Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
1 of 2
http://www.swe.org/SWE/RegionH/Detroit/CDBooks/BlueHigh.html
1/11/2008 10:17 AM
2 of 2
http://www.swe.org/SWE/RegionH/Detroit/CDBooks/BlueHigh.html
Additionally, Heat-Moon is an enthusiastic eater, something with which I can personally relate. His rating
system for diners is not to be forgotten or minimized: the more calendars on the wall, the better the food. He
rates them from zero calendars ("same as an interstate pit stop") to five calendars ("keep it under your hat, or
they'll franchise.") (For more on the ills of franchising, read the author's terrific views on franchises of page
16). Heat-Moon's descriptions of his food, waitresses and dinner companions are rich and hearty, like the
food he (most of the time) is eating. I think it would have been a terrific novel if he had just gone from diner
to bar to diner to bar and wrote about the food in these small towns!
A few things troubled me, and I later learned that they troubled my book club companions as well.
Heat-Moon's finances concerned many of us. When Heat-Moon starts the journey, he has a little over $450 in
cash plus four gas cards with him. He lives in his van, and frequently takes meals at university cafeterias
(which I assume are low cost), but we kept wondering about his bank account throughout the book.
Apparently, he finishes the journey with money to spare, so I guess we needn't have worried about him.
Further, my book club companions and I wondered if he could take this trip today. I was born in the 70s, and
remember it as an idyllic time even though I am sure it had its share of crime and problems. In today's
environment, however, I am not sure how much success Heat-Moon would have had in his travels. He was
occasionally bothered by police while he "camped" in his van-today would he be bothered by criminals as
well? What about the advent of cell phones, e-mail and wireless technology? Would people be as open to
talking and sharing with him as they had been in the late 70s?
Finally, we discussed whether a woman would have been able to take this trip. The general consensus was
that she probably could not. Unfortunately, security is a high priority for women and sleeping alone in a van
poses a high risk of danger in most places. Further, we wondered how people would react to a woman who
was alone in bars and restaurants, chatting people up.
Overall, I think the book was about 150 pages too long. For me, I would have loved to see him concentrate
on his conversations with people and his descriptions of his meals. Given Heat-Moon's engaging writing
style, I would be happy to read something else by this thoughtful author. This book also forced me to
reexamine how I react to and initiate social interactions. In fact, I have even started striking up conversations
with waiters, clerks and fellow patrons. I may not be as skilled at it as Heat-Moon is, but it's a start.
3 stars out of 5
Return to CD book club home page
1/11/2008 10:17 AM