Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 6
Software Verification NTC 2008 Example 001 PROGRAM NAME: REVISION NO.: ETABS 2013 0 W IDE

Software Verification

NTC 2008 Example 001

PROGRAM NAME:

REVISION NO.:

ETABS 2013

0

WIDE FLANGE SECTION UNDER COMBINED COMPRESSION & BENDING

EXAMPLE DESCRIPTION

In this example a continuous beam-column is subjected to factored axial load P = 1400 kN and major-axis bending moment M = 200 kN-m. The beam is continuously braced to avoid any buckling effects. This example was tested using the Italian NTC-2008 steel frame design code. The design capacities are compared with independent hand calculated results.

GEOMETRY, PROPERTIES AND LOADING

A M P L A Section A-A L = 0.4 m Material Properties Loading Design
A
M
P
L A
Section A-A
L = 0.4 m
Material Properties
Loading
Design Properties

E

v

G

= 210x10 3 MPa = 0.3 = 80769 MPa

P

M

= 1400 kN =

200 kN-m

TECHNICAL FEATURES TESTED

f y = 235 MPa

Section: 457x191x98 UB

Section compactness check (beam-column)

Section compression capacity

Section shear capacity

Section bending capacity with compression & shear reductions

Interaction capacity, D/C

Software Verification R ESULTS C OMPARISON PROGRAM NAME: REVISION NO.: ETABS 2013 0 Independent results

Software Verification

RESULTS COMPARISON

PROGRAM NAME:

REVISION NO.:

ETABS 2013

0

Independent results are taken from hand calculations based on the CSI steel design documentation contained in the file “SFD-NTC-2008.pdf,” which is available through the program “Help” menu. Examples were taken from Example 6.6 on pp. 57-59 from the book “Designers’ Guide to EN1993-1-1” by R.S. Narayanan & A. Beeby.

     

Percent

Output Parameter

ETABS

Independent

Difference

Compactness

Class 2

Class 2

0.00%

Section Compression Resistance, N c,Rd (kN)

2797.6

2797.6

0.00%

Section Shear Resistance,

719.2

719.2

0.00%

V c,Rd,y (kN)

Section Plastic Bending Resistance, M c,y,Rd (kN-m)

499.1

499.1

0.00%

Section Bending Resistance Axially Reduced, M N,y,Rd (kN-m)

310.8

310.8

0.00%

Section Bending Resistance Shear Reduced, M V,y,Rd (kN-m)

481.3

481.3

0.00%

Interaction Capacity, D/C

0.644

0.644

0.00%

COMPUTER FILE: NTC 2008 EX001

CONCLUSION

The results show an exact comparison with the independent results.

Software Verification H AND C ALCULATION Properties: Material: S275 Steel E = 210000 MPa f

Software Verification

HAND CALCULATION

Properties:

Material: S275 Steel

E = 210000 MPa

f y = 235 MPa

Section: 457x191x98 UB

PROGRAM NAME:

REVISION NO.:

ETABS 2013

0

A = 12,500 mm 2

b = 192.8 mm, t f = 19.6 mm, h = 467.2 mm, t w = 11.4 mm, r = 10.2 mm

Other:

h

w

d

h t

2

f

h

2

t

f

467.2

2

r

467.2

19.6 428 mm

2 19.6 10.2

407.6 mm

 

w

192.8

11.4

2

10.2

c

 

2

2

t

r

b

2

W pl,y = 2,230,000 mm 3

80.5 mm

M 0

1.05

Loadings:

P 1400 kN

axial load

M

y

200 kN-m

bending load at one end

Results in the following internal forces:

N

Ed

V

Ed

M

y

,

1400 kN

500

kN

Ed

200 kN-m

Software Verification Section Compactness: 235     1 f y 1  

Software Verification

Section Compactness:

235     1 f y 1   1   
235
 
 1
f
y
1 
1  
 
1 
N Ed
   1
2
2 ht
f
w
y
1, 400, 000
 
1  
1
2
2
467.2
11.4
235  

  1.0

Localized Buckling for Flange:

2.7818

PROGRAM NAME:

REVISION NO.:

1, so

ETABS 2013

0

For the tip in compression under combined bending & compression

 

9

9

1

cl

.1

1

9

 

c

80.5

 

 

 

4.11

 

e

t

f

19.6

e

4.11



cl .1

9

So Flange is Class 1 in combined bending and compression

Localized Buckling for Web:

  0.5,

so

 

396

396

1

 

cl

.1

13



1

13

1

 

1

 

d

407.6

 

 

 

 

35.75

 

e

t

11.4

 
 

w

 

 

35.75



 

33.00

 

e

cl

.1

 

456

456

1

cl .2

13



1

13 1

1

e

35.75 

cl

.2

38.00

33.00

38.00

for combined bending & compression

Software Verification PROGRAM NAME: REVISION NO.: ETABS 2013 0 So Web is Class 2 in

Software Verification

PROGRAM NAME:

REVISION NO.:

ETABS 2013

0

So Web is Class 2 in combined bending & compression.

Since Web is Class 2,

Section is Class 2

in combined bending & compression.

Section Compression Capacity

N

c Rd

,

N

pl Rd

,

Af

y

12, 500

235

M 0

1.05

N

c

, Rd

2797.6 kN

Section Shear Capacity

A  A  2 bt  t V , y f f A 
A
 A
 2
bt
 t
V
, y
f
f
A
 5, 565.5 mm
2
V
, y
f
V
y
A
c Rd
,
,
y
vy
3
M 0
 719.2 kN
V c Rd
,
,
y
 1.0
h
467.1
37.5 
t
11.4
w

t

w

2

r

235

12, 500

5, 565.5 

2

192.8

72

235 f y
235
f
y

72

1.0

235 235
235
235

72

19.6

19.6

11.4

So no shear buckling needs to be checked.

2

10.2

Section Bending Capacity

M

M

W

pl

,

y

f

y

2, 230, 000

235

 

c

,

y Rd

,

pl

,

y Rd

,

M 0

1.05

M

c

,

y Rd

,

499.1 kN-m

 
Software Verification ETABS 2013 PROGRAM NAME: 0 REVISION NO.: with Shear Reduction V  500

Software Verification

ETABS 2013 PROGRAM NAME: 0 REVISION NO.: with Shear Reduction V  500 kN 
ETABS 2013
PROGRAM NAME:
0
REVISION NO.:
with Shear Reduction
V
500 kN
0.5
 V
 359.6 kN
Ed
c , Rd
Shear Reduction is needed
A
 ht
467.2
11.4
4,879.2 mm
2
v
w
2
2
2
V
500
   
Ed
 1
1
0.1525
V
   2
719.2
 
c
,
Rd
   
2
 A
2
0.1525
4879.2
W
v
f
2, 230, 000 
 235
pl
,
y
yk
4 t
4
11.4
w
M
 M
y V
,
,
Rd
y
,
c
,
Rd
1.05
M 0
M
 481.3 kN-m
V
,
r Rd
,
with Compression Reduction
N
1400
n 
Ed
 0.50
N
2797.6
pl Rd
,
A
 2
bt
12, 500
2
192.8  19.6
a
f
0.40
0.5
A
12, 500
1  n
1
0.5
M
M
499.1
N
,
y Rd
,
pl
,
y Rd
,
1
0.5 a
1
0.5
0.4
M
 310.8 kN-m
N
,
y Rd
,
Interaction Capacity: Compression & Bending
Section Bending & Compression Capacity
Formula NTC 4.2.39
2
5 n
2
D
M
M
200
M
y , Ed
z
,
Ed
 
 
0
0.414
y
,
Ed
0.644
C
  
M
M
310.8
 
 
M
N
,
y
,
Rd
 
N
,
z
,
Rd
 
N
,
y
,
Rd
D
 0.644
(Governs)
C