC !&2"&2%$0*/ the candidates claiming reseration under <C - <T ;uota hae to submit certi=cates in the
format of 6ppendiB29/ anneBed to 4#3 )o <'L !%& <6: 08 :atedC !&2"&2%$0*# 9n the follo.ing instances this has not been follo.edC
Tab7e 5!&"
<L)3 RD4)3 )6?D< C6TD43RN (3<T<DLLDCTD: 9<<>D: TN(D< 3F F3R?< 6):
:6TD<#
% 8+%&0& L3KD<H#() <T T6H6<9L:6R F3R?/%
<6TN6<H3:6)6 (6TR6/
:6TD:#!*#0#%$$$
! 8"+$$, )646R6O6#K# <C-P?( T6H6<9L:6R F3R?#% <6TN6<H3:6)6 (6TR6/
:6TD:#!+#%%#%$0*
& +"!80" CH6):R6K6)TH ?6H6:DK#?# <C CT3 F3R?#% <6TN6<H3:6)6 (6TR6/
:6TD:#"8#"!#%$$$
, 8"&,0! )646R6O#L <T 6:L? F3R?#:/ :6TD:#%"#%"#!""%
6FTDR THD L6<T :>D :6TD 3F
)3T9F9C6T93)#
Ana7Ksis and )on)7usion o9 t*e BP1C Me6ber in respe)t o9 a77 )on)7usions arri<ed at bK t*e Petitioner Me6bers under t*e *ead/Findin4s re4ardin4
)aste and in)o6e )ertiJ)ates and ot*er do)u6ents-
Pa4e F$
6s per the order dated !"#"$#!"%& passed in '#(# )o# !*+*,-!"%! the scope of the fact =nding eBercise is limited to three broad areas in respect of the 4a5etted
(robationers recruitment of the years %$$0/ %$$$ and !"",/ namelyC
a) Daluation of marks and moderation of marks obtained by the candidates at the time of main .ritten eBamination#
b) 6.arding of ?arks during the personal interie. of candidatesA and
c) 9mplementation of the order dated %%#%"#!""! and ",#"*#!""& passed in '#(#)o#%!8,0-!""! and connected matters#
The (etitioner members hae recorded their conclusions on the said issue under arious sub2headings# 9n my opinion the terms of reference to this committee as stated in
aboe/ do not encompass these matters and hence/ 9 refrain from making any comments on the said aspects#
Mis)e77aneous - Certain app7i)ations =*i)* =ere 7iab7e to be reLe)ted on t*e 9a)e o9 it due to in*erent 7a)una o9 bein4 in)o6p7ete % =ere a))epted % T*e
9o77o=in4 tab7e i77ustrates t*e sa6e3
A+T*e detai7s o9 )andidates =*ose reser<ation and t*e )andidature )onsidered bK t*e BP1C t*ou4* t*e sa6e not )7ai6ed bK t*e )andidates
and not ad*erin4 t*e instru)tions 4i<en in t*e ad<ertise6ent 7isted as Fo77o=sT
TA!0E - ! &&
Sl. No. Reg. No. Name
Candidates
Category Considered
and Selected by the
KPSC
Post Selected
1 300656 SAMINA MERAJ GM-CAT NOT MENTAION IN
MAINS
GM/F ASST.CONTRL
2 503533 SIRI GOWRI.D.R. CAT.NOT MENTIONED IN
PRILMNS AND MAINS
GM/F DYSP
3 600135 RAMAKRISHNA. CAT-NOT CLIMED IN MAINS. GM ASST.COMNDNT
4 53043 AR!N F!RTADO CAT- NOT CLMED IN PRILMS. GM DO-SC/ST
5 606356 !MA SALIGO!DAR CAT- NOT CLMED IN MAINS GM/F DO.SC/ST
6 600233 PRASHANTH NALWAR CAT- NOT CLMED IN
MMAINS
GM TAHASILDAR
" 564416 LOKANATH.R CAT- NOT CLMED IN MAINS GM TAHASILDAR
# 56#022 DHARANI DE$I.K CAT-NOT CLMED IN MAINS GM/F DYSP
50"#64 ROOPA.M. CAT- NOT CLMED IN MAINS GM/F TAHASILDAR
Pa4e F#
10 503""" SHYLAJAPRIYADARSHANI.A.M CAT-NOT CLMED IN MAINS GM/F TAHASILDAR
11 530432 MATHAI.K. KPSC WRITTEN AS 0 %MP TAHASILDAR
12 560"65 $ENKATESH M!RTHY.T.S GM GM CTO
13 52#344 SHARADA.S.J CAT-NOT MENTIONED IN
MAINS
GM CTO
14 520322 S!MITHA .K.K RESER$ATION NOT CLAMED
IN PRLMNS
GM/F DYSE
15 5012#4 MEENA PATIL CAT- NOT CLMED IN MAINS GM/F LA&O!R OFFICER
16 5"1144 MANJ!NATH.K.D. CAT.CLAMED 3A IN
PRILMS' GM IN MAINS
GM EMPLOYMENT OFFICER.
D+ Mis)e77aneous Jndin4s-
a+ :egree certi=cates 1 ?arks cards not submitted .ith their ?ain DBamination application as per instruction issued/ but the candidatures considered in iolation of
instructions3
Tab7e/! &;
173 No3 Re43 No3 Na6e PO1T3 REMARB13
% 8!&*!0 R6K9K>?6R ?#R 6C :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD 6): ?6RK< C6R:< )3T
<>7?9TTD:#
Pa4e $'
! 8"0%0$ R6OD<H 43':6 #?#7 6C :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD 6): ?6RK< C6R:< )3T
<>7?9TTD:#
& 8""08& L6TH6K>?6R9#K#< 6C :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD< 3)LN F9)6L ND6R ?6RK<
C6R:<
, 8&",&$ 6R>) F>RT6:3 :3#<C-<T )3T <>7?9TD: :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD< 3)LN F9)6L
ND6R ?6RK< C6R:<# K(<C 37T69) LDTTDR#
8 +8,,*8 K6LLD<H6# :3#<C-<T )3T <>7?9TD: :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD< 3)LN F9)6L
ND6R ?6RK< C6R:<# (:C 9<<>D: 7N (R9)C9(6L#
+ +"+&8+ >?6 <6L943>:6R :3#<C-<T )3 :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD< 3)LN F9)6L ND6R
?6RK<C6R:<#
* +"!"$0 <H6)K6R6((6'6)9KN6L T6H6<9L:6R )3 :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD< <>7?9TTD: L6TDR#
0 8"%++% <H6)K6R6 43>:<3?6)6L T6H6<9L:6R )3 :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD< 3)LN ?6RK<C6R:<#
$ +%*&+$ <6R3O6#7#7 T6H6<9L:6R )3 :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD< 3)LN ?6RK<C6R:<#
%" 8",&%, 7H6R6TH K>?6R HD:4D CT3 )3T <>7?9TD: :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD</ 3)LN ?6RK<
C6R:<# (:C 9<<>D: 7N (R9)C9(6L#
%% +8&$+* (6T9L <H9K6L9)46??6 CT3 )3 :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD< 3)LN F9)6L ND6R
?6RK<C6R:<
%! 8%$8"" 43K9):6((6#C# 6:L? )3 :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD<#
%& 8"%%0* >?D<H#4# 6RC< 3)LN ?6RK<C6R:< D)CL3<D: )3 :D4RDD
CDRT9F9C6TD<#
%, 8",%8% R64H>#4/( 6:N< )3T <>7?9TD: :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD</ 3)LN (:C
9<<>D: 7N (R9)C9(6L 9< <>7?9TTD:#
%8 8"0$*! <3?6<HDKHDR#?# 6<<T#<>( (R<)<# )3 :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD< 6): )3 ?6RK<C6R:<
%+ +%,8&8 O3<H9<R9)6TH?6H6:DK6 :N<( :D4RDD CDRT9F9C6TD <>7?9TTD: L6TDR#
b+6pplications not properly signedC The follo.ing candidates/ .ho got selected/ had not signed the declaration portion of their applications#
Tab7e 5! &(
Cate4orK C7ai6ed
bK t*e Candidates
Post 1e7e)ted
% 8"&8+0 ?6R>TH9#?#( :DCL6R6T93) T6H6<9L:6R
Pa4e $"
(3RT93)
! 8+$0$0 CH6):R6??6#N#) )3T <94)D: 9)
:DCL6R6T93)
T6H6<9L:R
& 8"%%0* >?D<H6#4# )3T <94)D: 9)
:DCL6R6T93)
6RC<
Ana7Ksis and Con)7usion o9 t*e BP1C Me6bers in respe)t o9 Jndin4s o9 t*e Petitioner Me6bers under t*e *ead o9 Mis)e77aneous-
CHAPTER 5 ;
&''( !at)*
I3 Ano6a7ies in E<a7uation 1ta4e-
Ana7Ksis and Con)7usions o9 t*e Petitioner Me6bers-
The (etitioner ?embers hae gone through the ans.er scripts of selected candidates furnished by the K(<C and it has obsered thatC
a# The ans.er scripts are to be ealuated by the three eBaminers i#e %
st
/ !
nd
/ 1 &
rd
# T.o nearest eBaminers marks aerage is to be taken in a.arding the =nal
marks# The &
rd
aluation is to be done .hereer there are ,8 or more marks ariation bet.een the t.o eBaminers#
b# Ho.eer/ there is no scheme of ealuation for the aforesaid process and the process of ealuation done in the three batches ary#
c# The (etitioner ?embers also obsered that the marks of the candidates hae been manipulated by oer2.riting/ .ithout any corresponding shara regarding .hy/
ho./ .ho and under .hat circumstances it .as oer2.ritten#
d# The marks hae also been altered in the computer data#
Pa4e $&
e# 6nother important aspect noted by the (etitioner ?embers is the second time aluation in Compulsory Language papers of those .ho hae failed in the same/
although the scheme does not proide for the same#
Ana7Ksis and )on)7usion o9 t*e BP1C Me6ber-
The details of the procedure adopted by the K(<C for ealuation of ans.er scripts hae been proided to the (etitioner members under a letter2dated %"#"%#!"%,#
6long .ith the said letter dated %"#"%#!"%, the scheme of aluation follo.ed in respect of the !"", batch main eBamination (aluation done in the year !""8) has
been proided/ .hich document is titled as Recruitment to the posts of 4a5etted (robationers ?ain DBamination S !""8C Central Kaluation of 6ns.er <cripts# The
copy of the note sheet .here a decision (dated %,#%%#!""8) has been taken .ith regard to the certain doubts during the aluation process of the !"", batch has
also been furnished# For eery subse;uent batch of recruitments the manner of ealuation may be changed in order to improe the earlier system# This can be done
only/ if any mandatory procedure is not proided in any Rules goerning the particular recruitment# 9f a procedure is prescribed in the concerned Rules/ the same is
re;uired to be follo.ed# 9n the absence of any speci=c procedure contemplated in the Rules/ the commission is free to adopt an appropriate procedure# The
remaining aspects pointed out by the (etitioner members hae been dealt .ith by me in the sub2headings belo.#
The detail =ndings of the (etitioner ?embers are as underC
i3 Manipu7ation o9 6ar8s in )o6puter tabu7ation-
TA!0E 5 C"
<L
)3
)6?D RD4 )3 <>7ODCT-(6(DR DP6?9)DR 9
DP6?9)D
R 99
DP6?9)DR
999
6CT>6L
6KDR64D
?6RK<
6KDR64D
?6RK<
6'6R:D:
:9FFDRD)C
D
TOTA0
MARB1
!ENEFITC
0O11
(3<T <DLDCTD:
%
K9O6N6 ?6H6)TD<H 7
:6)6??6)6K6R
%%"0,% Q33299 %$" %,* %+0#8 %*" %#8 "3@ 6C
! KN<H6L9 ?#L %%080* 4D329 !!+ %,0 %8+ %8! %8& % " 6C
&
46)46:H6R6<'6?N
4#? %%*$0* 4D329 %!" %!0 %!, %&$ %8 "@ 6C
, K>?6R6# ,%8%"8 4<29 *+ 0+ 0% 0! % " 6C
8 R6O6((6#) !!8!$& 4<299 0+ %"% $&#8 $+ !#8 &3@ :9<T#3FF9CDR27C<
+ (6R6<H>R6?6#K ,%8"*8 4<299 %!+ %%8 %!"#8 %!& !#8 &3& :N#<(
* 6ODDO :D<69 !%%0*" 4<299 00 $0 $& %"% 0 $ T6H6<9L:6R
0 7H6R6TH9H3LL9KDR9 !"*&*+ (6299 %"0 %+" %&, %8$ !8 &@ T6H6<9L:6R
$ ?D4H6)#R %%**&8 4D3299 %!$ %+* %,0 %,$ % " T6H6<9L:6R
%" KDD)6#7#) ,%+%*+ K6)29 %+, !%" %0% %*!#8 !"% !*#8 &F3@ T6H6<9L:6R
%%
<HR9H6R<H6#<#<HDTT
N !!%,0, R:299 %$" %!0 %%, %!% %!8 , ( T6H6<9L:6R
Pa4e $;
%! <6R6L69TTN#< ,"%$!! 4<29 %+" %", %&! %%, 2%0 /"$ 6<<T#:9RDCT3R#L?
%& 79):><RDD# ( %,,+0& K6)29 %$% %,+ %+0#8 %,& 2!8#8 /&@3@ :N#<(2DPC9<D#
%, R6?6?6)9#K#K %"",&$ Q3329 %&" %** %8&#8 %+* %&#8 ";3@ CH9DF 3FF9CDR
%8 T><H6R6 R6?6)9
?#K
%"",,&
Q33299 %,% %%! %!+#8 %&! 8#8
&(3@
CH9DF 3FF9CDR 4<29 %%, %+" %&* %8+ %$
%+ <HD<H>?>RTHN#K ,%8&"0 K6)29 %%0 !%* %88 %&+#8 %&, 2!#8 /&3@
6<<T#<>(T:#(R9<3)
<#
%* R6?D<H6#(#< ,"&"0% K6)29 %+" %*" %+8 %+0 & ;
6<<T#<>(T:#(R9<3)
<#
%0 <>RD<H#K %%&$,0 (6299 %%* %&% %!, %&+ %! "&
6<<T#<>(T:#(R9<3)
<#
%$ L6TH6#R %%$0,% H9<299 %%+ %!* %!%#8 %,* !8#8 &@3@
6<<T#<>(T:#(R9<3)
<#
!" ?6)46L6#4#< %%+"0" (6299 %%" %"* %"0#8 %!$ !"#8
('3@
<DCT93) 3FF9CDR
4<299 %&8 0$ %%! %&! !"
!% CH6):R6<HDK6R#( %""8,0 73T299 $! %,& %%*#8 %8! &,#8 ;(3@ <DCT93) 3FF9CDR
!! CH9R6)O9K9#K %,,,&8 4<299 %+* %%0 %,!#8 %8$ %+#8 "E3@ <DCT93) 3FF9CDR
!&
<HR9<H9LK6)K6)6'6
:9 &",!&8 R:29 %++ %!" %,& %+& !" &' :9R#3F#F33:1C<
!, <6)TH3<HH9((6R649 %"!+80 K6)299 %&8 (%!$) %*0 %8! %,&#8 %8* %&#8 ";3@ L673>R 3FF9CDR
ii3 Mar8s ta6pered bK o<er =ritin4 or =ron4 tota7in4-
TA!0E/ C&
10 NO NAME REG NO 1,!DECTCPAPER MARB1 A?ARDED !2
E>AMINER
?RONG
TOTA0ING
C O<er
=ritin4
A.ERAGE
DIFFERENC
E
TOTA0
MARB1
!ENEFITC
0O11
PO1T 1E0ECTED
E>M " E>M & E>M ;
%
K9O6N6?6H6)TD<H 7
:6)6??6)6K6R %%"0,% 4<29 %,+ %88 %%
%G&@
6C
4<29 %!& %&! $
4<299 %+* %*! 8
! R6?N6#< %"!%8* D)4299 !"! !%! %" "' 6C
& 46)46:H6R6 <'6?N 4#? %%*$0* 4<29 %"$ %%8 + E 6C
, O6N6K97H6K6 <'6?N &""&$" (629 %"& %"$ + E 6C
8 (R6:DD( 4#< %%,8"" (629 %,* %88 0 "&
:9<TR9CT 3FF9CDR F3R
7#CW<
4<29 %+, %+0 ,
+ 76<6K6R6O6 < %"",+8 4<29 %%+ %!" , ( :N#<(#
Pa4e $(
* <H9K6K>?6R T#( ,"!$0* 4<299 %"" %"% %
";
:N#<(#
4D329 %8! %+, %! :N#<(#
0 <6)ODDK ? (6T9L %"",$+ K6)29 !!0 %+0 2+" /E' :N#<(#
$ CH6):R6K6L6 %"&*,+ 4<299 %!% %&% %" "' :N#<(#
%" R64H>)6TH6 K#<# ,%,$80 4<299 $" $+ + E 6<<T#C3? 3F K<R(
%% KD)K6T6R6K6)6 RD::N %""!8+ 4<299 %%! %&$ !*
;;
:9<T 3FF9CDR <C1<T 'DLF
4<299 %!$ %&8 +
%! ?D4H6)6 R %%**&8 4D329 %+" %*" %" "' T6H6<9L:6R
%& <>7H6<H6 K#R %&8&&& K6)29 %!, %&" + E C T 3
%, <H6)TH6?6LLD<H# R ,"+"0& L6'29 %*$ %*8 2, /( CT3
%8 6)>R6:H6 K#) %%8!8& CR929 %$! %$+ ,
"'
CT3
4<299 08 $% +
%+ R6?N6#K %%,0!8 4<299 0! %"! !" &' 6<<T#:9RDC3R LR(6:LR)
%* CH6T6)6#R#C %&,$*" 4<29 %%+ %!+ %" "' CH9DF 3FF9CDR
%0 <H6KDDL6H6?D:#C#' %,,""& 6)TR329 %&! %&+ , ( CH9DF 3FF9CDR
%$ R6)46<'6?N#7#T %"&!&& 641?KT29 %*, %0" + E CH9DF 3FF9CDR
!" <H6L9)9#R %%,%$0 4<29 $0 %"% & ; CH9DF 3FF9CDR
!% <H6<H9:6RL6N6:64>):9 %%,$$& 4<299 %", %"8 % " 6<<T#TRD6<>RN3FF9CDR
!! R6?D<H#7#) %%+$!8 4D329 %8% %+% %" "' 6<<T#<>(TD:#(R9<3)<#
!& L6L9TH6769#L ,%,,," 4<299 %&, %,+ %! "& 6<<T#<>(TD:#(R9<3)<#
!, ?6)O>)6TH676LL6R9 !!,$%! (629 %8& %80 8 @ <DCT93) 3FF9CDR#
!8 K6<>):6R6#K#) %!%+8+ 4<29 %%8 %%$ ,
F
:9<T#?RKT#3FF9CDR(:?3)
K6)29 %+8 %+0 &
!+ <R9)9K6<6RD::N#K %,,*"" K6)299 %&+ %&0 !
$
:9<T#?RKT#3FF9CDR(:?3)
4<299 %%! %%, !
4<299 $, $0 ,
!* :DD(6#? %%,&!! 4<299 %8" %8, , ( :9<T#?RKT#3FF9CDR(:?3)
!0 DL9<H6 6):RD'< %%*++! 4<29 %%0 %!+ 0
""
6<<T#:9RDCT3R#F33:1C<#
4<29 %&$ %,% &
!$ <6)TH3<HH9((6R649 %"!+80 K6)299 %!$ %&8 +
""
L673>R 3FF9CDR
4<299 %!! %!* 8
iii3 1e)ond ti6e <a7uationCRe<a7uation o9 Co6pu7sorK 0an4ua4e Paper o9 )andidates =*o *a<e 9ai7ed in t*e sa6e% =it*out anK pro<ision in t*e
Ru7es-
TA!0E 5 C;
Pa4e $@
17 no Na6e Re4 No Cate4eorK 1ubLe)t ?arks a.arded in %
st
aluation
?arks a.arded in <econd
time aluation - realuation
Post 1e7e)ted
" Ho7eKappa3H /("E"E( &A CR0/ Co6p3En47is* ;@ @; CTO/
GMCR0
& 0a7it*a!ai3 0/("(((' 1C/R0/BM1 Co6p/En47is* ;# (@ Asst 1uptd3Prisons
1CC?
Ana7Ksis and )on)7usion o9 t*e BP1C Me6ber in respe)t o9 sub/*eadin4s (i+% (ii+ (iii+ abo<e-
The remarks in the said tabulated statement aboe furnished by the (etitioner ?embers to the eBtent they tally .ith the remarks in the tabulated statement at
6nneBure2999 are correct# Ho.eer in so far as the (etitioner ?embers concluding that there .as tampering and manipulation on the basis of the respectie tabulated
statements aboe is not correct in my opinion as the material gathered .ould not be su@cient to conclude that there .as tampering and manipulation# 9n respect of
sub2head (iii)/ it is to be noted that the Rules are silent as to any procedure to be follo.ed and the K(<C is entitled to follo. the procedure that the K(<C deems =t
and in respect of the compulsory Kannada and Dnglish papers being subGect to realuation/ it .as only on account of the fact that only one eBaminer had alued all
the compulsory papers and only those papers .here the candidates had secured less than ;ualifying marks the respectie papers .ere subGect to second aluation
or re2aluation as an additional safe guard and in my opinion there is nothing arbitrary or illegal in so far as the said procedure adopted by the K(<C#
II+ Ano6a7ies durin4 t*e sta4e o9 Persona7itK Test-
The basic Ea. of the K(<C in these selection processes is that it has failed to properly/ logically and consistently apply the reseration policy is a is the %C!" ratio (for
?ain DBamination) and %C8 ratio (for (ersonality Test)# 6s per the Rules there are t.o stages before actual selection i#e# after the preliminary eBamination .hen candidates
are chosen to .rite the main eBamination it has to be in the ratio of %C!" i#e# if there is one post resered for a particular category then !" candidates from that category
are eligible to .rite the main eBamination# The same holds good for personality test/ but the ratio is %C8# 3nly after the (ersonality Test/ .hen the marks in the ?ain
DBamination and the (ersonality Test are added/ a merit list (irrespectie of the category-caste) on the basis of the total marks is prepared# Then the =rst 8"H of posts are
=lled in the 4? category and only thereafter the reseration sets in# 6ny candidate .ho is from 4?/ .ho is not in the =rst 8"H of the merit list/ .ill not get any post een
though he may hae scored more than others .ho hae the bene=t of reseration#
Pa4e $E
a+ Ratio .io7ation- 3n the basis of the information proided to the (etitioner ?embers/ the (etitioner ?embers hae come to =nding .ith regard to the proportional
ratio at the stage of (ersonality TestC The complete list of candidates and their categories/ .ho .ere called for the personality test is gien in tables put in is
produced here.ith as Anne:ure- C/"
TA!0E 5 C(
173 No3 Cate4orK
Nu6ber o9 posts
a77otted to ea)*
)ate4orK
Nu6ber to be
)a77ed IN "-@ RATIO
Nu6ber a)tua77K
)a77ed
DiMeren)e in t*e
nu6ber
Ratio DiMeren)e
% 4? 1 4?-P?( *8 &*8 $& 2!0! %C%#!,
! <C !8 %!8 %+0 M,& %C+#*!
& <T "* &8 ,8 M%" %C+#,&
, C2% "0 ," 88 M%8 %C+#00
8 !6 !% %"8 %** M*! %C0#,!
+ !7 "8 !8 &+ M%% %C*#!"
* &6 "+ &" %"+ M*+ %C%*#++
0 &7 "+ &" *$ M,$ %C%&#%+
TOTA0 "@; FE@ F@# /E
3n perusal of the aboe table/ it is clear that the ratio policy of %C8 for (ersonality Test has been iolated and disproportionate numbers of candidates are made
eligible# 9t may also be seen that there is gross disproportion in 4?/ .hich resulted in disadantage to 4? candidates and contrarily there is gross disproportion .ith
regard to &6 1 &7 candidates/ .hich resulted in disproportionate adantage to the said categories/ at the cost of the 4?# 9n this regard many aspiring 4eneral ?erit
candidates right to selection .as denied and is unconstitutional/ iolating 6rticles %, and %+#
Pa4e $F
&6 category had + posts resered and as per the ration &" candidates of that Category had to be called# Ho.eer/ %"+ candidates .ere called# 3ut of the said %"+
candidates/ * candidates .ho had got marks lesser than the =rst &" candidates/ ultimately got selected# The follo.ing table gies details of the said seen
candidatesC
Tab7e 5 C@
<L# )3#
<L# )3# 9)
(T L9<T
RD4# )3# )6?D 3F THD C6):9:6TD 'R9TTD) ?6RK<
C6TD43RN CL69?D: 9)
6((L9C6T93)
(3<T <DLDCTD:-C6TD43RN
<H3') 9) F9)6L L9<T
9)TDRK9D'
?6RK<
% && %,,*"" <R9)9K6< RD::N K 0&$ &6 :9<T# ?6RKDT9)4 3FF9CDR
%,"
! &, ,"&%," <HD<H6 T ( 0&$ &6 6<<T <>(:T 3F (R9<3)
%8"
& &$ %%$0$$
(6R9K<H9T
7 )
0!$ &6 C3??L# T6P 3FF9CDR
%8"
, ," %"8!,% ?6:H>CH6):R6 TDO6<K9 0!% &6 <DCT93) 3FF9CDR
%8"
8 ,* %%&$,0 <>RD<H6 K 0"$ &6 6<<T <>(:T 3F (R9<3)
%8"
+ 8" ,%8"&8
(33R)9?6
7 R
0"0 &6 6<<T C3??9<<93)DR
%88
* 8* ,%880! K9<H6L6K<H6??6 *$, &6 C3??L# T6P 3FF9CDR
%8%
Pa4e $$
b+A77 Me6bers a=arded sa6eCeNua7 Mar8sC 6fter the perusal of the interie. documents reeals that maGority of the selected candidates .ere a.arded e;ual ?arks
or similar ?arks to suit group 6 1 7 posts# 9t is indicatie of the fact that marks had been pre2determined# The follo.ing are some of the instancesC
TA!0E 5 CE
<l#)o )ame Reg# )o (ost <elected
)ame of the ?ember
?arks a.arded
6erage of
?arks
%
Raindrakaralingannaar !!"808
Tahasildar
L9LL96) P6K9DR %!% %!%
:6<696H %!%
KD)K6T<'6?N %!%
(6T9L H < %!%
! <hridei 7# <ankesh.ar %%+,08 CT3 L9LL96) P6K9DR %," %,"
:6<696H %,"
KD)K6T<'6?N %,"
(6T9L H < %,"
&
<hrishailKanana.adi &",!&8
6sst#:irector Food 1
Ciil <upplies L9LL96) P6K9DR %&" %&"
:6<696H %&"
KD)K6T<'6?N %&"
(6T9L H < %&"
, Roopa R ,%8$,% (6T9L H < *8/ Tampered as %8"
%8"
L9LL96) P6K9DR %8"
:6<696H %8"
KD)K6T<'6?N %8"
8 <hriHarsha#<#<hetty !!%,0, Tashildar (6T9L H < %8" %8"
L9LL96) P6K9DR %8"
:6<696H %8"
KD)K6T<'6?N %8"
Pa4e $#
)+3 Candidates absent =ere a=arded 6ar8s and 6ar8s a=arded )andidates 6ade absent3
Tab7e 5 CF
%
Kiran #K#<#
%"8!0!
%#Lillian Paier a.arded $" marks and marked as
67<D)T#
!#H#<#(atil <ho.n 6bsent#
&# Kenkatas.amy <ho.n 6bsent#
:asaiah <ho.n 6bsent#
!
Thomas
&"&0$8
%# Lillian Paier sho.n absent#
!# H#<#(atil a.arded 0" marks
&# Kenkatas.amy a.arded 0" marks
,# :asaiah a.arded 0" marks
d+3In t*e 9o77o=in4 instan)es a77 t*e 6e6bers =*o =ere present at t*e inter<ie= did not a=ard t*e 6ar8s- 6erage of marks a.arded by the members
of the interie. panel is to be considered# 9f the members .ho are present at the interie. do not a.ard marks/ then there .ould be ariation in the aerage marks#
TA!0E 5 C$
103 NO3 NAME OF CANDIDATE REG3 NO3
Na6e o9 t*e Me6ber
Present in t*e )o66ittee and
not a=arded 6ar8s
Date o9 PT Test Ot*er 6e6bers A=arded 6ar8s
%
Dlish 6ndre.s
%%*++!
(6sst :irector of food and Ciil <upply)
H#)#Krishna !!2&2!""+
%# Lilian Paier a.arded 2,8 marks
!#H#< (atil a.arded 2," marks#
&#Kenkatas.amy a.arded ," marks#
,#:asaiah a.arded ," marks
!
(unitha ?#C
,"++$&
H#)#Krishna !$2&2!""+
%#H#< (atil a.arded 2+" marks#
!#Kenkatas.amy a.arded *" marks#
&#:asaiah a.arded +" marks
&
Rangashamaiah#K#)#
%&8,0&
H#)#Krishna &2,2!""+
%# Lilian Paier a.ardrd *"" marks
&#H#< (atil a.arded 2*" marks#
,#Kenkatas.amy a.arded *" marks#
8#:asaiah a.arded *" marks
,
<hridei 7 <ankesh.ar
%%+,08
(Commercial TaB 3@cer)
H#)#Krishna 82,2!""+
%# Lilian Paier a.ardrd %," marks
!#H#< (atil a.arded %," marks#
&#Kenkatas.amy a.arded %," marks#
,#:asaiah a.arded %," marks
8 <hriharsha < <hetti
!!%,0,
H#)#Krishna 82,2!""+ %# Lilian Paier a.ardrd %8" marks
!#H#< (atil a.arded %8" marks#
Pa4e #'
(Tahasildar)
&#Kenkatas.amy a.arded %8" marks#
,#:asaiah a.arded %8" marks
+
Lalitha 7ai#C
,%,,,"
(:y#supdt#(rison)
Lilian Paier 02,2!""+
%#H#< (atil a.arded 28" marks#
!#Kenkatas.amy a.arded 8! marks#
&#:asaiah a.arded 8" marks
)+ Candidates )onsidered under GM 9or not produ)in4 Caste In)o6e CertiJ)ates- Candidates .ho did not produce caste and income certi=cates at the
time of interie. .ere considered under 4?/ after taking a representation from them# They had been considered under their respectie categories all along i#e
during the preliminary eBam and main eBamination and during the short listing for (ersonality Test# They got the bene=t of being considered in their respectie
categories all along and later they are considered under 4? for (ersonality Test at the time of the interie.# This is a gross iolation of the rules specifying that
candidates .ho do not produce the releant certi=cates shall not be considered for selection #
d+Tab7e 5 C#
<L
)3
)6?D 1 RD4 )3 )3T9)4 3F THD ( D 9) THD
6TTD):D)CD
RD?6RK 3F THD C3??) 9)
THD (T <T6TD?D)T
RD?6RK 3F THD 7R6)CH 3R:DR 3F THD C3??) (3<T <DLDCTD:
% CH9:6)6):6 )<
%%%0"&
3R4)L &7 CDRT9FCT :T
!!#"$#", )3T
(R3:>CD:/?RK< $"& C>T
3FF 4? ?6LD 08!#
3RC )3T (R3:>CD:
/9)TDRK9D'D: >):DR 4?
!!#"$#", )3T
(R3:>CD:/?RK< $"& C>T
3FF 4? ?6LD 08!#'-9 64D
L9?9T#C3??) C3)<D)T
<3>4HT
3K T6H<9L:6R
! )6R6<9?6R6O> R
,"8*!*
3R4)L# &6/RL 1 K?<
CDRT9FCT< )3T
(R3:>CD:/DL9497LD >):DR
4? F3R 3R:DR<
3RC )3T (T3:>CD:
/>):DR 4?
3R4)L# &6/RL 1 K?<
CDRT9FCT< )3T (R3:>CD:/
'-9 64D L9?9T/DL9497LD
>):DR 4? C3??) C3)<D)T
<3>4HT
3K T6H<9L:6R
& )6TD<H :7
%""8&%
3R4)L &7 1 R>R6L CDRT9FCT
:T "*#%!#", F3R
KDR9F)#DL9497LD >):DR
4?(K?<) F3R 3R:DR<#
3RC1 R>R6L CDRT9FCT</
)3T (R3:>CD:
/9)TDRK9D'D: >):DR 4?
3R4)L# &7/RL 1 K?<
'-9 64D L9?9T/DL9497LD
>):DR 4? C3??) C3)<D)T
<3>4HT
3K T6H<9L:6R
, (R67HK6R H4
,%8+08
3R4)L# &6/RL 1 K?<
'R9TTD) DP?)#?RK<
$!+/DL9497LD >):DR 4? F3R
3R:DR<
3R4)L# &6/RL 1 K?<
CDRT9FCT< )3T
(R3:>CD:/>):DR 4?#
3R4)L# &6/RL 1 K?<
'-9 64D L9?9T/DL9497LD
>):DR 4? C3??) C3)<D)T
<3>4HT
3K :3 7C?
8
(>TTD 43':6
,%,0$$
&"#"&#"8 )3T (R3:>CD:/
'R9TTD) ?RK< 08% C>T 3FF
4? K6))6:6 *$+#DL9497LD
VVVVV# 3R4)L# &6/CDRT9FCT< )3T
(R3:>CD:/ '-9 64D
L9?9T/DL9497LD >):DR 4?
C3??) C3)<D)T <3>4HT
3K <DCT93) 3FFR#
Pa4e #"
>):DR 4? K6))6:6/ F3R
3R:DR<
+ (R67H> L9)46 K6K6L9
K6TT9
%%0,,+
3R4)L R>R6L CDRT9F9C6TD
)3T (R3:>CD: RD(T)#49KD)
7N C6):T 9< F3R (DR><6L 1
3R:DR< DL9497LD >):DR
<C(3THDR<)
C3)<9:DRD: >):DR <C (3) 3R4)L R>R6L CDRT9F9C6TD
)3T (R3:>CD: T3 7D
C3)<9:DRD: >):DR <C (3)
C3??) C3)<D)T <3>4HT
3K 6C
* R33(6 9(
%%&+!"
%,#%!#", )3T (R3:>CD: F3R
KDR9F)#DL9497LD >):DR 4?
F3R 3R:DR</
3RC )3T (R3:>CD:
/>):DR 4?
%,#%!#", )3T (R3:>CD:/ '-9
64D L9?9T/ DL9497LD >):DR
4? C3??) C3)<D)T
<3>4HT#
3K T6H<9L:6R
0 79):><HRDD (
%,,+0&/ C6):T RDU
T3 7D C3)<9:DR:
>):DR 4? <9)CD &6
CDRT9FCT L3<T
/ C6):T )3T (R3: &6 CC '-9
64D L9?9T DL9497LD >):DR
4?#
CH?6)
3R:DR</C6):T<
RD()T) 7D C3)<9:DR:/
6): TRD6TD: 6< 4?
:N <D
$ (6K9THR6
%%8+$, C6):T RDU
T3 7D C3)<9:DR:
>):DR 4? <9)CD &6
CDRT9FCT L3<T
C6):T )3T (R3: &6 CC '-9
64D L9?9T DL9497LD >):DR
4?#
CH?6)
3R:DR</C6):T<
RD()T) 7D C3)<9:DR:/
6): TRD6TD: 6< 4?
6CCT
%" 4 (R67H>
%%*$,+/ C6):T RDU
T3 7D C3)<9:DR:
>):DR 4? <9)CD &6
CDRT9FCT L3<T
C6):T )3T (R3: &6 CC '-9
64D L9?9T DL9497LD >):DR
4?# C3??) C3)<D)T
<3>4HT
CH?6)
3R:DR</C6):T<
RD()T) 7D C3)<9:DR:/
6): TRD6TD: 6< 4?
6CCT
%% <6K9TH6 ?K
,",$8*/ C6):T RDU
T3 7D C3)<9:DR:
>):DR 4? <9)CD &6
CDRT9FCT L3<T
:>R9)4 (T &6 CDRFCT 9< )3T
(R3: /T3 7D TRD6TD: 6<
4?/DKD) R>R6L CDT9F9CT 9<
)3T (R3:>CD:#C6):T
DL94979L9TN 7D RDODCTD:#
CH?6)
3R:DR</C6):T<
RD()T) 7D C3)<9:DR:/
6): TRD6TD: 6< 4?
T6H<9L:6R
%! <9::6((6 H>LL3L9
!!+",,
%,#%!#", /K?< CDRTFCT#)3T
(R3:>CD:/ HD)CD R>RL
RD<RK) 6L<3 <T6):<
C6)CDLLD: ?RK< $,* C>T
3FF 4? 08!#DL947L F3R
9)TDRK9D'#
3R4)L# CDRT9FCT 3F
&7#R>R6L 1 K?< )3T
(R3:>CD: 6T THD T9?D 3F
9)T/HD)CD C3)<9:DRD:
>):DR 4?(3)/673KD C6T
C6)CDLLD:
<9)CD 3R4)L# CDRT9FCT 3F
&7#R>R6L 1 K?< )3T
(R3:>CD: 6T THD T9?D 3F
9)TR'# /'-9 64D
L9?9T/DL9497LD C6) 7D
TRD6TD: >):DR 4? C6T
3K T6H<9L:6R
%& <>76<H KR
%&8&&&
%8#%!#", )3T
(R3:>CD:/?RK< 00$
DL9497LD >):DR 4? F3R
3R:DR<
3R4)L &6 CDRT9FCT )3T
(R3:>CD: 6T T9?D 3F
9)RR'/HD)CD DL9497LD
6): 9)TDRK9D'D: >):DR
4?
%8#%!#", )3T (R3:>CD:/'-9
64D L9?9T/DL9497LD >):DR
4? C3??) C3)<D)T
<3>4HT#
3K CT3
%, <>RD<H 7 9T)6L 3R4)L &7 CDRT9FCT :T 3R4)L CDRT9FCT 3F &7 1 3R4)L &7 CDRT9FCT :T 3K 6CCT
Pa4e #&
!"!,$& "8#",#"8 )3T (R3:>CD:/9F
&7 C6)CDLLD: HD '9LL
L33<D R>R6L 6L<3 /?RK<
<DC>RD: $$8/4? C>T3FF
08!#DL9497LDL >):DR 4?#
R>R6L )3T (R3:>CD: 6T
THD T9?D 3F 9)TR'#7>T
DL9497LD >):DR 4?
/HD)CD 9)TR':#
"8#",#"8 1 R>R6L )3T
(R3:>CD: '-9 64D
L9?9T/DL9497LD >):DR 4?
C3??) C3)<D)T <3>4HT#
%8 KDD)6 7)
,%+%8+
3R4)L &6 CC )3T
(R3:>CD:/4? CRD6?N
L6NDR C )3T (R3: DL9497L
>):DR 4? FD?6LD F3R
3R:DR<
VVVVV 3R4)L &6 CC )3T
(R3:>CD:/4? CRD6?N
L6NDR C )3T (R3: F3R
R>R6L DL9497LTN
C3)<9:R)/THRF3RD >):DR
4? C3??) C3)<D)T
<3>4HT#
3K T6H<9L:6R
%+ <H6<H9 K>?6R
!""$&"
"+#"&##", )3T (R3:>CD:
F3R KDR9F)#DL9497LD >):DR
4?
3RC )3T (R3:>CD: F3R
>):DR 4?
"+#"&##", )3T (R3:>CD: '-9
64D L9?9T/DL9497LD >):DR
4? C3??) C3)<D)T
<3>4HT
3K T6H<9L:6R
Tab7e 5 C"'
DETAI01 OF CANDIDATE1 RE1ER.ATION CATEGOR2 MANIP,0ATED A1 GM CANDIDATE1 IN THE PREPARATION OF E0IGI!I0IT2 0I1T OF PER1ONA0IT2
TE1T IN THE RATIO OF "-@
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION (!ot*
Pre7i6s Mains+
CATEGOR2 P,RPO1F,002
MAN,PI0ATED
PO1T 1E00ECTED
% !"!,$& <>RD<H 7 9T)6L &7-RL 4? 6CCT
! %""8&% )6TD<H6 : 7 &7-RL-K?< 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
& !!+",, <9::6((6 H>LL3L9 &7-RL-K?< 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
, %%%0"& CH9:6):6 ) < &7-K?< 4?-K?< T6H6<9L:H6R
8 ,%+%*+ KDD)6 7 ) &6-R>R6L 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
+ !""$&" <H6<H9K>?6R ) &6 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
* %%*$,+ (R67H> 4 &6 4? 6CCT
0 %,,+0& 79):H><HRDD ( &6 4? :N<D
$ %%&+!" R33(6 9 ( &6 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%" ,",$8* <6K9TH6 ? K &6-RL-K?< 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%% ,"8*!* )6R6<9?H6R6O> R &6-RL-K?< 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
Pa4e #;
%! %&8&&& <H>7H6< K R &6 4? CT3
%& %,,*"" <RDD)9K6<6 RD::N K &6-K?< &6-K?< :?3
%, %%8+$, (6K9THR6 7 &6 4? 6CCT
%8 ,%8+08 (R67H6KH6R H 4 &6-RL-K?< 4? :3 7C?
%+ ,%,0$$ (>TTD43':6 H R &6-K?< 4? <3
e+ A=ardin4 o9 unusua77K *i4* 6ar8s bK t*e t*en C*air6an o9 BP1C- The (etitioner ?embers hae obsered that the then Chairman of K(<C/ :r# H# )#
Krishna has a.arded unusually high marks to certain candidates (in comparison .ith other members)# The follo.ing table is placed in this regard#Tab7e 5 C""
103 NO3
NAME OF CANDIDATE REG3
NO3
MARB1 A?ARDED !2 DR
H3N3
BRI1HNA
Mar8s A=arded bK t*e ot*er 6e6bers !OOB CDate o9 PT Test
%
N34D<6 6?
,%"*!8
%*"
%8" ?%
%8" ?!
%8" ?&
%8" ?,
%"-",-"+
!
<6K9TH6 ?K
,",$8*
%*"
%,8 ?%
%,8 ?!
%,8 ?&
%,8 ?,
",-",-"+
&
R6<H?9 O K
,%8$%8
%+8
%," ?%
%," ?!
%," ?&
%," ?,
"&-",-"+
,
R6O> C
,%8$%8
%80
%8" ?%
%8" ?!
%8" ?&
&%-"&-"+
8
6<H'9)9 ?
%,&+,$
%8,
%8"?%
%8" ?!
%8" ?& !"-"&-"+
9+ Ta6perin4 o9 inter<ie= 6ar8s bK t*e t*en )*air6an 6e6bers o9 BP1C- The (etitioner ?embers/ on the perusal of the records of the interie./ hae
found that marks of some of the candidates .ere altered# The statements gien by the then members/ under <ection %+, of Cr#(#C/ during the en;uiry of C9:/ also
gies reasons for such alterations# The tabular columns belo. illustrate the same#
Tab7e 5 C"&
Pa4e #(
<L#
)3
)6?D 3F THD
K(<C ?D?7DR
'H3 ?6:D
<T6TD?D)T
>):DR <DCT93)
%+,3F CR(C
<L#3
)?D 3F THD
C6):9:6TD 6): RD4
)3# 'H3 9LL946LLN
7D)DF9TD: 7N THD 6CT
3F K(<C ?D?7DR#
RD<DRK6T93)
C6RD43RN#
(3<T <DLLDCTD:#
37<DRK6T93)
?6:D#
RD6<3)-R9(LN 49KD)
7N THD K(<C
?D?7DR#
K9:D (64D
)>?7DR 3F H9<
<T6TD?D)T#
:R H#)# KR9<H)6# %
6?6RD<H K>?76R6#
RD4)3#&"$$!+#
(733K)"#%)
2222 222222
?6RK< 6LTDRDRD:
FR3? %"" T3 %8"
222222 22222
!
6)9TH6#
RD4)3#%",+8!
222222222 22222222
?6RK< 6LTDRDRD:
FR3? 8" T3 +"
222222 22222
9 :R# H#<# (6T9L &
<H6L9)9#R#
RD4)3 %%,%$0
996-F CH9DF 3FF9CDR
?6RK< 6LTDRDRD:
FR3? *" T3 %,"
TH9< 9< :>D T3
9)<TR>CT93)< FR3?
THD CH69R?D) H#H#
KR9<H)6#
(2+
,
R33(6#R#
RD4)3#,%8$,%
<C-F 2222
?6RK< 6LTDRDRD:
FR3? *8 T3 %8"
TH9< 9< :>D T3
9)<TR>CT93)< FR3?
THD CH69R?D) H#H#
KR9<H)6
(2*
8
)6RD):R6#<#7#
RD4)3#%%$"%8
996 2222
?6RK< 6LTDRDRD:
FR3? %"" T3 %8"
TH9< 9< :>D T3
9)<TR>CT93)< FR3?
THD CH69R?D) H#H#
KR9<H)
(2*
+
)6RD):R6#<#7#
RD4)3#%%$"%8
(733K )3#%+)
22222
?6RK< 6LTDRDRD:
FR3? %"" T3 %8"
222222 222222
99
<?T#L9L96)
P6K9DR
*
(R67H> R6O#
RD4)3#!%""*%
<T 2222
?6RK< 6LTDRDRD:
FR3? %," T3 %,8
TH9< 9< :>D T3
9)<TR>CT93)< FR3?
THD CH69R?D) H#H#
KR9<H)
(2*
0
?6H6:DK6)69K
RD4)3#,%8!+,
(733K#%&)
2222222
?6RK< 6LTDRDRD:
FR3? %," T3 %,8
222222 22222
$
R33(6#K#)#
RD4)3#%%8,8!
<T 22222 ?6RK< 6LTDRDRD:# 7N ?9<T6KD 22222
%"
?6H6K6)69K#
RD4)3#,%8!+,
C29 22222
?6RK< 6LTDRDRD:
FR3? %," T3 %,8
6< (DR THD
:9RDCT93) FR3?
THD :R# H/)#
KR9<H)6#
999
<R9 KD)K6T6
<'6??N
%%
R6OD<H#?#R#
,",$8*
996 T6H6<9L:6R
?6RK< 6LTDRDRD:
FR3? %," T3 %,8
9 :3)T RD?D?7DR# (2+
Pa4e #@
On t*e basis o9 t*e ana7Ksis o9 t*e data% t*e Petitioner Me6bers *a<e obser<ed t*at a )andidates o9 t=o parti)u7ar )ate4ories =ere abnor6a77K
9a<ored% abo<e a77 ot*ers% in t*e se7e)tion pro)ess3 T*e 9o77o=in4 se79/i77ustrati<e tab7e is p7a)ed =it* re4ard to t*e sa6eC
TA!0E 5 C ";
COMPARATI.E 1TATEMENT 1HO?ING THE CANDIDATE1 1E0ECTED FOR &''( GAUETTED PRO!PR1 GRO,P A ! PO1T1 ,NDER .ARIO,1 METHOD1 OF
1E0ECTION ?HO HAD C0AIMED RE1ER.ATION (@'A RE1ER.ATION+
10 NO3 CATEGOR2
NO3 OF PO1T1
RE1ER.ED A1
PER
AD.ERTI1EMENT
NO OF
PER1ON1
ACT,A002
CA00ED
FOR PT IN
.IO0ATION
OF "-@
RATIO
NO3 OF
CANDIDATE1
1E0ECTED A1
CATEGOR2
CANDIDATE1
NO3OF
CANDIDATE1
P,1HED TO
GM
CATEGOR2
NO3 OF
CANDIDATEP1
RE1ER.ATION
CATEGOR2
CHANGED A1
GM D,E TO
NOT
PROD,CING
ORIGINA0
RE1ER.ATION
CERTIFICATE1
(ORCP1+
D,RING
INTER.IE?
NO3OF
CATEGOR2
CANDIDATE1
1E0ECTED A1
GM
CANDIDATE1 !2
MANIP,0ATING
THE
CANIDAT,RE
D,RING
PREPARATION
OF "-@
E0IGI!I0IT2
0I1T OF
INTER.IE?
TOTA0 NO3 OF
CANDIDATE1
1E0ECTED
PERCENTAGE
OF
INCREA1E(A
a4e+
" 1C &; "E$ &; NI0 NI0 NI0 &; "''
& 1T F (@ F NI0 NI0 NI0 F "''
; CAT /I $ @@ $ NI0 NI0 " # ""'
( &A &" "FF &" & NI0 NI0 &; ""'
@ &! @ ;E @ & NI0 NI0 F "('
E ;A E "'E E "( "& ;& @;;
F ;! E F# E $ ( "$ ;''
TOTA0 FE EEE FE ""#
TA!0E 5C "(
NO3OF &A CANDIDATE1 P,1HED TO GM CATEGOR2
103 NO REG NO3
NAME OF THE
CANDIDATE1
?RITTEN MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% %&8&*8 R6OD<H ) )69K $,! !6 6T3
+0
! ,%80", K>?6R6 ? < 08* !6 6:L?
%,"
Pa4e #E
NO3OF &! CANDIDATE1 P,1HED TO GM CATEGOR2
103
NO
REG NO3
NAME OF THE
CANDIDATE1
?RITTEN
MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED
IN APP0ICATION
PO1T 1E00ECTEDC
CATEGEOR2
1HO?N IN FINA0
0I1T
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% !%%0*" 6ODDO :D<69 $8$ !7 T6H6<9L:H6R-4?-!7
0!
! ,"!$,*
6<H66: >R R6H?6)
<H6R9FF
0+& !7
CH9DF 3FF9CDR2
4?-!7
%%"
TA!0E 5 C"@
NO3OF ;A CANDIDATE1 P,1HED TO GM CATEGOR2
?RITTEN
MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% %%080* KN<H6L9 ? L $** &6 6C
%,"
! %%*$*$ 76L6CH6):R6 < ) $88 &6 6C
%8"
& %"&8&$ )646R6O6 H L $&! &6 T6H6<9L:H6R
%""
, ,%"*!8 N34DD<H 6 ? $!, &6 6C
%8,
8 %%8&$8 (R6K6<H6 43':6 6 ) $%* &6 :N<(
%8"
+ %""!8+ KD)K6T6R6K6)6 RD::N D K 00* &6 :3 <C-<T
%8"
* %",,%, <H9K6)6):6?>RTHN 7 C 0*$ &6 T6H6<9L:H6R
%,8
0 %%&$%& ?6LL9K6RO>)6 7 0*8 &6 T6H6<9L:H6R
%,8
$ %"&!&& R6)46<'6?N 7 T 0,+ &6 C3
%8"
%" ,"&%," <HD<H6 T ( 0&$ &6 6<T#<>(#(R9
%8"
%% %%$0$$ (6R9K<H9TH 7 ) 0!$ &6 CT3
%8"
%! %"8!,% ?6:H> CH6):R6 TDO6<'9 O : 0!% &6 <3
%8"
%& %%&$,0 <>RD<H6 K 0"$ &6 6<T#<>(#(R9
%8"
TA!0E 5 C"E
Pa4e #F
)3# 3F &6 C6):9:6TD< RD<DRK6T93) C6TD43RN CH6)4D: 6< 4? :>D T3 )3T (R3:>C9)4 3R949)6L RD<DRK6T93) CDRT9F9C6TD< (3RCs) :>R9)4 9)TDRK9D'
103
NO
REG NO3
NAME OF THE
CANDIDATE1
?RITTEN
MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED
IN APP0ICATION
(!ot* Pre7i6s
Mains+
CATEGOR2
P,RPO1F,002
MAN,PI0ATED
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% ,%+%*+ KDD)6 7 ) &6-R>R6L 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%,+
! !""$&" <H6<H9K>?6R ) &6 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%"*
& %%*$,+ (R67H> 4 &6 4? 6CCT
%8"
, %,,+0& 79):H><HRDD ( &6 4? :N<D
%&+
8 %%&+!" R33(6 9 ( &6 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%,8
+ ,",$8* <6K9TH6 ? K &6-RL-K?< 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%8"
* ,"8*!* )6R6<9?H6R6O> R &6-RL-K?< 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%,"
0 %&8&&& <H>7H6< K R &6 4? CT3
%,$
$ %,,*"" <RDD)9K6<6 RD::N K &6-K?< &6-K?< :?3
%,"
%" %%8+$, (6K9THR6 7 &6 4? 6CCT
%8"
%% ,%8+08 (R67H6KH6R H 4 &6-RL-K?< 4? :3 7C?
%,8
%! ,%,0$$ (>TTD43':6 H R &6-K?< 4? <3
%8"
TA!0E 5 C"F
NO3OF ;! CANDIDATE1 P,1HED TO GM CATEGOR2
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED IN
APP0ICATION
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% %"",8" (R6KDD) K>?6R 4 L %""! &7 6C
%8"
Pa4e #$
! %%"0,% K9O6N6?6H6)TD<H 7 :6)6??6)6K6R %""% &7 6C
%,0
& ,"+"0& <H6)TH6 ?6LLD<H6 R $+% &7 CT3
8"
, %"",+8 76<6K6R6O> < $", &7 :N<(
%,,
8 !!"808 R6K9):R6 K6R6L9)46))6K6R $"& &7 T6H6<9L:H6R
%!%
+ %%*$0* 46)46:H6R6 <'6?N 4 ? 0$$ &7 6C
%8"
* &",!&8 <HR9<H69L K6)K6)6'6:9 088 &7 6:FC<
%&"
0 !""%"! <3?6)6TH $"0 &7 6<<T C3)TR3LR
%,"
Tab7e 5 C"$
)3# 3F &7 C6):9:6TD< RD<DRK6T93) C6TD43RN CH6)4D: 6< 4? :>D T3 )3T (R3:>C9)4 3R949)6L RD<DRK6T93) CDRT9F9C6TD< (3RCs)
:>R9)4 9)TDRK9D'
103
NO
REG NO3
NAME OF THE
CANDIDATE1
?RITTEN
MARB1
CATEGOR2 C0AIMED
Pre7i6s Mains+
CATEGOR2
P,RPO1F,002
MAN,PI0ATED
PO1T 1E00ECTED
INTER.IE?
MARB1
% !"!,$& <>RD<H 7 9T)6L $$8 &7-RL 4? 6CCT %&8
! %""8&% )6TD<H6 : 7 $%% &7-RL-K?< 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%,"
& !!+",, <9::6((6 H>LL3L9 &7-RL-K?< 4? T6H6<9L:H6R
%,8
, %%%0"& CH9:6):6 ) < &7-K?< 4?-K?< T6H6<9L:H6R
%,8
Ana7Ksis and )on)7usion o9 t*e BP1C 6e6ber in respe)t o9 a77 sub/*eads under t*e 6ain *eadin4 o9 Ano6a7ies durin4 t*e sta4e o9 Persona7itK Test-
6ll the instances of the irregularities pointed out by the (etitioner members under arious sub2headings under the main head of 6nomalies during the stage of
(ersonality Test is a repetition of the =ndings recorded by the (etitioner members under similar head in respect of %$$0 batch and only the eBamples of the candidates
diFer and hence my analysis and conclusion that 9 hae furnished in respect of the %$$0 batch under similar heads .ould also ans.er the aforesaid analysis and
conclusion of the (etitioner members#
Pa4e ##
III Findin4s re4ardin4 )aste and in)o6e )ertiJ)ates and ot*er do)u6ents-
For claiming the bene=t of reseration/ proof of caste - tribe and for some categories of reseration caste and income proof are necessary# Caste and income certi=cates/
in the prescribed forms and .ithin the prescribed time limits had been made mandatory during the selection process for candidates claiming the reseration bene=t#
:uring the course of ascertaining facts/ it has come to the kno.ledge of the (etitioner ?embers that there hae been manipulations and large discrepancies/ resulting in
itiation of the process# The follo.ing paragraphs and tables bring out the factual aspect of these#
i# In)o6p7ete )ertiJ)atesC 3nly eri=cation portion of the Caste and income certi=cates of the follo.ing candidate is produced# The said certi=cate is incomplete#
Tab7e 5 C"#
Cate4orK C7ai6ed bK
t*e Candidates
(ost <elected
% !!%,0, <HR9 H6R<H6 < <HDTT9 &7 &7 Tahashildar
ii# Caste and In)o6e CertiJ)ates sub6itted a9ter t*e due dateC
Tab7e 5 C&'
Candidates
the last :ate FiBed in
the noti=cation to
submit the 6pplication
The date <ho.ing the
Category Certi=cate
submitted by the
Candidate
(ost <elected
% !"0+&, O646:DD<H KK !6 %*2%!2!"", %%2",2!""8 :N<(
! %&*&"8 <H9K6(>THR6 <C-RL %*2%!2!"", "!2"&2!""8 6ssistant Controller
& !"!,$& <>RD<H 7 9T)6L &7-RL %*2%!2!"", "&2"&2!""8 6CCT
Pa4e "''
, %!"88$ K>?6R6<'6?N 7T !6-RL-K?< %*2%!2!"", %!2",2!""8 TH6<H9L:6R
8 %,,*++ <>:H6 7 !6-P?( %*2%!2!"", %82",2!""8 TH6<H9L:6R
+ ,%880! K9<H6L6K<H6??6 &6-RL-K?< %*2%!2!"", &%2"&2!""8 CT3
* %%$!+8 <6)46((6 K3L9 %-RL-K?< %*2%!2!"", %!2"!2!""8 CT3
0 ,%,0$$ (>TTD43':6 HR &6-K?< %*2%!2!"", &"2"&2!""8 <3
$ %""8,0 CH6):R6<HDKH6R % %*2%!2!"", %$2"&2!""8 <3
%" %%0+!" 4DDTH6 L <C %*2%!2!"", %%2",2!""8 <3
11 114322 DEEPA M SC 1"-12-2004 11-04-2005 DMO
12 304235 SHREESHILA KANAKA$ADI 3&/RL/KMS 1"-12-2004 2#-03-2005 ADFC
13 115555 GEETHA . C.D SC 1"-12-2004 12-04-2005 THASHILDAR
14 115253 AN!RADHA K.N SC 1"-12-2004 12-04-2005 CTO
15 40234 RAJESH M.R 2A 1"-12-2004 26-3-2005 THASHILDAR
iii# Caste and in)o6e CertiJ)ate Not in For6 F Pres)ribed as per instru)tions issued bK t*e BP1C#
(6s per the 43 )o <':%&!<6: $* :6TD: 02!2!""")
Table S C!%
Candidates
(ost <elected
Form type and :ate
% ,%,0$$ (>TTD43':6 HR &6-K?< 4? <3
Form2&
&"2"&2"8
iB# Caste CertiJ)ate Not in For6 D (FOR 1CC1T CANDIDATE1+ Pres)ribed as per instru)tions issued bK t*e BP1C#
(6s per the 43 )o <':%&!<6: $* :6TD: 02!2!""")
Pa4e "'"
TA!0E 5 C&&
Candidates
(ost <elected
Form type and
:ate
% %%&008 K9O6NK>?6R C <C-P?( <C-P?(
6<<T#C3??9<<93)D
R
6((D):9P S9
:6TD:C %+-*-%$$$
! %"&*,+ CH6):R6K6L6 <C <C-F :N#<(
6((D):9P S9
:6TD:C !+-+-!"""
B# Rura7 )ertiJ)ates =*i)* =ere obtained and sub6itted a9ter t*e due dateC
Tab7e 5 C&;
Category Claimed by
the Candidates
the last :ate FiBed in
the noti=cation to
submit the 6pplication
The date <ho.ing the
Rural Certi=cate
submitted by the
Candidate
(ost <elected
% %%*$*$ 76L6CH6):R6 <? &6-RL
%*2%!2!"",
%82"%2"8
6ssistant
Commissioner
! %8,8,0 )64D):R6 (R6<6: <C-RL-K?<
%*2%!2!"",
%!2",2"8
6ssistant
Commissioner
& %""!8+ KD)K6T6R6K6)6 RD::N &6-RL %*2%!2!"", "+2",2"8 :3 <C-<T
, %%&$%& ?6LL9K6RO>)6 7 &6-RL-K?< %*2%!2!"", &"2"&2"8 Tahashildar
8 %!"88$ K>?6R6<'6?N 7T !6-RL-K?< %*2%!2!"", !+2"&2"8 Tahashildar
+ !"+,8% 6>:R6?6 !7-RL %*2%!2!"", "02",2"8 Tahashildar
* %""8&! )6KDD)K>?6R R6O> < % %*2%!2!"", &"2"!2"8 Tahashildar
Pa4e "'&
"!2"%2"+
0 %%*%&* 4DDTH6 )R <T-RL
%*2%!2!"", "*2",2"8
"02",2"8
Tahashildar
$ ,"+"0& <H6)TH6?6LLD<H R &7-RL
%*2%!2!"", "02",2"8
%&2",2"8
CT3
%" ,%880! K9<H6L6K<H6??6 &6-RL-K?< %*2%!2!"", !$2"&2"8 CT3
%% %%$!+8 <6)46((6 K3L9 %-RL-K?<
%*2%!2!"", !,2"%2"8
"*2",2"8
CT3
Bi# Bannada Mediu6 1tudied )ertiJ)ates =*i)* =ere obtained and sub6itted a9ter t*e due date or =*i)* =ere not sub6itted at a77-
Tab7e / C&(
<l#
)o#
Reg#
)o#
)ame
Category Claimed by
the Candidates
the last :ate FiBed in the noti=cation
to submit the 6pplication
The date <ho.ing the Kannada ?edium
Certi=cate submitted by the Candidate (K?<)
(ost <elected
% %%0,,+
(R67H>L9)46
K6K6L9K6TT9
<C-RL-K?<
%*2%!2!"",
)ot <ubmited the Certi=cate
6ssistant
Commissioner
! ,",0," 7H6R6TH9 : 4?-K?<
%*2%!2!"",
)ot <ubmited the Certi=cate
6ssistant
Commissioner
& &"!8,$ O9)D):R6 KH6)646K9 4?-K?< %*2%!2!"", %82",2"8 :N<(
, %!"88$ K>?6R6<'6?N 7T !6-RL-K?< %*2%!2!"", !+2"&2"8 Tahashildar
8 ,",8!% :DD(6 ) 4?-K?< %*2%!2!"", %%2",2"8 CT3
+ %%$!+8 <6)46((6 K3L9 %-RL-K?< %*2%!2!"",
!,2"%2"8
"*2",2"8
CT3
* %&$+*+ )646R6O> )? <C-RL-K?< %*2%!2!"", %%2",2"8 6RC<
Pa4e "';
0 %!"&"! RDKH6 R 4?-K?<
%*2%!2!"", "+2",2"8
"*2",2"8
"02",2"8
6T3
$ ,%,0$$ (>TTD43':6 HR &6-K?< %*2%!2!"", "02",2"8 <3
%" %!%+8+ K6<>):H6R6 K? 4?-K?< %*2%!2!"", "*2",2"8 :?3
%% %,,*"" <HR9)9K6<6RD::N K &6-K?< %*2%!2!"", %82%!2"8 :?3
Ana7Ksis and )on)7usion o9 t*e BP1C Me6ber in respe)t o9 a77 )on)7usions arri<ed at bK t*e Petitioner Me6bers under t*e *ead/Findin4s re4ardin4
)aste and in)o6e )ertiJ)ates and ot*er do)u6ents-
6s per the order dated !"#"$#!"%& passed in '#(# )o# !*+*,-!"%! the scope of the fact =nding eBercise is limited to three broad areas in respect of the 4a5etted
(robationers recruitment of the years %$$0/ %$$$ and !"",/ namelyC
a) Daluation of marks and moderation of marks obtained by the candidates at the time of main .ritten eBamination#
b) 6.arding of ?arks during the personal interie. of candidatesA and
c) 9mplementation of the order dated %%#%"#!""! and ",#"*#!""& passed in '#(#)o#%!8,0-!""! and connected matters#
I.3 Fina7 1e7e)tion 1ta4eC
Ana7Ksis and )on)7usions o9 t*e Petitioner Me6bers-
De)7aration o9 Jna7 se7e)t 7ist =it*out obtainin4 .a7iditK CertiJ)ates- Kalidity Certi=cates not obtained before declaration of =nal select listC 6s per 4#3 no <':
%&* 7C6 $& dated ,-%%-%$$& it is mandatory to obtain alidity certi=cates (alidating the caste of candidates .ho are in the proisional select list) before the declaration
of =nal select list# Ho.eer/ during the %$$0 selection not een a single alidity certi=cate .as obtained by the K(<C before declaration of =nal select list on !0#"&#!""+# 9t
indicates that the personnel at the helm at that time .ere in a haste to =nali5e the selection .ithout proper procedure#
Ana7Ksis and )on)7usions o9 t*e BP1C Me6ber-
Rule $ of the Karnataka <C/ <T and 37C (reseration of 6ppointments etc#/) Rules/ %$$! (for short Reseration Rules) proides that )o person .ho claims the bene=t of
reseration shall be appointed to a serice or a post under the 4oernment or to an establishment in the public sector .ithout the production of the alidity certi=cate#
The procedure being follo.ed in all the recruitments is that no candidates selected under <C/ <T and 37C is gien appointment till a alidity certi=cate is issued under the
Pa4e "'(
proisions of the Reseration Rules# 6 perusal of Rule + of the said Rules indicates that it is the candidate .ho can apply for a alidity certi=cate and it is not the duty of
the K(<C to obtain alidity certi=cates before =nali5ing the selections# 6 candidates claim for reseration at the time of selection is considered only on the basis of the
caste and income certi=cates# 9n my opinion the aforesaid conclusions of the (etitioner members is incorrect#
C*apter ( / Mis)e77aneous Findin4s
Mis)e77aneous Jndin4s re)orded bK t*e Petitioner Me6bers-
%# The K(<C has not maintained the attendance rolls and nominal rolls/ .ith regard to the attendance of candidates for the eBaminations# Kital documents hae
been destroyed/ despite pendency of hundreds of cases#
!# The K(<C ide its memo dated !*-"&-!""!/ =led before the Honble High Court of Karnataka in '#(# )o# %!8,0280$-!""! (=led by K(<C/ challenging the order
dated "+-"!-!""! of K6T/ 7angalore in 6ppl# )os# *$"% 2 *$"0-!""%) submitted that the total number of ans.er2scripts .herein there .as diFerence of M (plus)
or S (minus) !" 1 more marks (as bet.een the marks a.arded by the DBaminer and the Head - Chief DBaminer) is in ++% ans.er scripts# 9n order to identify the
said ++% ans.er scripts and to ascertain the said ariation/ a re;uest .as gien to K(<C to proide the said ans.er scripts and the details# 6 tabulated and
computer generated data .as made aailable in this regard# 9n the said data only %* instances .herein the said diFerence .as more than plus or minus !"
marks/ had been sho.n# This aspect .as recorded in the draft of this Report and .as circulated to the members of the (etitioner ?embers# 3nly thereafter i#e
only on !%
st
Oanuary !"%, another computer generated list .as proided by the K(<C purporting to hae details of the said ++% ans.er scripts# Ho.eer/ the ++%
ans.er scripts .ere not made aailable for eri=cation# 9t has come to the kno.ledge of the (etitioner ?embers that the computer data maintained by the K(<C
is neither accurate nor complete and has gien rise to doubts and suspicion# The K(<C has been reluctant in proiding many of the original records and in this
instance the ans.er scripts# The (etitioner ?embers note that such inaccurate and incomplete data maintained by the K(<C is a serious Ea. and is no.here
helpful for the resolution of the problems#
&# <election made in iolation of adertisement in !"", 7atchC 9n 4#( !"", batch there .ere four posts of :istrict ?arketing 3@cer/ ! of .hich .ere resered (% for
<C 1 another for !6) The other t.o .ere in 4?2Category in .hich one post is for Female candidate 1 6nother for Kannada medium candidate/ Though it is ery
clear in the noti=cation adertised for the post/ the K(<C blatantly selected <ri#<riniasa Reddy# K/ Reg#no 2%,,*""/ for the post :?3 under &6-K?< category in
iolations of the said noti=cation
,# <election .ithout proisionC There .as no hori5ontal reseration in respect of &6 1 &7 resered posts in %$$0 batch# Ho.eer/ the follo.ing candidates .ere
selected in disregard of thisC
a# <ri# Cho.daiah selected as/ Commercial TaB 3@cer For group 7 post under the hori5ontal reseration of 4?-&6-P2?(
b# <ri# )emappaNalappaHosura selected as/ 6sst Treasury 3@cer# For 4roup 7 (ost under the hori5ontal reseration 4?-&7-P2?(#
Pa4e "'@
8# The discrepancies in accepting or reGecting caste-category-income certi=cates of the candidates obsered by the (etitioner ?embers and the details of the
candidates sho.n belo. C
a# <mt# 6sha (areenReg )o#%%&*&! claimed !7 reseration as per the application submitted by her for the selection of 4( %$$0 batch# The (etitioner ?embers also
obsered the !7 category certi=cate enclosed in the application .as of date .hich is before the date speci=ed in the noti=cation# :uring the scrutiny of applications
it .as rightly remarked by K(<C as 7)(7DF3RD )3T9F9C6T93))# 7ut it is seen from the interie. records that the said candidate submitted a ne. !7 certi=cate
dated "$-"&-%$$0 and the same .as accepted by remarking as Xthe candidate claims 2B and she has produced original reservation certifcate of 2B considered
under 2B categoryY by then chairman :r#H#)#Krishna and the said candidate .as selected for Tahasildhar (ost under !7 reseration# 7ut .here as in the case of
another candidate/ ?rs# ReshmaTahseen/ though facts are the same/ she .as selected under 4?/ .hich sho.s discrimination and arbitrariness#
b# <ri# ?ohammed Ra= (asha/ bearing Reg# )o# %!&0*0/ !"", batch/ .ho .as on the =nal select list/ his candidature .as cancelled for the reason that he had
highlighted a fe. sentences of his ans.ers in 4eneral <tudies paper using Euorescent pen# as follo. .as a candidate .ho attended for the 4a5etted (robationers
group 617 !"", batch bearing the register no# %!&0*0# His candidature has been cancelled by the K(<C after the =nal select list .as announced# The fact of the
case .as the candidate .as underlined a fe. .ords of the sentences (by using Eorecent pen) .hich .ere .ritten in his ans.er scripts of 4eneral <tudies paper of
?ain DBamination# He had neither disclosed his identity nor tried to do so# Ho.eer/ on this Eimsy ground/ his candidature came to be cancelled# The (etitioner
?embers obsere that the cancelation of his candidature in !"", batch .as unGust#
c# The (etitioner ?embers obsere that <ri )atesh#:#7 .ho .as a candidate claimed under &7 reseration bearing registerno#%""8&%/ of !"", selection /.ho appear
for personality test could not produce &7 original certi=cate/ had in fact/ lost
his originals during transit and had lodged a complaint .ith the Gurisdictional police .hich .as ackno.ledged# This has been reported to the commission during the
personality test and sought some more time to produce the same in a representation dated "%-"8-!""+# 7ut the K(<C did not consider the re;uest on the facts
submitted by the candidate# Finally this candidate selected for the post of Tahasildhar under 4? category# The (etitioner ?embers obsere that the commission
has entertained many candidates re;uest for the change of interie. dates and on the basis of change of dates the interie.s .ere held (C3:<)# The (etitioner
?embers noted the fact that the discrimination resulted in denial of his selection to the higher post#
+# The (etitioner ?embers also .ent through the translations of ;uestion papers from Dnglish to Kannada in %$$$ batch# The (etitioner ?embers found that the translations
are faulty# This aspect has been accepted by the K(<C in its reply statement =led before the Karnataka 6dministratie Tribunal/ 7angalore in 6pplication )o#&&0$-!"",#
This has aFected candidates .ho took the eBamination in Kannada#
*# The (etitioner ?embers hae found that the ratio has not been follo.ed in the main eBamination stage (apart from the iolation of implementation of the ratio policy/ as
discussed in the earlier chapters of this Report)# 6s per the rules of the recruitment/ for the ?ain 'ritten DBamination the ratio that has to be follo.ed is %C!" i#e if there is
one post then !" candidates hae to be permitted to .rite main .ritten eBamination (in the order of merit in each category of reseration/ .hich is discussed separately
in the earlier chapters of this Report)# The follo.ing table illustrates the %C!" ratio has been iolatedC
TA!0E 5D"
Pa4e "'E
2ear
Post
Ad<ertised
No o9 )andidates to be e7i4ib7e in t*e Ratio "-&' 9or
6ain E:a6ination
No o9 Candidates a)tua77K 6ade e7i4ib7e
bK t*e BP1C
Ratio
diMeren)e
No o9 E:)ess
Candidates
"##
$
("@ $;'' "&E$'
"-;'3@@
(;$'
"##
#
"#" ;$&' (FF"
"-&(3#F
#@"
&''
(
"@; ;'E' ;&F(
"-&"3;#
&"(
0#9t has come to the kno.ledge of the (etitioner ?embers that no proision had been made for selection in the :isabled (ersons categories/ although mandated by
la.# 6ggrieed by the same/ certain persons had approached the Tribunal seeking relief and the said persons .ho .ere parties to the proceedings .ere proided
.ith employment# The follo.ing table illustrates the said instancesC
"### !at)*
<l no )ame 1 Reg# )o 'ritten DBam ?arks 9nterie. marks - Remarks
% Hidayathulla# K#6 2 %%%%*! 08" )ot eligible for interie.
&''( !at)*
<l no )ame 1 Reg# )o 'ritten DBam ?arks 9nterie. marks - Remarks
% Kish.anathHiremath 2 %!$!00 80, )ot eligible for interie.
! Hidayathulla# K#6 S
%!0$+%
)ot eligible for main eBam )ot eligible for interie.
& 9ndresh # R S %%"$0+ +%8 )ot eligible for interie.
, Rai# C#) S ,%8!"+ *$& $"
8 Qia Hulla # K#) 2 %%00&, +0" %""
+ <hankare 4o.da :oddamaniS %%%%*! )ot eligible for main eBam )ot eligible for interie.
$# :uring the .orking of this Committee/ arious re;uests .ere gien to obtain data and information# ?any a times information and data gien .ere either incomplete or
incorrect# The information and data .ere not gien .ithin reasonable time# Repeated reminders had to be gien# The computer data maintained/ .ith regard to the said
Pa4e "'F
recruitment process/ by the K(<C is found to be ery erroneous# 9t is also the feeling of the (etitioner ?embers that the K(<C parted .ith the information reluctantly and only
after repeated insistence# The follo.ing eBample .ould sho. that patently erroneous information .as suppliedC The (etitioner ?embers sought to kno. the dates on .hich the
moderation process (%$$0 batch) took place/ so as to ascertain .hether moderation process .as undertaken at the releant and reasonable time# The BP1C <ide its 7etter
No/E ("+ &&##C";H"(CP1C dated &"C"'C&'"; stated t*at RThe moderation"Scaling process was done during the year %& but speci'c dates are not knownS3
(CopK o9 t*e 7etter in *ere=it* en)7osed as Anne:ure 5 D/"+3 Ho.eer/ the (ersonality Tests for the %$$0 batch started from :ecember !+
th
!""8 and ended on February
0
th
/ !""+# The moderation process should hae been completed much before the start of the (ersonality Test/ as the =nal marks of the .ritten eBamination can be arried at
only after the moderation process and after calculating the =nal marks of all the candidates in the .ritten eBamination/ and after applying the ratio/ candidates .ho become
eligible are to be called for (ersonality Test# Hence/ it can be inferred that the said information gien by K(<C is obiously erroneous#
Ana7Ksis and )on)7usions o9 t*e BP1C Me6ber in respe)t o9 t*e Mis)e77aneous Jndin4s abo<eC
In re- para4rap* " #- K(<C has endeaored to proide all the data that .as aailable in its custody to the committee members# 'hereer/ information .as
not aailable/ reasons hae been furnished to the committee members# 9n fact/ the (etitioner members hae also sought for information .hich does not pertain
to the terms of reference of this Committee and K(<C has proided een the said information# )o information aailable has been deliberately .ithheld and
delayed as commented by the petitioner members#
In re- para4rap* &- Re4ardin4 t*e EE" ans=er s)ripts as re)orded in t*e order dated 'E3'&3&''&-6t page 0, of the order dated %%2%"2!""! passed in
'#(#)o#%!8,0280$-!""! and connected matters/ it is stated that K(<C has made aailable for the perusal of the Court/ statements sho.ing the subGect2.ise
marks a.arded by the DBaminer/ Head DBaminer and Chief DBaminer .here the diFerence .as plus or minus !" or aboe .ith the subGect .ise abstracts#
Further at (age 08 of the said order/ .here the ?emo dated !*2"&2!""! =led by the K(<C in the said 'rit (etition has been eBtracted/ it is stated that the total
number of cases .here the ariation is plus or minus !" or more are identi=ed as ++% in number# The (etitioner members had re;uested the K(<C to furnish
copies of the said statements =led in the said .rit petition purportedly along .ith the said ?emo dated !*2"&2!""!# Copies of the said statements .ere not
aailable .ith the K(<C in the 'rit (etition records and hence an eFort .as also made to obtain copies from this Honble Court on the said statements# 9n ie. of
the non2furnishing of the statements to the petitioner members/ the said members hae dra.n an inference that an imaginary =gure of ++% .as put forth to the
court (non2eBistent material) in order to obtain an order of moderation# The (etitioner members hae also on the basis of their o.n interpretation of certain data
opined that there are only %* cases in .hich there is ariation of plus or minus !" or more# This conclusion arried at is incorrect in my opinion as a bare perusal
of the tabulated statements at 6nneBure2% .ould indicate that there are more cases .here the ariation is plus or minus !" or more# Furthermore after much
eFort a physical copy of the said statements .ere traced by the K(<C in its computer section on %+2"%2!"%,/ .hich disclose that t.o statements .ere prepared
and =led/ one containing the list of subGect .ise marks .here the diFerence .as plus !" and aboe (&&8 cases) and .here the diFerence .as minus !" and
aboe (&!+ cases)# Hence/ in my opinion/ the aforesaid analysis and conclusion on 9ssue )o#% arried at by the (etitioner members is incorrect and based on a
.rong premise#
Pa4e "'$
In re- para4rap*s ;% (% @(b+ $C 9n my opinion the terms of reference to this committee/ do not encompass these matters and hence/ 9 refrain from making
any comments on the said aspects#
In re- para4rap*s @(a+% @()+ EC These speci=c instances are the subGect matter of pending cases before arious courts and hence/ 9 refrain from making any
comments on the said aspects#
In re- para4rap* FC 9 hae furnished my detailed conclusion and analysis on the said issue under the head of personality test in respect of %$$0/ %$$$ and
!"", batches and said conclusion and analysis hold good een for the said issues raised by the (etitioner members#
Co66ent o9 t*e Go<ern6ent Me6ber-
The factual information collated in 6nneBure 9/ 99 and 999/ (.ithout reference to the comments made in the XRemarksY column thereto)/ is found to be correct#
The issues raised by the (etitioner ?embers are sought to be met by the comments of the K(<C ?ember# <ince the analysis and conclusions dra.n by the (etitioner
?embers are basically inferences dra.n from their point of ie./ 9 refuse to pass any comment or be Gudgmental# 3n the other hand/ 9 deem it appropriate to
eBpress my serious concern/ keeping in ie. the larger public interest/ and suggest remedial measure# 9t is indeed astonishing that the K(<C has not come up .ith
speci=c Rules or regulations to goern the eBamination process .hich is so ital# The non eBistence of set rules seems to be the foundation on .hich the edi=ce of
irregularity has taken shape# 9t is high time the K(<C comes up .ith regulations on the lines of The Ciil <erices DBamination Rules of the >nion (ublic <erice
Commission#

(.IBRAM PHADBE+ (!A1A.ARADA PATE0 G3B+ (R3DE.DA1+ (R,!EN DACO!+
MEM!ER REPRE1ENTING MEM!ER REPRE1ENTING MEM!ER REPRE1ENTING MEM!ER REPRE1ENTING
THE PETETIONER1 THE PETETIONER1 THE GO.ERNMENT OF BARNATABA THE BP1C
Pa4e "'#

Fact Finding Committee Report

Загружено:

Сведения о документе

Авторское право

Доступные форматы

Поделиться этим документом

Поделиться или встроить документ

Параметры публикации

Этот документ был вам полезен?

Это неприемлемый материал?

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

Fact Finding Committee Report

Загружено:

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

REPORT OF THE FACT FINDING COMMITTEE (Gazetted Probationers Group A ! "##$% "###% &''( !

Вам также может понравиться