Checklist on Evaluating the Effectiveness of

Teaching Material during Presentation Stage

Class

: Year 3

Date

: 21/07/2014 (Day 1)

Time

: 08.45-09.45

Focus Skill : Listening & Speaking

Material

No
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
1
1
2
1
1
1

: Diorama of Water Creature

Item
A. Level
The material is suitable to pupils proficiency level
The material is suitable to pupils interest
B. Content
The material is suitable to pupils culture
The material is suitable to pupils prior knowledge
C. Clarity
The material can be clearly seen
The material can be clearly heard
D. Accessibility
Organization of the content in the material which makes pupils to access easily
E. Practicality
The material is usable in the classroom situation
F. Versatility
The material can be used in more than one situation
The material can be used for different type of pupils
G. Cost Effectiveness
The material is within the budget
H. Durability Impact
The material is strong enough to last long (sturdy)
I. Authenticity
The material is authentic

11

Yes

No

Checklist on Evaluating the Effectiveness of

Teaching Material during Presentation Stage
Class

: Year 3

Date

: 22/07/2014 (Day 2)

Time

: 12.35-01.35

Focus Skill : Reading

Material

No

: Big Book on Fish Facts

Item
A. Level
12

Yes

No

1
2
1
2
1
2
1
1
1
2
1
1
1

The material is suitable to pupils proficiency level

The material is suitable to pupils interest
B. Content
The material is suitable to pupils culture
The material is suitable to pupils prior knowledge
C. Clarity
The material can be clearly seen
The material can be clearly heard
D. Accessibility
Organization of the content in the material which makes pupils to access easily
E. Practicality
The material is usable in the classroom situation
F. Versatility
The material can be used in more than one situation
The material can be used for different type of pupils
G. Cost Effectiveness
The material is within the budget
H. Durability Impact
The material is strong enough to last long (sturdy)
I. Authenticity
The material is authentic

13

Checklist on Evaluating the Effectiveness of

Teaching Material during Presentation Stage
Class

: Year 3

Date

: 23/07/2014 (Day 3)

Time

: 12.05-01.05

Focus Skill : Writing

Material

No
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
1
1
2
1
1
1

: Photo of Blue Whale

Item
A. Level
The material is suitable to pupils proficiency level
The material is suitable to pupils interest
B. Content
The material is suitable to pupils culture
The material is suitable to pupils prior knowledge
C. Clarity
The material can be clearly seen
The material can be clearly heard
D. Accessibility
Organization of the content in the material which makes pupils to access easily
E. Practicality
The material is usable in the classroom situation
F. Versatility
The material can be used in more than one situation
The material can be used for different type of pupils
G. Cost Effectiveness
The material is within the budget
H. Durability Impact
The material is strong enough to last long (sturdy)
I. Authenticity
The material is authentic
14

Yes

No

Checklist on Evaluating the Effectiveness of

Teaching Material during Presentation Stage
Class

: Year 3

Date

: 24/07/2014 (Day 4)

Time

: 10.35-11.35

Focus Skill : Language Arts

Material

: Finger Puppets of Fish & Shark

15

No
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
1
1
2
1
1
1

Item
A. Level
The material is suitable to pupils proficiency level
The material is suitable to pupils interest
B. Content
The material is suitable to pupils culture
The material is suitable to pupils prior knowledge
C. Clarity
The material can be clearly seen
The material can be clearly heard
D. Accessibility
Organization of the content in the material which makes pupils to access easily
E. Practicality
The material is usable in the classroom situation
F. Versatility
The material can be used in more than one situation
The material can be used for different type of pupils
G. Cost Effectiveness
The material is within the budget
H. Durability Impact
The material is strong enough to last long (sturdy)
I. Authenticity
The material is authentic

16

Yes

No

Checklist on Evaluating the Effectiveness of

Teaching Material during Presentation Stage
Class

: Year 3

Date

: 25/07/2014 (Day 5)

Time

: 08.45-09.45

Focus Skill : Grammar

Material

: Video song of Water Creatures

No
1
2
1
2
1
2
1

Item
A. Level
The material is suitable to pupils proficiency level
The material is suitable to pupils interest
B. Content
The material is suitable to pupils culture
The material is suitable to pupils prior knowledge
C. Clarity
The material can be clearly seen
The material can be clearly heard
D. Accessibility
Organization of the content in the material which makes pupils to access

Yes

No

easily
1

E. Practicality
The material is usable in the classroom situation
F. Versatility
17

1
2
1
1
1

The material can be used in more than one situation

The material can be used for different type of pupils
G. Cost Effectiveness
The material is within the budget
H. Durability Impact
The material is strong enough to last long (sturdy)
I. Authenticity
The material is authentic

18