Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
BlackwellArticle
Original
Science, Ltd
Abstract Canine scabies is a challenging disease to diagnose because sarcoptic mites are hard to find on skin
scrapings. The purpose of this study was to evaluate a serologic enzyme-linked immunosorbant assay (ELISA)
as an aid in the diagnosis of canine scabies. In addition, serum samples were obtained post treatment to determine the duration and persistence of circulating scabies antibodies after resolution of natural infection. Nineteen
dogs diagnosed with sarcoptic mange and 38 control dogs were tested. Sixteen scabies-infested dogs showed
positive pretreatment ELISA results (84.2% sensitivity). Thirty-four control dogs showed negative ELISA results
(89.5% specificity). In the 11 scabies dogs from which multiple post treatment serum samples were obtained,
detectable antibodies were not present 1 month after treatment in four cases, but were present for 14.5 months
post treatment in seven dogs. Our results suggest that this scabies ELISA test is useful in the diagnosis of
canine scabies.
Keywords: dog, ELISA, Sarcoptes scabiei, scabies, serodiagnosis.
INTRODUCTION
Canine scabies is a parasitic skin disease caused by the
mite Sarcoptes scabiei var. canis. The mite is easily
spread by direct contact and so is very contagious.
Clinical signs of scabies infestation can be variable. The
classic presentation is an intensely pruritic dog with
alopecia and crusting involving the ear pinnal margins
and pressure points, but some dogs have the more
vague presentation of a generally pruritic dog with few
or no skin lesions.1,2 Scabies can, therefore, closely
mimic other causes of pruritus such as atopy, food
allergy and flea allergy. The diagnosis of scabies can be
challenging, as mites are found in only 2050% of skin
scrapings from infested dogs.13 Scabies-suspect dogs
are often treated empirically either topically or systemically with acaricidal agents, and a positive response to
treatment is viewed as an indirect way of diagnosing
the disease. Because allergic skin disease has clinical
signs similar to scabies, many pruritic dogs are treated
empirically with acaricides either prior to, or in con-
316
K. S. Lower et al.
Positive serology
Negative serology
Total
Scabies
cases
All
controls
16
3
19
4
34
38
RESULTS
Sera from dogs with scabies
Positive pretreatment ELISA test results were obtained
for 16 of 19 scabies-infested dogs (84.2% sensitivity,
Table 1). The mean converted OD value obtained for
scabies-infected dogs was 53.5% (range SD: 5.7
101.3 30.49%, Fig. 1). Two false-negative results
(converted OD values 5.7 and 14.7%) were from 8-weekold puppies which had symptoms for an unknown
period prior to sampling. One of these puppies had
monthly sequential samples obtained for 3 months
post treatment; all samples showed negative ELISA
results. The third falsely negative result (converted
OD, 17.0%) was obtained from a 5-year-old dog with
a 6-month history of pruritus treated by daily corticosteroid administration (prednisone 12 mg kg1).
Although the pretreatment titre on this dog was initially negative, sequential results were positive at 1
(converted OD, 62.0%) and 2 months post treatment
(converted OD, 33.5%).
In the other nine affected dogs from which multiple
samples were obtained, significantly detectable antibodies were not present 1 month after treatment in
three cases (one 8-week-old puppy, one 12-week-old
puppy and one dog > 6 months of age), but persisted
for 1 month post treatment in one dog (a 12-week-old
puppy) and for 24.5 months post treatment in five
dogs (one 8-week-old puppy, two 12-week-old puppies
and two dogs > 6 months of age) (data not shown, but
available upon request).
Negative control sera
Of 38 control dogs, 34 negative ELISA results were
obtained (89.5% specificity, Table 1). The mean converted OD value for control dogs was 10.0%
(range SD: 048.5 9.61%, Fig. 1). Two positive
results (converted OD values, 20.0 and 31.0%) were
obtained from normal dogs with no history of skin
disease or scabies exposure. No positive results were
obtained from the Demodex dogs. Two positive results
were obtained from atopic dogs with positive intradermal reactions to house dust and/or house dust mite
(Table 2). Of these two dogs, one (converted OD,
29.3%) responded well to allergy hyposensitization
and was never treated for scabies, and the other
(converted OD, 48.5%) was trial treated for scabies
twice (parenteral ivermectin, amitraz dips) with minimal effect; immunotherapy was initiated for this
patient.
317
Positive serology
Negative serology
Total
Statistical analysis
The Fishers exact test revealed a P-value < 0.0001,
confirming a significant association between ELISA
result and case status.
DISCUSSION
Scabies infestation causes the production of measurable antibodies in infested host species.311,1417,19,22 This
study demonstrates that this ELISA test is accurate
in the detection of antibodies to S. scabiei in dogs,
with a sensitivity of 84.2% and specificity of 89.5%.
This is comparable with a recent study carried out in
the UK using the Swedish scabies ELISA test which
analysed sera samples from 13 normal dogs, 12 atopic
dogs and 12 documented scabies dogs (83% sensitivity and 92% specificity).29 In our study, microscopic
identification of scabies mites and/or ova was used to
diagnose infestation, in contrast to other studies in
which clinical signs and response to treatment were used
to confirm the diagnosis in the majority of affected
animals.3,10,11,1416 This may account for the lower
sensitivity and specificity values obtained in this, and
the UK study, compared with the original Swedish
study (sensitivity 92%, specificity 96%).3 Although
diagnosis of scabies by response to treatment is more
Normal /
nonskin
disease
2
8
10
Atopy
Food
allergy
Demodex
Other
(lickgranuloma,
pyoderma)
2
16
18
0
3
3
0
5
5
0
2
2
318
K. S. Lower et al.
Dogs infested experimentally with scabies seroconverted 35 weeks post infection, or 13 weeks after the
onset of clinical signs.4 Sampling of the falsely negative
puppies may thus have occurred during the 13 week
window between onset of pruritus and seroconversion.
Another possible cause for the discordant results may
have been the young age (8 weeks) and immature
immune system of the puppies. A similar finding of
false-negative results in 78-week-old piglets infected
with S. scabiei var. suis was theorized to have been due
to inadequate production of specific antibodies, possibly secondary to interference from high maternal antibodies.11 A potential cause for the falsely negative titre
in the adult dog may have been prior treatment with
corticosteroids, which inhibit T- and B-cell function
and antibody production.27 This dog had clinical disease for 6 months and had been treated with high doses
of steroids. The initial ELISA result was negative, but
sequential samples became positive at 1 and 2 months
post treatment, after steroids had been discontinued.
Seroconversion post treatment in this dog may have
also been related to an increased immune reaction to
antigens released by dead and decomposing mites.18
Lastly, false-negative reactions can be due to laboratory error, such as prolonged storage of nonfrozen sera
samples, samples containing sodium azide, allowing
the chromagen solution or treated plates to be exposed
to light, or allowing plates to dry out between the different stages of the test. Elimination of these latter
potential causes is done by careful sample collection
and storage and by adherence to correct testing protocol. To rule out laboratory error as the cause for the
falsely negative results, duplicate serum samples from
the dogs in question were later resubmitted for repeat
testing and found to have the same results.
Measurable antibodies to scabies mites were found
14.5 months post treatment of natural infestation in
7 of 11 dogs in which antibody levels were followed.
This result is similar to previous studies of experimental
scabies infestation.4,6,8 This finding limits the use of
the scabies ELISA test in the evaluation of scabicidal
treatment efficacy in dogs which have an incomplete
clinical response to therapy.
The specificity of this test was 89.5%, because of four
positive results in negative control dogs which did not
have demonstrable scabies mites on skin scrapings, did
not respond completely to empirical scabicidal therapy
and did respond to noninsecticidal therapy. Inclusion
of more nonpruritic dogs in the control group may
have increased this value, however, use of pruritic
controls gives a more realistic measurement as in clinical use this test would not be performed in nonpruritic
dogs. The most likely reason for false positive results
would be prior exposure to scabies or concurrent
scabies infection in an allergic patient. Prior exposure
is strongly possible as this study shows that in natural
scabies infestation detectable antibodies may persist
for at least 4.5 months after successful treatment. Also,
as animals with allergic skin disease are frequently at
veterinary hospitals and grooming establishments,
2001 Blackwell Science Ltd, Veterinary Dermatology, 12, 315 320
REFERENCES
1. Scott, D.W., Miller, W.H., Griffin, C.E. Muller and Kirks
Small Animal Dermatology, 5th edn. Philadelphia:
W.B. Saunders, 1995: 1213.
2. Griffin, C.E., Kwochka, K.W., MacDonald, J.M. Current
Veterinary Dermatology: The Science and Art of Therapy.
St. Louis, MO: Mosby, 1993: 87.
3. Bornstein, S., Thebo, P., Zakrisson, G. Evaluation of an
enzyme-linked immunosorbant assay (ELISA) for the
serological diagnosis of canine sarcoptic mange. Veterinary Dermatology 1996; 7: 218.
4. Bornstein, S., Zakrisson, G. Humoral antibody response
to experimental Sarcoptes scabiei var. vulpes infection in
the dog. Veterinary Dermatology 1994; 4: 10710.
5. Bornstein, S., Zakrisson, G. Clinical picture and antibody response in pigs infected by Sarcoptes scabiei var.
suis. Veterinary Dermatology 1993; 4: 12331.
6. Arlian, L.G., Morgan, M.S., Vyszenski-Moher, D.L. et al.
Sarcoptes scabiei. The circulating antibody response and
induced immunity to scabies. Experimental Parasitology
1994; 78: 3750.
7. Arlian, L.G., Morgan, M.S., Arends, J.J. Immunologic
cross-reactivity among various strains of Sarcoptes
scabiei. Journal of Parasitology 1996; 82: 6672.
8. Arlian, L.G., Morgan, M.S., Rapp, C.M. et al. The
development of protective immunity in canine scabies.
Veterinary Parasitology 1996; 62: 13342.
9. Morgan, M.S., Arlian, L.G. Serum antibody profiles of
Sarcoptes scabiei infested or immunized rabbits. Folia
Parasitologica (Praha) 1994; 41: 2237.
10. Wallgren, P., Bornstein, S. The spread of porcine sarcoptic mange during the fattening period revealed by
development of antibodies to Sarcoptes scabiei. Veterinary Parasitology 1997; 73: 31524.
11. Bornstein, S., Wallgren, P. Serodiagnosis of sarcoptic
mange in pigs. Veterinary Record 1997; 141: 812.
12. Morsy, G.H., Gaafar, S.M. Responses of immunoglobulinsecreting cells in the skin of pigs during Sarcoptes scabiei
infestation. Veterinary Parasitology 1989; 33: 16575.
13. Hoefling, K.K., Schroeter, A.L. Dermatoimmunopathology of scabies. Journal of the American Academy of
Dermatology 1980; 3: 237 40.
14. Hollanders, W., Vercruysse, J., Raes, S. et al. Evaluation
of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for
the serological diagnosis of sarcoptic mange in swine.
Veterinary Parasitology 1997; 69: 11723.
319
Rsum La gale est une maladie difficile diagnostiquer chez le chien, car les Sarcoptes sont difficiles trouver
sur les raclages cutans. Le but de cette tude tait dvaluer un test ELISA comme aide au diagnostic de la gale
sarcoptique chez le chien. En outre, des prlvements sriques ont t obtenus aprs traitement pour dterminer
la dure et la persistance des anticorps circulants aprs gurison de linfection naturelle. Dix neuf chiens prsentant une gale sarcoptique et 38 chiens contrles ont t tests. Seize chiens infects avaient un test ELISA positif
avant traitement (sensibilit de 84.2%). Trente quatre chiens contrles avaient un test ngatif (spcificit de
89.5%). Chez les 11 chiens galeux pour lesquels des prlvements ont t obtenus aprs traitement, aucun anticorps na t dtect 1 mois aprs le traitement pour 4 cas, mais pour les sept autres chiens des anticorps taient
2001 Blackwell Science Ltd, Veterinary Dermatology, 12, 315320
320
K. S. Lower et al.
encore prsents 1 4.5 mois aprs traitement. Nos rsultats suggrent que ce test ELISA est utile dans le diagnostic
de la gale sarcoptique chez le chien.
Resumen La sarna sarcptica en el perro es una enfermedad de diagnstico difcil debido a la dificultad en
encontrar caros en raspados cutneos. El objetivo de este estudio fue evaluar una prueba de inmunoabsorbente
ligado a enzima (ELISA) como ayuda en el diagnstico de la sarna sarcptica canina. Adems, se obtuvieron
muestras de suero despus del tratamiento para determinar la duracin y la persistencia de anticuerpos circulantes de sarna sarcptica despus de la resolucin de la infeccin natural. Diecinueve perros con un diagnstico
de sarna sarcptica y 38 perros control fueron testados. Diecisis perros infestados mostraron resultados ELISA
positivos antes del tratamiento (84.2% de sensibilidad). Treinta y cuatro perros control mostraron resultados
ELISA negativos (89.5% especificidad). En los 11 perros con sarna sarcptica, de los cuales se obtuvieron
mltiples muestras de suero despus del tratamiento, no se detectaron anticuerpos 1 mes despus del tratamiento
en cuatro casos, pero estuvieron presentes durante 1 a 4.5 meses despus del tratamiento en siete perros. Nuestros
resultados sugieren que la prueba de ELISA para sarna sarcptica es til en el diagnstico de esta enfermedad.
Zusammenfassung Sarkoptesrude beim Hund ist eine diagnostische Herausforderung, weil Sarkoptesmilben
auf Hautgeschabseln schwer zu finden sind. Der Zweck dieser Studie war es, einen serologischen Enzym-linked
immunosorbent Assay (ELISA) als diagnostische Hilfe bei der Sarkoptesrude des Hundes zu bewerten.
Zustzlich wurden nach der Behandlung Serumproben genommen, um die Zeitdauer und Persistenz der zirkulierenden Serumantikrper nach Resolution der natrlichen Infektion zu bestimmen. Neunzehn mit Sarkoptesrude diagnostizierte Hunde und 38 Kontrollhunde wurden getestet. Bei 16 mit Sarkoptes befallenen Hunden
war der ELISA positiv (84.2% Sensitivitt). Bei 34 Kontrollhunden war der ELISA negativ (89.5% Spezifizitt).
Bei den 11 Hunden, bei denen mehrere Serumproben nach der Behandlung entnommen wurden, waren
Antikrper in 4 Fllen einen Monat nach der Behandlung nicht mehr nachweisbar, wurden aber bei 7 Hunden
nach 14.5 Monaten immer noch nachgewiesen. Unsere Ergebnisse deuten darauf hin, dass dieser Sarkoptes
ELISA Test bei der Diagnose von Sarkoptesrude beim Hund ntzlich ist.