Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Object 1
A cave mural from China depicting the parable of the burning house while
the Buddha preaches the Saddharma Pundarika Sutra
And what will become of their savings and Sunday trousers after a
revolution
We have nothing much to say.
suffering in this long cycle of birth and rebirth. His worry is whether he will
be able to complete his attainment by becoming a Buddha, a concept
believed in Mahayana Buddhism that the process of Nirvana is completed
only after attaining the Buddhahood.
It is believed in Mahayana that everyone has the capability of attaining this
status. The Buddha responds by saying that Sriputra having got onto the
correct path will in future, after many years, will be destined to be a Buddha
himself. He pronounces that the beneficial wheel of destiny for Sriputra to
reach this goal has already been set in motion. Sriputra is then praised by
all those who are present in the audience, humans, non-humans, gods, nongods etc.
Having been satisfied with his own destiny, Sriputra then raises the issue
of 1200 disciples who are with him. What shall he do to get them also to
attain the supreme bliss of Nirvana? The Buddha relates the parable of the
burning house, explaining the skilful methods to be used to motivate them
to leave the present suffering in worldly living for Nirvana which is free from
suffering.
Says the Buddha to Sriputra: Have I not told thee before, Sriputra, that
the Tathgata preaches the law by able devices, varying directions and
indications, fundamental ideas, interpretations, with due regard to the
different dispositions and inclinations of creatures whose temperaments are
so various? All his preachings of the law have no other end but supreme
and perfect enlightenment, for which he is rousing beings to the
Bodhisattva-course. But, Sriputra, to elucidate this matter more at large, I
will tell thee a parable, for men of good understanding will generally readily
enough catch the meaning of what is taught under the shape of a parable.
Skilful devices needed to motivate people into quick action
In the parable, there is a householder of means who one day returns to his
house to find that its roof is on fire. Inside the house, there are his children
of various ages, from five to 20, playing noisily and paying little attention to
the imminent danger.
The householder calls the children out saying that the house is on fire and
soon they will burn to death if they do not come out immediately. The
children, who are deeply engaged in their merry-making play, do not pay
heed to his calling. The householder then realises that time is passing
pretty fast and unless he does something to take them out, he will lose
them forever.
He designs a tactic which economists call an incentive system to draw their
attention and get them out taking into account the different tastes and
disposition of the children. He announces that those who come out of the
house immediately will get bullock-carts, goat-carts, deer-carts, which are
so pretty, nice, dear, and precious to play outside the house. And the
children on hearing the names mentioned of such playthings as they like
and desire, so agreeable to their taste, so pretty, dear, and delightful,
quickly rush out from the burning house, with eager effort and great
alacrity, one having no time to wait for the other, and pushing each other
on with the cry of Who shall arrive first, the very first? But they all get
disappointed after they come out of the burning house because they all get
only bullock-carts.
False promises can be made provided they arefor the benefit of people
The Buddha asks the question whether the householder has committed
something immoral by uttering a falsehood and misleading the children.
Sriputra answers in the negative by announcing that he uttered that
falsehood in order to save the children from death which was more
important at that particular point of time than looking at the morality of the
false promises he had made.
Economic takeaways from the Buddhas parable
There are several economic takeaways in the Buddhas parable. First,
incentives work to motivate people but they should be designed according
to the taste, disposition, temperament and desires of people.
Second, good governance sometimes permits somebody to lie, if and only if
that lie is uttered not for ones personal benefit but for the benefit of the
people for whom one works. For instance, a physician may lie to a
terminally ill patient simply to boost his morale and give him a last chance
to build his immunity system to fight the deadly disease. The physician
does not seek to gain a benefit from lying.
Third, having made a promise, one should deliver that promise for
otherwise he would not be trusted by people when he makes the same or a
different promise later.
Fourth, a person is credited for the delivery of promises and not for doing so
many other good things to people. Thus, claiming allegiance on the basis of
other good works done will not work unless the promises have been
delivered.
Both parables are useful and relevant to Sri Lankans in the current context
Thus, there are two parables of a burning house. One is by the Buddha in
the Saddharma Pundarika Sutra and the other, a creative interpretation of
same by Brecht. Both are relevant and useful in the current context of Sri
Lanka.
Brechts parable asks Sri Lankan voters to make a decision as fast as
possible having taken into account the dangers, if any, they are facing
today. Postponing the decision by getting into unnecessary arguments and
raising irrelevant questions will only result in losing the valuable time.
The Buddhas parable dictates that those who lie in making promises to
people are justified if and only if they have lied to deliver a benefit to
people and not to accumulate gains for them. It also requires them to
deliver their promises promptly if they are to have the allegiance and trust
of the people. Without delivering promises but doing all other things will not
help them to regain the lost trust of the people.
(W.A Wijewardena, a former Deputy Governor of the Central Bank of Sri
Lanka, can be reached at waw1949@gmail.com )
Posted by Thavam