Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Just-in-Time Use in
Marketing Channels
Toward a Development of a Decision Tool
S. Altan Erdem
Cathy Owens Swift
This study focuses on an empirical analysis of variables associated with the evaluation of inventory management techniques. There are 23 items that channel managers should examine before deciding to use just-in-time as the primary
inventory control method in a particular channel network.
These items can be grouped under the five categories of delivery effectiveness, information system needs, spatial concerns,
financial resources, and channel cohesiveness to form a crucial decision tool for channel managers. 1998 Elsevier
Science Inc.
INTRODUCTION
Increasing competitiveness among industrial channel
members has resulted in a growing awareness of various
cost-saving procedures in marketing. Efforts directed toward lowering the cost figures traditionally have focused
on the physical distribution functions of these members
as well as the production tasks. Transportation, warehousing, inventory management, materials handling, protective packaging, and order processing are the major
components of physical distribution in industrial channels. Among all of these elements, inventory control has
been one of the major areas in which recent marketing
research activities have focused.
Given the widespread availability of computer technology and the more complete understanding of sophisti-
0019-8501/98/$19.00
PII S0019-8501(97)00001-1
22
JUST-IN-TIME
JIT derives various inventory levels for optimum materials requirements and maximizes long-term efficiency
by focusing upon inventory management in the short-run.
JIT basically describes an inventory control technique
that has been used to schedule raw materials, components, or commodity inputs. Implementation of JIT concerns the production function from two unique perspectives: (1) it provides a method for deriving optimum
materials requirements and inventory levels in a production process; and (2) it maximizes long-term benefits by
accepting short-term dis-economies.
The time which a product takes to be completed can be
viewed as a function of motion and work [46]:
TABLE 1
Sample Characteristics
Sales
Classification
Distributors
Wholesalers/
Distributors
Manufacturers/
Distributors
Wholesalers
Manufacturers
24
No. of
Companies
,$2.5 mill.
.$2.5 mill.
94
22
72
324
67
16
51
229
25
12
6
19
12
5
6
0
1
533
426
334
SIC Code
Age of
Companies
TABLE 2
Results of Factor Analysis
Factor Loading
Factor 1: delivery effectiveness
Timing of delivery
Demand estimation
Quality of delivery
Proximity of suppliers
Cohesiveness with suppliers
Competition in the market
Factor 2: information system needs
Computer software needs
Computer hardware needs
Advanced automation
Factor 3: spatial concerns
Availability of space
Cost of space
Quality of space
Factor 4: financial resources
Cash-on-hand
Short-term debt
Long-term debt
Factor 5: channel cohesiveness
Vertical integration
Competition with suppliers
0.84449
0.83653
0.82619
0.82543
0.79365
0.75964
Cronbachs alpha 5 0.8867
0.90246
0.89211
0.84165
Cronbachs alpha 5 0.8624
0.84557
0.83455
0.82247
Cronbachs alpha 5 0.8591
0.83763
0.77576
0.68445
Cronbachs alpha 5 0.7654
0.85648
0.78798
Cronbachs alpha 5 0.6678
25
short-term debt, and long-term debt, need to be considered before deciding on JIT.
It has been shown in the literature that the financial results of JIT implementation are far more than a decrease
in inventory [13]. The combination of increased productivity, cost reduction, and revenue growth results in net
income increase. As a result, JIT use is to be perceived
by industrial marketers as a strategic competitive decision instead of just an operations tactic [15]. Even though
the results of the technique are promising, being able to
use the system is partially a financial concern. An important consideration in the selection of an inventory management technique is the availability and management of
funds.
In general, cash, short-, and long-term debt represent
basic funding sources. The accurate assessment of funds
represents an important consideration in the selection of
an inventory method. For example, in retailing, the traditional working capital analysis may be inappropriate
for inventory evaluation under decision since the current
assets include inventory value. By including the book
value of inventory in the value of working capital, the
analysis will likely understate/overstate the funds available for future inventory acquisition. The evaluation of
working capital for this application should reflect current
assets based upon the current market value of inventory
(if it were to be sold immediately in its present form). In
other words, working capital should be fully reduced by
the book (market) value of existing inventories. In this
way, a conservative picture of funds available for new inventory acquisition is provided.
The accurate determination of available funds is critical because without sufficient levels of cash and/or
credit, large purchases and their associated quantity benefits are impossible. Indeed, the underlying need for
funds rationing will be an important consideration in the
purchase of inventory.
The last factor was labeled channel cohesiveness
and contains the items vertical integration and competition with suppliers. The necessity of having close social
relationships with suppliers for the successful implemen-
members as both marketers (to retailers) and as customers (of manufacturers). There are a number of salient issues associated with inventory management that channel
members should consider in selecting JIT.
Delivery Effectiveness
The first factor, delivery effectiveness, included timing of delivery, demand estimation, quality of delivery,
proximity of suppliers, cohesiveness with suppliers, and
competition in the market. This supports similar findings
in other studies [38] that emphasize the importance of the
physical distribution system. The quality of service offered by a marketer in a JIT relationship depends on the
vendors ability to deliver the product on time and in the
proper amounts. Channel members will need to coordinate manufacturers schedules with the demands of retailers. Marketers may need to consider moving closer to
the customer or perhaps using private carriage systems
rather than common carriage.
As a customer, channel members should recognize the
need to track the vendors record on delivery performance. The customer may also want to analyze the vendors
commitment to other buyers, which may strain the delivery capabilities of the supplier. As a customer, the channel
member may be asked for a blanket purchase order, and
information on demand estimates will have to be shared.
Information System Needs
The dimension of information system needs includes
computer software needs, computer hardware needs, and
advanced automation. As a marketer, the channel member needs to have vital information on each customer. To
enable the exchange of information with customers, the
member will need a sophisticated hardware system as
well as customized software. Their customers will need
to share demand forecasts as well as logistics information. Any changes in retail demand scheduling will need
to be sent immediately to the marketer. Therefore, immediate follow-up with the customer is warranted.
When acting as a customer, the channel member needs
to plan bills of materials. In addition, special JIT software
will have to be used that includes manufacturers specifications, materials planning, and manufacturing control.
Spatial Concerns
Spatial concerns contains the items availability of
space, cost of space, and quality of space. The channel
27
member, as marketer, must recognize that materials management resources must be increased. This may call for
an increase in warehouse capacity, and inventory levels.
The marketer will have to hold goods for a longer period
of time and will have to do a better job of managing capacity.
As a customer, the channel member may need to make
physical plant changes. Specifically, because inventories
will not be as large for any single retailer, the intermediaries may be able to expand their own customer bases.
Financial Resources
Included in the financial resources dimension are cashon-hand, short-term debt, and long-term debt. As a marketer, the channel member should recognize that JIT implementation is a high risk proposition. Considerable
resources of the company will be devoted to making the
changes required for a JIT system.
JIT implementation also creates considerable risk for
the channel member as a customer. Considerable investments will be made in becoming involved with JIT. The
firm needs to ensure that resources are adequate and be
prepared to make appropriate investments.
Channel Cohesiveness
Channel cohesiveness concerns both vertical integration and competition with suppliers. The channel member, as a marketer, must be very selective in identifying
customers with whom they wish to implement JIT. This
will, of necessity, involve a closer relationship with the
retailer, and concentration on present customers, rather
than new customers. Even the role of the salesperson
changes.
As a customer, the channel member will need to ensure that there is a direct relationship between the planning
department and the supplier. This relationship should be
considered in all planning activities. The focus should be
on value added service on the part of the supplier.
LIMITATIONS
There are several limitations to this study. The surveys
were collected in a geographic region of the southwest,
limiting the generalizability of the results.
In addition, the managers who were interviewed were
a convenience sample. They were all prescreened to determine that they were in charge of inventory control and
were either using or considering a JIT system. However,
28
because the respondents were not chosen randomly, results cannot be generalized.
Finally, this was an exploratory study. As such, there
were no prior hypotheses to be tested in the study.
CONCLUDING REMARKS
This article has proposed tentative scale items to be
used in implementing JIT in distribution channels. An attempt was made to capture the core issues associated
with inventory management in general, and JIT in particular, and to reveal the commonalities across various
channel members at different levels.
There appear to be five factors considered by the managers in selecting JIT. The issues of delivery effectiveness, information system needs, spatial concerns, financial resources, and channel cohesiveness were presented
as dimensions relevant to JIT use.
This study involved the use of exploratory factor analysis. Before any generalizations can be made, further
work is needed with larger and different samples using
alternative techniques. Then a structural equation model
between common factors of JIT use and a given marketing feature can be established for future inquiry. This
structural equation will express the relative significance
of each factor in terms of its marketing implications. By
so doing, the contribution of each JIT attribute can be examined within the field of marketing.
REFERENCES
1. Aggarwal, Sumer C., MRP, JIT, OPT, FMS? Harvard Business Review
63 (SeptemberOctober), 816 (1985).
2. Anderson, James C., and Narus, James A., A Model of the Distributors
Perspective of Distributor-Manufacturer Working Relationships. Journal
of Marketing 48 (Fall), 6274 (1984).
3. Anderson, John C., and Schroeder, Roger G., Getting Results from Your
MRP System. Business Horizons 26 (May-June), 5764 (1984).
4. Ansari A., and Modarres, Batoul, Just-In-Time Purchasing: Problems and
Solutions. Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management 22 (Summer), 1115 (1986).
5. Arsham, H., and Shao, Jr., S. P., Seasonal and Cyclic Forecasting for the
Small Firm. American Journal of Small Business 9 (April), 4656 (1985).
6. Bhasin, Ajay, and Stern, Louis W., Vertical Integration: Considerations of
Efficiency, Risk and Strategy. Marketing Channels: Domestic and International Perspectives 3 (March), 15 (1982).
7. Billesbach, Thomas J., Harrison, Alan, and Croom-Morgan, Simon, Supplier Performance and Practices in JIT Companies in the U.S. and the U.K.
International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management 27 (Fall),
2428 (1991).
8. Blackstone, Jr., John H., and Cox, James F., Inventory Management Techniques. Journal of Small Business Management 23 (April), 2733 (1985).
9. Bowersox, D. J., Logistical Management. Macmillan Company, New
York, 1982.
10. Burnham, John A., Some Conclusions about JIT Manufacturing. Production and Inventory Management Journal 28, 711 (1987).
11. Carlson, Robert C., and Yano, Candace A., Safety Stocks in MRPSystems with Emergency Setups for Components. Management Science 32
(April), 403412 (1986).
12. Chapman, Stephen N., Schedule Stability and the Implementation of JustIn-Time. Production and Inventory Management Journal 31, 6670, (1990).
13. Courtis, John K., JITs Impact on a Firms Financial Statements. International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management 31, 4650,
(1995).
14. Cox, James F., Zmud, Robert W., and Clark, Steven J., Auditing an MRP
System. Academy of Management Journal 24 (June), 386402 (1981).
15. Dion, Paul A., Banting, Peter M., and Hasey, Loretta M., The Impact of
JIT on Industrial Marketers. Industrial Marketing Management 19, 4146
(1990).
16. Dowst, Somerby, ed., Just-In-Time Isnt Just Inventory Reduction. Purchasing 99 (December), 27 (1985).
17. Duncan, D. J., Hollander, S. C., and Savitt R. Modern Retailing Management. Richard D. Irwin, Inc., Homewood, IL, 1983.
18. Gattorna, John, Channels of Distribution Conceptualizations: A State-ofthe-Art Review. European Journal of Marketing 12, 471512 (1978).
19. Giunipero, Larry C., Motivating and Monitoring JIT Supplier Performance. Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management 14 (Summer),
1924 (1990).
20. Giunipergo, Larry C., and ONeal, Charles, Obstacles to JIT Procurement.
Industrial Marketing Management 17, 3541, (1988).
21. Hahn, C. K., Pinto, P. A., and Bragg, D. J., Just-In-Time Production and
Purchasing. Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management 19 (Fall),
210 (1983).
22. Harris, Ellen, The Impact of JIT Production on Product Costing Information. Production and Inventory Management Journal 31, 4448 (1990).
23. House, R. J., and Mitchell, T. R., Path-Goal Theory of Leadership. Journal
of Contemporary Business 3, 8197 (1974).
24. Jordan, S., Analysis and Approximation of a JIT Production Line. Decision Sciences 19, 672681 (1988).
25. Joshi, Kailash, and Campbell, James F., Managing Inventories in a JIT
Environment. International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management 27 (Spring), 3236 (1991).
26. Kahn, M. R., and Rocha, J. R., Recurring Managerial Problems in Small
Business. American Journal of Small Business 6 (January), 5058 (1982).
27. Krupp, James A. G., Measuring Inventory Management Performance.
Production and Inventory Management Journal 35, 16 (1994).
28. Lambert, Douglas M., and Bennion, Mark L., New Channel Strategies for
the 1980s. Marketing Channels: Domestic and International Perspectives
5 (March), 124128 (1982).
29. McMillan, Charles J., Production Planning and Organization Design at
Toyota. Business Quarterly 46 (Winter), 2230 (1981).
30. Malley, John C., and Ray, Ruthann, Informational and Organizational
Impacts of Implementing a JIT System. Production and Inventory Management Journal 29, 6670 (1988).
31. Manoochehri, G. H., Suppliers and the Just-In-Time Concept. Journal of
Purchasing and Materials Management 20 (Winter), 1621 (1984).
32. Mayer, Raymond R., A Critical Look at Kanban, Japans Just-In-Time
Inventory System. Management Review 71 (December), 4851 (1984).
33. Miltenburg, G. J., Changing MRPs Costing Procedures to Suit JIT. Production and Inventory Management Journal 31, 7783 (1990).
34. Morecroft, John D., A Systems Perspective on Materials Requirements
Planning. Decision Sciences 14 (January), 118 (1983).
35. Natarajan, R., and Weinrauch, J. Donald, JIT and the Marketing Interface.
Production and Inventory Management Journal 31, 4246 (1990).
36. Near, Janet P., and Olshavsky, Richard W., Japans Success: Luck or
Skill? Business Horizons 27 (November-December), 1522 (1985).
37. Nisanci, I., and Nicolli, A. D., Project Planning Network is Integrated Plan
for Implementing Just-In-Time. Industrial Engineering 19 (October), 50
52 (1987).
38. ONeal, Charles R., JIT Procurement and Relationship Marketing. Industrial Marketing Management 18, 5563 (1989).
39. Pearson, Michael, and Monoky, John F., The Role of Conflict and Cooperation in Channel Performance. Proceedings of American Marketing Association 240244 (1976).
40. Raia, Ernest, Just-In-Time Just in Time. Purchasing 100 (May 9), 8185
(1985).
41. Rosenberg, L. Joseph, and Campbell, David, Just-In-Time Inventory Control: Another Inventory Management Concept. Proceedings of the Southwestern Marketing Association March, 212216 (1985a).
42. Rosenberg, L. Jospeh, and Campbell, David, Just-In-Time Inventory Control: A Subset of Channel Management. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 13 (Summer), 124133 (1985b).
43. Sauers, Dale G., MRP for Small Business. Journal of Small Business Management 22 (July), 18 (1984).
44. Schonenberger, Richard J., Why Japanese Produce Just-In-Time. Industry
Week 229 (November), 58 (1982).
45. Schonenberger, Richard J., and Ansari, A. Just-In-Time Purchasing Can
Improve Quality. Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management 20
(Spring), 27 (1984).
46. Schniederjans, Marc J., Topics in Just-In-Time Management. Allyn and
Bacon, Needham Heights, MA, 1993.
47. Schul, Patrick L., Pride, William M., and Little, Taylor L., The Impact of
Channel Leadership Behavior on Intrachannel Conflict. Journal of Marketing 47 (Summer), 2134 (1983).
48. Tatikonda, Mohan V., Just-In-Time and Modern Manufacturing Environments: Implications for Cost Accounting. Production and Inventory Management Journal 29, 15 (1988).
49. Walleigh, Richard C., Whats Your Excuse for Not Using JIT? Harvard
Business Review 64 (March-April), 3854 (1986).
29