&YQPTVSF UP %JWFSTF *OGPSNBUJPO PO

'BDFCPPL
4k 7kfS` 4S]eZk Ea^a_a` ?Wee[`Y S`V >SVS 3VS_[U
3e bWab^W [`UdWSe[`Y^k fgd` fa eaU[S^ `Wfiad]e Xad `Wie S`V U[h[U [`Xad_Sf[a` cgWef[a`e
ZShW TWW` dS[eWV STagf iZWfZWd fZ[e bdSUf[UW ^WSVe fa fZW UdWSf[a` aX WUZa UZS_TWde [`
iZ[UZ bWab^W SdW WjbaeWV a`^k fa [`Xad_Sf[a` Xda_ ^[]W_[`VWV [`V[h[VgS^e M#O AfZWd
ebWUg^Sf[a` ZSe XaUgeWV a` iZWfZWd S^Yad[fZ_e geWV fa dS`] eWSdUZ dWeg^fe S`V eaU[S^
_WV[S baefe Uag^V UdWSfW ^fWd TgTT^We [` iZ[UZ a`^k [VWa^aY[US^^k SbbWS^[`Y Ua`fW`f
[e egdXSUWV M$O
DWeWSdUZ iW ZShW Ua`VgUfWV fa VSfW ZaiWhWd egYYWefe fZSf bWab^W SdW WjbaeWV fa V[
hWdeW eagdUWe aX [`Xad_Sf[a` a` 8SUWTaa] 3 bdWh[age $"#$ dWeWSdUZ bSbWd Ua`U^gVWV
fZSf _gUZ aX fZW [`Xad_Sf[a` iW SdW WjbaeWV fa S`V eZSdW Ua_We Xda_ iWS] f[We, fZaeW
Xd[W`Ve iW [`fWdSUf i[fZ ^Wee aXfW` S`V SdW _adW ^[]W^k fa TW V[ee[_[^Sd fa ge fZS` agd
U^aeW Xd[W`Ve M%O EWbSdSfW dWeWSdUZ egYYWefe fZSf [`V[h[VgS^e SdW _adW ^[]W^k fa W`YSYW
i[fZ Ua`fW`f Ua`fdSdk fa fZW[d ai` h[Wie iZW` [f [e bdWeW`fWV S^a`Y i[fZ eaU[S^ [`Xad_S
f[a` M&O
Agd ^SfWef dWeWSdUZ dW^WSeWV faVSk [` FV\XaVXcgS`f[We Xad fZW def f[_W WjSUf^k Zai
_gUZ [`V[h[VgS^e Uag^V TW S`V SdW WjbaeWV fa [VWa^aY[US^^k V[hWdeW `Wie S`V [`Xad_S
f[a` [` eaU[S^ _WV[S M"O
IW Xag`V fZSf bWab^W ZShW Xd[W`Ve iZa U^S[_ S` abbae[`Y ba^[f[US^ [VWa^aYk S`V fZSf fZW
Ua`fW`f [` bWab^We @Wie 8WWVe dWWUf fZaeW V[hWdeW h[Wie IZ[^W @Wie 8WWV egdXSUWe
Ua`fW`f fZSf [e e^[YZf^k _adW S^[Y`WV i[fZ S` [`V[h[VgS^e ai` [VWa^aYk TSeWV a` fZSf
bWdea`e SUf[a`e a` 8SUWTaa] iZa fZWk Xd[W`V S`V iZSf Ua`fW`f fZWk U^[U] a` SdW _adW
Ua`eWcgW`f[S^ fZS` fZW @Wie 8WWV dS`][`Y [` fWd_e aX Zai _gUZ Ua`fW`f fZWk W`Uag`fWd
fZSf Ugfe SUdaee [VWa^aY[US^ ^[`We
EbWU[US^^k

A` ShWdSYW $% bWdUW`f aX bWab^We Xd[W`Ve U^S[_ S` abbae[`Y ba^[f[US^ [VWa^aYk

AX fZW ZSdV `Wie Ua`fW`f fZSf bWab^We Xd[W`Ve eZSdW $+ 'bWdUW`f aX [f Ugfe SUdaee
[VWa^aY[US^ ^[`We
IZW` [f Ua_We fa iZSf bWab^W eWW [` fZW @Wie 8WWV $* +bWdUW`f aX fZW ZSdV `Wie

W`Uag`fWdWV Ugfe SUdaee [VWa^aY[US^ ^[`We a` ShWdSYW

$& +bWdUW`f aX fZW ZSdV `Wie Ua`fW`f fZSf bWab^W SUfgS^^k U^[U]WV a` iSe Udaee
Ugff[`Y

EZSd[`Y `Wie a` 8SUWTaa]

6gd[`Y fZW e[j _a`fZe TWfiWW` <g^k $"#& S`V <S`gSdk $"#' _adW fZS` ) _[^^[a` V[ef[`Uf
IWT ^[`]e GD>e iWdW eZSdWV Tk bWab^W a` 8SUWTaa] [` fZW G`[fWV EfSfWe IW iWdW [`
fWdWefWV [` ^WSd`[`Y Zai _gUZ bWab^W iWdW WjbaeWV fa ZSdV `Wie efad[We STagf ba^
[f[Ue iad^V SS[de S`V fZW WUa`a_k dSfZWd fZS` eaXf `Wie efad[We STagf W`fWdfS[`
_W`f UW^WTd[f[We S`V ebadfe S`V iZWfZWd fZ[e [`Xad_Sf[a` iSe S^[Y`WV bd[_Sd[^k i[fZ
^[TWdS^ ad Ua`eWdhSf[hW SgV[W`UWe Fa Va fZ[e iW fdS[`WV S egbbadf hWUfad _SUZ[`W U^Se
e[Wd iZ[UZ geWe fZW def XWi iadVe aX Sdf[U^We ^[`]WV Xad WSUZ GD> eZSdWV a` 8SUWTaa]
FZ[e S^^aiWV ge fa [VW`f[Xk _adW fZS` $$(""" g`[cgW ZSdV `Wie Sdf[U^We fZSf ZSV TWW`
eZSdWV Sf ^WSef #"" f[_We
@Wjf iW UZSdSUfWd[lWV fZW Ua`fW`f Se W[fZWd Ua`eWdhSf[hW ad ^[TWdS^ @[`W bWdUW`f aX
8SUWTaa] geWde [` fZW G`[fWV EfSfWe eW^XdWbadf fZW[d ba^[f[US^ S^[Sf[a` a` fZW[d bda^We
IW _SbbWV fZW _aef Ua__a` S^[Sf[a`e fa S hWba[`f eUS^W dS`Y[`Y Xda_ $ hWdk ^[T
WdS^ fa $ hWdk Ua`eWdhSf[hW 4k ShWdSY[`Y fZW S^[Sf[a`e aX fZaeW iZa eZSdWV WSUZ Sdf[
U^W iW Uag^V _WSegdW fZW [VWa^aY[US^ S^[Y`_W`f aX WSUZ efadk Fa TW U^WSd fZ[e eUadW
[e S _WSegdW aX fZW\WXb_bZ\VT_T_\Za`Xag bY g[X ThW\XaVX j[b f[TeXf Ta Teg\V_X S`V [e `af S
_WSegdW aX ba^[f[US^ T[Se ad e^S`f aX fZW Sdf[U^W FZ[e US^Ug^Sf[a` [e VWeUd[TWV [` fZW [^^ge
fdSf[a` TW^ai

<__hfgeTg\ba bY [bj \WXb_bZ\VT_ T_\Za`Xag Ybe VbagXag \f `XTfheXW! 9be XTV[ f[TeXW \gX` jX TiXe
TZX g[Xcb_\g\VT_T_\Tg\ba bY\aW\i\WhT_f j[b f[TeX! 9be XkT`c_X \a g[X _XYg `bfg XkT`c_X TUbiX
g[X Teg\V_X jTf f[TeXW Ul iX cXbc_X g[eXX j[b` \WXag\XW g[X`fX_iXf Tf _\UXeT_f baX Tf T `bWXe
TgX TaW baX Tf VbafXeiTg\iX cebWhV\aZ Ta TiXeTZX bY %"(!
IZW` iW ShWdSYW fZ[e _WSegdW Xad WhWdk efadk Xda_ S bSdf[Ug^Sd iWTe[fW Va_S[` iW US`

eWW ]Wk V[WdW`UWe [` iW^^]`ai` [VWa^aY[US^^kS^[Y`WV _WV[S eagdUWe, 8aj@Wie Ua_ [e

S^[Y`WV i[fZ Ua`eWdhSf[hWe 3e /  *" iZ[^W :g`Yfa`Baef Ua_ [e S^[Y`WV i[fZ ^[TWdS^e
3e /  (' FZWdW iSe egTefS`f[S^ ba^Sd[lSf[a` S_a`Y ZSdV `Wie eZSdWV a` 8SUWTaa]
i[fZ fZW _aef XdWcgW`f^k eZSdWV ^[`]e U^WSd^k S^[Y`WV i[fZ ^SdYW^k ^[TWdS^ ad Ua`eWdhSf[hW
babg^Sf[a`e Se eZai` TW^ai

G[\f ZheX f[bjf g[Tg `bfg _\a^f gb cTeg\Vh_Te [TeW aXjf Teg\V_Xf TeX f[TeXW X\g[Xe ce\`Te\_l Ul
_\UXeT_f T_\Za`XagfVbeX V_bfX gb $ be Ul VbafXeiTg\iXf T_\Za`Xag fVbeX V_bfX gb $ Uhg eTeX_l Ul
Ubg[ XdhT__l!
Ge[`Y fZW _WfZaVe VWeUd[TWV STahW iW fgd`WV faiSdV _WSegd[`Y fZW WjfW`f fa iZ[UZ
bWab^W Uag^V TW S`V SdW WjbaeWV fa [VWa^aY[US^^k V[hWdeW [`Xad_Sf[a` a` 8SUWTaa]
@Wfiad] efdgUfgdW S`V [VWa^aYk
:a_abZ[^k fZW fW`VW`Uk Xad e[_[^Sd [`V[h[VgS^e fa SeeaU[SfW i[fZ WSUZ afZWd T[dVe aX
S XWSfZWd aU] faYWfZWd [e S daTgef eaU[S^ bZW`a_W`a` 8d[W`Ve SdW _adW ^[]W^k fa TW
e[_[^Sd [` SYW WVgUSf[a`S^ SffS[`_W`f aUUgbSf[a` S`V YWaYdSbZk ;f [e `af egdbd[e[`Y fa
`V fZSf fZW eS_W Za^Ve fdgW Xad ba^[f[US^ S^[Sf[a` a` 8SUWTaa] IW US` eWW Zai ^[TWd
S^e S`V Ua`eWdhSf[hWe fW`V fa Ua``WUf fa bWab^W i[fZ e[_[^Sd ba^[f[US^ S^[Sf[a`eTSeWV a`
eS_b^W WYa`Wfiad]e VWb[UfWV [` fZW h[egS^[lSf[a`e TW^ai

8kT`c_X fbV\T_ aXgjbe^f Ybe T _\UXeT_ T `bWXeTgX TaW T VbafXeiTg\iX! Cb\agf TeX \aW\i\WhT_f
Ye\XaWf TaW _\aXf WXf\ZaTgX Ye\XaWf[\cf UXgjXXa g[X`!
:aiWhWd S_a`Y fZaeW iZa dWbadf fZW[d [VWa^aYk a` ShWdSYW STagf $% bWdUW`f aX fZW[d
Xd[W`Ve dWbadf S` S^[Sf[a` a` fZW abbae[fW e[VW aX fZW [VWa^aY[US^ ebWUfdg_ 8da_ fZW
YgdW TW^ai iW US` eWW fZSf fZWdW [e S i[VW dS`YW aX `Wfiad] V[hWde[fk :S^X aX geWde
ZShW TWfiWW` TWfiWW` + S`V %% bWdUW`f aX Xd[W`Ve Xda_ abbae[`Y [VWa^aY[We iZ[^W $'
bWdUW`f ZShW ^Wee fZS` + bWdUW`f S`V fZW dW_S[`[`Y $' bWdUW`f ZShW _adW fZS` %% bWd
UW`f

CXeVXag bY Ye\XaWf Yeb` bccbf\aZ \WXb_bZ\Xf T`baZ _\UXeT_f TaW VbafXeiTg\iXf!

FZW ai aX [`Xad_Sf[a` a` 8SUWTaa]

FZW V[hWde[fk aX Ua`fW`fbWab^W W`Uag`fWd VWbW`Ve `af a`^k a` iZa fZW[d Xd[W`Ve SdW Tgf
S^ea iZSf [`Xad_Sf[a` fZaeW Xd[W`Ve eZSdW S`V fZW [`fWdSUf[a` TWfiWW` bWab^W S`V 8SUW
Taa]e @Wie 8WWV @Wie 8WWV eZaie kag S^^ aX fZW Ua`fW`f eZSdWV Tk kagd Xd[W`Ve Tgf
fZW _aef dW^WhS`f Ua`fW`f [e eZai` def 7jSUf^k iZSf efad[We bWab^W U^[U] a` VWbW`Ve
a` Zai aXfW` fZWk geW 8SUWTaa] Zai XSd Vai` fZWk eUda^^ [` fZW @Wie 8WWV S`V fZW
UZa[UWe fZWk _S]W STagf iZSf fa dWSV

<__hfgeTg\ba bY [bj g[X XkcbfheX cebVXff Vbaf\fgf bY g[eXX c[TfXf- $ g[X aXjf lbhe Ye\XaWf f[TeX
CbgXag\T_ Yeb` aXgjbe^ % eTa^\aZ TaW g[X g\`X g[Tg \aW\i\WhT_f gT^X gb fVeb__ ZbiXeaf j[Tg
g[Xl fXX \a g[X\e AXjf9XXWf 8kcbfXW & V_\V^\aZ g[ebhZ[ gb TVghT_ Teg\V_X FX_XVgXW!
:ai _gUZ UdaeeUgff[`Y Ua`fW`f bWab^W W`Uag`fWd VWbW`Ve a` iZa fZW[d Xd[W`Ve SdW S`V
iZSf [`Xad_Sf[a` fZaeW Xd[W`Ve eZSdW ;X bWab^W iWdW fa SUcg[dW [`Xad_Sf[a` Xda_ dS`
Va_ afZWde Sbbdaj[_SfW^k &' bWdUW`f aX fZW Ua`fW`f ^[TWdS^e iag^V TW WjbaeWV fa iag^V
TW Udaee Ugff[`Y Ua_bSdWV fa &" bWdUW`f Xad Ua`eWdhSf[hWe AX UagdeW [`V[h[VgS^e Va `af
W`Uag`fWd [`Xad_Sf[a` Sf dS`Va_ [` a[`W W`h[da`_W`fe `ad a` fZW ;`fWd`Wf
:ai _gUZ aX fZW UdaeeUgff[`Y Ua`fW`f eZSdWV Tk kagd Xd[W`Ve SbbWSde [` @Wie 8WWV1
BWab^W SdW W^[Y[T^W fa eWW S^^ aX fZW Ua`fW`f eZSdWV Tk fZW[d Xd[W`Ve [` @Wie 8WWV Tgf
e[`UW bWab^W Va`f ZShW W`agYZ f[_W [` fZW VSk fa eWW WhWdkfZ[`Y iW eadf fZW Ua`fW`f
fa eZai bWab^W iZSf [e _aef dW^WhS`f fa fZW_ IW Xag`V fZSf $% bWdUW`f aX `Wie eZSdWV
Tk ^[TWdS^e Xd[W`Ve [e UdaeeUgff[`Y iZWdWSe iZSf [e eWW` [` fZW @Wie 8WWV [e $$ bWdUW`f
FZ[e UaddWeba`Ve faS d[e] dSf[a aX * bWdUW`f _WS`[`Y fZSf bWab^W iWdW * bWdUW`f ^Wee
^[]W^k fa eWW Uag`fWdhS[^[`Y Sdf[U^We fZSf ZShW TWW` eZSdWV Tk Xd[W`Ve Ua_bSdWV fa fZW
^[]W^[ZaaV aX eWW[`Y [VWa^aY[US^^k Ua`e[efW`f Sdf[U^We fZSf ZShW TWW` eZSdWV Tk Xd[W`Ve
A` fZW afZWd ZS`V %& bWdUW`f aX fZW Ua`fW`f eZSdWV Tk Ua`eWdhSf[hWe [e [VWa^aY[US^^k

UdaeeUgff[`Y hWdege %% bWdUW`f SUfgS^^k eWW` [` fZW @Wie 8WWV UaddWeba`V[`Y fa S d[e]
dSf[a aX ' bWdUW`f
:ai _gUZ UdaeeUgff[`Y Ua`fW`f fZSf SbbWSde [` @Wie 8WWV Va bWab^W SUfgS^^k U^[U] a`1
IZ[^W $$ bWdUW`f aX fZW Ua`fW`f eWW` Tk ^[TWdS^e iSe UdaeeUgff[`Y iW Xag`V fZSf $" bWd
UW`f aX fZW Ua`fW`f fZWk SUfgS^^k U^[U]WV a` iSe UdaeeUgff[`Y _WS`[`Y bWab^W SdW ( bWd
UW`f ^Wee ^[]W^k fa U^[U] a` Uag`fWdhS[^[`Y Sdf[U^We fZSf SbbWSdWV [` fZW[d @Wie 8WWV Ua_
bSdWV fa fZW ^[]W^[ZaaV aX eWW[`Y [VWa^aY[US^^k Ua`e[efW`f Sdf[U^We fZSf SbbWSdWV [` fZW[d
@Wie 8WWV 5a`eWdhSf[hWe eSi %% bWdUW`f aX UdaeeUgff[`Y Ua`fW`f [` @Wie 8WWV Tgf SU
fgS^^k U^[U]WV a` $+ bWdUW`f UaddWeba`V[`Y fa S d[e] dSf[a aX #) bWdUW`f

4iXeTZX \WXb_bZ\VT_ W\iXef\gl bY VbagXag $ f[TeXW Ul eTaWb` bg[Xef eTaWb` % f[TeXW Ul
Ye\XaWf cbgXag\T_ Yeb` aXgjbe^ & TVghT__l TccXTe\aZ \a cXbc_Xf AXjf 9XXWf XkcbfXW '
V_\V^XW ba fX_XVgXW!
IZW` iW ^aa] Sf bWab^W a` fZW _SdY[` aX W`Uag`fWd[`Y ZSdV `Wie a` 8SUWTaa] iW
eWW _adW Wh[VW`UW aX fZW [_badfS`f da^W [`V[h[VgS^ UZa[UW b^Ske FS]W bWab^W iZaeW
Xd[W`Ve eZSdWV Sf ^WSef a`W Ua`e[efW`f S`V a`W UdaeeUgff[`Y efadk ++ bWdUW`f aX fZW_
iWdW WjbaeWV fa Sf ^WSef a`W [VWa^aY[US^^k S^[Y`WV [fW_ S`V +( bWdUW`f W`Uag`fWdWV Sf
^WSef a`W [VWa^aY[US^^k UdaeeUgff[`Y [fW_ [` @Wie 8WWV IZW` iW ^aa]WV Sf iZa U^[U]WV
fZdagYZ fa ZSdV `Wie Ua`fW`f iW Xag`V fZSf '& bWdUW`f_adW fZS` ZS^XU^[U]WV a` [VW
a^aY[US^^k UdaeeUgff[`Y Ua`fW`f S^fZagYZ ^Wee fZS` fZW *) bWdUW`f iZa U^[U]WV a` [VWa
^aY[US^^k S^[Y`WV Ua`fW`f

Cebcbeg\ba bY \aW\i\WhT_f j\g[ Tg _XTfg baX Vebff Vhgg\aZ TaW T_\ZaXW fgbel $ f[TeXW Ul Ye\XaWf
cbgXag\T_ % TVghT__l TccXTe\aZ \a cXbc_Xf AXjf 9XXWf XkcbfXW & V_\V^XW ba fX_XVgXW!
6[eUgee[a`
4k eZai[`Y fZSf bWab^W SdW WjbaeWV fa S egTefS`f[S^ S_ag`f aX Ua`fW`f Xda_ Xd[W`Ve i[fZ
abbae[`Y h[Wiba[`fe agd `V[`Ye Ua`fdSef Ua`UWd`e fZSf bWab^W _[YZf ^[efW` S`V ebWS]
a`^k fa fZW ^[]W_[`VWV iZ[^W a`^[`W M#O FZW Ua_bae[f[a` aX agd eaU[S^ `Wfiad]e [e fZW
_aef [_badfS`f XSUfad SWUf[`Y fZW _[j aX Ua`fW`f W`Uag`fWdWV a` eaU[S^ _WV[S i[fZ [`
V[h[VgS^ UZa[UW S^ea b^Sk[`Y S ^SdYW da^W @Wie 8WWV dS`][`Y ZSe S e_S^^Wd [_bSUf a` fZW
V[hWde[fk aX [`Xad_Sf[a` iW eWW Xda_ fZW afZWd e[VW
IW TW^[WhW fZSf fZ[e iad] [e \gef fZW TWY[``[`Y aX S ^a`Y ^[`W aX dWeWSdUZ [`fa Zai bWab^W
SdW WjbaeWV fa S`V Ua`eg_W _WV[S a`^[`W 8ad _adW [`Xad_Sf[a` eWW agd bSbWd iZ[UZ
[e ShS[^ST^W a` abW` SUUWee Sf EU[W`UW7jbdWee,
7jbaegdW fa ;VWa^aY[US^^k 6[hWdeW @Wie S`V Ab[`[a` 7 4S]eZk E ?Wee[`Y > 3VS_[U
EU[W`UW Ha^ JJ $"#' ^[`]
M"O7jbaegdW fa ;VWa^aY[US^^k 6[hWdeW @Wie S`V Ab[`[a` 7 4S]eZk E ?Wee[`Y >
3VS_[U FV\XaVX Ha^ JJ $"#' ^[`]
M#O5 D Eg`efW[` EXchU_\V!Vb` %!# Bd[`UWfa` G`[hWde[fk BdWee $"")
M$O7 BSd[eWd G[X 9\_gXe 5hUU_X- J[Tg g[X <agXeaXg <f ;\W\aZ Yeb` Lbh BW`Yg[` BdWee >a`

Va` $"##
M%O 7 4S]eZk ; DaeW`` 5 ?Sd^ai > 3VS_[U FZW Da^W aX EaU[S^ @Wfiad]e [` ;`Xad
_Sf[a` 6[ge[a` CebVXXW\aZf bY g[X %$fg \agXeaTg\baT_ VbaYXeXaVX ba Jbe_W J\WX JXU CTZXf
#$"# &#&' $"#$
M&OE ?Wee[`Y E < IWefiaaV EW^WUf[hW 7jbaegdW [` fZW 3YW aX EaU[S^ ?WV[S, 7`VadeW
_W`fe Fdg_b BSdf[eS` EagdUW 3^[Sf[a` iZW` EW^WUf[`Y @Wie A`^[`W 6b``ha\VTg\ba
EXfXTeV[ $"#$