Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
AbstractThe electrochemical behavior of cast Mg, AZ91, and cast AZ91 in 0.1 M NaCl solution is investigated by measuring open-circuit potential (OCP), steady-state currentpotential, and electrochemical impedance spectra (EIS). The similar electrochemical impedance behavior is found of three corrosion electrodes.
There are two capacitances in high- and medium-frequency domains and one inductive loop or component in
low-frequency domain. From equivalent circuit simulation, cast AZ91 has the worst corrosion resistance. The
EIS results are in good agreement with those obtained by OCP and polarization curves. Based on the Cao theory, a simple corrosion mechanism is put forward, supplying a possible explanation for low-frequency inductive
behavior for Mg and its alloy in NaCl solution at OCP.
Key word: magnesium, corrosion, electrochemical technology, inductive behavior
DOI: 10.1134/S1023193507070142
INTRODUCTION
The employment of magnesium as an anodic material in different types of batteries has been the subject
of much attention in recent years. Magnesium offers
several advantages as negative electrode material [1, 2],
e.g. a high electrode potential (2.37 V vs. NHE), a low
electrochemical equivalent (0.45 g per A h), good stability towards corrosion, relative abundance from sea
bitterns, low toxicity. This has prompted the authors to
investigate magnesium in conjunction with certain
novel N-halogen organic compounds for use in battery
devices [3, 4].
Magnesium-based alloys exhibit an attractive combination of low density and high strength/weight ratio
associated with good castability and workability. Thus
they offer substitutes to ferrous alloys and aluminum in
automotive and aeronautical applications [5, 6]. Among
the magnesium alloys, AZ91D is one of those having
the best mechanical properties/corrosion resistance balance and the present study is a continuation of a previous one devoted to the influence of the elaboration process of the AZ91D alloy on its corrosion behavior in
corrosive environments [7, 8]. It was demonstrated that
the corrosion resistance of AZ91D elaborated through
the semi-solid process (SSP) was somewhat higher than
that of the same alloy manufactured by high pressure
die casting (DC). As the SSP process induces strong
modifications of the alloy microstructure, in terms of
distribution, composition and volume fraction of the
* The text was submitted by the authors in English.
z Corresponding author, e-mail: nelson_cao@zju.edu.cn
837
838
CAO et al.
Material
Cast Mg
AZ91
Cast AZ91
Al
Zn
Mn
Si
Cu
Ni
Fe
Mg
0.004
8.1
8.5
0.003
0.6
0.6
0.004
0.25
0.25
0.005
0.03
0.05
<0.001
0.003
0.25
<0.001
<0.001
0.001
0.002
0.003
0.004
>99.95
balance
balance
Electrochemical measurements
The experiments were performed in a classical
three-electrode electrochemical cell. The working electrode was cylindrical samples and had a 3-mm crosssectional diameter. The auxiliary electrode was a large
surface area platinum sheet and reference electrode was
a saturated Hg/Hg2Cl2 electrode (SCE). The reference
electrode was placed outside the cell and connected to
the specimen surface by a Luggin capillary and a salt
bridge. All potentials presented in this paper are
referred to SCE (E = 0.224 vs. NHE).
All electrochemical measurements were carried out
at 25 0.5 using a thermostat. The variation of open
circuit potential with immersion time was carried out
using powerlab/4sp recorder with a GP amplifier. The
potentiodynamic polarization curves and the electrochemical impedance measurements were performed
using an EG&G potentiostat (Model 273A) driven by a
computer. Impedance measurements were carried out
OCP, V
1.4
1
2
3
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
16
32
48
Time, h
Vol. 43
No. 7
2007
839
ImZ, cm2
1
2
3
4
5
8000
1
2
3
4
5
4000
2000
4000
4000
2000
0
10000
5000
10000
ReZ, cm2
20000
ReZ, cm2
Fig. 3. Nyquist plot for AZ91 in 0.1 M NaCl.
At first sight, there is one capacitive arc and an shown in Fig. 5 is applied to analysis EIS data by
inductive component in Nyquist plot for cast Mg in ZView program. Rs, Rp, and Rt are the solution, polar0.1 M NaCl solution (Fig. 2). Based on simulation pro- ization, and charge transfer resistances, while constant
cess and evolvement of EIS, we consider that there are phase elements, Chf and Clf, are high- and low-fretwo capacitive arcs above real axes. The radius of mid- quency capacitive loops corresponding to initial and
dle-frequency capacitive arc decreases with immersion corrodent interface, respectively. All the capacitances
time at the first 24 hours, then maintains a relatively sta- shown in the equivalent circuits are mathematically
ble value, which indicates that the oxide film formed in modeled using a constant phase element in order to
air improves the corrosion resistance, and its localized consider also the electrochemical behavior of systems
rupture is main process at the first 24 hours and repas- which do not correspond exactly to a pure capacitance;
sivation translate an important process at the following in this way we have two parameters describing the ele24 hours.
ment: the value of admittance (Q) and the exponent of
Typical Nyquist plot of AZ91 alloy in 0.1 N NaCl is angular frequency (n). The exponent n is usually related
shown Fig. 3. It can be seen that there are two capaci- to diffusion phenomena, surface morphology and dissitive loops above real axis, while some scattered points pative process. The simulated results of different elecunder real axis. The radius of second capacitive arc has trode are shown in Table 2. There is a need to point out
a litter change during whole immersion time what indicates corrosion process is relative stable. The scattered
points in low frequency domain show the slow reac- ImZ, cm2
tions on metal oxide film/solution interface are not stable enough.
1500
Electrochemical impedance behavior of cast AZ91
1
in 0.1 M NaCl (Fig. 4) is similar to cast Mg. There are 1000
2
two capacitive loops and an inductive loop during the
3
whole frequency domain. The inductive component is
4
more obvious than that of the above two situation.
500
5
Since the Randle circuit model does not apply to
alloys with this additional constant, a new approach
0
was necessary for determining the corrosion rate based
on the complex impedance behavior described above.
When corrosion is not controlled by one-step, the
500
polarization resistance may no longer serve as a measure of the corrosion rate. In many such cases, e.g. mul2000
0
4000
tistep electron transfer, diffusion control, charge transReZ, cm2
fer resistance could determine the corrosion rate, which
may be used in a SternGeary expression [16, 17].
Fig. 4. Nyquist plot for cast AZ91 in 0.1 M NaCl.
Based on the above discussion, equivalent circuit
RUSSIAN JOURNAL OF ELECTROCHEMISTRY
Vol. 43
No. 7
2007
840
CAO et al.
Chf
Rs
Clf
Rp
Rt
Fig. 5. Equivalent circuit of Mg and its alloy in 0.1 M NaCl.
that the equivalent circuit shown in Fig. 5 does not analyze impedance component under real axis. We omit
the inductive analysis in equivalent-circuit method.
More information will be given by mathematics
method of EIS developed by C.N. Cao [18, 19].
Double layer capacitance Chf increases form 0.28 to
240.01 F cm2 in turns of cast Mg, AZ91, and cast
AZ91 alloys, while corresponding dispersion coefficientnhf decreases from 1 to 0.333. The low-frequency
capacitive behavior takes on complex variation rule.
The Qlf value of cast Mg and AZ91 increases during the
first 24 h, then decreases, while Qlf of cast AZ91
increases during the whole immersion time. At the
same time, nlf is equal or close to unity, indicating that
the second capacitive loop is well-defined. The polarization resistance Rp is defined as real part of the impedance as frequency tends to zero, while charge transfer
resistance Rt is the real part of the impedance as frequency tends to infinite. Resistance Rt is generally considered as a corrosion rate parameter, rather than Rp, in
systems that contain more than one time constant. It is
easy to find that the corrosion resistance of cast Mg is
Mg
(1)
AZ91
Cast AZ91
nhf
Rp, cm2
Qlf, 1 cm2 sn
nhf
Rct, cm2
0.33
0.28
1.0
338.3
0.81
0.836
21510
0.50
0.988
799.2
0.52
0.992
10023
24
1.00
0.978
178.9
2.08
0.959
3233
30
1.02
0.966
223.6
1.90
0.939
2854
48
1.18
0.999
708.2
1.69
0.930
3164
0.5
1.05
0.8889
14 270
1.09
1.0
12592
1.46
0.848
13276
1.34
1.0
9803
24
2.71
0.742
16521
1.91
1.0
5468
30
3.72
0.682
1671
0.13
1.0
17122
48
4.39
0.691
681.6
0.22
1.0
12600
7.76
0.611
117.4
0.82
1.0
12.19
0.601
163.7
0.82
1.0
27.37
0.504
238.8
1.23
1.0
618.8
12
117.58
0.276
126.9
4.56
0.979
200.5
24
240.01
0.333
3.19
0.965
72.91
Vol. 43
618.8
4207
40.97
No. 7
2007
Mg
K1
Mg+
+ e.
(a)
4
K2
(2)
Mg2+ + OH + 1/2H2.
(3)
1/Rt, 1/
From our experiment, the hydrogen evolution process on the magnesium/alloy was very visible during
the whole immersion time. Otherwise, Eq. (3) supports
the negative difference effect (NDE) mechanism that
hydrogen evolution takes place on working electrode
by monovalent magnesium ion. The results are the formation of the stable valence of magnesium and the evolution of hydrogen. In neutral solution, the cathodic
reaction is Eq. (4) because the OH ions will be reacted
with Mg2+ ions:
2H2O+ 2e
K3
2OH +
1
2
3
The Mg+ ions have short lifetime with high reactivity. In the neutral solution, the monovalent magnesium
ion is oxidized by water rather than H+ in acidic solution [25]:
Mg+ + H2O
841
H2.
0.02
(7)
(9)
IF = (I1 I3).
(10)
(11)
+ ( I F / X 2 ) ( d X 2 / dE )/ [ 1 j/ ( X '2 / X 2 ) ].
RUSSIAN JOURNAL OF ELECTROCHEMISTRY
Vol. 43
0.0002
0.01
0.0001
0
12
24
36
48
0
0
X2 = cm.
1/Rt, 1/
0.0003
(4)
(b)
1
2
3
12
24
36
48
Time, h
(13)
( I F / ) ( d/dE ) > 0,
(14)
so
indicating the Nyquist plot should contain an inductive
loop related to the state variable for cast Mg and AZ
Mg alloy.
For the second state variable cm, from [24]:
( I F / c m ) ( dc m /dE ) < 0.
(15)
2007
842
CAO et al.
trend: cast AZ91 > AZ91 > cast Mg, which indicates
that cast AZ91's free corrosion current is much higher
than that of the other two corrosion electrodes. The
impedance shows the same trend. The shift of corrosion
potential may be considered to content of zinc and different microstructure of magnesium and its alloy. The
corrosion potential of AZ91 and cast pure Mg is so
closely, indicating that the cast Mg is not very pure. At
the same time, Cl ions improve the localized corrosion
susceptivity through making the surface active and
increasing the broken area of the film.
logi [A]
2
1
2
3
6
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
Potential, V
Fig. 7. Typical log i vs. log E plots for 0.1 M NaCl; scan rate
0.1 mV s1.
CONCLUSIONS
The results obtained in this study support the idea of
formation of intermediate species Mg+ in the neutral
solution containing Cl ions.
The result of OCP experiment indicates that the
main corrosion type is localized corrosion on the three
magnesium electrodes surface. Analysis of the impedance plots identifies the presence of three time constants at the corrosion potential, two capacitive loops
and one inductive component. It is obvious that the HF
capacitive loop is related the films double layer and
film resistance. The equivalent circuit simulation of EIS
show the cast AZ91 magnesium alloy has the lowest
corrosion resistance, while cast pure Mg has similar
value with AZ91 alloy, implied cast is not very perfect
because corrosion resistance of pure Mg should be
larger than that of AZ91. At the same time, according to
theory of Cao, the MF capacitive is originated by intermediate species Mg+, while the LF inductive component is related to coverage of film-free activate site
based on a simple reaction model. Since the MF capacitive loop is originated from intermediate species Mg+,
the corrosion rate is dependent on dissolution of Mg to
monovalent Mg ions on the Mg and its alloy surface,
supporting the idea of corrosion resistance simulating
from the MF capacitive arc. Moreover, the polarization
curves indicate similar result of EIS.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors acknowledge the financial support of
the National Natural Science Foundation of China
(no. 50 471 043) and the State Key Laboratory for Corrosion and Protection (China).
REFERENCES
1. Gregory, T.D., Hoffman, R.J., and Winterton, R.C.,
J. Electrochem. Soc., 1990, vol. 137, p. 775.
2. Udhayan, R., Muniyandi, N., and Mathur, P.B., Br. Core,
1992, vol. 27, p. 68.
3. Udhayan, R., Muniyandi, N., and Mathur, P.B., J. Power
Sources, 1991, vol. 34, p. 303.
4. Udhayan, R. and Bhatt, P.B., Electrochim. Acta, 1992,
vol. 37, p. 1971.
Vol. 43
No. 7
2007
Vol. 43
843
No. 7
2007