Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is located on
the World Wide Web at:
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/77/4/477
PEDIATRICS is the official journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics. A monthly publication,
it has been published continuously since 1948. PEDIATRICS is owned, published, and trademarked
by the American Academy of Pediatrics, 141 Northwest Point Boulevard, Elk Grove Village,
Illinois, 60007. Copyright 1986 by the American Academy of Pediatrics. All rights reserved. Print
ISSN: 0031-4005. Online ISSN: 1098-4275.
M Med, PhD,
D. Bowie, MD, FRCP
War Memorial
Childrens
Hospital,
Rondebosch,
were given
combinations
either
to infants
metronidazole,
as single agents
effect
with
that
of the drugs
in the
pretreatment
on apparent
nitrogen
after
diarrhea.
The
between
them
output
during
period.
The
diarrhea
following
1986;77:477-481;
acute
persistent
gastroenteritis.
diarrhea,
Pediatrics
gentamicin,
choles-
tyramine.
Because
the losses of nutrients
from the bowel are
directly
related
to stool
weight,
maintenance
of
nutrition
by the oral route
is usually
not possible
in infants
with fecal losses
exceeding
this value.2
Termination
of the diarrhea
is crucial
in preventing
the vicious
cycle of gastroenteritis
and malnutrition.
A previous,
uncontrolled
trial demonstrated
that
a combination
of oral gentamicin,
metronidazole,
and cholestyramine
therapy
was effective
in stopping persistent
diarrhea
in the majority
of cases.3
The present
study was undertaken
to test this in a
controlled
fashion
and to determine
which
of the
drugs used singly or in combination
was most effective. The effect
of individual
drugs
and combinations of drugs
was assessed
by comparing
the decrease
in stool output
following
the institution
of
treatment.
The effect of individual
drugs on apparent
was
nitrogen
and
also evaluated.
PATIENTS
Most children
admitted
to Red Cross
War Memona!
Childrens
Hospital
in Cape Town with gastroenteritis
have
a self-limiting
illness,
and the
diarrhea
diminishes
after
a few days.
In 10% to
15% of patients,
severe
diarrhea
continues
and requires
therapy
for more than seven days.
Persistent diarrhea
is defined
as a continuing
daily stool
output
exceeding
30 g/kg of body weight
for seven
days after
commencement
of hospital
treatment.
AND
fat
absorption
during
METHODS
Infants
between
the ages of 6 weeks and 1 year
requiring
admission
to the hospital
for dehydrating
diarrhea
were
assessed.
Only
boys were
studied
because
of the ease in separating
urine
and stool
collections.
Infants
with a history
of diarrhea
for
more than 72 hours and any with a history
of having
had diarrhea
or receiving
antibiotics
in the 2 weeks
preceding
the present
illness
were excluded.
None
had kwashiorkor,
marasmic
kwashiorkor,
or any
skin
lesions
associated
with
nutritional
Received
for publication
Jan 31, 1985; accepted
Aug 1, 1985.
Reprint
requests
to (M.D.B.)
Institute
of Child Health,
Red
Cross War Memorial
Childrens
Hospital,
Rondebosch,
7700,
cases.
American
Academy
of Pediatrics.
4005).
Copyright
1986
by
the
treatment
Routine
investigations
deficiencies.
was designated
the same
in all
included
examination
of stool and urine specimens
asites and stool and urine cultures.
Blood
microscopic
for parspecimens
PEDIATRICS
Vol. on
77July
No.11,
4 2012
April 1986
Downloaded from pediatrics.aappublications.org at Indonesia:AAP
Sponsored
477
were
cultured
and
measured
for
serum
electrolytes
the drug
and acid-base
status.
An inadequate
circulating
blood volume,
detected
clinically
by poor peripheral
capillary
perfusion,
was corrected
by rapid infusion
of a plasma
volume
expander
(Haemaccel).
Thereafter, the patients
were managed
in the same way
as
those
without
this
sign.
Severe
metabolic
acidosis
(pH
tially corrected
with intravenous
ate
administration.
nously
to
All
those
circulating
fluid
without
administered
signs
intrave-
of an
inadequate
blood
rows
solution
lated
volume
volume
was
half-strength
Dardextrose
in water.
The calcuof fluid for rehydration
was based
on
in 5%
the clinical
assessment
of dehydration
(ie, 50 mL/
kg if 5% dehydrated
and 100 mL/kg
if 10% dehydrated).
This, together
with a maintenance
volume
of 120 mL/kg/d,
was given at a constant
rate during
24 hours.
Oral
half-strength
Darrows
solution
with
dextrose
was given at three-hourly
intervals
starting three
to 12 hours
after
admission,
and the
intravenous
fluid rate was decreased
as necessary.
The
infants
were
requirements
frequently
reassessed
recalculated
according
and
fluid
to their
prog-
ress. About
24 hours
after
admission,
the oral halfstrength
Darrows
solution
was replaced
with cows
milk formula
feedings.
If the diarrhea
persisted
and
intravenous
fluids were required
to maintain
hydration
on day
based
4, the
formula
feedings
(Isomil)
were
given
changed
in
to a soya-
a volume
of
120
mL/kg/d
equally
divided
into three-hourly
feedings.
On day 5, those infants
still requiring
intravenous
fluid administration
to maintain
hydration
were
selected
for further
study.
From day 5 to 11, they
were nursed
on balance
beds, and stool and urine
were collected
separately.
Stool weight
and apparent
fat
daily.
and
nitrogen
Those
weight
who
greater
than
still
absorption
were
had
diarrhea
30 g/kg
severe
of body
(stool
per
day)
initial
have
na!
bacteriologic
a urinary
stool
pathogen
was excluded
studied
was
screen
tract
from
allocated
infection,
or parasite,
the
study.
to the
showed
a patient
a recognized
next
treatment
drug
478
levels
of each
(capital
letters
TREATMENT
factor
were
the
G, M, or C) or the
OF SEVERE
plus
cholestyramine
metronidazole
eight
possible
gentamicin
(GMC),
(GMc),
(3)
plus
(2) gen-
gentamicin
plus cholestyramine
(GmC),
(4) metronidazole
plus
cholestyramine
(gMC),
(5) gentamicin
(Gmc),
(6)
metronidazole
(gMc), (7) cholestyramine
(gmC),
(8)
no drugs (gmc).
Gentamicin
was given in a dosage
of 50 mg/kg/d
(maximum
360 mg/d)
in six divided
doses for three
days. The dose of cholestyramine
was 1 g every six
hours
and that of metronidazole
was 100 mg every
eight
hours
for
the cholestyramine
five
days.
Care
was taken
to
at least
one
hour
before
give
the
gentamicin
or metronidazole
to avoid possible
binding of the antibacterial
agents.
The nutritional
status of each infant was assessed
by expressing
the fully rehydrated
weight
as a percentage
of expected
weight
for age. The groups were
compared
with respect
to age and nutritional
status
and in the pretreatment
period
(days 5 to 7) with
respect
to daily stool weight
per kilogram
of body
weight
by analysis
of variance.
The effects
of the
drugs
and the interactions
between
them
on the
severity
of the
ing
decline
the
diarrhea
were
in stool
assessed
weight
from
by determin-
pretreatment
levels.
The daily
stool
weight
per kilogram
weight
on days 8, 9, 10, and 1 1 was subtracted
the mean
of the pretreatment
stool
weight
of body
from
of that
individual.
These
results
were
analyzed
in the
standard
way for a 2 x 2 x 2 factorial
design.4
The effect of the drugs on apparent
nitrogen
and
fat
absorption
was
assessed
on a three-day
balance
(days 9 to 11 inclusive)
using multiple
linear regression.5 The dependent
variable
was the percentage
of nitrogen
or the percentage
of fat absorption.
Stool weight
has a marked
effect on each of these
therefore,
it was
included
as a continu-
ous independent
variable.
The factors
gentamicin,
metronidazole,
and cholestyramine
were included
as categorical
variables
(1 when the drug was given
and 0 when it was not).
RESULTS
he
Details
of the groups
are shown
in Table 1. There
were no differences
between
the groups
with regard
to age or percentage
of weight
for age (P > .05).
There
were no differences
in stool weights
between
infant
to be
group
from
presence
tamicin
plus
(1)
to
which
the infant
had been excluded,
and the trial
continued
until 40 infants
had completed
the study.
The study was analyzed
as a 2 x 2 x 2 factorial
with
five replications
(ie, five infants
in each
group).4
The three
factors
were
gentamicin
(G),
metronidazole
(M), and cholestyramine
(C). The
two
metronidazole
were:
bacte-
or a bacteremia,
The
as g, m, or c). The
combinations
variables,2
measured
weight
(expressed
treatment
of the
absence
PERSISTENT
of
the
groups
in the
pretreatment
nor were
there
significant
group
between
those
days.
diarrhea
with
a stool weight
(mean
(days
5 to 7);
SEM).
The
ment
period
changes
within
each
All infants
had severe
of 105.7 8.5 g/kg/d
mean
levels
DIARRHEA
decrease
on days
in stool
weight
8, 9, 10, and
from
pretreat-
11 in the
presence
TABLE
1.
Characteristics
of Infants
in Treatment
Groups
Drug
Characteristic
GMC
Gmc
gMC
gMc
gmC
gmc
Age (mo)
Mean
Range
4.33
3.98
3.50
4.64
5.12
3.62
4.62
1.50-7.40
1.90-5.40
1.80-8.40
2.30-7.60
1.50-9.50
2.30-5.50
1.60-9.60
SEM
0.98
0.66
1.24
1.46
1.68
0.59
1.05
% expected
wt
for age
Mean
Range
73.9
64.4-88.6
65.1-100.8
G, gentamicin;
5.6
4.3
5.9
letters
M, metronidazole;
C, cholestyramine.
TABLE
by the
in Stool
Weights
of a drug
Decrease
2.
Day
47.2
small
(GMC
5.3
3.3
in Infants
on Different
11.5
63.1
9.3
64.4
38.7
15.3
63.3 16.4
11
98.8
49.1
are
13.8
expressed
receiving
the
drug.
as
15.3
the
65.7
mean
to 7) levels
G, gentamicin;
in Table
2. On
treatment
was
The decrease
in
in those infants
compared
with
effects
and
GmC)
compared
with
The
results
on
days
16.7
decrease
76.9
86.1
82.7
91.5
in
14.2
stool
TABLE
weights
15.2
g/kg/d
1 1 were
similar
to those on day 9. The effect of metronidazole treatment
was not significant,
but in those
patients
receiving
metronidazole
(GMC,
GMc, gMc
and gMC) on day 11, the stool weight
was 17.0 g/
3.
15.9
(g/kg/d)
of
Nitrogen
21.5
50.7
51.1
8.7
9.9
15.0
56.5
absence
Stool
14.3
SEM
from
(lower
case
Weight
and
Drug
% Nitrogen
% Fat
Absorption
Absorption
84.19
-.43 (.06)
(stool wt)
(gentamicin)
-3.61
(metronidazole)
(cholestyramine)
R
The partial
Regimen
B1
B,
B,
B4
capital
13.2
15.0
Effect
on Apparent
of genta-
10 and
12.6
73.8 14.6
in the presence
(capital
letter)
and
M, metronidazole;
C, cholestyramine.
The
54.0 11.2
30.2 10.8
12.1
by the
Regimens*
C
10.3
40.0
Drug
81.1
40.2-113.9
drug is indicated
45.3
87.6 12.1
98.4 12.5
Results
of a particular
g, m, or c.
in those
receiving
gentamicin
but not cholestyramine (Gmc and GMc),
28.8 g/kg/d
in those
given
cholestyramine
but
not
gentamicin
(gMC
and
gmC), and 27.9 g/kg/d
in those given neither
(gMc
and gmc).
On day 9 the effect of gentamicin
treatment
was
significant.
The decrease
in stool weight
was 47.6
g/kg
greater
in those
receiving
gentamicin
than
those
not (F,,32 = 9.95; P < .01). The effects
of
cholestyramine
treatment
(26.2 g/kg; F1,32 = 3.01;
P > .05) and metronidazole
treatment
(1.3 g/kg)
were not significant,
and there were no significant
interactions.
6.6
letters
micin treatment
(18.9 g/kg, F,,32 = 2.05; P > .05)
and metronidazole
treatment
(15.5 g/kg,
F1,32 =
1,31; P > .05) were not significant.
The effect
of
cholestyramine
treatment
on day 8 was largely
due
to a significant
interaction
between
cholestyramine
and gentamicin
(F,,32 = 5.75; P < .05). Stool weight
declined
79.2 g/kg/d
in those
who received
both
drugs
7.4
9
10
and absence
of each drug is shown
day 8, the effect of cholestyramine
significant
(F,,32 = 6.08; P < .05).
stool weight
was 32.5 g/kg greater
receiving
cholestyramine
treatment
not
79.9
70.4-90.8
28.3 8.9
pretreatment
(days
letter) of each drug.
those
79.4
63.0-94.0
Administration
g
11.9
78.5
54.4-89.4
82.5
5.00
3.10-9.00
1.05
59.0-101.7
87.1
79.8
64.2-93.9
SEM
*
GmC
GMc
Regimen*
1.70
-2.44
90.31
-.42 (.06)
(3.94)
-6.65
(4.04)
(3.71)
-1.48
(3.80)
(3.73)
-13.51
(3.82)
.60
regression
.61
coefficients
lin-
regression
not
receive
the
drug.
kg higher
than those who did not
Gmc, gmC, gmc).
Between
days 9 and 11, nitrogen
tion
improved
as
the
stool
receive
and
weight
it (GmC,
fat absorp-
decreased.
In
Table
3, the partial
regression
coefficients
for the
multiple
linear
regression
of percentage
nitrogen
and fat absorption
are shown.
Except
for their
effect
on stool weight,
none of the drugs
directly
affected
nitrogen
absorption,
but the administration of cholestyramine
was associated
with a reduction in fat absorption.
ARTICLES
Downloaded from pediatrics.aappublications.org at Indonesia:AAP Sponsored on July 11, 2012
479
gentamicin
treatment
(groups
GMC,
GMc,
GmC,
Gmc) did not have a significantly
greater
decrease
in stool output
in the first 24 hours
of treatment
compared
with those not receiving
gentamicin.
On
DISCUSSION
Prior to treatment,
all of the infants
in this study
had equally
severe
persistant
diarrhea.
The mean
daily stool weight
was more than 100 g/kg of body
weight,
and a previous
study has shown
that at this
magnitude
of diarrhea
nitrogen
and energy
requirements
cannot
be
met
with
oral
nutrient
days
intake.2
Such infants
are in negative
nitrogen
balance
and
apparent
fat absorption
is of the order of 30% of
intake.
Carbohydrate
absorption
is also impaired.6
Termination
of the diarrhea
is essential
if nutrition
is to be maintained.
To assess
the effects
of the drugs,
a 2 x 2 X 2
factorial
method
of analysis
was chosen
to overcome the problem
of having
small numbers
in each
group. Use of this method
allows the main effect of
a particular
drug to be assessed
by comparing
all
patients
receiving
the preparation
with all of those
not receiving
it. In effect, this means
that for each
drug used
in this study
20 patients
receiving
a
particular
drug were compared
with 20 not receiving
it.
During
the first 24 hours
of treatment,
infants
who
received
cholestyramine
treatment
(groups
GMC, GmC, gMC, gmC) had a significantly
greater
decrease
in stool weight
than
those
who did not
receive
the drug (Table
2). Thereafter,
on days 9 to
1 1, although
the
the
difference
decline
was
not
in stool
weight
significant.
was
Infants
greater,
receiving
9 to 11, the
administration
of gentamicin
those
receiving
gentamicin
without
cholestyramine
(groups
GMc
and Gmc)
or neither
drug
(groups
gMc and gmc). The effect on stool weight
of infants
receiving
both
gentamicin
and
cholestyramine
(GMC
and GmC)
compared
with those
receiving
neither
(gMc and gmc) is illustrated
in the Figure.
Metronidazole
treatment
appears
to have little effect on stool weight
either
alone or in combination
with the other drugs.
The
factors
responsible
for the persistence
of
severe
diarrhea
are not entirely
clear. None of the
infants
included
in this study
had a recognized
bacterial
pathogen
in their stools.
A previous
study
using the same criteria
for patient
selection
demonstrated
a grossly
abnormal
overgrowth
of microorganisms
in the small bowel of infants
with diarrhea
persisting
for seven
days
after
admission.7
20
C
H
A
N
G
E
20
_40
S
0
0
6O
80
G
H
I
-100
g
_120
10
d
DAY
OF
HOSPITAL
TREATMENT
Decrease
in stool weight from pretreatment
levels in infants receiving
a combiof gentamicin
and cholestyramine
(-)
and those receiving neither of these drugs
-). Horizontal
line at 0 represents
the mean daily stool weight
(g/kg of body weight!
Figure.
nation
(-
d) of each
480
TREATMENT
group
before
OF SEVERE
starting
treatment.
PERSISTENT
was
accompanied
by a significantly
greater
decrease
in
stool weight
in comparison
to those
not receiving
the drug (Table
2). It appears
that the effect
of
cholestyramine
on day 8 is largely
due to an interaction
with gentamicin.
During
the first 24 hours
of treatment,
the decrease
in stool weight
of infants
receiving
cholestyramine
but
not
gentamicin
(groups
gMC and gmC) was similar
to the effect in
DIARRHEA
Although
the duodenal
microflora
of the infants
in
this study was not investigated,
there is no reason
to believe
it should
be any different
from those
in
the previous
study.
We believe
the bacterial
overgrowth
plays a role in the pathogenesis
of persistent
diarrhea.
The microorganisms
may be directly
involved
by damaging
the intestinal
mucosa.8
Alternatively,
or in addition,
they
may be indirectly
involved
by the elaboration
of toxins
or by deconjugating
and dehydroxylating
the bile salts.8
The
early beneficial
effect noted with the use of cholestyramine
treatment
supports
the indirect
mechanism as a cause
of persistent
diarrhea.
The dominant
role of gentamicin
noted
after
the first 24
hours
of treatment
supports
the view that elimination
of the bacterial
overgrowth
is most important in controlling
ongoing
diarrhea.
As has been noted in a previous
study, the greater
the stool weight
the poorer
is apparent
nitrogen
and fat absorption.2
Nitrogen
and fat absorption
decreased
by about
0.4% with each gram per kilogram of body weight
increase
in stool output
(Table
3). Gentamicin
treatment
had a major
effect
on
stool weight
and indirectly
on apparent
nitrogen
and fat absorption.
As the stool weight
decreased,
apparent
nitrogen
and fat absorption
improved.
No
direct
effect of gentamicin
was noted.
In contrast,
metronidazole
treatment
did not produce
a decrease
in stool
weight;
therefore,
no indirect
effect
on
apparent
nitrogen
and fat absorption
occurred.
Neither was a direct effect noted.
By reducing
stool weight
(Table
2), cholestyramine indirectly
improved
nitrogen
absorption,
but
no direct effect was demonstrated.
The decrease
in
stool weight
also improved
fat absorption,
but the
drug directly
impaired
uptake
of fats (Table
3).
This is not surprising
because
cholestyramine
is a
bile salt-binding
resin. The net effect on fat absorption is a balance
between
the improvement
derived
from the reduction
of stool weight
and the direct
effect
of cholestyramines
impairment
of fat absorption.
By calculation,
a decrease
in stool weight
exceeding
32 g/kg of body weight
per day would
offset
the reduction
in fat absorption
associated
with cholestyramine
treatment.
Between
days 9 and
11, infants
receiving
cholestyramine
had a mean
reduction
in daily stool weight
that was 32 g/kg of
body weight
greater
than
those
not receiving
the
drug (Table
2). On average,
cholestyramine
treatment alone neither
improved
nor impaired
fat absorption.
The overall
effect of gentamicin
and cho-
lestyramine
together
was a marked
reduction
in
daily stool output
and an improvement
in nitrogen
and fat absorption.
It is a minority
of infants
with acute gastroenteritis who go on to have persistent
diarrhea
of the
severity
of the infants
in this study.
In patients
such as these, maintenance
of nutrition
via the oral
route
is not possible
because
of the large
stool
nitrogen
and energy
losses.
Termination
of the
diarrhea
and reduction
of these
losses is essential.
This study has shown
the use of a combination
of
oral gentamicin
and cholestyramine
to be an effective and rapid
means
of achieving
this. It is also
safe and, except for a mild metabolic
acidosis
during
the administration
of cholestyramine,
no complications
have been encountered
in 8 years of using
this treatment.
Measurements
of serum gentamicin
levels in a number
of similar
infants
receiving
oral
gentamicin
in the dose prescribed
have shown
absorption
to be insignificant
(unpublished
data).
It
is recommended
that oral gentamicin
and cholestyramine
be given to infants
with severe,
persistent,
dehydrating
diarrhea
who show
no signs
of improvement
after seven days of hospital
treatment.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This
Research
work was
Council.
supported
by the
Research
South
African
Medical
Associateship
for tech-
REFERENCES
1. Bowie
atrics
2. Mann
3.
MD,
Mann
MD,
MD,
Hill
ID, Peat
tion
in prolonged
1982;57:268-273
Hill ID, Mann
MD,
persistent
diarrhoea
243
4. Snedecor
Ames,
Hill
GW,
Iowa,
Iowa
GM,
diarrhoea
7.
bowel
et al: Protein
in
Bowie
MD:
in infants.
Cochrane
State
infancy.
Successful
S Afr Med
WG:
University
JH: Applied
5. Bottenberg
RA, Ward
sian.
Lackland
AF Base, TX.
Laboratory,
Aerospace
Medical
TDR-63-6,
1963
6.
ID: The
cocktail.
Pedi-
1981;67:920-921
Statistical
Press,
Multiple
and
fat absorp-
Arch
Dis
management
J 1980;58:241Methods,
1967
Linear
6570th
Personnel
Division,
report
Mann
MD,
Hill
ID, Moore
L, et al: Xylose
infants
with
severe
prolonged
diarrhoea.
180;58:598-599
Hill ID, Mann
MD, Moore L, et al: Duodenal
infants
with
acute
and persistent
diarrhoea.
1983;58:330-334
8. Lifshitz
F: The enteric
flora in childhood
rhoea. Am J Clin Nutr
1977;50:1511-1516
of
ed
6.
Regres-
Research
No. PRL-
absorption
S
Afr
in
Med
microflora
in
Arch Dis Child
disease-diar-
ARTICLES
Child
481
Reprints
PEDIATRICS is the official journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics. A monthly publication, it
has been published continuously since 1948. PEDIATRICS is owned, published, and trademarked by the
American Academy of Pediatrics, 141 Northwest Point Boulevard, Elk Grove Village, Illinois, 60007.
Copyright 1986 by the American Academy of Pediatrics. All rights reserved. Print ISSN: 0031-4005.
Online ISSN: 1098-4275.