Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
611
612
613
614
615
616
617
618
aim is to enter that society with a certain power since society doesnt
really protect its members who do not have their own individual
power. In the meantime, he operates on a code of ethics he considers
far superior to the legal structures of society. (Puzo 362 63)
Indeed, the opening scene of the novel establishes this point with a
petitioner who asks for justice because the American courts have failed
him. This sense of Corleone as a man with the vision and power to live
by his codeone that exceeds the moral justice of American
institutionsis perhaps the most compelling aspect of The Godfather
and explains its lasting influence in popular cultures revision and
development of gangster stories. The social history of the debate about
morality and individual responsibility undergirds The Godfathers
timelessness as a popular narrative. Although, for the most part, earlier
gangster film and pulp magazines and novels had designed amorality as
free will, Puzos revision reinforces the sense that a strict moral vision
and the wherewithal to live according to ones code are acts of individual
will. Vito Corleones morality appeals because of its individual
expression of authority and because of its universal application. The
code The Godfather popularizes has to do with modeling the mob Family
on the dynamics of the biological family. Seeming at times a benevolent
patriarch, the Don exacts loyalty, friendship, and respect, but wields
these as weapons as well. His code calls for effective brutality even as it
masquerades as generosity and good will.
In light of subsequent Mafia narratives, Caweltis analysis of The
Godfathers significance in presenting the family as the locus of this
code seems particularly astute. If one is neither the author of a gangster
code nor heir to its legacy, one is alienated from it entirely. The lesson
of Martin Scorseses film Goodfellas is in some ways the tragedy of
Henry Hills seduction by the gangster life from outside of its realm.
Because Henry, Jimmy, and Tommy are not family in either sense of
the word, they do not internalize the familys code. Alienated from the
family, they are outsiders distinctly disadvantaged by their less-thanfootsoldier status. They mistakenly attempt to live the gangster life
without the authority, demands, and privileges of its value structure.
The goodfellas demise has to do with the absence of clear boundaries,
discipline, and purpose that codes like Don Corleones provide.
One of the major functions of Don Corleones code as Puzo
articulates it is to live life as a critique of mainstream America and its
619
620
621
622
623
624
625
626
627
the film all resonate throughout the plot, but perhaps none as
powerfully as W. E. B. Du Boiss The Souls of Black Folk. Du Boiss
reflections on the doubled condition of black American life indicate a
condition that persists nearly a century later:
. . . the Negro is . . . born with a veil, and gifted with second-sight
in this American worlda world which yields him no true selfconsciousness, but only lets him see himself through the revelation
of the other world. It is a peculiar sensation, this doubleconsciousness, this sense of always looking at ones self through
the eyes of others, of measuring ones soul by the tape of a world that
looks on in amused contempt and pity. One ever feels his twoness
an American, a Negro; two souls, two thoughts, two unreconciled
strivings; two warring ideals in one dark body, whose dogged
strength alone keeps it from being torn asunder. (3)
Ghost Dog apparently avoids this fate by stepping out of black
American culture and into a different cultural reality, that of feudal
Japan. Hagakure addresses the danger of doubleness:
It is bad when one thing becomes two. One should not look for
anything else in the Way of the Samurai. It is the same for anything
that is called a Way. Therefore, it is inconsistent to hear something
of the Way of Confucius or the Way of the Buddha, and say that this
is the Way of the Samurai. If one understands things in this manner,
he should be able to hear about all Ways and be more and more in
accord with his own. (Tsunetomo, quoted in Ghost Dog)
As Tsunetomo understands it, this danger is not so much an
internalized split as it is a confusion of one philosophy with another.
The film suggests that the conflicts inherent to Ghost Dogs blackness
are resolved within the logic of his samurai philosophy: he needs only
to reject what is not the way of the samurai. Ghost Dog revises his
sense of himself within the samurai mythologyor, rather, he begins
to efface his sense of a self-in-the-world via his philosophical path. This
adopted identity serves him well when he revisits moments parallel to
the assault that Jarmusch presents as his formative experience. As a
revengeful ghost, Ghost Dog acts decisively and without the burden
of double consciousness.
Within this context, the film raises questions about ethnicity and
mutual social alienation. One might read Ghost Dogs fate as violent
deathhis only choice being which path he takes to that end. Or, one
628
might understand the samurai code (and, to a limited extent, the other
codes of violence) to provide a way of removing oneself from the
painful conditions of urban life. Jarmusch quotes Hagakure: It is a
good viewpoint to see the world as a dream. When you have a
nightmare, wake yourself up and say it was only a dream. It is said that
the world we live in is not a bit different from this. The film itself is
dreamlike, vague, slowed down, and spare in its landscape. Is this
adaptation of Zen Buddhism an escapism for Ghost Dog? Compare
him with the young men rapping in the park; they acknowledge him as
a powerful and dangerous man. Perhaps he has, as an assassin, simply
escaped the sense of limitation that he might otherwise find in
mainstream America. Now, when confronted by armed white men
(bear hunters and mafiosi), he is ready and quick with his weapon.
Although, as Hagakure instructs, the end is important in all
things, it is crucial that Jarmusch does not affect neat closure with
Ghost Dogs inevitable end. His death does not resolve the questions
Jarmusch raises about a black mans code of survival and social
conditions in the late twentieth century. Others inherit this world.
Significantly, Ghost Dog has anointed not the park rappers but two
immigrants of the African diaspora as his heirs.16 Pearline and
Raymond function as the next generation of black Americans (as
Jamaican and Haitian immigrants) learning to survive in this country.
As extensions of Ghost Dog, they inherit the challenges of urban life as
black people in the twenty-first century. Ghost Dog bequeaths to each
a distinct legacy. Pearline inherits Ghost Dogs doctrine, Hagakure,
which, unlike The Souls of Black Folk, will offer not just a lifting of the
veil of racism (she seems savvy enough already) but also will be a
proactive means of survival on the streets of her world. One doubts that
Pearline will end up like the few lone women we see haunting Ghost
Dogs landscape (in fact, the films Web site lists her as a warrior).
Entrepreneurial Raymond, however, inherits the suit in which Ghost
Dog passes as a black businessman. Although language is his barrier,
Raymond understands enough of his adopted country to know what
imperils him. The question of whether the costume (the suit) will keep
him from getting deported is answered, in part, by Ghost Dogs other
gift: the weapons and tools of his trade. As the film closes on Pearline,
engrossed in reading Rashoman, we can assume that Ghost Dogs
adopted code will continue to mutate to fit the complexities of her
world.
629
630
NOTES
1. The year-long investigation turned up a series of players who were associated with the mob
through stock trading: Mobbed up broker-dealers, top-shelf investment advisers,
unscrupulous issuers, unethical lawyers and accountants, and microcap manipulators (Mafia
Spins 10).
2. In his article on Youngstown, Ohio, David Grann explores what would be an almost quaint
relationship with the mob were it not for the dire economic reality galvanizing this strange
alliance: . . . the community has come to rely on mobsters who play the same role in civic
life that the police and political establishment do in other cities . . . (31). The flight of jobcreating businesses has meant that the community relies on the mob for its economic
infrastructure as well.
3. The Bureau of Indian Affairs estimates that in the last six years, the number of known Indian
gangs has tripled to 520, with over 6,000 members. With little economic activity or
commercial crime, most gang activity on the reservation consists of gang members assaulting
each other (Beisner 15). The exportation of gangsta culture as a mode of social interaction and
identification reaches beyond even these outposts to surpass national boundaries. Young El
Salvadoran refugees and the children of refugees who, in the 1980s, sought sanctuary from
right-wing violence in their home country, learned gang culture and rites in the United States
and have become the source of a massive gang culture now that they have been deported
(Wallace 50).
4. David Ruth discusses Capones desire and efforts to be part of American public life: Though
Al Capone lived in the realm of flesh and blood, for most Americans he existed only as a
cultural invention. Foremost among the inventors was Capone himself. By all accounts, he
was a man who welcomed the limelight and worked constantly to manipulate public
perceptions . . . racketeer or businessman, bootlegging or hospitality (119). Despite his
role in inspiring gangster films (Little Caesar and Scarface), Capone was a social conservative
concerned that these gang movies are making a lot of kids want to be tough guys (qtd. in
Mobilio 73).
5. Harpers published part of a transcript from a 1999 trial of the deCavalcante crime family
in which New Jersey mafiosi Anthony Totondo, Joseph Sclafani, and Billy Lnu discuss
whether they are inspiration for characters in The Sopranos. Rotondo insists that their
names are mentioned and that . . . every show you watch more and more you pick
up somebody [we know]. Every show (La Drama Nostra 26). At least one character
in the series, Pussy Bompensiero, is named for an assassinated mobster: Anthony Little Pussy
Russo.
631
6. Elsewhere, I have discussed this dynamic in Ice Ts career. See Walker Fields (1416).
7. The story of Sean Puffy Combs and his involvement with Wallace and Shakur illuminates the
double-edge of cultivating the gangsta image: Bad Boy (Combss label) was at war with
Shakurs label (Death Row Records) because Shakur alleged Combs orchestrated an assault on
him. One theory about the Shakur and Wallace killings is that both came out of their labels
antagonism and their labels association with Los Angeles gangs. Combs, who faced two
felony gun possession charges, backpedaled, declaiming the gangsta image he carefully
crafted. Steven Daly writes, In short, Combs must admit that his player persona is nothing
more than a role, the fantasy of a little boy from the burbs . . . (169). On the other end of the
spectrum, O.G. (Original Gangsta) Ice T asserts that the persona is a put-on: sometimes I
want to become characters, and I can play a drug dealer or drug addict. I can become any
person. You know, like in Cop Killer I became a psychopath that went on a rampage. Thats
not meIm not a psychopath that went on a rampage. I make records. . . . I drink milk, I
play video games, I bounce my little baby on my knee. Im a normal person . . . I mean I got
a tough side to me but I dont have to walk around and flaunt it. I dont need to do that (Ice
T interview).
8. Anthony Walton writes: Gangsta rap was first created by inner-city blacks for the
consumption of young inner city males andsoon afterfor the consumption of the mass
white suburban audience. In this way, gangsta rap served as a kind of minstrel show for the
suburban audience while at the same time giving birth in the inner cities to a culture . . .
that is progressively more damaging to the community, and that has turned lethal . . . (22).
The sales figures following the Notorious B.I.G.s (Biggie Smallss) death demonstrate the
commercial power of the gangsta lifestyle in popular culture. Christopher Wallaces untimely
end became a promotional force in the gangsta mythology of his label, Bad Boy. Puffy
Combss tribute single, Ill Be Missing You dominated the airwaves by mid-May and
Smallss posthumous Life After Death (five million copies sold) went double-platinum (Daly
166).
9. See the game Kingpin (http://www.urbangangsta.com). Versace and Chanel have been among
those in the fashion industry to lift gangsta style from the street to the runway (Hethorn 70).
10. Scorsese was quoted in Rolling Stone magazine (George 34).
11. Contradictions in the mobs morality are played out in other ways in the Dons strict
interdiction of drugs and prostitution business even as the novel relies on steamy sex scenes.
12. As the tag line to the shows second season proclaimed, If one family doesnt get him, the
other will.
13. Some of the most directly identifiable linksthe romanticized emblems of gangland culture
that are part of Mafia culture (real and fictional)originate in the 1930s crime culture and
are themselves a mix of social reality and Hollywood fetishization of the gangster. Tupac
Shakur, Ice T, and other gangsta rappers pose with automatic weapons, recalling the Tommy
guns of Hollywoods gangster films. Hollywood gangstas watch gangster films (e.g., Nino
Brown watching the 1970s remake of Scarface in New Jack City). And, in an ironic inversion of
this trend, a Ghost Dog mobster raps (Sonny Valerio comically misconstrues hiphop as gangsta
rap, aund thus singer as gangsta as samurai when explaining the cultural origin of Ghost
Dogs name to his mob boss).
14. This claim to street knowledge has become a hip hop hallmark that Niggaz With Attitude
made infamous with its opening line on Straight Outta Comptons title track: You are now
about to witness the strength of street knowledge.
15. Andrew Ross notes that the edge has been taken off the characterization of the gangsta, a
factor that informs all of Jarmuschs gangsta characterizations. The profile of todays gangsta
rapper, scaled down last season to the ultimate, low metabolism vibe of Dr. Dre and Snoop
Doggy Dog, evokes an affectless masculinity, conceived under siege, and resonating with a
632
long history of presenting a neutral face as a mask of inscrutability to the white gaze (161).
What is visually arresting about the park rappers in Ghost Dog is their prison-garb costuming,
a cue about the models for their masculinity as gangstas.
16. My thanks to Anthony Vital for pointing this out to me.
17. In a twist on the theme, in Jon Favreaus 2001 comedic mob film, Made, being made as a
member of the Mafia is rejected in favor of a quiet if unorthodox domestic lifestyle. After a
harrowing three-day trial period, Bobby and Ricky choose to raise Bobbys ex-girlfriends
daughter instead of pursuing an invitation to join Maxs mob organization. The final scene, in
which Ricky and Bobby argue about Chloes schooling in a Chuck-E-Cheese-esque birthday
party scenario, underscores the relief of abandoning the perilous lifestyle of a made man for
middle-class fatherhood.
Works Cited
Beisner, Vince. Boyz on the Rez. The New Republic July 2000:
1516.
Cawelti, John. The Mythology of Crime and its Formulaic Embodiments. Adventure, Mystery, and Romance. Chicago: U of Chicago
P, 1976. 5179.
Daly, Steven. The Player King. Vanity Fair Aug. 2000: 1301.
De Stefano, George. Ungood Fellas. The Nation 7 Feb. 2000: 3133.
Du Bois, W. E. B. The Souls of Black Folk. Chicago: A. C. McClurg &
Co., 1903.
George, Nelson. Hip Hop America. New York: Penguin Books. 1998.
Ghost Dog. Dir. Jim Jarmusch. Artisan Entertainment, 1999.
Goodfellas. Dir. Martin Scorsese. Warner Bros, 1990.
Grann, David. Crimetown U.S.A.: The City that Fell in Love with the
Mob. The New Republic July 2000: 2331.
Hethorn, Janet. Smooth Criminals. Icon Feb. 1999: 6670.
Hotheads, Turncoats Putting Philly Mob on Last Broken Legs. Palm
Beach Post 19 Sept. 1999: 10A.
Ice T. Interview with Terri Gross. Fresh Air. National Public Radio.
WHYY, Philadelphia. 1994.
La Drama Nostra. Harpers Mar. 2000: 2426.
Lives in Hazard. Dir. Edward James Olmos. Los Angeles: Olmos
Productions, 1993.
Made. Dir. Jon Favreau. Artisan Entertainment, 2001.
Mafia Spins Stock Market Scam on Web. Sunday Times 18 June 2000
hhttp://www.timesonline.co.uk/i.
Millman, Joyce. Married . . . With Hit Men. salon.com 11 Jan. 1999
hhttp://www.salon.com/i.
Mobilio, Albert. Made Men of Letters: Our Thing About the Cosa
Nostra. Harpers Oct. 1977: 6878.
633