Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Table of Contents
Second Semester Timeline.............................................................................................................2
Essential Question Final Draft......................................................................................................4
Non Profit Organization Interview ..............................................................................................6
Annotated Bibliography ................................................................................................................7
Source Check Directions ...............................................................................................................8
Source Check Sample ....................................................................................................................9
Thank You Letter ........................................................................................................................10
Policy Paper ..................................................................................................................................12
Policy Paper Simplified Diagram ...............................................................................................14
Policy Paper Rubric .....................................................................................................................15
Service Project Requirements .....................................................................................................16
Service Verification Form ...........................................................................................................18
Documenting Your Service .........................................................................................................19
Policy Presentation.......................................................................................................................20
Policy Presentation Rubric..........................................................................................................22
Answer to Essential Question .....................................................................................................24
Government Advocacy Letter .....................................................................................................25
Sample Government Advocacy Letter .......................................................................................26
QUEST Binder Checklist ............................................................................................................28
QUEST Testimony .......................................................................................................................30
QUEST Testimony Rubric ..........................................................................................................32
Citation Examples/References ....................................................................................................33
Simple QUEST Rubric ................................................................................................................34
ESSENTIAL QUESTION
Remember that your final Essential Question should have a solution component added to it (ie How
do we fix this?). Some essential questions may already have this component.
ESSENTIAL QUESTION:
SUBMIT THIS AND EACH SUBSEQUENT REVISION TO YOUR ENGLISH AND GOVERNMENT
TEACHER. Save each draft submitted. FINAL DRAFT DUE February 17th
Your essential question may change many times. Keep all copies of attempted essential
question with the teachers comments on them. Only final draft receives the signature of both
English and government/economics teacher.
Non-Profit Interview
Due February 17, 2015 (English)
Your Non-Profit Interview is the second formal interview with your Consultant. Turn in your
signed and dated (by your Consultant) notes from this interview to your English teacher by
February 25th. For this interview, you will need to create 10 new and relevant questions guide
your research to for a successful Policy Paper and Advocacy Letter.
Guidelines:
1. Make sure you take your 10 questions with you to have your Consultant sign and
date them as proof you did the interview.
2. You do not need to write a word for word account (no transcript). Write the answers or
the main ideas as the response to your questions.
3. Make sure your questions are relevant. You have 5 hours of Experience and 8 Research
sources to prepare questions that are specific and focused on finding solutions to your
social issue.
4. Refer to the first semester packet for interview hints and suggestions.
Turn in:
10 questions, typed; notes from Consultant interview; and Consultant signature and date
on the bottom of the page.
Remember:
You are interviewing this person as an expert on the
content of their field, not their personal or work life. Try to
write questions that your consultant would know from his or
her expertise and experience.
Many students find it awkward or uncomfortable to
interview an adult in the professional world. Being prepared
and organized will help to alleviate such feelings. You have
completed somewhat extensive research on your topic,
gathered your conclusions and made connections in writing
as well as presented your findings to your peers and
teachers. You now have the ability to ask specific, probing
questions based on the work you have completed. If you ask
questions of the same depth and ignorance as your first
interview, this will seem like an exercise in redundancy.
However, if you ask questions that demonstrate how much
your knowledge and interest has evolved, the interview will
reveal your aptitude and dedication. Your consultant will
feel like they have played an important role in your
achievement, which is never embarrassing.
An annotated bibliography is a works cited page that includes a summary for each source, along with
commentary on how you plan to use it in your research. For the QUEST project, you will gather sources in
order build an annotated bibliography over time by completing Source Checks (see directions for
creating these on the following page). In each source check you will be responsible for reading,
summarizing and citing two or three different sources. By the end of the first semester, you should have
at least 8 different sources summarized, and by the end of the project you should have a minimum of 14
different sources summarized.
Remember that we are not expecting you to find 14 different sources all at once! You will be turning in
Source Checks regularly in order to build your annotated bibliography over time. Your Annotated
Bibliography and source check due dates are outlined below:
Teacher
English
Due Date
10/28/2014
Number of Sources
2
Source Check #2
Government
11/18/2014
2
Source Check #3
English
12/2/2014
2
Source Check #4
Government
12/9/2014
2
Annotated Bibliography #1
Government (turnitin.com)
12/16/2014
8 Sources Total
st
rd nd
1 Semester Ends January 23 /2 Semester Begins January 26th
Source Check #5
Economics
2/24/2015
3
Source Check #6
English
3/10/2015
3
Annotated Bibliography #2
English (turnitin.com)
3/24/2015
14 Sources Total
Read and reread sources, then annotate and retell the content of the article in your own
words.
Evaluate the source, as well as the author, considering the purpose and any potential biases.
Figure out the intended audience and interpret the intended purpose the author is trying to
achieve.
Produce a properly formatted MLA works-cited entry for each source.
Answer questions created in the RFI.
For each source you read, you will need to create a Source Check Entry. This is the same as an
entry in your annotated bibliography. It consists of two parts:
1.
Citation: This includes all of the same information as an entry in your Works Cited Page
in MLA format.
2.
a. Summarizes the content of the source (exactly what the source says)
b. Analyzes the validity of the source (what makes it worthy of being in your
project?) including information on the author (such as purpose, audience,
authority, or bias) and discussion of any rhetorical strategies employed.
c. Reflects on the use or value this source had on your project. It may have
answered one of your RFI questions, alerted you to a new issue, debunked a
previous misconception, etc.
Reminder!!! Each source check assignment that you turn in will eventually go into your annotated
bibliography. As long as you complete your source checks on time, and make corrections
suggested by your teachers, all you will have to do for the annotated bibliographies is cut and
paste from your source checks! Here is the schedule again to remind you.
Sally Student
A business letter is not restricted to one page. Remember that this is a concise, but sincere thank you to
your consultant for their time.
10
11
Purpose: The purpose of a policy paper is to propose change in society by building a case that action
must be taken, and then suggest specific actions to be taken.
Objectives:
Establish your social issue in order to convince the audience that action must be taken.
Investigate 3-4 strategies/options for working toward solutions to your social issue.
Objectively explain/compare/explore/evaluate the varying perspectives on your topic.
Include your specific Service Plan/Project as one of these strategies to be evaluated.
Make recommendations as to which strategy or combination of strategies you believe should be
used and how this process should be initiated.
Requirements:
Cite and discuss the work of 6-10 different sources (including at least 2 Scholarly Articles) about
your social issue.
Write a 6-8 page Policy Paper which recommends an action plan meant to help solve your social
issue by analyzing the viewpoints of various authors and experts in the field.
Write a Works Cited page (in MLA format).
No 1st Person Narratives (save that for your presentations)
Respond to these various sources, combining them to formulate your own reasoning and
viewpoint.
Organizing Your Policy Paper
Section 1 (1.5-2.5 Pages): Establish Your Social Issue (This should be a shortened version of your social issue
research paper. Remember that we must prove that there is a problem before we can start trying to find ways
to solve it).
-
State the social issue (the problem) and prove that it exists with research and data.
Discuss the scope and severity of the social issue (How widespread is the problem? How bad is it?).
Discuss the background/history of the social issue.
Identify causal factors to your social issue (there should be several), and support this with research
and data (remember that very often, things that we think are direct causes, are in fact simply
correlated but thats OK! Acknowledging correlation with data to support it is great research!).
This paragraph should serve as the transition from analyzing the problem (the Social Issue) to
proposing options for making progress towards a solution. Think of this as a conclusion to section 1
and as the introduction to the rest of your paper.
Wrap up the discussion of your social issue with a thesis statement that advocates for a solution to
your social issue.
State your options for solutions to your social issue (a huge part of the rest of your paper will involve
analysis of these options, so dont worry about supporting them with research/data yet).
12
This section of the paper will consist of you stating 3-4 options for addressing your social issue in
order to work toward a solution. These options may range from strategies that are very costly, and
would take a great deal of time, effort and funding to those that can be carried out by the average
American in their daily life. These can and will probably be strategies/solutions that are already
being carried out or proposed.
For each of these options, address the following:
o Explain the strategy/option in depth
o Explain the benefits, including how the strategy would directly or indirectly help solve your
social issue? Use case studies/research (when possible) to show instances wherein the
strategy has been successful.
o Explain costs and/or obstacles to implementing this strategy (If it benefits society, why is not
widespread already?)
One of these strategies should resemble your own personal service project. It doesnt necessarily
have to be the best option for solving your social issue, but discuss your own project as one of the
strategies (but maintain 3rd person perspective).
Having discussed several potential strategies which could be used to help address your social issue,
which of these do you recommend to be implemented, and why?
Is there one specific strategy that we as a society should prioritize, or should it be a combination of
several? If several, which, and why?
Are any of these strategies not worth what they would cost to implement? Why?
Are there opportunity costs to any of these strategies? Meaning, if you implement one, would it
prevent you from implementing any of the others?
How would these strategies be implemented? Who would need to be involved? Government
officials? Private companies? School boards? The average citizen?
What would it take to actually implement your recommendations? Where should we start?
13
Strategy 1
Strategy 2
Strategy 3
Strategy 4
Recommendations
Based on your understanding of your social issue, and your research into these different
strategies which could be used to help solve the social issue, what is your recommended
action plan to address the problem? Which strategy or strategies should be emphasized
and/or implemented? What would it take to do so? Address potential barriers/obstacles to
progress.
Conclusion
14
Criteria
REDO
Content:
CCSS Writing 1: Write arguments to
support claims in an analysis of
substantive topics or texts, using valid
reasoning and relevant and sufficient
evidence.
CCSS Writing 2: Develop claim(s) and
counterclaims fairly and thoroughly,
supplying the most relevant evidence
for each while pointing out the
strengths and limitations of both in a
manner that anticipates the audience's
knowledge level, concerns, values, and
possible biases.
-Background
uninformed or
missing.
-Thesis may be missing
or difficult to identify.
May not have enough
explanation or enough
options to make
comparisons.
-Service plan/project
not discussed as one
of 3-4 strategies
-Recommendation
may be illogical or
simply a restatement
of one of the options.
-Background contains
relevant information and
is moderately well
developed.
-A clear thesis is presents a
rational argument.
Judgment is expressed.
-Several options presented
in reasonable detail.
-Comparisons made
between options.
-Service plan/project is
discussed as one of the 3-4
strategies.
-Recommendation is
rational and supported
with reasoning from the
selected evidence.
Organization:
CCSS Writing 2:
Introduce precise, knowledgeable
claim(s), establish the significance of
the claim(s), distinguish the claim(s)
from alternate or opposing claims, and
create an organization that logically
sequences claim(s), counterclaims,
reasons, and evidence.
-No progression of
ideas exists.
-Use of strategy and
technique is lacking.
-Some problems in
organization, but do not
interfere with
understanding
-Strategies and techniques
used to manage
complexity with some
success
-Transitional words and
statements applied
-Appropriate academic
moves employed
Use of Evidence:
CCSS Writing 8: Gather relevant
information from multiple print and
digital sources, assess the credibility
and accuracy of each source, and
integrate the information while
avoiding plagiarism.
CCSS Writing 9: Draw evidence from
literary or informational texts to
support analysis, reflection, and
research.
Style
CCSS Literacy 1c
-Language is nonacademic
-Grammar and
mechanical mistakes
impede understanding
-Reads like a rough
draft
-Language and
discourse are
academic and attempt
to use domain specific
vocabulary reflecting
an adequate
understanding of style
and tone
MLA
-Provides MLA
formatted paper with
works cited page and
in-text citations for
quoted and
paraphrased material
with 3 types of errors.
15
QUEST Service
The SERVICE component of QUEST is when you show the community what you now have discovered
about your social issue and the potential solutions that are currently being attempted. Your service
must be (or contribute to) a potential solution to your social issue.
SERVICE: FORMAT
Your SERVICE project will be something that you design with the help of your
government/economics teacher and an accredited non-profit organization. DO NOT base your
service on past projects. Each students service plan needs the approval of the non-profit that
you are working with and the QUEST Service Committee. The Committees decision regarding
approval is final.
Your service activities must be substantive in nature and truly serve the needs of a given
community/nonprofit organization.
Your service plan must be approved by your economics teacher BEFORE you may begin your
service project.
You must complete and verify AT LEAST 10 hours of approved service activities.
Service must be for a non-profit (501c3) or government agency and address a social issue. You
may not do a service for a company that makes money. (AKA slave labor)
NO YOU MAY NOT HELP A TEACHER IN A CLASSROOM DURING SCHOOL HOURS FOR YOUR SERVICE.
YOU MAY NOT GIVE PRESENTATIONS TO STUDENTS IN THEIR CLASSES. THEY ALREADY HAVE A
TEACHER. THIS IS NOT SERVICE.
SERVICE: EXAMPLES
Social Issue: Traffic congestion in Fremont. Service: Volunteering for the Bay Area Air
Quality Management Districts Spare the Air program, working to get companies to sign
up and participate in the GREAT RACE FOR CLEAN AIR.
Social Issue: Substance abuse among parents of young/teenage children. Service: Volunteer
at 2nd Chance Shelter, assisting site manager with painting and maintenance.
A substantive service would fulfill a preexisting community need (not YOUR OWN!) and be completed
in a series of activities (i.e.: tutoring/coaching twice a week for 3 months) or in fulfillment of a
substantive service recognized by the QUEST Service Committee, which will determine what is of
16
substance and how many hours necessary to fulfill the requirement). The best way to find a service is
to ask an organization what it needs. (What do you NEED volunteers to do for your organization?)
A substantive service might be organizing and facilitating a group of students to volunteer one
day at an event. Only attending the event would not be enough.
Translating and handing out information at an event could work, just standing at a table all day
without actively contributing to the event would not.
Volunteering twice a week for month as a tutor for a non-profit is a series, dropping by once or
twice and helping a few kids would not.
Your SERVICE activities must be scheduled and publicized. The activities must be done at a location offcampus and must involve members of the greater community (non IHS people). You must have
evidence of your SERVICE activities, which can include photographs, videotape footage, written
reactions from participants, or samples of work created by the participants. Document everything!
Finally, you must have your SERVICE hours signed by your consultant/contact person and have it
authenticated by IHS Service Learning Coordinator in order to receive hours towards graduation.
Document everything! Be ready to show-off what you did in your Policy Presentation and Testimony.
17
Location
Hours
Logged
Contact Signature
x___________________
x___________________
x___________________
x___________________
By signing this form, I agree that the above description is accurate and honest.
*Contact persons from non-profit organizations must sign each individual service verification form entry in the
log AND on the line provided above.
18
If you can take pictures or video footage of you working with the community during your service. You
must use these during your Power Point presentations.
To write you a letter (written on the non-profit organizations letterhead) detailing what you did and
how your work benefited a group within our community. You can scan this letter into your Power Point
presentations and include a copy in your QUEST binder. Make sure the letter contains contact
information and the total number of service hours you completed.
If you can collect examples of work you did with the community. For example, if you are working with
an after school tutoring program, ask to make a copy of a students work during your first session and
one during your last session to show the students improvement. You can scan this work into your
Power Point presentations and include a copy in your QUEST binder. Make sure to remove or cover the
any students names.
If they have alternate ideas for you to use for documentation, you must get your Gov/Econ teachers
approval to submit something other than these four types of documentation.
Use the Service Karma app! This is a fast and easy way to find, plan, and document service.
Step #3
Incorporate your documentation into your presentations and binder. A copy of your QUEST Service
Verification Form and any letters or pictures you receive must be placed in your final QUEST binder.
During your Policy Paper and Testimony presentations, you should incorporate any pictures or sample
work you have received.
Remember, regardless of the type of documentation you receive, it must be clear that you did the
activities that were approved in your Service Plan. As you discuss your service during your
presentations, your audience should be able to match your Service Plan activities with whatever
documentation you offer as proof of their completion.
19
Policy Presentation
Objectives:
#1 To provide insight into your social issue and its root causes by citing credible sources to support their claims
-Examine/evaluate symptoms of the social issue and the scope/severity of the problem
-Examine/evaluate causal factors to symptoms of social issue
#2 To investigate potential solutions to social issue
-Examine potential solutions which are currently being pursued
-Examine your service plan/project as one of those potential solutions
-Provide evidence of service project
#3 To provide insight as to how your consultant aided your research (establish credibility of consultant)
-Establish mentors professional/academic credibility
-Explain personal insight offered by mentor
-Explain if and/or how experience aided research
-Explain sources and/or leads provided by mentor
Presentation Requirements:
Integrate Graphics and visuals which HELP explain and enrich content
*For specific information to help you create your First Semester Research Presentation, see the Presentation
Guideline on the following page, as well as the Presentation Rubric on page 28.
20
The Background of the Social Issue Problem (Spend about 10% of your time on this)
Like you did before, address the symptoms, severity, and scope of your problem
What are the causal factors contributing to the problem?
What is the harm that is being caused?
These should align with what you wrote and supported with evidence in your policy paper (cite your
sources!)
You may want to start with less effective and build up to most effective
Acknowledge limitations of solutions
Dont try to advertise a silver bullet (humans are naturally attracted to a single solution, but this is
never the case)
Transition smoothly to show relationships between different solutions
What authority oversees your social issue? (there may be more than one) and how do they affect the
day to day operation of the non-profit organization?
Who would be in a position of power to help your non-profit or similar ones?
What action could they do to help bring about the solution?
Consider counterarguments. There is probably a reason he or she hasnt done it yet. What will you say
to convince them?
21
o
o
o
o
o
No
No
Non-existent
Distracting
Unprepared
o
o
o
o
o
Somewhat Inconsistent
o
o
o
o
o
Somewhat Inconsistent
Neutral
Limited Knowledge
o
o
o
o
o
Acceptable
Yes
Strength
Strength
Clear and Concise
Outline (3%)
-None submitted
-None submitted or
incomplete/not up-to-date
-Not clear
-Not clear
Time (6%)
Organization (22%)
CCSS Speaking and Listening 4: Present
information, findings, and supporting
evidence so listener can follow the line of
reasoning and the organization,
development, and style are appropriate to
task, purpose and audience.
CCSS Speaking and Listening 5: Make
strategic use of digital media and visual
displays of data to express information and
enhance understanding of presentations.
Sources/Citation (22%)
CCSS Writing 8: Gather relevant information
from multiple print and digital sources,
assess the credibility and accuracy of each
source, and integrate the information while
avoiding plagiarism.
CCSS Writing 9: Draw evidence from literary
or informational texts to support analysis,
reflection, and research.
-Improper
format
-5 > 7 minutes
Student Name:____________________________
(16%)
- Blatant omission
of source citations
- Sources are
scarcely named, or
one source is used
to support most
claims
-Works cited
incomplete
Exceeds Minimum
Standards
Content (22%)
CCSS Writing 1: Write arguments to support
claims in an analysis of substantive topics or
texts, using valid reasoning and relevant
and sufficient evidence.
CCSS Writing 2: Write
informative/explanatory texts to examine
and convey complex ideas and information
clearly and accurately through the effective
selection, organization, and analysis of
content.
Exceeds Minimum
Standards
Exceptional (22%)
- Social issue is clearly established and
proven to exist
- Scope, severity and causal factors of
social issue are supported with data from
multiple sources
-At least 3 potential solutions addressed
including specific benefits to community,
what it costs, and challenges for each
supported by multiple sources.
-Detailed description of service project,
including strengths/weaknesses in solving
social issue.
- Each portion of the presentation contains
information supported fluently by
evidence which allows the listener to
follow the speakers line of reasoning
-Presentation has clear organization.
- Media features (photos, sound, maps,
charts, diagrams) enhance understanding
and raise interest level in the audience
- Media format is clean and clear, devoid
of grammatical errors or distracting layout
-Contains multiple examples of visual
evidence of Service Project
- Claims are clearly supported by evidence
from credible sources
- Sources are correctly cited
- Sources are discussed and evaluated in
order to establish credibility
-Non-profit interview used as a source
- Complete Works Cited page included at
the end of the presentation, but NOT
DISCUSSED
Time:_____________
22
23
24
Purpose:
Students will write a formal persuasive letter to a government official advocating for a government
solution to their social issue.
Requirements:
Step 1: Based on your research conducted for you Social Issue Research Paper, and Policy Paper, what
actions can government take to solve your QUEST social issue or alleviate its effects? Provide support
and a source citation.
Step 2: Research:
What level of government is best suited to take the above action? Circle One
Federal
State
County
City
Other: __________________
Which department or governmental organization carries out public policies related to your
social issue? Who heads this department? What is their address?
Name:
Organization/Department:
Address:
Step 3: Outline the argument you will make in your letter (make this a simplified version of your policy
paper)
Thesis:
Use at least one paragraph to describe your service and your involvement with your non-profit
organization. Detail the challenges faced by the non-profit organization on a daily basis as well
as those faced long term. Include insights gained from your non-profit interview:
Supporting Evidence from Academic Research:
Supporting Evidence from Expert Interviews:
Supporting Evidence from Service Observations:
Possible Counter Arguments:
Your Rebuttal to Possible Counter Arguments:
25
[Your Name]
[Street Address]
[City, State Zip]
[Todays Date]
[Name of Recipient]
[Title and Government Organization]
[Address]
[City, State Zip]
Dear [Name of Recipient]:
[Short introduction paragraph stating purpose]
[Anecdotal description of service including challenges faced by non-profit organization]
[Additional information]
[Closing information, summary or thank you as appropriate]
Sincerely,
[Signature]
[Type Your Name]
[Title]
26
27
Binder Checklist
(QUEST Binder Due to English Teacher 4/21/2015)
Unless stated otherwise, all assignments included should be clearly graded and approved by your teachers.
Include all versions and attempts submitted and graded with the approved copy on top.
Label a Divider First Semester
-Social Issue Declaration Form
-Essential Question Form
-Consultant Agreement Form
-(Signed) Consultant Interview Notes
-Experience Plan
-Experience Hours Log
-Source Checks 1-4
-Social Issue Research Paper
-Social Issue Research Presentation Outline
-Graded Social Issue Research Presentation Rubric
Label a Divider Second Semester
-Final Essential Question Form
-Service Plan
-(Signed) Non-profit Interview Notes
-Service Verification
-Source Checks 5-6
-Policy Paper
-Government Advocacy Letter
-Policy Presentation Outline
-Graded Policy Presentation Rubric
-Answer Paper
-Annotated Bibliography (This should be a clean copy. That means print out a new one)
28
29
QUEST Testimony
Testimonies May 20 and 21, 2015
Youve done all the work; now is the time to show off. Remember that your panel wants you
to pass. Give them a reason to do it!
What to Bring with you:
1. Bring 5 outlines for your panel. Its better to have extras (and dont forget to keep one for
yourself!) A sample outline is attached yours should look very similar to this one! Outlines
should be one page (not two or three...ONE) long, single-spaced is fine. It must include your
name, teachers names, and your ID # on it. It also must have your italicized Essential Question
on it. You do not need a bullet point for every slide you need to outline the ideas and
evidence for your presentation.
2. Bring your QUEST binder (without #2 and #3 YOU WILL NOT BE ALLOWED TO PRESENT)
3. Put your name, both English and Government teachers names, and your Student ID # on the
first slide of your presentation and on the top of your outline.
STRUCTURE:
___________________________________________________________
Here are some tips!
yourself!) A sample outline is attached yours should look very similar to this one! Outlines
should be one page (not two or three...ONE) long, single-spaced is fine. It must include your
name, teachers names, and your ID # on it. It also must have your italicized Essential Question
on it. You do not need a bullet point for every slide you need to outline the ideas and
evidence for your presentation.
Bring your QUEST binder (without this, YOU WILL NOT BE ALLOWED TO PRESENT)
Put your name, both English and Government teachers names, and your Student ID # on the
first slide of your presentation and on the top of your outline.
Discuss your sources and tell you panel something about them. Any source you cite is fair
game for questions afterward. Know where youre getting your information.
On the rubric one of the categories requires that you use thoughtful transitions. State
clearly what piece you are presenting. Is it service? Experience? Research? If you are making
reference to something previously said make sure you let your panel know.
Make sure to refer to your visuals...display board? Book? Photos? Letters? Weave these into
your presentation instead of using them as an afterthought (Oh, yeah, these are pictures of
stuff I did. Bye!) Include visuals alongside text to keep your presentation colorful and
maintain momentum.
BREATHE! When stressed, we often forget to do this...it helps immensely to take a deep
breath just before you begin your presentation. And during. And after.
How will you fill 12-20 minutes?!?! Start with your Social Research Presentation, throw in
your Policy Presentation, add a clear answer to your essential question and tell us about what
your did for 8 months! We love to hear details about your experience and service, so dont be
shy about an interesting story from the interactive parts of your project.
31
o
o
o
o
o
No
No
Non-existent
Distracting
Unprepared
o
o
o
o
o
Somewhat Inconsistent
o
o
o
o
o
Somewhat Inconsistent
Neutral
Limited Knowledge
o
o
o
o
o
Acceptable
Yes
Strength
Strength
Clear and Concise
Outline (3%)
-None submitted
-Not clear
-Not clear
Time (6%)
-12-20 minutes
Content (22%)
CCSS Writing 1: Write arguments to
support claims in an analysis of
substantive topics or texts, using valid
reasoning and relevant and sufficient
evidence.
CCSS Writing 2: Write
informative/explanatory texts to
examine and convey complex ideas and
information clearly and accurately
through the effective selection,
organization, and analysis of content.
Organization (22%)
CCSS Speaking and Listening 4: Present
information, findings, and supporting
evidence so listener can follow the line
of reasoning and the organization,
development, and style are appropriate
to task, purpose and audience.
CCSS Speaking and Listening 5: Make
strategic use of digital media and visual
displays of data to express information
and enhance understanding of
presentations.
- Media serves as a
crutch
- Elements go
unexplained or
misinterpreted
- Significant lack of
organization makes
presentation hard to
follow
-Evidence of
Service/Experience
insufficient
Sources/Citation (22%)
CCSS Writing 8: Gather relevant
information from multiple sources,
assess the credibility and accuracy of
each source, and integrate the
information while avoiding plagiarism.
CCSS Writing 9: Draw evidence from
literary or informational texts to support
analysis, reflection, and research.
- Blatant omission of
source citations
- Sources are scarcely
named, or one source is
used to support most
claims
-Works cited incomplete
Student Name:____________________________
(16%)
Exceeds Minimum
Standards
-Improper
format
Exceptional (22%)
- Social issue is clearly established.
- Detailed and relevant background includes
scope, severity and causal factors of social
issue, supported with data from multiple
sources
-At least 3 potential solutions addressed
including specific benefits to community, what
it costs, and challenges for each supported by
multiple sources.
-Description of experience and how it aided
research
-Detailed description of service project,
including impact, strengths/weaknesses in
solving social issue.
-Clear answer to all parts of EQ
- Each portion of the presentation contains
information supported fluently by thoughtful
visuals and transitions which allow the listener
to follow the speakers line of reasoning
-Presentation has clear organization.
- Media features (photos, sound, maps, charts,
diagrams) enhance understanding and raise
interest level in the audience
- Media format is clean and clear, devoid of
grammatical errors or distracting layout
-Contains multiple examples of visual evidence
of Experience & Service Project
- Claims are clearly supported by evidence
from credible sources
- Sources are correctly cited
- Sources are discussed and evaluated in order
to establish credibility
- Complete Works Cited page included at the
end of the presentation
Time:_____________
32
CONTENT
FORMAT
Redo
Does not
incorporate all
content required;
makes few/weak
connections
between
assignment and
overall project/EQ
Incorporates all
content required;
makes connections
between assignment
and overall project/EQ
Incorporates all
content required;
makes clear
connections
between
assignment and
overall project/EQ
A
Incorporates all
content required;
makes strong
connections
between
assignment and
overall project/EQ
Does not
follow format
given in packet
no EQ at top of
assignment
incorrect
margin size
GRAMMAR &
MECHANICS
Many errors in
grammar or
mechanics
Some errors in
grammar or
mechanics
Few errors in
grammar or
mechanics
SPELLING
Many errors in
spelling
Follows format
given in packet
exactly
EQ in italics &
centered at top
of assignment
Name and date
typed in upper
right corner
1 margins
No errors in
grammar or
mechanics
No errors in spelling
*This rubric applies to all assignments without rubrics in the QUEST packet.
*All QUEST work must be in final draft form to receive full credit.
*Any work receiving a REDO grade will be given 65% credit when the assignment is of passing quality.
*All REDO work must be submitted with the original graded draft.
*REDO work will be submitted as many times as necessary (to get to a passing level) to earn credit.
34