Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
MAR 17 2014
TRANSCRIPT
NO.
151759-3
APPELLATE NO.
rti:coRI) ON
E2013-01528-COA-R3-CV
VOLUME I OF I
SUPPLEMENTAL # 2
APPEALED FROM
VS.
TO THE
COURT OF APPEALS
KNOXVILLE, TENNESSEE
FILED THIS
20
DAY OF
CLERK
COUwi ,
DEPUTY CLERK
NO.
TRANSMITTED THIS
DAY OF
20
011
No. 151759-3
E2 Ol3-Cl528-COA-R3CV
DATE
PAGE
Oj,/O 2 ,J 20 C 6
32
03/0""/201C
87
Answer
05/20/2008
62
Answer
05/20// 200E
62
11/14// 2001
11/-14 //2001
04/22/2013 112
04/28,2006
3':
ILO/01/'200 7
/
41
07/24/2008
75
Flat
08/13/2008
7q
07/29/2008
7&
Issued Injunction
07/24/2008
Issued Injunction
08/13./2008
Letter Filed
12/20/2S07
46
Letter Filed
02/21/2013
97
01/31/2013
95
Mediation Order
12/21/200/
/1
10/01 /12007
09/26/2006
80
08/26/2002
19
05/05/2 CO 8
60
07/21/20108
06/17/2008
05/17/2007
39
Notice
08/26/2002
24
Notice of Appearance
04/04/2008
03/31/2'008
57
06/12/2002
Notice of Hearing
06/17// 2008
67
05/30/2008
65
07/19 /1 2010
91
Order
03/11/2014
06/07/2002
16
06/26/2008
68
04/28/2006
31
09/'18/2007
401
06/04/2002
28
Subpoena Issued
03/20/2009
83 1
Subpoena Issued
03"'5/2009
Subpoena Issued
03/'30/2009
85
11/14 /2C 07
44
12/04/2007
aa
01/07/2008
49
02 /05/2 008
cc
Printed
03/31/20H8
58
051/2-3 /2008
64
06/19//2008
69
06/26/2008
70
03/06/2009
88
04 /20 // 20 10
8$
ummaru of No
dc cc
34 :
05/10/2010
89
06/29/2010
90
00/16/2010
92
01/22/2013
94
01/31/2013
96
Summons Executed
Secretary of State
01/16/2008
50
Summons Executed
Secretary of State
05/1 6/2013
1(16
05/16/2013
110
Secretary of State
05/16/2013
115
Summons Executed
07 / 31/2001
10/18/2002
29
12/10/2010
93
03/28/2013
98
03/28/2013
1)70
03/28/2013
102
04/10/2013
10 4
120
02 // 28/2002
Trial Notice
08/07/2002
18
Trial Notice
10 / 16 //0 0 2
26
Trial Norice
03/06/2003
27
Y COURT
AR 11 2014
Petitioner,
vs.
No. 151759-3
Respondent.
ORDER
The Clerk of the Court has exhaustively compared the contents of the Court's file
in the above-styled case. It appears that with the submission of the attached documents,
the Court of Appeals will have every document which exists in our files. The Court finds
that no documents remain within this file to further supplement the Appellate Record.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Entered this \
day of
MICHAEL W. MOYERS
CHANCELLOR
cc:
\ \5
)
)
Plaintiff,
vs.
No. 1I
/
Cl-
EI)
)
-
SUMMONS
day of
2001.
\11
Clerk>.
Deputy Clerk -
NOTICE
To the defendant:
Tennessee law provides a four thousand dollar ($4,000) personal property exemption
from execution or seizure to satisfy a judgment. J.fajudgment should be entered against you in
this action and you wish to claim property as exempt, you must file a written list, under oath,
of the items you wish to claim as exempt with the clerk of the court. The fist may be filed at
any time and may be changed by you thereafter as necessary, however, unless it is filed before
the judgment becomes final, it will not be effective as to any execution or garnishment issued
prior to the filing of the list. Certain items are automatically exempt by law and do not need to
be listed; these include items of necessary wearing apparel for yourself and your family and
trunks or other receptacles necessary to contain such apparel, family portraits, the family Bible,
and school books. Should any of these items be seized, you would have the right to recover
them. If you do not understand your exemption right or how to exercise it, you may wish to
seek the counsel of a lawyer.
216
day of
____ 20.__.
,Z,9
2001,1:
tnred this summons and a complaint on defendant MICHAEL PETER TULAY in the
liowing manner.
30 complete
Complete items 1, 2, and
item 4 if Restricted Deliver, desired.
Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to you.
Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,
or on the front if space permits.
B. Date of Delivery
4t411&1 ( t)
t(11u) t21
C. SianareA
/)
tWad
j4Lrzrrc/ 1
If YES,
.1
PS Form
3811,
DAgent
Wr Addressee I
11 Yes
13 No
3. S rvice Type
M.I D Express Mail
0 Return Receipt for Merchandise
Registered
0 Insured Mail
0 C.O.D.
0 Yes
March 2001
JI
3(
102595-01-M-142
I Complete items 1,
13. Also complete
item 4 if Restricted t
,ery is desired.
I Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to you.
Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,
or on the front if space permits.
Received by (Please
'le-0y)
B. Date of Delivery
C. Signature
DAgent
D Addressee
j
ArUcle
Addressed
. to:
OgIto
4
'44f9J CIYK1
3.a ic elype
()J72
2. Article Number
(flsnsfer from service lab"
PS Form
3811,
March 2001
0 yes
1618
'73
..',
102595-01M-14241
NOTICES SENT TO
LAFEVOR JAMES R
MYNATT,
WILLIAM A.,
JR.
1:21
IN THE CHANCERY COURT FOR KNOX COUNTY, TENNESSEE
PAMELA M. TULA.Y,
Plaintiff
V.
Defendant
JOHN K. BARBER
Pryor, Flynn, Priest & Barber
Two Centre Square, Suite 00
625 Gay Street
P. 0. Box 870
Knoxville, Tennessee 37901
(865) 522-4191
PRYOR, FLYNN
PRIEST & FIARBER
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
Suite 600
Two Centre Square
Me tor
11
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned hereby certifies that an exact copy
of this Report of the Mediator has been served upon the
following counsel of record by U.S. mail with sufficient
postage thereon to ensure the delivery of same:
James R. LaFevor
Nickle & LaFevor
1900 First Tennessee Plaza
800 S. Gay Street
Knoxville, Tennessee 37929
William A. Nynatt, Jr.
Sheppeard & Swanson
616 W. Rill Avenue
P. 0. Box 2149
Knoxville, Tennessee 37901
This the
PR'VR, FLYNN
PRIEST & HARBER
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
Suite 600
Two Centre Square
P.O. Box 870
Knoxville, TN 37901
N.
J
)
VS.
0:
13
lV
No.
Noti of Entry Required
Defendant
400
With Father
(even, odd or every)
__ODD_______
(THANKSGMNG EVE FROM
5:00 PM TO THURSDAY AT
7:00 PM)
EVERY
10
] There are limiting factors in Section VI, but there are no restrictions on
Father's ( ] Mother's residential time with the children for the following
reasons:
11
following reasons:
12
V. CHILD SUPPORT
5.1 Financial Support
[X] The (] Mother (XJ Father will pay child support in the amount of $3,900 per
month or $1,800.00 per BI-WEEKLY PAY PERIOD beginning _NOVEMBER 1, 2001.
FATHER WILL PAY CHILD SUPPORT BY PERSONAL CHECK UNTIL PAYROLL
EAJ
O1
S(
DIRECT DEPOSIT TO SUNTRUST BANK, ACCOUNT NO. 547036183 TAKES
EFFECT.
[X] The payer of child support shall make the payments set forth above directly
Mother's home with children.
to the other parent by mail or delivery at
[] The payer of child support shall make the payments set forth above by wage
assignment together with a 5% fee for a total of $______ per____________
beginning
(X] The payer of child support and the payer's attorney, if any, affirm that this
amount conforms to the Tennessee Child Support Guidelines.
(] The payer of child support and the payer's attorney, if any, affirm that this
amount of child support does not conform to the Tennessee Child Support
Guidelines, but it is in the best interest of the child(ren) because
13
14
MORITZ TULAY
//
?m
NOTARY PUBLIC
L(/!32
!
Date and place'of signature'
day of
My Commission Expires:
2001.
L4
_oS
15
Hj/3
Jot
Ktp.v, ifr,ft'-
Ml HALPETERTULAY
o4
My Commission Expires: LA
Th
2001.
NOTARY PUBLIC
Dated:
Judge:
____
M . 77, ~9
JUN 7 2002
Presented by Counsel:
---
S ,gnature
HOWARD G. hOGAN
1051
JamesR.LaFevor
Name
Address 800 S.Gay Street Ste. 1900
Knoxville, TN 37929-1900
Phone (865)637-6258
Name
Address
Address of Mother
Address of Father
BPR #
BPR # Signature
Phone
_KNOXVILLE, TN 37931
_KNOXVILLE, TN 37923
Deputy Clerk
Deputy Clerk
CERTIFICATE
I, Rm.e S. o -;n S.c .o; oLtiSt tSc,S I hc0
iIJtra
cli
[If applicable] Mediation servic es p rovided by: John KandilakisChiId & Clinical
pa:tioc 0; '11 elI ottSn;! 0.0 or; w Sore not approved
Psychology, 135 Fox Road Knoxville TN Tel (865) 694-8792 OOL,0, by p ia.yn; oa;;o is ISO U.S. 15a1, postage p;tpoiii 51115
_-tf_ 4J_I
26Q
8
CIek
--
Deputj den
16
)
-.
Plaintiffi,
vs.
)
)
)
No. 15 59-3
Noti of Entry Required
James R. LaFor
NICKLE and LAFEVOR
1900 First Tennessee Plaza
800 S. Gay Street
Knoxville, TN 37929
(865) 637-6258
(865) 637-8476 FAX
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
This is to certify that a true and exact copy of the foregoing Notice of Attorney's Lien
has been placed in the U. S. Mail for delivery to:
Diane M. Messer
SOBIESKI, MESSER & ASSOCIATES
900 S. Gay Street, Ste. 1801
Knoxville, TN 37902
William A. Mynatt, Jr.
SHEPPEARD & SWANSON
P.O. Box 2149 I
Knoxville, TN 37901-1249
Pamela M. Tulay
9423 Yuma Drive
Knoxville, TN 37931
this
/7
, 2002.
day of
/
JAMES R LAFEVOR
17
FILE COPY
08/07/02
vs.
MESSER, DIANE M
18
p1
FILED
2002 AUG 26 PK l: 36
PAMELA MORTTZ TIJLAY,
HOV4 G. HOGAN
Plaintiff,
vs.
No. 151759-3
James R. LaFevor, moves the Court to include an acknowledgement and protection of his
statutory attorney's lien in any Final Judgment of Divorce granted in this cause. In support of the
motion, he will show as follows:
1. James R LaFevor was attorney of record for Pamela Moretz Tulay.
2. James R. LaFevor and Pamela Moretz Tulay entered into a written agreement
concerning representation whereby she agreed to pay fees for time spent. (Attached as
Exhibit A is a copy of the retainer agreement).
3. James it LaFevor performed legal services on behalf of Ms. Tulay and submitted
billings for those. (Copies of the Billings may reflect attorney-client information and
will be submitted in camera for the court's review, if necessary.)
4. After negotiations and two lengthy mediation sessions with John Harber, Pamela
Moretz Tulay decided that she would seek other counsel.
5. James R. LaFevor has filed a Notice of Lien pursuant to the statute.
6. Pursuant to court opinions, the lien needs to be memorialized in any Final Judgment of
Divorce.
1
19
THEREFORE, James R. LaFevor moves that he be granted a lien against any assets of
Pamela Moretz Tulay pending resolution of the attorneys fee issue.
Respectfully submitted this
day of
, 2002.
JamIR.. LaFevor
914LE and LAFEVOR
00 First Tennessee Plaza
800 S. Gay Street
Knoxville, TN 37929
(865) 637-6258
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
This is to certify that a true and exact copy of the foregoing Motion for Attorney's Lien
has been HAND DELIVERED to:
Diane M. Messer
Attorney for Pamela Moretz Tulay
SOBIESKI, MESSER & ASSOCIATES
900 S. Gay Street, Ste. 1801
Knoxville, TN 37902
William A. Mynatt, Jr.
Attorney for Michael Peter Tulay
SHEPPEARD & SWANSON
P. 0. Box 2149
Knoxville, TN 37901-1249
Mailed this
44
0Y
FAMILY LAW FEES AND (OSTS AGREEMENT
DATE:
I jl_~
________
CLIENT NAME:
Qei
j-yl
ADDRESS:
9923
11'rv
11.4 !
Dr 'v'e
Street
APL
kk\ pi11
City
33J
State
(.,03
Zip Code
RE:
INTRODUCTION
This document constitutes our agreement for me representing you in your failtily law matter. Please read it
c.arefiully and call me if you have any questions. Discuss it with your regular family or business lawyer if you
like. If you find this agreement acceptable, please initial each page, sign on page 3, and return it to me with
your retainer for $2,000.00. Receipt by me will initiate my representation of you.
COUNSELING
If you are not in counseling, I recommend that you consider it. The length and expense of the case is usually
affected by the intensity of the parties' feelings. During a divorce or custody dispute many people experience
emotions that are difficult to handle without professional help. I find that the money invested in psychological
help is well spent because the client is better able to cope with the stress of the case. Counseling often results in
reduced attorneys' fees.
ADVANCE PAYMENT
A minimum $2,000.00 plus filing fees advance payment is required. if the case involves disputed custody
matters, it is often more expensive and a payment of $3,500.00 may be required, depending upon the
circumstances. I will place this retainer in the client trust account and bill you against this monthly. A 1)811 of
this $2,000.00 retainer is tion-refundable, namely, $700.00 in legal fees and a $60.0 1 ) case administration
fee which includes opening, copies, postage and local faxes. Express or certified mail, ITedex, and long
distance phone/lax are charged at cost. Example: Assume I complete 3.0 hours of work ($600.00). Your
costs would be the $700.00 minimum attorney labor charge and $60.00 case administration fee, for a total of
$760.00, trorn the $2,000.00 advance l)ayflleImt, $1,240.00 would be left in your trust acount. At the
conclusion of my representation of you, and after all charges are entered against your re airier, the remainder, if
any, in the client trust account will be refunded to you. If the balance in the client trust account is depleted
before the completion of the case, you areto replenish it, unless we have reached a sepal ate written agreement
otherwise. if you have any question about your bill, please call nrc.
CHARGES
My present hourly rate is $200.00, and $50.00 per hour for my legal assistant. These rates may increase from
time to time. I compute a minimum of one-tenth (1110) of an hour for each telephone call, no matter how short
its duralion. Additional time is recorded in tenths or all hour. Written coil ununicalions are encouraged because I
read faster than I can talk. Also, written coimurmuiricatiOil creates a record for the file.
Under Tennessee ethics rules, clients must bear expenses of litigation. Therefore, in ad hition to these fees, you
also will pay out-of-pocket costs incurred in your case. The costs include: court filing lees, long-distance
faxes/phone calls, computer research time, process servers, court reporters, witness fees, travel, experts and
investigators. I will not hire experts or investigators unless you agree that they should be hired and that you pay
directly to the expert or investigator their fees as incurred.
Page 1 of 3
ex
Ir"ITIALSJDATF
A
TOTAL BILL
I do not know how much time your case will take, because I do not know what the disputed issues will be nor
how long negotiations or trial preparation will last. Your cooperation in providing information and in working
viih ine on your case can considerably expedite the case and help reduce attorney's fees. Call me as often as you
like, but please keep in mind that telephone calls do increase your expenses (although nocj.iMge will be made for
telephone calls or in-person conferences reg a rding your bills). It may cost less if you keep me updated by mail,
however, if your information needs prompt attention, please call or fax information to ore right away.
NO GUARANTEES OF OUTCOME
You acknowledge that I have made no guarantees regarding the outcome of your case or about issues that may
he decided by the court prior to a final ruling. Statements that I make regarding the likely outcome or the range
Of possible outcomes are only my opinionnot a guarantee of results.
Page 2 of 3
crr1+ 7 I 3 1 1,
IflTIALS/DATE
DI
22
SCOPE OF REPRESENTATION
The provisions of this agreement shall apply only to the matter referenced above and, unless otherwise
specifically provided, my representation oIyou shall he for trial court proceedings only. If appellate proceedings
arc instituted, or if you want to institute appellate jrrocccdiiigs, additional fee and ictainer ;igrectncnls inut he
made. If I continue to represent you after final judgment or after our initial undertaking is ;ompleied. all of these
provisions shall apply, and we shall each be bound by these terms, unless we have a writicti agreement to the
contrary.
Effective January 1, 2001, Tennessee has enacted a new parenting plan requirement, which also calls for
alternative methods of dispute resolution. Charges will be incurred for all representation on dispute resolution.
A Permanent Parenting Plan is required in all cases involving children.
CONFIDENTIALITY
Communications with me and my assistants concerning your case are generally confidential and are protected
Front disclosure under attorney-client privilege rules. This privilege is not absolute, and I may be required to
reveal irnlormiflion II' necessary to prevent a crime or fraud. Your privilege of confidentiality can also be lost if
you discuss our communications with oilier persons. lithe court is asked to decide the is:ue of attorney's fees in
Iris case, this agreement may be disclosed to the court. If, at any time, you have questions about confidentiality,
please call ine to discuss them.
CLOSING
I look forward to representing you in this matter. We welcome and encourage your input and suggestions.
Signed this
?D
day ofit,1W1
ACCEPTED BY:
,2001.
(I lUYhJL'V't[
CLIENT
ES R. LAFEV(R, ATTORNEY
KLE & LAFEVOK
An Association and not a Partnership)
I
1900 First Tennessee Plaza
800 S. Gay Street
Knoxville, TN 37929
Telephone: (865) 637-6258
23
0
IN THE CHANCERY COURT FOR KNOX COUNTY, TENNESSEE
vs.
MICHAEL PETER TULAY,
Defendant.
NOTICE
That James K LaFevor will appear before the Chancellor on the 3rd of September, 2002,
on a motion concerning a lien for attorney's fees.
Respectfully submitted this 26th day of August, 2002.
LaFevor (. J
and LAFEVOR
9OO First Tennessee Plaza
800 S. Gay Street
Knoxville, TN 37929
(865) 637-6258
24
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
This is to certify that a true and exact copy of the foregoing Notice has been HAND
DELIVERED to:
Diane M. Messer
Attorney for Pamela Moretz Tulay
SOB1ESKI, MESSER & ASSOCIATES
900 S. Gay Street, Ste. 1801
Knoxville, TN 37902
William A. Mynatt, Jr.
Attorney for Michael Peter Tulay
SHEPPEARD & SWANSON
P. 0. Box 2149
Knoxville, TN 37901-1249
DATED this
2
25
CHC(
VS.
NOTICES SENT TO
W NATT WILLIAM A., JR.
OBIESI, WANDA G.
--
MESSER, DIANE M
W.
NOTICES SENT TO
MYNATT, WILLIA!1 A., JR.
SOBIESKI, WANDA G.
MESSER, DIANE M
27
1E
IN THE CHANCERY COURT FOR KNOx COUNTY, TENNESSEE
PLAINTIFF
VS
NO. 1S1759-3
DEFENDANT
TO THE
AND TO:
GREETINGS:
You are hereby notified, by Fiat of Chancellor
Sharon Bell
2002
December 20
at
9:30 a.m.
This
18th
day of
October
, 202
4
Clerk and Maste
/2'
I
f FAILED T
DAYS AFTER ISSUANCE BECAUSE
CIA
DEPUTY S2EIIFF
28
STATE OF TENNESSEE
Ql
PlaintiffPetitioner,
V.
I)efcndantfRespondent.
day of
, .te'
&e-?
,44-'.b Ac
Clerk
Deputy L erk
NOTICE
To the Defendant(s):
Tennessee law provides a Four Thousand Dollars ($4000) personal property
exemption from execution or seizure to satisfy a judgment. if a judgment should be
entered against you in this action and you wish to claim property as exempt, you must file
a written list, under oath, of the items you wish to claim asxempt with the clerk ef the
courL The list may be filed at any rime and may be changed by you thereafter as
necessary; however, unless it is filed . before the judgment becomes final, it will not be
effective as to any execution of garnishment issued prior to the filing of the list
Certain itenis are automaticaity exempt by law and do not need to be listed; these include
hems of necessary wearing apparel for yourself and your family and trunks or other
receptacles necessary to contain such apparel, family portraits, the family Bible, and
school books. Should any of these items be seized, you would have the right to recover
them, if you do not understand your exemption right, or how to exercise it. you may
wish to seek the counsel of a lawyer. Tenn. Code Ann. 26-2-114.
SERVICE INFORMATION
To the Process Server: Michael Peter Tulay can be served through his attorney of
-record, William A. Mynati, Jr. at Sheppcard & Swanson, 616 W. Hill Avenue, Knoxville,
Tennessee 37902.
RETUPN
Oc 4z,_
I received this summons on the - I_day of
,
led-
6-_
ec'-)_c_i
) 1
'
failee -tb seve ttns so fmor,s within thirty (30) days after its issuance because:
Process
29
FLED
STATE OF TENNESSEE
DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES
(865) 862-0366
FAX (865) 862-0403
200b APR 28 P 3: 5L
HOWARD HOGAN
C/C BLDG. 400 MAIN A N
0. HOGAW
FIRST -FLOOR1 SUITE
KNOXVILLEi TN 3?902 -CLERK &MASTER
04/21/2006
RE:
The enclosed Order/Notice to Withhold Income For Child Support is being provided to you pursuant to
Tennessee Code Annotated, 36-5-501(b)(4).
30
ME
STATE OF TENNESSEE
DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES
(865) 862-0366
RE:
REMITTANCE INFORMATION
With your remittance you must provide the payment Turnaround Document (Employer Obligation
Letter) provided to you by the Department of Human Services, or you must provide all of the following
information.
Date payment was deducted from
employee's/obligor's income
Docket number
Court identifier
Employee's/Obligor's name
Employee's/Obligor's Social Security number
Employee's/Obligor's return address
PLEASE CONTACT THE OFFICE LISTED ABOVE IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS ABOUT THIS NOTICE
31
AMENDED
TERMINATION
Date: _04121/2006
State/Tribe/Territory TENNESSEE
City/Co./Dist./Reservation KNOX
Non-governmental entity or Individual
Case Number CHANCERY 1 151759-3
ORDER INFORMATION: This document is based on the support or witholding order from TENNESSEE
You are required by law to deduct these amounts from the employee's/obligor's income until further notice.
Per _MONTH
3.900-00
current child support
1.950,00
Per MONTH
0 yes 0 no
REMITTANCE INFORMATION: When remitting payment, provide the pay date/date of withholding and the case identifier. If the
employee's/obligor's principal place of employment is Tennessee, begin withholding no later than the first pay period occurring 14
working days after the date of 0412112006. Send payment within 7 working days of the pay date/date of withholding. The total
withheld amount, including your fee, may not exceed 50'V0 of the employee's! obligor's aggregate disposable weekly earnings.
IF the employee's/ obligor's principal place of employment is not Tennessee, for limitations on withholding, applicable time requirements,
and any allowable employer fees, follow the laws and procedures of the employee's/obligor's principal place of employment (see
#3 and
Print Name
Signature
Signature
Date
0412112006
0 Court
IS IV-D Agency
U Attorney with authority under state law to issue order/notice
Date
U Attorney U Individual
U Private Entity
NOTE: Non-IV-D Attorneys, individuals, and non-governmental entities must submit a Notice of an Order to Withhold and
include a copy of the income withholding order unless, under a state's law, an attorney in that state may issue an income
withholding order. In that case, the attorney may submit an Order/Notice to Withhold and include a copy of the state law
authorizing the attorney to issue an income withholding order/notice.
IMPORTANT: The person completing this Form is advised that the information on this form may be shared with the obligor.
32
pJRL Hi
AGi
STATE OF TENNESSEE
DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES
L LZ U
MICHAEL P. TULAYC
9042 LEGENDS LAKE b
KNOXVILLE, TN 37922-5258
ME,
'
Pursuant to T.C.A. 3 6-5-803, you are hereby ORDERED to pay all future, support payments to
Central Child Support Receipting Unit, P. 0. Box 305200, Nashville, TN 37229. The payments
should include the following amounts:
$3,900.00
$.00
$.00
$ .00
$.00
$.00
$3,900.00
per
per
per
per
per
per
per
33
You must return with your payment the payment coupon provided by the Department of
Human Services. If you have not received one, contact Customer Service at 1-800-8386911. If you do not return the payment coupon, you must provide the following
information:
Docket ID: 151759-3
Court Identifier: 4709305
Your name
Your Social Security Number
Your return address
Pursuant to T.C.A. 36-5-120, failure to include the information requested above may
result in a civil penalty being issued against you.
You are hereby notified that no credit shall be given for any payments made by you or by another
person on your behalf directly to the custodial parent. Such payments would be considered to be
a gift by you or payments of an obligation other than those listed above.
It is FURTHER ORDERED that the parties complete the required information found in Exhibit
A to this order. You must provide the information immediately to the local child support office
listed above. Additionally, you are required to notify the Child Support Office listed on Exhibit
A of any changes in the information on Exhibit A within ten (10) days of the change.
You may appeal this Administrative Order by filing a written request for an administrative
hearing with the child support office shown above within fifteen (15) calendar days of the entry
date of this order. The only grounds for appealing this order are: a mistake of identity, a mistake
of fact, or that this case is not a Title IV-D case.
Failure to obey this Administrative Order may result in the imposition of civil penalties, and/or
imprisonment for contempt, or suspension of your driver's or other licenses.
If you have any questions concerning this Administrative Order, you should contact the child
support office at the above address.
Enter this
day of
A24/
/2Z2
Title IVjYdininistrator / Supervisory Designee
34
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that a copy of this ORDER was served on MICHAEL P. TULAY PAMELA A.
,
MORITZ, and the Clerk of CHANCERY Court of KNOX County by mailing to him/her by
First Class U.S. Mail postage prepaid on 28 April, 2006.
e,e--
X~ -'~'
"
Page 3
35
Father's Information
SSN: _____ - ____ -
Full Name:
Last
Residential Address:
First
Middle
Phone: ( )
Birthdate: -
Mailing Address:
Birthplace -
City: ____
State:
Drivers License
LIp1o\ersNarne
Phoe
Employee s AJ&ess.
Oros
____
ilk on
IfleLlIk.
( ) Yes
( ) No
Company:
Health Insurance
Address:
Cost to Employee (if any):
$
Mother's Information
Fall Name:
1iddIe
1 at
Phone:
Reidential Ades:
Birthdate:
Mail
Birthplace -
Addr:
T7:
Phone:
Employer's Name:
Gross Income:
Employer's Address:
Health Iurance
Company:
YS
1) p10
( )
No
Health baiance
Address:
Cost to En plor cc (it any:
37
Child(ren)'s Information
(1) Child's Full Name:
SSN:
Last
First
Middle
Birthdate:
Residential Address:
First
Middle
/ -
irthdats:
Residential ddre:
SSN:
Last
Middle
Birthdate:
Residential Address:
First
Last
Middle
Brthdaie:
Residental ddrss
Last
SSN:
First
Middle
Birthdate: - /
Residential Address:
38
NON-RESIDENT NOTICE
TO:
PAMELA
-VS-
No:
151759-3\/
In this cause, it appearing from the Complaint filed, which is sworn to, that the defendant
non resident
whose where-abouts cannot be ascertained upon diligent search and inquiry, so that the ordinary process of law
cannot be served upon HER
consecutive weeks.
This
17th
day of
KIMBERLY R. TAYLOR
within thirty
May
(3
,2007
CT
{ No. 1405442
2007
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania,
County of Berks
587,
Approved
May 16,1929.
LU1HSCP
} ss:
H 9:Q7
18
u G. HOGN'1
Jo Mm Gottschall, Assistant Secretary, READING EAGLE COMPANY, of the County and Commonwealth aforesaid, being duly sworn,
deposes and says that the READING EAGLE established January 28, 1868 is a newspaper of general circulation published at 345 Penn
Stjeet, City of Reading, County and State aforesaid, and that the printed notice or publication attached hereto is exactly the same as printed
and published in the regular edition and issues of the said READING EAGLE on the following dates, viz.:
Reading Eagle
Reading Eagle
Reading Eagle
Reading Eagle
Effective July 1, 2002 Reading Times Ceased Publication. The Reading Eagle will be a daily morning and Sunday edition.
Affiant further deposes that this person is duly authorized by READING EAGLE COMPANY, a corporation, publisher of said
READING EAGLE, a newspaper of general circulation, to verify the foregoing statement under oath, and affiant is not interested in the
subject matter of the aforesaid notice or advertisement, and that all allegations in the foregoing statements as to time, place, character of
publication are true.
Copy of Notice or Publication
(y1
Jo Ann Ciottschall
No14.RESIDENr.NaTtc
MORITZ
7ULAY)
'MoRrrZ -
ULAY) - VI
ETEP TULAY
511CC-I
IN THE
- -
--
-0-7- _M------------
46ERY COURT
C COUNTY.
lESSEE -
------Notary
-
MORITZ VS TULAY
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYL\'A
NOIARIAL SEAL
Probating same
Total
$624.00
$5.00
$629.00
40
uJ
STATE OF TENNESSEE
DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SER IUS'
25
(865) 862-0366
FAX (865) 862-0403
HOWARD HOGAN
C/C BLDG. 400 MAIN AVENUE
FIRST FLOOR, SUITE 125
KNOXVILLE, TN 37902
09/19/2007
RE:
TCSES Case:
000836172
The enclosed Order/Notice to Withhold Income For Child Support is being provided to you pursuant to
Tennessee Code Annotated, 36.5-501(b)(4).
41
A.
AGRWU
)RE
17 V
STATE OF TENNESSEE
DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES
(865) 862-0366
RE:
TCSES Case:
000836172
The amount shown on the first page of this order is the new total that you should deduct. This new
amount should be substituted for, and not added to the amount you were previously ordered to
deduct for this particular tribunal/ease number. This modification does not affect any other deductions
you may have been ordered to make for any other case(s) involving this same obligor/employee.
E If this box is checked, you are no longer required to withhold income for this employeefobligor
for the case specified at the top of the first page of the order. This order to stop deducting from this
employee's/obligor's income only affects the case specified in the attached order. It does not affect any
other deductions you may have been ordered to make for any other cases involving this same
employee/obligor.
B. Remittance Information
With your remittance you must provide the payment Turnaround Document (Employer Obligation
Letter) provided to you by the Department of Human Services, or you must provide all of the
following information.
Employee's/Obligor's name
Employee's/Obligor's Social Security number
Employee's/Obllgor's return address
42
PLEASE CONTACT THE OFFICE LISTED ABOVE IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS ABOUT THIS NOTICE
0
0
(]
AMENDED
[J
TERMINATION
Date: _09/19/2007
State/Tribe/Territory TENNESSEE
City(Co.jDist.jkeservation
KNOX
Non-governmental entity or Individual
Case Number CHANCERY I 151759-3
SEOUOYAH CONSULTING GROUP
Employer's/Withholder's Name
153 PLEASANT ST STE 4
Employer's! Withholder's Address
ATTLEBORO, MA 02703-2444
ORDER INFORMATION: This document is based on the support or witholding order from TENNESSEE
You are required by law to deduct these amounts from the employee's/obligor's income until further notice.
1.025.00
Per MONTH
current child support
$
past-due child support
- Arrears greater than 12 weeks?
S _____________________ Per
0 yes 0 no
You do not have to vary your pay cycle to be in compliance with the support order. If your pay cycle does not match the ordered
payment cycle, withhold one of the following amounts:
S236.53 per weekly pay period.
$473.07 per biweekly pay period (every two weeks).
S
S
REMITTANCE INFORMATION: When remitting payment, provide the pay date/date of withholding and the case identifier. If the
employee's/obligor's principal place of employment is Tennessee, begin withholding no later than the first pay period occurring 14
working days after -the date of 09119/2007. Send payment within 7 working days of the pay date/date of withholding. The total
withheld amount, including your fee, may not exceed 50% of the employee's/obligor's aggregate disposable weekly earnings.
If the employee's/obligor's principal place of employment is not Tennessee, for limitations on withholding, applicable time requirements,
and any allowable employer lees, follow the laws and procedures of the employee's/ohligor's principal place of employment (see #3 and
#9 , ADDITIONAL INFORMATION TO EMPLOYERS AND OTHER WITHHOLDERS).
Send check to: RECEIPTINGUNIT
Make check payable to: TENNESSEE _CHILD SUPPORT
before first submission.
P.O._ BOX 305200
IF remitting payment by EFT/EDI, call (800)838-6911
NAHVTI J& TN 17 7 29
Use this FIPS code: - Bank routing number:_ Bank account aumber:_.
Signature
Date
Signature
Date
IV-D Agency
0911912007
D Court
0 Attorney 0 Individual
0 Private Entity
43
--
Page 1 of 1
11/14/2007 09:06:30
Name
TAYLOR, KIMBERLY R
TULAY, MICHAEL PETER
Address
11/3012007
44
Page 1 of 1
12/04/2007 11:30:12
Name
Address
12/21/2007
TAYLOR, KIMBERLY R
45
Howard G. Hogan
Clerk and Master
Chancery Court
400 Main Street
Suite 125
Knoxville, TN 37902
RE: Docket No. 151759-3
Dear Mr. Hogan,
A re-hearing in this case has been set for Friday, December 21,
2007 at 9:30 A.M.
However, due to a four-day (Sunday 12/16 through Wednesday
12/19) loss of power due to a severe ice storm in Pennsylvania, and
having to seek shelter elsewhere with my children, I am unable to attend
this re-hearing.
I appreciate the court's understanding in this matter. I hope that
the re-hearing can be rescheduled for a future date.
Respectfully,
Pamela Moritz
rS*n
FROM
,-,~ )
05:52PM Pt
2(
To: ft o
0/0
4:.20 2007
V
no
cuw-
in
~ 0"
V'VL r
F(Zow-
0 ace4-J7
C
El)
'
~~ Ull N
Ii o
47
I!
\fl
ENNESSEEDJE ii
PAMELA MORJTZ (formerly TULAY),
Original Plaintiff7Respondent,
. nUN
V.
Original Defendant/Respondent.
MEDIATION ORDER
Apri z g,
co 9
'i
, 2007.
skI :IJZ.iIh:!!
J!)S.SUjI.
I"H 1010,
CERT1FCATE
. icgn bc.y cctiiy t:;at I
How
tii3 a trae d
pE
NI
&{ZM&Z
(3
48
D
Cr
Pagel of 1
01/07/2008 13:58:42
Name
TAYLOR, KIMBERLY R
TULAY, PAMELA MORITZ
Address
05/14/2008
49
F!
it
State of Tennessee
Department of State
Division of Business Services
312 Eighth Avenue North
6th floor Wm. ft Snodgrass Tower
Nashville, Tennessee 37243
70070220000300898172
1/16/2008
Date
Certifed Number
RE:
Dear Clerk:
Enclosed are the following papers in the above styled case:
Original Summons
Affidavit and Endorsement
!I
li~
Sincerely:
a"~
'
Riley C. Darnell
enclosures
Initials:
Q.E
CC: TAYLOR
S5-4210 (Rev. 12/96)
WA No. 1003
50
Im
IE
AFFIDAVIT
and
ENDORSEMENT
1/1612008
Date
70070220000300898172
Certified Number
VS:
I
having been duly authorized by Riley C. Darnell, Secretary of State
BOB GRUNOW
of Tennessee, do hereby make oath on his behalf and under authorization as follows:
Thursday. December 27. 2007
That on
, I received from the plaintiff the original
and certified copies of the Summons and Complaints issued against the defendant:
1
of KNOXVILLE
, and returned to
Riley C. Darnell
Subscribed and sworn to before me,
this 16TH
day of JANUARY
f1
b
, 2008
PC/?
NOTARY PUBLIC
My commission expires 1-4-2010
( f
I
I
C)
ST1TE\
OF
\
' IT
NOTARY
DUC
51
ff!~
I',
You are hereby summoned and required to serve upon Kimberly R. Taylor
Plaintiff's attorney, whose address is:
9724 Kingston Pike, Suite 703
Knoxville, Tennessee 37922
(865) 693-3080
a true copy of the answer to the Petition for Modification of Child Support and Petition for
Modification of Permanent Parenting Plan which is herewith served upon you, within 30 days
after service of this summons upon you, exclusive of the day of service. You will file the original
with the Court.
If you fail to do so, judgment by default will be taken against you for the relief demanded in the
complaint.
2007 at
day of
-.
M.
Witness Clerk and Master of said Court, at office in Knox County, Tennessee, the
2007.
/
'
4/
93
NOTICE
TO THE DEFENDANT(S):
Tennessee law provides a four thousand dollar ($4,000.00) personal property exemption from execution or seizure to
satisfy a judgment. If a judgment should be entered against you in this action and you wish to claim property as
exempt, you must file a written list, under oath, of the items you wish to claim as exempt with the clerk of the court.
The list may be filed at any time and may be changed by you thereafter as necessary; however, unless it is filed
before the judgment becomes final, it will not be effective as to any execution of garnishment issued prior to
the filing of the list. Certain items are automatically exempt by law and do not need to be listed; these include items
of necessary wearing apparel (clothing) for yourself and your family and trunks or other receptacles necessary to
contain such apparel, family portraits, the family Bible, and school books. Should any of these items be seized, you
would have the right to recover them. If you do not understand your exemption right or how to exercise it you may
wish to seek the counsel of a lawyer.
Received this
day of
2007,
Deputy Sheriff.
Petition for Modification of Child Support and Petition for Modification of Permanent Parenting Plan, the proposed
Permanent Parenting Plan, Fiat and Injunction upon the Respondent by
failed to serve this summons within 30 days after its issuance because______________________________________
No. 15759-3
CL AND MASTER
D. C.
I CERTIFY THAT I SERVED THE WITHIN INJUNCTION ON THE
DAY OF
_, 20,
BY DELIVERING A COPY OF THE PETITION AND INJUNCTION TO THE DEFENDANT
ERSONALLY,OR BY__________________
I FAILED TO SERVE THE DEFENDANT(S) LISTED DELOW WITHIN THIRTY (30) DAYS
AFTERAFTER ISSUANCE BECAUSE
DEPUTY SHERIFF
54
A Signature
DAgent
0 Addressee
X
B. A ved by (Th*ted/me)
-
C Date, DeIiv'
'L
/ C. Is delivery address different from Item 1? 0 Yes
0 No
If YES, enter delivery address below
Uill fihullI
172 *
0 0 8 9 8
2.ArtlaieNumber
PS Form
3811,
Yes
102595-C2-M-i54O
55
in
Page 1 of 1
02/05/2008 18:39:39
Name
TAYLOR, KIMBERLY R
TULAY, PAMELA MORITZ
Address
04/01/2008
1002
Original P)alntiffIRespondent,
VS.
- ...
. 'IOGAN
Original Defexdant/Petitioner.
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
Comes now Jason C. Rose of Rose & Moffatt, PLLC, and files this Notice of Appearance
in the above-styled cause, noting his appearance as counsel of record for the Respondent,, Pamela
Moritz 1'u1ay), herein
This the 3,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned hereby certifies that a true and exact copy of the foregoing pleading has
been sent to all interested parties or their attorneys by hand delivery or by placing the same in the
United States Mail, postage pre-paid, on this :3 day of Manth,, 2008.
57
RM
PI
Page 1 of 1
03/31/2008 13:33:26
Name
Address
ROSE, JASON C.
TAYLOR, KIMBERLY R
58
P1:12:15
'OYu G. HQGAJ
Original PlaintiffYRespondent,
VS.
)
)
)
)
Original Defendant/Petitioner.
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
Comes now Jason C. Rose of Rose & Moffatt, PLLC, and files this Notice of Appearance
in the above-styled cause, noting his appearance as counsel of record for the Respondent, Pamela
Moritz (Tulay), herein.
This the 31
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned hereby certifies that a true and exact copy of the foregoing pleading has
been sent to all interested parties or their attorneys by hand delivery or by placing the same in the
day of March, 2008.
United States Mail, postage pre-paid, on this 3 \.
59
I!
IN THE CHANCERY COURT FOR KNOX COUNTY, TENNESSEE
PAM1'T A 1%4flPTT7 (TTTT AV)
Vii
r'
Original Plaintiff'Respondent,
VS.
)
Case No.: 151759-31
)
)
)
)
Original Defendant/Petitioner.
Comes now Attorney Jason C. Rose, individually, and on behalf of the law firm of Rose &
Moffatt, PLLC, and moves the Court to be allowed to withdraw as the attorney of record for the
Respondent, Pamela Moritz, and in support thereof would show as follows:
1.
That the client, Pamela Moritz, has stated in writing that she wishes to terminate the.
representation by Jason C. Rose, individually, and the law firm of Rose & Moffatt, PLLC, effective
immediately.
2.
Movant would show that withdrawal will not cause foreseeable prejudice to the rights
of client.
3.
Counsel for the Petitioner has been contacted regarding this motion.
day of
/l/!cA.\/
3 2008.
Page 1 of 2
MR
I!
15
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned hereby certifies that a true and exact copy of the foregoing Motion for
Withdrawal of Counsel has been sent to all interested parties or their attorneys by either placing same
in the United States Mail, postage prepaid, or by hand delivery.
,200
This the(f1dday of
ATTORNEY
Page 2 of 2
61
12
VS.
No. I 1759
TCSS NoO8361 72
42
DOB 7-29-88
DOB 10-24-89
DOB 5-7-99
ANSWER
In this cause, the Mother comes, by and through her undersigned counsel, and responds
to the Petition for Modification of Child Support as follows:
1.
Any allegations pertaining to statistical information concerning the parties and
children of the parties (if applicable) are generally admitted, with the right to specifically amend
this Answer being reserved upon obtaining further information and/or discovery.
2.
If applicable, any allegations pertaining to prior orders of this Court and/or any
other Court(s) are admitted only as written and/or indicated within the records of such Court(s).
3.
If applicable, any allegations of willfully contemptuous acts and/or omissions are
denied, with the right to specifically amend this Answer being reserved upon obtaining further
information and/or disocovery.
4.
All other allegations are denied, with the right to specifically amend this Answer
being reserved upon obtaining further information and/or discovery.
5.
It is denied that the requesting party is entitled to any relief whatsoever.
WHEREFORE, it is respectfully submitted that the requests for relief to which this
Answer applies be denied so as to dismiss the cause of action relative to such requests, with all
Court costs being taxed accordingly and with the client of W. Brian Starnes being awarded a
judgment for the reimbursement of attorney's fees and litigation expenses.
Respectfu
IFN
62
TCSESFO008361 72
DOB 7-29-88
DOB 10-24-89
DOB 5-7-99
ANSWER
In this cause, the Mother comes, by and through her undersigned counsel, and responds
to the Petition for Modification of Child Support and Petition for Modification of Permanent
Parenting Plan as follows:
1.
Any allegations pertaining to statistical information concerning the parties and
children of the parties (if applicable) are generally admitted, with the right to specifically amend
this Answer being reserved upon obtaining further information and/or discovery.
2.
If applicable, any allegations pertaining to prior orders of this Court and/or any
other Court(s) are admitted only as written and/or indicated within the records of such Court(s).
3.
If applicable, any allegations of willfully contemptuous acts and/or omissions are
denied, with the right to specifically amend this Answer being reserved upon obtaining further
information and/or disocovery.
4.
All other allegations are denied, with the right to specifically amend this Answer
being reserved upon obtaining further information and/or discovery.
It is denied that the requesting party is entitled to any relief whatsoever.
5. .
WHEREFORE, it is respectfully submitted that the requests for relief to which this
Answer applies be denied so as to dismiss the cause of action relative to such requests, with all
Court costs being taxed accordingly and with the client of W. Brian Starnes being awarded a
judgment for the reimbursement of attorney's fees and litigation expenses.
Respectfully submitted,
ATTORNEY AT LAW
63
KM
Page 1 of 1
05/23/2008 11:04:50
Q.
(\J_
MOYERS, MICHAEL W
Name
Address
STARNES, W. BRIAN
06/24/2008
TAYLOR, KIMBERLY R
64
Ic,
IN THE CHANCERY COURT FOR KNOX COUNTY, TENNESSEE
No. 151759-3'/
MICHAEL PETER TULAY,
Defendant ("Father").
DOB 7-29-88
DOB 10-24-89
DOB 5-7-99
CcATF7
ATTORNEY AT LAW
65
I.
VS.
No. 151759-3',"
37
DOB 7-29-88
DOB 10-24-89
DOB 5-7-99
I certify that the Mother & counsel for the Father have
each been duly served with a true & exact copy of
this Motion by the placement of same in the US Mail
with sufficient postage & marked for delivery to their
respective last known addresses (2164 Highland Ave.,
Reading, PA 19606; 9724 Kingston Pk. #703, Knoxville, TN
37922), this 16th day of June, 2008.
66
I!
IN THE CHANCERY COURT FOR KNOX COUNTY, TENNESSEE
17
VS.
37
NlS7Sg3
TCSES No. 000836172
DOB 7-29-88
DOB 10-24-89
DOB 5-7-99
NOTICE OF HEARING
Please take notice that the self-explanatory Motion to Permit Withdrawal of Counsel filed in this
cause by Attorney W. Brian Stames shall be considered by this Honorable Court on the 26th
day of June, 2008 at 9:00 a.m. and that, absent the appearance of the Mother and the
presentation of an appropriate objection to the procedural relief sought within said Motion, the
Order Permitting Withdrawal of Counsel with Award of Judgment submitted for consideration
herewith may be found to be appropriate for the reasons set forth therein and may be entered
at that time.
Al lUkNT 1UNIVIUIrItN
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE:
I certify that the Mother & counsel for the Father have
each been duly served with a true & exact copy of
this Notice by the placement of same in the US Mail
with sufficient postage & marked for delivery to their
respective last known addresses (2164 Highland Ave.,
Reading, PA 19606; 9724 Kingston Pk. #703, Knoxville, TN
37922), this 16th day of June, 2008.
67
IF
IN THE CHANCERY COURT FOR KNOX COUNTY, TENNESSEE
PAMELA MORITZ TULAY (now MORITZ),
Plaintiff ("Mother"),
VS.
MICHAEL PETER TULAY,
Defendant ("Father").
No. 1517594
U)
110 ~m
1~[6
JUN
2 6 2003
Upon the Motion to Permit Withdrawal of Counsel filed herein by W. Brian Starnes and
for good cause shown therein, it is found that the relief sought therein is appropriate and that
the rights and interests of the Mother will not be jeopardized upon the granting of same.
Accordingly, it is hereby ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED that W. Brian
Starnes is permitted to withdraw as counsel for the Mother, with any subsequent pleadings,
notices, Orders, etc. being served upon the Mother at her last known address reflected
hereinbelow and with this matter remaining set for a hearing before the Honorable Michael W.
Moyers on the 45tflj day of July, 2008 at 9:30 a.m. regarding all pending Motions only.
ENTER this
__________________________________________________________
BRIAA T
__Af/JJ1
V
to an
292 5-y
Op
this
, 2 O22
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE:
E1
Page 1 of 1
06/19/2008 10:39:29
Name
Address
06/26/2008
STARNES, W. BRIAN
06/26/2008
TAYLOR, KTh'[BERLY R
06/26/2008
69
23Page 1 of 1
06/26/2008 09:19:47
Name
Address
TAYLOR, KIMBERLY R
07/23/2008
07/23/2008
Pkt16
70
KM
IN THE CHANCERY COURT FOR KNOX COUNTY, TENNESSEE
PAMELA MORITZ (then TULAY),
: 06
Original Plaintiff7Respondent,
)
V.
Defendant/Petitioner.
On May 21, 2008, Interrogatories and Requests for Production of Documents were
On May 22, 2003, Counsel for Michael Peter Tulay learned that Brian Starnes was
now representing Pamela Moritz, and a revised set of Interrogatories and Requests for Production
of Documents were subsequently hand delivered to Brian Stames on May 23, 2008.
3.
Said Responses were due to be tendered not later than June 23, 2008. As of July 11,
Counsel for the Petitioner would aver that Pamela Moritz has had more than
adequate time to fully and adequately respond to the Interrogatories and Requests for Production of
Documents.
5.
The Petitioner would request that this Court order that all information requested in
discovery by the Petitioner to the Respondent be immediately and fully responded to by Pamela
1
7
KM
Moritz.
6.
The Petitioner would request this Court to levy sanctions against the Respondent for
her failure to comply with discovery and would request the Court to award the Petitioner a
Judgment for all of his attorney fees incurred in this cause due to her willful failure to comply with
the Tennessee Rules of Civil Procedure both in discovery.
7.
In addition, the Petitioner would request the Court to grant him such other relief as
KIMBRLY R. TAYLOR
Attorney for Michael Peter Tulay
135 South David Lane
Knoxville, TN 37922
(865) 693-3080
NOTICE TO APPEAR FOR HEARING REGARDING THIS MOTION TO COMPEL
DISCOVERY AND FOR SANCTIONS
TO: PAMELA MORITZ (formerly TULAY)
2164 Highland Avenue
Reading, Pennsylvania 19606
Please take notice that I shall appear in front of the Honorable Michael W. Moyers,
Chancellor for the Chancery Court of Knox County, Part III, on the 23 day of July, 2008 at 9:30
a.m. to take up the forgoing MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY AND FOR SANCTIONS, and
you are hereby notified to appear on said date at said time if you should wish to contest the
granting of said MOTION.
KIMBERLY R. TAYLOR
OA
I!
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I do hereby certify that I have served an exact and true copy of the foregoing MOTION TO
COMPEL DISCOVERY AND FOR SANCTIONS AND NOTICE TO APPEAR FOR HEARING
upon the Respondent, Pamela Moritz (formerly Tulay), by Federal Express and by United States
Mail and addressed to her home address of 2164 Highland Avenue, Reading, Pennsylvania 19606
on this the 11th day ofJuly, 2008.
KfMBERLY RC-TAYLOR
74
PI
I!
T FOR KNOX
N 1P1 F- i
JUL24 2008
Original PlaintifflRespondent,
s/HOWARD G. HOC-,
Docket No. 151759-3
.108q -00 ,-,
V.
2A
ay
the Temporary Injunction prayed for therein, ordering Pamela Moritz to bring the parties' minor
child Mark Tulay to the Knox County Chancery Court, Part III, located at 400 Main Street, CityCounty Building, Knoxville, Tennessee 37902 at 9:00 a.m. on the l day of August, 2008 for
Father to have co-parenting time with said child with said child and enjoining Pamela Moritz from
interfering with Father's co-parenting time with said child.
1is77'ay of
, 2008.
71
VS
.
PAMELA MORITZ (then TULAY)
L.
DEFENDANT
bill of Complaint in said Chancery Court at Knoxville, against you, the said defendant to be relieved touching the matter set forth in said bill in
which it is charged that PAMELA MORITZ (then TULAY)
your actings and doings in the
MICHAEL W. MOYERS
premises are contrary to equity and good conscience, and whereas, the Honorable
Chancellor of the Chancery Court at Knoxville, Tenn., in said State has ordered that an injunction issue, as prayed by complaint
Therefore, in consideration of said fiat, and of the particular matters in said Bill set forth, you, the said defendant and the persons
efore named, and each and every one of you, are hereby strictly commanded and enjoined, under the penalty of a contempt of Court, that
EZA bring the parties' minor child Mark Tulay to the Knox County
jou do absolutely do
Chancery Court, Part III, located at 400 Main Street, CityCounty Building, Knoxville, TN
37902 at 9:00 a.m. on the 1st day of August, 2008 for Father to have Coparenting time
with said child witbj said child and enjoining Pamela Moritz from interfering with Father's
-"
4 th said child.
A.D. 2008
CLERK AND MASTER
D.C.
DAY OF
Y DELIVERING A COPY OF THE PETITION AND INJUNCTION TO THE DEFENDANT _Pc\Qk
20
()P,
PERSONALLY, OR BY____________________________
I FAILED TO SERVE THE DEFENDANT(S) LISTED DELOW WITHIN THIRTY (30) DAYS AFTER ISSUANCE
CAUSE
SHERIFF
TS\Q -
cz
-Lk rr
7o
-ui1 4
I!
V.
)
)
Defendant/Petitioner.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that I served the Order Granting Motion for Injunction, Granting Motion to
Compel, Dismissing Motion for New Trial or for Alteration/Amendment of Judgment, Dismissing
Motion for Relief from Judgments/Orders, and Dismissing Motion for Court to Decline Exercise of
Jurisdiction which was entered on July 24, 2008 upon Pamela Moritz (formerly Tulay) by
delivering a copy of said Order to Pamela Moritz, or by
L/
EPUTY SHERIFF'
fU5
Ln
L 1
&
116
Original PlaintifulRespondent,
Original Defendant/Petitioner.
FIAT
TO THE CLERK AND MASTER
OF THE CHANCERY COURT
FOR KNOX COUNTY, TENNESSEE
Pursuant to the Order entered on the
arising out of Pamela Moritz failure to comply with the Order entered by this Court on July 24,
2008, issue an Injunction compelling order Pamela Moritz to tender or cause to be tendered Mark
Tulay to Michael Peter Tulay, limiting Pamela Moritz to supervised visitation at Parent Place in
Knoxville, Tennessee pending further order of this Court, and enjoining Pamela Moritz from
interfering with Father's custody and control of Mark Tulay pending further order of this Court.
This Jday of
c/)
, 2008.
W. MOYERS,
79
STATE OF TENNESSEE
DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN sERvIcsSVP
26 r
(865) 862-0366
Fax: (865) 862-0403
SEQUO VAR-CONSULTING GROUP
153 PLEASANT ST STE 4
ATrLEBORO,MA 02703-2444
The amount shown on the first page of this order is the new total that you should deduct. This new
amount should be substituted for, and not added to the amount you were previously ordered to
deduct for this particular tribunal/case number. This modification does not affect any other deductions
you may have been ordered. to make for any other case(s) involving this same obligor/employee.
[X] If this box is checked, you are no longer required to withhold income for this
employee/obligor for the case specified at the top of the first page of the order. This order to stop
deducting from this employee's/obligor's income only affects the case specified in the attached order. It
does not affect any other deductions you may have been ordered to make for any other cases involving this
same employee/obligor.
B. Remittance Information
With your remittance you must provide the payment Turnaround Document (Employer Obligation Letter)
provided to you by the Department of Human Services, or you must provide all of the following
information.
Date payment was deducted from
employee's/obligor's income
Docket number
Court identifier
Employee's/Obligor's name
Employee's/Obligor's Social Security number
Employee's/Obligor's return address
PLEASE CONTACT THE OFFICE LISTED ABOVE IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS CONCERNING THIS NOTICE.
IE
[E]ORDERJNOTICE TO WITHHOLD INCOME FOR CHILD SUPPORT
ONOTICE OF AN ORDER TO WITHHOLD INCOME FOR CHILD SUPPORT
I ORIGINAL 0 AMENDED [XI TERMINATION
Date: 9/10/08
State/Tribe/Territory
TENNESSEE
City/Co./DistfReservatlon
KNOX
0 Non-governmental entity or Individual
Case Number 836172/151759-3
Employer's/Withholder's Name
RE:
MICHAEL TIJLAY
SEQUOYAH-CONSULTING GROUP
Employer's/Withholder's Address
153 PLEASANT ST STE 4
ATTLEBORO,MA 02703-2444
ORDER INFORMATION: This document is based on the support or withholding order from
You are required by law to deduct these amounts from the employee' s/obligor's income until further notice.
0 Per
$
month
current child support
- Per month
$
past-due child support - Arrears greater than 12 weeks? Dyes Dno
$
$
0.00 Per
0.00 Per
0.00 Per
0.00 Per
spousal support
past-due spousal support
0.00 Per
S
other (specify)
for a total of $00 per MONTH to be forwarded to the payee below.
You do not have to vary your pay cycle to be in compliance with the support order. If your pay cycle does not match the ordered
payment cycle, withhold one of the following amounts:
per weekly pay period.
S
per semimonthly pay period (twice a month).
per biweekly pay period (every two weeks). $
per monthly pay period.
REM17TANCE INFORMATION:
When remitting payment, provide the pay date/date of withholding and the case identifier. If the
employee's/obligor's principal place of employment is Tennessee, begin withholding no later than the first pay period occurring
14 worldn days after the date o19/10/08 5 Send payment within! working days of the pay date/date of withholding. The total withheld
amount, including your fee, may not exceed % of the employee's/obligor's aggregate disposable weekly earnings.
If the employee's/obligor's principal place of employment is not Tennessee. for limitations on withholding, applicable time
requirements, and any allowable employer fees, follow the laws and procedures of the employee's/obligor's principal place of
employment (see 93 and #9, ADDITIONAL INFORMATION TO EMPLOYERS AND OTHER WITHHOLDERS).
Tennessee Child Support
Make check payable to:
If remitting payment by EFL'EDI, call (800)438-6911
Bank routing number:
Use this FIPS code:
Ifthislaairrder fNoUtold:
_______
Print Name 4cz') t4"3
_________________________
Title of Issuing
________________________
Signature
--_-1 Date
______
0 Court
Date
Attorney 0 Individual
0 Private Entity
81
I. Priority: Withholding under this Order or Notice has priority over any other legal process under state law (or tribal law, if applicable)
against the same income. If there are federal tax levies in effect, please notify the contact person listed below. (See 10 below.)
2.
Combining Payments: You may combine withheld amounts from more than one employee ' s/obligor' s income in a single payment to
each agency/party requesting withholding. You must, however, separately identify the portion of the single payment that is attributable
to each employee/obligor.
3.
Reporting the Paydate/Date of Withholding: You must report the paydate/date of withholding when sending the payment The
paydate/date of withholding is the date on which the amount was withheld from the employee's wages. You must comply with the law
of the state of the employee's/obligor's principal place of employment with respect to the time periods within which you must
implement the withholding and forward the support payments.
4.
Employee/Obligor with Multiple Support Withholdings: If there is more than one Order or Notice against this employee/obligor and
you are unable to honor all support Orders or Notices due to federal, state, or tribal withholding limits, you must follow the state or tribal
law/procedure of the employee' s/obligor's principal place of employment You must honor all Orders or Notices to the greatest extent
possible. (see 9 below.)
5.
Termination Notification: You must promptly notify the Child Support Enforcement (IV-D) Agency and/or the contact person listed
below when the employee/obligor no longer works for you. Please provide the information requested and return a complete copy of this
Order or Notice to the Child Support Enforcement (TV-D) Agency and/or the contact person listed below. (See 10 below.)
THE EMPLOYEE/OBLIGOR NO LONGER WORKS FOR:
EMPLOYEE'SIOBLIGOR'S NAME:
DATE OF SEPARATION FROM EMPLOYMENT: LAST KNOWN HOME ADDRESS:
NEW EMPLOYER/ADDRESS:
CASE IDENTIFIER:
6.
Lump Sum Payments: You may be required to report and withhold from lump sum payments such as bonuses, commissions, or
severance pay. If you have any questions about lump sum payments, contact the Child Support Enforcement (IV-D) Agency.
7.
Liability: If you have any doubts about the validity of the Order or Notice, contact the agency or person listed below under 10. If you
fail to withhold income as the Order or Notice directs, you are liable for both the accumulated amount you should have withheld from
the employee's/obligor's income and any other penalties set by state or tribal law/procedure.
B.
Anti-discrimination: You are subject to a fine determined under state or tribal law for discharging an employeelobligor from
employment, refusing to employ, or taking disciplinary action against any employec/obligor because of a child support withholding.
9.
Withholding Limits: For state orders, you may not withhold more than the lesser of 1) the amounts allowed by the Federal Consumer
Credit Protection Act (15 U.S.C. 1673(b)); or 2) the amounts allowed by the state of the employee'slobligor's principal place of
employment. The federal limit applies to the aggregate disposable weekly earnings (ADWE). ADWE is the net income left after
making mandatory deductions such as: state, federal, local taxes, Social Security taxes, statutory pension contributions, and Medicare
taxes. The Federal CCPA limit is 50% of the ADWE for child support and alimony, which is increased by 1)10% if the employee does
not support second family; and /or 2) 5% if arrears greater than 12 weeks.
For tribal orders, you may not withhold more than the amounts allowed under the law of the issuing tribe. For tribal employers who
receive a state order, you may not withhold more than the amounts allowed under the law of the state that issued the order.
Tennessee Employers/Payers of Income should refer to the Department's Rule 1240-2-2-05, available on the internet at
httn://www.state.tn.us/sosIrules/1240/1240-02/1240-02-02pdf for state specific information, such as the priority and proration of
payments if multiple Orders/Notices are received for one employee.
Child(ren)'s Names and Additional Information:
TULAY. PETER M.
TULAY. MONICA C.
10.
TULAY, MARK K.
by telephone at
(865)
862-0366
0MB 0970-0154
82
two
83
84
vi
ao~
5/1 o//o
7
,1
L
.L
j)
t /
AdcL
O
.'Lc4)
85
Page 1 of 1
03/06/2009 11:28:57
Name
Address
TAYLOR, KIMBERLY R
04/09/2009
04/09/2009
PI
.4,
laz
87
Page 1 of 1
04/20/2010 14:20:15
Name
Address
TAYLOR, KIMBERLY R
06/08/2010
06/08/2010
IE
Page 1 of 1
05/10/2010 12:54:08
Name
Address
TAYLOR, KIMBERLY R
07/27/2010
07/27/2010
Page 1 of I
06/29/2010 11:17:36
Name
Address
TAYLOR, KIMBERLY R
09/14/2010
09/14/2010
IF
T
PAMELA MORTIZ TULAY,
JUL 1 9 2010
/4
Original Plaintiff/Respondent
No. 15175*
Mm
WARD G HOGApJ
,1nAG
VZ
j-
4ERLYJAYLOR, BP" 01
Attorney for Plaintiff
135 South David Lane
Knoxville, TN 37922
(865) 693-3080
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I do hereby certify that I have served an exact and true copy of the foregoing NOTICE TO
APPEAR FOR PETITION FOR CONTEMPT, FOR MODIFICATION, AND FOR
INJUNCTIVE RELIEF upon the Respondent, Pamela Moritz (formerly Tulay), by United
States Mail and addressed to her home address of 2164 Highland Avenue, Reading,
Pennsylvania 19606 on this the 16 T day of July, 2010.
Pamela Moritz
2164 Highland Ave.
Reading, PA 19606
This the I day ofZ1uij ,2010.
'
UMBER
AYLOR
Page 1 of 1
08/16/2010 13:52:42
Name
Address
08/24/2010
TAYLOR, KIMBERLY R
08/24/2010
92
I!
IN THE CHANCERY COURT FOR KNOX COUNTY, TENNESSEE
ADA
215-2952
TO:
You are hereby summoned and required to serve upon: PAMELA ALLISON MORITZ
Whose address is:
108 South Ann Street
Lancaster, PA 17602
(717)381-0329
a true copy of the answer to the Petition for Modification of Permanent Parenting Plan and
Custody Order which are herewith served upon you, within thirty (30) days after service of
this Summons upon you, exclusive of the day of service. You will file the original with the
Court.
If you fail to do so, judgment by default will be taken against you for the relief demanded in
the complaint.
Issued this 1 64 aday of
day of
j-_4._.'
2012 at
.M.
Witness Clerk and Master of said Court, at office in Knox County, Tennessee, the
,20l2.
/..4./a
b*2_
lL
zol
po6on PanW6- Horliz 4,94//,J
ptia76
BY: Deputy rk and Master
(This summons is issued pursuant to Rule 4 of the Tennessee Rules of Civil Procedure.)
93
Page 1 of 1
01/22/2013 10:22:37
'.-
Name
Address
03/28/2013
03/28/2013
94
RM
108 South Ann Street
Lancaster, PA 17602
(717)381-0329
12U 43
18 January 2013
HOWARD G. HOGAN
J
Dear Chancellor Moyers,
On December 17, 2012, in accordance with Rule 4 of the Tennessee Rules of Civil
Procedure, service of summons was made upon Respondent/Original Defendant Michael Peter
Tulay of the "Petition for Modification of Permanent Parenting Plan and Custody Order" filed
with this Honorable Court on December 10, 2012.
Thirty (30) days have now passed since service of summons was made with no Answer
being served to the Petitioner to the above-mentioned "Petition for Modification of Permanent
Parenting Plan and Custordy Order" nor having been filed by the Respondent.
Please consider this letter a Motion for Default Judgment in the above-referenced matter.
*es ectrully yours,
kUt
95
PI
Page! of!
01/31/2013 15:10:53
Name
Address
02/26/2013
02/26/2013
IF
I!
J'APS1LDVA
EyprsS YAM L
86592O
2.o
ELEE
I
L)S..5.
February% 13
/j \5
2)f2-o3
Howard G. Hogan
Clerk and Master
Knox County Chancery Court
Suite 125
City County Building
400 Main Street
Knoxville, TN 37902
C
/
A I 1.-U'
Sincerely,
3 Te A((/k)''
/2Pamela
Allison Moritz
(formerly Pamela Moritz Tulay),
Original Plaintiff/Petitioner
Enclosures (8 pages)
CO+
;-
k
J-r-i
bo y1e
SE
jru
97
RM
&JM'L~
FILED
Z0I3 KAR28
4K 10: %
Original Plaintiff/Petitioner
Docket No. 151759-3
V
Original Defendant/Respondent
TO:
You are hereby summoned and required to serve upon: PAMELA ALLISON MOR1TZ
108 South Ann Street
Whose address is:
Lancaster, PA 17602
(717)381-0329
a true copy of the answer to the Petition for Revocation of Invalid Parenting Plan and Child
Custody Order of April 9, 2009 is herewith served upon you, within thirty (30) days after
service of this Summons upoa you, exclusive of the day of service. You will file the original
with the Court.
If you fail to do so, judgment by default will be taken against you for the relief demanded in
the complaint.
.M.
2013 at
Witness Clerk and Master of said Court, at office in Knox County, Tennessee, the
2013.
-'
lk and Master
BY:
4 '-
-"--'-
crhis summons is issued pursuant to Rule 4 of the Tennessee Rules of Civil Procedure.)
4-11
RETURN OF SERVICE
Came to hand on the __9 day of
Executed in full as commanded, Witness
my hand this
57 day of
-,
99
tlIp1
ILED
j
IN THE CHANCERY COURT FOR KNOX COUNTY, Te
_ NNESSEE
HOGAN
Original Plaintiff/Petitioner
Docket No. 151759-3
V.
TO:
You are hereby summoned and required to serve upon: PAMELA ALLISON MORITZ
108 South Ann Street
Whose address is:
Lancaster, PA 17602
(717)381-0329
a true copy of the answer to the Petition for Def]LJ.udefit-Ganting "Petition for
d)rder" which is herewith served
Modification of Permanent Parenting Plan and
upon you, within thirty (30) days after service of this Summons upon you, exclusive of the
day of service. You will file the original with the Court.
If you fail to do so, judgment by default will be taken against you for the relief demanded in
the complaint.
Issued this 2Sdayof
day of
/'2
_.M.
Witness Clerk and Master of said Court, at office in Knox County, Tennessee, the
jV11L _ Z 7
,2013.
/
ESTCE ctLL.
/ 2152"7
/,D
/ 215-292
rv
2013 at
BY:
Deputy Clerk and Master
(This summons is issued pursuant to Rule 4 of the Tennessee Rules of Civil Procedure.)
100
-3
RETURN OF SERVICE
JLday of
-.
101
RM
rnt
0't )oyt)
zz
TO:
You are hereby summoned and required to serve upon: PAMELA ALLISON MORITZ
108 South Ann Street
Whose address is:
Lancaster, PA 17602
(717)381-0329
a true copy of the answer to the Petition for Revocation of Invalid Child Support Order and
Judgments of February 27, 2009 and April 9, 2009 which are herewith served upon you,
within thirty (30) days after service of this Summons upon you, exclusive of the day of
service. You will file the original with the Court.
If you fail to do so, judgment by default will be taken against you for the relief demanded in
the complaint.
Issued this 2-2 'day of
day of
2013 at
M.
Witness Clerl, and Master of said Court, at office in Knox County, Tennessee, the
Z'
,2013.
LIZ
L) kA
Clerk and Master
BY
e9-
ilrelh
RETURN OF SERVICE
20
_______
-
J5,
J5,r
Shriff
1 03
FILED
IN THE CHANCERY COURT OF KNOX COUNTY, TENNESSEE
AT KNOXVILLE
dOWAJib G. HoGj
Docket No. 151759-3
MICHAEL P TULAY
Petitioner! Counter-Respondent
IV-DNo.
V.
001465537
PAMELA A MORITZ
Respondent' Counter-Petitioner
SUMMONS
ittCL\J
TO:
9O
Lict
L'&eL- )
LThj
22
You are hereby summoned to appear before the CHANCERY Court of this county on the
c71tL 10
winsxstF
ief
1flLJ
H OW
By:
() day of
4O
HOGA
Pursuant to Rule 4.02, T.R.C.P. you must
respond within thirty (30) days of service, or a
default judgment may be entered against you.
(Attorney's Name)
Attorney for the State
(Attorney's Address)
(City, State, Zip)
104
(.
NOTICE
To the Respondent(s):
Based on section 466(a)( 13) of the Social Security Act 42 t S.C.
006( ii)(
vu are
required Lo disclose your Social Security number ic the child support aucnc. The number will
he used under the State's child support enforcrnent prourani
10
purposes of establishing paternity and establishing. modifying. and enforcirw supporT ohlivations.
Tennessee law provides a ten thousand dollar, S10.000; persona) properly e;ernpion
from execution or seizure to satisfy a udgmenL If a udgmen should be eni.ered against
VOL
in
this action and you wish to claim property as exempt, you must file a written list, under oath. of
the items you wish to claim as exempt with the clerk of court. The list may he flied at any time
and may be changed by you thereafter as necessary however, unless it is filed before the
judgment becomes final, it will not be effective as to any execution or garnishment issued prior
to the filing of the. list. Certain items are automatically exempt by law and do not need to he
listed. These include items of necessary wearing apparel for yourself and your family and trunks
or other receptacles necessary to contain such apparel, family portraits, the family Bible, and
school books. Should any of these items be seized, you would have the right to recover them. If
you do not understand your exemption right or how to exercise it, you may wish to seeh the
counsel of a lawyer.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certi' that a copy of this summons has been served upon the respondent by
eti-d-
irn rer.iptg
mS_lO
day of____________________
Summons -
U-
Page 2
105
In
11
State of Tennessee
Department of State
Division of Business Services
Wm. R. Snodgrass Tower
312 Rosa L. Parks Avenue, 6th Floor
Nashville, Tennessee 37243
Case Number:
151759-3
70111570000340465053
5/16/2013
Date
Certlfed Number
Dear Clerk:
Enclosed are the following papers In the above styled case:
Original Summons
Affidavit and Endorsement
Registered or Certified Return Receipt signed by:
PAMELA MORITZ
[I]
Sincerely:
Tre Hargett
enclosures
Initials: MMHAW
CC:
SS-4210 (Rev. 12196)
106
PI
AFFIDAVIT
and
ENDORSEMENT
5116/2013
Date
70111570000340465053
MICHAEL TULAY
VS:
PAMELA MORITZ
Certified Number
I DARLENE LAWRENCE , having been duly authorized by Tie Hargett, Secretary of State
of Tennessee, do hereby make oath on his behalf and under authorization as follows:
Wednesday. April 24, 2013
That on
I received from the plaintiff the original
and certified copies of the Summons and Complaints issued against the defendant:
PAMELA MORITZ
whose address is:
108 SMITH ANN ST. LANCASTER, PA 17602
Thursday, April 25, 2013
and that on
I mailed by registered or certified returnreceipt mail the certified copies of the Summons and Complaint to the defendant at the above address together with written notice that service was so made. I further make oath that the return
receipt for the registered or certified letter was received at my office in Nashville, Tennessee, on
Thursday, May 16. 2013
, and returned to
of KNOXVILLE
Tre Hargett
ryoftate
Subscribed and sworn to before me,
t is 16th
day of May
by
, 2013
7AL1i4w
NOTARY PUBLIC
y NN i LL
\\
! ev
107
STATE OF TENNESSEE
CHANCERY COURT OF KNOX COUNTY
'Z
C'
1
C
Plainti ff
___
PPc14LA MO
...:'.;.
'
,Defendant
Civil Action No
(Z
?t+&LA MOi
To
A1
I7tLk
%5tjA.?Oi
.%
371Q
You are hereby summoned to dcfend it civil action filed against you in Chancery Court, Knox County, Tennessee. Your.defcnse roust
be made within thirty (30) days from the date this summons is served upon you. You are directd to file your defense with the clerk.
of the court and send a copy to plaints attorney at the address below. If you fail to do so, judgment by default will be taken against
you for the relief demanded in5omplaint
Issued this
-.
)!P,
Witness, Howard G. Ho
Deputy Clerk
Tennessee law provides a ten thousand dollar ($10,000.00) personal property exemption from execution or seizure to satis fy a
judgment If a judgment should be entered against you in this action and you wish to claim property as exempt, you must file a written
listunder oath, of the items you wish to claim as exempt with the clerk of the court The list may be filed at anytime and may be
changed by you theresher as necesaiy howevem unless it is filed before the judgment becomes final, it will not be effective as to any
execution of garnishment issued prior to the filing of theiist. Certain items are automatically exempt by law and do not need to be
listed;- these include items of necessary wearing apparel (clothing) for yourself and your family and trunks of other recepta cles
necessary to contain such apparel, family portraits, the family Bible, and school books. Should any of these items be seized you would
have the right to recover them if you do not understand your exemption right or how to exercise it, you may wish to seek the counsel
of a lawyer. T.CA26-2-1 14.
20
.
Deputy Sheriff
OR ASS I STANCE-CALL
..
ADA
865/215-2952
day of _
Received this
20
.,Iserved
I failed to serve this summons within 30 days after its issuance because
Sheriff-Deputy Sheriff
..
S..
PAMELA MORITZ
108 SMITH ANN ST
LANCASTER, PA 17602
B.
k/4 M
0//Atme'ssee
j 9-Dat of Delivery
7Ib1QZIT71S/I3/J2,
3. Service Type
0 Certified Mall D 's ,111
0 Registered
0 Return Receipt for Merchandise
0 Insured Mall
0 C.O.D.
4. Restricted Delivery?
2. Article Number
7011 1570 0003
(Transfer from service /abel) PS Form
Pam Fee)
0 Yes
4046 5053
10259502-M-1540I
109
State of Tennessee
Department of State
Division of Business Services
Wm. R. Snodgrass Tower
312 Rosa L. Parks Avenue, 6th Floor
Nashville, Tennessee 37243
151759-3
CaseNumber:
70111570000340465046
5/16/2013
Date
Certifed Number
Dear Clerk:
Enclosed are the following papers in the above styled case:
Original Summons
Sincerely:
Tre Hargett
enclosures
Initials: [MHAW
CC:I
SS-4210 (Rev. 12/96)
110
IM
AFFIDAVIT
and
ENDORSEMENT
5)16/2013
Date
70111570000340465046
MICHAEL TULAY
VS:
PAMELA MORITZ
Certified Number
I DARLENE LAWRENCE
having been duly authorized by Tre Hargett, Secretary of State
of Tennessee, do hereby make oath on his behalf and under authorization as follows:
Wednesday, April 24, 2013
That on
I received from the plaintiff the original
and certified copies of the Summons and Complaints issued against the defendant:
,
PAMELA MORITZ
whose address is:
of KNOXVILLE
and returned to
~ &~~
-reta of Stte_&
SM
Subscribed and sworn to before me,
this 16th
day of May
MIA
.2013
NOTARY PUBLIC
My commission expires 9-9-14
co
"S'
ON
!o.
C,
111
SECRETARY OF STATE
312 ROSA L PARKS AVENUE
7TH FL. TN TOWER
NASHVILLE TN 37243-1102
615-741-0532
Invoice I Receipt
P
-1
255873
4I24/2o13
Ii
Bill To:
MICHAEL P TULAY PE
6042 LEGENDS LAKE LN
KNOXVILLE TN 37922
CustothriD
900009656
_1_
4:
4124/2013
258849
SUM500
Summons
1577593 MICHAEL TULAY VS PAMELA MORITZ ETAL
$20.001
00
r'
Check Number
$60.00
3124
$60.00
$6000
STATE OF TENNESSEE
CHANCERY COURT OF KNOX COUNTY
Sixth Judicial District
400 Main Avenue, Knoxville, Tennessee 37902
r
PP
CD
LA(
MtMl
Flaiatiff
PA ELA MO
,Defendant
Civil Action No
Sheriff of Knox County, Tennessee
StTMIIONS
To
'kE
5ri
-ili.z.
You are hereby summoned to defend a civil action filed against you in Chancery Court, Knox County, Tennessee. Your defense must
be made within thirty (30) days from the date this summons Is served upois you. You are directd to Lie your defense with the clerk.
of the court and send a copy to plaintiff a attorney at the address below. If you fail to do so, judgment by default will be taken against
you for the relief demanded in PC complaint
.
.
Witness, Howard G. HogarL Cleft and Master of said Court, at office in Knoxville, Tennessee.
Howard (3. Hogan, Clernd
..
S.
ter
Deputy Clerk
NOTICE TO ThE DEFENDANT (S):1
>
Tnnnesses law provides a ten thousand dollar ($10,000.00) personal property exemption from execution or seizure to satisfy a
judgment If ajudgxnent should be entered against you in this action and you wish to claim property as exempt, you must file a written
list, under oath, of the items you wish to claim as exempt with the clerk of the court The list may be filed at any time and may be
changed by you thereafter as necesSary, howeyer, unless it is filed before the judgment becomes final, it will not be effective as to any
execution of garnishment issued prior to the filing of thelist. Certain items are automatically exempt by law and do not need to be
listed these include items of necessary wearing apparel (clothing) for yourself and your family and thixil s of other receptacles
necessary to contain such apparel, family porbwits, the family Bible, and school books. Should any of these items be seized you would
have the right to recover them. If you do not understand your exemption right or how to exercise it you may wish to seek the counsel ofa lawyer. T.C.A.26-2-114.
S
.
day of
Received this.
55
S
Deputy Sheriff
I hereby certify and return that on the _______day of
S.
.
...
20
ADA.
FOR ASSSThNCECALL
865/215-2952
TTY: 865/215-2497
_.Iserved
.113
;~
Ignafure
/2&2"
I
-I
ddressee
C. Date of Delivery
p1BLA MOR1TZ
iOS SOUTH ON 17602
LAN CASTE PA
Service Type
0 CertIfied Mall
/z f3.
o Registered
O Insured Mail
4. Res
2. Article Number
(flansfer from seMce label)
PS Form
3811,
February 2004
tfl' 1""
0 Express Mail
0 Return Receipt for
0 C.O.D.
"-
Merchandise I
0 Yes
102595-02-M-1540
114
'
PI
I!
State of Tennessee
Department of State
Division of Business Services
Wm, R. Snodgrass Tower
312 Rosa L. Parks Avenue, 6th Floor
Nashville, Tennessee 37243
70111570000340465060
5/16/20 13
Case Number:
151759 - 3
Date
Certifed Number
KNOXVILLE, TN 37902-2423
MICHAEL TULAY
RE:
Dear Clerk:
Enclosed are the following papers in the above styled case:
Original Summons
Affidavit and Endorsement
Registered or Certified Return Receipt signed by:
_J
PAMELA MORITZ
Sincerely:
4~ Lt-e
Tre Hargett
enclosures
Initials:
IMMHAW
CC:L
115
I!
PI
AFFIDAVIT
and
ENDORSEMENT
5/1612013
Date
70111570000340465060
MICHAEL TULAY
VS:
PAMELA MORITZ
Certified Number
DARLENE LAWRENCE
, having been duly authorized by Tre Hargett, Secretary of State
I
of Tennessee, do hereby make oath on his behalf and under authorization as follows:
Wednesday, April 24, 2013
I received from the plaintiff the original
That on
and certified copies of the Summons and Complaints issued against the defendant:
PAMELA P4ORITZ
, and returned to
of KNOXVILLE
Tre Hargett
day of May
(J). !
by
&&" 0VZdAZk,<,
2013
J'
\LL/7-.
NOTARY PUBLIC
My commission expires 9-9-14
TLJI'
-.J
-'-----'.
\.
0
1M
, - ,
-
-sow o'
SS-4201 (Rev. 2/90)
116
STATE OF TENNESSEE
CHANCERY COURT OF KNOX COUNTY
..
..
..
.
:.
'
..
A
rL.
Pk1ELA
.
, Plaintiff
M 6tT?.
,Defendant
Civil Action No
-)
?MI-A Mo
To
Aui ,
id cou
fL\
cfrt
M,
M It-&EL 'T
.J Th-2 3'7IAZ.
You are hereby summoned to defend a civil action filed against you in Chancery Court, Knox County, Tennessee. Your defense must
be made within thirty (30) days from the date this summons is served upon you. You are directed to file your defense with the clerk.
of the court and send a copy to plains attorney at the address below. If you fail to do so,judgrnent by default will be taken against
you for the relief demande4 in he complaint . ... . . .... . .. .
Issued this
dayoft1c,D(,201D
. . . ..
Witness, Howard G. Hoga Clerk anster of said Court, at office in Knoxville, Tennessee.
Howard G Hogan, C1erand Mter
.
Deputy Clerk
..
Tennessee law provides a ten thousand dollar (10,000.00) personal property exemption from execution or seizure to satisfy a
judgment If a judgment should be entered against you in this action and you wish to claim property as exempt, you roust file a written
list,, under oath, of the items you wish to claim as exempt with the clerk of the court The list may be filed at any time and may be
changed by you thereafter as necessary however, unless it is fled before the judgment becomes final, it will not be effccth'c as to any
execution of garnishment issued prior to the filing of the list Certain items are automatically exempt by law and do not need to be
listed; these include items of necessary wearing apparel (clothing) for yourself and your family and trunks of other receptacles
necessary to contain such apparel, family portraits, the family Bible, and schoolbooks. Should any of these items be seized you would
have the right to recover them. If you do not understand your exemption right or how to exercise it you may wish to seek the counsel
of a lawyer. T.C.A.26-2-1 14.
.
.
. ..
.
. .
ADA
Received this
day . of
..
, 20
Deputy Sheriff .
day of
I hereby certify and return that on the
this summons together with the complaint as follows:
I failed to serve this summons within 30 days after its issuance because
..
TTY: 865/215-2497
.
I served
11 7.
4iz(r
C. Data of I
ci /3
PAMELA MOR1TZ
10 SOUTH ANN ST
LANCASTER, PA 17602
0 No
a Service Type
/zc
2. Article Number(rransfer (torn service labeO
::::?
-
0 Certified Mail
0 Express Mail
13 eisterad E3 Return, Receipt for Merchandise
fl"
DlnsuredMail
DYes
erc
1311 15
Domestic Return Receipt
10259 02-M.154o
Complete items 1, 2, L.
. Also complete
item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired.
Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to YOU.
Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,.
or on the front if space permits.
A. Si ture
X V
f)7
is deiery add
ES, e
0 Agent
0 Addressee
'
C. Date of Delivery
-
d-ent
b
Pamela A Moritz
108S. Ann St.
Lancaster, PA 17602-431300
--
3.'lcTYP
Certified Mail
0 Express Mail
1!J Registered
Return Receipt for Merchandise
D insured Mail
0 G.O.D.
PS Form
0 Yes
February 2004
------ -------------------.
102595-02-M1540
-----------
119
21
EN THE CHANCERY COURT FOR KNOX COUNTY, TENNESSEE
No. 151759-3
E20 13-01 528-COA-R3-CV
SUPPLEMENTAL # 2
CERTIFICATE OF APPELLATE RECORD
I, Howard G. Hogan, Clerk and Master of the Chancery Court of Knox County,
Tennessee, do hereby certify that the following items herewith transmitted to the Court of
Appeals are originals or true and correct copies of all or of the designated papers on file in my
office in the captioned case.
Technical Record attached to this certificate and consisting of 120 pages contained in
one (1) volume.
ihis
2014
120