The First International Benchmark in the area of Islamic Finance D I P L O M A IBF &T No 04, Collingwood Place, Colombo 06, Sri Lanka. Tel / Fax : +94 11 4413030
Email : info@fgkcentre.com Web : www.fgkcentre.com Hot Line - 077 46 16 710 FIRST GLOBAL KNOWLEDGE CENTRE R Empowering Knowledge, Transforming Lives F G K C BANKING & FINANCE QUALIFICATIONS INSIDE Overview... 03 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today Performance of Islamic Banks 09 Subprime Crisis & Islamic Finance 18 Basic Facts of SUKUK 34 When West meets East 13 Subtle nature of RIBA 24 Global News 36 Empowering knowledge, transforming lives Professional Studies Division The First International Benchmark in the area of Islamic Finance D I P L O M A IBF &T No 04, Collingwood Place, Colombo 06, Sri Lanka. Tel / Fax : +94 11 4413030
Email : info@fgkcentre.com Web : www.fgkcentre.com Hot Line - 077 46 16 710 FIRST GLOBAL KNOWLEDGE CENTRE R Empowering Knowledge, Transforming Lives F G K C BANKING & FINANCE QUALIFICATIONS With The Shariah Compliant way to help you... Asiff Hussein - Editor - Islamic Finance Today needing venture capital to offer the world something better in terms of innovations for example. As seen in the run up to the upcoming US election where fundraising decides the outcome to a significant extent, Barrack Obamas strategy of tapping a broader spectrum of the population for small contributions rather than depending on handouts by a few wealthy individuals such as Hilary Clinton did, paid off with the Obama campaign raising record campaign funds the highest ever in US history. As such, there is no reason why the same cannot apply to the banking or finance industry. Ready access to funds remains a pressing need for many people, particularly in the developing world and it is high time that they were given a chance to improve their lot. Another issue that besets the industry is its supply- driven approach with unfounded assumptions that the Islamic Finance market is a captive market. Although this may hold true for a few on religious grounds, it does not hold true for everybody. People today look for ease and convenience in financial transactions as well as a good deal on their investments. Those who cannot meet this demand will simply die out. As we have always stressed Islamic banking should be one of utter conviction, not just religious compulsion. Unfortunately, what has been lost on most IFIs is the need for satisfying their clientele on whom their business depends. This is all the more so if Islamic Banking and Finance is to gain its due place and not just a foothold in the demanding west. This is where winning hearts comes in. Business after all is the art of winning hearts. I t is quite apparent today that Islamic Banking and Finance has carved its niche in the financial markets of the world. Be it in boardrooms of the big-time finance corporates of the west, or various banking fora regularly held in the Middle East or South East Asia to small- time entrepreneurs in South Asian countries like India, Bangladesh or Sri Lanka, Islamic Finance is the buzz word, the in-thing today. The phenomenal growth of the industry has left its detractors dumbstruck and its proponents overjoyed. At the same time, however, this does not mean that Islamic Banking and Finance practitioners should rest on their laurels, for just as the industry has expanded, the problems it has encountered are also many. A home market bias with a focus on tapping the funds of the fabulously rich, a supply-driven approach resulting in the dearth of innovative products and services and the lack of a common lobbying group to convince and pressurize states to adopt Shariah compliant banking and financing are cases in point. For instance, it is often asked why Islamic Financial Institutions (IFIs) are so keen to turn out products that cater only to the financial needs of a few affluent clients rather than seeking to broadbase their services to include SMEs or enterprising entrepreneurs EDITORIAL No room for complacency Layout & Design M.G. Chandana Kumara chandana@pioneer-publications.com Marketing & Circulation Mohammed Bashith bashith@pioneer-publications.com Mohammed Hikam hikam@frstglobal-group.com Printed by : Printel (Pvt) Ltd, Sri Lanka International Distribution Malaysia - Singapore - Bahrain - Qatar United Arab Emirates - Maldives -India Islamic Finance Today is a magazine exclusively dedicated to Islamic Banking & Finance published by Pioneer Publications (Pvt) Ltd. It contains a variety of interesting features on various aspects of Islamic banking and fnance as well as other information of relevance to the Islamic fnance industry. No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form without the prior written permission of the publisher. Views expressed in this magazine are not necessarily those of the publisher. 496, R.A.De Mel Mawatha Colombo 03, Sri Lanka. Tel : +94 11 2555 902-4 Fax : +94 11 2555905-6 www.pioneer-publications.com Editor Asif Hussein editor@pioneer-publications.com Editorial Board Dr. M.A.M. Shukri Dr. Shariq Nisar Latheef Farook Khalid Farouk info@pioneer-publications.com Research Partner Research Intelligence Unit info@riunit.com The exclusive Islamic Finance Monthly Islamic Finance The Pulse of Ethical Business Today 05 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today With The Shariah Compliant way to help you... 06 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 Brian Kettell - Brian Kettell worked for several years as an Economic Advisor for what later became the Central Bank of Bahrain. He had numerous Islamic banking responsibilities. He has published 15 books on banking and fnancial markets. Three of these relate to Islamic banking. These are: Introduction to Islamic Banking and Finance, Islamic Structured Finance- A Guide to Sukuk and Islamic Banking and Finance in the Kingdom of Bahrain (BMA). Brian works as a consultant and specialist trainer in Islamic banking and fnance. Details of his Training courses can be found on www.islamicbankingcourses.com Islamic Banking and Finance OVERVIEW Islamic Banking... T he development of Islamic banking and finance is heralded as one of the most significant advances of the international financial markets in recent history. A recent study reported an increase in the number of Islamic financial institutions from 75 in 1975 to over 450 in 2008, within and outside of the Muslim world. The assets of these organizations are estimated at $500- $600 billion and growing at 20-30% per year and are expected to rise by as much as 50 % in the next decade given the high oil prices which have increased demand for such financial services. Yet another factor contributing to this increased demand is the growing Muslim population in Europe. The report notes that the increased demand for Muslim financial institutions in the West has also prompted western firms to provide these services. The report cites Lloyds, HSBC, Deutsche Bank, and Citigroup among the most notable examples of western firms adapting to tap these new funds. Western governments are also jumping into the fray, particularly the United Kingdom, where Prime Minister Gordon Brown recently declared his ambition for the UK to become a gateway to Islamic finance and trade. What is Islamic Banking? Ask a conventional banker exactly what is Islamic banking. He will mumble something about religion. He will then say well they cannot charge interest but they use something else which is the same thing. This something else, incidentally, is never defined. He will then move on to describe Islamic banking as being about smoke and mirrors. To conclude he will then profoundly announce that, with a few tweaks, it is what he does every day anyway. And that is the end of it. OVERVIEW Islamic Banking... If you push him to actually describe an Islamic financial instrument, and even worse if you actually use some Islamic terminology, murabaha, mudaraba etc, then his eyes will start to gloss over. Frankly this stereo-typed image is all too prevalent within the banking world. Islamic banking is not about smoke and mirrors. It is in fact about banking based on Islamically ethical principles which are, in many ways, very different indeed from conventional banking principles. So what exactly is Islamic banking all about? Islamic financial institutions are those that are based, in their objectives and operations, on Quranic principles. They are thus set apart from conventional institutions, which have no such religious preoccupations. Islamic banks provide commercial services which comply with the religious injunctions of Islam. Islamic banks provide services to their customers free from interest, (the Arabic term for which is riba), and the giving and taking of interest is prohibited in all transactions. This prohibition makes an Islamic banking system differ fundamentally from a conventional banking system. Financial systems based on Islamic tenets are dedicated to the elimination of the payment and receipt of interest in all forms. It is this taboo that makes Islamic banks and other financial institutions different in principle from their Western counterparts. This rejection of interest poses the central question of what replaces the interest rate mechanism in an Islamic framework. Financial intermediation is at the heart of modern financial systems. If the paying and receiving of interest is prohibited, how do Islamic banks operate? Here Profit and Loss Sharing (PLS) comes in, substituting profit-and-loss-sharing for interest as a method of resource allocation and financial intermediation. In fact, the basic idea of Islamic banking can be stated simply. The operations of Islamic financial institutions primarily are based on a profit-and-loss-sharing (PLS) principle. An Islamic bank does not charge interest but rather participates in the yield resulting from the use of funds. The depositors also share in the profits of the bank according to a predetermined ratio. There is thus a partnership between the Islamic bank and its depositors, on one side, and between the bank and its investment clients, on the other side, as a manager of depositors resources in productive uses. This is in contrast with a conventional bank, which mainly borrows funds paying interest on one side of the balance sheet and lends funds charging interest on the other. The complexity of Islamic banking comes from the variety (and nomenclature) of the instruments employed, and in understanding the underpinnings of Islamic law. 07 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today Islamic Banking Principles The principles as applied to Islamic banking and finance are set out below. 1. Predetermined payments are prohibited Any predetermined payment over and above the actual amount of principal is prohibited. Islam allows only one kind of loan and that is qard al hassan (literally good loan) whereby the lender does not charge any interest or additional amount over the money lent. 2. Profit and Loss Sharing The principle here is that the lender must share in the profits or losses arising out of the enterprise for which the money was lent. Islam encourages Muslims to invest their money and to become partners in order to share profits and risks in the business instead of becoming creditors. Islamic finance is based on the belief that the provider of capital and the user of capital should equally share the risk of business ventures, whether those are industries, service companies or simple trade deals. Translated into banking terms, the depositor, the bank and the borrower should all share the risks and the rewards of financing business ventures. This is unlike the interest-based commercial banking system, where all the pressure is on the borrower: he must pay back his loan, with the agreed interest, regardless of the success or failure of his venture. 3. Making money out of money is not acceptable Making money from money is not Islamically acceptable. Money, in Islam, is only a medium of exchange, a way of defining the value of a thing. It has no value in itself, and therefore should not be allowed to generate more money, via fixed interest payments, simply by being put in a bank or lent to someone else. The human effort, initiative, and risk involved in a productive venture are more important than the money used to finance it. Muslim jurists consider money as potential capital rather than capital, meaning that money becomes capital only when it is invested in business. Accordingly, money advanced to a business as a loan is regarded as a debt of the business and not capital and, as such, it is not entitled to any return (i.e. interest). 4. Uncertainty is prohibited Gharar, the Arabic term for uncertainty, risk or speculation, is also prohibited. Under this prohibition any transaction entered into should be free from uncertainty, risk and speculation. Contracting parties should have perfect knowledge of the counter values intended to be exchanged as a result of their transactions. The rationale behind the prohibition is the wish to protect the weak from exploitation. Therefore, options and futures are considered as un-Islamic and so are forward foreign exchange transactions given that forward rates are determined by interest differentials. 5. Only Shariah approved contracts are acceptable Conventional banking is secular in its orientation. In contrast, in the Islamic system, all economic agents have to work within the moral value system of Islam. Islamic banks are no exception. As such, they cannot finance any project which conflicts with the moral value system of Islam. For example Islamic banks are not allowed to finance a wine factory, a casino, a night club or any other activity which is prohibited by Islam or is known to be harmful to society. 6. Sanctity of contract Many verses in the Holy Quran encourage trade and commerce, and the attitude of Islam is that there should be no impediment to honest and legitimate trade and business, so that people are encouraged to earn a living, support their families and give charity to those less fortunate. Just as Islam regulates and influences all other spheres of life, so it also governs the conduct of business and commerce. Muslims have a moral obligation to conduct their business activities in accordance with the requirements of their religion. Islam upholds contractual obligations and the disclosure of information as a sacred duty. OVERVIEW Islamic Banking... 08 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 Roshan Madawela www.riunit.com Research to assess performance of Shariah Compliant Banks -The need of the day Empirical research incorporating time-series and cross country data is readily available in the conventional fnance industry as it has been studied, researched and documented over a long period of time. In the Islamic fnance sector, such material is scarce. With time and maturity in the industry, the demand for detailed studies is set to increase. W hilst the Islamic Banking or Shariah Compliant Banking (SCB) sector has been around for several decades now thanks primarily to pioneering efforts from countries like Sudan Iran, Bahrain and Malaysia, the rapid development of this sector has been a more recent phenomenon. Consequently, the research material that is available on the subject tends to lack the type of empirical analysis that the conventional banking sector enjoys. Despite the industry being valued at some $750 billion (McKinsey & Co) with over 300 dedicated institutions and thousands of SCB service windows operating in over 75 countries, proper research with time series-data and cross-country analysis has not been forthcoming as yet. In an attempt to fill this gap, the IMF has recently released a working paper using data on 18 banking REPORT Research to assess... 09 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today systems with substantial presence of SCB to provide a cross-country analysis on the impact of SCB on financial stability. It poses the question, Are Islamic Banks more or less stable that conventional banks? Diferent pillars At the foundation of the SCB system are the two concepts of profit and loss sharing and mark-up. In the former the rate of return on the financial asset or venture is either not known or fixed prior to the undertaking whilst in the latter case, the purchase- resale transaction is determined with reference to the benchmark rate of return. Benchmark rates similar to that offered by, for example, the London Inter- bank Offered Rate (LIBOR) would serve as reference points. The nature of profit share implies that the banks ability to secure a sound return is a function of its own investment decision and / or inputs made during the post-investment period as compared to the fixed return nature of the conventional system where the entire risk is transferred to the borrower. Thus, poor investment decisions on the part of the bank will have a direct bearing on the returns gained by depositors as the rate of return is determined by the profit and loss sharing ratio. Additionally, SCB instruments also differ from conventional banks in the overall legal contracts, governance and the liquidity structure. For instance, Islamic banks have had to operate in an environment sans proper inter-bank and money market functionality, government securities and limited access to lender of last resort facilities of the central banks. Due to the principal requirement to be Shariah compliant, Islamic Banks have less access to the risk-hedging techniques available to the conventional banks such as derivatives and swaps according to the IMF paper. Comparative stability With all these factors limiting the operations of SCB, can the IMF study indicate the comparative financial stability of SCB vis--vis their conventional counterparts? The findings suggest that SCB may be better able to transfer the risk of a negative shock from the asset side to the depositor. This aspect of SCB tends to make them less risky from the depositor side. The paper also suggests that the need to provide a stable and competitive return to investors under the constraint of limited access to liquid instruments may place pressure on SCB entities to be more conservative. The SCB players are also said to hold a larger proportion of their assets in reserve accounts of central banks than the conventional commercial banks. Furthermore, the depositors position in the deal of risk sharing with the bank will render him towards exercising tight oversight over the banks management. This too will serve towards less risk taking on the part of the SCB sector. The IMF study uses z-scores in order to analyze the combination of a banks capitalization, profitability and risk. The higher the z-score the less likely it is that the bank will run out of capital. Using a definition where banks with more than $1 billion in assets are categorized as large banks and those below $1billion as other, a number of results have been quoted. REPORT Research to assess... 10 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 The following are the key points; Small Islamic banks tend to be financially stronger (that is, have higher z-scores) than small and large commercial banks. Large commercial banks tend to be financially stronger than large Islamic banks. Small Islamic banks tend to be financially stronger than large Islamic banks. The paper suggests that the finding could be explained with reference to the contrast between the high risk stability in SCB entities as compared with larger SCB organizations in that it is significantly more complex for Islamic banks to adjust their credit risk monitoring system as they become bigger. For example, the profit share modes used by Islamic banks, are more diverse and more difficult to standardize than loans used by commercial banks. As the scale of the banking operations grow, monitoring of credit risk becomes rapidly more complex and the issues of adverse selection and moral hazard might also emerge. With reference to the Mudaraba type of transactions this argument has a clear basis. Where a SCB enters into a large investment under a profit share structure, it would also invest in ongoing consultation and exercise oversight of that project in order to safeguard their investment. The Islamic bank can even ask to be represented at the Board Room in order to actively play a role in the decision making process. Another finding of the study is that as the presence of Islamic banks grows in a countrys financial system, there is no significant impact on the soundness of other banks. This suggests that Islamic and commercial banks can coexist in the same system without substantial crowding out effects through competition and deteriorating soundness. Academic limitations Despite the studys recourse to a large and extensive amount of cross-country data, its limitations in describing the ground operations realities cannot be under-scored. For instance, the finding regarding co-existence, may be relevant for those fully-fledged Islamic Banks but the reality in the industry is that most players are conventional banks that have Shariah compliant windows. Thus the overlapping in the overall banking industry is significant in many respects as the exchange of information and resources between the conventional and SCB system will not be hindered by any academic definitions. The suggestion that Mudaraba instruments may give a comparative advantage to smaller SCB operators based on their ability to better monitor their investment may find broad agreement at first glance. However, large SCB entities can factor in the additional costs of oversight and monitoring into their Mudaraba deals and even leverage on economies of scale to be more competitive in the market. Thus the argument that small Islamic banks are more stable than larger banks is not entirely convincing. Moreover, larger SCB organizations typically have an entire range of financial products and services that go beyond the profit share and mark-up principals. REPORT Research to assess... 11 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today Markets fluctuate, Principles remain The ability of larger players to issue sukuks (Shariah compliant bonds) on various types of transactions including Ijarahs ( Leasing facilities) to be factored in. The fact that smaller SCB service providers tend towards a limited portfolio based on profit share and mark-up is possibly a consequence of their own financial constraints that prevent them from engaging in some of the larger Shariah compliant operations. The study also takes the aggregated portfolios of banks and makes sweeping statements regarding their overall operations with no reference to specific areas of activity and lending instruments of either the conventional or SCB entities. The prevailing economic environment will impact investors and depositors in different ways that could perhaps be better analyzed under different asset classes or industry sectors. In this way, greater similarity between sectors or asset classes that contribute to financial stability may be found across both the conventional and Islamic banking sector, at any given time period. Only disentangling the various components of the overall banking sector that is entwined at many levels will reveal an accurate account of financial stability for most countries. One further point on the IMF study is that it needs to factor in the impact of regulatory authorities in any given country as it may be the key contributing factor. Strong regulatory institutions with powers to enforce laws serve to stabilize both conventional and Islamic banking systems. In the absence of a healthy supply of such studies, it is difficult to rate the IMF paper for its usefulness to the industry. Whilst it is a positive contribution and serves as food for thought, the claim that large Islamic banks are less financially stable than their conventional counterparts or smaller small Islamic banks needs to be further researched. Sources: http://www.vanguardngr.com, The International Monetary Fund, the Research Intelligence Unit. All copyrights reserved. (RIU 2008). REPORT Research to assess... 12 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 When West Meets East Why Conventional Equity should adapt to Shariah Requirments Alberto Brugnoni - Interviewed by Roshan Madawela Alberto Brugnoni is President and Founding Member of the Association for the Development of Alternative Instruments and Innovative Finance (ASSAIF), an Islamic Finance-tailoring consultancy based in Italy. ASSAIFs mission is the creation of Islamic products for Middle Eastern investors and the Muslim community resident in Italy. It is also actively involved in the creation of a Mediterranean Islamic micro-fnance network. Q: In your view, what gaps are there in the currently functioning IFIs around the world in terms of capacity and enforcement? A: Islamic banks are facing serious bottlenecks with regard to human resources. They do not have a common/shared approach to human resources development and are competing with each other for the current staff members while poaching resources from conventional banks. Islamic banks lack innovation in product quality and should move from mimicking conventional products to the development of true Islamic products. Also the issue of products of ill repute, as tawarruq, should be addressed once and for all. Islamic banks should start focusing on policies (why and where to invest according to Islamic values and which model of society they want to push forward) and stop concentrating only on the development of over-complicated fees-rich techniques that very often achieve the same goals and deliver the same products as the conventional investments. The question of Shariah-compliant microfinance to deliver financial resources to the needy is, in my opinion, a key issue. Q: Are the shortcomings of the currently functioning IFIs due to the comparative immaturity of the IF industry as a whole or are there other factors involved? A: I think that IFIs are coming of age and that after the last 5 to 6 roaring years of tremendous development where a free- for-all attitude prevailed, it is entering a new phase of more mature reflection. In this respect an essential role shall be played by the new generation INTERVIEW When West meets East... 13 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today of Shariah scholars fully conversant with modern financial techniques while at the same time sharing the fundamental values of Islamic finance. They bear a tremendous responsibility. Civil society and stakeholders as a whole in Muslim and non-Muslim countries shall also have their say. Q: How can Europe, with the most mature conventional fnance markets lead the way in this regard? A: In the coming years the contribution of the EU to Islamic finance will be fundamental. On the one hand the IF wave has crossed the Channel and major European countries like Italy, France and Germany are entering - though cautiously and at different levels of involvement - this field. This change in attitude has been prompted by financial-inclusion policy considerations with regard to the Muslim communities living in their respective countries. On the other hand the wealth of financial know- how and the extent of public policies that are the heritage of the Western world can only increment the ethical added value imbedded in the IFI. Keep in mind that the Western consumer markets are more sophisticated than their MENA counterparts and that they should act as powerful stimulus to Islamic finance as a whole. Expansion in the EU markets will, of course, require proper banking laws that allow Islamic banks to market Shariah-compliant products, proper tax laws that prevent double taxation and a proper regulatory environment. Q: Would there be any disadvantages of relying too much on Europe to lead the way and would Malaysia be a better choice given that they were amongst the frst to develop IF? A: I think it would be deeply wrong and damaging to the industry to play the competition card and to identify absolute leaders. IF is, by definition, a collective movement that, if placed in the proper historical perspective, sees some countries more advanced than others in specific areas/ products during defined time periods. The success story will be written only when IF will be internationally perceived as a multinational and comprehensive viable alternative to the existing conventional system and when this alternative will be available to all members of society irrespective of their faith or purchasing power. Q: Given the current state of play, what are the issues faced by Islamic banks and fnancial institutions with regard to standards in their day-to-day operations? A: Let me mention just one issue that I think is central: the corporate governance of the Shariah boards. In the absence of standards, shareholders tend to appoint members of their Shariah boards with little regard to their qualifications. This leads to the use of products of ill repute and to arbitrage between scholars where bad but easier to implement Shariah opinions of non- specialists drive good Shariah opinions of specialists out of circulation. This is starting to damage the industry. INTERVIEW When West meets East... 14 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 Q: And in the future, if we assume a positive and sustained growth scenario, what new issues might emerge? A: Two trends will, in my opinion, converge: Islamic Finance risk-sharing and Private Equity as both agree on the same approach: they share value, risks & rewards through partnership. I think that in this respect conventionally financed businesses in the West will be restructured to adapt to new Shariah- compliant funds as a more cost effective route to capital. Then, of course, the tough questions will come to the fore and give Islamic finance an opportunity to really influence the international investment climate. The following issues should perhaps be addressed: shall the hyper investment flow in mega real estate projects/trophy buildings continue? Does it really serve the needs of a sustainable Islamic society? What role should the excess GCC liquidity play with regard to the current structural food crises and the yet-to- be-achieved food self reliance goal of many Third/ Fourth world countries? Why there are no Kyoto- protocol compliant investments in the Gulf area with just one notable exception? Healthcare and pharmaceuticals are an area where IFIs should take the lead whereas new sensible approaches to investments in basic infrastructure and heavy industry should characterize Islamic investments. Q: Finally, what were the factors that shaped your interest in Islamic fnance and what advice would you give to young people in Europe and the rest of the world thinking about a career in IF ? A: I started my professional life in a major international finance conglomerate but from the very beginning I felt that the conventional finance sector was unable to address many of the rising issues of contemporary society. More than ten years ago I started promoting ethical and microfinance programmes and thanks to my conventional background I quickly became a leading professional figure in this field. As an Arabist, a long-term visitor to the Middle East and practitioner of its culture, Islamic finance has been a natural output of my previous expertise. I also deeply believe that ethical finance is a natural market for Islamic products in all Western countries. Whereas a great number of assumptions are the same, what has been lost in the ethical finance world is the interest rate prohibition that has characterized the Mediaeval Christian world. In this sense the risk-sharing and riba-free policies on which the Islamic finance world hinges will strongly strengthen the case for Ethical finance in the West. Lastly, as ethical and financial inclusion issues are becoming central to the world financial agenda I think that is a safe bet for anyone with an interest in a financial career to make them an integral part of their professional background. INTERVIEW When West meets East... 15 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today Douglas Clark Johnson, CEO and Chief Investment Strategist, Calyx Financial Interviewed by Asif Hussein Home-market bias and supply-driven approach hinders Islamic Finance D ouglas Clark Johnson currently leads the development and management of Shariah- compliant products for the New York- based Calyx Financial which develops, markets, and manages offshore Shariah-compliant investment funds for a global clientele. He also supervises the firms global asset allocation strategies for internal and client use. He is also International Director for Muamalat Invest, the asset-management arm of Bank Muamalat Malaysia, one of the countrys largest Islamic institutions. Mr. Johnson is widely published on investment strategy and fund development topics. His contributions have been published by Euromoney, as well as in a number of Islamic finance trade publications. He holds dual Masters Degrees in Finance and International Affairs from Columbia University, with an emphasis on Asia and its capital markets. He also earned a Bachelors Degree in Finance from Georgetown University, and studied at Sophia University in Tokyo, Japan. Q: What prompted you to enter Islamic fund management? A: The evolution of our business really can be attributed to three factors. First, we were alarmed by the serious misunderstandings that exist in the West about the Islamic world, even among educated professionals. Second, we identified an industry gap for a firm to focus on institutional and institutional- scale investment efforts, primarily in non-traditional markets. And perhaps most importantly, its what our clients in the Middle East and Southeast Asia were asking us to do. This last point is a testimony to our longstanding ties to both regions. On a personal note, this has been one of the most rewarding journeys of my 20-plus years in the asset management business. It goes without saying that I have the support and commitment of some amazing colleagues. But surprisingly, the industry it self has been embracing of our work in ways that the conventional business has long since left behind. Whether it is in product design or sales strategy, countless peopleregulators and service providers among themdeserve credit for what weve accomplished to date. INTERVIEW 16 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 Q: How would you evaluate the performance of Calyx Financial in the Shariah-compliant fund management sector? Talking about track records out of context can be misleading, so suffice it to say that were confident in our ability to bring Wall Street expertise to the Islamic world. Other ways of evaluating performance might include our ability to make a contribution to the industry though our research-based commentaries, as well as our ability to build relationships that span a wealth of innovative opportunities for our clients. Im pleased that selected US colleagues have now come to us in partnership for co-branded Shariah- compliant funds and that our friends at Bank Muamalat Malaysia engage us in building their own business. Perhaps the best performance evaluation is the number of unsolicited queries on partnerships and joint business initiatives weve begun to receive. Its a kaleidoscope of activity that engages us twenty-four hours a day. Q: In which kind of investment funds do you invest monies? Our marquee fund is a Bahrain-authorized Islamic fund-of-funds program. We describe it as double Shariah because our own Shariah scholars help us to supervise investments in Shariah-compliant sub- funds. While primarily long-only equity, our fund does allocate to other asset classes, such as leasing, to help reduce overall portfolio volatility. Its objective is to provide a core, global holding for investors looking for low-risk, stable-return alternatives. The work we did in creating the fund-of-funds program has identified gaps in the Islamic fund universe, which we hope to help fill over time. Interestingly enough, many of our second-generation funds in development focus on Asia, including Indonesian infrastructure and Indian private-equity. Id like the industry to think of us as offering innovativebut not controversial investment products. We aim to offer Islamic funds that are competitive with the conventional universe on pricing, performance, and pedigree. Q: Any developments in the pipeline? My longstanding work as an investment strategist means that Im a visionary at heart, but sometimes have to reign in my enthusiasm. We dont measure success by size alonecertainly were not looking to be one of the biggest players in the business. My colleagues and I came out of those types of institutions. Rather, we aim to provide a high degree of service to a select group of institutions and institutional-scale clients. I believe our financial return to our own staff and venture backers will reflect that commitment over time. More to the point, if we can maintain our momentum, our hope is to open a small marketing and compliance office in Bahrain later this year to be as responsive as possible to our Gulf friends. Well pair that with added capabilities in Kuala Lumpur, given our burgeoning ties to Southeast Asia. Further, we may take advantage of cost efficiencies to open an analytical function in Colombo. Sri Lanka is within easy reach of all of our key markets. Q: How would you assess the growth of the Islamic fund management sector over the past few years and what do you expect of the future? The industryto the extent that you can define it has been opportunistic. Youd expect that in a high growth, emerging sector. In other words, firms have been asking, What can we do and how fast can we do it? Unfortunately, that has been largely a supply- driven approach, which has created far too many investment products that look similar to each other. The framework is shifting, though, to more client- responsive developments. A home-market bias among most Islamic investors meanwhile continues to prevent full globalization of the industry. The industry does have the benefit of using developments within the conventional space as a case study for many of its initiatives. For starters, we see a pairing of Islamic wealth management and asset management activities. Distribution and product development go hand-in-hand. Yet the focus on transaction business among the major Islamic players, such as sukuk and project finance deal flow, has yet to evolve to a focus on business segments driven by sustainable income streams. The obvious candidates are those supported by the wealth/asset management nexus. We also see more focus on investment strategy and portfolio analytics that are uniquely relevant to the Islamic investor in this context. INTERVIEW What hinders Islamic Finance... 17 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today By MKV Nair - Researcher, Monash University Malaysia Subprime Mortgage Crisis and Islamic Finance Introduction The subprime mortgage crisis, popularly known as the mortgage mess or mortgage meltdown, came to the worlds attention when a surge in US home foreclosures (repossessions) started in 2006 and spiralled seemingly out of control in 2007 and 2008. It triggered a national financial crisis that went global within two years. It has caused billions of dollars losses to banks and financial institutions that were involved in subprime lending. Besides, this crisis has plummeted stock markets across the globe. There is a substantial amount of criticism on the lack of regulatory monitoring and excessive interest rates in the conventional banking and financing system that contributed to the subprime mortgage crisis. What is prime and subprime mortgage? The main difference between prime and subprime mortgages in conventional banking lies in the risk profile of the borrower and the interest rates charged ANALYSIS 18 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 on them. Subprime mortgages are loans extended to high risk borrowers to purchase real estate property. Specifically, lenders differentiate among mortgage applicants by using loan risk grades based on factors such as their credit history, previous loan defaults or bankruptcy filings, debt-to-income (DTI) ratios, and the level of documentation provided by applicants to verify their income. Next, the lenders determine interest rates of a mortgage in a given risk grade based on the borrowers credit risk score, for example, the Fair, Isaac and Company (FICO) score, and the size of the down payment. Eligible borrowers for prime loans have a FICO credit score above 620, a debt-to-income ratio (DTI) not greater than 55 percent (meaning that not more than 55 percent of their net income pays for housing and other debt) and a combined loan-to-value (LTV) ratio of 90 percent, meaning that the borrower has to pay a minimum of 10 percent downpayment. Lenders charge the prevailing market interest rates to prime loan borrowers with lower credit risks. Generally, subprime lending encompasses a variety of credit instruments including subprime mortgages, subprime car loans and subprime credit cards, among others. Causes of subprime mortgage crisis Excessive interest rates led to subprime mortgage crisis There are many theories as to what led to the subprime mortgage into a crisis. Many experts and economists believe it came about through the combination of a number of factors in which subprime lending played a major part. One of the main factors is the interest rates charged on the subprime mortgage loans. Historically low interest rates were charged in the US for mortgage loans during the initial years of 2000. This was mainly to boost the American economy which was slowing down due to the Dot.Com crash and the September 11 attacks. The Federal Reserve Board (Fed) reduced short-term interest rates from about 6.5 percent to 1 percent. Former Chairman of the Fed, Alan Greenspan, admitted in 2007 that the housing bubble was fundamentally engendered by the decline in real long-term interest rates. Many subprime mortgages were Adjustable Rate Mortgages (ARMs) in which the interest rates are subjected to revisions when the market interest rates increase. Besides that an estimated one-third of ARMs originating between 2004 and 2006 had teaser rates below 4 percent. A teaser rate is very low but for a temporary period only and would increase significantly after the initial honeymoon period. These increases can sometimes be doubling the monthly repayment amount. The subprime borrowers were literally trapped in this tricky interest rate arrangement. Initially the borrowers found the interest rates to be well affordable for their income level, but when the ARMs were revised to higher rates the borrowers had no other choice than to default in their repayments. This situation certainly could not have happened in the Islamic financing system. Islamic finance is defined as a financial system based on Islamic law known as Shariah. Islamic finance is limited to financial relationships involving entrepreneurial investment subject to the moral prohibition of (i) interest earnings or usury (riba) on money lending, (ii) haram (sinful activity), such as direct or indirect association with lines of businesses involving alcohol, pork products, firearms, tobacco, and vulgar entertainment, (iii) speculation, betting, and gambling (maisir), including the speculative trade or exchange of money for debt without an underlying asset transfer, (iv) the trading of the same object between buyer and seller (bay al inah), as well as (v) preventable uncertainty (gharar) such as all financial derivative instruments, forwarding contracts, and future agreements. As opposed to conventional finance, where interest represents the contractible cost for funds tied to the amount of principal over a lending period, the central tenet of the Islamic financial system is the prohibition of riba (the interest earnings), meaning an excess which is interpreted as any unjustifiable increase of capital through loans. The general consensus among Islamic scholars is that riba covers not only usury but also the charging of interest and any positive, fixed predetermined rate of return that are guaranteed regardless of the performance of an investment. Since only interest-free forms of finance are considered permissible in Islamic finance, financial relationships between financiers and borrowers are governed by shared business risk (and returns) from investment in lawful activities (halal). The participants in banking transactions are considered business partners who jointly bear the risks and profits. The transfer of ANALYSIS Subprime Crisis... 19 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today funds from clients to the bank (depositing) is based on revenue-sharing usually calculated ex post on a monthly basis and the transfer of funds from the bank to the clients is based on profit-sharing (lending, financing), either at a mutually agreed-upon ratio mudarabah or at a mutually agreed-upon fixed rate. The word mudarabah means a profit sharing partnership in which one contributes the capital (bank) and the other (customer) manages the project. Islamic banks finance only real transactions with underlying assets. Speculative investments such as margin trading and derivatives transactions are prohibited. Lending, or financing, must be backed by collateral. Collateral-free lending would normally be considered as containing a speculative element or moral hazard. Similarly, to avoid speculation and moral hazard, only investors with sufficient level of income can qualify for financing. Islamic law does not object to payment for the use of an asset, and the earning of profits or returns from assets are indeed encouraged as long as both lender and borrower share the investment risk together. Profits must not be guaranteed based on assumption and can only accrue if the investment itself yields income. Any financial transaction under Islamic law assigns to investors clearly identifiable rights and obligations for which they are entitled to receive commensurate return. While the elimination of interest is fundamental to Islamic finance, Shariah compliant investment behaviour also aims to eliminate exploitation pursuant to Islamic law. The emergence of securitization led to subprime mortgage crisis The emergence of innovative lenders who are the non-banking and non government agency lenders is another factor that has caused the subprime mortgage crisis. These lenders are not regulated as the traditional banks. They invented new methods of mortgage lending through securitization. The securitization can be defined as a structured finance process in which assets, receivables or financial instruments are acquired, classified into pools and offered as collateral for third-party investment. In this new mortgage process the banks and lending institution lend money to home a buyer from extended funding by selling the mortgage documents to third party investors in the security and bond markets through issuers as Mortgage Backed Securities (MBSs) or as Collateralized Debt Obligations (CDOs). The securitization of mortgage loans is a complex and multistage activity that involves a number of different players along the entire process. Shariah principles prohibit selling a debt against a debt. In Islamic financing the permissibility of risky capital investment without explicit interest earning has spawned several finance techniques under Islamic law. There are three basic forms of Islamic financing methods for both investment and trade finance: (i) synthetic loans (debt-based) through a sale-repurchase agreement or back-to-back sale of borrower or third party-held assets, (ii) lease contracts (asset-based) through a sale-leaseback agreement (operating lease) or the lease of third-party acquired assets with purchase obligation components (financing lease), and (iii) profit-sharing contracts (equity-based) of future assets. As opposed to equity-based contracts, both debt-based and asset-based contracts are initiated by a temporary transfer of existing assets from the borrower to the lender or the acquisition of third-party assets by the lender on behalf of the borrower. However, this does not mean that securitization is totally prohibited in the Islamic financing system. There is permissible securitization in Islamic law, where the ownership of an asset is effectively divided into pieces and distributed in a manner similar to shares in a mutual fund. This is distinct from an Islamically non-permissible securitization of cash flows whereby investors might buy shares of interest, principal, both or margin as compared to what is based on markup interest in the conventional financing system. In the recent developments with Freddie Mac, an ijara wa iqtina (mean leasing and acquisition and it is variably called ijara muntahi bitamlik, leasing ending in ownership or lease to own) process has been securitized. In this case, the obligations of the lessee have been structured into a note by the holder and sold to Freddie Mac and the holder of the ANALYSIS Subprime Crisis... 20 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 property has granted a mortgage to secure the note. If in the Islamic perspective, the note represents an aspect of property ownership, then the relationship is permissible. Other factors that led to subprime mortgage crisis There are two other factors that led mortgage lending into a crisis. They are the act of predatory lending and predatory borrowing. Predatory lending is the practice of a lender deceptively convincing borrowers to agree to unfair and abusive loan terms, or systematically violating those terms in ways that make it difficult for the borrower to defend against. Other types of lending sometimes also referred to as predatory include payday loans, credit cards or other forms of consumer debt and overdraft loans, when the interest rates are considered unreasonably high. In predatory lending the lenders charge excessive interest rates, prepayment penalties for refinancing an existing mortgage and other forms of charging excessive fees by mortgaging the same loan many times. Predatory borrowing on the other hand is a fraudulent practice of the borrower who provides falsified income statements or lies about his income to be many times higher than the actual amount. These actions are totally prohibited in Islamic financing law. Islamic economic models emphasize fairness. This is reflected in the requirement that everyone involved in a transaction makes informed decisions and is not misled or cheated. On a macro-economic level, Islamic models aim at social justice and the economic prosperity of the whole community. Islam encourages and promotes the right of individuals to pursue personal economic wellbeing, but makes a clear distinction between what commercial activities are allowed and what are forbidden. For example, transactions involving gambling and other socially detrimental activities are strictly prohibited. Conclusion While the global economic system is being rattled by the US subprime mortgage crisis, the Islamic finance model may be the answer to this persistent economic turmoil. The current global economic crisis has opened many windows of opportunities for Islamic finance. This crisis is seen as a big opportunity for Islamic finance as it has the capacity and capability to bring stability to the economy. This global crisis which caused colossal financial loses running in billions of dollars, would have not occurred if the Islamic principles regarding mortgage backed securities (MBSs) and collateralized debt obligations (CDOs) were in vogue in the international financial market. Islamic bonds (sukuks), carrying unique structure features, cannot fall foul of a crisis such as subprime mortgage crisis. Subprime mortgages are backed by dubiously rated collateralized debt packages which subsequently precipitated a global credit crunch. It is the right time for the Islamic banking industry to present solutions to the global economic community in the wake of the crisis. The devastating subprime mortgage crisis would technically be unthinkable in the Islamic capital markets sector because it would be against Shariah principles to sell a debt against a debt. There is a very simple rule in Islamic trade, which clearly says that you cannot sell unless you possess. The present crisis has seen trillions of dollars trading without backing of assets. If such transactions followed the Islamic finance models it would have easily prevented the current economic crisis. ANALYSIS Subprime Crisis... 21 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today Rates For Advertising In Islamic Finance Today Unit Size Monthly Rate Annual Rate Double Page Spread 39cm x 26.5cm $ 2,500 $ 25,000 Full Page 18.5cm x 26.5cm $ 1,500 $ 15,000 Half Page (H) 18.5cm x 13cm $ 1,000 $ 10,000 Half Page (V) 8.8cm x 26.5cm $ 1,000 $ 10,000 Inner Front Cover 18.5cm x 26.5cm $ 2,000 $ 20,000 Inner Back Cover 18.5cm x 26.5 cm $ 1,800 $ 18,000 Back Cover Page 18.5cm x 26.5cm $ 2,500 $ 25,000 Our Readers Individuals : These are individuals who are either well versed in Islamic Banking & Financing or are looking for institutions that provide these services. Also, individuals who seek to enhance their knowledge and undertanding of what IB&F is all about. Institutions : These are Banks, Financial Institutions, Companies which are looking at a specific medium to create awareness and disseminate information of their products and services to a select target audience. They would also refer to IFT for updating and enhancing their knowledge on the latest trends, developments and challenges of the IB&F industry. How do we reach them Our Magazines are distributed to a select database of subscribers, advertisers, financial Institutions, universities, libraries, conferences and scholars. IFT is also sold through reputed International book chains. # 496, R.A.De. Mel Mawatha, Colombo 03, Sri Lanka. Tel : +94 112 555902 - 4 / 112 555511 Fax : +94 112 555905 / 6 Email : bashith@pioneer-publications.com www.pioneer-publications.com Islamic Finance Today (IFT) is a much sought after source of information on Islamic Banking & Finance because of its rich and varied content and reader - friendly style of presentation, layout & design. Todays Banking and Investment savvy readers want a fresh new approach. A source that is up-to-date, specific, resourceful, thought-sharing and thought-provoking, with an eye for useful and quality information where both theory and practice come together to speak to its audience in a unique way. The Magazine delivers a mix of scholarly articles, view points, news, tips & hints, industry trends and profiles relating to the Islamic Banking & Finance Industry. Our objective is to provide readers with the latest up-to-date information on the developments and growth potential of the industry. EN SU R IN G S R I C O M P L A H A A H
I N C E Rates For Advertising In Islamic Finance Today Unit Size Monthly Rate Annual Rate Double Page Spread 39cm x 26.5cm $ 2,500 $ 25,000 Full Page 18.5cm x 26.5cm $ 1,500 $ 15,000 Half Page (H) 18.5cm x 13cm $ 1,000 $ 10,000 Half Page (V) 8.8cm x 26.5cm $ 1,000 $ 10,000 Inner Front Cover 18.5cm x 26.5cm $ 2,000 $ 20,000 Inner Back Cover 18.5cm x 26.5 cm $ 1,800 $ 18,000 Back Cover Page 18.5cm x 26.5cm $ 2,500 $ 25,000 Our Readers Individuals : These are individuals who are either well versed in Islamic Banking & Financing or are looking for institutions that provide these services. Also, individuals who seek to enhance their knowledge and undertanding of what IB&F is all about. Institutions : These are Banks, Financial Institutions, Companies which are looking at a specific medium to create awareness and disseminate information of their products and services to a select target audience. They would also refer to IFT for updating and enhancing their knowledge on the latest trends, developments and challenges of the IB&F industry. How do we reach them Our Magazines are distributed to a select database of subscribers, advertisers, financial Institutions, universities, libraries, conferences and scholars. IFT is also sold through reputed International book chains. # 496, R.A.De. Mel Mawatha, Colombo 03, Sri Lanka. Tel : +94 112 555902 - 4 / 112 555511 Fax : +94 112 555905 / 6 Email : bashith@pioneer-publications.com www.pioneer-publications.com Islamic Finance Today (IFT) is a much sought after source of information on Islamic Banking & Finance because of its rich and varied content and reader - friendly style of presentation, layout & design. Todays Banking and Investment savvy readers want a fresh new approach. A source that is up-to-date, specific, resourceful, thought-sharing and thought-provoking, with an eye for useful and quality information where both theory and practice come together to speak to its audience in a unique way. The Magazine delivers a mix of scholarly articles, view points, news, tips & hints, industry trends and profiles relating to the Islamic Banking & Finance Industry. Our objective is to provide readers with the latest up-to-date information on the developments and growth potential of the industry. EN SU R IN G S R I C O M P L A H A A H
I N C E Rates For Advertising In Islamic Finance Today Unit Size Monthly Rate Annual Rate Double Page Spread 39cm x 26.5cm $ 2,500 $ 25,000 Full Page 18.5cm x 26.5cm $ 1,500 $ 15,000 Half Page (H) 18.5cm x 13cm $ 1,000 $ 10,000 Half Page (V) 8.8cm x 26.5cm $ 1,000 $ 10,000 Inner Front Cover 18.5cm x 26.5cm $ 2,000 $ 20,000 Inner Back Cover 18.5cm x 26.5 cm $ 1,800 $ 18,000 Back Cover Page 18.5cm x 26.5cm $ 2,500 $ 25,000 Our Readers Individuals : These are individuals who are either well versed in Islamic Banking & Financing or are looking for institutions that provide these services. Also, individuals who seek to enhance their knowledge and undertanding of what IB&F is all about. Institutions : These are Banks, Financial Institutions, Companies which are looking at a specific medium to create awareness and disseminate information of their products and services to a select target audience. They would also refer to IFT for updating and enhancing their knowledge on the latest trends, developments and challenges of the IB&F industry. How do we reach them Our Magazines are distributed to a select database of subscribers, advertisers, financial Institutions, universities, libraries, conferences and scholars. IFT is also sold through reputed International book chains. # 496, R.A.De. Mel Mawatha, Colombo 03, Sri Lanka. Tel : +94 112 555902 - 4 / 112 555511 Fax : +94 112 555905 / 6 Email : bashith@pioneer-publications.com www.pioneer-publications.com Islamic Finance Today (IFT) is a much sought after source of information on Islamic Banking & Finance because of its rich and varied content and reader - friendly style of presentation, layout & design. Todays Banking and Investment savvy readers want a fresh new approach. A source that is up-to-date, specific, resourceful, thought-sharing and thought-provoking, with an eye for useful and quality information where both theory and practice come together to speak to its audience in a unique way. The Magazine delivers a mix of scholarly articles, view points, news, tips & hints, industry trends and profiles relating to the Islamic Banking & Finance Industry. Our objective is to provide readers with the latest up-to-date information on the developments and growth potential of the industry. EN SU R IN G S R I C O M P L A N C H A A H
I E MOHAMMED ROBBANI - INSIF The Institute of Islamic Finance London THE SUBTLE NATURE OF RIBA It is a common practice to equate the English word Interest with the ancient Arabic word Riba. However, this simple correlation disregards the subtle nature of Riba THE TERMS INTEREST AND RIBA ARE NOT ENTIRELY SYNONYMOUS
The meaning & definition of Interest appropriate for our purposes is the one in common use, which happens to be a surcharge on the repayment of debt (borrowed money), rent paid for the use of money, The fee charged by a lender to a borrower for the use of borrowed money, etc. That is: a monetary charge applied for the use of money (the surcharge, rent or fee is money exchanged for more money in lieu of foregoing the use of the money by the lender and is stipulated in the lending agreement/contract either before or after the commencement of the loan). The meaning & definition of Riba shows that a monetary charge applied for the use of money (i.e. Interest) falls within the sphere of Riba and therefore, the payment and receipt of Interest is forbidden. However, although Interest is Riba, Riba is not restricted to just Interest and has a much wider sphere. Therefore, the terms Riba and Interest are not entirely synonymous, and although they are both forbidden, we should cease confusing one for the other as they both have other disparate meanings. What is required here and in general is for us to understand the proper definitions of both Arabic and English words and make clear the differentiations between the words and not confuse them. This will greatly help in understanding the subject of Riba and many other topics related to Islamic law. RIBA IS NOT JUST USURY Usury is simply the rate of Interest which the law of the land has deemed to be excessive (and thus in some countries, illegal) therefore it is Riba. However, some people believe that because extremely low rates of Interest are not usurious, therefore this low-rate Interest is not Riba. This is a fallacious argument because even a minute rate of interest is still a monetary charge for the use of money and is an excess on top of the loan principal/debt obligation. This clearly makes it Ribawi. IN-DEPTH 24 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 IS COMPENSATION FOR INFLATION RIBA? Inflation, in this context, is the depreciation of the purchasing power of a specific amount of money: measured at two (start & end) points of time (in the same currency and economic/regulatory zone) by purchasing the SAME products of the same quality and inherent (non-monetary) value at both time points. Some amongst the Fuqaha argue that a lender lends money knowing that there could be an inflationary loss, so why should they be compensated for Inflation? A few maintain the view that any payments to compensate for inflation is Riba. Inflationary loss: the argument that lenders know that they could suffer inflationary loss and thus should not be compensated is negated if the lender agrees to lend on the basis that the full return of his principal must include compensation for any inflationary loss. This leads to our second point. The view that compensation for inflation is Riba: a very simple definition of Riba is that it is an excess over (on top of) the loan principal. Compensation for inflation is merely making up the loan principal to its original value (when it was lent) and is not an excess over it. Thus, compensation for inflation is not Riba. The contention here is that by ascertaining the true economic value of a specific amount of money at the start and end time points, we can be fair and just when returning any money borrowed at the start point. If at the end point (when repaying the loan principal), there is a reduction of the purchasing power of the amount of money borrowed at the start point, then the true economic value of the amount borrowed at the start point is also reduced at the end point. Thus, we should make-up this deficit of both purchasing power and economic value when returning the amount borrowed/owed to the lender/creditor so that they receive EXACTLY (and not anything more or less than) what they lent - otherwise the lender/ creditor will suffer an unjust loss. Consider the following: what if the loan payback time is not adhered to by the borrower and becomes an extraordinarily long period or if the economic situation of the country is such that it results in rapid increases in prices of goods and/or a forced devaluation of the national currency what then? For instance (an extreme example): a person lends 10 to another person for 1 month, 100 years ago - but the borrower did not repay that money. Now, 100 years later, one of the lenders descendents finds proof of the loan and asks one of the borrowers descendents to pay back the loan (who agrees to do so). Is it fair and justified for the borrowers descendent to repay just 10 or should he consider the fact that the value of 10, 100 years ago is actually the same as, say 1,000 at present time? In that case, should he repay 10 or 1,000? Should the lenders descendent accept a potential (real) loss of 900? Remember, he is not asking for any profits (an increase on the loan principal), just that the lost value over time of the loan principal is made up. To reiterate: a monetary charge for the use of money (i.e. Interest) is not being asked for - simply that the full value of the original money is returned. Now, if the value of the loan principal itself depreciates over time, then asking the borrower to make-up for this depreciation ONLY (i.e. as long as the lender does not profit from this compensation) is fair and justified, but anything over and above the depreciatory compensation amount is Riba and thus forbidden. In the above example, as this was not a trade transaction (therefore taking a risk in losing his [the lenders] money was not part of the transaction), but a short-term loan transaction (which became severely delinquent), the lender is entitled to get his full principal back (in terms of the purchasing power and economic value). The contention here is that refusing to make-up the lenders loss is actually a form of Zulm in itself as it denies the lender the return of his full principal. Some people accept the above argument but insist on calling this compensation for the reduction of purchasing power Nominal Interest. This is incorrect and we should cease calling it by this name. Nominal Interest does not take into account the effects of inflation, but it is still an additional charge on a loan principal/debt obligation (i.e. direct Interest) and thus it is forbidden. Whereas Real Interest does take into account the effects of inflation [Real Interest = Nominal Interest - Inflation], and it is also an additional charge on a loan principal/debt obligation but with inflation taken into account (i.e. it is inflation adjusted Interest) and thus it is also forbidden. IN-DEPTH Subtle nature of riba... 25 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today Only the inflation component is not forbidden because it is not an additional (an excess or an increase) over and above the loan principal or the debt obligation. To avoid any such confusion, we should compensate for the reduction of purchasing power (of a given sum of money over a given period of time) caused by the inflation of prices within an agreed economic & regulatory zone, on a completely independent and separate basis when writing lending/borrowing agreements and not include it with any other agreements. We should also give this compensation an independent name which will not give the impression that it is linked to Interest. COMPONENTS OF INTEREST Some people break-down Interest into various components and say that this part is Halal and that part is Halal and that only this small particular part is probably Riba. They use this complex and detailed argument to assert the view that the entire Interest charge cannot be therefore, considered Ribawi. We should accept this argument to a certain extent. A modern day Interest charge has included within it a profit margin for the lender and no matter how small this profit margin is - it is this that is regarded as pure Riba (see the above). However, it is true that a typical Interest charge is composed of several components and that individually and separately, almost all of them may be allowed (Halal or Mubah). However, the problem arises when all of these allowed components are combined together as a single charge, because then, the payer does not know how much he is paying for what component (how much is legitimate administration costs? How much is compensation for inflation and on what basis is this calculated?). As a consequence, the entire composition becomes subject to extreme Gharar and may be considered invalid. The way to avoid this Gharar is to separate out and to have individually negotiated agreements for each allowed component. THE COMMIXTURE EFFECT Furthermore, if these allowed components are mixed with the disallowed profit margin component then the COMMIXTURE EFFECT comes into play, where: If anything that is Haraam is mixed (even by an extremely minute quantity) with anything that is Halal (or even Mubah, neutral) - then this renders the entire thing Haraam. This applies to the modern day Interest charge because the allowed aspects of it are mixed with the Ribawi aspects thus making the entire Interest charge Haraam. Once this commixture effect is fully appreciated, then the argument that Interest=Riba can be seen in its proper context. Without going too much into this argument, we can use an analogy to further illustrate this point. Wine is forbidden in its entirety because it intoxicates. However, its constituents are Halal. Wine is made with grapes, water and sugar. Individually, none of the ingredients are specifically forbidden - but the end result (i.e. an intoxicating drink) is forbidden because it is now something that intoxicates when drunk (even if it doesnt intoxicate, since it has the power to intoxicate then even a drop of it is just as forbidden as a whole bottle). Similarly, an Interest charge is forbidden in its entirety because some integral parts of it are equal to Riba. However, as stated, most of the constituents of Interest (such as the creditors operational costs, inflation adjustments, etc) are individually and separately allowed - but the end result (i.e. a higher value stipulated as a pre-condition to the agreement to exchange or subsequent to the conclusion of the exchange, i.e. an Interest charge) is forbidden because of the inclusion of one component the direct profit a creditor charges as compensation for it not having the use of the money. If the direct profit component was removed the Interest charge itself would not be direct Riba. However, it still cannot be demanded by the creditor, but requested with full & proper explanation as to why the additional charge is justified (in Shariah). If the borrower does not accept the reasons the creditor can opt not to lend to the borrower. Thus, we have to look at the constituents and also the end product of any given transaction - and not take something out of its contextual environment - before making judgements on it. Hence, breaking down Interest to Halal components and saying that as a result, Interest itself is Halal is IN-DEPTH Subtle nature of riba... 26 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 akin to saying that since grapes, water and sugar are Halal wine itself therefore, is also Halal (thus exposing the fallacy of such arguments). This point nullifies most arguments against the Interest=Riba position as the Interest that is Riba is not things such as operational costs, compensation for Inflation, etc but simply the direct profit a creditor charges as compensation for not having the use of the money. This compensation is usually stipulated/ demanded by the creditor as a pre-condition to the agreement to exchange or subsequent to the conclusion of the exchange thus bringing Interest into the sphere of Riba. RIBA IN NON-MUSLIM COUNTRIES AND BETWEEN MUSLIMS & NON-MUSLIMS There is an argument from some people that it is permissible to engage in Ribawi activities if it is between Muslims and Non-Muslims and/or if done so in a non-Muslim country (Dar Al-Harb). However, this argument is based primarily on activities of the Prophets (pbuh) uncle, Abbas ibn Abd al-Muttalib. The contention is that after he became a Muslim, Al-Abbas remained in Makkah (which, at that time, was still under the non-Muslims) and engaged in Ribawi transaction with some of the non-Muslims of Makkah. Even after the prohibition against Riba became effective, Al-Abbas Ribawi transitions remained in force. It was only during the final sermon did the Prophet cancel these Ribawi transactions. However, this argument is considered as factually incorrect. It has been counter-argued by some prominent scholars that Al-Abbas did not deal in Riba after he became a Muslim, but of course, dealt with it before. Mufti Taqi Usmani stated: Before embracing Islam he [Al-Abbas] used to advance loans on the basis of interest and his debtors owed him huge amounts. It seems that after the conquest of Makkah he migrated to Madinah and could not settle his transactions with his debtors. Therefore, when he travelled for Hajj along with Holy Prophet, Sall-Allahu alayhi wa sallam, it was the first occasion when he could settle his transactions, hence, the Holy Prophet, Sall-Allahu alayhi wa sallam, declared that the whole amount of riba payable to his uncle Abbas, Radi-Allahu anhu, was void and no more payable. The words first riba occurring in this declaration do not mean that no riba was declared void before it. What it means is simply that this is the first amount of riba which is being declared as void at that occasion of the last sermon Thus, according to Mufti Usmani, the Ribawi transactions Al-Abbas entered into was before he IN-DEPTH Subtle nature of riba... 27 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today became a Muslim. This point is also made apparent when we look at what the Prophet actually said (admittedly, the translation may be imperfect): All of the Riba of jahiliyya is annulled. The first Riba that I annul is our Riba, that accruing to Abbas ibn Abd al- Muttalib [the Prophets uncle]; it is being cancelled completely. When we look at this statement closely, we see that the Prophet is cancelling all Riba transactions (starting with that of Al-Abbas) that occurred during the period of ignorance (in general and of Al-Abbas) - not after the establishment of Islam. This is a critical point. Anyway, even if we do not agree with this argument it must be agreed that there is serious scholarly disagreement on this matter, thus we should not use the Al-Abbas argument to allow Ribawi transactions between Muslims and Non-Muslims and/or in a non- Muslim country (Dar Al-Harb). The Riba is allowed in a Dar Al-Harb argument has two other dimensions: [1] It is contended that since the final verses of the Quran relating to the prohibition of Riba were revealed after the battles of Taif and Hunayn, the final prohibition of Riba only came into force after these lands entered under the Muslim state through their allegiance and acceptance of Islam. Therefore, Riba was allowed between Dar A-Islam and Dar Al- Harb up until the Dar Al-Harb became Dar Al-Islam (at which point the Riba prohibition came into force). Hence, it is OK to engage in Ribawi transactions even now with countries that are not part of Dar Al- Islam. This argument is flawed as it is counter-argued by some prominent scholars that since Riba had become an essential constituent of the Arabian society, an immediate order of prohibition right from the start would have created immense social and economic problems and would have impeded the growth of Islam. God therefore, adopted a gradual way to eliminate it by starting with discouragement and condemnation of Riba (verse 39 of Surat Ar-Rum) to the final, clear & strong prohibition (verses 275 to 279 of Surat Al- Baqarah). Mufti Usmani points out that: ...It was a time when large number of Arab tribes were entering the fold of Islam throughout the peninsula. The practice of riba was rampant among them and it was apprehended that they would continue claiming the amounts of usury from one another [unless a strong & clear prohibition was made]therefore, the Holy Prophet, Sall-Allahu alayhi wa sallam [during the last sermon], deemed it fit to announce not only the [complete] prohibition of riba but also that all the previous transactions of riba will no more be honored. It was in this context that he declared the amounts of riba payable to his uncle Abbas ibn Abdul Muttalib, Radi-Allahu anhu, as void. If we look at the verses prohibiting Al-Khamr for example, they become more forceful as Islam became more established - as newly reverted Muslims may have found it difficult to suddenly give up something they loved so much. The same principle was applied to Riba. [2] It is also contended that some scholars of the Hanafi school stated that since a Muslim has entered or was living in a non-Muslim country with a promise of interacting safely and with civility, it is then only permissible for him to ...obtain their property by means that they deem lawful..... Textual constraints would then only allow dealing in Riba, as opposed to selling alcohol or pork for example. There are 2 problems here. 1) although Muslims can lawfully seize the property of the vanquished, the property has to be that which in itself is allowed for Muslims. Now, if we say that Riba is allowed for Muslims under certain circumstances, then we need to provide the explicit evidence for it. Since there are no such evidence but only indirect inferences made from the primary sources, this becomes a problem 2) as given the choice between explicit evidence (Quran and many Sahih Hadiths) in support of the clear universal prohibition of Riba versus indirect, inferred evidence for its permissibility in a Dar Al-Harb, the onus is on us to go with the explicit evidence. Furthermore, there are no real textual constraints that allow dealing in Riba in the scenarios described (if there were, proponents of such arguments would have proffered them by now). IN-DEPTH Subtle nature of riba... 28 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 NO RIBA ON COMMERCIAL LOANS ? There is an argument that commercial loans are not deemed to be loans from an Islamic perspective and that Riba is actually applicable to personal (consumptive) loans only. The argument continues that the definition of a loan according to the Fuqaha is charitable, and it is obvious that commercial banks have no charitable intent. Therefore, such loans are beyond the sphere of Riba. The counter- argument against this view is that if we take a look at verse 39 of Surah Al-Rum: Whatever you give of Riba bearing loans, so that your amount increases in the wealth of others, does not increase in the sight of God Then, (even if the original Arabic does not have the words Qard or Salaf in it) we can see from this verse that Riba applied to personal as well as commercial loans. How? well, Makkah was a bustling trading centre and many different types of people came to trade in its markets. Therefore, it is inconceivable that the Arabs (particularly in Makkah) engaged in only personal loans and did not have the idea of lending each other money to enable each other to carry out business transactions. Hence, it is most likely that the term the wealth of others stated by God, is a direct reference to business and trading activities of others because this was how wealth was generated in ancient Arabia (high salaried positions were virtually non-existent). CONCLUSION The subtle nature of Riba means that the Interest Riba equation is not a simple subject and the arguments provided above are a brief glimpse into this complex arena and are not exhaustive (there may be many more areas of research). However, thus far, one thing has stood the test of time and the various assaults on its foundations and that is no matter how one tries to find faults in the logic of the argument, the fact remains that after everything is said and done it is evident that modern day Interest is akin to Riba and thus it is forbidden by God Almighty for all of mankind (and Jinns). IN-DEPTH Subtle nature of riba... A Shari'ah Compliant - Pawn Broking System Al-Rahn Socially Responsible to make a difference Al-Rahn Pawning Centre offers a Shariah - compliant pawn broking system. For more details visit us or contact FIRST GLOBAL INVESTMENTS AL-RAHN PAWN BROKING CENTRE (A member firm of the First Global Group) TOTALLY ON NON INTEREST BASIS !!! Al-Rahn Al-RAHN PAWN BROKING R "Al-Rahn" Pawn Broking Centre First Global Investments 95, Ven S. Mahinda Mawatha, Colombo 10. (Formerly Avondale Road) (P) 4870237, 4602165 (F) 4602165 (E) alrahn@firstglobal-group.com www.firstglobal-group.com 29 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today BOOK REVIEW Introduction to Islamic Banking & Finance by Brian Ketell (2008) This comprehensive and yet concise handbook is a must-read for all those seeking to carve a niche for themselves in the Islamic banking and fnance industry. This invaluable work serves as both a frst-read for new entrants to the industry, as well as a handy reference book for practitioners. The author should be congratulated for this well written work which incorporates his several years of experience in both conventional and Islamic fnance, thereby enabling him to explain, in fairly simple language, the fundamental points of convergence and divergence between Islamic and conventional interest-based fnance. This is all the more important since many banking professionals still entertain the rather absurd notion that Islamic fnance is the same thing as mainstream, interest- based fnance and that only the name and form difers. As pointed out by the author, this stereotyped image is all too prevalent in the banking world and hence the need to debunk such assertions remains stronger than ever before. To start with the author gives a brief history of Islamic banking and fnance and draws our attention to the fact that the situation in the Christian world remained very similar during the mediaeval period when usury was banned and only the Jews were permitted to engage in usurious activities. He then goes on to give his readership the basic principles underlying Islamic banks and why they difer from conventional banks. As succinctly pointed out by the author the structure of an Islamic bank is radically diferent from its conventional counterpart. A conventional bank is primarily a borrower of funds on the one hand and a lender on the other. An Islamic bank, on the other hand, is a partner with its depositors as well as with entrepreneurs, sharing proft and loss on both sides of the balance sheet. Another distinction is that a conventional bank would not stop charging interest even if the deployment of its capital fails to bear proft for the entrepreneur, whereas an Islamic bank cannot claim proft if the outcome is a genuine loss. In the following pages the author proceeds to outline the legal basis for Islamic banking, based as it is on the Shariah and Islamic law before proceeding to defne what Islamic banking is all about including its emphasis on Proft and Loss Sharing and the rationale for banning interest. He then proceeds to deal in great detail with the various modes of Islamic fnance including Murabaha, Mudaraba, Musharaka, Ijara, Istisnaa , Salam before proceeding to cover Takaful or Islamic Insurance. What is most commendable is the authors detailed description of each area he covers, including the defnition of a particular product, what makes it Shariah-compliant, Shariah rules concerning it, the practicalities of implementing it, practical examples of its application and basic rules and other issues relating to the area covered. As commendable are the detailed appendices appended to the work including Worlds 100 largest Islamic Banks (including ranking, country, assets, fnancing, deposits, shareholder equity, operating income, operating expenses and net proft after tax and zakat) and Top 500 Islamic Financial Institutions (including type of institution, whether fully Islamic or Window, Shariah-compliant assets, pre-tax profts and return on assets). On the whole, a very valuable contribution to the Islamic banking and fnance industry that should considerably enhance the professionalism of those practitioners fortunate enough to lay their hands on a copy. Upcoming Islamic Finance Events 2008 August 11th-13th August MIF 2008 Issuers & Investors Forum at Mandarin Oriental, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, organized by Islamic Finance Events 25th August 2nd International Conference & Exhibition on Islamic Banking & Finance at Aiwan-e-Iqbal, Lahore, Pakistan, organized by Al- Huda Center of Islamic Banking & Economics. 25th-26th August Islamic Financial Markets, Indonesia, organized by Marcus Evans 25th-28th August - Islamic Finance & Investment World 2008 at Sandton Convention Centre, Johanesburg, South Africa, organized by Terrapinn October 7th-8th October Islamic Finance Congress at Melia White House, London, organized by IIR Conference 14th October Middle East Hedge Funds 2008 at Hotel Mandarin Oriental du Rhone, Geneva, Switzerland, organized by Jetfn Events 15th- 16th October Middle East Investors Summit 2008 at Emirates Towers Hotel, Dubai, UAE, organized by Worldwide Business Research 20th- 21st October Islamic Real Estate Investment, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, organized by Naseeba 21st October Islamic Private Equity, Dechert LLP, UK, organized by ICG Events November 2nd 4th November Islamic Funds World 2008 at Shangri-La, Dubai, UAE, organized by Terrapinn 3rd November The World Islamic Infrastructure Finance Conference. Doha, Qatar, organized by MEGA 4th-5th November 2nd Annual Islamic Capital Markets at Radisson Mayfair, London, organized by IFR Conferences December 1st-3rd December The World Islamic Banking Conference, Bahrain, organized by MEGA 14th-18th December Debt Capital Markets Summit in Dubai organized by IIR Middle East SUKUK Some Basic Facts S ukuk is a form of Shariah-compliant securitization which is gaining wide acceptance not only in Muslim states, but also in largely non-Muslim countries where it is seen as a very promising instrument to mobilize funds for economic development by government or public-related institutions. Sukuk could be said to have evolved due to the needs of Islamic Banks and Financial institutions to diversify their investments and for meeting their immediate liquidity requirements. The evolution of Sukuk and its phenomenal growth over the past few years as a secondary market tool could be said to have been facilitated by the fact that it is based on real assets and that it could be bought and sold. Sukuk is an Arabic term and is the plural of sakk which means a certificate This mode of financing involves the securitization of a tangible asset so that investors could share in its profits and risks for which purpose a certificate vesting ownership in such investors is issued. This would entitle investors to a portion of the income in proportion to their investment. Although often termed Islamic bonds Sukuk differs from a conventional bond in that there should be a true sale where the asset that has been sold should not remain in the books of the seller and should be transferred to the purchaser. Sukuk is of various types and includes Ijarah- based Sukuk, Istisna-based Sukuk, Salam- based Sukuk, Mudarabah-based Sukuk and Musharaka-based Sukuk. The most popular form of Sukuk is by far sukuk based on Ijarah (Islamic Leasing) due to its flexibility and the lower risk it entails since the asset is already in existence and the income more or less guaranteed from the leased assets, making it easier to convince investors that they will get some good returns from it. There are basically two types of Ijarah- based sukuk, namely, that which is based on the ownership of the underlying asset ( ijarah ayan) or that which is based on the sale of its usufruct (ijarah manafi). In ijarah manafi certificates are issued for the ownership of the usage of the asset and not the underlying asset itself. The returns from this type of investment come by way of the rent paid by the lessee which is distributed among the investors in proportion to their investment. In ijarah ayan, certificates are issued to investors conferring ownership of the underlying asset itself. Sovereign sukuks issued by states are normally of this type and comprise of the sale of public-related property such as airports, hospitals and schools to private investors. BASICS 34 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 Although there is unanimity as to the permissibility of sukuk by the Shariah scholars specializing in Islamic Banking & Finance, a controversy recently arose as to its permissibility following a highly sensationalized interview with a prominent Shariah scholar Mufti Taqi Usmani where he is reported to have stated that as much as 85 percent of the sukuks currently available in the market do not comply with Shariah requirements. All indications however are that he was misquoted and his statements taken out of context. In fact Mufti Usmani recently clarified his position at the Annual Shariah Conference organized by AAOIFI held in Bahrain from the 27th-28th May where he explained that he was referring to an undertaking in a Mudarabah or Musharakah-based sukuk where it is not allowed for any party to guarantee the performance of the sukuk. According to Dr.Burhan Arbouna, Head of Shariah Compliance, UIB and a well known scholar on Islamic Finance what often happens in Mudarabah- and Musharaka-based Sukuks is that there is some sort of undertaking to repurchase the asset in question at the nominal value which creates a Shariah compliance issue. He contends that in these types of transactions, if there is an undertaking to purchase depreciated assets at the nominal value rather than the market value of these assets where depreciation would inevitably be taken into consideration, it becomes a sort of riba-based guarantee which is prohibited in Islam. However this does not mean that all Mudarabah- and Musharakah-based Sukuks are non-Shariah compliant. What is necessary is that these should avoid undertaking to repurchase the assets at nominal value though an undertaking could be given to repurchase at market value. Sukuks are today a leading instrument for mobilizing funds by both governments and corporates. Malaysia has taken a lead in the issuance of Sukuk and has pioneered a number of unique and innovative Sukuks that show much promise for the future. Bahrain has also played a big role in the development of the Sukuk market on the basis of both Ijarah and Salam. In this connection the Bahrain-based Liquidity Management Center (LMC) has played a significant role in issuing, arranging and creating secondary markets for sukuk. Recent years have also seen a Sukuk issued by Kuwait Finance House based on Ijarah and Istisna and a Sukuk issued by Darul Arkan of Saudi Arabia which is lead arranged by Unicorn Investment Bank. Qatar too has issued a Sovereign Sukuk. These developments show that Sukuks are widely seen by governments as a promising tool to mobilize funds for public utility developments such as infrastructure development projects and by corporates as an instrument for tapping into the ready liquidity currently available in the Middle East and elsewhere. AAOIFI Standards for Sukuk have been in place for the past 5 years and it is likely that greater stringency will be needed as the industry progresses and expands to new areas. BASICS Sukuk... 35 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today Hong Kong will shortly be issuing its first Sukuk, thus boosting its ambition of becoming a leading financial centre in the region. The Citys Airport Authority, it is learnt, will take the lead in selling its first Islamic bond of up to $1 billion. The Hong Kong airport operator, according to the South China Morning Post was close to finalising arrangements for the sale of the Sukuk but was awaiting government approval for a tax exemption to enable the deal to comply with Islamic requirements. The main hurdle to be overcome for Islamic finance to take off is to modify the existing tax code where profits are taxed while interest income is not. Malaysia chosen as launching pad into Asian Islamic Finance Market Faisal Private Bank (Switzerland) SA, which is keen on expanding its activities in Southeast Asia, has selected Malaysia as its launch pad into the regions Islamic private banking market. First Sukuk from Hong Kong Alburaq launches new product in UK Alburaq has launched the UKs first Shariah-compliant capital protected savings plan as an alternative to a guaranteed equity bond. The product aims at giving investors access to uncapped returns linked to shares in 20 major companies, with capital protection. The minimum investment is 500 and the maximum 1m. Investment banking head, Giovanni Perin, announced that the bank will open a representative office here soon. We have been given the nod by the Swiss Federal Banking Commission to open a representative office here and we have just filed the documents with Bank Negara Malaysia for its approval, Perin told The Edge Financial Daily. The bank which is 79.6% owned by Bahrain-based Ithmaar Bank might also acquire strategic stakes in local financial institutions as part of its efforts to expand businesses. Indeed Faisal is said to have a genuine interest in using Malaysia as a platform to tap into other markets in the region, including Indonesia, Singapore and China. GLOBAL NEWS GLOBAL NEWS ROUND-UP 36 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 Indonesia is shortly expected to pass legislation to facilitate the growth of Islamic banking in the country. The proposed bill will permit foreigners to establish Shariah-compliant banks in partnership with Indonesian citizens or local entities. It would also offer more flexibility to commercial banks, thus facilitating their conversion into Islamic banks. According to the Central Bank of Indonesia, three local banks, the state-owned PT Bank Rakyat Indonesia (BRI) BBRI.JK, PT Bank Bukopin BBKP.JK and PT Bank Negara Indonesia Tbk (BNI) BBNI.JK plan to open Shariah-compliant units this year. According to analysts, the new law will strengthen the regulatory environment and pave the way for further expansion of Indonesias Islamic finance market. The potential for Islamic banking, finance and insurance remains vast as around 85 percent of Indonesias 226 million population is Muslim. Indonesia to boost Islamic Banking Fatwa for the People Egypts Al-Azhar University has issued a fatwa or religious edict ruling that the government should allocate some of its oil and gas wealth to the people, an edict which has won much popular acclaim, especially in a context where rising inflation, especially in food prices is bearing hard on ordinary peoples lives. The Islamic Research Centre of Cairos Al-Azhar issued the fatwa stating that it is a sacred duty to pay 20 percent of oil, gas and mineral revenues in the form of alms to the poor known as zakat which is one of the five pillars of Islam and an obligatory duty for all Muslims. The fatwa is based on a hadith (saying) of Prophet (Mohammed) which says that a zakat of 20 percent is obligatory on all metals and minerals, solid or liquid, Research Centre member and Al-Azhar teacher Mohammed Rafat Osman told Agence France-Presse. Egypts oil and gas exports amounted to 10.1 billion dollars in 2007, according to official figures. With crude oil reaching a record high of nearly 140 dollars a barrel last week, 2008 revenue is set to be still higher. Based on the 2007 figures, the governments annual alms payments should in theory amount to around two billion dollars. Despite its official growth rate of seven percent, it has been estimated that 40 percent of the population lives on or around the poverty line of two dollars a day. GLOBAL NEWS GLOBAL NEWS ROUND-UP 37 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today GLOBAL NEWS A prominent Indian lawmaker has called upon his country to promote Islamic banking as a participative investment option by taking a cue from the UK. Rajya Sabha Deputy Chairman K Rahman Khan said at a seminar on emergence of ethical investment organised by the Institute of Objective Studies and the Indo-Arab Economic Co-operation Forum that India should start Islamic investment on the lines of Bank of England, which has brought a regulatory mechanism for such ethical investment. India sadly lacks proper legislation in place to accommodate Islamic banking despite a Muslim minority comprising of nearly 14 percent of its approximately 1.12 billion population. In fact the country is home to the third largest Muslim population after Indonesia and Pakistan. However, the scope for Islamic investments in India remains vast. A recent survey showed that of 1,000 NSE listed companies, as many as 335 qualified on Shariah parameters. Calls for India to promote Islamic Banking 38 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 GLOBAL NEWS L anka ORIX Leasing Company PLC (LOLC), a leading Sri Lankan Financial Solutions Provider launched a range of Shariah-compliant financial products at a media conference held in Colombo recently. The entry of LOLC into the arena of Islamic Financing is likely to add momentum to the growth of the industry due to its strategically placed branch network which should allow easy access to potential clients. The new Islamic Business Unit (IBU) of LOLC will offer Ijarah (Leasing), Murabaha (Trade Financing), Mudarabah (Profit Sharing Investments) and Diminishing Musharakah T he Aligarh Muslim University, a leading Islamic university in India plans on offering a course on Islamic Banking and Finance leading to a Post Graduate Diploma from the next academic year. This is the outcome of a recent meeting Vice Chancellor, Professor P K Abdul Azis had with a team of experts comprising of Dr. Mohammad Nejatullah Siddiqui, former AMU Professor and a well known expert on Islamic Banking and Finance, Mr. Sayed Mohammad Beary and Dr. Shariq Nisar of Bearys Amnah Investments Pvt. Ltd., Bangalore. The meeting noted the rapid changes taking place in the Banking arena both within India and abroad, which is fast moving towards Shariah-based Banking and Finance operations. The presence of a number LOLC Launches Shariah compliant financing Aligarh University to commence Islamic Finance courses shortly (Property Financing). The Unit has its own dedicated team led by two well known local Shariah scholars, namely Sheikh Fazil Farook and Sheikh Murshid Mulaffar who are executive members of the All Ceylon Jamiyatul Ulama, the apex religious body of Islamic scholars in the country. It is also supported with the necessary infrastructure including separate IT, Documentation and Financial Accounting complying with strict Shariah standards. It also has its own brand identity, namely LOLC Al-Falaah which is derived from the Arabic term for success- Falaah. of Banking Enterprises in India working on Islamic Banking principles, the rapid growth of the industry and the great employment potential it shows were among the factors that prompted the university to consider offering the Diploma. The university is also considering the possibility of establishing a new Department dedicated to Islamic Banking and Finance. A high powered committee consisting of Dr. Mohammad Nejatullah Siddiqui (Chairman), Dr. Shariq Nisar (Bearys Amnah Investments Pvt. Ltd., Bangalore) and Dr. Javed Akhtar, Chairman, Department of Business Administration, AMU has been constituted to prepare a detailed proposal for commencing the programme. 39 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today KNOW IT ALL - A remarkable success Know It All a 2-day Seminar & Workshop on Islamic Banking, Finance & Takaful held on the 7th-8th June 2008 at the TransAsia Hotel was an immense success according to its organisers. This landmark event was organized by the First Global Knowledge Center (FGKC), a leading event manager and franchisee of Islamic Banking and Finance study courses in Sri Lanka and a subsidiary of the First Global Group, an emerging player in the local and global Islamic Finance industry which is involved in a number of areas connected with Islamic banking and fnance. The programme was organized by FGKC taking into consideration the success of previous events of this nature and the tremendous popular demand for such programmes on the part of students, accountants and banking professionals. Over 150 participants attended the seminar which included students of Islamic Banking and Finance, Accounting, Legal and Tax Advisory frms and Banking and Insurance frms such as BoC, NTB, HDFC and Amana Takaful. The programme was conducted by eminent personnel of international repute. Namely, Sheikh Esam Ishaq who is a renowned scholar from the Middle East represented in a number of Shariah Supervisory Boards of Islamic banks and fnancial institutions worldwide, Dr. Mohammed Burhan Arbouna, Shariah Advisor of United International Bank of Bahrain and a well-known tutor on Islamic Banking and Finance and Mr. Muhammed Ikram Thowfeek, a start-up specialist in setting up Islamic banks and fnancial institutions and a much sought after speaker at various international forums. The seminar sought to instill in students an understanding of the principles of Islam that are relevant to Islamic banking products and services, a familiarity with the full range of Islamic products and services, a grounding on how Islamic banks earn profts and distribute them among shareholders, depositors and investors and a training on how to create new markets with Islamic Financial Products. The topics dealt with included Introduction and background of Islamic Banking, Islamic Banking Modes of Financing such as Murabaha, Ijara and Ijara Muntahia Bittamleek, Instruments of equity investment such as Musharaka and Mudaraba ventures, Loan and its application by Islamic Banks and Islamic Insurance which is commonly known as Takaful. These subjects were dealt in detail from a practitioners perspective with the speakers sharing with the participants their knowledge and experience gathered over the years in the feld of Islamic banking. The panel discussions where the speakers answered and clarifed questions raised by the participants on various issues relating to the industry was particularly well appreciated. FGKC plans to have a follow up programme titled Know it Beyond which will deal with a variety of topics connected with Islamic Banking, Finance & Insurance in greater detail during the latter part of this year. First Global Investors Forum 2008 First Global Investments Holdings Ltd, an emerging player in Sri Lankan Islamic Financial market had its frst Investors Forum at the Trans Asia Hotel Colombo on the 6th June 2008. The objective of the Forum was to create an awareness among investors of the immense investment potential in the Islamic Financial industry with special emphasis on Sukuk or Islamic Securitization. A number of speakers addressed the this ground breaking event including Sheikh Esam Ishaq, Chairman of the Shariah Board of First Global who spoke on Islamic Capital Market Structure, Mr.Ikram Thowfeek, Founder and Managing Director, First Global who delved on First Globals Journey to success and Mr.Sabri Abdul Cader, Senior Vice President, First Global who outlined the potential for Sukuk in the local market and First Globals role in it. First Global Investments is currently working to secure mandates to raise USD 300 Million through the issuance of Sukuk. Founder and Managing Director of First Global Investments, Mr. Ikram Thowfeek said that FGIs objective is to bring FDI in to Sri Lanka through Islamic Banking. The Sukuk to be issued will go up to Rs.1 Billion, and will be open for review with a portfolio extending up to 3 years or 5 years, he said. He further explained that building credibility is the key diferentiation for any player providing Islamic fnancial services and commencing June 30, 2008 they hoped to raise capital up to USD 10 Million in two phases, with USD 5 Million in each. In this connection, First Global has joined with Investec Capital (Pvt) Ltd to act as lead arrangers to issue the frst Sri Lankan Sukuk to Peoples Leasing Company Limited Islamic Finance Services Unit. Deutsche Bank AG, Colombo Branch would be appointed the trustee to manage the trust on behalf of the investors. First Global will also act as the Structuring Advisor along with Investec and as Shariah Advisor to the transaction. Sukuk or Islamic fxed income securities have emerged over the years as an increasingly important and most promising asset class. This instrument serves a number of objectives, among them, enabling organizations to raise capital in a Shariah compliant manner, expanding the investor base, ofering investment opportunities to new groups and the ability to be structured in a number of increasingly complex ways. In short, it has become a widely accepted and most promising asset class, not only in Muslim countries, but also in non-Muslim countries which have resorted to it in a big way to raise monies from investors, particularly those based in the Middle East. Know your Institution Islamic Development Bank The Islamic Development Bank (IDB) is a multi-lateral development financial institution established to foster the economic development and social progress of its member countries and Muslim communities in non-member countries in accordance with the principles of Shariah (Islamic Law). The IDB was established in pursuance of the Declaration of Intent issued by the Conference of Finance Ministers of Muslim Countries held in Jeddah in December 1973 and the Bank formally commenced operations in October 1975. The Banks principal office is in Jeddah in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Two regional offices were opened in 1994; one in Rabat, Morocco, and the other in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. An IDB Representative Office at Almaty, Kazakhstan, to serve as a link between IDB member countries and Central Asian Republics became operational in July 1997 and is now a full-fledged Regional Office. The Bank also has field representatives in eleven member countries. These are: Indonesia, Iran, Kazakhstan, Libya, Pakistan, Senegal, Sudan, Gambia, Guinea Bissau, Mauritania and Algeria. The present membership of the Bank consists of 56 countries. The basic condition for membership is that the prospective member country should be a member of the Organization of the Islamic Conference, pay its contribution to the capital of the Bank and be willing to accept such terms and conditions as may be decided upon by the IDB Board of Governors. Among the functions of the Bank is to participate in equity capital and grant loans for productive projects and enterprises besides providing financial assistance to member countries in other forms for economic and social development. The Bank is also required PROFILE 42 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 Know your Scholar Sheikh Muhammed Al Bashir Al Amine Sheikh Muhammed Al Bashir Muhammad Al Amine is a renowned scholar on Islamic Banking and Finance. He is currently Shariah Compliance Department Manager at Unicorn Investment Bank - Bahrain and a Member of the Shariah Supervisory Board of First Global Investments Holdings- Sri Lanka. He was formerly the Head of Product Development and Shariah Compliance at International Islamic Financial Market. He holds a Ph.D in Laws from the International Islamic University Malaysia and a Bachelor of Shariah from the University of Medina, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. He is a Lecturer and Researcher at the International Islamic University of Malaysia and an author, who is published extensively on Islamic banking and finance in several renowned journals including the Arab Law Quarterly, International Journal of Islamic Financial Services and Islamic Finance Today. He is also a speaker in various international forums. to establish and operate special funds for specific purposes including a fund for assistance to Muslim communities in non-member countries, in addition to setting up trust funds. The Bank is authorized to accept deposits and to mobilize financial resources through Shariah compatible modes. It is also charged with the responsibility of assisting in the promotion of foreign trade especially in capital goods, among member countries; providing technical assistance to member countries; and extending training facilities for personnel engaged in development activities in Muslim countries to conform to the Shariah. Among its member organizations are the Islamic Corporation for Insurance of Investments and Export Credits (ICIEC) which was established with the objective of enlarging the scope of trade transactions and investment flows among the member countries of the Organisation of Islamic Conference (OIC), Islamic Research and Training Institute (IRTI) established to help the Bank in discharging its functions in the fields of research and training, Islamic Corporation for the Development of the Private Sector (ICD) to complement IDB through the development and promotion of the private sector as a vehicle for economic growth and development in member countries and the International Islamic Trade Finance Corporation (ITFC) which was established to promote trade of the member countries of the Islamic Development Bank through providing trade finance and engaging in activities that facilitate intra-trade and international trade. PROFILE 43 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today Realisation of the Worlds First International Benchmark in Islamic finance TRAINING T here are several drivers behind the IFQ, but most notable are Muslims seeking to embrace their religious convictions in their financial transactions and the economic boom in the Middle East as a result of the rise in oil prices. BDL, as a banking regulator was well aware of the growth taking place in the Islamic finance industry and wanted to ensure that there were staff trained to deal competently with that growth; otherwise, investors would suffer, as would the reputation of the industry. A steering group chaired by Alain Balian, Vice Governor of the BDL, was created to oversee the development of the programme, and in August 2005, the Advisory Council for Islamic Finance, the committee responsible for the IFQs By Margaret Spong The idea of an Islamic fnance qualifcation was frst discussed in 2005, when the Banque du Liban (BDL) approached both ESA and SII with the idea of developing a fnance qualifcation underpinned by the tenets of Shariah law. As a result of these talks, the SII, with its experience in developing regulatory examinations, joined with the Beirut-based Ecole Superieure des Afaires (ESA), the leading business school in the MENA region and a leader in Islamic Finance qualifcation. 44 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 developments met for the first time. This is chaired by the first Vice Governor of the BDL, Dr Ahmad Jachi, and draws its members from leading Shariah scholars and practitioners based around the Gulf and the UK. With SII operating out of the UK a supporting panel of experts based in the UK was established to ensure that the programme would be relevant to UK firms engaged in Islamic finance. And while banks and finance houses come to mind as the main users of the new qualification, the IFQ also draws interest from accountancy and law firms engaged in providing services to financial institutions. In a Class of its Own In general, academic studies of Islamic finance tend to be provided through courses developed by one institution which draw on a relatively small number of experts and have a focus on theoretical debate. In contrast, at the inception of the qualification, 45 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today the decision was taken that the IFQ should provide new comers to the industry with a broad overview of the industry. And while it was vital that the IFQ would help readers understand the role of Shariah in Islamic finance and familiarize them with the ethics underpinning the contracts, the aim was a practical qualification that would help candidates in their work - in short, the worlds first ever global benchmark qualification to cover Islamic finance from both a technical product knowledge and a Shariah aspect. The syllabus, study text and examination for the IFQ have been created using experts drawn from around the globe. Further the IFQ is unique because it is a global benchmark examination available to candidates via Computer Based Testing (CBT), which means it can be studied and the examination taken in almost 100 centres around the world. Currently, candidates in some 29 countries as far apart as Australia and Denmark are preparing for the examination. In summary, the IFQ is unique because : There is no other qualification or unified standard practice which covers Islamic finance from both a technical and Shariah aspect which offers the degree of international portability and professional competence comparable to that offered by the IFQ. The IFQ provides the first international benchmark in the area of Islamic finance and it is aimed at existing employees and new employees as well as individuals seeking a career in Islamic finance. The IFQ is jobs-focused and requires candidates to demonstrate a practical understanding of Islamic finance as opposed to discussing academic and theoretical issues. The IFQ has drawn on many experts from a number of countries in its creation. Launching the IFQ The SIIs role in the introduction of the IFQ is best summarized by SII Managing Director Ruth Martin: Setting standards for practitioners is a vital part of any professional bodys remit. SII has been delighted to combine its expertise in both examinations development and professional standards to partner with ESA in the Middle East in this innovative new qualification aimed at helping practitioners grasp the fundamentals of Islamic finance and banking. The IFQ was launched in October 2006 by the then Lord Mayor of the City of London, Alderman Sir David Brewer, and the Governor of Lebanons Central Bank, Mr. Riad Salame, at an event attended by the then UK Economic Secretary to the Treasury, Mr. Ed Balls, and Vice Governors of Lebanons Central Bank. Mr.Alain Balian and Dr Ahmad Jachi. The launch generated considerable interest in the media, as it was noted that the workbook underpinning the examination was the worlds first ever handbook on practical Islamic finance and banking and so would be of interest to organisations already engaged in this area, or those thinking of moving into Islamic banking and finance, as a practical guide for their staff. Test time As a wholly new qualification, it was vital that the examination was pitched at the correct standard. Two pilot examinations were held in Beirut and London in November 2006 and January 2007. Candidates experience at these sessions provided feedback on the workbook and the examinations with the result that an amended workbook was published in January 2007 and the first global public sittings of the IFQ took place in March 2007. For candidates, a further benefit of a CBT examination is that they receive their results instantly and can rebook quickly if they have failed. The examination is a two-hour, 100 multiple choice question paper covering the basis of Islamic banking and finance; the Islamic Law of contracts; the major contracts of Mudaraba, Murabaha, Musharaka, Ijara, Salam and Istisna; financial statements for Islamic banks; Islamic corporate governance; Islamic asset and fund management; Sukuk and Takaful. Candidates are advised to spend around 100 hours studying for the examination and if candidates are non-Muslims and have no experience of Islamic finance, they are strongly recommended to attend a face-to-face training session. The pass mark for the examination is 70 percent and the pass rate is currently around 70 percent. The examination fee is 150 and the workbook costs 75. Candidates seeking a training course are advised to contact the Accredited Training Provider for details of fees and dates. Courtesy: Islamica TRAINING Islamic Finance Qualifcation... 46 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 DOW JONES INDEXES Dow Jones Indexes, a leading global index provider announced the results of the regular quarterly review of the Dow Jones Islamic Market (DJIM) Indexes. Dow Jones Islamic Market Global Index Dow Jones Islamic Market Regional Indexes DJIM World Index 216 422 Index # of Components ADDED # of Components DELETED The free-foat market capitalization of the reconstituted Dow Jones Islamic Market World Index decrease to US$15.49 trillion from US$16.54 trillion. The free-foat market capitalization of the reconstituted Dow Jones Islamic Market Regional Indexes: DJIM BRIC Equal Weighted Index : increased to US$2.58 trillion from US$2.49 trillion DJIM Asia/Pacifc Index : decreased to US$2.45 trillion from US$2.59 trillion DJIM Europe Index : decreased to US$3.69 trillion from US$4.03 trillion DJIM Americas Index : decreased to US$9.21 trillion from US$9.78 trillion Index # of Components ADDED # of Components DELETED DJIM BRIC Equal Weighted Index 7 13 Index 151 182 DJIM Europe Index 27 91 DJIM Americas Index 34 144 INDEXES 47 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today Dow Jones Islamic Market Country Indexes The free-foat market capitalization of the reconstituted Dow Jones Islamic Market Country Indexes : DJIM Amana Sri Lanka Index : increased to US$357 million from US$238 million DJIM China Ofshore Index : decreased to US$172 billion from US$213 billion DJIM Hong Kong Index : decreased to US$235 billion from US$245 billion DJIM India Index : decreased to US$315 billion from US$339 billion DJIM Indonesia Index : decreased to US$45 billion from US$46 billion DJIM Japan Index : decreased to US$987 billion from US$1108 billion DJIM Malaysia Index : increased to US$45 billion from US$38 billion DJIM Kuwait Index : decreased to US$25 billion from US$46 billion DJIM Singapore Index : decreased to US$64 billion from US$70 billion DJIM Turkey Index : increased to US$19 billion from US$14 billion DJIM U.K. Index : decreased to US$1.22 trillion from US$1.39 trillion DJIM U.S. Index : decreased to $8.10 trillion from $8.59 trillion Dow Jones-JS Pakistan Islamic Index : increased to US$5.25 billion from US$4.65 billion INDEXES 48 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008 Dow Jones Islamic Market Specialty Index The free-foat market capitalization of the reconstituted Dow Jones Islamic Market Sustainability Index decreased to US$4.66 trillion from US$5.08 trillion. Dow Jones Islamic Market Industry Indexes, other Dow Jones Islamic Market Country Indexes and other Dow Jones Islamic Market Global Indexes are also part of this regular quarterly review. The Dow Jones Islamic Market Titans Indexes are reviewed annually in June and the Dow Jones DFM Indexes annually in March. The Dow Jones Islamic Market Indexes were introduced in 1999 as the frst indexes intended to measure the global universe of investable equities that pass screens for Shariah compliance. To determine their eligibility for the Dow Jones Islamic Market Indexes, stocks are screened based on their industry type and their fnancial ratios. Excluded are companies engaged in the following lines of business: alcohol, tobacco, pork-related products, fnancial services, defense/weapons and entertainment. Also excluded are companies for which the following fnancial ratios are 33% or more: debt divided by trailing 12-month average market capitalization; cash plus interest-bearing securities divided by trailing 12-month average market capitalization; and accounts receivables divided by trailing 12-month average market capitalization. INDEXES 49 June / July 2008 Islamic Finance Today COMPONENT CHANGES MADE TO DOW JONES ISLAMIC MARKET TITANS 100 INDEX NEW YORK (June 13, 2008) Dow Jones Indexes, a leading global index provider, today announced the results of the regular annual review of the Dow Jones Islamic Market Titans 100 Index and its three sub-indexes, the Dow Jones Islamic Market U.S. Titans 50 Index, Dow Jones Islamic Market Asia/Pacific Titans 25 Index and Dow Jones Islamic Market Europe Titans 25 Index. The changes will be effective as of the open of trading on Monday, June 23, 2008. The following seven components will be deleted from the Dow Jones Islamic Market Titans 100 Index and sub-index Dow Jones Islamic Market U.S. Titans 50 Index: Target Corp. (United States, Retail, TGT), Kimberly-Clark Corp. (United States, Personal & Household Goods, KMB), Motorola Inc. (United States, Technology, MOT), PepsiCo Inc. (United States, Food & Beverage, PEP), Schering- Plough Corp. (United States, Health Care, SGP), Tyco International Ltd. (New) (United States, Industrial Goods & Services, TYC) and Valero Energy Corp. (United States, Oil & Gas, VLO). The following seven companies will be added: Wal-Mart Stores Inc. (United States, Retail, WMT), Verizon Communications Inc. (United States, Telecommunications, VZ), Monsanto Co. (United States, Chemicals, MON), Exelon Corp. (United States, Utilities, EXC), Gilead Sciences Inc. (United States, Health Care, GILD), Devon Energy Corp. (United States, Oil & Gas, DVN) and Freeport- McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. (United States, Basic Resources, FCX). Rio Tinto Ltd.(Australia, Basic Resources, RIO.AU), Kao Corp. (Japan, Personal & Household Goods 4452. TO, KCRPY), Kyocera Corp.( Japan, Industrial Goods & Services, 6971.TO, KYO), Murata Manufacturing Co. Ltd. (Japan, Industrial Goods & Services, 6981. OK) and Sumitomo Metal Industries Ltd. (Japan, Basic Resources,5405.TO, SMMLY) will be deleted from the Dow Jones Islamic Market Titans 100 Index and sub-index Dow Jones Islamic Market Asia/Pacific Titans 25 Index and will be replaced by CNOOC Ltd. (Hong Kong, Oil & Gas, 0883.HK, CEO), CSL Ltd. (Australia, Health Care CSL.AU), Singapore Telecommunications Ltd. (Singapore, Telecommunications, SGAPY, Z74.SG), Daiichi Sankyo Co. Ltd. (Japan, Health Care, 4568.TO) and FUJIFILM Holdings Corp. (Japan, Personal & Household Goods, 4901.TO, FUJI). Rio Tinto PLC (United Kingdom, Basic Resources RIO.LN, RTP) and Enel S.p.A. (Italy, Utilities, ENEL. MI) will be deleted from the Dow Jones Islamic Market Titans 100 and its sub-index, Dow Jones Islamic Market Europe 25 and will be replaced by ArcelorMittal (France, Basic Resources, MTP.FR, MT.AE, MT) and ABB Ltd. (Switzerland, Industrial Goods & Services, ABB.SK, ABB, ABBN.VX). The free-float market capitalization of the reconstituted Dow Jones Islamic Market Titans 100 Index increased to US$7.938 trillion from US$7.759 trillion, as of May 30, 2008. The Dow Jones Islamic Market Titans 100 Index tracks the largest 100 stocks traded in the U.S., Europe and Asia/Pacific that pass rules-based screens for compliance with Islamic investment guidelines. Stocks are screened based on their industry type and their financial ratios. Excluded are companies engaged in the following lines of business: alcohol, tobacco, pork-related products, financial services, defense/weapons and entertainment. Dow Jones Indexes then screens out companies with unacceptable financial ratios: companies whose total debt divided by trailing 12-month average market capitalization is 33% or more; those whose cash plus interest-bearing securities divided by trailing 12-month average market capitalization is 33% or more and those whose accounts receivables divided by trailing 12-month average market capitalization is 33% or more. INDEXES 50 Islamic Finance Today June / July 2008