SSRN Id1721029 PDF

!
!
!
!
"#$%&%&'!(&)!"#$#&)%&'!*+#!,%'+*!*-!.(*#/!(&)!%*0!1%&%232!4-/#5!!
6#'(7!4-&0*/38*%-&!(&)!*+#!,-7#!-$!9(*%-&(7!:3/%0;/3)#&8#!
!
!
!!"#$%&#!'(!)*"%+,
M.A. International Law and Settlement of Disputes

United Nations University for Peace!
Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1721029
!"#$%&'(&)'*+%*+,&&&&&!&
&
!"#$%&%'(")*+#&(",-&
&
&
&
&
&
&
./*.'0"12340%1'&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
!"#"$%&'()%*+,"-.(/012030&$2&".(42560%7($28(9":'*8*,*17&
&
&
&
-&
&
&
&
.&
&
&
&
/&
&
-.&
(
(
(
-0(
.-(
.1(
&
45&
&
4.&
(
(
&
4.(
46(
47&
&
05&
(
(
0-(
00(
(
(
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
01(
0/(
0/&
0?&
60&
6?&
1-&
14&
17&
/-&
&
/0&
&
76&
(
(
76(
7/(
*
&
*
?5O-56&
&
../*56#*73&('*+%860*01*9(0#"*%'*.'0#"'(0%1'($*:(;<*=13"4#*('2*>1'0#'0&&
&
;< ='"(>"?",*@-"2:(*3($2(42:"%2$:0*2$,(A*2#"2#6#( (
(
(
B< >"302021(:'"(C"1$,(/*6%&"(*3(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%( (
(
(
A< ='"(E*%-$:0?"(A*2:"2:(*3(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%($28(:'"(!"#@*2#0+0,0:0"#((
!",$:"8(='"%":*(
23 )%*1%"##0?"(4-@,"-"2:$:0*2(
(
&
&
&
&
&
.../*?'2#"-0('2%'8*06#*@A%'%&3&*>1"#B*C1"*9(0#"& &
&
&
&
&
;< ='"(9020-6-(A*%"(A*2&"@:(F"2"%$,,7(
(
(
(
(
B< ='"(9020-6-(A*%"(3*%(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%( (
(
(
(
)3 ;(E*:"(*2(/$20:$:0*2(
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
.D/*56#*E#C%'%0%1'*1C*06#*+%860*01*9(0#"*('2*%0-*A%'%&3&*>1"#**
*******%'*F(0%1'($*>13"0"11&-* &
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
;< E*%-(A%"$:0*2($28(=%$2#-0##0*2($:(:'"(E$:0*2$,(C"?",(
(
(
B< ='"(E$:0*2$,(G2#'%02"-"2:(*3(!01':#($28($2(42:%*86&:0*2(:*(:'"(( (
A$#"(C$H(
A< ;(E*:"(*2(>":"%-02021($(/@"&030&(E6-+"%(*3(C0:"%#(3*%(:'"(9020-6-((
A*%"(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
>< !"?0"H(*3(E$:0*2$,(A$#"(C$H(
(
(
(
(
(
-3 8%$9:;<&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
.3 =*>:"& &
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
43 8"*9$">%,@&"*>&A"B:,+"*&
&
&
&
&
&
03 !@%&A@:$:CC:*%,&
&
&
&
&
&
&
63 =*>'*%,:"&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
13 DE9%*+:*"&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
/3 )'$'<#:"&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
73 F+@%E&G%9:'*,H&)'*+:*%*+"$&D(E:I"J&KLMDJ&M'E+@&D<%E:I"&"*>&&&
+@%&A"I:(:I&
?3 N';+@&D(E:I"& &
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
D/*>1'4$32%'8*+#&(",-&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
;< B%0"3(;2$,7#0#(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
B< 42(A*2&,6#0*2(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
G%H$%18"(I6%4($*.'C1"&(0%1'**
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
D$C@"#%+:I"$&O&!@%<"+:I&
&
&
&
&
&
&
Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1721029
E#C%'%'8*('2*E#C#'2%'8*06#*+%860*01*9(0#"*('2*%0-*A%'%&3&*>1"#<**
:#8($*>1'-0"340%1'*('2*06#*+1$#*1C*F(0%1'($*J3"%-I"32#'4#*
&
! (IJ:K'"(:'021#(H'0&'($%"(2$:6%$,,7("?"%7+*87L#($%"($0%.(3,*H021(H$:"%.(:'"(#"$($28(:'"(#"$(#'*%"<MN(
(
! ID"(2"?"%(O2*H(:'"(H*%:'(*3(H$:"%(62:0,(:'"(H",,(0#(8%7<MP((
&
FP%E&+@%&C",+&,%P%E"$&>%I">%,&C%'C$%&@"P%&#%9;*&+'&Q'EER&"#';+&Q"+%E3&SE'<&+@%&
"I">%<R&+'&+@%&,I:%*I%,J&(E'<&+@',%&+':$:*9&"+&+@%&8"E&+'&+@',%&('E<;$"+:*9&C'$:IRJ&:*IE%",%>&
"++%*+:'*&+'&+@%&%P%ETQ'E,%*:*9&C$:9@+&'(&+@%&Q'E$>U,&<',+&P"$;"#$%&E%,';EI%&@",&:*,C:E%>&
+@%&C;#$:I"+:'*&'(&%>:+%>&P'$;<%,J&+@%&('E<;$"+:'*&'(&I';*+$%,,&Q@:+%C"C%E,&"*>&%P%*&+@%&
CE'>;I+:'*&'(&>'I;<%*+"ER&(:$<,3&!@:,&:*IE%",%>&CE'(%,,:'*"$&"++%*+:'*J&@'Q%P%EJ&:,&
<:*:<"$&Q@%*&I'<C"E%>&Q:+@&+@%&>":$R&@"E>,@:C&Q"+%E&,I"EI:+R&I";,%,&+@',%&'*%&#:$$:'*&
C%'C$%&Q'E$>Q:>%&Q@'&$"IB&#",:I&"II%,,3&D(+%E&"$$J&Q"+%EU,&(;*>"<%*+"$:+R&+'&@;<"*&>:9*:+R&
:,&>:((:I;$+&+'&;*>%E,+"+%3&V"+%E&:,&"&*%I%,,:+R&('E&>'<%,+:I&$:(%&"*>&@R9:%*%J&"*&"9E:I;$+;E"$&
%$%<%*+J&"*&%I'*'<:I&+''$&"*>&%P%*&"&,C:E:+;"$&,R<#'$3&
!@:,&%,,"R&"++%<C+,&+'&I'*+E:#;+%&+'&+@%&'*9':*9&"I">%<:I&>:"$'9;%&,;EE';*>:*9&
Q"+%E&"*>&:+,&I%*+E"$:+R&+'&@;<"*&$:(%3&=+,&C;EC',%&:,&+'&CE'P:>%&:*,:9@+&:*+'&Q@"+&<"R&#%&+@%&
<',+&*'+"#$%&Q"+%E&<"*"9%<%*+&:**'P"+:'*&:*&@;<"*&@:,+'ERH&+@%&;*:P%E,"$&@;<"*&E:9@+&
+'&Q"+%E3&NC%I:(:I"$$RJ&+@:,&%,,"R&,%%B,&+'&';+$:*%&+@%&,';EI%&"*>&I'*+%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&
Q"+%E&"*>&+@"+&E:9@+U,&W<:*:<;<&I'E%X&Y&#'+@&I'*I%C+,&+@"+&@"P%&E%"I@%>&+@%&$%P%$&'(&
C',:+:P%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&=+&+@%*&,;<<"E:Z%,&+@%&E%I%*+&Q'EB&'(&*;<%E';,&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&
W9:P:*9&I'*+%*+X&+'&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&">>E%,,:*9&+@%&Q"R,&:*&Q@:I@&+@%&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&*'E<&:,&,+E%*9+@%*%>&'E&I@"$$%*9%>&#R&+@:,&[;E:,CE;>%*I%3&V:+@';+&"*&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&#'>R&I"C"#$%&'(&%*('EI%<%*+J&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&>%C%*>,&'*&+@%&
"I+:P:+R&'(&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&+'&<"B%&:+,&C@:$','C@:I"$&W;*:P%E,"$:+RX&"&<"++%E&'(&$%9"$&("I+3&
=*%P:+"#$R&"*&%(('E+&$:B%&+@:,&'*%&I"**'+&,+"*>&"$'*%J&#;+&:*,+%">&+"B%,&:+,&C$"I%&:*&"&
@:,+'ER&+@"+&9'P%E*,&:+,&I'*+%*+&"*>&>%+%E<:*%,&:+&C%E,;",:P%*%,,3&K"*R&";+@'E,&@"P%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-&\;,+:*:"*J&=*,+3&.3-3-J&56*:"8(02&J. Getzler, A History of Water Rights at Common Law&1/&].550^3&

&&&&.&Thomas Fuller, Gnomologia: Adages and Proverbs; Wise Sentences and Witty Sayings, Ancient and
Modern, Foreign and British&.4/&]8:#$:'_:(%&.5-5^&]-/4.^3&*
&
&
-&
"++%<C+%>&+'&>%(:*%&WQ"+%E&@:,+'ERX&:*&E%I%*+&R%"E,J&"*>&"&,+;>R&'(&+@%&E%I%*+&C",+&<"R&#%&
@%$C(;$&:*&I'*+%`+;"$:Z:*9&+@%&"E9;<%*+,&+'&I'<%34&V%&#%9:*J&+@%*J&Q@%E%&'+@%E,&$%"P%&'((3&
&
! ./*.F5+KE?>5.KFH&!@%&K'>%E*&D9%&Y&WV"+%E&8;E%";IE"IR&"*>&"&M%Q&a;<"*&G:9@+X&
&
bE#"*:Z"+:'*J&%`C$',:P%&I'*,;<C+:'*&"*>&E%,';EI%&C'$$;+:'*&@"P%&('EI%>&@;<"*&
,'I:%+R&+'&>%P:,%&%P%E&<'E%&:*9%*:';,&Q"R,&+'&%`+E"I+J&+E%"+&"*>&,+'E%&Q"+%E3&!@%&<%+@'>,&
%<C$'R%>&@"P%&#%I'<%&,'&I'<C$%`&+@"+&+'>"R&+@%R&I"*&'*$R&#%&<"*"9%>&#R&"*&"I+'E&Q:+@&
+@%&E%c;:,:+%&+%I@*:I"$&I"C"I:+R3&b*>%E,+"*>"#$RJ&+@:,&:*+E:I"+%&Q'EB&:*P'$P%,&"&I%E+":*&&*#:.(
Q@:I@&9:P%,&+@%&<'>%E*&C%E:'>&"&C'Q%E(;$&%I'*'<:I&>:<%*,:'*30&!@%&@'<%&9'P%E*<%*+&
E%+":*,&+@%&CE:<"ER&E%,C'*,:#:$:+R&('E&+@:,&#;E>%*3&V@%*&+@%&I',+&'(&:*(E",+E;I+;E"$&
>%P%$'C<%*+&#%I'<%,&CE'@:#:+:P%J&@'Q%P%EJ&,+"+%,&<"R&"$,'&>%$%9"+%&,%EP:I%&>%$:P%ER&+'&
CE:P"+%&:*+%E%,+,3&S'E&+@:,&E%",'*&<',+&:*>:P:>;"$,J&'*I%&C%E,'*"$$R&E%,C'*,:#$%&('E&
I'$$%I+:*9&+@%&Q"+%E&E%c;:E%>&('E&>":$R&$:(%J&<;,+&*'Q&C%+:+:'*&"&+6%"$6&%$&7&'(&,+"+%&"*>&
*'*T,+"+%&"I+'E,&('E&"II%,,&Y&"&,:9*:(:I"*+&,+%C&:*&@;<"*&>%P%$'C<%*+3&=*&+@%&%I'*'<:%,&'(&
+@%&d$'#"$&M'E+@J&<',+&WI'*,;<%E,X&,%I;E%&"II%,,&+@E';9@&C"R<%*+3&!@:,&<'>%$&@",&#%%*&
:<:+"+%>&#R&"*>&:*&,'<%&C$"I%,&('EI%>&;C'*&+@',%&>%P%$'C:*9&I';*+E:%,&,%%B:*9&+'&<:<:I&
M'E+@%E*&9E'Q+@36&=*&#'+@&@%<:,C@%E%,J&<'*%R&:,&*'Q&+@%&%",:%,+&]"*>&,'<%+:<%,&+@%&
'*$R^&Q"R&+'&"II%,,&+@%&I$%"*&Q"+%E&*%I%,,"ER&+'&,;,+":*&@;<"*&$:(%31&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&4&!@%&"*"$R,:,&#%$'QJ&Q@:$%&'E:9:*"$J&:,&#",%>&'*&+@%&"*"$R+:I"$&<'>%$,&'(&";+@'E,&$:B%&S%BE:&a",,"*3&a",,"*&#E%"B,&>'Q*&
+@%&$",+&.6J555&R%"E,&:*+'&W+@E%,@'$>,&:*&Q"+%E&@:,+'ERJX&>%<'*,+E"+:*9&+@%&I'T>%P%$'C<%*+&'(&%"E$R&I:P:$:Z"+:'*,&Q:+@&
+@%:E&"CCE'"I@%,&+'&E%,';EI%&<"*"9%<%*+&"*>&CE'P:*9&+@"+&Q"+%E&,@'E+"9%&@",&"$Q"R,&#%%*&"*&%*9:*%&'(&@;<"*&
:**'P"+:'*3&S%BE:&D3&a",,"*J&D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:($28(G$%,7(A0?0,0Q$:0*2#R(3%*-(A**@"%$:0*2(:*(A*23,0&:.(02&History and
Future of Shared Water Resources, .&]bMLN)F&%>3J&.554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOO;*%,>'I3;*%,I'3'E9O:<"9%,O55-4O55-44.O-44.71%3C>(3&F+@%E&";+@'E,&:*P'$P%>&:*&+@%&,"<%&@:,+'E:I"$&"*"$R,:,&
:*I$;>%&K"E+:*&G%;,,J&S0#:*%0&$,(GT@,$2$:0*2($28(D$:"%(4##6"#.&:*&+@%&,"<%&P'$;<%&"+&.53&S'E&"*&:$$;,+E"+:'*&'(&+@%&
%P'$;+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&I'*($:I+&"IE',,&@;<"*&@:,+'ERJ&,%%&9%*%E"$$R&Peter Gleick,&D$:"%(B%0"3(U*6%R(D$:"%(A*23,0&:(
A'%*2*,*17.(02&The Worlds Water 2008-2009: The Biennial Report on Freshwater Resources&-6-&].55?^3&
&&&&0&/""(a",,"*&"+&.&]We!f@%&I',+&'(&CE'I;E:*9&Q"+%E&:,&"&(;*I+:'*&'(&+@%&I'<#:*%>&I',+&'(&%`+E"I+:'*O@"EP%,+:*9J&
+E"*,C'E+"+:'*J&+E%"+<%*+J&,+'E"9%J&"*>&>%$:P%ER3&!@%E%&:,&+@;,&:*%P:+"#$R&"*&%I'*'<:I&",C%I+&'(&Q"+%E&"P":$"#:$:+R3X^3&
&&&&6&!@%&C'$:I:%,&'(&$%*>:*9&:*,+:+;+:'*,&$:B%&+@%&V'E$>&8"*B&"*>&=KS&+E%"+%>&Q"+%E&",&"*&%I'*'<:I&I'<<'>:+RJ&@'C:*9&+@"+&
#R&,%%B:*9&(;$$&I',+&E%I'P%ER&+@%R&Q';$>&>:,T:*I%*+:P:Z%&Q",+%&"*>&CE%,%EP%&E%,';EI%,3&/""(LE:B&83&8$;%<%$J&='"(
4-@,0&$:0*2#(*3(U*%-6,$:021($(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&4-&Ecology L.Q.&?6/J&?1.&].550^3&G%,';EI%&CE:P"+:Z"+:'*&<"R&#%&"&
$%9"$$R&P:"#$%&<'>%$&'(&CE'P:,:'*&:*&,'<%&I:EI;<,+"*I%,J&,;#[%I+&+'&"&,%E:';,&I'*,:>%E"+:'*&'(&C'C;$"+:'*&*%%>,&"*>&,+"+%&
I"C"I:+R3&/""(";+@'EU,&>:,I;,,:'*J(023%$(*3(4603(
&&&&1&V"+%E&CE:I%&@",&#%I'<%&"&B%R&%I'*'<:I&:*>:I"+'E3&/"".("<1<.(U.N. Dev. Programme, Beyond Scarcity: Power,
Poverty and the Global Water Crisis: UNDP Human Development Report 2006&64&(:93&-3-6&].551^3&
&e@%E%:*"(+%E&Report 2006fg(Arnaud Courtecuisse, Agence de lEau Artois-Picardie, Water Prices and
Households Available Income: Key Indicators for the Assessment of Potential Disproportionate Costs Illustration from the Artois-Picardie Basin (France) ].55/^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3#"$Q':,3I'<O#"$Q':,O"><:*:,+E"+:'*O(;$$hC"C%EO((CT7013C>(3&&
&
.&
D+&+@%&#",:,&'(&Q"+%E&#;E%";IE"IR&%`:,+,&"&C'Q%E(;$&"*>&Q%$$T%,+"#$:,@%>&$%9"$&
,+E;I+;E%&(';*>%>&'*&+@%&'E9"*:Z:*9&CE:*I:C$%&'(&,+"+%&,'P%E%:9*+R3/&S'E&<"*R&R%"E,&+@%&
*'E<"+:P%&('I;,&'(&+@:,&$%9"$&,R,+%<&@",&#%%*&+@%&>%P%$'C<%*+&"*>&<"*"9%<%*+&'(&
*"+:'*"$&:*(E",+E;I+;E%J&Q:+@&"*&%<C@",:,&'*&%((:I:%*IR&"*>&CE'(:+"#:$:+R&"I@:%P%>&+@E';9@&
+@%&;,%&'(&+%I@*'$'9RJ&C$"**:*9&"*>&,I:%*+:(:I&>"+"37&!@:,&,+E"+%9R&@",&#%%*&$%9"$$R&
E%:*('EI%>&'*&"&*"+:'*"$&$%P%$&+@E';9@&+@%&C",,"9%&'(&Q"+%E&<"*"9%<%*+&$"Q,J&E:C"E:"*&
,I@%<%,&"*>&I'*,;<%E&I'*+E"I+,3&!@%,%&$"Q,&9'P%E*&WI:P:$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,X&Y&>'<%,+:I&
%*+:+$%<%*+,&9E"*+%>&#R&+@%&,+"+%&Q:+@&"*&"IB*'Q$%>9%<%*+&+@"+&+@%&,+"+%U,&E%,';EI%&
:*+%E%,+,&E%<":*&CE%%<:*%*+3&?&N;I@&"&V%,+C@"$:"*&('I;,&<'E%&%",:$R&C%E<:+,&+@%&
%`CE'CE:"+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&+'&CE:P"+%&I'EC'E"+:'*,&Q@%E%&,%%*&",&,"+:,(R:*9&+@%&*"+:'*"$&
:*+%E%,+3&!@:,&CE:P"+%&I''C%E"+:'*J&+@';9@&"E9;"#$R&*%I%,,"ER&('E&:*(E",+E;I+;E"$&9E'Q+@&:*&
,'<%&I:EI;<,+"*I%,J&'(+%*&(;E+@%E&"$:%*"+%,&:*>:P:>;"$,&(E'<&E%,';EI%&<"*"9%<%*+3&-5&
D+&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$J&+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&"II%,,&E:9@+,&@",&+E">:+:'*"$$R&$"99%>&
#%@:*>&'+@%E&Q"+%E&I'*I%E*,3--&=*&+@%&$",+&,%P%E"$&>%I">%,J&@'Q%P%EJ&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&@",&
#%9;*&+'&I'*,:>%E&+@%&CE'C%E&C$"I%&('E&:*>:P:>;"$,&"*>&I'<<;*:+:%,&Q:+@:*&Q"+%E&
<"*"9%<%*+3&=*:+:"$$RJ&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&"CCE'"I@&<:EE'E%>&I'*I%E*,&('E&%I'*'<:I&
%((:I:%*IR&"*>&CE'(:+"#:$:+R&(';*>&'*&+@%&>'<%,+:I&$%P%$3&N;I@&"*&%<C@",:,&Q",&"+&+@%&@%"E+&
'(&+@%&:*P%,+<%*+&C'$:I:%,&'(&<"['E&$%*>:*9&:*,+:+;+:'*,&>%P%$'C%>&:*&+@%&G%"9"*T!@"+I@%E&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&
&&&&/&!@:,&('I;,&:,&%P:>%*I%>&#R&+@%&CE%C'*>%E"*I%&'(&*"+:'*"$&"*>&$'I"$&$"Q,&9'P%E*:*9&Q"+%E&;,"9%J&"*>&+@%&%`C$:I:+&
CE'+%I+:'*&'(&+%EE:+'E:"$&:*+%9E:+R&"*>&,'P%E%:9*&,+"+%&C'Q%E&#R&%"E$R&Q"+%E&<"*"9%<%*+&$"Q&"+&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$3&S'E&
"&>:,I;,,:'*&'(&+@%&$"++%EJ&,%%(!@'E,+%*&i:%(%E&j&)"+@%E:*%&8Ek$<"**J&B"7*28(/:$:"(/*?"%"012:7R(='"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&
6]4^&Non-State Actors & Intl L.&-74J&-74&].556^3&*
&&&&7&/""(8$;%<%$(#6@%$(*'+%&6J&"+&?6/3&/""&$,#*(1"2"%$,,7&Maude Barlow, Blue Covenant: The Global Water Crisis
and the Coming Battle for the Right to Water&].557^3&
&&&&?&S'E&"&>:,I;,,:'*&'(&>:((%E%*I%,&#%+Q%%*&I:P:$&"*>&@;<"*&E%,';EI%&E:9@+,&,%%(DE[;*&i3&i@">B"J&='"(G-"%1"2&"(*3(D$:"%(
$#($(VS6-$2(!01':L(*2(:'"(D*%,8(/:$1"R(A'$,,"21"#($28(W@@*%:620:0"#.&.1]-^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev.&4/J&05&].5-5^3&&
S'E&"&#",:I&%`C$"*"+:'*&'(&I:P:$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&"*>&+@%:E&*"+:'*"$&"*>&E%9:'*"$&P"E:"+:'*,J&,%%&9%*%E"$$R&Steven Hodgson,
FAO Legal Office, Modern Water Rights: Theory and Practice&].551^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
(+CHOO(+C3("'3'E9O>'IE%CO("'O5-5O"5710%O"5710%553C>(3&
&&&&-5&=*&+@%&>%P%$'C:*9&Q'E$>&+@',%&,';EI%,&*'+&>:E%I+$R&I'*+E'$$%>&#R&9'P%E*<%*+,&Q%E%&I$":<%>&'E&C;EI@",%>&#R&CE'(:+T
+"B:*9&CE:P"+%&:*>;,+ER&"*>&,%I;E%>&Q:+@&$%9"$&('EI%3&d'P%E*<%*+&:*:+:"+:P%,&+'&E%I$":<&+@',%&E:9@+,J&+@%E%#R&%`CE'CE:"+:*9&
CE:P"+%&:*+%E%,+,&"*>&E%:*+E'>;I:*9&>%<'IE"+:I&>%I:,:'*T<"B:*9J&I'*+:*;%&+'&CE'P%&I@"$$%*9:*93&A3<.(D*>E%Q&a'$$"*>J&
A'0,"L#(A*2#:0:6:0*2R(D$:"%(:*(+"($(9$::"%(*3(E$:0*2$,(/"&6%0:7J&Blog: The Transatlantic Dialogue on Climate Change
and Security ]\"*3&.1J&.5-5J&6H6/&AK^.(@++CHOOI$:<"+%,%I;E:+R3#$'9,C'+3I'<O.5-5O5-OI@:$%,TI'*,+:+;+:'*TQ"+%ET+'T#%T
<"++%E3@+<$3&
&&&&--&8';Ec;":*&*'+%,&+@"+&+@%&(:E,+&$'9:I"$&C$"I%&+'&$''B&('E&E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*&Q';$>&#%&+@%&#'>R&'(&%`:,+:*9&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
$"Q&9'P%E*:*9&Q"+%E&<"*"9%<%*+J&#;+&+@"+&+@:,&$"Q&Y&+@';9@&>%P%$'C:*9&CE:*I:C$%,&'(&*'&@"E<&"*>&%c;:+"#$%J&E%",'*"#$%&
;,%&Y&>'&*'+&,;((:I:%*+$R&CE'+%I+&"&E:9@+&+'&C%E,'*"$&"II%,,3&Kurt Bourquain, Freshwater Access from a Human
Rights Perspective: A Challenge to International Water and Human Rights Law&65T60&].557^3&
!@:,&:,&*'+&,;ECE:,:*9J&@'Q%P%EJ&",&#'+@&I;,+'<"ER&"*>&+E%"+R&$"Q&@"P%&$"E9%$R&>%P%$'C%>&+'&<":*+":*&W:*+%E*"+:'*"$&C%"I%&
"*>&,%I;E:+RX&"*>&%*@"*I%&W:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I''C%E"+:'*X&Y&#'+@&I'E%&'#[%I+:P%,&'(&+@%&bM&)@"E+%E3&/""(b3&M3&)@"E+%EJ&"E+3-3&
&
4&
%E"3-.&=*+%ET9'P%E*<%*+"$&>%I$"E"+:'*,&"*>&CE'(%,,:'*"$&'C:*:'*&"$,'&:*:+:"$$R&,;CC'E+%>&
+@:,&C',:+:'*3&!@%&-??.&W2;#$:*&N+"+%<%*+JX&'+@%EQ:,%&"&CE'9E%,,:P%&+E%"+<%*+&'(&Q"+%E&
<"*"9%<%*+J&*'+"#$R&@%$>&+@"+&lQ"+%E&@",&"*&%I'*'<:I&P"$;%&:*&"$$&:+,&I'<C%+:*9&;,%,&"*>&
,@';$>&#%&E%I'9*:Z%>&",&"*&%I'*'<:I&9''>3l-4&D*&%I'*'<:I&+E%"+<%*+&'(&Q"+%E&Q",&"E9;%>&
"+&+@%&+:<%&+'&%*I';E"9%&I'*,%EP"+:'*&#R&W>:,:*I%*+:P:Z:*9X&Q",+%3&&
!@%&%`+%*,:P%&E%"I@&'(&Q"+%E&#;E%";IE"IR&"*>&:+,&*"+:'*"$O:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&
,+E;I+;E%&@",&@">&"&;*:c;%&<%"*:*9&('E&:*>:P:>;"$,J&Q@'&@"P%&#%%*&<'P%>&+'&+@%&C%E:C@%ER&
'(&E%,';EI%&<"*"9%<%*+3&!@%&#:E+@&'(&"&9$'#"$J&(E%%T<"EB%+&%I'*'<R&Q:+@&"*&%<C@",:,&'*&
,+"+%&,'P%E%:9*+R&"*>&%I'*'<:I&%((:I:%*IR&@",&$"E9%$R&CE'@:#:+%>&:*>:P:>;"$,&"*>&
I'<<;*:+:%,&(E'<&"&E'$%&:*&>%I:,:'*T<"B:*9&>;%&+'&+@%:E&I'<C"E"+:P%&%I'*'<:I&Q%"B*%,,3&
V:+@&"&('I;,&'*&I',+&E%I'P%ER&"#'P%&@;<"*&*%%>&"*>&Q:+@';+&+@%&"#:$:+R&+'&:*I'EC'E"+%&
C%'C$%&:*+'&E%,';EI%&C$"**:*9J&+@%&<'>%E*&,R,+%<&:*">%c;"+%$R&CE'+%I+,&+@%&C''E3&
=*(E",+E;I+;E"$&">P"*I%<%*+,&'*I%&@'C%>&('E&@"P%&(":$%>&+'&<"+%E:"$:Z%J&"*>&+@%&*%9$%I+&'(&
:*>:P:>;"$&*%%>&@",&@">&>E"<"+:I&:<C$:I"+:'*,&('E&';E&WQ"+%E&"9%3X&
S:E,+J&]"^&C''E&:*(E",+E;I+;E%&"*>&+@%&%`"I+:*9&CE:I%&'(&Q"+%E&@"P%&+"B%*&"*&
%*'E<';,&+'$$&'*&@;<"*&@%"$+@&"*>&CE'>;I+:P:+R3&=*&,'<%&>%P%$'C:*9&I'*+%`+,J&'P%E&65m&'(&
+@%&C'C;$"+:'*&$"IB,&#",:I&"II%,,3-0&d$'#"$$RJ&*%"E$R&'*%&#:$$:'*&C%'C$%&I"**'+&>E"Q&(E'<&"*&
:<CE'P%>&,';EI%&'(&Q"+%EJ-6&"&E%"$:+R&+@"+&I',+,&+@%&$:P%,&'(&'P%E&+Q'&<:$$:'*&C%'C$%&%P%ER&
R%"E3-1&N'<%&%,+:<"+%&+@"+&Q"+%E&I'$$%I+:'*&+:<%,&"$'*%&I',+&D(E:I"&'P%E&05&#:$$:'*&Q'EBT
@';E,&"**;"$$R3-/&F(&I';E,%J&+@%&#;E>%*&:,&,@';$>%E%>&<":*$R&#R&Q'<%*&"*>&R';*9&9:E$,&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-.&=+&:,&I'<<'*$R&@%$>&+@"+&+@%&*%'T$:#%E"$&C'$:I:%,&'(&+@%&G%"9"*&"*>&!@"+I@%E&9'P%E*<%*+,&IE%"+%>&+@%&:<C%+;,&('E&
<"EB%+T#",%>&>%P%$'C<%*+&$%*>:*9&9%*%E"$$RJ&"*>&+@"+&+@:,&:<C%+;,&<',+&I$%"E$R&<"*:(%,+%>&:+,%$(&:*&Q"+%E&<"*"9%<%*+&
+@E';9@&+@%&:<C',:+:'*&'(&CE:P"+:Z"+:'*&,I@%<%,3&/""(BarlowJ&#6@%$&*'+%&7J&"+&413&
&&&&-4&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&V"+%E&"*>&+@%&L*P:E'*<%*+J&2;#$:*J&=E3J&\"*3&.1T4-J&-??.J&='"(>6+,02(/:$:"-"2:(*2(D$:"%(
$28(/6#:$02$+,"(>"?",*@-"2:<M(CE:*I3&0&"+&/&]-??.^&]leVf"+%E&@",&"*&%I'*'<:I&P"$;%&:*&"$$&:+,&I'<C%+:*9&;,%,&"*>&,@';$>&
#%&E%I'9*:Z%>&",&"*&%I'*'<:I&9''>3&3&3&3&&e=+&:,f&+@%&#",:I&E:9@+&'(&"$$&@;<"*&#%:*9,&+'&@"P%&"II%,,&+'&I$%"*&Q"+%E&3&3&3&"+&"*&
"(('E>"#$%&CE:I%3&3&3&3&K"*"9:*9&Q"+%E&",&"*&%I'*'<:I&9''>&:,&"*&:<C'E+"*+&Q"R&'(&"I@:%P:*9&%((:I:%*+&"*>&%c;:+"#$%&;,%J&"*>&
'(*%*I';E"9:*9&I'*,%EP"+:'*&"*>&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E%,';EI%,3l^3&!@%&+E%"+<%*+&'(&W+@%&#",:I&E:9@+X&+'&Q"+%EJ&Q@:$%&
CE'9E%,,:P%J&Q",&;*>';#+%>$R&<%"*+&+'&#%&E%">&:*&$:9@+&'(&+@%&%I'*'<:I&CE:*I:C$%&'(&I',+TE%I'P%ER3&N%%&8$;%<%$J&#6@%$&
*'+%&6J&"+&?14J&?16J&('E&"&>:,I;,,:'*3&
&&&&-0&N+%C@%*&)3&KI)"((E%RJ&;(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%R(>*-"#:0&($28(42:"%2$:0*2$,(4-@,0&$:0*2#.&6]-^&Geo. Intl Envtl. L.
Rev.(-J&1&]-??.^3&&
&&&&-6&World Health Org. & U. N. Childrens Fund Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply and
Sanitation, Progress in Drinking-water and Sanitation: Special Focus on Sanitation&].557^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3Q@'3:*+OQ"+%Eh,"*:+"+:'*h@%"$+@O<'*:+'E:*9O[<C.557O%*O:*>%`3@+<$3&*
&&&&-1&World Health Organization et al., The Right to Water&1&].554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3Q@'3:*+OQ"+%Eh,"*:+"+:'*h@%"$+@OE:9@+'Q"+%E&e@%E%:*"(+%E&WHO Right to Water]3&&
&&&&-/&Report 2006J&#6@%$&*'+%&1J&"+&-63(
&
0&
Q@'&'(+%*&@'$>&+@%&I;$+;E"$&E%,C'*,:#:$:+R&('E&Q"+%E&I'$$%I+:'*3-7&D$$&I@:$>E%*J&>;%&+'&+@%:E&
>%P%$'C<%*+"$&P;$*%E"#:$:+RJ&"E%&%,C%I:"$$R&"((%I+%>&#R&Q"+%E&,I"EI:+R3&V'E$>Q:>%J&004&
<:$$:'*&,I@''$&>"R,&"E%&$',+&%P%ER&R%"E&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*&E%$"+%>&,:IB*%,,3-?&&
!@%&+@E%"+&+'&@;<"*&>%P%$'C<%*+&:,&I'<C';*>%>&#R&]#^&'P%ET%`+E"I+:'*&"*>&
C'$$;+:'*J&]I^&I%E+":*&%*P:E'*<%*+"$&C@%*'<%*"&$:B%&I$:<"+%&I@"*9%&"*>&]>^&"&,'I:"$&
:*"#:$:+R&+'&%((%I+:P%$R&E%,C'*>&+'&+@%&IE:,:,&"+&@"*>3&.5&&
A'$$;+:'*&"*>&'P%ET%`+E"I+:'*&I'*+:*;%&+'&,+E%,,&E%,';EI%&"P":$"#:$:+R&('E&@;<"*&
,;EP:P"$J&"9E:I;$+;E%&"*>&%I'*'<:I&"I+:P:+R3.-&8'+@&,+%<&(E'<&;*,"(%&"*>&;*,;,+":*"#$%&
"9E:I;$+;E"$&"*>&:*>;,+E:"$&CE"I+:I%,J&..&CE:<"E:$R&"+&+@%&@"*>,&'(&<;$+:T*"+:'*"$&
I'EC'E"+:'*,&:*P'$P%>&:*&$"E9%T,I"$%&("E<:*9&'E&I'<<%EI:"$&"I+:P:+:%,&$:B%&#'++$:*9J&<:*:*9&
"*>&<"*;("I+;E:*93.4&A'$$;+:'*&"*>&'P%ET%`C$':+"+:'*&:EE%P%E,:#$R&>%9E">%&"II%,,:#$%J&
E%*%Q"#$%&E%,';EI%,&('E&@;<"*&I'*,;<C+:'*3.0&&
)$:<"+%&I@"*9%&@",&#%%*&CE%>:I+%>&+'&@"P%&"*&%*'E<';,&9$'#"$&:<C"I+&'*&Q"+%E&
E%,';EI%,3&8R&.5.5J&('E&%`"<C$%J&/6T..5&<:$$:'*&D(E:I"*,&"E%&CE'[%I+%>&+'&%`C%E:%*I%&
I$:<"+%&I@"*9%TE%$"+%>&Q"+%E&,+E%,,3.6&&
S:*"$$RJ&:*>:P:>;"$,&"*>&I'<<;*:+:%,&Y&'*I%&+@%&CE:<"ER&>%I:,:'*T<"B%E,&:*&Q"+%E&
<"*"9%<%*+&Y&"E%&*'Q&,'&"$:%*"+%>&(E'<&+@%&,R,+%<&+@"+&+@%:E&,'I:"$&I'<<'*,&I"*&*'&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-7&48<g&#""($,#*.&Henry Steiner, Philip Alston & Ryan Goodman, International Human Rights in Context: Law,
Politics, Morals&.11&]4E>&%>3&.557^3&
&&&&-?&Report 2006J&#6@%$(*'+%&1J&"+&063&
&&&&.5&!@%&"$+%E*"+:P%&<'>%$&'(&Wa;<"*&2%P%$'C<%*+JX&>%P%$'C%>&CE:<"E:$R&#R&2E3&K"@;#&;$&a;cJ&@",&,:*I%&#%I'<%&"&
I'<<'*C$"I%&+%E<&:*&>%P%$'C<%*+&%I'*'<:I,&"*>&Q:$$&#%&;,%>&Q:>%$R&:*&+@:,&+%`+3&S'E&"*&%`C$"*"+:'*&'(&:+,&'E:9:*,&"*>&
I'*+%*+&,%%&9%*%E"$$R(U.N. Dev. Programme, Human Development Report 1990: The Concept and Measurement
of Human Development(]-??5^<&
&&&&.-&/""(1"2"%$,,7J&Report 2006J&#6@%$(*'+%&13(
&&&&..&LP%*&:*&+@%&>%P%$'C%>&Q'E$>J&"9E:I;$+;E%&:,&+@%&CE:<"ER&,';EI%&'(&C'$$;+:'*&('E&"c;:(%E,J&+@%&$"E9%,+&,';EI%,&'(&
9E';*>Q"+%E&('E&>'<%,+:I&;,%3&=*>;,+E:"$&C'$$;+:'*&<":*$R&+"E9%+,&,;E("I%&E%,';EI%,3&Joan Goldstein, Demanding
Clean Food and Water: The Fight for a Basic Human Right&-./&]-??5^3&
&&&&.4&K;$+:*"+:'*"$&I'EC'E"+:'*,&:*P'$P%>&:*&+@%&C'$$;+:'*&'E&'P%ET%`+E"I+:'*&'(&E%,';EI%,&Q%E%&E%,C'*,:#$%&('E&,'<%&'(&+@%&
(:E,+&$%9"$&#"++$%,&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&/"".("<1<.(Maike Gorsboth, FoodFirst Information and Action Network,
Identifying and Addressing Violations of the Human Right to Water: Applying the Human Rights Approach&
-.&%+&,%c3&].551^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3(:"*3'E9OE%,';EI%,O>'I;<%*+,O'+@%E,O:>%*+:(R:*9T"*>T">>E%,,:*9TP:'$"+:'*,T
'(T+@%T@;<"*TE:9@+T+'TQ"+%EOn,%"EI@+%E<o:>%*+:(R:*9m.5"*>m.5">>E%,,:*9&]';+$:*:*9&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&,+E;99$%,&:*P'$P:*9&
M%Q<'*+&K:*:*9&)'ECJ&)'I"T)'$"&)'EC3&"*>&)'*,'EI:'&a:>E'%*%E9p+:I'&>%$&_:+'E"$^&
&&&&.0&=+&,@';$>&#%&*'+%>&+@"+&+@%&Q'E$>&:,&*'+&WE;**:*9&';+&'(&Q"+%EX&:*&"&$:+%E"$&Q"R3&=*&("I+J&+@%&9$'#"$&Q"+%E&,;CC$R&("E&
';+Q%:9@,&@;<"*&I'*,;<C+:P%&*%%>,&#R&+@';,"*>,&'(&+:<%,3&!'>"RU,&>:,+;E#:*9&+E%*>&:*P'$P%,&+@%&:EE%C"E"#$%&
>%*:9E"+:'*&'(&+@',%&"II%,,:#$%J&E%*%Q"#$%&E%,';EI%,&'(&9E';*>&"*>&,;E("I%&Q"+%E&]'(&Q@:I@&@;<"*,&"$E%">R&%`C$':+&'P%E&
65m^&+@E';9@&C'$$;+:'*J&,:*B:*9J&"*>&>%,%E+:(:I"+:'*3&S'E&"&>:,I;,,:'*&,%%(Peter GleickJ&)"$O(D$:"%.&02&The Worlds
Water 2008-2009: The Biennial Report on Freshwater Resources&-J&6&].55?^3&
&&&&.6&=*+%ETd'P%E*<%*+"$&A"*%$&'*&)$:<"+%&)@"*9%&e=dA))fJ&A,0-$:"(A'$21"(PXXYR(/72:'"#0#(!"@*%:&65&]M'P3&-/J&.55/^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3:CII3I@OC>(O",,%,,<%*+TE%C'E+O"E0O,REO"E0h,RE3C>(3&
&
6&
$'*9%E&<'>:(R&:+,%$(&+'&I@"*9%,&:*&,;CC$R3.1&=*&+@%&KLMD&E%9:'*J&"*&"E%"&:*&Q@:I@&<',+&
I';*+E:%,&"E%&I$",,:(:%>&WQ"+%E&,I"EI%JX&,'I:"$&%P'$;+:'*&"$$'Q%>&('E&+@%&">%c;"+%&
>:,+E:#;+:'*&'(&E%,';EI%,&('E&*%"E$R&6555&R%"E,3./&!'>"RJ&,@'E+"9%&:,&I'<<'*C$"I%3&!@%&
"$:%*"+:'*&'(&;,%E,&+@E';9@&+@%&:<C',:+:'*&'(&#;E%";IE"IRJ&Q@:$%&*%I%,,"ER&('E&9E'Q+@J&
#RC",,%,&@;<"*:+RU,&:*#'E*&I'C:*9&<%I@"*:,<,&('E&E%,';EI%&,I"EI:+R3&D,&"P":$"#$%&
E%*%Q"#$%&"*>&*'*TE%*%Q"#$%&E%,';EI%,&@"P%&>Q:*>$%>&'P%E&+@%&$",+&I%*+;ERJ&9$'#"$&Q"+%E&
I'*,;<C+:'*&@",&E:,%*&,:`T('$>J&"+&"&E"+%&+Q:I%&+@"+&'(&C'C;$"+:'*&9E'Q+@3.7&V"+%E&;,%&:,&
CE'[%I+%>&+'&E:,%&#R&05m&:*&+@%&*%`+&+Q'&>%I">%,&"$'*%3.?&&
&
!@%&@'C%&('E&+@%&:*>:P:>;"$&"+&+@%&@%"E+&'(&WQ"+%E&#;E%";IE"IRX&I'<%,&Q:+@&+@%&
,:<;$+"*%';,&>%P%$'C<%*+&'(&"&@;<"*&E:9@+,&C"E">:9<3&S'E&+@%&(:E,+&+:<%J&:*>:P:>;"$,&"E%&
'((%E%>&"&<%I@"*:,<&('E&+@%&E%>E%,,&'(&+@',%&P:'$"+:'*,&"9":*,+&+@%:E&@;<"*&>:9*:+R&'*I%&
I'<<:++%>&Q:+@&:<C;*:+R3&!@%&@;<"*&E:9@+,&"CCE'"I@&:*P'$P%,&%<C@",:Z:*9&,+"+%&
E%,C'*,:#:$:+R&:*&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&*"+;E"$&%*+:+$%<%*+,&Y&$:B%&#",:I&"II%,,&+'&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&
Y&+'&+@%&"#,'$;+%&%`+%*+&C',,:#$%&Q:+@';+&>:,IE:<:*"+:'*3&!@:,&%<C@",:,&<"B%,&,+"+%,&#'+@&
C'$:+:I"$$R&"*>&$%9"$$R&"II';*+"#$%&Q@%*&+@%R&(":$&+'&<%%+&+@%:E&'#$:9"+:'*,345&D,&,;I@J&+@%&
@;<"*&E:9@+,&"CCE'"I@&,%%B,&+'&IE:+:I"$$R&E%('E<&+@%&E%$"+:'*,@:C&#%+Q%%*&+@%&I:+:Z%*T
,+"B%@'$>%E&"*>&+@%&,+"+%J&"*>&+'&%*,@E:*%&+@:,&+E"*,('E<"+:'*&:*+'&#:*>:*9&$"Q3&a;<"*&
E:9@+,&$"Q&:,&(:E,+&>%P%$'C%>&"+&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$&Y&%,+"#$:,@:*9&%*+:+$%<%*+,&+@"+&"E%&
%,,%*+:"$$R&W;*:P%E,"$X&Y&"*>&:,&+@%*&+E"*,$"+%>&+@E';9@&+E%"+RJ&I;,+'<&"*>&*"+:'*"$&
$%9:,$"+:'*&:*+'&$'I"$$R&#:*>:*9&,+"*>"E>,&'(&,+"+%&#%@"P:'E3&&
=*&+@%&<:>T-??5,J&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'<<;*:+R&#%9"*&+'&IE:+:I:Z%&+@%&E'$%&'(&<"EB%+&
%I'*'<:I,&:*&E%,';EI%&CE'P:,:'*&",&:*">%c;"+%&('E&+@%&%c;:+"#$%&,"+:,("I+:'*&'(&@;<"*&
*%%>3&=+&Q",&#%$:%P%>&+@"+&CE:'E&Q"+%E&<"*"9%<%*+&@">&<">%&CE'P:,:'*&+'&+@%&C''E&I',+T
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.1&V"+%E&$:<:+"+:'*,&:*&a",,"*U,&<'>%$J&('E&%`"<C$%J&('EI%>&*"+;E"$&I@"*9%,&:*&C'C;$"+:'*&*;<#%E,J&I'*I%*+E"+:'*J&
"I+:P:+R&"*>&<:9E"+:'*3&/""(a",,"*.(#6@%$(*'+%&4J&"+&.T43&
&&&&./&/""&2"P:>&83&8E''B,J(S6-$2(!01':#(:*(D$:"%(02(E*%:'(;3%0&$($28(:'"(9088,"(G$#:R(D'$:(0#(E"H($28(D'$:(0#(E*:Z(D'$:(0#(
4-@*%:$2:($28(D'$:(0#(E*:.(.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev&../J&../T.7&].55/^3&KLMD&:,&+@%&K:>>$%&L",+&"*>&M'E+@&D(E:I"3&
&&&&.7&!@%&9$'#"$&C'C;$"+:'*&,+"*>,&"+&"CCE'`:<"+%$R&137&#:$$:'*&"*>&:,&CE'[%I+%>&+'&:*IE%",%&;CQ"E>,&'(&.&#:$$:'*&#R&.5653&
/""(U. N. Dept of Econ. and Soc. Affairs, The Word at Six Billion,&b3M3&2'I3&LNDOAOVA3-60&]-???^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*3'E9O%,"OC'C;$"+:'*OC;#$:I"+:'*,O,:`#:$$:'*O,:`#:$$:'*3@+<J&$#(-*8030"8(+7&U. N. Dept of Econ. and
Soc. Affairs, World Population Prospects: the 2008 Revision&b3M3&2'I3&N!OLNDONLG3DO.7/&].557^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOO%,"3;*3'E9O;*C>OQCC.557OC%C,h>'I;<%*+,3@+<3&
&&&&.?&/""(Report 2006,(#6@%$&*'+%&1J&"+&-46T-473&!@%&b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&%,+:<"+%,&+@"+&#R&.565J&'P%E&-36&#:$$:'*&C%'C$%&I';$>&
$:P%&:*&Q"+%E&,I"EI%&"E%",&'(&$%,,&+@"*&-J555&I;#:I&<%+%E,&C%E&C%E,'*J&Q%$$&#%$'Q&+@%&-J/55&I;#:I&$:+%E,&E%c;:E%>&('E&
"9E:I;$+;E%J&:*>;,+ERJ&%*%E9R&"*>&+@%&%*P:E'*<%*+J&48<("+&-6-J&(:93&0343(
&&&&45&GorsbothJ&#6@%$&*'+%&.4J&"+&-3&
&
1&
CE'@:#:+:P%J&E%,;$+:*9&:*&+@%&:<<%*,%&@;<"*&,;((%E:*9&';+$:*%>&"#'P%3&N$'Q$R&+@%E%&9E%Q&"&
9%*%E"$&>:,+E;,+&'(&'$>&>%P%$'C<%*+&C'$:I:%,J4-&"*>&+@:,&,@:(+&(E'<&<"EB%+T#",%>&
9$'#"$:Z"+:'*&+'&"*&%<C@",:,&'*&I:P:$&,'I:%+R&I;$<:*"+%>&Q:+@&I"$$,&('E&+@%&E%I'9*:+:'*&'(&"&
W*%QX&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E34.&D,&Q:+@&"*R&'+@%E&@;<"*&E:9@+,T#",%>&$%9"$&%*+:+$%<%*+J&+@%&
E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&E%c;:E%>&"&(';*>"+:'*&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&#%('E%&:+&I';$>&#%&>'<%,+:I"$$R&
",,%E+%>3&!@%&$%9"$&%*('EI%"#:$:+R&'(&"&;*:P%E,"$&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&E%<":*%>&>;#:';,J&
@'Q%P%EJ&",&Q"+%E&Q",&*'+&%`C$:I:+$R&<%*+:'*%>&:*&+@%&I'P%*"*+&%*,@E:*:*9&,:<:$"E&,'I:'T
%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3&&
&
!"#"$%&'()%*+,"-.(/012030&$2&".(42560%7($28(9":'*8*,*17(
&
S'E+;*"+%$RJ&"&E%I%*+&CE'$:(%E"+:'*&:*&+@%&*;<#%E&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>%I$"E"+:'*,&"*>&
:*,+E;<%*+,&+E%"+:*9&Q"+%E&",&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&*'Q&CE'P:>%,&,'<%&$%9"$&I@"$$%*9%&+'&+@:,&
:*:+:"$&:*>%+%E<:*"IR3&=*&("I+J&,+"+%&CE"I+:I%J&$%9"$&'C:*:'*&"*>&+E%"+R&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&"$$&
I;EE%*+$R&C':*+&+'Q"E>&+@%&%`:,+%*I%&'(&"*&:*>%C%*>%*+J&;*:P%E,"$&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:*&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&!@%&<',+&@%$C(;$&$%9"$&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@:,&E:9@+&:,&(';*>&:*&d%*%E"$&
)'<<%*+&-6&'(&+@%&b3M3&)'<<:++%%&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,&])LN)G^3&44&!@%&
)'<<:++%%U,&";+@'E:+"+:P%&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*J&:*&I$"E:(R:*9&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,&;*>%E&+@%&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'P%*"*+&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,&]=)LN)G^J&,%+,&
E%c;:E%<%*+,&'(&c;"$:+RJ&"P":$"#:$:+R&"*>&"II%,,:#:$:+R3&=+&"$,'&';+$:*%,&+@%&E:9@+U,&
:<<%>:"+%$R&%*('EI%"#$%&W<:*:<;<&I'E%X&Y&"&I'*I%C+;"$&+''$&>:,+:*9;:,@:*9&%`:9%*+&,+"+%&
'#$:9"+:'*,&(E'<&+@%&'+@%EQ:,%&CE'9E%,,:P%&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+340&&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&4-&D&I'*,%*,;,&>%P%$'C%>&:*&+@%&<:>T&+'&$"+%T?5,&+@"+&"$$'Q:*9&%I'*'<:I,&+'&>%+%E<:*%&Q"+%E&CE'P:,:'*&Q:+@';+&
I'*,:>%E"+:'*&('E&@;<"*&*%%>&Q",&I";,:*9&,%E:';,&,;((%E:*9J&E%,;$+:*9&:*&"&9%*%E"$&>:,+E;,+&'(&'$>&>%P%$'C<%*+&C'$:I:%,&
"*>&"&*%Q&('I;,&'*&@;<"*&E:9@+,3&8$;%<%$J&#6@%$(*'+%&6J&"+&?143&&
&&&&4.&S'E&";+@'E,&$:B%&\"RR';,:J&+@%&%<%E9%*I%&'(&"&@;<"*&E:9@+,&"CCE'"I@&+'&Q"+%E&:,&%P:>%*I%&'(&+@%&('EI%,&'(&I:P:$&,'I:%+R&
9$'#"$:Z"+:'*&#"$"*I:*9&Q:+@&+@%&<"EB%+T#",%>&9$'#"$:Z"+:'*&Q@',%&>'<:*"*I%&+'&+@:,&C':*+&:,&>%<'*,+E"+%>&#R&+@%&
>'<:*"*I%&'(&Q"+%E&:,,;%,&#R&%I'*'<:I&:*,+:+;+:'*,3&F>%@&"$&\"RR';,:J&D$:"%($#($(S6-$2(!01':R(=*H$%8#(A0?0,(/*&0":7(
F,*+$,0Q$:0*2.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev. 4.?J&445T4-&].55/^3&
&&&&44&)'<<:++%%&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,&e)LN)GfJ&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6H&!@%&G:9@+&+'&V"+%EJ&q.J&b3M3&2'I3&
LO)3-.O.55.O--&]\"*3J&.5J&.554^J&"+&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@I@E3I@O+#,O>'I3*,(O5O"6067>->-##>/-4(I-.61II05547?%?0nFC%*>'I;<%*+&e@%E%:*"(+%E&d)-6f3&
&&&&40&)LN)GJ&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&4H&!@%&M"+;E%&'(&N+"+%,&A"E+:%,U&F#$:9"+:'*,J&q-0J&b3M3&2'I3&aG=OdLMO-OG%P31&"+&-0&]2%I3&-0J&
-??5^J&"+&@++CHOOQQQ3;*@I@E3I@O+#,O>'I3*,(O5O?0#>#"(6?#04"0.0I-.614%>556.#110nFC%*>'I;<%*+&e@%E%:*"(+%E&
d)4f3&
&
/&
=*>:P:>;"$,&"*>&I'<<;*:+:%,&("I%>&Q:+@&"&$"IB&'(&"II%,,&+'&,;((:I:%*+J&,"(%J&"II%,,:#$%&
"*>&"II%C+"#$%&,';EI%,&'(&Q"+%E&('E&C%E,'*"$&I'*,;<C+:'*&E%c;:E%&$'I"$&"II%,,&+'&+@:,&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&,+"*>"E>&>%P%$'C%>&('E&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&+@%:E&>:9*:+R3&!@%&;E9%*IR&'(&
+@%:E&*%%>&:,&CE'P%*&#R&+@%&,%E:';,*%,,&'(&+@%&@;<"*&IE:,:,&';+$:*%>&"#'P%3&_%9"$&%`C%E+,&
@"P%&#%%*&#;,R&">"C+:*9&@;<"*&E:9@+,&+'&+@%&Q'EB&'(&Q"+%E&"II%,,&CE'+%I+:'*&:*&*"+:'*"$&
I';E+E''<,J46&"*>&E%I%*+&I",%,&(E'<&"&P"E:%+R&'(&[;E:,>:I+:'*,&@"P%&CE'P%*&+@"+&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
"E%&*'Q&[;,+:I:"#$%341&b*('E+;*"+%$RJ&+@%&#%*%(:+&'(&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&$:<:+%>&#R&+Q'&
:*+%EE%$"+%>&("I+'E,3&S:E,+J&+@%&$%9"$&,+"*>"E>&Y&>%,C:+%&:+,&*'E<"+:P%&>%P%$'C<%*+&"+&+@%&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$&Y&("I%,&*"+:'*"$&%*('EI%<%*+&I@"$$%*9%,&,+%<<:*9&(E'<&"*&"#,%*I%&'(&
";+@'E:+"+:P%&+E"*,T*"+:'*"$&I",%&$"Q3&S'E&+@:,&E%",'*&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&'(+%*&$"IB,&
+@%&$%9"$&>%+%E<:*"IR&'(&I:P:$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&%P%*&Q@%E%&%`C$:I:+$R&:*I'EC'E"+%>&:*+'&
>'<%,+:I&$"Q3&N%I'*>$RJ&Q@%*&I@'',:*9&+'&",,%E+&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&#",%>&'*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
*'E<,J&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&"E%&$%(+&Q:+@&"*&'C%*&I'*I%C+;"$&,C"I%&('E&WI'*+%*+T9:P:*9JX&",&Q"+%E&
E:9@+,&"E%&*'+&"T@,0&0:,7&>%$:*%"+%>&:*&"*R&+E%"+R34/&!@:,&I'*I%C+;"$&,C"I%&%`:,+,&"$'*9,:>%&
+@%&:*+%ECE%+"+:P%&CE'#$%<,&'(&WCE'9E%,,:P%&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*X&("I%>&#R&"$$&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&
E:9@+,3&!@:,&>;"$&$:<:+"+:'*&:,&+@%&E%,%"EI@&CE'#$%<&+@%&CE%,%*+&%,,"R&,%%B,&+'&:*P%,+:9"+%3&&
!@:,&%,,"R&Q:$$&('I;,&%*+:E%$R&'*&+@%&;*:P%E,"$&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&$%"P:*9&"&<'E%&
+@'E';9@&:*P%,+:9"+:'*&'(&+@%&,+"+%TI%*+E:I&Q"+%E&<"*"9%<%*+&C"E">:9<&"*>&:+,&$%9"$&
,+E;I+;E%&+'&'+@%E&";+@'E,347&&!@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&+@%&<',+&*'+"#$%&Q"+%E&
<"*"9%<%*+&:**'P"+:'*&:*&<'>%E*&@:,+'ERJ&",&:+&,%%B,&+'&C$"I%&+@%&:*>:P:>;"$&#"IB&"+&+@%&
I%*+%E&'(&E%,';EI%&<"*"9%<%*+3&!@%&9'"$&'(&+@:,&%,,"R&:,&+'&I$"E:(R&+@%&$%9"$&I'*+%*+&'(&+@:,&
E:9@+&Y&:*I$;>:*9&:+,&<:*:<;<&I'E%&Y&"*>&+'&%`C$'E%&+@%&Q"R&:*&Q@:I@&*"+:'*"$&
[;E:,CE;>%*I%&('E&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&WQ"+%E&E:9@+,X&:*+%E"I+,&Q:+@&+@:,&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&46&=*&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,J&+@%E%&@",&#%%*&"&E%I%*+&,@:(+&(E'<&"*&"#,+E"I+J&:>%'$'9:I"$&,+%E%'+RC:*9&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&",&
:*[;,+:I:"#$%&'E&$%,,T%*('EI%"#$%&+'Q"E>&"*&:*P%,+:9"+:'*&'(&+@%&+%I@*:I"$&"*>&[;E:,>:I+:'*"$&:,,;%,&+@"+&Q';$>&C%E<:+&+@%:E&
$:+:9"+:'*3&/""(1"2"%$,,7(!"E"&\3&K%$:,@J&!":'02O021(:'"(IC"##($#(9*%"M(='"#0#R(/6@%$2$:0*2$,(C0:01$:0*2(*3(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,(
$28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#(02(:'"(;-"%0&$#.&4?].^&N.Y.U. J. Intl L. & Pol3&-/-&].551^3&*
&&&&41&=*9$"&V:*B$%EJ&[680&0$,(G23*%&"-"2:(*3(:'"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%R(A$#"(C$H(3%*-(/*6:'(;3%0&$.(;%1"2:02$($28(4280$&
_"QJ&.557]-^&L. Soc. Just. & Global Dev. J. -J&-6 ]FI+3&?J&.557^J&
@++CHOOQQQ.3Q"EQ:IB3"I3;BO("IO,'IO$"QO%$[O$9>O.557h-OQ:*B$%EO3&V:*B$%EU,&E%P:%Q&'(&*"+:'*"$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
[;E:,CE;>%*I%J&+@';9@&$:<:+%>J&:,&"&@%$C(;$&C$"I%&+'&#%9:*&"*&:*P%,+:9"+:'*&'(&[;E:,CE;>%*+:"$&,+"*>"E>,&"*>&Q",&,%<:*"$&+'&
+@%&E%,%"EI@&('E&+@:,&%,,"R3&
&&&&4/&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'P%*"*+&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&2%I3&-1J&-?11J&??4&b3M3!3N3&4&e@%E%:*"(+%E&=)LN)Gf3&
&&&&47&DI">%<:I&:*P%,+:9"+:'*,&'(&+@%&@:,+'ER&"*>&$%9"$&,+E;I+;E%&'(&+E">:+:'*"$J&,+"+%TI%*+E:I&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:*I$;>%&d%+Z$%EU,J&
#6@%$&*'+%&-J&a'>9,'*U,J&#6@%$(*'+%&?J&D*+@'*R&NI'++&j&d%'E9:*"&)';,+"$:*J&='"(G?*,6:0*2(*3(D$:"%(!01':#.(46]0^ Nat. Res.
J.&7.-&]-??6^J&"*>&P"E:';,&'+@%E&Q'EB,&I'*I%*+E"+:*9&'*&+@%&*"+:'*"$J&E%9:'*"$&'E&I'<C"E"+:P%&9%*%,:,&'(&I:P:$&Q"+%E&
E:9@+,3&
&
7&
I'*,+E;I+3&D*&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%&:*+%E"I+:'*&#%+Q%%*&>'<%,+:I&"*>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&
,@';$>&"$$'Q&+@%&E%">%E&+'&#%&<'E%&,%*,:+:P%&+'&+@%&(;+;E%&Q'EB&'(&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&:*&Q"+%E&
E:9@+,&%*('EI%<%*+3&NC%I:(:I"$$RJ&:+&,@';$>&("I:$:+"+%&"*&:*IE%",%>&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%&
E%">%EU,&$%9"$&%*+:+$%<%*+,&"+&"*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$J&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&*'E<"+:P%&>%P%$'C<%*+&
'(&+@%,%&%*+:+$%<%*+,&"*>&+@%&P"E:';,&Q"R,&:*&Q@:I@&:*>:P:>;"$&,+"+%,&"E%&#';*>&+'&E%,C%I+&
+@%<3&!@E';9@&+@%&Q'EB&'(&+@:,&%,,"RJ&+@%&E%">%E&,@';$>&"$,'&I'<%&+'&;*>%E,+"*>&@'Q&
*"+:'*"$&%*('EI%<%*+&@",&CE'<'+%>&'E&I@"$$%*9%>&+@%&I'*I%C+;"$&:*+%9E:+R&'(&+@%,%&
%*+:+$%<%*+,&:*&+@%&E%I%*+&C",+3&!@:,&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&:,&<%"*+&+'&#%*%(:+&%P%ER'*%&Y&
,+"B%@'$>%EJ&$"QR%E&'E&[;>9%&Y&:*P'$P%>&:*&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&$:+:9"+:'*&#R&"$$'Q:*9&+@%&
WI'*+%<C'E"ER&@:,+'ERX&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&+'&9;:>%&(;+;E%&%*('EI%<%*+&%(('E+,3&
!@%&02:"%2$:0*2$,(@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&Q:$$&(:*>&+E;%&<%"*:*9&+@E';9@&+@%&Q'EB&'(&
2$:0*2$,&I';E+,&:*&"&Q"R&'+@%EJ&(;$$R&I'>:(:%>&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&@"P%&*'+3&=(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&
Q"+%E&:,&+'&#%&I'*,:>%E%>&"&;*:P%E,"$&E:9@+J&+@%&:*+%9E:+R&'(&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&*'E<&
<;,+&#%&E%:*('EI%>&"*>&*'+&Q%"B%*%>&:*&:+,&*"+:'*"$&"CC$:I"+:'*3&S'E&+@:,&E%",'*J&+@%&
CE:*I:C$%&E%,%"EI@&c;%,+:'*&('E&+@%&CE%,%*+&%,,"R&",B,J&WV@"+&:,&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&",&"&
I'*,+E;I+&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"QJ&"*>&@'Q&@",&+@:,&I'*I%C+&#%%*&+E%"+%>&#R&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,nX&
!@%&:*c;:ER&:,&;*>';#+%>$R&"&I'<C$%`&'*%J&"*>&:+&<"R&#%&@%$C(;$&+'&';+$:*%&,%P%E"$&'+@%E&
c;%,+:'*,&;*>%EC:**:*9&+@%&CE'I%%>:*9&"*"$R,:,3&
S:E,+H&V@"+&:,&+@%&;*:P%E,"$&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&#'+@&",&"&+@%'E%+:I"$&:**'P"+:'*&:*&
@;<"*&E:9@+,&"*>&",&"&C',:+:P%&*'E<&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Qn&V@"+&:,&+@%&,';EI%&"*>&I'*+%*+&
'(&,;I@&"&E:9@+J&"*>&Q@"+&%*"#$%,&:+&+'&Q:+@,+"*>&+@%&I@"$$%*9%&'(&CE'9E%,,:P%&
:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&("I%>&#R&'+@%EJ&%`C$:I:+$R&I'>:(:%>&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,n&
&
N%I'*>H&V@"+&:,&+@%&I'*I%C+&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%n&V@"+&:,&:+,&$%9"$&(;*I+:'*&"*>&
I@"E"I+%E&:*&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&%*('EI%<%*+n&K'E%&,C%I:(:I"$$RJ&Q@"+&:,&+@%&<:*:<;<&
I'E%&('E&"&;*:P%E,"$&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&"*>&Q@"+&C;EC',%&>'%,&:+&,%EP%&Q:+@:*&+@%&$"E9%E&
Q"+%E&E:9@+,&C"E">:9<n&
&
!@:E>H&a'Q&>'&,+"+%,&"II%,,&"*>&CE'<'+%&+@:,&*%Q&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<&:(&:+&E%<":*,&
;*I'>:(:%>n&a'Q&>'%,&+@%&Q'EB&'(&,+"+%,&:*&"CC$R:*9&"*>&:*+%ECE%+:*9&+@%&;*:P%E,"$&@;<"*&
E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:*($;%*I%&+@%&C',:+:'*&'(&,+"B%@'$>%E,&]#'+@&"+&@'<%&"*>&"#E'">^&"*>&"((%I+&
+@%&I'*I%C+;"$&:*+%9E:+R&'(&+@%&*'E<&:+,%$(n&
&
?&
&
S:*"$$RH&a'Q&@"P%&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&+E%"+%>&+@%&;*:P%E,"$&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:*&+@%:E&
>'<%,+:I&%*('EI%<%*+&'(&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,&P:,TrTP:,&,+"B%@'$>%E,n&a",&E%I%*+&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&
"II%,,%>&'E&:9*'E%>&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>n&=,&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<&,;CC'E+%>&'E&
I@"$$%*9%>&#R&+@:,&>%P%$'C:*9&I",%&$"QJ&"*>&Q@"+&Q:$$&+@:,&<%"*&('E&:+,&(;+;E%&"CC$:I"+:'*n&
N%I+:'*,&==&"*>&===&'(&+@:,&%,,"R&Q:$$&';+$:*%&+@%&$%9"$&*'E<&,;EE';*>:*9&+@%&;*:P%E,"$&
@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&:+,&<:*:<;<&I'E%J&+E"I:*9&+@%:E&,';EI%,&"*>&>%(:*:*9&#'+@&+@%:E&
I'*+%*+&"*>&I'EE%,C'*>:*9&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,3&!@:,&Q'EB&:,&$"E9%$R&>%,IE:C+:P%J&"&+E">:+:'*"$&
%`%EI:,%&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&I'*,+E;I+:'*&+@"+&"++%<C+,&+'&c;"$:+"+:P%$R&';+$:*%&"*&%`:,+:*9&
E;$%&'(&$"Q&#R&>E"Q:*9&(E'<&:+,&$%9"$&,';EI%,&"*>&>%+%E<:*:*9&:+,&I'*+%*+&Q:+@&"&P:%Q&
+'Q"E>&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*,%*,;,&E%$"+%>&+'&+@%&E:9@+3&&W)'*,%*,;,X&:,&%P:>%*I%>&#R&
,+"+%,U&;,%&'(&*"+:'*"$&"*>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&C'$:+:I"$&>%I$"E"+:'*,J&"9E%%<%*+,&"*>&$"Q,&:*&+@%:E&
+E%"+<%*+&'(&@;<"*&E:9@+,J&;*>%E$R:*9&:,,;%,J&'E&%P%*&E%$"+%>&E:9@+,&"*>&'#$:9"+:'*,3&V@%E%&
>:,,%*+&%`:,+,J&:+&:,&*'+%>&Q:+@&"*&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&+@"+&"&>:P%E,:+R&'(&'C:*:'*&<"R&,+:$$&,;CC'E+&
+@%&$%9"$&%`:,+%*I%&'(&"&E:9@+&Q:+@';+&"I@:%P:*9&;*:('E<:+R3&N;I@&"&E%,%"EI@&<%+@'>'$'9R&:,&
I'<<'*&:*&@;<"*&E:9@+,&$:+%E"+;E%3&
!@%&Q'EB&'(&N%I+:'*&==&Q:$$&>E"Q&(E'<&+@%&(';E&W+E">:+:'*"$X&,';EI%,&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
$"QH&#:*>:*9&I'*P%*+:'*J&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I;,+'<J&9%*%E"$&CE:*I:C$%&'(&$"QJ&"*>&+@%&'C:*:'*&'(&
$%9"$&%`C%E+,34?&D$+@';9@&CE%P:';,&%(('E+,&+'&';+$:*%&+@%&9$'#"$&I'*,%*,;,&,;EE';*>:*9&
Q"+%E&E:9@+,&Q:$$&CE'P%&:*>:,C%*,:#$%J&+@:,&I'*,%*,;,&I'*+:*;%,&+'&>%P%$'C&,:9*:(:I"*+$R3&
N%I+:'*&==&Q:$$&+@%E%('E%&>E"Q&"*%Q&(E'<&+@%&b3M3&!E%"+R&N%E:%,J&+@%&+%`+,&'(&E%I%*+&
>%P%$'C<%*+&I'*(%E%*I%,J&b3M3&E%,'$;+:'*,J&,+"+%&>%I$"E"+:'*,&"*>&$%9:,$"+:'*J&,I@'$"E$R&
E:9@+,&I'*,+E;I+:'*,J&+@%&E%C'E+,&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&",,'I:"+:'*,J&"*>&+@%&<%>:"3&V@%E%&
*%I%,,"ERJ&+%`+,&Q:$$&#%&C"E+:"$$R&E%CE'>;I%>3&!@%,%&,';EI%,&Q:$$&#%&"I">%<:I"$$R&"*"$RZ%>&
('E&+@%:E&$%9"$&I'*+%*+&"*>&+@%&Q"R,&:*&Q@:I@&+@:,&I'*+%*+&<'>:(:%,&'E&IE%"+%,&'#$:9"+:'*,&#R&
Q@:I@&,+"+%,&<"R&#%I'<%&#';*>3&D&$"E9%&*;<#%E&'(&%`C%E+&"I">%<:I&"*"$R,%,&Q:$$&#%&
E%(%E%*I%>&:*&",,%,,:*9&+@:,&$%9"$&%((%I+&"*>&:<C'E+"*I%3&2;%&+'&+@%&*"+;E%&'(&"&E:9@+&+'&
Q"+%E&",&"&W*%QX&@;<"*&E:9@+,&%*+:+$%<%*+J&:+&:,&C',,:#$%&+'&I'*,:>%E&"$$&E%$%P"*+&$%9"$&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&4?&!@%&(';E&+E">:+:'*"$&,';EI%,&"E%&+"B%*&(E'<&DE+:I$%&47&'(&+@%&N+"+;+%&'(&+@%&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)';E+&'(&\;,+:I%J&6?&N+"+3&-54-&
]W"3&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*P%*+:'*,J&Q@%+@%E&9%*%E"$&'E&C"E+:I;$"EJ&%,+"#$:,@:*9&E;$%,&%`CE%,,$R&E%I'9*:Z%>&#R&+@%&I'*+%,+:*9&
,+"+%,g&#3&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I;,+'<J&",&%P:>%*I%&'(&"&9%*%E"$&CE"I+:I%&"II%C+%>&",&$"Qg&I3&+@%&9%*%E"$&CE:*I:C$%,&'(&$"Q&
E%I'9*:Z%>&#R&I:P:$:Z%>&*"+:'*,g&>3&,;#[%I+&+'&+@%&CE'P:,:'*,&'(&DE+:I$%&6?J&[;>:I:"$&>%I:,:'*,&"*>&+@%&+%"I@:*9,&'(&+@%&<',+&
@:9@$R&c;"$:(:%>&C;#$:I:,+,&'(&+@%&P"E:';,&*"+:'*,J&",&,;#,:>:"ER&<%"*,&('E&+@%&>%+%E<:*"+:'*&'(&E;$%,&'(&$"Q3X^3&
&
-5&
,';EI%,&C%E+":*:*9&+'&+@%&E:9@+3&!@:,&<"B%,&"*&'#[%I+:P%&"*>&Q%$$T(';*>%>&$%9"$&[;,+:(:I"+:'*&
('E&+@%&E:9@+&Y&:*I$;>:*9&"&>%+%E<:*"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+U,&,I'C%&"*>&I'*+%*+&Y&C',,:#$%&@%E%3&
N%I+:'*&===&Q:$$&:*+E'>;I%&+@%&I'*I%C+&'(&"&W<:*:<;<&I'E%X&('E&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&
9%*%E"$$R&"*>&%`C$":*&+@%&I'*+%*+&'(&,;I@&"&I'E%&('E&Q"+%E3&K;I@&'(&+@:,&,%I+:'*U,&$%9"$&
"*"$R,:,&Q:$$&#%&#",%>&'*&"&,R*+@%,:,&'(&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&4&"*>&-6&Y&";+@'E:+"+:P%&
,;<<"E:%,&'(&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,&;*>%E&+@%&=)LN)G3&D,&:*&N%I+:'*&==J&+@:,&#",:I&(E"<%Q'EB&Q:$$&
#%&($%,@%>&';+&Q:+@&E%(%E%*I%&+'&+@%&I;EE%*+&$%9"$&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%&W<:*:<;<&I'E%JX&
:*I$;>:*9&+E%"+R&$"QJ&I;,+'<J&9%*%E"$&CE:*I:C$%&"*>&%`C%E+&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*3&G%I%*+&,I@'$"E$R&
+E%"+<%*+&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&Q:$$&@%$C&'E:%*+&+@%&I'*I%C+&Q:+@:*&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&
:*+E'>;I:*9&#'+@&:+,&C;EC',%&"*>&$:<:+"+:'*,3&!%I@*:I"$&E%C'E+,&'*&Q"+%E&c;"*+:+R&"*>&
c;"$:+R&Q:$$&"$,'&#%&I'*,:>%E%>J&",&+@%,%&<"R&9:P%&;,&"&#%++%E&:>%"&'(&Q@"+&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&
('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&<:9@+&<%"*&:*&CE"I+:I%3&&
S:*"$$RJ&N%I+:'*&=s&Q:$$&E%P:%Q&*"+:'*"$&I",%&$"Q&('E&:+,&E%I%*+&+E%"+<%*+&'(&+@%&
@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&I'*I%C+3&!@%&Q'EB&'(&N%I+:'*&=s&:,&#'+@&
8"#&%0@:0?"&Y&(":+@(;$$R&E%IE%"+:*9&+@%&$%9"$&,+"*>"E>,&>%P%$'C%>&:*&*"+:'*"$&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&Y&
"*>&"?$,6$:0?"&Y&I'<C"E:*9&+@%,%&$%9"$&,+"*>"E>,&+'&'*%&"*'+@%E&"*>&+'&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
*'E<&';+$:*%>&:*&,%I+:'*,&==&"*>&===3&!@E';9@&>:E%I+&E%(%E%*I%J&>%,IE:C+:P%&%`C$"*"+:'*&'E&
(''+*'+%J&N%I+:'*&=s&I'*,:>%E,&*%"E$R&%P%ER&E%I%*+J&*'+"#$%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&[;>9<%*+3&
!@%&"*"$R,:,&:*&N%I+:'*&=s&:,&$"E9%$R&#",%>&'*&"&+@%'E%+:I"$&(E"<%Q'EB&'(&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<&IE%"+:'*&"*>&+E"*,<:,,:'*J&Q@:I@&,%%B,&+'&;*>%E,+"*>&+@%&Q"R,&:*&
Q@:I@&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<,&(:*>&%((%I+:P%&CE'+%I+:'*&+@E';9@&+@%:E&*"+:'*"$&%*('EI%<%*+J&
%P%*&Q@%*&*'+&>:E%I+$R&+E"*,(%EE"#$%3&!@%&E%,%"EI@&:*P'$P%>&:,&c;"$:+"+:P%J&",&#'+@&+@%&
E%$"+:P%&C";I:+R&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&"*>&+@%&>:P%E,:+R&'(&$%9"$&("I+'E,&
>:((%E%*+:"+:*9&*"+:'*"$&,R,+%<,&$:<:+,&%((%I+:P%&>"+"&<:*:*93&=+&:,&*'+&+@%&9'"$&'(&+@:,&%,,"RJ&
@'Q%P%EJ&+'&%`@";,+:P%$R&';+$:*%&+@%&Q"R&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&@"P%&+E%"+%>&+@%,%&I'*I%C+,&:*&
E%I%*+&R%"E,3&!'&>'&,'&Q';$>&E%c;:E%&"*&"*"$R,:,&I"C"#$%&'(&"CCE%@%*>:*9&+@%&<'+:P"+:'*,&
'(&%"I@&I';E+&:*&c;%,+:'*J&+@%&C$"I%<%*+&'(&%"I@&I';E+&Q:+@:*&:+,&*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&'E>%EJ&+@%&
,R<C@'*R&'(&$"QJ&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'<<:+<%*+,&"*>&C'$:+:I"$&CE%,,;E%,&%`%E+:*9&:*($;%*I%&'*&
+@%&I';E+U,&Q'EBJ&*'+&+'&<%*+:'*&+@%&P",+&"<';*+&'(&,%C"E"+%&#;+&E%$"+%>&I",%&$"Q&Q@:I@&
<"R&@"P%&"*&:<C"I+3&D$+@';9@&*'*%&'(&+@%,%&("I+'E,&:,&:9*'E%>&#R&+@%&CE%,%*+&%,,"RJ&
%`@";,+:P%&I'*,:>%E"+:'*&'(&+@%,%&c;%,+:'*,&:,&#%++%E&$%(+&+'&,I@'$"E,&"*"$RZ:*9&+@%&
&
--&
+E%"+<%*+&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&#R&+@%:E&*"+:'*"$&[;>:I:"E:%,&02(@$%:0&6,$%<&D+&<',+J&N%I+:'*&=s&:,&
E%,+E:I+%>&+'&I'*,:>%E:*9&c;%,+:'*,&'(&*"+:'*"$&%*('EI%<%*+&:*&"&<;I@&<'E%&$:<:+%>&Q"RJ&
>E"Q:*9&"&(%Q&>%,IE:C+:P%&,;99%,+:'*,&('E&(;E+@%E&%P"$;"+:'*&"*>&E%,%"EI@3&
N%I+:'*&=s&Q:$$&#%9:*&Q:+@&"&+@%'E%+:I"$&'P%EP:%Q&'(&*'E<&+E"*,<:,,:'*&(E'<&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&+'&*"+:'*"$&I';E+E''<,3&!@:,&"*"$R,:,&Q:$$&>E"Q&@%"P:$R&(E'<&@;<"*&
E:9@+,&+@%'ER3&G:9@+T+'TQ"+%E&I",%&$"Q&(E'<&,%P%E"$&[;E:,>:I+:'*,&Q:$$&+@%*&#%&"*"$RZ%>&('E&
+@%&Q"R&:*&Q@:I@&:+&,;CC'E+,&'E&I@"$$%*9%,&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&*'E<,&,;EE';*>:*9&Q"+%E&
E:9@+,3&K"*R&'(&+@%,%&I",%,&Q:$$&#%&>E"Q*&(E'<&$:+:9"+:'*&9;:>%,&CE%C"E%>&#R&$%9"$&":>&MdF,J&
I'<C"E"+:P%&$"Q&"*"$R,%,J&"*>&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&<%>:"3&8%I";,%&$:+:9"+:'*&9;:>%,&"E%&'(+%*&
$:<:+%>&:*&>%+":$&'E&$"IB&+@%&<',+&I;EE%*+&[;E:,CE;>%*I%J&I';E+&E%C'E+%E,&"*>&%$%I+E'*:I&
>"+"#",%,&Q:$$&"$,'&#%&I'*,;$+%>3&)",%&$"Q&Q:$$&#%&"*"$RZ%>&Q:+@&+@%&@%$C&'(&,%I'*>"ER&
,';EI%,&:*I$;>:*9&$"Q&E%P:%Q,&"*>&I",%&#E:%(,3&=*&,%P%E"$&C$"I%,J&+@%&'E:9:*"$&$:+:9"+'E,&Q:$$&
#%&",B%>&+'&I'*+E:#;+%&#R&#E:%(&'E&,;CC'E+:*9&>'I;<%*+"+:'*3&F+@%E&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&I",%&
$"Q&Q:$$&#%&I'*,:>%E%>&Q@%E%&*%I%,,"ER&+'&%,+"#$:,@&I'*+%`+3&
=*&+@%&%*>J&:+&,%%<,&+@"+&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&:+,&<:*:<;<&I'E%&<"R&CE'P%&
%,C%I:"$$R&;,%(;$&:*&<'P:*9&@;<"*&:*+%E%,+&(E'<&+@%&C%E:C@%ER&'(&E%,';EI%&<"*"9%<%*+&
#"IB&+'&:+,&I%*+%E3&!@%&,;II%,,&'(&+@:,&9'"$J&@'Q%P%EJ&@:*9%,&+'&"&9E%"+&%`+%*+&'*&+@%&
CE"I+:I"$&;*:P%E,"$:+R&'(&+@%&*'E<&:*&c;%,+:'*3&S'E&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&+'&%`:,+&",&"&
$%9"$&("I+J&"&A"B:,+"*:&<'+@%E&<;,+&#%&9;"E"*+%%>&+@%&,"<%&,+"*>"E>&'(&CE'+%I+:'*&",&"&,$;<&
>Q%$$%E&:*&\'@"**%,#;E93&V%&<;,+&B*'Q&:(&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&@"P%&#%%*&Q:$$:*9&+'&">'C+&+@%&
(;$$&>%(:*:+:'*&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%J&:*&+@%:E&[;E:,CE;>%*I%3&V@%*&
+@%R&@"P%&>'*%&,'J&Q%&<;,+&",B&:(&+@%:E&;,%&'(&+@%&I'*I%C+&@",&E%CE'>;I%>&'E&>:,+'E+%>&+@%&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>3&&
&
! ../*56#*73&('*+%860*01*9(0#"*%'*.'0#"'(0%1'($*:(;<*=13"4#*('2*>1'0#'0&
&
&
!'&I'*I:,%$R&>%(:*%&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&I"*&#%&,'<%Q@"+&
CE'#$%<"+:I3&05&!@:,&:,&>;%&+'&:+,&'<:,,:'*&(E'<&+@%&<"['E&E:9@+,TCE'+%I+:*9&I'P%*"*+,&'(&+@%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&05&=+&,@';$>&#%&*'+%>&#%('E%&CE'I%%>:*9&+@"+&+@:,&C"C%E&;,%,&+@%&+%E<&WQ"+%E&E:9@+,JX&WE:9@+&+'&Q"+%EX&"*>&W@;<"*&E:9@+&
+'&Q"+%EX&:*+%EI@"*9%"#$R3&&!@%&;,%&'(&+@%,%&C@E",%,&+'&,:9*:(R&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&,"(%J&,;((:I:%*+&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&:,&
,;CC'E+%>&#R&+@%:E&;,%&:*&,I@'$"E$R&C;#$:I"+:'*,J&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&E%,'$;+:'*,&"*>&)LN)G&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,3&/"".("<1<.(
&
-.&
$",+&@"$(TI%*+;ER3&=*&("I+J&"*&:*P%,+:9"+:'*&'(&+E%"+R&$"Q&E%P%"$,&+@"+&We+f@%E%&"E%&*'t&
:*,+E;<%*+,&+@"+&9;"E"*+%%&"II%,,:#$%J&9''>&c;"$:+R&Q"+%E&:*&">%c;"+%&,;CC$R&",&"&
(;*>"<%*+"$&@;<"*&E:9@+3X0-&M'*TI'>:(:I"+:'*J&@'Q%P%EJ&>'%,&*'+&:<C$R&+@"+&,;I@&"&E:9@+&
>'%,&*'+&%`:,+J&*'E&+@"+&:+&:,&;*"IB*'Q$%>9%>&'E&;*CE'+%I+%>&#R&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&:*&,'<%&
'+@%E&Q"R30.&F*&+@%&I'*+E"ERJ&"*&:*P%,+:9"+:'*&'(&+@%&E%$%P"*+&,';EI%,&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&Y&
#'+@&+E%"+R&"*>&I;,+'<&Y&E%P%"$&+@"+&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&8*"#&:*&("I+&%`:,+&:*&C',:+:P%&$"QJ&"*>&
+@"+&#'+@&:+,&*'E<"+:P%&I'*+%*+&"*>&E%$"+%>&'#$:9"+:'*,&I"*&#%&';+$:*%>&:*>%C%*>%*+$R&'(&
'+@%E&E:9@+,3&!@:,&:,&+@%&Q'EB&'(&+@:,&,%I+:'*3&!@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&';+$:*%>&#%$'Q&+@E';9@&
+@%&+E">:+:'*"$&"I+:P:+R&'(&$%9"$&I'*,+E;I+:'*g&+@%&E:9@+U,&:*+%$$%I+;"$&'E:9:*&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
E%$"+:'*,J&",&Q%$$&",&:+,&$%9"$&#",:,J&,I'C%&"*>&'#$:9"+:'*,&"E%&I'<CE%@%*,:P%$R&+E%"+%>3&
D,&*'+%>&:*&+@%&:*+E'>;I+:'*J&E%I%*+&>%I">%,&@"P%&,%%*&+@%&,+E;99$%&'(&+@%&'CCE%,,%>&
'E&*%9$%I+%>&E%('E<;$"+%>&",&@;<"*&E:9@+,&:,,;%,304&!@%&,+E;99$%&('E&E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*&
#%9:*,&Q:+@&+@%&>:,C',,%,,%>&E%(E"<:*9&+@%:E&I$":<,&",&#",%>&:*&WE:9@+,&%*+:+$%<%*+,3X&
a;<"*&E:9@+,&I$":<,&"E%&*'+&$:B%$R&+'&#%&<">%&:(&,'I:%+:%,&I"*&,'$P%&*%Q&CE'#$%<,&'*&+@%:E&
'Q*3&D,&A%+%E&2'**%$$R&,;99%,+,J&W'*%&*%%>,&@;<"*&E:9@+,&CE:*I:C"$$R&Q@%*&+@%R&"E%&*'+&
%((%I+:P%$R&9;"E"*+%%>&#R&$"Q&"*>&CE"I+:I%3X00&S'E&*%Q&E:9@+,J&,;I@&",&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&
+@:,&:*P'$P%,&+@%&IE%"+:'*&'(&"&$%9"$&:>%*+:+R&('E&"&I$":<&#",%>&:*&"&,'I:'$'9:I"$&E%"$:+R3&!@%&
,;CC'E+&('E&,;I@&"*&%*>%"P'E&I'<%,&(E'<&+@%&W(;*>"<%*+"$:+RX&'(&+@%&I$":<&"+&+@%&I'E%&'(&
+@%&E:9@+3&a;<"*&E:9@+,&I$":<,&E%,+&'*&Q@"+&:,&I'*,:>%E%>&%,,%*+:"$&('E&"&$:(%&:*&@;<"*&
>:9*:+R3&=*&+@%&Q'E>,&'(&+@%&b*:P%E,"$&2%I$"E"+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&]b2aG^J&W+@%&
E%I'9*:+:'*&'(&+@%&:*@%E%*+&>:9*:+R&"*>&'(&+@%&%c;"$&"*>&:*"$:%*"#$%&E:9@+,&'(&"$$&<%<#%E,&'(&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
!@%&G:9@+&+'&2%P%$'C<%*+J(d3D3&G%,3&60O-/6J&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO60O-/6&]2%I3&-/J&-???^J&"*>&d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&443&!@%,%&
+%E<,&,@';$>&#%&>:,+:*9;:,@%>&(E'<&+@%&+E">:+:'*"$&I:P:$&$"Q&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&Y&+@',%&,+"+%T9E"*+%>&E:9@+,&('E&+@%&
;,%&'(&E%,';EI%,&+'&<%%+&,'I:"$&*%%>,3&V@%E%&"&>:,+:*I+:'*&*%%>,&+'&#%&<">%&#%+Q%%*&@;<"*&E:9@+,&"*>&E%,';EI%&E:9@+,J&
+@:,&C"C%E&Q:$$&;,%&+@%&+%E<&WI:P:$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,X&+'&>%,IE:#%&+@%&$"++%E3&
&&&&0-&The World Conservation Union, Water Law Series Issue 9: Human Rights and Water -&].557^J&$?$0,$+,"($:R(
@++CHOOI<,>"+"3:;I*3'E9O>'Q*$'">,O(,?3C>(<(*
&&&&0.&K"*R&";+@'E,&"E9;%&+@"+&+@%&*%,+&$'9:I"$&,+%C&:*&+@%&%*('EI%<%*+&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:,&+@%:E&I'>:(:I"+:'*&:*&"*&
:*>%C%*>%*+&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*P%*+:'*J&@'Q%P%E&+@:,&",,%E+:'*&("$$,&';+,:>%&'(&+@%&,I'C%&:(&+@:,&%,,"R3&/"".("<1<.(8$;%<%$J&
#6@%$&*'+%&6J&"+&?/4&]W!@%&E%I'9*:+:'*&'(&"&,:*9;$"E&E:9@+&Q@:I@&I';$>&,"+:,(R&+@%&%*+:E%+R&'(&N+"+%,U&'#$:9"+:'*,&;*>%E&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&,@';$>&CE'P:>%&9E%"+%E&I$"E:+R&"*>&I'*,:,+%*IR&:*&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*J&$%">:*9&+'&9E%"+%E&N+"+%&I'<C$:"*I%&"*>&
I$%"E%E&I'<C$":*"*+&E:9@+,&+'&E%<%>:%,3X^3&/""($,#*(A%+%E&a3&d$%:IBJ&='"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&-]6^&Water Policy 07/&
]-???^&e@%E%:*"(+%E&d$%:IBJ&!01':(:*(D$:"%fg&K";>%&8"E$'QJ&;(\E(A*2?"2:0*2(*2(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%R(;2(48"$(D'*#"(=0-"(
S$#(A*-".&Blue Planet&].551^J&@++CHOOQQQ3#$;%C$"*%+CE'[%I+3*%+O>'I;<%*+,ObMhI'*P%*+:'*hK8h2%I513C>(3&
&&&&04&Bob CliffordJ&U01':021(3*%(E"H(!01':#J&02&The International Struggle for New Human Rights&-J&-&].55?^3&
&&&&00&Jack Donnelly, International Human Rights ..]&4E>&%>3&.55/^3&
&
&
-4&
+@%&@;<"*&("<:$R&:,&+@%&(';*>"+:'*&'(&(E%%>'<J&[;,+:I%&"*>&C%"I%&:*&+@%&Q'E$>3X06&V"+%EU,&
(;*>"<%*+"$:+R&+'&@;<"*&>:9*:+R&:,&:*>:,C;+"#$%J&"*>&"*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*,%*,;,&@",&9E'Q*&
+'&E%($%I+&+@:,&("I+3&&
&
;<(='"(>"?",*@-"2:(*3($2(42:"%2$:0*2$,(A*2#"2#6#(
&
M%$,'*&C',:+,&+@"+&+Q'&I'<C$%<%*+"ER&("I+'E,&%*"#$%>&+@%&I$":<&'(&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&
Q"+%EH&]"^&"&WE%I%C+:P%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&%*P:E'*<%*+X&"*>&]#^&"&,%+&'(&%`+%E*"$&+@E%"+,301&!@%&
+@E%"+&+'&@;<"*&>%P%$'C<%*+&C',%>&#R&Q"+%E&,I"EI:+R&Q",&';+$:*%>&#R&+@%&:*+E'>;I+:'*3&
!@%&E%I%C+:P%*%,,&'(&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'<<;*:+R&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:,&>%<'*,+E"+%>&#R&:+,&
CE'9E%,,:P%&%<#E"I%&'(&,;I@&E:9@+,&'P%E&+@%&C",+&45&R%"E,3&M"+:'*"$&"*>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
C'$:+:I"$&"9%*>",&#%9"*&+'&E%($%I+&9E'Q:*9&I'*I%E*&('E&Q"+%E&:,,;%,&:*&+@%&<:>T-?/5,30/&8R&
+@%&%"E$R&.555,J&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&('I;,&'*&Q"+%E&#%9"*&+'&,@:(+&(E'<&<"*"9%<%*+J&
+%I@*'$'9R&"*>&%I'*'<:I,&+'&"&<'E%&E:9@+,T#",%>&"CCE'"I@307&!'>"RJ&E%I%*+&C'$$,&,;99%,+&
+@"+&+@%&9$'#"$&(E%,@Q"+%E&IE:,:,&:,&+@%&Q'E$>U,&<',+&CE%,,:*9&%*P:E'*<%*+"$&CE'#$%<J&"*>&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>%I$"E"+:'*,&@"P%&#%9;*&;+:$:Z:*9&E:9@+,T#",%>&$"*9;"9%&",&+@%R&,@:(+&+'&E%($%I+&
+@:,&9E'Q:*9&I'*,%*,;,30?&
N%P%E"$&+RC%,&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>'I;<%*+"+:'*&%:+@%E&%`C$:I:+$R&'E&:<C$:I:+$R&,;CC'E+&"&
E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3&!@%&';+$:*%&'(&+@%&E%,';EI%,&9E';C%>&#%$'Q&:,&",&('$$'Q,H&,';EI%,&'(&#:*>:*9&
+E%"+R&$"Q&"E%&:*P%,+:9"+%>&(:E,+3&!E%"+:%,&%*,@E:*%&I'<<:+<%*+,&+@"+&,+"+%,&C"E+:%,&"E%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&06&b*:P%E,"$&2%I$"E"+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&d3D3&G%,3&.-/&]===^&DJ&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO.-/]===^&]2%I3&-5J&-?07^&
e@%E%:*"(+%E&b2aGf3&
&&&&01&A";$&\3&M%$,'*J&C*&$,(A,$0-#.(42:"%2$:0*2$,(/:$28$%8#($28(:'"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&02&The International Struggle
for New Human Rights&-45J&-44&]8'#&)$:(('E>&%>3J&.55?^3*
&&&&0/&/""(D,:+&i3&8:,Q",J&D$:"%($#($(S6-$2(!01':(02(:'"(9GE;(!"10*2R(A'$,,"21"#($28(W@@*%:620:0"#.&.4].^&Intl J. Water
Res. Dev&.5?J&.--&].55/^&e@%E%:*"(+%E&8:,Q",&9GE;fg&D,:+&8:,Q",&j&)%I:$:"&!'E+"[">"J&A'$21021(F,*+$,(D$:"%(
9$2$1"-"2:(C$28#&$@".&02&Water Management in 2020 and Beyond&-J&-5&]D3i3&8:,Q",&%+&"$3&%>,3J&.551^3&
&&&&07&b*+:$&E%$%",%&'(&+@%&.551&a;<"*&2%P%$'C<%*+&G%C'E+J&#6@%$(*'+%&1J&"&$"IB&'(&Q"+%E&"II%,,&Q",&+@';9@+&+'&<%"*&"&$"IB&
'(&E%,';EI%,&'E&+%I@*:I"$&I"C"I:+R3&/"" Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions [COHRE], Human Rights and
Access to Water and Sanitation: Acting on the Report of the OHCHR&.&].55/^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3E:9@++'Q"+%E3:*('OC>(,O.55/aG)Q%#3C>(&e@%E%:*"(+%E&COHRE"f3&/""&$,#*&8$;%<%$J&#6@%$&*'+%&6&"+&?14g&
8E%++&V"$+'*J&]$3$%(;8"",R(;(A*2?"%#$:0*2(D0:'(:'"(E"H(A'$0%(*3(\E^D$:"%.&Circle of Blue&]K"E3&.6J&.5-5^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3I:EI$%'(#$;%3'E9OQ"+%E*%Q,O.5-5OQ'E$>OZ"("ET">%%$T"TI'*P%E,"+:'*TQ:+@T+@%T*%QTI@":ET'(T;*T
Q"+%EOu<'E%T-4/0/&]W=&+@:*B&@:,+'E:I"$$R&Q@"+&Q%&@"P%&>'*%&:,&,+"R&('I;,%>&,C%I:(:I"$$R&'*&Q"+%E&:,,;%,J&Q"+%E&c;"$:+RJ&
'*&<'*:+'E:*9&"*>&>':*9&E%,%"EI@J&#;+&+'&E%$"+%&:+&+'&C%'C$%U,&$:P%,&"*>&+'&E%$"+%&:+&+'&C'$:I:%,&:,&,'<%+@:*9&Q%&@"P%&*'+&
>'*%&P%ER&Q%$$&#%('E%3X^3&
&&&&0?&i%:+@&NI@*%:>%EJ&M">R"&=P"*'P"&j&D"E'*&\"((%J&D$:"%(=*@#(A,0-$:"(A'$21"($#(F,*+$,()%0*%0:7J&Circle of Blue&]D;93&
-7J&.55?^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I:EI$%'(#$;%3'E9OQ"+%E*%Q,O.55?OQ'E$>OQ"+%EP:%Q,TQ"+%ET+'C,TI$:<"+%TI@"*9%T",T9$'#"$T
CE:'E:+RO&](;$$&,;EP%R&E%,;$+,&"E%&$?$0,$+,"($:R&@++CHOOQQQ3I:EI$%'(#$;%3'E9OQ"+%E*%Q,OQCT
I'*+%*+O;C$'">,O.55?O57OI:EI$%h'(h#$;%h9$'#%,I"*3C>(^3&
&
-0&
#';*>&#R&$"Q&+'&(;$(:$$3&!@%R&"E%J&+@%E%('E%J&+@%&<',+&:<C'E+"*+&,';EI%,&:*&"*R&:*P%,+:9"+:'*&
'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&&N';EI%,&'(&*'*T#:*>:*9&$"Q&>%P%$'C%>&#'+@&Q:+@:*&"*>&';+,:>%&'(&+@%&
b3M3&,R,+%<&"E%&+@%*&E%P:%Q%>&I@E'*'$'9:I"$$RJ&>%<'*,+E"+:*9&+@%&>%P%$'C<%*+&'(&+@%&+%E<&
WE:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3X&!@%,%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>%I$"E"+:'*,&"*>&E%,'$;+:'*,&%*,@E:*%&+@%&C'$:+:I"$&
I'<<:+<%*+,&'(&,+"+%,&Q:+@:*&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'<<;*:+R3&D$+@';9@&+@%R&"E%&('E<"$$R&
*'*T#:*>:*9J&+@%R&I"*&#%&;,%>&",&:*+%ECE%+"+:P%&9;:>%,&Q:+@&E%,C%I+&+'&,+"+%,U&+E%"+R&
'#$:9"+:'*,365&S:*"$$RJ&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I;,+'<"ER&$"Q&:,&I'*,:>%E%>3&!@%E%&"E%&,%P%E"$&'+@%E&
$%9"$&,';EI%,&E%$%P"*+&+'&+@%&9E'Q+@&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&+@"+&('E&E%",'*,&'(&I$"E:+R&"*>&#E%P:+R&
Q:$$&*'+&#%&">>E%,,%>&@%E%3&!@%,%&:*I$;>%&E%9:'*"$&@;<"*&E:9@+,&+E%"+:%,J&>%I$"E"+:'*,&<'E%&
9%*%E"$$R&E%$"+:*9&+'&,;,+":*"#$%&>%P%$'C<%*+&"*>&I$%"*&%*P:E'*<%*+J&"*>&+@%&I'*I$;>:*9&
'#,%EP"+:'*,&'(&+@%&)LN)G36-&
N%P%E"$&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&+E%"+:%,&Y&+@%&<',+&>%(:*:+:P%&,';EI%,&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&Y&
%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I%&>;+:%,&E%$"+%>&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&!@%:E&>%(:*:+:'*,J&@'Q%P%EJ&("$$&,@'E+&'(&
CE'+%I+:*9&Q"+%E&E%,';EI%&">%c;"IRJ&c;"$:+R&'E&"II%,,:#:$:+R3&DE+:I$%&-0&'(&+@%&)'*P%*+:'*&
('E&+@%&L$:<:*"+:'*&'(&2:,IE:<:*"+:'*&D9":*,+&V'<%*&])L2DV^J&:*&CE'+%I+:*9&E;E"$&Q'<%*&
(E'<&>:,IE:<:*"+:'*J&E%c;:E%,&+@"+&,+"+%,&C"E+:%,&CE'+%I+&+@%&E:9@+&W+'&%*['R&">%c;"+%&$:P:*9&
I'*>:+:'*,J&C"E+:I;$"E$R&:*&E%$"+:'*&+'t&Q"+%E&,;CC$R3X6.&!@%&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&G:9@+,&'(&
+@%&)@:$>&])G)^J&Q@:I@&I"<%&:*+'&('EI%&*:*%&R%"E,&$"+%EJ&CE'+%I+,&+@%&W@:9@%,+&"++":*"#$%&
,+"*>"E>&'(&@%"$+@X&('E&I@:$>E%*&:*I$;>:*9&]02:"%($,0$^&I$%"*J&">%c;"+%&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E364&!@%&
b3M3&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&_"Q&'(&+@%&M'*TM"P:9"+:'*"$&b,%,&'(&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&V"+%E&)';E,%,J60&
+@';9@&*'+&:*&%((%I+J&",,%E+,&+@%&CE:'E:+R&'(&WP:+"$&@;<"*&*%%>,X&Q@%*&,+"+%,&"E%&"+&'>>,&
'P%E&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&Q"+%E&E%,';EI%,366&S:*"$$RJ&+@%&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&G:9@+,&'(&A%E,'*,&Q:+@&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&&65&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions [COHRE], Legal Resources for the Right to Water and
Sanitation: International and National Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&0-^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&
";+@'E^&e@%E%:*"(+%E&COHRE(c)f3&
&&&&6-&S'E&"&>:,I;,,:'*&'(&+@%,%&,';EI%,&,%%&9%*%E"$$R(COHRE(c).(#6@%$.&*'+%&65("*>&A"+E:I:"&V';+%E,J&\20?"%#$,($28(
!"10*2$,(;@@%*$&'"#(:*(!"#*,?021(42:"%2$:0*2$,(>0#@6:"#R(D'$:(C"##*2#(C"$%2"8(3%*-(/:$:"()%$&:0&"_(02&Resolution of
International Water Disputes&---&]=*+%E*"+:'*"$&8;E%";J&A%E<"*%*+&)';E+&'(&DE#:+E"+:'*&%>3J&.554^3&N%P%E"$&
)'*I$;>:*9&F#,%EP"+:'*,&"E%&:*I$;>%>&:*&N%I+:'*&=s&",&#"IB9E';*>&:*('E<"+:'*&('E&+@%&:*>:P:>;"$&,+"+%,&,;EP%R%>3*
&&&&6.&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&L$:<:*"+:'*&'(&D$$&S'E<,&'(&2:,IE:<:*"+:'*&"9":*,+&V'<%*J&DE+3-0J&q&.J&2%I3&-7J&-?/?J&-.0?&b3M3!3N3&
-43&
&&&&64&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&G:9@+,&'(&+@%&)@:$>J&DE+3&.0q.J&M'P3&.5J&-?7?J&-6//&b3M3!3N3&43&
&&&&60&!@%&#'>R&'(&$"Q&9'P%E*:*9&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&Q"+%EI';E,%,&<"R&,%%<&+@%&(:E,+&$'9:I"$&C$"I%&+'&$''B&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&
d%*%E"$$RJ&@'Q%P%EJ&$"Q&:,&:*,;((:I:%*+$R&>%P%$'C%>&+@%E%&+'&CE'+%I+&"&E:9@+&+'&:*>:P:>;"$&"II%,,3&/""(BourquainJ&#6@%$&
*'+%&4J&65T60g&i:%(%E&j&8Ek$<"**J&#6@%$&*'+%&/J&"+&-743&*
&&&&66&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&_"Q&'(&+@%&M'*TM"P:9"+:'*"$&b,%,&'(&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&V"+%EI';E,%,J&DE+3-53.J&d3&D3&E%,3&6-O..?J&
D**%`J&b3M3&dDFGJ&6-,+&N%,,3J&??+@&<+93J&bM&2'I3&DOGLNO6-O..?&]*@"2"8(3*%(#012$:6%"(K"R&.-J&-??/^J&41&=3_3K3&/553&!@:,&
I'*P%*+:'*&:,&*'+&:*&('EI%3&
&
-6&
2:,"#:$:+:%,&';+$:*%,&W+@%&E:9@+&'(&C%E,'*,&Q:+@&>:,"#:$:+:%,&+'&,'I:"$&CE'+%I+:'*&3&3&3&:*I$;>:*9&
<%",;E%,&+'&%*,;E%&%c;"$&"II%,,&#R&C%E,'*,&Q:+@&>:,"#:$:+:%,&+'&I$%"*&Q"+%E3X61&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*($:I+J&@;<"*:+"E:"*&"*>&IE:<:*"$&$"Q&"$,'&>%<'*,+E"+%&,'<%&
I'*,%*,;,&'*&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&#R&%,+"#$:,@:*9&E%$"+%>&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,3&!@%&d%*%P"&
)'*P%*+:'*,&Y&"$<',+&;*:P%E,"$$R&E"+:(:%>&Y&%*,;E%&+@"+&#'+@&CE:,'*%E,&'(&Q"E&"*>&I:P:$:"*,&
"E%&9;"E"*+%%>&Q"+%E&('E&I'*,;<C+:'*&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*&",&C"E+&'(&"*&">%c;"+%&,+"*>"E>&'(&
$:P:*9&('E&@%"$+@&"*>&Q%$$#%:*936/&D>>:+:'*"$&AE'+'I'$&=&]-?//^J&+@';9@&$%,,TQ:>%$R&E"+:(:%>J&
'#$:9%,&C"E+:%,&*'+&+'&"++"IB&'E&>%,+E'R&W'#[%I+,&:*>:,C%*,:#$%&+'&+@%&,;EP:P"$&'(&+@%&I:P:$:"*&
C'C;$"+:'*&3&3&3&e:*I$;>:*9f&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&,;CC$:%,3X67&6?&!@%&N+"*>"E>&K:*:<;<&G;$%,&('E&
+@%&!E%"+<%*+&'(&AE:,'*%E,&]-?66^&"*>&+@%&$"+%E&b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&G;$%,&('E&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&
\;P%*:$%,&2%CE:P%>&'(&+@%:E&_:#%E+R&]-??5^J&#'+@&%*,;E%&+@"+&We>fE:*B:*9&Q"+%E&,@"$$&#%&
"P":$"#$%&+'&%P%ER&CE:,'*%E&Q@%*%P%E&@%&*%%>,&:+3X15&
N:*I%&+@%&-?/5,J&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&",&"*&:*>%C%*>%*+&@;<"*&E:9@+,&%*+:+$%<%*+&@",&
(';*>&:*IE%",%>&,;CC'E+&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>%I$"E"+:'*,J&E%,'$;+:'*,&"*>&"9E%%<%*+,3&!@';9@&
*'*T#:*>:*9J&+@%,%&>%I$"E"+:'*,&,%EP%&",&%P:>%*I%&'(&,+"+%&CE"I+:I%&"*>&I"*&:*>:I"+%&"&
,+"+%U,&'Q*&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&:+,&$%9"$&'#$:9"+:'*,3&!@%&s"*I';P%E&2%I$"E"+:'*&(E'<&+@%&b3M3&
)'*(%E%*I%&'*&a;<"*&N%++$%<%*+&]-?/1^&@%$>&Q"+%E&+'&#%&"&#",:I&@;<"*&*%%>J&>:E%I+:*9&
,'<%&'(&:+,&E%I'<<%*>"+:'*,&('E&>%P%$'C:*9&I';*+E:%,&+'Q"E>&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&
,;CC$:%,&(E'<&C'$$;+:'*&"*>&+@%&">'C+:'*&'(&C'$:I:%,&Q:+@&WE%",'*"#$%&,+"*>"E>,&('E&c;"$:+R&
"*>&c;"*+:+R3X1-&!@%&K"E&>%$&A$"+"&DI+:'*&A$"*&(E'<&+@%&b3M3&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&V"+%E&]-?//^&:,&
'*%&'(&+@%&<',+&'(+TI:+%>&>%I$"E"+:'*,J&",&:+&%`C$:I:+$R&:*,:,+,&+@"+&"$$&C%'C$%,&W@"P%&+@%&E:9@+&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&61&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&"*>&AE'<'+:'*&'(&+@%&G:9@+,&"*>&2:9*:+R&'(&A%E,'*,&Q:+@&2:,"#:$:+:%,J&DE+3&
.7J&d3D3&G%,3&1-O-51J&D**%`&=J&b3M3&dDFGJ&1-,+&N%,,3J&N;CC3&M'3&0?J&"+&16J&b3M3&2'I3&DO1-O0?&]2%I3&-4J&.551^J&01&=3_3K3&0043&
&&&6/&d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*&G%$"+:P%&+'&+@%&!E%"+<%*+&'(&AE:,'*%E,&'(&V"EJ&DE+3&.1J&.?J&D;93&-.J&-?0?J&1&b3N3!3&44-1J&/6&b3M3!3N3&
-46g&d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*&G%$"+:P%&+'&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&):P:$:"*&A%E,'*,&:*&!:<%&'(&V"EJ&DE+3&763&7?J&-./J&D;93&-.J&-?0?J&1&
b3N3!3&46-1J&/6&b3M3!3N3&.7/&e@%E%:*"(+%E&!@:E>&d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*f3&
&&&&67&AE'+'I'$&D>>:+:'*"$&+'&+@%&d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*,&'(&-.&D;9;,+&-?0?J&"*>&G%$"+:*9&+'&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&s:I+:<,&'(&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&DE<%>&)'*($:I+,^J&DE+3&60J&\;*%&7J&-?//J&--.6&b3M3!3N3&43&
&&&&6?&S'E&"&E%I%*+&"*"$R,:,&'(&+@%&E%$"+:'*,@:C&#%+Q%%*&I'*($:I+&$"Q&"*>&@;<"*&E:9@+,J&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&,%%(="*&
NI'##:%()%02&0@,"(*%()%$1-$:0&#_(='"(!",$:0*2#'0@(+":H""2(S6-$2(!01':#(C$H($28(:'"(C$H(*3(;%-"8(A*23,0&:.(-0]4^&J.
Conflict & Security L.&00?&].55?^3&
&&&&15&b3&M3&G;$%,&('E&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&\;P%*:$%,&2%CE:P%>&'(&+@%:E&_:#%E+RJ&d3D3&G%,3&06O--4J&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO06O--4&]2%I3&
-0J&-??5^&]W)$%"*&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&,@';$>&#%&"P":$"#$%&+'&%P%ER&[;P%*:$%&"+&"*R&+:<%3X^g&S:E,+&b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&)'*9E%,,&'*&+@%&
AE%P%*+:'*&'(&)E:<%&"*>&+@%&!E%"+<%*+&'(&F((%*>%E,J&D;93&..&Y&N%C3&4J&-?66J&/:$28$%8(9020-6-(!6,"#(3*%(:'"(=%"$:-"2:(*3(
)%0#*2"%#J&b3M3&2'I3&DO)FMSO1--J&D**%`&=J&.5].^&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ-3;<*3%>;O@;<"*E+,O:*,+E%%O9-,<E3@+<3*
&&&&1-&b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&a;<"*&N%++$%<%*+J&s"*I';P%EJ&)"*3&K"R&4-&Y&\;*%&--J&-?/1J&`$2&*6?"%(>"&,$%$:0*2(*2(
S6-$2(/"::,"-"2:#J&bM3&2'I3&DO)FMS3/5O-6J&"+&q&7J&q&1J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3;*T>'I;<%*+,3*%+OP"*T>%I3@+<3&
&
-1&
+'&@"P%&"II%,,&+'&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&:*&c;"*+:+:%,&"*>&'(&"&c;"$:+R&%c;"$&+'&+@%:E&#",:I&*%%>3X1.&
D(+%E&+@:,&>%I$"E"+:'*J&+@%&",,%E+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&#%I"<%&I'<<'*C$"I%&:*&>%P%$'C<%*+T
E%$"+%>&"9E%%<%*+,3&!@%&2;#$:*&N+"+%<%*+&'*&V"+%E&"*>&N;,+":*"#$%&2%P%$'C<%*+&]-??.^&
,+"+%,&+@"+&+@%E%&%`:,+,&"&W#",:I&E:9@+&'(&"$$&@;<"*&#%:*9,&+'&@"P%&"II%,,&+'&I$%"*&Q"+%Et&"+&
"*&"(('E>"#$%&CE:I%3X14&D9%*>"&.-&(E'<&+@%&b3M3&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&L*P:E'*<%*+&"*>&
2%P%$'C<%*+&:*&G:'&>%&\"*%:E'&]-??.^&"IB*'Q$%>9%,&"&WE:9@+&+'&Q"+%EX&:*&$:*%&Q:+@&+@%&K"E&
>%$&A$"+"&C$"*310&=*&-??0J&+@%&AE'9E"<<%&'(&DI+:'*&'(&+@%&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&
A'C;$"+:'*&"*>&2%P%$'C<%*+&:*I$;>%>&Q"+%E&"<'*9&+@',%&%$%<%*+,&'(&W+@%&E:9@+&+'&"*&
">%c;"+%&,+"*>"E>&'(&$:P:*93X16&S:*"$$RJ&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&@",&(';*>&,;CC'E+&:*&(';E&E%I%*+&
>%P%$'C<%*+&I'*(%E%*I%,H&!@%&D(E:I"TN';+@&D<%E:I"&N;<<:+&:*&.551&]!@%&D#;["&
2%I$"E"+:'*^J11&+@%&-,+&D,:"&A"I:(:I&V"+%E&N;<<:+&:*&.55/&]K%,,"9%&(E'<&8%CC;^J1/&+@%&4E>&
N';+@&D,:"*&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&N"*:+"+:'*&:*&.557&]2%$@:&2%I$"E"+:'*^J17&"*>&+@%&vs&N;<<:+&'(&
a%">,&'(&N+"+%&"*>&d'P%E*<%*+&'(&+@%&M'*TD$:9*%>&K'P%<%*+&:*&.55?&]S:*"$&2'I;<%*+^31?&
!@%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&I'*I%C+&>%P%$'C%>&:*&+@%,%&>%I$"E"+:'*,&Q",&(:E,+&">'C+%>&#R&+@%&
b3M3&,R,+%<&:*&.555&Q:+@&"&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&E%,'$;+:'*&'*&+@%&G:9@+&+'&2%P%$'C<%*+3&!@"+&
E%,'$;+:'*&"IB*'Q$%>9%,&+@"+&WE:9@+,&+'&(''>&"*>&I$%"*&Q"+%E&"E%&(;*>"<%*+"$&@;<"*&
E:9@+,J&"*>&+@%:E&CE'<'+:'*&I'*,+:+;+%,&"&<'E"$&:<C%E"+:P%&#'+@&('E&*"+:'*"$&d'P%E*<%*+,&
"*>&('E&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'<<;*:+R3X/5&M'*T#:*>:*9&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&E%,'$;+:'*,&"E%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&1.&b3&M3&V"+%E&)'*(%E%*I%&eb3M3V3)3fJ&K"E&>%$&A$"+"J&DE93J&K"E3&-0T.6J&-?//J&!"@<(*3(:'"(\<(E<(D$:"%(A*23"%"2&"J&b3M3&2'I3&
LO)FMS3/5O.?J&b3M3&N"$%,&M'3&L3//3--3D3-.&]K"E3&.6J&-?//^3&*
&&&&14&>6+,02&/:$:"-"2:J&#6@%$&*'+%&-43&
&&&&10&b3&M3&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&L*PU+3&j&2%P3J&G:'&>%&\"*:%E'J&8E"Z3J&\;*%&4T-0J&-??.J&;1"28$(PNJ&I@3&-730/J&b3M3&2'I3&
DO)FMS3-6-O.1OGLs3-&]s'$3&==^&]\;*%&-0J&-??.^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3;*3'E9O%,"O>,>O"9%*>".-O3&&
&&&&16&b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&A'C;$"+:'*&"*>&2%P%$'C<%*+J&)":E'J&L9RC+J&N%C3&6T-4J&-??0J&)%*1%$--"(
*3(;&:0*2(*3(:'"(42:"%2$:0*2$,(A*23"%"2&"(*2()*@6,$:0*2($28(>"?",*@-"2:J&I@&.J&CE:*I3&.J&b3M3&2'I3&DO)FMS3-/-O-4&]N%C3&-7J&
-??0^3&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3::,>3I"O)":E'OCE'9E"<OC555553@+<$3&
&&&&11&S:E,+&D(E:I"TN';+@&D<%E:I"&N;<<:+J&D#;["J&M:9%E:"J&M'P3&.1T45J&.551J&;+6a$(>"&,$%$:0*2J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3%"I$[3'E9O:*>%`3C@Cn'C+:'*oI'<hC@'I">'Q*$'">jP:%QoI"+%9'ERj:>o-j=+%<:>o.-u3(
&&&&1/&S:E,+&D,:"TA"I:(:I&V"+%E&N;<<:+J&8%CC;J&\"C"*J2%I3&4T0J&.55/J&9"##$1"(3%*-(B"@@6J&q.J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3"CQ(3'E9O"EI@:P%O>'I;<%*+,O,;<<:+OK%,,"9%h(E'<h8%CC;h575-453C>(&
C%'C$%U,&E:9@+&+'&,"(%&>:*B:*9&Q"+%Et&",&"&#",:I&@;<"*&E:9@+X^3&
&&&&17&!@:E>&N';+@&D,:"*&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&N"*:+"+:'*J&M%Q&2%$@:J&=*>:"J&M'P3&-1T.-J&.557J&='"(>",'0(>"&,$%$:0*2J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOO>>Q,3*:I3:*O:*(',"I',"*OCC+O2%$@:m.52%I$"E"+:'*m.5/3C>(3&]W"II%,,&+'&,"(%&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&I'*,+:+;+%,&"&#",:I&
@;<"*&E:9@+3X^&
&&&&1?&vs&N;<<:+&'(&a%">,&'(&N+"+%&"*>&d'P%E*<%*+&'(&+@%&M'*TD$:9*%>&K'P%<%*+J&N@"E<&%$&N@%:BJ&L9RC+J&\;$R&--T-1J&.55?J&
U02$,(>*&6-"2:.(q4?-T4?6J&MDK.55?OS2O2'I3-J($?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3*"<%9RC+3'E9O%*OG%$%P"*+2'I;<%*+,OA"9%,O>%(";$+3",C`&]P:"&W(:*"$&>'I;<%*+X&@RC%E$:*B^&],+E%,,:*9&W+@%&
*%%>&+'&",,:,+&>%P%$'C:*9&I';*+E:%,&:*&+@%:E&%(('E+,&+'&3&3&3&CE'P:>%&"II%,,&+'&,"(%&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&"*>&#",:I&,"*:+"+:'*X&Q@:$%&
E%I"$$:*9&+@%&"IB*'Q$%>9%<%*+&'(&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:*&d)-6^3&
&&&&/5&!@%&G:9@+&+'&2%P%$'C<%*+J&#6@%$&*'+%&05J&"+&q-.]"^3&dD&E%,'$;+:'*,&9;:>%&+@%&Q'EB&'(&'+@%E&bM&'((:I%,&"*>&"9%*I:%,3&
!@%E%&"E%&I;EE%*+$R&.1&bM&'((:I%,&Q'EB:*9&'*&+@%&<"*"9%<%*+&'(&9$'#"$&(E%,@Q"+%E3&
&
-/&
,:<:$"E&+'&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>%I$"E"+:'*,&",&+@%R&:*>:I"+%&"&,+"+%U,&%P'$P:*9&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&:+,&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&'#$:9"+:'*,3&G%,'$;+:'*,&"$,'&CE'P:>%&"&I'*I%C+;"$&(E"<%Q'EB&('E&+@%&
"I+:P:+:%,&'(&'+@%E&b3M3&'((:I%,&"*>&"9%*I:%,3&S'E&+@:,&E%",'*J&+@%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&I'*I%C+&@",&
%*['R%>&P"E:';,&('E<,&'(&,;CC'E+&(E'<&b3M3&'E9"*,&"*>&"9%*I:%,&:*&+@%&$",+&>%I">%3&
&D(+%E&+@%&.555&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&E%,'$;+:'*J&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&$"*9;"9%&Q",&c;:IB$R&
">'C+%>&#R&>'I;<%*+,&$:B%&+@%&K:$$%**:;<&2%P%$'C<%*+&d'"$,&"*>&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6&'(&
+@%&)'<<:++%%&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,3&/-&&!@%&)'<<:,,:'*&'*&a;<"*&
G:9@+,&('$$'Q%>&,;:+&:*&.556&Q:+@&"&E%,'$;+:'*&'*&+@%&>;<C:*9&'(&+'`:I&Q",+%,J&
"IB*'Q$%>9:*9&WE:9@+,&+'&Q"+%EX&:*&+@E%%&C$"I%,3/.&!@%&b3M3&N;#T)'<<:,,:'*&'*&+@%&
AE'<'+:'*&"*>&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&E%$%",%>&Wd;:>%$:*%,&('E&+@%&G%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&
G:9@+&+'&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*X&+@%&,"<%&R%"EJ&,;CC'E+:*9&"*>&I$"E:(R:*9&+@%&
I'*I$;,:'*,&'(&'+@%E&#'>:%,J&<',+&*'+"#$R&+@%&)LN)G3/4&=*&.55/J&+@%&b3M3&a:9@&
)'<<:,,:'*%E&('E&a;<"*&G:9@+,&:,,;%>&"&E%C'E+&WF*&+@%&NI'C%&"*>&)'*+%*+&'(&+@%&G%$%P"*+&
a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&G%$"+%>&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*&;*>%E&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&a;<"*&G:9@+,&=*,+E;<%*+,JX&*'+"#$R&I'*I$;>:*9&+@"+J&W:+&:,&*'Q&+:<%&+'&
I'*,:>%E&"II%,,&+'&,"(%&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%Et&",&"&@;<"*&E:9@+3X/0&=*&.557J&+@%&a;<"*&G:9@+,&
)';*I:$&]aG)^&Y&+@%&<":*&#'>R&Q:+@&@;<"*&E:9@+,&I'<C%+%*IR&:*&+@%&b3M3&,R,+%<&Y&
,'<%Q@"+&#%$"+%>$R&"CC':*+%>&"*&=*>%C%*>%*+&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&E:9@+,&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&/-&!@%&K:$$%**:;<&2%I$"E"+:'*J&d3D3&G%,3&66O.J&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO66O.&]N%C3&7J&.555^3&V@:$%&+@%&K:$$%**:;<&2%P%$'C<%*+&
d'"$,&eK2d,f&">'C+&,'<%&@;<"*&E:9@+,&$"*9;"9%&"*>&:>%",J&+@%:E&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&@",&#%%*&IE:+:I:Z%>&('E&*'+&:*+%9E"+:*9&"&
@;<"*&E:9@+,&I"$I;$;,3&=*&D;9;,+&'(&.5-5&+@%&=*>%C%*>%*+&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&G:9@+&+'&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*&+E"*,<:++%>&"&
E%C'E+&+'&+@%&bM&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&I$"E:(R:*9&+@%&Q"R&:*&Q@:I@&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&E%$"+%&+'&+@%&Kd2,3&=*&@%E&E%C'E+J&,@%&
>%,IE:#%>&+@%&+Q'&",&WI'*,:,+%*+&"*>&<;+;"$$R&E%:*('EI:*9JX&Q@:$%&E%9E%++:*9&+@%&CE"I+:I"$&$"IB&'(&WI'*,+E;I+:P%&,R*%E9R3X&
=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&G%$"+%>&+'&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&='"&
9F>#($28(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$RJ&b3M3&2'I3&DO16O.60J&q1.&]D;93&1J&.5-5^&]#R&)"+"E:*"&>%&
D$#;c;%Ec;%^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O:,,;%,OQ"+%EO:%`C%E+O"**;"$3@+<&]P:"&@RC%E$:*B&Q:+@&+@%&
+:+$%&'(&+@%&>'I;<%*+^3(/""&1"2"%$,,7(d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&443(
&&&&/.&a;<"*&G:9@+,&)'<<:,,:'*&G%,3&.556O-6J&D>P%E,%&L((%I+,&'(&+@%&=$$:I:+&K'P:*9&"*>&2;<C:*9&'(&!'`:I&"*>&2"*9%E';,&
AE'>;I+,&"*>&V",+%,&'*&+@%&L*['R<%*+&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&1-,+&N%,,3J&K"E3&-0&Y&DCE3&..J&.556J&b3M3&LN)FGJ&.556J&N;CC3&M'3&
4J&LO.556O.4J&"+&61&]DCE3&-0J&.556^3&
&&&&/4&/""&b3&M3&N;#T)'<<U*&'*&+@%&AE'<'+:'*&"*>&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&G%,3&.551O-5J&AE'<'+:'*&'(&+@%&G%"$:Z"+:'*&
'(&+@%&G:9@+&+'&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&67+@&N%,,3J&D;93&/T.6J&.551J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O.O.TDOaG)ON;#3-O67O41J&"+&
4?&]D;93&.0J&.551^3&$8*@:021&NC%I:"$&G"CC'E+%;E&'*&+@%&L*['R<%*+&'(&LI'*3J&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,&"*>&+@%&G:9@+&+'&
2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&N;CC$R&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&>%$3:(F608",02"#(3*%(:'"(!"$,0Q$:0*2(*3(:'"(!01':(:*(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2J&
b3M3&N;#TI'<<U*&'*&+@%&AE'<'+:'*&"*>&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)M30ON;#3.O.556O.6&]\;$R&--J&.556^&]#R&
a">[:&d;:,,p^&e@%E%:*"(+%E&>%$3:(F608",02"#f3&S'E&"*&%`C$"*"+:'*&'(&+@%&>'I;<%*+U,&@:,+'ER&"*>&:*+%*+J&#""&COHRE(c)J&#6@%$(
*'+%&65J&"+&.00T.653&
&&&&/0&b3&M3&a:9@&)'<<UE&('E&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&!"@<(*3(:'"(\<(E<(S01'(A*--L%(3*%(S6-$2(!01':#(*2(:'"(/&*@"($28(A*2:"2:(*3(:'"(
!","?$2:(S6-$2(!01':#(W+,01$:0*2#(!",$:"8(:*(G560:$+,"(;&&"##(:*(/$3"(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2(628"%(42:L,(S6-$2(
!01':#(42#:%6-"2:#J&a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O1O4&]D;93&-4J&.55/^&]#R&_';:,%&DE#'E^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O:,,;%,OQ"+%EO&:*>%`3@+<3&
&
-7&
+'&Ib(;E+@%E&eI$"E:(Rf&+@%&I'*+%*+&'(&@;<"*&E:9@+,&'#$:9"+:'*,t&:*&E%$"+:'*&+'&"II%,,&+'&,"(%&
>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*3X/6&!@:,&"CC':*+<%*+&#%9"*&Q@"+&:,&:*('E<"$$R&E%(%EE%>&+'&",&
+@%&Wd%*%P"&AE'I%,,JX&"*&'*9':*9&I'$$"#'E"+:'*&#%+Q%%*&+@%&=*>%C%*>%*+&L`C%E+&"*>&+@%&
aG)&]:*&d%*%P"^&+'&>%+%E<:*%&+@%&$%9"$&,+"+;,&'(&+@%&E:9@+,&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*3&G%I%*+&
<'*+@,&@"P%&,%%*&"*&"#;*>"*I%&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,;CC'E+&('E&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&(E'<&
#'+@&Q:+@:*&"*>&Q:+@';+&+@%&d%*%P"&AE'I%,,3&
=*&\;$R&'(&.5-5&+@%&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&C",,%>&"&E%,'$;+:'*&('E<"$$R&E%I'9*:Z:*9&"&
@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*3/1&G%,'$;+:'*&10O.?.J&Q@:I@&C",,%>&Q:+@';+&>:,,%*+J&
I:+%,&<"*R&'(&+@%&+E%"+:%,&"*>&>%I$"E"+:'*,&*'+%>&"#'P%J&",&Q%$$&",&+@%&,+"*>"E>,&>%P%$'C%>&
#R&+@%&)LN)G&:*&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-63//&!@%&E%,'$;+:'*J&Q@:I@&>'%,&*'+&I$%"E$R&>%(:*%&+@%&
,I'C%&'E&I'*+%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+J&Q",&"E9;%>&#R&,'<%&+'&#%&"&>"*9%E';,&>:,+E"I+:'*&(E'<&+@%&
d%*%P"&AE'I%,,J&+@E%"+%*:*9&+'&CE%%<C+&:+,&(:*>:*9,&Q:+@&"*&",,%E+:'*&'(&E:9@+,&*'+&#",%>&:*&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&F+@%E,&P:%Q%>&+@%&E%,'$;+:'*&",&"&@%$C(;$&">>:+:'*&+'&+@%&d%*%P"&AE'I%,,&
>%,C:+%&:+,&P"9;%&$"*9;"9%3/7&!@%&=*>%C%*>%*+&L`C%E+&@%E,%$(&>%,IE:#%>&10O.?.&",&"&
W#E%"B+@E';9@3X/?&
!@%&('$$'Q:*9&N%C+%<#%EJ&+@%&aG)&E%",,%E+%>&:+,&I'*+E'$&'(&+@%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&"9%*>"&
#R&">'C+:*9&:+,&'Q*&E%,'$;+:'*&'*&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*375&G%I'9*:Z:*9&+@%&
d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&E%,'$;+:'*&'(&\;$R&.7+@J&+@%&aG)&>'I;<%*+&%,+"#$:,@%,&"&<'E%&
I'<CE%@%*,:P%&$%9"$&#",:,&('E&+@%&E:9@+J&%`@";,+:P%$R&>%(:*:*9&:+,&<"['E&,';EI%,&:*&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&/6&a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$&G%,3&/O..J&a;<"*&G:9@+,&"*>&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&/+@&N%,,3J&K"E3&4T.7J&
.557J&b3M3&dDFGJ&14>&N%,,3J&N;CC3&M'3&64J&DO14O64J&"+&-40&]K"E3&.7J&.557^3&!@%&Q'EB&'(&+@%&=*>%C%*>%*+&L`C%E+J&)"+"E:*"&
>UD$#;c;%Ec;%J&:,&'*9':*93&S'E&"&CE%$:<:*"ER&E%C'E+&'(&@%E&CE'9E%,,&"$'*9&Q:+@&"&,;<<"ER&'(&@%E&<"*>"+%&#""&=*>%C3&
L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&G%$"+%>&+'&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&)%*-*:0*2($28(
)%*:"&:0*2(*3($,,(S6-$2(!01':#.(A0?0,.()*,0:0&$,.(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#.(42&,68021(:'"(!01':(:*(>"?",*@-"2:.&
a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-5O1&]S%#3&.6J&.55?^&]#R&)"+"E:*"&>%&D$#;c;%Ec;%^3&
&&&&/1&!@%&a;<"*&G:9@+&+'&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&d3D3&G%,3&10O.?.J&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO10O.?.&&]\;$R&.7J&.5-5^3&*
&&&&//&483&"+&q73&
&&&&/7&K"*R&'(&+@%&0-&,+"+%,&"#,+":*:*9&(E'<&+@%&P'+%&Y&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&b3N3J&b3i3&"*>&!;EB%R&Y&[;,+:(:%>&+@%:E&I@':I%&",&
>%(%E%*I%&+'&+@%&d%*%P"&AE'I%,,3&!@%&b3N3&Q%*+&,'&("E&",&+'&,"R&+@"+&+@%&G%,'$;+:'*&>%,IE:#%>&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&
,"*:+"+:'*&@%&#%$:%P%>&*'+&+'&%`:,+&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&F+@%E,J&:*I$;>:*9&d%E<"*RJ&#%$:%P%>&+@%&P'+%&+'&#%&"&C"E+&'(&+@%&
d%*%P"&AE'I%,,&>%,C:+%&"*R&:<C%E(%I+:'*&'E&P"9;%*%,,&:*&:+,&$"*9;"9%3&/""(AE%,,&G%$%",%J&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$RJ&d%*%E"$&
D,,%<#$R&D>'C+,&G%,'$;+:'*&G%I'9*:Z:*9&DII%,,&+'&)$%"*&V"+%EJ&N"*:+"+:'*&",&"&a;<"*&G:9@+J&#R&G%I'E>%>&s'+%&'(&-..&:*&
S"P'EJ&M'*%&D9":*,+J&0-&D#,+%*+:'*,g&2%$%9"+%,&"$,'&)'*(:E<&M'<:*%%&+'&a%">&F((:I%&'(&=*+%E*"$&FP%E,:9@+&N%EP:I%,J&L$%I+&
8%$"E;,&+'&bMLA&d'P%E*:*9&)';*I:$J&b3M3&AE%,,&G%$%",%&dDO-5?1/&]\;$R&.7J&.5-5^3(
&&&&/?&/""(\E(GT@"%:(D",&*-"#(!"&*120:0*2($#($(S6-$2(!01':(*3(;&&"##(:*(/$3"($28(A,"$2(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.&
Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights ]\;$R&45J&.5-5^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3'@I@E3'E9OLMOM%Q,LP%*+,OA"9%,O2:,C$"RM%Q,3",C`nM%Q,=2o-5.05j_"*9=2oL3(
&&&&75&a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&a;<"*&G:9@+,&"*>&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-6O_3-0&
]N%C3&.0J&.5-5^J&"+&@++CHOO>"II%,,T'>,3;*3'E9O!KAO?410453-/--4.5773@+<$3&
&
-?&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q37-&G%,'$;+:'*&66O_3-0&I'*I$;>%,&+@"+&We+f@%&a;<"*&G:9@+&+'&,"(%&>E:*B:*9&
Q"+%E&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*&:,&>%E:P%>&(E'<&+@%&E:9@+&+'&"*&">%c;"+%&,+"*>"E>&'(&$:P:*9&"*>&
:*%`+E:I"#$R&E%$"+%>&+'&+@%&E:9@+&+'&+@%&@:9@%,+&"++":*"#$%&,+"*>"E>&'(&C@R,:I"$&"*>&<%*+"$&
@%"$+@J&",&Q%$$&",&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&"*>&@;<"*&>:9*:+R3X7.&!@%&aG)&E%,'$;+:'*&<"EB,&+@%&(:E,+&
+:<%&+@"+&+@%&)';*I:$&@",&>%I$"E%>&:+,%$(&('E<"$$R&'*&+@%&:,,;%&'(&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3&
D+&+@%&*"+:'*"$&$%P%$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&"E%&CE'+%I+%>&#R&-/&I'*,+:+;+:'*,J&+@%&<',+&E%I%*+&
'(&Q@:I@&])'*9'^&%`C$:I:+$R&E%I'9*:Z%,&W+@%&E:9@+&'(&"II%,,&+'&Q"+%EX&",&W9;"E"*+%%>3X74&!@%&
E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&@",&"$,'&%*['R%>&E%I%*+&E%I'9*:+:'*&:*&+@%&Q'EB&'(&E%9:'*"$J&:*+%ET
9'P%E*<%*+"$&'E9"*:Z"+:'*,&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&)';*I:$&'(&L;E'C%70&"*>&D(E:I"*&b*:'*J76&
,+"+%<%*+,&#R&*"+:'*"$&%`%I;+:P%,&,;CC'E+:*9&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&E%I'9*:+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J71&
"*>&+@%&'((:I:"$&C'$:I:%,&'(&>:P%E,%&*'*T,+"+%&"I+'E,37/&
!@:,&:*IE%",:*9&"IB*'Q$%>9%<%*+&'(&"*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&<%"*,&
+@"+&%P%*&#%('E%&+@%&">'C+:'*&'(&+@%&.5-5&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&E%,'$;+:'*J&%P%ER&<%<#%ET
,+"+%&'(&+@%&b3M3&@">&"IB*'Q$%>9%>&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"+&$%",+&'*I%&Y&Q@%+@%E&#R&*"+:'*"$&
$%9:,$"+:'*J&:*>%C%*>%*+&>%I$"E"+:'*J&+E%"+R&,:9*"+;E%&'E&<%<#%E,@:C&:*&"&,;CC'E+:P%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&7-&483&"+&q.3&
&&&&7.&48<("+&q43&!@%&aG)U,&I'*I$;,:'*&,%%<,&+'&%,+"#$:,@&"&@:%E"EI@R&'(&$%9"$&,';EI%,&('E&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&+@"+&Q:$$&#%&
:*P%,+:9"+%>&<'E%&+@'E';9@$R&#%$'Q3&
&&&&74&Constitution de la Rpublique Dmocratique du Congo&S%#3&-7J&.5513&*
"E+3&07J&-7&]w_%&>E':+&r&;*&$'9%<%*+&>pI%*+J&$%&>E':+&>x"IIy,&r&$x%";&C'+"#$%&%+&r&$xp*%E9:%&p$%I+E:c;%&,'*+&9"E"*+:,3U^&
&&&&70&/"".("<1<.();AG()%"#08"2:(A$,,#(3*%(;&&"##(:*(D$:"%(:*(+"(!"&*120Q"8($#($(B$#0&(S6-$2(!01':&&Council of Europe&]K"E3&
.5J&.55?^J&@++C,HOOQI>3I'%3:*+Os:%Q2'I3[,Cn:>oh0..444jN:+%o2)3&
&&&&76&/"".("<1<.(FE9"*:Z"+:'*&'(&D(E:I"*&b*:+RJ&D(E:I"*&)@"E+%E&'*&+@%&G:9@+,&"*>&V%$("E%&'(&+@%&)@:$>J&"E+3&-0].^]I^J&\;$R&--J&
-??5J&FDb&2'I3&)D8O_LdO.03?O0?3&!@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&@",&"$,'&(';*>&,'<%&,;CC'E+&:*&+@%&[;>:I:"$&Q'EB&'(&+@%&D(E:I"*&
)'<<:,,:'*3&=*&:+,&06+@&FE>:*"ER&N%,,:'*&'(&.55?J&+@%&)'<<:,,:'*&CE'+%I+%>&"II%,,&+'&,"(%&"*>&C'+"#$%&Q"+%E&Q:+@&%`C$:I:+&
E%(%E%*I%&+'&+@%&,+"*>"E>,&'(&"P":$"#:$:+RJ&"II%,,:#:$:+RJ&"II%C+"#:$:+R&"*>&c;"$:+R&,%+&#R&+@%&)LN)G&:*&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-0&
'*&+@%&G:9@+&+'&a%"$+@3&!@:,&E%I%*+&>%I:,:'*&"$,'&$:*B%>&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&+'&DE+:I$%,&0&"*>&..&'(&+@%&)@"E+%E3&&
/""()%*+E%&'*&a';,:*9&G:9@+,&"*>&LP:I+:'*,&P3&N;>"*J&D(E3&)'<<x*&a;<3&j&A%'C$%,x&G+,3&]AWS!G(?<(/68$2^J&)'<<3&M'3&.?1T
56&]\;$R&.?J&.5-5^g&SE%%&_%9"$&D,,:,+"*I%&dE';C&P3&z":E%J&D(E3&)'<<U*&a;<3&j&A%'C$%,x&G+,3J&)'<<3&M'3&.6O7?J&0/O?5J&
61O?-&j&-55O?4&]FI+3J&-??6^3&/""(1"2"%$,,7()LN)GJ&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-0H&!@%&G:9@+&+'&+@%&a:9@%,+&D++":*"#$%&N+"*>"E>&'(&
a%"+@J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.O.555O0&]D;93&--J&.555^J&"+&@++CHOOQQQ3;*@I@E3I@O+#,O>'I3*,(O],R<#'$ÔL3)3-.3.555303L*3&
&&&&71&=*&.5-5J&A%E;&C",,%>&"&*%Q&$"Q&E%I'9*:Z:*9&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&",&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&"*>&%*,;E:*9&+@"+&E%,';EI%,&I"**'+&
#%&#';9@+&"*>&;,%>&",&CE:P"+%&CE'C%E+R3&/""()"%6R(A*21%"##(;@@%*?"#(D$:"%(C$H.&International Water and Sanitation
Centre&]DCE3&4J&.55?^J&@++CHOOQQQ3:EI3*$OC"9%O0/16.3&8'$:P:"&"*>&d%E<"*R&"$,'&<">%&>%I$"E"+:'*,&+@:,&R%"E&
E%I'9*:Z:*9&+@%&E:9@+3&/""&B*,0?0$()6#'"#(3*%($(\20?"%#$,(D$:"%(!01':J&New Tang Dynasty Television Online&]K"E3&.4J&
.5-5^J&@++CHOO%*9$:,@3*+>+P3I'<O*+>+Ph%*O*,h,"O.5-5T54T.4O451.16.6-.-03@+<$g&&
F"%-$27(3*%(A,"$2(>%02O021(D$:"%($#($(B$#0&(S6-$2(!01':.&German Information Centre New Delhi&]K"E3&.4J&.5-5^J&
@++CHOO9%E<"*T:*('3I'<OCE%,,h,@'Q*%Q,3C@CnC:>o.4/03&
&&&&7/&/"".("<1<.(42:",(D$:"%()*,0&7J&Intel Corporation&]K"E3&.5-5^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3:*+%$3I'<OD,,%+,OA2SOA'$:IRO=*+%$hV"+%EhA'$:IR3C>(&]">'C+:*9&+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&CE'<;$9"+%>&#R&+@%&bM&
NR,+%<H&WC%'C$%x,&E:9@+&+'&,"(%J&,;((:I:%*+J&"II%C+"#$%J&C@R,:I"$$R&"II%,,:#$%&"*>&"(('E>"#$%&Q"+%E&('E&C%E,'*"$&"*>&>'<%,+:I&
;,%X^3&d%*%E"$$RJ&@'Q%P%EJ&CE:P"+%&:*+%E%,+,&@"P%&%`CE%,,%>&I'*I%E*&('E&+@%&I'>:(:I"+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&Q'EE:%>&+@"+&+@%R&
Q:$$&E%,+E:I+&CE:P"+:Z"+:'*&"*>&,'<%+:<%,J&+@%&"I@:%P%<%*+&'(&+@%&(;$$&CE'P:,:'*&'(&I$%"*&Q"+%E3&/"".("<1<.(;2*:'"%(B$8(48"$(
D'0&'(D"(E""8(:*(;&:(W2.(Global Water Intelligence&]K"E3&-7J&.5-5^J(
@++CHOOQQQ39$'#"$Q"+%E:*+%$3I'<O:*,:9@+O"*'+@%ET#">T:>%"TQ@:I@TQ%T*%%>T"I+3@+<$3&
&
.5&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&'E9"*:Z"+:'*377&!@:,&Q';$>&,%%<&+'&%P:*I%&"&>%P%$'C:*9&$"Q&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
I;,+'<37?&=*&.550J&+@%&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&_"Q&D,,'I:"+:'*&E%P:,%>&:+,&a%$,:*B:&G;$%,&'*&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&V"+%E&G%,';EI%,&#R&C;#$:,@:*9&+@%&8%E$:*&G;$%,3&!@%&>'I;<%*+&:,&<%"*+&+'&
W%`CE%,,&E;$%,&'(&$"Q&",&+@%R&CE%,%*+$R&,+"*>,&e,:If&"*>J&+'&"&,<"$$&%`+%*+J&E;$%,&*'+&R%+&
#:*>:*9&$%9"$&'#$:9"+:'*,&#;+&Q@:I@J&:*&+@%&[;>9<%*+&'(&+@%&D,,'I:"+:'*J&"E%&%<%E9:*9&",&
E;$%,&'(&I;,+'<"ER&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3X?5&N%I+:'*&-/&'(&+@"+&>'I;<%*+&:,&>%P'+%>&+'&W+@%&
G:9@+&'(&DII%,,&+'&V"+%E3X&);,+'<J&@'Q%P%EJ&E%<":*,&:*,;((:I:%*+$R&>%P%$'C%>&+'&
:*>%C%*>%*+$R&CE'+%I+&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&('E&+Q'&E%",'*,3&S:E,+J&+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&
E:9@+&>%P%$'C%>&"+&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$J&+@';9@&9E%"+$R&I$"E:(:%>&#R&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6J&
,+:$$&E%$:%,&@%"P:$R&'*&+@%&WI'*+%*+T9:P:*9X&(;*I+:'*&'(&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&"*>&$%9:,$"+:'*&>;%&+'&
:+,&*'P%$+R3?-&D,&:(&*'+:*9&+@:,J&)@"C+%E&=s&'(&+@%&8%E$:*&G;$%,&';+$:*%,&#",:I&CE:*I:C$%,&('E&"&
@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&#;+&"P':>,&';+$:*:*9&+@%&E:9@+U,&I'*+%*+&:*&>%+":$3?.&N%I'*>$RJ&+@%&:>%"&
'(&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&@",&+E:99%E%>&+@%&';+,C'B%*&E%(;,"$&'(&,'<%&,+"+%,&+'&"II%C+&+@"+&
E:9@+U,&%*,@E:*%<%*+&:*+'&#:*>:*9&$"QJ&"&E%"$:+R&+@"+&<"R&@:*>%E&+@%&>%P%$'C<%*+&'(&$%9"$&
I;,+'<3&)"*">"&@",&>%I$"E%>&+@"+&:+&>'%,&*'+&#%$:%P%&,;I@&"&E:9@+&+'&%`:,+&:*&"*R&Q"R3?4&&
&
B<(>"302021(:'"(C"1$,(/*6%&"(*3($(!01':(:*(D$:"%(
&
&
D$+@';9@&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'<<;*:+R&@",&"IB*'Q$%>9%>&+@%&%`:,+%*I%&'(&"&@;<"*&
E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&+@%&>'I;<%*+"+:'*&';+$:*%>&"#'P%&>'%,&*'+&%((%I+:P%$R&>%(:*%&+@%&,"1$,&
&*2:"2:&'(&,;I@&"&E:9@+3&=*:+:"$&%(('E+,&+'&>'&,'J&$:B%&+@',%&'(&A%+%E&d$%:IBJ&#%9"*&#R&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&77&COHRE(a), #6@%$&*'+%&07J&"+&.T43&
&&&&7?&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&I;,+'<&:,&9%*%E"$$R&I'*,:>%E%>&'*%&'(&+@%&CE:*I:C$%&,';EI%,&'(&#:*>:*9&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&/""&N+"+;+%&'(&
+@%&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)';E+&'(&\;,+:I%J&#6@%$&*'+%&4?J&"+&"E+3&473&
&&&&?5&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&_"Q&D,,'I:"+:'*&e=_DfJ&B"%,02(!6,"#(*2(D$:"%(!"#*6%&"#(0&]D;93&.-J&.550^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3I"Q"+%ET:*('3*%+O$:#E"ERO%*9O$O#%E$:*hE;$%,3C>(&e@%E%:*"(+%E&B"%,02(!6,"#K3(
&&&&?-&D*&:*P%,+:9"+:'*&'(&+@:,&E'$%&:,&+@%&Q'EB&'(&{=s&"*>&s&'(&+@:,&%,,"R3&
&&&&?.&B"%,02(!6,"#J&#6@%$&*'+%&?5J&"+&.4T.03&&
&&&&?4&)"*">"U,&C',:+:'*&",&"&C'+%*+:"$&WC%E,:,+%*+&'#[%I+'EX&:,&#%$:%P%>&+'&,+%<&(E'<&"&C%EI%:P%>&I'*($:I+&#%+Q%%*&Q"+%E&
E:9@+,&"*>&MDS!D3&2%C%*>:*9&'*&+@%&9$'#"$&CE%P"$%*I%&'(&,;I@&"&C',:+:'*J&+@%&>%P%$'C<%*+&'(&I;,+'<&<"R&#%&@:*>%E%>3&;(
E$:0*2$,(>0#1%$&".(A$2$8$L#(/'$-"36,()*#0:0*2(*2(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&The Council of Canadians&]K"E3&.6J&.557^.(
@++CHOOQQQ3I"*">:"*,3'E9OQ"+%EO>'I;<%*+,OVV2O.55?OVV2SNT545?TG!V3C>(3*
&]W=*&.55.&"*>&.554J&)"*">"&Q",&+@%&'*$R&I';*+ER&+'&P'+%&"9":*,+&b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&]bM^&E%,'$;+:'*,&'*&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&
Q"+%EJ&,+"+:*9J&w)"*">"&>'%,&*'+&"II%C+&+@"+&+@%E%&:,&"&E:9@+&+'&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*3UX^3&)"*">"U,&'((:I:"$&C',:+:'*&
<"R&#%&,'(+%*:*9J&@'Q%P%EJ&",&%P:>%*I%>&#R&+@%:E&P'+%&'(&"#,+%*+:'*&E%9"E>:*9&+@%&.5-5&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&E%,'$;+:'*&'*&
+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*J&#6@%$&*'+%&/13&N+:$$&)"*">"U,&E%CE%,%*+"+:P%&:*,:,+%>&'*&+@"+&'II",:'*&+@"+&*'&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*,%*,;,&@">&#%%*&E%"I@%>&'*&+@%&:,,;%3&/""&N+"+%<%*+&'(&+@%&G%CE%,%*+"+:P%&'(&)"*">"&+'&+@%&b3M3&d%*%E"$&
D,,%<#$R&]\;$R&.7J&.5-5^J&%"@%02:"8(02(AE%,,&G%$%",%J&#6@%$&*'+%&/73&
&
.-&
I'*,:>%E:*9&+@%&*+,01$:0*2#&E%$"+%>&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3?0&!@%,%&,'<%Q@"+&;*,'C@:,+:I"+%>&
%*>%"P'E,&":<%>&"+&"*,Q%E:*9&c;%,+:'*,&"#';+&+@%&,I'C%&'(&,;I@&"&E:9@+J&:*I$;>:*9&@'Q&
<;I@&Q"+%E&:+&Q';$>&E%c;:E%&"*>&('E&Q@"+&C;EC',%,3&D++%<C+,&"+&WE:9@+,&I'*,+E;I+:'*X&@"P%&
#%I'<%&:*IE%",:*9$R&%$"#'E"+%&'P%E&+@%&$",+&+Q%*+R&R%"E,3&!@%&(:E,+&'(&+@%,%&Q%E%&9E';*>%>&
:*&I:P:$&"*>&C'$:+:I"$&E:9@+,&"E9;<%*+,&:*&,;CC'E+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%3&K'E%&E%I%*+&"++%<C+,J&
$:B%&+@',%&'(&i:%(%E&"*>&8Ek$<"**?6&'E&=E;['J?1&,;CC'E+&+@%&%`:,+%*I%&'(&"*&:*>%C%*>%*+&
E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&",&"&>%E:P"+:P%&'(&,+"+%,U&#*&0*^"&*2*-0&&E:9@+,&'#$:9"+:'*,3&=+&:,&(E'<&+@:,&
I'*,+E;I+:'*&+@"+&Q%&(:*>&+@%&+E;%&$%9"$&,@"C%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3&
&
!@%&b2aGJ&";+@'E%>&:*&-?07J&9;"E"*+%%,&%P%ER'*%&W+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%J&$:#%E+R&"*>&
,%I;E:+R&'(&+@%&C%E,'*3X?/&V"+%E&:,&*'+&%`C$:I:+$R&%*,@E:*%>&:*&+@%&2%I$"E"+:'*J&+@';9@&
DE+:I$%&.6&*'+%,&+@"+&We%fP%ER'*%&@",&+@%&E:9@+&+'&"&,+"*>"E>&'(&$:P:*9&">%c;"+%&('E&+@%&
@%"$+@&"*>&Q%$$T#%:*9&'(&@:<,%$(&"*>&'(&@:,&("<:$RJ&:*I$;>:*9&(''>J&I$'+@:*9J&@';,:*9&"*>&
<%>:I"$&I"E%&"*>&*%I%,,"ER&,'I:"$&,%EP:I%,3X?7&!@%&*'*T#:*>:*9&E:9@+,&%*,@E:*%>&:*&+@%&
b2aG&Q%E%&,C$:+&:*+'&+Q'&I'P%*"*+,J&'*%&CE'+%I+:*9&I:P:$&"*>&C'$:+:I"$&E:9@+,&]=))AG^&"*>&
+@%&'+@%EJ&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&"*>&I;$+;E"$&E:9@+,&]=)LN)G^3??&)'<<'*&"E+:I$%&-].^&'(&#'+@&
)'P%*"*+,&,+"+%,&+@"+J&W:*&*'&I",%&<"R&"&C%'C$%&#%&>%CE:P%>&'(&:+,&'Q*&<%"*,&'(&
,;#,:,+%*I%3X&N;I@&"&W<%"*,&'(&,;#,:,+%*I%X&@",&#%%*&@%$>&+'&*%I%,,"E:$R&:*I$;>%&Q"+%E3-55&
!@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&+@%*J&I"*&#%&WI'*,+E;%>X&(E'<&%:+@%E&'(&+@%,%&>'I;<%*+,&+'&
>:((%E%*+&I'*I%C+;"$&%*>,J&"*>&"E9;<%*+,&@"P%&#%%*&<">%&('E&#'+@&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*,3&!@%&
'E:9:*&",,%E+%>&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&I"*&@"P%&"&$"E9%&:<C"I+&:*&*"+:'*"$&I';E+E''<,J&Q@%E%&
E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*&<"R&>%C%*>&'*&+E%"+R&E"+:(:I"+:'*3-5-&!@:,&:,&Q@R&:+&:,&:<C'E+"*+&+'&
>:,+:*9;:,@&+@%&Q"R&:*&Q@:I@&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&CE'C%E$R&>%E:P%>3&&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&?0&/""&1"2"%$,,R&d$%:IBJ&!01':(:*(D$:"%J&#6@%$(*'+%&0.3(
&&&&?6&/6@%$(*'+%&/3&
&&&&?1&/""(D*+'*:'&L3&=E;['J&='"(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev&.1/&].55/^3&
&&&&?/&b2aGJ&#6@%$(*'+%&06J&"+&"E+3&43&
&&&&?7&48<&"+&"E+3&.63&
&&&&??&!@%&>:,+:*I+:'*&Q",&$"E9%$R&'*%&I";,%>&#R&)'$>&V"E&C'$:+:I,3&!@%&E:9@+,&:*&+@%&b2aG&Q%E%&I'*,:>%E%>&+'&@"P%&*'&P"$;%&
E%$"+:P%&+'&%"I@&'+@%EJ&R%+&<"*R&V%,+%E*&C'$:+:I:"*,J&*'+"#$R&b3N3&AE%,:>%*+&G'',%P%$+J&,;#'E>:*"+%>&,'I:"$&"*>&%I'*'<:I&
I'*I%E*,&+'&I:P:$&"*>&C'$:+:I"$&E:9@+,3&/"".("<1<.(SE"*B$:*&23&G'',%P%$+J&;226$,(/:$:"(*3(:'"(\20*2(;88%"##(:*(A*21%"##&]\"*&1J&
-?0-^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOO"<%E:I"*E@%+'E:I3I'<O,C%%I@%,O(>E+@%(';E(E%%>'<,3@+<&]",,%E+:*9&(';E&#",:I&@;<"*&
(E%%>'<,&T&,C%%I@O%`CE%,,:'*J&E%$:9:'*J&(E%%>'<&(E'<&Q"*+J&(E%%>'<&(E'<&(%"E&Y&'(&Q@:I@&,'I:"$&"*>&%I'*'<:I&I'*I%E*,&
('E<&'*$R&"&,%I'*>"ER&C"E+^3&
&&&&-55&i:%(%E&j&8Ek$<"**J&#6@%$&*'+%&/J&"+&-76&]We=f+&:,&I$%"E&+@"+&"II%,,&+'&">%c;"+%&c;"$:+"+:P%&"*>&c;"*+:+"+:P%&Q"+%E&
,;CC$:%,&:,&"&(;*>"<%*+"$&CE%I'*>:+:'*&('E&+@%&(;$$&E%"$:,"+:'*&e,:If&'(&,%P%E"$&'(&+@%&E:9@+,&%`C$:I:+$R&9;"E"*+%%>&;*>%E&+@%&
=))AG&"*>&+@%&=)LN)G3X^3&
&&&&-5-&D+&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$J&,;I@&",&:*&+@%&:*+%ETD<%E:I"*&,R,+%<J&E:9@+,&'E:9:*&:,&$%,,&:<C'E+"*+&+@"*&+@%&W$"QR%E:*9X&
'(&+@',%&$:+:9"+:*9&+@%&I",%,3&/""&K%$:,@&#6@%$J&*'+%&46J&"+&-//3&
&
..&
=(&'*%&>%E:P%,&"&;*:P%E,"$&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&(E'<&+@%&=))AGJ&Q"+%E&:,&",,%E+%>&",&
"&(;*>"<%*+"$&%$%<%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%J-5.&E%c;:E:*9&<":*$R&+@"+&,+"+%,&>'&*'+&:*+%E(%E%&:*&
:+,&%*['R<%*+&Y&"&*%9"+:P%&'#$:9"+:'*3-54&&N'<%&@"P%&"E9;%>&('E&+@:,&I'*,+E;I+:'*&#%I";,%&
+@%&=))AG&C%E<:+,&*'&>%E'9"+:'*J&#%I";,%&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&<"R&:*&,'<%&I:EI;<,+"*I%,&#%&
I'*,:>%E%>&"&a6#(&*1"2#&*'E<J&"*>&#%I";,%&+@%&=))AG&:,&:<<%>:"+%$R&%*('EI%"#$%3-50&&=*&("I+J&
I%E+":*&";+@'E,&@"P%&9'*%&,'&("E&",&+'&,;99%,+&+@"+&"$$&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&$:+:9"+:'*&:*&
I%E+":*&$%9"$&,R,+%<,&,@';$>&#%&WE%(E"<%>X&",&I:P:$TC'$:+:I"$&I$":<,3-56 &D,&i:%(%E&"*>&
8Ek$<"**&"><:+J&W,;I@&"&E:9@+&Q';$>&9:P%&E:,%&+'&"&P%ER&('EI%(;$&,%+&'(&:<<%>:"+%&,+"+%&
'#$:9"+:'*,3X-51&&
!@%&a;<"*&G:9@+,&)'<<:++%%&]))AG^&E%I%*+$R&%<#E"I%>&"&,:<:$"E&"CCE'"I@&:*&:+,&
)'*I$;>:*9&F#,%EP"+:'*,&+'&=,E"%$U,&!@:E>&A%E:'>:I&G%C'E+&:*&.5-53-5/&S'E&+@%&(:E,+&+:<%&:*&
@:,+'ER&+@"+&#'>R&@%$>&+@%&>%*:"$&'(&Q"+%E&+'&#%&"&P:'$"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+,&+'&$:(%&"*>&%c;"$&
CE'+%I+:'*&;*>%E&+@%&$"Q3-57&=+&:,&:<C'E+"*+J&@'Q%P%EJ&+'&(;$$R&;*>%E,+"*>&+@%&)'<<:++%%U,&
E%",'*:*93&!@%&F#,%EP"+:'*,&>'&*'+&:*>:I"+%&+@%&$%9"$&#",:,&('E&"*&:*>%C%*>%*+&E:9@+&+'&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-5.&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'P%*"*+&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&"E+3&1J&2%I3&-1J&-?11J&???&b3M3!3N3&-/-3&e@%E%:*"(+%E&=))AGf3&
&&&&-54&N;,"*&K'$$%E&FB:*J&C0+"%:7($28(D",3$%"R(/*-"(4##6"#(02(S6-$2(!01':#(='"*%7.&02&Nomos XXIII: Human Rights&.45J&
.4/&]\3&G'$"*>&A%**'IB&j&\'@*&V3&)@"C<"*&%>,3J&-?7-^3&!@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&:,&@%$>&#R&<"*R&"$,'&+'&:*I$;>%&C',:+:P%&
'#$:9"+:'*,3&V@%+@%E&'E&*'+&'*%&#%$:%P%,&+@%&CE:*I:C"$$R&W*%9"+:P%X&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&"$,'&:*I$;>%,&C',:+:P%&'#$:9"+:'*,J&+@%&
%,,%*I%&'(&=))AG&"E+3&1&,%%<,&+'&;*>';#+%>$R&I'*,:,+&:*&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&+@%&%01':(+'&$:(%&:+,%$(J&*'+&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'E&
IE%"+:'*&'(&+@%&I:EI;<,+"*I%,&:*&Q@:I@&$:(%&I"*&#%&9;"E"*+%%>3&!@:,&,%I'*>&+",B&:,&<'E%&"B:*&+'&+@%&Q'EB&'(&,'I:'T
%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3&/"" J.E.S. Fawcett, The Application of the European Convention on Human Rights&4/&]-?7/^&
]:*,:,+:*9&:*&+@%&I",%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&:*&+@%&L;E'C%"*&)@"E+%E&+@"+J&W:+&:,&*'+&$:(%J&#;+&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%J&Q@:I@&:,&+'&#%&
CE'+%I+%>&#R&$"QX^3*
&&&&-50&/6@%$&*'+%&/J&"+&-713&
&&&&-56&/"".("<1<.(\"<%,&_3&)"P"$$"E'&j&L<:$R&\3&NI@"((%EJ&C"##($#(9*%"R(!":'02O021(/6@%$2$:0*2$,(C0:01$:0*2(*3(G&*2*-0&($28(
/*&0$,(!01':#(02(:'"(;-"%0&$#.&61&Hastings L.J.&.-/&].556^3&S'E&"&,:<:$"E&"E9;<%*+&('E&+@%&b3M3&,R,+%<J&,%%&9%*%E"$$R&
K:I@"%$&\3&2%**:,&j&2"P:>&A3&N+%Q"E+J&[6#:0&0$+0,0:7(*3(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#R(/'*6,8(='"%"(B"($2(42:"%2$:0*2$,(
A*-@,$02:#(9"&'$20#-(:*(;8a680&$:"(:'"(!01':#(:*(U**8.(D$:"%.(S*6#021.(S"$,:'_&?7]4^&Am. J. Intl L. 01.J&01/&].550^3&
!@%,%&,';EI%,&"E%&I:+%>&"*>&IE:+:I:Z%>&:*&K%$:,@J&#6@%$(*'+%&463&
&&&&-51&i:%(%E&j&8Ek$<"**J&#6@%$&*'+%&/J&"+&-7/3&
&&&&-5/&)'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&!@:E>&A%E:'>:I&G%C'E+&'(&=,E"%$&>;%&:*&.55/J&b3M3&2'I3J&))AGO)O=NGO4&]M'P3&.-J&
.557^J&"+&@++CHOO>"II%,,T>>,T*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd57O066O?5OA2SOd57066?53C>(nFC%*L$%<%*+3&!@%&a;<"*&
G:9@+,&)'<<:++%%&:,&+@%&#'>R&I@"E9%>&Q:+@&=))AG&%*('EI%<%*+3&/""&=))AGJ&#6@%$&*'+%&-5.J&"+&"E+3&.7J&0-3&&
&&&-57&!@%&Q'EB&'(&I'*I$;>:*9&'#,%EP"+:'*,&E%c;:E%,&,;#+$%&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*3&D&WE%I'<<%*>"+:'*X&:,&<">%&Q:+@&%`C$:I:+&
E%(%E%*I%&+'&"*&=))AG&"E+:I$%&+@E';9@&C"E%*+@%+:I"$&I:+"+:'*&"+&+@%&I'*I$;,:'*&'(&+@%&'#,%EP"+:'*&C"E"9E"C@3&D$+@';9@&+@%&
)'<<:++%%&*%P%E&I'*>%<*,&=,E"%$&('E&I'*+E"P%*:*9&+@%&$"QJ&+@%&,;#,%c;%*+&E%I'<<%*>"+:'*&('E&"I+:'*&:<C$:%,&+@"+&+@%&
$"Q&C;E,;"*+&+'&+@%&"E+:I$%,&E%(%E%*I%>&:,&*'+&#%:*9&">%c;"+%$R&'#,%EP%>3&=*&:+,&'#,%EP"+:'*,&E%$"+%>&+'&Q"+%E&"II%,,J&+@%&
)'<<:++%%&I:+%,&DE+:I$%,&1&]G:9@+&+'&_:(%^&"*>&.1&]G:9@+&+'&Lc;"$&AE'+%I+:'*^&=))AG&E%C%"+%>$R3&/""()'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&
A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&)'*,:>%E"+:'*&'(&G%C'E+,&N;#<:++%>&#R&N+"+%,&A"E+:%,&;*>%E&DE+:I$%&05&'(&+@%&)'P%*"*+&]=,E"%$^J&q7J&-/J&-7J&
.0J&b3M3&2'I3&))AGO)O=NGO)FO4&]N%C3&4J&.5-5^J("+(@++CHOO>"II%,,T>>,T
*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd-5O007O51OA2SOd-5007513C>(nFC%*L$%<%*+3&D&#%++%E&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%&$%9"$&
c;%,+:'*,&"+&@"*>&I"*&#%&(';*>&#R&E%">:*9&+@%&W_:,+&'(&=,,;%,3X&/""&)'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&_:,+&'(&=,,;%,&+'&#%&
!"B%*&bC&:*&)'**%I+:'*&Q:+@&+@%&)'*,:>%E"+:'*&'(&+@%&!@:E>&A%E:'>:I&G%C'E+&'(&=,E"%$&]D>P"*I%&s%E,:'*^J&b3M3&2'I3(
))AGO)O=NGO|O4&]M'P3&-/J&.55?^J("+(@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,O@EIO>'I,OD>P"*I%s%E,:'*,O))AGT)T=NGT
|43C>(3&
&
.4&
Q"+%E&>%E:P%>&(E'<&+@%&=))AGJ&#;+&'*$R&I$"E:(R&+@%&,I'C%&'(&'+@%EJ&Q%$$T%,+"#$:,@%>&
I:P:$OC'$:+:I"$&E:9@+,3&=*&:+,&(';E&E%(%E%*I%,&+'&=,E"%$:&(":$;E%,&E%9"E>:*9&Q"+%E&"II%,,J&+@%&
))AG&E%(%E,&'*$R&+'&,:+;"+:'*,&:*&Q@:I@&"II%,,&Q",&8"1%$8"8&]%`3&+@E';9@&+@%&>%,+E;I+:'*&'(&
%`:,+:*9&:*(E",+E;I+;E%^&'E&'028"%"8&]%`3&+@E';9@&E%,+E:I+:'*&'(&+@%&<'P%<%*+&'(&9''>,&"*>&
C%'C$%&%,,%*+:"$&+'&Q"+%E&CE'P:,:'*&'E&:*(E",+E;I+;E"$&:<CE'P%<%*+^3&D,&,;I@J&+@%&
)'<<:++%%U,&E%",'*:*9&%*,;E%,&+@"+&"*R&Q"+%ETE%$"+%>&'#$:9"+:'*&#",%>&'*&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&
E%<":*,&CE:*I:C"$$R&"&W*%9"+:P%X&'*%3&=+&:,&>';#+(;$&Q@%+@%E&+@%&)'<<:++%%&Q:$$&%P%E&",,%E+&
WC',:+:P%X&'#$:9"+:'*,J&*'+:*9&:+,&CE%P:';,&+E%"+<%*+&'(&,;I@&:,,;%,3-5?&=(&+@%&))AG&Q%E%&+'&
I'*,+E;%&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&"+&+@%&$%P%$&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&",&%"560%021(:'"(@%*?0#0*2&'(&$:(%T
,;,+":*:*9&%$%<%*+,&,;I@&",&Q"+%EJ--5&,;I@&"&I'*I%C+;"$&,+E%+I@&<:9@+&Q%"B%*&+@%&:*+%9E:+R&
'(&=))AG&DE+:I$%&1]-^&"*>&:*&+;E*J&:+,&>'<%,+:I&[;,+:I:"#:$:+R3---&N;I@&"&E:,B&:,&:*I'<C"+:#$%&
Q:+@&+@%&Q'EB&'(&$%9"$&I'*,+E;I+:'*&('E&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&",&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<&
E%$:%,&+'&"&9E%"+&%`+%*+&'*&+@%&I@"E"I+%E&'(&:+,&*"+:'*"$&;,%&Y&+@%&CE'I%,,&%`C$'E%>&:*&N%I+:'*&
=s3&
!'>"RJ&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&"E%&<'E%&"CCE'CE:"+%$R&I'*,+E;%>&",&*%I%,,"ER&('E&+@%&
%*['R<%*+&'(&+@%&WQ%$("E%X&E:9@+,&Q:+@:*&+@%&=)LN)G3&!@%,%&E:9@+,&"E%&9%*%E"$$R&,+%E%'+RC%>&
",&E%c;:E:*9&#'+@&C',:+:P%&"*>&*%9"+:P%&,+"+%&"I+:'*&('E&+@%:E&(;$$&E%"$:Z"+:'*3--.&AE%P:';,$RJ&
<',+&,I@'$"E,&>';#+%>&+@%:E&[;,+:I:"#:$:+RJ&",&+@%&=)LN)G&>'%,&*'+&%`C$:I:+$R&E%c;:E%&[;>:I:"$&
E%<%>R3--4&G%I%*+&I",%&$"QJ&@'Q%P%EJ&@",&CE'P%*&+@"+&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,&('E&+@%&E%,C%I+J&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-5?&N'<%&'(&+@%&)'<<:++%%U,&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,J&,C%I:(:I"$$R&M'3&1J&Q';$>&,%%<&+'&<"B%&:+&>:((:I;$+&+'&(:*>&"&>%(:*:+:P%&
P:'$"+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:(&'*%&Q%E%&"E9;%>&#%('E%&+@%&#'>R3&!@:,&:,&#%I";,%&"$+@';9@&+@%&)'<<:++%%&@",&P:%Q%>&+@%&E:9@+&
+'&$:(%&",&WE%c;:E%e:*9f&+@"+&,+"+%,&">'C+&C',:+:P%&<%",;E%,JX&:+&c;"$:(:%,&,;I@&"*&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&Q:+@&+@%&,+"+%<%*+J&W:*&+@:,&
I'**%I+:'*J&:+&Q';$>&#%&8"#0%$+,"&('E&,+"+%,&C"E+:%,&+'&+"B%&"$$&C',,:#$%&<%",;E%,&+'&E%>;I%&:*("*+&<'E+"$:+RtX&)'<<3&'*&
):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&1H&!@%&G:9@+&+'&_:(%J&-1+@&N%,,3J&\;$R&-.T45J&-?7.J&b3M3&dDFGJ&4/+@&N%,,3J&
N;CC3&M'3&05J&DO4/O05J&"+&q&6&]\;$R&45J&-?7.^J&%"@%02:"8(02&)'<C:$"+:'*&'(&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&"*>&d%*%E"$&
G%I'<<%*>"+:'*,&D>'C+%>&#R&a;<"*&G:9@+,&!E%"+R&8'>:%,J&b3M3&2'I3&aG=OdLMO-OG%P3-J&"+&1&]\;$R&./J&-??0^&]%<C@",:,&
">>%>^3&W2%,:E"#:$:+RX&:,&"*&'#P:';,$R&Q%"B%E&,+"*>"E>&'(&+E%"+R&%*('EI%<%*+&+@"*&WE%c;:E%<%*+3X&S'E&"*&%`C$"*"+:'*&'(&
>:((%E:*9&"I">%<:I&P:%Q,&'*&+@%&C',:+:P%&'E&*%9"+:P%&*"+;E%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&",&Q%$$&",&+@%&:<C'E+&'(&+@%&)'<<:++%%U,&
d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&1J&,%%&i:%(%E&j&8Ek$<"**J&#6@%$(*'+%(/.&"+&-77T?3&
&&&&--5&!@%&;,%&'(&+@%&C@E",%&W:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"QX&:,&<%"*+&+'&>:,+:*9;:,@&+@:,&"I+:P:+R&(E'<&+@%&Q'EB&'(&,'<%&*"+:'*"$&
I';E+,&CE'+%I+:*9&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&",&"&>%E:P"+:P%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&>;%&+'&[;E:,>:I+:'*"$&E%,+E:I+:'*3&/"".("<1<.(&W=*>:"JX&023%$&{&
=sJ&C"E+&).3&
&&&&---&/""(i:%(%E&j&8Ek$<"**J&#6@%$&*'+%&/J&"+&-7?&]"E9;:*9&+@"+&W'P%E+$R&C',:+:P%&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*,&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&3&3&3&I"EER&
+@%&E:,B&'(&#$;EE:*9&'E&'P%ET,+E%+I@:*9&e:+,f&*'E<"+:P%&I'*+%*+3X^3&
&&&&--.&/""(#6@%$&*'+%&-543&
&&&&--4&!@%&=)LN)G&>'%,&*'+&CE'P:>%&('E&[;>:I:"$&E%<%>RJ&*'+:*9&'*$R&+@"+&$%9"$&<%+@'>,&"E%&'*%&"CCE'CE:"+%&<%"*,&'(&
:<C$%<%*+"+:'*3&/""(=)LN)GJ&#6@%$(*'+%&4/J&"+&"E+3&.]-^3&=*&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&?J&@'Q%P%EJ&+@%&)LN)G&*'+%,&+@"+&)'P%*"*+&
E:9@+,&"E%&[;,+:I:"#$%J&"*>&+@"+&,+"+%,&(":$:*9&+'&'((%E&[;>:I:"$&CE'+%I+:'*&,@';$>&[;,+:(R&Q@R&+@%R&@"P%*U+&>'*%&,'3&/""()'<<3&
'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&?H&!@%&2'<%,+:I&DCC$:I"+:'*&'(&+@%&)'P%*"*+J&q&7J&b3M3&2'I3&
LO)3-.O-??7O.0&]2%I3&4J&-??7^J&"+&@++CHOO>'I;<%*+,T>>,T
*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd??O050O.0OC>(Od??050.03C>(nFC%*L$%<%*+3&
&
.0&
CE'+%I+:'*&"*>&(;$(:$$<%*+&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&$%"&[;>:I:"$$R&%*('EI%"#$%3--0&=*&("I+J&
"E9;:*9&+@"+&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&"E%&;*%*('EI%"#$%&<"R&@"P%&#%%*&'*%&'(&+@%&9E%"+%,+&
<:,I'*I%C+:'*,&:*&<'>%E*&@;<"*&E:9@+,&">P'I"IR3--6&&
!@%&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&CE:<"E:$R&>%E:P%>&(E'<&=)LN)G&DE+:I$%&--]-^&Y&
W+@%&I%*+E"$&$%9"$&#",:,&('E&+@%&E:9@+X&Y&#;+&:,&$:*B%>&+'&+@%&(;$(:$$<%*+&'(&'+@%E&%*;<%E"+%>&
E:9@+,&:*&--].^--1&"*>&-.]-^--/&=)LN)G3--7&DE+:I$%&--]-^&E%">,J&
(
e+f@%&N+"+%,&A"E+:%,&+'&+@%&CE%,%*+&)'P%*"*+&E%I'9*:Z%&+@%&E:9@+&'(&%P%ER'*%&+'&"*&">%c;"+%&
,+"*>"E>&'(&$:P:*9&('E&@:<,%$(&"*>&@:,&("<:$RJ&:*I$;>:*9&">%c;"+%&(''>J&I$'+@:*9&"*>&@';,:*9J&"*>&+'&
+@%&I'*+:*;';,&:<CE'P%<%*+&'(&$:P:*9&I'*>:+:'*,3&!@%&N+"+%,&A"E+:%,&Q:$$&+"B%&"CCE'CE:"+%&,+%C,&+'&
%*,;E%&+@%&E%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@:,&E:9@+J&E%I'9*:Z:*9&+'&+@:,&%((%I+&+@%&%,,%*+:"$&:<C'E+"*I%&'(&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'T'C%E"+:'*&#",%>&'*&(E%%&I'*,%*+3--?&
&
V"+%EU,&'<:,,:'*&(E'<&+@%&$:,+&'(&%$%<%*+,&%,,%*+:"$&('E&+@%&W">%c;"+%&,+"*>"E>&'(&$:P:*9X&
CE'+%I+%>&#R&DE+:I$%&--]-^&<"R&,+%<&(E'<&+@%&Q"R&+@%&CE%C"E"+'ER&I'<<:++%%&('E<;$"+%>&
b2aG&DE+:I$%&.6J&(E'<&Q@:I@&+@%&$"*9;"9%&:,&#'EE'Q%>3&a;<"*&E:9@+,&@:,+'E:"*&\'@"**%,&
K'E,:*B&:*,:,+,&+@"+&%"I@&E:9@+&:,&E%"$$R&"&$"R%E&'(&CE'+%I+:'*&'E9"*:Z%>&"E';*>&"&I'E%&
C@E",%J&Q@:I@&('E&DE+:I$%&.6&Q",&+@%&E:9@+&+'&W,%I;E:+R&:*&+@%&%P%*+&'(&;*%<C$'R<%*+&'E&
,:IB*%,,&3&3&3&'E&'+@%E&$"IB&'(&$:P%$:@''>&:*&I:EI;<,+"*I%,&#%R'*>&@:,&I'*+E'$3X-.5&!@%&
W">%c;"+%&,+"*>"E>&'(&$:P:*9X&$"*9;"9%&Q",&+"IB%>&'*+'&+@%&(E'*+&'(&+@:,&I'E%&CE'P:,:'*&#R&
,%P%E"$&_"+:*&D<%E:I"*&I';*+E:%,&"*>&CE'+%I+%>&(E'<&>%$%+:'*&#R&)@:*"3&N'I:"$&,%I;E:+R&Q",&
+@%&('I;,&'(&DE+:I$%&.6J&*'+&"&>%$:<:+"+:'*&'(&"$$&+@%&%$%<%*+,&%,,%*+:"$&+'&$:(%3&S'E&+@:,&E%",'*&
Q"+%E&Q",&CE%,;<"#$R&:<C$:%>&#R&+@%&Q'E>&W:*I$;>:*93X&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&--0&!@%&[;,+:I:"#:$:+R&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&:,&9%*%E"$$R&"IB*'Q$%>9%>3&/""&COHRE(c)J&#6@%$&*'+%&65J&"+&.//g&K%$:,@J&
#6@%$(*'+%&46g&V:*B%EJ&#6@%$&*'+%&413&
&&&&--6&/""()@:,"*9"&A;+%T)@%BQ%&j&M'E"&S$''>J&U%*-(>0?0#0*2(:*(42:"1%$:0*2R(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#($#(B$#0&(
S6-$2(!01':#.&02&Giving Meaning to Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights&4?J&4?&]=,("@"*&K%E"$:&j&s"$%E:%&
F',+%EP%$>&%>,3J&.55-^g&K%$:,@J&#6@%$(*'+%&46J&"+&A"E+&===D3&/""($,#*(i:%(%E&j&8Ek$<"**J&#6@%$&*'+%&/J&"+&-?-&]"E9;:*9&+@"+&
We+f@:,&>:I@'+'<Rt&:,&Q:>%$R&I'*,:>%E%>&"*&;*>;$R&*"EE'Q&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%&*"+;E%&'(&+@%,%&E:9@+,&"*>&I'EE%,C'*>:*9&
,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,3X^&
&&&&--1&=)LN)GJ&#6@%$&*'+%&4/J&"+&"E+3&--].^&]W!@%&N+"+%,&A"E+:%,&+'&+@%&CE%,%*+&)'P%*"*+J&E%I'9*:Z:*9&+@%&(;*>"<%*+"$&E:9@+&
'(&%P%ER'*%&+'&#%&(E%%&(E'<&@;*9%EJ&,@"$$&+"B%J&:*>:P:>;"$$R&"*>&+@E';9@&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'T'C%E"+:'*J&+@%&<%",;E%,J&
:*I$;>:*9&,C%I:(:I&CE'9E"<<%,J&Q@:I@&"E%&*%%>%>&3&3&3X^3&
&&&&--/&48<("+&"E+3&-.]-^&]W!@%&N+"+%,&A"E+:%,&+'&+@%&CE%,%*+&)'P%*"*+&E%I'9*:Z%&+@%&E:9@+&'(&%P%ER'*%&+'&+@%&%*['R<%*+&'(&+@%&
@:9@%,+&"++":*"#$%&,+"*>"E>&'(&C@R,:I"$&"*>&<%*+"$&@%"$+@3X^3&
&&&&--7&/""(COHRE(c)J&#6@%$&*'+%&65J&"+&/3&/""($,#*&i:%(%E&j&8Ek$$<"*J&#6@%$&*'+%&/J&"+&-?6&]WeDf&+E">:+:'*"$&%`%EI:,%&:*&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&I'*,+E;I+:'*&e>%<'*,+E"+%,f&3&3&3&+@"+&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&:<C$:%>&;*>%E&"E+:I$%,&--]-^&"*>&-.]-^&
=)LN)G3X^3&
&&&&--?&=)LN)GJ&#6@%$&*'+%&4/J&"+&"E+3&--]-^3&
&&&&-.5&Johannes Morsink, The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: Origins, Drafting and Intent,
-?-T?.&]-???^3&
&
.6&
!@%&<',+&C'Q%E(;$&$%9"$&,';EI%&+'&>"+%&('E&"*&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&"*&:*>%C%*>%*+&
@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&>%E:P%>&(E'<&+@%&=)LN)G&:,&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6&].554^&'(&+@%&
)LN)G3&!@%&C;EC',%&'(&"&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&:,&W+'&<"B%&+@%&%`C%E:%*I%&9":*%>t&+@E';9@&+@%&
%`"<:*"+:'*&'(&+@',%&e+E%"+R&<'*:+'E:*9f&E%C'E+,&"P":$"#$%&('E&+@%&#%*%(:+&'(&"$$&N+"+%,&
C"E+:%,&:*&'E>%E&+'&",,:,+&"*>&CE'<'+%&+@%:E&(;E+@%E&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&'(&+@%&)'P%*"*+3X-.-&
!@%&)LN)G&#%9"*&>E"(+:*9&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&:*&:+,&+@:E>&,%,,:'*J&"(+%E&#%:*9&:*P:+%>&+'&>'&
,'&#R&+@%&LI'*'<:I&"*>&N'I:"$&)';*I:$&]L)FNF)^&:*&-?77J&"*>&"(+%E&+@"+&:*P:+"+:'*&Q",&
%*>'E,%>&#R&+@%&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R3-..&L)FNF)&I'*(:E<%>&:+,&,;CC'E+&:*&-??5J&;E9:*9&+@%&
)LN)G&+'&WI'*+:*;%&;,:*9&+@"+&<%I@"*:,<&+'&>%P%$'C&+@%&(;$$%E&"CCE%I:"+:'*&'(&+@%&
'#$:9"+:'*,&'(&N+"+%&A"E+:%,&;*>%E&+@%&)'P%*"*+3X-.4&
&
d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&"E%&*'*T#:*>:*9J&"*>&",&,;I@J&<;,+&(:*>&,;CC'E+&('E&"$$&'(&+@%:E&
I'*I$;,:'*,&Q:+@:*&+@%&"II%C+%>&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&%"I@&E:9@+&+'&Q@:I@&+@%R&C%E+":*3&!@%R&<"R&
*'+&IE%"+%&*%Q&%*+:+$%<%*+,&"*>&'#$:9"+:'*,3&!@:,&E%,+E:I+:'*&'(&+@%&)'<<:++%%U,&<"*>"+%J&
I';C$%>&Q:+@&:+,&%`C%E+:,%&"*>&+@%&E%CE%,%*+"+:'*&'(&<%<#%E&,+"+%,J&9:P%,&:+,&)'<<%*+,&
WI'*,:>%E"#$%&e$%9"$f&Q%:9@+X&",&";+@'E:+"+:P%&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*,&'(&+@%&=)LN)G3-.0&d%*%E"$&
)'<<%*+&-6&]"^&>%(:*%,&+@%&*'E<"+:P%&I'*+%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&]#^&%,+"#$:,@%,&I'E%&
'#$:9"+:'*,&:*I;<#%*+&'*&,+"+%,J&]I^&*'+%,&W,C%I:"$&+'C:I,X&+'&I'*,:>%E&:*&)'P%*"*+&
"CC$:I"+:'*J&"*>&]>^&%,+"#$:,@%,&9;:>%$:*%,&('E&,+"+%&"I+:'*&:*&+@%&E%"$<&'(&*"+:'*"$&Q"+%E&
<"*"9%<%*+&C'$:IR3&!@%&>%(:*:+:'*&('E&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&(';*>&Q:+@:*&+@%&)'<<%*+&:,&
%`C$'E%>&#%$'QJ&",&,;CC'E+%>&"*>&(;E+@%E&I$"E:(:%>&#R&'+@%E&$%9"$&,';EI%,&$:B%&+@%&N;#T
)'<<:,,:'*&G%C'E+3-.6&
&
A<(='"(E*%-$:0?"(A*2:"2:(*3(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%($28(!"#@*2#0+0,0:0"#(!",$:"8(='"%":*(
&
&
!@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&%*+:+$%,&%"I@&C%E,'*&+'&,;((:I:%*+J&,"(%J&"II%C+"#$%J&"II%,,:#$%&"*>&
"(('E>"#$%&Q"+%E&('E&C%E,'*"$&"*>&>'<%,+:I&;,%3&!@:,&;,%&:*I$;>%,&+@%&CE%P%*+:'*&'(&>%"+@&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-.-&!@%&C;EC',%&'(&"&9%*%E"$&I'<<%*+&",&';+$:*%>&#R&+@%&)'<<:++%%&I"*&#%&(';*>&:*J&)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&=*+E'>;I+:'*H&!@%&A;EC',%&'(&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,J&4>&N%,,3J&S%#3&1T.0J&-?7?J&b3M3&LN)FGJ&-?7?J&N;CC3&M'3&0J&
LO-?7?O..TLO)3-.O-?7?O6J&"+&7/&]S%#3&.0J&-?7?^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOO>'I;<%*+,T>>,T
*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd7?O-/7O-?OC>(Od7?-/7-?3C>(nFC%*L$%<%*+3&
&&&&-..&S'E&"*&%`C$"*"+:'*&'(&+@:,&@:,+'E:I"$&CE'I%,,&,%%&48<("+&7/3(
&&&&-.4&L3N3)3&G%,3&-??5O06J&b3M3&2'I3&LO-??5O/5OD>>3-J&"+&-5&]K"R&4J&-??5^3&
&&&&-.0&COHRE(c)J&#6@%$(*'+%&65J&"+&13&
&&&&-.6&/6@%$&*'+%&/43&
&
.1&
(E'<&>%@R>E"+:'*J&+@%&"P':>"*I%&'(&>:,%",%J&"*>&Q"+%E&('E&C%E,'*"$&I'*,;<C+:'*J&(''>&
CE%C"E"+:'*J&Q",@:*9&"*>&@R9:%*%3&!@%&%$%<%*+,&'(&,;I@&"&E:9@+&W<;,+&#%&$8"56$:"(('E&
@;<"*&>:9*:+RJ&$:(%&"*>&@%"$+@JX&Q@:I@&:,&+'&,"R&+@"+&+@%&(;$$&,I'C%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&:,&#E'">%E&
+@"*&<%E%&,;EP:P"$&:*+%E%,+,3-.1&!@%&*'E<"+:P%&I'*+%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&Q@%*&('E<;$"+%>&:*&+@:,&
Q"R&:*I$;>%,&#'+@&(E%%>'<,&"*>&%*+:+$%<%*+,3&&
&
&
!@%&(E%%>'<,&:*I$;>%&+@%&E:9@+&+'&<":*+":*&"II%,,&+'&%`:,+:*9&Q"+%E&,;CC$:%,&*%I%,,"ER&('E&+@%&E:9@+&
+'&Q"+%EJ&"*>&+@%&E:9@+&+'&#%&(E%%&(E'<&:*+%E(%E%*I%J&,;I@&",&+@%&E:9@+&+'&#%&(E%%&(E'<&"E#:+E"ER&
>:,I'**%I+:'*,&'E&I'*+"<:*"+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&,;CC$:%,3&8R&I'*+E",+J&+@%&%*+:+$%<%*+,&:*I$;>%&+@%&E:9@+&
+'&"&,R,+%<&'(&Q"+%E&,;CC$R&"*>&<"*"9%<%*+&+@"+&CE'P:>%,&%c;"$:+R&'(&'CC'E+;*:+R&('E&C%'C$%&+'&
%*['R&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3-./&
&
L"I@&%$%<%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&E%c;:E%,&#",:I&>%(:*:+:'*3-.7&LM(%$(H%$%0)&E%(%E,&+'&
W,;((:I:%*+&"*>&E%9;$"EX&c;"*+:+:%,&('E&C%E,'*"$&;,%J&",&#",%>&:*&+@',%&9;:>%$:*%,&('E&@;<"*&
@%"$+@&>%P%$'C%>&#R&+@%&V'E$>&a%"$+@&FE9"*:Z"+:'*J&#;+&+":$'E%>&+'&$'I"$&I'*+%`+,3-.?&=*&
N3($%0)J&Q"+%E&,@';$>&#%&(E%%&'(&I'*+"<:*"+:'*J&"*>&*'+&*%9"+:P%$R&:<C"I+&@;<"*&@%"$+@3&
|;"$:+R&Q"+%E&:,&"$,'&W(44#I0(H$#X&:*&I'$'EJ&,<%$$&"*>&+",+%J&%*I';E"9:*9&C%'C$%&+'&;,%&,"(%&
,';EI%,3-45 &V"+%EU,&"II%,,:#:$:+R&:,&+@%&<',+&I'<C$%`&'(&+@%&E:9@+U,&%$%<%*+,3&L44#--%H$#&
Q"+%E&:,&"P":$"#$%&+'&"$$&:*>:P:>;"$,&C@R,:I"$$RJ&%I'*'<:I"$$RJ&"*>&'*&"&*'*T>:,IE:<:*"+'ER&
#",:,&]"&#",:I&@;<"*&E:9@+,&+%*%+^3&A@R,:I"$&"II%,,:#:$:+R&:<C$:%,&"*&"#:$:+R&+'&I'$$%I+&Q"+%E&
Q:+@';+&"*&;*E%",'*"#$R&$'*9&Q":+:*9&+:<%J&"*>&CE'`:<:+R&+'&%P%ER&@';,%@'$>J&C;#$:I&
:*,+:+;+:'*&"*>&Q'EBC$"I%3&!@%,%&E%c;:E%<%*+,&"E%&"$,'&+":$'E%>&+'&$'I"$&I'*+%`+,3-4-&
LI'*'<:I&"II%,,:#:$:+R&:,&,'<%+:<%,&E%T+%E<%>&W"(('E>"#:$:+R3X&LCC1"2(H$#&Q"+%E&,@';$>&
*'+&I'<CE'<:,%&+@%&:*>:P:>;"$U,&"#:$:+R&+'&CE'I;E%&'+@%E&*%I%,,:+:%,&]%393&(''>J&@';,:*9^3&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-.1&d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q--3&!@%&"CCE'"I@&+'&(;$(:$$:*9&+@%&E:9@+U,&(;$$&,I'C%&]",&,;CC'E+:*9&@;<"*&>:9*:+R^&,@';$>&#%&
>:,+:*9;:,@%>&(E'<&+@%&"CCE'"I@&+"B%*&+'Q"E>,&:+,&<:*:<;<&I'E%&]+'&%*,;E%&,;EP:P"$^3&S'E&"&>:,I;,,:'*&,%%&023%$&{&===J&
A"E+&83&
&&&&-./&d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&44J&"+(q-53&
&&&&-.7&!@%&,+"*>"E>,&'(&"II%,,:#:$:+RJ&"(('E>"#:$:+RJ&"II%C+"#:$:+R&"*>&c;"$:+R&Q%E%&'E:9:*"$$R&>%P%$'C%>&#R&+@%&)LN)G&:*&+@%&
I'*+%`+&'(&"II%,,&+'&@%"$+@&I"E%3&/""(1"2"%$,,7(d)-0J&#6@%$&*'+%&763(
&&&&-.?&d)-6&]#6@%$&*'+%&44&"+&q-.^&%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I%,&Guy Howard & Jamie Bertram, World Health Organization,
Domestic Water Quantity, Service Level and Health&].554^3&&
&&&&-45&d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&44J&"+(q-.]#^3&!@%&=*>%C%*>%*+&L`C%E+U,&%`C$"*"+:'*J&+@';9@&+''&#E'">&+'&#%&,;:+"#$%&('E&+@%&,"1$,&
>%(:*:+:'*J&:,&@%$C(;$&:*&I$"E:(R:*9&E%c;:E%<%*+&I'*I%C+,J&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&'(+TI'*(;,:*9&C;EC',%&'(&W"II%C+"#:$:+R3X&/""(=*>%C3&
L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&G%$"+%>&+'&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J(c6"#:0*22$0%"R(
VF**8()%$&:0&"#L(%",$:"8(:*(;&&"##(:*(/$3"(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2(]S%#3&.5-5^J&
@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O:,,;%,OQ"+%EO=%`C%E+O:*>%`3@+<&]('$$'Q&W!@%&d''>&AE"I+:I%,&|;%,+:'**":E%&T&L*9$:,@X&
@RC%E$:*B^3&
&&&&-4-&d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q-.]I^:T:::3&
&
./&
S'E&,'<%&'(&+@%&C''EJ&"(('E>"#:$:+R&<"R&%*+":$&(E%%&CE'P:,:'*3-4.&S:*"$$RJ&",&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&"E%&
'(+%*&",,%E+%>&:*&"&,;,+":*"#$%&>%P%$'C<%*+&C"E">:9<J&:+&,@';$>&#%&*'+%>&+@"+&+@%R&"E%&
6#63%6&:*%7&E:9@+,&Y&$:<:+%>&+'&;,%,&+@"+&>'&*'+&Q",+%J&>%,+E'R&'E&(;$$R&%`C$':+&"P":$"#$%&
E%,';EI%,3-44& &
&
!@%&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,&,+%<<:*9&(E'<&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"E%&'(+%*&#E'B%*&:*+'&+@E%%&
>;+:%,H&+'&%"#@"&:.(@%*:"&:("*>&36,30,,<Nde&+#-I#40&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&E%c;:E%,&+@"+&,+"+%,&E%(E":*&
(E'<&:*+%E(%E:*9&Q:+@&+@%&%*['R<%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+3-46&=*>:P:>;"$,&<;,+&"$,'&#%&I"10#40#2&
(E'<&+@:E>&C"E+R&%`C$':+"+:'*&]('E&:*,+"*I%J&(E'<&E%,';EI%&C'$$;+:'*&#R&I'EC'E"+:'*,^3-41&
S:*"$$RJ&,+"+%,&<;,+&%`C%>:+:';,$R&C3$C%$$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&#R&<":*+":*:*9&E%,C%I+&"*>&CE'+%I+:'*&
Q@:$%&,:<;$+"*%';,$R&CE'<'+:*9&+@%&(;$$&E%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+@E';9@&+"E9%+%>&%(('E+,&
":<%>&"+&",,:,+:*9&:*>:P:>;"$,&:*I"C"#$%&'(&E%"$:Z:*9&+@%&E:9@+&+@%<,%$P%,3-4/&!@%,%&%(('E+,&
<;,+&:*P'$P%&,+"B%@'$>%E&C"E+:I:C"+:'*3&N+"+%,&"$,'&@"P%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&'#$:9"+:'*,&E%$"+%>&+'&
%"I@&'(&+@%,%&+@E%%&>;+:%,&+@"+&+@%R&<;,+&,;#,;<%&:*+'&+@%:E&%`+%E*"$&E%$"+:'*,3-47&S:*"$$RJ&"&
E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&E%c;:E%,&+@"+&,+"+%,&I''E>:*"+%&:*+%E*"$&%(('E+,J&I$%"E$R&>%,:9*"+%&
E%,C'*,:#:$:+:%,J&"*>&Q@%*&P:'$"+:'*,&,;E("I%J&CE'P:>%&%((%I+:P%&E%<%>R&#'+@&*"+:'*"$$R&"*>&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$$R3-4?&M"+:'*"$&:*,+:+;+:'*,&,@';$>&#%&E%,C'*,:P%&+'&@;<"*&*%%>&"*>&
"II';*+"#$%&+'&,+"B%@'$>%E,3&
&
d%*%E"$&CE:*I:C$%,&'(&$"QJ&+@%&(';E+@&:*+%ECE%+"+:P%&,';EI%&(E'<&Q@:I@&W$%9"$&
I'*,+E;I+:'*X&<;,+&>E"QJ&@"P%&"&$"E9%&C"E+&+'&C$"R&:*&#'+@&+@%&*'E<"+:P%&I'*+%*+&"*>&
'#$:9"+:'*,&E%$"+%>&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&!@%&(:E,+J&'1'O2%-4"%&%'(0%1'P*QRS*:,&#'+@&"*&%$%<%*+&'(&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-4.&48<("+&q./3&
&&&&-44&/""(=_DJ&#6@%$&*'+%&?5J&"+&-63&L+R<'$'9:I"$$RJ&+@%&Q'E>&W;,;(E;I+'ERM(I'<%,&(E'<&+@%&I'<#:*"+:'*&'(&+@%&_"+:*&6#6#(
];,%^&"*>&3%6&:6#&]%*['R<%*+^J&>%$:#%E"+%$R&'<:++:*9&+@%&+@:E>&CE:*I:C$%&'(&"#,'$;+%&'Q*%E,@:CJ&$+6#6#&]"#;,%^3&
&&&&-40&!@%&+E:C"E+:+%&I'*I%C+&'(&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,&I'<%,&(E'<&L:>%&]('E<%E&NC%I:"$&G"CC'E+%;E&'*&S''>^&"*>&:,&#",%>&'*&
%"E$:%E&:>%",&#R&N@;%J&/""(H. Shue, Basic Rights, Subsistence, Affluence and U.S. Foreign Policy,&-7T66&]-?75^3&
L:>%&(:E,+&%<C$'R%>&+@%&+E:C"E+:+%&+RC'$'9R&:*J&NC%I:"$&G"CC'E+%;E&'*&+@%&L*['R<%*+&'(&LI'*3J&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,&
"*>&+@%&G:9@+&+'&D>%c;"+%&S''>J&='"(!01':(:*(;8"56$:"(U**8($#($(S6-$2(!01':.(b3M3&N;#TI'<<U*&'*&+@%&AE'<'+:'*&"*>&
AE'+%I+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&b3M3&2'I3&&
b3M3&2'I3&LO)M30ON;#3.O-?7/O.4J&"+&q-5/Y--/J&-1?Y-7-&]\;$3&/J&-?7/^&]#R&D,#['E*&L:>%^3&
&&&&-46&d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q.-3&!@:,&'#$:9"+:'*&:,&<',+&$:B%&+@',%&W*%9"+:P%X&'#$:9"+:'*,&",,'I:"+%>&Q:+@&I:P:$OC'$:+:I"$&
E:9@+,3&
&&&&-41&48<("+&q.43&
&&&&-4/&483&"+&q.6J&.1J&.?3&
&&&&-47&483&"+&q45T413&N%%&NC%I:"$&G"CC'E+%;E&'*&+@%&G:9@+&+'&S''>J&/0T:'(!"@*%:(*2(:'"(!01':(:*(U**8J&)'<<U*&'*&a;<"*&
G:9@+,J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)M30O.551O00J&"+&q.7T47&]K"E3&-1J&.551^&]#R&\"*&z:%9$%E^&('E&"&9''>&%`C$"*"+:'*&'(&%`+E"T+%EE:+'E:"$&
'#$:9"+:'*,&E%$"+%>&+'&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3*
&&&&-4?&d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q.6T.?3&
&&&&-05&M'*T>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&",&"&CE:*I:C$%&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&(:*>,&:+,&CE:<"ER&,';EI%&:*&b3M3&)aDG!LG&"E+3&-]4^J&66&"*>&
b2aGJ&#6@%$&*'+%&06J&"+&"E+3&.]-^3&_:B%Q:,%J&+@%&=)LN)G&'#$:9%,&,+"+%,&C"E+:%,&W+'&9;"E"*+%%&+@"+&+@%&E:9@+,&%*;*I:"+%>&:*&
+@%&CE%,%*+&)'P%*"*+&Q:$$&#%&%`%EI:,%>&Q:+@';+&>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&'(&"*R&B:*>&",&+'&E"I%J&I'$';EJ&,%`J&$"*9;"9%J&E%$:9:'*J&
&
.7&
W"II%,,:#:$:+RX&"*>&"*&W:<<%>:"+%&"*>&IE',,TI;++:*9&'#$:9"+:'*X&:*I;<#%*+&'*&,+"+%,/QRQ*!@%*
,%I'*>J&#CC#40%M#*"#&#2)J&@",&+Q'&I'<C'*%*+,3-0.&N+"+%,&"E%&'#$:9"+%>&+'&"<%*>&+@%:E&
>'<%,+:I&$%9"$&'E>%E&",&*%I%,,"ER&+'&9:P%&%((%I+&+'&+@%:E&+E%"+R&'#$:9"+:'*,3-04&N;I@&"I+:'*&
,@';$>&9;"E"*+%%&W%P%ER'*%&+@%&E:9@+&+'&"*&%((%I+:P%&E%<%>R&#R&+@%&I'<C%+%*+&*"+:'*"$&
+E:#;*"$,&('E&"I+,&P:'$"+:*9t&(;*>"<%*+"$&E:9@+,3X-00&!@%&+@:E>*9%*%E"$&CE:*I:C$%&:,&$#8($*
#N3($%0)P*Q@:I@&>%(:*%,&+@%&C"E"<%+%E,&;*>%E&Q@:I@&"*&%((%I+:P%&E%<%>R&:,&CE'C%E$R&
%*['R%>3&Lc;"$:+R&:*I$;>%,&"&>;"$&9;"E"*+%%&'(&%c;"$&"*>&%((%I+:P%&CE'+%I+:'*&#%('E%&"*>&
;*>%E&+@%&$"Q3-06&=+&:,&:<C'E+"*+&+'&",,%E+&%"I@&'(&+@%,%&%$%<%*+,&",&9%*%E"$&CE:*I:C$%,&'(&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"QJ&#%I";,%&"$+@';9@&%"I@&:,&"IB*'Q$%>9%>&#R&+@%&=)LN)G&:*&,'<%&Q"RJ&+@%:E&
<',+&I'<C$%+%&$%9"$&('E<,&"E%&(';*>&';+,:>%&'(&+@"+&>'I;<%*+3&
&&
D,&"><:++%>&#R&+@%&)LN)G&:*&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&?&]>'<%,+:I&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*^J&We+f@%&
)'P%*"*+&>'%,&*'+&,C%I:(R&+@%&,C%I:(:I&<%"*,&#R&Q@:I@&:+&:,&+'&#%&:<C$%<%*+%>&:*+'&+@%&
*"+:'*"$&'E>%EJX-01&"*>&We+f@%&E:9@+&+'&"*&%((%I+:P%&E%<%>R&*%%>&*'+&#%&:*+%ECE%+%>&",&"$Q"R,&
E%c;:E:*9&"&[;>:I:"$&E%<%>R3X-0/&D&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&",&>%E:P%>&(E'<&"*&=)LN)G&
'#$:9"+:'*J&+@%*J&>'%,&*'+&*%I%,,"E:$R&:*I$;>%&"&E:9@+&+'&>%(%*>&'*%U,&%*+:+$%<%*+&:*&I';E+3&
M%P%E+@%$%,,J&+@%&(":$;E%&'(&"&,+"+%&+'&9;"E"*+%%&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&+@E';9@&[;>:I:"$&E%<%>R&
Q';$>&@"P%&+'&#%&[;,+:(:%>&#R&"*&"E9;<%*+&+@"+&,;I@&$%9"$&E%>E%,,&Q';$>&#%&W:*"CCE'CE:"+%X&
'E&W;**%I%,,"ERX&Y&"*&%,C%I:"$$R&>:((:I;$+&+",B&Q@%*&'*%&"IB*'Q$%>9%,&+@"+&<',+&*'*T
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
C'$:+:I"$&'E&'+@%E&'C:*:'*J&*"+:'*"$&'E&,'I:"$&'E:9:*J&CE'C%E+RJ&#:E+@&'E&'+@%E&,+"+;,&3&3&3X&Y&"*&'#$:9"+:'*&E%",,%E+%>&
+@E';9@';+&+@%&)'P%*"*+&]=)LN)GJ&#6@%$&*'+%&45J&"+&"E+3&.].^^3&&
&&&&-0-&!@%&)LN)G&I'*,:>%E%>&+@%&*"+;E%&'(&*'*T>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&:*J&)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&
)'<<%*+&M'3&.5H&M'*T2:,IE:<:*"+:'*&:*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&q/J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.Od)O.5&]\;*%&-5J&
.55?^J&"+&QQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,OI%,IEO>'I,O9IOL3)3-.3d)3.53>'I3&
&&&&-0.&!@';9@&#'+@&I'<C'*%*+,&%`:,+&",&:*>%C%*>%*+&CE:*I:C$%,&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"QJ&+@%R&"E%&[':*%>&@%E%&+'&>%<'*,+E"+%&
+@%:E&I'<C$%<%*+"ER&(;*I+:'*,3&8'+@&"E%&;,%>&#R&+@%&)LN)G&",&CE:*I:C$%,&I'*>:+:'*:*9&+@%&CE'C%E&>'<%,+:I&"CC$:I"+:'*&'(&
+@%&=)LN)G3&/""()LN)G&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&?J&#6@%$(*'+%&--4J&"+&q43&
&&&&-04&!@:,&'#$:9"+:'*&:,&:<C$:%>&(E'<&+@%&$"*9;"9%&'(&+@%&s:%**"&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&_"Q&'(&!E%"+:%,&,C%I:(R:*9&+@"+&leDf&
C"E+R&<"R&*'+&:*P'B%&+@%&CE'P:,:'*,&'(&:+,&:*+%E*"$&$"Q&",&[;,+:(:I"+:'*&('E&:+,&(":$;E%&+'&C%E('E<&"&+E%"+R3l&s:%**"&
)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&_"Q&'(&!E%"+:%,J&"E+3&./J&K"R&.4J&-?1?J&--66&b3M3!3N3&44-3&
&&&&-00&ba2GJ&#6@%$&*'+%&06J&"+&"E+&73&K"*RJ&:(&*'+&"$$&'(&+@%&CE'P:,:'*,&'(&+@%&b2aG&"E%&:*IE%",:*9$R&I'*,:>%E%>&+'&('E<&
#:*>:*9&E;$%,&'(&I;,+'<"ER&$"Q3&!@:,&CE'P:,:'*&:,&*'+J&@'Q%P%EJ&CE%,%*+%>&@%E%&",&"&I;,+'<"ER&E;$%J&#;+&E"+@%E&",&"*&
%<#'>:<%*+&'(&"&,+"*>:*9&CE:*I:C$%&'(&$"Q3&
&&&&-06&!@%&>;"$&*"+;E%&'(&$%9"$&%c;"$:+R&I'<%,&(E'<&+@%&=))AGJ&Q@:I@&>'%,&*'+&%`C$:I:+$R&E%,+E:I+&+@%&E;$%&+'&+@%&"CC$:I"+:'*&
'(&I:P:$&"*>&C'$:+:I"$&E:9@+,&'*$R&]=))AGJ&#6@%$(*'+%&-5.J&"+&"E+3&.1^3&!@:,&,+"*>"E>&Q",&*'+&E%:+%E"+%>&:*&+@%&=)LN)GJ&Q@:I@&
'*$R&"IB*'Q$%>9%,&W+@%&%c;"$&"*>&:*"$:%*"#$%&E:9@+,&'(&"$$X&]=)LN)G.(#6@%$&*'+%&4/J&"+&WAE%"<#$%X^3&!@%&=))AG&,+"*>"E>&
@",&#%%*&",,%E+%>&#R&+@%&))AGJ&@'Q%P%EJ&+'&WI'*,+:+;+%&"&#",:I&"*>&9%*%E"$&CE:*I:C$%&E%$"+:*9&+'&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&@;<"*&
E:9@+,X&"*>&+@%E%('E%&"CC$:%,&%c;"$$R&+'&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3&/""()'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&
d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&-7H&M'*T2:,IE:<:*"+:'*J&4/+@&N%,,3J&FI+3&.4&Y&M'P3&-5J&-?7?J&b3M3&dDFGJ&06+@&N%,,3J&N;CC3&M'3&05J&
DO06O05J&"+&-/4&]M'P3&?J&-?7?^J&$?$0,$+,"&$:&@++CHOO>'I;<%*+,T>>,T
*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOM?5O.65O4-O:<9OM?5.654-3C>(nFC%*L$%<%*+3&
&&&&-01&)LN)G&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&?J&#6@%$&*'+%&--4J&"+&q63&
&&&&-0/&48<("+&q?3(
&
.?&
[;>:I:"$&E%<%>:%,&Q';$>&#%&E%*>%E%>&:*%((%I+:P%&Q:+@';+&$%9"$&E%:*('EI%<%*+3&-07&=*&<',+&
I",%,J&+@%*J&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,&P:,TrTP:,&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:*I$;>%&"*&'#$:9"+:'*&+'&%*,;E%&"+&$%",+&
,'<%&[;,+:I:"#:$:+R3-0?&
&
><()%*1%"##0?"(!"$,0Q$:0*2(
&
&
=<C$%<%*+"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&('$$'Q,&+@%&,"<%&<'>%$&'(&WCE'9E%,,:P%&
E%"$:Z"+:'*X&+@"+&I@"E"I+%E:Z%,&'+@%E&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3&=+&:,&C%E@"C,&+@:,&*'+:'*J&"*>&
*'+&+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&:+,%$(J&+@"+&<"B%,&:+,&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&%*('EI%<%*+&,'&>:((:I;$+3&
d%*%E"$$RJ&,+"+%,&"E%&'#$:9"+%>&;*>%E&+@%&s:%**"&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&_"Q&'(&!E%"+:%,&+'&<'P%&
",&%`C%>:+:';,$R&"*>&%((%I+:P%$R&",&C',,:#$%&+'Q"E>&+@%&(;$$&'#,%EP"*I%&'(&+E%"+R&'#$:9"+:'*,J&
:*I$;>:*9&+@%&E%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&@;<"*&E:9@+,3-65&&!@:,&9%*%E"$&>;+R&:,&c;"$:(:%>J&@'Q%P%EJ&#R&"&
E%,';EI%&W$''C@'$%X&>:E%I+$R&%*,@E:*%>&:*&DE+:I$%&.]-^&=)LN)G3&&
&
eD&,+"+%&<;,+f&+"B%&,+%C,///*01*06#*&(T%&3&*1C*%0-*(M(%$(H$#*"#-13"4#-J&Q:+@&"&P:%Q&+'&"I@:%P:*9&
CE'9E%,,:P%$R&+@%&(;$$&E%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+,&E%I'9*:Z%>&:*&+@%&CE%,%*+&)'P%*"*+&#R&"$$&
"CCE'CE:"+%&<%"*,J&:*I$;>:*9&C"E+:I;$"E$R&+@%&">'C+:'*&'(&$%9:,$"+:P%&<%",;E%,3-6-&
&
b*$:B%&+@%&=))AGJ&Q@:I@&'#$:9%,&"&,+"+%&+'&:<<%>:"+%$R&WE%,C%I+&"*>&+'&%*,;E%&+'&"$$&
:*>:P:>;"$,&Q:+@:*&:+,&+%EE:+'ER&"*>&,;#[%I+&+'&:+,&[;E:,>:I+:'*X&+@%&E:9@+,&:+&%*,@E:*%,J&+@%&
=)LN)G&'*$R&E%c;:E%,&+@"+&"&,+"+%&W+"B%&,+%C,X&+'&CE'P:>%&('E&E:9@+,TCE'+%I+:'*&",&#%,+&:+&I"*&
:*&+@%&CE%P":$:*9&I:EI;<,+"*I%,3&!@:,&>;+R&+'&CE'9E%,,:P%$R&E%"$:Z%&#'*6,8&E%c;:E%&,+"+%,&+'&
E%,C%I+J&CE'+%I+&"*>&(;$(:$$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&W+'&+@%&@:9@%,+&>%9E%%&C',,:#$%&"+&"*R&9:P%*&
<'<%*+JX&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&"P':>"*I%&'(&"*R&>%$:#%E"+%$R&E%+E'9E%,,:P%&<%",;E%,3-6.&N;I@&"*&
:>%"&"IB*'Q$%>9%,&+@%&%*'E<';,&+:<%&"*>&E%,';EI%,&+@"+&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&
:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&E%c;:E%,3&!@%&[;>9<%*+&'(&Q@"+&I'*,+:+;+%,&W%`C%>:+:';,X&"I+:'*&:*&+@%&("I%&
'(&,'&<"*R&E%$"+%>&#;+&,%C"E"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,J&@'Q%P%EJ&C%E<:+,&,+"+%,&"&>%9E%%&'(&(E%%>'<&:*&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-07&48<("+&q43&
&&&&-0?&=+&:,&I$%"E&(E'<&+@%&Q'EB&'(&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M',3&4J&?&"*>&-6&+@"+&*'+&"$$&%$%<%*+,&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&Q';$>&#%&
,;#[%I+&:<<%>:"+%&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&"*>&+@%E%('E%&:<<%>:"+%$R&[;,+:I:"#$%3&!@:,&:,&+@%&CE:*I:C$%&E%",'*&('E&+@%&
,:<;$+"*%';,&%`C$"*"+:'*&'(&+@%&W<:*:<;<&I'E%X&I'*I%C+&%`C$'E%>&:*&N%I+:'*&===&#%$'Q3&
&&&&-65&s:%**"&)'*P%*+:'*J&#6@%$&*'+%&-04J&"+&"E+3&.1&]WLP%ER&+E%"+R&:*&('EI%&:,&#:*>:*9&;C'*&+@%&C"E+:%,&+'&:+&"*>&<;,+&#%&
C%E('E<%>&#R&+@%<&:*&9''>&(":+@3X^3&
&&&&-6-&=)LN)GJ&#6@%$&*'+%&4/J&"+&"E+3&.]-^&]%<C@",:,&">>%>^3&
&&&&-6.&GorsbothJ&#6@%$&*'+%&.4J&"+&/&]%<C@",:,&">>%>^3&
&
45&
+@%:E&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&+@"+&:,&'(+%*&CE'#$%<"+:I3&!@:,&:,&#%I";,%&+@%&
,+"*>"E>,&#R&Q@:I@&+@:,&"I+:'*&I"*&#%&[;>9%>&"E%&,'&,;#[%I+:P%&+@"+&+@%R&'(+%*&"$$'Q&
)'*P%*+:'*&CE'+%I+:'*,&+'&#%&%((%I+:P%$R&*;$$:(:%>3-64&!@:,&E''<&('E&%EE'E&:,&(;E+@%E&
I'<C$:I"+%>&#R&E%,+E:I+:'*,&'*&+@%&";+@'E:+R&'(&+@%&:<C$%<%*+:*9&#'>RJ&+@%&)LN)G3-60&LP%*&
Q@%*&"#$%&+'&E%,C'*>&+'&"*&',+%*,:#$%&P:'$"+:'*J&+@%&$"E9%&"<';*+&'(&>"+"&E%c;:E%>&Y&
:*I$;>:*9&+@%&"#:$:+R&+'&,+"+:,+:I"$$R&"*"$RZ%&:+&Y&<"B%,&+@%&['#&'(&+@%&)LN)G&W;*E%"$:,+:I&"*>&
P:E+;"$$R&:<C',,:#$%X&:*&<"*R&C$"I%,3-66&*
AE'9E%,,:P%&E%"$:Z"+:'*J&:*&:+,&I'*(;,:*9&I'*+%*+&"*>&I'<<'*&<:,"CCE'CE:"+:'*&",&
"*&%Ì;,%&('E&:*,:*I%E%&>%P%$'C<%*+&%(('E+,J&@",&#%%*&I"$$%>&We+f@%&,:*9$%&<',+&I'<C$%`&"*>&
<:,;*>%E,+''>&>:<%*,:'*&'(&%I'*'<:I&"*>&,'I:"$&E:9@+,3X-61&!@:,&I'*(;,:'*&@",&CE'<C+%>&
+@%&9E'Q+@&'(&"*&:*+%$$%I+;"$&*'E<&E%I'9*:Z:*9&'#$:9"+:'*,&'(&"*&:<<%>:"+%&*"+;E%3&!@%&(:E,+&
@"$(&'(&+@:,&:>%"&">>E%,,%,&,+"+%,U&"I+:'*,&+@%<,%$P%,3&=*&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&4J&+@%&)LN)G&
@%$>&+@"+&,+"+%,&<;,+&+"B%&,+%C,&+'Q"E>&+@%&(;$$TE%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&E:9@+,3&!@%,%&,+%C,&<;,+&#%&",&
8",0+"%$:"J&&*2&%":"&"*>&:$%1":"8&",&C',,:#$%&+'Q"E>&+@%&(;$(:$$<%*+&'(&+@%&)'P%*"*+U,&
'#$:9"+:'*,3-6/ &!@%&)'<<:++%%&+@%*&>%P%$'C%>&"&I'EE%$"+:*9&:>%"&'(&%"I@&E:9@+U,&WI'E%&
I'*+%*+X&"*>&+@%&"#,'$;+%&<:*:<;<&'#$:9"+:'*,&E%$"+:*9&+'&+@"+&I'E%3&V@%*&+"B%*&+'9%+@%EJ&
+@%,%&+Q'&:>%",&,@';$>&@%$C&,+"+%,&[;>9%&Q@"+&"I+:'*,&"E%&:<<%>:"+%$R&E%c;:E%>&"*>&Q@"+&
"I+:'*,&Y&+@';9@&,+:$$&E%c;:E%>&Y&<"R&#%&+%<C'E"E:$R&>%(%EE%>&+'Q"E>&+@%&CE'9E%,,:P%&
:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+U,&(;$$&,I'C%3&!@%&I'*I%C+&'(&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&@",&#%%*&@":$%>&#R&
<"*R&('E&:+,&"#:$:+R&+'&"I+&",&"&#%*I@<"EB&('E&,+"+%&I'<C$:"*I%J&#%I";,%&:+&I"*&<'E%&I$%"E$R&
%,+"#$:,@&Q@%*&,+"+%,&@"P%&#E%"I@%>&+@%:E&'#$:9"+:'*,&CE:<"&("I:%<&=+&:,&+'&+@:,&I'*,+E;I+&+@"+&
Q%&*'Q&+;E*3&
&
&
&
&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-64&Audrey Chapman & Sage Russell, 42:%*86&:0*2.(02 Core Obligations: Building a Framework for Economic,
Social and Cultural Rights -J&6&].55.^&]"E9;:*9&+@"+&+@:,&,;#[%I+:P:+R&'(+%*&'C%*,&"&W$''C@'$%&$"E9%&%*';9@t&+'&*;$$:(R&
+@%&)'P%*"*+U,&9;"E"*+%%,X^3
&&&&-60&!@%&)LN)G&<"R&'*$R&WE%I'<<%*>X&<%",;E%,&"(+%E&+@%&C%E:'>:I&E%P:%Q&'(&,+"+%&,;#<:,,:'*,3&
&&&&-66&Chapman j&RussellJ&#6@%$&*'+%&-64J&"+&63&
&&&&-61&)E":9&NI'++&j&A@:$:CC&D$,+'*J&;8a680&$:021(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,()%0*%0:0"#(02($(=%$2#2$:0*2$,(A*2:"T:.($(A*--"2:(*2&
/**+%$-*2"7L#(C"1$&7($28(F%**:+,**-L#&)%*-0#".(-1&N3&Afr. J. Hum. Rts.&.51J&.1.&].555^3&
&&&&-6/&d)4J&#6@%$&*'+%&40J&"+&q.3&V"+%ETE%$"+%>&'#$:9"+:'*,&"E%&:<C$:I:+$R&:*I$;>%>&"(+%E&+@%:E&I$"E:(:I"+:'*&:*&d)-63&
&
4-&
! .../*?'2#"-0('2%'8*06#*@A%'%&3&*>1"#B*C1"*9(0#"*
&
;<(='"(9020-6-(A*%"(A*2&"@:(F"2"%$,,7(
&
&&
!@%&:>%"&'(&WI'E%&I'*+%*+X&('E&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&Q",&(:E,+&('E<;$"+%>&';+,:>%&'(&
+@%&b3M3&,R,+%<J&#;+&@",&,:*I%&9":*%>&Q:>%,CE%">&,;CC'E+&(E'<&@;<"*&E:9@+&CE"I+:+:'*%E,&
"*>&"I">%<:I,J&I;$<:*"+:*9&:*&:+,&">'C+:'*&#R&+@%&)LN)G3-67&L,,%*+:"$$RJ&:+&C',:+,&+@"+&+@%E%&
"E%&>%9E%%,&'(&E:9@+,&(;$(:$$<%*+J&"*>&+@"+&'*%&'(&+@%,%&>%9E%%,&:,&"&>%(:*"#$%J&#",:I&
+@E%,@'$>&Y&'E&('E&';E&C;EC',%,J&"&<:*:<;<&,"1$,&I'*+%*+&Y&('E&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3-6?&
!@%&I'*I%C+&<"R&@"P%&:+,&'E:9:*,&:*&d%E<"*&8",:I&_"QJ&Q@%E%&"&E:9@+U,&W#",:I&I'*+%*+X&:,&
CE'+%I+%>&(E'<&$%9"$&$:<:+"+:'*3-15&=+U,&<',+&<'>%E*&<"*:(%,+"+:'*&I'<%,&Q:+@&d%*%E"$&
)'<<%*+&4J&@'Q%P%EJ&:*&Q@:I@&+@%&)LN)G&"++%<C+,&+'&I$"E:(R&+@%&*"+;E%&'(&CE'9E%,,:P%&
E%"$:Z"+:'*&",&%,+"#$:,@:*9&I'*IE%+%&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,3&
&
e!f@%&C@E",%&eWCE'9E%,,:P%&E%"$:Z"+:'*Xf&<;,+&#%&E%">&:*&+@%&$:9@+&'(&+@%&'P%E"$$&'#[%I+:P%J&:*>%%>&
+@%&E":,'*&>x}+E%J&'(&+@%&)'P%*"*+&Q@:I@&:,&+'&%,+"#$:,@&I$%"E&'#$:9"+:'*,&('E&N+"+%,&C"E+:%,&:*&E%,C%I+&
'(&+@%&(;$$&E%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+,&:*&c;%,+:'*3&=+&+@;,&:<C',%,&"*&'#$:9"+:'*&+'&<'P%&",&
%`C%>:+:';,$R&"*>&%((%I+:P%$R&",&C',,:#$%&+'Q"E>,&+@"+&9'"$3-1-&&
(
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-67&A@:$:C&D$,+'*&:,&,'<%+:<%,&IE%>:+%>&Q:+@&+@%&>%P%$'C<%*+&'(&+@%&WI'E%&I'*+%*+X&I'*I%C+&>%,IE:#%>&"*>&>%P%$'C%>&:*&
+@:,&N%I+:'*3&/""(A@:$:C&D$,+'*J&W6:(*3(:'"(;+7##R(:'"(A'$,,"21"#(A*23%*2:021(:'"(E"H(\<E<(A*--0::""(*2(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(
A6,:6%$,(!01':#.(?]4^&Hum. Rts. Q.(444(]-?7/^3&8R&+@%&%"E$R&.555,J&+@%&I'*I%C+&@">&"I@:%P%>&Q:>%,CE%">&,;CC'E+&:*&#'+@&
+@%&DI">%<R&"*>&+@%&b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&,R,+%<3&/"".("<1<.(i:%(%E&j&8Ek$<"**<(#6@%$(*'+%&/&"+&-?0&**3&1/T1?3&D,&%P:>%*I%&'(&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&"II%C+"*I%J&i:%(%E&"*>&8Ek$<"**&I:+%&]"<'*9&'+@%E,^(83)3D3&!'%#%,J&=*H$%8#($2(4-@%*?"8(\28"%#:$28021(*3(
:'"(42:"%2$:0*2$,(S6-$2(!01':(:*(S"$,:'J&.-&Human Rights Quarterly(11-J&1/-&]-???^g&='"(9$$#:%0&':(F608",02"#(*2(
`0*,$:0*2#(*3(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#J&.5]4^&Hum. Rts. Q.&1?-J&1?4("+&q&?&]-??7^g&b3M3&)'<<U*&'*&a;<3&G+,3J&
M'+%&s%E#"$%&2"+%>&71O-.O56&(E'<&+@%&A%E<"*%*+&K:,,:'*&'(&+@%&M%+@%E$"*>,&+'&+@%&b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&F((:I%&"+&d%*%P"&
">>E%,,%>&+'&+@%&)%*+E%&('E&a;<"*&G:9@+,&]l_:<#;E9&AE:*I:C$%,l^J&q.6J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)M30O-?7/O-/&]\"*3&7J&-?7/^J&
%"@%02:"8(02&? Hum. Rts. Q. -..(]-?7/^3(/""($,#*&Chapman & RussellJ&#6@%$&*'+%&-64J&"+&7&]*'+:*9&+@"+&+@%&I'*I%C+,&'(&
WI'E%&<:*:<;<&I'*+%*+X&"*>&WI'E%&<:*:<;<&'#$:9"+:'*,X&@"P%&#%I'<%&CE%P"$%*+&:*&"I">%<:I&$:+%E"+;E%&,:*I%&+@%&-?75,&
"*>&+'9%+@%E&('E<&"&WB%R&I'*I%C+X&"+&+@%&@%"E+&'(&+@%:E&#''B^3(
&&&&-6?&!@:,&%,,"R&I'*,:>%E,&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&",&<'E%&+@"*&,:<C$R&"&*'E<"+:P%&%$%<%*+&'E&>%(:*:+:'*"$&":>&('E&
,'I:'%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,J&#;+&E"+@%E&",&"&,"1$,(#:$28$%8&+@"+&#:*>,&,+"+%,3&2%,C:+%&+@%&("I+&+@"+&+E"*,*"+:'*"$J&2*2â680&0$,&
"I+'E,&@"P%&@">&+@%&$"E9%,+&E'$%&:*&>%(:*:*9&+@%&I'*I%C+U,&I'*+%*+J&+@%&I'*I%C+&E%$:%,&'*&$"Q&('E&#'+@&:+,&#",:,&"*>&%((%I+3&
_:B%&"*R&:*,+:+;+:'*&"++E:#;+"#$%&+'&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"QJ&+@%&CE"I+:I"$&%*('EI%"#:$:+R&'(&,;I@&"&$%9"$&,+"*>"E>&E%<":*,&$"E9%$R&"&
c;%,+:'*&'(&I'*+%`+3&M'*T[;,+:I:"#:$:+RJ&@'Q%P%EJ&>'%,&*'+&,:9*"$&"&I'*I%C+U,&$%9"$&*'*T%`:,+%*I%3&/""(i"+@"E:*%&d3&~';*9J&
='"(9020-6-(A*%"(*3(G&*2*-0&($28(/*&0$,(!01':#.(;(A*2&"@:(02(/"$%&'(*3(A*2:"2:.&44&Yale J. Intl L.&--4J&--4J&-.4J&-.6&
].557^&]E%(%EE:*9&+'&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"$+%E*"+:P%$R&",&W<:*:<;<&$%9"$&I'*+%*+JX&W<:*:<;<&$%9"$&+@E%,@'$>X&"*>&
W<:*:<;<&$%9"$&,+"*>"E>X^3&
&&&&-15&483&"+&-.03&~';*9&I:+%,&Grundgesetz fr die Bundesrepublik Deutschland [Constitution]&.4&K"R&-?0?J&"E+3&
-?].^&]d%E3^&],+"+:*9&+@"+&We:f*&*'&I",%&<"R&+@%&%,,%*+:"$&I'*+%*+&'(&"&#",:I&E:9@+&#%&%*IE'"I@%>&;C'*X^3&
&&&&-1-&d)4J&#6@%$&*'+%&40J&"+&q?3&
&
4.&
!'&I$"E:(R&,;I@&'#$:9"+:'*,J&+@%&)'<<:++%%&:*+E'>;I%,&+@%&+Q'TC"E+&I'*I%C+&'(&"&E:9@+U,&
<:*:<;<&I'E%J&(:E,+&#R&>:,+:*9;:,@:*9&+@%&:<<%>:"+%&%((%I+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&(E'<&:+,&(;$$&
,I'C%J&"*>&,%I'*>$R&#R&>%(:*:*9&+@%&*"+;E%&'(&+@',%&,+%C,&+@"+&<;,+&#%&+"B%*&:*&+@%&
(;$(:$$<%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+U,&:<<%>:"+%&%((%I+3&!@%&)'<<:++%%&#%9:*,J&
&
e+@%&'#$:9"+:'*f&:*&"E+:I$%&.]-^&+'&+"B%&,+%C,Ut&:,&*'+&c;"$:(:%>&*'E&$:<:+%>&#R&'+@%E&I'*,:>%E"+:'*,t&
!@;,&Q@:$%&+@%&(;$$&E%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&E%$%P"*+&E:9@+,&<"R&#%&"I@:%P%>&CE'9E%,,:P%$RJ&,+%C,&+'Q"E>&
+@"+&9'"$&<;,+&#%&+"B%*&Q:+@:*&"&E%",'*"#$R&,@'E+&+:<%&"(+%E&+@%&)'P%*"*+,&%*+ER&:*+'&('EI%t&N;I@&
,+%C,&,@';$>&#%&>%$:#%E"+%J&I'*IE%+%&"*>&+"E9%+%>&",&I$%"E$R&",&C',,:#$%&+'Q"E>,&<%%+:*9&+@%&
'#$:9"+:'*,&E%I'9*:Z%>&:*&+@%&)'P%*"*+3-1.&
&
!@:,&(:E,+&I$";,%&';+$:*%,&+@',%&:<<%>:"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,&:*I;<#%*+&'*&,+"+%,&",&+@%R&#%9:*&
%(('E+,&+'Q"E>&CE'9E%,,:P%&E%"$:Z"+:'*3&!@%&$"*9;"9%&+@;,&'C%*,&I'*I%C+;"$&,C"I%&('E&
:**'P"+:'*&#R&>:,+:*9;:,@:*9&#%+Q%%*&+@%&W:<<%>:"+%&%((%I+X&'(&+@%&E:9@+&"*>&+@%&E%"$:Z"+:'*&
'(&+@%&E:9@+U,&(;$$&,I'C%3-14&!@%&)'<<:++%%&(:$$,&+@"+&*%Q&,C"I%&#R&:*,:,+:*9&+@"+J&
&
"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&'#$:9"+:'*&+'&%*,;E%&+@%&,"+:,("I+:'*&'(J&"+&+@%&P%ER&$%",+P*&%'%&3&*#--#'0%($*
$#M#$-*1C*#(46*1C*06#*"%860-&:,&:*I;<#%*+&;C'*&%P%ER&,+"+%&C"E+R3-10&
(
!@%&)'<<%*+&>'%,&*'+&%`@";,+:P%$R&>%(:*%&+@%&I'*+%*+&'(&+@:,&W<:*:<;<&%,,%*+:"$&$%P%$X&
('E&"*R&'(&+@%&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&+'&Q@:I@&:+&C%E+":*,3&!@:,&Q'EB&:,&$%(+&+'&,;#,%c;%*+&
)'<<%*+,&'*&%"I@&:*>:P:>;"$&E:9@+3&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&4&8*"#J&@'Q%P%EJ&I$"E:(R&@'Q&+@%&
#E%"I@&'(&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&'#$:9"+:'*&:,&+'&#%&E%I'9*:Z%>3&
(
!@;,J&('E&%`"<C$%J&"&N+"+%&C"E+R&:*&Q@:I@&"*R&,:9*:(:I"*+&*;<#%E&'(&:*>:P:>;"$,&:,&>%CE:P%>&'(&
%,,%*+:"$&(''>,+;((,J&'(&%,,%*+:"$&CE:<"ER&@%"$+@I"E%J&'(&#",:I&,@%$+%E&"*>&@';,:*9J&'E&'(&+@%&<',+&
#",:I&('E<,&'(&%>;I"+:'*J&:,&CE:<"&("I:%J&(":$:*9&+'&>:,I@"E9%&:+,&'#$:9"+:'*&;*>%E&+@%&)'P%*"*+3-16&
&
&
!@%&)LN)GJ&:*&:*+%ECE%+:*9&+@%&>;+:%,&%*,@E:*%>&:*&+@%&=)LN)GJ&I'*(:E<,&+@"+&+@%&
,+"+%&:,&%`C%I+%>&+'&<%%+&I%E+":*&'#$:9"+:'*,&%P%*&:*&+@%&<',+&>%P%$'C<%*+"$$R&I@"$$%*9:*9&
I:EI;<,+"*I%,3&K:*:<;<&I'E%&'#$:9"+:'*,&,%+&"*&:*>%C%*>%*+&9;:>%$:*%&":<%>&"+&I$',:*9&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-1.&48<&"+&&q.3&
&&&&-14&!@%&'*$R&:<<%>:"+%&'#$:9"+:'*&*'+&,;#[%I+&+'&CE'9E%,,:P%&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&*'+%>&#R&+@%&=)LN)G&:,&*'*T>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&
]=)LN)G&DE+&.].^&"*>&.]4^^3&!@%&#E'">&$"*9;"9%&'(&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&4J&@'Q%P%EJ&,%%<,&+'&>%(:*%&'+@%E&:<<%>:"+%&
'#$:9"+:'*,&Q@:$%&[;,+:(R:*9&:+,%$(&",&"*&";+@'E:+"+:P%&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&'(&+@%&)'P%*"*+3&!@:,&:,&Q@"+&:,&<%"*+&#R&W'C%*:*9&
I'*I%C+;"$&,C"I%3X&
&&&&-10&d)4J&#6@%$&*'+%&40J&"+&q-53*
&&&&-16&48<&
&
44&
+@%&W$''C@'$%X&Q:+@:*&CE'9E%,,:P%&E%"$:Z"+:'*&#R&;,:*9&,:+;"+:'*,&'(&9E',,&*%9$%I+&",&CE:<"&
("I:%&$%9"$&CE''(&+@"+&"&,+"+%&@",&#E%"I@%>&:+,&+E%"+R&'#$:9"+:'*,3&!@%'E%+:I"$$RJ&+@:,&Q';$>&
%*"#$%&,+"+%,&:*&>:((%E:*9&I'*+%`+,&'(&C'$:+:I"$&%I'*'<R&'E&E%,';EI%&"P":$"#:$:+R&+'&#%&@%$>&+'&
+@%&,"<%&,+"*>"E>&'(&CE'+%I+:'*3-11&
D,&:+,&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&<;,+&E%($%I+&+@%&,C:E:+&'(&+@%&'E:9:*"$&)'P%*"*+J&+@%&)'<<:++%%&"$,'&
C$"I%,&"&E%,';EI%&$:<:+"+:'*&'*&+@%&;,%&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%3&
&
e=f+&<;,+&#%&*'+%>&+@"+&"*R&",,%,,<%*+&",&+'&Q@%+@%E&"&N+"+%&@",&>:,I@"E9%>&:+,&<:*:<;<&I'E%&
'#$:9"+:'*&<;,+&"$,'&+"B%&"II';*+&'(&E%,';EI%&I'*,+E":*+,&"CC$R:*9&Q:+@:*&+@%&I';*+ER&
I'*I%E*%>3-1/&
&
F*&+@%&,;E("I%J&+@:,&$:<:+"+:'*&:,&,:<:$"E&+'&+@%&WCE'9E%,,:P%&E%"$:Z"+:'*X&I$";,%&:*&
=)LN)G&.]-^3&V@%*&C$"I%>&Q:+@:*&+@%&$"E9%E&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"*>&:+,&
I'EE%,C'*>:*9&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,J&@'Q%P%EJ&:+&@",&"&P%ER&>:((%E%*+&%((%I+3&L,,%*+:"$$RJ&+@%&
)'<<%*+&%"?"%#"#&+@%&#;E>%*&'(&CE''(&('E&,+"+%&I'<C$:"*I%&:*&+@%&=)LN)G3&D,:>%&(E'<&
,:+;"+:'*,&'(&>%$:#%E"+%&E%+E'9E%,,:'*J&+@%&)'P%*"*+&*%P%E&E%c;:E%,&+@"+&"&,+"+%&[;,+:(R&:+,&
"I+:'*,&",&;+:$:Z:*9&W+@%&<"`:<;<&'(&:+,&"P":$"#$%&E%,';EI%,3X-17&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&4J&
@'Q%P%EJ&E%c;:E%,&%`C$:I:+&,+"+%&[;,+:(:I"+:'*&:(&+@%&<:*:<;<&'(&+@%&E:9@+&%P%E&9'%,&
;*,"+:,(:%>J&",&+@%&#E%"I@&:,&CE:<"&("I:%(CE''(&'(&*'*TI'<C$:"*I%3&&
!@%&%*+:E%&I'*,+E;I+&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%J&(E'<&:+,&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&"&E:9@+U,&:<<%>:"+%&
%((%I+&+'&:+,&E%P%E,"$&'(&+@%&#;E>%*&'(&CE''(J&:,&[;,+:(:%>&",&*%I%,,"ER&('E&+@%&I'*I%C+;"$&
:*+%9E:+R&'(&+@%&)'P%*"*+&:+,%$(3&
&
=(&+@%&)'P%*"*+&Q%E%&+'&#%&E%">&:*&,;I@&"&Q"R&",&*'+&+'&%,+"#$:,@&,;I@&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&'#$:9"+:'*J&
:+&Q';$>&#%&$"E9%$R&>%CE:P%>&'(&:+,&E":,'*&>U%+E%3-1?&
(
=*&E%"$:+RJ&+@';9@J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&4&:,&<'E%&*'P%$&+@"*&+@%&)'<<:++%%&Q';$>&$%+&'*J&
%,C%I:"$$R&",&:+&%,+"#$:,@%,&"&*%Q&[;>:I:"$&(;*I+:'*H&+@%&>%+%E<:*"+:'*&'(&,:+;"+:'*,&:*&Q@:I@&
"&,+"+%&@",&#E%"I@%>&:+,&<:*:<;<&I'E%&'#$:9"+:'*,&#R&>%CE:P:*9&"&W,:9*:(:I"*+X&*;<#%E&'(&
C%'C$%&'(&+@%:E&E:9@+,J&"*>&+@%&,;#,%c;%*+&E%P:%Q&'(&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&W:*&+@%&I'*+%`+&'(&+@%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-11&48<&"+&-.-T-..3&
&&&&-1/&48<("+&q-5&
&&&&-17&=)LN)GJ&#6@%$&*'+%&4/J&"+&"E+3&.]-^3&
&&&&-1?&d)4J&#6@%$&*'+%&40J&"+&q-53&
&
40&
(;$$&;,%&'(&+@%&<"`:<;<&"P":$"#$%&E%,';EI%,3X&!@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&*'+&'*$R&<"B%,&:+&%",:%E&
+'&[;>9%&+@%&"II%C+"#:$:+R&'(&,+"+%&:*:+:"+:P%,J&:+&"$,'&,+E%*9+@%*,&+@%&[;,+:I:"#:$:+R&'(&,'I:'T
%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&:*&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,3-/5&&
(
B<(='"(9020-6-(A*%"(3*%(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%(
&
&
S'$$'Q:*9&+@%&I$"E:(:I"+:'*&'(&+@%&I'*I%C+&:*&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&4J&+@%&)LN)G&#%9"*&
>%(:*:*9&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&('E&+@%&E:9@+,&+'&@';,:*9J&(''>J&%>;I"+:'*J&@%"$+@I"E%J&"*>&
(:*"$$RJ&Q"+%E3-/-&!@%&"CCE'"I@&'(&+@%&)'<<:++%%&:*&%"I@&'(&+@%,%&>'I;<%*+,&@",&#%%*&+'&
('I;,&'*&I'E%&,+"+%&*+,01$:0*2#&<'E%&+@"*&I'E%&E:9@+U,&","-"2:#3-/.&!@:,&@",&$%">&,'<%&+'&
"E9;%&+@"+&+@%&)'<<:++%%U,&"CCE'"I@&:,&($"Q%>J&%,C%I:"$$R&#%I";,%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&"E%&*'+&
%`@";,+:P%$R&>%(:*%>&:*&"*R&I'P%*"*+3-/4&K',+&@;<"*&E:9@+,&+E%"+:%,J&@'Q%P%EJ&>'&*'+&
>:,+:*9;:,@&#%+Q%%*&E:9@+,&"*>&'#$:9"+:'*,J-/0&"*>&W:*&+@%'ERJ&+@%&I'E%&%$%<%*+,&'(&"&E:9@+&
,@';$>&I"EER&>:E%I+$R&I'EE%$"+:P%&'#$:9"+:'*,3X-/6&!@:,&"$$'Q,&;,J&<;I@&$:B%&+@%&CE'I%,,&'(&
E:9@+,&I'*,+E;I+:'*&:*&N%I+:'*&==J&+'&E%I'*,+E;I+&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&('E&Q"+%E3&S:E,+&Q%&Q:$$&
';+$:*%&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*,%*,;,&>%(:*:*9&Q"+%EU,&<:*:<;<&I'E%&",&CE'+%I+:*9&W#",:I&
*%%>,JX&+@%*&Q%&Q:$$&I'<C$%+%&+@%&$%9"$&>%(:*:+:'*&#R&<"+I@:*9&I'E%&%$%<%*+,&+'&+@%&
'#$:9"+:'*,&';+$:*%>&#R&+@%&)'<<:++%%&:*&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-63-/1&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-/5&F(&I';E,%J&+@:,&,+:$$&>%C%*>,&'*&@'Q&,+"+%,&%*,@E:*%&=)LN)G&'#$:9"+:'*,&"*>&)LN)G&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&:*+'&*"+:'*"$&
$"Q3&!@:,&CE'#$%<&Q:$$&#%&I'*,:>%E%>&:*&+@%&('$$'Q:*9&,%I+:'*&]=s^3&
&&&&-/-&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&0J&-.J&-4J&-0&"*>&-6J&E%,C%I+:P%$R3&!@%&)LN)G&@",&*'Q&C;#$:,@%>&.-&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,3&/""(
A*--0::""(*2(G&*2*-0&($28(/*&0$,(!01':#(F"2"%$,(A*--"2:#.&Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights,
@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,OI%,IEOI'<<%*+,3@+<&]$",+&P:,:+%>&M'P3&7J&.5-5^3&!@%&)LN)G&"$,'&E%9;$"E$R&;,%,&
+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&I'*I%C+&:*&:+,&)'*I$;>:*9&F#,%EP"+:'*,3&~';*9J&#6@%$&*'+%&-6?J&"+&-.53&
&&&&-/.&/"".("<1<.&D;>E%R&G3&)@"C<"*J&;(I`0*,$:0*2#(;@@%*$&'M(3*%(9*20:*%021(:'"(42:"%2$:0*2$,(A*?"2$2:(*2(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,(
$28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#.(-7&Hum. Rts. Q.&.4&]-??1^3&
&&&&-/4&K"$I'$<&_"*9('E>J&;-+0:0*2(:'$:(*?"%,"$@#(0:#",3_(;(!"#@*2#"(:*(/:"@'"2(=6,,7L#(VA%0:056"L(*3(:'"(F"2"%$,(A*--"2:(*2(
:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&.1]4^&Neth. Q. Hum. Rts.&044J&067&].551^3&
&&&&-/0&Malcolm Langford & Aofie Nolan, Centre for Housing Rights and Evictions, Litigating Economic,
Social and Cultural Rights: Legal Practitioners' Dossier&.-&].551^3&
&&&&-/6&D<"*>"&)"@:$$J&='"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%(f(;(!01':(*3(\2056"(/:$:6#R(='"(C"1$,(/:$:6#($28(E*%-$:0?"(A*2:"2:(*3(:'"(
!01':(:*(D$:"%.(?]4^(Intl J. Hum. Rts.&47?J&4??&T&055&].556^3&&
&&&&-/1&!@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&@",&<%+&+@%&E%I%*+&IE:+:I:,<&'(&,%P%E"$&,I@'$"E,&*'+:*9&:+,&]"^&I'*I%C+;"$&">%c;"IR&",&"CCE'"I@%,&
+'&:+,&>%(:*:+:'*&$%">&+'&:*>%+%E<:*"IR.(]#^&:+,&I'*I%C+;"$&:*">%c;"IR&",&:+&<"R&I'*(;,%&;+:$:+R&('E&CE:*I:C$%&:*&:+,&CE'+%I+:'*&
'(&:*>:P:>;"$&E:9@+,J&"*>&]I^&:+,&CE"I+:I"$&:*"CCE'CE:"+%*%,,&",&"&+''$&('E&[;>:I:"$&E%",'*:*93&D$$&+@E%%&IE:+:I:,<,&'P%E$"C&"*>&
$%">&+@%:E&";+@'E,&+'&"E9;%&+@"+&'+@%E&"CCE'"I@%,&+'&%*('EI%<%*+&T&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&N';+@&D(E:I"*&)';E+,U&WE%",'*"#$%*%,,X&
+%,+&>:,I;,,%>&:*&N%I+:'*&s&Y&"E%&<'E%&[;E:,CE;>%*+:"$$R&"CCE'CE:"+%3&!@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"CCE'"I@&:,&I'*,:>%E%>&#R&+@:,&
%,,"RJ&@'Q%P%EJ&+'&('E<&"*&%,,%*+:"$&C"E+&'(&%`:,+:*9&$%9"$&>;+:%,&E%$"+%>&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&+@';9@&IE:+:I:,<&'(&+@%&I'*I%C+&
<"R&#%&Q'E+@&I'*,:>%E:*9&(;E+@%E&%$,%Q@%E%3&S'E&"E9;<%*+,&"9":*,+&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%J&#""(1"2"%$,,7J&~';*9J&#6@%$&*'+%&
-6?g&i"E%*&_%@<"**J&42(>"3"2#"(*3(:'"(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*6%:R(C0:01$:021(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#($28(:'"(97:'(*3(:'"(9020-6-(
A*%".&..]-^&Am. U. Intl L. Rev. -14&].551^g&K"EB&N3&i%*>%J&='"(/*6:'(;3%0&$2(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*2#:%6&:0*2(*3(/*&0*(
G&*2*-0&(!01':#.(;(!"#@*2#"(:*(A%0:0&#.&-?&Conn. J. Intl L. 1-/&].554^3&D;+@'E,&:*&,;CC'E+&'(&+@%&I'*I%C+&:*I$;>%&K"E:;,&
&
46&
&
!@%&I'E%&I'*+%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&"*&%*+:+$%<%*+&+'&,;CC'E+&+$#0&(2""8#H&We"f,&
"*&"#,'$;+%&<:*:<;<J&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&%*+:+$%,&%P%ER'*%&+'&%,,%*+:"$&c;"*+:+:%,&'(&,"(%&
(E%,@Q"+%E&('E&C%E,'*"$&"*>&>'<%,+:I&;,%,&:*&'E>%E&+'&CE%P%*+&>%@R>E"+:'*&"*>&>:,%",%3X-//&
V:+@&(%Q&%Ì%C+:'*,J&%P%ER&,%I+'E&'(&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'<<;*:+R&:*P'$P%>&:*&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
@",&,"*I+:'*%>&+@:,&"CCE'"I@3&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6&*'+%,&+@"+&Q@:$%&Q"+%E&:,&WE%c;:E%>&('E&
"&E"*9%&'(&>:((%E%*+&C;EC',%,t&CE:'E:+R&:*&+@%&"$$'I"+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&<;,+&#%&9:P%*&+'&+@%&E:9@+&
+'&Q"+%E&('E&C%E,'*"$&"*>&>'<%,+:I&;,%,3&AE:'E:+R&,@';$>&"$,'&#%&9:P%*&+'&+@%&Q"+%E&
E%,';EI%,&E%c;:E%>&+'&CE%P%*+&,+"EP"+:'*&"*>&>:,%",%3X-/7&!@%&CE:'E:+:Z"+:'*&'(&C%E,'*"$&"*>&
>'<%,+:I&;,%,&('E&,;EP:P"$&:,&,;CC'E+%>&#R&+@%&G%C'E+&'(&+@%&a:9@&)'<<:,,:'*%E&('E&a;<"*&
G:9@+,J-/?&"*>&#R&+@%&I'*I%C+U,&:*I$;,:'*&:*&<"*R&'(&+@%&+E%"+:%,&E%P:%Q%>&:*&N%I+:'*&==3&!@%&
!@:E>&d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*J&('E&:*,+"*I%J&E%c;:E%,&+@"+&We+f@%&2%+":*:*9&A'Q%E&,@"$$&,;CC$R&
CE:,'*%E,&'(&Q"E&>;E:*9&+E"*,(%E&Q:+@&,;((:I:%*+&(''>&"*>&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&+'&B%%C&+@%<&:*&
9''>&@%"$+@3X-75&=*&,:+;"+:'*,&Q@%E%&Q"+%E&:,&,I"EI%&'E&CE'P:,:'*&$:<:+%>J&Q"+%E&('E&,;EP:P"$&
+"B%,&CE:'E:+R3&!@%&b3M3&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&V"+%E&)';E,%,&:*,:,+,&+@"+&:*&C%E:'>,&'(&I'*($:I+&'P%E&
E%,';EI%,J&CE:'E:+R&#%&9:P%*&+'&Q"+%E&+'&<%%+&WP:+"$&@;<"*&*%%>,3X-7-&!@%&8'**&)'*(%E%*I%&
'*&SE%,@Q"+%E&].55-^&,+"+%,&+@"+&WeQf"+%E&,@';$>&#%&%c;:+"#$R&"*>&,;,+":*"#$R&"$$'I"+%>J&
(:E,+$R&+'&#",:I&@;<"*&*%%>,3X-7.&K"*R&'+@%E&>%I$"E"+:'*,&+"B%&"&,:<:$"E&C',:+:'*3&
);,+'<"ER&$"Q&"$,'&,;CC'E+,&+@%&:>%"&'(&Q"+%EU,&<:*:<;<&I'E%&",&#",%>&:*&#",:I&
*%%>,3&!@%&8%E$:*&AE:*I:C$%,J&:*&($%,@:*9&';+&(;*>"<%*+"$&%$%<%*+,&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&
:*,:,+&+@"+&We%fP%ER&:*>:P:>;"$&@",&"&E:9@+&'(&"II%,,&+'t&Q"+%E&+'&<%%+&+@"+&:*>:P:>;"$U,&P:+"$&
@;<"*&*%%>,3X-74&S:*"$$RJ&+@%&#",:I&*%%>,&"CCE'"I@&:,&9%*%E"$$R&,;CC'E+%>&#R&,I@'$"E,&:*&
#'+@&$"Q&"*>&@;<"*&E:9@+,&"*>&#R&%`C%E+&+%I@*:I"$&#'>:%,3-70&!@%&VaFJ&('E&:*,+"*I%J&:*,:,+,&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
A:%+%E,%J&G$:021(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#R(='"(\#"36,2"##(*3(!01':#(=$,O(02(;,,"?0$:021(/*&0$,(S$%8#'0@(!"?0#0:"8.&.?&Hum. Rts.
Q. /?1&].55/^g&2"P:>&8:$I@:+ZJ&F0?021(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#(="":'R(='"(9020-6-(A*%"($28(4:#(4-@*%:$2&".&--?&S. Afr. L.J.&
070&].55.^3&
&&&&-//&i:%(%E&j&8Ek$<"**J&#6@%$(*'+%&/J&"+&.5-3&
&&&&-/7&d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q13&
&&&&-/?&/""(a'Q"E>&j&8"E+E"<J&#6@%$&*'+%&-..3&
&&&&-75&!@:E>&d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*J&#6@%$&*'+%&6/J&"+&"E+3&013&
&&&&-7-&/6@%$&*'+%&66J&"+&q13&
&&&&-7.&8'**&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&SE%,@Q"+%EJ&8'**J&d%E3J&2%I3&4T/J&.55-J(!"&*--"28$:0*2#(3*%(;&:0*2.(q03&
&&&&-74&/6@%$&*'+%&?5J&"+&.4T.03&
&&&&-70&8$;%<%$&*'+%,&+@:,&"9E%%<%*+&#;+&#%<'"*,&"*&:*"#:$:+R&+'&>:,I;,,&"II%,,&"*>&c;"$:+R&E%c;:E%<%*+,&",&(;$$R3&/""(
8$;%<%$J&,;CE"&*'+%&6J&"+&?713&N%%($,#*.(d$%:IBJ&='"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%J(#6@%$&*'+%&0.Z(\;$:"&a";,%E<"*J&G:9@+,&j&
a;<"*:+RJ&D&a;<"*&G:9@+,&DCCE'"I@&+'&2%P%$'C<%*+H&N'<%&AE"I+:I"$&=<C$:I"+:'*,&('E&V"+%ED:>U,&V'EBJ&-5&]N%C3&-5J&
-???^&]+E"*,IE:C+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^g&GorsbothJ&#6@%$(*'+%&.4J&"+&/&],"(%&"II%,,&+'&"&<:*:<"$&,;CC$R&<;,+&#%&
CE'P:>%>&W"+&"$$&+:<%,X^3&
&
41&
+@"+&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"+&$%",+&W:<C$:%,&"II%,,&+'&+@%&<:*:<;<&*%I%,,"ER&('E&#",:I&*%%>,JX&
Q@:I@&,@';$>&#%&+@%&(:E,+&C$"I%&('E&*"+:'*"$&C'$:IR&%<C@",:,3-76&&
!@%,%&,"<%&%`C%E+,&@"P%&>%P'+%>&,:9*:(:I"*+&+:<%&+'&"&>%+%E<:*"+:'*&'(&Q@"+&
$-*62:&'(&Q"+%E&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&CE'+%I+,3&|;"*+:+"+:P%&,+"*>"E>,&('E<&C"E+&'(&"&
E%,C'*,:#$%&('E<;$"+:'*&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%J&#%I";,%&+@%R&C%E<:+&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&"II%,,&
+'&"II%C+"#$%&#%*I@<"EB,&+@"+&I"*&:*('E<&+@%:E&I'*+%`+;"$:Z%>&>%I:,:'*,3&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&
-6&E%(%E%*I%,&+@%&"<';*+,&,+:C;$"+%>&#R&#'+@&"&VaF&,+;>R&]a'Q"E>&"*>&8"E+E"<^-71 &"*>&
+@%&:*>%C%*>%*+&,+;>R&'(&A%+%E&d$%:IB3-7/&8'+@&";+@'E,&I'*I;E&+@"+&Q@:$%&.5T.6&$:+%E,&C%E&
C%E,'*&C%E&>"R&]$OCO>^&:,&%*';9@&+'&%*,;E%&@;<"*&,;EP:P"$J&+@%&"<';*+&C',%,&"&W@:9@X&
@%"$+@&E:,B&",&@R9:%*%&I"**'+&#%&",,;E%>3-77&D,&#",:I&@R9:%*%&('E<,&"&C"E+&'(&+@%&E:9@+U,&
<:*:<;<&I'E%J&@'Q%P%EJ&:+&:,&9%*%E"$$R&"9E%%>&+@"+&,'<%Q@%E%&#%+Q%%*&.6T65&$OCO>&:,&
,;((:I:%*+&+'&"P':>&"*&:*+'$%E"#$%&E:,B&+'&@;<"*&@%"$+@&"IE',,&9%'9E"C@:I"$&"*>&,'I:"$&
I'*+%`+,3-7?&D$+@';9@&+@%&*;<#%E&:,&,'<%Q@"+&:<CE%I:,%&"*>&,;#[%I+&+'&I'*+%`+;"$:Z"+:'*J&
+@%&"<';*+&'(&Q"+%E&+'&<%%+&I'E%&WP:+"$&@;<"*&*%%>,X&Q'E$>Q:>%&:,&+@;,&9%*%E"$$R&
>%+%E<:*"#$%3-?5&G:9:>J&I'*+%`+T#$:*>&E%$:"*I%&'*&+@%,%&,+"*>"E>,J&@'Q%P%EJ&:,&+'&#%&
"P':>%>3-?-&
!@:,&:*:+:"$&>%+%E<:*"+:'*&'(&I'E%&I'*+%*+&:,&,'<%Q@"+&<'>:(:%>&#R&+@%&$'*9%E&
>%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&I'E%&*+,01$:0*2#&E%$"+%>&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:*&C"E"9E"C@&4/&'(&d%*%E"$&
)'<<%*+&-63&!@"+&C"E"9E"C@&';+$:*%,&*:*%&E%$"+%>&,+"+%&>;+:%,J&Q@:I@&I"*&#%&,;<<"E:Z%>&
:*+'&+@E%%&"I+:'*&"E%",3-?.&S:E,+J&,+"+%,&<;,+&%*,;E%&+@"+&%P%ER'*%&@",&:<<%>:"+%&"II%,,&+'&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-76&/6@%$&*'+%&-.?J&"+&43&
&&&&-71&d)-6&#6@%$(*'+%&44J&"+&6&*3&-03&d3)3&-6&>%$:#%E"+%$R&"P':>,&,%++:*9&,;I@&"&c;"*+:+"+:P%&#",:,&:+,%$(3&483&"+&q13(
&&&&-7/&48<("+&6&*3&-0&/""($,#*.&A%+%E&a3&d$%:IBJ&B$#0&(D$:"%(!"560%"-"2:#(3*%(S6-$2(;&:0?0:0"#.&.-].^&Water Intl&74&]-??1^3*
&&&&-77&/6@%$&*'+%&-.?J&"+&43&
&&&&-7?&!@:,&:,&>:,+:*9;:,@%>&(E'<&'+@%E&E%c;:E%<%*+,J&,;I@&",&+@"+&'(&-55&$:+%E,&,%+&#R&S"$$%*#%E9&"*>&bND=2&%*,;E:*9&W"&
>%I%*+&"*>&E%"$:,+:I&56$,0:7&'(&$:(%tX&T&<%",;E%,&E%$"+%>&+'&+@%(36,,(#&*@"&'(&+@%&E:9@+3&/"".(K"$I'$<&_"*9('E>J&A%*##30%"R(
='"%"(0#(2*(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%(3*%(C0?",0'**8#R(;(>"+$:"(H0:'(9",?02(D**8'*6#".&.7]-^&Waterlines&6J&6&].55?^3&
&&&&-?5&K',+&%`C%E+,J&:*I$;>:*9&a'Q"E>&"*>&8"E+E"<&I";+:'*&"#';+&+@%&W$:<:+%>&,:9*:(:I"*I%X&'(&"&*;<%E:I"$&>%(:*:+:'*&>;%&+'&
I'*+%`+;"$&>:((%E%*I%,3&/6@%$(*'+%&-.?J&"+&-3&K"$I'<&_"*9('E>&:*,:,+,&+@"+&We@f;<"*&E:9@+,&:,&*'+&[;,+&"#';+&
,+E":9@+('EQ"E>&%*+:+$%<%*+,&+'&<:*:<;<&c;"*+:+:%,g&:+&CE'P:>%,&"&,;#+$%&"*>&CE:*I:C$%>&(E"<%Q'EB&('E&%*,;E:*9&+@"+&+@%&
"$$'I"+:'*&'(&9''>,&"*>&,%EP:I%,&:,&*'+&#",%>&,:<C$R&'*&+@%&>:,+E:#;+:'*&'(&C'Q%E&"*>&Q%"$+@&#;+&:,&<">%&+'&E%,C%I+&@;<"*&
>:9*:+R3X&)E',,(:E%J&#6@%$(*'+%&-.?J&"+&-.3&V"+%E&:,&C%E@"C,&;*:c;%&",&,;I@&"&*;<%E:I"$&$%P%$&'(&CE'P:,:'*&:,&*'+&",&%",:$R&
>%+%E<:*"#$%&('E&'+@%E&E:9@+,J&#;+&+@%,%&,+"*>"E>,&Y&Q@:$%&@%$C(;$&:*&:$$;,+E"+:*9&,;CC'E+&('E&+@%&E:9@+&:*&,'<%&I",%,&Y&,+:$$&
E%c;:E%&I'*+%`+;"$:Z"+:'*3&S'E&(;E+@%E&>:,I;,,:'*J&,%%&023%$.&{&s3&
&&&&-?-&d$%:IB&*'+%,&+@"+&Q:+@';+&<%%+:*9&#",:I&Q"+%E&E%c;:E%<%*+,J&$"E9%T,I"$%&@;<"*&,;((%E:*9&:,&CE'[%I+%>&+'&9E'Q&
%`C'*%*+:"$$RJ&IE%"+:*9&C'+%*+:"$&('E&I'*($:I+3&d$%:IBJ&!"560%"-"2:#.&#6@%$&*'+%&-71J&"+&743&!''&<;I@&'(&"&('I;,&'*&c;"*+:+RJ&
@'Q%P%EJ&<"R&$,#*&I";,%&I'*($:I+&#R&:9*'E:*9&%c;"$$R&:<C'E+"*+&CE:*I:C$%,&'(&*'*T>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&"*>&%c;"$:+R3&_"*9('E>J&
A%*##30%"J&#6@%$&*'+%&-7?J&"+&/T73&D&I"E%(;$&#"$"*I%&I"*&#%&,+E;IB&+@E';9@&"CCE'CE:"+%&I'*+%`+;"$:Z"+:'*3&&
&&&&-?.&M'+%&+@"+&+@%&I'E%&'#$:9"+:'*&E%$"+:*9&+'&,"*:+"+:'*&@",&#%%*&>%$:#%E"+%$R&%Ì$;>%>3&/""(023%$&A"E+&)J&+@:,&,%I+:'*3&
&
4/&
+@%&I'E%&I'*+%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+3-?4&N%I'*>J&+@:,&"II%,,&<;,+&#%&",,;E%>&:*&"&*'*T>:,IE:<:*"+'ER&
Q"R&:*&$:*%&Q:+@&"E+:I$%,&.].^&"*>&4&'(&+@%&=)LN)G3-?0&S:*"$$RJ&,+"+%,&<;,+&+"B%&>%$:#%E"+%J&
I'*IE%+%&"*>&+"E9%+%>&,+%C,&+'Q"E>&+@%&(;$$&E%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+J-?6&:*I$;>:*9&E%I'9*:+:'*&
'(&+@%&E:9@+J-?1&+@%&">'C+:'*&"*>&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&'(&"&*"+:'*"$&Q"+%E&,+E"+%9R&+@"+&">>E%,,%,&
%P%ER'*%U,&*%%>,J-?/&"*>&+@%&IE%"+:'*&'(&"&<%I@"*:,<&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&<'*:+'E:*93-?7&D,&
*'+%>&"#'P%J&+@%,%&'#$:9"+:'*,&"E%&*'+&,;#[%I+&+'&+@%&WCE'9E%,,:P%&E%"$:Z"+:'*X&$:<:+"+:'*&
I$";,%&:*&=)LN)G&.]-^3&
=+&:,&C',,:#$%&+'&,R*+@%,:Z%&+@%&W#",:I&*%%>,X&%$%<%*+&';+$:*%>&"#'P%&Q:+@&+@%&
'#$:9"+:'*,&'(&C"E"9E"C@&4/3&!@%&I'E%&I'*+%*+&'(&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&I"*&+@%<&#%&,;<<"E:Z%>&
:*&+@%&('$$'Q:*9&Q"RH&
&
!@%&W<:*:<;<&I'E%X&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&"*&:*>:P:>;"$&E:9@+&+'&,;((:I:%*+J&,"(%J&"II%C+"#$%J&
C@R,:I"$$R&"II%,,:#$%&"*>&"(('E>"#$%&Q"+%E&+'&<%%+&P:+"$&@;<"*&*%%>,&"+&"$$&+:<%,J&>:,+E:#;+%>&:*&"&
*'*T>:,IE:<:*"+'ER&Q"RJ&"IB*'Q$%>9%>&#R&+@%&@'<%&9'P%E*<%*+J&"*>&E%:*('EI%>&#R&>%$:#%E"+%J&
I'*IE%+%&"*>&+"E9%+%>&,+"+%&"I+:'*,&+'Q"E>&+@%&%*['R<%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+U,&(;$$&,I'C%J&Q@%E%&"&(":$;E%&+'&
>'&"*R&'(&+@%,%&+@:*9,&E%c;:E%,&[;,+:(:I"+:'*&Q:+@&E%(%E%*I%&+'&+@%&<"`:<"$&;,%&'(&"P":$"#$%&E%,';EI%,3&
&
D&I"E%(;$&E%">%E&Q:$$&*'+%&+@"+&*%P%E&>'%,&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&%`C$:I:+$R&E%c;:E%&+@"+&Q"+%E&
#%&CE'P:>%>&('E&(E%%3&=*&("I+J&We+f@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&*'&<'E%&+@%&E:9@+&('E&%P%ER'*%&+'&
E%I%:P%&+@%:E&Q"+%E&('E&(E%%&+@"*&+@%&E:9@+&+'&(''>&:,&+@%&E:9@+&+'&E%I%:P%&'*%U,&(''>&('E&
(E%%3X-??&!@%&I'E%&E%c;:E%<%*+&'(&$&&"##0+0,0:7J&@'Q%P%EJ&<"R&*%I%,,:+"+%&+@%&(E%%&CE'P:,:'*&
'(&+@%&Q"+%E&E%c;:E%>&+'&,;,+":*&$:(%&:(&C"R:*9&('E&Q"+%E&Q';$>&"+&"$$&:<C"I+&"*&:*>:P:>;"$U,&
"#:$:+R&+'&CE'I;E%&'+@%E&%,,%*+:"$,&]%393&#",:I&(''>&'E&,@%$+%E^3&
S:*"$$RJ&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&,@';$>&"$Q"R,&#%&>:,+:*9;:,@%>&(E'<&+@%&I'*+%*+&"*>&
'#$:9"+:'*,&E%$"+%>&+'&+@%&%*['R<%*+&'(&+@%&36,,(#&*@"&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3&=*&:+,&>%(:*:+:'*&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&-?4&d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q4/]"^3&
&&&&-?0&48<("+&q4/]#^3&
&&&&-?6&48<("+&q-/3&
&&&&-?1&D$+@';9@&*'+&%`C$:I:+$R&,+"+%>&",&"*&%$%<%*+&:*&q4/J&E%I'9*:+:'*&:,&:<C$:%>&#R&+@%&%*+:E%+R&'(&+@%&)'<<%*+&"*>&
,;CC'E+%>&#R&(:*>:*9,&'(&+@%&)'<<:++%%&:*&,'<%&)'*I$;>:*9&F#,%EP"+:'*,3(/"".("<1<.()'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&)'*I$;>:*9&F#,%EP"+:'*,&'(&+@%&)'<<:++%%&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&)"*">"J&q45J&10J&b3M3&
2'I3&LO)3-.O)DMO)FO0J&LO)3-.O)DMO)FO6J&]K"R&..J&.551^J&"+&@++CHOOQQQ3;*@IE3'E9OE%(Q'E$>O>'I:>O064//("453@+<$&
&]We+f@%&)'<<:++%%&E%9E%+,&+@"+&+@%&,+"+%&C"E+R&>'%,&*'+&E%I'9*:Z%&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%Et&,+E'*9$R&E%I'<<%*>,&+@"+&+@%&,+"+%&
C"E+R&E%P:%Q&:+,&C',:+:'*&'*&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:*&$:*%&Q:+@&+@%&)'<<:++%%U,&9%*%E"$&I'<<%*+&M'3&-6X^3&
&&&&-?/&d)-6J&#6@%$(*'+%&44.("+&q4/](^3&
&&&&-?7&48<("+&q4/]9^3&
&&&&-??&/""(Henri Smets, Agence Franaise de Dveloppement, The Right to Water in National Legislations -6
].551^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOP"9;%3%;E%I'<3(EO,%<:>%OA2SOE:9@+T+'TQ"+%EhLM3&/""($,#*&d$%:IBJ&='"&S6-$2&!01':(:*(D$:"%.&
#6@%$&*'+%&46J&"+&03&
&
47&
'(&+@%&(;$$&E:9@+J&+@%&)'<<:++%%&">'C+,&"&W*%%>,&C$;,X&"CCE'"I@&+'&I'*+%*+3.55&!@:,&@'$:,+:I&
;*>%E,+"*>:*9&:*I$;>%,&+@%&Q"+%E&*%I%,,"ER&('E&">%c;"+%&@%"$+@&"*>&@;<"*&>:9*:+RJ&Q@:I@&
"E%&<'E%&+@"*&Q@"+&:,&E%c;:E%>&('E&#",:I&,;EP:P"$3.5-&!@%&'#$:9"+:'*,&E%$"+%>&+'&+@%&(;$$&
,I'C%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&"E%&I'<C"E"+:P%$R&#E'">%E&+@"*&+@%:E&I'E%&I';*+%EC"E+,&",&Q%$$3&LP%*&
Q@%*&WI'E%&'#$:9"+:'*,X&I"*&#%&I'*,:>%E%>&(;$(:$$%>J&,+"+%,&E%+":*&+@%&>;+R&+'&WCE'9E%,,:P%$R&
E%"$:Z%X&+@%&(;$$&,I'C%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&+@%&<"`:<;<&%`+%*+&C',,:#$%3&&&
&
A<(;(E*:"(*2(/$20:$:0*2(
&
&
!@%E%&:,&I'*,:>%E"#$%&>%#"+%&Q:+@:*&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'<<;*:+R&'P%E&+@%&CE'C%E&
C$"I%&('E&,"*:+"+:'*&Q:+@:*&+@%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&C"E">:9<3&V@:$%&<"*R&@;<"*&E:9@+,&">P'I"+%,&
"E9;%&('E&:+,&(;$$&:*+%9E"+:'*J&'+@%E,&*'+%&+@%&(;*>"<%*+"$&>:((%E%*I%,&#%+Q%%*&+@%&+Q'&
%*+:+$%<%*+,J&,"+:,(:%>&+'&,"R&+@"+&+@%R&"E%&,:<C$R&:*+%EE%$"+%>3.5.&!@:,&:*:+:"$&$"IB&'(&I$"E:+R&
Q",&(;E+@%E&I'<C$:I"+%>&#R&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6J&Q@:I@&I;E,'E:$R&">>E%,,%>&">%c;"+%&
,"*:+"+:'*&",&%,,%*+:"$&('E&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&:*I$;>%>&"&,"*:+"+:'*&%$%<%*+&"<'*9&:+,&
I'E%&'#$:9"+:'*,&Q:+@';+&">>E%,,:*9&:+&",&"&WE:9@+X&:+,%$(3.54&D$+@';9@&+@%E%&,%%<,&+'&#%&"&
I'*,%*,;,&E%9"E>:*9&+@%&*%I%,,:+R&'(&">%c;"+%&,"*:+"+:'*&('E&+@%&(;$$&%*['R<%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&
+'&Q"+%EJ&+@%E%&:,&*'&"CC"E%*+&I'*,%*,;,&'*&Q@%+@%E&,"*:+"+:'*&('E<,&"&C"E+&'E&%`:,+,&
:*>%C%*>%*+$R&'(&+@"+&E:9@+3.50&S'E&+@:,&E%",'*J&+@%&:*I$;,:'*&'(&"&,"*:+"+:'*&%$%<%*+&
,'<%Q@"+&I'<C$:I"+%,&"*&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%&E:9@+U,&WI'E%&I'*+%*+X&#R&IE%"+:*9&"&I'E%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.55&N%%&8$;%<%$J&#6@%$&*'+%&6J&"+&?713&
&&&&.5-&8:$I@:+Z&>:,+:*9;:,@%,&+@%&:*+%E%,+,&"+&+@%&@%"E+&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&",&W#",:I&:*+%E%,+,X&]:*I$;>:*9&(E%%>'<&+'&
+@E%"+,&(E'<&,;EP:P"$J&(E'<&C@R,:I"$&,;((%E:*9&"*>&(E'<&,%E:';,&@%"$+@&E:,B,&+@"+&:<C%>%&,%$(T>%+%E<:*"+:'*^&"*>&Q:+@:*&
+@%&(;$$&,I'C%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&",&W9%*%E"$&:*+%E%,+,X&]%*I'<C",,:*9&#'+@&#",:I&:*+%E%,+,&"*>&+@%&<"`:<"$&%*['R<%*+&'(&+@%&
E:9@+J&"$$'Q:*9&('E&@;<"*&>%P%$'C<%*+^3&/""(2"P:>&8:$I@:+ZJ&#6@%$&*'+%&-/1J&"+&0?5T0?.3&
&&&&.5.&/""J&%393J&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&L`C%E+,&K%%+:*9&'*&+@%&G:9@+&+'&V"+%EJ&A"E:,J&SE3J&\;$R&/T7J&.55?J&W6:&*-"(*3(:'"(42:"%2$:0*2$,(
GT@"%:#L(9"":021(*2(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%.(0&]FI+3&.55?^J&$?$0,$+,"&$:&
@++CHOO;*%,>'I3;*%,I'3'E9O:<"9%,O55-7O55-760O-7604.%3C>(&]WV@:$%&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&:*IE%",:*9$R&
E%I'9*:Z%>&#R&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'<<;*:+RJ&,"*:+"+:'*&:,&*'+&R%+&Q:>%$R&C%EI%:P%>&",&"&@;<"*&E:9@+3X^3&!@%&N;#T
)'<<:,,:'*U,&>E"(+&9;:>%$:*%,&"$,'&(":$&+'&>%(:*%&+@%&+%E<&W,"*:+"+:'*JX&"$+@';9@&+@%R&>'&<'E%&I$%"E$R&>%(:*%&,"*:+"+:'*&
'#$:9"+:'*,3&/""(>%$3:(F608",02"#.(#6@%$&*'+%&/43&B6:&#""(1"2"%$,,7(=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&
G%$"+%>&+'&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&!"@*%:(*3(:'"(GT@"%:(*2(:'"(4##6"(*3(S6-$2(!01':#(W+,01$:0*2#(
!",$:"8(:*(;&&"##(:*(/$3"(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.&a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-.O.0&]\;$R&-J&.55?^&]#R&
)"+"E:*"&>%&D$#;c;%Ec;%^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,O@EI';*I:$O>'I,O-.,%,,:'*ODTaG)T-.T
.0hL3C>(&]I:+:*9&"&<'P%<%*+&+'Q"E>&+@%&E%I'9*:+:'*&'(&"*&:*>%C%*>%*+&E:9@+&+'&,"*:+"+:'*&",&"&I'<C'*%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&
"*&">%c;"+%&,+"*>"E>&'(&$:P:*9&"*>&';+$:*:*9&%`:,+:*9&$%9"$&'#$:9"+:'*,&E%$"+%>&+'&,"*:+"+:'*&:*I;<#%*+&'*&,+"+%&"I+'E,^3(
&&&&.54&/""&d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q-&]*'+:*9&+@"+&+@%&$"IB&'(&"II%,,&+'&">%c;"+%&,"*:+"+:'*&W:,&+@%&CE:<"ER&I";,%&'(&Q"+%E&
I'*+"<:*"+:'*&"*>&>:,%",%,&$:*B%>&+'&Q"+%E3X^3&N"*:+"+:'*&:,&'*$R&">>E%,,%>&"9":*&:*&q4/]:^3&
&&&&.50&S'E&"&>:,I;,,:'*&,%%()"@:$$J&#6@%$&*'+%&-/6J&"+&05-T0503&
&
4?&
'#$:9"+:'*&+@"+&>'%,&*'+&>:E%I+$R&E%(%E&+'&Q"+%E&:+,%$(3&!@:,&<"R&#%&%`C$":*%>&#R&+@%&("I+&+@"+&
#",:I&,"*:+"+:'*&:,&*%I%,,"ER&('E&+@%&CE'P:,:'*&'(&I$%"*&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&"+&+@%&I'E%&'(&+@%&
E:9@+J.56&"*>&+@"+&:+&Q"EE"*+,&:*I$;,:'*&#%I";,%&"&E:9@+&+'&,"*:+"+:'*&:,&*'+&CE'+%I+%>&#R&"*R&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'P%*"*+3.51&
&
=*&+@%&%*>J&+@%&[;,+:(:I"+:'*&'E&I$"E:(:I"+:'*&'(&"&E:9@+&+'&,"*:+"+:'*&:,&#%R'*>&+@%&
,I'C%&'(&+@:,&%,,"R3&!@:,&%,,"R&Q:$$&+E%"+&+@%&CE'P:,:'*&'(&<:*:<"$$R&">%c;"+%&H$:"%(3*%(
#$20:$:0*2&",&:*+%9E"$&+'&+@%&I'E%&'#$:9"+:'*&+'&CE'P:>%&"II%,,&+'&">%c;"+%&Q"+%E&('E&
>'<%,+:I&"*>&C%E,'*"$&;,%3&=+&:,&*'+&,;<<"E:Z%>&",&C"E+&'(&+@%&E:9@+U,&I'E%&&*2:"2:&"#'P%J&
*'E&Q:$$&:+&#%&I'*,:>%E%>&:*&+@%&CE'I%%>:*9&:*P%,+:9"+:'*&'(&*"+:'*"$&[;E:,CE;>%*I%J&
@'Q%P%EJ&#%I";,%&+@%&";+@'E&#%$:%P%,&+@"+&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&I"*&#%&
('E<;$"+%>J&>%<'*,+E"+%>&"*>&[;,+:(:%>&:*>%C%*>%*+$R&'(&+@:,&%$%<%*+3&
&
&
! .D/*56#*E#C%'%0%1'*1C*06#*+%860*01*9(0#"*('2*%0-*A%'%&3&*>1"#*%'*F(0%1'($*
>13"0"11&-*
&
&
=+&:,&I$%"E&(E'<&+@%&CE%I%>:*9&,%I+:'*,&+@"+&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&:<C',%,&"&I'*IE%+%&,%+&
'(&'#$:9"+:'*,&'*&,+"+%,&C"E+:%,&+'&+@%&=)LN)G&E%9"E>:*9&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&2%P%$'C:*9&I;,+'<&
@",&#%9;*&+'&%`+%*>&E%,C'*,:#:$:+R&('E&+@:,&$%9"$&*'E<&+'&'+@%E&,+"+%,&*'+&%`C$:I:+$R&#';*>&
#R&+E%"+R&CE'P:,:'*3.5/&!@%,%&'#$:9"+:'*,&,+%<&(E'<&+@%&*'E<"+:P%&I$"E:+R&'(&+@%&I'*I%C+&'(&
Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:+,%$(J&#",%>&:*&,+"+%&CE"I+:I%&]%P:*I%>&#R&>%I$"E"+:P%&I'*,%*,;,^J&+@%&$%9"$&
'C:*:'*&'(&%`C%E+&#'>:%,&$:B%&+@%&)LN)G&"*>&+@%&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&_"Q&D,,'I:"+:'*J&"*>&+@%&
+%$%'$'9:I"$&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&'(&@;<"*&E:9@+,&+E%"+:%,&%`C$":*%>&:*&N%I+:'*,&==&"*>&===3&D,&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.56&d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q.?&]WL*,;E:*9&+@"+&%P%ER'*%&@",&"II%,,&+'&">%c;"+%&,"*:+"+:'*&:,&*'+&'*$R&(;*>"<%*+"$&('E&
@;<"*&>:9*:+R&"*>&CE:P"IRJ&#;+&:,&'*%&'(&+@%&CE:*I:C"$&<%I@"*:,<,&('E&CE'+%I+:*9&+@%&c;"$:+R&'(&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&,;CC$:%,&
"*>&E%,';EI%,3X^&V"+%E&('E&,"*:+"+:'*&:,&:*I$;>%>&:*&+@%&(';ET('$>&I'*I%C+&'(&8",:I&V"+%E&G%c;:E%<%*+,&]8VG^&(:E,+&
>%P%$'C%>&#R&d$%:IB3&/""(d$%:IBJ&B$#0&(D$:"%(!"560%"-"2:#(3*%(S6-$2(;&:0?0:0"#J&#6@%$&*'+%&-7/J&"+&6J&74T?.3&F(&+@%&.6&$:+%E,&
E%c;:E%>&('E&@;<"*&,;EP:P"$J&'*$R&4&"E%&*%%>%>&+'&E%C$%*:,@&+@%&#'>RU,&*"+;E"$&,';EI%,3&!Q%*+R&"E%&E%,%EP%>&('E&
,"*:+"+:'*3&
&&&&.51&/""(\3&8"E+E"<J&G%CE%,%*+"+:P%&'(&+@%&V'E$>&a%"$+@&FE9"*:Z"+:'*J&FE"$&,;#<:,,:'*&+'&d%*%E"$&2:,I;,,:'*&'*&+@%&2E"(+&
d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&'*&+@%&G:9@+&+'&V"+%E&]M'P3&..J&.55.^3&!@%&$"*9;"9%&'(&d)-6&Q';$>&,%%<&+'&:*>:I"+%&+@"+&+@%E%&"E%&
<;$+:C$%&$%9"$&#",%,&('E&+@%&E:9@+J&#;+&*'&:*>%C%*>%*+&,';EI%&'(&$%9"$&CE'+%I+:'*3&d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q.?&]I:+:*9&+@%&
E:9@+,&+'&@%"$+@&"*>&@';,:*9^&
&&&&.5/&);,+'<J&:(&*'+&,;((:I:%*+$R&>%P%$'C%>&+'&I'*,+:+;+%&"&(:E<&E;$%&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"QJ&:,&"+&$%",+&,;((:I:%*+$R&>%P%$'C%>&+'&
E%c;:E%&+@%&I'*,:>%E"+:'*&'(&+@%&$%9"$&:*+%*+&'(&Q"+%ETE%$"+%>&>%I$"E"+:'*,J&E%,'$;+:'*,&"*>&E%$"+%>&+E%"+:%,&Y&",&Q%$$&",&
*'*T'#[%I+:'*&+'&>%P%$'C:*9&*'E<,&Y&",&C$"I:*9&,'<%&'#$:9"+:'*&'*&+@',%&,+"+%,&*'+&R%+&C"E+:%,&+'&+@%&=)LN)G3&!@%&
CE"I+:I"$&"CC$:I"#:$:+R&'(&,;I@&$"QJ&@'Q%P%EJ&:,&$%(+&+'&+@%&>:,IE%+:'*&'(&"&[;>:I:"$&#'>R&I"C"#$%&'(&%,+"#$:,@:*9&[;E:,>:I+:'*3&&
&
05&
i:%(%E&"*>&8Ek$<"**&I'EE%I+$R&,;E<:,%J&,+"+%&(":$;E%&Q:+@&E%,C%I+&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
'#$:9"+:'*,&<"R&$%"P%&+@"+&"I+'E&:*&#E%%I@&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&!@%R&"E%&%c;"$$R&I'EE%I+&
Q@%*&+@%R&"IB*'Q$%>9%J&@'Q%P%EJ&+@"+&,;I@&E%,C'*,:#:$:+R&$"IB,&+"*9:#$%&I'*,%c;%*I%&:*&"&
,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&,R,+%<&Q:+@';+&W";+@'E:+"+:P%X&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I",%&$"Q3.57&
&
FE:9:*"$$RJ&+@:,&Q%"B*%,,&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&%*('EI%<%*+&$%>&<"*R&+'&>';#+&Q@%+@%E&
+@%&,+"*>"E>&Q';$>&%P%E&(:*>&>'<%,+:I&"CC$:I"+:'*3&D,&+@%&I",%&,+;>:%,&#%$'Q&CE'P%J&
@'Q%P%EJ&>'<%,+:I&I';E+,&@"P%&#%9;*&+'&%<#E"I%&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&@;<"*&
E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&'(&+@%:E&'Q*&"II'E>&Y&,'<%+:<%,&%P%*&IE%"+:P%$R&WI'*,+E;:*9X&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
(E'<&,%%<:*9$R&;*E%$"+%>&%*+:+$%<%*+,3&!@%&Q'EB&#%$'Q&';+$:*%,&,%P%E"$&%`"<C$%,&'(&
>'<%,+:I&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&%*('EI%<%*+&Q:+@&>:((%E:*9&$%P%$,&'(&,;CC'E+&('E&+@%&C',:+%>&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<3&!@%&"*"$R,:,&'(&+@:,&,%I+:'*&:,&I'*,I:';,&'(&+@%&("I+&+@"+&:(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
"E%&+'&#%&;*:P%E,"$$R&9;"E"*+%%>J&+@:,&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>&<;,+&#%&">%c;"+%$R&E%:*('EI%>&
"*>&*'+&;*>%E<:*%>&#R&*"+:'*"$&[;E:,CE;>%*I%3&
&
;<(E*%-(A%"$:0*2($28(=%$2#-0##0*2($:(:'"(E$:0*2$,(C"?",(
(
!@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&Q';$>&#%&<%"*:*9$%,,&:(&*'+&,;CC'E+%>&#R&N+"+%,J&+@',%&
<%<#%E,&'(&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'<<;*:+R&;*:c;%$R&I"C"#$%&'(&E%I'9*:Z:*9&#:*>:*9&E;$%,&'(&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3.5?&=*&("I+J&#%I";,%&@;<"*&E:9@+,&CE:<"E:$R&9'P%E*&+@%&E%$"+:'*,@:C&
#%+Q%%*&"&9'P%E*<%*+&"*>&:+,&I:+:Z%*,J&+@%&<":*&E%",'*&('E&+@%&I'>:(:I"+:'*&'(&"&*%Q&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<&:,&:+,&*"+:'*"$&%*('EI%<%*+3.-5&N+"+%,&"E%&P:+"$&+'&+@%&CE'<'+:'*&'(&*%Q&
E:9@+,&('E&+Q'&E%",'*,H&(:E,+J&#%I";,%&+@%R&@'$>&+@%&E%c;:,:+%&C'Q%E&+'&"I+:P%$R&:<C$%<%*+&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.57&i:%(%E&j&8Ek$<"**J&#6@%$&*'+%&/J&"+&.5/3&
&&&&.5?&D><:++%>$RJ&CE'#$%<,&'(&C',:+:P:,<&I'<C$:I"+%&+@%&C@:$','C@:I"$&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&@%E%3&DE%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
*"+;E"$&E:9@+,&#",%>&'*&+@%:E&(;*>"<%*+"$:+R&+'&"&$:(%&:*&>:9*:+R&'E&"E%&+@%R&$%9"$&%*+:+$%<%*+,&#",%>&:*&+@%:E&E%I'9*:+:'*&#R&
,+"+%,n&A',:+:P:,<&:*,:,+,&+@"+&$"Q,&"E%&E;$%,&<">%&#R&@;<"*&#%:*9,J&"*>&+@"+&",&I'*,+E;I+,&+@%R&I"*&#%&,%C"E"+%>&(E'<&
P"$:>:+R&I'*>:+:'*,&'(&<'E"$:+R&"*>&%+@:I,&"*>&#",%>&,+E:I+$R&'*&,'I:"$&("I+3&a;<"*&E:9@+,&:*&+@:,&C"E">:9<&"E%&+@',%&E;$%,&
"E+:I;$"+%>&#R&";+@'E:+"+:P%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&#'>:%,&"*>&Q:>%$R&"II%C+%>3&!@:,&C@:$','C@:I"$&CE'#$%<&:,&%,C%I:"$$R&C%E+:*%*+&
+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&",&+@%R&E%<":*&('E<"$$R&;*I'>:(:%>3&!@%&CE%,%*+&%,,"R&"P':>,&+@:,&I'*I%C+;"$&>:$%<<"&Q:+@&"*&%`C$"*"+'ER&
>%(:*:+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&+@"+&('I;,%,&'*&+@%&E%I%*+&%"$,0Q$:0*2&'(&+@%:E&(;*>"<%*+"$:+R&",&2*H(%"560%021&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&
@;<"*&>:9*:+R&+@E';9@&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&E%I'9*:+:'*3&=*&+@:,&Q"RJ&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&>%<'*,+E"+%,&@'Q&@;<"*&E:9@+,&:*&+@%:E&
<',+&C%E(%I+&('E<&,:<;$+"*%';,$R&%`:,+&",&#'+@&>:9*:+RT#",%>&%*+:+$%<%*+,&"*>&WC',:+%>X&$"Q,3&D,&+@%&VaF&:*,:,+,&:*&:+,&
@"*>#''B&'*&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&We@f;<"*&E:9@+,&"E%&CE'+%I+%>&#R&:*+%E*"+:'*"$$R&9;"E"*+%%>&,+"*>"E>,&+@"+&%*,;E%&+@%&
(;*>"<%*+"$&(E%%>'<,&"*>&>:9*:+R&'(&:*>:P:>;"$,&"*>&I'<<;*:+:%,3X&WHO Right to Water, #6@%$(*'+%&-1J&"+&/3&S'E&"&
>:,I;,,:'*&'(&C',:+:P:,<J&,%%&9%*%E"$$R&John Austin, Province of Jurisprudence Determined&-6/&])"<#E:>9%&
-??6^]-74.^3&
&&&&.-5&/""(Clifford.(#6@%$&*'+%&04J&"+&-.3&
&
0-&
E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*J&"*>&,%I'*>J&#%I";,%&+@%R&"$'*%&@"P%&+@%&";+@'E:+R&+'&E%I'9*:Z%&'E&E%[%I+&
*'P%$&I$":<,&",&,+%<<:*9&(E'<&E:9@+,&P:'$"+:'*,3.--&!@%&(:E,+&E%",'*&>%E:P%,&(E'<&+@%&
$%9:,$"+:P%&"*>&%`%I;+:P%&(;*I+:'*,J&.-.&"*>&+@%&$",+&,%P%E"$&>%I">%,&@"P%&,%%*&+@%&#:E+@&'(&
<"*R&$"Q,&Y&:*I$;>:*9&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&"<%*><%*+,&Y&E%I'9*:Z:*9&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3.-4&!@%&
,%I'*>&E%",'*&,+%<,&(E'<&+@%&C'Q%E&'(&+@%&[;>:I:"ER&:*&:+,&'P%E,:9@+&'(&"&,+"+%U,&#%@"P:'E&:*&
E%$"+:'*&+'&:+,&I:+:Z%*,3&!@:,&(;*I+:'*&:,&C%E@"C,&%P%*&<'E%&:<C'E+"*+&+@"*&+@%&(:E,+J&.-0&"*>&
:+&:,&+@%&('I;,&'(&+@:,&,%I+:'*3&
D#E'<'P:I@&"*>&)';E+:,&*'+%&+@"+J&&
&
[t]he adoption of international human rights treaties at the highest level of the local normative
pyramid and the acceptance of the jurisdiction of international bodies in the area of human rights,
obliges the local judicial actors to recognize the interpretation of these treaties that has taken place
at international venues.215
&
_'I"$&E%I'9*:+:'*&'(&"*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<&Y&$:B%&+@%&I'*,%*,;,&,;EE';*>:*9&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
%`C$'E%>&:*&N%I+:'*&==&Y&:,&<'E%&I'<C$:I"+%>J&@'Q%P%EJ&+@"*&+@:,&C",,"9%&,;99%,+,3&!@:,&:,&
#%I";,%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&@;<"*&E:9@+,&,+"*>"E>,&"E%&%*,@E:*%>&+'&P"ER:*9&>%9E%%,&:*&$'I"$&
I'*+%`+,3&S;E+@%E<'E%J&@;<"*&E:9@+,&"E%&I'>:(:%>&"+&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$&",&;*:P%E,"$&
CE:*I:C$%,J&*'+&I'*+%`+;"$:Z%>&%*+:+$%<%*+,3&!@:,&<%"*,&+@"+&%P%*&Q@%*&$'I"$$R&E%I'9*:Z%>J&
+@%R&E%c;:E%&"&>%9E%%&'(&[;>:I:"$&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&'E&WI'*+%*+T9:P:*93X&D,&8:$I@:+Z&%`C$":*,J&W:*&
9:P:*9&I'*+%*+&+'&+@%&E:9@+J&"&I';E+&%*9"9%,&:*&+@%&CE'I%,,&'(&,C%I:(R:*9&9%*%E"$&CE:*I:C$%,&
+@"+&>%(:*%&+@%&'#$:9"+:'*,&C$"I%>&;C'*&+@%&,+"+%3X.-1&N'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&"E%&%,C%I:"$$R&
'C%*&+'&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&",&+@%:E&C',:+:P%&'#$:9"+:'*,&"$$'Q&('E&"&>%9E%%&'(&$:#%E"$:+R&:*&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.--&/""(48<("+&/g&#""($,#*(8:,Q",&9GE;J&#6@%$&*'+%&0.J&"+&.-?3(
&&&&.-.&D$+@';9@&+@%&";+@'E&@",&>:,+:*9;:,@%>&+@%<&@%E%J&+@%,%&(;*I+:'*,&"E%&'(+%*&@R#E:>:Z%>&';+,:>%&'(&,+E:I+&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&
,R,+%<,3&
&&&&.-4&/""&Malcolm Langford et al., Centre for Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right
to Water: International and National Standards, {&6J&].550^&e@%E%:*"(+%E&COHREbf3&
&&&&.-0&!@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&%*,@E:*%<%*+&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:,&<%"*:*9$%,,&Q:+@';+&[;>:I:"$&,;CC'E+3&/""&2"P:>&z%+$"*>J&W2(97(
9028R(D$:"%(!01':#($28(S6-$2(!01':#J&Forbes Magazine Online&]DCE3&-.J&.5-5^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3('E#%,3I'<O('E#%,O.5-5O50-.O'C:*:'*,T,"*:+"+:'*T@":+:T@;<"*TE:9@+,T'*T<RT<:*>3@+<$&]*'+:*9&+@"+&:*&
.551&"II%,,&E',%&/m&:*&I';*+E:%,&Q:+@&E:9@+,&%*,@E:*%<%*+J&#;+&,+:$$&E',%&6m&9%*%E"$$R^3&
&&&&.-6&s:I+'E&D#E"<'P:I@&j&)@E:,+:"*&)';E+:,J&=*H$%8#($(>"-$28$+0,0:7(*3(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#R(
42:"%2$:0*2$,(/:$28$%8#($28(:'"0%(;@@,0&$:0*2(02(C*&$,(A*6%:#.(02&The Application of Human Rights Treaties for
Local Juristictions&4.0&]K"E+*&D#E%9&j&)@E:,+:"*&)';E+:,&%>,3J&-??/^3&8$;%<%$&"$,'&*'+%,&+@"+&9%*%E"$$RJ&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&E%9"E>:*9&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&]"$+@';9@&*'+&$%9"$$R&#:*>:*9^&@",&CE%,,;E%>&,'<%&,+"+%,&:*+'&$%9:,$"+:P%&
"*>&[;>:I:"$&E%I'9*:+:'*3&/""(8$;%<%$J&#6@%$(*'+%&6J&"+&?//3*
&&&&&.-1&8:$I@:+ZJ&#6@%$&*'+%&-/1J&"+&07/3&&
&
0.&
>%(:*:*9&I'EE%,C'*>:*9&>;+:%,3.-/&!@:,&<%"*,&+@"+&+@%&H$7&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&*'E<,&"E%&
*"+:'*"$$R&%*('EI%>&:,&'(+%*&[;,+&",&:<C'E+"*+&",&%*('EI%<%*+&:+,%$(3&&
S'E&Q"+%E&+@:,&CE'I%,,&:,&%,C%I:"$$R&CE%I"E:';,&>;%&+'&+@"+&E:9@+U,&,+"+;,&",&"&$%9"$&
W>%E:P"+:P%X&'(&'+@%E&'#$:9"+:'*,3&8%I";,%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&+@';9@&:*>%C%*>%*+$R&>%(:*"#$%&$#(
,$H.&"E%&*'+&R%+&:*>%C%*>%*+$R&%*,@E:*%>&02(,$HJ&+@%R&E%c;:E%&"&>%9E%%&'(&$%9:+:<"+:'*&+@"+&
I"*&'*$R&I'<%&Q:+@&+@%:E&,;CC'E+&:*&*"+:'*"$&[;E:,CE;>%*I%3.-7&d:P%*&"<C$%&,C"I%&('E&
WI'*+%*+T9:P:*9JX&"&*"+:'*"$&I';E+&<:9@+&",,%E+&Q"+%E&"II%,,&",&,'<%&W$%,,%E&'#$:9"+:'*3X&.-?&&
V'E,%J&:+&<:9@+&",,%E+&"&W@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EX&>%P':>&'(&"*R&*'E<"+:P%&,+"*>"E>&'(&
c;"$:+RJ&"II%,,:#:$:+R&'E&"II%C+"#:$:+R3&=+&:,&:<C'E+"*+&+'&I'*,:>%E&'*H(*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&
%*('EI%&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:(&Q%&"E%&+'&;*>%E,+"*>&+@%&Q"R&:*&Q@:I@&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<&:,&
,+E%*9+@%*%>&'E&I@"$$%*9%>3&!@:,&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&,@';$>&%*"#$%&;,&+'&<'E%&">%c;"+%$R&
>%(%*>&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&",&"&;*:P%E,"$&%*+:+$%<%*+&#",%>&:*&@;<"*&>:9*:+R3..5&
!@%&:<C'E+"*I%&'(&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&:*&>%(:*:*9&"*>&>%(%*>:*9&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&
@%:9@+%*%>&#R&"&@:9@&E"+%&'(&[;>:I:"$&+E"*,<:,,:'*3&D+&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$J&+@%&#'EE'Q:*9&
'(&'*%&+E:#;*"$U,&E%",'*:*9&",&"*&";+@'E:+"+:P%&,+"*>"E>&:,&"$E%">R&I'<<'*C$"I%3..-&2;%&+'&
+@%&E%$"+:P%&*'P%$+R&'(&+@%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&I'*I%C+J&@'Q%P%EJ&,+"*>"E>,&,%+&#R&2$:0*2$,&I';E+,&
"E%&"$,'&#%:*9&">'C+%>&%$,%Q@%E%3&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&+E:#;*"$,&:*IE%",:*9$R&#'EE'Q&(E'<&+@:,&
[;E:,CE;>%*I%J...&"*>&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&@"P%&%P%*&#%9;*&+'&<:<:I&%"I@('+@%E3&~';*9&*'+%,&
+@"+&+@:,&W+E"*,*"+:'*"$&[;>:I:"$&>:"$'9;%X&'(+%*&#;:$>,&;C'*&+@%&+%`+;"$&,:<:$"E:+:%,&,+"+%,&
,@"E%&:*&E:9@+,&E%I'9*:+:'*3..4&N+"+%,&Q:+@&,:<:$"E&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&,R,+%<,&'E&,@"E%>&I'$'*:"$&
@:,+'E:%,J&('E&%`"<C$%J&'(+%*&,@"E%&[;E:,CE;>%*I%3&S'E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&E%I%*+&I",%,&(E'<&,+"+%,&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.-/&/""&{&==J&A"E+&)J&+@:,&%,,"R3&S'E&%`"<C$%J&Q@:$%&+@%&(E%%>'<&'(&,C%%I@&9%*%E"$$R&E%c;:E%,&'((:I:"$&C'$:I:%,&E%,C%I+:*9&:+,&
%`%EI:,%J&+@%&E:9@+&+'&@';,:*9&<"R&E%c;:E%&,+"+%,&]:*&,'<%&,:+;"+:'*,^&+'&>%I:>%&H'$:&@';,:*9&:,&,;:+"#$%&+'&<%%+&+@%&E:9@+U,&
E%c;:E%<%*+,3&D$+@';9@&+@%E%&:,&*'&,+E:I+&>:I@'+'<R&#%+Q%%*&C',:+:P%&"*>&*%9"+:P%&E:9@+,J&+@%&>:((%E%*I%,&:*&E:9@+,&
%*('EI%<%*+&I"*&'II",:'*"$$R&#%&>";*+:*9&:*&CE"I+:I%3&&
&&&&.-7&V@:$%&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&E%$"+:P%$R&Q%$$&>%(:*%>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$$RJ&WI'<C$:"*I%&:,&CE:<"E:$R&"*&:,,;%&'(&>'<%,+:I&
C'$:+:I,3&X&CliffordJ&#6@%$&*'+%&04J&"+&-.3&8'+@&d'E,#'+@&"*>&)FaGL&>%<'*,+E"+%&+@%&:<C'E+"*I%&'(&*"+:'*"$&
[;E:,CE;>%*I%&:*&E:9@+,&>%(:*:+:'*3&/""(Gorsboth,(#6@%$&*'+%&.4g&COHREb, #6@%$(*'+%&.51J&"+&{&/3&
&&&&.-?&M'+&%P%ER'*%&"9E%%,&Q:+@&+@%&CE%P":$:*9&I'*,%*,;,3&8:,Q",&"E9;%,&+@"+&:*I'*,:,+%*I:%,&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&'C:*:'*&
C%E<:+&"E9;<%*+,&+@"+&Q"+%E&I'*,+:+;+%,&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&'E&'*$R&"&W$%,,%E&'#$:9"+:'*JX&",&*%:+@%E&>%(:*:+:'*&@",&#%%*&
8"3020:0?",7&"9E%%>&;C'*3&/""(8:,Q",&9GE;J&#6@%$&*'+%&0/J&"+&.-73&
&&&&..5&=*&("I+J&'*%&'(&+@%&<":*&E%",'*,&('E&+@%&CE'>;I+:'*&'(&)FaGLU,&$:+:9"+:'*&9;:>%&]**3&65J&.51^&:,&+'&:*($;%*I%&(;+;E%&
$%9"$&>%I:,:'*,&#R&CE'P:>:*9&"&E%,';EI%&('E&[;>9%,&W:*&'+@%E&[;E:,>:I+:'*,&Q@'&<"R&#%&I'*I%E*%>&"#';+&+@%:E&"#:$:+R&'E&
<"*>"+%&+'&">>E%,,&E:9@+T+'TQ"+%ET"*>T,"*:+"+:'*&:,,;%,3X&COHRE(c)J&#6@%$(*'+%&65J&"+&./73&
&&&&..-&Langford & Nolan,(#6@%$&*'+%&-/0J&"+&--3&&
&&&&...&48<(_"*9('E>&"*>&M'$"*&I:+%&L;E'C%"*&I",%&$"Q&'*&+'E+;E%&",&;,%>&+'&:*('E<&+@%&>%I:,:'*,&'(&+@%&)'<<:++%%&D9":*,+&
!'E+;E%&])D!^3&
&&&&..4&/6@%$(*'+%&-6?J&"+&-.03&
&
04&
",&>:P%E,%&",&N';+@&D(E:I"J&=*>:"&"*>&DE9%*+:*"&@"P%&,:9*:(:I"*+$R&:*($;%*I%>&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&
"#E'">3..0&!@%&#'EE'Q:*9&'(&('E%:9*&,+"*>"E>,&:,&'(+%*&:*,+:9"+%>&#R&+@%&[;>:I:"ERJ&#;+&
$:+:9"+'E,&<"R&#%&[;,+&",&:*,+E;<%*+"$&:*&,'<%&I",%,3..6 &&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<,J&+@%*J&E%$"+%&+'&*"+:'*"$&E:9@+,&,+E;99$%,&:*&"&,R<#:'+:I&Q"R3&
S:E,+J&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<&$%9:+:<"IR&,+E%*9+@%*,&+@%&C',:+:'*&'(&E:9@+,&@'$>%E,&:*&*"+:'*"$&
I';E+,3..1&D&[;>9%J&$:+:9"+'E&'E&,+"B%@'$>%E&<"R&*'Q&E%(%E&+'&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&
Q"+%E&E:9@+,&]:*I$;>:*9&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%^&:*&C%+:+:'*:*9&('E&*"+:'*"$&CE'+%I+:'*3&=*&+@%&
E%P%E,%J&+@%&Q:$$:*9*%,,&'(&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&+'&CE'+%I+&E:9@+,&+@E';9@&+@%&%*('EI%<%*+&'(&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,&#'+@&I$"E:(:%,&"*>&,+E%*9+@%*,&+@',%&,+"*>"E>,&('E&(;E+@%E&;,%&:*&
'+@%E&[;E:,>:I+:'*,3&!@%&Q"R&=*>:"*&I';E+,&@"P%&:*+%ECE%+%>&"*>&"CC$:%>&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&('E&
:*,+"*I%J&@",&#%%*&<:<:IB%>&#R&I';E+,&:*&A"B:,+"*&"*>&8"*9$">%,@3&S:*"$$RJ&:(&+@%&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>%(:*:+:'*&:,&>:,+'E+%>&'E&Q%"B%*%>J&E:9@+,&@'$>%E,&Q:$$&:*&+;E*&,;((%E&"&$',,&'(&
CE'+%I+:'*3&G:9@+,&">P'I"+%,&Q'EERJ&('E&:*,+"*I%J&+@"+&E%I%*+&N';+@&D(E:I"*&[;>9<%*+,&Q:$$&
,;#,+"*+:"$$R&Q%"B%*&(;E+@%E&%*('EI%<%*+&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&C"E+:I;$"E$R&E%9"E>:*9&+@%&
<:*:<;<&I'E%3&=(&+@:,&:,&+@%&I",%J&+@%&CE"I+:I"$&;*:P%E,"$:+R&'(&+@%&,+"*>"E>&<"R&#%&
I'<CE'<:,%>3&
&
B<(='"(E$:0*2$,(G2#'%02"-"2:(*3(!01':#($28($2(42:%*86&:0*2(:*(:'"(A$#"(C$H(
&
&
a;<"*&E:9@+,&+"B%&+Q'&('E<,&:*&*"+:'*"$&I'*+%`+,H&(:E,+&+@%R&I"*&#%&E%T%`CE%,,%>&",&
$"Q,&>:E%I+$R&%*,@E:*%>&:*&"&,+"+%U,&I'*,+:+;+:'*&'E&'+@%E&$%9:,$"+:P%&:*,+E;<%*+3&!@:,&I"*&
@"CC%*&:*&Q"R,&+@"+&:<C%E(%I+$R&:<:+"+%&'E&"$<',+&>:E%I+$R&E%IE%"+%&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
,+"*>"E>,&'*&Q@:I@&+@%R&"E%&#",%>3../&N%I'*>$RJ&,+"+%,&I"*&%*,@E:*%&@;<"*&E:9@+,&#R&
,:9*:*9&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&+E%"+:%,&+@%R&"E%&+@%*&#';*>&+'&:<C$%<%*+&>'<%,+:I"$$R&"*>&E%,C%I+&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&..0&L`"<C$%,&Q:$$&#%&%`C$'E%>&:*&>%+":$&#%$'Q3&
&&&&..6&_:+:9"+'E,&'(+%*&E%(%E%*I%&'+@%E&I';E+,&:*&+@%:E&"E9;<%*+,&'E&('E<;$"+%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$:+:9"+:'*&,+E"+%9:%,&Q:+@&+@%:E&
C"E+*%E,&"#E'">3(S'E&%`"<C$%.(+@%&V'E$>&N'I:"$&S'E;<&#%9"*&+'&@'$>&,%,,:'*,&'*&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&">P'I"IR&:*&.5563&/""&Juan
Miguel Picolotti, Center for Human Rights and Environment, The Right to Water in Argentina&4-T4.&].554^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3E:9@++'Q"+%E3:*('OC>(,O"E9%*+:*"h)N3C>(3&
&&&&..1&CliffordJ&#6@%$&*'+%&04J&"+&-.3&
&&&&../&A*-@$%"&Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, Act 108 of 1996&S%#3&0J&-??/J&"E+3&./]-^]#^&
]W%P%ER'*%&@",&+@%&%01':(:*b(#6330&0"2:(3**8($28(H$:"%bX^J&H0:'&Constitution of the Kingdom of Cambodia&N%C3&.-J&
-??4J&"E+3&6?&]We+f@%&N+"+%&,@"$$&CE'+%I+&+@%&%*P:E'*<%*+&"*>&#"$"*I%&'(&"#;*>"*+&*"+;E"$&E%,';EI%,&"*>&%,+"#$:,@&"&
CE%I:,%&@,$2(*3(-$2$1"-"2:('(&$"*>J&Q"+%EtX^&]%<C@",%,&">>%>^3&
&
00&
:*&+@%:E&%`+%E*"$&E%$"+:'*,3..7&N'<%&,+"+%,&>'&#'+@J&"*>&+@%&$%9"$&#",:,&'(&"&E:9@+&"E9;%>&:*&"&
*"+:'*"$&I';E+E''<&I"*&#%&c;:+%&I'<C$:I"+%>3&S'E+;*"+%$RJ&+@%&W:*+%ECE%+"+:P%&"++:+;>%X&'(&
+@%&I';E+&Q:+@&E%,C%I+&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:,&<'E%&:<C'E+"*+&+'&';E&Q'EB&:*&+@:,&,%I+:'*&+@"*&
+@%&*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&'E>%E&:+,%$(3&..?&=*&("I+J&Q%&Q:$$&*'+%&+@%&,:<:$"E:+R&'(&+@%&Q"R&>:P%E,%&
I';E+,&@"P%&]"^&"$$'Q%>&('E&+@%&$:+:9"+:'*&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&"*>&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&I",%,J&]#^&
E%I'9*:Z%>&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"CCE'"I@&"*>&]I^&%`C$:I:+$R&'E&:<C$:I:+$R&"CC$:%>&"&<:*:<;<&
I'E%&I"$I;$;,&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,t&"$$&8"#@0:"&$%9"$&>:((%E%*I%,3&!@%&$%9"$&'E>%E&Q:$$&'*$R&#%&
#E:%($R&%`C$":*%>&:*&%"I@&I",%&+'&>%<'*,+E"+%&I'*+%`+T,C%I:(:I&I'*,+E":*+,&'*&+@%&[;>:I:"ER&
'E&+'&@:9@$:9@+&+@%&+E"*,<:,,:'*&'(&[;>:I:"$&CE:*I:C$%,3&=)LN)G&E"+:(:I"+:'*&Y&+@%&I%*+E"$&$%9"$&
#",:,&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&Y&Q:$$&"$,'&#%&*'+%>J&",&,+"+%,TC"E+:%,&+'&+@:,&)'P%*"*+&"E%&+@%&
C"E+:%,&<',+&I$%"E$R&E%,C'*,:#$%&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&%*('EI%<%*+&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&
&
V@%*&I'<C"E%>&+'&'+@%E&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&[;E:,CE;>%*I%J&+@%&$:,+&'(&I",%,&
%`C$'E%>&#%$'Q&:,&E%$"+:P%$R&,@'E+3&!@:,&:,&#%I";,%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&E%<":*&WE%$"+:P%$R&Q%"B&",&
%*('EI%"#$%&$%9"$&I$":<,X&>;%&+'&#'+@&+@%:E&*'P%$+R&"*>&+@%:E&+%*>%*IR&+'&I'*($:I+&Q:+@&<'E%&
Q%$$T%,+"#$:,@%>&E:9@+,&]%393&CE'C%E+R^3.45 &!@%&%`C$:I:+&;,%&'(&"&W<:*:<;<&I'E%X&I'*I%C+&#R&"&
*"+:'*"$&I';E+&:,&%P%*&<'E%&E"E%3.4-&!@%&#'>R&'(&I",%&$"Q&W9:P:*9&I'*+%*+X&+'&+@%&@;<"*&
E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&@'Q%P%EJ&:,&9E'Q:*9&Y&#'+@&:*&:+,&E%I'9*:+:'*&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&CE:*I:C$%,&"*>&
,;CC'E+&'(&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&I'*I%C+3.4.&)",%,&(E'<&N';+@&D(E:I"J&=*>:"&"*>&DE9%*+:*"&"E%&
'(+%*&I:+%>&",&+@%&<',+&*'+"#$%&%`"<C$%,J&#;+&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&(E'<&<"*R&I';*+E:%,&I"*&#%&
"*"$RZ%>&('E&,;CC'E+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&'E&'*%&'E&<'E%&'(&:+,&B%R&%$%<%*+,3.44&&
&
K',+&[;E:,>:I+:'*,&@"P%&*%P%E(%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I%>&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&('E&+@%&E:9@+&+'&
Q"+%E3&)",%,&(E'<&+@%,%&I';E+,&Q:$$&#%&I'*,:>%E%>&(:E,+3&!@%&[;>9<%*+,&Q:$$&#%&"EE"*9%>&#R&
I';*+ER&"*>&#E:%($R&,;<<"E:Z%>&+'&>%<'*,+E"+%H&]"^&+@%&"CC$:I"+:'*&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&
CE:*I:C$%,&:*&,;CC'E+&'(&+@%&E:9@+U,&>%(:*:+:'*J&]#^&+@%&>%P%$'C<%*+&'(&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&..7&/""&1"2"%$,,7&_';:,&a%*B:*J&42:"%2$:0*2$,(S6-$2(!01':#($#(I!01':#M.(02&Nomos XXIII: Human Rights&.6/&]\3&G'Q$"*>&

A%**'IB&j&\'@*&V3&)@"C<"*&%>,3J&-?7-^&]CE'P:>:*9&#"IB9E';*>&",&+'&+@%&CE'I%,,&'(&+E%"+R&,:9*"+;E%&"*>&%*,@E:*%<%*+^3&
&&&&..?&!@%&*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&'E>%EJ&Q@:$%&'(&CE"I+:I"$&:<C'E+"*I%J&:,&'*$R&'*%&("I+'E&+'&+"B%&:*+'&I'*,:>%E"+:'*&@%E%3&!@%&
W:*+%ECE%+:P%&"++:+;>%X&'(&+@%&I';E+&Y&I"C"#$%&'(&,:>%T,+%CC:*9&[;E:,>:I+:'*"$&:,,;%,&:*&<"*R&C$"I%,&Y&@",&"&<'E%&,:9*:(:I"*+&
E'$%&+'&C$"R&:*&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3&/""(Langford & NolanJ&#6@%$&*'+%&-/0J&"+&--T-.3&
&&&&.45&M%$,'*J(#6@%$(*'+%&01J&"+&-4?3&
&&&&.4-&~';*9J&#6@%$&*'+%&-6?J&"+&-.03&
&&&&.4.&M'+%&+@%&>:((%E%*I%&#%+Q%%*&+@%&(:E,+&)FaGL&$:+:9"+:'*&9;:>%&I:+:*9&-5&Q"+%ETE%$"+%>&I",%,&"*>&+@%&('E+@I'<:*9&>E"(+&
Q@:I@&I:+%,&*%"E$R&/53&/""(#6@%$&*'+%,&.-4&"*>&65J&E%,C%I+:P%$R3&
&&&&.44&!@%&E%">%E&,@';$>&("<:$:"E:Z%&@:<O@%E,%$(&Q:+@&+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&:+,&<:*:<;<&I'E%&]#6@%$({&==J&
===J&+@:,&%,,"R^J&",&+@%&E%<":*>%E&'(&+@%&%,,"R&Q:$$&>%C%*>&'*&"&,+E'*9&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%,%&I'*I%C+,3&
&
06&
I'*I%C+&"*>&]I^&+@%&E%$"+:'*&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&:(&"*R3&!@%&C"E+:I;$"E&
Q"+%ETE%$"+%>&:,,;%,J&@:,+'E:I"$&>%P%$'C<%*+,&'E&C'$:+:I"$&E%"$:+:%,&,%%*&",&:*($;%*I:*9&+@%&
I';E+U,&>%I:,:'*,&Q:$$&#%&I'*,:>%E%>&Q@%E%&E%$%P"*+3.40&N%P%E"$&[;>9<%*+,&(E'<&N';+@&
D(E:I"&Q:$$&#%&9:P%*&,C%I:"$&"++%*+:'*&"+&+@%&%*>&'(&+@:,&,%I+:'*J&",&+@"+&I';*+ERU,&
I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&%*,@E:*%<%*+&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&"*>&%`C$:I:+&E%(%E%*I%&+'&"&<:*:<;<&
I'E%&('E&Q"+%E&$%*>&:+&,C%I:"$&CE'<:*%*I%3.46&&
&
A<(;(E*:"(*2(>":"%-02021($(/@"&030&(E6-+"%(*3(C0:"%#(3*%(:'"(9020-6-(A*%"&
&
&
&
D,&*'+%>&:*&N%I+:'*&===J&A"E+&8&'(&+@:,&%,,"RJ&+@%&"<';*+&'(&Q"+%E&E%c;:E%>&('E&+@%&
(;$(:$$<%*+&'(&#",:I&*%%>,&:,&9%*%E"$$R&>%+%E<:*"#$%3&=*&,%P%E"$&'(&+@%&I",%,&,;<<"E:Z%>&
#%$'QJ&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&E%c;:E%&+@%:E&E%,C%I+:P%&9'P%E*<%*+,&+'&CE'P:>%&"&,C%I:(:I&"<';*+&
'(&(E%%&Q"+%E&+'&+@',%&>:,C',,%,,%>&'(&+@%:E&E:9@+,&:*&%<%E9%*IR&,:+;"+:'*,3.41&!@:,&:,&I:+%>&
",&:<C$:I:+&,;CC'E+&('E&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"CCE'"I@&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&",&]"^&:+&>:,+:*9;:,@%,&
:<<%>:"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,&(E'<&+@%&<'E%&CE'9E%,,:P%&E%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+U,&(;$$&,I'C%&"*>&
]#^&"++%<C+,&+'&>%+%E<:*%&+@%&"<';*+&'(&Q"+%E&E%c;:E%>&('E&,;EP:P"$J&'(+%*&Q:+@&E%(%E%*I%&
+'&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,3.4/&!@%&;,%&'(&+@:,&C"E+:I;$"E&+''$&#R&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,J&@'Q%P%EJ&
,@';$>&*'+&#%&<:,;*>%E,+''>3&&
S:E,+J&c;"*+:+"+:P%&,+"*>"E>,&"E%&*'+&('E<;$"+%>&('E&>:E%I+&"CC$:I"+:'*3&G"+@%EJ&+@%R&
,@';$>&#%&I'*,:>%E%>&",&@%$C(;$&9;:>%$:*%,&('E&+@%&IE%"+:'*&'(&"CCE'CE:"+%J&I'*+%`+T,C%I:(:I&
,+"*>"E>,&+@"+&@%$C&,+"+%,&<%%+&;*:P%E,"$&$%9"$&'#$:9"+:'*,3.47&N%I'*>$RJ&Q@:$%&+@%&
>%+%E<:*"+:'*&'(&"&,C%I:(:I&+@E%,@'$>&:*&*"+:'*"$&I",%,&:,&'(+%*&%P:>%*I%&'(&+@%&:<C$:I:+&;,%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&&.40&2:((%E%*I%,&"*>&,:<:$"E:+:%,&:*&+@%&>%P%$'C<%*+TE%$"+%>&CE'#$%<,&("I%>&#R&+@%&I';*+E:%,&I:+%>&,'<%+:<%,&9'P%E*&
>:((%E%*I%,&"*>&,:<:$"E:+:%,&+@%&I",%&$"Q3&N%EP:I%&>:,I'**%I+:'*&I",%,J&('E&:*,+"*I%J&@"P%&$%>&+'&+@%&I$%"E%,+&CE'+%I+:'*&'E&
E%[%I+:'*&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&:*&>:P%E,%&[;E:,>:I+:'*,3&V:*B$%E&(:E,+&'#,%EP%>&+@:,&:*&@%E&C:%I%&'*&[;>:I:"$&%*('EI%<%*+&'(&
Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&/""(V:*B$%EJ&#6@%$&*'+%&41J("+&43&!@%&I",%&$"Q&,;<<"E:Z%>&#R&+@:,&%,,"RJ&@'Q%P%EJ&:,&I'*,:>%E"#$R&<'E%&
I'<CE%@%*,:P%3&(
&&&&.46&V@:$%&"&('I;,&'*&N';+@&D(E:I"*&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&:,&I'<<'*&:*&"I">%<:I&$:+%E"+;E%J&,;I@&"*&"CCE'"I@&$:<:+,&"*&
;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%&02:"%2$:0*2$,(,+"+;,&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&"*>&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&:(&:+&:9*'E%,&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&
(E'<&'+@%E&[;E:,>:I+:'*,3&/""(Litigating Economic, Social and Cultural Rights: Achievements, Challenges and
Strategies(]K"$I'$<&_"*9('E>J&%>3J&.554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3I'@E%3'E9O,:+%,O>%(";$+O(:$%,O$:+:9"+:*9h%,IhE:9@+,hT
h"I@:%P%<%*+hI@"$$%*9%,h"*>h,+E"+%9:%,h.5543C>(3&]N';+@&D(E:I"&:,&'(+%*&,%%*&",&"&W$:+<;,&+%,+3&&3&3&e#;+f&+@:,&P:%Q&
'#P:';,$R&:9*'E%,&>%I">%,&'(&$:+:9"+:'*&:*&'+@%E&[;E:,>:I+:'*,3X^3&
&&&&.41&/"".("<1<.(I",%&$"Q&(E'<&8%$9:;<J&=*>:"J&DE9%*+:*"&"*>&N';+@&D(E:I"J&023%$.({&=s3&
&&&&.4/&F(&I';E,%J&:<C$:I:+&,;CC'E+&('E&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&$"IB,&+@%&>%+%E<:*"IR&'(&"*&%`C$:I:+&"II%C+"*I%&"*>&:,&$%,,&@%$C(;$&
:*&%,+"#$:,@:*9&I'*IE%+%&$%9"$&E%,C'*,:#:$:+R3&
&&&&.47&!@:,&9'%,&('E&"*R&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>%P%$'C<%*+&,+"*>"E>J&:*I$;>:*9&%393J&+@%&K:$$%**:;<&2%P%$'C<%*+&d'"$,3&!@%&
K:$$%**:;<&2%I$"E"+:'*J&#6@%$&*'+%&163&
&
01&
'(&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&I"$I;$;,J&+@%&3$0,6%"&'(&"&I';E+&+'&>'&,'&I"**'+&#%&+"B%*&:+,%$(&",&%"a"&:0*2&
'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"CCE'"I@3&V:+@:*&:*&+@%&"I">%<RJ&I%E+":*&";+@'E,&:*,:,+&+@"+&"&I';E+U,&
(":$;E%&+'&,%+&"&,C%I:(:I&,+"*>"E>&:,&%P:>%*I%&+@"+&+@%&I';E+&@",&E%[%I+%>&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%J&
'E&:,&CE''(&'(&+@"+&,+"*>"E>U,&W"E#:+E"E:*%,,X&:*&I'*+%`+;"$:Z"+:'*3.4?&!'&[;>9%&"&I';E+U,&
:*+%*+:'*&(E'<&+@:,&"I+:'*&"$'*%&Q';$>&#%&,@'E+,:9@+%>J&@'Q%P%EJ&",&*%:+@%E&+@%&(E%%&
CE'P:,:'*&'(&Q"+%E&*'E&+@%&,C%I:(:I"+:'*&'(&"&C"E+:I;$"E&"<';*+&'(&Q"+%E&"E%&E%c;:E%>&#R&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&!'&,"R&+@"+&+@%&(":$;E%&+'&,%+&"&+@E%,@'$>&"<';*+,&+'&"&E%[%I+:'*&'(&+@%&
<:*:<;<&I'E%&I'*(;,%,&+@%&"II%C+"*I%&'(&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&]"*>&:+,&<:*:<;<&I'E%^&Q:+@&+@%&
I@':I%&'(&C'$:I:%,&+'&",,:,+&:*&:+,&(;$$&E%"$:Z"+:'*3&!@%&$"++%E&"E%&"CCE'CE:"+%$R&>%+%E<:*%>&#R&
+@%&$%9:,$"+;E%&"*>&%`%I;+:P%J&,'&$'*9&",&+@%&%,,%*+:"$&<:*:<;<&'(&+@%&E:9@+&:,&(;$(:$$%>&"*>&
:+,&(;$$&,I'C%&CE'9E%,,:P%$R&E%"$:Z%>&+'&+@%&%`+%*+&C',,:#$%3&=*&,'<%&I'*+%`+,&+@:,&<"R&Q%$$&
E%c;:E%&+@%&(;$$J&(E%%&CE'P:,:'*&'(&"&,C%I:(:I&"<';*+&'(&Q"+%E3&=*&'+@%E,J&@'Q%P%EJ&:+&<"R&*'+3&
&
><(!"?0"H(*3(E$:0*2$,(A$#"(C$H(
&
LbGFAL&
-3&8%$9:;<&
&
&
V%&#%9:*&';E&:*P%,+:9"+:'*&'(&+@%&I",%&$"Q&,;CC'E+:*9&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&:+,&
<:*:<;<&I'E%&Q:+@&"&,:*9$%&[;>9<%*+&(E'<&8%$9:;<3&8%I";,%&'(&+@%&@:9@&$%P%$&'(&
>%P%$'C<%*+&'(&#'+@&+@%&Q"+%E&,R,+%<.05&"*>&+@%&E%9:'*"$&<%I@"*:,<,&('E&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&
'(&@;<"*&E:9@+,J.0-&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&I",%,&"E%&E"E%&:*&+@%&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&'(&L;E'C%3&DC"E+&(E'<&
$:<:+%>&I",%&$"Q&:*&#'+@&=E%$"*>.0.&"*>&SE"*I%.04&%*,@E:*:*9&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&",&"*&%,,%*+:"$&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.4?&/""(1"2"%$,,7(~';*9J(#6@%$&*'+%&-6?3&/""($,#*&8$;%<%$J(#6@%$(*'+%&6J&"+&?76&]"E9;:*9&+@"+&+@%&,+"*>"E>&,%+&:*&+@%&
9"2*%"#&I",%&]DE9%*+:*"^&:,&*'+&#",%>&'*&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&",&+@%&*;<%E:I"$&,+"*>"E>&,%+&#R&+@%&I';E+&>:((%E,&(E'<&
+@%&VaF&,+"*>"E>&,%+&:*&a'Q"E>&"*>&8"E+E"<^3&/""(Howard & Bartram, #6@%$&*'+%&-.?J&"+&4g&9"2*%"#(I",%J&023%$&*'+%&
46?3&
&&&&.05&!@%&.551&a;<"*&2%P%$'C<%*+&E%C'E+&'*$R&E%I'9*:Z%,&+Q'&I';*+E:%,&:*&+@%&L;E'C%"*&E%9:'*&",&W>%P%$'C:*9X&Y&
)RCE;,&"*>&!;EB%R3&F+@%E&I';*+E:%,&"E%&>%+%E<:*%>&+'&#%&W>%P%$'C%>X&#",%>&02:"%($,0$&:*&+@%:E&a2=&]a;<"*&2%P%$'C<%*+&
=*>%`^J&"&I'<C',:+%&*;<#%E&Q@:I@&,%EP%,&",&%P:>%*I%&'(&Q"+%E&:*(E",+E;I+;E%&>%P%$'C<%*+&",&+@:,&:,&,%%*&",&:*+%9E"$&+'&"&
,+E'*9&$:(%T%`C%I+"*IR3&/""&Report 2006, #6@%$&*'+%&1J&"+&0-13&
&&&&.0-&!@%&L;E'C%"*&a;<"*&G:9@+,&,R,+%<&:,&'(+%*&I:+%>&",&+@%&Q'E$>U,&<',+&%((%I+:P%3&/""("<1<.(Steiner et al3J&#6@%$(*'+%&
-7J&"+&{&--]DT8^3(
&&&&.0.&GR"*&P3&D++UR&d%*3J&e-?16f&=3G3&.?0&]=E3^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&COHRE(c), #6@%$&*'+%&65J&<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.75&]Q@:I@&
I'*+":*,&"&<:*:<"$$R&>%P%$'C%>&E%I'9*:+:'*&'(&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E^3&
&
0/&
%$%<%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%J&+@%&8%$9:"*&CE%I%>%*+&:,&+@%&<',+&:<C'E+"*+&L;E'C%"*&Q"+%E&
E:9@+,&I",%&,:*I%&+@%&>%P%$'C<%*+&'(&@;<"*&E:9@+,&"*>&+@%&'*$R&L;E'C%"*&CE%I%>%*+&
:*I$;>%>&@%E%3.00&
&
=*&\;>9<%*+&M'3&41&'(&-??7J&+@%&8%$9:"*&)';E+&'(&DE#:+E"+:'*&]CE%>%I%,,'E&+'&+@%&
<'>%E*&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+^&"IB*'Q$%>9%>&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&'(&"&,C%I:(:I&<:*:<;<&
c;"*+:+R&,;CC'E+%>&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&"*>&CE'+%I+%>&#R&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*3&.06&&!@%&)';E+&
E%P'B%>&+@%&"CC$:I"+:'*&'(&+@%&K;*:I:C"$:+R&'(&V%<<%$J&Q@:I@&I'*+%,+%>&+@%&
I'*,+:+;+:'*"$:+R&'(&+@%&_"Q&d'P%E*:*9&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&]-?44^.01 &",&
:*+%E(%E:*9&Q:+@&+@%&<;*:I:C"$:+RU,&I'<C%+%*I%&:*&>%+%E<:*:*9&Q"+%E&CE:I%3.0/&!@"+&$"QJ&",&
"<%*>%>&#R&+@%&S$%<:,@&)';*I:$&:*&-??1J&E%c;:E%>&+@%&CE'P:,:'*&'(&-6&I;#:I&<%+%E,&'(&(E%%&
+"C&Q"+%E&"&R%"E&+'&%P%ER&C%E,'*&:*&"&@';,%@'$>&'*&+@%&C;#$:I&9E:>3.07&
!@%&)';E+&'(&DE#:+E"+:'*&(';*>&+@%&$"Q&+'&#%&Q:+@:*&+@%&%`%I;+:P%&I'<C%+%*I%&'(&+@%&
E%9:'*"$&9'P%E*<%*+3&=*&:+,&[;>9<%*+&+@%&)';E+&*'+%>&+@"+&+@%&$"Q&CE'+%I+%>&+@%&:*>:P:>;"$&
E:9@+&+'&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&"II%,,&",&>%E:P%>&(E'<&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+&+'&"&$:(%&:*&>:9*:+R.0?&
"*>&",&:*('E<%>&#R&+@%&,+"*>"E>&:*&D9%*>"&.-J.65&*'+:*9&+@"+&Q"+%E&,;CC$R&:,&"&<'E%&
3628$-"2:$,&@;<"*&*%%>&+@"*&'+@%E&C;#$:I&,%EP:I%,3.6-&!@%&"CC$:I"+:'*&'(&"*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
,+"*>"E>&Y&%,C%I:"$$R&"&*'*T#:*>:*9&>%I$"E"+:'*&Y&:,&*'+"#$%&('E&:+,&%"E$R&,;CC'E+&'(&+@%&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*,%*,;,&,;EE';*>:*9&+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&D$+@';9@&8%$9:;<&@">&
E"+:(:%>&+@%&=)LN)G&:*&-?74J&+@%&)';E+&>:>&*'+&I:+%&+@:,&$%9"$&,';EI%&",&:+&@">&*'+&R%+&#%%*&
@%$>&#R&+@%&)LN)G&+'&:*I$;>%&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3.6. &
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.04&!E:#;*"$&>%&9E"*>%&:*,+"*I%&e!d=f&e'E>:*"ER&I';E+&'(&'E:9:*"$&[;E:,>:I+:'*f&DP:9*'*J&K"R&-.J&-??6J&*3&-0?.O?6&]SE3^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3I"I%3(EO[;E:,CE;>%*I%OE%+,O%";CE%,,:'*O+9:-.56-??63@+<$&]"&>:,I'**%I+:'*&I",%&*'+:*9&+@"+&+@%&
$"IB&'(&Q"+%E&:,&"*&W:<C'E+"*+&:<C%>:<%*+&"*>&@%"$+@&E:,BX&#;+&(":$:*9&+'&E%I'9*:Z%&"&E:9@+^3(
&&&&.00&S'E&"&,;<<"ER&'(&+@%&$%9"$&(E"<%Q'EB&CE'+%I+:*9&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:*&8%$9:;<J&:*I$;>:*9&E%$%P"*+&I",%&$"QJ&,%%(
)@:"E"&D<"*:J&='"(!01':(:*(D$:"%(02(B",106-J&International Environmental Law Research Centre Briefing Paper&
].557^J&@++CHOOQQQ3:%$EI3'E9OI'*+%*+O(575.3C>(3&
&&&&.06&A*6%:(8L;%+0:%$1"&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+f&"EE}+&*'&41O-??7J&DCE3&-J&-??7J&Moniteur Belge&eK8f&eF((:I:"$&d"Z%++%&'(&
8%$9:;<fJ&DCE3&.0J&-??7&]8%$93^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Cohre(c), "+&.?13&
&&&&.01&;#($-"28"8(+7&2pIE%+&>%&$"&)'<<;*";+p&S$"<"*>%&I'*I%E*"*+&>:P%E,%,&<%,;E%,&>U"II'<C"9*%<%*+&>;&#;>9%+&
-??/&e2%IE%%&'(&+@%&S$%<:,@&)'<<;*:+R&G%$"+:*9&+'&s"E:';,&K%",;E%,&DII'<C"*R:*9&+@%&8;>9%+&'(&-??/f&'(&2%I3&.5J&
-??1J&Monitieur Belge&eK383f&eF((:I:"$&d"Z%++%&'(&8%$9:;<f&2%I3&4-J&-??1J&"E+3&43-3&
&&&&.0/&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+J&"EE}+&*'&41O-??7J&DCE3&-J&-??7J&q8303.J&"+&-43(
&&&&.07&2%IE%%&'(&+@%&S$%<:,@&)'<<;*:+R&G%$"+:*9&+'&s"E:';,&K%",;E%,&DII'<C"*R:*9&+@%&8;>9%+&'(&-??/J&"E+3&40&]8%$93^3&
&&&&.0?&!@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*&%*,@E:*%,&%I'*'<:I&,'I:"$&"*>&I;$+;E"$&E:9@+,&Q:+@&+@%&$"*9;"9%H&WD&I%++%&(:*J&$"&$':J&$%&>pIE%+&';&$"&
Ey9$%&P:,p%&r&$x"E+:I$%&-40&9"E"*+:,,%*+J&%*&+%*"*+&I'<C+%&>%,&'#$:9"+:'*,&I'EE%,C'*>"*+%,J&$%,&>E':+,&pI'*'<:c;%,J&,'I:";`&
%+&I;$+;E%$,J&%+&>p+%E<:*%*+&$%,&I'*>:+:'*,&>%&$%;E&%`%EI:I%3X Constitution Coordonn&S%#3&-/J&-??0J&"E+3&.4&]8%$93^3&
&&&&.65&/""(#6@%$&{&==&A"E+&DJ&+@:,&%,,"R3&
&&&&.6-&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+J&"EE}+&*'&41O-??7J&DCE3&-J&-??7J&q8313.3&
&&&&.6.&!@:,&%Ì;,%&:,&%",:$R&]"*>&'(+%*&I'EE%I+$R^&#'EE'Q%>&:*&'+@%E&*"+:'*"$&I'*+%`+,3&=+&:,&:<C'E+"*+&+'&*'+%&+@"+&d%*%E"$&
)'<<%*+&-6&Q",&*'+&E%$%",%>&;*+:$&.55.J&"*>&%P%*&+@%*&:+,&:>%",&+''B&+:<%&+'&(;$$R&>:,,%<:*"+%3&
&
07&
!@%&)';E+U,&,+:C;$"+:'*&+@"+&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:*I$;>%&"&>%(:*"#$%&<:*:<;<&"<';*+&
'(&Q"+%E&+'&#%&CE'P:>%>&(E%%&'(&I@"E9%&I"*&#%&,%%*&",&:<C$:I:+&,;CC'E+&('E&+@%&E:9@+U,&
<:*:<;<&I'E%J&%,C%I:"$$R&Q@%*&'*%&I'*,:>%E,&+@%&:*+%*+&'(&+@%&$"Q&;C@%$>3&=*&:+,&-??1&
>%I$"E"+:'*J&+@%&S$%<:,@&)';*I:$&E%I'9*:Z%>&+@"+&W%P%ER&I;,+'<%E&:,&%*+:+$%>&+'&"&#",:I&
;*:*+%EE;C+%>&,;CC$R&'(t&Q"+%E&('E&@';,%@'$>&C;EC',%,&:*&'E>%E&+'&#%&"#$%&+'&$:P%&>%I%*+$R&
"II'E>:*9&+'&CE%P":$:*9&$:P:*9&,+"*>"E>,3X.64&!@%&,+:C;$"+:'*&'(&-6&I;#:I&<%+%E,&C%E&R%"E&
Q",&"&<:*:<;<&%*+:+$%<%*+&"$$'++%>&+'&0280?086$,#&"*>&#",%>&:*&+@%&VaF&9;:>%$:*%,&I:+%>&
#R&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6&,:`&R%"E,&$"+%E3.60&D$+@';9@&+@%&"$$'+<%*+&'(&Q"+%E&('E&"&W>%I%*+X&
$:(%&:,&#E'">%E&+@"*&+@%&Q"+%E&E%c;:E%>&('E&,;EP:P"$J&+@%&)';*I:$U,&E;$%&,+:$$&CE'+%I+%>&"*&
$-*62:&'(&Q"+%E&+@"+&("$$,&Q:+@:*&+@%&W#",:I&*%%>,X&9;:>%$:*%3.66&!@%&[;>9<%*+&+@%E%('E%&
:<C$:I:+$R&,;CC'E+%>&+@%&:>%"&'(&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&('E&Q"+%E&%P%*&#%('E%&+@%&)LN)G&@">&
"CC$:%>&:+&:*&,;I@&"&Q"R3&&
&&
DN=D&
.3&=*>:"&
&
&
V%&*%`+&+;E*&+'&=*>:"J&Q@%E%&,'<%&[;>:I:"$&IE%"+:P:+R&@",&"$$'Q%>&('E&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&
'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&"9":*&Q:+@&:<C$:I:+&E%(%E%*I%&+'&+@"+&E:9@+U,&<:*:<;<&I'E%3&!@%&$"E9%,+&
Q"+%ETE%$"+%>&I'*I%E*,&:*&=*>:"&"E%&C'$$;+:'*&"*>&'P%ET%`+E"I+:'*3&D&.554&,+;>R&#R&+@%&
=*>:"*&9'P%E*<%*+&(';*>&+@"+&$%,,&+@"*&46m&'(&Q",+%Q"+%E&(E'<&+@%&I';*+ERU,&(';E&$"E9%,+&
I:+:%,&Q",&+E%"+%>&#%('E%&E%+;E*:*9&+'&+@%&9E';*>3.61&AE:P"+%&I'EC'E"+:'*,&@"P%&"&$"E9%&E'$%&
+'&C$"R&:*&+@%&>%9E">"+:'*&'(&I'<<;*"$&E%,';EI%,J&"*>&+@%:E&"I+:'*,&@"P%&$%>&+'&+@%&
$:+:9"+:'*&'(&*;<%E';,&I",%,&"9":*,+&CE:P"+%&:*+%E%,+,3.6/&=*>:"U,&;*:c;%&$%9"$&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&
,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&#%"E,&,'<%&I'*,:>%E"+:'*&#%('E%&CE'I%%>:*9&Q:+@&+@%,%&I",%,3&&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.64&2%IE%%&'(&+@%&S$%<:,@&)'<<;*:+R&G%$"+:*9&+'&s"E:';,&K%",;E%,&DII'<C"*R:*9&+@%&8;>9%+&'(&-??/J&"E+3&43-&]8%$93^33&
&&&&.60&d)-6&#6@%$&*'+%&44J&"+&q-.3&&
&&&&.66&-6&I;#:I&<OCOR&:,&"CCE'`:<"+%$R&0-&$OCO>J&Q%$$&Q:+@:*&+@%&46T65&$OCO>&E"*9%&*'+%>&"#'P%J&#6@%$&{&==J&A"E+&83&
&&&&.61&D$:"%(`0"H#R(4280$.&Circle of Blue&]D;93&-7J&.55?^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3I:EI$%'(#$;%3'E9OQ"+%E*%Q,O.55?OQ'E$>OQ"+%EP:%Q,T:*>:"O3&&
&&&&.6/&N%%&GorsbothJ&#6@%$&*'+%&.4J&"+&-4T-0g&FoodFirst Information and Action Network, Investigating Some
Alleged Violations of the Human Right to Water in India: Report of the International Fact Finding Mission
to India&]N"#:*%&A"#,+&%+&"$3&%>,3J&.550^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3E":*Q"+%EI$;#3'E9O>'I,OE%C'E+hB'<C$%++3C>(3&
&
0?&
N:*I%&:+,&"II%,,:'*&+'&+@%&=)LN)G&:*&-?/?J&=*>:"&@",&#%%*&I@",+:,%>&#R&+@%&)LN)G&('E&
*'+&9:P:*9&(;$$&$%9"$&%((%I+&+'&)'P%*"*+&CE'P:,:'*,&:*&>'<%,+:I&$"Q3.67&V@%*&",,%E+:*9&"&E:9@+&
+'&Q"+%EJ&=*>:"*,&<;,+&E%$R&'*&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+,&"$<',+&%Ì$;,:P%$R3&!@%&'*$R&,'I:'T
%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&%*,@E:*%>&#R&+@%&=*>:"*&)'*,+:+;+:'*&('E<&C"E+&'(&+@%&2:E%I+:P%&AE:*I:C$%,&
'(&N+"+%&A'$:IR&]2ANA^.6?&Q@:I@&DE+:I$%&4/&E%,+E:I+,&Q:+@&+@%&$"*9;"9%H&W,@"$$&*'+&#%&
%*('EI%"#$%&#R&"*R&I';E+J&#;+&+@%&CE:*I:C$%,&+@%E%:*&$":>&>'Q*&"E%&*%P%E+@%$%,,&
(;*>"<%*+"$&:*&+@%&9'P%E*"*I%&'(&+@%&I';*+ER&"*>&:+&,@"$$&#%&+@%&>;+R&'(&+@%&,+"+%&+'&"CC$R&
+@%,%&CE:*I:C$%,&:*&<"B:*9&$"Q,3X.15&!@%&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&'(&=*>:"J&@'Q%P%EJ&@"P%&IE%"+:P%$R&
"P':>%>&+@%&[;,+:I:"#:$:+R&E%,+E:I+:'*,&'*&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3&8'+@&+@%&N;CE%<%&"*>&a:9@&
)';E+,&'(&=*>:"&@"P%&CE'*';*I%>&W,'C@:,+:I"+%>X&[;>9<%*+,&#;:$+&'*&+@%&[;,+:I:"#$%&E:9@+&+'&
$:(%J.1-&%*"#$:*9&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&]:*+%E&"$:"^&+@%&E:9@+&+'&"&@%"$+@R&%*P:E'*<%*+&"*>&"&E:9@+&
+'&Q"+%E3.1.&&
&
!@%,%&[;>9<%*+,&Q%E%&<">%&C',,:#$%&+@E';9@&+@%&;,%&'(&C;#$:I&:*+%E%,+&$:+:9"+:'*H&
+@%&"II%C+"*I%&'(&"&C%+:+:'*&(E'<&"*R&:*>:P:>;"$J&%P%*&:(&*'+&>:E%I+$R&"&P:I+:<J&E%$"+:*9&+'&+@%&
P:'$"+:'*&'(&"&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+3.14&!@%&CE"I+:I%&'(&A;#$:I&=*+%E%,+&_:+:9"+:'*&Q",&
>%P%$'C%>&#R&+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&",&"&E%,C'*,%&+'&+@%&"+E'I:+:%,&I'<<:++%>&>;E:*9&+@%&
:*+%E*"$&%<%E9%*IR&'(&+@%&$"+%&-?/5,3.10&=*>:"*&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&,+%<<:*9&(E'<&C;#$:I&
:*+%E%,+&$:+:9"+:'*&CE'+%I+,&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&@",&*'+"#$R&">'C+%>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,&
:*&:+,&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&'(&+@"+&E:9@+U,&I'*+%*+J&>%,C:+%&+@%&(":$;E%&'(&+@%&A"E$:"<%*+&+'&9E"*+&+@%&
=)LN)G&"&$%9"$&I@"E"I+%E3&=*>:"*&I",%&$"QJ&+@';9@&*'+&%`C$:I:+$R&<%*+:'*:*9&"&W<:*:<;<&
I'E%X&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&@",&"$,'&E%(%EE%>&+'&W<:*:<;<&'#$:9"+:'*,X&('E&'+@%E&,'I:'&%I'*'<:I&
E:9@+,&I'*,+E;%>&:*&"&,:<:$"E&Q"R3&&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.67&)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&)'*I$;>:*9&F#,%EP"+:'*,&'(&+@%&)'<<:++%%&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&=*>:"J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.O=M2O)FO6J&q7T-5&]D;93&7J&.557^J&"+&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@IE3'E9OE%(Q'E$>O>'I:>O07##>"I0.3@+<$3&
&&&&.6?&India Const.&"E+3&41T653&
&&&&.15&48<&"+&"E+3&4/3&
&&&&.1-&48<&"+&"E+3&.-3&&
&&&&.1.&V:*B$%E&I:+%,&,%P%E"$&,';EI%,&",&:*('E<"+:P%&'*&=*>:"*&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&$:+:9"+:'*3&/""("<1.&G3&A"+@"BJ&)6+,0&(42:"%"#:(
C0:01$:0*2(02(4280$.&02&Democracy, Human Rights and the Rule of Law, Essays in Honour of Nani Palkhivala&-.6&
]s%*B"+&=R%E&%>3J&.555^3*
&&&&.14&LitigatingJ&#6@%$&*'+%&.46J&"+&453&
&&&&.10&48<(/""($,#*([6#:0&0$+0,0:7(*3(G/A(!01':#R(='"(4280$2(GT@"%0"2&"J&02&Circle of Rights: Economic, Social and
Cultural Rights Activism, a Training Resource&]N;*:$"&D#%R%,%B%E"&%+&"$3J&.555^J&
@++CHOOQQQ-3;<*3%>;O@;<"*E+,O%>;<"+O=aG=AOI:EI$%O[;,+:I:"#:$:+R3@+<&]W!@%&:*+%E*"$&%<%E9%*IR&+@"+&Q",&:*&('EI%&
#%+Q%%*&-?/6&"*>&-?//&"*>&:+,&"(+%E<"+@&I'*+E:#;+%>&,:9*:(:I"*+$R&+'&+@%&I@"*9%&:*&+@%&[;>:I:"ERU,&C%EI%C+:'*&'(&:+,&E'$%&
:*&+@%&Q'EB:*9&'(&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*3X^3*
&
65&
&
!@%&U628$-"2:$,(!01':#(I",%&IE%"+%>&+@%&CE%I%>%*+&('E&+@%&[;,+:I:"#:$:+R&'(&,'I:'T
%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&]2ANA^&+@E';9@&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%3&.16&=*&+@"+&I",%J&+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&@%$>&
+@"+&Q@"+&Q",&I'*,:>%E%>&W(;*>"<%*+"$X&+'&+@%&9'P%E*"*I%&'(&+@%&I';*+ER&]",&%*;<%E"+%>&
:*&+@%&2ANA^&I';$>&*'+&#%&,%%*&",&$%,,&,:9*:(:I"*+&+@"*&Q@"+&:,&W(;*>"<%*+"$X&+'&+@%&$:(%&'(&
+@%&:*>:P:>;"$3&S;*>"<%*+"$&E:9@+,&"*>&2ANAJ&+@%*J&Q%E%&I'*,:>%E%>&I'<C$%<%*+"ERJ&
W*%:+@%E&C"E+&#%:*9&,;C%E:'E&+'&+@%&'+@%E3X.11&!@:,&>%I:,:'*&$%>&+'&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&,'I:'T
%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&",&(;*>"<%*+"$&%*+:+$%<%*+,&;*>%E&DE+:I$%&.-J&"&CE"I+:I%&+@"+&Q",&>%(:*%>&
"*>&%`C"*>%>&#R&"&,%E:%,&'(&N;CE%<%&)';E+&I",%,&#%9:**:*9&:*&-?7-3.1/&
=*&+@%&I",%&'(&U%$2&0#(A*%$,0"(96,,02(?<(='"(;8-020#:%$:*%.(\20*2(="%%0:*%7(*3(>",'0J&.17&
+@%&)';E+&@%$>&+@"+&>%+":*%%,&%*['R&"$$&(;*>"<%*+"$&E:9@+,&"C"E+&(E'<&+@',%&>;$R&E%,+E:I+%>&
#R&:<CE:,'*<%*+3&D<'*9&+@%,%&:,&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%J&Q@:I@&+@%&)';E+&:*+%ECE%+%>&",&:*I$;>:*9&
W+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:P%&Q:+@&@;<"*&>:9*:+R&"*>&%P%ER+@:*9&+@"+&9'%,&"$'*9&Q:+@&:+J&*"<%$R&+@%&
#",:I&*%I%,,:+:%,&'(&$:(%3X.1?&=*&U<g<(S6##$02(?<(\20*2(*3(4280$.PYX&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&'(&i%E"$"&
#%9"*&>%+":$:*9&+@%,%&W#",:I&*%I%,,:+:%,JX&*'+:*9&+@"+&$:(%&W:,&<;I@&<'E%&+@"*&+@%&E:9@+&+'&
"*:<"$&%`:,+%*I%3&3&3&3&!@%&E:9@+&+'&,Q%%+&Q"+%EJ&"*>&+@%&E:9@+&+'&(E%%&":EJ&"E%&"++E:#;+%,&'(&+@%&
E:9@+&+'&$:(%&3&3&3&#",:I&%$%<%*+,&Q@:I@&,;,+":*&$:(%&:+,%$(3X./-&!@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&c;:IB$R&
('$$'Q%>&,;:+&:*&/6+'$#'(g6-$%(?<(/:$:"(*3(B0'$%(+@%&('$$'Q:*9&R%"E3(./.&!@%&,;#<:,,:'*&'(&
+@:,&C;#$:I&:*+%E%,+&$:+:9"+:'*&+'&(:9@+&I'EC'E"+%&C'$$;+:'*&]+@';9@&%P%*+;"$$R&>:,<:,,%>^J&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.16&i%E"$"&P3&M3&K3&!@'<",&]U628$-"2:$,(!01':#^J&]-?/1^&].^&N3)3)3&4-5&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3E:,@"#@>"E"3I'<O,IOP:%Q3C@CnI",%o674-3&
&&&&.11&48<&"+&q&-40J&C3&41/3&
&&&&.1/&!@%&"CCE'"I@&'(&+@%&)';E+&:*&CE'+%I+:*9&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&+@E';9@&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&,@';$>&#%&>:,+:*9;:,@%>&(E'<&
+@%&"CCE'"I@&:*&N%I+:'*&==&8"302021&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&",&>%E:P"+:P%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&](E'<&=))AG&"E+31^3&!@%&=*>:"*&*"+:'*"$&
I';E+,&"E%&(;*I+:'*"$$R&E%,+E:I+%>&:*&+@%:E&"#:$:+R&+'&E%I'9*:Z%&:*>%C%*>%*+&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,J&"$+@';9@&+@%&\;>9<%*+&
:*&+@%&U628$-"2:$,(!01':#(A$#"&"*>&,;#,%c;%*+&I",%,&,%%<&+'&:*>:I"+%&+@"+&+@%&I';E+,&#%$:%P%&+@"+&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&
8*&%`:,+&:*>%C%*>%*+$R&'(&I:P:$&"*>&C'$:+:I"$&E:9@+,&]W*%:+@%E&C"E+&#%:*9&,;C%E:'E&+'&+@%&'+@%EX^J&"$+@';9@&+@%R&E%c;:E%&
CE'+%I+:'*&+@E';9@&"E9;<%*+,&'(&3628$-"2:$,0:7&+:%>&+'&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%3&!@:,&E%"$:+R&Q:+@:*&+@%&=*>:"*&$%9"$&,R,+%<&>'%,&
*'+&I@"$$%*9%&+@%&",,%E+:'*&:*&N%I+:'*&==&+@"+&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&"E%&<',+&"CCE'CE:"+%$R&I'*,+E;I+%>&",&"&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&
%*+:+$%<%*+&,+%<<:*9&(E'<&+@%&=)LN)G3&
&&&&.17&SE"*I:,&)'E"$:%&K;$$:*&P3&b*:'*&!%EE:+'ER&'(&2%$@:J(]-?7-^&.&N3)3G3&6-1&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3:*>:"*B"*''*3'E9O>'IO/7641O3&
&&&&.1?&48<&"+&q13&
&&&&./5&S3i3&a;,,":*&P3&b*:'*&'(&=*>:"&]-??5^&D3=3G3&]i%E3^&4.-J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.0?/3&!@%&[;>9<%*+&
#R&\3&N"*B"E"*&M":E&:,&:>%*+:I"$&+'&@:,&[;>9<%*+&:*&+@%&E%$"+%>&I",%&D++"B'R"&!@"*9"$&P3&b*:'*&'(&=*>:"&V3A3&:*&+@%&,"<%&
)';E+&[;,+&'*%&<'*+@&#%('E%3&8'+@&"E%&I:+%>&:*+%EI@"*9%"#$RJ&+@';9@&+@%&a;,,":*&>%I:,:'*&:,&:*I$;>%>&#R&)FaGL&:*&+@%:E&
$:+:9"+:'*&9;:>%3&/""(Cohre(b), *'+%&.-4&"+&--13(
&&&&./-&48<&"+&q/3&&
&&&&./.&N;#@",@&i;<"E&P3&N+"+%&'(&8:@"EJ&]-??-^&D3=3G&0.5&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3:%$EI3'E9OI'*+%*+O%?-573C>(3&
&
6-&
"$$'Q%>&+@%&)';E+&+'&>%I$"E%&+@"+&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&W:*I$;>%,&+@%&E:9@+&'(&%*['R<%*+&'(&
C'$$;+:'*&(E%%&Q"+%E&"*>&":E&('E&(;$$&%*['R<%*+&'(&$:(%3X./4&&
=*&-??1J&+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&C$"I%>&Q@"+&Q%E%&CE%P:';,$R&P"9;%&E%(%E%*I%,&+'&Q"+%E&
"*>&":E&Q:+@:*&+@%&(E"<%Q'EB&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3&=*&A'$-",0(/021'(?<(/:$:"(*3(\::$%(
)%$8"#'.PYe&+@%&)';E+&@%$>&+@"+&We+@%f&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&9;"E"*+%%>&#R&"*R&I:P:$:Z%>&,'I:%+R&:<C$:%,&
+@%&E:9@+&+'&(''>J&Q"+%EJ&,@%$+%EJ&>%I%*+&%*P:E'*<%*+J&%>;I"+:'*J&<%>:I"$&I"E%&"*>&
,@%$+%E3X./6&S:*"$$RJ&:*&;<)<()*,,6:0*2(A*2:%*,(B*$%8^44(?<()%*3<(9<`<(E$7686J./1&+@%&N;CE%<%&
)';E+&E%I'9*:Z%>&+@"+&*'+&'*$R&:,&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&"*&:*>%C%*>%*+J&(;*>"<%*+"$&I'<C'*%*+&
'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%J&#;+&+@"+&+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&,@';$>&#%&9;:>%>&#R&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
,+"*>"E>,&$:B%&+@%&K"E&>%$&A$"+"&DI+:'*&A$"*&,:9*%>&#R&=*>:"&:*&-?//3.//&!@%&)';E+&>:E%I+$R&
c;'+%>&+@%&A$"*J&Q@:I@&,+"+%,&+@"+&We"f$$&C%'C$%J&Q@"+%P%E&+@%:E&,+"9%&'(&>%P%$'C<%*+&"*>&
+@%:E&,'I:"$&"*>&%I'*'<:I&I'*>:+:'*,J&@"P%&+@%&E:9@+&+'&@"P%&"II%,,&+'&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&:*&
c;"*+;<&"*>&'(&"&c;"$:+R&%c;"$&+'&+@%:E&#",:I&*%%>,3X./7&!@%&)*,,6:0*2(A*2:%*,(B*$%8&I",%&
"$,'&>%<'*,+E"+%,&+@%&+E"*,<:,,:'*&'(&[;>:I:"$&CE:*I:C$%,&E%$"+%>&+'&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3&
!@%&)';E+&*'+%>&+@"+&+@%&I'*I%C+&'(&"&E:9@+&+'&"&@%"$+@R&%*P:E'*<%*+&]",&>%P%$'C%>&#R&+@%&
)';E+&"*>&"9":*&:*('E<%>&#R&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,^&@">&9":*%>&Q:>%,CE%">&"II%C+"*I%&
:*&#'+@&E%9:'*"$&"*>&*"+:'*"$&I';E+E''<,&"#E'">3./?&
b*('E+;*"+%$RJ&*'&=*>:"*&I';E+&@",&%P%E&%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I%>&"*R&E:9@+U,&W<:*:<;<&
I'E%3X&!@:,&:,&C%E@"C,&;*,;ECE:,:*9J&@'Q%P%EJ&",&+@%&:>%"&'(&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&]",&,;I@^&:,&
+RC:I"$$R&$:*B%>&+'&E:9@+,T>%(:*:+:'*&+@E';9@&+@%&=)LN)GJ&Q@:I@&+@%&"#'P%&[;>9<%*+,&
*'+"#$R&:9*'E%&",&"&$%9"$&,';EI%3&F*&,%P%E"$&'II",:'*,J&@'Q%P%EJ&+@%&)';E+&@",&;,%>&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&./4&48<&"+&q/3&
&&&&./0&)@"<%$:&N:*9@&P3&b++"E&AE">%,@J&]-??1^&D3=3G3&-??1&N3)3&-56-&]=*>:"^3&/""($,#*(Gorsboth, #6@%$&*'+%&.4J&"+&-0&
]C"E+:"$$R&E%C'E+:*9&+@%&I",%^3&
&&&&./6&/021'&]-??1^&D3=3G3&-??1&N3)3&-56-J&-564&q/3&&
&&&&./1&D3A3&A'$$;+:'*&)'*+E'$&8'"E>T==&P3&K3s3&M"R;>;J&].55-^&0&=3_3G3&16/&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3:%$EI3'E9OI'*+%*+O%55-53C>(3(
&&&&.//&48<&"+&q04&]WL`%EI:,%&'(&,;I@&"&C'Q%E&:*&("P';E&'(&"&C"E+:I;$"E&:*>;,+ER&<;,+&#%&+E%"+%>&",&"E#:+E"ER&"*>&I'*+E"ER&+'&
C;#$:I&:*+%E%,+&"*>&:*&P:'$"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&I$%"*&Q"+%E&;*>%E&DE+:I$%&.-&'(&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*&'(&=*>:"3X^3&
&&&&./7&483&"+&q43&=*&+@%&I",%&)"%6-$::7(F%$-$()$2&'$7$:&?<(/:$:"(*3(g"%$,$J&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&'(&i%E"$"&"$,'&E%(%E%*I%>&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,&Q@%*&>%(:*:*9&+@%&$%9"$&$:<:+,&'(&Q"+%E&%`+E"I+:'*3&!@%&)';E+&E%(%E%*I%>&AE:*I:C$%&.&'(&+@%&
N+'IB@'$<&2%I$"E"+:'*J&*'+:*9&+@"+&+@%&*"+;E"$&E%,';EI%,&'(&+@%&%"E+@&<;,+&#%&,"(%9;"E>%>&('E&+@%&#%*%(:+&'(&CE%,%*+&"*>&
(;+;E%&9%*%E"+:'*,3&/""(A%E;<"++R&dE"<"&A"*I@"R"+&P3&i%E"$"J&].550^&-&i3_3!3&/4-&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-0-5J&"+&q-43&
&&&&./?&;<)<()*,,6:0*2(A*2:%*,(B*$%8^44&].55-^&0&=3_3G3&16/&"+&q?&]I:+:*9&+@%&L;E'C%"*&)';E+&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&=*+%ETD<%E:I"*&
)'<<:,,:'*J&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&'(&)'$'<#:"J&"*>&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&'(&N';+@&D(E:I"^3&
&
6.&
$"*9;"9%&$:B%&W+@%&%,,%*+:"$&<:*:<;<&'(&+@%&E:9@+X.75&'E&WQ@"+&:,&<:*:<"$$R&E%c;:E%>X.7-&:*&
I",%,&E%$"+:*9&+'&'+@%E&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&$:B%&(''>&"*>&@%"$+@I"E%3&V@%*&+"B%*&
+'9%+@%EJ&+@%,%&C@E",%,&>%<'*,+E"+%&,;CC'E+&('E&#'+@&W@"$P%,X&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&
I'*I%C+H&<:*:<;<&I'*+%*+&"*>&<:*:<;<&'#$:9"+:'*,3.7.&S;E+@%E<'E%J&+@%&<:*:<;<&
'#$:9"+:'*,&",&%,+"#$:,@%>&:*&)"*@,"h#(\20*2(3*%(A0?0,(C0+"%:0"#(?<(\20*2(*3(4280$(i(W:'"%#J&
:*I$;>%>&+@%&3%""&CE'P:,:'*&'(&"&#@"&030&&$-*62:&'(&(''>&+'&#'+@&I@:$>E%*&"*>&">;$+,&
:*I"C"#$%&'(&"(('E>:*9&:+J&"&[;>9<%*+&I'*I;EE%*+&Q:+@&)LN)G&9;:>%$:*%,&"*>&%",:$R&
+E"*,$"+"#$%&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3.74&&
!@%&'*$R&:<C$:I:+&@R#E:>:Z"+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&Q:+@&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"CCE'"I@&
I'<%,&(E'<&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&'(&D$$"@"#">&:*&b++"E&AE">%,@&,+"+%3&=*&:+,&-???&[;>9<%*+&:*&/<(g<(
F$%1(?<(/:$:"(*3(\::$%()%$8"#'.Pje&+@%&)';E+&*'+&'*$R&E%I'9*:Z%>&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&#;+&"$,'&
I'*,:>%E%>&+@%&C',:+:P%&$%9"$&'#$:9"+:'*,&E%$"+:*9&+'&Q"+%EJ&:<C$:I:+$R&,;CC'E+:*9&"*&:>%"&'(&
+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%3.76&!@:,&C;#$:I&:*+%E%,+&$:+:9"+:'*&+"E9%+%>&+@%&:*,;((:I:%*IR&'(&+@%&Q"+%E&
,R,+%<&:*&+@%&E%9:'*&",&#%:*9&+@%&E''+&I";,%&'(&"&$'I"$&Q"+%E&,@'E+"9%&"*>&+@%E%('E%&"&E:9@+,&
P:'$"+:'*3&D$+@';9@&+@%&)';E+&>:>&*'+&:+,%$(&,C%I:(R&"&E%<%>RJ&:+&%,+"#$:,@%>&"&I'<<:++%%&+'&
I'*,:>%E&@'Q&+'&#%,+&,'$P%&+@%&:*(E",+E;I+;E"$&CE'#$%<,&:*&+@%&E%9:'*3&!@%&<',+&:*+%E%,+:*9&
%$%<%*+&:*&+@%&)';E+U,&>%I:,:'*&Q",&:+,&:*,+E;I+:'*&+'&+@%&I'<<:++%%&+@"+&:+&I'*,:>%E&#'+@&
;E9%*+J&E%<%>:"$&,+%C,&+'&CE'P:>%&#",:I&"II%,,&+'&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&Q@:$%&"$,'&>%P%$'C:*9&$'*9&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.75&A",I@:<&8"*9"&i@%+&K"Z>''E&N"<:+R&P3&V%,+&8%*9"$J&]-??1^&D3=3G3&.0.1J&.0.?&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3<"**E%++:*>:3:,O+@%T@;<"*TE:9@+,T
EC'[%I+O@;<"*E:9@+,I",%,"*><"+%E:"$,OI",%,O*"+:'*"$I",%,O,;CE%<%I';E+'(:*>:"O*EO4?03&
&&&&.7-&!@%&I:+%>&$"*9;"9%&:,&E%C'E+%>&:*&\':%&)@'Q>@;ERJ&[680&0$,(;8'"%"2&"(:*($(9020-6-(A*%"(;@@%*$&'(:*(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(
!01':#(f(;(A*-@$%$:0?"()"%#@"&:0?".&?&*3&4/&]K"E3&.4J&.557^&];*C;#$:,@%>&Q'EB:*9&C"C%EJ&)'E*%$$&_"Q&NI@''$^]'*&(:$%&Q:+@&
";+@'E^];,%>&Q:+@&C%E<:,,:'*^3&!@%&$"*9;"9%&:,&+"B%*&(E'<&"&>:((:I;$+T+'T(:*>&I'<<%*+"ER&'*&"*&:*+%E:<&'E>%E&(E'<&.55-3&
A%'C$%x,&b*:'*&('E&):P:$&_:#%E+:%,&P3&b*:'*&'(&=*>:"J&VE:+&'(&A%+:+:'*&M'3&-?1O.55-&]N3)3&M'P3&.7J&.55-J&'E>%E&9E"*+:*9&
CE%$:<:*"ER&CE'+%I+:'*^3&!@';9@&"&C;#$:,@%>&,';EI%&:,&*'+&E%">:$R&"P":$"#$%J&+@%&I",%&:,&Q%$$TB*'Q*&:*&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&
E:9@+,&I:EI$%,&",&$:+:9"+:'*&+"E9%+:*9&+@%&E:9@+&+'&(''>&:,&c;:+%&E"E%3&/""(A$#"(C$HR()"*@,"L#(\20*2(3*%(A0?0,(C0+"%:0"#(?<(\20*2(*3(
4280$($28(W:'"%#.(ESCR-Net.org, @++CHOOQQQ3%,IET*%+3'E9OI",%$"QOI",%$"Qh,@'Q3@+<n>'Ih:>o05-544&]$",+&P:,:+%>&
M'P3&7J&.5-5^3 D&(:*"$&>%I:,:'*&('E&+@%&I",%&Q",&>%$:P%E%>&:*&.55/J&:*&("P'E&'(&+@%&A%'C$%U,&b*:'*3&A%'C$%x,&b*:'*&('E&):P:$&
_:#%E+:%,&P3&b*:'*&'(&=*>:"J&].55/^&-&N3)3)3&/-?&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOO:*>:"*B"*''*3'E9O>'IO0--741O3(
&&&&.7.&!@%&=*>:"*&)';E+U,&$"*9;"9%&:,&*'+&>:E%I+$R&:*+%EI@"*9%"#$%&('E&+@%&:>%"&'(&"&W<:*:<;<&I'E%3X&LP%*&"&,;#+$%&I@"*9%&:*&
+@%&Q'E>,&;,%>&I"*&@"P%&"&9E%"+&%((%I+&'*&Q@"+&:,&<%"*+&Q@%*&E%(%E%*I:*9&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%3&S'E&"*&%`C$"*"+:'*J&,%%(
Chapman & Russell,&#6@%$&*'+%&-64J&"+&?3&
&&&&.74&/""(A%'C$%x,&b*:'*&('E&):P:$&_:#%E+:%,&P3&b*:'*&'(&=*>:"J&VE:+&'(&A%+:+:'*&M'3&-?1O.55-&]N3)3&K"R&.J&.554J&,%I'*>&'E>%E&
9E"*+:*9&CE%$:<:*"ER&CE'+%I+:'*^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%,IET*%+3'E9OI",%$"QOI",%$"Qh,@'Q3@+<n>'Ih:>o05-544&
],%$%I+&W>'Q*$'">X&@RC%E$:*B&:*&$%(+T@"*>&C"*%$^<(/""($,#*(d)-6J&#6@%$&*'+%&443&
&&&&.70&N3&i3&d"E9&P3&b++"E&AE">%,@J&]-???^&D3=3G3&]D$$3^&0-&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOO:*>:"*B"*''*3'E9O>'IO7?76..OJ&
@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02(D02O,"%.(#6@%$&*'+%&41J&"+&-03&
&&&&.76&!@%&"*"$R,:,&'(&+@:,&I",%&:,&#'EE'Q%>&(E'<&V:*B$%EJ&#6@%$&*'+%&41&"+&-03&&
&
64&
+%E<&,'$;+:'*,3.71&!@%&,;CC'E+&('E&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&:*&+@:,&"CCE'"I@&Q",&$:<:+%>J&",&+@%&
)';E+&*%:+@%E&E%(%E%*I%>&"&WI'E%X&*'E&">>E%,,%>&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'*+%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&
"$'*9,:>%&:+,&<:*:<;<&'#$:9"+:'*,3&=+&<"R&#%&"&,<"$$&I'*I%C+;"$&,+%C&(E'<&,;I@&"&[;>9<%*+&
+'&"*&%`C$:I:+&<%*+:'*&'(&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&('E&Q"+%EJ&%,C%I:"$$R&*'+:*9&+@%&Q:$$:*9*%,,&'(&+@%&
N;CE%<%&)';E+&+'&;,%&,:<:$"E&$"*9;"9%&:*&E%$"+%>&I",%,3&N;I@&"&,+%CJ&@'Q%P%EJ&@",&R%+&+'&#%&
<">%3&8"EE:*9&(;E+@%E&[;>:I:"$&:*:+:"+:P%J&=*>:"*&CE'9E%,,&@:*9%,&'*&$%9:,$"+:P%&:*I'EC'E"+:'*&
'(&+@%&=)LN)GJ&+'&Q@:I@&+@%&I';*+ER&E%<":*,&#';*>&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&&
&
43&8"*9$">%,@&"*>&A"B:,+"*&&
&
&
8"*9$">%,@&"*>&A"B:,+"*&"E%&:*I$;>%>&@%E%&+'&>%<'*,+E"+%&+@%&+E"*,<:,,:'*&'(&
[;>:I:"$&CE:*I:C$%,&(E'<&=*>:"*&I';E+E''<,&+'&+@%:E&8"*9$">%,@:&"*>&A"B:,+"*:&I';*+%EC"E+,3&
M'*%&'(&+@%&I",%,&#%$'Q&(;$$R&CE'+%I+&"&E:9@+&+'&I$%"*J&">%c;"+%&Q"+%E&"II%,,&'(&"&,C%I:(:I&
c;"$:+R&'E&c;"*+:+R&+'&%*,;E%&@;<"*&,;EP:P"$3&M'E&>'&+@%,%&I",%,&E%(%E%*I%&+@%&<:*:<;<&
I'E%&I'*I%C+3&!@%R&'*$R&%`+%*>&$:<:+%>&CE'+%I+:'*&+'&(:9@+&E%,';EI%&C'$$;+:'*&:*&"&Q"R&
,:<:$"E&+'&+@%&=*>:"*&N;CE%<%&)';E+U,&[;>9<%*+&:*&/6+'$#'(g6-$%&"#'P%3.7/&!@%&I",%,&
#%$'QJ&@'Q%P%EJ&"$$&>%<'*,+E"+%&"&E%"$&[;>:I:"$&"++%<C+&+'&<'E%&">%c;"+%$R&CE'+%I+&,'I:'T
%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&Y&"*&%(('E+&+@"+&<"R&>%P%$'C&(;E+@%E&:*&+@%&(;+;E%&Q:+@&$%9:,$"+:P%&I@"*9%3&
8"*9$">%,@&:,&'(+%*&I'<<%*>%>&('E&Q%$$T:*+%9E"+%>&Q"+%E&<"*"9%<%*+J&:*I$;>:*9&
:+,&,+E"+%9:%,&('E&I$:<"+%&I@"*9%&I'<C%*,"+:'*&"*>&C'P%E+R&"$$%P:"+:'*3.77&2;%&+'&:+,&$%P%$&'(&
>%P%$'C<%*+&"*>&9%'9E"C@:I"$&,:+;"+:'*J&:+&("I%,&<"*R&'(&+@%&,"<%&E%,';EI%&CE'#$%<,&
,;((%E%>&#R&=*>:"J&'(&Q@:I@&:+&;,%>&+'&('E<&"*&:*+%9E"$&C"E+3.7? &A'$$;+:'*J&%,C%I:"$$R&
,+%<<:*9&(E'<&;*,"(%&:*>;,+E:"$&CE"I+:I%,J&:,&"&CE'<:*%*+&I'*I%E*&:*&8"*9$">%,@&Q@%E%&
'P%E&-555&:*>;,+E:%,&@"P%&#%%*&:>%*+:(:%>&,:*I%&+@%&-?75,&",&;*,"(%$R&>:,I@"E9:*9&Q",+%&
:*+'&+@%&Q"+%E&"*>&":E3.?5&D9":*J&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&CE:*I:C$%,&"E%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$$R&%*,@E:*%>&",&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.71&F$%1&]-???^&D3=3G3&]D$$3^&0-J&q?T-43&!@%&)';E+&:+,%$(&"$,'&'E>%E%>&+@%&:<<%>:"+%&E%C":E&'(&@"*>TQ%$$,&"*>&+@%&+%,+:*9&
'(&Q"+%E&c;"$:+R&+'&%*,;E%&,C%%>RJ&#",:I&"II%,,3&483&
&&&&.7/&/6@%$(C3&65-J&*'+%&./.3&
&&&&.77&=dA))J&#6@%$(*'+%&.6J&"+&613&
&&&&.7?&8"*9$">%,@&]('E<%E$R&L",+&A"B:,+"*&('$$'Q:*9&C"E+:+:'*^&,%I%>%>&(E'<&=*>:"&",&"&E%,;$+&'(&+@%&8"*9$">%,@&V"E&'(&
=*>%C%*>%*I%&#%9;*&:*&K"EI@&'(&-?/-3&!@%&:*+%E*"$&I'*($:I+&I";,%>&#R&+@:,&Q"E&IE%"+%>&,'I:"$&+;E<':$&:*&+@%&<:>T-?/5,&
CE'<C+:*9&+@%&:*P%*+:'*&'(&WA;#$:I&=*+%E%,+&_:+:9"+:'*X&:*&=*>:"3&/""(1"2"%$,,7 Jona Razzaque, Public Interest
Environmental Litigation in India, Pakistan and Bangladesh ].550^3&
&&&&.?5&COHRE(c)J&#6@%$&*'+%&65J&"+&.7-3&
&
60&
*'*T[;,+:I:"#$%&WCE:*I:C$%,&'(&,+"+%&C'$:IRJX&"*>&+@%&=)LN)GJ&+@';9@&"II%>%>&+'J&:,&$"E9%$R&
:9*'E%>&:*&>'<%,+:I&$"Q&"*>&[;E:,CE;>%*I%3.?-&N:<:$"E&"CCE'"I@%,&@"P%&#%%*&+"B%*&#R&#'+@&
A"B:,+"*&"*>&M%C"$3.?.&=*&"&.5-5&E%C'E+&('$$'Q:*9&@%E&P:,:+&+'&+@%&I';*+ERJ&+@%&=*>%C%*>%*+&
L`C%E+&'*&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*&%`CE%,,%>&I'*I%E*&'P%E&+@%&9'P%E*<%*+U,&
(":$;E%&+'&:,,;%&"&CE%$:<:*"ER&E%C'E+&+'&+@%&)LN)G&"*>&+'&,:9*&:+,&FC+:'*"$&AE'+'I'$3.?4&&
=*&+@%&-??5,J&+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&'(&8"*9$">%,@&#%9"*&+'&C%E<:+&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&
'+@%EQ:,%&*'*T[;,+:I:"#$%&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&+@E';9@&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%3.?0&D,&:*&=*>:"J&+@%&
+E%*>&:*&8"*9$">%,@&#%9"*&"+&+@%&:*,+:9"+:'*&'(&+@%&[;>:I:"ER3&=*&+@%&!$80*$&:0?"(90,O()*H8"%(
I",%&'(&%"E$R&\;$R&-??1J&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&2:P:,:'*&'(&+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&%`%EI:,%>&,C%I:"$&
'E:9:*"$&[;E:,>:I+:'*&+'&%*('EI%&"&VE:+&'(&AE'+%I+:'*&"9":*,+&+@%&N+"+%&'*&#%@"$(&'(&+@%&
8"*9$">%,@&L*P:E'*<%*+"$&_"QR%EU,&D,,'I:"+:'*&]8L_D^3(=*&:+,&>%I:,:'*&+'&CE'@:#:+&+@%&
9'P%E*<%*+&(E'<&E%$%",:*9&C'+%*+:"$$R&E">:'"I+:P%&<:$B&C'Q>%E&'*+'&+@%&'C%*&<"EB%+J&+@%&
)';E+&@%$>&+@"+&We,f:*I%&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&@",&*'+&#%%*&:*+%ECE%+%>&:*&';E&>'<":*t&Q%&<"R&
,%%&Q@"+&<%"*:*9&Q",&9:P%*&#R&+@%&,;C%E:'E&I';E+,&'(&'+@%E&I';*+E:%,&+'&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%3X.?6&&
!@%&('$$'Q:*9&[;>9<%*+&c;'+%>&,%P%*&('E%:9*&I",%,J&,:`&(E'<&=*>:"&"*>&'*%&(E'<&+@%&b*:+%>&
N+"+%,3&!@%&)';E+&%`C"*>%>&CE'+%I+:'*&('E&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&+'&]:*+%E&"$:"^J&W%*['R<%*+&'(&
C'$$;+:'*&(E%%&Q"+%E&"*>&":EJ&#"E%&*%I%,,:+:%,&'(&$:(%t&e"*>f&<":*+%*"*I%&"*>&:<CE'P%<%*+&
'(&C;#$:I&@%"$+@&#R&IE%"+:*9&"*>&,;,+":*:*9&I'*>:+:'*,&I'*9%*:"$&+'&9''>&@%"$+@&"*>&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.?-&=*+%EP:%Q&Q:+@&2E3&i"<"$&a',,":*J&D>P'I"+%J&S'E<%E&K:*:,+%E&'(&8"*9$">%,@&"*>&bM&NC%I:"$&G"CC'E+%;E&'*&
D(9@"*:,+"*J&02&LitigatingJ&#6@%$(*'+%&..7J&"+&0.3&
&&&&.?.&V:*B$%EJ&#6@%$(*'+%&41J&"+&-63&=*&:+,&"II%,,:'*&+'&+@%&=)LN)GJ&A"B:,+"*&E%,%EP%>&+@%&E:9@+&+'&:*+%ECE%+&+@%&)'P%*"*+&
Q:+@:*&+@%&(E"<%Q'EB&'(&:+,&)'*,+:+;+:'*J&Q@:I@&>'%,&*'+&9:P%&%c;"$&Q%:9@+&+'&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3&M%C"$J&+@';9@&*'+&
<"B:*9&"*R&,;I@&E%,%EP"+:'*J&@",&#%%*&IE:+:I:Z%>&#R&+@%&)LN)G&('E&:+,&*'*T:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3&/""(
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&)'*I$;>:*9&F#,%EP"+:'*,&'(&+@%&)'<<:++%%&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&M%C"$J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.OMA_O)FO.J&q.0&]\"*3&-1J&.557^J&"+&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@IE3'E9OE%(Q'E$>O>'I:>O0/?76I.5.3@+<$3&M%C"$%,%&I';E+,&@"P%&"$,'&#%9;*&+'&CE'+%I+&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
+@E';9@&+@%&[;,+:I:"#$%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%3&M%C"$J&@'Q%P%EJ&:,&*'+&:*I$;>%>&:*&+@:,&"*"$R,:,&",&+@%&[;E:,CE;>%*+:"$&,+"*>"E>&+@%E%&
@",&*'+&R%+&"IB*'Q$%>9%>&'E&CE'+%I+%>&"*&:*>%C%*>%*+&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&*'E&@",&:+&>%P%$'C%>&CE'+%I+:'*&('E&"*R&
E:9@+U,&<:*:<;<&I'E%3&)FaGL&*'+%,&+Q'&E%$%P"*+&M%C"$%,%&I",%,&:*&+@%:E&;CI'<:*9&9;:>%3&/""(COHRE(c), #6@%$&*'+%&65J&
<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.?.J&4503&/""($,#*(N;ER"&2@;*9%$&P3&d'>"P"E:&K"E#$%&=*>;,+E:%,J&]-??6^&.56.&M3i3A3&4/&]M%C"$^Z&AE"B",@&
K"*:&N@"E<"&P3&M%C"$&V"+%E&N;CC$R&)'EC'E"+:'*J&]-??5^&8N&.50/&>%I:>%>&:*&].55-^&8N&.567&D,@">@&.1J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-4743&
&&&&.?4&=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&G%$"+%>&+'&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*&j&
=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&|;%,+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&"*>&L`+E%<%&A'P%E+RJ&[*02:(!"@*%:(*3(:'"(428"@"28"2:(GT@"%:(*2(:'"(
c6"#:0*2(*3(S6-$2(!01':#($28(GT:%"-"()*?"%:7.(9$18$,"2$(/"@k,?"8$(A$%8*2$.($28(:'"(428"@"28"2:(GT@"%:(*2(:'"(4##6"(*3(
S6-$2(!01':#(W+,01$:0*2#(!",$:"8(:*(;&&"##(:*(/$3"(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.(A$:$%02$(8"(;,+656"%56"R(90##0*2(:*(
B$21,$8"#'.&a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-6O66J&q7&]\;$R&..J&.5-5^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,O@EI';*I:$O>'I,O-.,%,,:'*ODTaG)T-.T.0hL3C>(&]P:"&@RC%E$:*B&Q:+@&+@%&+:+$%&'(&
+@%&>'I;<%*+^&e@%E%:*"(+%E&B$21,$8"#'(!"@*%:f3(
&&&&.?0&Bangladesh Shongbidhan [Constitution} M'P3&0J&-?/.J&"E+3&4.&]8"*9$3^&]E:9@+&+'&$:(%^3&&
&&&&.?6&S"E''c;%&P3&8"*9$">%,@&]!$80*$&:0?"&90,O&)*H8"%^J&;*E%C'E+%>&V3A3&?.J&q.5&]\;$3&-J&-??1^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-4.43&
&
66&
%*,;E:*9&c;"$:+R&'(&$:(%&I'*,:,+%*+&Q:+@&@;<"*&>:9*:+R3X.?1&!@%&:**'P"+:P%&,+"*>"E>&
%<#E"I%>&#R&+@%&=*>:"*&N;CE%<%&)';E+&:*&/6+$#'(g6-$%&Q",&c;'+%>&:*&+@%&[;>9<%*+J&'*$R&
(';E&R%"E,&"(+%E&:+&Q",&>%$:P%E%>3&_"+%E&:*&+@%&,"<%&<'*+@J&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&2:P:,:'*&
E%:+%E"+%>&:+,&C',:+:'*&:*&+@%&U,**8(;&:0*2(),$2(I",%3.?/&&!@"+&[;>9<%*+&Q",&"9":*&;C@%$>&:*&
+@%&DCC%$$"+%&2:P:,:'*J&#R&Q@:I@&"&,:<:$"E&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&Q",&"$,'&C;+&
('E+@3&.?7 &
=*&-???J&8"*9$">%,@&"II%>%>&+'&+@%&=)LN)G&"*>&+@%&K:*:,+ER&'(&V"+%E&G%,';EI%,&
C;#$:,@%>&"&M"+:'*"$&V"+%E&A'$:IR&"IB*'Q$%>9:*9&+@"+&+@%&W"P":$"#:$:+R&e'(&Q"+%Ef&('E&
,;,+%*"*I%&'(&$:(%J&:*&#'+@&c;"*+:+"+:P%&"*>&c;"$:+"+:P%&+%E<,J&:,&"&#",:I&@;<"*&E:9@+3X.??&S'E&
+@%:E&C"E+J&8"*9$">%,@:&I';E+,&I'*+:*;%>&+'&#'EE'Q&('E%:9*&,+"*>"E>,&",&+@%R&%`+%*>%>&
,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*&%P%*&(;E+@%E3&=*&,'<%&I",%,&+@:,&:**'P"+:'*&I"<%&(E'<&+@%&
#%*I@&:+,%$(g&:*&'+@%E,&:+&Q",&">'C+%>&"+&+@%&,;99%,+:'*&'(&+@%&"CC$:I"*+3&=*&;#O(;02(*(/$,0#'(
g"28%$(?<(F*?"%2-"2:(*3(B$21$8"#'.dXX(I$":<"*+&"++'E*%R&2E3&i"<"$&a',,":*&:*,:,+%>&+@"+&
+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&%`+%*>&CE'+%I+:'*&+'&,$;<&>Q%$$%E,&:*&"&Q"R&,:<:$"E&+'&+@%&=*>:"*&
)';E+U,&[;>9<%*+&:*&+@%(W,1$(=",,0#(I",%345-&!@%&)';E+&I'<C$:%>3&=*&:+,&.55-&[;>9<%*+&:*&+@%(
4286#:%0$,()*,,6:0*2(I",%J45.&+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&('EI%>&+@%&9'P%E*<%*+&+'&:<C$%<%*+&$"Q,&
":<%>&"+&I'*+E'$$:*9&:*>;,+E:"$&C'$$;+:'*&"*>&CE'+%I+:*9&%*P:E'*<%*+"$&@%"$+@3&!@%&
[;>9<%*+&"9":*&E%(%E%*I%>&=*>:"*&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&+'&",,%E+&+@"+&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&W:*I$;>%,&
%P%ER+@:*9&Q@:I@&:,&*%I%,,"ER&+'&<"B%&:+&<%"*:*9(;$&"*>&"&$:(%&Q'E+@&$:P:*9J&,;I@&",J&"<'*9&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&.?1&48<&"+&q&413&
&&&&.?/&S"E''c;%&P3&8"*9$">%,@&]U,**8(;&:0*2(),$2R(S01'(A*6%:^J&]-??1^&07&23_3G3&]a)^&047J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&\'*"&
G"ZZ"c;%J&;&&"##(:*(G2?0%*2-"2:$,([6#:0&"R(!*,"(*3(:'"([680&0$%7(02(B$21,$8"#'&0]-^&Bangl. J. L.&-J&/&**3&4T0&].555^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3#:$:"#>3'E9O#$[OI'*+%*+-3@+<3&/""($,#*(COHRE(c), <"*;,IE:C+&"+&45/3&
&&&&.?7&S"E''c;%&P3&8"*9$">%,@&]U,**8(;&:0*2(),$2(A$#"R(;@@",,$:"lJ&]-??/^&0?&23_3G3&]D2^&-J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&G"ZZ"c;%J&
;&&"##.(#6@%$&*'+%&.7?&"+&/J&**3&4T0&]WDE+:I$%&4-&"*>&4.&3&3&3&%*I'<C",,&Q:+@:*&:+,&"<#:+J&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&"*>&CE%,%EP"+:'*&'(&
%*P:E'*<%*+J&%I'$'9:I"$&#"$"*I%&(E%%&(E'<&C'$$;+:'*&'(&":E&"*>&Q"+%EJ&,"*:+"+:'*&Q:+@';+&Q@:I@&$:(%&I"*&@"E>$R&#%&%*['R%>3&
D*R&"I+&'E&'<:,,:'*&I'*+E"ER&+@%E%+'&Q';$>&#%&P:'$"+:P%&'(&+@%&,":>&E:9@+&+'&$:(%3X^3&
&&&&.??&Gov. of the Peoples Republic of Bangl., Ministry of Water Resources, National Water Policy -&]\"*&45J&
-???^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3<'QE39'P3#>O2'I;<%*+,OM"+:'*"$m.5V"+%Em.5A'$:IRm.5]L*9$:,@^3C>(3&&
&&&&455&D,B&D:*&'&N"$:,@&i%*>E"&P3&8"*9$3&&]-???^&-?&83_323&077&]8"*9$3^J&#6--$%0Q"8(02&D,B&D:*&'&N"$:,@J&a;<"*&G:9@+,&:*&
8"$9$">%,@&.555, ESCR-Net ].55-^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3%,IET*%+3'E9OI",%$"QOI",%$"Qh,@'Q3@+<n>'Ih:>o055?.5&
]$",+&P:,:+%>&M'P3&?J&.5-5^3(
&&&&45-&483&/""($,#*(F$9"&!%$$:,&P3&8'<#"R&K;*3&)';*I:$J&]-?76^&.&N3)3G3&6-&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.745g&/""($,#*.(=*+%EP:%Q&#6@%$&*'+%&.70J&"+&04&]W=&Q",&"$,'&"#$%&+'&,"R&+'&+@%&I';E+&e:*&+@%&
F$9"&!%$$:,&)",%fH&$''BJ&%P%*&:*&*%:9@#'E:*9&=*>:"&+@%R&;,%&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&",&"&#",:,J&"&C$"*BJ&'*&Q@:I@&+'&9:P%&$:<:+%>&
E:9@+,3X^3&
&&&&45.&S"E''c;%&P3&8"*9$">%,@&]4286#:%0$,()*,,6:0*2^J&;*E%C'E+%>&V3A3&7?-&]-??0^J&]>%I:,:'*&\;$R&-6J&.55-^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.6/7<(/""($,#*(COHRE(c), <"*;,IE:C+&"+&.7.3(
&
61&
'+@%E,&<":*+%*"*I%&'(&@%"$+@t&$"IB&'(&Q@:I@&<"R&C;+&+@%&$:(%&'(&+@%&I:+:Z%*&"+&*";9@+3X454&
b*('E+;*"+%$RJ&*%:+@%E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&*'E&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&Q%E%&%`C$:I:+$R&CE'+%I+%>&:*&%:+@%E&
'(&+@%,%&[;>9<%*+,3&&
N'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&@",&(":$%>&+'&>%P%$'C&#%R'*>&+@%,%&:*:+:"$&
$"*><"EB&I",%,J&"*>&+@%E%&:,&,;#,+"*+:"$&I'*I%E*&'P%E&+@%&(;+;E%&'(&[;>:I:"$&CE'+%I+:'*&('E&
+@%,%&E:9@+,3&!@%&M"+:'*"$&a;<"*&G:9@+,&)'<<:,,:'*J&IE%"+%>&#R&CE%,:>%*+:"$&'E>%E&:*&
.55?J&,+:$$&$"IB,&+@%&E%c;:,:+%&(:*"*I:"$&"*>&@;<"*&E%,';EI%,&+'&I'<<%*I%&Q'EB3&V@%*&+@%&
)'<<:,,:'*&#%I'<%,&(;*I+:'*"$J&:+,&<"*>"+%&Q:$$&E%<":*&E%,+E:I+%>&#R&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&
>:((%E%*+:"+:'*&#%+Q%%*&(;*>"<%*+"$&E:9@+,&"*>&>:E%I+:P%&CE:*I:C$%,3450&D&CE'<C+&$%9:,$"+:P%&
,'$;+:'*&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&E%I'9*:+:'*&,%%<,&:<CE'#"#$%J&",&+@%&<',+&E%I%*+&>E"(+&'(&+@%&
V"+%E&DI+&(":$,&+'&%`C$:I:+$R&E%I'9*:Z%&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&>%,C:+%&+@%&%"E$:%E&,+"*I%&'(&
+@%&-???&M"+:'*"$&V"+%E&A'$:IR3456&V:+@&"&[;>:I:"ER&,%:Z%>&W'*$R&E"E%$RX&'(&"$$%9%>&P:'$"+:'*,&
'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&8"*9$">%,@&Q:$$&I'*+:*;%&+'&$"9&#%@:*>&=*>:"&:*&%((%I+:P%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
CE'+%I+:'*&;*+:$&$%9:,$"+:P%&:**'P"+:'*&I"*&W'C%E"+:'*"$:Z%X&%`:,+:*9&E:9@+,&Q:+@&<%I@"*:,<,&
('E&+@%:E&%*('EI%"#:$:+R3451 &
A"B:,+"*:&)';E+,&#%9"*&+'&>%P%$'C&Q"+%E&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&:*&+@%&-??5,J&"9":*&Q:+@&
E%(%E%*I%&+'&=*>:"*&[;>:I:"$&,+"*>"E>,3&D$+@';9@&A"B:,+"*&@",&<'E%&%`C$:I:+$R&%<#E"I%>&+@%&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*,%*,;,&,;EE';*>:*9&E%,';EI%&CE'+%I+:'*J&:+&+''&@",&("$$%*&,@'E+&'(&
,:9*:(:I"*+$R&,;CC'E+:*9&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3&
=*&+@%&-??4&/$,:(902"%#(I",%.(+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&(';*>&+@"+&We+f@%&Q'E>&w$:(%U&@",&+'&
#%&9:P%*&"*&%`+%*>%>&<%"*:*9&"*>&I"**'+&#%&E%,+E:I+%>&+'&"&P%9%+"+:P%&$:(%&'E&<%E%&"*:<"$&
%`:,+%*I%3&We!f@%&E:9@+&+'&@"P%&Q"+%E&(E%%&(E'<&C'$$;+:'*&"*>&I'*+"<:*"+:'*&:,&"&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&
:+,%$(3X&45/&!@%&>%I:,:'*&E%(%E%*I%>&"*&%"E$:%E&[;>9<%*+&:*&/'$,$(]0$(?<(D;)>;457 &:*&Q@:I@&
+@%&)';E+&(';*>&+@"+&+@%&E:9@+,&+'&$:(%&"*>&>:9*:+R&:*I$;>%&"&E:9@+&+'&"&@%"$+@R&%*P:E'*<%*+J&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&454&4286#:%0$,()*,,6:0*2.&"+&q-/3&!@%&,+"*>"E>&@%E%&Q",&>%P%$'C%>&:*&"*&%"E$:%E&:*,+"*I%&'(&+@%&,"<%&I",%J&#;+&+@%&
$"*9;"9%&Q",&*'+"#$R&">'C+%>&#R&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&2:P:,:'*&'(&+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+3&&
&&&&450&/""&B$21,$8"#'(!"@*%:.(#6@%$&*'+%&.?4J&"+&--3&
&&&&456&48<&"+&653&!@%&<',+&E%I%*+&>E"(+&:,&>"+%>&2%I%<#%E&.5573&
&&&&451&48<&"+&603&!@%&=*>%C%*>%*+&L`C%E+,&(:*"$&E%I'<<%*>"+:'*&">>E%,,%,&+@%&WI$":<"#:$:+RX&"*>&%*('EI%"#:$:+R&'(&Q"+%E&
E:9@+,&"*>&+@%&:*,+:+;+:'*&'(&"II';*+"#:$:+R&<%I@"*:,<,3&
&&&&45/&d%*%E"$&N%IE%+"ER&P3&!@%&2:E%I+'E&&]/$,:(902"%#^&]-??0^&N)KG&.51-J&$#(%"@*%:"8(02&COHRE(c),&#6@%$&*'+%&65J&
<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.?53&
&&&&457&N@"$"&z:"&P3&VDA2DJ&]-??0^&N)KG&1?4&]A"B3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-40.3&!@:,&I",%&"$,'&$%">&+'&
<"*R&,:<:$"E&>%I:,:'*,3&S'E&"*&%`+%*,:P%&"*"$R,:,&,%%&Parvez Hassan, United Nations Environmental Programme,
Environmental Rights as Part of Fundamental Rights: the Leadership of the Judiciary in Pakistan&].554^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O,R,+%<O(:$%,OL*P:E'*<%*+"$3G:9@+,3A"B:,+"*3>'I3&
&
6/&
>%,C:+%&+@%&("I+&+@"+&+@%&%*P:E'*<%*+&%*['R%>&*'&$%9"$&CE'+%I+:'*&"+&+@%&+:<%3&!@%&/$,:(
902"%#(I",%&,%%<,&+'&#%&+@%&'*$R&+:<%&+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&@",&%`C$:I:+$R&<%*+:'*%>&"&E:9@+&
+'&Q"+%EJ&"*>&",&,;I@J&+@%&,+"*>"E>&E%<":*,&",&,:<:$"E$R&$:<:+%>&",&:*&8"*9$">%,@345?&&
!@%E%&<"R&#%&,'<%&@'C%&('E&(;+;E%&:<CE'P%<%*+J&@'Q%P%EJ&*'+:*9&+@%&Q:$$:*9*%,,&
'(&+@%&A"B:,+"*:&N;CE%<%&)';E+&+'&E%(%E%*I%&=*>:"*&[;>:I:"$&,+"*>"E>,3&=*&/028'(42#:0:6:0*2(?<(
E"#:,"(90,O@$O($28(W:'"%#.4-5&+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&(';*>&+@"+&M%,+$pU,&C$"*,&+'&#'++$%&"&$'I"$&
Q"+%E&,';EI%&P:'$"+%>&N%I+:'*&-.&'(&+@%&-??/&A"B:,+"*&L*P:E'*<%*+"$&AE'+%I+:'*&DI+34--&
!@%&[;>9<%*+&E%(%EE%>&+'&#'+@&CE%P:';,&=*>:"*&%*P:E'*<%*+"$&I",%,J4-.&"*>&I%E+":*&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>%I$"E"+:'*,&E%$"+:*9&+'&+@%&;,%&'(&*"+;E"$&E%,';EI%,34-4 &!@%&'C:*:'*&"$,'&
E%(%E%*I%>&W9%*;:*%&*%%>,X&",&+@%&#",:,&('E&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&$'I"$&Q"+%E&"II%,,J&:,,;:*9&"*&
:*+%E:<&'E>%E&#"**:*9&+@%&I'*,+E;I+:'*&'(&+@%&#'++$:*9&C$"*+3&&
S;E+@%E&CE'+%I+:'*&('E&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&:*&A"B:,+"*&:,&("I%>&#R&+Q'&I@"$$%*9%,H&
]"^&"&CE%C'*>%E"*I%&'(&I:P:$&"*>&C'$:+:I"$&E:9@+,&"#;,%,&('E&Q@:I@&+@%E%&:,&<'E%&
)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&CE'+%I+:'*J4-0&"*>&]#^&c;%,+:'*,&'P%E&#'+@&+@%&('E<"$&"*>&E%"$&:*>%C%*>%*I%&
'(&+@%&[;>:I:"ER34-6&b*+:$&+@%,%&CE'#$%<,&"E%&,'$P%>J&+@%&IE%"+:P%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&,'I:'T
%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&:*&+@"+&I';*+ER&I"*&#%&%`C%I+%>&+'&$"9&#%@:*>&+@%&=*>:"*&%`"<C$%3&
&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&45?&D$+@';9@&+@%&[;>9<%*+&:,&'*$R&$:<:+%>$R&"CC$:I"#$%&@%E%J&:+&:,&:*+%E%,+:*9&+'&*'+%&+@"+&"&a:9@&)';E+&:*&+@%&C$'*%"(;0%(
)*,,6:0*2(A$#"(:*,:,+%>&'*&Q"+%EU,&(;*>"<%*+"$:+R&+'&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&Q:+@&E%(%E%*I%&+'&:+,&CE'+%I+:'*&:*&#'+@&b3N3&$"Q&"*>&
+@%&i'E"*3&/""(D*[;*&=E("*&P&_"@'E%&2%P3&D;+@&]C$'*%"&;0%&)*,,6:0*2^3&].55.^&A_2&]_"@'E%^&666J&q-4T-/&]A"B3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.4?53(
&&&&4-5&N:*>@&=*,+3&'(&bE'$'9R&"*>&!E"*,C$"*+"+:'*&P3&M%,+$p&K:$BC"B&_+>3J&].556^&)_)&]N:*>@J&i"E"I@:^&0.0J&].550^&]A"B3^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3,@%@E:3'E9O,;#C"9%,O*%,+$%3C>(J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02(Cohre(b),(#6@%$&*'+%&.-4J&"+&-7?3&
&&&&4--&A"B:,+"*&L*P:E'*<%*+"$&AE'+%I+:'*&DI+J&M'3&40&'(&-??/J&{-.J&The Gazette of Pakistan ExtraordinaryJ&2%I3&1J&
-??/&]A"B3^3&
&&&&4-.&/028'(42#:<(*3(\%*,*17($28(=%$2#@,$2:$:0*2&].556^()_)&0.0J&&0:021&!"<:$*">;&P3&a:*>&N+'*%J&]-?7-^&].^&N)KG&.56&"+&
.-.&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3E:,@"#@>"E"3I'<O,IOP:%Q3C@CnI",%o/6--3(
&&&&4-4&48<("+&0&]W!@%&*"+;E"$&E%,';EI%,&'(&+@%&%"E+@J&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&":EJ&Q"+%EJ&$"*>J&($'E"&"*>&(";*"&%,C%I:"$$R&E%CE%,%*+"+:P%&
,"<C$%,&'(&*"+;E"$&%I'T,R,+%<,J&<;,+&#%&,"(%9;"E>%>&('E&+@%&#%*%(:+&'(&CE%,%*+&"*>&(;+;E%&9%*%E"+:'*,&+@E';9@&I"E%(;$&
C$"**:*9&'E&<"*"9%<%*+J&",&"CCE'CE:"+%3X^3&
&&&&4-0&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&a;<"*&G:9@+,&Q"+I@>'9,&"*>&+@%&b3N3&N+"+%&2%C"E+<%*+&I'*+:*;%&+'&C;#$:,@&E%C'E+,&E%9"E>:*9&@;<"*&
E:9@+,&I'*I%E*,&E%$"+%>&+'&%`+E"[;>:I:"$&B:$$:*9,J&+%EE'E:,<J&<:$:+"*IRJ&,%I;E:+R&'C%E"+:'*,&"*>&(E%%>'<&'(&+@%&CE%,,3&/"".(
"<1<.&[$26$%7(PXNX(A*62:%7(/6--$%7R()$O0#:$2J&Human Rights Watch&]\"*3&.5-5^J&@++CHOOQQQ3@EQ3'E9O%*OQ'E$>T
E%C'E+T.5-5OC"B:,+"*&]@%E%:*"(+%E&aGV^g&WBureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor, United States
Department of State, 2009 Human Rights Report: Pakistan ].5-5^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3,+"+%39'PO9O>E$OE$,O@EEC+O.55?O,I"O-415?.3@+<3&!@%&A"B:,+"*:&)'*,+:+;+:'*&>:E%I+$R&CE'+%I+,&E%$"+%>&
W(;*>"<%*+"$&E:9@+,X&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&,%I;E:+R&'(&+@%&C%E,'*J&,"(%9;"E>,&+'&"EE%,+&"*>&>%+%*+:'*J&"*>&(E%%>'<&'(&,C%%I@3&
Pakistan Const.&"E+3&?J&-5J&-?&]E%,C%I+:P%$R^3&!@%&\;>:I:"ER&@",&"$E%">R&#%9;*&@%"E:*9,&E%$"+%>&+'&+@%&Q'E,+&'(&+@%,%&
>:,"CC%"E"*I%&I",%,3&&
&&&&4-6&!@%&[;>:I:"ER&,@';$>&#%&%*,;E%>&$%9"$&,;CE%<"IR&'P%E&+@%&'+@%E&'E9"*,&'(&+@%&,+"+%&"C"E+&(E'<&+@%&"#:$:+R&+'&:,,;%&
'E>%E,&>:E%I+$R&I'*+E"ER&+'&"&CE%,:>%*+:"$&>%IE%%J&#;+&@",&'*$R&E%I%*+$R&E%I$":<%>&+@"+&"#:$:+R&:*&.55?3&Pakistan Const.&
"E+3&-/1T?-3&=*&K"EI@&'(&+@"+&,"<%&R%"EJ&+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&E%,+'E%>&';,+%>&I@:%(&[;,+:I%&=(+:B@"E&)@";>@ER&+'&+@%&#%*I@&
"$'*9&Q:+@&<"*R&'+@%E&[;>9%,&>:,<:,,%>&#R&K;,@"EE"(3&/""&aGVJ&#6@%$(*'+%&4-03&
&
67&
&
03&!@%&A@:$:CC:*%,&
&
&
D$+@';9@&:+,&)'*,+:+;+:'*&"$,'&%*,@E:*%,&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&",&W>:E%I+:P%&
CE:*I:C$%,X&:*&"&Q"R&,:<:$"E&+'&=*>:"U,J&+@%&A@:$:CC:*%,&:,&I'*,:>%E%>&,%C"E"+%$R&",&:+,&I';E+,&
@"P%&:*+%ECE%+%>&+@%,%&CE:*I:C$%,&<'E%&I'*,%EP"+:P%$R34-1&G%I%*+&[;>9<%*+,&@"P%&
I@"$$%*9%>&#'+@&+@%&+E"*,<:,,:'*&'(&[;>:I:"$&CE:*I:C$%,&"*>&+@%&%((%I+:P%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&
E:9@+,&('E&S:$:C:*',3&&
!@%&A@:$:CC:*%,&@",&@">&"&X<:`%>&"*>&"<#:P"$%*+&@:,+'ER&Q:+@&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&
E:9@+,X&>;%&+'&I%E+":*&@:,+'E:I"$&"*>&C'$:+:I"$&E%"$:+:%,34-/&&a;<"*&G:9@+,&:*&+@%&A@:$:CC:*%,&
"E%&'(+%*&I'*($"+%>&Q:+@&I:P:$&"*>&C'$:+:I"$&E:9@+,J&"*>&+@',%&Q'EB:*9&+'&CE'+%I+&@;<"*&
E:9@+,&"E%&'(+%*&#E"*>%>&",&$%(+:,+,J&I'<<;*:,+,&'E&%P%*&+%EE'E:,+,34-7&N'<%&,;99%,+&+@"+&
+@:,&,%*+:<%*+&:,&E%($%I+%>&:*&N;CE%<%&)';E+&[;>9<%*+,J&Q@:I@&@"P%&(":$%>&+'&E%,C%I+&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&E:9@+,&,+"*>"E>,J&'(+%*&#R&<"B:*9&#$"+"*+$R&:*"II;E"+%&$%9"$&",,;<C+:'*,3&=*&
+@%&-??1&I",%&)"*@,"(?<(C"*(G&'"1$%$7.dNm (('E&%`"<C$%J&+@%&)';E+&@%$>&'*&"&<'+:'*&('E&
E%I'*,:>%E"+:'*&+@"+&W+@%&A@:$:CC:*%,&I"**'+&#%&>%%<%>&:EE%P'I"#$R&#';*>X&#R&+@%&
CE'P:,:'*,&'(&+@%&=))AG&"*>&:+,&AE'+'I'$&WI'*,:>%E:*9&+@"+&+@%,%&"9E%%<%*+,&@"P%&E%"I@%>&
'*$R&+@%&)'<<:++%%&$%P%$3X4.5&!@%&[;>9<%*+&Q",&>%$:P%E%>&'P%E&+%*&R%"E,&"(+%E&+@%&,%I'*>&
'(&+@',%&>'I;<%*+,&%*+%E%>&:*+'&('EI%34.-&=*&'+@%E&I",%,J&I';E+,&@"P%&CE'#$%<"+:I"$$R&
>%*:%>&+@%&C%E%<C+'ER&*"+;E%&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&'#$:9"+:'*,J4..&"E9;:*9&+@"+&<;*:I:C"$&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&4-1&Litigating,&#6@%$&*'+%&.46&"+&073&)'*,+3&]-?/4^&"E+&.3&,%I3&/T.73&
&&&&4-/&48<&
&&&&4-7&=*+%EP:%Q&Q:+@&K"3&N'II'E'&W)''B:%X&2:'B*'J&02&LitigatingJ&#6@%$&*'+%&.46J&"+&65T6-3&
&&&&4-?&A@:$:CC:*%,&P3&_%'&LI@%9"E"R&R&A:$'J&d3G3&M'3&--/0/.&]\;*%&.6J&-??1^&]A@:$^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3I@"*E'#$%,3I'<OIE"$"Q-??1-/3@+<3(
&&&&4.5&483&:*&WG%,'$;+:'*&'*&K'+:'*&('E&G%I'*,:>%E"+:'*X&]S%#3&/J&-??/J&C3&?^3&
&&&&4.-&!@%&AE'+'I'$&%*+%E%>&:*+'&('EI%&:*&-?/1&"*>&+@%&A@:$:CC:*%,&E"+:(:%>&:+&:*&-?7?3&
&&&&4..&D,&"&9%*%E"$&E;$%J&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&@'$>,&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&CE:*I:C$%,&"*>&"9E%%<%*+,&'P%E&*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&
I'*,+E;I+,J&*'&<"++%E&+@%&Q"R&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'<<:+<%*+,&"E%&:*I'EC'E"+%>&:*+'&+@%&*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&'E>%E3&=*&CE"I+:I%J&+@:,&
<%"*,&+@"+&,+"+%,&I"**'+&E%$R&'*&9"C,&:*&>'<%,+:I&$"Q&",&"&[;,+:(:I"+:'*&('E&"&(":$;E%&+'&<%%+&"*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&'#$:9"+:'*3&
!@:,&,+"*>"E>&Q",&C%E@"C,&#%,+&%`C$":*%>&#R&+@%&A3)3=3\3&:*&+@%&U%""(]*2"#(A$#"J&Q@%E%&:+&@%$>&WI%E+":*&+@"+&SE"*I%&I"**'+&
E%$R&'*&@%E&'Q*&$%9:,$"+:'*&+'&$:<:+&+@%&,I'C%&'(&@%E&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&'#$:9"+:'*,3X&)",%&'(&+@%&SE%%&z'*%,&'(&bCC%E&N"P'R&"*>&
+@%&2:,+E:I+&'(&d%`&]SE3&s3&NQ:+Z3^J&-?4.J&A3)3=3\3&]N%E3&DO8^&M'3&01J&"+&?1J&-17&]\;*%&/^3&S'E&"*&%`C$"*"+:'*&#""(Peter
Malanczuk,&Akehursts Modern Introduction to International Law&14T16&]G';+$%>9%J&/+@&%>3&-??/^]-?/5^3&
D><:++%>$RJ&+@:,&$%9"$&CE:*I:C$%&:,&$%,,&$:B%$R&+'&#%&;+:$:Z%>&:*&>'<%,+:I&[;>:I:"$&#'>:%,&Q:+@&<'E%&,+"+%TI%*+E:I&:>%",&"#';+&
+@%&"CC$:I"#:$:+R&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&N+:$$J&+@%&>%$:#%E"+%&>:,E%9"E>&('E&%,+"#$:,@%>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,&:*&+@%&I",%,&
#%$'Q&]023%$.&*'+%&4.4^&E%<":*,&CE'#$%<"+:I&(E'<&"*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>C':*+3&&
&
6?&
'E&>'<%,+:I&$"Q&I"*&+E;<C&%,+"#$:,@%>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,J&%P%*&Q@%E%&+@%&,+"+%U,&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&'#$:9"+:'*,&"E%&#%:*9&%`C$:I:+$R&I'*,:>%E%>34.4&&
F*%&'(&+@%&'*$R&C',:+:P%&%`"<C$%,&'(&E:9@+,&%*('EI%<%*+&:*&+@%&A@:$:CC:*%,&I"<%&
Q:+@&+@%&-??4&N;CE%<%&)';E+&[;>9<%*+&:*&902*%#(W@*#$(?<(/"&%":$%7(*3(:'"(>"@$%:-"2:(*3(
G2?0%*2-"2:$,($28(E$:6%$,(!"#*6%&"#<dPe &=*&+@"+&I",%&"&9E';C&'(&<:*'E,&Q%E%&9:P%*&,+"*>:*9&
+'&I@"$$%*9%&+@%&>%,+E;I+:'*&'(&*"+:'*"$&E":*('E%,+,&Q:+@&"&I$":<&#",%>&:*&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&
E:9@+,&+'&"&W#"$"*I%>&"*>&@%"$+@(;$&%I'$'9RX&"*>&+'&W,%$(TCE%,%EP"+:'*&"*>&,%$(T
C%EC%+;"+:'*X&]#'+@&>:E%I+:P%&CE:*I:C$%,^34.6&!@%&)';E+&(';*>&+@"+&+@%&E:9@+,&+'&"&I$%"*&
%*P:E'*<%*+J&+'&%`:,+&(E'<&+@%&$"*>J&"*>&+'&CE'P:>%&('E&(;+;E%&9%*%E"+:'*,&"E%&
W(;*>"<%*+"$3X4.1&=+&"$,'&@%$>&+@"+&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*&E%c;:E%,&+@"+&+@%&9'P%E*<%*+&WCE'+%I+&
"*>&CE'<'+%&+@%&@%"$+@&'(&+@%&C%'C$%3X4./&!@%&'E:9:*"$&I$":<&Q",&#",%>&:*&C"E+&'*&"&I'*I%E*&
('E&Q"+%E&,@'E+"9%&,+%<<:*9&(E'<&>%('E%,+"+:'*34.7&!@%&I",%J&@'Q%P%EJ&>:>&$:++$%&+'&>%(:*%&
'E&>%(%*>&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&
N'I:"$&E%+:I%*I%&E%$"+%>&+'&@;<"*&E:9@+,&@",&<%"*+&+@"+&+@%&<"*"9%<%*+&'(&Q"+%E&:*&
+@%&A@:$:CC:*%,&:,&I"EE:%>&';+&:*&"&,+"+%TI%*+E:I&Q"RJ&Q:+@&$:<:+%>&]:(&"*R^&"IB*'Q$%>9<%*+&
'(&@;<"*&>:9*:+RJ&:*@%E%*+&%*+:+$%<%*+&'E&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*3&!@%&-?/1&V"+%E&)'>%J&('E&
:*,+"*I%J&C$"I%,&"$$&Q"+%E&E%,';EI%,&;*>%E&,+"+%&I'*+E'$&"*>&E%c;:E%,&+@"+&WeCfE%(%E%*I%&:*&
+@%&>%P%$'C<%*+&'(&Q"+%E&E%,';EI%,t&I'*,:>%E&,%I;E:+R&'(&+@%&N+"+%J&<;$+:C$%&;,%J&
#%*%(:I:"$&%((%I+,J&">P%E,%&%((%I+,&"*>&I',+&'(&>%P%$'C<%*+3X4.?&D$+@';9@&+@%&)'>%&%`%<C+,&
>E:*B:*9J&#"+@:*9J&I''B:*9&"*>&'+@%E&>'<%,+:I&;,%,&(E'<&"&C%E<:+&E%c;:E%<%*+J&@;<"*&
*%%>&"*>&$:P%$:@''>&"E%&*'+"#$R&:9*'E%>&(E'<&+@%&I"$I;$;,&'(&"CCE'CE:"+%&;,%J&"*>&+@%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&4.4&/""("<1<.&A@:$:C&K'EE:,&P3&)';E+&'(&DCC%"$,J&d3G3&M'3&?-44.J&..0&N3)3G3D3&6/1&]\;$R&-1J&-??4^&]A@:$3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3$"QC@:$3*%+O[;>[;E:,O[;E:-??4O[;$-??4O9Eh?-44.h-??43@+<$3&=*&+@:,&I",%J&+@%&)';E+&@%$>&+@"+&W+@%&("I+&+@"+&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&@",&#%%*&<">%&C"E+&'(&+@%&$"Q&'(&+@%&$"*>&>'%,&*'+&#R&"*R&<%"*,&:<C$R&+@%&CE:<"IR&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&
'P%E&*"+:'*"$&$"Q&:*&+@%&<;*:I:C"$&,C@%E%3&333E;$%,&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&"E%&9:P%*&"&,+"*>:*9&%c;"$J&*'+&,;C%E:'EJ&+'&*"+:'*"$&
$%9:,$"+:P%&%*"I+<%*+,3X&&483&"+&C"E"3&.-3&!@%&)';E+&+@%*&CE'I%%>%>&+'&C$"I%&<;*:I:C"$&$"Q&*?"%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"QJ&"E9;:*9&
+@"+&:+&W<;,+&,;#'E>:*"+%&"*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&"9E%%<%*+&:*",<;I@&",&+@%&"CC"E%*+&I$",@&:,&#%:*9&>%I:>%>&#R&"&<;*:I:C"$&
+E:#;*"$3X&483 /""($,#*(i;E'>"&P3&\"$"*>'*:J&74&PhiL. Rep.&-/-&]-?0?^&]A@:$3^&]Q:+@&"&,:<:$"E&E;$:*9^3(
&&&&4.0&FC',"&P3&S;$9%*I:'&N3&S"I+'E"*&\E3J&d3&G3&M'3&-5-574&]\;$R&45J-??4^&]A@:$3^J&%"@%02:"8(02&44&=_K&]-??0^&C3&-/43&/""($,#*&
COHRE(c), #6@%$&*'+%&65J&<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.?.3&
&&&&4.6&Saligang Batas ng Pilipinas [Constitution]&S%#&--J&-?7/J&"E+3&==&{&-1&]A@:$^3&&
&&&&4.1&S'E&"&,;<<"ER&'(&+@%&I",%&,%%&)'0,0@@02"#R(902*%#(W@*#$(?<(/"&%":$%7(*3(:'"(>"@$%:-"2:(*3(G2?0%*2-"2:$,($28(E$:6%$,(
!"#*6%&"#(Nmmd.&Child Rights Information NetworkJ(@++CHOOQQQ3IE:*3'E9O_"QO:*,+E;<%*+3",Cn=*,+=2o-.15&]$",+&
P:,:+%>&FI+3&-?J&.5-5^3&
&&&&4./&Const. ]-?7/^J&"E+3&==&{&-6&]A@:$^3&
&&&&4.7&!@%&I$":<&I:+%>&I'*I%E*&'P%E&"&W@',+&'(&%*P:E'*<%*+"$&+E"9%>:%,J&,;I@&",&]"^&Q"+%E&,@'E+"9%,&E%,;$+:*9&(E'<&+@%&
>ER:*9&;C&'(&+@%&Q"+%E&+"#$%t&e"*>f&]#^&,"$:*:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&Q"+%E&+"#$%3X&COHRE(c)J&#6@%$(*'+%&65J&"+&.?.3&
&&&&4.?&V"+%E&)'>%&'(&+@%&A@:$:CC:*%,J&AE%,:>%*+:"$&2%IE%%&M'3&-51/J&"E+3&47&]-?/1^&/4&F3d3&4660&]K"R&--J&-?//^&]A@:$3^3(&
&
15&
>'I;<%*+&@",&*%P%E&#%%*&"<%*>%>&+'&:*I$;>%&,;I@&"&E%(%E%*I%3445&=*&:+,&)'*I$;>:*9&
F#,%EP"+:'*,&'(&.557J&+@%&)LN)G&E%<"EB%>&+@"+&>%,C:+%&%*,@E:*%<%*+&'(&+@%&=)LN)G&",&
*"+:'*"$&$"QJ44-&W)'P%*"*+&CE'P:,:'*,&"E%&,%$>'<&:*P'B%>&#%('E%&'E&>:E%I+$R&%*('EI%>&#R&
*"+:'*"$&I';E+,J&+E:#;*"$,&'E&"><:*:,+E"+:P%&";+@'E:+:%,3X44.&\;>:I:"$&CE'+%I+:'*&('E&Q"+%E&
E:9@+,&Q:$$&I'*+:*;%&+'&,+"9*"+%&;*+:$&#'+@&S:$:C:*'&,+"B%@'$>%E,&"*>&I';E+,&I"*&'P%EI'<%&
+@%&,'I:"$&,+:9<"&,;EE';*>:*9&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&@;<"*&E:9@+,&,+"*>"E>,&$:B%&+@%&=)LN)G3&&
&
&
63&=*>'*%,:"&
&
&
D$+@';9@&=*>:"*&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&:,&;,;"$$R&*'+%>&('E&:+,&;*:c;%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&
E:9@+,J&'*%&I",%&(E'<&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&'(&=*>'*%,:"&<"R&#%&+@%&,+E'*9%,+&%`"<C$%&'(&
N';+@&D,:"*&,;CC'E+&('E&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3444&=*&.550&"&9E';C&'(&$%9"$&":>&'E9"*:Z"+:'*,&"*>&
MdF,&I@"$$%*9%>&+@%&_"Q&'*&V"+%E&G%,';EI%,J440&Q'EE:%>&+@"+&:+&:*">%c;"+%$R&
"IB*'Q$%>9%>J&>%(:*%>&"*>&CE:'E:+:Z%>&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&?0#^n^?0#(I:P:$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
('E&I'<<%EI:"$&%`C$':+"+:'*3446&!@%&$"Q&Q",&<%"*+&+'&E%C$"I%&+@%&-?/0&_"Q&'*&=EE:9"+:'*441&
"*>&Q",&,%%*&#R&IE:+:I,&",&"*&"++%<C+&#R&+@%&V'E$>&8"*B&+'&CE%,,;E%&"II%C+"*I%&'(&"&
CE:P"+:Z"+:'*&,I@%<%344/&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&445&48<&"+&"E+3&1J&-5g&DE+:I$%&..&"$,'&:*I$;>%,&"&E%(%E%*I%&+'&+@%&CE:'E:+R&'(&>'<%,+:I&"*>&<;*:I:C"$&;,%&'P%E&'+@%E&;,%,3&
We2f'<%,+:I&"*>&<;*:I:C"$&C;EC',%,&,@"$$&@"P%&"&#%++%E&(:9@+&'P%E&"$$&'+@%E&;,%,3X&483&"+&"E+3&..3&
&&&&44-&Const. ]-?7/^J&"E+3&==&{&.&]A@:$^3&
&&&&44.&)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&)'*I$;>:*9&F#,%EP"+:'*,&'(&+@%&)'<<:++%%&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&A@:$:CC:*%,J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.OAa_O)FO0J&q-.&]2%I3&-J&.557^J&"+&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@IE3'E9OE%(Q'E$>O>'I:>O0?4(?07753@+<$3&
&&&&444&=*>'*%,:"J&"$+@';9@&:*I$;>%>&:*&+@%&,%I'*>&>E"(+&'(&+@%&)FaGL&9;:>%J&@",&$"E9%$R&#%%*&:9*'E%>&#R&,I@'$"E,&E%P:%Q:*9&
*"+:'*"$&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&'E&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&"II%C+"*I%&'(&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&I'*I%C+&('E&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&
E:9@+,3&/""(COHRE(c)J&#6@%$(*'+%&653&
&&&&440&_"Q&'*&V"+%E&G%,';EI%,J&M'3&/&'(&.550J&The Official Gazette of Indonesia,&.550J&M'3&113&
&&&&446&N%%&#6@%$&{==&('E&"&>:,I;,,:'*&'(&+@%&>:((%E%*I%3&DCC$:I"*+,&I@"$$%*9%>&DE+:I$%,&?J&-5J&.1J&06J&.1J&75J&?-J&?.J&4?].^J&1&]4^&
"*>&].^J&47].^J&07]-^J&.?]6^&"*>&0?]0^J&"$+@';9@&+@%&)';E+&>%I:>%>&+'&E%P:%Q&+@%&$"Q&:*&:+,&%*+:E%+R3&\;>:I:"$&G%P:%Q&'(&+@%&
_"Q&M'3&/&'(&.550&'*&V"+%E&G%,';EI%,J&\;>9<%*+&'(&-4+@&\;$R&.556J&M'3&567T56?T515T514OAbbT&==O.5503&])3)3^&]=*>'*3^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3<"@B"<"@B'*,+:+;,:39'3:>OC;+;,"*OC;+;,"*h,:>"*9h%*9hA;+;,"*m.5567T56?T514m.5AbbT==T
.5503m.5557TAbbT===T.556m.5]bbm.5N2D^3C>(3&
&&&&441&_"Q&)'*I%E*:*9&=EE:9"+:'*J&M'3&--&'(&-?/0J&The Official Gazette of Indonesia,&-?/0J&M'3&163&!@%&$"Q&Q",&>E"(+%>&
"+&"&+:<%&'(&Q"+%E&"#;*>"*I%&"*>&>:>&*'+&%((%I+:P%$R&CE'+%I+&Q"+%E&,';EI%,&*'E&CE'P:>%&('E&<"*"9%<%*+3&/""(K'@"<">&
K'P"&D$UD(9@"*:J&A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*6%:L#(!"?0"H($28(:'"(U6:6%"(*3(D$:"%(C$H(02(428*2"#0$.&.]-^&L. Env. & Dev. J.&-J&0&
].551^3*
&&&&44/&48<&"+&43&&
&
1-&
&
D$+@';9@&:+&>'%,&*'+&%`C$:I:+$R&%*,@E:*%&"&WE:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJX&+@%&=*>'*%,:"*&
)'*,+:+;+:'*&CE'+%I+,&Q"+%E&",&"&>%E:P"+:P%&'(&'+@%E&%*+:+$%<%*+,3447&!@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*&"$,'&
E%9;$"+%,&Q"+%EU,&;,%&",&"&*"+;E"$&E%,';EI%&:*&:+,&%I'*'<:I&I@"C+%E,344?&!@:,&>;"$&CE'+%I+:'*&
('E&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&I:P:$&E:9@+&'(&%`C$':+"+:'*J&@'Q%P%EJ&Q",&*'+&<:EE'E%>&:*&+@%&
V"+%E&G%,';EI%,&_"Q3&D$+@';9@&+@%&$"Q&C$"I%>&"*&'#$:9"+:'*&'*&I:+ROE%9%*IR&9'P%E*<%*+,&
+'&<%%+&W%P%ER'*%U,&E:9@+&+'&'#+":*&Q"+%E&('E&+@%:E&<:*:<;<&>":$R&#",:I&*%%>,JX&+@%&
$"*9;"9%&>%,IE:#:*9&+@:,&,;#,:,+%*I%&E:9@+&Q",&*'+&>:,+:*9;:,@%>&(E'<&+@%&$"*9;"9%&
>%,IE:#:*9&+@%&,%C"E"+%&E:9@+&+'&%`C$':+&E%,';EI%,&Q:+@&"&$:I%*,%3405&!@%&$"Q&<"R&*%P%E&@"P%&
#%%*&:*+%*>%>&+'&>%(:*%&'E&CE'+%I+&@;<"*&E:9@+,340-&M%P%E+@%$%,,J&:*&CE"I+:I%&+@:,&$"IB&'(&
>:,+:*I+:'*&$%>&+'&"&$"IB&'(&"II';*+"#:$:+R&Q@%*&I'<C"*:%,&Q%E%&9:P%*&C%E<:+,&+'&%`+E"I+&
E%,';EI%,&+@"+&+@%*&@:*>%E%>&+@%&%*['R<%*+&'(&,;#,:,+%*I%&E:9@+,&#R&$'I"$&I'<<;*:+:%,340.&
&
!@%&=*>'*%,:"*&)';E+&%P%*+;"$$R&(';*>&+@%&$"Q&I'*>:+:'*"$$R&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$J&
<%"*:*9&+@"+&:+&Q",&CE%,;<%>&+'&#%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&Q@%*&"CCE'CE:"+%$R&:*+%ECE%+%>3404&
)'*I;EE:*9&[;,+:I%,J&@'Q%P%EJ&;,%>&+@%&)';E+U,&'C:*:'*&+'&(;E+@%E&>%(:*%&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&
Q"+%E&",&>%E:P%>&(E'<&+@%&=*>'*%,:"*&)'*,+:+;+:'*&Y&"*&%`%EI:,%&:*&$%9"$&I'*,+E;I+:'*&+@"+&
"$<',+&C%E(%I+$R&,;CC'E+%>&+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&"+&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$3&!@%&
)';E+&%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I%>&+@%&VaF&)@"E+%EJ&DE+:I$%&.6&'(&+@%&b2aGJ&DE+:I$%&-.&'(&+@%&
=)LN)GJ&DE+:I$%&.0]-^&'(&+@%&)G)&"*>&#'+@&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&-0&"*>&-6&'(&+@%&)LN)G3&!@%&
)';E+&@%$>&+@"+&+@%,%&,+"*>"E>,J&Q@%*&"II'<C"*:%>&#R&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+,&+'&$:(%&"*>&
Q%$$T#%:*9J400&<%"*&+@"+&+@%&,+"+%&@",&+@%&>;+R&+'&E%,C%I+J&CE'+%I+&"*>&(;$(:$$&+@%&E:9@+&+'&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&447&Undang-Undang Dasar Republik Indonesia [U.U.D.] 1945 (Constitution)&\;$R&6J&-?6?3&
M"<%$R&E:9@+&'(&I@:$>E%*&+'&>%P%$'C&"*>&#%&*;E+;E%>&]48<("+&"E+3&.78].^^J&+@%&E:9@+&+'Q"E>&+@%&(;$(:$$<%*+&'(&#",:I&*%%>,&]48<(
"+&"E+3&.7)]-^^J&+@%&E:9@+&+'&"&$:(%&'(&Q%$$T#%:*9&:*&#'>R&"*>&<:*>&"*>&('E&+@%&%*['R<%*+&'(&"&@%"$+@R&%*P:E'*<%*+&]48<("+&"E+3&
.7a]-^^J&+@%&E:9@+&+'&'#+":*&,'I:"$&,%I;E:+R&]48<("+&"E+3&.7a]4^^&"*>&+@%&E:9@+&+'&I;$+;E"$&:>%*+:+:%,&"*>&+@%&"IB*'Q$%>9<%*+&
'(&+@%&E:9@+,&'(&+E">:+:'*"$&I'<<;*:+:%,&]48<("+&"E+3&.7=]4^^3&
&&&&44?&483&"+&I@3&v=s3&&
&&&&405&)'*(;,:'*&#%+Q%%*&'$O(162$(@$O$0($0%&];,%&('E&>":$R&,;#,:,+%*I%^&"*>&'$O(162$(6#$'$($0%&]I'<<%EI:"$&;,%^3&!@%&(:E,+&
+%E<&:,&%,C%I:"$$R&>:((:I;$+&+'&;*>%E,+"*>&",&+E"*,$"+%>&:+&<%"*,&E';9@$R&]WQ"+%E&;,%&E:9@+&:*&;+:$:Z:*9&Q"+%EX^&"*>&>'%,&*'+&
,C%I:(R&Q"+%E&;,%&('E&%`C$':+"+:'*&'(&('E&>":$R&,;#,:,+%*I%3&/""&D$UD(9@"*:&#6@%$(*'+%&441&"+&73&
&&&&40-&D$UD(9@"*:&,;99%,+,&+@"+&+@%&("I+&+@%&$"Q&E%(%E%*I%,&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&"E+:I$%&44&]E%9"E>:*9&*"+;E"$&E%,';EI%,^&"*>&*'+&
"E+:I$%&.7a]-^&]+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%&"*>&Q%$$T#%:*9^&<"R&:*>:I"+%&+@"+&+@%&$"Q&Q",&*%P%E&<%"*+&+'&#%&"*R+@:*9&<'E%&+@"*&
E%,';EI%&<"*"9%<%*+&$%9:,$"+:'*3&48<&"+&-/3&/""($,#*(U.U.D. Const.&"E+3&.4J&.7a]-^&\;$R&6J&-?6?&]=*>'*3^3&
&&&&40.&D$UD(9@"*:&I:+%,&"&>%<'*,+E"+:'*&:*&+@%&)*,$2'$%a*(2:,+E:I+J&:*&Q@:I@&E%,:>%*+,&C:IB%+%>&"&Q"+%E&#'++$%E&('E&%`+E"I+:*9&
+''&<;I@&Q"+%E&(E'<&$'I"$&"c;:(%E,J&+@%E%#R&"((%I+:*9&:EE:9"+:'*3&483&"+&-.&*3&6.3&/""($,#*(8%+"&!%E["["@(!;"*T!;"*J&
F"2:,"-"2.(D"($%"(A*,*20#"8o&Gatra Magazine&].55.^3*
&&&&404&!@:,&$"*9;"9%&:,&+"B%*&(E'<&+@%&N+"+%<%*+&'(&)@":E<"*&'(&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+J&AE'(3&2E3&\:<$R&D,,@:>>:c:%J&N3a3&
/""(AE'(3&2E3&\:<$R&D,,@:>>:c:%J&N3a3J&)@":E<"*&'(&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+J&K"@B"<"@&i'*,+:+;,:&>"$"<&N:,+%<&
i%+"+"*%9"E""*&G%C;#$:B&=*>'*%,:"&]2%I3&--J&.556^J&$#(&0:"8(02(D$UD(9@"*:&#6@%$&*'+%&441J&"+&43&
&&&&400&U.U.D. Const. "E+3&.7aJ&\;$R&6J&-?6?&]=*>'*3^3&
&
1.&
Q"+%EJ&"*>&+@"+&+@%&9'P%E*<%*+&:,&'#$:9"+%>&+'&<%%+&W+@%&>":$R&*%%>,&'(&%P%ER&
:*>:P:>;"$3X406&&
&
=*&E%(%E%*I:*9&"$<',+&%P%ER&<"['E&$%9"$&,';EI%&('E&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"+&+@%&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$&Y&:*I$;>:*9&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6&Y&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&*'+&'*$R&
"CC$:%>&+@"+&,+"*>"E>&+'&:+,&'Q*&*"+:'*"$&I'*+%`+g&:+&"$,'&:<C$:I:+$R&%<#E"I%>&+@%&E:9@+U,&
<:*:<;<&I'E%3&S;E+@%E<'E%J&+@%&>%I:,:'*&">'C+%>&"&W#",:I&*%%>,X&"CCE'"I@&+'&:<<%>:"+%&
,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,&Q@:$%&E%c;:E:*9&+@"+&+@%&9'P%E*<%*+&I'*+:*;%&+'&CE'9E%,,:P%$R&E%,C%I+J&
CE'+%I+&"*>&(;$(:$$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&D$+@';9@&I'*I%E*,&('E&+@%&>%,:E"#:$:+R&'(&+@%&V"+%E&
K"*"9%<%*+&_"Q&C%E,:,+J&+@%&)';E+U,&Q'EB&"+&WI'*+%*+T9:P:*9X&CE'P:>%>&I'*IE%+%&,;CC'E+&
('E&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3&!@:,&,+"*>"E>J&:(&+E"*,<:++%>&"#E'">J&Q';$>&9E%"+$R&,+E%*9+@%*&
+@%&C',:+:'*&'(&,+"B%@'$>%E,&:*+%E*"+:'*"$$R3&
&
&
_D!=M&DKLG=)D&
13&DE9%*+:*"&
&
&
)'*I%E*,&'P%E&Q"+%E&CE'P:,:'*&:*&DE9%*+:*"&,+%<&(E'<&:*>;,+E:"$&C'$$;+:'*&"*>&(E'<&
(":$%>&CE:P"+:Z"+:'*&E%('E<,&:*&+@%&-??5,3&AE'P:*I:"$&I';E+,&@"P%&E%,C'*>%>&+'&+@%,%&
I@"$$%*9%,&#R&",,%E+:*9&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&#",%>&:*&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+&+'&"&@%"$+@R&
%*P:E'*<%*+3401&\;>:I:"$&"I+:P:,<&:*&,%P%E"$&CE'P:*I%,&@",&$%>&+'&I$":<,&+@"+&I';E+,&
*"+:'*Q:>%&*'Q&@"P%&"&$%9"$&#",:,&]+@';9@&*'*T*'E<"+:P%^&;C'*&Q@:I@&+'&CE'+%I+&"&E:9@+&+'&
>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E340/&DE9%*+:*%&I';E+,&@"P%&%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I%>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>'I;<%*+"+:'*&
:*&+@%:E&[;E:,CE;>%*I%J&"*>&@"P%&"$,'&>%P%$'C%>&,+E'*9&:<C$:I:+&]:(&:<C%E(%I+^&,;CC'E+&('E&
Q"+%EU,&<:*:<;<&I'E%3&!@%&DE9%*+:*%&I",%,&#%$'QJ&'(+%*&I:+%>&",&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&<'>%$,J&"E%&
"$,'&>%<'*,+E"+:P%&'(&+@%&9%*%E"$&"CCE'"I@&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&+"B%*&:*&<"*R&_"+:*&D<%E:I"*&
[;E:,>:I+:'*,3407&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&406&/""(D$UD(9@"*:J&#6@%$&*'+%&441.("+&?J&{.3&
&&&&401&DE+3&0-J&Constitucin Nacional [Const. Nac.](D;93&..J&-??0&]DE93^3&!@:,&"CCE'"I@&:,&I'<<'*&:*&_"+:*&D<%E:I"3&
)'$'<#:"*&I';E+,&@"P%&">'C+%>&,:<:$"E&[;>9<%*+,g&,%P%E"$&"E%&,;<<"E:Z%>&#%$'Q3&
&&&&40/&PicolottiJ&#6@%$&*'+%&..6J&"+&-.3&
&&&&407&D$+@';9@&'*$R&I",%,&(E'<&)'$'<#:"&"*>&DE9%*+:*"&"E%&I:+%>&@%E%J&I",%&$"Q&'*&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&@",&E%"I@%>&"&,:<:$"E&
$%P%$&'(&>%P%$'C<%*+&:*&%$,%Q@%E%&:*&_"+:*&D<%E:I"3&)',+"&G:I"*&[;E:,CE;>%*I%J&('E&%`"<C$%J&@",&E%c;:E%>&,%EP:I%&
%`+%*,:'*,&+'&+@',%&Q:+@';+&"II%,,3&8E"Z:$:"*&I';E+,&@"P%&#%9;*&+'&E%P%E,%&>:,I'**%I+:'*,3&/""(COHRE(C)J&#6@%$(*'+%&65J&
"+&.//3(8E"Z:$J&A%E;J&)@:$%&"*>&s%*%Z;%$"&@"P%&"$,'&E%I%*+$R&>%P%$'C%>&$:<:+%>&,;CC'E+&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&/""("<1<.&)'E+%&
&
14&
SE'<&-??-Y-???J&V'E$>&8"*B&"*>&=KST>:E%I+%>&(;*>:*9&#E';9@+&'*%&'(&+@%&
@:,+'ERU,&$"E9%,+&>%P%$'C<%*+&:*P%,+<%*+&CE'9E"<,&+'&DE9%*+:*"340?&D9E%%<%*+,&Q%E%&
#E'B%E%>&:*&"$$&.4&CE'P:*I%,&CE:P"+:Z:*9&Q"+%E&;+:$:+:%,J&I'P%E:*9&'P%E&15m&'(&+@%&
C'C;$"+:'*&#R&-???3465&)'EE;C+:'*&"*>&"&$"IB&:*(E",+E;I+;E%&I";,%>&"$<',+&:<<%>:"+%&
CE'#$%<,3&=*">%c;"+%&'P%E,:9@+&c;:IB$R&$%>&+'&C'$$;+:'*&#R&#'+@&:*>;,+ER&"*>&<"['E&,%EP:I%&
CE'P:>%E,&",&C''E&E%9:'*,&Q%E%&$%(+&Q:+@&:*I'<C$%+%&E%*'P"+:'*,&"*>&Q"+%E&CE:I%,&,+%">:$R&
:*IE%",%>3&=*&,'<%&C$"I%,&+"E:((,&9E%Q&#R&/5m&('E&+@%&C''E%,+&-5m&'(&+@%&C'C;$"+:'*J&Q@:$%&
CE:P"+:Z"+:'*&(":$%>&+'&I'**%I+&'P%E&65m&'(&C'+%*+:"$&I$:%*+,&+'&"&Q"+%E&,';EI%346-(V:+@&+@%&
'*,%+&'(&+@%&.55-&%I'*'<:I&IE:,:,J&#:$$&I'$$%I+:'*&E"+%,&>E'CC%>&#R&?5m&"*>&,@;+T'((,&
#%I"<%&E';+:*%3&!@%&,%$(T(:*"*I:*9&I"C"#:$:+R&'(&+@%&<"EB%+&>:,"CC%"E%>&"*>&"*R&"++%<C+&"+&
WI',+&E%I"C+;E%X&Q",&$',+346.&D,&M%$,'*&,;99%,+,J&WAE'(:+"#:$:+R&:,&+@%&B%R&+'&"$$&+@%&
"E9;<%*+,&('E&CE:P"+%&,%I+'E&CE'P:,:'*H&%((:I:%*IRJ&:*I%*+:P%,&+'&:<CE'P%&:*(E",+E;I+;E%&"*>&
:*I%*+:P%,&+'&I'*,%EP%3X464&=*&CE:P"+:Z"+:'*J&@'Q%P%EJ&Q"+%E&9%*%E"$$R&($'Q,&+'&<'*%RJ&*'+&
+'&*%%>3&DE9%*+:*"&CE'P%,&+@"+&Q@%*&CE'(:+"#:$:+R&>:,"CC%"E,J&Q"+%E&,+'C,&($'Q:*9&"+&"$$3460&(
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
N;CE%<"&>%&\;,+:I:"&e)3N3\3f&eN;CE%<%&)';E+fJ&.6&*'P:%<#E%&.55?J&WD$%["*>E'&A"C:I&2'<:*9;%Z&I'*&)'<;*:>">&=*>:9%*"&
DR<"E"&)@;Z<:Z"&R&b,<"9"<"JX&G'$&>%&$"&I";,"H.705T57J&E%I;E,'&>%&CE'+%II:*&])@:$%^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3C'>%E[;>:I:"$3I$O<'>;$',O8;,c)";,",O8)Dh%,+"05.3C@CnE'Q>%+"$$%oDDDM'ADDMDD);LEDD)jI'*,;$+"o55jI";,"o.705O.557j*;<I;"o0-.0.j,%IE%obM=)D&]:*&Q@:I@&+@%&)';E+&CE'+%I+%>&+@%&:*>:9%*';,&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&'(&"&
I'<<;*:+R&(E'<&(;$$&%`C$':+"+:'*&#R&"&#'++$:*9&I'EC'E"+:'*3&!@%&[;>9<%*+&CE'+%I+%>&"&,C%I:(:I&"<';*+&'(&(E%,@&Q"+%E&]?&
$:+%E,&C%E&,%I'*>^&"*>&"CC$:%>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,&]=_F&)'*P%*+:'*^&#;+&:*&E%$"+:'*&+'&02801"2*6#(%01':#&:*&#'+@&
*"+:'*"$&"*>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"QJ&*'+&+'&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&",&,;I@3(&
&&&&40?&/""&N%#",+:%*&a"I@%EJ&D*%,8H08"(D$:"%(9*?"-"2:(D02#(`0&:*%0"#Z(;%1"2:02$(D$:"%()%0?$:0Q$:0*2(/&'"-"(!62#(>%7.&
Michigan Quarterly Review&]K"E3&-4J&.550^3&/""($,#*.(dE%9&A"$",+J&='"(U*6%(/:"@#(D'0&'(>"#:%*7"8(;%1"2:02$J&
Prosperity UK,&S%#3&.554J&$?$0,$+,"($:&QQQ3CE',C%E:+R;B3I'<OCE',C%E:+RO"E+:I$%,O"E9%*3@+<$3&AE:P"+%&,%I+'E&
:*P'$P%<%*+J&$:*B%>&,+E'*9$R&+'&>%P%$'C<%*+&#"*B,J&Q",&(:E,+&:<C$%<%*+%>&:*&>%P%$'C:*9&I';*+E:%,&]-?75,^&"*>&Q",&'*$R&
,;#,%c;%*+$R&:*+E'>;I%>&+'&>%P%$'C%>&"*>&+E"*,:+:'*:*9&%I'*'<:%,&$:B%&DE9%*+:*"3&/""(=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&
a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&G%$"+%>&+'&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&!"@*%:(*3(:'"(GT@"%:(*2(:'"(4##6"(*3(
S6-$2(!01':#(W+,01$:0*2#(!",$:"8(:*(E*2^/:$:"(/"%?0&"()%*?0#0*2(02(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.&a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&b3M3&2'I3&
DOaG)O-6O4-J&q1&]\;*%&.?J&.5-5^&]#R&)"+"E:*"&>%&D$#;c;%Ec;%^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O:,,;%,OQ"+%EO:%`C%E+O"**;"$3@+<&]P:"&@RC%E$:*B&Q:+@&+@%&+:+$%&'(&+@%&>'I;<%*+^&
e@%E%:*"(+%E&E*2^/:$:"(;&:*%(!"@*%:f3(
!@%&CE:P"+:Z"+:'*&Q",&;*>%E+"B%*&C;E,;"*+&+'&_"Q&M'3&.41?1J&D;93&-7J&-?7?J&ev_=vT)f&D323_3D3&.000&]DE93^3&&
&&&&465&N%#",+:"*&d"$:"*:J&A";$&d%E+:%E&j&LE*%,+'&N@"E9E'>,BR3&D$:"%(3*%(C03"R(='"(4-@$&:(*3(:'"()%0?$:0Q$:0*2(*3(D$:"%(
/"%?0&"#(*2(A'0,8(9*%:$,0:7.&--4]-^&J. Pol. Econ. -J&?&].556^3&&
&&&&46-&\&\",'*&8E:IB%EJ&)%0?$:0Q$:0*2(*3(D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:(02(;%1"2:02$.&American University Trade Environment
Database .T4&].55-^.(@++CHOOQQQ-3"<%E:I"*3%>;O+%>OQ"+%ET"E9%*+:*"3@+<3&/""($,#*(8$;%<%$J&#6@%$&*'+%&6J&"+&?70g(
s:P:"*"&D$'*,'J(D$:"%($28(/"H$1"()%0?$:0#$:0*2(F*2"(/*6%.(Inter Press Service&]D;93&-6J&.554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOO:C,*%Q,3*%+O:*+%E*"3",Cn:>*%Q,o-?1?43&&
&&&&46.&8E:IB%E&#6@%$&*'+%&46-J&"+&4&
&&&&464&A";$&\3&M%$,'*J&S6-$2(!01':#.(:'"(90,,"2206-(>"?",*@-"2:(F*$,#.($28(:'"(U6:6%"(*3(>"?",*@-"2:(A**@"%$:0*2.&46]-.^&
World Dev. .50-J&.50?&].55/^3&*
&&&&460&=*&@%E&E%C'E+&'*&M'*TN+"+%&N%EP:I%&AE'P:,:'*J&+@%&=*>%C%*>%*+&L`C%E+&*'+%,&+@"+&9%*%E"$$RJ&@;<"*&E:9@+,&"E%&W*%;+E"$&
",&+'&%I'*'<:I&<'>%$,XJ&"*>&+@"+&+@%&>%I:,:'*&:,&$%(+&+'&+@%&,+"+%&",&+'&+@%&#%,+&Q"R&'(&:<C$%<%*+:*9&:+,&@;<"*&E:9@+,&
'#$:9"+:'*,3&E*2^/:$:"(;&:*%(!"@*%:.(#6@%$&*'+%&40?J&"+&q-6J&143&!@%&CE%,%*+&%,,"R&,;CC'E+,&+@:,&$%9"$&C',:+:'*J&*'+:*9&+@"+&
+@%&I@':I%&#R&"&,+"+%&+'&:*P'$P%&CE:P"+%&:*+%E%,+&"+&,'<%&$%P%$&'(&E%,';EI%&CE'P:,:'*&<"R&#%&"*&"CCE'CE:"+%&'*%J&"$Q"R,&
I'*,:>%E:*9J&@'Q%P%EJ&+@"+&We+e@%&N+"+%&I"**'+&%`%<C+&:+,%$(&(E'<&:+,&@;<"*&E:9@+,&'#$:9"+:'*,&#R&:*P'$P:*9&*'*TN+"+%&
&
10&
DE9%*+:*%,&%*['R&;*:c;%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*J&Q@:I@&@",&@%$C%>&E%>E%,,&,'<%&'(&
+@%,%&P:'$"+:'*,3&!@%&-764&)'*,+:+;+:'*&@",&#%%*&E%('E<%>&,:`&+:<%,J&<',+&E%I%*+$R&:*&-??6&
Q@%*&%$%P%*&+E%"+:%,&]:*I$;>:*9&+@%&=)LN)G^&Q%E%&:*I'EC'E"+%>&",&(;$$R&[;,+:I:"#$%3466&!@%&
N;CE%<%&)';E+&@",&@%$>&+@"+&$'Q%E&I';E+,&,@';$>&('$$'Q&+@%&";+@'E:+"+:P%&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*,&'(&
+@%,%&+E%"+:%,&Q@%E%&"CC$:I"#$%3461&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+,&]:*I$;>:*9&+@',%&>%E:P%>&(E'<&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'<<:+<%*+,^&"E%&'(+%*&CE'+%I+%>&#R&I$",,T"I+:'*&,;:+&#%9;*&Q:+@&"&I';E+T
'E>%E%>&:*[;*I+:'*&'E&$&&0p2($-@$%*<&;-@$%*&:*[;*I+:'*,&I"*&"$,'&#%&C$"I%>&#R&A;#$:I&
2%(%*>%E,J&,;#[%I+&+'&,;#,%c;%*+&E%P:%Q346/&D,&:*&=*>:"J&"*R'*%&I"*&:*:+:"+%&,;I@&"&I",%&:*&
+@%&C;#$:I&:*+%E%,+3467&&
!@%&(:E,+&*'+"#$%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&I",%J&9"2*%"#(A*--6208$8()$72"-0,dqm &"E',%&(E'<&"*&
:*[;*I+:'*&C$"I%>&#R&"&A;#$:I&2%(%*>%E&;C'*&$%"E*:*9&+@"+&+@%&9'P%E*<%*+&@">&*'+&+"B%*&
,+%C,&+'&,+'C&+@%&:*>;,+E:"$&I'*+"<:*"+:'*&'(&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E3&V@:$%&>E:$$:*9&"&*%Q&Q%$$J&
<%<#%E,&'(&+@%&A"R*%<:$&I'<<;*:+R&%*I';*+%E%>&@R>E'I"E#'*J&I'*(:E<%>&#R&"*&
:*>%C%*>%*+&E%C'E+3415&!@%&CE'P:*I:"$&)';E+&'(&DCC%"$,&(';*>&+@"+&+@%&9'P%E*<%*+&Q",&
E%,C'*,:#$%&('E&*%9$:9%*+&'P%E,:9@+&'(&"&*%"E#R&':$&I'<C"*RJ&"&P:'$"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&"&
@%"$+@R&%*P:E'*<%*+3&!@%&)';E+&'E>%E%>&+@%&9'P%E*<%*+&+'&CE'P:>%&.65&$OCO>&'(&I$%"*&
Q"+%E&+'&A"R*%<:$&Q:+@:*&07&@';E,&"*>&+'&W%*,;E%&+@%&CE'P:,:'*&'(&>:*B:*9&Q"+%E&#R&
"CCE'CE:"+%&<%"*,&Q:+@:*&06&>"R,3X41-&!@%&I",%J&+@';9@&*'+&%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I:*9&"*&
:*>%C%*>%*+&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&@",&#%%*&:*+%ECE%+%>&",&,+E'*9&[;>:I:"$&,;CC'E+&('E&,;I@&"&
E:9@+341.&K',+&:<C'E+"*+$RJ&:+&>%P%$'C,&"&+Q'TCE'*9%>&"CCE'"I@&,:<:$"E&+'&+@%&=*>:"*&I';E+&
:*&/<(g<(F$%1(?<(/:$:"(*3(\::$%()%$8"#'(#R&E%c;:E:*9&+@%&:<<%>:"+%&CE'P:,:'*&'(&"&,C%I:(:I&
"<';*+&'(&I$%"*&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&+'&<%%+&#",:I&*%%>,&Q@:$%&%*,;E:*9&+@"+&+@%&,+"+%&<'P%&
CE'9E%,,:P%$R&+'Q"E>&+@%&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+U,&(;$$&,I'C%3414&&&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
"I+'E,&:*&,%EP:I%&CE'P:,:'*3&=EE%,C%I+:P%&'(&E%,C'*,:#:$:+:%,&'(&+@%&$"++%EJ&+@%&N+"+%&E%<":*,&+@%&CE:<"ER&>;+RT#%"E%E&('E&+@%&
E%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&@;<"*&E:9@+,3X&48<($:(rNj<&=EE%,C%I+:P%&'(&+@:,&C',:+:'*J&<"*R&:<C'E+"*+&[;>:I:"$&I$":<,&I'*,:>%E%>&:*&+@:,&
I@"C+%E&@"P%&"E:,%*&(E'<&+@%&:<C%E(%I+&'E&:<CE'C%E&CE:P"+:Z"+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E%,';EI%,&"*>&"&$"IB&'(&,+"+%&'P%E,:9@+3&
&&&&466&{&/6J&q..J&Const. Nac.&DE9%*+:*"&E"+:(:%>&+@%&=)LN)G&:*&-?713&
&&&&461&V:*B$%EJ&#6@%$&*'+%&41J&"+&?3&
&&&&46/&DE+3&04J&Const. Nac.&]DE93^J&Q",&C"E+&'(&+@%&-??0&E%('E<3&
&&&&467&Litigating, #6@%$&*'+%&..7&"+&15g&{&04J&Const. Nac.&]DE93^3&
&&&&46?&)<"E"&>%&DC%$"I:'*%,&%*&$'&):P:$&R&)'<%EI:"$&e)DC%$3))&Mc*3f&eM%;c;%*&)';E+&'(&DCC%"$,&:*&):P:$&"*>&)'<<%EI:"$&
K"++%E,f&.O4O-??/J&WK%*'E%,&)'<;*:>">&A"R*%<:$&O&"II:*&"<C"E'&]9"2*%"#^&]DE93^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%,IET
*%+3'E9O;,Eh>'IO,%*+%*I:"hI<"E"hA"R*%<:$3+:(J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&COHRE(b), #6@%$&*'+%&.-4J&"+&---3&
&&&&415&D&,%9<%*+&'(&+@:,&E%C'E+&:,&E%CE:*+%>&:*&Picolotti,(#6@%$&*'+%&..6&"+&-43&
&&&&41-&9"2*%"#J&:%$2#,$:"8($28(%"@*%:"8(02&COHRE(b)J&#6@%$&*'+%&.-4J&"+&---3&
&&&&41.&/""(Picolotti(#6@%$&*'+%&..6J("+&-4g&COHRE(b)J&#6@%$&*'+%&.-4J&"+&---3&
&&&&414&/""(#6@%$(A"E+&.J&+@:,&N%I+:'*3&
&
16&
!@%&A"R*%<:$&E;$:*9&Q",&%I@'%>&#R&"&,;#,%c;%*+&[;>9<%*+&:*&"*'+@%E&-"2*%"#&I",%J&
+@:,&+:<%&('E&+@%&s"$%*+:*"&M'E+%&)'$'*R3410&D*&%"E$R&[;>9<%*+&:*&+@%&I",%&'E>%E%>&+@%&(E%%&
CE'P:,:'*&'(&-55&$OCO>&+'&%P%ER&I'<<;*:+R&:*@"#:+"*+&Q:+@:*&07&@';E,3416&D+&+@%&"CC%$$"+%&
$%P%$J&+@:,&'E>%E&Q",&,%%*&",&%((%I+:P%$R&:*I%*+:P:Z:*9&+@%&:$$%9"$&'II;C"+:'*&'(&$"*>&#R&
E%c;:E:*9&+@%&CE'P:,:'*,&'(&Q"+%E&+'&+@',%&Q:+@';+&+:+$%3&!@%&'E:9:*"$&E;$:*9&Q",&+@%E%('E%&
,+E;IB&>'Q*3&S'E+;*"+%$RJ&+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&'P%E+;E*%>&+@%&"CC%$$"+%&(:*>:*9J&"9":*&I:+:*9&
DE+:I$%,&0-411&"*>&0441/&'(&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*3&!@:,&+:<%J&@'Q%P%EJ&+@%&)';E+&%`C$:I:+$R&
<%*+:'*%>&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&E%(%E%*I:*9&E%$%P"*+&CE'P:,:'*,&'(&+@%&)G)3417&!@%&)';E+&"$,'&
I:+%>&+@%&CE'&@'<:*%dsm&"*>&%E9"&'<*%,dYX&CE:*I:C$%,&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&@;<"*&E:9@+,&$"Q&",&
9;:>:*9&:+,&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&'(&,+"+%&E%,C'*,:#:$:+R&+'Q"E>&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&&
8'+@&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&:+,&<:*:<;<&I'E%&@"P%&#%%*&<',+&I$%"E$R&>%(:*%>&
:*&I",%,&,+%<<:*9&(E'<&+@%&CE:P"+:Z"+:'*&Q'%,&'(&+@%&-??5,3&=*&\#6$%0*#($28(A*2#6-$8*%"#(
"2(>"3"2#$(8"(#6#(>"%"&'*#(?<(;16$#(8",(F%$2(B6"2*#(;0%"#.4/-&"&)';E+&'(&S:E,+&=*,+"*I%&@%$>&
+@"+&+@%&>:,I'**%I+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&,%EP:I%J&%P%*&('E&$"IB&'(&C"R<%*+J&P:'$"+%,&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&
E:9@+,&+'&$:(%&"*>&@%"$+@J&#;+&"$,'&:<C$:%,&"&P:'$"+:'*&'(&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&+E%"+R&'#$:9"+:'*,34/.&
=*&%*;*I:"+:*9&"&E;$%&'(&9%*%E"$&%((%I+J&+@%&'C:*:'*&E%I'9*:Z%>&"&E:9@+&+'&(E%,@Q"+%E&@%$>&#R&
$,,(&0:0Q"2#&E%9"E>$%,,&'(&+@%:E&"#:$:+R&+'&C"R3&&
=*&)E>'#"&,%P%E"$&R%"E,&$"+%EJ&+@%&)';E+&"9":*&CE'+%I+%>&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:*&+Q'&;+:$:+:%,&
I",%,J&+@:,&+:<%&Q:+@&I$%"E%E&,;CC'E+&('E&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"*>&"&<'E%&>%+":$%>&E%(%E%*I%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&410&!E:#;*"$&N;C%E:'E&>%&\;,+:I:"&>%&M%;c;p*&e!E:#3&N;C3&Mc*3f&eN;C%E:'E&!E:#;*"$&'(&\;,+:I%f&Ws"$%*+:*"&M'E+%&)'$'*RJ&
2%(%*,'E"&>%&K%*'E%,&M&4&I3&A'>%E&L[%I;+:P'&K;*:I:C"$&O&"II:*&"<C"E'X&]DE93^J&#6--$%0Q"8($28&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&
COHRE(b)J&#6@%$&*'+%&.-4J&"+&--43&
&&&&416&48<(!@%&)';E+&"$,'&E%c;:E%>&+@"+&"&<%"*,&('E&,+'E:*9&Q"+%E&#%&9:P%*&+'&+@',%&+''&C''E&+'&#%&"#$%3&
&&&&411&DE+3&0-J&Const. Nac.]E:9@+&+'&@%"$+@R&"*>&#"$"*I%>&%*P:E'*<%*+^3&
&&&&41/&DE+3&04J&Const. Nac.]E:9@+&+'&I'*+%,+&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$:+R&'(&"&,+"+%&"I+:'*^3&
&&&&417&!@%&)G)&"*>&:+,&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&"II%,,&('E&I@:$>E%*&:,&"<'*9&+@%&%$%P%*&+E%"+:%,&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$$R&:*I'EC'E"+%>3&
)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&G:9@+,&'(&+@%&)@:$>J&#6@%$&*'+%&643&
&&&&41?&!@%&CE'&@'<:*%&CE:*I:C$%&@",&#%%*&>%(:*%>&#R&+@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&'(&DE9%*+:*"&+'&@'$>&+@"+&:+&,@"$$&"$Q"R,&#%&
CE%(%E"#$%&+'&'C+&('E&+@%&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&+@"+&:,&$%,,&E%,+E:I+:P%&+'&,;I@&E:9@+,3&)'E+%&N;CE%<"&>%&\;,+:I:"&>%&$"&M"I:*&e)N\Mf&
eM"+:'*"$&N;CE%<%&)';E+&'(&\;,+:I%fJ&.6O7O.55?J&WN%#",+:*&DEE:'$"&R&F+E',&O&I";,"JX&q.4&]DE93^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3":>,$%`3'E9O,:+%h>'I;<%*+,O2GT5-40N3C>(&]W;#t(&6$28*(62$#(2*%-$#(*3%"Q&$2(-$7*%(@%*:"&&0p2.("#:$#('$+%u2(
8"(@%0-$%.(8"(,$(-0#-$(-$2"%$(56"(#0"-@%"('$+%u(8"(@%"3"%0%#"("2(,$(02:"%@%":$&0p2(,$('"%-"2v6:0&$(56"(%"#6,:"(-"2*#(
%"#:%0&:0?$(@$%$(,$($@,0&$&0p2(8",(8"%"&'*(3628$-"2:$,(&*-@%*-":08*3X^3&
&&&&4/5&LE9"&'<*%,J&(E'<&+@%&_"+:*&<%"*:*9&w:*&E%$"+:'*&+'&%P%ER'*%JU&:,&;,%>&:*&@;<"*&E:9@+,&$"Q&+'&E%(%E%*I%&'#$:9"+:'*,&'E&
E:9@+,&@%$>&#R&'E&+'Q"E>&%"I@&C%E,'*&%c;"$$R3&
&&&&4/-&\;Z9">'&M"I:'*"$&>%&AE:<%E"&=*,+"*I:"&>%&K'E%*'J&8;%*',&D:E%,&e-"&=*,+3&K3&83D3f&e_'Q%E&)';E+&'(&FE>:*"ER&
\;E:,>:I+:'*fJ&.-O7O.55.J&Wb,;"E:',&R&)'*,;<">'E%,&%*&2%(%*,"&>%&,;,&2%E%I@',&D,'I:"I:*&):P:$&IO&D9;",&>%$&dE"*&
8;%*',&D:E%,&N3D3&O&"II:*&"<C"E'(_"&_%R&8;%*',&D:E%,&e_3_383D3f&].55.T-46?^&q-&]DE93^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3$%9"$<"*:"3I'<3"EO>%E%I@'O("$$'h",'I:"I:'*hI'*,;<:>'E3@+<3&&
&
&&&&4/.&M"<%$RJ&=)LN)GJ&"E+3&--J&$28&)G)J&"E+3&.0].^]I^3&
&
11&
+'&+@%&E:9@+U,&,';EI%&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&)E>'#"&:,&*'+%>&('E&:+,&CE'9E%,,:P%&I'*,+:+;+:'*&
"*>&Q"+%E&I'>%J&Q@:I@&CE'+%I+&Q"+%E&",&"&P:+"$&%$%<%*+&"*>&CE:'E:+:Z%&I'<<;*"$&'P%E&
CE:P"+%&;,%34/4&=*&c6"?$8*(9016",(;21",(?<(;16$#(A*%8*+"#$#.4/0&+@%&S:E,+&=*,+"*I%&)';E+&
<'>:(:%>&"&I'*+E"I+;"$&'#$:9"+:'*&#%+Q%%*&"&CE:P"+%&:*+%E%,+&"*>&I'*,;<%E,J&:*IE%",:*9&+@%&
(E%%&CE'P:,:'*&'(&>":$R&Q"+%E&(E'<&65&+'&.55&$:+%E,&C%E&@';,%@'$>&C%E&>"R3&!@%&)';E+&@%$>&
+@"+&W+@%&CE'P:,:'*&'(&"&<:*:<;<&c;"*+:+R&'(&C'+"#$%&Q"+%Et&#%I";,%&'(&:+,&C;#$:I&;+:$:+R&
I@"E"I+%E&<;,+&#%&9;"E"*+%%>&+'&"$$&:*>:P:>;"$,3X&S:(+R&$:+%E,&Q",&E;$%>&:*,;((:I:%*+&+'&<%%+&
+@"+&<:*:<;<&",&:+&WI"**'+&9;"E"*+%%&+$#0&(&*280:0*2#(*3('710"2"($28('"$,:'3X4/6 &&
=*&9$%&'0#0*([*#"(B$6:0#:$(?<(A068$8(8"(Ap%8*+$.dYs (+@%&"CC$:I"*+,&"$$%9%>&+@"+&,%P%E"$&
C''EJ&';+$R:*9&*%:9@#'E@''>,&,;((%E%>&(E'<&"*&;*I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&$"IB&'(&"II%,,&+'&+@%&C;#$:I&
Q"+%E&,R,+%<&"*>&+@"+&%`:,+:*9&E%,';EI%,&Q%E%&#%:*9&I'*+"<:*"+%>&#R&;*+E%"+%>&,%Q"9%34//&
D$+@';9@&+@%&(:*>:*9&Q",&"9":*&CE:*I:C"$$R&#",%>&:*&+@%&E:9@+&+'&@%"$+@J4/7&+@%&)';E+&"$,'&
E%(%E%*I%>&"&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&#",%>&:*&DE+:I$%&.6&'(&+@%&b2aGJ&DE+:I$%,&--&"*>&-.&'(&+@%&
=)LN)G&"*>&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-63&!@%&)';E+U,&>%+":$%>&"++%*+:'*&+'&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
>%(:*:+:'*&<:EE'E%>&+@%&:**'P"+:P%&902*%#(W@*#$&[;>9<%*+&(E'<&=*>'*%,:"34/?&!@%&)';E+&
'*I%&"9":*&,;CC'E+%>&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&('E&Q"+%E&#R&E%c;:E:*9&+@%&CE'P:,:'*&'(&.55&$:+%E,&
C%E&@';,%@'$>&C%E&>"R&;*+:$&:+&I';$>&%*,;E%&(;$$&"II%,,&+'&C;#$:I&Q"+%E&,%EP:I%3&
!@%&,+"*>"E>&,%+&:*&8";+:,+"&@",&#%%*&;C@%$>&:*&'+@%E&I",%,&",&E%I%*+$R&",&.55/J&
Q@%*&+@%&NC%I:"$&D><:*:,+E"+:P%&)@"<#%E&('E&8;%*',&D:E%,&I'*(:E<%>&+@"+&+@%&,+"+%&:,&
E%,C'*,:#$%&('E&CE'P:>:*9&P;$*%E"#$%&,%9<%*+,&'(&+@%&C'C;$"+:'*&Q:+@&">%c;"+%&Q"+%E&
"II%,,J&%P%*&:(&+@:,&Q'EB&E%c;:E%,&I',+$R&<%",;E%,3&K'E%&,:9*:(:I"*+$RJ&+@%&)';E+&;,%>&:+,&
>%I:,:'*&+'&I'*>%<*&"*R&WE%+E'9E%,,:P%X&<%",;E%,&",&#$"+"*+$R&:$$%9"$J&<:EE'E:*9&+@%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&4/4&DE+3&113.J&Constitucin de la Provincia de Crdoba(DCE3&.1J&-?7/&])E>'#"J&DE93^g&_"Q&M'3&667?(",&<'>:(:%>&#R(
_"Q&M'3&7?.7J&)#"3J&K"R&.7J&-?/4J&83F3&.-O56O-?/4&]DE93^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3+'>'>%:;E%3I'<3"EO$%R%,OI'E>'#"O667?3@+<3&/""($,#*(PicolottiJ&#6@%$&*'+%&..6J&"+&-.3(
&&&&4/0&\;Z9">'&>%&AE:<%E"&=*,+"*I:"&>%&)E>'#"&e-"&=*,+3&)#"3f&e)'E>'#"&_'Q%E&)';E+&'(&FE>:*"ER&\;E:,>:I+:'*fJ&7O0O.55.J&
W|;%P">'&K:9;%$&D*9%$&R&'+E',&IO&D9;",&)'E>'#%,",&N3D&O&"II:*&"<C"E'X&]DE93^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&COHRE(b), ,;CE"&
*'+%&.51J&"+&--43&
&&&&4/6&|;'+"+:'*&+"B%*&(E'<&"&+E"*,$"+:'*&"*>&,;<<%ER&'(&+@%&I",%&(E'<&8E%+&!@%:$%J&2:E%I+'E&'(&_:+:9"+:'*&('E&)FaGL&]\;*%&
.-J&.5-5^]'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^]%<C@",:,&">>%>^3&
&&&&4/1&\;Z9">'&>%&AE:<%E"&=*,+"*I:"&>%&)E>'#"&e-"&=*,+3&)#"3f&e)'E>'#"&_'Q%E&)';E+&'(&FE>:*"ER&\;E:,>:I+:'*fJ&
-?O-5O.550J&WK"EI@:,:'&\',p&8";+:,+"&O&"II:*&"<C"E'X&]B$6:0#:$^(]DE93^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02(V:*B$%EJ&#6@%$&*'+%&41J&"+&
-53&
&&&&4//&/""(GorsbothJ&#6@%$(*'+%&.4J&"+&-13&
&&&&4/7&B$6:0#:$J&"+&q7J&%"@*%:"8(02(V:*B$%EJ&#6@%$&*'+%&41J&"+&--&]W!@%&)';E+&I'*+:*;%>&+'&C':*+&';+&+@"+&+@%&E:9@+&+'&@%"$+@&
:*I$;>%,&<%",;E%,&+'&#%&+"B%*&+'&CE%P%*+&>"<"9%,&+'&@%"$+@&,;I@&",&CE'P:>:*9&Q"+%E&"*>&'#$:9%,&e,:If&+@%&N+"+%&+'&+"B%&
C',:+:P%&<%",;E%,3X^3&
&&&&4/?&/""(M;<#%E&6J&+@:,&N%I+:'*3&
&
1/&
$"*9;"9%&:*&#'+@&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&4&"*>&-63&475&&D$+@';9@&+@%E%&"E%&'+@%E&E;$:*9,&(E'<&
,%P%E"$&>:((%E%*+&CE'P:*I%,&E%9"E>:*9&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&+@%&DE9%*+:*%&,+"*>"E>&",&>%P%$'C%>&:*&
+@%&I",%,&"#'P%&:,&:$$;,+E"+:P%&'(&+@"+&I';*+ERU,&$";>"#$%&"CCE'"I@&:*&E%I%*+&R%"E,347-&&
&
&
/3&)'$'<#:"&
&
&
)'$'<#:"&("I%,&>%P%$'C<%*+&I'*I%E*,&,:<:$"E&+'&DE9%*+:*"U,J&:*I$;>:*9&:*,;((:I:%*+&
I'**%I+:'*&+'&C;#$:I&"*>&CE:P"+%&;+:$:+:%,3&D,&:*&DE9%*+:*"J&)'$'<#:"*&I';E+,&@"P%&>%(%*>%>&
"II%,,&+'&Q"+%E&('E&C%E,'*"$&I'*,;<C+:'*&",&"&(;*>"<%*+"$&E:9@+&,:*I%&+@%&<:>T-??5,J&
>%E:P:*9&:+&CE:<"E:$R&(E'<&'+@%E&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+,J&#;+&Q:+@&>%(:*:+:'*"$&E%(%E%*I%&+'&+@%&
CE%P":$:*9&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*,%*,;,3&)'$'<#:"*,&$:+:9"+%&('E&E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*&+@E';9@&"*&
$&&0p2&8"&:6:",$.&'E&QE:+&('E&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&CE'+%I+:'*&,:<:$"E&+'&"*&$&&0p2&$-@$%*347.&&
)'$'<#:"&:,&"&C"E+R&+'&+@%&=)LN)GJ&"*>&:+,&CE'P:,:'*,&<;,+&#%&;,%>&+'&:*+%ECE%+&,%I+:'*,&'(&
+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*3474&!@:,&9:P%,&,'<%&*"+:'*"$&Q%:9@+&+'&+@%&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&'(&+@%&)LN)G3&
)'$'<#:"&:,&*'+%>&('E&:+,&%`C$:I:+&,;CC'E+&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&I'*I%C+&:*&'+@%E&,'I:'T
%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&I",%,J&"$+@';9@&+@%&,+"*>"E>&@",&*%P%E&#%%*&"CC$:%>&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&&
!@%&[;>:I:"$&,+"*>"E>&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*&Q",&(:E,+&>%P%$'C%>&:*&+@%&A$%,*#(
;,3*2#*(!*a$#(!*8%016"Q(I",%J470&Q@%E%&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&@%$>&+@%&C;#$:I&,%EP:I%&'(&
Q"+%E&+'&#%&"&(;*>"<%*+"$&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+&$:*B%>&+'&+@%&E:9@+,&+'&$:(%J&"*>&@%"$+@3476&W=*&
CE:*I:C$%JX&E%",'*%>&+@%&'C:*:'*J&WQ"+%E&:,&+@%&,';EI%&'(&$:(%&"*>&"&$"IB&'(&,%EP:I%&E;*,&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&475&/""(1"2"%$,,7(\;Z9">'&M"I:'*"$&>%&AE:<%E"&=*,+"*I:"&e-"&=*,+3f&eM"+:'*"$&_'Q%E&)';E+&'(&FE>:*"ER&\;E:,>:I+'*fJ&
-4O57O.55/J&WD,'I:"I:*&):P:$&C'E&$"&=9;"$>">&R&$"&\;,+:I:"&I3&d'#:%E*'&>%&$"&):;>">&>%&8;%*',&D:E%,&O&"III:*&"<C"E'JX&q&
vv=&]DE93^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3*%Q,<"+:I3%T
C'$3I'<3"EO:*>%`3C@CnC;#h:>o??j,:>o-501j":>o..?41j%:>o.7jM'<#E%N%II:'*o\;E:,CE;>%*I:"m.5):;>">m.5>%m.
58,3D,jDII:'*os%EDE+:I;$'3&
&&&&47-&/""("<1<.()'E+%&N;CE%<"&>%&\;,+:I:"&>%&$"&M"I:*&e)N\Mf&eM"+:'*"$&N;CE%<%&)';E+&'(&\;,+:I%fJ&-7O?O.55/J&W2%(%*,'E&>%$&
A;%#$'&>%&$"&M"I:*&I3&L,+">'&M"I:'*"$&O&"II:*&"<C"E'X&]DE93^&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3>%E%I@'T
I'<C"E">'3'E9O,%*+%*I:",O"E9!'#",3@+<3&
&&&&47.&_:+%E"$$RJ&W+E;,+%%,@:C3X&AE"I+:I%&%,+"#$:,@%>&#R(_3&.6?-J&*'P:%<#E%&-?J&-??-J&05&Diario Oficial&e23F3f&-16&])'$'<3^3&
&&&&474&Constitucin Political de Colombia [C.P.]&\;$R&6J&-??-J&{&?43&)'$'<#:"&E"+:(:%>&+@%&=)LN)G&:*&-?1?3&
&&&&470&)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&);"E+"&>%&G%P3J&*'P:%<#E%&4J&-??.J&L`C%>:%*+%&-??.T-707&
]A$%,*#(;,3*2#*(!*a$#(!*8%016"Q^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??.O!T6/7T?.3@+<&
D$$&)'*3&)';E+&>%I:,:'*,&"E%&"P":$"#$%&'*$:*%&"+&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"OE">:I">'EO#;,I"E3C@C3&
&&&&476&C.P.&"E+3&--J&"E+3&0?&])'$3^&]E%,C%I+:P%$R^3&!@%&E:9@+&+'&@%"$+@&:,&(E"<%>&",&"*&'#$:9"+:'*3&WeAf;#$:I&@%"$+@&"*>&
%*P:E'*<%*+"$&CE'+%I+:'*&"E%&C;#$:I&,%EP:I%,&('E&Q@:I@&+@%&,+"+%&:,&E%,C'*,:#$%3&D$$&:*>:P:>;"$,&"E%&9;"E"*+%%>&"II%,,&+'&
,%EP:I%,&+@"+&CE'<'+%J&CE'+%I+J&"*>&E%@"#:$:+"+%&C;#$:I&@%"$+@3X&]D;+@'EU,&+E"*,$"+:'*^3&DE+:I$%&0.&'(&+@%&$"Q&%,+"#$:,@:*9&+@%&
CE"I+:I%&'(&:6:",$&:,&"$,'&I'<<'*$R&E%(%E%*I%>&",&"&,';EI%&'(&"&E:9@+&+'&C;#$:I&;+:$:+R&,%EP:I%,&",&:+&%,+"#$:,@%,&$%9"$&
E%I';E,%&:*&I",%,&'(&>:,"9E%%<%*+&'P%E&CE'P:,:'*3&/""(_3&.6?-&'(&M'P3&-?J&-??-&])'$3^3&
&
17&
I'*+E"ER&+'&+@%&(;*>"<%*+"$J&:*>:P:>;"$&E:9@+&+'&$:(%3X471&!@"+&,+"*>"E>&Q",&(;E+@%E&
>%P%$'C%>&:*&"&,%E:%,&'(&,;#,%c;%*+&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&I",%,J&Q@:I@&,C%I:(:%>H&]"^&+@"+&+@%&E:9@+&+'&
Q"+%E&:,&#",%>&:*&@;<"*&*%%>&",&>%E:P%>&(E'<&DE+:I$%&411&'(&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*g47/&]#^&+@%&
E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&'*$R&%*('EI%"#$%&:*&,:+;"+:'*,&Q@%E%&"I+;"$&@;<"*&I'*,;<C+:'*&:,&"+&
,+"B%g477&"*>&]I^&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&(;E+@%E&#",%>&:*&+@%&E:9@+&+'&@;<"*&>:9*:+R347?&&
\;>9<%*+,&'(&+@%&$",+&,%P%E"$&R%"E,&@"P%&#%9;*&+'&%`C$'E%&+@%&C"E+:I;$"E,&'(&,;I@&"&
I'*,+:+;+:'*"$$RT>%E:P%>&E:9@+&Q:+@&%`C$:I:+&E%(%E%*I%&+'&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&,';EI%,&$:B%&+@%&
=)LN)GJ&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6J&"*>&E%9:'*"$&I",%&$"Q34?5 &=*&U,*%(G208([0-"2"Q(8"(A*%%"$(?<(
9"8",,t2()6+,0&(A*-@$20"#J4?-&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&'E>%E%>&+@%&,%EP:I%&E%I'**%I+:'*&'(&
"&61TR%"E&'$>&Q'<"*&,;((%E:*9&(E'<&"&,%E:';,&:$$*%,,&"*>&:*I"C"#$%&'(&"(('E>:*9&@%E&;+:$:+R&
#:$$3&):+:*9&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6J&+@%&)';E+&@%$>&+@"+&C"E+:%,&+'&+@%&=)LN)GJ&W@"P%&"&,C%I:"$&
'#$:9"+:'*&+'&CE'P:>%&+@',%&Q@'&>'&*'+&@"P%&,;((:I:%*+&<%"*,&Q:+@&+@%&*%I%,,"ER&Q"+%Et&
e"*>f&+'&%*,;E%&+@"+&Q"+%E&:,&"(('E>"#$%J&,+"+%,&C"E+:%,&<;,+&">'C+&+@%&*%I%,,"ER&<%",;E%,&
Q@:I@&<"R&:*I$;>%J&:*+%E&"$:"H&t&(E%%&'E&$'Q&I',+&Q"+%E3X4?.&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&'(&+@%&)LN)G&
Q%E%&@%$>&+'&#%&C"E+&'(&+@%&)'$'<#:"*&WI'*,+:+;+:'*"$&#$'IBX&"*>&+@%E%('E%&";+@'E:+"+:P%&:*&
;*>%E,+"*>:*9&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+,34?4&N;I@&"*&",,%E+:'*&:<C$:I:+$R&%<#E"I%,&+@%&<:*:<;<&
I'E%&]",&C"E+&'(&+@%&)LN)GU,&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*^&%P%*&:(&*'+&%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I:*9&+@%&I'*I%C+3&
=*&G*,37(U,p%"Q(?<(,$(;,&$,8t$(7(G-@%"#$#(9620&0@$,"#(+Q'&R%"E,&$"+%EJ(4?0&+@%&)';E+&
%,+"#$:,@%>&+@%&CE:'E:+R&'(&I@:$>E%*&:*&Q"+%E&CE'P:,:'*&#R&c;'+:*9&"E+:I$%&.0].^&'(&+@%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&471&A$%,*#(;,3*2#*(!*a$#(!*8%016"Q.&"+&{13&
&&&&47/&/""("<1<.()'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&NpC+:<"&>%&G%P3J&[;*:'&-7J&-??4J&L`C%>:%*+%&-??4T
?/-4(]A0%*(G80,+"%:*(C02$%"#(B"a$%$2*^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??4O!T.4.T?43@+<g&&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&NpC+:<"&>%&G%P3J&>:I:%<#E%&?J&.55?J&L`C%>:%*+%&.55?T.4006-.&
]9$%0$(8"(["#k#(9"802$()v%"Q^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??0O!T6.4T?03@+<3&
&&&&477&/""("<1<.&)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&);"E+"&>%&G%P3J&"9',+'&-J&.55.J&L`C%>:%*+%&.554T
1?/11/(][*%1"(S"%2$2(F*-"Q(w21",^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.554O!T0-5T543@+<3&
&&&&47?&/""("<1<.()'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&NpC+:<"&>%&G%P3J&"#E:$&.0J&.551J&L`C%>:%*+%&.551T
-.11.5?&];,?$%*(F$%&0$(A$?0"8"#^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.551O!T4-/T513@+<&
&]"&>%+%*+:'*&I",%&",,%E+:*9&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&",&*'*T>%EE'9;"#$%&:*&+:<%,&'(&$%9"$&:*+%E*<%*+^3&
&&&&4?5&/""&1"2"%$,,7&{&==J&+@:,&%,,"R3&
&&&&4?-&)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&AE:<%E"&>%&G%P3J&"#E:$&-/J&.55/J&L`C%>:%*+%&.55/T-0.17-7&
]U,*%(G208([0-v2"Q(8"(A*%%"$^(])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.55/O!T./5T5/3@+<3&
&
&&&&4?.&U,*%(G208([0-v2"Q(8"(A*%%"$J&"+&q0&]WI:0"2"2(,$(*+,01$&0p2("#@"&0$,(8"(3$&0,0:$%($16$(7(1$%$2:0Q$%(",(#6-020#:%*(2"&"#$%0*(
8"($16$($(560"2"#(2*(80#@*2"2(8"(-"80*#(#630&0"2:"#M(<(<(<(,*#(G#:$8*#()$%:"#(xblM(($"&">'CI:*&>%(Ixbl(@*,t:0&$#($8"&6$8$#("2(
-$:"%0$(8"(@%"&0*#Z(&*-*(",(#6-020#:%*(8"(!"#!$!$%&%#'($")!%#*%((*($(+$a*(&*#:*MMl<&
&&&&4?4&483&]Wx00l(G,()$&:*(42:"%2$&0*2$,(8"(>"%"&'*#(/*&0$,"#.(G&*2p-0&*#(7(A6,:6%$,"#('$&"(@$%:"(8",(+,*56"(8"(
&*2#:0:6&0*2$,08$8.($-@,0$28*(",("#@"&:%*(8"(@%*:"&&0p2(@*%(?t$(8"(:6:",$(8"(,*#(8"%"&'*#(3628$-"2:$,"#X^3&
&&&&4?0&)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&NpC+:<"&>%&G%P3J&>:I:%<#E%&?J&.55?J&L`C%>:%*+%&.55?T
.4006-.&]!*,37(U,p%"Q^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??0O!T6.4T?03@+<3&
&
1?&
)G)34?6&K',+&E%I%*+$RJ&:*&A$%*,02$(96%&0$(W:u%*,$(?<(G-@%"#$#()6+,0&$#(8"(E0"?$(G</<)J4?1&+@%&
)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&I"E%(;$$R&';+$:*%>&+@%&I'*+%*+&'(&+@%&)'$'<#:"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&#R&
c;'+:*9&DE+:I$%,&--&"*>&-.&'(&+@%&=)LN)GJ&+@%&,+"*>"E>,&'(&"P":$"#:$:+RJ&c;"$:+R&"*>&
"II%,,:#:$:+R&(E'<&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6J&)G)J&)L2DVJ&I",%&$"Q&(E'<&+@%&=*+%ETD<%E:I"*&
)';E+&"*>&%P%*&+@%&G%C'E+&'(&+@%&F)a)G&].55/^34?/&8R&I:+:*9&%$%P%*&CE%P:';,&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
>%I:,:'*,&(E'<&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+J&+@%&'C:*:'*&%((%I+:P%$R&IE'Q*%>&+@%&W:*%*,$&
[;>9<%*+&",&+@%&I;$<:*"+:'*&'(&+@',%&CE%P:';,&%(('E+,34?7&&
!@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&Q",&(:E,+&%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I%>&#R&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&:*&
-??/J4??&"*>&Q",&;,%>&+'&:>%*+:(R&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&'(&E:9@+,&$:B%&@';,:*9&"*>&@%"$+@&",&
E%I%*+$R&",&.5573055&=*&+@%&I",%&C6Q(9$%7(W#*%0*()$,$&0*(?<(A*,@$:%0$(G/)J05-&+@%&)';E+&
%<#E"I%>&+@%&)LN)GU,&E:9@+&+'&@%"$+@&(E"<%Q'EB&#R&9:P:*9&P%ER&>%+":$%>&I'*+%*+&+'&+@%&
<:*:<;<&I'E%J&>%(:*:*9&:<<%>:"+%$R&%*('EI%"#$%&",C%I+,&'(&+@%&E:9@+&(E'<&+@',%&,;#[%I+&+'&
CE'9E%,,:P%&E%"$:Z"+:'*&"*>&E%,';EI%&I'*,+E":*+,305.&N:<:$"E&CE'+%I+:'*&@",&*'+&R%+&#%%*&
%`+%*>%>&+'&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&CE'#"#$R&>;%&+'&+@%&)';E+U,&,+"*>:*9&I",%&$"Q&E%c;:E:*9&
;+:$:+:%,&C"R<%*+&%P%*&('E&+@%&(:*"*I:"$$R&:*I"C"#$%3&N%EP:I%&,;,C%*,:'*,&"E%&'(+%*&;C@%$>&:*&
)'$'<#:"J&"*>&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&@",&",,%E+%>&+@"+&leCf'P%E+R&>'%,&*'+&%`%<C+&'*%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&4?6&483&"+&03&
&&&&4?1&)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&N%9;*>"&>%&G%P3J&"9',+'&1J&.55?J&L`C%>:%*+%&.55?T..6?6-?&
]A$%*,02$(96%&0$(W:u%*,$^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.55?O!T601T5?3@+<3&
&&&&4?/&483&"+&43-T4343&
&&&&4?7&483&"+&4&I:+%,&!T64?O?4J&!T.00O?0J&!T6.4O?0J&!T5?.O?6J&!T&4/?O?6J&!T0-4O?6J&!T0-5O54J&!T--50O56J&!T./5O5/J&!T
5..O57&"*>&!T777O573&
&&&&4??&)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&<"R'&.7J&-??/J&L`C%>:%*+%&2T-100J&q6&])'$'<3^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??/O)T6.-T?/3@+<&]W_',&>%E%I@',&@;<"*',&:*I'EC'E"*&$"&*'I:*&>%&
c;%&%,&>%#%E&>%&$",&";+'E:>">%,&",%9;E"EJ&<%>:"*+%&CE%,+"I:'*%,&C#$:I",J&;*&&U'%&1*2#*41'2%4%1'#-*-14%($#-*
&(0#"%($#-*(*012(-*$(-*I#"-1'(-J&:>%"&>%&$"&I;"$&,;E9%*&$',&$$"<">',&>%E%I@',&@;<"*',&>%&,%9;*>"&9%*%E"I:*&'&
>%E%I@',&%I'*<:I',J&,'I:"$%,&R&I;$+;E"$%,3M^&]%<C@",:,&">>%>^3&
&&&&055&/"".("<1<.&)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&,%C+:%<#E%&.6J&.554J&L`C%>:%*+%&!T/44--.&R&/6115?&
]G86$%8*(9*2:"$,"1%"(C72"::^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.554O!T76?T543@+<g&)'E+%&
)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&%*%E'&..J&.550J&L`C%>:%*+%&!T1645-5&]9$26",([*#"(A"@"8$(G#@02*#$^&
])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.550O!T5.6T503@+<g&)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&
e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&[;$:'&./J&.551J&L`C%>:%*+%&!T--?./16&]9$%&*(F"%$%8*(9*2%*7(A$+%$^&])'$'<3^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.551O!T676T513@+<g&)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&
[;$:'&4-J&.557J&L`C%>:%*+%&!T-.7-.0/&]9$%&*(F"%$%8*(9*2%*7(A$+%$^&])'$'<3^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.557O!T/15T573@+<3&
&&&&05-&)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&N%9;*>"&>%&G%P3J&[;$:'&4-J&.557J&L`C%>:%*+%&.554T-.7-.0/J&!T
-.7?115J&!T-457-??J&!T-4-5057J&!T-4-6/1?J&!T-4.5051J&!T-4.7.46J&!T-446./?J&!T-44/706J&!T-447165J&!T-465655J&
!T-106.?6J&!T-101571J&!T-76660/J&!T-767??6J&!T-767???J&!T-76?577J&!T-71.547J&&!T-71.501J&!T-711?00J&!T
-71/4-/J&R&!T-71/4.1&]C6Q(9$%7(W#*%0*()$,$&0*^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.557O!T
/15T573@+<3&
&&&&05.&S'E&"*&"*"$R,:,&'(&+@%&I",%&,%%&D$:I:"&L$R&~"<:*&j&F,I"E&A"EE"&s%E"J&='"(!*,"(*3(A*6%:#(02(>"302021(S"$,:'()*,0&7R(='"(
A$#"(*3(:'"(A*,*-+0$2(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*6%:&]a"EP"E>&_"Q&NI@''$&a;<"*&G:9@+,&AE'9E"<&V'EB:*9&A"C%EJ&.557^J&$?$0,$+,"(
$:(@++CHOOQQQ3$"Q3@"EP"E>3%>;OCE'9E"<,O@ECO>'I;<%*+,O~"<:*hA"EE"hQ'EB:*9hC"C%E3C>(3&S'E&"&#",:I&%`C$"*"+:'*&'(&
+@%&)'$'<#:"*&I';E+U,&"CCE'"I@&+'&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&,%%()@'Q>@;ERJ&#6@%$(*'+%&./0J&"+&73(
&
/5&
(E'<&+@%&,'I:"$&'#$:9"+:'*&+'&@%$C&(:*"*I%&9'P%E*<%*+&%`C%*>:+;E%3X054&!@%&)';E+&>%<"*>,&
WE%,C'*,:#$%&;,%JX&E%c;:E:*9&+@%&C''E&+'&>E"Q&'*$R&Q@"+&+@%R&I"*&"(('E>3&N+E"*9%$RJ&+@:,&
C',:+:'*&Q",&E%:+%E"+%>&:*&W:*%*,$&"$'*9,:>%&+@"+&[;>9<%*+U,&E%(%E%*I%&+'&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
>'I;<%*+"+:'*&:*&,;CC'E+&'(&%I'*'<:I&"II%,,:#:$:+R3050&D$+@';9@&,;I@&[;>9<%*+,&>'&*'+&
I'*,+:+;+%&"&E%[%I+:'*&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"CCE'"I@J&+@%R&>%(R&"*&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%&
<:*:<;<&I'E%&",&>%P%$'C%>&:*&N%I+:'*&===&"*>&",&,;I@J&<"R&<"B%&:+&@"E>%E&+'&E%I'*I:$%&,;I@&
"*&"CCE'"I@&Q:+@&I;EE%*+&I",%&$"Q&:*&+@%&(;+;E%3&
&
&
F!aLG&GLd=FMN&
73&)'*+:*%*+"$&D(E:I"J&KLMDJ&M'E+@&D<%E:I"&"*>&+@%&A"I:(:I&
&
&
8%('E%&I'*,:>%E:*9&+@%&N';+@&D(E:I"*&I",%,J&:+&,@';$>&#%&*'+%>&+@"+&+@%&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&
+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:*&'+@%E&E%9:'*,&'(&+@%&Q'E$>&@",&<%+&Q:+@&P"ER:*9&>%9E%%,&'(&
,;II%,,3&V"+%E&E:9@+,&@"P%&(';*>&:*IE%",:*9&,;CC'E+&:*&+@%&D(E:I"*&)'<<:,,:'*J&",&*"+:'*"$&
[;>:I:"$&,+E;I+;E%,&"IE',,&D(E:I"&,'<%+:<%,&I"**'+&$%*>&%((%I+:P%&E%<%>R3056&!@%&
)'<<:,,:'*&@",&E%I%*+$R&>%$:<:+"+%>&,+"+%&'#$:9"+:'*,&+'Q"E>&Q"+%E&"II%,,J&:*I$;>:*9&
I'*>:+:'*,&'(&"II%,,:#:$:+RJ&"P":$"#:$:+RJ&"II%C+"#:$:+R&"*>&c;"$:+R&#",%>&:*&)LN)G&d%*%E"$&
)'<<%*+&-03051&V"+%E&E:9@+,&"E%&CE'+%I+%>&",&"&>%E:P"+:P%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&+@%&@:9@%,+&
"++":*"#$%&,+"*>"E>&'(&@%"$+@&:*&DE+:I$%&-1&'(&+@%&D(E:I"*&)@"E+%E305/&!@%,%&I",%,J&Q@:$%&
*'+"#$%&('E&+@%:E&CE'+%I+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:*&+@%&("I%&'(&*"+:'*"$&(":$;E%J&>'&*'+J&@'Q%P%EJ&
C',:+&,;I@&"&E:9@+&",&%`C$:I:+$R&#",%>&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q3&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&054&)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&!%EI%E"&>%&G%P3J&"9',+'&-J&.55.J&L`C%>:%*+%&.55.T6744.5&
][$0%*(9*%$,"#^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.55.O!T6?7T5.3@+<3&
&&&&050&A$%*,02$(96%&0$(W:u%*,$.(#6@%$(*'+%&4?1J&"+&03&&
&&&&056&V"+%E&E:9@+,&@"P%&#%%*&<',+&%`C$:I:+$R&",,%E+%>&:*&+@%&.55?&[;>9<%*+&:*&)FaGL&P3&N;>"*&E%$%",%>&+'&+@%&C;#$:I&:*&
\;$R&.5-53&AWS!G(?<(/68$2.(#6@%$&*'+%&763&!@%&"><:,,:#:$:+R&'(&+@%&,;#<:,,:'*J&I'*+%,+%>&#R&+@%&N;>"*J&Q",&C%E<:++%>&",&
N;>"*%,%&I';E+,&Q%E%&@%$>&+'&(":$&+@%&+%,+&'(&%((%I+:P%&E%<%>R&I'*,:,+:*9&:*&"P":$"#:$:+RJ&%((%I+:P%*%,,&"*>&,;((:I:%*IR&",&
>%P%$'C%>&:*&+@%&[$H$%$&A$#"<(2"Q>"&\"Q"E"&P3&d"<#:"J&D(E3&)'<<U*&a;<3&j&A%'C$%,x&G+,3J&)'<<3&M'3&-0/O?6&j&-0?O?1&
q4-&]K"R&--3&.555^3&!@%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&,+"*>"E>&Q",&CE%P:';,$R&%$"#'E"+%>&:*&SE%%&_%9"$&D,,:,+"*I%&dE';C&P3&z":E%J&D(E3&
)'<<U*&a;<3&j&A%'C$%,x&G+,3J&)'<<3&M'3&.6O7?J&0/O?5J&61O?-&j&-55O?4&]FI+3J&-??6^3&=*&+@:,&I",%&:+&Q",&,:<:$"E$R&
W:<CE"I+:I"$&'E&;*>%,:E"#$%&('E&+@%&I'<C$":*"*+&+'&,%:Z%&+@%&>'<%,+:I&I';E+,X&",&z":E%&Q';$>&*'+&%P%*&"IB*'Q$%>9%&+@%&
I'<C$":*+&#%('E%&+@%&)'<<:,,:'*3&483&"+&q&4/3&
&&&&051&48<&
&&&&05/&!@:,&[;E:,CE;>%*+:"$&,+"*>"E>&Q",&(:E,+&,%+&:*&U%""(C"1$,(;##0#:$2&"(F%*6@($28(W:'"%#(?<(]$0%"J&#;+&Q",&E%:+%E"+%>&:*&
AWS!G(?<(/68$2.("+&q.51T.-.3&
&
/-&
!@%&WP",+&<"['E:+RX&'(&9'P%E*<%*+,&:*&KLMD&@"P%&$"E9%$R&:9*'E%>&+@%&9E'Q:*9&
I'*,%*,;,&'*&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&!@E';9@&"&,%E:%,&'(&:*+%EP:%Q,&:*&.55/J&D,Q:+&8:,Q",&(';*>&+@"+&
WC'$:IR&<"B%E,&:*&+@%&<"['E:+R&'(&Q"+%ETE%$"+%>&:*,+:+;+:'*,&e:*&KLMDf&"CC%"E&+'&#%&%:+@%E&
;*"Q"E%J&'E&,'<%Q@"+&,;C%E(:I:"$$R&"Q"E%J&'(&+@:,&>%I$"E"+:'*&"*>&@'Q&:+&<"R&"((%I+&+@%:E&
Q'EB3X057&!@:,&:,&>%,C:+%&+@%&("I+&+@"+&+@%&E%9:'*&Y&C"E+:I;$"E$R&+@%&M:$%&"*>&\'E>"*&E:P%E&
#",:*,&Y&:,&@'<%&+'&,'<%&'(&+@%&Q'E$>U,&<',+&+E';#$:*9&Q"+%E&I'*($:I+305?&D,&:+&@"CC%*,J&+@%&
)LN)G&(:E,+&<%*+:'*%>&"&WE:9@+&+'&Q"+%EX&:*&E%(%E%*I%&+'&=,E"%$U,&+E%"+<%*+&'(&A"$%,+:*:"*,&
+@%E%&:*&-??730-5&!@%&))AG&@",&"$,'&+E%"+%>&=,E"%$U,&Q"+%E&C'$:IR&Q:+@&,C%I:"$&"++%*+:'*J&
,C%I:(R:*9&:*&:+,&.5-5&)'*I$;>:*9&F#,%EP"+:'*,&+@"+&+@%&>%*:9E"+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&"II%,,&('E&
A"$%,+:*:"*,&I'*,+:+;+%>&"&P:'$"+:'*&'(&+@%&=))AG&E:9@+,&+'&$:(%&"*>&%c;"$&CE'+%I+:'*30--&&
=*&M'E+@&D<%E:I"J&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&E%<":*&$"E9%$R&"&<"++%E&'(&I:P:$&CE:P:$%9%&"*>&*'+&"&
@;<"*TE:9@+,&%*+:+$%<%*+3&!@%&,+";*I@&;*Q:$$:*9*%,,&'(&)"*">"&+'&E%I'9*:Z%&+@%&E:9@+&+'&
Q"+%E&:,&*'+%>&"#'P%30-.&!@%&b*:+%>&N+"+%,&@",&"&$'*9&@:,+'ER&'(&:9*'E:*9&"$$&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&
E:9@+,J&,+%<<:*9&(E'<&"&)'$>&V"E&>:,"9E%%<%*+&Q:+@&+@%&bNNG3&!@%&b3N3&9'P%E*<%*+&,:9*%>&
+@%&=)LN)G&:*&-?/?J&#;+&@",&*'+&R%+&E"+:(:%>&+@%&)'P%*"*+&>;%&+'&#'+@&"&$"IB&'(&C'$:+:I"$&Q:$$&
"*>&+'&+@%&'((:I:"$&C',:+:'*,&'(&,%P%E"$&,;#,%c;%*+&AE%,:>%*+,&Q@'&I'*,:>%E%>&,'I:'T
%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&",&'*$R&W>%,:E"#$%&,'I:"$&9'"$,3X0-4&!@%&b3N3&N;CE%<%&)';E+&*'+"#$R&@%$>&:*&
C028#"7(?<(E*%-":&+@"+&W+@%&eb3N3f&)'*,+:+;+:'*&>'%,&*'+&CE'P:>%&[;>:I:"$&E%<%>:%,&('E&%P%ER&
,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&:$$3X0-0&=*&"&,C%%I@&#%('E%&+@%&">'C+:'*&'(&+@%&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&E%,'$;+:'*&
E%I'9*:Z:*9&"&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:*&.5-5J&+@%&b3N3&E%CE%,%*+"+:P%&,+"+%>&+@"+&+@%E%&:,&*'&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&057&8:,Q",J&9GE;J&#6@%$&*'+%&0/J&"+&.-6T.-13&
&&&&05?&/""("<1<.(Amnesty International, Troubled Waters: Palestinians Denied Access to Water&].55?^J&$?$0,$+,"(
$:&@++CHOOQQQ3*9'T<'*:+'E3'E9O>"+"O:<"9%,OS:$%OD<*%,+RhQ"+%Eh--.3C>(&]:*,:,+:*9&+@"+&,'<%&A"$%,+:*:"*,&;*>%E&
=,E"%$:&I'*+E'$&$"IB&#",:I&"II%,,&+'&Q"+%E&%P%*&#%$'Q&.5T.6&$OCO>^3&!@%&E%C'E+&<"R&@"P%&,'<%&,@'E+I'<:*9,&:*&:+,&
:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&'#$:9"+:'*,&:*I;<#%*+&'*&+@%&=,E"%$:&,+"+%J&@'Q%P%E3&S'E&"&IE:+:I"$&"*"$R,:,&,%%&\",'*&
8E'Z%BJ&!"?0"H(*3(;-2"#:7(42:"%2$:0*2$,L#(V=%*6+,"8(D$:"%#R()$,"#:020$2#(>"20"8(;&&"##(:*(D$:"%L(4]-^&Water
Alternatives -1-&].5-5^3&&
&&&&0-5&)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&)'*I$;>:*9&F#,%EP"+:'*,&'(&+@%&)'<<:++%%&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&=,E"%$J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.O-OD>>3./&]2%I3&0J&-??7^J&"+&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@IE3'E9OE%(Q'E$>O>'I:>O4(1I#041/3@+<$&]W!@%&)'<<:++%%&;E9%,&+@%&N+"+%&A"E+R&+'&E%I'9*:Z%&+@%&%`:,+:*9&
DE"#&8%>';:*&P:$$"9%,J&+@%&$"*>&E:9@+,&'(&+@%&:*@"#:+"*+,&"*>&+@%:E&E:9@+&+'&#",:I&,%EP:I%,&:*I$;>:*9&Q"+%E3X^3*
&&&&0--&!@:,&I",%&:,&%`C$'E%>&:*&#6@%$&{&==J&A"E+&DJ&*'+%&-5/3&
&&&&0-.&/""&#6@%$&{&==J&+@:,&%,,"R3&
&&&&0-4&David Shiman, Economic and Social Justice: A Human Rights Perspective ]-???^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ-3;<*3%>;O@;<"*E+,O%>;<"+O@E%>;,%E:%,O+#-#O:*>%`3@+<$3&
&&&&0-0&_:*>,%R&P3&M'E<%+J&056&b3N3&61&]-?/.^3&
&
/.&
WE:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&"*>&,"*:+"+:'*X&:*&"*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&,%*,%&",&>%,IE:#%>&#R&+@%&
E%,'$;+:'*30-6&!@%&b3N3&+@%*&"#,+":*%>&(E'<&P'+:*93&
!@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*,&'(&,%P%E"$&b3N3&,+"+%,&%*,@E:*%&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&]:*I$;>:*9&
Q"+%E&E:9@+,^&<'E%&I$%"E$R30-1&)%E+":*&I",%,J&$:B%&A$-@$012(3*%(U0#&$,(G560:7(?<(/:$:"(*3(E"H(
y*%O.(@"P%&%P%*&$:<:+%>$R&,;CC'E+%>&+@%&:>%"&'(&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%30-/&=+&:,&;*$:B%$RJ&@'Q%P%EJ&
+@"+&,+"+%&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&Q:$$&%P%E&"((%I+&(%>%E"$&,+"*>"E>,&Q:+@';+&+@%&%`C$:I:+&",,%*+&'(&+@%&
$%9:,$"+;E%&'E&%`%I;+:P%J&*'+:*9&I'*I%E*&'P%E&,%C"E"+:'*&'(&C'Q%E,30-7&
S:*"$$RJ&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&:*&+@%&A"I:(:I&E%9:'*&@"P%&#%%*&I'<C$%+%$R&,:$%*+&E%9"E>:*9&"&
@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&>%,C:+%&$'Q&$%P%$,&'(&"II%,,&:*&,'<%&C$"I%,30-?&D$+@';9@&<',+&'(&+@%,%&
-1&,+"+%,&@"P%&E"+:(:%>&+@%&=)LN)GJ&)G)J&"*>&)L2DVJ&'*$R&+@E%%&@"P%&%,+"#$:,@%>&*"+:'*"$&
@;<"*&E:9@+,&:*,+:+;+:'*,30.5J&0.-&=*+%E%,+:*9$RJ&*%:+@%E&D;,+E"$:"&*'E&M%Q&z%"$"*>&@",&
>%P%$'C%>&"&#'>R&'(&$"Q&E%I'9*:Z:*9&Q"+%E&",&"&@;<"*&E:9@+J&>%,C:+%&+@%&("I+&+@"+&#'+@&
I';*+E:%,&@"P%&E"+:(:%>&+@%&=)LN)G30..&=*&D;,+E"$:"J&=)LN)G&CE'P:,:'*,&"E%&*'+&>:E%I+$R&
%*,@E:*%>&:*+'&*"+:'*"$&$"QJ0.4&"*>&%`:,+:*9&*"+:'*"$&$%9:,$"+:'*&'*$R&C"E+:"$$R&CE'+%I+,&
Q"+%E&E:9@+,30.0&&=*&M%Q&z%"$"*>J&I'*I%E*,&'P%E&CE:P"+:Z"+:'*&%(('E+,&#%9;*&:*&+@%&%"E$R&
.555,&@"P%&R%+&+'&CE%I:C:+"+%&"&E:9@+,T>%(:*:*9&I@"$$%*9%&:*&*"+:'*"$&I';E+E''<,3&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&0-6&/""(N+"+%<%*+&'(&+@%&b*:+%>&N+"+%,&G%CE%,%*+"+:P%&+'&+@%&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$RJ&%"@%02:"8(02&AE%,,&G%$%",%J&#6@%$&*'+%&763&
&&&&0-1&/""("<1<.&C.A. Const.&"E+3&vJ&{&.3&
&&&&0-/&!@';9@&*%:+@%E&;,:*9&+@%&$"*9;"9%&W<:*:<;<&I'E%X&*'E&E%(%E%*I:*9&+@%&)LN)GJ&+@%&)';E+&*'+%,&"&WI'*,+:+;+:'*"$&
<:*:<;<X&('E&+@%&E:9@+&+'&%>;I"+:'*&E%C%"+%>$R3&)"<C":9*&('E&S:,I"$&Lc;:+R&P3&N+"+%&'(&M~J&-55&M3~&3.>&7?4&].554^J&C"E"&4g&
)"<C":9*&('E&S:,I"$&Lc;:+R&P3&N+"+%&'(&M~J&7&M3~3&4>&-0&].551^3&!@:,&"*"$R,:,&:,&#'EE'Q%>&(E'<&)@'Q>@;ERJ&#6@%$&*'+%&.7-J&
"+&-53&
&&&&0-7&)'*I%E*&('E&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&,%C"E"+:'*&'(&C'Q%E,&",&E%,+E:I+:*9&+@%&[;>:I:"$&%*('EI%<%*+&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&:*&
+@%&b*:+%>&N+"+%,&<:EE'E,&+@"+&'(&+@%&N';+@&D(E:I"*&,R,+%<&I'*,:>%E%>&#%$'Q3&
&&&&0-?&s"*"+";&"*>&+@%&N'$'<"*&=,$"*>,J&+@%&C''E%,+&:*&+@%&E%9:'*&:*&+%E<,&'(&>E:*B"#$%&Q"+%EJ&%*['R&/5m&"*>&15m&Q"+%E&
,;CC$R&I'P%E"9%&('E&+@%:E&C'C;$"+:'*,J&E%,C%I+:P%$R3&2"+"&"P":$"#$%&+@E';9@&c;%ER&"+&>$:$(902021(F$:"H$7.(
WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply and Sanitation(
@++CHOOQQQ3Q,,:*('3'E9O>"+"<:*:*9O+"#$%,3@+<$&]$",+&P:,:+%>&FI+3&-7J&.5-5^&],%$%I+&W;C>"+%&+"#$%X&$:*B&Q:+@&>%(";$+&
P"$;%,^3&
&&&&0.5&D;,+E"$:"J&M%Q&z%"$"*>&"*>&S:[:3&
&&&&0.-&!@%&A"I:(:I&G%9:'*&]bM&>%,:9*"+:'*^&:*I$;>%,&D;,+E"$:"J&M%Q&z%"$"*>J&A"C;"&M%Q&d;:*%"J&N'$'<'*&=,$"*>,J&s"*;"+;J&
)''B&=,$"*>,J&S:[:&"*>&N"<'"J&S%>%E"+%>&N+"+%,&'(&K:IE'*%,:"J&i:E:#"+:J&K"E,@"$$&=,$"*>,J&M:;%J&!;P"$;J&!'*9"J&M";E;&A"$";&
]"EE"*9%>&@%E%&#R&E"+:(:I"+:'*&E"+%&('E&WI'E%X&bM&a;<"*&G:9@+,&!E%"+:%,^3&/""(F((:I%&'(&+@%&a:9@&)'<<UE&('E&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&
G%9:'*"$&F((:I%&('E&+@%&A"I:(:IJ&!$:030&$:0*2(*3(S6-$2(!01':#(=%"$:0"#R(;88"8(`$,6"(3*%(:'"()$&030&(!"10*2&]\;$R&.55?^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOC"I:(:I3'@I@E3'E9O>'I,OG"+:(:I"+:'*8''B3C>(/*
&&&&0..&D;,+E"$:"&E"+:(:%>&+@%&=)LN)G&'*&-5&2%I%<#%EJ&-?/6&"*>&M%Q&z%"$"*>&'*&.7&2%I%<#%EJ&-?/73&
&&&&0.4&2%,C:+%&+@:,&("I+J&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&(';*>&:*&9020#:"%(3*%(4--01%$:0*2($28(G:'0&(;33$0%#(?(="*'&+@"+&D;,+E"$:"*,&@"P%&"&
w$%9:+:<"+%&%`C%I+"+:'*U&+@"+&>'<%,+:I&$"Q,&Q:$$&#%&:<C$%<%*+%>&:*&"&Q"R&I'*,:,+%*+&Q:+@&+@%&I';*+ERU,&+E%"+R&'#$:9"+:'*,3&
/""(9020#:"%(3*%(4--01%$:0*2($28(G:'0&(;33$0%#(?<(="*'&]-??6^&-74&)_G&./4&]_%%&\3&"*>&)"EE3&\3^&]D;,+$3^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(+7&
Child Rights Information Network, @++CHOOQQQ3IE:*3'E9O_"QO:*,+E;<%*+3",Cn=*,+=2o-04-&]$",+&P:,:+%>&FI+3&./J&
.5-5^3
&&&&0.0&!@E';9@&Q"+%E&<"*"9%<%*+&"*>&E%9;$"+:'*3&D<'*9&+@%&<',+&*'+"#$%&:,&+@%&D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:(;&:&PXXX&])+@^&
]D;,+$3^3&/""&\"*:I%&dE"R.(4-@,"-"2:021(:'"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%(02(;6#:%$,0$.(-/]-^(Hum. Rts. Defender&-J&0&].557^<&
&
/4&
&
&
DSG=)D&
?3&N';+@&D(E:I"&
&
&
N';+@&D(E:I"&@",&@">&:+,&'Q*&>E"<"+:I&,+E;99$%&Q:+@&>%P%$'C<%*+J&,;((%E:*9&"&C',+T
I'$'*:"$&@:,+'ER&'(&:*,+:+;+:'*"$:Z%>&'CCE%,,:'*&+@"+&I'*+:*;%,&+'&@"P%&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&
E%C%EI;,,:'*,&+'>"R3&D,&E%I%*+$R&",&.55/&+@%&I';*+ER&,;((%E%>&(E'<&05m&;*%<C$'R<%*+&
"*>&"&45m&$"IB&'(&"II%,,&+'&,;:+"#$%&@';,:*9J&:*I$;>:*9&C:C%>&Q"+%E30.6&!@%&-??1&WC',+T
"C"E+@%:>X&)'*,+:+;+:'*J&@%E"$>%>&('E&:+,&WE%>:,+E:#;+:P%X0.1&"*>&W+E"*,('E<"+:P%X0./ &
C'+%*+:"$J&,';9@+&+'&E%>E%,,&>%P%$'C<%*+&Q'%,&#R&%*,@E:*:*9&'(+%*&'P%E$''B%>&E:9@+,&,;I@&
",&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E30.7 &=*&("I+J&*'Q@%E%&:*&+@%&Q'E$>&:,&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&<'E%&I$%"E$R&
CE'+%I+%>&#R&$%9:,$"+:'*J&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&<'E%&%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I%>&:*&[;E:,CE;>%*I%J&
"*>&I",%&$"Q&<'E%&:<C'E+"*+&",&"&<'>%$&('E&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&E%C$:I"+:'*3&b*('E+;*"+%$RJ&+@%&
Q'EB&'(&+@%&N';+@&D(E:I"*&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&Y&+@%&(:*"$&"E#:+%E&('E&+@%,%&>%I:,:'*,&Y&@",&
E%,+E:I+%>&>:E%I+&"II%,,&+'&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*J0.?&I";,:*9&<"*R&+'&I'*,:>%E&
+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*&@",&@"P:*9&(":$%>&+'&E%"$:Z%&:+,&C'+%*+:"$3045&
&
N:*I%&+@%&-??5,J&I';E+,&@"P%&"++%<C+%>&+'&>:,+:*9;:,@&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E%,C'*,:#:$:+R&
(E'<&+@%&'#$:9"+:'*,&Q:+@:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'P%*"*+,&$:B%&+@%&=)LN)G&]Q@:I@&N';+@&D(E:I"&
@",&,:9*%>&#;+&*'+&E"+:(:%>^304-&!@:,&+E%*>&@",&$%>&+'&"&E%[%I+:'*&'(&I%E+":*&",C%I+,&'(&+@%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&0.6&_%@<"*J&#6@%$&*'+%&-1/J&"+&-103&
&&&&0.1&A%+%E&8'*>&j&\"IB:%&2;9"E>J&D$:"%.(S6-$2(!01':#($28(/*&0$,(A*23,0&:R(/*6:'(;3%0&$2(GT@"%0"2&"#.&.557]-^&L. Soc.
Just. & Global Dev. J. 4&]S%#3&--J&.557^J&@++CHOOQQQ.3Q"EQ:IB3"I3;BO("IO,'IO$"QO%$[O$9>O.557h-O#'*>h>;9"E>3(
&&&&0./&M:I@'$",&a"R,'<J&A*2#:0:6:0*2$,0#-.(9$a*%0:$%0$2(>"-*&%$&7($28(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#.&7]0^&N. Afr. J. Hum. Rts.&
06-J&06?T15&]-??.^3&
&&&&0.7&{./]-^]#^&"*>&].^J&Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, Act 108 of 1996&S%#3&0J&-??/&]W]-^&
LP%ER'*%&@",&+@%&E:9@+&+'&@"P%&"II%,,&+'t&]#^&,;((:I:%*+&(''>&"*>&Q"+%Et&]I^].^&!@%&,+"+%&<;,+&+"B%&E%",'*"#$%&$%9:,$"+:P%&
"*>&'+@%E&<%",;E%,J&Q:+@:*&:+,&"P":$"#$%&E%,';EI%,J&+'&"I@:%P%&+@%&CE'9E%,,:P%&E%"$:,"+:'*&'(&%"I@&'(&+@%,%&E:9@+,3X^3&
&&&&0.?&a'C%,&Q%E%&@:9@&('$$'Q:*9&+@%&-??1&(:*>:*9&'(&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&:*&:+,&)%E+:(:I"+:'*&\;>9<%*+&+@"+&,'I:'T
%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&W"E%J&"+&$%",+&+'&,'<%&%`+%*+J&[;,+:I:"#$%3X&/""&A"%:030&$:0*2(*3(:'"(A*2#:0:6:0*2(*3(:'"(!"@6+,0&(*3(/*6:'(;3%0&$(
-??1&]//^&ND&/00&]))^&]N3&D(E3^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&M3&d"#E;J&/*-"(A*--"2:#(*2(D$:"%(!01':#(02(/*6:'(;3%0&$.&7]-^&
Potchefstroom Elec. L.J.&6&].556^J&@++CHOO"['$3:*('O:*>%`3C@COC%$[O"E+:I$%OP:%QS:$%O04061O.1??-3&/""($,#*&8'*>&j&
2;9"E>J&#6@%$&*'+%&0-4J&"+&03&
&&&&045&/""("<1<.(_%@<"*J&#6@%$&*'+%&-1/J&"+&-103&
&&&&04-&N';+@&D(E:I"&,:9*%>&+@%&=)LN)G&:*&-??0&"*>&@",&R%+&+'&E"+:(R&:+3&{&4?]-^]#^J&S. Afr. Const.&-??1&E%c;:E%,&+@%&
I'*,:>%E"+:'*&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&Q@%*&:*+%ECE%+:*9&+@%&8:$$&'(&G:9@+,3&!@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&E;$%>&:*&9$OH$27$2"(+@"+&
*'*T#:*>:*9&E;$%,&'(&$"Q&"E%&"$,'&E%$%P"*+&:*&+E%"+R&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*3&/<(?<(9$OH$27$2"(-??6&]4^&ND&4?-&]))^&q46&]N3&D(E3^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3,"($::3'E9OZ"OI",%,OzD))O-??6O43@+<$3&=*&,'<%&I",%,&Q@%E%&+@:,&,+"*>"E>&@",&#%%*&+"I:+$R&
E%,C%I+%>J&@'Q%P%EJ&]",&:*&+@%&9$Q0+6O*(AA(I",%J&023%$&*3&006^J&+E;%&,;CC'E+&('E&+@%&I@"E"I+%E&'(&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<&
@",&CE'P%*&:$$;,'ER3&&
&
/0&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&>%(:*:+:'*&('E&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&$:B%&Q"+%EJ&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&I'*I%C+&'(&"&
W<:*:<;<&I'E%3X&!@%,%&,+"*>"E>,&@"P%&#%%*&"#"*>'*%>&:*&("P'E&'(&Q%"B%EJ&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&
+%,+,&'(&WE%",'*"#$%*%,,3X&K',+&E%I%*+$RJ&N';+@&D(E:I"*&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&@",&%P%*&
I@"$$%*9%>&+@%&CE:*I:C$%&'(&*'*T>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&"*>&+@%&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%&CE'C%E&E'$%&'(&
+@%&)';E+&"+&+@%&@%"E+&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&@;<"*&E:9@+,3&&
)",%,&I'*I%E*:*9&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&,+%<&(E'<&+@%&:*%c;:+"#$%&>:,+E:#;+:'*&'(&E%,';EI%,&
%,+"#$:,@%>&>;E:*9&DC"E+@%:>304.&D,&:*&DE9%*+:*"J&CE:P"+:Z"+:'*&C'$:I:%,&":<%>&"+&I',+&
E%I'P%ER&(":$%>&+'&">>E%,,&:*%c;:+RJ&I";,:*9&,@'E+"9%,J&>:,I'**%I+:'*,&"*>&"&9%*%E"$&
E%+E'9E%,,:'*&:*&"II%,,&$%P%$,3044&_%9:,$"+:P%&"++%<C+,&+'&">>E%,,&Q"+%E&,@'E+"9%&#%9"*&Q:+@&
+@%&D(E:I"*&)'*9E%,,&A"E+RU,&WdE'Q+@J&L<C$'R<%*+&"*>&G%>:,+E:#;+:'*X&]dLDG^&C'$:IR&:*&
-??13&!@%&C'$:IR&+"E9%+%>&"II%,,($%P%$,&#R(,%++:*9&"&SE%%&8",:I&V"+%E&]S8V^&%*+:+$%<%*+&'(&
,:`&B:$'$:+%E,&C%E&<'*+@J&"*>&CE%C":>&<%+%E,&Q%E%&:*,+"$$%>&:*&,'<%&"E%",&+'&<'E%&
%((:I:%*+$R&E%9;$"+%&CE'P:,:'*3040&!@%&C'$:IR&Q",&*'+&#",%>&'*&"&>%+%E<:*"+:'*&'(&P:+"$&*%%>,&
@'Q%P%EJ&"*>&Q",&*'+&+@%E%('E%&WE:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*3X046&V"+%E&E:9@+,&Q%E%&+'&#%&,"(%9;"E>%>&
#R&+@%&,:<;$+"*%';,&C",,"9%&'(&+@%&V"+%E&N%EP:I%,&DI+J&%*,;E:*9&%P%ER'*%&W"&E:9@+&'(&"II%,,&
+'&#",:I&Q"+%E&,;CC$RtX041&"*>&E%c;:E:*9&+@"+&,+"+%&C'$:IR&*%P%E&WE%,;$+&:*&"&C%E,'*&#%:*9&
>%CE:P%>&"II%,,&+'&#",:I&Q"+%E&,%EP:I%,&('E&*'*TC"R<%*+3X04/&!@%&+Q'&C'$:I:%,&Q%E%&+'&Q'EB&
:*&I'*I%E+J&#;+&>:,I'**%I+:'*,&C%E,:,+%>J&"*>&I",%,&Q%E%&,''*&#E';9@+&+'&I';E+3&DCC%"$,&
(E'<&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&+'&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&@"P%&#%%*&I'<<'*C$"I%&:*&,'I:'%I'*'<:I&
E:9@+,&$:+:9"+:'*3&
D+&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&$%P%$J&CE'+%I+:'*&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&@",&#%%*&<:`%>3&=*&9$25","(?<(
>6%+$2(=%$2#0:0*2$,(9":%*@*,0:$2(A*62&0,.047 &"&a:9@&)';E+&:*&2;E#"*&E;$%>&"9":*,+&+@%&
"CC$:I"*+&:*&"&>:,I'**%I+:'*&I",%J&"E9;:*9&+@"+&@%E&$',,&'(&"II%,,&Q",&$%9"$$R&[;,+:(:%>&#R&@%E&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&04.&V:*B$%EJ&#6@%$&*'+%&41J&"+&/3&
&&&&044&48<("+&0J&&0:021&G',%&SE"*I:,J&D$:"%([6#:0&"(02(/*6:'(;3%0&$R(E$:6%$,(!"#*6%&"#()*,0&7($:(:'"(42:"%#"&:0*2(*3(S6-$2(!01':#.(
G&*2*-0&#.($28()*,0:0&$,()*H"%.&-7]-^&Geo. Intl. Envtl. L. Rev.(-05T-?1&].556^3&
&&&&040&V:*B%EJ&#6@%$(*'+%&41J&"+&7g&8'*>&j&2;9"E>J&#6@%$&*'+%&0.1J&"+&?&]%`C$":*:*9&+@"+&.6&$OCO>&:*&"&@';,%@'$>&'(&%:9@+&:,&
@:9@%E&+@"*&+@%&*"+:'*"$&"P%E"9%&#;+&,+:$$&,;#,+"*+:"$$R&$'Q%E&+@"*&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&@;<"*&E:9@+,&*'E<^3&8%+Q%%*&-??1&
"*>&.55.&+@%&S8V&E%"I@%>&"CCE'`:<"+%$R&./&<:$$:'*&N';+@&D(E:I"*,3&8$;%<%$J&#6@%$&*'+%&6J&"+&?/?J&I:+%,&K:$$%**:;<&
AE'[%I+&!",B&S'EI%&/&'*&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&;&'0"?021(:'"(90,,"2206-(>"?",*@-"2:(F*$,#(3*%(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2R(D'$:(
0:(H0,,(=$O"(--1(]S%#3&-J&.550^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3;*<:$$%**:;<CE'[%I+3'E9O>'I;<%*+,O+(/:*+%E:<3C>(3&
&&&&046&!@%&1&B:$'$:+%E&$:<:+&Q",&"I+;"$$R&#",%>&'*&%I'*'<:I&%((:I:%*IR3&/""&8'*>&j&2;9"E>J&#6@%$(*'+%&0.1J&"+&7J&--&
]%`C$":*:*9&+@%&CE%I%>%*+&'(&+@%&C'$:IRJ&"&C:$'+&CE'[%I+&:*&2;E#"*&:*,+:+;+:*9&"*&W:*('E<"$&,%++$%<%*+&#%I";,%&:+&Q",&
I@%"C%E&+'&9:P%&"Q"R&+@%&Q"+%E&+@"*&+'&"><:*:,+%E&#:$$,&('E&:+X^3&
&&&&041&V"+%E&N%EP:I%,&DI+J&-57&'(&-??/J&"+&{&4]-^3&
&&&&04/&48<("+&0]4^]I^3&V@%*&"*&:*"#:$:+R&+'&C"R&I"*&#%&>%<'*,+E"+%>3&
&&&&047&9$25","(?<(>6%+$2(=%$2#0:0*2$,(9":%*<(A*62&0,.&.55.&].^&ND&4?&]2^&]N3&D(E3^3&
&
/6&
E%(;,"$&+'&,+'C&%`+E"I+:*9&Q"+%E&#%R'*>&@%E&,:`TB:$'$:+%E&"$$'Q"*I%&>%,C:+%&@%E&:*"#:$:+R&+'&
C"R&Y&"&@'$>:*9&,:<:$"E&+'&+@%&)'$'<#:"*&)';E+&:*&W:*%*,$304?&!@%&"CC$:I"*+&",,%E+%>&@%E&
E:9@+,&:*&+@%&V"+%E&N%EP:I%,&DI+J&#;+&+@%&)';E+&(';*>&+@%&DI+U,&CE'+%I+:'*&:*I'<C$%+%&"*>&
$"IB:*9&$%9:,$"+:P%&9;:>"*I%&('E&%*('EI%<%*+3005 &!@%&\;>9%&I'*,:>%E%>&Q"+%E&CE'P:,:'*&"&
WC'$:IR&<"++%EX&$:*B%>&+'&+@%&"P":$"#:$:+R&'(&E%,';EI%,&"*>&(":$%>&+'&%`+%*>&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&
CE'+%I+:'*J&",&+@%&"CC$:I"*+&>:>&*'+&I'*,:>%E&+@',%&E:9@+,&:*&@%E&"E9;<%*+300-&&
N%P%E"$&<'*+@,&$"+%E&"&a:9@&)';E+&:*&V:+Q"+%E,E"*>&%`@:#:+%>&"&<'E%&'C%*&"++:+;>%3&
=*&!"#08"2:#(*3(B*2(`0#:$(9$2#0*2#(?<(/*6:'"%2(9":%*@*,0:$2(C*&$,(A*62&0,J00.&+@%&)';E+&
9E"*+%>&"&E%c;%,+&('E&:*+%E:<&E%$:%(&+'&"&C''E&I'<<;*:+R&>:,I'**%I+%>&(E'<&+@%&Q"+%E&
,;CC$R3&!@%&[;>9<%*+&*'+%>&+@"+&>:,I'**%I+:'*&:,&"&CE:<"&("I:%&#E%"I@&'(&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&
'#$:9"+:'*&+'&E%,C%I+&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&"*>&+@"+&+@%&#;E>%*&'(&CE''(&('E&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&
I'<C$:"*I%&E%,+,&'*&+@%&E%,C'*>%*+3004&!@%&$%9"$&,+"*>"E>&:*&+@"+&I",%&Q",&,:<:$"E&+'&+@',%&
>%P%$'C%>&#R&I';E+,&:*&=*>:"&"*>&DE9%*+:*"J&"*>&+@%&[;>9<%*+&%P%*&E%(%E%*I%>&+@%&=)LN)G&
",&:*('E<:*9&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+3000&D&a:9@&)';E+&"9":*&>%(:*%>&"*>&CE'+%I+%>&Q"+%E&
E:9@+,&:*&"*&%"E$R&[;>9<%*+&'(&+@%&9$Q0+6O*&I",%&#%$'Q3&b*('E+;*"+%$RJ&@'Q%P%EJ&+@%&
'C:*:'*&Q",&'P%E+;E*%>&#R&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+J&Q@:I@&@",&>%P%$'C%>&"&E%C;+"+:'*&('E&
:9*'E:*9&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,&:*&("P'E&'(&$%,,T,+E:*9%*+J&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$$RT>%E:P%>&
,+"*>"E>,&('E&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3&
!@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+U,&F%**:+**-006&[;>9<%*+&('I;,%>&'*&@';,:*9&E:9@+,&('E&"&
I'<<;*:+R&'(&C''E&N';+@&D(E:I"*,&,;#[%I+%>&+'&W"C"E+@%:>T,+R$%X&%P:I+:'*,&(E'<&+@%:E&
,@"*+R&+'Q*J&V"$$"I%>%*%3001&D$+@';9@&+@%&I",%U,&'E:9:*"$&%<C@",:,&Q",&*'+&'*&Q"+%EJ&+@%&
)';E+&@%$>&+@"+&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&<;,+&#%&I'*,:>%E%>&+'9%+@%EJ&C$"I:*9&,C%I:"$&
%<C@",:,&'*&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:*&:+,&I'*,+E;I+:'*&'(&+@%&WE%",'*"#$%*%,,X&+%,+&('E&Q@:I@&+@%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&04?&483&"+&013&!@:,&Q",&#%('E%&+@%&:<C',:+:'*&'(&CE%TC":>&<%+%E,3&/""($,#*()'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&
)';E+fJ&N"$"&N%9;*>"&>%&G%P3J&"9',+'&1J&.55?J&L`C%>:%*+%&.55?T..6?6-?&]A$%*,02$(96%&0$(W:u%*,$^&])'$'<3^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.55?O!T601T5?3@+<J&#6@%$&*3&4743&
&&&&005&483&"+&04T003&
&&&&00-&483&
&&&&00.&!"#08"2:#(*3(B*2(`0#:$(9$2#0*2#(?<(/*6:'"%2(9":%*@*,0:$2(C*&$,(A*62&0,(.55.&]1^&8)_G&1.6&]V^&]N3&D(E3^3&
&&&&004&48<&"+&145T14.3&
&&&&000&!@%&[;>9%&E%c;:E%>&+@%&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&'(&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*&:*&$:*%&Q:+@&N';+@&D(E:I"U,&I'<<:+<%*+&+'&+@%&=)LN)G&
Q@:I@&:+&@">&,:9*%>&]#;+&*'+&E"+:(:%>^&:*&"II'E>"*I%&Q:+@&{&4?]-^]#^J&S. Afr. Const.&-??13&/""(!"#08"2:#.&"+&1.?3&
&&&&006&/*6:'(;3%0&$(?<(F%**:+**-(xF%**:+**-(AAl(.555&]--^&8)_G&--1?&]))^&]N3&D(E3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3I'*,+:+;+:'*"$I';E+3'E93Z"ODEI@:<"9%,O./?73A2S3(
&&&&001&483&"+&q-5&]WE%<:*:,I%*+&'(&"C"E+@%:>T,+R$%&%P:I+:'*,X^3&!@%&E%,:>%*+,&'(&+@%&,@"*+R&I'<<;*:+R&'(&V"$$"I%>%*%&
%E%I+%>&,@%$+%E,&'(&(';*>&<"+%E:"$,&Q:+@';+&"II%,,&+'&,"*:+"+:'*J&%$%I+E:I:+R&'E&'+@%E&C;#$:I&,%EP:I%,3&
&
/1&
[;>9<%*+&:,&'(+%*&I:+%>300/&=*&@:,&'C:*:'*J&\;,+:I%&~"I''#&\3&"E9;%>&+@"+&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*007&
E%c;:E%,&+@%&,+"+%&+'&CE'9E%,,:P%$R&:<C$%<%*+&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&Q:+@&"&I'@%E%*+&
CE'9E"<&'(&"I+:'*&:*&"&Q"R&+@"+&:,&%"$#*2$+,"&:*&#'+@&:+,&I'*I%C+:'*&"*>&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*J&
:*I$;>:*9&%$%<%*+,&'(&#"$"*I%J&($%`:#:$:+R&"*>&"++%*+:'*&+'&,@'E+J&<%>:;<&"*>&$'*9T+%E<&
*%%>,300?&!@%&E%",'*"#$%*%,,&,+"*>"E>&Q",&*'+&<%"*+&+'&>%+%E<:*%&+@%&W#%,+X&C'$:IR&
C',,:#$%J&#;+&'*$R&Q@%+@%E&'E&*'+&+@%&,'$;+:'*&:*&c;%,+:'*&Q",&"II%C+"#$%3065&N+"+%&C'$:I:%,&
:*&+@%&CE%,%*+&I",%&Q%E%&(';*>&+'&#%&;*E%",'*"#$%J&#%I";,%&+@%R&(":$%>&+'&WCE'P:>%&E%$:%(&+'&
+@',%&:*&>%,C%E"+%&*%%>3X06-&V@:$%&+@%&[;>9<%*+&CE'+%I+%>&+@%&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&'(&+@%&
"CC$:I"*+,&+'&,'<%&>%9E%%J&:+&E%[%I+%>&"*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&#",:,&('E&+@',%&E:9@+,3&
K"*R&,;99%,+%>&+@"+&+@%&)';E+U,&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&'(&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&
Q",&W,:<:$"EX&]+@';9@&*'+&:>%*+:I"$^&+'&+@%&)LN)GU,&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&:*&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&
-6306.&!@%&<"['E&>:((%E%*I%J&@'Q%P%EJ&Q",&+@"+&:*&,%++:*9&"&*%Q&,+"*>"E>&'(&
WE%",'*"#$%*%,,JX&+@%&)';E+&%((%I+:P%$R&;,;EC%>&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"CCE'"I@3064&!@%&
E%",'*"#$%*%,,&,+"*>"E>&c;:%+$R&#'EE'Q%>&,%P%E"$&%$%<%*+,&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%J&#;+&
Q%"B%*%>&+@%&'P%E"$$&I'*I%C+&#R&:*,:,+:*9&+@"+&,+"+%&C'$:I:%,&":<%>&"+&E:9@+,&E%"$:Z"+:'*&
<"R&#%&WE%",'*"#$%X&%P%*&:(&+@%R&>'*U+&"$Q"R,&E%,C'*>&+'&+@%&*%%>,&'(&+@%&<',+&
>%,C%E"+%3060 &8R&I'*+E",+J&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&Q';$>&@"P%&$:B%$R&E%c;:E%>&+@%&:<<%>:"+%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&00/&!@%&[;>9<%*+&:*&F%**:+**-&"$,'&*'+%>&+@"+&Q"+%E&I'*I%E*,&Q%E%&C"E+&'(&+@%&W$"<%*+"#$%X&$:P:*9&I'*>:+:'*,&'(&+@%&
"CC$:I"*+,&",&We+f@%R&@">&*'&Q"+%EJ&,%Q"9%&'E&E%(;,%&E%<'P"$&,%EP:I%,tX&F%**:+**-(AAJ&"+&q/3&!@%&E%",'*"#$%*%,,&
,+"*>"E>&<'>:(:%,&+@%&,+"*>"E>&'(&WE"+:'*"$:+RX&%,+"#$:,@%>&#R&"*&%"E$:%E&I",%J&/**+%$-*2"7(?<(9020#:"%(*3(S"$,:'.(gH$Q6,6(
E$:$,(-??7&]-^&ND&/16&]))^&]N3&D(E3^3&&
&&&&007&{.1J&S. Afr. Const.&-??13&
&&&&00?&F%**:+**-(AA.&"+&q0-T043&!@%&">"C+:'*&"*>&(;E+@%E&"CC$:I"+:'*&'(&+@%&$%9"$&,+"*>"E>&(:E,+&>%P%$'C%>&:*&/**+%$-*2"7&
Q",&I'*,:>%E%>&CE'#$%<"+:I&",&:+,&E%",'*:*9J&+@';9@&$%">:*9&+'&"&I'EE%I+&[;>9<%*+&:*&+@"+&I",%J&:,&I'*,:>%E%>&+''&E:9:>&('E&
"&)';E+&("I%>&Q:+@&%P%ET<'E%&I'<C$%`&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&I",%,3&/""(1"2"%$,,7.(NI'++&j&D$,+'*J&#6@%$&*'+%&-613&
&&&&065&!@%&)';E+&@%$>&+@"+&+@%&'#$:9"+:'*,&C%E<:++%>&"&WQ:>%&E"*9%&'(&C',,:#$%&<%",;E%,X&"*>&+@"+&+@%&)';E+J&+@%E%('E%J&
Q';$>&W*'+&%*c;:E%&Q@%+@%E&'+@%E&<'E%&>%,:E"#$%&'E&("P';E"#$%&<%",;E%,&I';$>&@"P%&#%%*&">'C+%>3X&F%**:+**-(AA.&"+&
q0-3&
&&&&06-&48<&"+&q113&!@:,&[;>9<%*+J&Q@:I@&(';*>&"&P:'$"+:'*&'(&{.1J&S. Afr. Const.&-??1&]+@%&E:9@+&+'&@';,:*9^J&#;+&*'&
P:'$"+:'*&'(&{.7J&S. Afr. Const.&-??1&]E:9@+,&'(&+@%&I@:$>&*'+&,;#[%I+&+'&CE'9E%,,:P%&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*^J&:,&,'<%Q@"+&
I'*(;,:*9$R&+@%&*@@*#0:"&'(&+@%&a:9@&)';E+U,&(:*>:*9&:*&"*&%"E$:%E&:*,+"*I%&'(&+@%&,"<%&I",%3&/""(F%**:+**-(?<(W*#:"2+"%1(
.555&]4^&8)_G&.//&])^&]N3&D(E3^3&!@%&a:9@&)';E+&<'>:(:%>&+@%&,+"*>"E>&,%+&:*&/**+%$-*2"7&Q:+@&+@%&+%,+&'(&
WE%",'*"#$%*%,,X&$"+%E&;,%>&#R&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+J&#;+&B%C+&+@%&,"<%&,C:E:+&'(&[;>:I:"$&>%(%E%*I%&('E&+@%&>%I:,:'*,&'(&
C;#$:I&'((:I:"$,&<">%&:*&W9''>&(":+@X&%`CE%,,%>&#R&+@%&)';E+&:*&+@%&%"E$:%E&I",%3&
&&&&06.&N%%J&%393J&8$;%<%$J&#6@%$&*'+%&6J&"+&?//T?/73&!@%&)';E+&"I+;"$$R&"E9;%>&+@"+&+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&WCE'9E%,,:P%&
:<C$%<%*+"+:'*X&:*&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&4&Q",&W:*&@"E<'*RX&Q:+@&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&>%(:*:+:'*3&F%**:+**-(AA.("+&q063&!@%&
)';E+&(":$%>J&@'Q%P%EJ&+'&:*I$;>%&"*R&E%(%E%*I%&+'&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%3&&
&&&&064&!@%&)';E+&@">&"$E%">R&E%[%I+%>&+@%&"CCE'"I@&:*&"&CE%P:';,&I",%&'*&+@%&E:9@+&+'&@%"$+@J&",&:+&Q",&#%$:%P%>&+'&IE%"+%&"&
CE'#$%<"+:I&E:9@+&'(&:*>:P:>;"$&C%+:+:'*&('E&:<<%>:"+%&I'E%&#%*%(:+,&+@"+&W,@';$>&*'+&#%&I'*,+E;%>X&(E'<&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*U,&
,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&CE'+%I+:'*J&%,C%I:"$$R&I'*,:>%E:*9&+@"+&,;I@&"*&%*+:+$%<%*+&Q';$>&#%&W:<C',,:#$%X&+'&"><:*:,+%E3&9020#:"%(
*3(S"$,:'(?<(=%"$:-"2:(;&:0*2(A$-@$012&]=;A^&.55.&]6^&ND&/.-J&q.1J&4.J&40T46&]))^3&
&&&&060&D;+@'E,&$:B%&)@"C<"*J&G;,,%$$&"*>&8:$I@:+Z&#%$:%P%&+@"+&~"I''#&\U,&I'*I$;,:'*&#%+E"R,&"*&:<C$:I:+&<:*:<;<&I'E%&
I"$I;$;,3&/""(8:$I@:+ZJ&#6@%$(*'+%&-/1J&"+&0?7g&Chapman & RussellJ&#6@%$&*'+%&-64J&"+&-?3&!@%&Q%"B*%,,&'(&+@%&,+"*>"E>&:,&
&
//&
CE'P:,:'*&'(&Q"+%E&+'&<%%+&+@%&#",:I&*%%>,&'(&"$$&V"$$"I%>%*%&E%,:>%*+,3&=(&,;I@&"&C'$:IR&
I';$>&*'+&@"P%&#%%*&:<C$%<%*+%>J&+@%&N+"+%&Q';$>&@"P%&#%%*&E%,C'*,:#$%&('E&[;,+:(R:*9&:+,&
(":$;E%&Q:+@&E%(%E%*I%&+'&"P":$"#$%&E%,';EI%,3066&!@%&)';E+&E%(%EE%>&+'&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&
'*$R&",&"&W>%+":$%>J&@%$C(;$&"*>&&%"$:0?"&"CCE'"I@&+'&+@%&>:((:I;$+&"*>&,%*,:+:P%&:,,;%,&
:*P'$P%>&:*&+@%&I",%3X061&D+&+@%&+:<%J&+@%&)';E+&:*,:,+%>&+@"+&:+&Q",&W*'+&*%I%,,"ERX&+'&>%I:>%&
+@%&;$+:<"+%&"CCE'CE:"+%*%,,&'(&+@%&"CCE'"I@J&$%"P:*9&'C%*&+@%&C',,:#:$:+R&'(&:+,&(;+;E%&
;,%306/&
!@%&>%I:,:'*&:*&F%**:+**-&:*IE%",%>&"*+:I:C"+:'*&('E&+@%&)';E+U,&,;#,%c;%*+&
[;>9<%*+&:*&+@%&.55?&C0280H"&9$Q0+6O*&I",%3067&!@%&I",%&:*P'$P%>&"&,;:+&#R&(:P%&E%,:>%*+,&
'(&A@:E:&:*&N'Q%+'J&"&>%,+:+;+%&;E#"*&>%P%$'C<%*+&#;:$+&>;E:*9&DC"E+@%:>&'*&+@%&';+,B:E+,&'(&
\'@"**%,#;E93&!@%&$:+:9"+:'*&I@"$$%*9%>&+@%&:<C',:+:'*&'(&+@%&S8V&A'$:IR&"*>&+@%&
:*,+"$$"+:'*&'(&CE%C":>&<%+%E,&:*&+@"+&>:,+E:I+3&!@%&E%,:>%*+,&'(&A@:E:&Q%E%&CE%P:';,$R&
"II;,+'<%>&+'&#%:*9&I@"E9%>&"&($"+&E"+%&('E&Q@"+&Q",J&:*&E%"$:+RJ&"*&;*<%+%E%>&"*>&
;*$:<:+%>&,;CC$R&'(&Q"+%E306?&&!@%&,;:+&"$$%9%>&+@"+&+@%&S8V&C'$:IR&P:'$"+%>&+@%&
I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&"*>&+@"+&+@%&:*,+"$$"+:'*&'(&CE%C":>&<%+%E,&Q",&]:*+%E&"$:"^&
"><:*:,+E"+:P%$R&;*(":EJ&>:,IE:<:*"+'ER&:*&"CC$:I"+:'*J&"*>&"&P:'$"+:'*&'(&+@%&V"+%E&N%EP:I%,&
DI+3015&!@%&9$Q0+6O*&I",%&:,&"&I$%"E&%`"<C$%&'(&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+U,&E%,+E:I+:P%&E:9@+,&
CE'+%I+:'*&:*&I'*+E",+&+'&+@%&<'E%&'C%*&[;>:I:"$&"++:+;>%&'(&+@%&a:9@&)';E+3&&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
#%+E"R%>&:*&+@%&)';E+U,&[;>9<%*+&:+,%$(J&,+"+:*9&+@"+&:(&+@',%&<%",;E%,&":<%>&"+&E%"$:Z:*9&+@%&E:9@+&W+@';9@&,+"+:,+:I"$$R&
,;II%,,(;$J&(":$&+'&E%,C'*>&+'&+@%&*%%>,&'(&+@',%&<',+&>%,C%E"+%J&+@%&e'*$Rf&-01':&*'+&(":$&+@%&+%,+3X&F%**:+**-(AA.("+&q16&
]%<C@",:,&">>%>^3&8:$I@:+Z&(:*>,&"&WI$":<&+@"+&:+&<"R&@"P%&#%%*&"II%C+"#$%&*'+&+'&I"+%E&('E&#",:I&*%%>,&W:(&+@%&*"+:'*Q:>%&
@';,:*9&CE'9E"<<%&Q';$>&E%,;$+&:*&"(('E>"#$%&@';,%,&('E&<',+&C%'C$%&Q:+@:*&"&E%",'*"#$R&,@'E+&+:<%3X&8:$I@:+Z.(#6@%$&
*'+%&-/1J&"+&0??3&
&&&&066&N%%(#6@%$&{&===3&
&&&&061&F%**:+**-(AAJ&"+&q-/&]E%(%EE:*9&+'&+@%&,;#<:,,:'*,&'(&$-0&0(&6%0$"&Q@'&%`C$:I:+$R&E%(%E%*I%>&+@%&"CCE'"I@^3&
&&&&06/(48<("+&q&443&
&&&&067&LP%*&#%('E%&:+&Q",&>%I:>%>J&9$Q0+6O*&Q",&%`C%I+%>&+'&W+%,+&+@%&$:<:+,&'(&+@%&%*('EI%<%*+&'(&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+&
+@E';9@&$%9"$&"*>&[;>:I:"$&<%"*,3X&8'*>&j&2;9"E>J&#6@%$&*'+%&0.1J&"+&-43&9$Q0+6O*(?<([*'$22"#+6%1&]9$Q0+6O*(AA^(.5-5&
]4^&8)_G&.4?&]))^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3,"($::3'E9OZ"OI",%,OzD))O.55?O.73@+<$3(
&&&&06?&!@:,&#"IB9E';*>&:,&#'EE'Q%>&(E'<(A%+%E&2"*I@:*J&;(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%_(='"(/*6:'(;3%0&$2(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*6%:L#(
>"&0#0*2(02(:'"(9$Q0+6O*(A$#".&EJIL Talk! Blog&]\"*3&-4J&.5-5^J&@++CHOOQQQ3%[:$+"$B3'E9O"T@;<"*TE:9@+T+'TQ"+%ET+@%T
,';+@T"(E:I"*TI'*,+:+;+:'*"$TI';E+U,T>%I:,:'*T:*T+@%T<"Z:#;B'TI",%O3&2"*I@:*&<:,+"B%*$R&:*,:,+,&+@"+&+@%&)';E+&E%[%I+%>&
+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"CCE'"I@&>%,C:+%&+@%&:*,:,+%*I%&'(&+@%&$%9"$&+%"<&$:+:9"+:*9&+@%&I",%3&!@:,&:,&*'+&,+E:I+$R&+E;%J&",&,;I@&"*&
"CCE'"I@&Q",&*%P%E&">P'I"+%>&#R&QE:++%*&,;#<:,,:'*3(
&&&&015&9$Q0+6O*(AA.&"+&-4-<(;2:0T>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&:,&;C@%$>&#R&{?J&S. Afr. Const.&-??13&&D$$&)';E+&,;#<:,,:'*,&"*>&
[;>9<%*+,&I"*&#%&(';*>&"+H&@++CHOOQQQ3%,IET*%+3'E9OI",%$"QOI",%$"Qh,@'Q3@+<n>'Ih:>o---54.13&
&
/7&
=*&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&'C:*:'*J&\;,+:I%&!',B"&E%I'9*:Z%>&+@%&'CC'E+;*:+R&+'&"CC$R&"&
<:*:<;<&I'E%&I"$I;$;,&$%(+&'C%*&#R&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&:*&F%**:+**-301-&!',B"&
,;99%,+%>&+@"+&"&$"IB&'(&:*('E<"+:'*&E%,+E:I+%>&+@%&"CC$:I"+:'*&'(&+@:,&,+"*>"E>&:*&CE%P:';,&
I",%,J&"*>&+@"+&Q@%*&,;((:I:%*+&:*('E<"+:'*&:,&"P":$"#$%J&+@%&)';E+&,@';$>&"CC$R&"&<:*:<;<&
I'E%&I"$I;$;,301.&!@%&[;>9<%*+&"$,'&*'+%>&+@"+&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&$%*>&+@%<,%$P%,&<'E%&%",:$R&+'&
"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"CCE'"I@&+@"*&@';,:*9&E:9@+,J&"*>&+@"+&"&#",:I&$%P%$&'(&<:*:<;<&CE'P:,:'*&
]:*&+@:,&I",%&65&$OCO>^&Y&+@';9@&E%c;:E:*9&"&I",%T#RTI",%&">[;,+<%*+&Y&:,&9%*%E"$$R&
>%+%E<:*"#$%3014&=*&:+,&[;>9<%*+J&+@%&)';E+&<">%&%`+%*,:P%&E%(%E%*I%&+'&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&"*>&
I'<C"E"+:P%&$"Q&'*&,%EP:I%&>:,I'**%I+:'*,J&,+E'*9$R&,;CC'E+:*9&+@%&9$'#"$&I'*,%*,;,&'*&
Q"+%E&E:9@+,3010&=*&+@%&%*>J&+@%&)';E+&(';*>H&]"^&+@"+&CE%C":>&<%+%E,&I;+&'((&Q"+%E&Q:+@';+&
E%",'*"#$%&*'+:I%J&CE'@:#:+:*9&%`C$"*"+:'*&('E&(:*"*I:"$&I'*,+E":*+J&]#^&+@"+&+@%&:*,+"$$"+:'*&
'(&+@%&<%+%E,&Q",&"><:*:,+E"+:P%$R&;*(":E&"*>&]I^&+@"+&:*,+"$$"+:'*&Q",&I"EE:%>&';+&:*&#$"IB&
I'<<;*:+:%,&Q@:$%&<'E%&$%%Q"R&Q",&9:P%*&+'&Q@:+%&,%++$%<%*+,&Y&"&>:,IE:<:*"+'ER&
CE"I+:I%3016 &!@%&a:9@&)';E+U,&$'9:I&I'<CE%@%*,:P%$R&,;CC'E+%>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
*'E<,&Y&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&Y&>%,C:+%&+@%:E&,+E:I+&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&I'*,+E;I+:'*3&!@:,&
,+"*>"E>&$"E9%$R&@%$>&'*&:*:+:"$&"CC%"$3011&!@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+U,&,;#,%c;%*+&E%C%"$&'(&
+@"+&>%I:,:'*&Q",&,'&E%,+E:I+:P%J&@'Q%P%EJ&+@"+&:+&@",&+@E'Q*&:*+'&c;%,+:'*&+@%&%*+:E%&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*,%*,;,&>%P%$'C%>&+@;,&("E3&
=*&:+,&[;>9<%*+J&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&I'*I$;>%>&+@"+&+@%&S8V&A'$:IR&]"*>&+@%&
:*,+"$$"+:'*&'(&CE%C":>&<%+%E,^&>:>&*'+&I@"$$%*9%&+@%&V"+%E&N%EP:I%,&DI+&'E&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*&
"*>&Q",&:*&("I+&WE%",'*"#$%X&:*&:+,&I'*I%C+;"$:Z"+:'*&"*>&%`%I;+:'*3&L,,%*+:"$$RJ&+@%&)';E+&
"E9;%>&+@"+&E%,:>%*+,&Q%E%&,+:$$&E%I%:P:*9&Q"+%E&"*>&+@"+&+@%&,;CC$R&Q",&'*$R&W+%<C'E"E:$R&
,;,C%*>%>X&#%@:*>&"*&";+'<"+:I&<%+%E301/&!@%&)';E+&+@%*&I'*(:E<%>&:+,&CE%(%E%*I%&('E&+@%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&01-&=+&,@';$>&#%&*'+%>&+@"+&"&W<:*:<;<&I'E%X&"*"$R,:,&Q",&*%P%E&;E9%>&#R&+@%&"CC$:I"*+,&:*&+@%&I",%J&*'E&Q",&:+&#R&"*R&'(&
+@%&$-0&0(&6%0$"3&9$Q6+6O*(?<([*'$22"#+6%1(]9$Q0+6O*(SA^.&)",%&M'3&51O-4761&].557^&]a)J&V:+3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3:"+C3'E9O+E">%'#,%EP"+'ERO$:#E"ER3I(<nE%(=2o-5.64?3&
&&&&01.&9$Q0+6O*(AA.&"+&q-4-J&I'*+:*;:*93&
&&&&014&9$Q0+6O*(SA.("+&q-4-T-40J&q64J&-.13&
&&&&010&48<("+&40T05&]I:+:*9&+@%&=)LN)GJ&d)-6J&"*>&)G)^3&
&&&&016&48<("+&q?.T?0J&-6-J&-643(
&&&&011&/""([*'$22"#+6%1(?<(9$Q0+6O*&.55?&]7^&8)_G&/?-&]N)D^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3,"($::3'E9OI9:T
#:*O>:,C3C$n(:$%oZ"OI",%,OzDN)DO.55?O.53@+<$jc;%ERom.5<"Z:#;B'3&!@%&N;CE%<%&)';E+&'(&DCC%"$,&$"E9%$R&;C@%$>&+@%&
[;E:,CE;>%*+:"$&,+"*>"E>J&P"ER:*9&+@%&'E>%E&#R&I@"*9:*9&+@%&E%c;:E%>&"<';*+&'(&(E%%&Q"+%E&(E'<&65&$OCO>&+'&0.&$OCO>&Q:+@&
"&+Q'TR%"E&,;,C%*,:'*&C%*>:*9&+@%&E%('E<;$"+:'*&'(&+@%&9'P%E*<%*+U,&C'$:IR3&AE%TC":>&<%+%E,&Q%E%&;C@%$>&",&;*$"Q(;$3&
48<("+&q.0J&643((
&&&&01/&9$Q0+6O*(AA.&"+&q-.53&AE%C"R<%*+&<%+%E,&Q%E%&(';*>&*'+&+'&>:,I'**%I+&Q"+%E&,;CC$R&",&:+&W>'%,&*'+&I%",%tX&#;+&:,&
W#%++%E&;*>%E,+''>&",&"&+%<C'E"ER&,;,C%*,:'*&:*&,;CC$RJ&*'+&"&>:,I'*+:*;"+:'*3X&
&
/?&
WE%",'*"#$%*%,,X&+%,+J&E;$:*9&>%(:*:+:P%$R&+@"+&+@%&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&:*&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*&
>'&*'+&@"P%&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%J&"*>&+@"+&+'&>%+%E<:*%&"*&"CCE'CE:"+%&$%P%$&'(&#",:I&CE'P:,:'*&
Q';$>&#%&[;>:I:"$$R&:*"CCE'CE:"+%3&=E'*:I"$$R&WCE:*I:C$%,&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"QX&Q%E%&I:+%>&:*&
,;CC'E+&'(&+@%&)';E+U,&>;#:';,&I'*I$;,:'*3017&):+:*9&+@%&F%**:+**-("*>(=;A(I",%,J&+@%&
'C:*:'*&@%$>&+@"+&W+@%&E:9@+&+'&"II%,,&+'&,;((:I:%*+&Q"+%Et&>'%,&*'+&E%c;:E%&+@%&,+"+%&;C'*&
>%<"*>&+'&CE'P:>%&%P%ER'*%&Q:+@&,;((:I:%*+&Q"+%Et&E"+@%E&:+&E%c;:E%,&+@%&,+"+%&+'&+"B%&
E%",'*"#$%&$%9:,$"+:P%&"*>&'+@%E&<%",;E%,&+'&E%"$:Z%&+@%&"I@:%P%<%*+&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&"II%,,&
+'&,;((:I:%*+&Q"+%EJ&Q:+@:*&"P":$"#$%&E%,';EI%,3X01?&!@%&)';E+&(';*>&+@"+&+@%&,+"+%U,&C'$:IR&:*&
A@:E:&<%+&+@%&IE:+%E:"&('E&WE%",'*"#$%*%,,JX&"*&",,%,,<%*+&Q'E+@&c;'+:*9&"+&$%*9+@&",&:+&
>:,+:*9;:,@%,&+@"+&,+"*>"E>&(E'<&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%3&
&
e!f'&E":,%&+@%&(E%%&#",:I&Q"+%E&"$$'Q"*I%&('E&"$$&,'&+@"+&:+&Q';$>&#%&,;((:I:%*+&+'&I'P%E&+@',%&
,+"*>,&e>Q%$$:*9,f&Q:+@&<"*R&E%,:>%*+,&Q';$>&#%&%`C%*,:P%&"*>&:*%c;:+"#$%J&('E&:+&Q';$>&
>:,CE'C'E+:'*"+%$R&#%*%(:+&,+"*>,&Q:+@&(%Q%E&E%,:>%*+,3&
L,+"#$:,@:*9&"&(:`%>&"<';*+&C%E&,+"*>&Q:$$&:*%P:+"#$R&E%,;$+&:*&;*%P%**%,,&#%I";,%&+@',%&
,+"*>,&Q:+@&<'E%&:*@"#:+"*+,&Q:$$&@"P%&$%,,&Q"+%E&C%E&C%E,'*&+@"*&+@',%&,+"*>,&Q:+@&(%Q%E&
E%,:>%*+,3&!@:,&:,&"*&;*"P':>"#$%&E%,;$+&'(&%,+"#$:,@:*9&"&;*:P%E,"$&"$$'I"+:'*3&~%+&:+&,%%<,&I$%"E&
'*&+@%&):+RU,&%P:>%*I%&+@"+&+'&%,+"#$:,@&"&;*:P%E,"$&C%E&C%E,'*&"$$'Q"*I%&Q';$>&#%&
"><:*:,+E"+:P%$R&#;E>%*,'<%&"*>&I',+$RJ&:(&C',,:#$%&"+&"$$3&!@%&(E%%&#",:I&Q"+%E&"$$'Q"*I%&:,&
9%*%E';,&:*&E%$"+:'*&+'&+@%&"P%E"9%&@';,%@'$>&,:Z%&:*&\'@"**%,#;E93&=*>%%>J&:*&E%$"+:'*&+'&75m&'(&
@';,%@'$>,&]Q:+@&(';E&'II;C"*+,&'E&(%Q%E^J&+@%&"$$'Q"*I%&:,&">%c;"+%&'*&+@%&"CC$:I"*+U,&I",%3&=*&
+@%&$:9@+&'(&+@:,&%P:>%*I%J&I';C$%>&Q:+@&+@%&("I+&+@"+&+@%&"<';*+&CE'P:>%>&#R&+@%&):+R&Q",&#",%>&
'*&+@%&CE%,IE:#%>&*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>&('E&#",:I&Q"+%E&,;CC$RJ&:+&I"**'+&#%&,":>&+@"+&+@%&"<';*+&
%,+"#$:,@%>&#R&+@%&):+R&Q",&;*E%",'*"#$%30/5&
&
!@%&'C:*:'*&E%$:%,&'*&"&($%`:#$%&I"$I;$"+:'*&'(&;+:$:+R&:*&9'P%E*<%*+"$&CE'+%I+:'*&('E&
Q"+%E&E:9@+,&+@"+&9E%"+$R&Q%"B%*,&+@%&;*:P%E,"$&,+"*>"E>&%*,@E:*%>&:*&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&
-63&D><:*:,+E"+:P%&#;E>%*&"*>&"&>:,CE'C'E+:'*"+%&#%*%(:+&+'&,'<%&P:,TrTP:,&'+@%E,&[;,+:(R&
+@%&,+"+%U,&E%[%I+:'*&'(&W;*:P%E,"$&"$$'I"+:'*X&",&WI',+$RJ&:(&C',,:#$%&"+&"$$3X&N:<:$"E&E%",'*:*9&
:*&F%**:+**-&Q",&"E9;%>&#R&,I@'$"E,&$:B%&8:$I@:+Z&+'&#%&;*%+@:I"$J&",&WE%",'*"#$%*%,,X&
C%E<:+,&+@%&"#,'$;+%&>:,%*(E"*I@:,%<%*+&'(&,'<%&",&$'*9&",&%(('E+,&"E%&('I;,%>&'*&*'*T
%,,%*+:"$&:<CE'P%<%*+,&('E&'+@%E,30/-&!@%&,+"*>"E>&:*&9$Q0+6O*&:,&%P%*&<'E%&c;%,+:'*"#$%J&
@'Q%P%EJ&",&:+&C%E<:+,&+@%&N+"+%&+'&>%I:>%&"9":*,+&<%",;E%,&+@"+&Q';$>&E%"$:Z%&+@%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&017&483&"+&q05&*3&4-&]I:+:*9&=)LN)G&"E+3&.]-^&"*>&)LN)G&d)4&",&';+$:*:*9&CE:*I:C$%,&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&WI'*,:,+%*+X&Q:+@&
+@%&)';E+U,&'Q*&$:<:+%>&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&CE'9E%,,:P%&E%"$:Z"+:'*J&E%c;:E:*9&'*$R&I'*+:*;';,&E%P:%Q&:*&$:9@+&'(&$%9"$:+R&"*>&
WE%,'*"#$%*%,,X3&!@:,&:,&>%,C:+%&+@%&C;EC',%&'(&d)4&+'&%*>&,;I@&,;C%E(:I:"$&"*>&;*T*;"*I%>&;*>%E,+"*>:*9,&'(&+@%&+%E<^3&&
&&&&01?&48<&"+&q653&
&&&&0/5&483&q77T7?3&
&&&&0/-&8:$I@:+ZJ&#6@%$&*'+%&-/1J&"+&0?4T4??3&
&
75&
<:*:<;<&'(&+@%&E:9@+&('E&"$$&:(&+@',%&%(('E+,&Q';$>&>:,CE'C'E+:'*"$$R&+"2"30:&+@',%&"$E%">R&
%*['R:*9&+@%:E&E:9@+,3&=*&%((%I+J&+@%&[;>9<%*+&"E9;%,&+@"+&:+&:,&#%++%E&*'+&+'&E%"$:Z%&+@%&
<:*:<;<&'(&+@%&E:9@+&('E&,'<%&:(&E%"$:Z:*9&+@%&<:*:<;<&('E&"$$&Q';$>&$%">&+'&:*%c;:+"#$%&
%*['R<%*+J&%,C%I:"$$R&Q@%*&,;I@&%(('E+,&Q';$>&#;E>%*&+@%&,+"+%3&&
!@%&[;>9<%*+&:,&*'+"#$%&('E&:+,&I'*I%C+;"$&E%+E'9E%,,:'*&:*&+Q'&'+@%E&"E%",3&S:E,+J&
+@%&)';E+&%,+"#$:,@%>&"&>:,+;E#:*9&,+"*>"E>&('E&*'*T>:,IE:<:*"+:'*3&V@%*&I'*(E'*+%>&Q:+@&
+@%&"CC$:I"*+U,&,;#<:,,:'*&+@"+&+@%&<%+%E,&Q%E%&'*$R&:*,+"$$%>&:*&C''EJ&#$"IB&"E%",J&+@%&
)';E+&@%$>&+@"+&+@%&C'$:IR&Q",&*'+&>:,IE:<:*"+'ER&",&<%+%E,&@">&*'+&#%%*&:*,+"$$%>&:*&$,,&
C''E&#$"IB&"E%",30/.&\"IB:%&2;9"E>&I@"E"I+%E:Z%>&+@%&(:*>:*9&",&W:*,"*%X&"*>&W+@%&<',+&
;++%E$R&';+E"9%';,&"*>&;*"II%C+"#$%&'(&"$$&+@%&I'<C'*%*+,&'(&+@%&[;>9<%*+3X0/4&!@%&
,+"*>"E>&,%%<,&+'&I'<<:+&"&I'*I%C+;"$&("$$"IR3&N:*I%&*'*T>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&:,&"*&"#,'$;+%J&"&
(:*>:*9&'(&>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&:,&:*,+"*I%T#",%>&"*>&>'%,&*'+&E%$R&'*&CE''(&'(&;*:P%E,"$:+R3&=(&+@%&
Q"R&"&C'$:IR&:,&I"EE:%>&';+&$%">,&+'&'*%&:*,+"*I%&'(&>:,IE:<:*"+:'*J&+@%&C'$:IR&<;,+&#%&
I@"$$%*9%>&",&>:,IE:<:*"+'ER&;*+:$&+@%&>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&:,&,+'CC%>3&!'&"E9;%&+@"+&+@%&CE%C":>&
<%+%E&C'$:IR&:*&+@%&9$Q0+6O*&I",%&:,&*'*T>:,IE:<:*"+'ER&#%I";,%&:+&>'%,&*'+&>:,IE:<:*"+%&
%P%ERQ@%E%J&:,&$:B%&"E9;:*9&+@"+&"&,+"+%&C'$:IR&">%c;"+%$R&CE'+%I+,&+@%&E:9@+&+'&$:(%J&%P%*&:(J&
:*&"&$:<:+%>&*;<#%E&'(&I",%,J&:+&>:E%I+$R&I";,%,&>%"+@3&M'*T>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&:,&"&I%*+E"$&
%$%<%*+&'(&"$$&@;<"*&E:9@+,J&%`C$:I:+$R&%*,@E:*%>&#R&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6&",&C"E+&'(&#'+@&
+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&"*>&<:*:<;<&I'E%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3&
!@%&,%I'*>&]"*>&('E&';E&C;EC',%,&<'E%&>:,+;E#:*9^&E%+E'9E%,,:'*&:*&+@%&9$Q0+6O*(
I",%&:*P'$P%,&+@%&$:<:+"+:'*&'(&+@%&)';E+U,&E'$%&:*&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&%*('EI%<%*+3&!@%&
Q'EB&'(&+@:,&%,,"R&E%$:%,&'*&"*&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&+@%&E'$%&'(&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&",&,;CC'E+:*9&
+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*,%*,;,&'*&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&+@E';9@&I'*+%*+T9:P:*930/0&!@%&
)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&:*&9$Q0+6O*.&@'Q%P%EJ&%((%I+:P%$R&%"a"&:#&,;I@&"&E'$%&('E&:+,%$(J&I'*+%*+&
+'&$%+&$%9:,$"+:P%&<%",;E%,&"$'*%&>%(:*%&+@%&*"+;E%&'(&C',:+:P%&'#$:9"+:'*,3&!@%&)';E+&@%$>&
+@"+&:+&:,&'*$R&E%c;:E%>&+'&E%P:%Q&+@%&E%",'*"#$%*%,,&'(&+@%&I@',%*&<%+@'>&'(&
:<C$%<%*+"+:'*J&'E&:*&I",%,&Q@%E%&*'&,+%C,&@"P%&#%%*&+"B%*J&+'&E%c;:E%&'*$R&+@"+&+@%&,+"+%&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&0/.&9$Q0+6O*(AAJ&"+&q-66T-6/3&!@%&'C:*:'*&@%$>&+@"+&%P%*&:(&>:,IE:<:*"+'ERJ&+@%&C;EC',%&('E&+@%&:<C$%<%*+"+:'*&'(&+@%&
CE%C":>&<%+%E&,I@%<%&Q",&*'+&"><:*:,+E"+:P%$R&;*(":EJ&;*I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&'E&%P%*&@"E<(;$&('E&A@:E:&E%,:>%*+,3&
&&&&0/4&L<":$&(E'<&\"IB:%&2;9"E>J&L`%I3&2:E3J&N'I:'TLI'*3&G+,3&=*,+3&'(&N3&D(E3J&+'&+@%&";+@'E&]\;*%&7J&.5-5&50H-7"<&)N!^]'*&(:$%&
Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&K,3&2;9"E>&"$,'&"E9;%>&+@"+&+@%&,+"*I%&'P%E+;E*,&+@%&$";>"#$%&"*+:T>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&'(&
N';+@&D(E:I"*&I';E+,&:*&CE%P:';,&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&I",%,3&
&&&&0/0&/""&#6@%$.(A"E+&DJ&8J&+@:,&,%I+:'*3&
&
7-&
"I+&Q:+@';+&>%(:*:*9&,C%I:(:I&C"E"<%+%E,&('E&+@"+&"I+:'*30/6&W)';E+,JX&+@%&'C:*:'*&:*,:,+,J&
W"E%&:$$TC$"I%>&+'&<"B%&+@%,%&",,%,,<%*+,&('E&#'+@&:*,+:+;+:'*"$&"*>&>%<'IE"+:I&E%",'*,3X0/1&
N;I@&"&(:*>:*9&"9":*&#;:$>,&;C'*&"&I'*I%C+;"$&<:,;*>%E,+"*>:*9&:*&F%**:+**-3&!@%&)';E+&
(":$,&+'&>:,+:*9;:,@&#%+Q%%*&+@%&E:9@+&:+,%$(&Y&+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&Q@:I@&E%c;:E%,&+@"+&%P%ER&
,+"+%&C'$:IR&I'*+":*&I%E+":*&%,,%*+:"$&%$%<%*+,0//&Y&"*>&+@%&WQ:>%&E"*9%&'(&C',,:#$%&
<%",;E%,&e+@"+f&I';$>&#%&">'C+%>&#R&+@%&,+"+%&+'&<%%+&:+,&'#$:9"+:'*,3X0/7&
V@%*&("I%>&Q:+@&I'*IE%+%&:*,+"*I%,&'(&E:9@+,&:*(E:*9%<%*+J&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&
>%(:%>&+@%&Q'EB&'(&%P%ER&'+@%E&*"+:'*"$&I';E+&,+E;99$:*9&+'&%*('EI%&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&:*&
+@%&("I%&'(&:*,;((:I:%*+&9'P%E*<%*+"$&CE'+%I+:'*3&!@:,&:,&>%,C:+%&+@%&'CC'E+;*:+R&"(('E>%>&#R&
:+,&;*:c;%&I'*,+:+;+:'*J&[;>:I:"$&,+"#:$:+R&"*>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'+'E:%+R3&N';+@&D(E:I"J&:*&]"^&
E%(;,:*9&+'&#",%&:+,&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&'*&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*,%*,;,J&:*&]#^&
E%[%I+:*9&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&I"$I;$;,&:*&("P'E&'(&"&WE%",'*"#$%*%,,X&+%,+J&:*&]I^&Q%"B%*:*9&
CE'+%I+:'*&"9":*,+&>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&"*>&:*&]>^&>:<:*:,@:*9&:+,&'Q*&E'$%&:*&E:9@+,&I'*,+E;I+:'*J&
CE'P:>%,&"&C'Q%E(;$&I@"$$%*9%&+'&+@%&CE'9E%,,&"I@:%P%>&+@;,&("E&:*&+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&"*>&
>%(%*,%&'(&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E30/?&
&
90:01$:021(U$&:*%#(:*(A*2#08"%(
&
8%('E%&"#"*>'*:*9&@'C%&('E&+@%&(;+;E%&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*J&
+@%E%&"E%&+@E%%&:<C'E+"*+&("I+'E,&+'&I'*,:>%E&E%9"E>:*9&+@%&N';+@&D(E:I"*&I",%,&"#'P%3&
S:E,+J&>:((%E%*I%,&#%+Q%%*&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*&"*>&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,&<"R&,'<%Q@"+&
[;,+:(R&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+U,&(:*>:*9&"*>&<"R&$:<:+&+@%&"CC$:I"+:'*&'(&+@"+&,+"*>"E>&:*&
I';E+E''<,&"#E'">3&i%*>%&,;99%,+,&+@"+&+@%&>E"(+%E,&'(&+@%&CE'9E%,,:P%&N';+@&D(E:I"*&8:$$&
'(&G:9@+,&W*%P%E&:*+%*>%>&+'&@"P%&+@%&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&CE'P:,:'*,&IE%"+%t&"*&
:*>:P:>;"$&E:9@+&+'&>%<"*>JX&$"E9%$R&>;%&+'&+@%&C%EI%:P%>&;*(%",:#:$:+R&'(&,;I@&"*&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&0/6&9$Q0+6O*(AA.&q1.T14J&1/T173&
&&&&0/1&48<("+&q1.3&
&&&&0//&%393&*'*T>:,IE:<:*"+:'*J&#",:I&CE'P:,:'*&+'&"$$J&I'*,:>%E"+:'*&'(&"II%,,:#:$:+RJ&c;"$:+RJ&%+It&",&>%E:P%>&(E'<&d)-6&"*>&
+@',%&'+@%E&,';EI%,&$:,+%>&#6@%$.&{&==3&
&&&&0/7&F%**:+**-(AAJ&"+&q0-3&!@:,&"E9;<%*+&:,&"+&+@%&@%"E+&'(&8:$I@:+ZU,&%,,"R3&/""&#6@%$&*'+%&-/13&
&&&&0/?&!@%&:*+%$$%I+;"$&E%+E'9E%,,:'*&'(&+@%&I",%&Q",&I'*,:>%E%>&#R&,'<%&$:B%&2"*I@:*&+'&I'*(:E<&+@%&Q'EE:%,&'(&,I@'$"E,&
$:B%&~';*9&'P%E&+@%&I'*I%C+;"$&:*>%+%E<:*"IR&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%3&/6@%$(*'+%&06?J&"+&q-1&]W!@%&,%c;%*I%&'(&[;>9<%*+,&
:*&+@%&K"Z:#;B'&I",%&$%*>,&IE%>%*I%&+'&i"+@%E:*%&~';*9U,&"E9;<%*+&:*&@%E&E%I%*+&"E+:I$%X^3&/""($,#*(~';*9J&#6@%$&*'+%&
-6?3&
&
7.&
"CCE'"I@3075&!@%&)';E+&:+,%$(&E%I'9*:Z%>&+@:,&@:,+'E:I"$&("I+&:*&+@%&$"*><"EB(=;A(
[;>9<%*+307- &!'&%*,;E%&+@"+&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&Q';$>&*'+&+''&I$',%$R&
<:EE'E&+@%:E&#E'">%E&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I';*+%EC"E+,J&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&$"*9;"9%&Q",&E%,+E:I+%>3&
!@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*J&('E&%`"<C$%J&'*$R&%*,@E:*%,&+@%&E:9@+&W:*('$?"($&&"##(:*t&,;((:I:%*+&(''>&
"*>&Q"+%EX&Y&"&,+"*>"E>&>:((%E%*+&(E'<&+@"+&'(&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6307.&S;E+@%E<'E%J&
#%I";,%&N';+@&D(E:I"&@",&*'+&R%+&E"+:(:%>&+@%&=)LN)GJ&+@%&)';E+&@",&*'&(:E<&'#$:9"+:'*&+'&
:*+%ECE%+&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+&Q:+@&E%(%E%*I%&+'&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,J&"*>&@",&
CE%P:';,$R&",,%E+%>&:*&#'+@&+@%&F%**:+**-&"*>&=;A&I",%,&+@"+&,;I@&"*&"CCE'"I@&Q';$>&#%&
:*"CCE'CE:"+%3074&8R&,+E:I+$R&#",:*9&:+,&[;>9<%*+&'*&N';+@&D(E:I"*&$"QJ&+@%&)';E+&<"R&@"P%&
$:<:+%>&+@%&C',,:#:$:+R&('E&[;>:I:"$&+E"*,<:,,:'*&"#E'">3&
N%I'*>$RJ&+@%&[;>9<%*+&:*&9$Q0+6O*&<"R&@"P%&":<%>&"+&%((%I+:P%$R&E%"$:Z:*9&,'<%&
E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*&Q@:$%&,"(%9;"E>:*9&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&,%C"E"+:'*&'(&C'Q%E,3&!@%&9$Q0+6O*&
'C:*:'*&>:E%I+$R&I:+%,&I'*I%E*&('E&,%C"E"+:'*&'(&C'Q%E,&",&+@%&#",:,&('E&+@%&)';E+U,&E%+:I%*I%&
+'&%*('EI%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+,&<'E%&,+E:I+$R3070&!@%&)';E+U,&I"E%(;$&I:EI;<,C%I+:'*&'(&"&
,%*,:+:P%&:,,;%&@",&#%%*&CE":,%>&#R&,'<%&N';+@&D(E:I"*&$%9"$&,I@'$"E,J&E%(%EE:*9&+'&,:<:$"E&
C',:+:'*,&",&WCE"9<"+:IX&'E&%P%*&W[;E:,CE;>%*+:"$$R&,';*>%E3X076&&=*&+@%&%*>J&+@%&9$Q0+6O*(
[;>9<%*+&<"R&#%&$%,,&"#';+&E:9@+,&%*('EI%<%*+&"*>&<'E%&"#';+&+@%&"CCE'CE:"+%&E'$%&'(&+@%&
[;>:I:"ER&Q:+@:*&+@%&N';+@&D(E:I"*&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&,R,+%<3071&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&075&i%*>%J&#6@%$&*'+%&-/1J&"+&1.4J&1.6T1.?3&B6:&#""(_%@<"*J&#6@%$(*'+%&-/1J&"+&-/7&]"E9;:*9&+@"+&+@%&IE:+:I:,<&+@"+&+@%&
)';E+&@",&*%P%E&(';*>&,;I@&"&E:9@+&:,&;*(":E^3&
&&&&07-&K:*:<;<&I'E%&E%c;:E%<%*+,&Q%E%&E%[%I+%>&:*&+@%&=;A(I",%J&",&+@%R&Q%E%&@%$>&+'&IE%"+%&"&CE'#$%<"+:I&E:9@+&'(&
:*>:P:>;"$&C%+:+:'*&('E&:<<%>:"+%&I'E%&#%*%(:+,&+@"+&W,@';$>&*'+&#%&I'*,+E;%>X&(E'<&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*U,&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&
E:9@+,&",&,;I@&"*&%*+:+$%<%*+&Q';$>&#%&W:<C',,:#$%X&+'&"><:*:,+%E3&9020#:"%(*3(S"$,:'(?<(=%"$:-"2:(;&:0*2(A$-@$012&]=;A^&
.55.&]6^&ND&/.-J&q.1J&4.J&40T46&]))^3&
&&&&07.&{&./]-^]#^J&S. Afr. Const.&-??13&&!@%E%&"E%&+Q'&'+@%E&+%`+;"$&>:((%E%*I%,&#%+Q%%*&+@%&+Q'&,+"*>"E>,3&!@%&
)'*,+:+;+:'*&:+,%$(&:*+E'>;I%,&+@%&*'P%$&$"*9;"9%&'(&E%",'*"#$%*%,,3&8:$I@:+Z&*'+%,&+@"+&+@:,&+%E<&<'>:(:%,&+@%&Q'E>&
<%",;E%,&"*>&*'+&+@%&E:9@+&:+,%$(3&8:$I@:+Z(#6@%$&*'+%&-/1J&"+&0?13&N%I'*>$RJ&Q@%E%&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*&E%c;:E%,&'*$R&"I+:'*&
WQ:+@:*&"P":$"#$%&E%,';EI%,JX&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>&E%c;:E%,&"I+:'*&W+'&+@%&<"`:<;<&'(&"P":$"#$%&E%,';EI%,3X&!@%&
>:((%E%*I%J&@'Q%P%EJ&:,&9%*%E"$$R&I'*,:>%E%>&+'&#%&;*CE'#$%<"+:I&",&I';E+,&"E%&;*$:B%$R&+'&*%9"+:P%$R&:*(%E&+@"+&+@%&,+"+%U,&
'#$:9"+:'*&:,&$%,,'*%>J&*'+:*9&CE:*I:C$%,&'(&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&9'P%E*:*9&+E%"+R&"CC$:I"+:'*&$:B%&+@%&s:%**"&)'*P%*+:'*3&/""&
NI'++&j&D$,+'*J&#6@%$&*'+%&-61&"+&.1.T.143&
&&&&074&!@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&E;$%>&:*&9$OH$27$2"&+@"+&*'*T#:*>:*9&E;$%,&'(&$"Q&"E%&"$,'&E%$%P"*+&:*&+E%"+R&
:*+%ECE%+"+:'*3&/<(?<(9$OH$27$2"(-??6&]4^&ND&4?-&]))^&q46&]N3&D(E3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3,"($::3'E9OZ"OI",%,OzD))O-??6O43@+<$3&
&&&&070&9$Q0+6O*(AA.&"+&q1-g&2"*I@:*&#6@%$(*'+%&00/J&"+&q-13&
&&&&076&/""(_%@<"*J(#6@%$&*'+%&-/1J&"+&-16&]CE'C',:*9&+@"+&+@%&I';E+U,&>%$:#%E"+%&>:,;,%&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&I"$I;$;,&,+%<,&
(E'<&"&>:,I'<('E+&:+&@",&R%+&+'&(;$$R&"E+:I;$"+%3^&N""(1"2"%$,,7(i%*>%J&#6@%$&*'+%&-/13&
&&&&071&/""(=*+%EP:%Q&Q:+@&d%'((&8;*>$%*>%EJ&02&LitigatingJ&#6@%$&*'+%&.46J&"+&?1&]W!@"+U,&Q@%E%&+@%&E%"$&"E9;<%*+&+"B%,&
C$"I%H&"#';+&+@%E%&+@%&E'$%&'(&+@%&[;>:I:"ER&,+"E+,&"*>&,+'C,3X^3*
&
74&
S:*"$$RJ&[;>:I:"$&E%[%I+:'*&'(&+@%&W<:*:<;<&I'E%X&I';$>&#%&"&E%>&@%EE:*9J&",&+@%&
I'*I%C+&<"R&,+:$$&(:*>&:<C%E(%I+&,;CC'E+&:*&N';+@&D(E:I"*&[;E:,CE;>%*I%J&"$#%:+&;*>%E&"&
>:((%E%*+&*"<%3&N'<%&";+@'E,&@"P%&%P%*&,;99%,+%>&+@"+&+@%&)';E+U,&"CCE'"I@&:,&%,,%*+:"$$R&
,;CC'E+:P%&'(&+@%&I'*I%C+U,&"CC$:I"+:'*J&"*>&'*$R&I"$I;$"+%>$R&E%,+E:I+:P%&('E&C'$:+:I"$&
E%",'*,3&)@'Q>@;ER&*'+%,&+@"+J&
&
"&,<'B%,IE%%*&"*>&<:EE'E,&"CCE'"I@&:,&eC%E@"C,f&;,%(;$&9:P%*&+@%&<"*R&$%9:+:<"+%&E%",'*,&+@%&
I';E+,&@"P%&+'&*'+&">'C+&"*&%`C$:I:+&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"CCE'"I@&,;I@&",J&('E&:*,+"*I%J&$"IB&'(&
:*('E<"+:'*07/&"*>&R%+&9:P%*&+@%&:<C'E+"*I%&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"CCE'"I@3&N'&+@%&E%[%I+:'*&'(&
+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&#R&+@%&N';+@&D(E:I"*&)';E+,&I';$>&#%&I@"E"I+%E:Z%>&",&"&E%>&@%EE:*9&:*&+@"+&:+&
>:,+E"I+,&(E'<&+@%&"I+;"$&<"I@:*"+:'*,&'(&+@%&I",%,3077&
(
!@%E%&"E%&<"*R&Q"R,&:*&Q@:I@&%,,%*+:"$&%$%<%*+,&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&"E%&CE'+%I+%>&
#R&%`:,+:*9&$"QJ&:*I$;>:*9&+@%&V"+%E&N%EP:I%,&DI+&"*>&S8V&C'$:IRJ07? &"*>&+@%&)';E+U,&'Q*&
'C:*:'*,&,%%<&+'&<"B%&%`+%*,:P%&I"$I;$"+:'*,&'*&+@%&WE%",'*"#$%*%,,X&'(&"&C'$:IR&#",%>&:*&
+@%&"<';*+&'(&Q"+%E&*%I%,,"ER&+'&,;,+":*&@;<"*&$:(%30?5&N+:$$J&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+U,&
>%I:,:'*&:*&9$Q0+6O*&,'&>%(:*:+:P%$R&E%[%I+,&+@%&,+"*>"E>J&+@"+&%P%*&:(&"&E%>&@%EE:*9J&:+&Q:$$&
<',+&$:B%$R&$:<:+&%`C$:I:+&;,%&'(&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&#R&N';+@&D(E:I"*&I';E+,&:*&+@%&(;+;E%3&(
=*&+@%&%*>J&+@%&E%",'*"#$%*%,,&+%,+&Y&Q@"+%P%E&:+,&W($%`:#:$:+RX&'E&W"CCE'CE:"+%*%,,X&+'&
+@%&N';+@&D(E:I"*&I'*+%`+&Y&Q%"B%*,&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>&'(&CE'+%I+:'*&('E&+@%&@;<"*&
E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3&G%",'*"#$%*%,,&+E%"+,&CE'9E%,,:P%&E%"$:Z"+:'*&",&"*&'C%*T%*>%>&I'*I%C+&
Q:+@:*&Q@:I@&E%,;$+,&I"*&#%&:*>%(:*:+%$R&>%(%EE%>30?-&=*&("I+J&+@%&E%",'*"#$%*%,,&+%,+&<"R&
'*$R&W+E">%&"E#:+E"E:*%,,&('E&:*>%+%E<:*"IRX&",&:+&%*I';*+%E,&+@%&,"<%&>:((:I;$+:%,&'(&
:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&"*>&I'*+%`+;"$:Z"+:'*&+@"+&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&Q';$>&%*I';*+%E&:*&
"CC$:I"+:'*30?. &&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&07/&)@'Q>@;ER&E%(%E,&+'&+@%&>%+%E<:*"+:'*&#R&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&:*&F%**:+**-&+@"+&+@%E%&Q",&*'+&%*';9@&:*('E<"+:'*&
"P":$"#$%&+'&>%(:*%&+@%&"CCE'CE:"+%&"<';*+&'(&Q"+%E&CE'+%I+%>&#R&+@%&E:9@+3&/""()@'Q>@;ERJ&#6@%$(*'+%&.7-J&"+&-43&
&&&&077&483&)@'Q>@;ER&:,&E%(%E%*I:*9&+@%&'E:9:*"$&>%I:,:'*&:*&+@%&a:9@&)';E+&I",%3&
&&&&07?&8'+@&,C%I:(R&"&w($''EU&('E&#",:I&CE'P:,:'*3&
&&&&0?5&!@%&[;>9<%*+,&:*&#'+@&F%**:+**-&"*>&9$Q0+6O*(AAJ&+@';9@&%((%I+:P%$R&E%[%I+:*9&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%J&,+:$$&('E<;$"+%&
'C:*:'*,&'*&+@%&"<';*+&'(&Q"+%E&E%c;:E%>&('E&@;<"*&,;#,:,+%*I%&#",%>&'*&%`C%E+&,+"*>"E>,3&8:$I@:+Z&:*,:,+,&+@"+&+@%&
E%",'*"#$%*%,,&I"$I;$;,&;,%>&#R&~"I''#&\3&%*9"9%,&:*&"&CE'I%,,&'(&#"$"*I:*9&('E&<:*:<;<&,"+:,("I+:'*&"*>&CE'9E%,,:P%&
E%"$:Z"+:'*&+@"+&(:E,+&E%c;:E%,&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%T$:B%&"><:,,:'*&+@"+&+@%&"I@:%P%<%*+&'(&"&9;"E"*+%%>&<:*:<;<&:,&"+&"$$&+@%&
E%,C'*,:#:$:+R&'(&+@%&,+"+%3&/""(8:$I@:+Z&#6@%$&*'+%&-/1J&"+&0??3&
&&&&0?-&/""(NI'++&j&D$,+'*J&#6@%$&*'+%&-61J&"+&.143&
&&&&0?.&/""(2"*I@:*J&#6@%$&*'+%&06?J&"+&q..3&/""($,#*&N"*>E"&_:%#%*#%E9J&/*6:'(;3%0&$L#(G?*,?021([6%0#@%68"2&"(*2(/*&0*^
G&*2*-0&(!01':#R($2(G33"&:0?"(=**,(02(A'$,,"21021()*?"%:7_&1&L. Democracy & Dev. J. -6?J&-/6&].55.^3&
&
70&
V%&(:*>&:*&N';+@&D(E:I"&"*&"$<',+&*"+:'*"$:,+:I&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&Q@:I@&
,;((%E,&:*&:+,&[;>:I:"$&:,'$"+:'*&(E'<&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&*'E<,3&LP%*&Q@%*&I:+:*9&
:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"QJ&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+&>'%,&,'&:*&"&+E"*,C"E%*+$R&:*";+@%*+:I&Q"R&Y&
Q:+@&*'&E%(%E%*I%&+'&%`C%E+&'C:*:'*J&$%9"$&I'*,%*,;,&'E&+E;%&+%$%'$'9R30?4&D9":*&+@%&N';+@&
D(E:I"*&%`"<C$%&CE'P%,&@'Q&>:((:I;$+&:+&I"*&#%&+'&(:*>&%((%I+:P%&CE'+%I+:'*&('E&'*%U,&
;*:P%E,"$&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&Q:+@';+&+E;%&E%I';E,%&+'&+@%&=)LN)G3&!@:,&E%"$:Z"+:'*&:,&
%,C%I:"$$R&#:++%E&('E&N';+@&D(E:I"*,J&@'Q%P%EJ&",&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&,%%<%>&+'&@"P%&#%%*&
I'*,+:+;+:'*"$$R&%<#E"I%>3&S'E+;*"+%$RJ&+@%&%((%I+&'(&+@%&E;$:*9&"#'P%&:,&$:<:+%>&#R&+@%&
<:+:9"+:*9&("I+'E,&*'+%>&@%E%3&D$+@';9@&+@%&N';+@&D(E:I"*&I",%&CE%,%*+,&"&,:9*:(:I"*+&
I@"$$%*9%J&+@%&Q%"$+@&'(&CE'9E%,,&<">%&:*&'+@%E&*"+:'*"$&I';E+E''<,&:,&("E&(E'<&$',+3&
&
&
! D/*>1'4$32%'8*+#&(",-*
&
;<(B%0"3(;2$,7#0#(
&
!@E';9@&+@%&Q'EB&'(&+@:,&%,,"RJ&Q%&@"P%&,%%*&+@%&,R<#:'+:I&E%$"+:'*,@:C&#%+Q%%*&
+@%&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&"+&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%P%$&"*>&+@%&;,%&'(&+@"+&E:9@+&('E&,+"B%@'$>%E&
CE'+%I+:'*&"+&@'<%3&D(+%E&E%P:%Q:*9&+@%&I",%&$"Q&"#'P%J&:+&:,&C',,:#$%&+'&>E"Q&,%P%E"$&
@%$C(;$&I'*I$;,:'*,&"#';+&+@%&*"+;E%&'(&+@:,&CE'I%,,&('E&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3&!@%,%&
I'*I$;,:'*,&,@';$>&CE'P:>%&9;:>"*I%&('E&(;E+@%EJ&<'E%&I'*+%`+T,C%I:(:I&:*c;:ER3&
S:E,+J&[;>:I:"$&"I+:P:,<&I"*&#%&%`C%I+%>&+'&@"P%&I'*+:*;%>&:<C'E+"*I%&:*&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
$:+:9"+:'*3&F(&+@%&,%P%*+%%*&,+"+%,&Q:+@&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+,&+'&Q"+%EJ&'*$R&'*%&]N';+@&
D(E:I"^&:,&:*I$;>%>&@%E%&",&"&*'+"#$%&%`"<C$%&'(&[;>:I:"$&%*('EI%<%*+3&LP%ER&'+@%E&I';E+&
E%(%E%*I%>&:*&+@:,&%,,"R&>%P%$'C%>&"&,+"*>"E>&'(&CE'+%I+:'*&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&#R&WI'*,+E;:*9X&
CE'+%I+:'*&+@E';9@&"*'+@%EJ&[;,+:I:"#$%&$%9"$&%*+:+$%<%*+3&!@:,&[;>:I:"$&"I+:P:,<&,%%<,&+'&
:*>:I"+%&"&CE%,,:*9&*%%>&('E&"*&%`C$:I:+$R&I'>:(:%>&;*:P%E,"$&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&
Q'E$>Q:>%3&K'E%&,:9*:(:I"*+$RJ&:+&,:9*"$,&+@%&I'*+:*;:*9&E'$%&+@%&[;>:I:"ER&I"*&#%&%`C%I+%>&+'&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
&&&&&0?4&/""("<1<.(+@%&)';E+U,&<:,T:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&'(&d)4J&#6@%$&*3&017J&"*>&:+,&(":$;E%&+'&9:P%&$%9"$&%((%I+&+'&+@%&(;$$&I'*I%C+&'(&
Q"+%E&E:9@+,&",&';+$:*%>&:*&d),&4&"*>&-6&>%,C:+%&+@%&CE%P:';,&E;$:*9&:*&9$OH$27$2".&#6@%$&*3&074<(V@%*&I:+:*9&"&,+"*>"E>&
'(&*'*T#:*>:*9&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q&+@%,%&:*+%ECE%+"+:P%&,';EI%,&#%I'<%&"$$&+@%&<'E%&:<C'E+"*+&:*&>:E%I+:*9&+@%&Q'EB&'(&"&
*"+:'*"$&I';E+3&
&
76&
C$"R&:*&%`+%*>:*9&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*&+'&,+"B%@'$>%E,J&<"B:*9&"*R&;*>;%&E%,+E:I+:'*&'*&
[;>:I:"$&I'<C%+%*I%&:*&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&%*('EI%<%*+&]",&:*&9$Q0+6O*^&%,C%I:"$$R&Q'EE:,'<%3&&
&
N%I'*>$RJ&+@%&I",%&$"Q&E%P%"$,&+@%&I%*+E"$&E'$%&'(&+@%&=)LN)G&:*&%*,;E:*9&%((%I+:P%&
Q"+%E&E:9@+,&CE'+%I+:'*3&=+&:,&*'+&$+#*,6:",7(2"&"##$%7&+@"+&,+"+%,&E"+:(R&+@%&=)LN)G&'E&
%*,@E:*%&:+&:*+'&*"+:'*"$&$%9:,$"+:'*&+'&CE'+%I+&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&!@:,&:,&#%I";,%&"+&+@%&*"+:'*"$&
$%P%$&I';E+,&E%$R&CE:*I:C"$$R&'*&"&W$'I"$X&#",:,&('E&+@%&E:9@+J&%P%*&Q@%*&=)LN)G&CE'P:,:'*,&
"E%&>:E%I+$R&%*('EI%"#$%3&=*,+%">&'(&",,%E+:*9&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&",&"&;*:P%E,"$&$%9"$&
%*+:+$%<%*+J&+@%&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&"#'P%&9E';*>%>&+@%:E&"E9;<%*+,&:*&+@%&E:9@+,&+'&$:(%&]=*>:"J&
A"B:,+"*J&8"*9$">%,@J&=*>'*%,:"J&)'$'<#:"^J&Q%$$T#%:*9&]=*>'*%,:"^J&@%"$+@&])'$'<#:"J&
DE9%*+:*"^J&@%"$+@R&%*P:E'*<%*+&]=*>:"^&"*>&>:9*:+R&]8%$9:;<J&)'$'<#:"^3&
&
V@%*&I';E+,&8*(E%(%E%*I%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&,+"*>"E>,&:*&+@%:E&[;E:,CE;>%*I%J&@'Q%P%EJ&
+@%&$%P%$&'(&CE'+%I+:'*&('E&+@%&,+"B%@'$>%E&:,&,+E%*9+@%*%>3&!@%&8%$9:"*&)';E+&'(&DE#:+E"+:'*J&
:*&I:+:*9&+@%&+%`+&'(&D9%*>"&.-J&(';*>&"*&:*>%C%*>%*+&E:9@+&+'&>E:*B:*9&Q"+%E&%P%*&#%('E%&
+@%&$%9"$&#",:,&('E&,;I@&"&E:9@+&@",&#%%*&>%$:*%"+%>&#R&+@%&)LN)G3&=*&+@%&)*,,6:0*2(A*2:%*,(
B*$%8&I",%J&+@%&=*>:"*&N;CE%<%&)';E+&,:<:$"E$R&;,%>&+@%&K"E&>%$&A$"+"&DI+:'*&A$"*&+'&C',:+&
"*&:*>%C%*>%*+&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&<'E%&I$%"E$R&+@"*&:*&"*R&I",%&#%('E%&'E&,:*I%3&&
!@%&=)LN)G&"*>&:+,&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&"E%&+@%&,+E'*9%,+&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$%9"$&,';EI%,&
('E&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&+'&Q@:I@&"&,+"+%&<"R&@"P%&E%I';E,%3&)",%,&%`C$:I:+$R&
E%(%E%*I:*9&+@%,%&+%`+,&@"P%&+@%E%('E%&>%P%$'C%>&+@%&<',+&I'<CE%@%*,:P%&,+"*>"E>,&'(&
CE'+%I+:'*&+'&>"+%3&M'&D,:"*&I",%&$"QJ&('E&%`"<C$%J&:,&<'E%&I'<CE%@%*,:P%&:*&:+,&
:*+%ECE%+"+:'*&'(&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&+@"*&+@%&4%%01$:0*2(!"?0"H([;>9<%*+&(E'<&
=*>'*%,:"3&!@"+&I",%&>:E%I+$R&I:+%>&=)LN)G&DE+3&-.&"*>&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&4&"*>&-63&D<'*9&
+@%&I';*+E:%,&,"<C$%>J&DE9%*+:*"&"*>&)'$'<#:"&@"P%&>%P%$'C%>&+@%&<',+&*;"*I%>&
;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&"*>&I'<%&I$',%,+&+'&%`C$:I:+$R&CE'+%I+:*9&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%3&
8'+@&@"P%&>:E%I+&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&"II%,,&+'&+@%&=)LN)G3&
&
=*&+@%&E%P%E,%J&"*&;*Q:$$:*9*%,,&+'&:*+%ECE%+&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+,&Q:+@&E%(%E%*I%&+'&
+@%&=)LN)G&I"*&I";,%&+@%&,%P%E%&$:<:+"+:'*&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&):+:Z%*,&'(&+@%&b*:+%>&N+"+%,&"*>&
D;,+E"$:"&Y&#'+@&I';*+E:%,&Q:+@&,+E'*9&$%9"$&,R,+%<,&Y&@"P%&*'&[;>:I:"$&9;"E"*+%%&'(&"&E:9@+&
+'&Q"+%EJ&Q@:I@&<"R&,+%<&:*&C"E+&(E'<&+@%:E&*"+:'*"$&E%(;,"$&+'&%<#E"I%&+@%&=)LN)G3&
!@';9@&$:<:+%>&[;>:I:"$&"I+:P:,<&:*&+@%&A@:$:CC:*%,&@",&"++%<C+%>&+'&%`C"*>&E:9@+,&
CE'+%I+:'*J&"&<"*:(%,+&;*Q:$$:*9*%,,&+'&%*('EI%&+@%&=)LN)G&@",&$:<:+%>&+@%&%`+%*+&'(&+@:,&
&
71&
Q'EB3&8"*9$">%,@&"*>&A"B:,+"*&E%<":*&:*I"C"#$%&'(&=*>:"U,&[;>:I:"$&:*:+:"+:P%&('E&+@%&,"<%&
E%",'*3&!@%&CE'#$%<,&'(&*'*T%*,@E:*%<%*+&"E%&<',+&I$%"E$R&,%%*&:*&+@%&N';+@&D(E:I"*&
9$Q0+6O*&I",%3&!@%&I';E+&+@%E%&I@',%&+'&:*+%ECE%+&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&Q:+@&
E%(%E%*I%&+'&>'<%,+:I&$%9"$&,+"*>"E>,&"$'*%J&,@;**:*9&+@%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<3&!@%&
:*"CCE'CE:"+%*%,,&'(&WE%",'*"#$%&,+"+%&"I+:'*X&",&"&#%*I@<"EB&('E&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&
%*('EI%<%*+&@",&"$E%">R&#%%*&>%<'*,+E"+%>3&
&
=+&<"R&,%%<&'#P:';,&+'&",,%E+&+@"+&+@%&=)LN)G&:,&+@%&$:*I@C:*&('E&%((%I+:P%&CE'+%I+:'*&
'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,J&%,C%I:"$$R&,:*I%&+@%&$%9"$&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&>%C%*>,&,'&<;I@&'*&
)'P%*"*+&CE'P:,:'*,3&=*&+@%&%*>J&@'Q%P%EJ&:+&:,&Q'E+@&*'+:*9&+@"+&E"+:(:I"+:'*&'(&+@%&=)LN)G&
:,&*'+&'*$R&"*&:<C'E+"*+&,+%C&:*&%,+"#$:,@:*9&E%,C'*,:#:$:+R&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
$"QJ&#;+&"$,'&"&B%R&%$%<%*+&:*&*"+:'*"$&CE'+%I+:'*&",&:+&CE'P:>%,&I';E+,&Q:+@&"*&:*P"$;"#$%&
$%9"$&#",:,&('E&:*+%ECE%+"+:'*3&=(&'*%&$%,,'*&I"*&#%&>E"Q*&(E'<&+@%&CE%I%>:*9&I",%,J&:+&:,&+@:,H&
+@%&<'E%&I$%"E$R&"II%,,:#$%&+@%&=)LN)G&('E&[;>:I:"$&;,%J&+@%&9E%"+%E&"*>&<'E%&*;"*I%>&+@%&
CE'+%I+:'*&('E&Q"+%E&E:9@+,3&&
&
B<(42(A*2&,6#0*2(
&
!@:,&%,,"R&@",&>%<'*,+E"+%>&+@%&$%9"$&#",:,&('E&"*&:*>%C%*>%*+&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&
Q"+%EJ&>%P%$'C:*9&(E'<&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&I'*,%*,;,&:*+'&"&E%"$:+R&'(&C',:+:P%&$"Q3&!@%&,'I:'T
%I'*'<:I&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&<',+&"CCE'CE:"+%$R&>%E:P%>&(E'<&+@%&=)LN)GJ&@",&I$%"E&*'E<"+:P%&
I'*+%*+&"*>&C$"I%,&%c;"$$R&I$%"E&'#$:9"+:'*,&'*&+@%&,+"+%3&N;I@&"*&;*>%E,+"*>:*9&'(&Q"+%E&
E:9@+,J&#'E*&",&:+&:,&(E'<&+@%&:*+%ECE%+"+:P%&Q'EB&'(&+@%&)LN)GJ&I"**'+&#%&%`C$":*%>&
,%C"E"+%$R&(E'<&+@%&I'*I%C+&'(&:+,&W<:*:<;<&I'E%3X&!@:,&I'*I%C+;"$&+''$&:,&<%"*+&+'&
>:,+:*9;:,@&:<<%>:"+%$R&#:*>:*9&'#$:9"+:'*,&(E'<&+@%&(;$$&,I'C%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&:*&"&Q"R&+@"+&
,;CC'E+,&+@%&%$0#*2(8L":%"&'(&+@%&)'P%*"*+&:+,%$(3&!@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%J&:+&:,&@'C%>J&Q:$$&<'E%&
">%c;"+%$R&CE'+%I+&,+"B%@'$>%E,&#R&I$',:*9&+@%&$''C@'$%&'(&WCE'9E%,,:P%&E%"$:Z"+:'*3X&!@%&
I'<C$:I"+:'*&"<:>,+&+@:,&I$"E:+R&I'<%,&:*&+@%&;+:$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&#R&*"+:'*"$&
I';E+,J&",&+@:,&E:9@+&]*'&<"++%E&:+,&%`:,+%*I%&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&$"Q^&$"IB,&%`C$:I:+&
%*,@E:*%<%*+&:*&+E%"+R3&=(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:,&+'&#%I'<%&"&620?"%#$,&E:9@+&:*&CE"I+:I%J&+@%&
:*+%9E:+R&'(&+@%&$%9"$&*'E<&<;,+&#%&E%:*('EI%>&"*>&*'+&Q%"B%*%>&:*&:+,&*"+:'*"$&"CC$:I"+:'*3&
&
7/&
V:+@&'*%&*'+"#$%&%Ì%C+:'*J&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&@",&R%+&+'&<%%+&"&,%E:';,&
I@"$$%*9%&:*&:+,&*"+:'*"$&"CC$:I"+:'*3&=(&"*R+@:*9J&*"+:'*"$&I",%&$"Q&%`@:#:+,&"&I%E+":*&
:<<"+;E:+R&:*&:+,&I'*I%C+;"$&>%(%*,%&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3&K',+&[;>9<%*+,&E%(%E%*I%&+@%&
E:9@+&:*&P"9;%J&9%*%E"$&+%E<,J&(":$:*9&+'&';+$:*%&:+,&I'*+%*+&"*>&'#$:9"+:'*,&I'*I$;,:P%$R3&
V:+@';+&"&>';#+J&+@:,&C;%E:$:+R&:,&#'E*&(E'<&+@%&*'P%$+R&'(&+@%&I'*I%C+&:+,%$(&"*>&:+,&
+%*>%*IR&+'&I$",@&Q:+@&%*+E%*I@%>&$%9"$&*'E<,&]%`3&CE'C%E+R&$"Q^&"*>&[;,+:I:"#:$:+R&
E%c;:E%<%*+,3&\;>:I:"$&@%,:+"*IRJ&@'Q%P%EJ&<"R&#%&Q%"B%*:*9&,'<%Q@"+3&M"+:'*"$&I';E+,&
@"P%&CE'P%*&:*IE%",:*9$R&Q:$$:*9J&%,C%I:"$$R&:*&+@%&C",+&(:P%&R%"E,J&+'&E%(%E%*I%&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&
,+"*>"E>,&:*&+@%:E&[;E:,CE;>%*I%3&!@%E%&:,&C$%*+R&'(&E''<&('E&+@%&(;+;E%&>%P%$'C<%*+&'(&+@:,&
W9E%%*X&[;E:,CE;>%*I%&:*+'&<'E%&<"+;E%&%(('E+,&'(&$%9"$TI'*,+E;I+:'*J&%,C%I:"$$R&:(&I';E+,&
"E%&9E"*+%>&9E%"+%E&"II%,,&+'&+@%&=)LN)G&+@E';9@&$%9:,$"+:'*&'E&[;>:I:"$&:*:+:"+:P%3&!@%&
CE'I%,,&';+$:*%>&"#'P%&:,&'*$R&#%9:**:*9J&#;+&,'&("E&:+&,%%<,&+'&#%&9':*9&Q%$$3&
=+&E%<":*,&+''&%"E$R&+'&B*'Q&@'Q&*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&Q:$$&(:*"$$R&@"*>$%&+@%&<:*:<;<&
I'E%3&D*&"*"$R,:,&'(&+@%&"#'P%&I",%,&E%P%"$,&"&9E%"+&>%"$&'(&:<C$:I:+&,;CC'E+&('E&,;I@&"&
I"$I;$;,J&",&I';E+,&@"P%&]"^&<">%&E%(%E%*I%&+'&W%,,%*+:"$&<:*:<;<&$%P%$,X&('E&,'I:'T
%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&]N+"+%&'(&M%Q&~'EBJ&=*>:"^J&]#^&>:,+:*9;:,@%>&:<<%>:"+%&(E'<&CE'9E%,,:P%&
E%,C'*,:#:$:+:%,&]=*>:"J&DE9%*+:*"^J&]I^&%,+"#$:,@%>&,C%I:(:I&"<';*+,&'(&Q"+%E&+'&#%&CE'P:>%>&
(E%%&'(&I@"E9%&]8%$9:;<J&DE9%*+:*"^J&"*>&]>^&%<#E"I%>&+@%&(;$$&>%(:*:+:'*&'(&+@%&E:9@+&:*&
d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6&]=*>'*%,:"J&)'$'<#:"^3&)'$'<#:"&@",&%P%*&"CC$:%>&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&+'&
'+@%E&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,&$:B%&@';,:*9&"*>&@%"$+@3&=*&*'*%&'(&+@%&"#'P%&I",%,J&@'Q%P%EJ&
@",&"&*"+:'*"$&I';E+&%`C$:I:+$R&%<#E"I%>&+@:,&"CCE'"I@&('E&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E3&
&
V@%+@%E&$"99:*9&"II%C+"*I%&'(&+@%&I'E%&I'*I%C+&,+%<,&(E'<&:+,&C'$:+:I"$&
;*C'C;$"E:+RJ&I'*I%C+;"$&CE'#$%<,J&'E&'*$R&+@%&$"IB&'(&>%P%$'C<%*+&:*&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&
[;E:,CE;>%*I%&9%*%E"$$RJ&'*%&+@:*9&E%<":*,&I$%"EH&+@%&E%C$"I%<%*+&'(&"&<:*:<;<&I'E%&Q:+@&
"&Q%"B%E&,+"*>"E>&'(&%*('EI%<%*+&I"*&I";,%&,:9*:(:I"*+&I'*I%C+;"$&CE'#$%<,&:*&E:9@+,&
:*+%ECE%+"+:'*3&!@%&9$Q0+6O*&I",%&:,&+@%&'*$R&*'+"#$%&I@"$$%*9%&+'&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&,:*I%&
d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6&Q",&C;#$:,@%>&:*&.55.3&8R&E%C$"I:*9&+@%&<:*:<;<&I'E%&Q:+@&"&
,+"*>"E>&'(&WE%",'*"#$%*%,,JX&+@%&I';E+&:*+%ECE%+%>&+@%&I'*,+:+;+:'*"$&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&:*&"&
Q"R&+@"+&;*>%E<:*%>&#'+@&+@%&CE:*I:C$%&'(&*'*T>:,IE:<:*"+:'*&"*>&+@%&P:+"$&E'$%&'(&+@%&
[;>:I:"ER3&=*&>%$:#%E"+%$R&$:<:+:*9&+@%&>'<%,+:I&%*('EI%"#:$:+R&'(&+@%&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&+@%&
)';E+U,&E%",'*:*9&Q%"B%*%>&+@%&*'E<"+:P%&(';*>"+:'*&'(&+@"+&E:9@+&:+,%$(3&D,&:<C'E+"*+&",&
&
77&
+@:,&[;>9<%*+&<"R&,%%<&:*&W9:P:*9&I'*+%*+X&+'&+@%&@;<"*&E:9@+&+'&Q"+%EJ&@'Q%P%EJ&+@%E%&
,%%<&+'&#%&,:9*:(:I"*+&>'<%,+:I&("I+'E,&"+&Q'EB&+@"+&Q';$>&$:<:+&:+,&+E"*,<:,,:'*&"#E'">3&
F;E&Q'EB&@%E%&CE'P%,&+@%&[;>:I:"$&%*('EI%"#:$:+R&'(&Q"+%E&E:9@+,&Y&"&("I+&+@"+&Q",&
'*I%&I'*,:>%E%>&>;#:';,&('E&"$$&,'I:'T%I'*'<:I&E:9@+,3&K'E%&+@"*&+@:,J&:+&,;99%,+,&+@"+&
*"+:'*"$&I';E+,&"E%&+@%<,%$P%,&<'P:*9&+'Q"E>&"&<'E%&'C%*&%<#E"I%&'(&+@:,&[;,+:I:"#:$:+R3&=(&
I'*I%C+;"$$R&E''+%>&:*&:*+%E*"+:'*"$&*'E<,J&+@:,&$%9"$&,@:(+&<"R&'*%&>"R&%*,;E%&+@%&@;<"*&
E:9@+&+'&Q"+%E&+E;%&W;*:P%E,"$:+RX&:*&CE"I+:I%3&V:+@&I$:<"+%&I@"*9%J&C'C;$"+:'*&9E'Q+@&"*>&
'+@%E&IE:,%,&:*&@;<"*&>%P%$'C<%*+&R%+&;*('E%,%%*&$''<:*9&#%('E%&;,J&,;I@&"&9'"$&#%I'<%,&
%P%E&<'E%&CE%,,:*93&
! ='0#("##$7(0#(#6+-0::"8(H0:'(:'"($6:'*%L#(1%$:0:68"(:*(B%":(='0","($:()FaGL(x3*%(1608$2&"l.(
F$+%0","(c6$28:.(!$@'$",(C$21"2#&'"08:($28(C"*2$%8(C$21"2#&'"08:(x3*%(@%*?08021(:'"(+"#:(
02:",,"&:6$,($:",0"%(@*##0+,"l.(/&*::(A'%0#:0$2.(!"8$(g$8-0%0.(9$%0:T6(A'$#:",,0"%.(g$:",72(>0"-$2^
y$6-$2($28(/0-*2"([$11"%#^!$8*,@'(x3*%(3%0"28#'0@($28(-*%$,(#6@@*%:l.(9$'-*68(S$-08(x3*%($2(
02"#:0-$+,"(H"$,:'(*3(@$:0"2&"l($28([*'2($28(`"%*20&$(9&F%$H(x3*%(:'"0%("28,"##(,*?"($28(@%$7"%#l(
;9>F<(((
&
7?&
! G.G:.KV+L!7.>L:*.FWK+AL5.KF*
*
L:!7LGX5.>L:*G.G:.KV+L!7Y*
&
vs&N;<<:+&'(&a%">,&'(&N+"+%&"*>&d'P%E*<%*+&'(&+@%&M'*TD$:9*%>&K'P%<%*+J&N@"E<&%$&N@%:BJ&L9RC+J&\;$R&--T-1J&.55?J&
U02$,(>*&6-"2:J&MDK.55?OS2O2'I3-J($?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3*"<%9RC+3'E9O%*OG%$%P"*+2'I;<%*+,OA"9%,O>%(";$+3",C`&]P:"&W(:*"$&>'I;<%*+X&@RC%E$:*B^3(
(
;(E$:0*2$,(>0#1%$&".(A$2$8$L#(/'$-"36,()*#0:0*2(*2(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&The Council of Canadians&]K"E3&.6J&.557^.(
&
D3A3&A'$$;+:'*&)'*+E'$&8'"E>T==&P3&K3s3&M"R;>;J&].55-^&0&=3_3G3&16/&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3:%$EI3'E9OI'*+%*+O%55-53C>(3(
&
D$:I:"&L$R&~"<:*&j&F,I"E&A"EE"&s%E"J&='"(!*,"(*3(A*6%:#(02(>"302021(S"$,:'()*,0&7R(='"(A$#"(*3(:'"(A*,*-+0$2(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(
A*6%:&]a"EP"E>&_"Q&NI@''$&a;<"*&G:9@+,&AE'9E"<&V'EB:*9&A"C%EJ&.557^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3$"Q3@"EP"E>3%>;OCE'9E"<,O@ECO>'I;<%*+,O~"<:*hA"EE"hQ'EB:*9hC"C%E3C>(3&
&
D<"*>"&)"@:$$J&='"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%(f(;(!01':(*3(\2056"(/:$:6#R(='"(C"1$,(/:$:6#($28(E*%-$:0?"(A*2:"2:(*3(:'"(!01':(
:*(D$:"%.(?]4^(Intl J. Hum. Rts.&47?&].556^3&&
&
Amnesty International, Troubled Waters: Palestinians Denied Access to Water&].55?^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3*9'T<'*:+'E3'E9O>"+"O:<"9%,OS:$%OD<*%,+RhQ"+%Eh--.3C>(3&&
&
D*>E%Q&a'$$"*>J&A'0,"L#(A*2#:0:6:0*2R(D$:"%(:*(+"($(9$::"%(*3(E$:0*2$,(/"&6%0:7J&Blog: The Transatlantic Dialogue on
Climate Change and Security ]\"*3&.1J&.5-5J&6H6/&AK^.(@++CHOOI$:<"+%,%I;E:+R3#$'9,C'+3I'<O.5-5O5-OI@:$%,T
I'*,+:+;+:'*TQ"+%ET+'T#%T<"++%E3@+<$3&
&
D*[;*&=E("*&P&_"@'E%&2%P3&D;+@3&].55.^&A_2&]_"@'E%^&666&]_"@'E%&D:E&A'$$;+:'*&)",%^&]A"B3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.4?5J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources
for the Right to Water and Sanitation: International and National Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&
]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.?5^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
;2*:'"%(B$8(48"$(D'0&'(D"(E""8(:*(;&:(W2.(Global Water Intelligence&]K"E3&-7J&.5-5^J(
&
D*+@'*R&NI'++&j&d%'E9:*"&)';,+"$:*J&='"(G?*,6:0*2(*3(D$:"%(!01':#.(46]0^&M"+3&G%,3&\3&7.-&]-??6^3&
&
D*+'*:'&L3&=E;['J&='"(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev&.1/&].55/^3*&
&
DE[;*&i3&i@">B"J&='"(G-"%1"2&"(*3(D$:"%($#($(VS6-$2(!01':L(*2(:'"(D*%,8(/:$1"R(A'$,,"21"#($28(W@@*%:620:0"#.&.1]-^&Intl
J. Water Res. Dev.&4/&].5-5^3&&
&
Arnaud Courtecuisse, Agence de lEau Artois-Picardie, Water Prices and Households Available Income:
Key Indicators for the Assessment of Potential Disproportionate Costs - Illustration from the ArtoisPicardie Basin (France) ].55/^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3#"$Q':,3I'<O#"$Q':,O"><:*:,+E"+:'*O(;$$hC"C%EO((CT7013C>(3&&
&
D,:+&8:,Q",&j&)%I:$:"&!'E+"[">"J&A'$21021(F,*+$,(D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:(C$28#&$@".&02&Water Management in 2020 and
Beyond&-5&]D3i3&8:,Q",&%+&"$3&%>,3J&.551^3&
&
D,:+&i3&8:,Q",J&D$:"%($#($(S6-$2(!01':(02(:'"(9GE;(!"10*2R(A'$,,"21"#($28(W@@*%:620:0"#.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev&
.5?&].55/^3&
&
D,B&D:*&'&N"$:,@&i%*>E"&P3&8"*9$3&&]-???^&-?&83_323&077&]8"*9$3^J&#6--$%0Q"8(02&D,B&D:*&'&N"$:,@J&a;<"*&G:9@+,&:*&
8"$9$">%,@&.555, ESCR-Net ].55-^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3%,IET*%+3'E9OI",%$"QOI",%$"Qh,@'Q3@+<n>'Ih:>o055?.5&
]$",+&P:,:+%>&M'P3&?J&.5-5^3(
&
Audrey Chapman & Sage Russell, 42:%*86&:0*2.(02 Core Obligations: Building a Framework for Economic,
Social and Cultural Rights -&].55.^3
&
?5&
&
D;>E%R&G3&)@"C<"*J&;(I`0*,$:0*2#(;@@%*$&'M(3*%(9*20:*%021(:'"(42:"%2$:0*2$,(A*?"2$2:(*2(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(
!01':#.(-7&Hum. Rts. Q.&.4&]-??1^3&
&
Bangladesh Shongbidhan [Constitution} M'P3&0J&-?/.&]8"*9$3^3&
83)3D3&!'%#%,J&=*H$%8#($2(4-@%*?"8(\28"%#:$28021(*3(:'"(42:"%2$:0*2$,(S6-$2(!01':(:*(S"$,:'J&.- Human Rights
Quarterly 11-&]-???^3
&
8%+"&!%E["["@(!;"*T!;"*J&F"2:,"-"2.(D"($%"(A*,*20#"8o&Gatra Magazine&].55.^3*
&
Bob Clifford,&U01':021(3*%(E"H(!01':#J&02 The International Struggle for New Human Rights -&].55?^3&
(
B*,0?0$()6#'"#(3*%($(\20?"%#$,(D$:"%(!01':J&New Tang Dynasty Television Online&]K"E3&.4J&.5-5^J&
@++CHOO%*9$:,@3*+>+P3I'<O*+>+Ph%*O*,h,"O.5-5T54T.4O451.16.6-.-03@+<$3&*
&
8'**&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&SE%,@Q"+%EJ&8'**J&d%E3J&2%I3&4T/J&.55-J(!"&*--"28$:0*2#(3*%(;&:0*2<&
&
Q"+%EOu<'E%T-4/0/3&
&
Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor, United States Department of State, 2009 Human Rights
Report: Pakistan ].5-5^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3,+"+%39'PO9O>E$OE$,O@EEC+O.55?O,I"O-415?.3@+<3&
C.A. Const.&"E+3&vJ&{&.3&
)<"E"&>%&DC%$"I:'*%,&%*&$'&):P:$&R&)'<%EI:"$&e)DC%$3))&Mc*3f&eM%;c;%*&)';E+&'(&DCC%"$,&:*&):P:$&"*>&)'<<%EI:"$&
K"++%E,f&.O4O-??/J&WK%*'E%,&)'<;*:>">&A"R*%<:$&O&"II:*&"<C"E'&]DE93^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%,IET
*%+3'E9O;,Eh>'IO,%*+%*I:"hI<"E"hA"R*%<:$3+:(J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Malcolm Langford et al., Centre for Housing
Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water: International and National Standards&---&
].550^3&&
)"<C":9*&('E&S:,I"$&Lc;:+R&P3&N+"+%&'(&M~J&-55&M3~&3.>&7?4&].554^3&
&
)"<C":9*&('E&S:,I"$&Lc;:+R&P3&N+"+%&'(&M~J&7&M3~3&4>&-0&].551^3&
A$#"(C$HR()"*@,"L#(\20*2(3*%(A0?0,(C0+"%:0"#(?<(\20*2(*3(4280$($28(W:'"%#.(ESCR-Net.org, @++CHOOQQQ3%,IET
*%+3'E9OI",%$"QOI",%$"Qh,@'Q3@+<n>'Ih:>o05-544&]$",+&P:,:+%>&M'P3&7J&.5-5^3
)",%&'(&+@%&SE%%&z'*%,&'(&bCC%E&N"P'R&"*>&+@%&2:,+E:I+&'(&d%`&]SE3&s3&NQ:+Z3^J&-?4.J&A3)3=3\3&]N%E3&DO8^&M'3&0/J&"+&?1&]\;*%&/^3
Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Human Rights and Access to Water and Sanitation: Acting on the
Report of the OHCHR&].55/^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3E:9@++'Q"+%E3:*('OC>(,O.55/aG)Q%#3C>(3&
&
Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water and Sanitation:
International and National Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
)%*+E%&'*&a';,:*9&G:9@+,&"*>&LP:I+:'*,&P3&N;>"*J&D(E3&)'<<x*&a;<3&j&A%'C$%,x&G+,3J&)'<<3&M'3&.?1T56&]\;$R&.?J&.5-5^3(
&
A"%:030&$:0*2(*3(:'"(A*2#:0:6:0*2(*3(:'"(!"@6+,0&(*3(/*6:'(;3%0&$(-??1&]//^&ND&/00&]))^&]N3&D(E3^3&
&
)@"<%$:&N:*9@&P3&b++"E&AE">%,@J&]-??1^&].^&N3)3)3&60?&]=*>:"^3&
&
&
)@:,"*9"&A;+%T)@%BQ%&j&M'E"&S$''>J&U%*-(>0?0#0*2(:*(42:"1%$:0*2R(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#($#(B$#0&(S6-$2(
!01':#.&02&Giving Meaning to Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights&4?&]=,("@"*&K%E"$:&j&s"$%E:%&F',+%EP%$>&%>,3J&
.55-^3&
&
&
?-&
)'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&)'*,:>%E"+:'*&'(&G%C'E+,&N;#<:++%>&#R&N+"+%,&A"E+:%,&;*>%E&DE+:I$%&05&'(&+@%&)'P%*"*+&
]=,E"%$J&D>P"*I%&)'CR^J&?/+@&N%,,3J&FI+3&-.T45J&.55?J&b3M3&2'I3&))AGO)O=NGO4&]M'P3&.-J&.557^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOO>"II%,,T
>>,T*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd57O066O?5OA2SOd57066?53C>(nFC%*L$%<%*+3&
&
)'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&1H&!@%&G:9@+&+'&_:(%J&-1+@&N%,,3J&\;$R&-.T45J&-?7.J&b3M3&dDFGJ&
4/+@&N%,,3J&N;CC3&M'3&05J&DO4/O05&]\;$R&45J&-?7.^J&%"@%02:"8(02&)'<C:$"+:'*&'(&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&"*>&d%*%E"$&
G%I'<<%*>"+:'*,&D>'C+%>&#R&a;<"*&G:9@+,&!E%"+R&8'>:%,J&b3M3&2'I3&aG=OdLMO-OG%P3-J&"+&1&]\;$R&./J&-??0^3&
&
)'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&-7H&M'*T2:,IE:<:*"+:'*J&4/+@&N%,,3J&FI+3&.4&Y&M'P3&-5J&-?7?J&b3M3&
dDFGJ&06+@&N%,,3J&N;CC3&M'3&05J&DO06O05J&"+&-/4&]M'P3&?J&-?7?^J&$?$0,$+,"&$:&@++CHOO>'I;<%*+,T>>,T
&
)'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&_:,+&'(&=,,;%,&+'&#%&!"B%*&bC&:*&)'**%I+:'*&Q:+@&+@%&)'*,:>%E"+:'*&'(&+@%&!@:E>&
A%E:'>:I&G%C'E+&'(&=,E"%$&]D>P"*I%&s%E,:'*^J&b3M3&2'I3())AGO)O=NGO|O4&]M'P3&-/J&.55?^J("+(
@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,O@EIO>'I,OD>P"*I%s%E,:'*,O))AGT)T=NGT|43C>(3&
)'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&!@:E>&A%E:'>:I&G%C'E+&'(&=,E"%$&>;%&:*&.55/J&b3M3&2'I3&))AGO)O=NGO4&]M'P3&.-J&.557^J&
"+&@++CHOO>"II%,,T>>,T*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd57O066O?5OA2SOd57066?53C>(nFC%*L$%<%*+3&
&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&)"*">"J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.O)DMO)FO0J&LO)3-.O)DMO)FO6J&]K"R&..J&.551^J&"+&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@IE3'E9OE%(Q'E$>O>'I:>O064//("453@+<$3&
&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&=*>:"J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.O=M2O)FO6&]D;93&7J&.557^J&"+&
&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@IE3'E9OE%(Q'E$>O>'I:>O4(1I#041/3@+<$3&
&
&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&M%C"$J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.OMA_O)FO.&]\"*3&-1J&.557^J&"+&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@IE3'E9OE%(Q'E$>O>'I:>O0/?76I.5.3@+<$3&
&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&A@:$:CC:*%,J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.OAa_O)FO0&]2%I3&-J&.557^J&"+&
&
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&4H&!@%&M"+;E%&'(&N+"+%,&A"E+:%,U&F#$:9"+:'*,J&b3M3&2'I3&
aG=OdLMO-OG%P31&"+&-0&]2%I3&-0J&-??5^J&"+&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@I@E3I@O+#,O>'I3*,(O5O?0#>#"(6?#04"0.0I-.614%>556.#110nFC%*>'I;<%*+3&
&
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&?H&!@%&2'<%,+:I&DCC$:I"+:'*&'(&+@%&)'P%*"*+J&b3M3&
2'I3&LO)3-.O-??7O.0&]2%I3&4J&-??7^J&"+&@++CHOO>'I;<%*+,T>>,T
&
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&-.H&!@%&G:9@+&+'&D>%c;"+%&S''>J&b3M3&2'I3&
LO)3-.O-???O--&]K"R&-.J&-???^J&$?$0,$+,"&$:&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@I@E3I@O+#,O>'I3*,(O5O4>5./67I/5/54->675.61//(554#/4#?3&
&&
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-0H&!@%&G:9@+&+'&+@%&a:9@%,+&D++":*"#$%&
N+"*>"E>&'(&a%"+@J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.O.555O0&]D;93&--J&.555^J&"+&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@I@E3I@O+#,O>'I3*,(O],R<#'$ÔL3)3-.3.555303L*3&
&
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6H&!@%&G:9@+&+'&V"+%EJ&.?+@&N%,,3J&M'P3&--T.?J&.55.3&
b3M3&LN)FGJ&&.554J&N;CC3&M'3&.J&LO.554O..TLO)3-.O.55.O-4J&"+&-.5&]\"*3&.5J&.554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOO>'I;<%*+,T>>,T
*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd54O0-0O66OC>(Od540-0663C>(nFC%*L$%<%*+3&
&
&
?.&
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&.5H&M'*T2:,IE:<:*"+:'*&:*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.Od)O.5&]\;*%&-5J&.55?^J&"+&
QQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,OI%,IEO>'I,O9IOL3)3-.3d)3.53>'I3&
&
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&=*+E'>;I+:'*H&!@%&A;EC',%&'(&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,J&4>&N%,,3J&S%#3&1T.0J&
-?7?J&b3M3&LN)FGJ&-?7?J&N;CC3&M'3&0J&LO-?7?O..TLO)3-.O-?7?O6J&"+&7/&]S%#3&.0J&-?7?^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOO>'I;<%*+,T
>>,T*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd7?O-/7O-?OC>(Od7?-/7-?3C>(nFC%*L$%<%*+3&
&
A*--0::""(*2(G&*2*-0&($28(/*&0$,(!01':#(F"2"%$,(A*--"2:#.&Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights,
@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,OI%,IEOI'<<%*+,3@+<&]$",+&P:,:+%>&M'P3&7J&.5-5^3&
&
Constitucin Nacional(D;93&..J&-??0&]DE93^3&
&
&
Constitucin de la Provincia de Crdoba(DCE3&.1J&-?7/&])E>'#"J&DE93^3&
(
Constitucin Political de Colombia&\;$R&6J&-??-3&
Constitution Coordonn&S%#3&-/J&-??0&]8%$93^3(
Constitution de la Rpublique Dmocratique du Congo&S%#3&-7J&.5513&*
&
Constitution of India, \"*3&.1J&-?653&
&
Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, D;93&-0J&-?/43&
&
Constitution of the Kingdom of Cambodia&N%C3&.-J&-??43&

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, Act 108 of 1996&S%#3&0J&-??/3&
&
)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&L$:<:*"+:'*&'(&D$$&S'E<,&'(&2:,IE:<:*"+:'*&"9":*,+&V'<%*J&2%I3&-7J&-?/?J&-.0?&b3M3!3N3&-43&
&
)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&_"Q&'(&+@%&M'*TM"P:9"+:'*"$&b,%,&'(&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&V"+%EI';E,%,J&d3&D3&E%,3&6-O..?J&D**%`J&b3M3&dDFGJ&
6-,+&N%,,3J&??+@&<+93J&bM&2'I3&DOGLNO6-O..?&]*@"2"8(3*%(#012$:6%"(K"R&.-J&-??/^J&41&=3_3K3&/553&
&
)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&G:9@+,&'(&+@%&)@:$>J&M'P3&.5J&-?7?J&-6//&b3M3!3N3&43&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&<"R'&.7J&-??/J&L`C%>:%*+%&2T-100&])'$'<3^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??/O)T6.-T?/3@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&);"E+"&>%&G%P3J&"9',+'&-J&.55.J&L`C%>:%*+%&.554T1?/11/&])'$'<3^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.554O!T0-5T543@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&);"E+"&>%&G%P3J&*'P:%<#E%&4J&-??.J&L`C%>:%*+%&-??.T-707&
])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??.O!T6/7T?.3@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&AE:<%E"&>%&G%P3J&"#E:$&-/J&.55/J&L`C%>:%*+%&.55/T-0.17-7&
])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.55/O!T./5T5/3@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&N%9;*>"&>%&G%P3J&"9',+'&1J&.55?J&L`C%>:%*+%&.55?T..6?6-?&
])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.55?O!T601T5?3@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&N%9;*>"&>%&G%P3J&[;$:'&4-J&.557J&L`C%>:%*+%&.554T-.7-.0/J&!T
-71/4-/J&R&!T-71/4.1&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.557O!T/15T573@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&NpC+:<"&>%&G%P3J&"#E:$&.0J&.551J&L`C%>:%*+%&.551T-.11.5?&
])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.551O!T4-/T513@+<3&
&
])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??0O!T6.4T?03@+<3&
&
?4&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&NpC+:<"&>%&G%P3J&[;*:'&-7J&-??4J&L`C%>:%*+%&-??4T?/-4&])'$'<3^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??4O!T.4.T?43@+<3&&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&NpC+:<"&>%&G%P3J&*'P:%<#E%&..J&-??0J&L`C%>:%*+%&-??0T4061-&
])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??0O!T6.4T?03@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&!%EI%E"&>%&G%P3J&"9',+'&-J&.55.J&L`C%>:%*+%&.55.T6744.5&])'$'<3^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.55.O!T6?7T5.3@+<3&
&
)'E+%&N;CE%<"&>%&\;,+:I:"&e)3N3\3f&eN;CE%<%&)';E+fJ&.6&*'P:%<#E%&.55?J&WD$%["*>E'&A"C:I&2'<:*9;%Z&I'*&)'<;*:>">&
=*>:9%*"&DR<"E"&)@;Z<:Z"&R&b,<"9"<"JX&G'$&>%&$"&I";,"H.705T57J&E%I;E,'&>%&CE'+%II:*&])@:$%^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3C'>%E[;>:I:"$3I$O<'>;$',O8;,c)";,",O8)Dh%,+"05.3C@CnE'Q>%+"$$%oDDDM'ADDMDD);LEDD)jI'*,;$+"o55jI";,"o.705O.557j*;<I;"o0-.0.j,%IE%obM=)D3&
&
)'E+%&N;CE%<"&>%&\;,+:I:"&>%&$"&M"I:*&e)N\Mf&eM"+:'*"$&N;CE%<%&)';E+&'(&\;,+:I%fJ&-7O?O.55/J&W2%(%*,'E&>%$&A;%#$'&>%&$"&
M"I:*&I3&L,+">'&M"I:'*"$&O&"II:*&"<C"E'X&]DE93^&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3>%E%I@'T
I'<C"E">'3'E9O,%*+%*I:",O"E9!'#",3@+<3&
&
)'E+%&N;CE%<"&>%&\;,+:I:"&>%&$"&M"I:*&e)N\Mf&eM"+:'*"$&N;CE%<%&)';E+&'(&\;,+:I%fJ&.6O7O.55?J&WN%#",+:*&DEE:'$"&R&F+E',&
O&I";,"X&]DE93^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3":>,$%`3'E9O,:+%h>'I;<%*+,O2GT5-40N3C>(3&
&
)';E+&>UDE#:+E"9%&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+f&"EE}+&*'&41O-??7J&DCE3&-J&-??7J&Moniteur Belge&eK8f&eF((:I:"$&d"Z%++%&'(&
8%$9:;<fJ&DCE3&.0J&-??7&]8%$93^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources
]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.?1^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
)E":9&NI'++&j&A@:$:CC&D$,+'*J&;8a680&$:021(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,()%0*%0:0"#(02($(=%$2#2$:0*2$,(A*2:"T:.($(A*--"2:(*2&
/**+%$-*2"7L#(C"1$&7($28(F%**:+,**-L#&)%*-0#".(-1&N3&Afr. J. Hum. Rts.&.51&].555^3&
(
>$:$(902021(F$:"H$7.(WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply and Sanitation(
@++CHOOQQQ3Q,,:*('3'E9O>"+"<:*:*9O+"#$%,3@+<$&]$",+&P:,:+%>&FI+3&-7J&.5-5^3&
&
2"P:>&8:$I@:+ZJ&F0?021(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#(="":'R(='"(9020-6-(A*%"($28(4:#(4-@*%:$2&".&--?&S. Afr. L.J.&070&].55.^3&
&
2"P:>&83&8E''B,J(S6-$2(!01':#(:*(D$:"%(02(E*%:'(;3%0&$($28(:'"(9088,"(G$#:R(D'$:(0#(E"H($28(D'$:(0#(E*:Z(D'$:(0#(
4-@*%:$2:($28(D'$:(0#(E*:.(.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev&../&].55/^3&
&
David Shiman, Economic and Social Justice: A Human Rights Perspective ]-???^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
&
2"P:>&z%+$"*>J&W2(97(9028R(D$:"%(!01':#($28(S6-$2(!01':#J&Forbes Magazine Online&]DCE3&-.J&.5-5^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3('E#%,3I'<O('E#%,O.5-5O50-.O'C:*:'*,T,"*:+"+:'*T@":+:T@;<"*TE:9@+,T'*T<RT<:*>3@+<$3&
&
2"Q>"&\"Q"E"&P3&d"<#:"J&D(E3&)'<<U*&a;<3&j&A%'C$%,x&G+,3J&)'<<3&M'3&-0/O?6&j&-0?O?1&]K"R&--3&.555^3&
&
2pIE%+&>%&$"&)'<<;*";+p&S$"<"*>%&I'*I%E*"*+&>:P%E,%,&<%,;E%,&>U"II'<C"9*%<%*+&>;&#;>9%+&-??/&e2%IE%%&'(&+@%&
S$%<:,@&)'<<;*:+R&G%$"+:*9&+'&s"E:';,&K%",;E%,&DII'<C"*R:*9&+@%&8;>9%+&'(&-??/f&'(&2%I3&.5J&-??1J&Monitieur Belge&
eK383f&eF((:I:"$&d"Z%++%&'(&8%$9:;<f&2%I3&4-J&-??13&
&
L3N3)3&G%,3&-??5O06J&b3M3&2'I3&LO-??5O/5OD>>3-&]K"R&4J&-??5^3&
&
LE:B&83&8$;%<%$J&='"(4-@,0&$:0*2#(*3(U*%-6,$:021($(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&4-&Ecology L.Q.&?6/&].550^3(
&
S3i3&a;,,":*&P3&b*:'*&'(&=*>:"&]-??5^&D3=3G3&]i%E3^&4.-J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.0?/J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&
Malcolm Langford et al., Centre for Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to
Water: International and National Standards&--1&].550^3&
&
S"E''c;%&P3&8"*9$">%,@J&]-??1^&07&23_3G3&]a)^&047&]S$''>&DI+:'*&A$"*&)",%J&a:9@&)';E+^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&\'*"&
$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3#:$:"#>3'E9O#$[OI'*+%*+-3@+<3&
&
?0&
&
S"E''c;%&P3&8"*9$">%,@J&]-??/^&0?&23_3G3&]D2^&-&]S$''>&DI+:'*&A$"*&)",%J&DCC%$$"+%^3&
&
S"E''c;%&P3&8"*9$">%,@J&;*E%C'E+%>&V3A3&?.&]\;$3&-J&-??1^&]G">:'"I+:P%&K:$B&A'Q>%E&)",%^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-4.43&
&
S"E''c;%&P3&8"*9$">%,@J&;*E%C'E+%>&V3A3&7?-&]-??0^J&]>%I:,:'*&\;$R&-6J&.55-^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.6/7.(@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources
]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.7.^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3(
&
S%BE:&D3&a",,"*J&D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:($28(G$%,7(A0?0,0Q$:0*2#R(3%*-(A**@"%$:0*2(:*(A*23,0&:.(02&History and Future of
Shared Water Resources, .&]bMLN)F&%>3J&.554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOO;*%,>'I3;*%,I'3'E9O:<"9%,O55-4O55-44.O-44.71%3C>(3&*
&
S:E,+&D(E:I"TN';+@&D<%E:I"&N;<<:+J&D#;["J&M:9%E:"J&M'P3&.1T45J&.551J&;+6a$(>"&,$%$:0*2J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
&
S:E,+&D,:"TA"I:(:I&V"+%E&N;<<:+J&8%CC;J&\"C"*J2%I3&4T0J&.55/J&9"##$1"(3%*-(B"@@6J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
&
S:E,+&b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&)'*9E%,,&'*&+@%&AE%P%*+:'*&'(&)E:<%&"*>&+@%&!E%"+<%*+&'(&F((%*>%E,J&D;93&..&Y&N%C3&4J&-?66J&
/:$28$%8(9020-6-(!6,"#(3*%(:'"(=%"$:-"2:(*3()%0#*2"%#J&b3M3&2'I3&DO)FMSO1--J&D**%`&=J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ-3;<*3%>;O@;<"*E+,O:*,+E%%O9-,<E3@+<3&
&
FoodFirst Information and Action Network, Investigating Some Alleged Violations of the Human Right to
Water in India: Report of the International Fact Finding Mission to India&]N"#:*%&A"#,+&%+&"$3&%>,3J&.550^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3E":*Q"+%EI$;#3'E9O>'I,OE%C'E+hB'<C$%++3C>(3&
&
SE"*I:,&)'E"$:%&K;$$:*&P3&b*:'*&!%EE:+'ER&'(&2%$@:J(]-?7-^&.&N3)3G3&6-1&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3:*>:"*B"*''*3'E9O>'IO/7641OJ&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal
Resources for the Right to Water and Sanitation: International and National Standards&].*>&%>3J&
('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&./7^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
SE"*B$:*&23&G'',%P%$+J&;226$,(/:$:"(*3(:'"(\20*2(;88%"##(:*(A*21%"##&]\"*&1J&-?0-^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOO"<%E:I"*E@%+'E:I3I'<O,C%%I@%,O(>E+@%(';E(E%%>'<,3@+<3&
&
SE%%&_%9"$&D,,:,+"*I%&dE';C&P3&z":E%J&D(E3&)'<<U*&a;<3&j&A%'C$%,x&G+,3J&)'<<3&M'3&.6O7?J&0/O?5J&61O?-&j&-55O?4&]FI+3J&
-??6^3&
&
d%*%E"$&N%IE%+"ER&P3&!@%&2:E%I+'E&]-??0^&N)KG&.51-&]N"$+&K:*%E,&)",%^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing
Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water and Sanitation: International and National
Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.?5^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*&G%$"+:P%&+'&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&):P:$:"*&A%E,'*,&:*&!:<%&'(&V"EJ&D;93&-.J&-?0?J&1&b3N3!3&46-1J&/6&b3M3!3N3&
.7/3&
&
d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*&G%$"+:P%&+'&+@%&!E%"+<%*+&'(&AE:,'*%E,&'(&V"EJ&D;93&-.J&-?0?J&1&b3N3!3&44-1J&/6&b3M3!3N3&-463&
&
&
Gov. of the Peoples Republic of Bangl., Ministry of Water Resources, National Water Policy&]\"*&45J&-???^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3<'QE39'P3#>O2'I;<%*+,OM"+:'*"$m.5V"+%Em.5A'$:IRm.5]L*9$:,@^3C>(3&
&
dE%9&A"$",+J&='"(U*6%(/:"@#(D'0&'(>"#:%*7"8(;%1"2:02$J&Prosperity UK,&S%#3&.554J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
QQQ3CE',C%E:+R;B3I'<OCE',C%E:+RO"E+:I$%,O"E9%*3@+<$3&
&
?6&
&
F%**:+**-(?<(W*#:"2+"%1(.555&]4^&8)_G&.//&])^&]N3&D(E3^3&
&
Grundgesetz fr die Bundesrepublik Deutschland [Constitution]&.4&K"R&-?0?&]d%E3^3*
&
Guy Howard & Jamie Bertram, World Health Organization, Domestic Water Quantity, Service Level and
Health&].554^3&&
&
Guy Howard & Jamie Bartram, World Health Organization, Domestic Water Quantity, Service Level and
Health: Executive Summary&].554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3Q@'3:*+OQ"+%Eh,"*:+"+:'*h@%"$+@O>:,%",%,OVNa545.%`,;<3C>(3&
&
H. Shue, Basic Rights, Subsistence, Affluence and U.S. Foreign Policy (1980).&
&
Henry Steiner, Philip Alston & Ryan Goodman, International Human Rights in Context: Law, Politics,
Morals&]4E>&%>3&.557^3&
&
Henri Smets, Agence Franaise de Dveloppement, The Right to Water in National Legislations ].551^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOP"9;%3%;E%I'<3(EO,%<:>%OA2SOE:9@+T+'TQ"+%EhLM3&
&
a;<"*&G:9@+,&)'<<:,,:'*&G%,3&.556O-6J&D>P%E,%&L((%I+,&'(&+@%&=$$:I:+&K'P:*9&"*>&2;<C:*9&'(&!'`:I&"*>&2"*9%E';,&
4J&LO.556O.4J&"+&61&]DCE3&-0J&.556^3&
&
a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&a;<"*&G:9@+,&"*>&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-6O_3-0&]N%C3&
.0J&.5-5^J&"+&@++CHOO>"II%,,T'>,3;*3'E9O!KAO?410453-/--4.5773@+<$3&
&
a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$&G%,3&/O..J&a;<"*&G:9@+,&"*>&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&/+@&N%,,3J&K"E3&4T.7J&
.557J&b3M3&dDFGJ&14>&N%,,3J&N;CC3&M'3&64J&DO14O64J&"+&-40&]K"E3&.7J&.557^3&
&
Ian Brownlie, Principles of Public International Law&]1+@&%>3&.554^3&
&
="*&NI'##:%()%02&0@,"(*%()%$1-$:0&#_(='"(!",$:0*2#'0@(+":H""2(S6-$2(!01':#(C$H($28(:'"(C$H(*3(;%-"8(A*23,0&:.(-0]4^&J.
&
9F>#($28(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$RJ&b3M3&2'I3&DO16O.60&]D;93&1J&.5-5^&]#R&)"+"E:*"&>%&
+:+$%&'(&+@%&>'I;<%*+^3(
&
=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&G%$"+%>&+'&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&
)%*-*:0*2($28()%*:"&:0*2(*3($,,(S6-$2(!01':#.(A0?0,.()*,0:0&$,.(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#.(42&,68021(:'"(!01':(:*(
>"?",*@-"2:.&a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-5O1&]S%#3&.6J&.55?^&]#R&)"+"E:*"&>%&D$#;c;%Ec;%^3&
&
=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&G%$"+%>&+'&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J(
c6"#:0*22$0%"R(VF**8()%$&:0&"#L(%",$:"8(:*(;&&"##(:*(/$3"(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2(]S%#3&.5-5^J&
@RC%E$:*B^3&
&
=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&G%$"+%>&+'&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&!"@*%:(*3(
:'"(GT@"%:(*2(:'"(4##6"(*3(S6-$2(!01':#(W+,01$:0*2#(!",$:"8(:*(;&&"##(:*(/$3"(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.&a;<"*&G:9@+,&
)';*I:$J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-.O.0&]\;$R&-J&.55?^&]#R&)"+"E:*"&>%&D$#;c;%Ec;%^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,O@EI';*I:$O>'I,O-.,%,,:'*ODTaG)T-.T.0hL3C>(3(
&
:'"(GT@"%:(*2(:'"(4##6"(*3(S6-$2(!01':#(W+,01$:0*2#(!",$:"8(:*(E*2^/:$:"(/"%?0&"()%*?0#0*2(02(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.&a;<"*&
G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-6O4-&]\;*%&.?J&.5-5^&]#R&)"+"E:*"&>%&D$#;c;%Ec;%^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O:,,;%,OQ"+%EO:%`C%E+O"**;"$3@+<&]P:"&@RC%E$:*B&Q:+@&+@%&+:+$%&'(&+@%&>'I;<%*+^3(
&
&
?1&
=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&G%$"+%>&+'&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*&j&=*>%C3&
L`C%E+&'*&+@%&|;%,+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&"*>&L`+E%<%&A'P%E+RJ&[*02:(!"@*%:(*3(:'"(428"@"28"2:(GT@"%:(*2(:'"(c6"#:0*2(*3(
S6-$2(!01':#($28(GT:%"-"()*?"%:7.(9$18$,"2$(/"@k,?"8$(A$%8*2$.($28(:'"(428"@"28"2:(GT@"%:(*2(:'"(4##6"(*3(S6-$2(
!01':#(W+,01$:0*2#(!",$:"8(:*(;&&"##(:*(/$3"(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.(A$:$%02$(8"(;,+656"%56"R(90##0*2(:*(B$21,$8"#'.&
a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-6O66&]\;$R&..J&.5-5^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
+@%&>'I;<%*+^3(
&
=*9$"&V:*B$%EJ&[680&0$,(G23*%&"-"2:(*3(:'"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%R(A$#"(C$H(3%*-(/*6:'(;3%0&$.(;%1"2:02$($28(4280$&_"QJ&
.557]-^&L. Soc. Just. & Global Dev. J. ]FI+3&?J&.557^J&
@++CHOOQQQ.3Q"EQ:IB3"I3;BO("IO,'IO$"QO%$[O$9>O.557h-OQ:*B$%EO3&
&
42:",(D$:"%()*,0&7J&Intel Corporation&]K"E3&.5-5^J&@++CHOOQQQ3:*+%$3I'<OD,,%+,OA2SOA'$:IRO=*+%$hV"+%EhA'$:IR3C>(3&
&
=*+%ETd'P%E*<%*+"$&A"*%$&'*&)$:<"+%&)@"*9%&e=dA))fJ&A,0-$:"(A'$21"(PXXYR(/72:'"#0#(!"@*%:&]M'P3&-/J&.55/^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3:CII3I@OC>(O",,%,,<%*+TE%C'E+O"E0O,REO"E0h,RE3C>(3&
&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&V"+%E&"*>&+@%&L*P:E'*<%*+J&2;#$:*J&=E3J&\"*3&.1T4-J&-??.J&='"(>6+,02(/:$:"-"2:(*2(D$:"%($28(
/6#:$02$+,"(>"?",*@-"2:<M&
&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&"*>&AE'<'+:'*&'(&+@%&G:9@+,&"*>&2:9*:+R&'(&A%E,'*,&Q:+@&2:,"#:$:+:%,J&d3D3&G%,3&
1-O-51J&D**%`&=J&b3M3&dDFGJ&1-,+&N%,,3J&N;CC3&M'3&0?J&"+&16J&b3M3&2'I3&DO1-O0?&]2%I3&-4J&.551^J&01&=3_3K3&0043&
&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'P%*"*+&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&2%I3&-1J&-?11J&???&b3M3!3N3&-/-3&
&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'P%*"*+&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&2%I3&-1J&-?11J&??4&b3M3!3N3&43&
&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&L`C%E+,&K%%+:*9&'*&+@%&G:9@+&+'&V"+%EJ&A"E:,J&SE3J&\;$R&/T7J&.55?J&W6:&*-"(*3(:'"(42:"%2$:0*2$,(GT@"%:#L(
9"":021(*2(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%&]FI+3&.55?^J&$?$0,$+,"&$:&@++CHOO;*%,>'I3;*%,I'3'E9O:<"9%,O55-7O55-760O-7604.%3C>(3&*
&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&_"Q&D,,'I:"+:'*&e=_DfJ&B"%,02(!6,"#(*2(D$:"%(!"#*6%&"#(]D;93&.-J&.550^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3I"Q"+%ET
:*('3*%+O$:#E"ERO%*9O$O#%E$:*hE;$%,3C>(3(
&
\3&8"E+E"<J&G%CE%,%*+"+:P%&'(&+@%&V'E$>&a%"$+@&FE9"*:Z"+:'*J&FE"$&,;#<:,,:'*&+'&d%*%E"$&2:,I;,,:'*&'*&+@%&2E"(+&d%*%E"$&
)'<<%*+&'*&+@%&G:9@+&+'&V"+%E&]M'P3&..J&.55.^3&
&
J.E.S. Fawcett, The Application of the European Convention on Human Rights&]-?7/^3&
&
J. Getzler, A History of Water Rights at Common Law&].550^3&
Jack Donnelly, International Human Rights ]4E>&%>3&.55/^3&
&
\"<%,&_3&)"P"$$"E'&j&L<:$R&\3&NI@"((%EJ&C"##($#(9*%"R(!":'02O021(/6@%$2$:0*2$,(C0:01$:0*2(*3(G&*2*-0&($28(/*&0$,(!01':#(02(
:'"(;-"%0&$#.&61&Hastings L.J.&.-/&].556^3&&
&
\"*:I%&dE"R.(4-@,"-"2:021(:'"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%(02(;6#:%$,0$.(-/]-^(Hum. Rts. Defender&-&].557^<&
&
[$26$%7(PXNX(A*62:%7(/6--$%7R()$O0#:$2J&Human Rights Watch&]\"*3&.5-5^J&@++CHOOQQQ3@EQ3'E9O%*OQ'E$>TE%C'E+T
.5-5OC"B:,+"*3&
&
\",'*&8E:IB%EJ&)%0?$:0Q$:0*2(*3(D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:(02(;%1"2:02$.&American University Trade Environment Database
].55-^.(@++CHOOQQQ-3"<%E:I"*3%>;O+%>OQ"+%ET"E9%*+:*"3@+<3&
&
\",'*&8E'Z%BJ&!"?0"H(*3(;-2"#:7(42:"%2$:0*2$,L#(V=%*6+,"8(D$:"%#R()$,"#:020$2#(>"20"8(;&&"##(:*(D$:"%L(4]-^&Water
&
Joan Goldstein, Demanding Clean Food and Water: The Fight for a Basic Human Right&]-??5^3&
&
\':%&)@'Q>@;ERJ&[680&0$,(;8'"%"2&"(:*($(9020-6-(A*%"(;@@%*$&'(:*(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#(f(;(A*-@$%$:0?"()"%#@"&:0?".&
]K"E3&.4J&.557^&];*C;#$:,@%>&Q'EB:*9&C"C%EJ&)'E*%$$&_"Q&NI@''$^]'*&(:$%&Q:+@&";+@'E^];,%>&Q:+@&C%E<:,,:'*^3(
&
?/&
&
Johannes Morsink, The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: Origins, Drafting and Intent
]-???^3&
&
[*'$22"#+6%1(?<(9$Q0+6O*&.55?&]7^&8)_G&/?-&]N)D^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3,"($::3'E9OI9:T
#:*O>:,C3C$n(:$%oZ"OI",%,OzDN)DO.55?O.53@+<$jc;%ERom.5<"Z:#;B'3&
&
John Austin, Province of Jurisprudence Determined&])"<#E:>9%&-??6^]-74.^3&
&
Jona Razzaque, Public Interest Environmental Litigation in India, Pakistan and Bangladesh ].550^3&
&
Juan Miguel Picolotti, Center for Human Rights and Environment, The Right to Water in Argentina&].554^J&
&
\;$:"&a";,%E<"*J&G:9@+,&j&a;<"*:+RJ&D&a;<"*&G:9@+,&DCCE'"I@&+'&2%P%$'C<%*+H&N'<%&AE"I+:I"$&=<C$:I"+:'*,&('E&
V"+%ED:>U,&V'EB&]N%C3&-5J&-???^&]+E"*,IE:C+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
\;>:I:"$&G%P:%Q&'(&+@%&_"Q&M'3&/&'(&.550&'*&V"+%E&G%,';EI%,J&\;>9<%*+&'(&-4+@&\;$R&.556J&M'3&567T56?T515T514OAbbT&
==O.5503&])3)3^&]=*>'*3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3<"@B"<"@B'*,+:+;,:39'3:>OC;+;,"*OC;+;,"*h,:>"*9h%*9hA;+;,"*m.5567T56?T514m.5AbbT==T
.5503m.5557TAbbT===T.556m.5]bbm.5N2D^3C>(J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions,
Legal Resources for the Right to Water and Sanitation: International and National Standards&].*>&%>3J&
('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&./?^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
[6#:0&0$+0,0:7(*3(G/A(!01':#R(='"(4280$2(GT@"%0"2&"J&02&Circle of Rights: Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
Activism, a Training Resource&]N;*:$"&D#%R%,%B%E"&%+&"$3J&.555^J&
@++CHOOQQQ-3;<*3%>;O@;<"*E+,O%>;<"+O=aG=AOI:EI$%O[;,+:I:"#:$:+R3@+<3*
&
\;Z9">'&M"I:'*"$&>%&AE:<%E"&=*,+"*I:"&e-"&=*,+3f&eM"+:'*"$&_'Q%E&)';E+&'(&FE>:*"ER&\;E:,>:I+'*fJ&-4O57O.55/J&WD,'I:"I:*&
):P:$&C'E&$"&=9;"$>">&R&$"&\;,+:I:"&I3&d'#:%E*'&>%&$"&):;>">&>%&8;%*',&D:E%,&O&"III:*&"<C"E'JX&]DE93^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3*%Q,<"+:I3%T
C'$3I'<3"EO:*>%`3C@CnC;#h:>o??j,:>o-501j":>o..?41j%:>o.7jM'<#E%N%II:'*o\;E:,CE;>%*I:"m.5):;>">m.5>%m.
58,3D,jDII:'*os%EDE+:I;$'3&
&
\;Z9">'&>%&AE:<%E"&=*,+"*I:"&>%&)E>'#"&e-"&=*,+3&)#"3f&e)'E>'#"&_'Q%E&)';E+&'(&FE>:*"ER&\;E:,>:I+:'*fJ&7O0O.55.J&
W|;%P">'&K:9;%$&D*9%$&R&'+E',&IO&D9;",&)'E>'#%,",&N3D&O&"II:*&"<C"E'X&]DE93^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Malcolm
Langford et al., Centre for Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water:
International and National Standards&--4&].550^3&
&
\;Z9">'&M"I:'*"$&>%&AE:<%E"&=*,+"*I:"&>%&K'E%*'J&8;%*',&D:E%,&e-"&=*,+3&K3&83D3f&e_'Q%E&)';E+&'(&FE>:*"ER&\;E:,>:I+:'*fJ&
.-O7O.55.J&Wb,;"E:',&R&)'*,;<">'E%,&%*&2%(%*,"&>%&,;,&2%E%I@',&D,'I:"I:*&):P:$&IO&D9;",&>%$&dE"*&8;%*',&D:E%,&N3D3&O&
"II:*&"<C"E'(]DE93^&$?$0,$+,"($:J&@++CHOOQQQ3$%9"$<"*:"3I'<3"EO>%E%I@'O("$$'h",'I:"I:'*hI'*,;<:>'E3@+<3&.55.&__8D&
-46?&%+&,%c3&
&
\;Z9">'&>%&AE:<%E"&=*,+"*I:"&>%&)E>'#"&e-"&=*,+3&)#"3f&e)'E>'#"&_'Q%E&)';E+&'(&FE>:*"ER&\;E:,>:I+:'*fJ&-?O-5O.550J&
WK"EI@:,:'&\',p&8";+:,+"&O&"II:*&"<C"E'X&]DE93^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&=*9$"&V:*B$%EJ&[680&0$,(G23*%&"-"2:(*3(:'"(S6-$2(
!01':(:*(D$:"%R(A$#"(C$H(3%*-(/*6:'(;3%0&$.(;%1"2:02$($28(4280$&_"QJ&.557]-^&L. Soc. Just. & Global Dev. J. -5 ]FI+3&?J&
.557^J&@++CHOOQQQ.3Q"EQ:IB3"I3;BO("IO,'IO$"QO%$[O$9>O.557h-OQ:*B$%EO3&
&
i"E%*&_%@<"**J&42(>"3"2#"(*3(:'"(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*6%:R(C0:01$:021(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#($28(:'"(97:'(*3(:'"(9020-6-(A*%".&
..]-^&Am. U. Intl L. Rev. -14&].551^3&&
&
i"+@"E:*%&d3&~';*9J&='"(9020-6-(A*%"(*3(G&*2*-0&($28(/*&0$,(!01':#.(;(A*2&"@:(02(/"$%&'(*3(A*2:"2:.&44&Yale J. Intl L.&
--4&].557^3&&
&
i%:+@&NI@*%:>%EJ&M">R"&=P"*'P"&j&D"E'*&\"((%J&D$:"%(=*@#(A,0-$:"(A'$21"($#(F,*+$,()%0*%0:7J&Circle of Blue&]D;93&-7J&
.55?^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I:EI$%'(#$;%3'E9OQ"+%E*%Q,O.55?OQ'E$>OQ"+%EP:%Q,TQ"+%ET+'C,TI$:<"+%TI@"*9%T",T9$'#"$T
CE:'E:+RO3&
&
i%E"$"&P3&M3&K3&!@'<",J&]-?/1^&].^&N3)3)3&4-5&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3E:,@"#@>"E"3I'<O,IOP:%Q3C@CnI",%o674-3&
&
&
?7&
Kurt Bourquain, Freshwater Access from a Human Rights Perspective: A Challenge to International
Water and Human Rights Law&].557^3&
&
i;E'>"&P3&\"$"*>'*:J&74&PhiL. Rep.&-/-&]-?0?^&]A@:$3^3&&&
&
_3&.6?-J&*'P:%<#E%&-?J&-??-J&05&Diario Oficial&e23F3f&-16&])'$'<3^3&
&
_"Q&)'*I%E*:*9&=EE:9"+:'*J&M'3&--&'(&-?/0J&The Official Gazette of Indonesia,&-?/0J&M'3&163&
&
_"Q&M'3&.41?1J&D;93&-7J&-?7?J&ev_=vT)f&D323_3D3&.000&]DE93^3&
&
_"Q&M'3&667?(",&<'>:(:%>&#R(_"Q&M'3&7?.7J&)#"3J&K"R&.7J&-?/4J&83F3&.-O56O-?/4&]DE93^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3+'>'>%:;E%3I'<3"EO$%R%,OI'E>'#"O667?3@+<3(
&
_"Q&'*&V"+%E&G%,';EI%,J&M'3&/&'(&.550J&The Official Gazette of Indonesia,&.550J&M'&113&
&
_:*>,%R&P3&M'E<%+J&056&b3N3&61&]-?/.^3&
&
Litigating Economic, Social and Cultural Rights: Achievements, Challenges and Strategies(]K"$I'$<&
_"*9('E>J&%>3J&.554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3I'@E%3'E9O,:+%,O>%(";$+O(:$%,O$:+:9"+:*9h%,IhE:9@+,hT
h"I@:%P%<%*+hI@"$$%*9%,h"*>h,+E"+%9:%,h.5543C>(3&
&
_';:,&a%*B:*J&42:"%2$:0*2$,(S6-$2(!01':#($#(I!01':#M.(02&Nomos XXIII: Human Rights&.6/&]\3&G'Q$"*>&A%**'IB&j&\'@*&V3&

)@"C<"*&%>,3J&-?7-^3&
&
Maike Gorsboth, FoodFirst Information and Action Network, Identifying and Addressing Violations of the
Human Right to Water: Applying the Human Rights Approach&].551^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3(:"*3'E9OE%,';EI%,O>'I;<%*+,O'+@%E,O:>%*+:(R:*9T"*>T">>E%,,:*9TP:'$"+:'*,T'(T+@%T@;<"*TE:9@+T+'T
Q"+%EOn,%"EI@+%E<o:>%*+:(R:*9m.5"*>m.5">>E%,,:*93&
&
K"$I'$<&_"*9('E>J&;-+0:0*2(:'$:(*?"%,"$@#(0:#",3_(;(!"#@*2#"(:*(/:"@'"2(=6,,7L#(VA%0:056"L(*3(:'"(F"2"%$,(A*--"2:(*2(:'"(
!01':(:*(D$:"%.&.1]4^&Neth. Q. Hum. Rts.&044&].551^3&
&
K"$I'$<&_"*9('E>J&A%*##30%"R(='"%"(0#(2*(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%(3*%(C0?",0'**8#R(;(>"+$:"(H0:'(9",?02(D**8'*6#".&.7]-^&
Waterlines&6&].55?^3&
&
Malcolm Langford & Aofie Nolan, Centre for Housing Rights and Evictions, Litigating Economic, Social
and Cultural Rights: Legal Practitioners' Dossier&].551^3&
Water: International and National Standards&].550^3&
&
9$25","(?<(>6%+$2(=%$2#0:0*2$,(9":%*<(A*62&0,.&.55.&].^&ND&4?&]2^&]N3&D(E3^3&
&
K"E:;,&A:%+%E,%J&G$:021(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#R(='"(\#"36,2"##(*3(!01':#(=$,O(02(;,,"?0$:021(/*&0$,(S$%8#'0@(!"?0#0:"8.&.?&
Hum. Rts. Q. /?1&].55/^&
&
K"EB&N3&i%*>%J&='"(/*6:'(;3%0&$2(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*2#:%6&:0*2(*3(/*&0*(G&*2*-0&(!01':#.(;(!"#@*2#"(:*(A%0:0&#.&-?&Conn. J.
Intl L. 1-/&].554^3&
&
K"E+:*&G%;,,J&S0#:*%0&$,(GT@,$2$:0*2($28(D$:"%(4##6"#.(02&History and Future of Shared Water Resources&]bMLN)F&
%>3J&.554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&;*%,>'I3;*%,I'3'E9O:<"9%,O55-4O55-44.O-44.71%3C>(3&
&
K";>%&8"E$'QJ&;(\E(A*2?"2:0*2(*2(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%R(;2(48"$(D'*#"(=0-"(S$#(A*-".&Blue Planet&].551^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3#$;%C$"*%+CE'[%I+3*%+O>'I;<%*+,ObMhI'*P%*+:'*hK8h2%I513C>(3&
&
Maude Barlow, Blue Covenant: The Global Water Crisis and the Coming Battle for the Right to Water&
].557^3&
&
9$Q0+6O*(?<([*'$22"#+6%1&]9$Q0+6O*(AA^(.5-5&]4^&8)_G&.4?&]))^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3,"($::3'E9OZ"OI",%,OzD))O.55?O.73@+<$3&
&
??&
&
9$Q0+6O*(?<([*'$22"#+6%1.&)",%&M'3&51O-4761&].557^&]a)J&V:+3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3:"+C3'E9O+E">%'#,%EP"+'ERO$:#E"ER3I(<nE%(=2o-5.64?3(
&
K:I@"%$&\3&2%**:,&j&2"P:>&A3&N+%Q"E+J&[6#:0&0$+0,0:7(*3(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#R(/'*6,8(='"%"(B"($2(42:"%2$:0*2$,(
A*-@,$02:#(9"&'$20#-(:*(;8a680&$:"(:'"(!01':#(:*(U**8.(D$:"%.(S*6#021.(S"$,:'_&?7]4^&Am. J. Intl L. 01.&].550^3&
&
K:$$%**:;<&AE'[%I+&!",B&S'EI%&/&'*&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&;&'0"?021(:'"(90,,"2206-(>"?",*@-"2:(F*$,#(3*%(D$:"%($28(
/$20:$:0*2R(D'$:(0:(H0,,(=$O"(]S%#3&-J&.550^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3;*<:$$%**:;<CE'[%I+3'E9O>'I;<%*+,O+(/:*+%E:<3C>(3&
&
9020#:"%(3*%(4--01%$:0*2($28(G:'0&(;33$0%#(?<(="*'&]-??6^&-74&)_G&./4&]D;,+$3^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(+7&Child Rights
Information Network, @++CHOOQQQ3IE:*3'E9O_"QO:*,+E;<%*+3",Cn=*,+=2o-04-&]$",+&P:,:+%>&FI+3&./J&.5-5^3
&
9020#:"%(*3(S"$,:'(?<(=%"$:-"2:(;&:0*2(A$-@$012&]=;A^&.55.&]6^&ND&/.-&]))^3&
&
K'@"<">&K'P"&D$UD(9@"*:J&A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*6%:L#(!"?0"H($28(:'"(U6:6%"(*3(D$:"%(C$H(02(428*2"#0$.&.]-^&L. Env. & Dev. J.&
-&].551^3*
&
M3&d"#E;J&/*-"(A*--"2:#(*2(D$:"%(!01':#(02(/*6:'(;3%0&$.&7]-^&Potchefstroom Elec. L.J.&6&].556^J&

@++CHOO"['$3:*('O:*>%`3C@COC%$[O"E+:I$%OP:%QS:$%O04061O.1??-3&
&
M:I@'$",&a"R,'<J&A*2#:0:6:0*2$,0#-.(9$a*%0:$%0$2(>"-*&%$&7($28(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#.&7]0^&N. Afr. J. Hum. Rts.&06-&
]-??.^3&
&
F>%@&"$&\"RR';,:J&D$:"%($#($(S6-$2(!01':R(=*H$%8#(A0?0,(/*&0":7(F,*+$,0Q$:0*2.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev. 4.?&

].55/^3&
&
F((:I%&'(&+@%&a:9@&)'<<UE&('E&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&G%9:'*"$&F((:I%&('E&+@%&A"I:(:IJ&!$:030&$:0*2(*3(S6-$2(!01':#(=%"$:0"#R(;88"8(
`$,6"(3*%(:'"()$&030&(!"10*2&]\;$R&.55?^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOC"I:(:I3'@I@E3'E9O>'I,OG"+:(:I"+:'*8''B3C>(/*
&
F$9"&!%$$:,&P3&8'<#"R&K;*3&)';*I:$J&]-?76^&.&N3)3G3&6-&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.7453&
&
FC',"&P3&S;$9%*I:'&N3&S"I+'E"*&\E3J&d3&G3&M'3&-5-574&]\;$R&45J-??4^&]A@:$3^J&%"@%02:"8(02&44&=_K&]-??0^&C&-/4&%+&,%c3J&
@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water and
Sanitation: International and National Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.?.^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&
+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
FE9"*:Z"+:'*&'(&D(E:I"*&b*:+RJ&D(E:I"*&)@"E+%E&'*&+@%&G:9@+,&"*>&V%$("E%&'(&+@%&)@:$>J&\;$R&--J&-??5J&FDb&2'I3&
)D8O_LdO.03?O0?3&
&
A"B:,+"*&L*P:E'*<%*+"$&AE'+%I+:'*&DI+J&M'3&40&'(&-??/J&The Gazette of Pakistan ExtraordinaryJ&2%I3&1J&-??/&]A"B3^3&
&
Parvez Hassan, United Nations Environmental Programme, Environmental Rights as Part of Fundamental
Rights: the Leadership of the Judiciary in Pakistan&].554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O,R,+%<O(:$%,OL*P:E'*<%*+"$3G:9@+,3A"B:,+"*3>'I3&
&
A",I@:<&8"*9"&i@%+&K"Z>''E&N"<:+R&P3&V%,+&8%*9"$J&]-??1^&D3=3G3&.0.1&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3<"**E%++:*>:3:,O+@%T@;<"*TE:9@+,T
EC'[%I+O@;<"*E:9@+,I",%,"*><"+%E:"$,OI",%,O*"+:'*"$I",%,O,;CE%<%I';E+'(:*>:"O*EO4?03
&
A"+E:I:"&V';+%E,J&\20?"%#$,($28(!"10*2$,(;@@%*$&'"#(:*(!"#*,?021(42:"%2$:0*2$,(>0#@6:"#R(D'$:(C"##*2#(C"$%2"8(3%*-(/:$:"(
)%$&:0&"_.(02&Resolution of International Water Disputes&---&]=*+%E*"+:'*"$&8;E%";J&A%E<"*%*+&)';E+&'(&
DE#:+E"+:'*&%>3J&.554^3&*
&
A";$&\3&M%$,'*J&S6-$2(!01':#.(:'"(90,,"2206-(>"?",*@-"2:(F*$,#.($28(:'"(U6:6%"(*3(>"?",*@-"2:(A**@"%$:0*2.&46]-.^&
World Dev. .50-&].55/^3&*
&
&
-55&
A";$&\3&M%$,'*J&C*&$,(A,$0-#.(42:"%2$:0*2$,(/:$28$%8#($28(:'"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&02&The International Struggle for

New Human Rights&-45&]8'#&)$:(('E>&%>3J&.55?^3*
&
A%'C$%x,&b*:'*&('E&):P:$&_:#%E+:%,&P3&b*:'*&'(&=*>:"J&].55/^&-&N3)3)3&/-?&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOO:*>:"*B"*''*3'E9O>'IO0--741O3(
&
CE%$:<:*"ER&CE'+%I+:'*^3&
&
A%'C$%x,&b*:'*&('E&):P:$&_:#%E+:%,&P3&b*:'*&'(&=*>:"J&VE:+&'(&A%+:+:'*&M'3&-?1O.55-&]N3)3&K"R&.J&.554J&,%I'*>&'E>%E&9E"*+:*9&
CE%$:<:*"ER&CE'+%I+:'*^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%,IET*%+3'E9OI",%$"QOI",%$"Qh,@'Q3@+<n>'Ih:>o05-544&],%$%I+&
W>'Q*$'">X&@RC%E$:*B&:*&$%(+T@"*>&C"*%$^<&
&
A%+%E&8'*>&j&\"IB:%&2;9"E>J&D$:"%.(S6-$2(!01':#($28(/*&0$,(A*23,0&:R(/*6:'(;3%0&$2(GT@"%0"2&"#.&.557]-^&L. Soc. Just. &
Global Dev. J. ]S%#3&--J&.557^J&@++CHOOQQQ.3Q"EQ:IB3"I3;BO("IO,'IO$"QO%$[O$9>O.557h-O#'*>h>;9"E>3(
&
A%+%E&2"*I@:*J&;(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%_(='"(/*6:'(;3%0&$2(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*6%:L#(>"&0#0*2(02(:'"(9$Q0+6O*(A$#".&EJIL
Talk! Blog&]\"*3&-4J&.5-5^J&@++CHOOQQQ3%[:$+"$B3'E9O"T@;<"*TE:9@+T+'TQ"+%ET+@%T,';+@T"(E:I"*TI'*,+:+;+:'*"$TI';E+U,T
>%I:,:'*T:*T+@%T<"Z:#;B'TI",%O3&
&
)"%6R(A*21%"##(;@@%*?"#(D$:"%(C$H.&International Water and Sanitation Centre&]DCE3&4J&.55?^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3:EI3*$OC"9%O0/16.3&
&
A%E;<"++R&dE"<"&A"*I@"R"+&P3&i%E"$"J&].550^&-&i3_3!3&/4-&]=*>:"^3&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-0-5J&
@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02(Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water and
Sanitation: International and National Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.7/^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&
+@%&";+@'E^3&
Peter GleickJ&)"$O(D$:"%.&02&The Worlds Water 2008-2009: The Biennial Report on Freshwater Resources&-&
].55?^3&
&
Peter Gleick,&D$:"%(B%0"3(U*6%R(D$:"%(A*23,0&:(A'%*2*,*17.(02&The Worlds Water 2008-2009: The Biennial Report
on Freshwater Resources&-6-&].55?^3&
&
A%+%E&a3&d$%:IBJ&B$#0&(D$:"%(!"560%"-"2:#(3*%(S6-$2(;&:0?0:0"#.&.-].^&Water Intl&74&]-??1^3*
&
A%+%E&a3&d$%:IB&='"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&-]6^&Water Policy 07/&]-???^3&
&
Peter Malanczuk,&Akehursts Modern Introduction to International LawJ&]G';+$%>9%J&/+@&%>3&
-??/^]-?/5^3&
&
A@:$:C&D$,+'*J&W6:(*3(:'"(;+7##R(:'"(A'$,,"21"#(A*23%*2:021(:'"(E"H(\<E<(A*--0::""(*2(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#.(
?]4^&Hum. Rts. Q.(444(]-?7/^3*
&
A@:$:C&K'EE:,&P3&)';E+&'(&DCC%"$,J&d3G3&M'3&?-44.J&..0&N3)3G3D3&6/1&]\;$R&-1J&-??4^&]A@:$3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3$"QC@:$3*%+O[;>[;E:,O[;E:-??4O[;$-??4O9Eh?-44.h-??43@+<$3&
&
)'0,0@@02"#R(902*%#(W@*#$(?<(/"&%":$%7(*3(:'"(>"@$%:-"2:(*3(G2?0%*2-"2:$,($28(E$:6%$,(!"#*6%&"#(Nmmd.&Child Rights
Information NetworkJ(@++CHOOQQQ3IE:*3'E9O_"QO:*,+E;<%*+3",Cn=*,+=2o-.15&]$",+&P:,:+%>&FI+3&-?J&.5-5^3&
&
A@:$:CC:*%,&P3&_%'&LI@%9"E"R&R&A:$'J&d3G3&M'3&--/0/.&]\;*%&.6J&-??1^&]A@:$^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3I@"*E'#$%,3I'<OIE"$"Q-??1-/3@+<3(
&
AE"B",@&K"*:&N@"E<"&P3&M%C"$&V"+%E&N;CC$R&)'EC'E"+:'*J&]-??5^&8N&.50/&>%I:>%>&:*&&
].55-^&8N&.567&D,@">@&.1J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-474J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02(Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal
('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&450^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
AE%,,&G%$%",%J&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$RJ&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&D>'C+,&G%,'$;+:'*&G%I'9*:Z:*9&DII%,,&+'&)$%"*&V"+%EJ&N"*:+"+:'*&",&"&
a;<"*&G:9@+J&#R&G%I'E>%>&s'+%&'(&-..&:*&S"P'EJ&M'*%&D9":*,+J&0-&D#,+%*+:'*,g&2%$%9"+%,&"$,'&)'*(:E<&M'<:*%%&+'&a%">&
&
-5-&
F((:I%&'(&=*+%E*"$&FP%E,:9@+&N%EP:I%,J&L$%I+&8%$"E;,&+'&bMLA&d'P%E*:*9&)';*I:$J&b3M3&AE%,,&G%$%",%&dDO-5?1/&]\;$R&.7J&
.5-5^3&
&
AE'(3&2E3&\:<$R&D,,@:>>:c:%J&N3a3J&)@":E<"*&'(&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+J&K"@B"<"@&i'*,+:+;,:&>"$"<&N:,+%<&i%+"+"*%9"E""*&
G%C;#$:B&=*>'*%,:"&]2%I3&--J&.556^3&
&
AE'+'I'$&D>>:+:'*"$&+'&+@%&d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*,&'(&-.&D;9;,+&-?0?J&"*>&G%$"+:*9&+'&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&s:I+:<,&'(&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&DE<%>&)'*($:I+,&]AE'+'I'$&=^J&\;*%&7J&-?//J&--.6&b3M3!3N3&43&
&
G3&A"+@"BJ&)6+,0&(42:"%"#:(C0:01$:0*2(02(4280$.&02&Democracy, Human Rights and the Rule of Law, Essays in Honour
of Nani Palkhivala&-.6&]s%*B"+&=R%E&%>3J&.555^3*
&
!"#08"2:#(*3(B*2(`0#:$(9$2#0*2#(?<(/*6:'"%2(9":%*@*,0:$2(C*&$,(A*62&0,(.55.&]1^&8)_G&1.6&]V^&]N3&D(E3^3&
&
G',%&SE"*I:,J&D$:"%([6#:0&"(02(/*6:'(;3%0&$R(E$:6%$,(!"#*6%&"#()*,0&7($:(:'"(42:"%#"&:0*2(*3(S6-$2(!01':#.(G&*2*-0&#.($28(
)*,0:0&$,()*H"%.&-7]-^&Geo. Intl. Envtl. L. Rev.(-05&].556^3&
&
GR"*&P3&D++UR&d%*3J&e-?16f&=3G3&.?0&]=E3^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal
('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.75^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
/<(?<(9$OH$27$2"(-??6&]4^&ND&4?-&]))^&]N3&D(E3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3,"($::3'E9OZ"OI",%,OzD))O-??6O43@+<$3(
&
N3&i3&d"E9&P3&b++"E&AE">%,@J&]-???^&D3=3G3&]D$$3^&0-&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOO:*>:"*B"*''*3'E9O>'IO775774OJ&@$%:0$,,7(
%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water and
Sanitation: International and National Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&457^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&
+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
Saligang Batas ng Pilipinas [Constitution]&S%#&--J&-?7/&]A@:$^3*
&
N"*>E"&_:%#%*#%E9J&/*6:'(;3%0&$L#(G?*,?021([6%0#@%68"2&"(*2(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#R($2(G33"&:0?"(=**,(02(A'$,,"21021(
)*?"%:7_&1&L. Democracy & Dev. J. -6?&].55.^3&
&
N%#",+:"*&d"$:"*:J&A";$&d%E+:%E&j&LE*%,+'&N@"E9E'>,BR3&D$:"%(3*%(C03"R(='"(4-@$&:(*3(:'"()%0?$:0Q$:0*2(*3(D$:"%(/"%?0&"#(*2(
A'0,8(9*%:$,0:7.&--4]-^&J. Pol. Econ. ].556^3&&
&
N%#",+:%*&a"I@%EJ&D*%,8H08"(D$:"%(9*?"-"2:(D02#(`0&:*%0"#Z(;%1"2:02$(D$:"%()%0?$:0Q$:0*2(/&'"-"(!62#(>%7.&Michigan
Quarterly Review&]K"E3&-4J&.550^3&
&
N:*>@&=*,+3&'(&bE'$'9R&"*>&!E"*,C$"*+"+:'*&P3&M%,+$p&K:$BC"B&_+>3J&].556^&)_)&]N:*>@J&i"E"I@:^&0.0J&].550^&]A"B3^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3,@%@E:3'E9O,;#C"9%,O*%,+$%3C>(J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02(Malcolm Langford et al., Centre for
Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water: International and National
Standards&-7?&].550^3&&&
&
N@"$"&z:"&P3&VDA2DJ&]-??0^&N)KG&1?4&]A"B3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-40.3(
(
/**+%$-*2"7(?<(='"(9020#:"%(*3(S"$,:'.(gH$Q6,6(E$:$,(-??7&]-^&ND&/16&]))^&]N3&D(E3^3&
(
/*6:'(;3%0&$(?<(F%**:+**-(.555&]--^&8)_G&--1?&]))^&]N3&D(E3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3I'*,+:+;+:'*"$I';E+3'E93Z"ODEI@:<"9%,O./?73A2S3&
&
NC%I:"$&G"CC'E+%;E&'*&+@%&L*['R<%*+&'(&LI'*3J&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,&"*>&+@%&G:9@+&+'&D>%c;"+%&S''>J&='"(!01':(:*(
;8"56$:"(U**8($#($(S6-$2(!01':.(b3M3&N;#TI'<<U*&'*&+@%&AE'<'+:'*&"*>&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&b3M3&2'I3&&
b3M3&2'I3&LO)M30ON;#3.O-?7/O.4&]\;$3&/J&-?7/^&]#R&D,#['E*&L:>%^3&
&
NC%I:"$&G"CC'E+%;E&'*&+@%&L*['R<%*+&'(&LI'*3J&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,&"*>&+@%&G:9@+&+'&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&N;CC$R&"*>&
N"*:+"+:'*J&>%$3:(F608",02"#(3*%(:'"(!"$,0Q$:0*2(*3(:'"(!01':(:*(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2J&b3M3&N;#TI'<<U*&'*&+@%&
AE'<'+:'*&"*>&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)M30ON;#3.O.556O.6&]\;$R&--J&.556^&]#R&a">[:&d;:,,p^3&
&
NC%I:"$&G"CC'E+%;E&'*&+@%&G:9@+&+'&S''>J&/0T:'(!"@*%:(*2(:'"(!01':(:*(U**8J&)'<<U*&'*&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&b3M3&2'I3&
LO)M30O.551O00&]K"E3&-1J&.551^&]#R&\"*&z:%9$%E^3*
&
-5.&
&
N+"+%<%*+&'(&+@%&G%CE%,%*+"+:P%&'(&)"*">"&+'&+@%&b3M3&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&]\;$R&.7J&.5-5^J&%"@%02:"8(02(AE%,,&G%$%",%J&
d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$RJ&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&D>'C+,&G%,'$;+:'*&G%I'9*:Z:*9&DII%,,&+'&)$%"*&V"+%EJ&N"*:+"+:'*&",&"&a;<"*&G:9@+J&
#R&G%I'E>%>&s'+%&'(&-..&:*&S"P'EJ&M'*%&D9":*,+J&0-&D#,+%*+:'*,g&2%$%9"+%,&"$,'&)'*(:E<&M'<:*%%&+'&a%">&F((:I%&'(&
=*+%E*"$&FP%E,:9@+&N%EP:I%,J&L$%I+&8%$"E;,&+'&bMLA&d'P%E*:*9&)';*I:$J&b3M3&AE%,,&G%$%",%&dDO-5?1/&]\;$R&.7J&.5-5^3&
&
N+"+%<%*+&'(&+@%&G%CE%,%*+"+:P%&'(&+@%&b*:+%>&N+"+%,&+'&+@%&b3M3&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&]\;$R&.7J&.5-5^J&%"@%02:"8(02(AE%,,&
G%$%",%J&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$RJ&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&D>'C+,&G%,'$;+:'*&G%I'9*:Z:*9&DII%,,&+'&)$%"*&V"+%EJ&N"*:+"+:'*&",&"&
.5-5^3&
&
N+"+;+%&'(&+@%&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)';E+&'(&\;,+:I%J&6?&N+"+3&-54-3&
&
N+%C@%*&)3&KI)"((E%RJ&;(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%R(>*-"#:0&($28(42:"%2$:0*2$,(4-@,0&$:0*2#.&6]-^&Geo. Intl Envtl. L. Rev.(-&
]-??.^3&&
&
Steven Hodgson, FAO Legal Office, Modern Water Rights: Theory and Practice&].551^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
(+CHOO(+C3("'3'E9O>'IE%CO("'O5-5O"5710%O"5710%553C>(3&&
&
N;#@",@&i;<"E&P3&N+"+%&'(&8:@"EJ&]-??-^&D3=3G&0.5&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3:%$EI3'E9OI'*+%*+O%?-573C>(3&
&
N;ER"&2@;*9%$&P3&d'>"P"E:&K"E#$%&=*>;,+E:%,J&]-??6^&.56.&M3i3A3&4/&]M%C"$^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-70?J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02(Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources
]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.?.^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3(
&
N;,"*&K'$$%E&FB:*J&C0+"%:7($28(D",3$%"R(/*-"(4##6"#(02(S6-$2(!01':#(='"*%7.&02&Nomos XXIII: Human Rights&.45&]\3&
G'$"*>&A%**'IB&j&\'@*&V3&)@"C<"*&%>,3J&-?7-^3&*
&
!"<:$*">;&P3&a:*>&N+'*%J&]-?7-^&].^&N)KG&.56&"+&.-.&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3E:,@"#@>"E"3I'<O,IOP:%Q3C@CnI",%o/6--3(
&
!"E"&\3&K%$:,@J&!":'02O021(:'"(IC"##($#(9*%"M(='"#0#R(/6@%$2$:0*2$,(C0:01$:0*2(*3(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#(02(:'"(
;-"%0&$#.&4?].^&N.Y.U. J. Intl L. & Pol3&-/-&].551^3&*
&
!@%&a;<"*&G:9@+&+'&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&d3D3&G%,3&10O.?.J&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO10O.?.&&]\;$R&.7J&.5-5^3&*
&
='"(9$$#:%0&':(F608",02"#(*2(`0*,$:0*2#(*3(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#J&.5]4^&Hum. Rts. Q.&1?-&]-??7^3&
&
!@%&K:$$%**:;<&2%I$"E"+:'*J&d3D3&G%,3&66O.J&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO66O.&]N%C3&7J&.555^3*
&
!@%&G:9@+&+'&2%P%$'C<%*+J(d3D3&G%,3&60O-/6J&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO60O-/6&]2%I3&-/J&-???^3&&
The World Conservation Union, Water Law Series Issue 9: Human Rights and Water ].557^J&$?$0,$+,"($:R(
@++CHOOI<,>"+"3:;I*3'E9O>'Q*$'">,O(,?3C>(<(*
&
!@:E>&N';+@&D,:"*&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&N"*:+"+:'*J&M%Q&2%$@:J&=*>:"J&M'P3&-1T.-J&.557J&='"(>",'0(>"&,$%$:0*2J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOO>>Q,3*:I3:*O:*(',"I',"*OCC+O2%$@:m.52%I$"E"+:'*m.5/3C>(3&
&
Thomas Fuller, Gnomologia: Adages and Proverbs; Wise Sentences and Witty Sayings, Ancient and Modern,
Foreign and British&]8:#$:'_:(%&.5-5^]-/4.^3&*
&
!@'E,+%*&i:%(%E&j&)"+@%E:*%&8Ek$<"**J&B"7*28(/:$:"(/*?"%"012:7R(='"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&6]4^&Non-State Actors &
Intl L.&-74&].556^3&*
&
!E:#;*"$&>%&9E"*>%&:*,+"*I%&e!d=f&e'E>:*"ER&I';E+&'(&'E:9:*"$&[;E:,>:I+:'*f&DP:9*'*J&K"R&-.J&-??6J&*3&-0?.O?6&]SE3^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3I"I%3(EO[;E:,CE;>%*I%OE%+,O%";CE%,,:'*O+9:-.56-??63@+<$J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on
Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water and Sanitation: International and
National Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&455^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3(
&
&
-54&
!E:#;*"$&N;C%E:'E&>%&\;,+:I:"&>%&M%;c;p*&e!E:#3&N;C3&Mc*3f&eN;C%E:'E&!E:#;*"$&'(&\;,+:I%f&Ws"$%*+:*"&M'E+%&)'$'*RJ&
2%(%*,'E"&>%&K%*'E%,&M&4&I3&A'>%E&L[%I;+:P'&K;*:I:C"$&O&"II:*&"<C"E'X&]DE93^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Malcolm
&
b3M3&)@"E+%E3&&
&
b3M3&)'<<U*&'*&a;<3&G+,3J&M'+%&s%E#"$%&2"+%>&71O-.O56&(E'<&+@%&A%E<"*%*+&K:,,:'*&'(&+@%&M%+@%E$"*>,&+'&+@%&b*:+%>&
M"+:'*,&F((:I%&"+&d%*%P"&">>E%,,%>&+'&+@%&)%*+E%&('E&a;<"*&G:9@+,&]l_:<#;E9&AE:*I:C$%,l^J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)M30O-?7/O-/&
]\"*3&7J&-?7/^J&%"@%02:"8(02&? Hum. Rts. Q. -..(]-?7/^3
&
b3M3&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&L*PU+3&j&2%P3J&G:'&>%&\"*:%E'J&8E"Z3J&\;*%&4T-0J&-??.J&;1"28$(PNJ&b3M3&2'I3&DO)FMS3-6-O.1OGLs3-&]s'$3&
==^&]\;*%&-0J&-??.^3*
U.N. Dept of Econ. and Soc. Affairs, The Word at Six Billion,&b3M3&2'I3&LNDOAOVA3-60&]-???^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*3'E9O%,"OC'C;$"+:'*OC;#$:I"+:'*,O,:`#:$$:'*O,:`#:$$:'*3@+<
U.N. Dept of Econ. and Soc. Affairs, World Population Prospects: the 2008 Revision&b3M3&2'I3&
N!OLNDONLG3DO.7/&].557^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOO%,"3;*3'E9O;*C>OQCC.557OC%C,h>'I;<%*+,3@+<3&
U.N. Dev. Programme, Beyond Scarcity: Power, Poverty and the Global Water Crisis: UNDP Human
Development Report 2006&].551^3&
&
U.N. Dev. Programme, Human Development Report 1990: The Concept and Measurement of Human
Development(]-??5^<&
&
\E(GT@"%:(D",&*-"#(!"&*120:0*2($#($(S6-$2(!01':(*3(;&&"##(:*(/$3"($28(A,"$2(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.&Office of
the High Commissioner for Human Rights ]\;$R&45J&.5-5^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3'@I@E3'E9OLMOM%Q,LP%*+,OA"9%,O2:,C$"RM%Q,3",C`nM%Q,=2o-5.05j_"*9=2oL3&
&
b3M3&a:9@&)'<<UE&('E&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&!"@<(*3(:'"(\<(E<(S01'(A*--L%(3*%(S6-$2(!01':#(*2(:'"(/&*@"($28(A*2:"2:(*3(:'"(
!","?$2:(S6-$2(!01':#(W+,01$:0*2#(!",$:"8(:*(G560:$+,"(;&&"##(:*(/$3"(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2(628"%(42:L,(S6-$2(
&
b3M3&G;$%,&('E&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&\;P%*:$%,&2%CE:P%>&'(&+@%:E&_:#%E+RJ&d3D3&G%,3&06O--4J&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO06O--4&]2%I3&-0J&
-??5^3&*
&
b3M3&N;#T)'<<U*&'*&+@%&AE'<'+:'*&"*>&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&G%,3&.551O-5J&AE'<'+:'*&'(&+@%&G%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&
G:9@+&+'&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&67+@&N%,,3J&D;93&/T.6J&.551J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O.O.TDOaG)ON;#3-O67O41J&"+&4?&
]D;93&.0J&.551^3&*
&
b3M3&V"+%E&)'*(%E%*I%&eb3M3V3)3fJ&K"E&>%$&A$"+"J&DE93J&K"E3&-0T.6J&-?//J&!"@<(*3(:'"(\<(E<(D$:"%(A*23"%"2&"J&b3M3&2'I3&
b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&a;<"*&N%++$%<%*+J&s"*I';P%EJ&)"*3&K"R&4-&Y&\;*%&--J&-?/1J&`$2&*6?"%(>"&,$%$:0*2(*2(
S6-$2(/"::,"-"2:#J&bM3&2'I3&DO)FMS3/5O-6J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3;*T>'I;<%*+,3*%+OP"*T>%I3@+<3&
b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&A'C;$"+:'*&"*>&2%P%$'C<%*+J&)":E'J&L9RC+J&N%C3&6T-4J&-??0J&)%*1%$--"(*3(
;&:0*2(*3(:'"(42:"%2$:0*2$,(A*23"%"2&"(*2()*@6,$:0*2($28(>"?",*@-"2:J&b3M3&2'I3&DO)FMS3-/-O-4&]N%C3&-7J&-??0^3&$?$0,$+,"(
$:&@++CHOOQQQ3::,>3I"O)":E'OCE'9E"<OC555553@+<$3&
Undang-Undang Dasar Republik Indonesia 1945 (Constitution)&\;$R&6J&-?6?3&
&
b*:P%E,"$&2%I$"E"+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&d3D3&G%,3&.-/&]===^&DJ&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO.-/]===^&]2%I3&-5J&-?07^3&&
&
s:I+'E&D#E"<'P:I@&j&)@E:,+:"*&)';E+:,J&=*H$%8#($(>"-$28$+0,0:7(*3(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#R(42:"%2$:0*2$,(
/:$28$%8#($28(:'"0%(;@@,0&$:0*2(02(C*&$,(A*6%:#.(02&The Application of Human Rights Treaties for Local
Juristictions&4.0&]K"E+*&D#E%9&j&)@E:,+:"*&)';E+:,&%>,3J&-??/^3*
&
&
-50&
s:%**"&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&_"Q&'(&!E%"+:%,J&K"R&.4J&-?1?J&--66&b3M3!3N3&44-3&
&
@++CHOO:C,*%Q,3*%+O:*+%E*"3",Cn:>*%Q,o-?1?43&
&
V"+%E&)'>%&'(&+@%&A@:$:CC:*%,J&AE%,:>%*+:"$&2%IE%%&M'3&-51/&]-?/1^&/4&F3d3&4660&]K"R&--J&-?//^&]A@:$3^3&
&
D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:(;&:&PXXX&])+@^&]D;,+$3^3&
&
V"+%E&N%EP:I%,&DI+J&-57&'(&-??/&]N3&D(E3^3&
&
D$:"%(`0"H#R(4280$.&Circle of Blue&]D;93&-7J&.55?^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I:EI$%'(#$;%3'E9OQ"+%E*%Q,O.55?OQ'E$>OQ"+%EP:%Q,T
:*>:"O3&&
&
World Health Organization et al., The Right to Water&].554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3Q@'3:*+OQ"+%Eh,"*:+"+:'*h@%"$+@OE:9@+'Q"+%E3&&
&
World Health Organization and United Nations Childrens Fund Joint Monitoring Programme for Water
Supply and Sanitation, Progress in Drinking-water and Sanitation: Special Focus on Sanitation&].557^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3Q@'3:*+OQ"+%Eh,"*:+"+:'*h@%"$+@O<'*:+'E:*9O[<C.557O%*O:*>%`3@+<$3&&
&
D*%,8()*@6,$:0*2()%*#@"&:#R(='"(PXXj(!"?0#0*2.&United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs,
Population DivisionJ&@++CHOO%,"3;*3'E9O;*CC&]$",+&P:,:+%>&FI+3&-7J&.5-5^3*
&
&
57XAL5.>*G.G:.KV+L!7Y*
!*L8#'4)*+#I1"0-*('2*!3H$%4(0%1'-*ZV1M#"'&#'0($P*.'0#"OV1M#"'&#'0($*('2*F1'O
V1M#"'&#'0($[*
&
Amnesty International, Troubled Waters: Palestinians Denied Access to Water&].55?^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3*9'T<'*:+'E3'E9O>"+"O:<"9%,OS:$%OD<*%,+RhQ"+%Eh--.3C>(3&&
&
Arnaud Courtecuisse, Agence de lEau Artois-Picardie, Water Prices and Households Available Income:
Key Indicators for the Assessment of Potential Disproportionate Costs - Illustration from the ArtoisPicardie Basin (France) ].55/^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3#"$Q':,3I'<O#"$Q':,O"><:*:,+E"+:'*O(;$$hC"C%EO((CT7013C>(3&&
&
Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor, United States Department of State, 2009 Human Rights
Report: Pakistan ].5-5^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3,+"+%39'PO9O>E$OE$,O@EEC+O.55?O,I"O-415?.3@+<3&
Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Human Rights and Access to Water and Sanitation: Acting on the
Report of the OHCHR&].55/^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3E:9@++'Q"+%E3:*('OC>(,O.55/aG)Q%#3C>(3&
&
FoodFirst Information and Action Network, Investigating Some Alleged Violations of the Human Right to
Water in India: Report of the International Fact Finding Mission to India&]N"#:*%&A"#,+&%+&"$3&%>,3J&.550^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3E":*Q"+%EI$;#3'E9O>'I,OE%C'E+hB'<C$%++3C>(3&
&
Guy Howard & Jamie Bertram, World Health Organization, Domestic Water Quantity, Service Level and
Health&].554^3&&
&
Guy Howard & Jamie Bartram, World Health Organization, Domestic Water Quantity, Service Level and
Health: Executive Summary&].554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3Q@'3:*+OQ"+%Eh,"*:+"+:'*h@%"$+@O>:,%",%,OVNa545.%`,;<3C>(3&
&
Henri Smets, Agence Franaise de Dveloppement, The Right to Water in National Legislations ].551^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOP"9;%3%;E%I'<3(EO,%<:>%OA2SOE:9@+T+'TQ"+%EhLM3&
&
&
-56&
9F>#($28(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$RJ&b3M3&2'I3&DO16O.60&]D;93&1J&.5-5^&]#R&)"+"E:*"&>%&
+:+$%&'(&+@%&>'I;<%*+^3(
&
=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&G%$"+%>&+'&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&
)%*-*:0*2($28()%*:"&:0*2(*3($,,(S6-$2(!01':#.(A0?0,.()*,0:0&$,.(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#.(42&,68021(:'"(!01':(:*(
>"?",*@-"2:.&a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-5O1&]S%#3&.6J&.55?^&]#R&)"+"E:*"&>%&D$#;c;%Ec;%^3&
&
:'"(GT@"%:(*2(:'"(4##6"(*3(S6-$2(!01':#(W+,01$:0*2#(!",$:"8(:*(;&&"##(:*(/$3"(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.&a;<"*&G:9@+,&
)';*I:$J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-.O.0&]\;$R&-J&.55?^&]#R&)"+"E:*"&>%&D$#;c;%Ec;%^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,O@EI';*I:$O>'I,O-.,%,,:'*ODTaG)T-.T.0hL3C>(3(
&
:'"(GT@"%:(*2(:'"(4##6"(*3(S6-$2(!01':#(W+,01$:0*2#(!",$:"8(:*(E*2^/:$:"(/"%?0&"()%*?0#0*2(02(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.&a;<"*&
G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-6O4-&]\;*%&.?J&.5-5^&]#R&)"+"E:*"&>%&D$#;c;%Ec;%^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O:,,;%,OQ"+%EO:%`C%E+O"**;"$3@+<&]P:"&@RC%E$:*B&Q:+@&+@%&+:+$%&'(&+@%&>'I;<%*+^3(
&
=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&G%$"+%>&+'&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*&j&=*>%C3&
L`C%E+&'*&+@%&|;%,+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&"*>&L`+E%<%&A'P%E+RJ&[*02:(!"@*%:(*3(:'"(428"@"28"2:(GT@"%:(*2(:'"(c6"#:0*2(*3(
S6-$2(!01':#($28(GT:%"-"()*?"%:7.(9$18$,"2$(/"@k,?"8$(A$%8*2$.($28(:'"(428"@"28"2:(GT@"%:(*2(:'"(4##6"(*3(S6-$2(
!01':#(W+,01$:0*2#(!",$:"8(:*(;&&"##(:*(/$3"(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.(A$:$%02$(8"(;,+656"%56"R(90##0*2(:*(B$21,$8"#'.&
a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-6O66&]\;$R&..J&.5-5^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
+@%&>'I;<%*+^3(
&
=*+%ETd'P%E*<%*+"$&A"*%$&'*&)$:<"+%&)@"*9%&e=dA))fJ&A,0-$:"(A'$21"(PXXYR(/72:'"#0#(!"@*%:&]M'P3&-/J&.55/^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3:CII3I@OC>(O",,%,,<%*+TE%C'E+O"E0O,REO"E0h,RE3C>(3&
&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&L`C%E+,&K%%+:*9&'*&+@%&G:9@+&+'&V"+%EJ&A"E:,J&SE3J&\;$R&/T7J&.55?J&W6:&*-"(*3(:'"(42:"%2$:0*2$,(GT@"%:#L(
9"":021(*2(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%&]FI+3&.55?^J&$?$0,$+,"&$:&@++CHOO;*%,>'I3;*%,I'3'E9O:<"9%,O55-7O55-760O-7604.%3C>(3&*
&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&_"Q&D,,'I:"+:'*&e=_DfJ&B"%,02(!6,"#(*2(D$:"%(!"#*6%&"#(]D;93&.-J&.550^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3I"Q"+%ET
:*('3*%+O$:#E"ERO%*9O$O#%E$:*hE;$%,3C>(3(
&
Juan Miguel Picolotti, Center for Human Rights and Environment, The Right to Water in Argentina&].554^J&
&
Litigating Economic, Social and Cultural Rights: Achievements, Challenges and Strategies(]K"$I'$<&
_"*9('E>J&%>3J&.554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3I'@E%3'E9O,:+%,O>%(";$+O(:$%,O$:+:9"+:*9h%,IhE:9@+,hT
h"I@:%P%<%*+hI@"$$%*9%,h"*>h,+E"+%9:%,h.5543C>(3&
&
Maike Gorsboth, FoodFirst Information and Action Network, Identifying and Addressing Violations of the
Human Right to Water: Applying the Human Rights Approach&].551^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3(:"*3'E9OE%,';EI%,O>'I;<%*+,O'+@%E,O:>%*+:(R:*9T"*>T">>E%,,:*9TP:'$"+:'*,T'(T+@%T@;<"*TE:9@+T+'T
Q"+%EOn,%"EI@+%E<o:>%*+:(R:*9m.5"*>m.5">>E%,,:*93&
&
Malcolm Langford & Aofie Nolan, Centre for Housing Rights and Evictions, Litigating Economic, Social
and Cultural Rights: Legal Practitioners' Dossier&].551^3&
Water: International and National Standards&].550^3&
&
K:$$%**:;<&AE'[%I+&!",B&S'EI%&/&'*&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&;&'0"?021(:'"(90,,"2206-(>"?",*@-"2:(F*$,#(3*%(D$:"%($28(
/$20:$:0*2R(D'$:(0:(H0,,(=$O"(]S%#3&-J&.550^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3;*<:$$%**:;<CE'[%I+3'E9O>'I;<%*+,O+(/:*+%E:<3C>(3&
&
F((:I%&'(&+@%&a:9@&)'<<UE&('E&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&G%9:'*"$&F((:I%&('E&+@%&A"I:(:IJ&!$:030&$:0*2(*3(S6-$2(!01':#(=%"$:0"#R(;88"8(
`$,6"(3*%(:'"()$&030&(!"10*2&]\;$R&.55?^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOC"I:(:I3'@I@E3'E9O>'I,OG"+:(:I"+:'*8''B3C>(/*
&
&
-51&
Parvez Hassan, United Nations Environmental Programme, Environmental Rights as Part of Fundamental
Rights: the Leadership of the Judiciary in Pakistan&].554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O,R,+%<O(:$%,OL*P:E'*<%*+"$3G:9@+,3A"B:,+"*3>'I3&
&
NC%I:"$&G"CC'E+%;E&'*&+@%&L*['R<%*+&'(&LI'*3J&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,&"*>&+@%&G:9@+&+'&D>%c;"+%&S''>J&='"(!01':(:*(
;8"56$:"(U**8($#($(S6-$2(!01':.(b3M3&N;#TI'<<U*&'*&+@%&AE'<'+:'*&"*>&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&b3M3&2'I3&&
b3M3&2'I3&LO)M30ON;#3.O-?7/O.4&]\;$3&/J&-?7/^&]#R&D,#['E*&L:>%^3&
&
NC%I:"$&G"CC'E+%;E&'*&+@%&L*['R<%*+&'(&LI'*3J&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,&"*>&+@%&G:9@+&+'&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&N;CC$R&"*>&
N"*:+"+:'*J&>%$3:(F608",02"#(3*%(:'"(!"$,0Q$:0*2(*3(:'"(!01':(:*(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2J&b3M3&N;#TI'<<U*&'*&+@%&
AE'<'+:'*&"*>&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)M30ON;#3.O.556O.6&]\;$R&--J&.556^&]#R&a">[:&d;:,,p^3&
&
NC%I:"$&G"CC'E+%;E&'*&+@%&G:9@+&+'&S''>J&/0T:'(!"@*%:(*2(:'"(!01':(:*(U**8J&)'<<U*&'*&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&b3M3&2'I3&
LO)M30O.551O00&]K"E3&-1J&.551^&]#R&\"*&z:%9$%E^3*
&
N+"+%<%*+&'(&+@%&G%CE%,%*+"+:P%&'(&)"*">"&+'&+@%&b3M3&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&]\;$R&.7J&.5-5^J&%"@%02:"8(02(AE%,,&G%$%",%J&
d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$RJ&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&D>'C+,&G%,'$;+:'*&G%I'9*:Z:*9&DII%,,&+'&)$%"*&V"+%EJ&N"*:+"+:'*&",&"&a;<"*&G:9@+J&
#R&G%I'E>%>&s'+%&'(&-..&:*&S"P'EJ&M'*%&D9":*,+J&0-&D#,+%*+:'*,g&2%$%9"+%,&"$,'&)'*(:E<&M'<:*%%&+'&a%">&F((:I%&'(&
=*+%E*"$&FP%E,:9@+&N%EP:I%,J&L$%I+&8%$"E;,&+'&bMLA&d'P%E*:*9&)';*I:$J&b3M3&AE%,,&G%$%",%&dDO-5?1/&]\;$R&.7J&.5-5^3&
&
N+"+%<%*+&'(&+@%&G%CE%,%*+"+:P%&'(&+@%&b*:+%>&N+"+%,&+'&+@%&b3M3&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&]\;$R&.7J&.5-5^J&%"@%02:"8(02(AE%,,&
G%$%",%J&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$RJ&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&D>'C+,&G%,'$;+:'*&G%I'9*:Z:*9&DII%,,&+'&)$%"*&V"+%EJ&N"*:+"+:'*&",&"&
.5-5^3&
&
The World Conservation Union, Water Law Series Issue 9: Human Rights and Water ].557^J&$?$0,$+,"($:R(
@++CHOOI<,>"+"3:;I*3'E9O>'Q*$'">,O(,?3C>(<(*
&
b3M3&)'<<U*&'*&a;<3&G+,3J&M'+%&s%E#"$%&2"+%>&71O-.O56&(E'<&+@%&A%E<"*%*+&K:,,:'*&'(&+@%&M%+@%E$"*>,&+'&+@%&b*:+%>&
M"+:'*,&F((:I%&"+&d%*%P"&">>E%,,%>&+'&+@%&)%*+E%&('E&a;<"*&G:9@+,&]l_:<#;E9&AE:*I:C$%,l^J&C"E"3&.6J&b3M3&2'I3&
LO)M30O-?7/O-/&]\"*3&7J&-?7/^J&%"@%02:"8(02&? Hum. Rts. Q. -..(]-?7/^3&
&
b3&M3&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&L*PU+3&j&2%P3J&G:'&>%&\"*:%E'J&8E"Z3J&\;*%&4T-0J&-??.J&;1"28$(PNJ&b3M3&2'I3&DO)FMS3-6-O.1OGLs3-&]s'$3&
==^&]\;*%&-0J&-??.^3*
U. N. Dept of Econ. and Soc. Affairs, The Word at Six Billion,&b3M3&2'I3&LNDOAOVA3-60&]-???^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*3'E9O%,"OC'C;$"+:'*OC;#$:I"+:'*,O,:`#:$$:'*O,:`#:$$:'*3@+<
U. N. Dept of Econ. and Soc. Affairs, World Population Prospects: the 2008 Revision&b3M3&2'I3&
N!OLNDONLG3DO.7/&].557^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOO%,"3;*3'E9O;*C>OQCC.557OC%C,h>'I;<%*+,3@+<3&
U. N. Dev. Programme, Beyond Scarcity: Power, Poverty and the Global Water Crisis: UNDP Human
Development Report 2006&].551^3&
&
U. N. Dev. Programme, Human Development Report 1990: The Concept and Measurement of Human
Development(]-??5^<&
&
b3&M3&a:9@&)'<<UE&('E&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&!"@<(*3(:'"(\<(E<(S01'(A*--L%(3*%(S6-$2(!01':#(*2(:'"(/&*@"($28(A*2:"2:(*3(:'"(
!","?$2:(S6-$2(!01':#(W+,01$:0*2#(!",$:"8(:*(G560:$+,"(;&&"##(:*(/$3"(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2(628"%(42:L,(S6-$2(
&
b3&M3&V"+%E&)'*(%E%*I%&eb3M3V3)3fJ&K"E&>%$&A$"+"J&DE93J&K"E3&-0T.6J&-?//J&!"@<(*3(:'"(\<(E<(D$:"%(A*23"%"2&"J&b3M3&2'I3&
&
World Health Organization et al., The Right to Water&].554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3Q@'3:*+OQ"+%Eh,"*:+"+:'*h@%"$+@OE:9@+'Q"+%E3&&
&
&
-5/&
World Health Organization and United Nations Childrens Fund Joint Monitoring Programme for Water
Supply and Sanitation, Progress in Drinking-water and Sanitation: Special Focus on Sanitation&].557^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3Q@'3:*+OQ"+%Eh,"*:+"+:'*h@%"$+@O<'*:+'E:*9O[<C.557O%*O:*>%`3@+<$3&*
&
&
!G11,-*('2*=61"0#"*91",-*%'*(*G13'2*>1$$#40%1'&
&
D,:+&8:,Q",&j&)%I:$:"&!'E+"[">"J&A'$21021(F,*+$,(D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:(C$28#&$@".&02&Water Management in 2020 and
Beyond&-5&]D3i3&8:,Q",&%+&"$3&%>,3J&.551^3&
&
Audrey Chapman & Sage Russell, 42:%*86&:0*2.(02 Core Obligations: Building a Framework for Economic,
Social and Cultural Rights -&].55.^3
&
Bob CliffordJ&U01':021(3*%(E"H(!01':#J&02&The International Struggle for New Human Rights&-&].55?^3&
&
)@:,"*9"&A;+%T)@%BQ%&j&M'E"&S$''>J&U%*-(>0?0#0*2(:*(42:"1%$:0*2R(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#($#(B$#0&(S6-$2(
!01':#.&02&Giving Meaning to Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights&4?&]=,("@"*&K%E"$:&j&s"$%E:%&F',+%EP%$>&%>,3J&
.55-^3&
&
David Shiman, Economic and Social Justice: A Human Rights Perspective ]-???^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
&
S%BE:&D3&a",,"*J&D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:($28(G$%,7(A0?0,0Q$:0*2#R(3%*-(A**@"%$:0*2(:*(A*23,0&:.(02&History and Future of
Shared Water Resources, .&]bMLN)F&%>3J&.554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOO;*%,>'I3;*%,I'3'E9O:<"9%,O55-4O55-44.O-44.71%3C>(3&*
&
H. Shue, Basic Rights, Subsistence, Affluence and U.S. Foreign Policy&]-?75^3&
&
Henry Steiner, Philip Alston & Ryan Goodman, International Human Rights in Context: Law, Politics,
Morals&]4E>&%>3&.557^3&
&
Ian Brownlie, Principles of Public International Law&]1+@&%>3&.554^3&
&
J.E.S. Fawcett, The Application of the European Convention on Human Rights&]-?7/^3&
&
J. Getzler, A History of Water Rights at Common Law&].550^3&
Jack Donnelly, International Human Rights ]4E>&%>3&.55/^3&
&
Joan Goldstein, Demanding Clean Food and Water: The Fight for a Basic Human Right&]-??5^3&
&
Johannes Morsink, The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: Origins, Drafting and Intent
]-???^3&
&
John Austin, Province of Jurisprudence Determined&])"<#E:>9%&-??6^]-74.^3&
&
Jona Razzaque, Public Interest Environmental Litigation in India, Pakistan and Bangladesh ].550^3&
&
Kurt Bourquain, Freshwater Access from a Human Rights Perspective: A Challenge to International
Water and Human Rights Law&].557^3&
&
_';:,&a%*B:*J&42:"%2$:0*2$,(S6-$2(!01':#($#(I!01':#M.(02&Nomos XXIII: Human Rights&.6/&]\3&G'Q$"*>&A%**'IB&j&\'@*&V3&
)@"C<"*&%>,3J&-?7-^3&
&
K"E+:*&G%;,,J&S0#:*%0&$,(GT@,$2$:0*2($28(D$:"%(4##6"#.(02&History and Future of Shared Water Resources&]bMLN)F&
%>3J&.554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&;*%,>'I3;*%,I'3'E9O:<"9%,O55-4O55-44.O-44.71%3C>(3&
&
Maude Barlow, Blue Covenant: The Global Water Crisis and the Coming Battle for the Right to Water&
].557^3&
&
&
-57&
A"+E:I:"&V';+%E,J&\20?"%#$,($28(!"10*2$,(;@@%*$&'"#(:*(!"#*,?021(42:"%2$:0*2$,(>0#@6:"#R(D'$:(C"##*2#(C"$%2"8(3%*-(/:$:"(
)%$&:0&"_.(02&Resolution of International Water Disputes&---&]=*+%E*"+:'*"$&8;E%";J&A%E<"*%*+&)';E+&'(&
DE#:+E"+:'*&%>3J&.554^3&*
&
A";$&\3&M%$,'*J&C*&$,(A,$0-#.(42:"%2$:0*2$,(/:$28$%8#($28(:'"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&02&The International Struggle for
New Human Rights&-45&]8'#&)$:(('E>&%>3J&.55?^3*
&
Peter GleickJ&)"$O(D$:"%.&02&The Worlds Water 2008-2009: The Biennial Report on Freshwater Resources&-&
].55?^3&
&
Peter Gleick,&D$:"%(B%0"3(U*6%R(D$:"%(A*23,0&:(A'%*2*,*17.(02&The Worlds Water 2008-2009: The Biennial Report
on Freshwater Resources&-6-&].55?^3&
&
Peter Malanczuk,&Akehursts Modern Introduction to International LawJ&]G';+$%>9%J&/+@&%>3&
-??/^]-?/5^3&
&
G3&A"+@"BJ&)6+,0&(42:"%"#:(C0:01$:0*2(02(4280$.&02&Democracy, Human Rights and the Rule of Law, Essays in Honour
of Nani Palkhivala&-.6&]s%*B"+&=R%E&%>3J&.555^3*
&
Steven Hodgson, FAO Legal Office, Modern Water Rights: Theory and Practice&].551^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
(+CHOO(+C3("'3'E9O>'IE%CO("'O5-5O"5710%O"5710%553C>(3&]KFsL&!F&GLAFG!N^&
&
N;,"*&K'$$%E&FB:*J&C0+"%:7($28(D",3$%"R(/*-"(4##6"#(02(S6-$2(!01':#(='"*%7.&02&Nomos XXIII: Human Rights&.45&]\3&
G'$"*>&A%**'IB&j&\'@*&V3&)@"C<"*&%>,3J&-?7-^3&*
&
Thomas Fuller, Gnomologia: Adages and Proverbs; Wise Sentences and Witty Sayings, Ancient and Modern,
Foreign and British&]8:#$:'_:(%&.5-5^]-/4.^3&*
&
s:I+'E&D#E"<'P:I@&j&)@E:,+:"*&)';E+:,J&=*H$%8#($(>"-$28$+0,0:7(*3(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#R(42:"%2$:0*2$,(
/:$28$%8#($28(:'"0%(;@@,0&$:0*2(02(C*&$,(A*6%:#.(02&The Application of Human Rights Treaties for Local
Juristictions&4.0&]K"E+*&D#E%9&j&)@E:,+:"*&)';E+:,&%>,3J&-??/^3*
&
&
!>(-#*:(;**
&
D3A3&A'$$;+:'*&)'*+E'$&8'"E>T==&P3&K3s3&M"R;>;J&].55-^&0&=3_3G3&16/&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3:%$EI3'E9OI'*+%*+O%55-53C>(3(
&
D*[;*&=E("*&P&_"@'E%&2%P3&D;+@3&].55.^&A_2&]_"@'E%^&666&]_"@'E%&D:E&A'$$;+:'*&)",%^&]A"B3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.4?5J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources
]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.?5^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
D,B&D:*&'&N"$:,@&i%*>E"&P3&8"*9$3&&]-???^&-?&83_323&077&]8"*9$3^J&#6--$%0Q"8(02&Ask Ain o Salish, Human Rights in
Balgladesh 2000 ].55-^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3%,IET*%+3'E9OI",%$"QOI",%$"Qh,@'Q3@+<n>'Ih:>o055?.53(
&
)<"E"&>%&DC%$"I:'*%,&%*&$'&):P:$&R&)'<%EI:"$&e)DC%$3))&Mc*3f&eM%;c;%*&)';E+&'(&DCC%"$,&:*&):P:$&"*>&)'<<%EI:"$&
K"++%E,f&.O4O-??/J&WK%*'E%,&)'<;*:>">&A"R*%<:$&O&"II:*&"<C"E'&]DE93^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%,IET
*%+3'E9O;,Eh>'IO,%*+%*I:"hI<"E"hA"R*%<:$3+:(J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Malcolm Langford et al., Centre for Housing
Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water: International and National Standards&---&
].550^3&&
&
)"<C":9*&('E&S:,I"$&Lc;:+R&P3&N+"+%&'(&M~J&-55&M3~&3.>&7?4&].554^3&
&
)"<C":9*&('E&S:,I"$&Lc;:+R&P3&N+"+%&'(&M~J&7&M3~3&4>&-0&].551^3&
&
)",%&'(&+@%&SE%%&z'*%,&'(&bCC%E&N"P'R&"*>&+@%&2:,+E:I+&'(&d%`&]SE3&s3&NQ:+Z3^J&-?4.J&A3)3=3\3&]N%E3&DO8^&M'3&01J&"+&?1&]\;*%&/^3&
&
)%*+E%&'*&a';,:*9&G:9@+,&"*>&LP:I+:'*,&P3&N;>"*J&D(E3&)'<<x*&a;<3&j&A%'C$%,x&G+,3J&)'<<3&M'3&.?1T56&]\;$R&.?J&.5-5^3(
&
-5?&
(
A"%:030&$:0*2(*3(:'"(A*2#:0:6:0*2(*3(:'"(!"@6+,0&(*3(/*6:'(;3%0&$(-??1&]//^&ND&/00&]))^&]N3&D(E3^3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&<"R'&.7J&-??/J&L`C%>:%*+%&2T-100&])'$'<3^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??/O)T6.-T?/3@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&);"E+"&>%&G%P3J&"9',+'&-J&.55.J&L`C%>:%*+%&.554T1?/11/&]F*-"Q(
w21",^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.554O!T0-5T543@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&);"E+"&>%&G%P3J&*'P:%<#E%&4J&-??.J&L`C%>:%*+%&-??.T-707&]!*a$#&
!*8%t16"Q^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??.O!T6/7T?.3@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&AE:<%E"&>%&G%P3J&"#E:$&-/J&.55/J&L`C%>:%*+%&.55/T-0.17-7&
][0-v2"Q&8"&A*%%"$^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.55/O!T./5T5/3@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&N%9;*>"&>%&G%P3J&"9',+'&1J&.55?J&L`C%>:%*+%&.55?T..6?6-?&
]96%&0$(W:u%*,$^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.55?O!T601T5?3@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&N%9;*>"&>%&G%P3J&[;$:'&4-J&.557J&L`C%>:%*+%&.554T-.7-.0/J&!T
-71/4-/J&R&!T-71/4.1&]W#*%0*()$,$&0*^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.557O!T/15T573@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&NpC+:<"&>%&G%P3J&"#E:$&.0J&.551J&L`C%>:%*+%&.551T-.11.5?&]F$%&0$(
A$?0"8"#^(])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.551O!T4-/T513@+<3&
&
]U,*%"Q^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??0O!T6.4T?03@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&NpC+:<"&>%&G%P3J&[;*:'&-7J&-??4J&L`C%>:%*+%&-??4T?/-4&]_:*"E=%,&
B"a%$2*^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??4O!T.4.T?43@+<3&&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&NpC+:<"&>%&G%P3J&*'P:%<#E%&..J&-??0J&L`C%>:%*+%&-??0T4061-&
]K%>:*"&ApE%Z^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O-??0O!T6.4T?03@+<3&
&
)'E+%&)'*,+:+;I:'*"$&])3)3^&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+fJ&N"$"&!%EI%E"&>%&G%P3J&"9',+'&-J&.55.J&L`C%>:%*+%&.55.T6744.5&
]9*%$,"#^&])'$'<3^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I'E+%I'*,+:+;I:'*"$39'P3I'OE%$"+'E:"O.55.O!T6?7T5.3@+<3&
&
)'E+%&N;CE%<"&>%&\;,+:I:"&e)3N3\3f&eN;CE%<%&)';E+fJ&.6&*'P:%<#E%&.55?J&WD$%["*>E'&A"C:I&2'<:*9;%Z&I'*&)'<;*:>">&
=*>:9%*"&DR<"E"&)@;Z<:Z"&R&b,<"9"<"JX&G'$&>%&$"&I";,"H.705T57J&E%I;E,'&>%&CE'+%II:*&])@:$%^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3C'>%E[;>:I:"$3I$O<'>;$',O8;,c)";,",O8)Dh%,+"05.3C@CnE'Q>%+"$$%oDDDM'ADDMDD);LEDD)jI'*,;$+"o55jI";,"o.705O.557j*;<I;"o0-.0.j,%IE%obM=)D3&
&
)'E+%&N;CE%<"&>%&\;,+:I:"&>%&$"&M"I:*&e)N\Mf&eM"+:'*"$&N;CE%<%&)';E+&'(&\;,+:I%fJ&-7O?O.55/J&W2%(%*,'E&>%$&A;%#$'&>%&$"&
M"I:*&I3&L,+">'&M"I:'*"$&O&"II:*&"<C"E'X&]DE93^&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3>%E%I@'T
I'<C"E">'3'E9O,%*+%*I:",O"E9!'#",3@+<3&
&
)'E+%&N;CE%<"&>%&\;,+:I:"&>%&$"&M"I:*&e)N\Mf&eM"+:'*"$&N;CE%<%&)';E+&'(&\;,+:I%fJ&.6O7O.55?J&WN%#",+:*&DEE:'$"&R&F+E',&
O&I";,"X&]DE93^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3":>,$%`3'E9O,:+%h>'I;<%*+,O2GT5-40N3C>(3&
&
)@"<%$:&N:*9@&P3&b++"E&AE">%,@J&]-??1^&].^&N3)3)3&60?&]=*>:"^3&
&
)';E+&>UDE#:+E"9%&e)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+f&"EE}+&*'&41O-??7J&DCE3&-J&-??7J&Moniteur Belge&eK8f&eF((:I:"$&d"Z%++%&'(&
8%$9:;<fJ&DCE3&.0J&-??7&]8%$93^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources
]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.?1^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
2"Q>"&\"Q"E"&P3&d"<#:"J&D(E3&)'<<U*&a;<3&j&A%'C$%,x&G+,3J&)'<<3&M'3&-0/O?6&j&-0?O?1&]K"R&--3&.555^3&
&
S3i3&a;,,":*&P3&b*:'*&'(&=*>:"&]-??5^&D3=3G3&]i%E3^&4.-J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.0?/J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&
&
--5&
Water: International and National Standards&--1&].550^3&
&
S"E''c;%&P3&8"*9$">%,@J&]-??1^&07&23_3G3&]a)^&047&]S$''>&DI+:'*&A$"*&)",%J&a:9@&)';E+^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&\'*"&
$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3#:$:"#>3'E9O#$[OI'*+%*+-3@+<3&
&
S"E''c;%&P3&8"*9$">%,@&]U,**8(;&:0*2(),$2.(;@@",,$:"^J&]-??/^&0?&23_3G3&]D2^&-3&
&
S"E''c;%&P3&8"*9$">%,@&]!$80*$&:0?"&90,O&)*H8"%^J&;*E%C'E+%>&V3A3&?.&]\;$3&-J&-??1^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-4.43&
&
S"E''c;%&P3&8"*9$">%,@J&;*E%C'E+%>&V3A3&7?-&]-??0^J&]>%I:,:'*&\;$R&-6J&.55-^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.6/7.(@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources
]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.7.^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3(
&
SE"*I:,&)'E"$:%&K;$$:*&P3&b*:'*&!%EE:+'ER&'(&2%$@:J(]-?7-^&.&N3)3G3&6-1&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3:*>:"*B"*''*3'E9O>'IO/7641OJ&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal
('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&./7^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
SE%%&_%9"$&D,,:,+"*I%&dE';C&P3&z":E%J&D(E3&)'<<U*&a;<3&j&A%'C$%,x&G+,3J&)'<<3&M'3&.6O7?J&0/O?5J&61O?-&j&-55O?4&]FI+3J&
-??6^3&
&
d%*%E"$&N%IE%+"ER&P3&!@%&2:E%I+'E&]-??0^&N)KG&.51-&]N"$+&K:*%E,&)",%^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing
Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water and Sanitation: International and National
Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.?5^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
F%**:+**-(?<(W*#:"2+"%1(.555&]4^&8)_G&.//&])^&]N3&D(E3^3&
&
[*'$22"#+6%1(?<(9$Q0+6O*&.55?&]7^&8)_G&/?-&]N)D^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3,"($::3'E9OI9:T
#:*O>:,C3C$n(:$%oZ"OI",%,OzDN)DO.55?O.53@+<$jc;%ERom.5<"Z:#;B'3&
&
\;>:I:"$&G%P:%Q&'(&+@%&_"Q&M'3&/&'(&.550&'*&V"+%E&G%,';EI%,J&\;>9<%*+&'(&-4+@&\;$R&.556J&M'3&567T56?T515T514OAbbT&
==O.5503&])3)3^&]=*>'*3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3<"@B"<"@B'*,+:+;,:39'3:>OC;+;,"*OC;+;,"*h,:>"*9h%*9hA;+;,"*m.5567T56?T514m.5AbbT==T
.5503m.5557TAbbT===T.556m.5]bbm.5N2D^3C>(J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions,
Legal Resources for the Right to Water and Sanitation: International and National Standards&].*>&%>3J&
('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&./?^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
Juzgado Nacional de Primera Instancia [1a Inst.] [National Lower Court of Ordinary Jurisdicton], 13/08/2007,
Asociacin Civil por la Igualdad y la Justicia c. Gobierno de la Ciudad de Buenos Aires / acccin amparo, (Arg.),
available at http://www.newsmatic.epol.com.ar/index.php?pub_id=99&sid=1046&aid=22936&eid=28&NombreSeccion=Jurisprudencia%20Ciudad%20de%2
0Bs.As&Accion=VerArticulo.&
&
\;Z9">'&>%&AE:<%E"&=*,+"*I:"&>%&)E>'#"&e-"&=*,+3&)#"3f&e)'E>'#"&_'Q%E&)';E+&'(&FE>:*"ER&\;E:,>:I+:'*fJ&7O0O.55.J&
W|;%P">'&K:9;%$&D*9%$&R&'+E',&IO&D9;",&)'E>'#%,",&N3D&O&"II:*&"<C"E'X&]DE93^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Malcolm
&
\;Z9">'&M"I:'*"$&>%&AE:<%E"&=*,+"*I:"&>%&K'E%*'J&8;%*',&D:E%,&e-"&=*,+3&K3&83D3f&e_'Q%E&)';E+&'(&FE>:*"ER&\;E:,>:I+:'*fJ&
.-O7O.55.J&Wb,;"E:',&R&)'*,;<">'E%,&%*&2%(%*,"&>%&,;,&2%E%I@',&D,'I:"I:*&):P:$&IO&D9;",&>%$&dE"*&8;%*',&D:E%,&N3D3&O&
"II:*&"<C"E'(]DE93^&$?$0,$+,"($:J&@++CHOOQQQ3$%9"$<"*:"3I'<3"EO>%E%I@'O("$$'h",'I:"I:'*hI'*,;<:>'E3@+<3&.55.&__8D&
-46?&%+&,%c3&
&
\;Z9">'&>%&AE:<%E"&=*,+"*I:"&>%&)E>'#"&e-"&=*,+3&)#"3f&e)'E>'#"&_'Q%E&)';E+&'(&FE>:*"ER&\;E:,>:I+:'*fJ&-?O-5O.550J&
WK"EI@:,:'&\',p&8";+:,+"&O&"II:*&"<C"E'X&]DE93^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&=*9$"&V:*B$%EJ&[680&0$,(G23*%&"-"2:(*3(:'"(S6-$2(
&
---&
!01':(:*(D$:"%R(A$#"(C$H(3%*-(/*6:'(;3%0&$.(;%1"2:02$($28(4280$&_"QJ&.557]-^&L. Soc. Just. & Global Dev. J. -5 ]FI+3&?J&

.557^J&@++CHOOQQQ.3Q"EQ:IB3"I3;BO("IO,'IO$"QO%$[O$9>O.557h-OQ:*B$%EO3&
&
i%E"$"&P3&M3&K3&!@'<",J&]-?/1^&].^&N3)3)3&4-5&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3E:,@"#@>"E"3I'<O,IOP:%Q3C@CnI",%o674-3&
&
i;E'>"&P3&\"$"*>'*:J&74&PhiL. Rep.&-/-&]-?0?^&]A@:$3^3&&&
&
_:*>,%R&P3&M'E<%+J&056&b3N3&61&]-?/.^3&
(
9$25","(?<(>6%+$2(=%$2#0:0*2$,(9":%*<(A*62&0,.&.55.&].^&ND&4?&]2^&]N3&D(E3^3&
&
9$Q0+6O*(?<([*'$22"#+6%1&]9$Q0+6O*(AA^(.5-5&]4^&8)_G&.4?&]))^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3,"($::3'E9OZ"OI",%,OzD))O.55?O.73@+<$3&
&
9$Q0+6O*(?<([*'$22"#+6%1.&)",%&M'3&51O-4761&].557^&]a)J&V:+3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3:"+C3'E9O+E">%'#,%EP"+'ERO$:#E"ER3I(<nE%(=2o-5.64?3(
&
9020#:"%(3*%(4--01%$:0*2($28(G:'0&(;33$0%#(?<(="*'&]-??6^&-74&)_G&./4&]D;,+$3^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(+7&Child Rights
Information Network, @++CHOOQQQ3IE:*3'E9O_"QO:*,+E;<%*+3",Cn=*,+=2o-04-&]$",+&P:,:+%>&FI+3&./J&.5-5^3
&
9020#:"%(*3(S"$,:'(?<(=%"$:-"2:(;&:0*2(A$-@$012&]=;A^&.55.&]6^&ND&/.-&]))^3&
&
F$9"&!%$$:,&P3&8'<#"R&K;*3&)';*I:$J&]-?76^&.&N3)3G3&6-&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O.7453&
&
FC',"&P3&S;$9%*I:'&N3&S"I+'E"*&\E3&]902*%#(W@*#$lJ&d3&G3&M'3&-5-574&]\;$R&45J-??4^&]A@:$3^J&%"@%02:"8(02&44&=_K&]-??0^&C&-/4&
%+&,%c3J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water
and Sanitation: International and National Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.?.^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&
Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
A",I@:<&8"*9"&i@%+&K"Z>''E&N"<:+R&P3&V%,+&8%*9"$J&]-??1^&D3=3G3&.0.1&]=*>:"^3&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3<"**E%++:*>:3:,O+@%T@;<"*TE:9@+,T
EC'[%I+O@;<"*E:9@+,I",%,"*><"+%E:"$,OI",%,O*"+:'*"$I",%,O,;CE%<%I';E+'(:*>:"O*EO4?03
&
A%'C$%x,&b*:'*&('E&):P:$&_:#%E+:%,&P3&b*:'*&'(&=*>:"J&].55/^&-&N3)3)3&/-?&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOO:*>:"*B"*''*3'E9O>'IO0--741O3(
&
CE%$:<:*"ER&CE'+%I+:'*^3&
&
A%'C$%x,&b*:'*&('E&):P:$&_:#%E+:%,&P3&b*:'*&'(&=*>:"J&VE:+&'(&A%+:+:'*&M'3&-?1O.55-&]N3)3&K"R&.J&.554J&,%I'*>&'E>%E&9E"*+:*9&
CE%$:<:*"ER&CE'+%I+:'*^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%,IET*%+3'E9OI",%$"QOI",%$"Qh,@'Q3@+<n>'Ih:>o05-544&],%$%I+&
W>'Q*$'">X&@RC%E$:*B&:*&$%(+T@"*>&C"*%$^<&
&
A%E;<"++R&dE"<"&A"*I@"R"+&P3&i%E"$"J&].550^&-&i3_3!3&/4-&]=*>:"^3&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-0-5J&
@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02(Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water and
Sanitation: International and National Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.7/^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&
+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
A@:$:C&K'EE:,&P3&)';E+&'(&DCC%"$,J&d3G3&M'3&?-44.J&..0&N3)3G3D3&6/1&]\;$R&-1J&-??4^&]A@:$3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3$"QC@:$3*%+O[;>[;E:,O[;E:-??4O[;$-??4O9Eh?-44.h-??43@+<$3&
&
A@:$:CC:*%,&P3&_%'&LI@%9"E"R&R&A:$'J&d3G3&M'3&--/0/.&]\;*%&.6J&-??1^&]A@:$^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3I@"*E'#$%,3I'<OIE"$"Q-??1-/3@+<3(
&
AE"B",@&K"*:&N@"E<"&P3&M%C"$&V"+%E&N;CC$R&)'EC'E"+:'*J&]-??5^&8N&.50/&>%I:>%>&:*&&
].55-^&8N&.567&D,@">@&.1J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-474J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02(Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal
('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&450^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
(
!"#08"2:#(*3(B*2(`0#:$(9$2#0*2#(?<(/*6:'"%2(9":%*@*,0:$2(C*&$,(A*62&0,(.55.&]1^&8)_G&1.6&]V^&]N3&D(E3^3&
&
--.&
&
GR"*&P3&D++UR&d%*3J&e-?16f&=3G3&.?0&]=E3^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal
('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.75^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
(
/<(?<(9$OH$27$2"(-??6&]4^&ND&4?-&]))^&]N3&D(E3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3,"($::3'E9OZ"OI",%,OzD))O-??6O43@+<$3(
&
N3&i3&d"E9&P3&b++"E&AE">%,@J&]-???^&D3=3G3&]D$$3^&0-&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOO:*>:"*B"*''*3'E9O>'IO775774OJ&@$%:0$,,7(
%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water and
Sanitation: International and National Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&457^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&
+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
N:*>@&=*,+3&'(&bE'$'9R&"*>&!E"*,C$"*+"+:'*&P3&M%,+$p&K:$BC"B&_+>3J&].556^&)_)&]N:*>@J&i"E"I@:^&0.0J&].550^&]A"B3^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3,@%@E:3'E9O,;#C"9%,O*%,+$%3C>(J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02(Malcolm Langford et al., Centre for
Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water: International and National
Standards&-7?&].550^3&&&
&
N@"$"&z:"&P3&VDA2DJ&]-??0^&N)KG&1?4&]A"B3^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-40.3(
(
/**+%$-*2"7(?<(='"(9020#:"%(*3(S"$,:'.(gH$Q6,6(E$:$,(-??7&]-^&ND&/16&]))^&]N3&D(E3^3&
(
/*6:'(;3%0&$(?<(F%**:+**-(.555&]--^&8)_G&--1?&]))^&]N3&D(E3^3&
&
N;#@",@&i;<"E&P3&N+"+%&'(&8:@"EJ&]-??-^&D3=3G&0.5&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3:%$EI3'E9OI'*+%*+O%?-573C>(3&
&
N;ER"&2@;*9%$&P3&d'>"P"E:&K"E#$%&=*>;,+E:%,J&]-??6^&.56.&M3i3A3&4/&]M%C"$^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3%$"Q3'E9O*'>%O-70?J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02(Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources
]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&.?.^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3(
&
!"<:$*">;&P3&a:*>&N+'*%J&]-?7-^&].^&N)KG&.56&"+&.-.&]=*>:"^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3E:,@"#@>"E"3I'<O,IOP:%Q3C@CnI",%o/6--3(
&
!E:#;*"$&>%&9E"*>%&:*,+"*I%&e!d=f&e'E>:*"ER&I';E+&'(&'E:9:*"$&[;E:,>:I+:'*f&DP:9*'*J&K"R&-.J&-??6J&*3&-0?.O?6&]SE3^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOOQQQ3I"I%3(EO[;E:,CE;>%*I%OE%+,O%";CE%,,:'*O+9:-.56-??63@+<$J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Centre on
Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water and Sanitation: International and
National Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&]<"*;,IE:C+&"+&455^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3(
&
!E:#;*"$&N;C%E:'E&>%&\;,+:I:"&>%&M%;c;p*&e!E:#3&N;C3&Mc*3f&eN;C%E:'E&!E:#;*"$&'(&\;,+:I%f&Ws"$%*+:*"&M'E+%&)'$'*RJ&
2%(%*,'E"&>%&K%*'E%,&M&4&I3&A'>%E&L[%I;+:P'&K;*:I:C"$&O&"II:*&"<C"E'X&]DE93^J&@$%:0$,,7(%"@*%:"8(02&Malcolm
&
&
!>1'4$32%'8*KH-#"M(0%1'-*('2*=0(0#*!("0)*=3H&%--%1'-*Z>X=>+\>>!+[*
&
)'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&)'*,:>%E"+:'*&'(&G%C'E+,&N;#<:++%>&#R&N+"+%,&A"E+:%,&;*>%E&DE+:I$%&05&'(&+@%&)'P%*"*+&
]=,E"%$^J&b3M3&2'I3&))AGO)O=NGO)FO4&]N%C3&4J&.5-5^J("+(@++CHOO>"II%,,T>>,T
*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd-5O007O51OA2SOd-5007513C>(nFC%*L$%<%*+3&
&
)'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&_:,+&'(&=,,;%,&+'&#%&!"B%*&bC&:*&)'**%I+:'*&Q:+@&+@%&)'*,:>%E"+:'*&'(&+@%&!@:E>&
A%E:'>:I&G%C'E+&'(&=,E"%$&]D>P"*I%&s%E,:'*^J&b3M3&2'I3())AGO)O=NGO|O4&]M'P3&-/J&.55?^J("+(
@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,O@EIO>'I,OD>P"*I%s%E,:'*,O))AGT)T=NGT|43C>(3&
&
)'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&!@:E>&A%E:'>:I&G%C'E+&'(&=,E"%$&>;%&:*&.55/J&b3M3&2'I3&))AGO)O=NGO4&]M'P3&.-J&.557^J&
"+&@++CHOO>"II%,,T>>,T*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd57O066O?5OA2SOd57066?53C>(nFC%*L$%<%*+3&
&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&)"*">"J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.O)DMO)FO0J&LO)3-.O)DMO)FO6J&]K"R&..J&.551^J&"+&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@IE3'E9OE%(Q'E$>O>'I:>O064//("453@+<$3&
&
--4&
&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&=*>:"J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.O=M2O)FO6&]D;93&7J&.557^J&"+&
&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@IE3'E9OE%(Q'E$>O>'I:>O4(1I#041/3@+<$3&
&
&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&M%C"$J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.OMA_O)FO.&]\"*3&-1J&.557^J&"+&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@IE3'E9OE%(Q'E$>O>'I:>O0/?76I.5.3@+<$3&
&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&A@:$:CC:*%,J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.OAa_O)FO0&]2%I3&-J&.557^J&"+&
&
&
!>1'-0%030%1'-*
Bangladesh Shongbidhan [Constitution} M'P3&0J&-?/.&]8"*9$3^3&
C.A. Const.&"E+3&vJ&{&.3(
(
Constitucin Nacional(D;93&..J&-??0&]DE93^3&
Constitucin de la Provincia de Crdoba(DCE3&.1J&-?7/&])E>'#"J&DE93^3&
Constitucin Political de Colombia&\;$R&6J&-??-3&

Constitution Coordonn&S%#3&-/J&-??0&]8%$93^3(
Constitution de la Rpublique Dmocratique du Congo&S%#3&-7J&.5513&*
Constitution of India, \"*3&.1J&-?653&
&
Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, D;93&-0J&-?/43&
&
Constitution of the Kingdom of Cambodia&N%C3&.-J&-??43&
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, Act 108 of 1996&S%#3&0J&-??/3&
&
Grundgesetz fr die Bundesrepublik Deutschland [Constitution]&.4&K"R&-?0?&]d%E3^3*
Saligang Batas ng Pilipinas [Constitution]&S%#&--J&-?7/&]A@:$^3*
&
Undang-Undang Dasar Republik Indonesia 1945 (Constitution)&\;$R&6J&-?6?3&
&
&
!V#'#"($&>1&&#'0-*Z>X=>+\>>!+[*&
&
)'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&1H&!@%&G:9@+&+'&_:(%J&-1+@&N%,,3J&\;$R&-.T45J&-?7.J&b3M3&dDFGJ&
4/+@&N%,,3J&N;CC3&M'3&05J&DO4/O05&]\;$R&45J&-?7.^J&%"@%02:"8(02&)'<C:$"+:'*&'(&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,&"*>&d%*%E"$&
G%I'<<%*>"+:'*,&D>'C+%>&#R&a;<"*&G:9@+,&!E%"+R&8'>:%,J&b3M3&2'I3&aG=OdLMO-OG%P3-J&"+&1&]\;$R&./J&-??0^3&
&
)'<<3&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&-7H&M'*T2:,IE:<:*"+:'*J&4/+@&N%,,3J&FI+3&.4&Y&M'P3&-5J&-?7?J&b3M3&
dDFGJ&06+@&N%,,3J&N;CC3&M'3&05J&DO06O05J&"+&-/4&]M'P3&?J&-?7?^J&$?$0,$+,"&$:&@++CHOO>'I;<%*+,T>>,T
&
&
--0&
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&4H&!@%&M"+;E%&'(&N+"+%,&A"E+:%,U&F#$:9"+:'*,J&b3M3&2'I3&
aG=OdLMO-OG%P31&"+&-0&]2%I3&-0J&-??5^J&"+&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@I@E3I@O+#,O>'I3*,(O5O?0#>#"(6?#04"0.0I-.614%>556.#110nFC%*>'I;<%*+3&
&
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&?H&!@%&2'<%,+:I&DCC$:I"+:'*&'(&+@%&)'P%*"*+J&b3M3&
2'I3&LO)3-.O-??7O.0&]2%I3&4J&-??7^J&"+&@++CHOO>'I;<%*+,T>>,T
&
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&-.H&!@%&G:9@+&+'&D>%c;"+%&S''>J&b3M3&2'I3&
LO)3-.O-???O--&]K"R&-.J&-???^J&$?$0,$+,"&$:&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@I@E3I@O+#,O>'I3*,(O5O4>5./67I/5/54->675.61//(554#/4#?3&
&&
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-0H&!@%&G:9@+&+'&+@%&a:9@%,+&D++":*"#$%&
N+"*>"E>&'(&a%"+@J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.O.555O0&]D;93&--J&.555^J&"+&
@++CHOOQQQ3;*@I@E3I@O+#,O>'I3*,(O],R<#'$ÔL3)3-.3.555303L*3&
&
)'<<:++%%&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&-6H&!@%&G:9@+&+'&V"+%EJ&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.O.55.O--&
]\"*3J&.5J&.554^J&"+&@++CHOOQQQ3;*@I@E3I@O+#,O>'I3*,(O5O"6067>->-##>/-4(I-.61II05547?%?0nFC%*>'I;<%*+3&
&
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+&M'3&.5H&M'*T2:,IE:<:*"+:'*&:*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&
);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&b3M3&2'I3&LO)3-.Od)O.5&]\;*%&-5J&.55?^J&"+&
QQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,OI%,IEO>'I,O9IOL3)3-.3d)3.53>'I3&
&
)'<<3&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&=*+E'>;I+:'*H&!@%&A;EC',%&'(&d%*%E"$&)'<<%*+,J&4>&N%,,3J&S%#3&1T.0J&
-?7?J&b3M3&LN)FGJ&-?7?J&N;CC3&M'3&0J&LO-?7?O..TLO)3-.O-?7?O6J&"+&7/&]S%#3&.0J&-?7?^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(@++CHOO>'I;<%*+,T
>>,T*R3;*3'E9O>'IObM2F)OdLMOd7?O-/7O-?OC>(Od7?-/7-?3C>(nFC%*L$%<%*+3&
*
*
!.'0#"OV1M#"'&#'0($*K"8('%](0%1'*+#-1$30%1'-**
*
L3N3)3&G%,3&-??5O06J&b3M3&2'I3&LO-??5O/5OD>>3-&]K"R&4J&-??5^3&
&
a;<"*&G:9@+,&)'<<:,,:'*&G%,3&.556O-6J&D>P%E,%&L((%I+,&'(&+@%&=$$:I:+&K'P:*9&"*>&2;<C:*9&'(&!'`:I&"*>&2"*9%E';,&
4J&LO.556O.4J&"+&61&]DCE3&-0J&.556^3&
&
a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$J&a;<"*&G:9@+,&"*>&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O-6O_3-0&]N%C3&
.0J&.5-5^J&"+&@++CHOO>"II%,,T'>,3;*3'E9O!KAO?410453-/--4.5773@+<$3&
&
a;<"*&G:9@+,&)';*I:$&G%,3&/O..J&a;<"*&G:9@+,&"*>&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&/+@&N%,,3J&K"E3&4T.7J&
.557J&b3M3&dDFGJ&14>&N%,,3J&N;CC3&M'3&64J&DO14O64J&"+&-40&]K"E3&.7J&.557^3&
&
!@%&a;<"*&G:9@+&+'&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&d3D3&G%,3&10O.?.J&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO10O.?.&&]\;$R&.7J&.5-5^3&*
&
!@%&K:$$%**:;<&2%I$"E"+:'*J&d3D3&G%,3&66O.J&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO66O.&]N%C3&7J&.555^3*
&
!@%&G:9@+&+'&2%P%$'C<%*+J(d3D3&G%,3&60O-/6J&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO60O-/6&]2%I3&-/J&-???^3&&
&
b3&M3&G;$%,&('E&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&\;P%*:$%,&2%CE:P%>&'(&+@%:E&_:#%E+RJ&d3D3&G%,3&06O--4J&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO06O--4&]2%I3&-0J&
-??5^3&*
b3&M3&N;#T)'<<U*&'*&+@%&AE'<'+:'*&"*>&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&G%,3&.551O-5J&AE'<'+:'*&'(&+@%&G%"$:Z"+:'*&'(&+@%&
G:9@+&+'&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J&67+@&N%,,3J&D;93&/T.6J&.551J&b3M3&2'I3&DOaG)O.O.TDOaG)ON;#3-O67O41J&"+&4?&
]D;93&.0J&.551^3&*
*
b*:P%E,"$&2%I$"E"+:'*&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,J&d3D3&G%,3&.-/&]===^&DJ&b3M3&2'I3&DOGLNO.-/]===^&]2%I3&-5J&-?07^3&&
&
&
--6&
!.'0#"'(0%1'($&>1M#'('0-&('2&5"#(0%#-*
&
)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&L$:<:*"+:'*&'(&D$$&S'E<,&'(&2:,IE:<:*"+:'*&"9":*,+&V'<%*J&2%I3&-7J&-?/?J&-.0?&b3M3!3N3&-43&
&
)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&_"Q&'(&+@%&M'*TM"P:9"+:'*"$&b,%,&'(&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&V"+%EI';E,%,J&d3&D3&E%,3&6-O..?J&D**%`J&b3M3&dDFGJ&
6-,+&N%,,3J&??+@&<+93J&bM&2'I3&DOGLNO6-O..?&]*@"2"8(3*%(#012$:6%"(K"R&.-J&-??/^J&41&=3_3K3&/553&
&
)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&G:9@+,&'(&+@%&)@:$>J&M'P3&.5J&-?7?J&-6//&b3M3!3N3&43&
&
d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*&G%$"+:P%&+'&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&):P:$:"*&A%E,'*,&:*&!:<%&'(&V"EJ&D;93&-.J&-?0?J&1&b3N3!3&46-1J&/6&b3M3!3N3&
.7/3&
&
d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*&G%$"+:P%&+'&+@%&!E%"+<%*+&'(&AE:,'*%E,&'(&V"EJ&D;93&-.J&-?0?J&1&b3N3!3&44-1J&/6&b3M3!3N3&-463&
&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&"*>&AE'<'+:'*&'(&+@%&G:9@+,&"*>&2:9*:+R&'(&A%E,'*,&Q:+@&2:,"#:$:+:%,J&d3D3&G%,3&
1-O-51J&D**%`&=J&b3M3&dDFGJ&1-,+&N%,,3J&N;CC3&M'3&0?J&"+&16J&b3M3&2'I3&DO1-O0?&]2%I3&-4J&.551^J&01&=3_3K3&0043&
&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'P%*"*+&'*&):P:$&"*>&A'$:+:I"$&G:9@+,J&2%I3&-1J&-?11J&???&b3M3!3N3&-/-3&
&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'P%*"*+&'*&LI'*'<:IJ&N'I:"$&"*>&);$+;E"$&G:9@+,J&2%I3&-1J&-?11J&??4&b3M3!3N3&43&
&
FE9"*:Z"+:'*&'(&D(E:I"*&b*:+RJ&D(E:I"*&)@"E+%E&'*&+@%&G:9@+,&"*>&V%$("E%&'(&+@%&)@:$>J&\;$R&--J&-??5J&FDb&2'I3&
)D8O_LdO.03?O0?3&
&
AE'+'I'$&D>>:+:'*"$&+'&+@%&d%*%P"&)'*P%*+:'*,&'(&-.&D;9;,+&-?0?J&"*>&G%$"+:*9&+'&+@%&AE'+%I+:'*&'(&s:I+:<,&'(&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&DE<%>&)'*($:I+,&]AE'+'I'$&=^J&\;*%&7J&-?//J&--.6&b3M3!3N3&43&
&
N+"+;+%&'(&+@%&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)';E+&'(&\;,+:I%J&6?&N+"+3&-54-3&
&
b3M3&)@"E+%E3&&
&
s:%**"&)'*P%*+:'*&'*&+@%&_"Q&'(&!E%"+:%,J&K"R&.4J&-?1?J&--66&b3M3!3N3&44-3&
&
&
!.'0#"'(0%1'($&E#4$("(0%1'-*&
&
vs&N;<<:+&'(&a%">,&'(&N+"+%&"*>&d'P%E*<%*+&'(&+@%&M'*TD$:9*%>&K'P%<%*+J&N@"E<&%$&N@%:BJ&L9RC+J&\;$R&--T-1J&.55?J&
U02$,(>*&6-"2:J&MDK.55?OS2O2'I3-J($?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOOQQQ3*"<%9RC+3'E9O%*OG%$%P"*+2'I;<%*+,OA"9%,O>%(";$+3",C`&]P:"&W(:*"$&>'I;<%*+X&@RC%E$:*B^3(
&
8'**&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&SE%,@Q"+%EJ&8'**J&d%E3J&2%I3&4T/J&.55-J(!"&*--"28$:0*2#(3*%(;&:0*23&
&
S:E,+&D(E:I"TN';+@&D<%E:I"&N;<<:+J&D#;["J&M:9%E:"J&M'P3&.1T45J&.551J&;+6a$(>"&,$%$:0*2J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
&
S:E,+&D,:"TA"I:(:I&V"+%E&N;<<:+J&8%CC;J&\"C"*J2%I3&4T0J&.55/J&9"##$1"(3%*-(B"@@6J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
&
S:E,+&b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&)'*9E%,,&'*&+@%&AE%P%*+:'*&'(&)E:<%&"*>&+@%&!E%"+<%*+&'(&F((%*>%E,J&D;93&..&Y&N%C3&4J&-?66J&
/:$28$%8(9020-6-(!6,"#(3*%(:'"(=%"$:-"2:(*3()%0#*2"%#J&b3M3&2'I3&DO)FMSO1--J&D**%`&=J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ-3;<*3%>;O@;<"*E+,O:*,+E%%O9-,<E3@+<3&
&
=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&V"+%E&"*>&+@%&L*P:E'*<%*+J&2;#$:*J&=E3J&\"*3&.1T4-J&-??.J&='"(>6+,02(/:$:"-"2:(*2(D$:"%($28(
/6#:$02$+,"(>"?",*@-"2:<M&
&
!@:E>&N';+@&D,:"*&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&N"*:+"+:'*J&M%Q&2%$@:J&=*>:"J&M'P3&-1T.-J&.557J&='"(>",'0(>"&,$%$:0*2J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOO>>Q,3*:I3:*O:*(',"I',"*OCC+O2%$@:m.52%I$"E"+:'*m.5/3C>(3&
&
&
--1&
b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&a;<"*&N%++$%<%*+J&s"*I';P%EJ&)"*3&K"R&4-&Y&\;*%&--J&-?/1J&`$2&*6?"%(>"&,$%$:0*2(*2(
S6-$2(/"::,"-"2:#J&bM3&2'I3&DO)FMS3/5O-6J&$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3;*T>'I;<%*+,3*%+OP"*T>%I3@+<3&
&
b*:+%>&M"+:'*,&=*+%E*"+:'*"$&)'*(%E%*I%&'*&A'C;$"+:'*&"*>&2%P%$'C<%*+J&)":E'J&L9RC+J&N%C3&6T-4J&-??0J&)%*1%$--"(*3(
;&:0*2(*3(:'"(42:"%2$:0*2$,(A*23"%"2&"(*2()*@6,$:0*2($28(>"?",*@-"2:J&b3M3&2'I3&DO)FMS3-/-O-4&]N%C3&-7J&-??0^3&$?$0,$+,"(
$:&@++CHOOQQQ3::,>3I"O)":E'OCE'9E"<OC555553@+<$3&
&
&
!J13"'($*L"0%4$#-*&
&
D<"*>"&)"@:$$J&='"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%(f(;(!01':(*3(\2056"(/:$:6#R(='"(C"1$,(/:$:6#($28(E*%-$:0?"(A*2:"2:(*3(:'"(!01':(
:*(D$:"%.(?]4^(Intl J. Hum. Rts.&47?&].556^3&&
&
D*+@'*R&NI'++&j&d%'E9:*"&)';,+"$:*J&='"(G?*,6:0*2(*3(D$:"%(!01':#.(46]0^ Nat. Res. J.&7.-&]-??6^3&

&
D*+'*:'&L3&=E;['J&='"(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev&.1/&].55/^3*&
&
DE[;*&i3&i@">B"J&='"(G-"%1"2&"(*3(D$:"%($#($(VS6-$2(!01':L(*2(:'"(D*%,8(/:$1"R(A'$,,"21"#($28(W@@*%:620:0"#.&.1]-^&Intl
J. Water Res. Dev.&4/&].5-5^3&&
&
D,:+&i3&8:,Q",J&D$:"%($#($(S6-$2(!01':(02(:'"(9GE;(!"10*2R(A'$,,"21"#($28(W@@*%:620:0"#.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev&

.5?&].55/^3&
&
D;>E%R&G3&)@"C<"*J&;(I`0*,$:0*2#(;@@%*$&'M(3*%(9*20:*%021(:'"(42:"%2$:0*2$,(A*?"2$2:(*2(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(
!01':#.(-7&Hum. Rts. Q.&.4&]-??1^3&
&
83)3D3&!'%#%,J&=*H$%8#($2(4-@%*?"8(\28"%#:$28021(*3(:'"(42:"%2$:0*2$,(S6-$2(!01':(:*(S"$,:'J&.-&Human Rights
Quarterly(11-&]-???^3&
&
)E":9&NI'++&j&A@:$:CC&D$,+'*J&;8a680&$:021(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,()%0*%0:0"#(02($(=%$2#2$:0*2$,(A*2:"T:.($(A*--"2:(*2&
/**+%$-*2"7L#(C"1$&7($28(F%**:+,**-L#&)%*-0#".(-1&N3&Afr. J. Hum. Rts.&.51&].555^3&
&
2"P:>&8:$I@:+ZJ&F0?021(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#(="":'R(='"(9020-6-(A*%"($28(4:#(4-@*%:$2&".&--?&S. Afr. L.J.&070&].55.^3&
&
2"P:>&83&8E''B,J(S6-$2(!01':#(:*(D$:"%(02(E*%:'(;3%0&$($28(:'"(9088,"(G$#:R(D'$:(0#(E"H($28(D'$:(0#(E*:Z(D'$:(0#(
4-@*%:$2:($28(D'$:(0#(E*:.(.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev&../&].55/^3&
&
LE:B&83&8$;%<%$J&='"(4-@,0&$:0*2#(*3(U*%-6,$:021($(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&4-&Ecology L.Q.&?6/&].550^3(
&
="*&NI'##:%()%02&0@,"(*%()%$1-$:0&#_(='"(!",$:0*2#'0@(+":H""2(S6-$2(!01':#(C$H($28(:'"(C$H(*3(;%-"8(A*23,0&:.(-0]4^&J.
&
=*9$"&V:*B$%EJ&[680&0$,(G23*%&"-"2:(*3(:'"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%R(A$#"(C$H(3%*-(/*6:'(;3%0&$.(;%1"2:02$($28(4280$&_"QJ&
.557]-^&L. Soc. Just. & Global Dev. J. ]FI+3&?J&.557^J&
@++CHOOQQQ.3Q"EQ:IB3"I3;BO("IO,'IO$"QO%$[O$9>O.557h-OQ:*B$%EO3&
&
\"<%,&_3&)"P"$$"E'&j&L<:$R&\3&NI@"((%EJ&C"##($#(9*%"R(!":'02O021(/6@%$2$:0*2$,(C0:01$:0*2(*3(G&*2*-0&($28(/*&0$,(!01':#(02(
:'"(;-"%0&$#.&61&Hastings L.J.&.-/&].556^3&&
&
\"*:I%&dE"R.(4-@,"-"2:021(:'"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%(02(;6#:%$,0$.(-/]-^(Hum. Rts. Defender&-&].557^<&
&
\",'*&8E'Z%B&!"?0"H(*3(;-2"#:7(42:"%2$:0*2$,L#(V=%*6+,"8(D$:"%#R()$,"#:020$2#(>"20"8(;&&"##(:*(D$:"%L(4]-^&Water
&
\'*"&G"ZZ"c;%J&;&&"##(:*(G2?0%*2-"2:$,([6#:0&"R(!*,"(*3(:'"([680&0$%7(02(B$21,$8"#'&0]-^&Bangl. J. L.&-&].555^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3#:$:"#>3'E9O#$[OI'*+%*+-3@+<3&
&
&
--/&
i"E%*&_%@<"**J&42(>"3"2#"(*3(:'"(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*6%:R(C0:01$:021(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#($28(:'"(97:'(*3(:'"(9020-6-(A*%".&
..]-^&Am. U. Intl L. Rev. -14&].551^3&&
&
i"+@"E:*%&d3&~';*9J&='"(9020-6-(A*%"(*3(G&*2*-0&($28(/*&0$,(!01':#.(;(A*2&"@:(02(/"$%&'(*3(A*2:"2:.&44&Yale J. Intl L.&
--4&].557^3&&
&
K"$I'$<&_"*9('E>J&;-+0:0*2(:'$:(*?"%,"$@#(0:#",3_(;(!"#@*2#"(:*(/:"@'"2(=6,,7L#(VA%0:056"L(*3(:'"(F"2"%$,(A*--"2:(*2(:'"(
!01':(:*(D$:"%.&.1]4^&Neth. Q. Hum. Rts.&044&].551^3&
&
K"$I'$<&_"*9('E>J&A%*##30%"R(='"%"(0#(2*(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%(3*%(C0?",0'**8#R(;(>"+$:"(H0:'(9",?02(D**8'*6#".&.7]-^&
Waterlines&6&].55?^3&
&
K"E:;,&A:%+%E,%J&G$:021(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#R(='"(\#"36,2"##(*3(!01':#(=$,O(02(;,,"?0$:021(/*&0$,(S$%8#'0@(!"?0#0:"8.&.?&
Hum. Rts. Q. /?1&].55/^&
&
K"EB&N3&i%*>%J&='"(/*6:'(;3%0&$2(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*2#:%6&:0*2(*3(/*&0*(G&*2*-0&(!01':#.(;(!"#@*2#"(:*(A%0:0&#.&-?&Conn. J.
Intl L. 1-/&].554^3&
&
K:I@"%$&\3&2%**:,&j&2"P:>&A3&N+%Q"E+J&[6#:0&0$+0,0:7(*3(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#R(/'*6,8(='"%"(B"($2(42:"%2$:0*2$,(
A*-@,$02:#(9"&'$20#-(:*(;8a680&$:"(:'"(!01':#(:*(U**8.(D$:"%.(S*6#021.(S"$,:'_&?7]4^&Am. J. Intl L. 01.&].550^3&
&
K'@"<">&K'P"&D$UD(9@"*:J&A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*6%:L#(!"?0"H($28(:'"(U6:6%"(*3(D$:"%(C$H(02(428*2"#0$.&.]-^&L. Env. & Dev. J.&

-&].551^3*
&
M3&d"#E;J&/*-"(A*--"2:#(*2(D$:"%(!01':#(02(/*6:'(;3%0&$.&7]-^&Potchefstroom Elec. L.J.&6&].556^J&

@++CHOO"['$3:*('O:*>%`3C@COC%$[O"E+:I$%OP:%QS:$%O04061O.1??-3&
&
M:I@'$",&a"R,'<J&A*2#:0:6:0*2$,0#-.(9$a*%0:$%0$2(>"-*&%$&7($28(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#.&7]0^&N. Afr. J. Hum. Rts.&06-&
]-??.^3&
&
F>%@&"$&\"RR';,:J&D$:"%($#($(S6-$2(!01':R(=*H$%8#(A0?0,(/*&0":7(F,*+$,0Q$:0*2.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev. 4.?&

].55/^3&
&
A@:$:C&D$,+'*J&W6:(*3(:'"(;+7##R(:'"(A'$,,"21"#(A*23%*2:021(:'"(E"H(\<E<(A*--0::""(*2(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#.(
?]4^&Hum. Rts. Q.(444(]-?7/^3*
&
A";$&\3&M%$,'*J&S6-$2(!01':#.(:'"(90,,"2206-(>"?",*@-"2:(F*$,#.($28(:'"(U6:6%"(*3(>"?",*@-"2:(A**@"%$:0*2.&46]-.^&
World Dev. .50-&].55/^3&*
&
A%+%E&8'*>&j&\"IB:%&2;9"E>J&D$:"%.(S6-$2(!01':#($28(/*&0$,(A*23,0&:R(/*6:'(;3%0&$2(GT@"%0"2&"#.&.557]-^&L. Soc. Just. &
Global Dev. J. ]S%#3&--J&.557^J&@++CHOOQQQ.3Q"EQ:IB3"I3;BO("IO,'IO$"QO%$[O$9>O.557h-O#'*>h>;9"E>3(
&
A%+%E&a3&d$%:IBJ&B$#0&(D$:"%(!"560%"-"2:#(3*%(S6-$2(;&:0?0:0"#.&.-].^&Water Intl&74&]-??1^3*
&
A%+%E&a3&d$%:IB&='"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&-]6^&Water Policy 07/&]-???^3&
&&
G',%&SE"*I:,J&D$:"%([6#:0&"(02(/*6:'(;3%0&$R(E$:6%$,(!"#*6%&"#()*,0&7($:(:'"(42:"%#"&:0*2(*3(S6-$2(!01':#.(G&*2*-0&#.($28(
)*,0:0&$,()*H"%.&-7]-^&Geo. Intl. Envtl. L. Rev.(-05&].556^3&
&
N"*>E"&_:%#%*#%E9J&/*6:'(;3%0&$L#(G?*,?021([6%0#@%68"2&"(*2(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#R($2(G33"&:0?"(=**,(02(A'$,,"21021(
)*?"%:7_&1&L. Democracy & Dev. J. -6?&].55.^3&
&
N%#",+:"*&d"$:"*:J&A";$&d%E+:%E&j&LE*%,+'&N@"E9E'>,BR3&D$:"%(3*%(C03"R(='"(4-@$&:(*3(:'"()%0?$:0Q$:0*2(*3(D$:"%(/"%?0&"#(*2(
A'0,8(9*%:$,0:7.&--4]-^&J. Pol. Econ. ].556^3&&
&
&
--7&
N+%C@%*&)3&KI)"((E%RJ&;(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%R(>*-"#:0&($28(42:"%2$:0*2$,(4-@,0&$:0*2#.&6]-^&Geo. Intl Envtl. L. Rev.(-&

]-??.^3&&
&
!"E"&\3&K%$:,@J&!":'02O021(:'"(IC"##($#(9*%"M(='"#0#R(/6@%$2$:0*2$,(C0:01$:0*2(*3(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#(02(:'"(
;-"%0&$#.&4?].^&N.Y.U. J. Intl L. & Pol3&-/-&].551^3&*
&
='"(9$$#:%0&':(F608",02"#(*2(`0*,$:0*2#(*3(G&*2*-0&.(/*&0$,($28(A6,:6%$,(!01':#J&.5]4^&Hum. Rts. Q.&1?-&]-??7^3&
&
!@'E,+%*&i:%(%E&j&)"+@%E:*%&8Ek$<"**J&B"7*28(/:$:"(/*?"%"012:7R(='"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&6]4^&Non-State Actors &
Intl L.&-74&].556^3&*
&
&
!:#8%-$(0%1'*('2*!1$%4)&
&
2pIE%+&>%&$"&)'<<;*";+p&S$"<"*>%&I'*I%E*"*+&>:P%E,%,&<%,;E%,&>U"II'<C"9*%<%*+&>;&#;>9%+&-??/&e2%IE%%&'(&+@%&
S$%<:,@&)'<<;*:+R&G%$"+:*9&+'&s"E:';,&K%",;E%,&DII'<C"*R:*9&+@%&8;>9%+&'(&-??/f&'(&2%I3&.5J&-??1J&Monitieur Belge&
eK383f&eF((:I:"$&d"Z%++%&'(&8%$9:;<f&2%I3&4-J&-??13&
&
Gov. of the Peoples Republic of Bangl., Ministry of Water Resources, National Water Policy&]\"*&45J&-???^J&
$?$0,$+,"($:&@++CHOOQQQ3<'QE39'P3#>O2'I;<%*+,OM"+:'*"$m.5V"+%Em.5A'$:IRm.5]L*9$:,@^3C>(3&
&
_3&.6?-J&*'P:%<#E%&-?J&-??-J&05&Diario Oficial&e23F3f&-16&])'$'<3^3&
&
_"Q&)'*I%E*:*9&=EE:9"+:'*J&M'3&--&'(&-?/0J&The Official Gazette of Indonesia,&-?/0J&M'3&163&
&
_"Q&M'3&.41?1J&D;93&-7J&-?7?J&ev_=vT)f&D323_3D3&.000&]DE93^3&
&
_"Q&M'3&667?(",&<'>:(:%>&#R(_"Q&M'3&7?.7J&)#"3J&K"R&.7J&-?/4J&83F3&.-O56O-?/4&]DE93^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3+'>'>%:;E%3I'<3"EO$%R%,OI'E>'#"O667?3@+<3(
&
_"Q&'*&V"+%E&G%,';EI%,J&M'3&/&'(&.550J&The Official Gazette of Indonesia,&.550J&M'3&113&
&
A"B:,+"*&L*P:E'*<%*+"$&AE'+%I+:'*&DI+J&M'3&40&'(&-??/J&The Gazette of Pakistan ExtraordinaryJ&2%I3&1J&-??/&]A"B3^3&

&
V"+%E&)'>%&'(&+@%&A@:$:CC:*%,J&AE%,:>%*+:"$&2%IE%%&M'3&-51/&]-?/1^&/4&F3d3&4660&]K"R&--J&-?//^&]A@:$3^3&
&
D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:(;&:&PXXX&])+@^&]D;,+$3^3&
&
V"+%E&N%EP:I%,&DI+J&-57&'(&-??/&]N3&D(E3^3&
&
&
!*A#2%(*('2*X$#40"1'%4&+#-13"4#-*&
&
;(E$:0*2$,(>0#1%$&".(A$2$8$L#(/'$-"36,()*#0:0*2(*2(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&The Council of Canadians&]K"E3&.6J&.557^.(

&
D*>E%Q&a'$$"*>J&A'0,"L#(A*2#:0:6:0*2R(D$:"%(:*(+"($(9$::"%(*3(E$:0*2$,(/"&6%0:7J&Blog: The Transatlantic Dialogue on
Climate Change and Security ]\"*3&.1J&.5-5J&6H6/&AK^.(@++CHOOI$:<"+%,%I;E:+R3#$'9,C'+3I'<O.5-5O5-OI@:$%,T
I'*,+:+;+:'*TQ"+%ET+'T#%T<"++%E3@+<$3&
&
;2*:'"%(B$8(48"$(D'0&'(D"(E""8(:*(;&:(W2.(Global Water Intelligence&]K"E3&-7J&.5-5^J(
&
8%+"&!%E["["@(!;"*T!;"*J&F"2:,"-"2.(D"($%"(A*,*20#"8o&Gatra Magazine&].55.^3*
(
B*,0?0$()6#'"#(3*%($(\20?"%#$,(D$:"%(!01':J&New Tang Dynasty Television Online&]K"E3&.4J&.5-5^J&
@++CHOO%*9$:,@3*+>+P3I'<O*+>+Ph%*O*,h,"O.5-5T54T.4O451.16.6-.-03@+<$3&*
&
&
--?&
Q"+%EOu<'E%T-4/0/3&
&
A$#"(C$HR()"*@,"L#(\20*2(3*%(A0?0,(C0+"%:0"#(?<(\20*2(*3(4280$($28(W:'"%#.(ESCR-Net.org, @++CHOOQQQ3%,IET
*%+3'E9OI",%$"QOI",%$"Qh,@'Q3@+<n>'Ih:>o05-544&]$",+&P:,:+%>&M'P3&7J&.5-5^3
&
&
A*--0::""(*2(G&*2*-0&($28(/*&0$,(!01':#(F"2"%$,(A*--"2:#. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights,
@++CHOOQQQ.3'@I@E3'E9O%*9$:,@O#'>:%,OI%,IEOI'<<%*+,3@+<&]$",+&P:,:+%>&M'P3&7J&.5-5^3&
&
>$:$(902021(F$:"H$7.(WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply and Sanitation(
@++CHOOQQQ3Q,,:*('3'E9O>"+"<:*:*9O+"#$%,3@+<$&]$",+&P:,:+%>&FI+3&-7J&.5-5^3&&
&
2"P:>&z%+$"*>J&W2(97(9028R(D$:"%(!01':#($28(S6-$2(!01':#J&Forbes Magazine Online&]DCE3&-.J&.5-5^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3('E#%,3I'<O('E#%,O.5-5O50-.O'C:*:'*,T,"*:+"+:'*T@":+:T@;<"*TE:9@+,T'*T<RT<:*>3@+<$3&
&
SE"*B$:*&23&G'',%P%$+J&;226$,(/:$:"(*3(:'"(\20*2(;88%"##(:*(A*21%"##&]\"*&1J&-?0-^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
@++CHOO"<%E:I"*E@%+'E:I3I'<O,C%%I@%,O(>E+@%(';E(E%%>'<,3@+<3&
&

&
dE%9&A"$",+J&='"(U*6%(/:"@#(D'0&'(>"#:%*7"8(;%1"2:02$J&Prosperity UK,&S%#3&.554J&$?$0,$+,"($:&
QQQ3CE',C%E:+R;B3I'<OCE',C%E:+RO"E+:I$%,O"E9%*3@+<$3&
&
=*>%C3&L`C%E+&'*&+@%&=,,;%&'(&a;<"*&G:9@+,&F#$:9"+:'*,&G%$"+%>&+'&DII%,,&+'&N"(%&2E:*B:*9&V"+%E&"*>&N"*:+"+:'*J(
c6"#:0*22$0%"R(VF**8()%$&:0&"#L(%",$:"8(:*(;&&"##(:*(/$3"(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2(]S%#3&.5-5^J&
@RC%E$:*B^3*
&
42:",(D$:"%()*,0&7J&Intel Corporation&]K"E3&.5-5^J&@++CHOOQQQ3:*+%$3I'<OD,,%+,OA2SOA'$:IRO=*+%$hV"+%EhA'$:IR3C>(3&
&
[$26$%7(PXNX(A*62:%7(/6--$%7R()$O0#:$2J&Human Rights Watch&]\"*3&.5-5^J&@++CHOOQQQ3@EQ3'E9O%*OQ'E$>TE%C'E+T

.5-5OC"B:,+"*3&
&
\",'*&8E:IB%EJ&)%0?$:0Q$:0*2(*3(D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:(02(;%1"2:02$.&American University Trade Environment Database

].55-^.(@++CHOOQQQ-3"<%E:I"*3%>;O+%>OQ"+%ET"E9%*+:*"3@+<3&
&
[6#:0&0$+0,0:7(*3(G/A(!01':#R(='"(4280$2(GT@"%0"2&"J&02&Circle of Rights: Economic, Social and Cultural Rights

Activism, a Training Resource&]N;*:$"&D#%R%,%B%E"&%+&"$3J&.555^J&
@++CHOOQQQ-3;<*3%>;O@;<"*E+,O%>;<"+O=aG=AOI:EI$%O[;,+:I:"#:$:+R3@+<3*
&
i%:+@&NI@*%:>%EJ&M">R"&=P"*'P"&j&D"E'*&\"((%J&D$:"%(=*@#(A,0-$:"(A'$21"($#(F,*+$,()%0*%0:7J&Circle of Blue&]D;93&-7J&
.55?^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I:EI$%'(#$;%3'E9OQ"+%E*%Q,O.55?OQ'E$>OQ"+%EP:%Q,TQ"+%ET+'C,TI$:<"+%TI@"*9%T",T9$'#"$T
CE:'E:+RO3&
&
K";>%&8"E$'QJ&;(\E(A*2?"2:0*2(*2(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%R(;2(48"$(D'*#"(=0-"(S$#(A*-".&Blue Planet&].551^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3#$;%C$"*%+CE'[%I+3*%+O>'I;<%*+,ObMhI'*P%*+:'*hK8h2%I513C>(3&
(
);AG()%"#08"2:(A$,,#(3*%(;&&"##(:*(D$:"%(:*(+"(!"&*120Q"8($#($(B$#0&(S6-$2(!01':&&Council of Europe&]K"E3&.5J&.55?^J&
@++C,HOOQI>3I'%3:*+Os:%Q2'I3[,Cn:>oh0..444jN:+%o2)3(
(
)"%6R(A*21%"##(;@@%*?"#(D$:"%(C$H.&International Water and Sanitation Centre&]DCE3&4J&.55?^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3:EI3*$OC"9%O0/16.3&
&
-.5&
&
A%+%E&2"*I@:*J&;(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%_(='"(/*6:'(;3%0&$2(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*6%:L#(>"&0#0*2(02(:'"(9$Q0+6O*(A$#".&EJIL
Talk! Blog&]\"*3&-4J&.5-5^J&@++CHOOQQQ3%[:$+"$B3'E9O"T@;<"*TE:9@+T+'TQ"+%ET+@%T,';+@T"(E:I"*TI'*,+:+;+:'*"$TI';E+U,T
>%I:,:'*T:*T+@%T<"Z:#;B'TI",%O3&
&
)'0,0@@02"#R(902*%#(W@*#$(?<(/"&%":$%7(*3(:'"(>"@$%:-"2:(*3(G2?0%*2-"2:$,($28(E$:6%$,(!"#*6%&"#(Nmmd.&Child Rights
Information NetworkJ(@++CHOOQQQ3IE:*3'E9O_"QO:*,+E;<%*+3",Cn=*,+=2o-.15&]$",+&P:,:+%>&FI+3&-?J&.5-5^3&
&
AE%,,&G%$%",%J&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$RJ&d%*%E"$&D,,%<#$R&D>'C+,&G%,'$;+:'*&G%I'9*:Z:*9&DII%,,&+'&)$%"*&V"+%EJ&N"*:+"+:'*&",&"&
.5-5^3&
&
N%#",+:%*&a"I@%EJ&D*%,8H08"(D$:"%(9*?"-"2:(D02#(`0&:*%0"#Z(;%1"2:02$(D$:"%()%0?$:0Q$:0*2(/&'"-"(!62#(>%7.&Michigan
Quarterly Review&]K"E3&-4J&.550^3&
&
\E(GT@"%:(D",&*-"#(!"&*120:0*2($#($(S6-$2(!01':(*3(;&&"##(:*(/$3"($28(A,"$2(>%02O021(D$:"%($28(/$20:$:0*2.&Office of
the High Commissioner for Human Rights ]\;$R&45J&.5-5^J&
@++CHOOQQQ3'@I@E3'E9OLMOM%Q,LP%*+,OA"9%,O2:,C$"RM%Q,3",C`nM%Q,=2o-5.05j_"*9=2oL3&
&

@++CHOO:C,*%Q,3*%+O:*+%E*"3",Cn:>*%Q,o-?1?43&
&
D$:"%(`0"H#R(4280$.&Circle of Blue&]D;93&-7J&.55?^J&@++CHOOQQQ3I:EI$%'(#$;%3'E9OQ"+%E*%Q,O.55?OQ'E$>OQ"+%EP:%Q,T
:*>:"O3&&
&
D*%,8()*@6,$:0*2()%*#@"&:#R(='"(PXXj(!"?0#0*2.&United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs,
Population DivisionJ&@++CHOO%,"3;*3'E9O;*CC&]$",+&P:,:+%>&FI+3&-7J&.5-5^3&&
&
&
!?'I3H$%-6#2*('2*K06#"*=13"4#-*&
&
D$:I:"&L$R&~"<:*&j&F,I"E&A"EE"&s%E"J&='"(!*,"(*3(A*6%:#(02(>"302021(S"$,:'()*,0&7R(='"(A$#"(*3(:'"(A*,*-+0$2(A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(
A*6%:&]a"EP"E>&_"Q&NI@''$&a;<"*&G:9@+,&AE'9E"<&V'EB:*9&A"C%EJ&.557^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(
@++CHOOQQQ3$"Q3@"EP"E>3%>;OCE'9E"<,O@ECO>'I;<%*+,O~"<:*hA"EE"hQ'EB:*9hC"C%E3C>(3&
&
Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions, Legal Resources for the Right to Water and Sanitation:
International and National Standards&].*>&%>3J&('E+@I'<:*9^&]>E"(+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
\3&8"E+E"<J&G%CE%,%*+"+:P%&'(&+@%&V'E$>&a%"$+@&FE9"*:Z"+:'*J&FE"$&,;#<:,,:'*&+'&d%*%E"$&2:,I;,,:'*&'*&+@%&2E"(+&d%*%E"$&
)'<<%*+&'*&+@%&G:9@+&+'&V"+%E&]M'P3&..J&.55.^3&
&
\'%R&)@'Q>@;ERJ&[680&0$,(;8'"%"2&"(:*($(9020-6-(A*%"(;@@%*$&'(:*(/*&0*^G&*2*-0&(!01':#(f(;(A*-@$%$:0?"()"%#@"&:0?".&
]K"E3&.4J&.557^&];*C;#$:,@%>&Q'EB:*9&C"C%EJ&)'E*%$$&_"Q&NI@''$^]'*&(:$%&Q:+@&";+@'E^];,%>&Q:+@&C%E<:,,:'*^3(
&
\;$:"&a";,%E<"*J&G:9@+,&j&a;<"*:+RJ&D&a;<"*&G:9@+,&DCCE'"I@&+'&2%P%$'C<%*+H&N'<%&AE"I+:I"$&=<C$:I"+:'*,&('E&
V"+%ED:>U,&V'EB&]N%C3&-5J&-???^&]+E"*,IE:C+&'*&(:$%&Q:+@&+@%&";+@'E^3&
&
AE'(3&2E3&\:<$R&D,,@:>>:c:%J&N3a3J&)@":E<"*&'(&+@%&)'*,+:+;+:'*"$&)';E+J&K"@B"<"@&i'*,+:+;,:&>"$"<&N:,+%<&i%+"+"*%9"E""*&
G%C;#$:B&=*>'*%,:"&]2%I3&--J&.556^3&
&
(
&
-.-&

SSRN Id1721029 PDF

Загружено:

Сведения о документе

Оригинальное название

Авторское право

Доступные форматы

Поделиться этим документом

Поделиться или встроить документ

Параметры публикации

Этот документ был вам полезен?

Это неприемлемый материал?

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

SSRN Id1721029 PDF

Загружено:

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

!

M.A. International Law and Settlement of Disputes

Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1721029

Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1721029

&&&&-&\;,+:*:"*J&=*,+3&.3-3-J&56*:"8(02&J. Getzler, A History of Water Rights at Common Law&1/&].550^3&

&&&&..7&/""&1"2"%$,,7&_';:,&a%*B:*J&42:"%2$:0*2$,(S6-$2(!01':#($#(I!01':#M.(02&Nomos XXIII: Human Rights&.6/&]\3&G'Q$"*>&

Amnesty International, Troubled Waters: Palestinians Denied Access to Water&].55?^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&

Constitution of the Kingdom of Cambodia&N%C3&.-J&-??43&

_';:,&a%*B:*J&42:"%2$:0*2$,(S6-$2(!01':#($#(I!01':#M.(02&Nomos XXIII: Human Rights&.6/&]\3&G'Q$"*>&A%**'IB&j&\'@*&V3&

M3&d"#E;J&/*-"(A*--"2:#(*2(D$:"%(!01':#(02(/*6:'(;3%0&$.&7]-^&Potchefstroom Elec. L.J.&6&].556^J&

F>%@&"$&\"RR';,:J&D$:"%($#($(S6-$2(!01':R(=*H$%8#(A0?0,(/*&0":7(F,*+$,0Q$:0*2.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev. 4.?&

A";$&\3&M%$,'*J&C*&$,(A,$0-#.(42:"%2$:0*2$,(/:$28$%8#($28(:'"(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&02&The International Struggle for

World Health Organization et al., The Right to Water&].554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:(

John Austin, Province of Jurisprudence Determined&])"<#E:>9%&-??6^]-74.^3&

!01':(:*(D$:"%R(A$#"(C$H(3%*-(/*6:'(;3%0&$.(;%1"2:02$($28(4280$&_"QJ&.557]-^&L. Soc. Just. & Global Dev. J. -5 ]FI+3&?J&

Constitucin de la Provincia de Crdoba(DCE3&.1J&-?7/&])E>'#"J&DE93^3&

Constitucin Political de Colombia&\;$R&6J&-??-3&

D*+@'*R&NI'++&j&d%'E9:*"&)';,+"$:*J&='"(G?*,6:0*2(*3(D$:"%(!01':#.(46]0^ Nat. Res. J.&7.-&]-??6^3&

D,:+&i3&8:,Q",J&D$:"%($#($(S6-$2(!01':(02(:'"(9GE;(!"10*2R(A'$,,"21"#($28(W@@*%:620:0"#.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev&

K'@"<">&K'P"&D$UD(9@"*:J&A*2#:0:6:0*2$,(A*6%:L#(!"?0"H($28(:'"(U6:6%"(*3(D$:"%(C$H(02(428*2"#0$.&.]-^&L. Env. & Dev. J.&

M3&d"#E;J&/*-"(A*--"2:#(*2(D$:"%(!01':#(02(/*6:'(;3%0&$.&7]-^&Potchefstroom Elec. L.J.&6&].556^J&

F>%@&"$&\"RR';,:J&D$:"%($#($(S6-$2(!01':R(=*H$%8#(A0?0,(/*&0":7(F,*+$,0Q$:0*2.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev. 4.?&

N+%C@%*&)3&KI)"((E%RJ&;(S6-$2(!01':(:*(D$:"%R(>*-"#:0&($28(42:"%2$:0*2$,(4-@,0&$:0*2#.&6]-^&Geo. Intl Envtl. L. Rev.(-&

_"Q&)'*I%E*:*9&=EE:9"+:'*J&M'3&--&'(&-?/0J&The Official Gazette of Indonesia,&-?/0J&M'3&163&

_"Q&'*&V"+%E&G%,';EI%,J&M'3&/&'(&.550J&The Official Gazette of Indonesia,&.550J&M'3&113&

A"B:,+"*&L*P:E'*<%*+"$&AE'+%I+:'*&DI+J&M'3&40&'(&-??/J&The Gazette of Pakistan ExtraordinaryJ&2%I3&1J&-??/&]A"B3^3&

;(E$:0*2$,(>0#1%$&".(A$2$8$L#(/'$-"36,()*#0:0*2(*2(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&The Council of Canadians&]K"E3&.6J&.557^.(

F"%-$27(3*%(A,"$2(>%02O021(D$:"%($#($(B$#0&(S6-$2(!01':.&German Information Centre New Delhi&]K"E3&.4J&.5-5^J&

[$26$%7(PXNX(A*62:%7(/6--$%7R()$O0#:$2J&Human Rights Watch&]\"*3&.5-5^J&@++CHOOQQQ3@EQ3'E9O%*OQ'E$>TE%C'E+T

\",'*&8E:IB%EJ&)%0?$:0Q$:0*2(*3(D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:(02(;%1"2:02$.&American University Trade Environment Database

[6#:0&0$+0,0:7(*3(G/A(!01':#R(='"(4280$2(GT@"%0"2&"J&02&Circle of Rights: Economic, Social and Cultural Rights

s:P:"*"&D$'*,'J(D$:"%($28(/"H$1"()%0?$:0#$:0*2(F*2"(/*6%.(Inter Press Service&]D;93&-6J&.554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&

Вам также может понравиться

&&&&-&\;,+::"J&=,+3&.3-3-J&56:"8(02&J. Getzler, A History of Water Rights at Common Law&1/&].550^3&

&&&&..7&/""&1"2"%$,,7&_';:,&a%B:J&42:"%2$:02$,(S6-$2(!01':#($#(I!01':#M.(02&Nomos XXIII: Human Rights&.6/&]\3&G'Q$">&

_';:,&a%B:J&42:"%2$:02$,(S6-$2(!01':#($#(I!01':#M.(02&Nomos XXIII: Human Rights&.6/&]\3&G'Q$">&A%**'IB&j&\'@*&V3&

M3&d"#E;J&/-"(A--"2:#(2(D$:"%(!01':#(02(/6:'(;3%0&$.&7]-^&Potchefstroom Elec. L.J.&6&].556^J&

F>%@&"$&\"RR';,:J&D$:"%($#($(S6-$2(!01':R(=H$%8#(A0?0,(/&0":7(F,+$,0Q$:02.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev. 4.?&

A";$&\3&M%$,'J&C&$,(A,$0-#.(42:"%2$:02$,(/:$28$%8#($28(:'"(S6-$2(!01':(:(D$:"%.&02&The International Struggle for

!01':(:(D$:"%R(A$#"(C$H(3%-(/*6:'(;3%0&$.(;%1"2:02$($28(4280$&_"QJ&.557]-^&L. Soc. Just. & Global Dev. J. -5 ]FI+3&?J&

D+@'R&NI'++&j&d%'E9:"&)';,+"$:J&='"(G?,6:02(*3(D$:"%(!01':#.(46]0^ Nat. Res. J.&7.-&]-??6^3&

D,:+&i3&8:,Q",J&D$:"%($#($(S6-$2(!01':(02(:'"(9GE;(!"102R(A'$,,"21"#($28(W@@%:620:0"#.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev&

K'@"<">&K'P"&D$UD(9@":J&A2#:0:6:02$,(A6%:L#(!"?0"H($28(:'"(U6:6%"(3(D$:"%(C$H(02(4282"#0$.&.]-^&L. Env. & Dev. J.&

M3&d"#E;J&/-"(A--"2:#(2(D$:"%(!01':#(02(/6:'(;3%0&$.&7]-^&Potchefstroom Elec. L.J.&6&].556^J&

F>%@&"$&\"RR';,:J&D$:"%($#($(S6-$2(!01':R(=H$%8#(A0?0,(/&0":7(F,+$,0Q$:02.&.4].^&Intl J. Water Res. Dev. 4.?&

N+%C@%&)3&KI)"((E%RJ&;(S6-$2(!01':(:(D$:"%R(>-"#:0&($28(42:"%2$:02$,(4-@,0&$:0*2#.&6]-^&Geo. Intl Envtl. L. Rev.(-&

_"Q&)'I%E:9&=EE:9"+:'J&M'3&--&'(&-?/0J&The Official Gazette of Indonesia,&-?/0J&M'3&163&

A"B:,+"&LP:E'<%+"$&AE'+%I+:'*&DI+J&M'3&40&'(&-??/J&The Gazette of Pakistan ExtraordinaryJ&2%I3&1J&-??/&]A"B3^3&

;(E$:02$,(>0#1%$&".(A$2$8$L#(/'$-"36,()#0:02(2(:'"(!01':(:*(D$:"%.&The Council of Canadians&]K"E3&.6J&.557^.(

[$26$%7(PXNX(A62:%7(/6--$%7R()$O0#:$2J&Human Rights Watch&]\"3&.5-5^J&@++CHOOQQQ3@EQ3'E9O%*OQ'E$>TE%C'E+T

\",'&8E:IB%EJ&)%0?$:0Q$:02(*3(D$:"%(9$2$1"-"2:(02(;%1"2:02$.&American University Trade Environment Database

s:P:""&D$','J(D$:"%($28(/"H$1"()%0?$:0#$:02(F2"(/*6%.(Inter Press Service&]D;93&-6J&.554^J&$?$0,$+,"($:&