Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 136

Topic 3: Smart Grid Communications

DepartmentofElectrical&ComputerEngineering
TexasTechUniversity
Spring2012

A.H.MohsenianRad(UofT)

NetworkingandDistributedSystems

NIST Conceptual Reference Model for Smart Grid


Interactionsacross7SmartGridDomains:

Eachdomaininvolvesitsownactors andapplications.
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

NIST Conceptual Reference Model for Smart Grid


Consumers:
Theend usersofelectricity.
Mayalsogenerate/storeelectricity.
Traditionally:Residential,Commercial,andIndustrial.

Market:
Participantsinwholesalemarket:dayahead,hourahead,...
Involvesprediction,bidding,auctions,
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

NIST Conceptual Reference Model for Smart Grid


ServiceProviders:
Organizationsprovidingserviceto:
Bothutilitiesandconsumers.
ISPs,CellPhoneCompanies,Aggregators,

Operations:
IndependentSystemOperators(ISOs)
RegionalTransmissionOrganization(RTOs)
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

NIST Conceptual Reference Model for Smart Grid


BulkGeneration:
MajorPowerPlants.

Transmission:
Carriersofbulkelectricityoverlongdistances.

Distribution:
Distributionofelectricityto(andfrom!)consumers.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

MDMS:MeterDataManagementSystem,
CIS:CustomerInformationSystem
EMS:EnergyManagementSystem

NIST Model for Smart Grid Information Network

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

Smart Grid Communications


Therearetwoquestionstoanswer:
How candifferentsmartgridentitiesexchangemessages?
Whatkind ofmessages(andwhy)shouldtheyexchange?

OurfocusinTopic3isonthefirstquestion.

Wewanttolearnwhichcommunicationtechnologiesmayhelp.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

Smart Grid Communications


Inparticular,wecoverthesecommunicationstechnologies:

Sensors

Operation

Aggregator

PLC
IP
WMN
Smart
Meter

PLC
IP/IEC

ZigBee (HomeAreaNetwork)

Substations

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

Smart Grid Communications

ZigBee

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

ZigBee Overview
ZigBee isaworkinggrouptopromoteIEEE802.15.4standard.
Highlevelcommunication
Small,lowcost,lowpower devices

MPR2400Micaz ZigBee WirelessSensorNode

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

www.wsncanada.ca

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

10

ZigBee Overview
IEEE802.15isforWirelessPersonalAreaNetworking(WPAN)
802.15.1:Bluetooth
802.15.2:Coexistence(e.g.,withWLAN)
802.15.3:HighRate WPANviaUltrawideband(UWB)
802.15.4: LowRate
LowPowerConsumption
LongBatteryLife
Inexpensive!

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

11

ZigBee Overview
WPANvs WLAN/WiFi andWMAN/WiMax

Frequency
Range
Data Rates
Nodes

802.16
WiMAX
2 11GHz
31 miles

802.11
WiFi
2.4GHz
100 Meters

802.15
WPAN
Varies
10 Meters

70 Mbps

11 - 110Mbps 20k 55Mbps

Thousands

Dozens

Dozens

*Datafor802.16aand802.11a

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

12

ZigBee Overview

WWAN

IEEE 802.22

WMAN

WiMax
IEEE 802.16

WLAN
ZigBee
802.15.4 Bluetooth
802.15.1

WPAN
0.01

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

0.1

WiFi
802.11

1
10
Data Rate (Mbps)

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

802.15.3
802.15.3a
802.15.3c
100

www.zigbee.org

Range

IEEE 802.20

1000

Texas Tech University

13

ZigBee Overview
SimplerandLessExpensivethanBluetooth

Cost:OnefourthofBluetooth

Complexity:
ComplexZigBee Nodes:10%CodeofaBluetoothnode
SimpleZigBee Nodes:2%CodeofaBluetoothnode

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

14

ZigBee Applications
Awirelessmouse thatworksforyears withoutnewbatteries!

KeyApplicationAreas:
Building/Home
Energy

Telecommunications

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

www.zigbee.org

Health

Texas Tech University

15

ZigBee Applications in Smart Grid


KeyApplication:
SmartMeter CommunicationswithSmartAppliances
SmartAppliances:
Washer,Dryer,DishWasher,Fridge
AirConditioning
PumpsandWaterHeaters
PHEVs
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

16

ZigBee Alliance
DefiningNetwork,Security,andApplicationSoftware
AssuringInterpretability
MarketAwareness
Managing/EvolvingStandards

www.zigbee.org

Membership:$3500

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

17

www.zigbee.org

ZigBee Alliance

*Zigbee isanOPEN GlobalStandard


Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

18

ZigBee Protocol Stack


Therearefourlayers inZigBee ProtocolStack:
UserDefined

www.zigbee.org

ZigBee Alliance

IEEE802.15.4

[DE:DataEntity,ME:ManagementEntity,SAP:ServiceAccessPoint]
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

19

ZigBee Protocol Stack


ZigBee devicesmayusedifferentfrequencybands:

PHY

Frequency
Band

Channel
Numbering

Bit Rate

868 MHz

868 870 MHz

20 kb/s

915 MHz

902 928 MHz

1 - 10

40 kb/s

2.4 GHz

2.4 2.4835 GHz

11 - 26

250 kb/s

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

20

ZigBee Wireless Channels


FrequencychannelsusedbyZigBee devices:

Channel0

Channels110

868.3MHz

902MHz

Channels1126

2.4GHz

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

2MHz

928MHz

5MHz

2.4835GHz

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

21

ZigBee Wireless Channels


ZigBee maycoexistwithothertechnologiesatcertainbands.

Someofthefeaturesforcoexistence:
CarrierSenseMultipleAccess(CSMA)(Q:Remember?)
EndtoendACKandRetransmission
BuiltinChannelScanning/FindAvailableChannels

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

22

ZigBee Packet Structure


PacketFields[specifiedbyIEEE802.15.4]:
Preamble:32bitsforsynchronization(Q:Remember?)
StartofPacketDelimiter:8bits
PHYHeader:8bits/indicatesPSDUlength,etc.
PSDU:0to127bytesofdata

Preamble

Startof
Packet
Delimiter

6Bytes
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

PHY
Header

PHYService
DataUnit(PSDU)

0127Bytes
Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

23

ZigBee Packet Structure


InsidePSDU:

Preamble

Startof
Packet
Delimiter

PHY
Header

PHYService CRC-16
DataUnit(PSDU)

6Bytes

0127Bytes

PC

ADDR

DSN

Link Layer PDU

CRC

PC:AddressingModeFlags
ADDR:Address
DSN:DataSequenceNumber
CRC:CyclicRedundancyCheck
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

24

ZigBee Device Addressing


AllDevicesHaveAddress:
Twobytes:Wecanhaveupto65,536nodes(Q:Why?)
AddressingModes:
Star
AddressingModesDepend
ontheNetworkTopology.

PeertoPeer
ClusterTree

[Wewillseemoreontopologies]

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

25

ZigBee Device Classes


ZigBee hastwo mainDeviceClasses:
FullFunctionDevice(FFD)
ReducedFunctionDevice(RFD)

FFD:
Availableinany topology
Canbecomeanetworkcoordinator
Talkstoany otherdevice
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

26

ZigBee Device Classes


RFD:
Limitedtostartopology
Cannot becomeanetworkcoordinator
Talkstoonlyanetworkcoordinator
SimplerImplementation
Lesspowerconsumption

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

27

ZigBee Device Classes


EachZigBee networkhasonenetworkcoordinator.
Itinitiates networkformation.
Weneedatleastone FullFunctionDevice.(Q:Why?)

OtherdevicescanbeeitherFFDorRFD.
FFDsthatarenotnetworkcoordinator actasrouters.
RecallthatRFDsonlytalktothenetworkcoordinator.
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

28

ZigBee Network Topologies


FFDasRouter

Mesh

Star
PAN coordinator
Full Function Device
Reduced Function Device
Q:CanwebuildameshtopologywithRFDsonly?
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

29

ZigBee Network Topologies


NetworkCoordinatorinitiates thenetworkformation.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

30

ZigBee Network Topologies


ZigBee routershelpexpanding thenetwork

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

31

ZigBee Network Topologies


ZigBee routershelpexpanding thenetwork

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

32

ZigBee Network Topologies


WecanformTreeClusters.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

33

ZigBee Tree Clusters


EachclusterhasoneFFD asitsroot.

Therootfortheoveralltreeisthenetworkcoordinator.

Theyallowroutingwithminimumoverhead.

Thetreemayspanphysicallylarge areas.

Intotal,wecanhave255clustersof254nodes=64,770nodes.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

34

ZigBee Addressing
Foreachnewnode(i.e.,associateddevice):
Auniqueaddressisallocatedbyparent(router/coordinator)
RecallthattheparentcanonlybeaFFD.
Themax numberofdevicesthataparentcansupport=32.
Twotypesofaddresses:
NetworkAddress:16bit,onlyuniqueinthis network
ExtendedAddress:64bit,uniqueinall networks
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

35

ZigBee Addressing
Thefollowingnetworkattributesareimportant:
nwkcMaxDepth:
Themaximumabsolutedepth allowedinthisnetwork.
nwkMaxDepth (Lm):
Themaximumabsolutedepthaparticulardevice canhave.
nwkMaxChildren (Cm):
Themaximumnumberofchildrenadeviceisallowedtohave.
nwkMaxRouters (Rm):
Themaximumnumberofrouters adevicecanhaveaschildren.
Itissetbythecoordinator foralldevicesinthenetwork.
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

36

ZigBee Addressing
Thenetworkattributesforanode/routerwithabsolutedepthd:

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

37

ZigBee Addressing
TheseattributesletuscomputethefunctionCskip(d).
Sizeofaddressblock allocatedbyeachparentatdepthd.
Wehave:

1 Cm ( Lm d 1)

Cskip (d )
1 Cm Rm Cm Rm Lm d 1

1 Rm

Rm 1

otherwise

AFFDparentwithCskip(d)>0 mayacceptchilddevices.
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

38

ZigBee Addressing
Aparentassignsaddressestochildrenbasedon:
Whetherthechildisroutercapable ornot.

LetAparent denotetheaddressofaparent atdepthd.


RouterCapableChild:[nthsuchchildatdepthd+1]
Address: An Aparent Cskip (d ) (n 1) 1
AddressBlock: Aparent Cskip (d ) (n 1) 1, , Aparent Cskip (d ) n

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

39

ZigBee Addressing
EndDeviceChild:[mth suchchildatdepthd+1]
Address:

Am Aparent Cskip (d ) Rm m

Notethateachchildneedsanaddress.

Arouterchildalso needsanaddressblock foritsfuturechildren.

OverallIdea:Assurehavingunique addressesforallnodes.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

40

ZigBee Addressing
Example:Rm =1,Cm=2,andLm=3.
Cskip(0)=1+2x(3 0 1)=5
Cskip(1)=1+2x(3 1 1)=3
Cskip(2)=1+2x(3 2 1)=1

Blockwith
5Addresses
Blockwith
3Addresses

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

41

ZigBee Addressing
ConsideraddressingatthenetworkcoordinatorwithANC =0.
RouterChild:Addr =0+5x(1 1)+1=1
Addr Block =15x1=15
EnddeviceChild:Addr =0+5x1+1=6
0
16

Block:15
Blockwith
3Addresses

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

42

ZigBee Addressing
Attherouternodeatdepth1withAparent =1.
RouterChild:Addr =1+3x(1 1)+1=2
Addr Block =21+3x1=24
EnddeviceChild:Addr =1+3x1+1=5
0
16

25

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Block:15

Block:24

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

43

ZigBee Addressing
Attherouternodeatdepth2withAparent =2.
RouterChild:Addr =2+1x(1 1)+1=3
Addr Block =32+1x1=33
EnddeviceChild:Addr =2+1x1+1=4
0
16

25

Block:15

Block:24

34
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

44

ZigBee Addressing
Example:Rm =2,Cm=4,andLm=3.
Cskip(0)=(1+4 2 4x2301)/(12)=13
Cskip(1)=
Cskip(2)=
Showhowtheaddressblocksareallocated.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

45

ZigBee Addressing

YourJob:Choosetheaddressesandaddressblocks!

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

46

ZigBee Addressing
Q:Whatifthetopologyisnotcomplete?

Q:Whatifthetopologyisnotstar?Doesitaffectaddresses?
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

47

ZigBee Routing
Weneedtofindapathfromasourcetoadestinationnode.

Keyobservation:Forarouter deviceatdepthd+1,wehave
Address: An Aparent Cskip (d ) (n 1) 1
AddressBlock: Aparent Cskip (d ) (n 1) 1, , Aparent Cskip (d ) n

Wecanrewritetheaddressblockas
An , , An Cskip (d ) 1

Q:Canweusethisobservationforrouting?
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

48

ZigBee Routing
AssumethatsuchrouterissearchingforapathforaddressD.

IfthefollowingisTrue,thenD isadescendent oftherouter:


An D An Cskip (d ) 1

An D An Cskip (d )

Otherwise,theroutershouldforward themessagetoitsparent.

Thus,wecaneasilyfind arouter withD asitsdescendent.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

49

ZigBee Routing
Next,weshouldfindawayforaroutertoforwardthemessage:
Totherightchildatnextdepthlevel.

ThisistrivialifDistheaddressforanenddevice.(Q:Why?)

Otherwise,theaddressoftherightrouterchild isobtainedas
D ( An 1)
An 1
Cskip (d )

Cskip (d )

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

50

ZigBee Routing
Example:Node13 wantstosendamessagetonode17.
0(028)
2728

14(1426)
1213
1(113)
Cskip(0)=13
Cskip(1)=5
Cskip(2)=1

Rm =2
Cm=4
Lm=3

25

15(1519)

17
16

Q:Canyouexplainhowthedestinationisfound?
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

51

ZigBee Routing
Thisroutingmechanismisparticularlygoodfortreetopologies.

Althoughitworksforothertopologiesaswell.

However,formorecomplexnetworks,ZigBee uses:
AODV:AdhocOndemandDistanceVector
UsesBellmanFord(BF)EquationasaDValgorithm
Butfirstitrequiresroutediscovery ondemand

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

52

ZigBee Routing
AODVroutediscoveryisdoneusing:
RouteRequest (RREQ)andRouteReply (RREP)Messages
Sourcefloods RREQmessages:

E
F

C
G
B

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

53

ZigBee Routing
AODVroutediscoveryisdoneusing:
RouteRequest (RREQ)andRouteReply (RREP)Messages
Reverepaths areformedwhennodeshearRREQ:

E
F

C
G
B

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

54

ZigBee Routing
AODVroutediscoveryisdoneusing:
RouteRequest (RREQ)andRouteReply (RREP)Messages
RREQflooding continuesinthenetwork:

E
F

C
G
B

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

55

ZigBee Routing
AODVroutediscoveryisdoneusing:
RouteRequest (RREQ)andRouteReply (RREP)Messages
Reverepaths areformedwhennodeshearRREQ:

E
F

C
G
B

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

56

ZigBee Routing
AODVroutediscoveryisdoneusing:
RouteRequest (RREQ)andRouteReply (RREP)Messages
RREPmessage(s)is/aresentthroughreversepath(s):

E
F

C
G
B

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

57

ZigBee Routing
AODVroutediscoveryisdoneusing:
RouteRequest (RREQ)andRouteReply (RREP)Messages
Thiswillleadtoforming/discoveringforwardpath(s):

E
F

C
G
B

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

58

www.ti.com

ZigBee Building Solutions

AutomaticNotification:Calltheownerifproblemoccurs.
DoorControl:Whenthedoorislocked,lightsareturnedoff.
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

59

www.ti.com

ZigBee Building Solutions

Smartappliances canalsocommunicatewithsmartmeters.
Example:Theycanobtainpricesandadjusttheirload.(Topic4!)
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

60

ZigBee Building Solutions

www.ti.com

ZigBee solutionsbyTexasInstrument(TI)atdifferentlayers:

RefertoTIsZigBee pagesformoredetail.
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

61

ZigBee Collocation with WiFi

Ref:P.Yietal.

ZigBee andWiFi collocateat2.4GHzFrequencyBand

Inadditiontomediumaccesscontrol:
Theyshouldautomaticallyavoid commonchannels.
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

62

ZigBee Collocation with WiFi


ZigBee andWiFi collocateat2.4GHzFrequencyBand

(3OrthogonalChannels)

WiFi:

Ref:P.Yietal.

ZigBee:

ZigBee (orWiFi orboth)shouldsearch forunusedchannels.


Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

63

ZigBee Collocation with WiFi


AnAlgorithmforZigBee ChannelSwitching:
PER:PacketErrorRate
TobecheckedbyEndDevice

LQI:LinkQualityIndicator
TobecheckedbyRouter/Coordinator
From0 to255 [Strongest]

ED:EnergyDetection

Ref:P.Yietal.

Strength ofReceivedPackets

RSSI:ReceivedSignalStrengthIndicator
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

64

ZigBee Collocation with WiFi


ExperimentalResultsbyP.Yietal.toobtain:
SafeDistance
SafeOffsetFrequency

Ref:P.Yietal.

WiFI UplinkandDownlinkassourceofinterferenceonZigBee:

PERvs Distance(Meter)
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

65

ZigBee Collocation with WiFi

Ref:P.Yietal.

At7MHzFrequencyOffset,SafeDistanceis5Meter.

PERvs Distance(Meter)
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

66

ZigBee Collocation with WiFi

Ref:P.Yietal.

8MHzisSafeFrequencyOffsetregardlessofDistance.

PERvs Distance(Meter)

Wecandosimilarexperimentsforothertechnologies.
OnecanalsostudyZigBee interferenceonWiFi [thereverse!].
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

67

Z-Wave
AnalternativehomeareanetworkingtechnologyforZigBee:
ToresolveZigBee/WiFi collocationproblem.

ZWaveoperatesataround900MHzband
ItdoesnotcollocatewithWiFi
Itmaycompetewithsomecordlesstelephones
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

68

Z-Wave
SimilartoZigBee,ZWaveaimstobuildasmarthome:
AwirelessHANecosystem

ZWaveappliancescanparticipateinAMI,AMR,andDemandResponse

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

69

Smart Grid Communications

WirelessMeshNetworks
(MetropolitanArea)

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

70

Wireless Mesh Networks (WMNs)


WMNsarecomposedofseveral wirelessaccesspoints(routers).
UsuallyWiFi orWiMax Routers

Together,theycreateafullywirelesscommunicationbackbone:
Toservewirelessmeshclients(fixed/mobile)

TheWMNcanbeconnectedtotheInternetorothernetworks:
Throughafewgatewayrouters

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

71

Wireless Mesh Networks (WMNs)


Example:aWMNwithInternetandCellularConnectivity:

Ref:Akyildiz etal.

FullyWireless
Backbone

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

72

Wireless Mesh Networks (WMNs)

Ref:Akyildiz etal.

Example:WirelessMeshRouters

WithTwo Network
InterfaceCards(NICs)

WithOne Network
InterfaceCard

Q:WhatisthebenefitofhavingmultipleNICsonaWirelessMeshRouet?

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

73

Wireless Mesh Networks (WMNs)

Ref:Akyildiz etal.

Example:WirelessMeshClients

(a)Laptop,(b)PDA,(c)WiFiIPPhoneand(d)WiFiRFIDReader.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

74

WMNs Applications Before Smart Grid


SomeoftheInitialApplicationsofWMNsincluded:
CommunityNetworks
EnterpriseNetworks
LocalAreaNetworksforHotels,Malls,Parks,Trains,etc.
MetropolitanAreaNetworks

Citywide WMNshavebeendeployedinmultipleU.S.cities.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

75

City-Wide Wireless Mesh Networking

Tempe,AZWirelessMeshNetwork
Nearly600MeshAccessPoints
CoveragetoanAreaof40SquareMiles
ProjectCompletedinonly120days!

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

76

WMNs Benefits
SomeoftheadvantagesofWMNs:
Lowupfrontcosts
Easeofincrementaldeployment
Easeofmaintenance

Thewirelessmeshclients canalsobe:
SmartMeters,Sensors,Substations,etc.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

77

WMNs for Smart Grid Communications

MeshRouter

www.tropos.com

Aggregator

VideotoWatch:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=09dhjDcaT7g
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

78

Tropos Wireless Mesh Routers for Smart Grid

WirelessTechnology:IEEE802.11b/g/n
FrequencyBand:2.42.483GHz
MediaAccessProtocol:CSMA/CAwithACK
Dimensions:15.16highx6.97widex2.01deep
Weight:4.0lbs
Windsurvivability:>165mph
Tropos 1410Wireless
MeshRouters

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

CommunicationRange:About100m

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

79

WMNs Challenges
KeychallengesinWMNs:
WirelessInterferenceandFrequentCollisions
WirelessMultihop Transmissions(e.g.,forTCPconnections)
Congestion atGateways(Q:Why?)

DoE hasrequirementsforSmartGridCommunications [willsee]:


PacketLossandDelay(Q:Howcanweassurethese?)

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

80

Modeling Packet Loss in WMNs


Considertwowirelesslinksi andj:
Pi:transmitpower oflinkis transmitternode
Gij:channelgain fromlinkjs transmittertolinkis receiver.
G21

t1

r2

Link1

Link2

r1
t2

AsimplemodelforGij =k(dij)2,wheredij isthedistance.


Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

81

Modeling Packet Loss in WMNs


ReceivedSignal Poweratlinkis receivernode:
Gii Pi

ReceivedInterference Poweratlinkis receiverfromjs transmitter

Gij Pj

Similarly,wecanobtaininterferencepowerfromall otherlinks.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

82

Modeling Packet Loss in WMNs


Wecandefinesignaltointerferenceratio(SIR) forlinki as:
Gii Pi
SIRi
Gik Pk

SignalPower
AggregateInterferencePower

k i

Forcorrectreceptionofthepacket,itisrequiredthat
SIRi SIR th

(Threshold)

Otherwise,thepacketislost.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

83

Modeling Packet Loss in WMNs


Theprobabilityoflosingthepacketonlinki:

Oi Prob SIRi SIR th


(Outage)

Prob Gii Pi SIR th Gik Pk


k i

KeyQuestion:Whyarewetalkingaboutprobabilityhere?
Whatisthestochastic/randompart?

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

84

Modeling Packet Loss in WMNs


Obviouslynotall nodestransmitatall times!

Weassumesomerandomdistributionforpackettransmission.

Ifnodestransmitfollowingindependentexponentialdistributions:
1
th
SIR
Gik Pk
k i
1
Gii Pi

Oi 1

[Proof:SeeAppendixIinIEEETWCpaperbyS.Kandukuri andS.Boyd]

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

85

Modeling Packet Loss in WMNs


Letusconsiderthepacketlossmodelagain:
1
Oi 1
SIR th Gik Pk
k i
1
Gii Pi

ProbabilityofpacketlossincreasesIf:
Linki transmitswithlower power
Interferinglinkstransmitwithhigher power
Interferinglinksgetcloser
Therearemore interferinglinksintheneighborhood
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

86

Modeling Packet Loss in WMNs


Themodelsofaronlygivesperlinkpacketloss.

Q:Howaboutendtoendpacketlossprobability?
MeshRouter
Aggregator

Afullywirelessmultihop communication!
SmartMeter
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

87

Modeling Packet Loss in WMNs


Link2

Link3

Link4

Aggregator

Link1
PerlinkLossProbabilities:O1,O2,O3,andO4.

SmartMeter

EndtoendProbabilityofPacketLoss(Q:Why?):
OPath 1 (1 O1 )(1 O2 )(1 O3 )(1 O4 )

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

88

Modeling Packet Loss in WMNs


Ingeneral,forapathwithR asthesetofwirelesslinks:
OPath 1 (1 Oi )
iR

ForeachpathinWMN(e.g.,AMI),wecancalculateOpath ifknow
Locationsofthemeshroutersandclients(channelgains)
Transmitpowerofmeshroutersandclients
TheSIRthresholdvaluesforthetechnologybeingused
[Example:YoucancheckifitsatisfiestheDoE requirements!]
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

89

Modeling Packet Loss in WMNs


Wewantlowperlinklossratesforlinkscloser toaggregator:

Link3

Link2
Link1

Link4

Aggregator

Link6

Link5
O4 shouldbelow!(Q:Why?)

SmartMeter

SmartMeter
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

90

Modeling Packet Loss in WMNs


Q:Howcanweassurerequiredpacketlossboundsforall path?

Firstofall,weshouldnothavepathsthataretoolong!
ThisrequireshavingseveralgatewaysinlargeWMNs.

Second,weneedtodoresourcemanagement:
Powerallocation,channelassignment,etc.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

91

Channel Assignment in WMNs


AssumethatweuseWiFi technologyforourWMN.
Letuslookattheavailable11channels inIEEE802.11b:
1234 5 6 7891011

PartiallyOverlapping:1and2NonOverlapping:1and6and11

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

92

Channel Assignment in WMNs


Weassigndifferentnonoverlappingchannelstodifferentlinks:
Link2
Ch6

Link1

Link3

Link4

Ch11

Aggregator

Ch1

Ch1
Links1,2,and3willnolonger interfereoneachother.
SmartMeter

Links1and4mayinterfere,buttheyarefar fromeachother.

Suchmultichanneldeploymentrequiresmeshrouterswithmultiple NICs.(Q:Why?)

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

93

Channel Assignment in WMNs


Sameideaappliestoamorecomplexnetwork:

Aggregator

ChannelassignmentdependsonthenumberofNICspernode.
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

94

Channel Assignment in WMNs


Sameideaappliestoamorecomplexnetwork:

6
1

Aggregator
6

11

11

6
11
6

11
6

1
1

ChannelassignmentdependsonthenumberofNICspernode.
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

95

Channel Assignment in WMNs


Sameideaappliestoamorecomplexnetwork:

6
1

Aggregator
6

11

11

6
11
6

11
6

1
1

KnowingNIC=2:Q:Doyouseemorethan2channelspernode?
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

96

Channel Assignment in WMNs


Here,wehavethreedifferentcontentiondomains:
Channel1:SevenLinks
Channel6:FiveLinks
Channel11:FourLinks

Notethatlinksonchannel1arefarfromeachother
Wecanbetterremoveinterferencewithmorechannels/NICs.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

97

ATCP for WMNs


Whenitcomestowirelessnetworks:
Packetlossduetolinkfailure/interferencecanaffectTCP.
Theproblem:TCPbackoff everytimeapacketislost.
OneSolution:AdhocTransmissionControlProtocol(TCP)
ATCPusesnetworkfeedback:
ICMPDestinationUnreachable (whenapathbreaks)
EarlyCongestionNotification (whenthereiscongestion)
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

98

ATCP for WMNs


Thekeyidea:Wewanttodistinguish:
Packetlossduetocongestion
Packetlossduetowirelessinterference/collision

ECNFlags:Indicationofcongestion

Timeoutand3duplicateACKs:Indicationofcollision/linkproblem
[Linkproblemscanbebecauseofmobility]
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

99

ATCP for WMNs


ATCPintheTCP/IPStack:

ItonlyaffectstheTCPsenderside.Itisacrosslayersolution.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

100

ATCP for WMNs


ATCP/TCPBehavior:
Timeoutand3rd DuplicateACK:
Retransmitthesegment
NoCongestionControlReaction
Assumedtobeduetolinkcollision
ACKwithECNFlag:
InvokesCongestionControl
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

101

ATCP for WMNs


ATCP/TCPBehavior:
ICMPDestinationUnreachableMessage:
StopsTransmission
EntersPersistMode
StartsPersistTimer
ProbesforPathAvailabilitywhenTimerExpires
ResumeTransmissionwhenNewPathFound

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

102

Smart Grid Communications

IEC61850
(CommunicationsofSubstations)

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

103

IEC 61850 Overview


IEC:InternationalElectrotechnical Commission

IEC61850
SmartGridCommunicationsStandard
CommunicationsacrossIntelligentElectronicDevices (IEDs)
Focus:Substations(butalsosupportsmeters,etc.)
RunsoverTCP/IP networks
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

104

IEC 61850 Overview

Ref:ABBSwitzerlandLtdCorporateResearch

ExampleSubstation:

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

105

IEC 61850 Overview


IEC61850Aimstoprovideinteroperability

Key focus: IEC 61850 provides a comprehensive model for


how power system devices should organize data in a manner
that is consistent across all types and brands of devices.

TheIEC61850devicesareintendedtobeplugandplay.

Theyareconfiguredbyuploadingsimpleconfigurationfiles.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

106

IEC 61850 Overview


IEC61850NetworkArchitecture:
XCBR

MMXU1
PhysicalDevice
(DataConcentrator)

MMXU2
LogicalDevices/Nodes

XCBR:CircuitBreaker,MMXU1:MeasurementUnitforFeeder1,
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

107

IEC 61850 Overview


Datatypestobetransmittedforeachlogicaldevice:
Shouldfollowcertainspecifications:

ObjectNameDataClassName(DataStructure)
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

108

IEC 61850 Overview


Datatypestobetransmittedforeachlogicaldevice:
(Cont.)

ObjectNameDataClassName(DataStructure)
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

109

IEC 61850 Data Classes


Example:SPS:SinglePointStatus
(Cont.)

ST:Status
DC:Description
SV:Substitution

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

110

IEC 61850 Data Classes


OtherDataClasses:
Statusinformation(binary,integer):
SPS:SinglePointStatus
DPS:DoublePointStatus
INS:IntegerStatus
ACT:ProtectionActivationinfo
ACD:ActivationInfoDirectionalProtection
SEC:SecurityViolationCounting
BCR:BinaryCounterReading
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

111

IEC 61850 Data Classes


OtherDataClasses:
ControlStatus:
SPC:SinglePointControl
DPC:DoublePointControl
INC:IntegerStatusControl
BSC:BinaryControlledStepPositionInfo
ISC:IntegerControlledStepPositionInfo

JustliketheexampleforSPS,eachitemhasadatastructure.
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

112

IEC 61850 Logical Nodes


RecallthatweusednamesXCBR,MMXU1,forlogicalnodes.

Thefirstletter indicatesthetype forthelogicalnode:


X:Switchgear
M:MeteringandMeasurement
A:AutomaticControl
C:SupervisoryControl
G:GenericFunction

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

113

IEC 61850 Logical Nodes


RecallthatweusednamesXCBR,MMXU1,forlogicalnodes.

Thefirstletterindicatesthetypeforthelogicalnode:
I:Interfacing
P:Protection
S:Sensors
T:InstrumentTransformer
Y:PowerTransformers

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Z:Otherdevices

Texas Tech University

114

IEC 61850 Logical Nodes

Ref:ABBSwitzerlandLtdCorporateResearch

Example:Canyouidentifydifferentlogicalnodes?

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

115

IEC 61850 Logical Nodes


IEC61850givesanobjectorientedmodelforcommunications.

ExampleforObjectNames:

WewouldliketoknowifthecircuitbreakerlogicalnodeXCBR1 in
logicaldeviceRelay1 isintheremoteorlocal modeofoperation.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

116

IEC 61850 Logical Nodes


TheobjectnamesareusedtoformMMSmessages:
MMS:ManufacturingMessagingSpecification

Themessagesareexchangedasapplicationlayer messages.

TheMMSmessagesareexchangedoverTCP/IPnetworks
LAN
WebBased
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

117

Smart Grid Communications

PowerLineCommunications

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

118

PLC Overview
PowerLineCommunications(PLC):
Carryingdataonaconductoralso usedforpowertransmission

PLCisawiredcommunicationstechnology
Butitcancompetewithwirelesstechnologieswithlowcost
Becausetheinfrastructurealreadyexists

Harshenvironmentofthepowertransmissionlines.
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

119

PLC Overview
Idea:
Digitalsignaltobetransmittedismodulatedover powerline.
Thisisdonebyapropercouplerdevice.
Thesignalispropagatedoverthepowerline.
Itwillbedecoupledanddecodedatthereceiverside.

Inductivecoupler
PLCModem

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

120

PLC Overview

Ref:H.C.Ferreiraetal.

HarshNoiseEnvironment:

Powerspectraldensitiesofnoise duetovarioussources

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

121

PLC Classes
ThreeclassesofPLCTechnologies:
Broadband(BB):
Operatingat1.8 250MHz.
DataRate:Upto200Mbps
InitialApplication:ResidentialInternetAccess
ShortCommunicationRange(fewkilometers)
GoodforAMI/AMR,NotGoodforsubstations(Q:Why?)

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

122

PLC Classes
ThreeclassesofPLCTechnologies:
Broadband(BB):

Gateway/
Internet

Example:Residentialbroadbandaccess/AMI/AMR

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

123

PLC Classes
ThreeclassesofPLCTechnologies:
Narrowband(NB):
Operatingat3 500kHz.
UnitedStatesFCC:10490kHz
DataRate:Upto500kbps(usuallyseveralkbps)
Consideredforsubstationcommunications

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

124

PLC Classes
ThreeclassesofPLCTechnologies:
UltraNarrowband(UNB):
Operatingat30Hz 3kHz.
DataRate:Upto100bps(verylow,butgoodenough!)
CommunicationRange:150km ormore
CurrentApplications:
AMI,AMR,DemandResponse(DirectLoadControl)

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

125

HomePlug
HomePlug isanindustryAlliancetoenableandpromotePLC:

HomePlug 1.0:ResidentialInternet
HomePlug AV:ResidentialCableTV
HomePlug GreenPHY:SmartGridApplications(inhome)
Wiredalternative/additiontoZigBee andZWaveforHAN
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

126

Smart Grid Communications

DoE Requirementsfor
SmartGridCommunications

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

127

DoE Smart Grid Communication Requirements

Notthathigh!
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

128

Smart Grid Communications

OtherSmartGrid
CommunicationsTechnologies

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

129

Ref:V.C.Gngretal.

Other Smart Grid Communication Technologies

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

130

Ref:V.C.Gngretal.

Other Smart Grid Communication Technologies

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

131

References
A. VanNieuwenhuyse, M. Alves, and A. Kouba, "On the use of
the ZigBee protocol for Wireless Sensor Networks", Technical
Report, IPP Hurray, Jun 2006. [Online] http://www.open
zb.net/publications/trhurray060603.pdf.
P. Yi, A. Iwayemi, and C. Zhou, "Developing ZigBee Deployment
Guideline Under WiFi Interference for Smart Grid Applications",
IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, Vol. 2, No. 1, pp. 110120,
March 2011.
S. Safaric and K.~Malaric, "ZigBee Wireless Standard", Proc. of
the IEEE International Symposium on Multimedia Signal
Processing and Communications, Zadar, Croatia, June 2006.
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

132

References
M. Armel, "ZigBee Overview", Lecture Notes, The George
Washington Univ. 2007. [Online] http://www.seas.gwu.edu/
~cheng/388/LecNotes2007/ZigBee.pdf.
S. C. Ergen, "ZigBee/IEEE 802.15.4 Summary", Technical
Report, University of California Berkeley, September 2004. [On
Line] http://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~suman/courses/838/papers/
zigbee.pdf.
ZigBee Alliance, "ZigBee and Wireless Radio Frequency
Coexistence", Document Number: Zigbee_075219, June 2007,
[OnLine] www.zigbee.org.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

133

References
ZigBee Alliance, "ZigBee Overview", Document Number:
Zigbee_075482, June 2007, [OnLine] www.zigbee.org.
J. Liu and S. Singh, ATCP: TCP for mobile Ad Hoc Networks,
IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications, pp. 1300
1315, vol. 19, no. 7, July 2001.
S. Kandukuri and S. Boyd, "Optimal power control in
interferencelimited fading wireless channels with outage
probability specifications", IEEE Transactions on Wireless
Communications, pp. 46 55, vol. 1, no. 1, January 2002.
I. Akyildiz, X. Wang, and W. Wang, "Wireless Mesh Networks: A
Survey," Computer Networks, vol. 47, pp. 445487, March 2005.
Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

134

References
Department of Energy, Communications Requirements of
Smart Grid Technologies", October 5, 2010.
G. Iyer, P. Agrawal, E. Monnerie, R.S. Cardozo, Performance
analysis of wireless mesh routing protocols for smart utility
networks, in Proc. of the IEEE International Conference on
Smart Grid Communications, Brussels, Belgium, October 2011.
M. ErolKantarci, H. T. Mouftah, Wireless Sensor Networks for
CostEfficient Residential Energy Management in the Smart
Grid, IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 314
325, June 2011.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

135

References
M. Adamiak, D. Baigent, and R. Mackiewicz, IEC 61850
Communication Networks and Systems In Substations: An
Overview for Users, in Proc. of Syst. Protection Seminar, 2004.
V. C. Gngr, D. Sahin, T. Kocak, S. Ergt, C. Buccella, C. Cecati,
G. P. Hancke, Smart Grid Technologies: Communication
Technologies and Standards, IEEE Transactions on Industrial
Informatics, vol. 7, no. 4, pp. 529539, November 2011.
H.C. Ferreira, H.M. Grovk, 0. Hooijen, and A.J. HanVinck,
Power Line Communications: An Overview, Proc. of the IEEE
AFRICON, Stellenbosch , South Africa, September 1996.

Dr. Hamed Mohsenian-Rad

Communications and Control in Smart Grid

Texas Tech University

136

Вам также может понравиться