Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
INTRODUCTION
Foulkes (1975) referred to group therapy as “ hall of mirrors “ in which people can see
themselves reflected in others. Group therapy is a powerful therapeutic tool to help the
patients, correct maladaptive personal behaviors and to enhance a patient’s ability to
function as a contributing member of the community. The experience of being in a group
does not deny the uniqueness of each person. Rather, it allows people to directly
experience their talents and possibilities through the eyes and personal experience of
others. By using a variety of technical maneuvers and theoretical constructs, the leader
directs group members’ interactions to bring about changes. The principles of group
psychotherapy have also been applied with success in the fields of business and
education in the form of training.
DEFINITION
Group therapy is a “hall of mirrors” in which people can see themselves reflected in
others.
[FOULKES, 1975]
1
HISTORY
2
• A healthy balance exist between task and maintenance role functioning.
• Individual contributions are acknowledged and respected.
• Diversity is encouraged. Interpersonal effectiveness, innovation and problem
solving adequacy are evident.
Certain essential elements are common to all types of group therapy. Yalom (2005)
has identified eleven essential elements of group therapy. This include
1. Instillation Of Hope: It is the first and often most important factor. People
participating in the group experience initially feel demoralized and helpless. So
providing them with hope is therefore a most worthwhile achievement. Client
should be encouraged to believe that they can find help and support in the
group and that it is realistic to expect that problem will eventually be resolved.
2. Universality: It can be defined as the sense of realizing that one is not
completely alone in any situation. Group members can identify this factor as a
3
major reason for seeking group therapy. During the sessions, members are
encouraged to express complex, often very negative feelings in the hope that
they will experience understanding and support from others with similar
thoughts and feelings.
3. Imparting Of Information: This includes both didactic instructions and direct
advice, and refers to the imparting of specific educational information plus the
sharing of advice and guidance among members. The transmission of this
information also indicates to each member the other’s concern and trust.
4. Altruism: It is the personalized help that one group member extends to
another. Clients have the experience of learning to help others, and in the
process they begin to feel better about themselves. Both the group therapist and
the members can offer invaluable support, insight and reassurance while
allowing themselves to gain self knowledge and growth.
5. Corrective Recapitulation Of The Primary Family Group: This allows
members in the group to correct some of the perceptions and feelings
associated with unsatisfactory experiences they have had with their family. The
participants receive feedback as they discuss and relieve early familial conflicts
and experience corrective responses. Family roles are explored, and members
are encouraged to resolve unresolved family business.
6. Development of Socializing Techniques: It is essential in the group as
members are given the opportunity to learn and test new social skills. Members
also receive information about maladaptive social behaviors.
7. Imitative Behaviour: It refers to the process in which members observe and
model their behaviors after one another. Imitation is an acknowledged
therapeutic force; a healthy group environment provides valuable opportunities
for experimenting with desired changes and behaviors.
8. Inter Personal learning: This includes the gaining of insight, the development
of an understanding of a transference relationship, the experience of correcting
emotional thoughts and behaviors and the importance of learning about oneself
in relation to oneself.
4
9. Group Cohesiveness: It is the development of strong sense of group
membership and alliance. The concept of cohesiveness refers to the degree to
which a group functions as a supportive problem solving unit. Ideally, each
member feels acceptance and approval from all others in the group. This factor
is essential in ensuring optimal individual and group growth.
10. Catharsis: It is similar to group cohesiveness and involves members relating to
one another through the verbal expression of positive and negative feelings.
11. Existential Factors: These factors are consistently operating in the group and
help to make up the final component. These intangible issues encourage each
group member to accept the motivating that he or she is ultimately responsible
for his or her life choices and actions.
5
encouraged transference neurosis fostered, fostered, no
to promote evoked and evoked and negative examination
improved analyzed analyzed feelings of
functioning analyzed transference
Always
DREAMS Not analyzed Analyzed Analyzed
analyzed & Not used
frequently encouraged rarely
Intra group
dependence Intra group Intra group Intra group Intra group
6
The functions of a group vary depending on the reason the group was formed. Clark
identifies three types of groups in which nurses most often participate: task, teaching &
supporting or therapeutic groups, self help groups
1. TASK GROUPS
The function of a task group is to accomplish a specific outcome or task. The
focus is in solving problems and making decisions to achieve this outcome. Often
a deadline is placed on completion of task, and such importance is placed on a
satisfactory outcome, that conflict within the group maybe smoothed over or
ignored to focus on the priority at hand.
2. TEACHING GROUPS
Teaching, or educational groups exist to convey knowledge and information to a
number of individuals. Nurse can be involved in teaching groups of many
varieties such as medication education, child birth education, breast self
education and effective parenting classes. These groups usually have a set time
frame or set number of meetings. Members learn from each other as well as from
the designated instructor. The objective of teaching group is verbalization or
demonstration by the learner of the material presented by the end of the
designated period.
3. SUPPORTIVE OR THERAPEUTIC GROUPS
The primary concern of support group is to prevent future upsets by teaching
participants effective ways dealing with emotional stress arising from situational
or developmental crises
4. SELF HELP GROUPS
An additional type group in which, nurses may or may not be involved is the self
help group. It allows clients to talk about their fears and relieve feelings of
isolation while receiving comfort and advice from others undergoing similar
experiences. Eg. Alcoholic anonymous, narcotic anonymous, over eaters
anonymous, women’s groups and men’s group.
7
Patient Selection:
Member selection is based on a patient’s treatment need capacity to contribute to
group goals. Group members do not know each other before entering the group,
and it is best not to include people in the same group who socialize with each
other. It is not possible to have full control over patient selection, particularly in
inpatient or partial hospitalization settings, but the therapist should carefully
consider the rationale for including patients who are actively psychotic,
uncontrolled manic, paranoid or hostile even in inpatient setting. These
individuals cannot benefit from the group when their symptoms are intense and
they will disrupt the group even with the most skilled leadership.
Functional Similarity:
Group members should have enough in common with each other to feel
interpersonally comfortable in the group and it is referred as the functional
capacity. This means that group members should have sufficient levels of
functional ability and social recognizability to allow them in meaningful
conversation. Significant differences in educational level, life experiences or
developmental levels can be barriers to full participation. When group members
feel uncomfortable, they are not as likely to talk with each other. The leader
should avoid including members who are the only ones with permanent
characteristics such as different race, gender, education or age than the other
members.
MacKenzie referred to this as the “ Noah’s Arch” phenomenon. That is, a
therapy group ideally should have at least two members with similar
characteristics. Pairing members in this way precludes the creation of a group
social isolate. For eg: it would not be appropriate to place a single adolescent girl
in a group of adolescent boys.
Capacity to contribute:
8
Group members must be able to both contribute to group goals and derive benefit
from this treatment modality. Usually, patients with more than mild cognitive
disorders, anti social behaviors, strong hostility or paranoid symptoms do not
profit from group intervention. First, their symptoms disrupt the group
functioning. Second, their pathologies interfere with their own ability to derive
benefit because their symptoms preclude the necessary co – operation with other
members. They should be included only after their symptoms are under sufficient
control that they gain some benefit from group membership. All group members
need to be able to contribute in a meaningful way to the functioning of the group
as a whole.
Matching individual need with membership:
Another factor to consider with group composition is the issue of homogenous
compared with heterogeneous group membership. Homogenous group include
patients with same diagnosis, similar age group and same gender. They are
particularly useful in treating disorders in which denial plays a role, for example,
addiction or eating disorders. Heterogeneous groups draw their membership from
a variety of diagnoses. These groups are composed of men and women, rather
than being single gender and prospective members can run the age gamut of
adulthood. The advantage of a heterogeneous group is that the rich complexity of
its membership can provide several different ways of approaching interpersonal
relationships. The format works well with patients experiencing relationship
difficulties.
Choosing open or closed groups:
Another decision is whether to have open or closed membership. Open groups
are those in which group membership changes frequently. This type of group is
found in inpatient settings that depend on member residency and in many mutual
help and support groups. Closed groups are those in which group membership
does not change for the life of the group or only for a clearly understood reason.
Members often must meet certain criteria for acceptance, such as a diagnosis or a
particular therapeutic issue. Foe example, alcoholic anonymous is open only to
9
people with a drug problem .psychotherapy group can share characteristics of
both open and
closed membership. They are open in that as one member leaves the group,
another fills the empty slot, but they have a closed membership in that members
cannot arbitrarily enter the group simply because they have similar interests or
problems.
Group size:
Psycho educational groups can consist of 10-15 members. In psycho educational
groups, the members discuss a particular topic such as medication, prevention or
symptom management of a mental disorder, but the process does not allow
individual to address personal psychological issues unrelated to the discussion
topic. Most insight oriented therapy groups limit membership to six to eight. This
size not only allows for a variety of interpretations but also permits sufficient
interpersonal space for intimate sharing. Therapy group needs to have at least
five members. With fewer than five members, the group is likely to produce an
emotional intensity or to form sub groups, both of which are difficult to regulate.
Time boundaries:
Time boundaries in group therapy are extremely important. Most group therapy
sessions last 75 – 90 minutes. Therapy sessions should begin and end on time.
Attention to time boundaries respects the need of individuals to have lives
outside the group and firmly integrates the group as a set pattern in the patient’s
life.
Inpatient versus outpatient groups:
Inpatient groups differ from outpatient groups in several ways. Group
membership in the inpatient groups depends on the particular patient population.
Because of short stays, the focus of group may be on spotting mal adaptive
behaviors that can be worked on in outpatient therapy and stabilizing symptoms
enough to permit discharge. The content and process of inpatient therapy is more
superficial than in outpatient settings. With inpatient therapy, the therapist takes a
much more active role, clarifies more often and directs the process of establishing
appropriate norms.
10
PHASES OF GROUP DEVELOPMENT:
The phases of group development are sequential and overlapping, beginning with
planning, which takes place before the group starts and ending with termination and
referrals if needed. Tuckman 1965 describe the phases of group development as forming,
storming, norming, performing and adjourning.
Forming Phase:
The forming phase of group therapy is the orientation phase in which group members
begin to know each other. The therapist can begin the group with a self introduction
and ask the members to say their names and tell the group something about
11
themselves. The manner in which the individuals express themselves and the type of
information they choose to share provide important data that can be used later, in the
working phase. However, the therapist needs to make sure that members do not
prematurely disclose lengthy intimate details about themselves because premature
sharing can lead to intense discomfort when the shares reflects on it, resulting in
unanticipated termination.
Acceptance, inclusion and trust are primary values held by members in beginning
group meetings. Initially, group communication tends to be tentative, polite and
guarded, as members explore their values and ideas with each other. They need to
know that other group members, including the leader, will respect their contribution
and will not make them look foolish to their peers. Finding that other members have
had similar experiences and related feelings help strengthen initial emotional
bonding among group members. The group leader encourages the development of
universality by linking member contributions together, pointing out similarities, and
stressing the importance of group members as therapists for each other.
When the group begins to meet, the leader plays an important role in establishing the
group structure. A standard first meeting format is to (1) identify the group‘s purpose
and goals; (2) name fundamental structural norms such as expected attendance,
confidentiality, and what to do incase of absence; and (3) explain how the group will
function. A general statement about the nature of work (i.e., that the group provides a
place where members can discuss serious personal issues and receive personal
feedback from each other) establishes the task of the group as serious. If members
have never been in group therapy before, the therapist briefly educates them as to
their roles as members.
Storming Phase:
The storming phase of group development signals movement beyond the initial
hesitancy and fear about being in the group. It can appear as a subtle questioning of
appropriateness of time or group objectives. This opens the door to exploration of
stronger feelings, hidden agendas and open conflicts as members struggle with issues
of power and control. Although uncomfortable, this phase of group development is
12
absolutely essential because it sets the foundation for the development of the group
specific norm that will guide the group in the working phase. This phase usually does
not last long. Establishing trust remains a central task for this phase of group
development. During this phase, the therapist acts as a gatekeeper by helping
individual group members identify but move beyond their personal agendas and
engage in their group dialogues. During this phase group members begin to engage
with each other at deeper level and to reveal more of their issues while asking for a
similar commitment from others.
Norming Phase:
During this phase, the group develops norms- behavioral standards and basic
operating procedures- that provide structural boundaries and guidelines for behaviors
that will or will not be tolerated. Some behaviors as classified as universal norms
because they are standards found in all psychotherapy groups. These are
predetermined norms, voiced during the opening session, that include regular
attendance, confidentiality and the expectation of verbal contributions. Other
standards are group specific norms, which emerge from the need of group members
to facilitate goal achievement. For eg, group specific norms for a chronic
schizophrenic therapy group might include specific basic group behaviors such as
talking one at a time, not leaving the room during the session, refraining from violent
behaviors towards other group members and refraining from obscene language.
Specific norm in a drug abuse group would be to remain drug free during the group
session.
The group pressure on members who do not confirm to expected norms helps
reinforce bonding. Because norm violation by one member affects the entire group,
the leader must always address norm violations as being significant.
Performing/Working Phase:
Once the ground rules for operating the group are in place, members actively engage
in working on group determined agendas. The performing phase is characterized by
cohesion and productivity and the most in depth work of the group takes place during
13
this phase. Self disclosure is more spontaneous and honest in the performing phase.
Members know what to expect from each other. In the process of working through
differences, a genuine respect for other members has developed, members trust the
comments of others and the sense of belonging is at its highest peak. Here, group
members experience the altruism of helping others, interpersonal learning, self
understanding, and recapitulation of the family.
Throughout the performing phase, the therapist’s primary function is to facilitate
movement towards the group goals by providing an accepting interpersonal
environment in which group members feel supported in exploring difficult issues.
Group members take responsibility for leadership activities and, in essence, become
therapist for each other.
14
INDIVIDUAL FUNCTIONS WITH IN A GROUP:
Aggressor: Acts negatively, with hostility toward other members; criticizes others’
contributions; attacks the group and its members.
Recognition-seeker: calls attention to own activities; boasts; redirects things
towards self.
15
Help-seeker or confessor: uses the group as a vehicle either to gain sympathy or to
achieve personal insight and self-satisfaction without consideration for others or the
group as a whole.
Dominator: asserts authority and seeks to manipulate others so as to be in control of
everything that happens.
16
COMMON PROBLEMS AFFECTING GROUP THERAPY AND PROCESS AND
ASSOCIATED NURSING INTERVENTIONS:
3. Hidden Agenda
• Identify the source of individual and
group anxiety causing the hidden
17
agenda.
• Explore the hidden agenda with the
group and its meaning and effect on
the group’s functioning.
18
in the group.
19
NURSES’ RESPONSIBILITY IN GROUP THERAPY
The primary role of the nurse – therapist in group therapy is to guide individuals through
a problem solving process by anticipating and responding to the needs and concerns of
the group members. The nurse therapist has both task and maintenance role functions.
Group task functions are concerned with the practical issues of leading a group, where
as group maintenance functions focus on less tangible group process.
ADVANTAGES:
1. More clients can be treated in a group, making the method cost effective.
2. Members benefit by hearing others discuss similar problems; feelings of
isolation, alienation, and uniqueness.
3. It provides the client opportunity to explore their specific styles of
communication in a safe atmosphere where they can receive feedback and
undergo changes.
4. Members learn multiple ways of solving a problem from others and group
exploration may help them to discover new ways of solving problems.
5. Members learn about the functional roles of individuals in the group. Sometimes
a member shares the responsibility as a co-therapist.
6. The group provides for its members’ understanding, confrontation and
identification with more than one person. The member gains a reference group.
DISADVANTAGES:
20
as resistance; others may be reluctant to expose themselves because they do not
want to change.
3. Group therapy is not helpful if the therapist conducts the group as if it is an
individual therapy. Such a therapist may see dynamics and group process as
incidental or antagonistic to the therapeutic process. The effective group leader
must be skilled in techniques and interventions that foster group interaction and
shape group behaviour and growth.
CONCLUSION
Purpose of group therapy is to intervene in mentally disorder behaviour, thinking
and feeling. Group therapy offers multiple stimuli to reveal examine and resolve
distortion in interpersonal relationship. The purpose of the group is related to goals and
expected outcomes. The group therapist focuses on the process of interpersonal learning
and change.
21
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1) Benner, Carson, Verna. Mental health nursing: The nurse patient journey. 2nd
ed. Philadelphia: W B Saunders Company; 2000. Page no. 354 – 362.
2) Taylor M, Cecelia. Essentials of psychiatric nursing. 14 th ed. Philadelphia:
Mosby publishers; 2001.Page no. 468 – 476.
3) Rebraca L, Shives. Basic concepts of psychiatric mental health nursing.7 th ed.
Philadelphia: Lippincott publishers; 2000. Page no.206 – 211.
4) Benjamine J S , Virginea A S . Synopsis of psychiatry. 10 th ed. Philadelphia:
Lippincott publishers; 2001. Page no. 934 – 940.
5) Townsend M C. Psychiatric mental health nursing. 5th ed. New Delhi: J P
Publishers; 2004. Page no. 151 – 157.
6) Mohr K W. Psychiatric Mental Health Nursing. 6 th ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott
Publishers; 2006. Page no: 198 – 205.
7) Johnson D P, Penn D L, Bauer D J, Meyer P, Evans E. Predictor of the
therapeutic alliance in group therapy for individuals with treatment resistant
auditory hallucinations. British journal of clinical psychology. 2008; 47: 171 –
183.
22