Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Daniela Klingebiel
Pension & Endowments Departments
Nov. 20, 2014
Outline
Structural trends in emerging markets (EM) external and local
currency sovereign debt
14,000.00
5,000.00
12,000.00
4,000.00
10,000.00
8,000.00
3,000.00
6,000.00
2,000.00
4,000.00
1,000.00
2,000.00
-
Emerging Markets
Source: Bloomberg.
United States
EM FX Debt
EM DX Debt
The market capitalization of EM debt grew significantly during last 14 years. While sovereign debt
outstanding for 55 emerging markets, amounted to $1.3 trillion in 2000, 13 years later it had grown sixfold to $6.3 trillion. With $6.3 trillion, EM debt outstanding now almost half of the size of the US
Treasury markets, the world biggest and most liquid market.
Growth in EM debt outstanding driven by local currency debt (EMDX). While EM external debt (EMFX)
almost doubled over this period from $576 billion to $1.0, EM local currency debt grew sevenfold from
90.00%
85.00%
5,000.00
80.00%
US $ bn
4,000.00
75.00%
3,000.00
70.00%
65.00%
2,000.00
60.00%
1,000.00
55.00%
50.00%
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Source: Bloomberg
EM DX Debt
In 2000, local currency debt accounted for roughly 55% of outstanding tradeable debt in
EM.
By 2013, the share of EM local currency debt to 83% of total outstanding EM debt.
85.00%
4,000.00
84.00%
3,500.00
US $ bn
3,000.00
83.00%
2,500.00
2,000.00
82.00%
1,500.00
1,000.00
81.00%
500.00
-
80.00%
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Top 10 EM DX stock
EM local currency debt market is highly concentrated with the ten largest issuers
accounting for 81% of the local currency debt market and 74% of overall EM debt.
With $1.3 trillion, Chinas market cap of outstanding local currency debt largest in EM
space.
5
Country
China
Brazil
India
Mexico
Turkey
Poland
Malaysia
Russia
South Africa
Thailand
DX Stock (% GDP)
Dec-00
Dec-13
11.17%
14.74%
20.82%
40.62%
2.50%
32.93%
8.72%
24.32%
5.92%
29.72%
21.59%
41.07%
47.17%
51.51%
3.44%
6.88%
53.69%
36.13%
13.17%
29.36%
DX Stock (% of total
EM DX Debt)
Total Debt (USD billions)
Dec-13
Dec-00
Dec-13
26.29%
139.20
1,363.49
17.61%
216.13
986.88
11.93%
11.92
618.04
5.92%
138.70
405.26
4.70%
42.63
299.78
4.10%
50.58
299.88
3.11%
49.08
164.78
2.78%
98.51
237.71
2.45%
75.40
139.03
2.19%
18.13
113.79
81.08%
Total Debt (% of
total EM Debt)
Dec-13
21.85%
15.82%
9.91%
6.50%
4.80%
4.81%
2.64%
3.81%
2.23%
1.82%
74.19%
China, Brazil, and India also have debt stock of local currency bonds that exceed $500 mn.
Also interesting to note that largest issuers of local currency debt also issue very little hard
currency debt.
Country
China
Brazil
India
Mexico
Turkey
Poland
Malaysia
Russia
South Africa
Thailand
GBI-EM
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
EMGBI
WGBI
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
Notes:
1. Local currency long-term debt
2. GBI-EM = JPMorgan Government Bond Index Emerging Markets, EMLCTRUU = Barclays Emerging Markets Local Currency
Government Bond Index, LEGATRUU = Barclays Global Aggregate Index, LCEMTRUU = Barclays Emerging Markets Local Currency
Government Universal Bond Index, EMGBI = Citi Emerging Markets Global Bond Index, WGBI = Citi World Government Bond Index
11.32%
31.37%
3.03%
3.10%
Sub-Saharan Africa
Middle East & North Africa
East Asia Pacific
Europe & Central Asia
30.45%
20.73%
With 31.3% LATAM region highest share of total sovereign emerging market debt
outstanding, followed by with 30.5%.
Sub-Saharan Africa
3.33%
2.90%
45.86%
4.10%
16.66%
35.31%
Sub-Saharan Africa
1.55%
6.67%
40.63%
South Asia
South Asia
Country
China
Brazil
India
Mexico
Poland
Turkey
Malaysia
Russia
South Africa
Thailand
Philippines
Colombia
Indonesia
Egypt
Hungary
Argentina
Ukraine
Romania
Peru
Lithuania
Bulgaria
0.09
14.75
0.89
11.90
25.61
21.20
4.72
0.99
5.49
1.33
6.11
3.46
15.42
5.50
1.01
0.02
-
22.54
138.39
8.36
140.04
66.76
40.86
43.00
29.84
43.28
18.11
12.14
5.30
23.17
0.14
23.25
1.19
1.45
6.05
6.55
0.53
0.03
0.02%
2.88%
0.26%
7.57%
21.25%
13.84%
8.40%
2.55%
8.59%
2.73%
0.00%
0.00%
13.12%
18.57%
28.81%
16.80%
0.00%
0.00%
27.21%
1.26%
0.00%
1.68%
16.10%
1.23%
36.87%
34.92%
21.53%
29.40%
24.75%
37.85%
17.41%
14.44%
6.43%
30.01%
0.21%
40.36%
3.20%
4.83%
22.30%
51.08%
16.09%
0.98%
In 10 of 21 countries
for which information
was available,
foreign investors
hold at least 20% of
outstanding local
currency holding.
In 6 countries,
foreigners hold at
least 30%.
Sources: IMF Sovereign Investor Base Dataset for Emerging Markets, Arslanalp and Tsuda (2014)
10
11
South Africa
Egypt
China
Indonesia
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Bulgaria
Hungary
Lithuania
Poland
Romania
Russia
Turkey
Ukraine
Argentina
Brazil
Colombia
Mexico
Peru
India
2013 Total Debt (USD billions) Foreign Official Foreign Bank Foreign Nonbank Domestic Central Bank Domestic Bank Domestic Nonbank Total Foreign Total Domestic
151.37
1.59%
3.69%
33.52%
0.55%
22.28%
38.37%
38.80%
61.20%
238.59
9.78%
0.06%
2.57%
24.48%
43.10%
20.02%
12.40%
87.60%
4,630.49
1.17%
0.02%
0.07%
5.45%
91.72%
1.57%
1.26%
98.74%
194.53
30.43%
4.93%
23.29%
14.94%
13.15%
13.26%
58.65%
41.35%
167.60
6.96%
3.34%
20.33%
0.00%
23.89%
45.48%
30.62%
69.38%
99.53
15.95%
4.84%
20.40%
6.73%
32.08%
20.01%
41.18%
58.82%
116.66
1.80%
3.11%
12.43%
6.34%
21.72%
54.60%
17.34%
82.66%
10.40
19.72%
2.57%
10.28%
0.00%
41.45%
25.98%
32.57%
67.43%
107.40
14.08%
5.88%
38.29%
0.60%
21.52%
19.64%
58.24%
41.76%
18.83
11.23%
2.07%
58.41%
0.39%
18.44%
9.45%
71.71%
28.29%
310.38
9.77%
4.49%
33.82%
0.00%
25.11%
26.81%
48.08%
51.92%
74.39
27.65%
5.28%
21.13%
0.00%
33.23%
12.70%
54.07%
45.93%
263.37
1.66%
3.93%
17.96%
4.21%
40.74%
31.49%
23.56%
76.44%
266.68
12.13%
8.43%
20.77%
2.15%
46.43%
10.10%
41.32%
58.68%
59.61
14.06%
1.81%
29.74%
30.36%
19.31%
4.71%
45.61%
54.39%
178.56
10.90%
1.69%
20.78%
42.95%
19.18%
4.49%
33.37%
66.63%
1,346.51
2.28%
3.84%
8.87%
30.00%
22.55%
32.47%
14.98%
85.02%
135.73
11.09%
2.68%
16.38%
0.06%
20.23%
49.57%
30.14%
69.86%
419.58
8.45%
6.78%
34.23%
0.00%
8.17%
42.37%
49.46%
50.54%
37.51
20.31%
9.35%
30.00%
1.49%
9.72%
29.12%
59.66%
40.34%
1,196.95
5.11%
0.14%
0.56%
9.14%
29.76%
55.29%
5.81%
94.19%
Sources: IMF Sovereign Investor Base Dataset for Emerging Markets, Arslanalp and Tsuda (2014)
Notes: This data series covers general government debt, both local and hard currency. This chart is not
comparable to previous tables on foreign ownership of local currency federal government debt securities.
Foreign Central Banks and non-bank holders are largest holders of EM debt.
12
Sources: IMF Sovereign Investor Base Dataset for Emerging Markets, Arslanalp and Tsuda (2014)
Notes: This data series covers general government debt, both local and hard currency. This chart is not
comparable to previous tables on foreign ownership of local currency federal government debt securities.
13
Ticker
Inception
Market Cap
(USD billions)
Number of
Constituents
Country Criteria
Liquidity Criteria
Instrument Criteria
i. Fixed coupon or zero coupon.
ii. Bonds with option features are excluded.
iii. At rebalance date, maturity > 13 months.
iv. No explicit face value minimum.
GBI-EM
Jun-05
1,594
18
GBI-EM
Jan-06
993
16
GBI-EM
Jan-06
873
14
WGBI
Dec-84
20,361
23
EMGBI
Dec-07
918
14
22
25
EMLCTRUU
LCEMTRUU
Jul-08
Jul-08
In response to an increase in investor appetite, local currency debt indices were developed: the Government Bond Index-Emerging Markets (GBIEM) series; index exists in three variations - the GBI-EM, GBI-EM Global and GBI-EM Broad - which cater to different investment objectives and
inclusion criteria; the indices span over 15 countries and are also available in diversified weighting versions.
4 EM countries (Malaysia, Mexico, Poland and South Africa) are also part of the Citi World Government Bond Index that tracks the performance of
local government investment grade bonds. And finally, the Barclays Agg Index now has a small portion of the index dedicated to a number of
EMS. The weight of these indices, however, is below 3%.
14
Now $554 bn managed against various JP EM sovereign bond indices. Market cap of bond indices together account for
roughly $3 trillion in EM market cap or roughly 50% of EM total outstanding debt.
External debt still dominates. Despite its significantly smaller size, assets managed against hard currency index amount
to $310 bn in 2014 up from $178 bn in 2007. Market cap of debt of countries allocated to index amount to roughly $830
mn, indicating that more than a third of outstanding debt is managed against the index.
But assets managed against the EM local currency market index has increased ten fold from $21 bn to $221 in
September 2014.
15
Rate/Credit view reflecting a view of future monetary policy/ and development of fiscal
balance.
Currency view reflecting what extent home market currency may appreciate or
depreciate vs currency of country.
Easier for investors to express their view if they can separate decision:
In order to do that need functioning interest rate swap market that allows investor to
take exposure to market without taking on currency risk (to create synthetic exposure).
17
Does an asset offer attractive risk and return characteristics. All else equal, a higher Sharpe ratio
is more desirable as it indicates better rewards per unit of risk.
Are the returns of the asset class normally distributed and risks thoroughly understood?
Does the asset class capture any risk premium, if any. Is there any economic rationale for the
risk premium and if any is this stable over time. Can it be captured through a passive exposure or
does it require skill.
Does asset have any diversification benefit vs main risk exposures of plan. Are diversification
benefits stable.
Is market for asset large enough that Plans exposure not meaningful to overall market (to
preserve liquidity)
20
21
No.
Fund Name
AUM ($
billions)
Exposure to FX EMD?
325.7
No
Allocation hedged?
In % AUM
N/A
None
N/A
N/A
N/A
262
Yes
Opportunistic
No
N/A
0.05%
176.8
No
N/A
None
N/A
N/A
N/A
166
Yes
Opportunistic
No
N/A
No
0.10%
143.9
No
N/A
None
N/A
N/A
N/A
132.4
No
N/A
None
N/A
N/A
N/A
117.1
No
N/A
None
N/A
N/A
N/A
95.4
Yes
SAA
Yes
Yes, by policy
unclear
88.5
Yes
Yes
10
83.9
Yes
SAA
Yes
SAA
11
80
No
N/A
No
N/A
N/A
N/A
12
79.3
Yes
Opportunistic
Yes
Yes
1.30%
13
74.4
No
N/A
No
N/A
N/A
N/A
14
70
No
N/A
No
N/A
N/A
N/A
15
68
Yes
Opportunistic
Yes (majority)
SAA
No
0.38%
16
66
Yes
Opportunistic
Yes
Not required
0.71%
17
53.2
Yes
Yes
18
24.8
No
N/A
Yes
Not completely - Non-U.S. dollar based Target allocation of 3% (0-5% range) for the Defined
securities are limited to 25% of the Benefit Portfolio; 5% (2-10% range) for the Health Care
total Fixed Income assets.
Portfolio
N/A
N/A
22
24
25