Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 63

Assessor Information

Assessor Company Name


Assessor E-mail Address
Assessor Phone Number
Date of Assessment
Date of CAP Finalization
Date of Report Submission

Facility Information
Facility Name
Facility Address

Bureau Veritas
2-8143387
29-Apr-14
5-May-14
21-Jan-15

Amantex Limited
Boiragirchala
Sreepur, Gazipur
Sreepur, Gazipur
Dhaka
Bangladesh

Key Facility Contact Name


Facility Phone Number
Contact Email
Lead Brand Company
Lead Brand Contact Name
Lead Brand Contact Email
Audit Type/Name
CAP Responder at Facility
Important Criteria/Instructions

Md. Samsuzzaman
samsuzzaman@amangroupbd.com

Md. Samsuzzaman

Audit Closing Comments

There are two main factory buildings & some


ancillary buildings in the premises of Amantex
Ltd. Auditor team have gone through the
submitted documents and found no significant
deficiencies except structural design reports in
the availability of necessary documents to asses
the said buildings. In the same way through visual
observations, the factory building-1 is found
seven storied but in general notes of design
documents , it is noted six storied. However, an
as built structure design report is found which
confirms the safety & stability of this buildings
against expected upcoming loads.

Subheader
Structural System Construction

Question
Is the structural system free of distress,
separations, or cracking that indicates lack of
performance or overstress of the lateral loadcarrying system?

Description
Some minor cracks have been found, specifically
in the joint of two beams at the 3rd, 4th & 5th
floors.

Structural System Construction

Is the structural system free of distress,


settlement, shifting, or cracking in columns or
walls?

There is no visual sign of distress, settlement,


shifting, or cracking in columns. But, some
hairline cracks have been found in wall at
mezzanine as well as 6th floor of seven storied
building.

Structural System Construction

Are all non-structural elements suspended from,


attached to, or resting atop the structure
adequately anchored and braced to resist
earthquake forces?

There are some unbraced, plastic, overhead


water tanks on the roof.

Structural System Design

Have provisions been made in floors or decks for


a concentrated load (such as heavy equipment,
water tanks, stored materials, etc) applied at a
location wherever this load acting upon an
otherwise unloaded floor would produce stresses
greater than those caused by a uniform load?

No provisions have been made for a floor with a


concentrated load. This makes the location of
water tanks very hazardous.

Structural System Design

Where density of operations, storage of materials, The live load for storage was almost 80 psf.
or equipment weights require live load capacity in
excess of 2.0 kN/m2 (42 psf), do the design
documents confirm that the required load
capacity exists? Or has the load capacity been
analytically confirmed and certified by an
Alliance-qualified structural engineer?

Structural System Design

Are credible structural design documents


available for review and kept on site?

Structural design documents are available


showing six stories. However, building is found
seven storied; design report is available. All the
submitted documents are properly signed by the
engineer with MIEB no. As-built structural
assessment report is submitted; but cannot be
accepted due to presence of
deficiencies.structural design documents for the
security building were not available.

Structural System Design

If the structure has been previously expanded,


was the structural impact on the entire structure
analytically evaluated and confirmed by a
qualified structural engineer.

General notes show that the factory building-1


was designed as a six storied structure. In reality,
it is a seven-storied building.

Structural System Construction

If the building is currently being renovated or


expanded, are the Construction Practices and
Safety requirements of Section 9 being followed?

The 8-storied factory building (building-2) is


under construction but the safety arrangement
(such as temporary canopy and safety net) is not
sufficient as per construction Practices and Safety
requirements of Alliance standard part-9. The
observed steel shed constructed on the roof for
building-1. This construction is approved but
detailed the structural design documents is
unavailable.

Structural Safety Programs

Is a program in place to ensure that the live loads There is no program available to manage floor
for which a floor or roof is or has been designed
and roof live loads. Floor load plans are also not
will not be exceeded?
available.

Structural System Construction

Have all areas of needed maintenance, including Dampness has been found in the 1st floor of
areas with efflorescence, dampness, standing
building 2.
water on rooftops, and corrosion been addressed.

Structural Safety Programs

Have Load Plans been prepared for each floor


documenting the actual maximum operational
loading that is intended and/or allowable on each
floor.

No Load Plans have been prepared for each floor


documenting actual maximum operational
loading that is intended or allowable on each
floor.

Structural Safety Programs

Are Floor Load Plans posted as required?

Floor Load Plans are not posted as required.

Structural Safety Programs

Are areas used for storage of work materials and


work products, clearly marked to indicate the
acceptable loading limits as described in the Load
Plan for that floor?

Storage of work materials and work products are


not marked to indicate the acceptable loading
limit. Also, the floor Load Plan is not available in
the floor.

Structural Safety Programs

Is a designated representative (Factory Load


Factory Load Manager or designated
Manager), who is onsite full time, trained
representative is not available.
regarding the structural floor capacity, and serves
as an ongoing vendor resource and monitor of
operational factory floor loadings?

Structural System Design

Is a Geotechnical Report available for review and


kept on site?

Geotechnical report is available and kept on site


to review, but the IEB no. of the engineer is not
available.

Structural System Design

Are Certificates of Occupancy available for


review?

The factory has not obtained the Certificate of


Occupancy from the authority.

682552787

Suggested Plan of Action


Engage a qualified structural engineer to provide
additional investigations of the cracking and
provide a remediation plan if necessary.

Suggested Deadline
Standard
Date 15-Sep-14 Alliance Standard Part 8 Section 8.3.3

Have a qualified structural engineer provide


further testing and analysis of distress,
settlement, shifting, or cracking in walls and
provide a remediation plan to correct noted
issues.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standard Part 8 Section 8.3.3

Relocate the water tanks. Adequately anchor and


brace all non-structural elements to resist
earthquake forces as to comply with the BNBC
and Alliance Standard.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standards Part 8 Section 8.18 Seismic


Bracing of Key Non-Structural Elements and 2006
BNBC Part 6

Relocate water tanks to a safe location. Engage a


qualified structural engineer to confirm and
document that provisions have been made to
accommodate concentrated loads. If provisions
have not been made, have a qualified structural
engineer develop a remediation plan.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standard Part 8 Section 8.13 and 8.14

Have a qualified structural engineer confirm that


capacity to support the load is available through
detailed structural assessment with SDT. Load
Plans complying with Alliance Standard Part 8
Section 8.20.4.3 should also be developed.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standards Part 8 Section 8.15 Minimum


Floor Design Loads

Have a qualified structural engineer prepare


credible as-built documents (drawings and
detailed assessment) based on the requirements
of Part 8 Section 8.19 of the Alliance Standard.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standard Part 8 Section 8.19 Required


Structural Documentation for New and Existing
Factories

Have a qualified structural engineer complete a


detailed structural assessment with SDT for
evaluation of the structural impact of the
addition.

15-Sep-14 Reference Alliance Standards Part 8 Section 8.1


Applicability of Building Code.

Provide sufficient safety arrangements (such as


temporary canopy will be provided just below the
construction floor surround the building and also
surrounded by safety net) as per construction
Practices and Safety requirements of Alliance
standard part-9.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standard Part 9 Construction Practices


and Safety.

Develop a program to ensure that all live loads


for which a floor or roof has been designed will
not be exceeded. The designated Load Manager
shall over see this program and ensure it is
enforced.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standard Part 13 Section 13.7 and Part 8


Section 8.9.

Under guidance from a qualified structural


engineer, address all areas of needed
maintenance.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standard Part 8 Section 8.26 Durability


and Maintenance

Have a qualified structural engineer to develop


floor Load Plans through detailed structural
assessment with SDT as per the requirements of
Part 8 Section 8.20.5.3.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standard Part 8 Section 8.10 Floor


Loading Plans (Load Plans)

Have a qualified structural engineer prepare load


plans including the information required in
Section 8.20 of the Alliance Standard. Floor load
plan should be posted in each floor.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standard Part 8 Section 8.20.5.3

Provide appropriate markings at all areas used for


storage to indicate the acceptable loading limits
detailed in the Load Plan.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standard Part 8 Section 8.11 Floor Load


Markings

Designate a representative as the Factory Load


Manager. The Factory Owner shall ensure that
one Factory Load Manager is located onsite full
time. The Factory Load Manager must be trained
in calculating operational load characteristics of
the factory. The Factory Load Manager shall serve
as an ongoing resource to RMG vendors and be
responsible to ensure that the factory operational
loads do not at any time exceed the factory floor
loading limits as described on the Floor Loading
Plans.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standards Part 8 Section 8.9 Factory Load


Manager

The IEB no. of the engineer must be mentioned in


the geotechnical report.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standard Part 8 Section 8.2 Structural


Integrity of Existing Factory Buildings

Apply for issuance of Certificate of Occupancy


and pursue the matter to obtain the same.

15-Sep-14 Alliance Standard Part 8 Section 8.3 Preliminary


Structural Assessment

Factory CAP
We will do it within 20-Nov-2014.

Factory CAP Deadline Date


Factory Responsible
20-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Person
Ahmed

We will do it within 20-Nov-2014.

20-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

We will do it within 20-Nov-2014.

1-Jan-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

We will do it within 20-Nov-2014.

20-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

Already capacity plan confirm by Structural


designer

20-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

Already credible load plan confirm by Structural


designer for seven storied building and sign with
MIEB no.

20-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

Already credible load plan confirm by Structural


designer for seven storied building and given
notes by sign with MIEB number.

20-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

Already provided sufficient safety arrangement


including temporary canopy with safety net.

20-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

Already developed a program to ensure that all


live loads.

6-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

We will do it within 20-Nov-2014.

20-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

Already developed floor load plan by structural


consultant.

20-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

Already developed floor load plan by structural


consultant.

20-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

Already provided appropriate markings at all


areas used for storage to indicate the acceptable
loading limits detailed in the Load Plan.

20-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

We will appoint a designated representative as


the Factory Load Manager.

6-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

Geotechnical report is available and kept on site


to review which signed by the MIEB engineer.

20-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

We will collect the Certificate of Occupancy from


the authority.

20-Nov-14 Engr. Faruq Ahmed

Source of Findings
Level
Visual Assessment: Some minor cracks have been High
found, especially in the joint of two beams at 3rd,
4th & 5th floor.

Non-Compliance Level
1

Visual Assessment: In visual assessment no visual High


sign of distress, settlement, shifting, or cracking
in columns. But, some hairline cracks have been
found in wall at mezzanine as well as 6th floor of
seven storied building.

Visual Assessment: Some unbraced plastic


overhead water tanks are located on the roof.

Medium

Document Review: Based on the structural


document, the provisions
for a concentrated load, such as water tanks,
have not been made., Visual Assessment:
Arrangement for water tanks is not safe.

Medium

Document Review: Floor load capacity is not


mentioned in the document., Visual Assessment:
Live load exceeds 42 psf.

Medium

Document Review: Structural drawings are


Medium
available for six storied building; design report is
not available., Visual Assessment: The six storied
building shown in drawing was noted as seven
storied from visual observation.

Document Review: Structural drawings show that Medium


the building is designed to have six stories.,
Visual Assessment: The building has seven
stories.

Visual Assessment: Observations of the factory


building-2.

Medium

Visual Assessment: Floor load plan is not


available.

Medium

Visual Assessment: Dampness has been found in


the 1st floor of building 2.

Medium

Document Review: No Load Plan is documented.

Low

Visual Assessment: In visual assessment no load


plans have been found.

Low

Visual Assessment: No Load Plan is available in


the floor.

Low

Document Review: The HR file of Factory Load


Manager or designated representative is not
documented., Visual Assessment: Presence of
factory load manager or designated
representative has not been seen.

Low

Document Review: Geotechnical report is


available in the submitted
document. However, the IEB no. of the engineer
is not available.

Low

Document Review: The document review shows


that the factory has not obtained the Certificate
of Occupancy from the authority.

Low

Assessor Information
Assessor Company Name
Assessor E-mail Address
Assessor Phone Number
Date of Assessment
Date of CAP Finalization
Date of Report Submission

Facility Information
Facility Name
Facility Address

Bureau Veritas
2-8143387
16-Apr-14
3-May-14
21-Jan-15

Amantex Limited
Boiragirchala
Sreepur, Gazipur
Sreepur, Gazipur
Dhaka
Bangladesh

Key Facility Contact Name


Facility Phone Number
Contact Email
Lead Brand Company
Lead Brand Contact Name
Lead Brand Contact Email
Audit Type/Name
CAP Responder at Facility
Important Criteria/Instructions

Md. Samsuzzaman
samsuzzaman@amangroupbd.com

Md. Samsuzzaman

Audit Closing Comments

Subheader
Means of Egress

In the closing meeting, the non-conformities were


explained to the factory personnel. The issues are
as follows- One door width found 0.7m at
ground floor which is not sufficient in accordance
with Alliance Standard in Building-2. Visually
some of the doors are fire rated. However no
credible certificate is available. There are
collapsible gates and steel sliding doors with
locking arrangement at some egress locations.
Height of the highest occupied floor of the main
building is 19.51m (64ft) above grade i.e. above
23 m (75 ft). Therefore, class III standpipe system
needs to be installed throughout the building as
per Alliance Standard 5.4.2 and NFPA 14. Only
class-II(40 mm) fabric hoses are connected with
underground Water Reservoir. There are 4 stairs
in the main building. Two of them are interior
stairs and others are external stairs. There are
swinging glass doors available at interior exits.
All doors in a means of egress are not side-hinged
swinging type. Most of them are collapsible,
sliding. There is dedicated fire pump available
in the factory and one jockey pump with
alternative automatic backup power but no
approved design with hydraulic calculation was
found as per NFPA 20. On ground floor there is
Chemical store without proper fire separation.
Chemical store need to be fire separated
according to BNBC Table-3.2.2 pg-10355. On 2nd
floor there is no proper fire separation between
production floor and fabric store. Two hour fire
Question
Doors along the path of egress have a minimum
width of 0.8 m (32 in) and have required ratings.

Description
One door width found 0.7m at ground floor which
is not sufficient in accordance with Alliance
Standard in building-2. Visually some of the doors
appear fire-rated. However, no credible fire-rating
certification for the doors is available.

Means of Egress

Doors are not locked in the direction of egress


There are collapsible gates and steel sliding doors
under any conditions. All hasps, locks, slide bolts, with locking arrangements at some egress
and other locking devices have been removed
locations.
where required.

Means of Egress

All doors in a means of egress are of the sidehinged swinging type.

Some doors in means of egress are not sidehinged swinging and self-latching type. Most of
them are collapsible, sliding gates.

Fire Protection Systems

Does the building have a Standpipe System?

Height of the highest occupied floor of the main


building is 19.51m (64ft) above grade i.e. above
23m (75 ft). Therefore, class III standpipe system
needs to be installed throughout the building as
per Alliance Standard 5.4.2 and NFPA 14. Only
class-II (40mm) fabric hoses are connected with
underground Water Reservoir.

Fire Protection Systems

Does the building have a fire pump?

There is a dedicated fire pump available in the


factory and one jockey pump with alternative
automatic backup power, but no approved design
with hydraulic calculation was found as per NFPA
20.

Fire Protection Construction

Are exit enclosures provided with fire-resistive


rated construction barriers?

There are 4 sets of stairs in the main building.


Two of them are interior stairs and two are
external stairs. There are swinging glass doors at
the interior exits.

Fire Protection Construction

Are separations between hazards provided with


fire-resistive rated construction barriers.

On ground floor there is chemical storage without


proper fire separation. Chemical storage needs to
be fire separated according to BNBC Table-3.2.2
pg-10355.
On 2nd floor there is no proper fire separation
between production floor and fabric storage. Two
hour fire separation required between production
floor and fabric storage according to BNBC Table
3.2.1 pg-10352.

Means of Egress

Occupant loads are posted for every assembly


and production floor in a conspicuous space near
the main point of egress.

Occupant loads are not posted for every


assembly and production floor in a conspicuous
space near the main point of egress.

Means of Egress

Every door in a stair enclosure serving more than There are no re-entry doors available in
5 stories is provided with re-entry unless it meets accordance with Section-6.8.3 and 6.8.3.1(a).
the requirements of Alliance Standards Part 6
Section 6.8.3.1.

Means of Egress

Emergency power for exit signs is tested at least


once per year. If battery operated, these lights
are tested on a monthly basis. Functional testing
of battery powered signs is provided for a
minimum 90 min once per year.

Means of Egress

Emergency power for means of egress


Available documents of periodical testing of
illumination is verified at least once per year. If
emergency power for means of egress were
battery operated lights are used, these lights are found but do not comply with Alliance Standard.
tested on a monthly basis. Functional testing of
battery powered lights is provided for a minimum
90 min once per year.

Fire Protection Systems

Fire extinguishers are inspected, tested, and


maintained as required.

Documentation of periodical testing for


emergency power of means of egress signs were
found but the documentation does not comply
with the Alliance Standard.

Extinguishers are inspected monthly by factory's


staff. No documents were found in support of i)
annual maintenance of extinguishers by a
servicing agent, ii) annual testing of nozzle,
and/or iii) internal inspection of extinguishers at 5
year interval.

Fire Safety Programs

Chemicals and other flammable materials are


stored within approved enclosures.

Chemicals and other flammable materials are not


stored within approved enclosures.

Fire Safety Programs

Training programs are implemented and


documented in accordance with the Alliance
Safety Training Curriculum.

No records of training programs are available in


accordance with the Alliance Safety Training
Curriculum on fire safety.

Fire Protection Systems

Standpipe system piping is free of mechanical


damage, leakage, and corrosion?

Complete standpipe system not installed yet.


Current standpipe system piping is free of
mechanical damage, leakage, and corrosion.

Fire Protection Systems

Is the fire alarm and detection system monitored An automatic fire alarm and detection system is
by a central station monitoring service or directly available in the factory. However, there is no
connected to the Fire Service and Civil Defense? monitoring company in Bangladesh. Fire Service
and Civil Defense are not capable of monitoring
the fire alarm and detection systems of the
factories.

Fire Safety Programs

An emergency evacuation plan has been


developed and communicated to all employees.

An emergency evacuation plan has not been


developed yet.

Fire Safety Programs

Fire Department pre-planning has been


completed.

Fire Department pre-planning has not been


completed.

Means of Egress

Stair designation signs are provided at each floor Stair designation signs are not provided at each
entrance from the stair to the floor in English and floor. Only floor level is designated in Bengali &
Bengali. Signs indicate the name of the stair and English.
the floor level. Signs are posted adjacent to the
door.

Fire Protection Systems

Are inspection, maintenance, and testing


procedures of the standpipe and hose system
documented and up to date? Including inspection
and testing of hoses if provided.

Complete standpipe system not installed yet.


There are maintenance plans and records for the
testing and maintenance of the current standpipe
system.

Fire Protection Systems

Is signage for the standpipe system installed at


required locations and on required components?

Complete standpipe system is not installed yet.


Signage for the existing standpipe system is not
installed.

Fire Protection Systems

Are inspection, maintenance, and testing


procedures of the fire pump documented and up
to date?

Proper fire pump has not been installed.


Inspection, maintenance, and testing procedures
of the existing fire pump has not been
documented or kept up to date.

Fire Protection Construction

Certificates of Occupancy for each building have


been issued and are on file.

No occupancy certificates are available for any


buildings.

Fire Safety Programs

A hot-work permit program has been established. A hot-work permit program has not been
established.

Fire Safety Programs

A written housekeeping policy is established and


enforced.

The available record is not in compliance with the


Alliance standard.

682552787

Suggested Plan of Action


Provide 1.5 hour fire-rated opening assemblies in
2 hour fire-rated exit enclosure. Increase door
width to 0.8m or greater by demolishing wall
adjacent to the door. If this door is not required to
satisfy the requirement of total exit width (based
on occupant load) and maximum travel distance,
eliminate this door.

Suggested Deadline
Standard
Date 8-Aug-14 Alliance Standard Part 6 Section 6.5.6 Minimum
Widths. Increased occupant loads will require a
door width greater than 0.8 m.

Provide side-swinging, self-closing and latching


non-lockable certified 1.5 hour fire-rated doors
that open in the direction of egrees in 2 hour
rated exit enclosures. Exits shall be enclosed with
the same fire-resistance rating as the floor
penetrated but will not need to exceed 2 hour.

30-May-14 Alliance Standards Part 6 Section 6.8 Doors and


Gates

Replace all collapsible, sliding gates and shutters


in means of egresses with side-hinged swinging,
self-latching doors of proper width and rating to
comply with Section-6.8.1.

8-Aug-14 Alliance Standards Part 6 Section 6.8 Doors and


Gates

Install a standpipe system at required locations


which are to be designed by a qualified fire
protection engineer. The system must be
compliant with the requirements of NFPA 14. The
hydraulic calculations should be reviewed by
Alliance and review to be completed prior to start
of work. All standpipe system installations shall
be submitted for review by the Alliance for review
prior to commencement of installation according
to 5.4.3.2. Testing of the installation shall be
conducted in accordance with NFPA 14
acceptance testing requirements. Documentation
of all testing shall be submitted for review by the
Alliance. Final inspection and testing of the
installation shall be witnessed by the Alliance as
per clause 5.4.3.3.

8-Aug-14 Does the building have a standpipe system


installed where required. Alliance Standard Part 5
Section 5.4.2

Install a pump dedicated for fire fighting or fire


protection. Should follow the requirements of
NFPA 20. Pump design should also account for 5th
floor which is under construction. Fire pump
installation is to be tested for final acceptance in
presence of Alliance and a final inspection of the
installation shall be conducted by the Alliance
prior to final acceptance of the installation.
Acceptance testing of the installation shall be in
accordance with NFPA 20, 22, and 24 testing
requirements. Documentation of all testing shall
be submitted to the Alliance for review prior to
final acceptance. This pump is to be connected to
an alternative power source like a generator and
the generator is to be connected with ATS (auto
starter).

31-Oct-14 Alliance Standard Part 5 Fire Protection Systems

Provide 2 hr fire-resistive rated construction


barriers at exit enclosures. Fit outward opening,
side-swinging, self-closing and latching, nonlockable certified fire doors of 1.5 hr rating in all
stairwell enclosures. Consult a qualified fire
protection engineer to design the required rated
construction barriers.

8-Aug-14 Reference Alliance Standards Part 4 Section 4.5


Separation

Provide fire-resistive rated construction barriers


between hazard types following Table 4.4.1 of
Alliance Standard or Table 4.1.1 from BNBC Part
4. Consult a qualified fire protection engineer to
design the required rated construction barrier.

31-Oct-14 Reference Alliance Standards Part 4 Section 4.5


Separation

Post the occupant load for every assembly and


production floor in a facility in a conspicuous
space near the main exit or exit access doorway
for the space.

13-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 6 Section 6.4.4 Posting of


Occupant Load

Every door in a stair enclosure serving more than


5 stories shall be provided with re-entry unless it
meets the following requirements. Stair doors
may be permitted to be locked from the stair
(ingress) side that prevents re-entry to the floor
provided at least two floors allowing re-entry to
access another exit are provided, there are not
more than 4 stories intervening between re-entry
floors, re-entry is allowed on the top or next to
top level, reentry doors are identified as such on
the stair side, and locked doors shall be identified
as to the nearest re-entry floors. When the
discharge floor is determined to be a required reentry floor using the above requirements, reentry does not have to be provided back into the
building on this level.

8-Aug-14 Alliance Standards Part 6 Section 6.8 Doors and


Gates

Develop a testing and maintenance program that


ensures the emergency power for exit signs is
tested at least once per year. If battery operated
signs are used, these lights must be tested on a
monthly basis. Functional testing of battery
powered signs must be conducted for a minimum
90 min once per year.

13-Jun-14 Alliance Standard Part 10 Section 10.12


Illumination of Exit Signs and Means Of Escape.

Develop a testing and maintenance program that


ensures the operation of all exit signs is verified
at least once per year. If battery-operated signs
are used, these lights shall be tested on a
monthly basis. Functional testing of battery
powered signs shall be provided for a minimum
90 minutes once per year.

13-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.12


Illumination of Exit Signs and Means Of Escape
Lighting

Fire extinguishers are to be inspected, tested, and


maintained in accordance with NFPA 10 Chapter
7.

31-Oct-14 NFPA 10 Chapter 7

Store chemicals and all flammable materials in


approved enclosure in a safe manner.

30-Jun-14

Implement training program with proper


documentation in accordance with the Alliance
Safety Training Curriculum on fire safety.

13-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 13

An appropriate standpipe system needs to be


installed at required locations designed by a
qualified fire protection engineer. The system is
to be compliant with the requirements of NFPA
14. Also install required identification signs at the
noted locations. Signage must comply with NFPA
14 Chapter 6.

31-Oct-14 NFPA 25 Chapter 6 Standpipe and Hose Systems

Arrange for direct connection of the fire alarm


system to a central monitoring station or Fire
Service and Civil Defense. Until direct monitoring
can be set up, a person shall be assigned to
contact the fire department in the event of fire
alarm activation. An annunciator shall be located
in a constantly attended location (such as a fire
control room) to alert this person.

13-Jun-14 Alliance Standard Part 5 Section 5.7.5 Monitoring

Develop an emergency evacuation plan which


includes all components required by the Alliance
Standards and communicate the plan to all
employees.

13-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 13 Section 13.1 Fire


Safety Director

Complete Fire Department pre-planning activities


with the local Fire Service and Civil Defense.

13-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 13 Section 13.1 Fire


Safety Director

Install signage adjacent to each stair door


indicating the stair name and the floor level at
the noted locations in accordance with Section
6.9.3.1.

13-Jun-14 Alliance Standard Part 6 Section 6.9 Stairs

An appropriate standpipe system needs to be


designed by a qualified fire protection engineer
and installed at required locations. The system
must comply with the requirements of NFPA 14.

31-Oct-14 Reference NFPA 25 Chapter 6 Standpipe and Hose


Systems Table 6.1.1.2

An appropriate standpipe system needs to be


installed at the required locations designed by a
qualified fire protection engineer. The system is
to be compliant with the requirements of NFPA
14. Also, install required identification signs at the
noted locations. Signage must comply with NFPA
14 Chapter 6.

27-Jun-14 Reference NFPA 14 Chapter 6

Install a pump dedicated for fire fighting or fire


protection following the requirements of NFPA 20.
Also Establish an inspection, maintenance, and
testing program for the fire pump. Program must
comply with NFPA 25.

31-Oct-14 Reference NFPA 25 Chapter 8 Fire Pumps

Apply to PWD for issuance of occupancy


certificate and pursue the matter to expedite.

27-Jun-14 Are certificates of occupancy provided for each


building or ancillary structure?

Develop a hot-work permit program that complies


with Section-9.1.7 and NFPA 51B. In general, this
program should address the process of request
and approval of authorities, necessary checks
prior to approval, standby fire watch and
firefighting equipment, sounding of alarm
procedure, duration and expiry of permit, and reapproval procedures, etc.

31-Oct-14 Alliance Standards Part 13 Section 13.4 Hot Work


Permit and NFPA 51B

Establish written corporate and plant policies on


housekeeping to ensure scheduled cleaning for
floor, wall, ceiling, supply, and return air
ventilation systems. Promptly reschedule skipped
cleanings. Provide a documented line of authority
for authorizing a cleaning delay and rescheduling.
As a general rule the maximum tolerable deposit
thickness for loose fluffy lint is 13mm (in.) over
a maximum of 46.5m2 (500ft2). Limit dense
deposits to 6mm (in.) and oil saturated deposits
to 3.2mm (in.).

23-Jan-15 Alliance Standards Part 13 Section 13.6


Housekeeping

Factory CAP
We will do it within 30-Nov-2014.

Factory CAP Deadline Date


Factory Responsible
Person
23-Feb-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

Done

Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 31-Dec-2014.

23-Feb-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 31-Dec-2014.

23-Feb-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 25.02.2015

18-May-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 25.02.2015

23-Feb-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 25.02.2015

18-May-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

Done.

Mr. Abdur Rahim

We are working on it. We need huge construction


works.

23-Feb-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 31-Dec-2014.

29-Dec-14 Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 31-Dec-2014.

29-Dec-14 Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 31-Dec-2014.

18-May-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 31.01.2015.

15-Dec-14 Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 31-Dec-2014.

29-Dec-14 Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 31-Dec-2014.

18-May-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

Done.

Mr. Abdur Rahim

Done.

Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 31-Dec-2014.

29-Dec-14 Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 31-Dec-2014.

29-Dec-14 Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 31-Dec-2014.

18-May-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

We will do it within 31-Dec-2014.

We have fire pump. We will maintain document


on maintenance, and testing.

We will do it within 31-Dec-2014.

Done.

We will do it within 31.01.2015.

12-Jan-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

18-May-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

12-Jan-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

Mr. Abdur Rahim

10-Aug-15 Mr. Abdur Rahim

Source of Findings
Photograph: Door widths were not sufficient to
comply with Alliance Standard in building-2.

Level
High

Non-Compliance Level
3

Visual Assessment: There are collapsible gates


High
and steel sliding doors with locking arrangements
at some egress locations.

Photograph: Side-hinged swinging exit.

High

Photograph: Photograph shows the standpipe


system.

High

Photograph: Available dedicated fire pump and


one jockey pump with alternative automatic
backup power.

High

Visual Assessment: Interior exit enclosures are


not fire protected.

High

Visual Assessment: Chemical storage was found


without proper fire separation.

Medium

Visual Assessment: Visual Assessment shows that Medium


occupant loads are not posted for every assembly
and production floor in a conspicuous space near
the main point of egress.

Visual Assessment: No re-entry doors are


provided in the main building.

Medium

Document Review: Relevant document available


but is not complying with the alliance standard.

Medium

Document Review: Relevant document found of


Medium
periodical testing of emergency power for means
of egress were found but do not comply with
Alliance Standard.

Document Review: Documents show that fire


extinguishers are inspected, tested, and
maintained on a monthly basis., Photograph: Fire
extinguishers are inspected, tested, and
maintained monthly.

Medium

Visual Assessment: Chemicals and other


flammable materials are not stored within
approved enclosures.
Document Review: No records of training
programs are available in accordance with the
Alliance Safety Training Curriculum on fire safety.

Medium

Medium

Photograph: No mechanical damage, leakage, or


corrosion is identifiable on current standpipe
system.

Medium

Photograph: Automatic fire alarm and detection


system is available in the factory.

Medium

Document Review: Among the documents shown


by the factory personnel, no proper emergency
evacuation plan was found.

Medium

Document Review: Documents show that Fire


Low
Department pre-planning has not been completed
yet.
Photograph: Floor level is mentioned in Bengali & Low
English only.

Photograph: Registry book of maintenance and


testing procedures of the standpipe and hose
system. This shows that the factory conducted
proper inspection, maintenance, and testing
procedures of the standpipe and hose system.

Low

Visual Assessment: No signage is found for the


available standpipe.

Low

Document Review: There is no evidence of a plan Low


or record for maintenance of the fire pump.

Document Review: Document review shows that


the factory has no occupancy certificate for any
of its structures.
Document Review: A hot-work permit program
has not been established.

Low

Low

Document Review: Available record is not in


compliance with the Alliance standard.

Low

Assessor Information
Assessor Company Name
Assessor E-mail Address
Assessor Phone Number
Date of Assessment
Date of CAP Finalization
Date of Report Submission

Facility Information
Facility Name
Facility Address

Bureau Veritas
2-8143387
16-Apr-14
3-May-14
21-Jan-15

Amantex Limited
Boiragirchala
Sreepur, Gazipur
Sreepur, Gazipur
Dhaka
Bangladesh

Key Facility Contact Name


Facility Phone Number
Contact Email
Lead Brand Company
Lead Brand Contact Name
Lead Brand Contact Email
Audit Type/Name
CAP Responder at Facility
Important Criteria/Instructions
Audit Closing Comments

Md. Samsuzzaman
samsuzzaman@amangroupbd.com

Md. Samsuzzaman
Number of observations were found during Audit,
but following observations were highlighted
during closing meeting: 1. Looping at Circuit
Breaker Terminal (DB-Unit 2/1, DB-Unit 3/1). 2.
Lint and Dirt present inside the Distribution Panel
(DB-Unit 3/2). 3. Non Graded rubber mat present
infront of Distribution Panel (DB-5/GF, DB-Mid
Level TR, DB-GF/2, MDB-Wash). 4. No Phase
separator at Circuit Breaker terminal (DBCanteen).

Subheader
Electrical System Maintenance

Question
Have workers that operate and maintain the
electrical system received electrical safety
training? Is training documentation on site?

Description
Workers that operate and maintain the electrical
system have not received any electrical safety
training.

Electrical System Conditions

Are all switchboards and/or distribution boards


metal enclosed with a dead front construction?

All distribution boards are metal enclosed but lack


dead front construction.

Emergency Power System

Are life safety loads (fire alarm, fire pump,


elevators, emergency lighting, exit signage, etc)
connecting to the emergency power system?

The emergency generator is not under Amantex


management nor is it in the Amantex compound.

Emergency Power System

Are emergency power switchboards, distribution


boards, and circuits properly identified?

Emergency power switchboards, distribution


boards, and circuits are not properly identified.

Emergency Power System

Is an uninterruptable power supply (UPS)


provided?

No uninterruptible power supply (UPS) has been


provided for certain electrical appliances that
require uninterruptible conditioned sinusoidal
wave.

Emergency Power System

Are cable trenches properly covered?

Electrical System Conditions

Light fixtures without protective covers are not


installed in storage areas or in any area where
the Inspector of the Factories Rules (1.5.3.5) Part
53 disallows these fixtures.

No cover on cable trench.


Location: Boiler Room.
Light fixtures without protective covers are
installed in storage areas.
Location: 4th floor, Main Building

Electrical System Conditions

No circuits are drawn for loads without the


incorporation of a overcurrent protection device
(circuit breaker).

Circuits are drawn for loads without the


incorporation of an overcurrent protection device
(circuit breaker).
Location: DB-GF/6, Ground Floor, Main Building

Electrical System Conditions

Is electrical wiring/cables sized according to


capacity of circuit breakers (No higher rated
circuit breakers with lower rated wiring)?

Electrical cables are not sized according to


capacity of circuit breakers.
Location: DB- W/T, Ground Floor, Main Building
(Problem found 2 DBs out of 32 DBs).

Electrical System Conditions

Indications of overheating, overloading, or signs


of burning were not observed.

Indications of overheating were observed (Critical


Temperature 76.7 found in thermography scan).
Location: LT Panel, Substation room.

Electrical System Maintenance

Are records concerning the testing and inspection Records concerning the testing and inspection of
of the electrical systems maintained on site and the electrical systems are not maintained.
up to date?

Electrical System Maintenance

Are thermographic scans of electrical equipment


completed at least every three years?

Thermographic scans of electrical equipment are


not completed properly.

Electrical System Conditions

Do switchboards and/or distribution boards have


clear identification markings?

Distribution boards have no clear identification


markings.
Location : All Distribution boards.

Electrical System Conditions

Do switchboards and/or distribution boards have


capacity information labels?

Distribution boards do not have capacity


information labels.
Location: All distribution boards.

Electrical System Conditions

Are switchboards and/or distribution boards


provided with physical means to prevent the
installation of more over current devices than
that number for which the panel board was
designed, rated, and listed.

Distribution boards are not provided with physical


means to prevent the installation of more over
current devices than that number for which the
panel board was designed, rated, and listed.
Location: All distribution boards.

Electrical System Maintenance

Are periodic safety inspections of the electrical


Periodic safety inspections of the electrical
system components completed and documented? system components were neither completed nor
documented.

Electrical System Conditions

Are electrical wiring/cables properly identified?

Electrical cables are not properly identified.


Location: All distribution boards.

Electrical System Conditions

A wire/cable shaft is provided for the whole


building. Wiring and cables are arranged in shaft
for ease of inspection and maintenance.

No cable shaft is provided for the whole building.

Lightning Protection System

The air termination network vertical and


horizontal conductors are appropriately spaced.

No designs or documents were found to verify air


termination network vertical and horizontal
conductors are appropriately spaced.

Lightning Protection System

The appropriate number of down conductors are


installed based on the building size.

No designs or documents were found to verify if


the appropriate number of down conductors were
installed based on the building size.
Location: Roof top of the building

Lightning Protection System

The lightning protection ground terminals are


bonded to the building or structure grounding.

The lightning protection ground terminals are not


bonded to the building or structure grounding.

Electrical System Conditions

Each circuit is provided with a dedicated neutral.

Some circuits are not provided with a dedicated


neutral.
Location: DB- Boiler, Ground Floor, Boiler Room
(Problem found 12 DBs out of 32 DBs).

Electrical System Conditions

Lighting fixtures are supported from the structure Lighting fixtures are not supported properly.
and seismic bracing is installed as required.
Location: 2nd Floor, Training section.

Electrical System Conditions

Cable joints are through porcelain/PVC connectors Improper cable joints were found.
with PIB tape wound around joint.
Location: SDB-1, Training, 1st Floor, Training
Section. (All DBs of Ground floor main building
and 1st floor, main building) (Problem found 8
DBs out of 31 DBs).

Electrical System Conditions

Electrical connections at equipment, fixtures, etc


are properly secured.

Electrical System Conditions

Electrical wiring and conduit is properly


supported.

Electrical System Conditions

Are electrical insulation mats provided in front of


substation, switchboards and/or distribution
boards?

Electrical connections at equipment are not


properly secured.
Location: 4th floor, Main Building.
Electrical wiring and conduits are not properly
supported.
Location: 1. DB- W/T, Ground Floor, Main Building.
Electrical insulation mats are non-graded and
insufficient in front of distribution boards.
Location: All distribution boards.

Electrical System Conditions

Are meters and other electrical devices


(Ammeter, Voltmeter, PFI Auto Controller, etc)
installed on the main electrical equipment
operational?

Meters and other electrical devices (Ammeter,


Voltmeter and indicator light) are not installed on
the main electrical equipment.
Location: MDB-Utility, Ground Floor, Main
Building.

682552787

Suggested Plan of Action


Develop and implement an electrical safety
program. Include key topics such as lock-out tagout procedures, personal protective equipment
requirements, etc. Provide training document on
site.
Ensure switchboards and/or distribution boards
are metal enclosed with a dead front
construction.
Provide emergency power connection for life
safety loads (fire alarm, fire pump, elevators,
emergency lighting, exit signage, etc.).

Suggested Deadline
Standard
Date 29-Jun-14 Reference NFPA 70e for example

14-May-15 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.7 Main


Switch, Switchboards and Metal Clad Switchgear

11-Jun-14 Alliance Standard Part 10 Section 10.8 Standby


Power

Ensure proper identification of emergency power


switchboards, distribution boards, and circuits.

1-Jun-14 NFPA 70 Chapter 7 Article 700.10 Wiring,


Emergency System

Provide uninterruptable power supply (UPS) for


life safety loads (fire alarm, fire pump, elevators,
emergency lighting, exit signage, etc.).

13-Jul-14 Not Applicable

Provide adequate cover on cable trench.


Ensure light fixtures without protective covers are
not installed in storage areas or in any area
where the Inspector of the Factories Rules
(1.5.3.5) Part 53 disallows these fixtures.

14-May-14 Alliance Standard Part 10 Section 10.13.7


Inspection of the Installation
4-May-14 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.15 Naked
Lights

Ensure overcurrent protection device (circuit


breaker) is incorporated in every circuit.

15-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.9 Protection


of Circuits

Consult with a qualified Electrical Engineer and


ensure electrical wiring/cables are sized
according to capacity of circuit breakers.

29-Jun-14 Alliance Standard Part 10 Section 10.3.1 Electrical


Connections.

Factory CAP

Investigate the cause of the overheating and take


proper action.

4-May-14 Alliance Standard Part 10 Section 10.3.5

Develop an electrical maintenance program that


includes inspections and testing of the electrical
systems. Keep records on site.

29-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.13.8


Electrical Inspections

Complete thermographic scans at least on a three


year cycle. [Thermographic scans should be
completed in accordance with the Standard for
Infrared Inspection of Electrical Systems &
Rotating Equipment and NFPA70B or a
comparable standard.]

29-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.13.8


Electrical Inspections

Ensure clear and permanent identification marks


are painted in all distribution boards,
switchboards, sub main boards and switches.
Provide capacity information labels (maximum
current rating, number of circuit breakers, etc.)
for switchboards and/or distribution boards.

25-May-14 Alliance Standard Part 10 Section 10.7


BNBC Part 8 Section 2.11.5.4

8-Jun-14 Alliance Standard Part 10 Section 10.7 Main


Switch, Switchboards And Metal Clad Switchgear
and 10.13.7 Inspection of the Installation

Ensure switchboards and/or distribution boards


are provided with physical means to prevent the
installation of more over current devices than
that number for which the panel board was
designed, rated, and listed following NFPA 70
section 408.54.

29-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.7 Main


Switch, Switchboards and Metal Clad Switchgear

Establish a periodic inspection program to ensure


the electrical systems are free from damage,
debris, dirt, lint, etc. Maintain records concerning
inspections and follow up actions.

29-Jun-14 Alliance Standard Part 10 Section 10.13


Inspection and Testing and Part 13 Section 13.6
Housekeeping

Ensure a clear and easy means of identification


for electrical wiring and cables by separating
them by color coding, marking tape, tagging, or
other approved means.

29-Jun-14 Bangladesh Electricity Rules 1937 Rule 51 and 56

Provide wire/cable shaft for the whole building.


Wiring and cables are arranged in shaft for ease
of inspection and maintenance.

27-Jul-14 BNBC Part 8 Section 2.5.6.1

Consult with an expert electrical engineer and


make sure the system is secure.

8-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.11


Lightning Protection

Consult with an expert electrical engineer and


make sure the system is secure.

22-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.11


Lightning Protection

Ensure the lightning protection ground terminals


are bonded to the building or structure grounding.

15-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.11


Lightning Protection

Provide dedicated neutral for each and every


circuit.

29-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.3 Electrical


Wiring and Cabling

Ensure lighting fixtures are supported from the


structure and seismic bracing is installed as
required.

1-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.3.6 Lighting


Fittings

Ensure cable joints are through porcelain/PVC


connectors with PIB tape wound around joint.

29-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.3.8.4 Cable


Joints

Ensure electrical connections at equipment are


properly secured.

15-Jun-14 Alliance Standards Part 10 Section 10.3.1


Electrical Connections

Provide adequate supports for electrical wiring


and conduits.

15-Jun-14 Alliance Standard Part 10 Section 10.3.2,


10.3.4.3, and 10.3.5

Provide graded electrical insulation mats in front


of distribution boards.

1-Jun-14 Alliance Standard Part 10 Section 10.13.7


Inspection of the Installation.

Ensure meters and other electrical devices


installed on the main electrical equipment are
operational.

15-Jun-14 Alliance Standard 10.13.7 Inspection of the


Installation

Factory CAP Deadline Date

Factory Responsible
Person

Source of Findings
Worker Interviews: In interviews with workers
they indicated that they have received no
electrical safety training.

Level
High

Non-Compliance Level
3

Photograph: No dead front construction.

High

Visual Assessment: No emergency power for life


safety loads.

High

Visual Assessment: No identification of


emergency DBs/CKTs.

High

Visual Assessment: No UPS found.

High

Photograph: No cover on cable trench.

High

Photograph: Naked light fixtures installed in


storage areas.

High

Photograph: No protection device.

High

Photograph: Higher rated circuit breakers with


lower rated wiring.

High

Photograph: Indications of overheating.

High

Document Review: No testing and inspection


records of the electrical systems.

Medium

Document Review: No thermographic scans for


electrical equipment.

Medium

Photograph: No clear identification markings.

Medium

Photograph: No DB capacity information labels.

Medium

Photograph: No means to prevent the installation Medium


of more over current devices.

Document Review: No periodic safety inspections Medium


of the electrical system.

Photograph: Electrical cables are not identified.

Medium

Visual Assessment: No cable shaft.

Medium

Document Review: No such document found.

Medium

Document Review: No such document found.

Medium

Visual Assessment: The lightning protection


ground terminals are not bonded to the building
or structure grounding.

Medium

Photograph: No dedicated neutral.

Medium

Photograph: Lighting fixtures are not supported


properly.

Medium

Photograph: Improper cable joints.

Medium

Photograph: Electrical connections are not


secured.

Medium

Photograph: Inadequate cable support.

Medium

Photograph: Non-graded mats provided in front of Low


distribution boards.

Photograph: No Meters and other electrical


Low
devices (Ammeter, Voltmeter and indicator lamp)
are installed.

Вам также может понравиться