Открыть Электронные книги
Категории
Открыть Аудиокниги
Категории
Открыть Журналы
Категории
Открыть Документы
Категории
06UTOpe
13
BBe~eHHe
15
Y~OBJIeTBOpeHHJI"eJlOBe'lecKHX n0Tpe6HOCTeit
21
23
35
47
POCTE MCTA&MnbHOCTM
67
nOTPE&MTEnEM M nPEAnPMSlTMM
DIaaa 8. IIpe.lUIoJKeHHe H cnpoc
_. DIaaa 9. 3HaKOMltTeC..: n0'I'pe6HTeJ1", MaKCHMH3HpYIODJ;Hii nOJle3HOCTh
DIua 10. OCHoaa KaIIJITIlJIII3Ma: npe~pH.RTHe, MaKCHMH3HpYIOInee npH6b1J1b
DIaaa 11. IIo'leMY 3KOHOMHCTbI mo6JIT cB060~e PbIHKH H KOHKYPeHUHIO
Thaaa 12. MOHonOJlHH: KaK IIJIOXO Be.lJYf Ce6R Te, Y KOro HeT KOHKypeIITOB
Thaaa 13. OJIHfOnOJlHR H MOHOnOJIHCTII'IecKaR KOHKypeIlllHR
Thaaa 14. IIpaaa Co6cTBeHHOCTH H ax OTCyrcTBRe
DIaaa 15. HecOCTOJlTeJlbHOCTh pblHKa: aCHMMeTPaqau HHcItoPManu
R 06m.ecTBeHHble TOaapbl
159
161
185
203
229
253
275
297
309
325
327
333
341
DIQCcapd
347
IIpe,nMeTHbIii y u 3 a T e J I b '
353
Do 8lITope
13
llOCBJllIleHHe
13
B~aro~PHOCTH
14
BBe,ll,eHHe
15
o KHHre
15
16
17
17
18
19
20
20
"IACTb I.
ThaBa
3KOHOM~"IECKAR TEOP~R
- HAYKA 0 TOM,
21
23
23
24
24
25
26
27
27
27
28
28
29
29
29
,llecPH:Qure
3TO 3)lOpOBO
30
30
30
31
31
' 31
33
NQ 1: KpHBalI crrpoca
35
35
36
37
COAepJlCaHMe
39
39
40
40
41
OrpaHHlIeHHOCTb pecypcoB
TeXHOJIOrHlleCKHe OrpaHHlIeHlliI
OrpaHHlIeHHOcTb BpeMeHH
CroHMOCTb B03MO)I(HOCTH: HeH36e)I(Hoe orpaHHlIeHHe
)l,eJIaeM OKOHllaTeJIbHbIit BbI60p
HCCJIe.nyeM orpaHHlIeHlliI H npOTHBOpelllliI Mo,neJIH nOTPe6HTeJIbCKoro BbI60pa
KaK npOHcxo,nHT npHIUITHe peweHHit npH HenOJIHoit HH<popMaIIHH
PaIIHOHaJIbHOe B HppaIIHOHaJIbHOM
ThaDa
37
38
38
43
43
43
y)l,OBJUITBOpeHWllleJIOBelleCKHX Dmpe6HOCnA
47
48
48
49
50
51
54
55
56
62
65
POCTE M CTA&MnbHOCTM
Thasa 4. MaKp03KOHOMHIJ:eCKHe nOKll3aTeJIH: UK 3KOHOMHCThI CJIe~ 3a DceM
BBII )l)UI OTCJIe)I(HBaHlliI 3KOHOMHlIecKHX npoIIeccoB
qro He yqHTbIBaeTCH a BBII
qro yqHTbIBaeTcH B BBII
HcnOJIb3yeM
I-
BBII
BBII
nOTPe6HTeJIbCKHe pacxo,nbI
HHBeCTHIIHH B OCHOBHOit KanHTaJI
G - rocy,napCTBeHHbIe pacxo,nbI
NX - lIHCTbIit ofu.eM 3KcnoPTa
67
69
70
70
71
72
73
75
76
76
77
79
80
81
82
83
84
OTHOCHTeJIbHOe npeHMyrnecTBo
85
ThaDa
5. HHcIlJIJI~:
C~ep.aHHe
89
90
90
92
97
99
100
101
101
102
103
104
105
105
107
108
109
110
111
111
112
113
114
116
118
119
119
120
121
122
130
r: AeifcTBHH rrpaBHTenbCTBa
133
134
134
136
136
137
138
140
143
144
145
147
148
149
151
152
153
154
155
ll,enb -
Co.llepJKBHHe
'tACTb III.
M~KP03KOHOM~KA-
HAYKA 0
nOBEAEH~~
nOTPE6~TEnEA ~ nPEAnp~SlT~A
159
KPHBaH crrpoca
MaKCHMH3aU;HH hpH6hiJIH
KO~HU;HH
CQAepJIC8HHe
161
162
162
162
163
166
167
168
169
172
174
174
175
177
177
178
180
180
182
185
186
186
187
190
191
192
195
197
198
199
203
204
205
205
206
207
209
210
212
213
214
9 .
215
215
217
218
220
222
224
IIpe,I(eJIbHbIe H3,I(ep:>KKH
ToqKa nepeCeqeHIDI: KPHBbIX MC, AVC H ATC
CpaBHeHHe npe,I(eJIbHOrO ,I(OXO,I(a C npe,I(eJIbHbIMH H3,I(ep)l(lQlMH
BOJIwe6HaH cPopMyJIa: KOr,I(a MR:= MC
BH3YaJIH3aUHH npH6hmH
BH3YaJIH3aUIDI: y6bITKOB
Kor,I(a nyqme HHqero He npOH3BO,I(HTb
YCJIOBIDI: KPaTKOCpOqHOrO 3aKphITHH npe,I(npIDI:THH: nepeMeHHbIe H3,I(ep)KI(H
224
225
226
COBOKYIIHhIH ,I(OXO,I(
3aBHCHMOCTb OT pbIHOqHbIX ueH
Thaua
229
230
230
232
234
239
240
241
244
244
245
247
npH6hillH
253
253
254
254
259
263
263
265
266
267
267
267
268
269
269
269
270
272
ThaDa
10
Co,qepJIC8HMe
Than
TIDKeJIhIH Tpy~
275
276
276
277
277
278
278
279
280
283
284
286
Thasa
287
288
288
288
289
289
290
297
298
299
300
300
302
303
304
"Tpare~IDI o6:w;HH"
CO)'l;epxaHHe KOpOB: qpe3MepHoe cTpaBJIHBaHHe rracroHma Ha o6meCTBeHHOM rrOJIe
306
306
307
co6cTBeHHOCTH
ThaDa
aCHMMeTJ)II'IHaJI HH4oPMalUUl
rro~epxaHHbIXaBTOM06HJ1eii:
309
310
310
311
315
319
319
320
321
321
Co,qepJlCBHHe
11
325
327
A,p;aM CMHT
Pd6ePT ilYKac
327
328
328
329
329
330
330
330
331
331
332
333
333
334
334
~35
OIlIH60'IHoe COnOCTaBJIeHHe
336
336
337
)l;aBH,ll PHKap,!J,o
KaPJI MapKc
AJIbCPpe,!J, MapwaJIJI
,llxOH MeAHap,!J, KeAHc
KeHHeT 3ppoy H )l(epap )l;e6pe
MHJlTOH cI>pH,!J,MaH
IIoJI CaMY3JIbCOH
P06epT COJIoy
[appH DeKep
MaprnHaJIH3M
"HecTa6HJ1bHOCTb CB060,!J,HhIX PbIHKOB TaUT B ce6e OnaCHOCTb"
"HH3KHe 3apITJIaTbI y HHOCTPaHHbIX pa60lJHX 03HaQaIOT, 'ITO 60raTble CTpaHbI
"IIoBbIIIIeHHe HaJIoroB He OKa3bIBaeT BJIIDIHIDI Ha TPY,!J,oBOA 3HTYJH33M"
I1rnopHpoBaHHe Henpe,!J,BH,!J,eHHbIX nocJIe,!J,cTBHA nOJIHTHKH
337
338
339
341
341
342
342
342
342
343
He CMOryr KOHKYPHpoBaTb"
343
344
344
345
ThoccapHii:
347
npe,lJ;MeTIIbIii yD38TeJ1b
353
C 0KPyxaIOIQeA cpe,!J,oH
Me~apo,!J,HaH TOproBJIH ~ 3TO OQeHb xopowee ,!J,eJIO
lJacTHbIe lPHPMbI nepeXHBaIOT TPY,!I,HOCTH C npe,!J,OCTaBJIeHHeM 06meCTBeHHbIX 6JIar
12
Co,qepJlCBHlfe
068BTope
mo.. ClJIHHH
oepKJIH, IIITaT KanH$oPHIDI; ero yqHTeJUlMH 6hIJIH JlaypeaTbI H06en:eBcKoii rrpeMHH ~OP,ll,X{
AKepJlo$ H ,LJ:3HH3J1 MaK-<%>a.nn;eH.
ABrop .IlBJUleTC.Il qJIeHOM AMepHKaHCKOH 3KOHOMH'IeCKOH aCCOUHaUHH, AMepHKaHCKOi{
$HHaHCOBoii aCCOUHauHH, AcCOUHauHH 3KOHOMH'IeCKHX HaYK H 06IUeCTBa pa3BHTIDI nOBe
,lI,eHtIeCKOH 3KOHOMHKH.
OOJlbWe Bcero aBTOpa HHTepecyeT Henpe,ll,CKa3yeMoe H tIacTO IeIDKyl.Ueec.Il HPpauHOHaJIbHbIM
nOBe,ll,eHHe yqacTHHKOB PbIHKa ueHHbIX 6yMar; OH TaIOlCe HCCJle.nyeT H ,lI,pyrHe TeMbI: HarrpH
Mep, tIro BJIIDIeT Ha nOBe,ll,eHHe nOCeTHTen:ei{ pecropaHoB H nOtIeMY TOJIbKO B orrpe,ll,eJleHHbIX
OTPaCJl.llX MO)l{}{O YBH,lleTb MHOJKeCTBO He 06'be,ll,HHeHHbIX B npo$cOI03bI pa6OTHHKOB. <l>JlHHH
.IlBJI.IleTC.Il TaKJKe tJe;llylUHM CneUHaJIHcroM no HHBecTHUHOHHbIM $oH.1l3M 3aKPbIroro THrra.
KpoMe roro, aBTOpa OTJlH'laeT 60JIbWWI J1IOOOBb K .IlrrOHCKOMY 6oeBOMY HCKycCTBy aiIKH,llo,
KOropOMY ooJlee ,lI,eC.IlTH JleT OH 06yqaeT TbIC.Il'IH cTY,lI,eHTOB B Coe,ll,HHeHHbIX IIITaTax H 3a HX
rrpe,ll,eJlaMH. ECJlH BbI HHTepecyeTecb 60eBbIMH HCKYccTBaMH, MoxeTe rrpO'll{TaTb ero KHHry
6-ro MHa"),
KOTOpll.ll
,LJ:JI.Il3TOro
www.learn-econimics.com.
nOCBSI~eHMe
MoeMY
0TllY,
&narOAapHOCTM
14
6narOABPHOCTH
BBeAeHMe
A TaKHe
H npOH3BOL\$lT rrepeMeHhI. ORR CMatpfl Ha TO, 'IeM BJIaLleIOT, H LlYMaIOT 0 TOM, 'ITO OHH MO
lYI'
C 3THM cLleJIaTb; OHH npeLlnpHHHMaIOT KaKHe-TO MephI .lJ)Ul Toro, 'IT06hI y6eLlHTbCg: eCJIH
THTb 3apa6oTaHHhIe LleHbrH HJIH OTJIO:lKHTb HX Ha rrOTOM; rrpO.llOJI:lKHTb yqe6y HJIH rroAm pa6o
TaTb; CJIepYeT JIH roCYLlapcTBY TpaTHTb 60JIbille LleHer Ha o6mee 06paJOBaHHe HJIH HarrpaBHTb
HX Ha HCCJIeLlOBaHHg B o6JIaCTH JIe'IeHHg paKOBhIX 3860JIeBaHHA.
ITpou;ecc rrpHH$lTHg peIIIeHHA -
3KOHOMH'IeC~ TeOpHg -
n03BO
3TY HaYKY
B KOHIJ;e KOHUOB,
eCJIH 3KOHOMHIIecKYIO TeOpHIO TaK TpYLlHO nOH$lTb, 3Ha'IHT, OHa no onpeLleJIeHHIO LlOJI:lKHa 6hITb
Ba:lKHoA, He TaK JIH?
3TY KHHIy
$I
CQ3LlaBarr .lJ)Ul TOro, 'ITo6hI BhI MOrJIH 6blCTpO H JIerKO rrOH$lTb CYTb 3KOHO
3TY KHHIy,
/tJi,uze
:nOM KHHre BbI Haii:,n;eTe orrHcaHHe CaMhIX Ba:lKHhIX 3KOHOMH'IeCKHX TeopHA, rHrrOTe3 H
Bse,qeHJfe
15
yc.rryrn.
./ KaKHM 06paJOM
./ KaK rrpoc'nm
.SI
we -
H ,IJ;axe 60JIb
TaKHM 06PaJOM, qro6bI rrepe.aaTb BaM 6pa3,IJ;bI rrpaBJIeHHH. BbI MOXeTe qHTaTb fJIaBbI B rrpo
H3BOJIbHOM rrOPMKe, Y BaC eCTb B03MOXHOCTb CpaJY xe rronaCTb TY,IJ;a, KY,IJ;a rroxeJIaeTe, 6e3
Heo6xo,IJ;HMOCm qHTaTb BCe TO, Ha qro BIoI He XOTHTe TPaTHTb CBOe BHHMaHHe.
3KOHOMHCTaM MpaBHTCH KOHtc:ypeHUIDl, rro3TOMY HaC He ,IJ;OJI)({HO y,IJ;HBJIjiTb, qro y Hac cyme
BaPHaHTOB
KaKHX-JIH60 orrpe,IJ;eJIe~.
lioJIee TOro,
!/tU,08/tbte Otf03H.a1te/tu.R 14
. UCJI,fJ.,I,b3'1eJtbte
JiiejzJi.tlJtbt.,
8 aJiioii ItItUU!
.umr
MHHHMHJaUHH Hepa36e
. pHXH B TOM ~ae, KOr,IJ;a MHe rrpH,IJ;eTCH 03HaKOMHTb BaC C HOBbIM repMHHOM, H 6y.ny IIHCaTb
ero ICYPCUBOM H corrpoBO)({)laTb JIeI'KHM ,IJ;JIjI BOcrrpIDITIDI orrpe,IJ;eJIeHHeM. TaKXe, KOr,IJ;a H 6y.ny
rrpH6eraTb K aJIre6pa~eCKHM cP0PMYJIaM, H BHOBb 6y.ny rrpH6eraTb K y,IJ;06HOMY KypCUBHOMy
BbI,IJ;eJIeHHIO ,IJ;;JUI TOro, lfI'06bI BbI 3HaJIH, qro H 06paIDaIOCb K aJIre6p~eCKOMY 3JIeMeHTY.
llpHMepbI H rrOCTapaIOCb cBecm K
MHHHMYMY,
MbI, rrOCKOJIbKY rrOMoraIOT rrpOKCHHTb HeKOTOpbIe BeUJ;H. B TaKHX ~WlX H HHOr,IJ;a BblHY
16
BBflA8H1f8
KaX. HarrpHMep:
"
I
(1)
HaKOHeu, CJIe.ll}'lOID;He yCJIOBHH HCrr0JIb30BaHbl B TeKCTe BCeX KHHf CepHH iJlIR "rtOlmu
K08" )J;JIH TOro, 'IT06hI c.n;eJIaTb co.n;ep:lIGlHHe JIerKHM B BOCrrpHHTHH:
Bce a.n;peca B HHTepHeTe ,naHhI TaKl1M IIlpl1q,TOM.
"
llOJlYJKHPUYI
lPa.KThI H aHeK
Bpe3KH -
" TeKCT,
o6ooHalfellllWA
IIIIIITOrpllMMoA
U ,l{ODOJIIIIITeJIbIIlUI
HH4loPMaIUUI". 3Ta HH
8ee,
'ITO H HaIlH
CaJI B 3TOH KHHre, HO He HyJKHO HOJIHOBaTbCH. Bce paBHO H HHKor,na 06 3TOM He Y3HaIO!
KJiio dbt,
H
HarrHCaJI
"
J/.ott
'tUlhaJiiLtb
.
3TY KHHIy,
"
BhI -
rro H3yqaeMoH TeMe, HJIH rpaJlClJ,aHHH MHpa, KOTOpbdt OC03Haer, 'ITO 3HaHHe
3KOHOMH'IeCKHX 3aKOHOB rrOMoxeT rrOHR:Tb Bce, Ha'IHHaR: OT 6H3Heca H rrOJIH
THKH H JaKaH'IHBllH COUHaJIbHhIMH HBJIeHHHMH, TaKHMH KaK 6e,nHOCTb H paJ
pyrneHHe OKPYJKaIO~eHcpe.!U>l.
88e,qeHIfe
17
nO~p)l(JJ,eHHeMBMe
3To
03HaQaeT, 'ITO BaM XOtIeTCR Y3Han., nOtIeMY 'ITO-TO c.nyqaeTCR H KaK Bce
II
III
CJIe~eT Tpa,nHUHOH
HO HHq,opMaTHBHbIX nepeqHeH
'4acTb
I.
MTCR B HaJIHtIHH.
qacTb
'4acTb
II. MaKp03KOHOMMKa -
HayKa 06
18
8.8A8Hffe
'taCTb
IV.
Kax.nasr
BenMKonenHble AeCRTKM
KHHra cepHH ... 0/111 ""aUHUIC06" 3aKaHqHBaeTCR ,neCSlTKaMH JIyqWHX -
JIJO,ne1t,
:Jlu"IiiOZjtaJ,iJ(,bt, UC/l.OJ,b3'1e.Jttne 8
,!l..JuI
aJliou "RUle
TOro qT06bI 06JIerqHTb qTeHHe 3T01t KHHrH H c,neJIaTb ee 60JIee npocT01t, HCnOJIb30
Ii,."
~,
j)
! .,
H.nTH
,naJIbwe.
BaeAeHHe
19
~
lEr
YCHJIIDl.
~.Bee paBHO
'
./
7.
./
14.
8.
Bce tIaCTH KHHrH He3aBHCHMhI, TaK'ITO BhI Moxere, K npHMepy, npo<IHTaTb Bee 0 MHK
p03KOHOMHKe, eCJIH y Bac HeT He06xO,llHMOCTH 'IHTaTb 0 MaKp03KoHoMHKe. Pa3,lleJIbI
"CO,llepXaHHe" H "npe,llMeTHhIil: YKaJareJIb" nOMoryr BaM JIerKO OThICKaTb KOHKPeTHhIe
reMhI.
Ho eCJIH BhI He 3HaeTe, 0TKY,lla HaqaTb, BOCrrOJIb3yWreCb CTaphIM ,ll06PhIM MeTO,llOM H
Ha'IHHre CHaqana. KaK noeTCH B Moeil: iII06HMOil: neCHe H3 KHHocPHJIbMa "3ByKH MY3hIKH":
"J],aBail:re
BhI, '1HTareJIb 3TOil: KHHrH, H eCTb rJIaBHblil: ee KPHTHK H KOMMeHTarop. MhI u;eHHM Harne
MHeHHe H XOTHM 3HaTb, 'ITO 6hIJIO C,lleJIaHO HaMH npaBHJIbHO, 'Iro MO:lKHO 6b1J1o C,lleJIaTb
nyq
me H '1ro eme BbI XOTeJIH 6hI YBH,lleTb H3.llaHHhIM HaMM. HaM HHTepeCHO YCJIhIwaTb H JII06hIe
,llPyrHe 38MeqaHHSI, KOTOphIe BaM XOTeJIOCb 6hI BhICKaJaTb B Haw a,llpeC.
MbI )I(,lleM BalliHX KOMMeHTapHeB H Ha,lleeMCH Ha HHX. BhI MOXeTe npHCJIaTb HaM 6~8:lK
Hoe HJIH 3JIeKTPOHHOe nHCbMO JIH60 npocTO rrOceTHTb Haw
~b-cepBep H
OCTaBHTb CBOH 38
MeqaHHH TaM. O,llHHM CJIOBOM, JII06hIM y,ll06HhIM ,llJIH HaC cnoco60M ,llail:re HaM 3HaTb, Hpa
BHTCSI HJIH HeT BaM 3Ta KHHra, a TaK:lKe BhICKa:lKHTe CBoe MHeHHe 0 TOM, KaK C,lleJIaTb HaWH
KHHrH 60JIee HHrepeCHhIMH ,llJIH BaC.
nOChIJIaH nHCbMO HJIH coo6meHHe, He 386Y,llbTe YKaJaTb Ha3BaHHe KHHrH H ee aBTopoB, a
TaK:lKe Baw 06pa'rHhIil: a,llpec. MhI BHHMareJIbHO 03HaKOMHMCH C BaWHM MHeHHeM H 06H3a
TeJIbHO yqTeM ero npH OT6ope H rrO,llroTOBKe K H3,llaHHIO rrOCJIeJlYIOmHX KHHr. HawH KOOP.llH
HaTbl:
E-mail:
~
info@dialektika.com
http://www.dialektika.com
I1H<PoPMau;HH,llJIH rrHceM:
H3 POCCHH:
H3 YKPaHHhI:
20
C'rp.
"
'90~09~V~~ ~W~906~
I QJ.3eh
rJlasa 1
nO"leMy cneAyeT M3Y"laTb
3KOHOMM"IeCKYIO TeOpMIO
B a/li()l4 u.aIIe...
~ KpaTKHH 0630P HCTOpHH pa3BHTHl1 3KOHOMHKH
~ KaK mOAH cnpaBmllOTCSI C Aeq,Hl.lHTOM
~ MaKpo- H MHKp03KOHOMHKa
~ 3KOHOMWleCKHe l.lHK11b1
~
.:7
KOHOMH'leCKWI TeopIDI -
HbIX pecypcOB.
30%
25
JIeT
250 JIeT,
60
MOryr rr03BOJIHTb ce6e ynyqillHTh yCJIOBIDl Be,neHIDl ,nOMaillHero x03H:A:CTBa, nyqine o,neBaTbCH
H IIHTaTbCH, qeM MOXHO 6blJIO Bo06paJHTb HeCKOJIbKO CTOJIem:A: TOM)' HaJa,n.
De3YCJIOBHO, He Bce eme H,lI;eaJIbHO. Bo MHorHX perHOHax MHpa Bce eme npHCYTCTBy
eT yxaCHaH 6e,nHOCTb, H ,naxe caMble 60raTbIe. CTPaHbl ,nOJIXHbl CrrpaBJIHTbCH c rrpeccHHroM
KOrrHYTb HeMHoro rny6xe, TO MOXHO y,ll;HBHTbCH, noqeM)' 06mecTBO TeXHOJIO~eCKHXHHHOBaIJ,HH He B03HHKJIO paHbille.
24
'IacT" I.
3KOHoMHlfecKafl
TeOpHfI...
TaK 'ITO, HeCMOTPH Ha TOT cPaKT, 'ITO B KIDK.llOM 06meCTBe BO BCe BeKa pO)l{,Il,aJIHCb rrO-Ha
CTOHmeMY YMHbIe JIIO.llH, ,n;0 TOro, KaK B
XVIII
XVIII BeKa,
MHKH TaK pa.n;HKaJIbHO YCKOPHJICH? ECJIH BKpame, TO MOJKHO OTBeTHTb Ha 3TOT Borrpoc, co
CTaBHB CJie.D;yIOmHH rrepeqeHb
./ ,l);eMoJqtllTlUl.
./ UllTelfl1lhle
H306peTllTeJleit
JIIO,n;bMH,
./ illllpOll:Oe pacnpocTpuelllle
rpaMO'I1IOCTH II
o6pll3OBalUDl.
Ee3 BbICOKo06paJo
A 6e3
)KHTb
CMOTPMM B 6YAy~ee
QT06bI ,n;BHraTbCH Brrepe,n;, He06xo,n;HMO rronyqaTb eme 60JIbille TeX 6JIar, KOTOpbIe JIIO,n;H
XOTHT HMeTb H3 cymeCTByIOmHX B MHpe orpaHH'IeHHbIX pecypCOB. 3KOHOMH'IeCKHH POCT He
06xO)UfM, rrOCKOJIbKY B MHpe Bce eme CymeC'fByeT MHoro rrpo6JIeM, KOTOpbIe MOIYJ' 6bITb "oc
JIa6JIeHbI" TOJIbKO rrpH yCJIOBHH rrOBbIIIIeHHH JKH3HeHHoro ypOBHH.
HeKOTOpbIe rrp06JIeMbI, TaKHe KaK KpaitHHH 6e,n;HOCTb, MOIYJ' 6bITb CMHNeHbI C03.D;aHHeM
B 6e,n;HbIX CTPaHax CrreU;HaJIbHbIX 06m;eCTBeHHbIX HHC'fHTYTOB, KOTOpbIe yx<:e "HCrrbITaHbI" B
60JIee 60raTbIX CTPaHax, 'ITO rrpHBeJIO K rrOBbIrneHHIO XGl3HeHHoro ypOBHH. Ho ,n;pyrHe npo
25
3KOHoM~eclGle 3HaHHH.
rrocTpoHJI 31)' KHHry TaKHM 06pa30M, qTOOhI nOCTapaTbCH OCBeTHTb KaK MOJKHO 60JIblIIe
K TOMY
:lICe, H c.n;eJIaJI Bce OT MeHH JaimCHmee, qT06h1 OHa 6bma XHBOH H HHTepeCHoH. AHrJIHHCKHH
rr03T TOMac KaPJIaHJI Ha:3BaJI 3KoHoMWIecKYIO TeOpHIO "Mpa~OH HaYKOH", HO ero orrpe.n;eJIeHHe
MHe He HPaBHTCH, H H rrOCTapaIOCb c,n:eJIaTb Bee, ~hI BaM He npHlIIJIOCb C HHM COrJIalIIaTbCH.
[JIaBHhlH OpraHHJaIJ;HOHHbIH rrpHHIJ;Hn, KOTOPhIM H PYKOBO,n:CTBOBaJICH rrpH C03)l;aHHH 3TOH
KHHrH, 3aKJIIOqaeTCH B pa3,n:eJIeHHH 3KOHOM~eCKOH reopHH Ha.n;Be OCHOBHhle qaCTH -
MaK
P03KOHOMHKY H MHKp03KOHOMHKY.
0/
0/
ca. B OTHOlIIeHHH HH,n:HBH,D;yyMOB OHa 06'MICHHeT, KaK OHH Be.n:yr ce6H, Kor.n;a
HM HyxHO rrpHHHMaTb pelIIeHHH 0 TOM, r,n:e nQTPaTHTh CBOH .n;eHbrH HJIH KY,n:a
BJIO:lKHTb co6CTBeHHhle c6epe:llCeHHH. B OTHOlIIeHHH qaCTHoro 6H3Heca OHa
o6'MIcHHeT, KaK <pHPMbI, Hau;eJIeHHble Ha YBeJIHqeHHe npH6h1JIH, Be.n;YT ce6H
K<UK,ll,aIl B OT.n;eJIbHOCTH H B yCJIOBIDIX PhlHOqHOH KOHKypeHU;HH.
III.
H rrocBHmy ofu,
II H
MHKP03KO
OCTaBlIIaJICR qaCTb rJIaBbI B OCHOBHOM CJIY:lKHT peKJIaMOH .n:mI oCTaBlIIeHCg qaCTH KHHrH.
II03ToMY eCJIH BhI npe)l;rrOqHTaeTe CIOpnpH3b1, BaM JIY'IlIIe rrpHMO CeHqac rrpoqYCTHTb He
CKOJIbKO CTPaHHU;. HCKJIIOqeHHeM B )l;aHHOM CJIY'Iae MOJKeT CTaTb nOCJIe)l;HH.H pa3)l;eJI, r,n:e R
paCCKa3h1BaIO 0 TOM, KaK 3KOHOMHCThI Hcrr0JIb3YIOT .n;HarpaMMhI H rpa<pHIGI. ECJIH BaM Hyx
26
'IacT"
I. 3fCOHOM.,,,ecfCBJI reOpHJI...
,~
;
KaK
15h1.
IIOJIYtIHTb Bce, OHH XOTH 6bI HMeIOT JIY'IlIIee, tIro MO)({}{O IIOJIYtIHTb B ,lJ;aHHbIX 06
CroHTeJIbCTBaX. fJIaBa
BbI
rnaBe
3 ,lJ;eMOHCTpHpyeTcH,
omiJa'tu,
KOTOPbIH
OIIHChlBaeT TOT IIetIaJIbHbIH <paKT, 'ITO KIDK./loe ,lJ;OrrOJIHHTeJIbHOe KOJIHlJeCTBO pecypCOB, BJIO
xeHHbIX B rrpouecc rrpOH3BO,lJ;CTBa, Brrpe,lJ;b rrpHHOCHT Bee MeHbillee KOJIH'leCTBO IIpo,ZJ;yKUHH.
KaK H B CJIYtIae C ,lJ;e<pHI.J;HTOM, YMeHbIIleHHe OT,lJ;atIH HeH36e)({}{O, H B maBe
KaK JIIO,ZJ;H peIIlaIOT
3TY
3 06b.ll:ClUleTCJl,
pecypcOB.
II
HOMHKY KaK e,lJ;HHoe UeJIoe. I-byqeHHe MaKp03KOHOMHKH rrOJIe3HO rrOTOMY, tIro TaKHe <paK
roPhl, KaK rrpOueHTHbIe CTaBKH H HaJIOfOBaH IIOJIHTHKa, BJIIDIIOT Ha BCe c<pepbI 3KOHOMHKH,
H KOf,lJ;a 3KOHOMHKa rrepeXHBaeT OtIepe,lJ;HOH rrO,lJ;'beM (HJIH crra)];), KIDK./lbIH tIeJIOBeK H BCHKHH
6H3Hec omyruaeT Ha ce6e BJIIDIHHe 3KOHOMHlJeCKHX 3aKOHOB.
MaKp03KOHOMMlieCKMe nOKa3aTenM
B maBe 4
(BBn) -
MexyTOK BpeMeHH (06bItIHO 3TO KBaPTaJI HJIH ro,lJ;). CYMMHpOBaHHe Bcero 3TOro XH3HeHHO
He06xo,lJ;HMO, rrOCKOJIbKY eCJIH MbI He MoxeM OIIpe,lJ;eJIHTb, KaK pa60TaeT 3KOHOMHKa, MbI He
CMoxeM CKa3aTb, 6bIJIa rocy,lJ;apCTBeHHaH IIOJIHTHKa, HarrpaBJIeHHaH Ha pa3BHTHe 3KOHOMHKH,
rrOJIe3HOH HJIH Bpe,lJ;OHOCHoH.
TeMn
5,
27
6,
Moma 6bI 3aBepIIIHTbCfI B KOPOTKHit rrepHO,lJ,. Ho TaK KaK ueHbI He MOryT yrraCTb
JlerKO H 6bICTPO, 3KOHOMHCTbI ,lJ,OJDICHbI paJpa60TaTb aHTHpeueCCHOHHYIO rrOJIHTH
1936 ro.D.Y
imec
aHmHHCKHH 3KOHO
6 CO,lJ,epXHT orrHcaHHe
KeHHCHaHCKOH MO,lJ,eJlH 3KOHOMHKH, yqHThIBaIOw;eit roT paKT, qro ueHbI He MOryT 6bICTPO H
JlerKO CHH3HTbCfI ,lJ,JIfI roro, qT06bI rrOMOqb BbI6paTbCfI H3 peueCCHH. ITPHHHMWI BO BHHMaHHe
,lJ,aHHbIit paKT, MO,lJ,eJlb KeHHca CJIYXHT OTJlHtIHbIM crroc06oM rrpOHJlJlIOCTPHpOBaTb ,lJ,Ba paKTO
pa, Koropble M02ym rrOMOqb rrpeo,lJ,OJleTb crrll,ll,.
3bIBaeTCfI B maDe 7
./ MOHeTapHWI rrOJlHTHKa 3aKJIIOqaeTCfI B TOM, qro roCY,lJ,apCTBO yrrpaBJlfleT KO
JlHqeCTBOM ,lJ,eHer, qT06bI H3MeHHTb rrpoueHTHbIe CTaBKH H CTHMYJlHPOBaTb
3KOHOMHtIecKYIO ,lJ,eflTeJlbHOCTh. HarrpHMep, eCJlH rocy,lJ,apCTBO C03,lJ,aeT YCJlO
BIDI ,lJ,JIfi rr3,!J,eHIDI rrpoueHTHbIX CTaBOK, rrOyPe6HTeJlH JaHHMaIOT 60JIbilie ,lJ,eHer
,lJ,JIfI rrOKYrrKH TaKHX Bem:eH,KaK ,lJ,OMa H MaIIIHHbI, rr03TOMY rrpOHCXO,lJ,HT CTH
rrepBbIe HeCKOJlbKO ,lJ,eCHTHJIeTHH rrocJle rrOHBJleHIDI H,lJ,eH KeHHca Ka3aJIOCb, qTO OHH
XX BeKa OHH
JapeKOMeH,lJ,OBa
JlH ce6f1 He JIyqIIIHM 06paJOM, H CTaJlO HCHO, qro XOTH MOHeTapHWI H pHCKaJIbHWI rrOJlHTIIKH
flBJlflIOTCfI MOm:HbIMH HHCTPYMeHTaMH ,lJ,JIfI rrpeO,lJ,OJleHIDI 3KOHOMHqeCKoro crr3,!J,a, Y HHX Bce
)l(e eCTh CBOH orpaHH'IeHJJH.
ITo 3TOH rrpHtIHHe B maBe 7 06'bflCIDleTCfI, KaK H rroqeMY MOHeTapHWI H pHCKaJIb
HWI rrOJlHTHKH orpaHH'IeHbI B CooeH ~KTHBHOCTH. KJIIOqeBYIO POJlb 3,lJ,eCb Hrpa
eT KOHuerrUIDI pa14UOHOJIbHbIX QJlCuiJaHuii. COrJIaCHO 3TOit KOHuerrUHH, paUHOHaJIb
HO MbICJIfIW;He JlIO,lJ,H 3aqaCTYIO MeIDlIOT CBoe rrOBe,lJ,eHHe B OTBeT Ha H3MeHeHHe
rrOJlHTHKH rocy,lJ,apcTBa TaKHM crroc060M, KOTOPbIH orpaHHtIHBaeT 3PPeKTHBHOCTh
3THX H3MeHeHHit.
28
118CT1J I.
3KOHOMIfIIeCK8f1 r80plfll
.bu"ft03"OJt(J.,l(,U"a.~ ho8eqeJUte
qaCTH
III
3To JIOrH'lHO,
9 60JIee
qeCKHe pemeHHH, KaClUOIllHeCH TOro, KaK MaKCHMaJIbHO y.n;OBJIeTBOpHTb CBOH 3alIPOCbI HCXO,D;H
H3 orp~eHHbIX,D;OXO,D;OB. 3TH pemeHHH C03,D;3.IOT KPHBYJO cnpoca, KOTOpaH BJIHHeT Ha ueHbI
H KOJIH'leCTBO TOBapoB Ha pbIHKaX.
nOXO:JKHM 06pa30M .n;eitcTBYJOT H <pHPMbI, KOr,D;a npHHHMaIOT 3KOHOMH'leCKHe pemeHHH,
B pe3YJIbTaTe qero C03,D;aeTCH KPHBaH npeMO:JKeHHH, KOTOpaH BJIHHeT Ha pbIHKH. B rJIaDe
10
o6'bHcHHeTcH, KaK 3TO npOHCXO,D;HT H KaK <pHPMbI nOCTYJIaIOT,D;AA Toro, qT06bI MaKCHMaJIbHO
YBeJIH'IHTb CDOH npH6bIJIH. ECJIH BaM 3HaKOMbI HeJIeCTHhIe BbICKa3bIBaHHH 0 IqlIIHTaJIHCTHqe
CKOit CHCTeMe, 3Ta rJIaBa npe,D;OCTaDHT BaM B03MO:JKHOCTh BCTPeTHTbCH C yxaCHbIM qy.n;OBHilleM
JIHUOM K JIHUy.
.n;o Tex
nop, nOKa OHH .n;eitCTBYJOT B ycJIOBIDIX KOHKYPeHUHH. np~Ha 3TOro, eCJIH roBOpHTb KOpOT
KO, 3aKJIlOqaeTCH B TOM, qTO 3TH <pHpMbI, BbIlfYJIOJ;eHHbIe KOHKYPHpoBaTh, pemaIOT Cpa3y .n;Be
3a,D;aqH.
"
Bo-nepBbIX, OHH
3rjJrjJeKmU8HblMU npOU3800UmeJlJlMU -
3TO 3Ha
qHT, QTO OHH npOH3BO,D;HT 3TH TOBapbI H'YCJIYfH, 3aTPaTHB Ha 3TO MHHHMyM
cpe.n;CTB.
MaMa CMHTa -
H3BeCT
rnasa
11.
29
:no MOHonCMWI,
MhlWJIeHHOCTH CYllleCTB}'eT TOJIbKO o.o;Ha cPHpMa H y Hee B006~e HeT KOHKYPeH~H. KaK 06'&
RCIDIeTCJl B rJIaDe
12, MOHOnOJlHH
peryJIHpOBaHHJl HX nOBe.o;eHHJl.
BIlacm He
npe.o;npH
B TaKHX CHtya-
B rJIaDe 13 .o;eT.aJIbHOHCCJIe.o;Y!OTCR
KaK OHH HenpaBHJlbHO Be.o;yT ce6R, HO H 0 TOM, ':!:TO OHH 'l:aCTO nepeXCHBaIOT rpytlHhle BpeMe
Ha, BhlnOJIHAA 06JlJaTeJIbCTB8. no .o;OroBOpaM.o;pyr C .o;pyroM 0 coxpalieHHH BIaICOKHX ueH H Bbl
COKHX npH6hIJIe~.
:9TO
~.
Ii . ..
\1'
KOHKYPeHTHO~
.o;e~CTByeT 3PcPeK
BOLUIT K TOMY, 'ITO 3KOHOMHCTbi JII06JlT Ha3bIBaTb HeCOCmOJlmeJlbHOCmblO pblHKO. TaK HroblBaIOT
CHTyaUHH, KOr,ll,a B pe3YJIbTaTe .o;ejITeJIbHOCTH PblHKOB B03HHKalOT HeraTHBHlde nOCJIe,ll,CTBHJl
,ll,illl 06mecTBa B UeJ10M. )l,Ba ,ll,pyrHX pacnpocrpaHeHHblX CJlyqWl HeCOCTOJlTeJIbHOCTH pbIHKa
C,ll,eJIKH
):UUI
nOTeH~aJIbHO
30
'Isen I.
3ICOHOMIf"eCIC8J1 TeOplfJl...
./ 06U4eCm6eHHWe m06apW -
06e
3TH CHTYlUlHH -
06Cy}K,IJ;aIOTCJI B rJIaDe
15.
~ .3"OJU1.4l,H,cJ!ibt. I4CIlfM,63/fJOJ!i
.M091U.14 14 ZjlarpUleI4
9KOHOMHCThI JII015JIT JIOrHKY H TOtiHOCTh, n03TOMY OHH HCnOJIh3Y1QT aJIre6py H MaTeMa
THKY.
HarJIJl,IJ;HOM cTHJIe, n03TOMy OHH HCnOJIh3Y1QT TaKOe 6oJIbwoe KOJIH'leCTBO rpalPHIt.OB: l{1'06hJ.
nOMO'lh BaM CnpaBHThCJI co CTPaxOM nepe,IJ; rpa4>HKaMH, KOTOphle 6ym nepHO,IJ;HtleCKH B03
HHOTh HaCTPaHHUax 3TOA KHHrH, nOCBwfHM HeCKOJIhKO CTPaHHU 06'W1CHeHHIO 3THX "Jq)H
BhIX qy,IJ;OBHW:". HTaK, ,IJ;hlWHTe rny6)({e, HHtlero CTPaWHoro!
aT peanbHOCTM K a6CTpaK~MM
@j
IPa4>HKH Y 3KOHOMHCTOB -
YCJIYI',
4>aKTOphl, TaKHe KaK H3MeHeHHe cTHJIeA H BKYCOB, TO:>Ke OKa3h1BaIOT BJIHJlHHe Ha nOTPe6H
TeJIbCKHA cnpoc, HO CaMYJO BroKHYJO POJIb HrpaeT ueHa. ,l:(aBait're, K npHMepy, paJ6epeM
'IaA C aneJIbCHHOBbIM COKOM. UeHa aneJIbCHHoBOro COKa -
50 ,IJ;OJIJI.
CJIY
(11 He
4,54
1 ,IJ;OJIJI. 3ifaJIJIOH.
T.6nN",.
L~Ha 38
Pe3YJIbTaTbI
1:1. KonN'IeCTIO raMOHOI anenbCNHOBoro cOKa, KOTOpb!A XOTenM 6b! KYflMTb nOTpe6MTenM
1 r8MoH, AOJIn.
Kon"'IeCTBOrannOHOB
10
10
31
8etlU'tUHOU cnpoca, HJIH cnpocOM, no 3THM ueHaM. PaCCMaTPHBllH 1'36JI. 1.1, Mbl BH)I,HM,
ueHaM,
'ITO ueHa H BeJIH'IHHa cnpoca Ha aneJIbCHHOBhlH COK, npo,l(aBaeMhl:lt no TaKOH ueHe, CBR3ar
HbI
I~
llOCKOJIbKY 3Ta 06paTHllH CBR3b Me)l{)l,y ueHo:lt H BeJIH'lHHOH cnpoca YHHBepCaJIbHa H nO)l,TBepx,uaeTCR no'ITII )I,JUI Bcex TOBapOB H ycnyr, 3KOHOMHCThI Ha3hlBaIOT ee
\~ 3aICOHOM cnpoca.
Ha rpaPHKe. Ha pHC.
1.1
1.1, - 3m pa3MeCTHTb HX
B H C. fOPH30HTaJIbHllH OCb
npHBe)l,eHHhle B 1'36JI.
A-
1 fllJIJIOH
10 )l,OJIJl.
JIlO)I,j{M
10
9
1.1.
1 )l,OJIJl.
A
E
7
B
3 ----.----------------------- --
2
c
2
345
10
11
12
13
14
32
"Isc.,. I.
3KOHOMtf'leCKSfI TeOp"fI
COe,lJ;HHHM TO'lKH
A, B U C O,lJ;HOit
(8,
46,lJ;oJIJI.
3a faJIJIOH, 2,23 ,lJ;OJIJI. 3a raJIJIOH H T.n.), KOJI~eCTBO TO'leK Ha rpaqmKe Momo UbI 6bITb Ha
MHOfO 6oJIbIIIe. Ho nOCKOJIbKY OHH He C,lJ;eJIaJIH 3TOro, MbI rrpOBO,lJ;HM rrpHMYJO JIHHHIO. JIHHIDI
3Ta MO)l(eT COCJIyxrnTb XOPOIIIYlO CJIY)I(6y, nOMOfM Y3HaTb crrpoc Ha arreJIbCHHOBbIH COK rro
ueHaM, KOTopbIe 3KOHOMHCTbI rrpH ,lJ;aHHOM orrpoce He HMbIBaJIH.
IIpHMM JIHHHH, COe,lJ;HAAIOIUM TO'IKH Ha pHC.
rrpeKPac
HO nOHHMaIO, 'ITO Ha caMOM ,lJ;eJIe OHa HHKaKM He KpHBM, HO ,lJ;JIJI rrpOCTOTbI 3KOHOMHCTbI
HCrrOJIb3YIOT TepMHH ICpU60J1 cnpoca ,lJ;JIJI rrepe,lJ;a'lH Bcex OTMe'IeHHbIX CBH3eH Me)l(,lJ;y ueHoit H
BeJIH'IHHOH cnpoca, 6e30THOCHTeJIbHO TOro, rrpHMM HJIH KpHBM JIHHHH HX CBH.3bIBaeT. (3Ta
YCJIOBHOCTb He npOTHBOpe'lHT IaKTY, KOTOPbIit 3KOHOMHCTbI 06CY,lJ;HJIH H COmaCOBaJIH.)
B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT TOro, npHMM HJIH Iq)HBM JIHHHH Y rpalHKa, MbI HMeeM B03MO)I(HOCTb
1.1,
MO)I(HO orrpe.ueJIHTb, 'ITO rro ueHe 9,lJ;oJIJI. 3a raJIJIOH JIlO,lJ;H 3aXOTfl rrpH06pecTH Bcero JIHIIIb
2 faJIJIOHa arreJIbCHHoBOro COKa B MeCHU. Ha rpalHKe 3TO H306paxaeT To~a, 0603Ha'leHHM
6YKBOHR
1.1.
1.1,
H He
CHU XOTeJIH 6bI rrpH06pecTH JIIO,lJ;H, eCJIH ueHa arreJIbCHHoBOro COKa 6Y,lJ;eT COCTaBJIHTb 3,lJ;0JIJI.
3a faJIJIOH? B3fAAHYB Ha BTOpYIO H TPeTbIO CTPOKH Ta6JI.
1.1,
10 B MeCHU.
Ho
@j
IIocMQTPeB Ha pHC.
1.1,
F Ha
r~oHoB B MeCHU.
(,IVuI
HarJIH,lJ;HOCTH Ha rpalHKe
rrpom03Hp:?~Ha
HHM rrpOCToe 3a,lJ;aHHe, B KOTOpOM 6Y,lJ;eT Hf)I(HO rrpOCTaBHTb BCero JIHlllb HeCKOJIbKO TO'IeK H
HapHCOBaTb Me)l(,lJ;y HHMH JIHHHH.
33
HMeIOT 60JIee HH3KOe KpOBRHOe ,llaBJIeHHe, HX MeHhWe nopaxaIOT HHCyJIbTbl, y HHX BblWe
:lKH3HeHHaR aKTHBHOCTb -
BblWJIa Ha yJIHUbl H CHOBa HaqaJIa crrpawHBaTb JIIO,lleit 0 TOM, CKOJIbKO aneJIbCHHoBOro COKa
OHH renepb XOreJIH 6bl npH06peCTH exeMeCjJqHO no Ka:lK.lloit H3 TPex npHBe,lleHHblX B Ta6JI.
ueH:
10, 5 H 1 ,llOJIJI.
1.1
38 1 rannoH, AOnn.
KonMlf8CTlOrannOHOI
10
13
Bame 3a,llaHHe, eCJIH Bbl noxeJIaere ero BblnOJIHHTb, 6Y,lleT JaKJIIOQaTbCR B TOM, QT06bl no
CTaBHTb 3TH TPH TOqKH Ha pHC.
1.1.
1 faJIJIOH
B MecHl{ no ueHe
faJIJIOHa B MecHU.
De3YCJIOBHO, Mbl BH,llHM 06paTHyx> CBR3b Me)l{,lly ueHoit H BeJIIflIHHOit cnpoca, 03HaqaIO
myIO, qTO ,llaxe XOTR nOJIbJa .llJIR 3,ll0POBbR OT aneJIbCHHOBOfO COKa npHBO,llHT K TOMy, qTO
cnpoc Ha Hero paCTeT, JIIO,llH Bce ell.l,e OqeHb qy&CTBHTeJIbHbl K nOBblweHHIO ueH Ha aneJIb
CHHOBblit COK. DOJIee BblCOKHe ueHbl no-npe:lKHeMY 03HaqaIOT 60JIee HH3KHit cnpoc, H Hama
HOBaR KPHBaR crrpoca HaKJIOHeHa BHH3.
Bbl roroBbl K TOMy, 'IT06bl C,lleJIaTb ell.l,e O,llHO, nOCJIe,llHee, 3a,llaIlHe, nepe,ll reM KaK Bbl OT
npaBHTeCb B ,llaJIbHeitwee rryrewecTBHe no KHHfe? BOCnO)lb3yitTecb HOBOit KPHBOit cnpoca
.llJIR TOro, qT06bl y3HaTb, CKOJIbKO raJIJIOHOB B MeCRU JIIO,llH renepb C06HpaIOTCR nOKYIlaTb no
ueHe
7 ,llOJIJI.
H no ueHe
2 ,ll0JIJI.
1.2,
6y
,lleT TPY,llHO,' HO Hama HOBaR KPHBaR crrpoca JIenco CnpaBHTCR C 3TOit 3a,llaqeit.
34
'I8CT.
I.
3K(IOMff'l8CK8f1 T80pfffl
rJlasa 2
nMpO>KHOe MnM MOpO>KeHOe?
M3YlfeHMe nOTpe6MTenbCKOrO Bbl60pa
B ,91/i()14 ua88...
> MaKCMMaJlbHOe YAOBJIeTBOpeHMe nOTpe6HOCTeA
> OrpaHMyeHIo1R, YMeHbWalOl14lo1e Bbl60p
> MOAenMpOBaHMe npo~ecca Bbl60pa
> OrpaHMyeHI1R MOAenl1 nOTpe611TenbCKoro Bbl60pa
V~
3KOHOMHCThI TPanlT Maccy BpeMeHH Ha TO, qT06hI npOaHaJIH3HpOBaTh, KaK rpynnhI .I:(eJIaIOT
BhI6op, HO nOCKOJIbKY BhI60p rpynnhI 06~HO OqeHb nOXO:lK Ha BhI60p HH.I:(HBH.D:YYMa, B 3TOH.
rJIaBe pacCKa3hIBaeTCH HMeHHO 0 nOCJIe,I:(HeM.
ECJIH rOBOpHTh npocThIM H3hIKOM, TO Ooo,gCHeHHe npoQecca HH.I:(HBH.D:YaJIbHOrO BhI60pa
OCHOBaHO Ha
lleJIaIOT JIIO.I:(H, KaCaeTCg nOTPe6JIeHHH TOBapOB H yCJIYI'. Ho, 6e3YCJIoimo, B peaJIbHOH :lKH3HH
Ha BhI60p qaCTO BJIHHeT MaCCa .I:(pyrHX rpaKTOpoB, Cpe.D:H KOTOPbIX eCTh Oqem H OqeHb Ba:lKHble.
qacTo JIIO.a;H .a;OJI)l{HhI c.a;eJIaTh BhI60p, HMeIOIQHtl: .a;OJIroBpeMeHHhIe nOCJIe.a;CTBHH, HanpHMep,
Me)l(.lJ:y nOHCKOM paOOThI H npO.a;OJI)l{eHHeM yqe6hI HJIH, qTO HaMHOrO 60JIee CepLe3HO, Me)l{.I:(y
npo.a;QJI)I{eHHeM .I:(HIUIOMaTuqeCKHX OTHOWeHHtl: H o6'bHBJIeHHeM BOAHhI.
MhI nOCTOgHHO BhIHY:lK.D:eHhI BhI6HpaTh, nOCKOJIbKY HawH :lKeJIaHHH nO~H BCer.a;a npeBhI
WaIOT HawH B03MO:lKHOCTH. OrpaHuqeHHhIe peCypchI, HJIH
B pe3YJIbTare
nOCKOJIbKY eCJIH MhI CMoxeM noHifb, KaK JIIO.a;H CoaepWaJIH BhI60p B npOIIIJIOM, y Hac nog
BHTCg 1I03MO:lKHOCTh noHSlTb, KaK bHH 6yllYI' COBepWaTb CBOtl: BhI60p B 6Y.D:YIQeM.
nOHHMaHHe (H .a;aJKe npOrH03HpOBaHHe) 6y.D:YIQHX cxeM BhI60pa OqeHb B8:lKHO, nOCKOJIb
ICY rJIaBHhIe
(0 BBn
paCCKa3bIBaeTCH B rJIaBe
(BBn)
H COBOKYIIHhIH
4.)
.J].JIH TOro qTo6bI COCTaBHTb nporH03 Toro, KaK MepKa~THJIbHhIe HH)I,HBH.lI.YYMbI 6y)l,YT )l,e
JIaTb COOH BhI60p, 3KOHOMHCThI C03)l,aJIH MO)l,eJIb rrOBe)l,eHHH qeJIOBeKa, KOTOPaH rrpe)l,rrOJIaraeT
pauHOHaJIbHOCTb H cnoco6HOCTb "JIaBHpOBaTb" Cpe)l,H B03MO:lKHbIX BapHaHTOB. 3Ta MO)l,eJIb
rrpe)l,CTaB.IDIeT CoGOH TPexcTYIIe~aThIlirrpouecc.
1.
3. BhI6paTh upHam,
Kor)l,a HeT rrOJIHoro OlIHcaHHH rrOBe)l,eHHH qe;:ioBeKa B MOMeHT BhI6opa, 3Ta MO)l,eJIb o6bfi
HO n03BOJllleT C)I,eJIaTb TOqHbIe rrporH03hI. TeM He MeHee MHorne JIIO)I,H COMHeBalOTCH B 3TOM
06'bHCHeHHH rrOBe)l,eHHH qeJIOBeKa. CBOIO TOqKY 3pemrn: OHH apryMeHTHpylOT TPeMH pacrrpo
CTPaHeHHbIMH KOHTP-BonpocaMH
.,/ .n;eHCTBHTeJIbHO JIH JIIO)I,H )l,eliCTByroT B CBOHX HHTepecax? He PYKOBO)l,CTByIOT
CH JIH OHH qame TeM, qTO JIyqwe)I,JIH )l,pyrnx?
.,/ .n;eliCTBHTeJIbHO JIH JIIO)I,H BCer)l,a OCBe)l,OMJIeHbI 0 CBOHX B03MO:lKHOCTHX?
KaK
OHH CMOrYT C)I,eJIaTb paUHOHaJIbHhIli BhI60p Cpe)l,H TeX BeIIJ;eli, KOTOphIe OHH
HHKOma He rrOI{yIIaJIH paHbwe?
.,/ .n;eHCTBHTeJIbHO JIH JIIO)I,H COO60)l,Hbl B CBoeM BhI6ope? He orpaHJ1qeHhI JIH OHH
MOPaJIbHhIMH H COUHaJIbHhIMH CTaH)I,aPTaMH, a TIIlOKe HopMaMH JaKoHa?
Cne)I,yIDIIJ;He HeCKOJIbKO paJ)I,eJIOB 3Toli rJIaBbI nOCBHI.UeHhI 60JIee IIo)l,po6HOMy 06'bHCHe
HHIO TPex 3TarrOB MO)l,eJIH rroTPe6HTeJIbCKoro BhI60pa H OTBeTaM Ha BCe BhIWeH3JIOXeHHhIe
B03pIDKeHHH.
~b ~ JtaltCUJI,Q.,I,bROe
,'I906'.uJii80peJtUe ItOIiijteOROCIiieU
3KOHOMHCTaM HpaBHTCH )l,YMaTb 0 JIlOlUIX, KaK 0 CBo60)l,HhIX JIHqHOCTHX, 06JIa,ualOmHx
CBo60)l,Holi BOJIeH.
)l;JIH
B )l,BYX CJIOBax:
3ro rrpe)I,IIOJIO
:lKeHHe 03HaqaeT, qTO JIIO)I,8 )l,eJIaIOT BhI6op, PYKOBO)l,CTBYHCb MhICJIblO: C)I,eJIaeT HJIH He C)I,eJIaeT
3TOT BhI60p HX HaCTOJIbKO CqaCTJIHBhIMH, HaCKOJIbKO 3TO n03BOJIeHO B orrpe)l,eJIeHHhIX yCJIO
BHHX.
36
'IacTb
I. 3KOHOMH'IecKafl TeOpHfI.
nOlle3HocmblO.
KylO rrOJIe3HOCTb, TOr,lJ;a KaK BernH, KOTopbIe HpaBHTCH JIHillb OrqaCTH, 06JIa.AalOT
HH3KOH HJIH .n,axe 0TPHuaTeJIbHOH rrOJIe3HOCTbIO.
TIpHHUHrr rrOJIe3HOCTH OqeHb o6'beMeH.
,lLJuI
IllKOJIe
[IV
me. -
llpUMe'l. nep.)
BeK ,lJ;0 H.3.]; ueJIbIO XH3HH H BbICillHM 6JIaroM re,lJ;OHH3M npH3HaeT HaCJIroK,!J;e
HO)J;JIH HpaBCTBeHHo pa3BHTOH JIHqHOCTH nOJIe3HOCTh MoxeT 6bITh qeM
,lLJuI
MumepUHClwe
37
1776 ro.ny:
"MhI
MoxeM paCCqHThIBaTb Ha 06e,n He nOTOMY, qTO MHCHHK, nHBOBap HJIH neKapb XOpOlliO K HaM
OTHOCHTCH, a nOTOMY, qTQ OHH npH 3TOM npeCJIe,nyroT C06CTBeHHhIe HHTepeChI"
MHCHHK, llHBOBap H neKapb He roTOBHT BaM npo.nyKThI noTOMY, qTQ BhI HM HpaBH
TeCb, a nOTOMy, qTQ HM uyxHhI BaIIIH ,neHbrH. O,LJ;HaKO, nOCKOJIbKy HM HYXHhI BalliH
,neHbrH, OHM TPy,LJ;HTCH HM TeM, ~hI npOH3BeCTH MH RaC Bce, qTQ HYXHO MH XO
pOlliero 06e,na. Kor,na BhI 06MeHHBaeTe HX TOBaphI Ha CBOH ,neHbrH, KroK,LJ;hIH H3 Bac
CqaCTJIHB. BhI .nyMaere, qTQ OTCyrcTBHe He06xo,lUfMoCTH roTOBHTh BCe 3TH npo.nyKThI
yqIIIe, qeM ,nepxaTb ,neHbrH npH ce6e.
A OHM .nyMaIOT,
qTQ
nOJIyqeHHe ~ ,neHer
OHH
n03TOMY 06lUeCTBO ,nOJI)l(HO pelliHTb, CKOJIbKO HelPTH n01paTHTb Ha06e 3TH xopOlliHe ueJIH,
OC03HaBaH, 'ITO Ka)I{,D;bIH raJIJIOH HelPTH, n01paqeHHhIH Ha o,nuy H3 HHX, He CMoxeT 6hITh no
TPaqeH Ha ,LJ;pyryIO.
3TOT pa3,neJI B 06IUHX qePTax onHChIBaeT pa3Hhle orpaHHqeHHH, TaK xe KaK HeH36ex
HbIe H3,LJ;ep:lKKll -
cmOUMocmb 603MQJlCHOCmU -
38
8. ,
OrpaHM~eHHOCTbpeCYPCOB
CaMbIe O'leBH,lJ.HbIe OrpaHH'IeHIDI, OKa3bIBalOIUHe BJIIDIHHe Ha YJJ:OBJIeTBOpeHHe rroTPe6
HocreD '1eJIOBeKa, -
,llIDl: KaJK,J:J;Oro H3 Hac, 'IT06bI norryqHTb TaK MHOro, KaK eMy XO'leTCH.
OrpaHH'IeHHble 3arraCbI npHpOJJ:HbIX peCYPCOB pacrrpeJJ:eAAlOTCH no-pa3HOMy. B HeKOTOpbIX
CJIY'laHX,
JJ:JIH MaKCHMH3aIIHH
co6CTBeHHoro C'IaCThH.
TeXHonorM~eCKMeOrpaHM~eHMR
HeJIb3H CKa3aTb, 'ITO Ha cerOJJ:HHWHHD JJ:eHb CTaJIO 60JIbWe 3arraCOB HelPrn HJIH COJIHe'I
HOro CBeTa, HJIH JIeCOMaTepHaJIOB, 'IeM HX 6b1.llo
HaMHoro 60JIee BbICOKHD ypOBeHb :JKH3HH, qeM y HaWHX npeJJ:KOB. Bce MbI :JKHBeM B 60JIee
KOM<P0PTHbIX YCJIOBHHX nOTOMy, 'ITO npoH30lIIJIO COBepWeHCTBOBaHHe TeXHOJIomD rrpe06pa
30BaHIDI CbIPbH B Te BelIIH, KOTOPbIMH HaM HpaBHTCH nOJIb30BaTbCH.
TOJIbKO 3a nOCJIeJJ:HHe
200
JIyHY,
KOpMHTb HaMHoro 60JIbWe JIlOJJ:eD. TOJIbKO 3a nOCJIeJJ:HHe JJ:Ba.!lUaTh JIeT HHTepHeT H JJ:emeBaH
M06HJIbHaH CBH3b rrpOH3BeJIH peBOJIlOUHlO BO BceM, Ha'lHHaH C pa3BJIe'leHHD H 3aKaH'lHBaH
reM, KaK rrpaBHTeJIbCTBO 06IUaeTCH CO CBOHMH rpIDK,ll;aHaMH.
ITOCKOJIbKY C re'leHHeM BpeMeHH TeXHOJIOrIDI COBepWeHCTByeTCH, JIlOJJ:H MOryT
npo
K C'IaCTblO,
39
OrpaHM~eHHOCTbBpeMeHM
BpeMH -
,lJ;paroueHHhlA: pecypc. X}')Ke Bcero TO, 'ITO BpeMR HeJIb3H pacTHHyrb. ll03TOMY
JIy'lwee, 'ITO TeXHOJIOI'IDI MO:lKeT C,lJ;eJIaTb ,lJ;JIH JIIO,lJ;eA:, 3TO npe,lJ;OCTaBHTh B03MO:lKHOCTb npo
H3BO,lJ;HTh 60JIbwe 3a TO BpeMR, KOTOpoe HaM OTnyWeHO, HJIH rapaHTHpOBaTb HaM HeCKOJIbKO
,lJ;OnOJIHHTeJIbHbIX JIeT :lKH3HH, npe,lJ;OCTaBJIeHHbIX 60JIee COBpeMeHHbIMH Me,lJ;HUHHCKHMH Tex
HOJIOI'IDIMH.
Ho ,lJ;a:lKe HMeH B 3anace 60JIee MHHHbI~ :lKH3HeHflbIA: OTpe30K; BbI He MO:lKeTe 6bITh B ,lJ;Byx
MecTaX O,lJ;HOBpeMeHHO. ECJIH 6hl BbI MOfJIH C,lJ;eJIaTh no, BpeMR He 6b1JIO 6bI TaKHM Cepbe3HbIM
orpaHH'leHHeM, nOCKOJIbKY 3a O,lJ;HH H TOT :lKe npoMe:lKyrOK BpeMeHH Bhl MOfJIH 6bI BbInOJIHHTh
,lJ;BOHHOR 06beM pa6oTbI. Ho rrOCKOJIbKY BbI He MO:lKeTe HaxO,lJ;HTbCH B ,lJ;BYX MecTax O,lJ;HOBpe
MeHHO, BbI nOCTOHHHO ,lJ;OJI:lKHbI BbI6HpaTh, 'ITO,lJ;JIH Bac JIy'lwe.
.H
CTOH
B03MO~OCTH
'
aJIbTepHaTHBhl HJIH
3000.
CTOHMOCTh B03MO:lKHOCTH
rrpOCTO ueHa CJIe,D;yIOIUero, 60JIee Y,lJ;aqHOrO BbI60pa, rrOCKOJIbKY BbI MO:lKere BCer,lJ;a CBeCTH
CJIO:lKHhlA: BhI60p H3 MHOfHX BapHaHTOB K rrpocTOMY BbI60PY O,lJ;HOro BapHaHTa H3,lJ;BYX: BapH
He
H36e:lKHoe orpaHH'leHHe B nOBe,lJ;eHHH, nOCKOJIbKY BbI BCer,lJ;a ,lJ;OJI:lKHbl peWHTh, 'ITO JIY'lwe, H
OTKa3aTbCH OT CJIe,D;yIOIUHX JIY'lWHX aJIbrepHaTHB.
40
IIscrb
I.
3KOHOMKileCKSfI reOpKfI...
3TO 06bI'iHbIH
CaHHH peIIIeHHil: THIIa "Bee HJIH H~ero", no,n06HO peIIIeHHIO "eCTb HJIH He eCTb MopoxeHoe".
B 60JIee CJIOxmOM aHaJIH3e CTOHtdOCTH H nOJIe3HOCTH HCnOJIb3yeTcH npHHUHn, HaJbIBae
MbIH npeiJe.JlbHou nO/le3HOCmblO, C nOMOIUbIO KOTOporo BbI Moxere Y3HaTb He TOJIbKO 0 TOM,
C06HpaIOCb JIH H eCTb MopoxeHoe, HO TaIOKe H TO, CKOAblW MopoxeHoro H peIIIY. C'beCTb.
Ii eCJIH
13-H KYCOqe~nHIUJ,bI
aa
~~
ArrH TOro qT06bI YBH,neTb, KaK JIIO,nH npHHHMaKlT peilieHIDI 0 TOM, CKOJIbKO H q_ero
OHH XOTHT npHo6pecTH, npe,nnOJIO)I{HM, qTO eCTb
10 ,n0JIJI.,
2 ,n0JIJI.
2 ,nOM.
10 ,nO'JTJI.
H He nQTPaqy
ECJIH H KYUJIIO
Ii
2 ,nOM.,
qT06b1
41
B caMOM ):(eJIe,
eCJIH npe
10 ):(OJIJI.
A TOT,
10 ):(OJIJI.
Ha nHUU;Y.
A):(JIH JIIO):(eH,
KOTOpbIe BbI6epYT ~O-TO eme, OTITHMaJIbHOe KOJIHqeCTBO KaJK,lJ.oro npo):(yKfa 6y):(eT 3aBHCeTb
OT HX HH):(HBH):(YaJIbHOrO OTHOIIIeHHH K KaJK,lJ.OMY H3 ):(Byx npO):(yKfOB H TOro, HaCKOJIbKO 6bI
CTPO 6y):(eT YMeHbIIIaTbCH HX npe):(eJIbHaH nOJIe3HOCTb.
HHIPOpMaUHH
B maDe 9 HaxO,II,HTCH
60JIee nO):(p06HaH
B CJIe):(YJOIUeM
42
06
3TOM nO):(p06Hee.
nr"I.1'"
nOA06Hoe nOBeAeHHe.
li1
phIe HM H)')KHO rrpHlUITh, H OHH He Bcer)),a pauHOHaJIbHbI HJIH JIOrHtIHhI, KaK rrpe)),nOJIaraIOT
3KOHOMHCTbl.
3TY
B )),eACTBHTeJIbHOCTH
Pa~MOHanbHoe B Mppa~MOHanbHOM
)laxe Kor)),a JIIOJJ.H nOJIHOCThIO HHlPoPMHpOBaHbI 0 B03MO)I(HhIX BapHaHTaX, OHH qaCTO ')),e
JIaIOT JIOrHtJeCKHe oWH6KH rrpH oueHKe CTOHMOCTH (3aTPaT) H nOJIe3HOCTH (BhIro)),bI).
CJIe
43
CJIHiliKOM 6eCnOKOHTeCb. IToCJIe TOro KaK JIIOMM 06'bJlCHJlT 3TH JIOrJflIeCKHe OIIIH6KH, OHH
06bIqHO npeIq>amaIOT HX )J;eJIaTb H HaqHHaIOT )J;eJIaTl> BbI6op, Coo6pa3yJlcb C paUHOHaJIbHO
B3BeIIIeHHbIMH npe)J;eJIbHOH BbIrO)J;OH H npe)J;eJIbHbIMJ{ H3)J;ep:xacaMH.
15
TOp~?
'
,lJ,JIH 3KOHOMHCTa OTBeT Ha nepBbIH BOnpOC 6y)J;eT TaKHM: BbI C'be)J;HTe pOBHO CTOJIbKO,
6Y)J;eT BbIrJIH)J;eTb CJIe)J;YIOIUHM 06Pa30M: CKOJIbKO UbI 3anJIaTHJIH 3a TO, QT06bI nOnaCTb B 3TOT
pecTOpaH, POJIH He HrpaeT, noTOMY qro C1>e)J;HTe BbI
1 KYcOqeK
CyiliH HJIH
80 KYCOqKOB
CyUIH,
'ITO He )J;OJDK
BapH~B.
qyacTBYeTe ce6H 06H3aHHbIM C1>eCTb OrpoMHoe KOJI~eCTBO CYIIIH, qT06bI OnpaB)J;aTb nOTPa
qeHHbIe
15 )J;OJIJI.?
oesyCJIOBHO, HeT.
BJIHHTb Ha npHHHTHe peIIIeHHH,)J;o Tex nop, nOKa 3KOHOMHCT He 06'bHCHHT HM, qro HeB03
BpaTHMbIe H3)J;ep:lKKH K )J;eJIy He OTHOCHTCH, HJIH, KaK He YCTaIOT nOBTopHTb 3KOHOMHCTbI:
"HeB03BpaTHMbIe H3)J;ep:lKKH HeB03BpaTHMbI!" (C )J;pyrOH CTOpOHbI, He3KOHOMHCTbI 6bICTPO ~
yCTaIOT OT 3TOH lj.lPa3bI.)
COBepIIIHB
90 )J;OJIJI.,
100. Tor)J;a
2000 )J;OJIJI.
1990 )J;OJIJI.
B )J;pyroM ropo
0,5%,
BaM KaxeTCH,
2000 )J;OJIJI.
B 6JIH:lKaHilieM Mara3HHe.
JIOrJflIHO H HppaUHOHaJIbHO. B nepBOM cnyqae BbI 3axOTeJIH BeCTH MaIIIHHy B TeqeHHe O)J;HOro
qaca MH TOro, 'IT06bI C3KOHOMHTb
44
10 )J;OJIJI.
Bo BTOpOM -
IIscn. I.
SKOHOMM.,eCKSfI reOPK
ttl
30
MJIH. ,a:0JIJI.
10 MJIH.
Ha O,a:HH MOCT.
36
12
MOCTa.
BCKOpe rrOCJIe 3Toro KaKOU-TO rrOJIHTHqeCKHH ,a:e~ITeJIb BbICTYIIaeT C rrpeMO)ICeHHeM rro
CTPOHTb qeTBepThIH MOCT, apryMeHTHpyH 3TO TeM, qTO rrOCKOJIbKY MOCT B cpe,a:HeM CTOHT
10 MJIH.
12
O,a:HH. )l;OJI)KHbI JIH BbI eMy BepHTb? B KOHeqHOM HTOre, ecJIH KIDIQlbrn MOCT rrpHH;OCHT 06I1.1,eCT
By
2 MJIH.
~r
(~
npeOeJlbHQJl CTOH
npeOe.tibHQJl rrOJIe3HOCTh, a He CTOHMOCTh H rrOJIe3HOCTh, B3HTbIe CpeOHeM
KaKYIO
BbIro,a:y
rrpHHeCJIH Bce rrpe,a:bI.lJ:YI1.I,He MOCTbI? BaM H;y)KH0 CpaBHHTh CTOHMOCTb 3TOro ,a:o
rrOJIHHTeJIbHOrO, rrOCJIe,a:Hero MocTa, C rrOJIe3HOCTbIO 3TOro ,a:orrOJIHHTeJIbHoro, rro
CJIe,a:Hero MOCTa. ECJIH rrpe,a:eJIbHaH rrOJIe3HOCTh rrpeBhIIIIaeT rrpe,a:eJIbHbIe H3,a:ep)IC
KH, MOCT cTPOHTb HYXHo. B rrpoTHBHOM cnyqae CTPOHTb MOCT He CJIe.a:yeT.
TIpe.a:rrOJIO)ICHM, K rrpHMepy, qTO He3aBHCHMaH rpyrrrra Ha6JIIO,a:aTeJIeU HaHMa HH)KeHepa,
KOTOPbIU ,a:OJI)KeH paCCqHTaTb CTOHMOCTb rrOCTPOHKH eI1.l,e O,a:HOro MOCTa, H 3KOHOMHCTa, KO
TOPbIH ,a:OJI)KeH BhICqHTaTb Bblro,a:y OT 3TOro CTPOHTeJIbCTBa. HH)KeHep C006I1.1,HT, qTO qepe3
peKY ~e rrOCTPoeHO TPH MOCTa, rrpH'leM HX rrOCTPOHJIH B caMbIX HeIIIHpoKHX MecTax. 3HaqHT,
qeTBepTbIH MOCT ,a:OJI)KeH 6bITb MHHHee TPex rrpe,a:bI.lJ:YI1.I,HX. <l>aKTH'leCKH CTPOHTeJIbCTBO HO
BOro MOCTa 6y,a:eT CTOHTb
15 MJIH.
,a:OJIJI.
MJIH.
,a:OJIJI. rrpH6bIJIH B ro,a:. Cn:e,a:oBaTeJIbHO, 3TOT qeTBepTbIH MOCT He ~O CTpOHTb, rrOTOMY 'ITO
ero rrpe,a:eJIbHaH CTOHMOCTh B
15 MJIH. ,a:OJIJI.
8 MJIH.
45
rllasa 3
nOTpeOHOCTI1 mOAeiil
~.
-7
Y nOTPe6HTeJIe1t
2).
Y BpatIe1t
YCJIYI'H,
npo
uecce HX HCnOJIb30BaHIDI.
1.
npe,ll,DOJIOmrreJlhHO, KOMOHH8
T.e., KaK 06meCTBO Onpe)l;eJIHeT, 'ITO MO)J(HO npOH3BeCrn H qTO JIyqIlIe Bee
OJt/te'1I!...Ul&U,
ltJhO .,I/,O.JltJtO
h/t0U3d~CJhIt
IIpH onpe)J;eJIe!iHH TOro, KaKHe HMeHHO npo)J;}'KTbI MOryT 6b1Tb npOH3Be)l;eHhI, 3KOHOMH
CThI yqHThIBaIOT )J;Ba rJIaBHhIX <l>aKTOpa, BJIHHIOmHe KaK Ha MaKCHMaJIhHblit 06'heM, TaK H Ha
,/
OrpaHHtIeHHOCTh peCypCOB;
,/ YMeHhIIIeHHe OT)J;aqH.
TOBapa, TeM 60JIhIIIe 3aTPaT nOTPe6yeT npOH3BO)J;CTBO e,ll;HHHUbl TOBapa. XOTH nep
Bble HeCKOJIhKO napTHH TOBapa MOryT 6b1Th npOH3Be)J;eHhI npH HH3KHX 3aTPaTax,
nOCJIe)l;yIOmHe naprnH 6y)J;yT CTOHTh Bee 60JIhIIIe H 6oJIhwe. Co BpeMeHeM 3aTPaThI
Ha npOH3BO)l;CTBO npeBhICHT )J;OXO)J;bI, a 3TO CTaHeT npH'lHHOH orpaH~eHHH KOJIH
qeCTBa TOBapa, KOTOPhIH BhI XOTHTe npOH3Becrn, )J;a)I(e eCJIH 3TO BaIII JII06HMhIH TO
Bap. BaIIIH pecypcbI ,n;OJI)J(HhI 6hITh HCnOJIh30BaHhI,lI.JUI npOH3BO)J;CTBa,n;pyrnx TOBa
poB, Bhlro)J;bI OT KOTOphIX Bce eme 6y)J;yT npeBhIWaTh 3aTPaThI Ha HX npOH3BO)J;CTBO.
fJIaBHhIil: pe3YJIhTaT B03)J;eitCTBHH <l>aKTOpa YMeHhweHHH OT)J;aqH COCTOHT B TOM, 'ITO 06me
CTBa 06hI'1HO ~TaHOBHTCH 6oratIe, eCJIH OHH HCnOJIb3YIOT HMeIOIUHeCH orpaHHtIeHHble pecypChI
MH Bblpa60TKH YMepeHHOro KOJIHqeCTBa Pa3HhIX TOBapOB, BMecTO TOro 'IT06hI npoH3BO)J;HTh
orpOMHoe
KOJI~eCTBO O)J;HOro
TOBapa.
tIa onpe,n;eJIHIOT npoH3Bo,n;CTBeHHhIe B03MO)J{HOCrn. 113 Hero MhI CMO)l(eM y:JHaTh, KaK npe,n;C'ra
BHTh 3TH B03MO)J(HOCTH rpa<l>~ecKHM cnoc060M.
KnaCCM~MKaI.4MSInpOM3BOACTBeHHblX pecypcoB
IIPO)J;yKUHIO HeJIb3H npoH3Becrn 6e3 BJIO)l(eHHH pecypCOB. 3KOHOMHCThI TPa)l;HIJ;HOHHO )J;e
JIHT BJIO)l(eHHble peCYPCbl, HJIH
,/ 3eMeJJI>Hlile
pecypCW::
48
'1scr"
t,
3KOHOMH'IeCKSfI reapHfI...
./ TpY,lI.OBWe pecypcw:
rrOCTPOHKH, KOTO
yc.rryr,
yc.rryr.
MeHT HYJKHO ,D;YMaTb 06 ypOBHe qenOBeqeCKoro KarrHTaJIa B 0611IeCTBe KaK 0 BeJI~HHe cPHKCH
pOBaHHoH. B COqeTaHHH C orpaHHqeHHbIM KOJIHqeCTBOM 3eMeJIbHbIX H TPY,lI.OBbIX peCYPCOB H
KarrHTaJIa orpaHH'IeHHOCTb qeJIOBeqeCKoro KaIIHTaJIa 03HaqaeT, 'ITO 0611IecTBO crroc06Ho rrpo
H3BeCTH orpaHHqeHHoe KOJI~eCTBO TOBapa.
o TOM, KaK JIy'Illie pacrrpe.n;eJIHTb 3TH
If
orpaH~eHHbIe pecypCbI,
6bITb HCrrOJIb30BaHbI ,lI.JUI rrpOH3Bo.n;CTBa TOBapOB H YeJIYr, KOTOpbIe rrpHHecyT caMoe 6oJIbllIOe
y.n;OBJIeTBopeHHe rrOTpe6HOCTeH. (EoJIee rro.n;p06HO 06 orpaH~eHHbIXpecypcax H rrpoH3BO.n;CT
BeHHbIX B03MOJKHOCTSIX paccKa3bIBaeTCll .n;3JIbllIe B rro.n;pa3.n;eJIe "HeMHOJKKO 3.n;eCb, HeMHOJKKO
TaM: pacrrpe.n;eJIeHHe pecypCOB").
,lI.JUI TOqHOro orrpe.n;eJIeHHll, 'ITO HMeHHO HYJKHO rrpOH3BO.n;HTb H30 BCeX TeX BemeH,
KOTopbIe MOJYT 6bITb rrpOH3Be.n;eHhI H3 HMeIOIlIHXCll orpaHH'IeHHbIX pecypcOB. OH
orrHpaeTCll Ha TOT cPaKT, 'ITO npaKTH'IeCKH,lI.JUI Bcero, 'ITO rrpOH3Bo.n;HTCH JIIO,D;bMH,
KO~~eCTBO
49
B TeqeHHe nepBO
ro qaCa pa60ThI 6y.ueT C06paHO MHOlKeCTBO H6JIOK, nOCKOJIbKY MhI 6y.ueM C06HpaTb
HH3KO BHCHmHe llJIO.uhI, KOTOphIe JIerKO .uOCTaTb.
B TeqeHHe
B TeqeHHe
TPeTbero qaca
pa60ThI 6y.ueT co6paHO eme MeHbIIIe H6JIOK; Tenepb npHXo.uHTCH KaJlmhIA Pa3 no.u
nphIrHBaTb,UJIH Toro, ~06hI JlOTHHYTbCH .uo H6JIOKa, nOTOMY qTO OCTaBIIIHeCH Ha
.uepeBbHX H6JIOKH BHCHT OqeHb BhICOKO. TaM.
CH npOH3Bo.uHTeJIbHOCTb -
3.1 .ueMOHCTPHPyeT,
KaK YMeHbIIIaeT
C KaJlmhIM
C06PIHHbl8
R6noKM, WTyK
1-~
300
2 LleHTB
2-~
200
3 LleHT8
3-~
120
5 LleHTOB
,L(pyroA cnoco6 ,UJIH TOro, qT06hI YBH.ueTb 3<P<PeJcr YMeHbIIIeHIDI OTJlaqH, - 3m onpe.ueJlHTb
YBeJI~eHHe 3aTPaT Ha npOH3BOJlCTBO e.uHHHUhI TOBapa. ECJIH pa60QHM llJIaTHT no 6 .uOJIJI. 3a
Kax,UhIA qac pa60ThI Ha c60pe ypOxaH H6JIOK, paCXO}lhI Ha nonyqeHHe
qac pa60ThI COCTaBHT
6paHo TOJIbKO
200
2 ueHTa
3.1.
300 HMOK B
nepBhIA
npo.uOJDKalOT nonyqaTb
6 JlOJIJI.
3a qac pa6oThI).
HMOKO.
B KOHeqHOM
.:If.MIf~
)lJIH TOro ~06hI nOHHTb, nOQeMY 3TO npoHCXOJlHT, npe.uCTaBbTeCe6e, qTO MhI MO
...
l . ' xeM pacnpe.ueJIHTb pa60qHX KaK Ha c60p H6mJK, Tate H Ha c60p aneJIbCHHOB. MhI
1 JlOJIJI.,
50
'1'CT.
I.
3ICOHOMH'IeCIC TeOpH....
leaK
IIJIaTjlT OLJ;HHaKOBO, BHe 3aBHCHMOCTH OT roro, KaKOit cPPYKT OH c06HpaeT, TPYLJ; :noro pa60qe
ro BbIroLJ;Hee HCnOJIb30BaTb LJ;JIj{ coopa jl6JIOK, nOCKOJIbKY OLJ;HO jl6JIOKO npOLJ;aeTCjI nO TOR xe
u;eHe, 'ITO H O,nHH aneJIbCHH.
MOXHO nepeBeCTH Ha c60p jl6JIOK BropOro pa60qero, a, B03MOXHO, H TPeTbero HlIH qeT
aepTOro. Ho nOCKOJIbKY 3cPcPeKT YMeHbWeHHjI OT.n;aqH npOjlBJIjleTCjI npH c60pe jl6JIOK TOqHO
TaK xe, KaK 3TO npoHcxo.nHJIO C aneJIbCHHaMH, HeBbIro,nHo nepeBeCTH Ha c60p jl6JIOK Bcex
pa60qHX. Kax.nbIit ,nonOJIHHTeJIbHbIit paoo'IHit, nOCTaBJIeHHbIit Ha coop jl6JIOK, c06epeT MeHb
we, HeXeJIH npe,nbILJ;yIUHit pa60qHit, C06HpaIOI1lHit jl6JIOKH. B onpe.neJIeHHbIit MOMeHT nepe
MeIUeHHe .nonOJIHHTeJIbHblX paooqHX C yqacTKa c60pa 3neJIbCHH Ha c60p H6JIOK 60JIbWe He
6y.neT BbIro,nHblM. By,neT ,nOCTHrHYTO COCTOjlHHe, KOTOpoe 3KOHOMHCTbl Ha3bIBaIOT OnmUMQ.llb
HbIM pacnpeiJeAeHUeM TPy,nOBblX peCYPCOB. KaK roJIbKO MbI onpe,neJIHM 3TY e.nHHCTBeHHYID TOq
KY, HaM He HYXHO 60JIbIIIe HarrpaBJUlTb pa60'lHX; C0611p8IOIUHX O,nHH BH.n cPpylcrOB, Ha .npyroit
yqacToK paooTbl, nOTOMy'ITo HHKaKHe ,nonOJIHHTeJIbHbIe nepeCTaHOBKH He yBeJIH'laT 06w:ee
KOJIH'leCTBO c06paHHblX <PPYKTOB. B 3roit roqKe MbI MaKcHMH3HpOBaJIH CBOit nOTeHIJ;HaJI npH
c60pe cPPYKTOB.
Y 3KOHOMHCTOB
3.1
B Ta6JI. 3.2
3.2.
CjI, eCJIH no-,npyroMy pacnpe,neJIHTb fij{Tb HMeIOI1lHXCjI paoo'lHX LJ;JIj{ c60pa jl6JIOK HlIH aneJIb
CHHOB. HanpHMep, eCJIH nOCTaBHTb BCex ~PhIX pa60qHX c06l1paTb jl6JIOKH B TeqeHHe u;e
JIoro ,nMjl, Tc) B pe3YJIbTaTe nOJIY'lHM
700
jl6JIOK H
paooqero Ha arreJIbCHHbI (ror.n;a qeTBepo paooqHX 6yllYf c06HpaTb jl6JIOKH, a O.nHH RbI), 6y.neT c06paHo
arreJIbCH
20 IIITYK.
300,
800
600
500
'"
.ao" 400
c;
300
200
100
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
AnenbCHHbI
P~c.
3. 1.
B03MO)/(HOcrej;i (nnB)
1
Pa6o~He,
co6HpalOlllHe anenbCHHbI
Pa6o~He,
co6HpalOlllHe R6noKH
KonH~ecTBo
co6paHHblx aneJlbCHHOB
300
500
620
680
700
KOJlH~eCTBo
co6paHHblx R6JlOK
700
6.80
620
500
300
Ha pHC.
3.1
me: pacnpe)leJIeHIDl pa60qHX, fKB3BHHbIX B Ta6JI. 3.2; TaKHM ofiPB30M rpalPHK C03)laH C HCrrOJIb
30BaHHeM BCex rrpoH3BO)lCTBeHHbIX B03MOJKHOCTejt. ToqKa A COOTBeTCTByeT CHTYaI.J;HH, KOf)la
BCeX pa60qHe C06HPaIOT HMOKH. ToqKa B COOTHOCHTCH C reM, KaKOe KOJIH'leCTBO IIJIO)lOB CO
6epYT qeTbIpe pa60qHX, C06HpaIOmHX H6JIOKH, H OJlHH, C06HpaIOIUHH arreJIbCHHbl, H T.)l.
3aMeTbre, qTO KroK)laH H3 meCTH TOqeK
oocmU3ICUMa -
mee KOJIH'IeCTBO KroK)lOfO BH)la lPPYKTOB )lejtCTBHTeJIbHO MOJKHO rrO~HTb C rrOMOmbIO HeKO
TOPOro rrepeMemeHIDl IIHTH pa60qHX.
C He)lOCTIDKHMa.
52
I.
3KOHOM....eCKSfI TeOp"f1
'1SCTIt
MbI 6hI CMOmH rroJIY'lHTh B pe3YJIhTare TaKOe KOJIHqeCTBO C06paHHbIX l!>PYKTOB, HO Be,nh MhI
OrpaHHqeHbI JIHIIIh IUl'ThIO pa60qHMH.
npe,nCTaBhTe, 'ITO BMeCTO pacrrpe,neJIeHIDI KOJIH'leCTBa paoo~HX MhI pacrrpe,neJUleM pa60
'lee BpeMH. nHTh pa60qHX 6y,neT pa60TaTh B TeqeHHe O,nHOro
HHH HMeeTCH
@j
(IIIIB),
nnB ,neMOHCTPnpyeT
KI>YTH3Ha rro Mepe ,nBH:lKeHIDI B,nOJIh KPHBOH rrOKa3bIBaeT, 'ITO COOTHOIIIeHHe BbIro,n H 3aTPaT
npH c60pe HMOK H arreJIhCHHOB 6y,neT 3aBHCeTh OT TOro, C KaKOH TOqKH HaqHlIaeTCH ,nBH:lKe
HHe. ECJIH MhI HaxO,nHMCH B TOqKe
A,
IUhIO rrepeCTaHOBKH TPy,nOBbIX pecypCOB MO:JKHO c06paTh MHOro arreJIhCHHOB, He,n06paB JlHilih
HeCKOJIhKO H6JIOK. Ho eCJIH HaqHHaTh B TOqKe
D,
arreJIhCHHOB, Tor,na rrpH,neTCH OTKa3aThCH OT 60JIhillOro KOJIHqeCTBa H6JIOK, )J;JUI Toro qT06bI
rrOJIyqHTh eme HeMHoro arreJIhCHHOB.
Ha 3KOHOMH'leCKOM :lKaproHe H3MeHHIOIIlHHcH HaKJIOH
2,
1 ,nOJIJI.
3a IIITyKy.
maH Ha KPHBOH
B,
TO e,nHHCTBeHHhIH crroc06
rnSBS
3. B",nYCK npaB~nbHO
B",6pSHH",X TOBSpOB
53
E Ha pHc.3.!,
qTQ
arreJIbCHHOB.
CJIyqae HCrrOJIbJYeTCR TPY,lI, JIHlIIb ,lI,BYX H3 BalIIHX IUITH pa60qHX; TPY,lI, OCTaBIIIHXCR TPOHX pa
60qHX 6Y,lI,eT rroTPaqeH BrryCTYJO HJIH He 6Y,lI,eT HCrrOJIbJOBaH B006me.
B peaJIbHOM MHpe MbI MOlKeM ,lI,OCT~b TOqKH, rro,ll,06HoH
E,
H3BO,ll,CTBa HJIH IIJIoxoro MeHe,lOKMeHTa. no o,ll,Hoii. H3 3THX ,lI,Byx np~HH rrpH HMeIOIIJ,HXCR pe
cypcax He 6Y,lI,eT rrpOH3Be,ll,eHO TaKoe KOJI~eCTBO TOBapa, KaKoe Morno 6b1 6b1Tb.
Kax.zlblH MeHe,lOKep, KOTOPblH ,lI,OJDKeH pacrrpe,ll,eJIHTb TPY,ll, IIRTH pa60qHX H y KOToporo
B pe3YJIbTare rrOJIyqaeTCR KOM6HHaUHR
E,
TYID H
pHaHThI pacrrpe,ll,eJIeHHR O,ll,HOro BH,lI,a 3aTPaT C ueJIbIO rrpOH3BO,ll,CTBa ,lI,Byx B03MO:lKHhIX BH,lI,OB
TOBapOB. EeJrCJIOBHO, peaJIbHbIH MHp 60JIee CJIO)ICeH, B HeM cymeCTByeT Macca pecypCOB, KO
TopbIe pacrrpe,ll,eJIeHbI Me)l{,ll,y 60JIblIIHM KOJI~eCTBOM rrpOH3BO,ll,CTB. Ho rrpHHUHrrbl orpaHH
qeHHOCTH pecypcOB H YMeHblIIeHHR OT,lI,aqH, KOTOpbIe TaK OT'IeTJIHBO BH,lI,HbI H'a KPHBOtl: nnB,
MOryT 6bITb HCrrOJIbJOBaHhI ,lI,JIR 60JIbliiOro KOJI~eCTBa pa3Ho06paJHbIX 3aTPaT H rrpOH3BO,ll,H
MhIX TOsapOB H ycnyr, cymeCTBYIOmHX B peaJIbHOM MHPe.
Eme O,ll,HO yrrpomeHHe
KO~eCTBa pecypcoB,
He)ICeJIH paublIIe.
3.2
nnB Brrpa
3.2
yseJI~HBaeT BaillY crroC06HOCTb rroJIyqHTb 60JIblIIe TOBapa o6oHX BH,lI,OB. npHMepoM C6aJIaH
CHpoBaHHoro TeXHOJIOr~ecKoroH3MeHeHHR Morno 6hI 6bITb ycoBepWeHCTBOBaHHe y,ll,06pe
HHH HJIH rreCTHUH,lI,OB, KOTophIe yseJI~aT YPO~HOCTb KaK R6JIOK, TaK H arreJIbCHHOB.
Ho reXHOJIOrHqeCKHe HHHOBaUHH B 60JIbWHHCrne CBoeM pacrrpe,ll,eJIeHhI Hepa8HOMepHO.
npe,ll,rrOJIOJKHM, ~o BbI paCCM:aTPHBaere nnB.. F,lI,e ,lI,BYMH BH,lI,aMH rrpoH:)Be,ll,eHHhIX TOBapOB ..
RBJIRIOTCR CTaJIb H rrlIIeHHua. YcoBepWeHCTBOBaHHe rrpouecca H3roTOBJIeHHR CTaJIH 06R3a
reJIbHO rr03BOJIHT BaM BhIpa60TaTb 60JIbWe CTaJIH H3 BaIIIHX orpaH~eHHbIXpecypcoB, HO HH
KaK He Ol'paJHTCR Ha BblpamHBaHHH rrlIIeHHUhI.
54
'laC"" t.
3KOHOMHIf8CK8f1 reOpHfI
.a
0;:
AnenbCIIIHbI
3.3,
rrO)J.HHMaeTCH Ha TOM KOHQe, r)J.e BeCb BallI OT)J.eJIbHbllt pecypc (CKIDKeM, TPY)J.) H8IIpaBJIeH Ha
rrpoH3BO,lI.CTBO CTaJIH, HO OCTaeTCH Ha rrpe)l(J{eM Mecre Ha TOM KOHQe, r,ll.e 3TOT pecypc HaIIpaB
JIeH Ha rrpOH3BO,lI.CTBO IIIlleHHQhI.
!:s:
c:
Cranb
TY KOM6HHaQHIO TOBapOB H
U38oi}cm8a.
npo
:xjxpeKmu8Hocmb pacnpeOeJleHUR.
55
)l(HBeTe PH.llOM C HHM, 3arpH3HeHHe Ha Bac BJIHHeT, H BbI npOTHB Hero npOTecTYeTe.
B03MO}l{}fO, B .llaHHOM eJIy'Iae BaM nOHa.n06HTCH nOMOmb BJIaCTeH, KOTopbIe CMOIYI
OrpaHH'IHTb 6ypHYIO .lleHTeJIbHOCTb BaIIIero Coce.lla. IIOXO)I(HM 06Pa30M BJIaCTH 06
Cy)I(.llaIOT TO, 'ITO .llOJI}l{}fO 6bITb npoH3Be.lleHO npH cymecTBYIOmHX orpaHH'IeHHbIX
pecypcax. HeKOTopbIM XO'IeTCH cy6CJt.llHPOBaTb 4>epMepcKHe X03HHCTBa, TOr.lla KaK
.llPyrHe npe.llnO'IHTaIOT TPaTHTb .lleHbrH Ha 060POHY H.JIH nporpaMM}' nOAlIep)I(KH
6e.llHbIX CJIOeB HaCeJIeHHH.
IIo npH'IHHe cymecTBOBaHHH TaKHX KOHKypHpYIOmHX npHopHTeTOB .llOJI}l{}fbI 6bITb YC
TaHOBJIeHbI 'IeTKHe npOIIeCCbI npHHHTHH pemeHHit B HHTepecax 60JIbIIlHHCTBa HaCeJIeHHH.
B 60JIbIIlHHCTBe CTPaH peIIleHIDI no nOBO.ny npOH3BO.llCTBa Tex HJIH HHbIX BH.llOB TOBapOB H
yc.nyr,
56
"IBcr.
I.
3KOHOM",IfeCKBfI reop",fI
./
3TH
B COBpeMeHHbIX
TYIO),
60JIhIIIe Bcero Hy:lKHbI JIIO.D;HM). Ceittlac H B 06~HX QePTax 06PHCyIO npeHMYI.QeCTBa H He,noc-'
TaTKH cB060,nHoro pbIHKa H rocy,napcTBeHHOrO BMeIIIaTeJIbCTBa.
onpe,neJIeHIDI CHTYauHH, Kor,na O.D;HH HH.D;RBH.D;yyM npe.D;JIaraeT ,npyroMY TOBap HJIH YCJIYry no
ueHe, npli:eMJIeMoit
meH, 3a KOTOpbIe JIIO,nH XOTHT llJIaTHTh. K TOMY )ICe pbIHKH HMeIOT TeH.D;eHUHIO 6bITh OQeHb 3<1>
<peKTHBHbIMH, eCJIH eCTh MHOro ToproBueB, rOTOBbIX npo,naTh HJIH KynHTh TOBap HJIH YCJIYTY.
KOHlCypeHmHblu PblHOIC -
B TaKOH
.npyr C ,npy
npo,naBaTh no caMoH B03MOXHOH HH3KOH ueHe .D;ID.l Toro, q'J'06bI C6HTb ueHy CBOHM KOHKy
peHTaM H nOCTeneHHO "3axBaTHTb" HX nOKynaTeJIeH. OOCKOJIbKy KmK,llaH <pHpMa HMeeT 3TOT
CTHMyJI, ueHbI HMeIOT Hlj.CTOJIbKO MaJIyIO TeH.D;eHUHIO K pO cry, QTO npe,ncTaBHTeJIH 6H3Hec
C1pYKTYP MOryr nonyqaTh JIHIIIb He60JIbIIIyIO npl16billh.
l~
. ~:
\~
57
nOJIOXCHM, 'ITO MbI XCHBeM B MHpe, KOTOPbID Hacem.reT npHMepHO ceMb MHJIJIHap,nOB JIIO,neil.
BaM HJIH MHe, HJIH KOMy-HH6y)l.b elQe MOlKeT 6bITb OqeHb TPy,nHO nOJIY'lHTb ,nOCTaTOlJHYIO HH
<PoPMaIlHIO.lJ,JUl TOro, lJr06bI paCCqHTaTb, 1eaK0D HMeHHo TOBap HJIH yCJIYI'Y JIIO,nH XOTRT npH
06pecTH B nepBYJO Oqepe,nb. lloTPe6yeTCH HeCKOJIbKO XH3HeH, 'IT06bI noroBOpHTb C K3)K,!1;bIM
OT,ne.n:bHbIM lJe.n:OBeKOM C lleJIbIO Y3HaTb XOTB 6bI TO, 'ITO HMeHHO OHH XOTHT BH,n6Tb Ha CBoeM
o6e,neHHOM CTOJIe, OCTaBHB 6e3 BHHMaHIDI BCe OCT8J[l>HOe, e:lKe,nHeBHO HMH :lKeJIaeMoe.
Ho nOCKOJIbKY npOllecc npoH3BO,nCTBa H pacnpe,neJIeHIDI B coupeMeHHoD 3KOHOMHKe He
lleHTPaJIH30BaH, BaM BOBce He HY:lKH0 3HaTb 06w;yIO KapTMHy. <I>aKTHtIecKH HaCTOHlQaH MaI'IUI
PbIHOlJHOD 3KOHOMHKH COCTOHT B TOM, 'ITO BCB OHa -
He 6b1J10
~1'
I~
cucmeMOU 14eH,
\.~ COKYIO lleHY, a BeIllH, cnpoc Ha KOTOpbIe HH3KHD, npo,naIOTCH no HH3KHM lleHaM.
llOCKOJIbKY npe,nCTaBHTeJUlM 6H3HeC-CTPYKTYP MpaBHTCH ,neJIaTb ,neHbrH, OHH CJIe
,nBT 3a TaKHMH lleHOBbIMH CHnlaJIaMH. H npOH3B0.lUl1 60JIbWe Tex TOBapoB, KOTO
pbIe HMeIOT BbICOKYIO lleHY, H MeHbme TeX,
58
npoHcxo,nHT
P}'lO~HMH opraHsMH;
XX BeK8 6b1118
O'leHb XopoWO.
'npOH3BeAeHH~e TOBap~
BpeM~
HQAO
YXOAHllH
rnSIS
3.
59
OWH6KH pWHKOS
TIpaIma, PbIHKll .n;aneKO He H,lleanbHbI. B qaCTHOCTH, OHH CTPa.D;alOT OT ,llByx maBHbIX rrp06
JIeM.
./
PbIHKH rrpOH3BO)J.SlT Bce, 3a qTO JIlO.n;H XOTHT ruIaTHTb .n;eHbrH, .n;axe eCJIH 3TH
TOBapbI H ycnyrn rrpHHOCHT Bpe.n; JIlO.D;HM rum OIql}')KalOmeil: cpe.n;e
./
TeM, 'lT06bI H3MeHHTb CHTYauHIO; TaK rrpoHCXO.D;HT Tor.n;a, Kor.n;a CHCTeMa ueH He rrpeMaraeT
.n;OCTaTOqHOro CTHMyJIa, qro6bI rrpOH3BO.n;JfTeJIH caMH MeHHJIH HelKeJIaTeJIbHYlQ CHTYauHIO.
CJIe.D;YlQmM 60JIbUlaH rrp06JIeMa PbIHKOB COCTOHT B TOM, qTO OHH 06cJIYlKHBalOT Tex, KTO
HMeeT .n;emrn H B03MO}l(JiOCTb HX TPaTHTb. CHCTeMa ueH CTHMyJIHpyeT rrpOH3BO.n;CTBO TOJIbKO
Tex TOBapOB, KOTopbIe JIlO.n;H lKeJIaIOT rrpH06pecTH H rrpH06peTaIOT 3a .n;eHbrH. ECJIH KTO-TO
OqeHb 6e.n;eH, OH He MOXeT CTHMyJIHpoBaTb npOH3BO.n;CTO .n;axe CaMbIX He06xo.n;HMbIX .D;JIH ce6H
Bemeil:, HanpHMep, JIeKapCTB H npO.nyKTOB rrHTaHHH. B qHCTO PbIHOqHOii. 3KOHOMHKe pecypcbI
HanpaBJIHlOfCH Ha rrpOH3BO.n;CTBO Bemeil: .D;JIH Tex, y KOro eCTb .n;eHbrn.
Eme o.n;Ha CBH3aHHaH C pbIHKaMH np06JIeMa -
YCJIYI'.
Ifscr. I.
3IcoHOMJf'lecICSII
reopJffl...
YCJI)T,
DOJle3HLIX ,lJ,JIJI
06mecTBa.
./ H3JlorH
Ha ,lI,OXO,ll,W R RMYIneCTBO,
,lI,OCTllTKe. 3TH
ycJIYI'lf ,lI,IDl:oe~HbIX.
KaKaSI
61
ycrryr,
npe.n.OCTaBJUIeMhlX rocy.n.apcTBOM
Ii .
~
H fI'aK HaJhlBaeMoro
mpaOUI4UOHHOeo npou3600cm6a. B
./ PYuO'lH8JI 3KOHOMIIIUl -
HefIMeUlameJlbCm60M
JIIO. -
llpUMelf. nep.)
./ KoMaJWUUI
3KOHOMHKa -
62
Iacn. I.
3ICOHOUHY8CICall r80pHfI...
./ Tp~OHHllJI SKOBOMHKa -
CMe
MH (H He38KOHHhIMH).
BhIllie B 3ToA maBe), KOMaH,llHaH 3KOHOMHKa HMeeT Bce 3JIOBeIlUfe npH3HaKH HeCOCTOHTeJIb
HOCTH. )l;aJKe CaMhIe 6JIaroHaMepeHHhIe rrpaBHTeJIbCTBa He MOryT c06paTb .n;OCTaTOqHOe KOJIH
qeCTBO HHpopMarum 0 npoH3Bo.n;CTBe H pacrrpoC'l'paHeHHH TOBapoB H
YCJIYf,
laire)
RaJa,IJ; B OTBeT Ha rrpHBhJllKY BJIacTeA TOD 3noXH CJIHlliKOM qaCTO BMelliHBaTbCH B 3KOHOMH'leCKYIO lleHTeJIbHOCTb.
63
3aMeTbTe, qTO Bce 3TO ,D;OJDKHO CYIIIeCTBOBaTb .lmH Toro, qT06bI PbIHKH MomH tPYHKIIHO
HHpOBaTh. CJIe,D;OBaTeJIbHO, 60JIee YMepeHHasI, 60JIee COBpeMeHHasI BepcHH HeBMeIIIaTeJIbCTBa
3aKJIIOqaeTCH B TOM, lffO rrpaBHTeJIbCTBO ,D;OJDKHO o6ecrreqlfTh OpraHH3aIIHOHHYIO CTPYKTYPY,
Heo6xo.D:HMYIO ,D;JlH tPYHKIIHOHHPOBaHHH PbIHOqHOH 3KOHOMHKH, a JaTeM "yHTH C ,D;opom" H
rr03BOJIHTb JIIO.D:HM rrpoH3BO,D;HTh H rrpO,D;aBaTh Bce TO, ~ lIM Tpe6YeTCH.
TeM He MeHee rrO,D;aBJIHIOIIIee 60JIbIIIHHCTBO JIIO,D;eH XOqeT, qT06b1 rrpaBHTeJIbCTBa ,D;eJIBJIH
60JIbIIIe, He:lKeJIH rrpocTO yCTaHaBJIHBaJIH Heo6xo,D;HMbIe opraHH3au.HOHHbIe paMKH ,D;JlH ,D;eH
TeJIbHOCTH pbIHKa. JIIO,D;H XOTHT, lffo6bI rrpaBHTeJIbCTBa 3arrpeTHJIH rrpOH3BO,D;CTBO H rrpo,D;a:lKY
HeKOTOpbIX TOBaPOB THrra HapKOTHKOB HJlH qTo6bI OHH HaqaJIH Cy6cH,D;HpOBaTb rrpOH3BO,D;CTBO
BeIIIeH, KOTopbIe PhlHOQHasI 3KOHOMHKll MoxeT rrpOH3BO,D;HTb B He,nOCTaTOQHOM KOJIlfqeCTBe,
HarrpHMep :lKHJIbe ,D;JlH 6e,D;HbIX. 06IIIeCTBeHHOCTb 3aHHTepeCOBaHa TaK:lKe B TOM, lffo6bI CO
CTOHTeJlbHbIe rplUK,llaHe IIJIaTHJlH HaJIOrn, KOTopbIe B ,D;aJIbHeHIIIeM H,D;yT Ha OIIJIary rrpaBHTeJIb
CTBeHHbIX rrporpaMM .lmH 6e,D;HbIX.
MHorHe rrpaBHTeJIbCTBeHHbIe rrporpaMMbI CTaJIH HaCTOJIbKO 06h1qHbIMH, qTO
BbI ,D;a:lKe He ,D;YMaeTe 0 HHX, KllK 0 BMeIIIaTeJIbCTBax CO CTOpoHhI rrpaBHTeJIbCTBa.
HarrpHMep, 6eCIIJIaTHbIe 06IIIeo6paJOBaTeJIbHbIe IIIKOJIbI, KOMIIJIeKC Mep rro o6ec
rreQeHHIO 6e30rraCHOCTH aBTOM06HJleit, rrpe.D:YIIpe)K,llaIOIIIHe Ha,D;rrHCH Ha rry3bIpb
cPoH,D; -
IIIaTeJIbCTBa B 3KOHOMHKY.
BMeIIIaTeJIbCTBo BJIaCTeit,Heo6xo,D;HMoe.lmH BHe,D;peHHH TaKHX rrporpaMM, BO MHornx cny
qaHX rrpH6bIJlH He rrpHHOCHT. Ho MHorne CqHTaIOT, qTO TaKHe rrporpaMMbI Heo6xo,D;HMbI .lmH
:lKH3HH, a He,D;JlH rrpH6bmeH, H lffO OTCYTCTBHe rrpH6bmeH OT MHorHX BH,D;OB rrpaBHTeJIbCTBeH
HbIX BMeIIIaTeJIbCTB CTORT Tex rrpH6billeH, KOTopbIe MO)K}{O 6bl,}lO 6bI rronyqHTb. TIo MHeHHIO
3THX JIIO,D;eit, rocy,D;apCTBeHHbIe rrporpaMMbI CJIY:lKaT y,D;OBJIeTBopeHHIO rrOTPe6HOCTeH HaCeJIe
HHH, ,D;a:lKe eCJIH He rrpHHOCRT HHKllKOH MaTepHaJIbHOH BbIro,D;bI.
TIOCKOJIbKY PbIHOqHasI 3KOHOMHKll He MO:lKeT rrpe,D;OCTaBHTh Bce TO, lffO XOTRT rronyqHTh
JIIO.D:H, 60JIbIIIHHCTBO CTPaH BbI6HpaeT KllK MHHHMYM HeCKOJIbKO ,D;OCTaTOqHO 6oJIbIIIOe KOJIHQeCTBO -
H B HeKOTopbIX CnyqaHX
64
&laen.
I.
3KOHOMlflf8eKafl TeOplffl...
pe3YJIb
CJIYXHT
CIlIA
H BeJIHK06pHTaHHH, -
Ha
B3)K
60nee
06ec
2%,
nOCKOnbKY
6-8%
6na
B rOA. no
10 neT.
65
20 JIeT.
CJIYJKHT
JaU1HTe HHTeJI
JIeKTYaJIbHOR C06cT:SeHHOCTH. Kor,lla TBOpqeCKHe JIIO,llH 3HaIOT, lfI'0 OHH MOryr )l(HTb Ha ,lleHb
rH, Korophle OHH nOJIyqaT 3a CBOIO pa60ry, TO C03,ll;aIOT orpOMHoe KOJIHqeCTBO pa3Ho06pa3
He1l:wHx KaPTHH, MY3hIKaJIbHbIX H JIHTepaTypHbIX npOH3Be,lleHH1l:. Ho BMeCTe C TeM JIerKOCTb
CH.IlTH.Il xonH1l: H 6ypHoe pa3BHTHe UHcPPOBbIX TeXHOJIOrH1l: H I-brrepHeT BhI3hIBalOT ,llOCTaTOq
HO np06JIeM, nOCKOJIbKY Bce 3T0 OCJIa6JI.1leT cnOC06HOCTb TBOpqeCKHX JIIO,lle1l: npOCJIe)I(HBaTb
nyrH pacnpOCTPaHeHH.Il HX npOH3Be,lleHH1l:, Ha.zt KOTOphIMH OHH Tax ,llOJIro TPY,llHJIHCb.
If
,llOJI)l(HO y,llHBJUlTb, qTO B Ka)I()101l: 60raTo1l: CTPaHe MHpa eCTb C06CTBeHHa.Il nO.1lHTHKa OTHOCH
TeJIbHO Bce06111ero HaqaJIbHOrO H Cpe,llHerO 06pa3oBaHH.Il, eCTb CneUHaJIbHhIe yHHBepCHTeThI,
r,lle MO)I(HO nonyqHTb npeBOCXO,llHOe BhIcwee 06paJoBaHHe. Pa3BHThIe HOBhIe TeXHOJIOrHH TPe
6Y1OT Pa3BHTbIX, XopOWO 06pa30BaHHbIX HCCJIe,llOBaTeJIe1l:, HO HM HeOTKY,lla 6Y,lleT B3.1lTbC.Il 6e3
BhlCOKOKJIaCcHo1l: CHCTeMhI 06Pa3PBaHH.Il.
66
'1SCn.
I.
3ICOHO,.",,,ecICBII r8opHII
t.\?1~~ ?1H~n9\\
M.LOOHqUMgB.LO, M 9.LOOd
WO>109hMWOHO>l go
B>lABH - B>lMWOHO>lOd>lBW
II Q.10eh
rl1aBa 4
MSKp03KOHOMM"IeCKMe nOKS3STenM:
KSK 3KOHOMMCTbi CneASIT 3SBCeM
B .J1IitJ'; uak...
)0> H3MepSleM BBn: 06l1.l8.Sl CTOMMOCTb TOBapOB M yCJ1yr
)0> PaCIU1!lAblBaeM BBn Ha
C + I + G + NX
~~
QlCP03ICOHOMUICa
3TO xopowo
~TO:l%
yc.rryrH,
HO
oe30naCHOCTb 00
meCTBa, ooopOHa CTPaHhI H TaKHe OOllleCTBeHHbIe TOBapbI, KaK ,IJ;oporH H MOCThI. llOMHMO
3TOro rocy,IJ;apcTBO npe,IJ;OCTaBJUleT oomeCTBy,3aKOHO,IJ;aTeJIbHYJO CHCTeMY, B paMKax KOTOpo:l%
p;e:l%CTByeT qaCTHbIit OH3Hec; BMeWHBaeTCR B 3KOHOMHKy C lleJIbIO KOHTPOllil H8,ll ypoBHeM 3a
rpSl3HeHHR OKP}')KaIOme:l% Cpe,IJ;hI; llpe,IJ;OCTaBJUleT rapaHTHH oe30naCHocm Ha npOMhIWJleHHoe
06opY,IJ;oBll1IHe H nepeplcnpe,IJ;eJUIeT ,IJ;OXO,IJ;hI, 3aOHPasI H3JIHWKH y ooraThIX H OT,IJ;aB~ HX He
HMYI1lHM. (RoJIee nO,IJ;p06Ho 0 pacnpe,IJ;eJIeHHH 38,llaq, CTORlllHX nepe,IJ; qaCTHhIM OH3HeCOM H
rocy.zr,aPCTBOM, R paCCKa3blBaIO B rnaBe
)lJuI
3.)
TpeOJIeHHR B peaJlbHo:l% X<H3HH, HM HYXHO CJIe,IJ;HTb Ja TeM, CKOJIbKO TO~O OhIJIO npoH3Be,IJ;e
HO H qero OhIJIO ,IJ;OCTHrHYTO. ll03TOMY 3KOHOMHCThI C03,IJ;aJIH OrpOMHhI:l% CqeTHhI:l% MexaHH3M,
Ha3hIBaeMhl:l%
NIPA)
6HympeHHuu npOdyICm
ycnyr,
6a.tl060U
6 H 7.)
ll03TOMY, nO)l{~CTa,
ttCJ1,tU,b3'1eJl
DOff'1~ oJ1i~tdaJUlJl,
aICo/tOJtl4lteCICu,x H/toll,eccol
BaJIOBOA BHyrpeHHHA npo.nyxT, HJIH BBIT, -
()lmI 03Ha
He Bcer,na 0TPIDKaTb B03POCWHH
ypOBeHb y,nOBJleTBOpeHHSI, CM. CJIe.nyIOIlJ,HA no.npa3,lleJI "XopOWO, llJIOXO H CKBepHO: Bce MIDI
eT Ha YBe~eHHe BBIT".)
B fJIaBaX
2 H 3 paCCMaTPHBaeTCSI pYH.naMeHTaJIbHlUI
3KoHo~~ecKlUI lJ,eJIb -
MaKCHMaJIb
yc.rryrn,
ycnyr,
B 3TOM pa3,D;eJIe SI noKaxY BaM, leaK H nOqeMY 3KOHOMHCThl, KOTOphle COCTaBJlSlIOT Ta6
JIHlJ,hl Hau,HOHaJIbHhlX CqeTOB, Pa36HBaIOT BBIT Ha COCTaBJlSllOllJ,He. Pa36HBKa BBIT n03BOJISI
eT BaM npOaHaJIH3HpOBaTb Kll)f(}J;ylO qaCTb B OT,neJIbHOCTH H pa306paTb Bee fJIaBHhle paKTO
Phl, KOTophle OKa3hlBalOT BJlHSlHHe Ha npOH3Bo,nCTBO TOBapoB H ycrryr. Ho CHaqaJIa SI ,naM BaM
xpaTKoe 06'LsI:cHeHHe Toro, qro
He BXO,nHT B BBIT.
B 3KOHOMHKax TaKHX CTPaH, KaK ClIIA, BBIT OqeHb XopOWO pHKcHpyeT nOqTH Bce npo
H3Be,neHHhle TOBaphl, nOCKOJIbKY noqm Bee, qTO npOH3Be,neHO TaM, BnOCJIe,nCTBHH npo,naeTCSI.
.Ho B CTPaHax, r,ne 60JIbweA qaCTbIO Pa3BHTO CeJIbCKOe X03S1tl:CTBO, Be.nymeecSI Ha He60JIbWHX
<PePMax, 60JIbWHHCTBO npoH3Be,neHHoA npO,D;yKlJ,HH npe,D;Ha3HaqeHO ,D;JISI nOTPe6JIeHIDI B npe
,neJIax ,nOMaWHHX X03HHCTB, a 3TO 3HaqHT, qTO TOBap npOH3Be,neH, HO OH He BXO,nHT B 0pHlJ,H
aJIbHyx> CTaTHCTHKY BBn, COCTaBJlSleMYlO 3KOHOMHCTaMH 3THX CTPaH. Kor,na CTPaHa HaqHHa
70
ttaCTI:t
II.
MaKpo3KoHoMHKa - HayKa
BBll B TaKO~
6hIJIH yqTeHhI BnepBhIe. TeM He MeHee 3TO MHHMoe H3MeHeHHe MoX<:eT He HMeTb HHKaKOro
(-'
BBn B
llpH paccMOTPeHHH
3) -
X03JlUCmBa
HanpHMep, HH,!J;HBH
ycnyr,
KOTO
ICpyzoo6opom
,ll,ox~
4.1.
(Aonn. CWA)
PeCYPCbI
,ll,oMawHlol9
X03Sli\cTBa
Cl>IolPMbI,
I
71
CJIOBOM "Pacxo,nhI".
II,
OCHOBHoe, 'ITO lfYXHO rrolUITh: $HPMhI rrpHHa,n;JIe:lKllT ,nOMlUllHHM x03SlitCTBaM (rpWK,naHaM), OHH He cymeCTByIDT caMH rro ce6e. B pe3YJIhTaTe JII06LIe ,neHhrH, KOTOpLIe
rronyqaIOT $HPMhI, Kor,na rrpo,naIOT TOBap HJIH YCJIYIY, HarrpaBJUllOTCJI B BH,ne rrpH
6hIJIH K O,nHOMY H3 HH,nHBH..nYYMOB HJIH rpyrrrre HH,nHBH.nYYMOB.
TeKaHHJI ,nOXO,nhI, 0603HaqeHHhIe Ha pHC.
4.1,
paBHLI K pacXo,naM.
'CJIY)KHT
rrp~HOD
./
./
./
BLI Moxere 3aMeTHTh, 'ITO rrepBLIe TPH KaTeropHH eCTh TPH TPa.nHUHOHHLIX $aKTOpa
rrpoH3BO,nCTBa, KOTOpLIe JI rrepeqHCJIHJI B rJIaDe
3. Ii eCJIH
TPy,n H KarrHTaJI .ZJ;JIjf TOro, qT06hI rrpoH3BO,nHTh TOBaphI, BaM lfYXHO 3a HHX IIlIaTHTh.
TI03TOMY qaCTh ,noxo,na COCTOHT H3 3THX OIIlIaT. Ho B ,nHHaMHqHOD, KOHKYPeHTHoD 3KOHOMHKe BaM TaKXe lfYXHhI JIIO,nH, XeJIaIOIIIHe rroDTH Ha pHCK H BJlO)l(HTh
cBoD KarrHTaJI B pa3BHTHe HOBLIX TeXHOJIorHD.
,I:Vrn
BaM HYXHO 3aIIlIaTHTh HM, rr03TOMY qaCTh ,noxo,na HYXHO rrepeBeCTH Ha CqeTa Ta
KHX "PHCKYIOIIIHX" rrpe,nrrpHHHMaTeJIeD B $opMe IlpH6hIJ1H. B CaMOM ,neJIe MHe (,na
H'MHOrHM ,npyrHM 3KOHOMHCTaM) HPaBHTCJI .nyMaTh 0 rrpe,nrrpHHHMareJIhCTBe, KaK
o qerneproM $aKTOpe rrpoH3Bo,nCTBa, -
BKJIa,nOM B rrpOH3BO,nCTBO.
./
Pa60qHe rronyqaIOT
./ BJIa,neJIhULI
3tlpa6omHylO fIJlamy
MLIX He,nBHXHMOCThIO.
./ <1>HPMhI, XeJIaIOIIIHe rrpH06pecTH ycnym, rrpe,nocTaBJIjfeMhIe KarrHTaJIOM (Ha
rrpHMep, MaIIIHHaMH H KOMrrhIOTepaMH), ,nOJI)l(HhI 3a HHX IIlIaTHTh. 3TH IIlIa
TeXH rrpe,nCTaBJIjfIOT c060D npo~eHmbl, rrOTOMY 'ITO CTOHMOCTh rronyqeHHJI YC
JIyr, rrpe,nOCTaBJljfeMLIX o6opy,noBaHHeM CTOHMOCThIO ThICJI'!Y ,nOJIJIapoB, rrpo:u;eHTHhle IIlIaTeXH, KOTOphIe $HpMa ,nOJI)l(Ha BLIIIlIaTHTh
no
Ja ThICJI'!Y ,nOJIJIa
72
IIscn, II.
MSKP03KoHoMlfKa - HayKa
I~
H HaKOHeu,
npU6bL1lb
YlflfTbiSaeAf IfAfyu.ceCTSO
qTO npoHCXO,IJ.HT C ,lJ,HHaMllKOit ,lJ,OXO.n;OB, eCJIH t>HpMa nOKYIIaeT CBOIO 3eMJIIO H 04>HcHbie
nOMeIlleHIDl BMecTO TOro, 'IT06b1 6pan HX B apeH.DY? HJIH ec;m t>HpMa BJIMeeT CBOHM KanH
TaJIOM HanpHMYIO BMecTO TOro, 'ft06hI 3aHHTb .n;eHbTH )J;JIH ero npH06peTeHIDl? ECJIH t>HpMa
BJIa,rJ;eeT 3THM HMyI.IJ;eCTBOM (KOTOpoe H33hIBaIOT aKTHBaMH), eH 60JIbme He HYJKHO llJIaTHTb
.n;eHbrH, 'IT06hI noJIyqHTb ero. H 6y.n;yr JIH B TaKOM CJIyqae paCXO)J;hI PaBHhI .n;oxo.n;aM?
He CTOHT BOJIHOBaTbCH: ,lJ,OXO,lJ,hI Bce eIlle paBHhI pacxo.n;aM. O,lJ,HaKO HaM HYJKHO c.n;eJIaTb
HeKOTOphIe no.n;cqeTbI, qT06bI y6e.n;HTbCH B 3TOM caMHM.
,lVuI
3anac,
~~
I~
\.~
,lVuI
nomo".
.n;y
3Ta
4.1
ByeT )J;JIH BeHKOro pacxo.n;a. TeM He MeHee, nOCKOJIbKY .D.HarpaMMa p33.n;eJIHeT BCIO 3KOHOMHKY
TOJIbKO Ha t>HpMhI H ,lJ,OMOX03HitcTBa, B Heit OTCYTCTByeT Macca .n;eitCTBHH, KOTophIe npOHC
XO.n;HT B peaJIbHOM MHpe. Ha pHC.
4.2
73
npOl{eHm
Cma8KY, KOTOplUl eCTb ueHO~, KOTOPYlO BbI lJ,OJI)KHbI 3allJIaTHTb, qT06bI
AOXO,Qbl
PblHKM .
OnnBTB cpe,QCTB
CPB,QCTB
npOM3BO,QCTBB
npOI13BO,QCTBB
C6ePBlKBHI1R
I
I
I cJ)I1HBHCOBbiB PblHICM I
AB$I1I..\1'lT
rOCY,l:\BpCTBBHHoro
151O,[\lKera
IAOMOX03R~CTBB II Hanorl1
: npBBI1TenbCTBO
I cJ)I1PMbl I
rOCY,l:\BpCTBeHHble
aBKYnKI1
I1HBeCTMlll111
nOTpe6neHl1B
PblHKI1
TOBBpOB
AOXOAbl $I1PMbI
11 ycnyr
4.2
OllJIalfllBalOT apeHJJ,y, BbI)l;aIOT 3apa60THYIO llJIaTy, B03BpaInalOT npOueHTbI H Jl,eJISlT CBOIO npM
6bIJIb. T.e. OHH llJIaTSlT Jl,OMOX03S1~CTBaM 3a cpe)l;CTBa npOH3BO,llCTBa -
74
II'CTII
II.
M'KP03KOHOMMK' - HByKB
HpUMelfaHlle.
BBII
BBII
BBII 3a
3TOT ro..u.)
BBII
..uo TOro, OK ero npo..ua,.uyr. 3T0 HeMHoro YCJImKHJleT OTCJIeXHBaHHe ..ueHer, CBJl3aHHhIX C HO
BOH npo.JlYKll,lleil:.
~~
CIlIA
BBII
29 ..ueKa6pJl
2004 ro..ua. ECJIH ..uOM 6y..ueT npo..uaH n03..uHee, 21ll>eBpaJIJI 2005 ro..ua,
BBII
CqHTaTb ..uB8)I{,LlhI.
Kor..ua ..uOM npo..uaH, ero CqHTaIOT qaCTbIO cTapoil: c06CTBeHHOCTH H He 3aCqHThIBaIOT KaK
HOBYIO npo.JlYKll,llIO. 3KOHOMHCThI TOJIbKO 0603HaqaT, qTO npaBO BJIa,LleHIDI Ha renepb }')ICe CTa
PhIH ..uOM nepexo..uHT OT ~l'pOHTeJIJI K HOBOMy BJIa,.ueJIbIJ,y. IIOCKOJIbKY TOproBJUI CTaphIM HMY
!fo~
BBII
2004 ro..ua, XOTJI OH He 6bill npo..uaH nOl'pe6HTeJIIO ..uo HaqaJIa CJIe..uYIO~ero ro..ua.
QT06hI MO)I{HO 6billO JIyqwe npe..uCTaBHTb 3TOT npou,ecc, 6y..ueM CqHTaTb, ~o
Sony
BblnycTHJIa TeJleBH30p JI 3areM npo..uaJIa ero ce6e caMOR, BKJIIOqHB ero B COCTaB Ma
TepHaJIbHhIX 3anaCOB. 3Ta "npo..u8)l{8" 6y..ueT CqHTaTbCJI B
reJIeBH30p -
n03,Llaee -
BBII
BBII
BBII,
ou,eHH
03HaqaeT, ~o 6oJIbIIIOe KO
rn.l.
4.
M.Kp03KOHOMlflfeClCMe nOK.3.TenIf
75
Ha CaMOM ,IleJIe cymecTByeT BepmITHOCTb TOro, 'ITO ,IlWKe npH BblCOKOM ypOBHe
BBI1 3KOHOMHKa MoxeT HaxOMTbCH B COCTOHHHH, 6JIH3KOM K Jq>H3HCHOMy, no
CKOJIbKY 3anaCbI MaTepHaJIbHblX 060POTHbIX Cpe,llCTB HaKa,llJIHBlUOTCH, H BCKope
MeHe.n:xepbI 6y.llYT cOKpamaTb npOH3BO,IlCTBO, qTQ6bI BepHYTb OO1.eM MarepHaJIbHblX
3anaCOB Ha I\eJIeBoli ypOBeHb. Crre,llOBaTeJIbHO, 3KOHOMHCTbI, KOTOpbIe CTapalOTCH
COCTaBHTb nporH03 3KOHOM~ecKoroKypca, y,lleJIHlOT HaMHOro GoJIbWc;l BHHMaHHH
ypoBHIO MaTepHaJIbHblX JanaCOB, qeM ,IlllHHbIM 0 BBI1 Ja nOCJIe,ll,HllH KBapTaJI.
y,llOBJIeTBope~
\HHH, noTOMy ~O BBI1 qaCTO nO,llHHMaeTCH, KOr,lla B XH3HH 06mecTBa npOHCXO,llHT 'ITO-TO
llJIOxoe. HanpHMep, eCJIH CJIyqHTCH yparaH, KOTOpblli pa3pYWHT 60JIbWOH paliOH ropO,lla,
BBI1 nO,ll,HHMeTCH H3-3a TOro, ~o HYXHO 6Y,lleT peKOHCTpYHpoBaTb YH~TOXeHHbIe 3)1,aHHH H
BbIIIyCTHTb MHOro TOBapoB, He06xo,llHMblX
AHaJIO~HO, 60JIee BblCOKHA BBI1 B03MoxeH B CHTYaI\HHX, KOr)l,a Bbl rOTOBbI COrJIaCHTb
CH Ha YBeJI~eHHe 3arpH3HeHHH oKpyxalOmeli Cpe,llbI HJIH yCHJIeHHe HepaBeHCTBa ,Il0XO,llOB.
CTpaHbI nepeXHBaIOT 6ypHoe 3KOHoM~ecKoepa3BHTHe H yCKOpeHHblMH TeMllaMH nOBbIwaIOT
ypoBeHb XH3HH, 3aqacTYIO eme GoJIbWe 3arpH3HHH oKpyxalOmyIO cpe.llY H C03,llaBaH 60JIbWe
COI\HaJIbHbIX 6ecnOpH,llKOB, nOTOMy qTQ HeKOTOpbIe JIIOM CTaHOBHTCH 'GoraTbIMH 3HaqHTeJIbHO
6bICTpee, HeXeJIH ,IlpyrHe. I1oKa3aTeJIb BBll He OTpaxaeT 3TH HeraTHBHbIe CTOpoHbl.
BBll TaKXe He yqHTbIBaeT CTOHMOCTb Coo6o,llHOro BpeMeHH.
KOTOpoe H npO:lKHJI, He npoH3BO)I,H H He nOTpe6JIHH H~ero, qTQ MOrJIO 6bI 6bITb nO)l,C~TaHO B
BBI1, -
DOJIee TOro, POCT BBll qaCTO npoHCXO)l,HT H3-Ja TOro, qTQ MbI npHHOCHM B xePTBY Haw ,Il0cyr,
a no 3Ha~, qTQ eCJIH Bbl Ha6JIIO,IlaeTe pOCT BBI1, TO npH 3TOM He 06HJaTeJIbHO ynyqwaIOTcH
BCe06mee 6JIarococTOHHHe HJIH cqaCTbe.
OrclO,Ila CJIe.llYeT, 'ITO XOTH
KYPC
IIIJIO BpeMH)I,JIH BaC n0.llPYXHTbCH C BBI1, qTQ6bI Bbl MOrJIH nOHHTb Bce MaJIeHbKHe ceKpeTbI
3TOro nOKaJaTeJIH -
6)
1936
HaCTOJIbKO orpoMHoe, ~O
76
&facrb
II.
MalCp03KOHOMMK8 - H8yK8
ycnyr,
H3BO,nCTBa TOBapoB H ycnyr. 06a pe3YJIbTaYa ,nOJIXHbI 6bITb paBHbIMH. TaKHM 06paJOM, 3TO
nepeKJIIO'IeHHe Ha MeTO,n no,nC'IeTa paCXO,nOB ,ZJ;JIH BbI'IHCJIeHHH BBll nOJIHOCTbIO onpaB,ZJ;aHo.
(3To
TaKXe OTJIH'lHlUI B03MOXHOCTb,ll)lH BaC nOHHTb 3KOHOMHKY C n03HUHt%. TOro, KTO TPaTHT
(G)
noopeMeHHe
(NX) -
(C),
HHBeCTHIJ;HH
(1),
rocy,napCTBeH
(Y).
ycnyr
B aJIre6paH'leCKOt%. lPopMe
Y=C+I+G+NX
XOTH CJIe.nyIOIIJ;He pa3,neJIbI co,nepxaT 60JIee ,neTaJIbHOe onHcaHHe, H npe,nOCTaBJIlO BaM
B03MOXHOCTb KOpoTKO 03HaKOMHTbCH C 'IeTbIpbMH BH,naMH pacxo,nOB, KOTOpble CYMMHpyIOTCH
BBBn.
./ C
TOaapbI H
./ I
T~ H~Py6eXHOronpoH3BO,LlCTBa
NX
= EX -
3TH
'IeTbIpe BH,na pacxo,nOB COCTaBJIHIOT BBn, nOTOMY'ITO Bce BMecre OHH OruIa'lHBaIOT
C-
nOTpe6MTenbCKMe paCXOAbi
77
laKTOphl BJIIDIIOT Ha TO, KaKYIO 'IaCTb CBOHX .rlOXO,D;OB ,D;OMOX03JIitCTBa peWalOT nOTpaTHTb Ha
nOTpe6JIeHHe H CKOJIbKO OHH peWaT COXPaHHTb Ha 6Y.lJYIIl:ee.
CneU;HaJIHCThI no MHKp03KOHOMHKe npOBOMT Maccy BpeMeHH, }J3yqasI pa3Ho06pa3Hhle
laKTOphl, BJIIDIlOwHe Ha nO,D;06Hhle peweHIDI. Cpe,nH TaKHX laKTOpOB eCTb, HanpHMep, OXCH
,D;aHIDI OTHOCHTeJIbHO 6Y.lJYIIl:ero COCTOHHIDI 3KOHOMHKH HJIH HOpMhI ,D;OXO.rlHciCTH c6epexeHHit
III
(CM. tIaCTb
,D;aHHoit KHHrH, TaM BhI H~eTe Bce, 'ITO HYXHO 3HaTb 0 MHKp03KOHOMHKe).
@j
IlT
l.HaQHHTe C
Y,
Y paBHH~TCH
2. BIII'IHCJlHTe,
no nO,D;OXO.rlHhlH H 'ITO
t.
Hl).IIpHMep,
re6paHtIeCKOH l0PMYJIe
YD'
YD = Y - T= Y - t"'Y= (1 - t)"'Y.
nOCJIe ~ro KaK nOJIyqHJIH pacnOJIaraeMhlH ,D;OXO.rl, BbI HCnOJIb3yere O'IeHb npocTYIO MO,D;eJIb
)J,IDI BbI'IHCJIeHIDI nOTPe6HTeJIbCKHX paCXO.rlOB ,D;OMOX03Hi%:CTB. MO,D;eJIb nOKa3bIBaeT, 'ITO nOTpe6
JIeHHe,
C, -
Co H
c:
C =Co + c"'YD ,
r.rle c -
3TO
0 H 1,
0,9,
H3 Kax.nO~ .rlOJIJIapa 'IHCTOro ,D;OXO,D;a, KOTOPblit y Bac OCTaeTCH nOCJIe ynJIaThI HaJIOrOB, BbI
TpaTHTe
90 IIeHTOB.
Co? 3To
roBOpHT 0
TOM, CKOJIbKO JIIO,D;H nOTpe6JIHIOT, ,D;axe eCJIH B 3TOM ro,D;y OHH HMelOT HYJIeBOH pacnOJIarae
C = Co.)
YD = 0 B
ypaBHeHHH
C = Co + c"'YD ,
TO 3TO paBeH
Co>
eCJIH y Bac HYJIeBoi%: pacnOJIaraeMbIit .llOXO.ll? OHH nocTYITHT H3 BawHX JIHtIHbIX c6epexeHHit,
KOTophle BhI C06paJIH B TeqeHHe npe,D;bI,D;yw:HX JIeT.
78
HSyKS
/I
\
B :QeJIOM paBeHCTBO
3T0 nOTOK,
KOTOP~ YBeJIHqHBaeT
OCHOBHOH Ka
nHTaJI 3KOHOMHKH.
Ho, 6e3YCJIOBHO, Cpe,IICTBa npOH3BO,IICTBa H3HaWHBaIOTCH BO BpeMR HCnOJIb30BaHHH. qaCTb
HX nopTHTCH. qacTb JIOMaeTCH. qacTb BbI6paCbIBaeTCH 3a HeHa,lI06HOCTbIO, nOCKOJIbKY HeH3
6e)KH0 yCTapeBaeT. Bce 3TH npO:QeCCbI, KOTopble YMeHbwaIOT OCHOBHOit KanlITaJI, 3KOHOMH
CTbI Ha3b1BaIOT U3HOCOM OCH06HOZO KanUmaAa.
ECTeCTBeHHO, <pHPMbI ,lIOJDKHbl ,lIeJIaTb HeKOTopbIe HHBecm:QHH ,IIJIR Toro, qro6b1 33MeHHTb
H3HoweHHble cpe,IICTBa npOH3BO,IICTBa. Ho KaX,lIaH HHBecm:QHH CBepx H3Hoca npHBO,IIHT K 06
meMy YBeJIlfqeHHIO OCHOBHOro KanHTaJIa, C03,IIaBaH nOTeH:QHaJIbHyro B03MO)KHOCTb npoH3BO,II
CTBa 60JIbWerO KOJIlfqeCTBa nOTPe6HTeJIbCKHX TOBapOB.
IToqeMy npOueHTHaH CTaBKa TaK MHoro 3HaqHT? ECTeCTBeHHO, eCJIH q>HpMa Hy:lKLlaeTCH B
cCY,IIe ,IIJIR npH06peTeHHH KanHTaJIa, 60JIee BblCOKHe np0:QeHTHble CTaBKH ,lIeJIaIOT npouecc 33
HMCTBOBaHHH ,lIeHer MeHee npHBJIeKaTeJIbHblM, nOToMy 'ITO BbIllJIaTbI no cCy,IIe 6y.IIYT O'leHb
BbICOKHMH. TeM He MeHee, ,lIaJKe eCJIH <pHpMa HMeeT Ha PYKax ,lIOCTaTOqHO HaJIHqHbIX ,lIJIH
nOKYllKH ,lIaHHOro cpe,IICTBa npOlf3BO,IICTBa, 60JIee BblCOKHe np0:QeHTHbIe CTaBIOf 33CTaBJIHIOT
<pHpMy BbI6HpaTb Me:lK,lIy HCnOJIb30BaHHeM 3THX HaJIHqHbIX ,lIJIH nOKYllKH 060pY,IIOBaHHH H
B03MO)KHOCTbIO HX O,IIOJlXHTb KOMy-TO. Cne,IIOBaTeJIbHO, 60JIee BbICOKHe np0:QeHTHbIe CTaB
KH npenHTCTByIDT HHBeCmUHRM, 6e30THOCHTeJIbHO TOro, ,lIOJI)KHbI <PHPMbI 33HHMaTb cpe,IICTBa
2,
79
I,
r,
1= 10 - I,""r.
3To
meM pa3,ll.eJIe, 3a HCKJIlOqeHHeM 3HaKa "MHHYC", KOTOPbIH 03HaqaeT, 'ITO Kor.n.a npoueHTHlUI
I na.n.aeT.
I, nOKa3bIBaeT,
CTaBKa nOBbIwaeTCH,
Ko3l>l>HUHeHT
HaCKOJIbKO na.n.aeT
I"
CKaJKeM, paBeH
10 MJIP.n. .n.0JIJI.,
r nOBbICHJIaCb
"YHKT YBe
10 nOKa3bIBaeT,
CTaBKa paBHa HYJIIO. no npaB.n.e roBOpH, npoueHTHble CTaBKH HHKor.n.a He OnycKalOTCH .n.o HY':'
JIeBOH OTMeTKH, HO npe.n.nOJIO:lKHM, 'ITO TaK npoH30illJIO. Tor.n.a BTOpoe 3HaqeHHe B ypaBHeHHH
6Y.n.eT paBHO HYJIIO, H Y BaC nOJIyqHTCH
1= I{)o
PaBeHCTBO B ueJIOM nOKa3bIBaeT, 'ITO eCJIH 6bI npoueHTHbIe CTaBKH 6bIJIH paBHbI HYJIIO,
KanHTaJIOBJIO:lKeHHH 6bIJIH 6bI MaKCHMaJIbHbIMH B
I{)o
ueHTHbIe CTaBKH, TeM 60JIbWe 6y.nyr COKPamaTbCH HHBecrnUHH. <I>aKrn'IeCKH CTaBKH MOryT
(nOTeHUHaJIbHO) nOBbICHTbClI HaCTOJIbKO, 'ITO HHBeCTHUHH CHH3HTCH.n.0 HYJIeBOH OTMeTKH.
CBR3b Me:lK.ZJ.Y npoueHTHhIMH CTaBKaMH H HHBeCTHUHHMH- o.n.Ha H3 npWlHH, no
qeMY B03MO:lKHOCTb npaBHTeJIbCTBa yCTaHaBJIHBaTb npoueHTHbIe CTaBKH I:IMeeT
6oJIbwoe 3HaqeHHe ,l(JIR 3KOHOMHKH. YCTaHaBJIHBaR npOueHTHbIe CTaBKH, npaBH
TeJIbCTBO MOXeT onpe.n.eJIHTb, CKOJIbKO .n.eHer 6H3HeC-CTPYKTYPbI nOXeJIalOT nOTPaTHTb Ha npH06pereHHe HHBeCTH:QHOHHbIX TOBapoB. B qaCTHOCrn, eCJIH 3KOHOMHXa
HaxO.n.HTCH B COCTOHHHH 3KOHOMWlecKoro cna.n.a, npaBHTeJIbCTBO MOXeT CHH3HTb
npOueHTHbIe CTaBKH C TeM, 'IT06bI nOBbICHTb HHBeCrnUHOHHbIe pacxo.n.bI l>HPM, H
TaKHM 06PaJOM (6y.n.eM Ha.n.eHTbCH!) nOMOtIb BOCCTaHOIiJIeHHIO 3KOHOMHKH.
GB
rOCYAapCTBeHHble paCXOAbi
60JIbIIIlfHCTBe CTPaH OrpoMHlUI .n.OJIR BBn
35%
~r
I~
\~
l>e
50%.
JIYI'
80
06 3ICOHOMIPIeCICOMPOCTeIf CT86IfnWfOCTIf
10
BaM re
KIDIOl:bIH
npoMe
~qHblH ro,ll,. ECJIH BbI npHHHMaere ycJIOBIDI H nOKyIlaeTe lleHHYID 6YMary, 3HaqHT, BbI ,lI,ae
re B3aitMbI rocy,lI,apcTBY
10 TbIC.
10%
G,
3TH paCXO,ll,bI, a He Ha TO, KaKHM 06pa30M OHM ,lI,OCTHraIOT 3THX 06'beMOB. CJIe,ll,OBaTeJIbHO, B
oCTaBIIIei!:C}I QaCTH KHHrH }I ,lI,emUO ynpomeHHoe npeMOJIO)ICeHHe, 'ITO paCXOllhl npaBHTeJIbCT
Ba MOryr 6bITb 0603HaQeHbI KaK
G=Go
31'03HaQHT, 'ITO
THqeCKHM npolleCCOM. 3TO 3HaQeHHe MO)ICeT 6bITb 60JIbiliOe HJIH MaJIeHbKOe B 3aBHCHMOCTH
OT nOJIHTHKH, HO B HTOre Hac ,lI,OJI)KHO HHTepeCOBaTb JIHlDb TO, HaCKOJIbKO 60JIbIIIHM HJIH Ma
JIbIM OHO 6y,ll,eT H 'ITO HCTOQHHK ero npoHcxo.xmeHH}l MO)KHO HffiOpHpoBaTb.
@j
G BKJIIOQaeT TOJIbKO
yc.ny
.npyroMy.
6e,ll,HblM,
G.
G,
TO HMeIO B BJlllY
NX -
3KcnopmOM.
3TO npocTO 06mHi!: 06beM Bcero 3KcnopTIl MHHyC 06mHH 06'beM Bcero
HMnOPTa 3a onpe,ll,eJIeHHbIA
npoMe~OK BpeMeHH.
Ho noqeMY TOJIbKO
ltUCmblU
NX.
H}lIOT CKY'IHYJO pa6oTy, 06'b}lCH}I}I, nOQeMY B 3TOM paBeHCTBe Hy)KH0 BbIQHTaTb HMnopT H3
3KcnopTIl.
06weD 3a.naQeH CYMMHpoBaHIDI paCXO,ll,OB,lI,JISI BblBe,ll,eHIDI
BBII
}IBJUIeTC}I BbIQHCJIeHHe,
81
)KIfTeJIH ,npyrHX CTPaH (Hepe3H,neHTbI) TOXe MOryI' nOTPaTHTb ,neHbrH Ha Bawy npO,nyKUHJO.
3To
npoHCXO,nHT, KOr,na OHH llJIaTHT BaM 3a TOBaphI, KOTOphIe BhI nOCTaBWlH HM B BH,ne 3KC
EX,
Bee TOBaphI
H ycJIyrH, H HX pacxo,nhI Ha
Oml!lteCmBeHHble
C (CM.
paHee p83,neJI
"c -
He
1M,
OTeqeCTBeHHhIe TOBapbI.
B peJyJIbTare BbI MoxeTe HanHCaTb ypaBHeHHe BBIl, KOTOPoe CYMMHpyeT Bce pacxo,nbI,
nOl'paqeHHbIe Ha OreqeCTBeHHbIe TOBaphl, CJIe.nyJOUlHM 06p830M:
Y = C - 1M + 1+ G + EX
Ho 31'0 paBeHCTBO 06bIqHO HeMHoro neperpynnHpoBbIBaJOT AIUI Toro, qT06h1 nOCTaBHTb
3KcnoPT H HMnoPT O,nHH 3a ,nPYTHM; TOr,na nOJIyqaeTCH CJIe.nyJOUlee ypaBHeHHe:
Y = C + I + G + EX - 1M.
EX - 1M BbIpaxaeT mopzoBblU
EX - 1M n03HTHBHbIit, BbI 3KCnOpTHpyere 60JIbWe,
6atzaHc Baweit
CTPaHbI. Kor,na
3Ty reMY H
50%
NXH3
Y=-C
+ I + G + NX
82
Tor.na
Lf.~
,lVIH
HYX
urryxy.
lPPYKTOB).
3aTeM npe,nnOJIO}KHM, 'ITO qeJIoseK, KOTOPblA BLlpawHltaeT H6JIOKH, JIlo6HT eCTb aneJIbCH
Hbl H XOqeT KYllHTb HX 30 WTYK 3a 30 ,nOM., a TOT, KOTOpbln BLlpaIUHBaeT aneJIbCHHLI, XOqeT
KYllHTb 20 H6JIOK 3a 20 ,nOM. I<iulc.nLIA H3 HHX CqaCTJIHB y,nOBJIeTBOpHTb XeJIaHHe ,npyroro,
nonoMy TOT, KOTOpLln BblpaIUHBaeT H6JIOKH, TPaTHT 30 ,nOM. Ha noKYllKY aneJIbCHHOB y BJIa
,neJIbua aneJIbCHHOBhIX ,nepeBbeB, a TOT, B CBOIO oqepe.zu" TPaTHT 20 ,nOM. Ha noKYllKY 20 H6
JIOK Y BJIa,neJIbua H6JIOHb.
3Ta c,neJIKa HH y KOro H3 yqaCTHHKOB HapeKaHHtt He BbI3L1BaeT, HO eCJIH JIIO,nH HaqHHaIOT
paCCMaTPHBaTb ee C TOqKH 3peHHH
OHH qaCTO npHXO,ngT K OWH60qHOMy BLlBO.D;Y, 'ITO TOJIbKO O,nHOMy H3 yqaCTHHKOB BLlro,nHa 31'8.
c,neJIKa, KOTOPYIO B ,neHCTBHTeJIbHOCTH OHH 06a XeJIaJIH B ,nOCTaTOqHOH Mepe.
)l,JIH Toro qT06L1 YBH,neTb, r,ne HaqHHaeTCH nYTaHHua, npHMHTe BO BHHMaHHe, 'ITO Ha
TaKOBa CTOH
CTOHMOCTh
aneJIbCHHOB. Y TOproBua aneJIbCHHaMH eCTb 110 ,nOM. HaJIH'lHLlMH llJIIOC 20 ,nOM. aneJIbCHHOB H 20 ,nOM. -
B BH,ne
B BH,ne SI6JIOK.
YTBepx.neHHe, 'ITO B pe3YJIb1'8.Te npose,neHHoA ToproBon onepaUHH O,nHH H3 HHX CTaJI 6e,n
Hee, He HMeeT no,n co6on HHKaKHX OCHOBaHHA. B ,nenCTBHTeJIbHOCTH OHH 06a CTaJIH CqaCTJIH
Bee OT npOBe,neHHoit C,neJIKH, He:llCeJIH 6b1JlH ,no Hee, noTOMy 'ITO 3Ta c,ne.rrKa 6hIJla cosepIIIeHa
,n06pOBOJIbHO. ECJIH 6L1 TOproBeu SI6JIOKaMH CTaJI CqaCTJIHsee OT TOro, 'ITO COXpaHHJl H3Ha
qaJIbHLle 100 ,nOM. HaJIHqHLlMH H 50 SIMOK, OH He nOKynaJI 6L1 ane.rrbCHHLI. To xe caMoe
MO}KHO CKaJaTh 0 TOproBue aneJIbCHHaMH.
ma.s
4.
MaKp03KOHOMtf"eClCIfe nOKS38Tentf...
83
3H8
3TO
90 -
nOCJle
Hee, KaxeTCR YJKaCHbIM, noTOMY 'ITO OHH IJ;eJIHKOM nOmOII.J;eHbI TeM, 'ITO TOproBeIJ; RMOKaMH
CTaJI Ha
10 .n:0JIJI.
Ii HX
ern;e 60JIblIIe p83fijJaxaeT, 'ITO B KOHe'lHOM HTOre 10 .n;OJIJI., OK838BIIIHeCR y TOproBIJ;a aneJIb
GHHaMH, npe.n:OCTaBJUlIOT eMY npeHMYlIIeCTBO -
B nepeBo.n:e Ha
.n:eHbrH.
npHBepXeHIJ;bI no.n:06HoH TO'lKH 3peHHR He yqHTbIBaIOT TOT lPaKT, 'ITO 06mee 60raTCTBO
TOproBIJ;a R6JIOKaMH COCTaBJUleT 150 .n:OJIJI. H 'ITO Y Hero Tenepb eCTb TaKOe pacnpe.n:eJIeHHe
aKTHBOB, KOTOpoe ero y.n:OBJIeTBOpReT 6oJIb1IIe, 'IeM TO, KOTOPoe OH HMeJI paHbwe. Ho eCJIH BbI
npHBe.n:eTe 3TOT .n:OBO.n:, TO npOTHBHHKH .n:elPHllIITa cnpocRT Jl8.C: 'ITO npoH30MeT nOCJIe TOro,
KaK TOproBeIJ; R6JIOKaMH C1>eCT CBOH 30 RMOK H 30 aneJIbCHHOB, H nOCJIe TOro, KaK TOproBeIJ;
aneJIbCHHaMH Cl>eCT CBOH 20 R6JIOK H 20 aneJIbCHHoB? B HTOre Bee, 'ITO ocnlHeTCR y TOproB
IJ;eB lPPYKT8MH, 3TO HX HaJIH'lHbIe. nOCKOJIbKY y TOproBI.J;a R6JIOKaMH HaJIH'lHbIX Ha 20 .n;OJIJIa
pOB MeHbwe, 'IeM y BJIa.n;eJIbIJ;a aneJIbCHHOB, OH .n:OJDKeH 6y.n:eT 'lyBcTBOBaTb ce6R xyxe H3-3a
TOproBOro .n:elPHI.J;HTa.
C .n:pyroA CTOpoHbI, 3TO paccyx.n:eHHe ynyCKaeT TOT lPaKT, 'ITO BJIa.n;eJIeIJ; R6JIOK 6bIJI c'Ia
CTJIHBee, COBepWHB c.n:eJIKY H OCTaBIllHCb C 90.n:0JIJI. }{aJIH'lHbIMH, 'IeM eCJIH 6bI OH HH'lero He
MeHRJI H CoxpaHHJI CBOH 100.n:0JIJI. EcJIH 6bI 3TOA c.n:eJIKH He 6bIJIO, OH 6bI npo.n:OJI)I(aJI CH.D:eTb
Ha .n:HeTe H3 O.n:HHX TOJIbKO Ha.n;oeBIIIHX eMY R6JIOK.
OnnoHeHTbI ToproBoro .n:elPHIJ;HTa .n;eACTBHTeJIbHO npe.n:CTaBJUlIOT Bce B Mp,a'lHbIX TOHax,
Kor.n;a OHH Ha'lHHaIOT roBOpHTb 0 TOproBJIe 3eMeJIbHblMH pecypcaMH, 06ycJIoBJIeHHoA Me:llm}'
Hapo.n:HoH ToproBJIeH. ("BbI TOJIbKO nocMQTPHTe, 3TH HHoCTPaHIJ;bI 3axBaTbIB8IOT B8IIIY cTPa
MY!".) QT06bl nOHRTb HX TO'IKY 3peHHR, npe.n:cTaBbTe, 'ITO BMeCTO TOro, 'ITo6bI Ha'laTb CO CTa
.n:OJIJIapoB HaJIH'IHbIX y KIDIOJ,oro, TOproBI.J;bI lPPYKT8MH Ha'IHHaIOT CO eTa aIqJOB 3eMJIH CTOHMO
CTbIO .n:oJIJIap 38 aKp. EzuiHCTBeHHbIA cnoc06 LlJIR BJIa.n;eJIbI.J;a R6JIOHb nOJIyqHTb
10 .n:0JIJI.
HaJIH'I
HbIMH, 'ITo6bI BOCnOJIHHTb cBOA TOproBbIA .n:elPHI.J;HT, 3TO npo.n:aTb 10 aKpoB 3eMJIH BJIa.n;eJIbI.J;y
aneJIbCHHoBOro ca.n;a. 3T0 3Ha'lHT, 06maH CYMM8 c.n:eJIKH, KOTOPYIO OH COBepIIIHT, COCTaBHT
20 RijJIOK llJIIOC 10 aKpOB 3eMJIH o6m:eA CTOHMOCTbIO 30 .n:OJIJI. -
B 06MeH Ha 30 aneJIbCHHOB
B 6YKBaJIbHOM CMbICJIe
3TOro CJIOBa.
~'!!!!rt
84
pe