Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 75

EE5702R Advanced Power System

Analysis:: Power System Control I


Panida Jirutitijaroen
Fall 2013
10/10/2013
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

Outline
Control of active and reactive power
Frequency & Voltage control
Basic control loop

Frequency control
Turbine-governor control
Load frequency control

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

Reading Materials
Todays material
Chapter 11.1-11.6 Power Systems Analysis 2nd
edition by Arthur R. Bergen and Vijay Vittal
Chapter 12.1-12.5 Power System Control, Power
System Analysis by Hadi Saadat
Dynamics and Control of Electric Power Systems
Lecture 227-0528-00, ITET ETH, Gran Andersson,
EEH - Power Systems Laboratory, ETH Zrich,
February 2012
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

Syllabus
Week
1:15/08
2:22/08
3:29/08
4:05/09
5:12/09

Topics
Introduction and Network equations
Power flow analysis
Power flow analysis
Power flow analysis
e-learning week: Overview of power
system stability and control

6:19/09
23/09
7:03/10
8:10/10
9:17/10
10:24/10
11:31/10
12:07/11
13:14/11
29/11

Power system stability


Recess week
Power system stability
Power system control
Power system control
Power system state estimation
Power system state estimation
Case study presentation
Case study presentation
Final exam (30%) from 9-11am

10/9/2013

Assessment

Assignment
Project 1 (20%), Due 23/09

Quiz 1 (5%)
Quiz 2 (5%)

Case study (10%), list of


group members.

Quiz 3 (5%)

Project 2 (20%), Due 31/10

Quiz 4 (5%)
Quiz 5 (5%)

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

Physical Structures
Voltage control

Frequency control

Source: http://www.powerworld.com/files/T01ModelRelationships.pdf
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

Supervisory Control and Data


Acquisition (SCADA)
Computer
Systems that
monitor and
control energy
system. The
crucial part of
Energy
Management
System.

Source: ABB
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

Energy Management Systems

Source: FUNDAMENTALS OF ELECTRIC POWER SYSTEMS by Xiao - Ping Zhang


10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

Control structure
Time scale
Basic generator control loop

POWER SYSTEM CONTROLS

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

Hierarchical Control Structure


Source: Dynamics and Control
of Electric Power Systems
Lecture 227-0528-00, ITET
ETH Gran Andersson EEH Power Systems Laboratory
ETH Zrich, February 2012

The lecture
focuses on
how we can
control
generators.

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

Time Scales of Power System Control


Frequency control

Generator-Voltage
control
Reactive power
control

Turbine-Governor
control
Real power control

Load-Frequency
control
Source: Dynamics and Control of Electric Power
Systems Lecture 227-0528-00, ITET ETH Gran
Andersson EEH - Power Systems Laboratory ETH
Zrich, February 2012
10/9/2013

Bring frequency back


to the nominal value.

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

10

Schematic Diagram of a
Steam-Turbine Generator

Frequency control

Voltage Control
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

11

Basic Generator Control Loops


Reference
power
+
Reference
voltage
+
-

SpeedGovernor

Steam valve
position

Voltage
Regulator

Turbine

+
-

Electrical
power
output

Mechanical
power
output
Field
voltage

Generator
Terminal
voltage

Exciter

Stabilizer

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

12

Reactive Power and Voltage Control


Generator Excitation System
The exciter delivers DC
power to the field winding
on the rotor of a
synchronous generator.
Automatic Voltage
Regulator (AVR)
Reactive power control of a
generator.

10/9/2013

Other Voltage Control Devices


Reactive shunt devices
Transformer tap changers
Flexible AC transmission
system (FACTS) controllers
Static VAR Compensator (SVC)
STATic Synchronous
COMpensator (STATCOM)
Unified power flow controller
(UPFC)

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

13

Real Power and Frequency Control


Turbine-Governor control
Primary control loop
Real power control
Immediate (automatic)
action to sudden change of
load.
Governor
accelerate/decelerate,
which affects the frequency

Load-Frequency control
Secondary control loop
Automatic Generation Control,
AGC.
Detect deviation in frequency
and tie-line power flows.
Adjust the input power to
each generator to bring back:
System frequency
Tie-line flow agreement

to nominal value.
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

14

Automatic Generation Control (AGC)

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

15

Purpose of AGC
To maintain power balance in the system.
Make sure that operating limits are not
exceeded: Generators limit
Tie-lines limit

Make sure that system frequency is constant


(not change by load).

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

16

3 Components of AGC
Primary control Turbine-Governor Control
Immediate (automatic) action to sudden change of load.
For example, reaction to frequency change.

Secondary control Load-Frequency Control


To bring tie-line flows to scheduled.
Corrective actions are done by operators.

Economic dispatch
Make sure that the scheduled of units are done in the most
economical way.

This presentation covers only primary and secondary control


of AGC.
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

17

Basic Control Theory


Analysis and design of a control system
requires the mathematical modeling of the
system.
Transfer function method
State variable method

In this lecture, we will use transfer function


method.
See the lecture note on basic control and
MATLAB simulink.
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

18

Generator model
Load model
Generator-Load model
Turbine (Prime mover) model
Governor model
Turbine-Governor model

BASIC CONTROL BLOCK DIAGRAM

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

19

Basic Frequency Control Loops


Reference
power

PC

SpeedGovernor

Mechanical
power output

Steam valve
position

Pv

Turbine

Pm

Electrical power
output

Pe

Generator

Pe

Pm

PL

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

20

Real Power Control: Block Diagram


Prime mover Model
Generator Model

Pe

Pm

Load
Model
System
Network

PL

Speed-Governor Model
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

21

Generator Model
According to swing equation to small
perturbation (linearized model):

M Pm Pe
Taking Laplace transform, we have.

Pm Pe Ms
2

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

22

Generator Model: Block Diagram


The block diagram of the generator model is
given below.
As the transfer function is derived from swing
equation, we call Rotor angle transfer function.
This model assume that the damping D of the
generator is negligible.

Pm

1
Ms 2

Pe
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

23

Load Model
For resistive load, the impedance is
independent of frequency.
For motor loads, the power drawn is sensitive
to frequency, depending on speed-load
characteristics and is approximated by,

Pe PL DL

Taking Laplace transform, we have.

Pe PL DL s
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

24

Load Model: Block Diagram


The block diagram of the load model is given
below.
Pe

D s
L

PL
We will now eliminate Pe by combining
generator and load model.

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

25

Generator-Load Model
Pm

1
Ms 2 DL s

PL

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

26

Turbine (Prime Mover) Model


Prime mover is the
source of mechanical
power such as hydraulic
turbines, steam
turbines, or gas
turbines.
This model relates the
changes in mechanical
power output Pm to
the change in steam
valve position Pv
10/9/2013

The simplest model can


be approximated with a
single time constant (T)
as shown in the
following transfer
function.

Pv

1
1 s T

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

Pm

27

Governor Model
The speed governor compares the control set point Pc
to the change of power consumed that is measured by
the deviation in frequency .
It is assumed that the deviation in frequency causes
the change in power consumption proportionally. This
type of governor is characterized as a proportional
controller with a gain of 1/R.
Consider a time constant (G) of the governor, we can
write the following transfer function.

1
1

Pc
Pv
R

1 s G
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

28

Governor Model: Block Diagram


The inputs of this model are the frequency
deviation and the control set point.
The output of this model is the valve position
command Pv.

1
R

PC

10/9/2013

1
1 s G

Pv

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

29

Turbine-Governor Model

1
R

PC

1
1 s G

Pv

1
1 s T

Pm

1
R

PC

10/9/2013

1
1 s G 1 s T

Pm

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

30

Speed-Power Relationship
From synchronous turbine-governor,
1
1

Pm
Pc
1 s G 1 s T
R

At steady state (s = 0), we have,


1
Pm Pc
R

R is called speed regulation or droop. It refers


to the variation of frequency with turbine
mechanical power output.
The unit of R depends on the units of and Pm.
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

31

The Unit for Regulation (R)


Unit for regulation (R) is radian per sec/ MW.
Consider a static-speed power curve in per
unit system,
1
PM PC
R

PM ,p.u .
Or,
This means that,

10/9/2013

PM PC
B

SB
S B R S B B
1
PC ,p.u .
p.u .
Rp.u .
Rp.u .

SB

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

32

Static Speed-Power Curve

Slope = -R

0
0

At steady state, the


change in frequency can
be related to power
output linearly.

2
1

1
Pm Pc
R

L
Pm
PC1= Pm1 PC 2 Pm 2
Pm 0

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

33

Example 11.2 (Bergen and Vittal)


A standard figure for R is 0.05 p.u. (or 5%).
This relates fractional changes in to
fractional (per unit) changes in Pm. Thus, we
have /0 = -0.05Pm, where Pm is in p.u.
If the frequency changes from 60 Hz to 59 Hz, find
the increase in Pm.
What change in frequency would cause Pm to
change from 0 to 1 i.e. no load to full load?

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

34

Example 11.2 (Bergen and Vittal)


Let

Rp.u . 0.05,
(a) Find increase in PM ,p.u .
59 Hz.

PM ,p.u .

p.u .

when frequency change from 60 Hz to

2 59 60 1

2 60
60

1
1 1
PC ,p.u .
p.u . 0
0.333
Rp.u .
0.05 60

(b) Find change in frequency when PM ,p.u .

PM ,p.u .

10/9/2013

1
p.u . 0 1
0.05

changes from 0 to 1.

p.u . 5%

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

3
60
35

AGC for single generator


AGC for multi generators
Special case: AGC for two generators

AUTOMATIC GENERATION
CONTROL FOR SINGLE AREA
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

36

AGC for Single Generator


Combine all the control block diagrams, we
can draw closed-loop real power control of a
synchronous generator as follows.

1
R

PC

1
1 s G 1 s T

Pm
-

1
Ms DL

PL
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

37

1
PC
R

PM

1
1 s G 1 s T
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

38

Steady-State Frequency Calculation:


Without Load Damping
At steady-state, s=0, we can write:
1
Pm Pc
R
Pm PL
When the control power setting of the generator
remains constant, the change in load will cause
the frequency to vary according to:

PL

1
R
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

39

Steady-State Frequency Calculation:


With Load Damping
At steady-state, s=0, we can write:
1
Pm Pc
R
Pm PL DL

When the control power setting of the generator


remains constant, the change in load will cause
the frequency to vary according to:
PL

1
DL
R
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

40

Example 12.2 (Hadi and Saadat)


A single area consists of two
Assume that the two units are from
generating units, 600 MVA and 500 the same power plant i.e. ignore the
MVA with 6% and 4% per unit
effect of transmission lines.
based on its own rating. Both units
1
Pm1 Pc1
are sharing 900 MW at the
R1
nominal frequency. Unit 1 supplies
1
500 MW and unit 2 supplies 400

m2
c2
MW at 60 Hz. The load is increased
R2
by 90 MW.
Assume there is no frequencyPm1 Pm2 PL DL
dependent load i.e. D=0. Find the new
steady state frequency and the new
PL
generation on each unit.

1
1
The load varies 1.5 percent for every 1
D

L
percent change in frequency i.e. D =
R1 R2
1.5. Find the new steady state
frequency and the new generation on
each unit.
Ans: 59.76 Hz, (540,450) MW,59.775 Hz, (537.5,446.875) MW

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

41

Example 12.2 (Hadi and Saadat)


Change the base of the regulation of both units to the same
value. Let the base complex power be 1000 MVA, then
Rp.u ., new

S B, new
S B, old

Rp.u .,old

The per unit load change is 90/1000 = 0.09 p.u.


When D = 0, per unit frequency deviation is,
The new steady state frequency is,
Change in generation for each unit can be found from:

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

42

Example 12.2 (Hadi and Saadat)


When D = 1.5, per unit frequency deviation is,
The new steady state frequency is,
Change in generation for each unit can be
found from:

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

43

AGC for Multiple Generators


Consider effect of
power flows in transmission lines, and
loads at each bus

to mechanical power of each generator.


This analysis assumes that every bus is a
generator bus.

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

44

Power Balance Equation at Each Bus


At each bus,
Pei PDi Pi

Where
Pei = Electrical power output of
Generator i
PDi = Load power at bus i
Pi = Net power injection from
bus i

Consider a small
change,

Pei PDi Pi
10/9/2013

G1

V1
PD1

G2

Pe2

Pe1

P2

P1

V2
PD 2

V3
Pe3

PD3
G3

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

45

Load Power Equation (PDi)


Assume that
PDi DLi i PLi DLi i PLi
Where

PLi = Small change of load input


PDi = Small change of load power
i = Small change of voltage angle

Substitute in power balance equation,


Pei PDi Pi

We have
10/9/2013

Pei DLi i PLi Pi


EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

46

Turbine Mechanical Power Output


Linearized equation relating mechanical power to
generator power and generator speed.

Pmi M i i Pei
From,

Pei DLi i PLi Pi

We have

Pmi M i i DLi i PLi Pi


How to represent this term?
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

47

AGC for Multiple Generators

Change in tie-line
Pi power flow

1
Ri

PCi

Pmi

1 s Gi 1 s Ti

1
M i s DLi

PLi
GMi s

10/9/2013

1 s Gi 1 s Ti

1
GPi s
M i s DLi

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

48

Tie-line Model ( Pi )
From power flow equation,
n

Pi Vi Vk Bik sin i k
k 1

Approximate at normal operating condition, we


n
have
Pi Bik i k
k 1

Then, for small change,


n

k 1

k 1

Pi Bik i k Tik i k
Where Tik is called stiffness or synchronizing power coefficient
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

49

Tie-Line Block Diagram


n

From Pi Tik i k and


k 1

We have,
i
Pi

Tik
Pi i k
k 1 s
i

1
s

Tik

1

s

+
-

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

50

AGC for Two Generators


Governor 1 sense
speed , try to
mechanical power

PC1

G M 1 s

PC 2
Governor 2 sense
speed , try to
mechanical power
10/9/2013

PL1
PM 1 +

Steady state: New


(lower) system
Frequency

1
R1

G P1 s

P1 P12

Transfer power 12

-1

G M 2 s

PM 2+

Frequency 1

+
Different phase angle

P2 P21

G P 2 s

T12
Frequency 2

1
R2

PL 2

Load

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

51

Static Speed-Power Characteristic


Consider two
generators, each with
different regulation R1
and R2.
When the load
increases, frequency
drops.
Steady state is reached
when the frequency of
both generators are the
same.
10/9/2013

2
1
+

= Change in
total load
PM

PM 1

PM 1 PM 2

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

PM 2
52

Steady State Frequency Calculation


Consider a special case of 2 generators connected via a
transmission line.
Consider the frequency at steady state,
Pm1 DL1 PL1 Pt line

Pm2 DL 2 PL 2 Pt line

When the control power setting of each generator


remains constant,
1
PM 1
R1

Then,

10/9/2013

PM 2

1

R2

PL1 PL 2

1
1
DL1 DL 2
R1 R2

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

53

Note that
In single area- multi generators case, we have
not discussed how to systematically bring
back the new steady state frequency by
adjusting control power: Pc.
We will discuss this in the following section.

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

54

Simplified Control Model


Area Control Error (ACE)
Example 11.5

AUTOMATIC GENERATION
CONTROL FOR MULTI-AREA
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

55

NERC Control Areas

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

56

Simplified Control Model


Generators are grouped into control areas.
Consider
An area as one generator in single area, and,
Tie-lines between areas as transmission lines
connecting buses in single area.

We can apply the same analysis to multi-area!!


However, we have to come up with frequencypower characteristics of each area.
Actual application of this model is for power pool
operation.
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

57

Area Frequency Response


Characteristic
Consider a one-area system with multiple generators.
Neglecting losses and dependence of load on
frequency, steady-state frequency-power relation can
be found as follows.
Pm Pm1 Pm2 Pm3

1
1
Pc1 Pc 2 Pc3

R1 R2 R3

Pm Pc

10/9/2013

PL

1
1
1

R1 R2 R3

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

58

Area Frequency Response


Characteristic with Load Damping
From
And

Pm Pm1 Pm2 Pm3

1
1
Pc1 Pc 2 Pc3

R1 R2 R3

Pm PL DL

We can write

Pm Pc

10/9/2013

PL

1
1
1
DL
R1 R2 R3

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

59

Example 11.2 (Glover, Sarma, Overbye)


An interconnected 60 Hz power system
consists of one area with three turbinegenerator units rated 1000, 750, and 500
MVA. The regulation constant of each unit
is R = 0.05 per unit based on its own
rating. Each unit is initially operated at
one-half of its own rating, when the
system load suddenly increases by 200
MW. Assume that the control power
setting of each generator remains
constant. Neglect losses and the
dependence of load on frequency. Find:
The per-unit area frequency response
characteristic on a 1000 MVA system
base.
The steady-state drop in area frequency.
The increase in turbine mechanical power
output of each unit.
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

60

Power Pool Operation


Power pool is an interconnection of the power
systems of individual utilities.
Each company operates independently, BUT,
They have to maintain
contractual agreement about power exchange of
different utilities, and,
same system frequency.

Basic rules
Maintain scheduled tie-line capacities.
Each area absorbs its own load changes.
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

61

AGC for Multi Areas


During transient period, sudden change of load causes each
area generation to react according to its frequency-power
characteristics.
This is called primary control.
This change also effects steady state frequency and tie-line
flows between areas.
We need to
Restore system frequency,
Restore tie-line capacities to the scheduled value, and,
Make the areas absorb their own load.

This is called secondary control.


10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

62

Area Control Error (ACE)


Control setting power of each area needs to
be adjusted corresponding to the change of
scheduled tie-line capacity and change of
system frequency.
For two-area case, ACE measures this balance,
and is given by,
ACE1 P12 B1

ACE 2 P21 B2

B is called frequency bias setting.


10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

63

Frequency Bias Setting B


The constant B is called frequency bias setting.
The choice of B depends on the control center.
To get the accurate adjustment of the control
power setting of each generator unit, the
frequency bias setting should be set as follows.

1
Bi DLi
Ri

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

64

ACE: Tie-Line Bias Control


Use ACE to adjust setting control power Pci of
each area.
Goal:
To drive ACE in all area to zero.
To send appropriate signal to setting control
power Pci

We should therefore use integrator


controller so that ACE goes to zero at steady
state.
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

65

AGC for 2-Area with Tie-line Bias Control: Block


Diagram
Governor 1 sense speed ,
try to mechanical power

Governor 1 sense speed1,


try to mechanical power
R

B1
+

ACE1

P12+
-1
P21+
+

ACE 1 = 0

ACE2
ACE 2 < 0

B2
2

10/9/2013

K1
s

PC1

G M 1 s

PM 1

PL1
-

Frequency 1
Frequency 1

G P1 s

P1 P12Different phase angle +


Transfer power 12
T12
Transfer power 12
-1
Different phase angle Setting control power 2
P2 P21
2
K 2 PC 2
PM 2
2 s

+
G M 2 s
G P 2 s
s
+
Frequency 2
Governor 2 sense speed 1
,
PL 2 Load 2 Frequency 2
try to mechanical power
R2
Steady state:
+

Governor 2 sense
speed , try to
mechanical power

Maintain Frequency
Set control power 2 > 0

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

66

AGC for 2-Area with Tie-line Bias Control :


Static Speed-Power Curve
Load in area 2 increases.

Frequency of both area


drops.
ACE makes Control power of0
area 2 increases.

Steady state is reached
when frequency is back at
the operating point and
generator in area 2 take its
own load.

2
2
1
+

= Change in load 2

PM
PM 1

PM 1 PM 2

PM 2 PM 2

PM 1
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P.


Jirutitijaroen

67

Example 11.5 (Bergen and Vittal)


Two-area system,
A

PGA0 PLA0 1000 MW


RA 0.015 rad per sec/MW

PGB0 PLB0 10,000 MW

DLA DLB 0

RB 0.0015 rad per sec/MW

PLA 10 MW

Find change in frequency, ACE, and


appropriate control action.
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

68

Example 11.5: Frequency Calculation


From,

PMA DLAA PLA PAB PLA PAB


PMB DLB B PLB PBA PBA

And,
And,

1 2

1
P
RA
A
M

We have,

1
P
RB
B
M

PLA
10

0.0136 rad per sec


1
1
1
1

RA RB 0.015 0.0015
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

69

Example 11.5: ACE Calculation


First, find

PAB

from

1
1
P

0.0136 0.9091 MW
RA
0.015
PMA PLA PAB PAB PMA PLA 9.091 MW
A
M

Then,

PBA PAB 9.091 MW

1
1
0.0136 10 MW
ACE A PAB
9.091
RA
0.015
1
1
0.0136 0 MW
ACE B PBA
9.091
RB
0.0015
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

70

Example 11.5: Control Action


ACE indicates each area action to the change
of load.
ACE of area B is zero, this means that nothing
should be done in area B.
ACE of area A < 0, this means that area A
should increase the setting control power by
(-10) = 10 MW to cover its own load.

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

71

ERCOT Frequency Plot


60.1
Primary Control
60.05
60

Recovery

59.95
59.9
59.85
59.8

Secondary Control

From www.ercot.com
59.75
10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

72

ERCOT ACE
Operating requirement: Standard BAL-001-0 Real Power Balancing Control
Performance, effective April 1, 2005 from www.ercot.com

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

73

Economic Dispatch
The last component of AGC is economic
dispatch.
The main goal of economic dispatch is to make
sure that the scheduled of units are done in
the most economical way.
This section is covered in Lecture 4: Economic
dispatch and optimal power flow.

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

74

Next Lecture
Relation between voltage and reactive power
Reactive power and voltage control
Generator excitation control
Other voltage control devices

Voltage stability analysis


North American August 2003 Blackout

10/9/2013

EE5702R Advanced Power System Analysis:: Control I by P. Jirutitijaroen

75

Вам также может понравиться