Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Question 1 2 3 4
1
Existing
Project/program function
(program management, project IT function (developer, Business function (functional
management, business practice application developer, lead, IT analyst, business analyst,
Generally classify your role: consultant, etc.) analyst, development manager) management) Executive
Demographics 1 Generally classify your role: Project/program function IT function developer, application Business function (functional Executive function
(program management, project developer, lead, IT analyst, analyst, business analyst,
Final
management, business practice development manager) management)
consultant, etc.)
2
Final Existing
Have you already purchased a
BPM solution? Yes Currently evaluating. Just researching options
2 Have you already purchased a Yes (drop-down list from "BPM Currently evaluating (same drop- Just researching options
BPM solution? competitors" Tab) down list).
3 As a mechanism to convince
Existing
others within my
What are your goals for this Evaluation of options for a Determining best practices for department/company of the
assessment? Self-education and research specific project process improvements. importance of BPM
3 What are your goals for this Self-education and research Evaluating options for a specific Determining best practices for As a mechanism to convince
assessment? project process improvements. others within my
Final
department/company of the
importance of BPM
0 How would you rate your
Final Existing Final Existing
4 What are your goals for Business Not a priority Important Urgent
Process Management?
4 What are your goals for Business Not a priority Important Very Important
Process Management?
Existing Final Existing Final Existing Final Existing
1 of48 12/23/2009
Promote Business and IT alignment
ANALYZE 5
Limited management:
Processes are defined because Structured, but siloed:
Existing
Individualistic: Motivation to just people have been working Processes are defined,
"get the job done" makes people together for a long time. measured and monitored.
step up to the challenge. Even as Bottlenecks are occasional, but Training in systems, products
such, deliverables will often "fall escalating to the right manager and procedures is more common
Pick the scenario that best through the cracks" and can sometimes clear out the than not. However, cross-team
describes your company bottlenecks are common. roadblocks collaboration is rare.
Analyze 5 Pick the scenario that best Individualistic: Motivation to just Limited management: Structured, but siloed:
describes your company "get the job done" makes people Processes are defined because Processes are measured and
Process complexity
"step up to the challenge." Even people have been working monitored. Training in systems,
as such, deliverables will often together for a long time. products and procedures is more
Final
"fall through the cracks" and Bottlenecks are occasional, but common than not. However,
bottlenecks are common. escalating to the right manager cross-team collaboration is rare.
can sometimes clear out the
roadblocks.
Process aware 6
whiteboard or in a document. Microsoft Visio. Visio to model processes. standard modeling tools
(Lombardi, AquaLogic BPM,
ARIS, or UML tools).
Process 7
modeling
Existing
2 of48 12/23/2009
7 Are your business processes Almost Never: The organization Occasionally: A few business Commonly: Most critical
documented? has documented very few of its processes have been functions have been
business processes. documented, particularly for high documented, including all human
Technology
turnover processes. and process steps in a specific
process flow.
Final
Process 8
documentation
Existing
Managed, such as using
Chaotically, business processes Casually, for example, writing simulation to validate Programmatically, such as
are mostly static; to whatever process steps on a whiteboard documented requirements and using a requirements document,
How are changes made to extent that change occurs, it is and validating the diagram with graphical models and identify functional design, or other
specific business processes? unmanaged. process owner(s). bottlenecks. documented use case validation
8 How are changes made to Chaotically, business processes Casually, for example, writing Repetitively, such as using a Programmatically, such as
specific business processes? are mostly static; to whatever the process steps on a requirements document, using simulation to validate
extent that change occurs, it is whiteboard and validating the functional design, or other documented requirements and
Final
unmanaged. diagram with the process documented use case validation. graphical models and identify
owner(s). bottlenecks.
Process 9
simulation
Existing
Process owners 10
Semi-Structured. Specific IT
Organizational
Existing
ORCHESTRATE 11
Existing
3 of48 12/23/2009
Orchestrate 11 Describe the scope of your current No processes targeted. Small pilot project. Many processes within a
Process complexity
or planned BPM project(s). department or line of project.
Final
Interdepartment 12
al processes
Very little. Either process Investigating BPMS. Investment
Existing
Does your company use a improvement is not a priority, or in Business Process
standard technology (or set of no decision has been made to Some first-generation workflow, Management technologies (like
technologies) to implement changes invest in technologies to improve rules, or document management Business Process Management
to business processes? business processes. solutions exist. Suites) is just beginning.
12 Does your company use a Very little: Either process Some first-generation workflow, Investigating BPMS: Investment
standard technology (or set of improvement is not a priority, or rules, or document management in Business Process
technologies) to implement changes no decision has been made to solutions exist. Management technologies (like
Final
Process 13
Technology
execution
All manual. Automation of
Existing
Process 14
automation
Existing
No meaningful collaboration A little. Business develops For the most part, business
Do IT and business process owners exists between IT development requirements, which they then develops requirements and
generally collaborate on projects? teams and process owners. hand off to IT. iterates with IT in the design.
IT/Business 14 Do IT and business process owners No meaningful collaboration A little: Business develops For the most part: Business
Collaboration generally collaborate on projects? exists between IT development requirements, which they then develops requirements and
Organizational
teams and process owners. hand off to IT. iterates with IT in the design.
Final
OPTIMIZE 15
Existing
4 of48 12/23/2009
Optimize 15 How common is it for one Almost never: Processes are A little: There has been some
Process complexity
department to share, link and not formalized enough to be reuse and interlinking of
reuse processes with another shared or interlinked. processes between two
department? departments.
Final
Interprocess 16
linking and
Existing
reuse
Does your organization use Almost never. Processes are A little. There has been some
templates for designing business not formalized enough to be development and use of process
processes? templated. templates.
16 Does your organization use Almost never: Processes are A little: There has been some
templates for designing business not formalized enough to use development and use of process
Technology
Process 17
templates
Existing
Process 18
measurement
Centralized: Rules are
Existing
multiple systems. governance is a constant resources, meaning required Business users can make real
challenge. while ensuring proper time changes to policies without
Final
Process 19
Governance
Existing
5 of48 12/23/2009
Process 19 Is your company following an No, the company is too early in Currently investigating an Yes, the company is using an
methodology industry-accepted process its understanding of BPM to industry-accepted process industry-accepted process
improvement methodology like Six follow an industry-accepted improvement methodology. improvement methodology.
Sigma, TQM, or LEAN? process improvement
methodology.
Final
INNOVATE 20
External process 21
focus
Existing
SOA-enabled 22
processes
Existing
Goal-driven 23
organization
Existing
Change is desired but little Sporadically: Competition has Strategic Priority: Enterprise has
Which best describes your coordination exists to execute forced innovation within specific a commitment and a plan in
company's ability to innovate? new ideas. lines of business. place for consistent innovation.
6 of48 12/23/2009
Innovative 23 Which best describes your Change is desired but little Sporadically: Competition has Strategic Priority: Enterprise
organization company's ability to innovate? coordination exists to execute forced innovation within specific has a commitment and a plan in
Final
new ideas. lines of business. place for consistent innovation.
7 of48 12/23/2009
5 0
Open
8 of48 12/23/2009
A Center of Process
Excellence (COE) has the
funding and cross-functional
membership to establish and
document best practices across
the entire Enterprise. Don't know/Other
A Center of Excellence (CoE) Don't know/Other
has the funding and cross-
functional membership to
establish and document best
practices across the entire
Enterprise.
9 of48 12/23/2009
Always: Senior Management Don't know/Other
has committed to documenting
processes across the enterprise,
partners, customers and other
parties using a common BPMS
and following established best
practices and methodologies.
Enterprise-wide process
project(s).Don't know/Other
10 of48 12/23/2009
Enterprise-wide projects. Don't know/Other
Commonly. Organization
regularly creates reusable
optimized sub-processes to
incorporate into larger processes
throughout the enterprise. Don't know/Other
11 of48 12/23/2009
Commonly: Organization Don't know/Other
regularly creates reusable
optimized subprocesses to
incorporate into larger processes
throughout the enterprise.
12 of48 12/23/2009
Yes, the organization follows an Don't know/Other
industry-accepted process
improvement methodology, like
Six Sigma or Lean, or culls best
practices from multiple
methodologies. Methodology is
enforced by the BPM Center of
Excellence.
13 of48 12/23/2009
Rapid Innovation: Company is a Don't know/Other
thought leader, and IT spending
supports rapid delivery of
automated processes.
14 of48 12/23/2009
Answer Number
Question 1 2 3 4 5 0
Demographics 1 Generally classify your role: Project/program function IT function developer, application Business function (functional Executive function
(program management, project developer, lead, IT analyst, analyst, business analyst,
management, business practice development manager) management)
consultant, etc.)
2 Have you already purchased a BPM Yes (drop-down list from "BPM Currently evaluating (same drop- Just researching options
solution? competitors" Tab) down list).
3 What are your goals for this Self-education and research Evaluation of options for a Determining best practices for As a mechanism to convince
assessment? specific project process improvements. others within my
department/company of the
importance of BPM
4 How would you rate your Few in my company are familiar My company is just beginning to My company has adopted BPM There's strong BPM knowledge My company is continually
company’s familiarity with Business with BPM. learn about BPM. in specific departments; BPM throughout company. measuring and optimizing all of
Process Management (BPM)? knowledge is strong in some its processes using BPM.
teams, but weak in others.
5 What are your goals for Business Not a priority Important Very Important
Process Management?
describes your company "get the job done" makes people Processes are defined because Processes are measured and has the funding and cross-
"step up to the challenge." Even people have been working monitored. Training in systems, functional membership to
as such, deliverables will often together for a long time. products and procedures is more establish and document best
"fall through the cracks" and Bottlenecks are occasional, but common than not. However, practices across the entire
bottlenecks are common. escalating to the right manager cross-team collaboration is rare. Enterprise.
can sometimes clear out the
roadblocks.
Process modeling 7 Currently, how does your company Whiteboard, or not at all: If Occasionally Visio: A few Visio is standard: The regular, Standard BPM tools: At the Standard shared process Don't know/Other
graphically model its business processes are modeled, they are processes have been modeled established procedure department level, IT and models. Organization has
processes? sketched out in steps on a using desktop tools such as throughout the company is to use business users work together on standardized on a common tool
whiteboard or in a document. Microsoft Visio. Visio to model processes. standard modeling tools for modeling, with
(Lombardi, AquaLogic BPM, institutionalized training and
ARIS, or UML tools). expertise.
Process documentation 8 Are your business processes Almost Never. The organization Occasionally. A few business Commonly. Most critical Always. Senior Management has Don't know/Other
documented? has documented very few of its processes have been functions have been committed to documenting
business processes. documented, particularly for high documented, including all human processes across the enterprise,
Technology
turnover processes. and process steps in a specific partners, customers and other
process flow. parties using a common BPMS
and following established best
practices and methodologies.
Process simulation 9 How are changes made to Chaotically, business processes Casually, for example, writing Repetitivly, such as using a Programatically, such as using Proactively, real-time monitoring Don't know/Other
specific business processes? are mostly static; to whatever the process steps on a requirements document, simulation to validate of KPIs (Key Performance
extent that change occurs, it is whiteboard and validating the functional design, or other documented requirements and Indicators) forms the basis for
unmanaged. diagram with the process documented use case validation. graphical models and identify continual optimization through
owner(s). bottlenecks. ongoing simulation.
Process owners 10 Who identifies which processes No one. Business processes are A manager. Teams with strong Evangelist: A specific individual LOB process owners: Each Team with executive mandate: Don't know/Other
need to be improved? static, or changes are made by managers will identify sub- is tasked with identifying line-of-business has a process A team composed of both
individuals acting on their own optimal processes and begin to candidate processes. owner who is goaled and Business and IT has an
initiative. document and/or model those measured based on process enterprise-wide mandate to
processes. improvements. identify and target processes
Organizational
priorities.
Organizational
Process coordinators 11 Does IT have a dedicated staff to Impossible. Individuals need to Ad-Hoc. Once approved and Semi-Structured. Specific IT Dedicated and measured. IT Don't know/Other
implement changes to business beg, plead and borrow to get IT funded, changes to any business staff are assigned to regularly organization has dedicated
processes? resources to make changes. process get staffed like any other liaise with business managers. business analysts to liaise with
IT project. process owners from lines-of-
business and work jointly on
process improvement projects.
ORCHESTRATE
Process complexity
Orchestrate Interdepartmental 12 Describe the scope of your current No processes targeted. Small pilot project. Many processes within a Enterprise-wide projects. Don't know/Other
processes or planned BPM project(s). department or line-of-project.
Process execution 13 Does your company use a Very little. Either process Some first-generation workflow, Investigating BPMS. Investment BPMS. Organization has Don't know/Other
standard technology (or set of improvement is not a priority, or rules, or document management in Business Process standardized on BPMS system
technologies) to implement changes no decision has been made to solutions exist. Management technologies (like for process deployment and
to business processes? invest in technologies to improve Business Process Management execution.
Technology
Process 14 Is it common for your organization All manual. Automation of In some cases the organization Yes, the organization is focused Don't know/Other
automation to automate routine or predictable human tasks is fairly rare or has automated routine functions on automating predictable or
activities? nonexistent, no matter how and reduced mindless, repetitive routine human activities and
routine, repetitive, redundant, functions. system interchanges.
costly or predictable.
IT/Business 15 Do IT and business process owners No meaningful collaboration A little. Business develops For the most part, business Almost always. Both business Don't know/Other
Organizational
Collaboration generally collaborate on projects? exists between IT development requirements, which they then develops requirements and and IT use the same standard
teams and process owners. hand off to IT. iterates with IT in the design. tools in concert to collaborate on
process improvement projects
throughout the project lifecycle.
OPTIMIZE
Technology Process complexity
Optimize Interprocess 16 How common is it for one Almost never. Processes are A little. There has been some Commonly. Organization Don't know/Other
linking and reuse department to share, link and not formalized enough to be reuse and interlinking of regularly creates reusable
reuse processes with another shared or interlinked. processes between two optimized subprocesses to
department? departments. incorporate into larger processes
throughout the enterprise.
Process templates 17 Does your organization use Almost never. Processes are A little. There has been some Commonly. Organization has Don't know/Other
templates for designing business not formalized enough to be development and use of process standardized on a BPMS that
processes? templated. templates. offers a repository of templates
for reusing process objects or
entire processes.
Process 18 In general, how does your company No reporting. Some data is manually Historical reporting tools (such Business Activity Monitoring A continual cycle of process Don't know/Other
measurement measure its performance on captured into excel or other as Cognos, Seibel analytics, (BAM) dashboards provide real- improvement includes constant
business processes? desktop software. Hyperion, Business Objects etc.) time data alongside the standard process measurement against
provide some process analysis historical reporting tools common Key Performance Indicators
data. throughout the Enterprise. (KPIs).
Process 19 How does IT maintain control of No controls: Business rules are Limited Auditing: IT has limited Controlled: Change is limited Centralized: Rules are Optimal: Organization has Don't know/Other
Organizational
Governance changes to business processes? ad-hoc and spread across visibility and ensuring proper based on availability of IT centralized across the enterprise. established a BPM Center of
multiple systems. governance is a constant resources to ensure proper Business users can make real Excellence (CoE) with cross-
challenge. governance and visibility for IT. time changes to policies without functional business, IT and
IT resources, while ensuring executive representation to guide
proper governance and visibility the business on how to achieve
for IT. process improvements.
Process 20 Is your company following an No, the company is too early in Currently investigating an Yes, the company is using an Yes, the organization follows an Don't know/Other
methodology industry-accepted process its understanding of BPM to industry-accepted process industry-accepted process industry-accepted process
improvement methodology like Six follow an industry-accepted improvement methodology. improvement methodology. improvement methodology, like
Sigma, TQM, or LEAN? process improvement Six Sigma or Lean, or culls best
methodology. practices from multiple
methodologies. Methodology is
enforced by the BPM Center of
Excellence.
INNOVATE
SOA-enabled 22 To what degree has your company No investment. Targeted investment. Company Strong commitment. IT heavily Don't know/Other
processes invested in a Service Oriented has committed resources to invests in SOA-related
Architecture to support your service-enabling certain key technologies to manage services
business processes? processes and even whole processes for
reuse, governance and
auditability.
Goal-driven 23 Are teams measured based on the No. Process improvements are Only tangentially. Team Occasionally. In order to reach Almost Always. The majority of Don't know/Other
Organizational
organization productivity of their processes? independent of any team incentives and individual team goals or performance the organization is goaled on
incentives or individual performance benchmarks are benchmarks, some teams must making process improvements
performance reviews. easier to reach when make process improvements. and process measurement is
improvements are made in commonly part of individual and
underlying process. team performance reviews.
Innovative 24 Which best describes your Change is desired but little Sporadically: Competition has Strategic Priority: Enterprise Rapid Innovation: Company is a Don't know/Other
organization company's ability to innovate? coordination exists to execute forced innovation within specific has a commitment and a plan in thought leader, and IT spending
new ideas. lines of business. place for consistent innovation. supports rapid delivery of
automated processes.
Actions-Bus Impact
None Ad Hoc LOB Enterprise
1 2 3 4
Analyze
4 Consider improving one or more high-profile processes which could render significant benefits.
Not possible
5 Consider increasing the effort spent documenting and analyzing your existing processes, even
beyond the key processes that may already have been addressed. Not possible
8 Consider staffing a specific role to identify problematic processes. Consider empowering roles Consider obtaining an executive
within each line of business and mandate for a team composed
measuring them on process of both business and IT to
improvements within their identify and target processes
organization. priorities across the enterprise.
9 Consider staffing a team within IT to regularly resolve business Consider adding business
process issues. analysts to IT for the sole
Not possible
purpose of working on process
improvements.
Well documented processes can reduce employee training costs.
Visibility into processes enables better compliance with regulations such as with Sarbanes Oxley or the U.S. Patriot Act.
Identifying the sources of errors and bottlenecks can significantly reduce the costs of executing business processes.
Business Impact
Identifying best practice processes can reduce the effort and costs needed to complete common or important work.
Reuse of common design patterns across multiple projects can enable faster time-to-delivery at lower cost.
Establishing an appropriate staffing structure to quickly identify and prioritize process improvements can provide significant and immediate returns on investment.
Eliminating redundant processes and applications can reduce costs in system maintenance and management.
Printed 12/23/2009
Actions-Bus Impact
None Ad Hoc LOB Enterprise
1 2 3 4
Orchestrate
10 Consider identifying a pilot project Consider systematically Consider prioritizing cross-
that spans multiple processes or improving several processes department or divisional
departments. within a single department or processes using BPM. These BPM
Not possible
division. projects can be complex, but
much higher-impact.
11 Investigating using a BPM suite for more effective process Consider standardizing on a BPM
Actions to Consider
13 Consider requiring business process owners and IT developers to use the same standard tools to
collaborate and iterate on process improvement projects. Not possible
The value obtained through process improvement typically multiplies when process improvements span organizational and divisional boundaries.
Automated processes can reduce redundant work, improve customer service and reduce costs - providing a significant return on investment.
Business Impact
Teams can usually build and deploy processes much faster when they effectively collaborate using a single, standardized BPMS for supporting both human-intensive
and system-intensive processes.
Easy-to-use BPM and business process reporting tools can empower the line of business to drive change and achieve new levels of agility.
Process audits and process measurements can significantly improve overall accountability, thus improving customer service and meeting Service Level Agreements
(SLAs).
Improved exception handling can significantly improve time-to-resolution and identify any dropped hand-offs between departments or divisions.
Printed 12/23/2009
Actions-Bus Impact
None Ad Hoc LOB Enterprise
1 2 3 4
Optimize
15 Consider creating a repository of process templates to let business users share best practices and
pave a faster path to success. Not possible
16 Consider investing in business Consider deploying business activity monitoring dashboards in Consider employing a continual
Actions to Consider
analytics tools, such as Cognos, cases where real-time monitoring of business activity could cycle of process improvement
Hyperion or Business Objects. increase management efficiency. including constant process
measurement against Key
Performance Indicators.
17 Consider enabling business users to make real time changes to policies without IT resources. Consider establishing a BPM
Center of Excellence (CoE) with
cross-functional business, IT and
executive representation to
prioritize process improvement
projects and pool best practices.
18 Consider using a process Consider deploying and standardizing on an industry-accepted process improvement methodology,
improvement methodology, such such as Six Sigma, Total Quality Management (TQM) or Lean Manufacturing.
as Six Sigma, Total Quality
Management (TQM) or Lean
Manufacturing.
Reusable templates and process objects can significantly reduce the time it takes to improve processes or deploy new processes using BPM.
Business Impact
Seamless synchronization and a real-time feedback loop between business users and IT ensures applications are built right the first time, saving time and money.
Using an industry-accepted BPM methodology, your company can realize the BPM best practices others learned through experience, also saving time and money.
Effective process metrics can proactively alert management to bottlenecks and break downs, thus improving responsiveness to business-critical issues, allowing for
better customer service, product development or implementation of strategic initiatives.
Printed 12/23/2009
Actions-Bus Impact
None Ad Hoc LOB Enterprise
1 2 3 4
Innovate
19 When working on internal process Consider involving partners,
improvement projects, consider suppliers and customers in
addressing partner, supplier or business process improvement Not possible Not possible
customer touch points. projects.
Actions to Consider
21 Consider making process improvements a common part of individual and team performance reviews.
Not possible
22 Identify ways in which BPM might increase your company's ability to improve employee productivity, improve customer service, react
to change, or grow revenue.
Improve the chance of dominating your customers by using process improvements to change the game.
Decrease chance of business failure or loss through better visibility into current operations.
Business Impact
Establish industry leadership gains that clearly separate your company from competitors.
Secure greater customer satisfaction through better exception handling and visibility into Key Performance Indicators.
Decrease operating costs and improve employee productivity through process improvements.
Printed 12/23/2009
Actions-Bus Impact
Innovative
5
Printed 12/23/2009
Actions-Bus Impact
Innovative
5
nd divisional boundaries.
eturn on investment.
ew levels of agility.
Printed 12/23/2009
Actions-Bus Impact
Innovative
5
Sustain commitment to
continuous process
improvement and change.
Ensure ongoing availability of
staff and resources. Advertise
successes.
Printed 12/23/2009
Actions-Bus Impact
Innovative
5
Printed 12/23/2009
Top
# Question Possible scores score Category
1 Generally classify your role: 1 2 3 4 4 Demographics
2 Have you already purchased a BPM solution? 1 2 3 3 Demographics
3 What are your goals for this assessment?
How would you rate your company’s familiarity with Business
4 Process Management (BPM)? 1 2 3 4 4 Demographics
New Scoring
6 Pick the scenario that best describes your company 0 1 2 3 5 5 Analyze 70% 24% 5% 1%
Currently, how does your company graphically model its business Example: An aggregate score of 17
7 processes? 0 1 2 3 4 5 5 Analyze None Ad Hoc LOB Enterprise Innovative Example: We believe 70% of the
in Analyze will render the text for
new survey takers will score no
Nrmlized Nrmlized Nrmlized Nrmlized Nrmlized "LOB adoption" in the Analyze
better than 12 on orchestrate.
8 Are your business processes documented? 0 1 2 3 5 5 Analyze Domain Range of Raw score Break Range of Raw score Break Range of Raw score Break Range of Raw score Break Range of Raw score Break section.
9 How are changes made to specific business processes? 0 1 2 3 4 5 5 Analyze Analyze 0 8 27 9 14 47 15 17 57 18 23 77 24 30 100
10 Who identifies which processes need to be improved? 0 1 2 3 4 5 5 Analyze Orchestrate 0 7 35 8 12 60 13 15 75 16 18 90 19 20 100
Does IT have a dedicated staff to implement changes to business
11 processes? 0 1 2 3 5 5 Analyze Optimize 0 8 32 9 14 56 15 16 64 17 22 88 23 25 100 Example: A normalized score 70 in
Innovate 0 5 25 6 10 50 11 15 75 16 18 90 19 20 100 optimize would render the text for
"Enterprise." Note that 70 exceeds
the 64 break point for LOB but does
12 Describe the scope of your current or planned BPM project(s). 0 1 2 3 5 5 Orchestrate not exceed the 88 break point for
Does your company use a standard technology (or set of Enteprise.
13 technologies) to implement
Is it common for changes
your organization to to businessroutine
automate processes?
or predictable 0 1 2 3 5 5 Orchestrate
14 activities? 0 3 5 5 Orchestrate
Do IT and business process owners generally collaborate on "average" calculations,
15 projects? 0 1 2 3 5 5 Orchestrate until we have critical
Domain Normalizing factor mass
How common is it for one department to share, link and reuse
16 processes with another department? 0 1 3 5 5 Optimize raw score normalized
Does your organization use templates for designing business
11 37
17 processes? 0 1 2 5 5 Optimize Analyze 3.33
In general, how does your company measure its performance on
10 48
18 business processes? 0 1 2 3 4 5 5 Optimize Orchestrate 5
11 44
19 How does IT maintain control of changes to business processes? 0 1 2 3 4 5 5 Optimize Optimize 4
23 Are teams measured based on the productivity of their processes? 0 1 2 3 5 5 Innovate Previous survey bucketed into these percentages
Raw Raw Example: Previous
24 Which best describes your company's ability to innovate? 0 1 2 3 4 5 5 Innovate Minimum 70% 24% 5% 1% Maximum Example: 70% of the
survey score of 19 in
Domain None Ad Hoc LOB Enterprise Innovative previous respondents
Analyze would result in
scored no better than 17
Analyze 5 8 9 14 15 17 18 23 24 25 "Enterprise" for that
in orchestrate
Orchestrate 6 9 10 17 18 20 21 21 22 28 category.
Optimize 6 8 9 17 18 23 24 25 26 29
Innovate 2 5 6 7 8 8 9 9 10 10
e
or
e
tic
or
Sc
n
ac
ai
Sc
e
om
Pr
ag
ur
st
D
er
Yo
Be
Av
Analyzing 70 37 100
Orchestrating 100 48 100
Optimizing 96 44 100
Innovating 65 38 100
100
100 100 100 100 100
96
80
70
Your Score
65
60
Average Score
Best Practice
48
40 44
37 38
20
0
Analyzing Orchestrating Optimizing Innovating
Analyzing
100
100
80
70
60
40
37
20
0
Your Score Average Score Best Practice
70
60
40
37
20
0
Your Score Average Score Best Practice
Orchistrating
100
100 100
80
60
48
40
20
0
Your Score Average Score Best Practice
Optomizing
100
100
96
80
60
40 44
20
0
Your Score Average Score Best Practice
Innovating
100
100
80
60 65
40
38
20
0
Your Score Average Score Best Practice
100
Your Score
65
Average Score
Best Practice
38
Innovating
Company Profile 1: Little-to-No BPM
Analyze
Orchestrate
Optimize
Innovate
Orchestrate
Optimize
Innovate
Orchestrate
33 of 48 printed12/23/2009
Optimize
Innovate
Orchestrate
Optimize
Innovate
34 of 48 printed12/23/2009
Orchestrate
Optimize
Innovate
35 of 48 printed12/23/2009
pany Profile 1: Little-to-No BPM
Little Awareness, Analysis or Documentation: Processes are likely ill-defined and inefficient, perhaps
leading to costly rework or time lost. Organization is not yet cognizant of the issue, and thus has not yet
focused groups or individuals on identifying problems or solutions.
Little Process Coordination and Automation: Manual processes mean IT and business are
disorganized and occasionally in conflict. Personnel training is complicated, usually involving significant
mentoring from individuals who know the systems and processes, since there is little documentation.
Exception handling is hap-hazard and can overwhelm the systems and personnel. If there is an
investment in improving a process, the change is usually piecemeal and reactive; downstream effects
aren't usually thought-through or communicated.
Little-to-No Optimization: Process effectiveness is rarely measured. Since there has not been an
investment in process repositories, process templates or Service Oriented Architecture components, IT
has few reusable resources.
Little Motivation to Innovate with BPM: Business is not using BPM in a significant way to expand
business, grow revenue or cut costs. No funding or organization is assigned to formally drive innovation
through process improvement techniques.
Minimal Process Coordination and Automation: Some business processes are defined and
documented, but very few are automated. Non-standard systems and methodologies in a manual
process environment likely means IT and business have difficulty collaborating and agreeing on critical
improvements. Exception-handling is likely very reactive and dependant on "heroes" within the
organization.
Ad-hoc Process Optimization: Processes are only reviewed, analyzed and modified as problems arise.
If process success metrics are available, they must be manually prepared in a program like Excel.
Early State of Change: Innovation is cultivated in some departments, but broad support for innovation
using BPM is limited. Business lacks the focus, funding, or ability to effectively create change using
business process innovation.
Extending Process Coordination and Automation: Business and IT effectively collaborate to model,
manage and monitor processes. Automation of critical processes is becoming commonplace in
departments or divisions. Management defines and watches key performance indicators driven by BPM
execution and automation.
36 of 48 printed12/23/2009
Department-Level Optimization: Some processes are simulated, reviewed and optimized. Some
process reporting is available, typically through standardized reporting tools such as Cognos, Siebel
Analytics or other similar tools. Business process changes are becoming easier to make and have
increased governance resulting in better downstream change management.
Moderate Interest in BPM Innovation: Strategic goals include BPM projects focused on cutting costs or
increasing revenue. Business and IT headcount are dedicated to working on process improvement
opportunities for specific line of business needs. Commitment to innovating using BPM varies widely
across the organization.
Effective Process Coordination and Automation: Processes are modeled and measured using a
company-standard BPM tool integrated with legacy and backend systems, likely using a SOA framework
of reusable components. IT and business managers are able to collaborate on process improvement
projects using a shared set of process tools. All critical processes are properly documented, reviewed,
simulated and updated regularly. Management defines and watches Key Performance Indicators (KPI’s),
and nearly all exceptions are effectively addressed, measured, and tracked.
Proactive Optimization: IT and business groups are working together to provide real-time reporting on
process results, potentially through Business Activity Monitoring (BAM) dashboards. Process changes
are planned, supported and relatively easy to make. Process changes are simulated and governance is
in place to ensure that effects of process changes are managed appropriately.
Increasing Innovation Through BPM: Business process improvement projects are aligned to strategic
initiatives. A specific group has responsibility for driving business process improvements across the
organization to maximize competitive differentiators. Business and IT are aligned on need to realize
innovation through the effective use of BPM.
37 of 48 printed12/23/2009
Effective Process Coordination and Automation: Processes are modeled and measured using a
company-standard BPM tool integrated with legacy and backend systems, likely using a SOA framework
of reusable components. IT and business managers are able to collaborate on process improvement
projects using a shared set of process tools. All critical processes are properly documented, reviewed,
simulated and updated regularly. Management defines and watches Key Performance Indicators (KPI’s),
and nearly all exceptions are effectively addressed, measured, and tracked.
Intense Commitment to Innovation Through BPM: Company relies on BPM to enable rapid innovation
and “game changing" moves. Business, IT and senior management are committed to the use of Key
Performance Indicators to measure processes. Process improvements are commonly a part of individual
and team performance reviews. The organizational direction and strategy relies on innovating with
business processes.
38 of 48 printed12/23/2009
Domain Domain Definition Report Content Company Profile
75% 20% 4%
Summary Limited Documentation and Limited Documentation and Siloed Documentation: Processes Standardization of Process
Analysis: Processes are ill-defined, Analysis: Processes ill-defined, are identified by project, some Documentation: Processes defined
little to no documentation exists, little to no documentation exists, interdepartmental processes exist, in single, standardized tool, used for
evangelist may exist but with limited evangelist may exist but with limited stronger BPM business drivers exist. business execution and best
authority, the business has not authority, the business has But funding is still limited and practices.
dedicated funding and or interest to dedicated limited funding and restricted to specific projects.
the project, business process interest to the project, business
modeling is manual. process modeling is manual.
Documented, defined
processes, reviewed, Action Dynamcially driven from answer choices
Analyze
simulated and updated
regularly.
Reduce training costs by having (prev +) Identification of "best (Prev +) Reduced costs of (Prev +) Establish structure to
documented processes available. practice" process for a particular redundant process tools in each line quickly identify and prioritize new
Simplify business processes to service for more efficient process of business, or multiple systems. opportunities to increase revenue
reduce costs and errors. flow. Reuse common design patterns and/or reduce costs.
across multiple projects for faster
Business Impact time-to-delivery and lower cost.
Domain Domain Definition Report Content Company Profile
Little Control or Governance: Minimal control or governance: Business can effectively manage Roles are defined across enterprise.
Process may be documented but in Process may be documented but in and monitor processes. Controls Processes are integrated with
a manual form, difficult for IT and a manual form, difficult for IT and and governance defined and used, legacy and backend systems using
business to collaborate due to business to collaborate due to roles in process are identified and and SOA framework of reusable
manual nature of processes, roles in manual nature of processes, roles in referenced to organization structure, components. Enterprise integration
the organization are loosely defined. the organization are loosely defined. key processes are automated and strategy allows for the broader
Summary Exception handling is hap-hazard integrated in a “point-to-point” application of governance and
and can sometimes fashion, business a control. Management is invo
Little-to-No Optimization: If Limited Optimization: Processes Reactive Optimization: Business Proactive Optimization: A specific
processes are documented, they are infrequently reviewed, analyzed and IT engage process systems to group has responsibility for creating
are rarely reviewed, analyzed or and modified. Process change is monitor current state of business efficiency standards for business
modified. Process changes are reactive and process development process. Efforts to improve processes across the organization.
reactive, ad-hoc and are not often is at a "maintenance" level. efficiency gains are focused on IT and business groups are working
captured or communicated to other parts of process rather than the together to provide more real-time
groups that may be impacted. entire process. Business process reporting on process results and
rules are refined and updated simulation
Summary
Continuous process
improvement of business
processes. Key metrics are
captured and analyzed
Optimize regularly. Processes are
fine-tuned using simulated
scenarios. Evolution of
processes is real-time
Action Dynamcially driven from answer choices
rather than reactive.
Maintaining the Status Quo: Early State of Change: Company is Moderate Interest In Innovation: Focus on Increasing Innovation:
Industry supports static business in an early state of change, some Strategic goals include business Industry is in state of transition or
model, no real innovation is innovation is cultivated in processes focused on efficiency company experiences a drive
required. Business strategy is to departments, but broad support for gains. Industry provides returns for toward more rapid and strategic
"maintain status quo" since current innovation limited, or corporate 'red gradual process improvement. business plan changes. Company
processes work with relatively little tape' slows process of innovation. Some business processes within has business strategy in place lead
urgent pain. IT spending is focused Some business processes are your company are prioritized, its industry in areas perceived as
predominately on mai defined and documented documented and automated, but key differentiators. Bu
Summary
Expand business horizons Increased revenue potential through Grow current market through Achieve greater business agility to
through consideration of new ways added value offered to customers. streamlined processes. Decreased capitalize on new opportunities.
of operating or capitalizing on Potential of greater customer costs through automated, finely Improve chance for competitive
opportunities for improved customer satisfaction through improved tuned process management. Secure domination through game-
service, increased revenue or processes. Potential of decreased greater customer satisfaction changing tactics. Decrease chance
decreased costs. operating costs due to efficiency through better exception handling, of business failure or loss through
gains. visibility into key performance better visibility into current operating
Business Impact indicators. climate.
Internal and External BPM
Innovation
1%
Standardization of Process
Documentation: Processes defined in
single, standardized tool, used for
business execution and best practices.