Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Introduction
Most
physicians believe
that
ultrasonography has limited usage in
chest diseases. However, since the introduction of the concept of the "ultrasonic window" (1), the applications of
chest ultrasound have been greatly extended. Chest ultrasound is not only useful for chest-wall or pleural-based lesions
(2-4), it is also very useful for evaluation
of and biopsy guidance of mediastinal
and peripheral pulmonary nodules (1,
5-7). In pulmonary consolidation, the
fluid-containing air spaces become a
good ultrasonic window. Lesions deep
seated in the consolidated lung can be
visualized by ultrasound (8). Fewreports
on the ultrasonic descriptions of pulmonary consolidation are available (9, 10).
We have found that high-resolution realtime ultrasound in conjunction with
Doppler ultrasound can be very useful
in the evaluation of pulmonary consolidation. Not only the air or fluid bronchogram, but also the abscess cavity of
necrotizing pneumonia and associated
tumors in the consolidated lung can be
detected by ultrasound (8, 11). We present our experience with chest ultrasound
in the evaluation of 161 cases of pulmonary consolidation. The ultrasonographic features and technical aspects are also
discussed.
Methods
One hundred seventy consecutive patients
with lobar or segmental consolidations were
examined by chest ultrasound from July 1988
to July 1990. Patients with (1) radiographic
evidenceof pneumonic consolidation that extended to the visceral pleura (ultrasonic window) and (2) an unsatisfactory response to
antibiotic treatment for at least 1 wk were referred for ultrasonographic examinations.
There werenine patients whose consolidation
was not complete or not in contact with the
pleura to a large extent. The ultrasound examination in these patients was not successful. A total of 161 patients were evaluable;
113 were men and 48 were women, ranging
in age from 18 to 87 yr.
Forty-five patients also underwent chest
computerized tomography (CT scan) exami-
SUMMARY A total of 161 patients with lobar or segmental consolidation were examined by realtime ultrasound and Doppler ultrasound. Air bronchograms were detected In 141 patients, fluid bronchograms In 27 patients, and parapneumonic effusion In 74patients. In 36 patients with necrotizing
pneumonia, ultrasound detected mlcroabscesses in 33 (91.7%) compared with the air-fluid levels
detected by standard chest radiographs in 20 patients (55.6%; p < 0.05). Of 31 patients with tumors
causing obstructive pneumonitis, 29 (93.5%) had tumors detected by chest ultrasound, whereas
only 11patients (35.5%) had chest radiographs that suggested a tumor was causing the obstructive
pneumonitis (p < 0.05). Chest ultrasound was used to guide thoracentesis for parapneumonlc effusion In 65 patients, with a 100% success rate. Twenty-six patients with necrotizing pneumonia underwent ultrasound-guided needle aspiration of mlcroabscesses. The procedure was successful
in 24 patients (92.3%), and 21 patients (80.8%) had microbiologic confirmation. lWenty patients
with tumor-associated obstructive pneumonitis received needle aspiration biopsy under ultrasound
guidance; 19 patients (95.0%) had the histology confirmed. Five patients with malignancy manifesting as pulmonary consolidation underwent a diagnostic ultrasound-guided needle aspiration biopsy. Five patients (3.8%) developed complications of minimal pneumothorax or mild hemoptysis in
132 episodes of needle aspiration. We conclude that ultrasonography is useful for the evaluation
of pulmonary consolidation. It can also be used for needle aspiration guidance for etiologic diagnosis of patients with complicated pneumonia.
AM REV RESPIR DIS 1992; 146:757-762
nations (Somatom DR; SiemensMedical System, Iselin, NJ), and 58 patients underwent
fiberoptic bronchoscopy with or without biopsy.The final diagnoses of these 161 patients
were based on the results of the CT scan,
fiberoptic bronchoscopy, trans bronchial biopsy, percutaneous transthoracic aspiration
biopsy, and clinical follow-up.
Chest radiographs of all patients performed
during the same period of time as the ultrasound examination wereinterpreted by a radiologist and a chest physician without their
knowing the results of the bronchoscopic examination, CT scan, or chest ultrasound. Special note was made of the radiographic evidences of air bronchograms, microabscess
formation, tumor, and parapneumonic
effusion.
All patients underwent ultrasound examinations without prior knowledge of the bronchoscopy, CT scan, or chest-radiograph
results. The physicans who performed the
ultrasound examination had only information on the consolidated area present in the
chest radiographs to find the ultrasonic window. The patients were examined with realtime, linear-array, convexand sector ultrasonic units with a 3.5-MHz or a 5.0-MHz transducer (Aloka SSD 630 and Toshiba 100A;
Tokyo, Japan). The Toshiba l00A ultrasonic
units were also equipped with Doppler ultrasound, which can be used in conjunction with
sector units to evaluate blood flow. Patients
were scanned in a supine or prone position
757
758
could also be present inside the cavity. A tumor causing obstructive pneumonitis was a
well-defined,homogeneous, hypoechoic nodule or mass inside a consolidated lung, located near the hilum (8). Parapneumonic effusion showed as an echo-free space between
the visceralpleura and the parietal pleura that
could change shape with the respiratory
movement.
The echogenicity of the pulmonary consolidation, tumor, or microabscess was compared with the echogenicity of the liver and
defined as hypoechoic, isoechoic, or hyperechoic. The echogenicity of gallbladder was
used as a reference for anechoic lesions. The
sonographic results were compared with the
results of chest radiographs. The data were
analyzed statistically with the X! test.
After assessment of the ultrasonographic
features of the pulmonary consolidation,
those patients without a conclusivehistologic
diagnosis attained by conventional methods,
which included sputum and bronchoscopic
examinations underwent (after informed consent was obtained) ultrasound-guided needle
aspiration of the parapneumonic effusion,
microabscess, tumor, or even consolidated
lung parenchyma. The aspirated materials
were sent for bacteriologic, cytologic, and
histologic examination. A 22-gauge needle
with an outer sheath and an inner stylet was
used for aspiration. The ultrasound-guided
needle aspiration technique is detailed in
previous studies (1, 7, 8). The needle aspiration route was prechosen by the ultrasound
image to avoid passing through the bronchi
or major vessels. Repeated aspirations were
performed immediately if the aspirated material was inadequate for bacterial, cytologic, or histologic studies (8, 11). A routine chest
radiograph was taken on the day after the
needle aspiration to assess potential
complications.
Results
TABLE 1
CLINICAL DIAGNOSIS AND RESULTS OF ULTRASOUND-GUIDED
NEEDLE ASPIRATION IN 161 PATIENTS
WITH PULMONARY CONSOLIDATION
Clinical Diagnosis
Simple pneumonia
Necrotizing pneumonia
Tumor with obstructive
pneumonia
Malignancy
Parapneumonic effusion
Aspiration
Successful
Diagnosis
Confirmed
n
No. of
Cases
Aspiration
Done
89
36
16
26
12
24
75.0
92.3
6*
21
37.5
80.8
31
5
74
20
5
65
20
5
65
100.0
100.0
100.0
19
5
95.0
100.0
* Three patients had a Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection, one a cryptococcal infection, one a
Klebsiella pneumoniae pneumonia, and one a Pseudomonas aeruginosa pneumonia.
Ultrasonographic Features oj
Pulmonary Consolidation
The consolidated lung was triangular in
shape, hypoechoic, and heterogeneous in
echotexture. The air bronchograms
presented as arborizing hyperechoic lines
arising from the hilar region. The scattered hyperechoic linear echoes could
change shape with respiration (figure 1).
The fluid bronchograms showed branching, hyperechoic, parallel lines or tubular structures. The fluid bronchograms
usually paralleled the pulmonary vessels.
Doppler ultrasound was excellent in
demonstrating blood flow present in the
pulmonary vasculature (figure 2). The
759
Ultrasound-guided Aspiration of
Pulmonary Consolidation
Of 74 patients with parapneumonic effusion, nine had pleural effusions that
wereso evident on the chest radiographs
760
Fig. 4. (A) A 75-yr-old man with obstructive pneumonia at the left lower lobe. (B)
Chest ultrasound shows an irregular
hypoechoic tumor (T) inside the consolidated lung. There is a minimal amount
of parapneumonic effusion (E). The effusion cytology is negative for malignancy; however, needle aspiration biopsy
from the tumor shows squamous cell
carcinoma.
761
TABLE 2
TABLE 3
Morphology
Ultrasound
Air bronchogram
Fluid bronchogram
Parapneumonic effusion
Tumor with obstructive pneumonitis
(n = 31)
Necrotizing pneumonia with cavity
(n = 36)
141
27
74
Chest Radiograph
p Value*
106
42
29 (93.5%)
11 (35.5%)
< 0.05
33 (91.7%)
20 (55.6%)
< 0.05
Table 3 shows the microorganisms isolated from the aspirates. Twelve patients
had their treatment regimens modified
based on the culture results, and the lesions improved after an initial lack of response to antibiotics.
There were 29 patients who had
demonstrable tumors in the consolidated lung. All underwent a fiberoptic bronchoscopic examination. Nine patients
had histologic diagnoses 0 btained by
bronchoscopy with biopsy, 10 patients
No. of
Isolates
Microorganism
had brushing cytology positive for malignancy, and 10 were negative. The 10 patients whose results werenegative and the
10patients who had only cytologic diagnoses made by bronchoscopic brushing
underwent an ultrasound-guided needle
aspiration biopsy for histologic diagnosis. Definite histologic diagnoses were
made in 19 cases (95.00/0). The material
aspirated from one patient yielded only
necrotic tissue. This patient was proven
to have a squamous cell carcinoma by a
Klebsiella pneumoniae
Pseudomonas aeruginosa
Staphylococcus aureus
Streptococcus viridans
Enterobacter cloacae
Haemophilus influenzae
Bacteroides melaninogenicus
Bacteroides fragilis
Peptostreptococcus
Microaerophilic streptococci
Aspergillus fumigatus
Total
5
3
2
2
1
1
1
2
2
5
2
26
762
nia is the most common cause, other conditions such as cancer infiltration or
tumors with obstructive pneumonia may
manifest as pulmonary consolidation
(12-14). Conventional chest radiographs
offer little information concerning the
underlying etiology or morphologic details of pulmonary consolidation (15).
Chest radiography may not be sensitive
enough to detect minimal effusion, necrotizing pneumonia, or tumors with obstructive pneumonitis. CT scans with
contrast study are superb in demonstrating the morphologic changes of pulmonary consolidation (16); however, a routine chest CT scan for pulmonary consolidation may be not cost effective. In
this study, we demonstrated that chest
ultrasound can be useful in evaluating
pulmonary consolidation. Parapneumonic effusions, necrotizing pneumonias, or tumors with obstructive pneumonitis can be clearly identified by chest
ultrasound. The sensitivity of chest ultrasound in demonstrating necrotizing pneumonia, parapneumonic effusion, and tumor with obstructive pneumonitis may
be higher than conventional chest radiographs, but this has not been confirmed
by CT scan.
Our results also showed that chest
ultrasound can be used for thoracentesis
guidance of parapneumonic effusions.
Though most effusions in this study were
minimal, the success rate of ultrasoundguided thoracentesis was 100070. Chest
ultrasound can also be used as a guide
in the needle aspiration of microabscesses
for microbiologic study in patients with
necrotizing pneumonia. Successful aspiration was achieved in 92.3070 of our patients. Microbiologic diagnoses wereconfirmed in 80.8070, and 46.1070 of the patients had their antibiotic treatments
modified after needle aspiration. This
technique provides a reliable etiologic diagnosis for necrotizing pneumonia. It
would be particularly useful for the immunocompromised host with necrotizing pneumonia, in whom an accurate diagnosis is especially important.
Ultrasound-guided transthoracic needle aspiration through the consolidated
lung is relatively safe. The major bronchi and pulmonary vessels can be clearly
differentiated by high-resolution realtime ultrasound and Doppler ultrasound.
The route for needle aspiration can be
preselected to avoid these vital structures,
and thus the complication of major
bleeding can be minimized. Ultrasound
can select an area where the consolida-