Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Prologue:
Business Turnaround Strategies: Rescue Management
We often hear this story. A company records phenomenal growth. It makes the Fortune 500 list. It
soon rises to national glory. The companys operational and financial performances become new
benchmarks or industry standards. The company is hailed as the industry champion. The Wall Street
analysts rave about it. Competitors try to emulate it. The CEO is venerated as a hero, a charismatic
leader and an executive icon. Then something happens. The company stumbles. The sales are down,
the market share is fast eroding, the profits are negative, and the companys stock plummets. Soon, the
Wall Street features another similar story, the story of downfall. Strange as this business fairytale cycle is,
it happens repeatedly. In short, business reversals are becoming more and more a business norm today
(Gilson 2001). Currently, corporate success has been very fragile. It has become less persistent. This
book captures and analyzes this phenomenon.
Why do good and great companies go suddenly bad? What can you do to predict and prevent such
failure? What can you do to turnaround sick companies, or resurrect them and even transform them?
When companies are on the brink of failure or bankruptcy they need quick and effective actions to bring
about a speedy and effective business turnaround. Planning and monitoring dynamism, energy,
innovation and good planning of any business are important turnaround tasks that should be started much
before distress or insolvency sets in. This book is all about business turnarounds. Our focus is rescue
strategies.
They can create additional slack and reduce restrictions on debt covenants. They have definite positive
effects on share prices such as higher share prices, reduced share-price volatility, increased value of stock
options, lower cost of equity capital, and increased market evaluation. Additionally, they can boost profitbased bonuses and other corporate benefits. Nevertheless, they all mislead and misreport financial results
that appear in corporate official financial statements that investment bankers, investors, creditors and
shareholders read and on which they base their investment decisions. When some insider whistle- blows
or external financial analysts discover and expose these fraudulent acts, the companies undertake several
adjustments, often restating financial statements of prior years.
Unfortunately, the investor public comes to know of these acts too late that is, after investmentdecisions have been made and share prices have fallen precipitously (Mulford and Comiskey 2005).
Accordingly, corporate frauds and, hence, corporate failures leading to bankruptcies, have ever been on
the increase, reaching all-time highs in 2001-2002 (see Forbes 2002; Fortune 2002). Fraud experts, fraud
auditors and forensic accountants estimate that the costs of white-collar crime average about twenty times
the costs of street crimes each year (Singleton et al. 2006).
How to resolve the day-to-day operational problems of cash flow management and
How to restructure the debt and equity of the business until the corporation is back on its feet again.
Both are operational problems. Turnaround is the word that we often use to refer to the process of
solving both operational problems in a business decline. Turnaround-rescue strategies deal with the first
problem that primarily relates to cash flow management, and turnaround-restructuring strategies deal with
the second problem that most often relates to long-term debt-equity issues. Typically, business
turnarounds deal with both rescue and restructuring strategies in relation to failing corporations. Under
both strategies, turnaround management means improving the position of a given business as a low-cost
provider of increasingly differentiated products and services in a highly competitive world (Bibeault
1998; Zimmerman 1991:111). Restructuring is the term used to describe the process of developing a
financial structure that will provide a basis for a turnaround (Gilson 2001).
This book attempts to describe, analyze, synthesize, detect and prevent various corporate failure
phenomena under the rubric of business turnaround management (BTM). A turnaround situation must be
identified, assessed and resolved using principles and functions of business management such as human
resources management, motivation management, business law, accounting, finance, production,
operations research, marketing research, promotions and advertising and public relations management.
Hence, BTM is normally a subset of and a sequel to the traditional masters in business administration
(MBA).
In the classical MBA programs, we primarily train students to handle ongoing business and nonbusiness concerns. The traditional MBA courses, in general, implicitly presume that the organization is
healthy and, accordingly, impart to students principles, theories, skills and techniques of running day-today healthy business operations. On the contrary, business turnaround management (BTM) principles,
processes and practices assume that the organization is underperforming, declining, demoralized,
pathologically sick, organically troubled, in a cash crisis mode, financially distressed or insolvent, or
approaching bankruptcy and death. Given the high incidence of current business failures, the chances that
our MBA students will encounter corporate sickness sometime early in their business careers are very
high. Business Turnaround Strategies: Rescue Management: empowers students to detect, face and
combat corporate sickness effectively.
Typical BTM programs, therefore, should have two sequential stages: a) Rescue Strategies to revive
the failing business and b) Transformation Strategies to revitalize and transfigure the revived business.
This book focuses primarily on Rescue Strategies. The latter is published already; see (Mascarenhas
2011) Business Transformation Strategies: The Role of the CEO as Innovation Leader. Both rescue and
transformation strategies must be legal, human, ethical and moral. We discussed these aspects in an
earlier book, especially in relation to responsible marketing (Mascarenhas 2008). Another book
(Mascarenhas 2013) will focus primarily on ethical and moral aspects of business turnaround
management.
new program, Business Turnaround Management an MBA Program with steroids! I hope that this book
will pioneer this new movement beyond the traditional MBA domain and discipline.
Every turnaround situation is a corporate problem that must be timely and effectively
resolved. As a concluding synthesis and Epilogue, Chapter Fourteen studies the nature and
challenges of business turnaround problems and proposes systems-thinking and critical-thinking
principles for defining, identifying, formulating, specifying, and resolving such problems and for
ethically assessing the solution alternatives.
Figure 1 lays out the plan of this book. Every company needs a turnaround process (Ch 2), either
proactively to fight against external constantly changing domestic markets, government regulations and
ordinances, and globalizing factors, or reactively to survive against internal underperformance, distress,
cash flow crisis, insolvency, or bankruptcy situations (Ch 1). An ongoing concern will engage in
transformation strategies (see Mascarenhas 2011), or a struggling company will focus on various rescue
strategies (Chs. 3-14).
Each chapter provides a series of very practical, insightful and carefully framed Turnaround
Executive Exercises highlighting the major concepts and constructs, theories and models, strategies and
implications covered in that chapter. A serious student and scholar will learn best from this book by
doing those exercises.
This book is positioned for MBA students concentrating on BTM, for students pursuing Certificate
and/or Masters in BTM, for managers preparing for CTP (Certified Turnaround Professionals), CIRA
(Certified Insolvency and Restructurings Advisor), and for TMA (Turnaround Management Association)
members requiring professional updates, and the like. Turnaround executives and experts could profit
from any chapter, especially the first two.
Acknowledgements
My academic background is philosophy, theology, economics and marketing with over 30 years of
teaching and research in corporate strategy in general and marketing and business turnaround
management, in particular. Several professors have influenced me during my management studies. I am
especially indebted to Russell Ackoff, Paul Green, Len Lodish and Howard Perlmutter of the Wharton
School of Business, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, where I obtained MBA and Ph.D.
This book represents my latest research and thinking in the critical domain of business turnaround
management, especially with a focus on rescue strategies. This work has taken over six years from
conception to execution. The origins of this book are linked with the business turnaround management
(BTM) program that I designed in 2002 with the active collaboration of several business turnaround
executives who were members of the MBA Advisory Board of the College of Business Administration,
University of Detroit Mercy, Detroit, Michigan. From its early beginnings, the BTM program was uniquely
conceived, developed and delivered in continuous partnership with the turnaround industry. Soon, a
Steering Committee of over twenty-four senior executives of turnaround companies formed the industrial
backbone for the formulation and implementation of the Masters level BTM program. The contents of this
book were originally delivered as a gateway course in Business Management starting from 2002 titled,
Business Turnaround Management: An Overview. In its early stages, this course covered both rescue and
transformation strategies. Within a few years, the course rapidly grew in content, depth and breadth that it
gave birth to a full masters level program in 2007, a pioneering program, the first of its kind in the business
academic world. This book focuses only on rescue strategies. A sequel to this book (Mascarenhas 2011)
focuses on transformation strategies. I am grateful to the on-going inspiration and support the BTM
Steering Committee gave me throughout the production of this book.
Each chapter of this book has been read and discussed by my students since 2002. Comments and
suggestions of hundreds of graduate students have benefited me in the final editions of each chapter and I
am very grateful. In addition, my fellow academicians have critiqued several chapters of this book, and
their constructive criticisms have been incorporated. In this connection, I am particularly grateful to Ken
Kuna and Eugene Greenstein, both Steering Committee members and my fellow companions in the BTM
journey. My niece, Sunita Elisha, painstakingly prepared the Contents in Brief and Contents in Detail for
this book. Several graduate research assistants have been my rescue in this long production process: Jim
Linton proofread and critiqued the entire manuscript with his wonted professionalism in English; B. N.
Aravindan, Dipesh Mehta, Tarun Nandkishore and Ramesh Venkataraman provided technical assistance in
formatting the entire text, its contents, and in constructing the author, company and subject indexes.
Oswald A. J. Mascarenhas S. J., Ph.D.
Director: Business Turnaround Management Graduate Programs
Charles H. Kellstadt Professor of Marketing, College of Business and Administration
University of Detroit Mercy, Detroit, Michigan
Since July 2010:
Chairman: MBA Programs,
St. Aloysius (Autonomous) College, AIMT Campus, Beeri, Mangalore 575022
Environmental
Pressure:
Shrinking markets
Acknowledgments
Industry stagnation
Increasing competition
Globalization
Government regulations
Proactive
Transformation Strategies:
(Mascarenhas 2011)
Transformation
Management:
Rightsizing
Upsizing
Redesigning
Reengineering
Retrofitting
The Turnaround
Process:
Types, nature, content, and
determinants of business
turnaround processes (Ch
2)
Rescue Strategies:
(Mascarenhas 2014)
Reactive
Organizational
Turnaround
Situation:
Underperformance
Decline, distress,
Cash crisis, insolvency
Bankruptcy & death
(Ch 1)
Organizational
Rescue
Management:
Downsizing
Resizing
Plant Closings
Outsourcing
Debt-restructuring
References
Barney, Jay B. (2001), Gaining and Sustaining Competitive Advantage, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Beer, Michael and Nitin Nohria (2000), Cracking the Code for Change, Harvard Business Review (May-June); see
also HBR on Turnarounds, pp. 1-23.
Bibeault, Donald B. (1998), Corporate Turnaround: How Managers Turn Losers into Winners, 2nd edition, Beard
Group.
Collins, Jim and Jerry I. Porras (1997), Built to Last: Successful Habits of Visionary Companies. Harper Business.
Collins, Jim (2001), Good to Great. Harper Business.
Copeland, Tom, Tim Koller and Jack Murrin (1996), Valuation: Measuring and Managing the Value of Companies,
New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Dobbs, Richard F. C. and Timothy M. Koller (1998), The Expectations Treadmill, The McKinsey Quarterly,
Summer, Issue 3, 10-17.
Forbes Magazine (2002), Recent Accounting Frauds, www.Forbes.com.accountingtracker.html) July 25.
Fortune Magazine (2002), Recent Corporate Scams, September 2, 64-74.
Gavetti, Giovanni and Jan W. Rivkin (2005), How Strategists really Think: Tapping the Power of Analogy, Harvard
Business Review, (April), 54-65.
Ghemavat, Pankaj (2007), Managing Differences: The Central Challenge of Global Strategy, Harvard Business
Review, (March), 58-68.
Gilson, Stuart C. (2001), Creating Value through Corporate Restructuring: Studies in Bankruptcy, Buyouts, and
Breakups. John Wiley & Sons.
Greenwald, Bruce and Judd Kahn (2005), All Strategy is Local, Harvard Business Review, (September), 94-107.
Guzik, Ronald E. and Marc Kramer (2002), Build your Business Stronger: And do it Quickly. Humanomics
Publishing.
Hamel, Gary and Lisa Vlikangas (2003), The Quest for Resilience, Harvard Business Review, (September), 5265.
Hartman, Amir (2004), Ruthless Execution: What Business Leaders do When their Companies Hit the Wall. Upper
Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Jones, Thomas O. and Earl W. Sasser (1995), Why Satisfied Customers Defect, Harvard Business Review, 73
(November-December), 88-99.
Kaplan, Robert S. and David P. Norton (2005), The Office of Strategy Management, Harvard Business Review,
(October), 72-81.
Kaplan, Robert S. and David P. Norton (2006), How to Implement a New Strategy without Disrupting your
Organization, Harvard Business Review, (March), 100-109.
Keiningham, Timothy and Terry Vavra (2002), The Customer Delight Principle, Marketing Management, 11:3
(May-June).
Kim, W. Chan and Rene Mauborgne (2004), Blue Ocean Strategy, Harvard Business Review, (October), 76-85.
Mascarenhas, Oswald A. (2008), Responsible Marketing: Concepts, Theories, Models, Strategies and Cases, North Richland
Hills, TX, Roval Publishing Co.
Mascarenhas, Oswald A. (2011), Business Transformation Strategies. The Role of the CEO as an Innovation Leader, Sage
Publications, New Delhi, New York, London, UK and Hong Kong.
Mascarenhas, Oswald A. (2014), Business Turnaround Management: Ethical Imperatives. Pearson Publications.
[Forthcoming]
McGrath, Rita Guenther and Ian C. MacMillan (2005), Market Busting: Strategies for Exceptional; Business
Growth, Harvard Business Review (March), 80-91
Mulford, Charles W. and Eugene E. Comiskey (2002), The Financial Numbers Game: Detecting Creative
Accounting Practices, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Mulford, Charles W. and Eugene E. Comiskey (2005), Creative Cash Flow Reporting: Uncovering Sustainable
Financial Performance, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Pate, Carter and Harlan Platt (2002), The Phoenix Effect: 9 Revitalizing Strategies No Business Can Do Without.
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Porter, Michael E. (1996), What is a Strategy? Harvard Business Review, 74: 6, 61-78.
Prahalad, C. K. and Venkatram Ramaswamy (2000), Co-opting Customer Experience, Harvard Business Review,
78 (January-February), 79-87.
Prahalad, C. K. and Venkatram Ramaswamy (2003), The Future of Competition: CO-Creating Unique Value with
Customers. Harvard Business School Press.
Rooke, David and William R. Torbert (2005), Transformations of Leadership, Harvard Business Review, (April),
66-76.
Sawhney, Mohanbir and Jeff Zabin (2002), Managing and Measuring Relational Equity in the Network Economy,
Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 30: (Fall), p. 320, 328.
Schilit, Howard M. (2002), Financial Shenanigans: How to Detect Accounting Gimmicks and Fraud in Financial
Reports, 2nd edition, McGraw-Hill.
Schneider, Benjamin and David E. Bowden (1999), Understanding Customer Delight and Outrage, MIT Sloan
Management Review, 41:1(Fall), 35-45.
Singleton, Tommie, Jack G. Bologna, Robert J. Lindquist and Aaron Singleton (2006), Fraud Auditing and Forensic
Accounting: New Tools and Techniques, 2nd edition. John Wiley & Sons.
Slatter, Stuart (1984), Corporate Recovery: Successful Turnaround Strategies and their Implementation.
Harmondsworth, UK: Penguin Books.
Stalk, George Jr. (2006), Curveball: Strategies to Fool the Competition, Harvard Business Review, (September),
114-123.
Stalk, George, Jr. and Ron Lachenauer (2004), Hardball: Are you Playing to Play or Playing to Win? Harvard
Business School Press.
Sudarsanam, Sudi (2003), Creating Value from Mergers and Acquisitions: The Challenges. The Financial Times:
Prentice-Hall.
Sutton, Gary (2001), The Six Month Fix: Adventures in Rescuing Failing Companies. John Wiley & Sons.
Zimmerman, Frederick M. (1991), The Turnaround Experience, New York: McGraw-Hill.
10