Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
874
doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2788.2006.00904.x
pp
Blackwell Publishing LtdOxford, UKJIRJournal of Intellectual Disability Research- The Authors. Journal compilation Blackwell Publishing Ltd12874882Original ArticleBehaviour
et al.
Abstract
Background Behavioural and emotional problems
occur at a high rate in children and adolescents with
intellectual disability, often from a young age. Some
studies have indicated that children and adolescents
with autism present with even higher rates. Less is
known about the presentation, development and
family impact of these difficulties in young children
with autism. This study aimed to explore these issues
in toddlers with pervasive developmental disorders
(PDDs), those with delay without a PDD, and their
families.
Methods Participants were children aged
months, referred to a developmental assessment
clinic. Parents completed a checklist on child behavioural and emotional problems, and individual questionnaires on family functioning, their own mental
health, and stress in relation to parenting their child.
The childs language and cognitive skills, adaptive
functioning and behaviour were assessed by stan-
Introduction
Autism is a neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by severe qualitative impairments in reciprocal
social interaction, communication, and restricted,
repetitive behaviour, interests and activities (American Psychiatric Association ). Having a child
with autism has a significant impact upon parents,
particularly in terms of stress (Bristol & Schopler
; Sanders & Morgan ; Dunn et al. ),
mental health (DeMeyer ; Olsson & Hwang
; Yirmiya & Shaked ) and family functioning (Choutka ; Johnson & Hastings ).
Greater levels of distress are present in families of
children with autism than those of typical children
(Koegal et al. ; Fombonne et al. ; Mruzek
et al. ) or children with other disabilities (Holroyd & McArthur ; Sanders & Morgan ;
Fombonne et al. ). Mothers of children with
autism generally report greater distress than fathers
(Milgram & Atzil ; Wolf et al. ; Konstantareas et al. ; Gray ; Hastings ; Hastings
et al. ), although this finding is not universal
(Bebko et al. ; Konstantareas & Homatidis ;
Hastings et al. ). Child behaviour and parent
mental health are variables proposed to impact differentially on the stress of mothers and fathers of
children with autism (Hastings ; Hastings et al.
).
Research indicates that compared with children
and adolescents with intellectual disability (ID),
behaviour and emotional problems occur at particularly high rates in children and adolescents with
autism (Tonge & Einfeld ) and in preschool children with a pervasive developmental disorder (PDD)
(Gadow et al. ). It has been suggested that the
presence of behaviour and emotional problems contributes significantly to the stress of mothers of children with ID (Hastings ; Beck et al. ), and
to stress in parents of older children and adolescents
with autism (Donenberg & Baker ; Bromley et al.
; Tomanik et al. ; Lecavalier et al. ).
Method
Participants
A total of children aged months were
referred to an assessment clinic with suspected developmental difficulties. Children and their parents were
allocated to a PDD [(Autistic Disorder, Pervasive
Developmental Disorder Not Otherwise Specified
(PDD-NOS)] or non-PDD group based on the
childs diagnosis at Time .
Measures
Diagnosis was made according to Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorder (DSM)-IV
(American Psychiatric Association ) criteria,
based upon information gathered through administration of the Autism Diagnostic Interview Revised
(ADI-R; Lord et al. ) and the Autism Diagnostic
Observation Schedule (Lord et al. ). The clinicians (K.G. and D.S.) arrived at a consensus diagnosis, taking into account all information obtained
during the assessment. Developmental age was
assessed using the Psychoeducational Profile
Revised (Schopler et al. ). Adaptive behaviour
was assessed with the Vineland Adaptive Behaviour
Scales parent interview (Sparrow et al. ); adaptive behaviour level indicated with the derived Adaptive Behaviour Composite (ABC) standard score.
Language ability was assessed with the Reynell
Developmental Language Scales (Edwards et al.
).
Where possible, the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence (WPPSI-III; Wechsler
) was administered as a measure of general intellectual ability. Of the non-PDD group, one child
completed a WPPSI at Time ; at Time , full scale
IQs ranged from to . Of the PDD group,
children completed a WPPSI at Time , full scale IQs
ranging from to . Children were classified as
developmentally delayed if their developmental age
was or more months below their chronological age
or their WPPSI-III full scale IQ less than . Children
were classified as having delayed language if their
Reynell age-equivalent scores were or more months
below their chronological age. Child behavioural and
emotional problems were assessed using the Developmental Behaviour Checklist Primary Carer Version (DBC-P; Einfeld & Tonge ); level of
disturbance indicated by the mean total behaviour
problem score.
Parental mental health was evaluated with the item version of the General Health Questionnaire
(GHQ-; Goldberg & Williams ). The GHQ
total score provides an overall screening measure of
mental health problems. Family functioning was evaluated with the Family Assessment Device General
Functioning Scale (FAD; Epstein et al. ; Byles
et al. ). Parenting stress was measured with a
stress thermometer visual analogue scale. Parents
rated how stressed they felt in relation to parenting
their child on a -point Likert scale, ranging from
no stress to very very very stressed. All parent
questionnaires were self-report; increasing scores
indicated increasing distress.
Procedure
Data were collected as part of a larger prospective
community screening study for autism, involving
assessment at three time points: diagnosis, -month
postdiagnosis review and -month review. The current study utilized data from Times and . All
children were referred to the clinic by participating
paediatricians or the Department of Human Services
Specialist Childrens Services with suspected
autism and/or developmental delay. Families of children meeting selection criteria of less than years of
age with suspected developmental or language delay
were invited for a comprehensive assessment. The
first assessment session involved administration of the
Data analysis
Preliminary group comparisons were conducted in
Version .. for Windows (SPSS Inc. ),
comprising independent and paired samples t-test
and chi-square. Correlational and regression analyses
were conducted in Stata (StataCorp ). Pearsonss correlations were calculated for Time and
Time parent outcome variables and for Time and
Time child behaviour and emotional problems.
Longitudinal regression was used to model parental
outcomes as linear functions of the childs gender,
age, relative delay, behaviour problem score and diagnostic group (PDD, non-PDD). For the parental
stress outcomes, partner mental health was added to
the model. The ratio of developmental to chronological age was used to represent developmental age in
the regression analyses. Adaptive behaviour level was
not included in regressions due to a high correlation
with this ratio (r = .). The childs age was decomposed into average age across Times and (reflecting age at entry to the study) and deviation from this
average at Times and (reflecting ageing during the
study). In light of multiple comparisons, a P-value of
<. was considered significant.
Results
Seventy-nine mothers and fathers in the PDD
group, and mothers and fathers in the nonPDD group completed parent questionnaires at Time
. At Time , six families declined or were unable to
continue to participate in the study; children
(.%) remained, with mothers and fathers
participating. Time parental response rate was
therefore .% of original sample. Seventy-one of
the children had a diagnosis of autistic disorder and
of PDD-NOS. Other descriptive data for the sample at Times and are presented in Table .
Independent sample t-tests revealed the PDD
group had significantly lower developmental ages,
t() = ., P < ., and recorded significantly
lower adaptive behaviour levels, t() = .,
P < ., than the non-PDD group at Time . Chisquare analyses with Yates correction for continuity
indicated a significantly larger proportion of the PDD
group were developmentally delayed, 2(,
n = ) = ., P < .. There were no significant
differences between the two groups in terms of chronological age, gender distribution or language delay
at Time .
In terms of behaviour and emotional problems,
there were no differences between the PDD and nonPDD groups at Time , nor was there any significant
change over time for either group. However, at Time
, the PDD group had higher mean total behaviour
problem score than the non-PDD group,
t() = ., P < ..
Group differences on parental measures were
investigated with independent sample t-tests. Mean
scores on parent measures are presented in Table .
There were no significant differences between PDD
and non-PDD groups on parent variables of stress,
mental health or reported family dysfunction at Time
. At Time , fathers in the PDD group reported
significantly more stress than those in the non-PDD
group, t() = ., P < .. At Time , mothers
reported significantly more stress than fathers in both
the PDD and non-PDD groups, t() = ., P < .;
t() = ., P < .. At Time , mothers again
reported more stress than fathers for both groups,
t() = ., P < .; t() = ., P < ..
The relationship between the Time and Time
outcome variables was also explored with Pearsons
correlations. Results are presented in Table . All
Table 1 Descriptive data means, standard deviations, frequencies for PDD and non-PDD samples at Time and Time
Sample
PDD (n = 84)
Non-PDD (n = 39)
Time 1
Time 2
Time 1
Time 2
37.75 (7.07)
21.42* (8.27)
61.78* (13.13)
0.55 (0.27)
50.19 (6.96)
26.34 (11.41)
58.68 (12.80)
0.58* (0.27)
38.25 (7.73)
29.29* (9.17)
73.95* (12.06)
0.50 (0.32)
49.66 (7.50)
35.25 (9.65)
72.64 (14.71)
0.43* (0.28)
PDD
Male
Developmental delay
Language delay
Non-PDD
Frequency
Percentage
Frequency
Percentage
75
75
81
89.3
89.3*
96.4
29
25
36
74.4
64.1*
92.3
Mean (SD).
*P < ..
DBC-P, Developmental Behaviour Checklist Primary Carer Version; PDD, pervasive developmental disorder.
Table 2 Means and standard deviations for parent outcome variables at Times and for PDD and non-PDD samples
Time 1
Parent outcome variable
PDD
2.22
53.00
1.93
1.58
47.25
1.84
(0.99)
(11.22)
(0.46)
(0.95)
(10.25)
(0.35)
Time 2
Non-PDD
PDD
Non-PDD
2.13
49.61
1.88
1.33
46.15
1.77
2.13 (0.96)
51.10 (12.39)
1.99 (0.54)
1.71* (0.98)
48.84 (11.73)
1.95 (0.47)
1.74 (0.96)
47.94 (11.55)
1.86 (0.47)
1.06* (0.93)
44.28 (8.20)
1.77 (0.42)
(0.93)
(10.47)
(0.50)
(0.85)
(9.67)
(0.48)
Mean (SD).
*P < ..
FAD, Family Assessment Device General Functioning Scale; GHQ, General Health Questionnaire; PDD, pervasive developmental disorder.
Discussion
The results of this study indicated that behaviour
and emotional problems have a significant impact on
parent outcome, with the exception of father stress.
Overall, fathers consistently reported less stress than
mothers, regardless of whether their child had a
PDD or not. However, fathers of children with a
PDD were significantly more stressed than other
Outcome variable
T1T2
correlation
0.41***
0.58***
0.53***
0.52***
0.59***
0.39**
0.75***
Table 4 Unstandardized coefficients for regressions of maternal and paternal outcome variables on child variables
Stress
GHQ
FAD
Child variables
Mother
Father
Mother
Father
Mother
Father
Female gender
Age at entry
Ageing during study
Developmental to chronological age ratio
DBC-P mean TBPS
PDD
Partner GHQ
(Constant)
0.26
0.02
0.02
0.05
1.27*
0.08
0.01
1.94*
0.34
0.02
0.01
0.37
0.28
0.16
0.01
0.09
1.02
0.29
0.21
2.79
10.11*
1.96
_
58.39*
3.62
0.03
0.02
6.20
8.46*
0.58
_
45.61*
0.07
0.00
0.00
0.05
0.48*
0.08
_
1.70*
0.08
0.01
0.01
0.13
0.36*
0.09
_
1.35*
*P < ..
DBC-P, Developmental Behaviour Checklist Primary Carer Version; FAD, Family Assessment Device General Functioning Scale; GHQ,
General Health Questionnaire; PDD, pervasive developmental disorder; TBPS, total behaviour problem score.
Conclusion
Results from this study highlight the importance of
addressing emotional and behavioural problems in
very young children with autism and/or developmental delay. Such behaviours should be a target for early
intervention, and existing evidence supports intervention for behaviour problems (e.g. Gavidia-Payne
& Hudson ; Hudson et al. ). Reduction of
child behaviour problems has the potential to ameliorate parental stress, mental health problems and
family dysfunction. As studies have shown that
behavioural and emotional problems in autism and
persist into adolescence and young adulthood (Tonge
& Einfeld ), understanding of these issues in
very young children and their parents has important
implications for intervention and long-term outcomes. An emphasis on providing early intervention
for behaviour and emotional problems, along with
additional support, education and skills training for
parents, is justified.
Acknowledgements
This research was funded by the National Health and
Medical Research Council and the Australian
Research Council, Australia. The authors would like
to thank Erin Mooney for her assistance in data collection, and participating children and their families
for their support.
References
American Psychiatric Association () Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (th: text revision
ed.). American Psychiatric Association, Washington, DC.
Baker B. L., Blacher J., Crnic K. A. & Edelbrock C. ()
Behaviour problems and parenting stress in families of
three-year-old children with and without developmental
delays. American Journal on Mental Retardation ,
.
Baker B. L., McIntyre L. L., Blacher J., Crnic K. A., Edelbrock C. & Low C. () Pre-school children with and
without developmental delay: behaviour problems and
parenting stress over time. Journal of Intellectual Disability
Research , .
Baker B. L., Blacher J. & Olsson M. () Preschool
children with and without developmental delay: behaviour problems, parents optimism and well-being. Journal
of Intellectual Disability Research , .
Hastings R. P. () Child behaviour problems and partner mental health as correlates of stress in mothers and
fathers of children with autism. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research , .
Fombonne E., Simmons H., Ford T., Meltzer H. & Goodman R. () Prevalence of pervasive developmental
disorders in the British nationwide survey of child mental
health. Journal of the Academy of Child and Adolescent
Psychiatry , .
Sparrow S. S., Balla D. A. & Cicchetti D. V. () Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales: Interview Edition Expanded
Form Manual. American Guidance Service, Circle Pines,
MN.
SPSS Inc. () SPSS Version for Windows. SPSS, Inc.,
Chicago, IL.
StataCorp. () Stata Statistical Software: Release . StataCorp LP, College Station, TX.
Tomanik S., Harris G. E. & Hawkins J. () The relationship between behaviours exhibited by children with
autism and maternal stress. Journal of Intellectual and
Developmental Disability , .
Tonge B. J. & Einfeld S. L. () Psychopathology and
intellectual disability: the Australian child to adult longitudinal study. International Review of Research in Mental
Retardation , .
Wechsler D. () Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of
Intelligence Australian Standardisation. The Psychological
Corporation, Marrickville.
Wolf L. C., Noh S., Fisman S. N. & Speechley M. ()
Brief report: psychological effects of parenting stress on
parents of autistic children. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders , .
Wood Rivers J. & Stoneman Z. () Sibling relationships
when a child has autism: marital stress and coping. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders , .
Yirmiya N. & Shaked M. () Psychiatric disorders in
parents of children with autism: a meta-analysis. Journal
of Child Psychology and Psychiatry , .
Accepted July