Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Liver Transplantation
for Biliary Atresia*
Thomas E. Starz}, M.D., Ph.D.
Carlos O. Esquivel, M.D., Ph.D.
INTRODUCTION
Orthotopic liver transplantation is the treatment of
choice for patients with end-stage liver disease. The
increasing enthusiasm for hepatic transplantation
during the last decade is the result of better immunosuppression, particularly with the introduction of cyc\osporine in the early 1980s and of
monoclonal antibodies more recently New improvements in technique have made the operation
more practica\. For these reasons, liver transplantation is no longer considered an experimental
procedure but rather an accepted mode of therapy
for patients with hopelessly advanced hepatic dis-
61
ease.
CLINICAL TRIALS
The first attempt at hepatic transplantation in a
human was in 1963. The patient, a 3-year-old boy
Main Indication
Biliary atresia
Inborn metabolic errors
Nonalcoholic cirrhosis
Primary liver malignancy
Neonatal hepatitiS
Congenital hepatic fibrosis
Secondary biliary cirrhosis'
Total
Percent
51
13
13
3
2
2
2
I~
I
I
,
I
llf
\9titlj
I,
.i
PatIents
(\I.lT(h I. 1%3F,'bruarv 29,
'.;n.
I;
59.3
15.1
15.1
3.6
2.3
2.3
2.3
T
62
SURGICAL TECHNIQUES
Donor Operation
The technical aspects of the donor hepatectomy and
preservation have been discussed in detail elsewhere. A significant problem in the procurement
of organs for children is the limited availability of
small pediatric donors. In extreme circumstances,
adult livers have been used in children after partial
resections at the "back table."
In small donors, it is advisable to leave the celiac
axis in continuity with the thoracic or abdominal
aorta or both. This is particularly important when
the recipient or donor hepatic artery cannot be used
for the reconstruction, as in the presence of anomalous vessels. If the donor abdominal aorta cannot
be retrieved, the thoradc aorta may be turned down
180 for anastomosis to the recipient's aorta. A
useful technique is to transect the thoracic aorta,
reanastomose it to the aortic cuff below the celiac
axis, and tailor the transected end of the thoracic
aorta to form a smooth funnel. This avoids a blind
pouch, which could be the source of thrombus formation (Fig. 43). It must be emphasized, however,
that in the presence of a redpient hepatic artery of
good quality, the best results are obtained when
an end-ta-end anastomosis is carried out between
the redpient hepatic artery and the donor celiac
axis.
Recipient Operation
In children, a bilateral subcostal incision, often using the previous indsion, will suffice. The dissection is then continued in the hilum of the liver,
attempting to identify the Roux-en- Y limb of the
No. of Patients
(March J, 1980December 1,
Main Indication
Biliary atresia
Inborn metabolic errors
Nonalcoholic cirrhosis
Familial cholestasis
Neonatal hepatitis
Acute hepatic necrosis
Congenital hepatic fibrosis
Secondary biliary cirrhosis
Sclerosing cholangitis
Toxic hepatic injury
Trauma
Inflammatory pseudotumor
Budd-Chiari syndrome
Total
Percent
1985)
99
45
21
14
6
5
3
3
2
2
203
48.8
22.2
10.3
6.9
3.0
2.5
1.5
1.5
1.0
1.0
0.5
0.5
0.5
100%
(edure. H,
drainage, (
right uppe
extremely ,
been used
children. I
nami( ph\"
less renal II
ous bypasallows ml
hepatic ph
with venOl
If disse(:
because llt
toduodena'
permit en
ligament i
structures
sected mOl
employed
tectomy is
divide it, ;
intrahepat
is then di5
hepatic ca
placed on
control.
The seql
Y
astomose~
tion of an.:
portance.
materialls
should bt:'
is a practl
at the ana
tomosis, :
allowing t
diameter.
the suturl'
The bih.,
sa tis factor
End-to-<;IJ
duct to a
temal ster
of biliary r
suits ever
newborns
of these p.
Roux-en-l
been dam.
old Rouxstances bt
has been
struction.
63
IMMUNOSUPPRESSION
Precyc/osporine Era
The current immunosuppression therapy for liver
transplantation was derived from experience with
renal transplantation, since the latter provided a
much simpler model with which to work. Combination therapy with azathioprine and prednisone
was the first widely used immunosuppressive regimen. However, most of the liver recipients from
1963 to 1980 in our series were treated with azathioprine, prednisone, and antilymphocyte (ALG). Occasionally, cyclophosphamide was substituted for
azathioprine. Other additions to the immunosuppressive therapy, such as thoracic duct drainage,
had no obvious benefit in hepatic transplantation.
The overall survival with the triple-drug therapy
was 32.9% and 20% at 1 and 5 years, respectively.
Cyclosporine Era
Cyc\osporine A is derived from two strains of fungi,
RESULTS (SURVIVAL)
Precyc/osporille Era
Eighty-six out of a total of 170 patients underwent
liver replacement from 1963 to 1980. Fifty-three of
the 86 died within a year after transplantation. The
main causes of death are listed in Table 3. There
was a high incidence of bacterial, fungal, and viral
infections. Technical complications played an important role and, in part, were the cause of the
poor results obtained in patients with biliary atresia
compared to children with inborn errors of metab-
64
300
250
(/)
....
z
uJ
FIG, I
200
"u.
0150
a:
uJ
CIl
~ 100
Z
50
19'
Figure 45. t
trtlnSl,fallts d,
rent/reses rel"
FIG. 2
olism (Fig
surgical pro
made the,
anomalies'
are freque!
bilia ry a tTl
biliary atn
Cyclospor:
The 5-yea
(500 patie
children I
survival i!
survival!
Figure 4~
JJ
"GrOWlh faclor" lechnique used with conlinuous
,ulllre of ,;mall 1'L'SSe/,. Note Ihat anastomosis of half
lilt' ClrCIIlllfererra of the Pt:ssel, is pt'rforml'd with each half of
Ih" OT/X'llaf ,ulure. Where Ihe two hah>t's meel, tile knol IS
Fi)?11Y1'
44.
['",/t'llt"
Table 3. C
After Hl'f'
Pediatric J
Infection
Technical
Rejection
lntra- am'
Primary F
Other
Total
'One patl
pulmonal
failure se
300
(321
250
...
(/)
UJ
!;i
"-
II.
0150
a:
CD
~ 100
50
1980
1981
1982
1983
1984
1985
YEAR
"',
....I
c(
"'''""'
""--x...,
80
a:
60
::l
~
U
40
iF
20
0~~1~2--~------6------~9-------,L2~
~\ONTHS
wlmulw:-:;irTl'rt'~~iOll.
10Cli--.:.'
0- -
90 ....
80
-c
C",~R[V
Percent
of Total
-.',lBOI.JC E.,t:loq
20
15
9
3
3
3"
23.3
17.4
10.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
53
61.7%
i
l
...
---
~j
4">
,20]
...... ,<.a:::,',
:i 70~ ~ ..............................
..
~----~----e-----o{'l
60
(J)
0-
Total
Cyclosporine Era
Infection
Technical complication
Rejection
Intra- and perioperative death
Pnmary graft dysfunction
Other
"
::l
....I
861
INoS!)
;;
(/)
.... ,
>
TOTAL CHILDREN
IN
100
65
g
w
(l.
50
40
30
20
10
~~~6~~----~----~3~----74----~5--~
mos
YEARS
$
66
100
90
80
~--o--
--0--
--~
....J
< 70
>
:;:
II:
60-
C/)
I-
()
II:
W
0-
50 f40
30
20
10
I
weight. Tra
soon as the'
decompens,
The scare
important r
age may stJ
A single att,
any risks to
procedures
of portoenl
should be ,
final optior
The pro!=
last few yea
tient selec:
niques in t
transplanta
have all pIa
YEARS
years of age.
few years. Although there was an immediate improvement in survival when cyclosporine was introduced, there were some early deaths which
could have been avoided by more effective dose
control of cyclosporine and by aggressive retransplantation. At present, cyclosporine blood levels
are monitored daily until the patient is discharged,
and then twice a week for several weeks until the
best dosage is reached in order to prevent irreversible rejection or overimmunosuppression.
Growth
In a recent report, Urbach et al. I showed that 76%
of 29 children who received liver replacement and
were followed for at least 2 years had excellent
growth patterns. This response is explained in part
by the small doses of steroids needed for immunosuppression when cyclosporine is used in conjunction. Biliary atresia accounted for 13 out of the
29 patients.
Ret rtlllspJalltatlon
Effect of Age
011
SIIn.'li'ai
CONCLUSIONS
Biliary atresia is the most common indication for
hepatic transplantation in the pediatric population.
Liver replacement is the treatment of choice for
biliary atresia, and there is no limitation of age or
Figure 49.
en/s. A ,h.
than 3 mo'
Recommended Reading
Bismuth H, Houssin D: Reduced sized orthopic liver graft
in hepatic transplantation in children. Surgery 95:367,
1984.
Borel JF, Feurer C. Gubler HU, et al: Biological effects of
cydosporin A: A new antilymphocyte agent. Agents
Actions 6:468, 1976.
t 76%
:1 and
dlent
part
nmuconIf the
iatric
1 aI.'
prehose
veen
s. In
hool
ears
nore
t in,rine
a:
w
CD
~
::J
Z
a:
CD
::2:
::J
Z
10
for
on.
for
. or
15
Figure 49. Age distribution of 126 childhood liver recipients. A slwded square represents a child who surllitlf?d more
tlwn 3 months, and a black square represents a child who
67
Caine RY, [{olles K, Whitl' DjG, et al: Cvclosporin A Initially ,1S the only imll1unOSUpprl'ssant in 34 recipil'nts
of cadJwric "rgans, 32 kidneys, 2 pancreases, and 2
livers. UIIlC('/ 2: 1033, 1979.
Fung Jj, Dcmctris AJ, Porter KA, et .11: Use of OKT3 with
cydosporine and steroids for reversal of acute kidney
and liver allograft rejection. SlIrS Cl/Ilt'col Obslt'l (in
press)
Iwatsuki S, Shaw BW Jr, Starzl TE: Liver transplantation
for biliary atresia. World' SurS 8:51, 1984.
Iwatsuki S, Shaw BW Jr, Starzl TE: Biliary tract complications in liver transplantation under cyclosporinesteroid therapy. Trallsplmll Prot: 15:1288, 1983.
Kam L Lynch S, Todo S, et al: Low flow veno-venous
bypasses in small animals and pediatriC patients
undergOing liver replacement. SlIrg Gyllt'col Obslet (in
press).
National Institutes of Health Consensus Development
Conference Statement: Liver transplantation-June 2023, 1983, Hepatology 4:107S, 1984.
Shaw BW Jr, Iwatsuki S, Starzl TE: Alternative methods
of arterialization of the hepatic graft. SlIrg Gyllecol Obslet
159:490, 1984.
Shaw BW Jr, Gordon RD, Iwatsuki S, et al: Hepatic transplantation. Trallsplant Proc 17:264, 1985.
Shaw BW Jr, Martin OJ, Marquez JM, et aI: Venous bypass
in clinical liver transplantations. AmI SlIrg 200:524, 1984.
Starzl TE, Iwatsuki S, Van Thiel DH, et al: Evaluation of
liver transplantation. Hepatology 2:614, 1982.
Starzl TE, Marchioro TL, von Kaulla K, et al: Homotransplantation of the liver in humans. Slirg GyllL'col Obstet
117:659, 1963.
Starzl TE, Groth CG, Brettschneider L, et al: Orthotopic
homotransplantation of the human liver. Alln SlIrg
WU92.1968.
Starzl TE, Hakala TR, Shaw BW Jr, et al: A flexible procedure for multiple cadaveric organ procurement. SlIrg
Gl/llt'col Obstet 158:223, 1984.
Star'zl TE (with the assistance of Putnam CvV): EXI't'rIt'llct'
III Ht'I~ltK Trall"plalltatloll. Phil.1delphia, WB Saunders
Co, 1969.
Starzl TE, Koep LJ, Weil R Ill, et al: Development of a
suprahepatic recipIent H'na cava cuii for liver transplantali"n. Surg Cl/llL'col Obstd 1-1976, 1979.
Starzl TE, Iwatsuki S, Esqui\l'1 CO, et al: Refinements in
the ,urglCal technique of her transplantation. SCIIIII1
Lit'''' D", 53-19, 1985.
Starzl TE, Iwatsuki S, Shaw BW Jr: A "growth factor" in
fine vascular anastomoses. SlIrS Gyllt'Col O/lstl'f 159:164,
1984.
Tzakis AG, Gordon RD, Shaw BW Jr, et al: Clinical presentation of hepatic arterY thrombosis afler liver transplantation in the cyclosporine era. Trallsl'la'ltatiOll
40:667, 1986.
.vi'
:~./.
I,
TYPE'
'I
~,
/'/
,.--/
. I
TYPE.
References
JJ, et al: Linear
growth following pediatric liver transplantation. J Pediatr, Am' Dis. Child. 141:(5):547-9; 1987.
2. Iwatsuki S, Starzl TE: Liver transplantation for fulminant hepatic failure. Sem Liver Dis 5:325, 1985.
1. Urbach AH, Gartner AC Jr, Malalack
TYPE IV.
TYPE IV b
TYPE