Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 105

Report

on

Stakeholders' Workshop
for

The Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal


(RSMSN)
(A comprehensive approach for developing Road Safety Management System)

Number of Persons Involved in Road Crashes in Nepal


16000
Slight Injuries

14000

Serious Injuries

12000

8000

1689

1837

1816

2010/11

2011/12

2012/13

3986

1734

2009/10

4018

1356

2008/09

4701

1131 2663

2007/08

4130

735 2583

2006/07

3609

3655
815 1866

2005/06

4039
685 1795

2004/05

3925
654 1659

2003/04

4442
623 785

2002/03

458 4138
603

2001/02

2000

5331

6000

5245

8000

4000

7813

6457

7383

10000

8503

Fatalities

31 October 2014
The Everest Hotel, Baneshwore, Kathmandu, Nepal

Table of Contents

Page

Title Page

Table of Contents

ii

Background

The Genesis of Proposal and Rationale for the Workshop

2.1

Workshop Planning

2.2

Organising Committee

2.3

Meetings of Organising Committee

2.4

Planning for Resources


2

Introduction to the Workshop


3.1

Objectives

3.2

Target Audience

3.3

Workshop Format

3.4

Workshop Brochure

3.5

Workshop Programme

3.6

Workshop Invitees

3.7

Workshop Participants

3.8

Funding Proposal

Workshop Sessions
4.1

Opening Session

4.2

Technical Sessions

4.3

Address by Chief Guest

4.4

Discussion Session

Post-workshop Activities

10

Statement of Expenses

11

Documentation of Information

11

Acknowledgements

11

Appendices

12

ii

Background

A team of international experts in road safety and related field of expertise of Nepalese origin working
overseas and having interest in the development of Nepal came together to assist the Government of Nepal
to implement ways on reducing road deaths in the country. Members of the team have been watching closely
frequent occurrences of unfortunate incidents in their country of origin. These members are considering
options to contribute their expertise gained internationally to save innocent lives on roads in the country.
These crashes are occurring on the door step of their parents, brothers, sisters, relatives and close friends in
the country. The lead team members have been working in the research of theses crashes and in finding
potential solutions that can be implemented in Nepal to reduce the frequency of occurrences of these crashes
and on options how roads in Nepal can be made safer.
The team believes that the carnage on roads can be significantly reduced with just a few selected low-cost
interventions on key governance, policy, planning, social and infrastructure development fronts. Piece meal
approaches being currently taken in these fronts needed to be replaced by a more holistic approach with
vision. The holistic approach is to develop and implement a sustainable road safety management system in
Nepal. A draft proposal for the development of this management system has been developed by the team and
consultation with key stakeholders was needed before finalising the proposal and submission to the
Government of Nepal for its consideration.
With sharply rising cases of road crashes involving multiple fatalities (exceeding well above 50), the
initiative has been considered to be very timely. A workshop was organised in Kathmandu Nepal on October
31, 2014 and the proposal presented. This report documents various aspects of planning and delivery of this
workshop, which will be shared with the members of team and its key stakeholders who would contribute to
the finalisation of the proposal.
This is the first workshop in series which aimed at presenting the overall framework of the proposed Road
Safety Management System in Nepal (RSMSN) and collecting input from stakeholders which could be used
to finalise the proposal. Workshops in future will focus on elaborating the concept of each component/subcomponents of the management system with details at individual project/sub-project level, while concurrently
finalising and refining the proposal. These project and sub-project level workshops will be of more interest to
the government, industry and road safety practitioners who like to see the impacts on the ground today and
not tomorrow.

The Genesis of Proposal and Rationale for the Workshop

Thinking about the need of the development of Nepal Road Safety Management System in Nepal (RSMSN)
started soon after the launch of Road Safety Unit by Nepal Transportation and Development Research Centre
(NTDRC) in Kathmandu Nepal on 30 September 2012, where Dr Partha Parajuli, a key member of the team,
had the opportunity to present a paper on road safety and shared his experience working in Queensland
Department of Transport and Main Roads, Australia. A number of other local road safety specialists also
presented the paper in the event. From the papers presented and discussions among the delegates it was not
difficult to realise the challenges posed by the existing situation of road crashes and opportunities available
to contribute to manage road safety in Nepal.
On return to Brisbane Dr Parajuli discussed the urgency of the matter with his few colleagues and friends. Dr
Kali Prasad Nepal, senior lecturer in Deakin University, quickly agreed to work on it. The need to form a
team was conceived and search for more specialists, primarily of Nepali origin, who could potentially be
interested to contribute back to their home land, started while continuing works on the development of
proposal.
With over one year of works, a basic draft of the proposal was completed. It was soon realised the need to
engage local specialists and road safety stakeholders and to seek local input. Consideration of local input was
felt necessary primarily for two reasons. First, a check of the proposal's ability to capture ground reality and
validation would offer the opportunity to incorporate more convincing models/ elements in the proposed
safety management system. Second, the engagement of local stakeholders at the very early stage of the
proposal development would provide opportunity to take key stakeholders into confidence and work
collaboratively. Taking the ownership of the management system to be developed under the proposed

framework by the Government of Nepal and Nepalese Community is very critical for ensuring desired
outcomes from this work, which has been completed entirely by voluntary contributions of time and
resources of the key members of the team and their friends.

2.1

Workshop Planning

Preliminary planning for the workshop commenced in Brisbane. October 31, 2014 was chosen for the
workshop after the confirmation of the trips to Nepal by Dr. Parajuli and Dr Nepal who were instrumental in
conceptualising and developing the proposal. Dr Parajuli's trip to Nepal was to begin in September 15 and
finish November 3, 2014. Dr. Nepal was scheduled to arrive at Kathmandu in the second week of October
and required to return to Melbourne also on the early first week of November. This schedule provide enough
time for planning and preparing for the workshop.
A decision was made to engage NTDRC as the local partner for the work. NTDRC and NASREC (Nepal
Australia Study and Research Centre, an initiative of Nepalese Association of Queensland) have an enduring
Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) signed under the initiation of Dr Parajuli on 29 September 2013 who
is also the executive member of NASREC. This well established relationship between the key member of the
team and NTDRC provided a good starting platform to collaborate.

2.2

Organising Committee

A workshop organising committee was formed soon after the arrival of Dr Parajuli, Project Coordinator
(designate) in Kathmandu on September 15, 2014. The organising committee comprised mainly the members
of the NTDRC, Dr Parajuli and Dr Nepal from Australia. The list of members and their affiliation is given in
Appendix 1.

2.3

Meetings of Organising Committee

The organising committee met four times in total, all in the meeting room at The Hotel Greenwich Village in
Lalitpur, Nepal: three times before the workshop and last one after the workshop. These dates were:

8 October 2014: First planning meeting


27 October 2014: Second planning meeting
30 October 2014: Pre-workshop meeting
2 November 2014: Post workshop meeting

The first meeting distributed the roles and responsibilities to each member. Subsequent meetings were
organised to review the progress and develop strategies and actions for smooth and successful delivery of the
workshop. The last meeting assessed the management of the workshop and developed /agreed post-workshop
action plan.
A typical meeting agenda and actions arising from the meeting is included in Appendix 2. All meetings were
well structured to maximise the resources available for managing the workshop.

2.4

Planning for Resources

The workshop organising committee in its meetings held time to time undertook an assessment of the road
safety situation in Nepal, potential responsible agencies and likely stakeholders and interest groups and
decided about the following key matters:

Workshop Organiser: National Road Safety Council Nepal (Ad hoc Committee);
Workshop Co-organiser: NTDRC;
Workshop Partner: Road Safety Society Sponsors: Ministry of Physical Infrastructure and Transport
(MoPIT), Asian Development Bank Nepal Office, Nepal Engineering College (nec);
Workshop Chair: Secretary of MoPIT and Chair of NRSC;
Chief Guest: Chief Secretary, Ministry of Parliamentary and Council of Ministers;
Design of Workshop Banner;
Development and design of workshop brochure/ flyer;
Workshop program; and
Funding sources

Approach to other distinguished guests such as Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Director General of
Department of Roads (DoR), Director General of Department Transport and Main Roads (DoTM),
Deputy Director Generals from DoR, senior government officials from National Planning
Commission, other ministries, Departments, Nepal Police, ADB, World Bank (WB), DfID, JICA,
UN Habitat etc to take part in the workshop.

Introduction to the Workshop

The workshop was scheduled in the second half of Friday October 31, 2014 and jointly organised by
National Road Safety Council (NRSC) and NTDRC. This workshop was planned to follow another related
workshop being scheduled by DoTM in the first half on the Development of Road Crash Information
Management System, which forms a part of a component of Road Safety Management System in Nepal.
Due to unexpected last minute change in the circumstance, the morning session of the workshop organised
by DoTM had to be cancelled. This report summarises the workshop completed in the second half of the day
and is about the proposal on the Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal. If the morning
workshop were on, it was not necessary to repeat the discussion on road crash information management
system.

3.1

Objectives

The objective of the workshop was to share the works undertaken so far on the development of the proposal
with all relevant stakeholders of road safety and seek local input on the same. The local input will be
incorporated in the draft proposal presented in the workshop and the proposal will be finalised for presenting
it to the Government of Nepal. Specifically, the objectives are:

inform the community and officials of the Government of Nepal about the intent of developing the
proposal and the importance of this work in addressing road safety in Nepal;
introduce the team working in the development of proposal;
share the experience of the team on road safety and best practice approach in managing road safety
and provide comparison with the approach being considered in Nepal;
present the proposal to the key stakeholders of road safety in Nepal;
familiarize with the works being undertaken in Nepal in the field of road safety improvement;
identify gaps in knowledge on road safety in Nepal;
collect local input/ feedbacks to refine the proposal; and
identify needs and come up with the list of projects to address local needs to include in the proposal

A sample of letter introducing the team and objectives of the workshop sent to selected government
organisations and funding agencies involved in managing road safety in Nepal is included in Appendix 3.
The letter was also meant to introduce the team to the stakeholders, rationale of the proposal and objectives
of the workshop. Request for assistance in organising the workshop was also made in this introduction letter.

3.2

Target Audience

The target audience for the workshop was selected keeping in mind the objectives of the workshop and
expected outcomes. The audience included:

Senior government officers involved in road safety policy making and funding;
Officers/ engineers from various government departments involved in the planning, design and
delivery of road safety projects;
Road safety specialists working in Nepal;
Multilateral agencies involved or likely to be involved in funding road safety projects;
Bilateral donor agencies involved or likely to be involved in funding road safety projects;
Faculty members of selected engineering colleges/universities in Nepal;
Health professionals working in Nepal;
Traffic Police officers;
Media personnel (newspapers/ TV);
Representatives from selected national and international consultants;

Representatives from Disability Association, Transport Industry, Automobile Association; and


Representative engineering / law students

Organisers, co-organisers, partners, sponsors were instrumental in identifying target audience for the
workshop.
3.3

Workshop Format

The workshop was designed with a view to run it in a more informal manner and to allow as much
interaction as possible with, and input collected from, the participants on the proposal. There was no formal
opening ceremony planned. The technical presentation started immediately after welcoming the chief guest
and other distinguished delegates requesting them to take the seat.
Registration desk was set up to welcome distinguished guests and workshop participants and to keep record
of the participants. Address by chief guest was scheduled at the end of the presentation followed by the floor
discussion to invite comments/ input from the participants. Floor discussion was planned by dividing
participants into six groups for six different components of the safety management system. Closing remarks
by the chair person was scheduled following the panel discussion.
The original format of the workshop involving the planned address by the chief guest at the end of technical
presentation was changed to accommodate the need of the chief guest to leave the workshop early. Also the
formation of six panels (for six components) for discussion on the proposal and to come up with the
suggestions on the proposal did not materialize due to the last moment cancellation of the DoTM workshop
scheduled in the morning and the need to accommodate two more presentations from Transport Research
Laboratory of UK.
3.4

Workshop Brochure

Workshop brochure containing the summary of the proposal presented in the workshop was designed in an
attractive form and a copy distributed to each participants for prior information.
A copy of the workshop brochure is included in Appendix 4.

The brochure has also been uploaded in the NTDRC website for those who want to access the workshop
materials in future.
3.5

Workshop Programme

Based on the selected format, the workshop programme was developed and distributed to each participants
of the workshop upon registration
The front page of the programme shows the design of the workshop banner. The banner shows the name of
the organiser, co-organiser and sponsors to recognise their role and appreciate their important contribution to
the workshop.
A copy of the programme is attached in Appendix 5

3.6

Workshop Invitees

The list of invitees was finalised after a number of iterations with input from the members of the organising
committee and assistance from the organiser, sponsors, selected stakeholders and road safety professionals
active in the country. The aim was to capture as many relevant people as necessary to get local input on the
project proposal.
The list of invitees together with the details on their affiliation, position, contact numbers and email
addresses is included in Appendix 6.

3.7

Workshop Participants

It is not reasonable to expect every invitee identified for the workshop would attend. Representatives were
nominated by those invitees who could not attend themselves due to other prior or pressing commitments.
The actual invitees who could participate in the workshop are documented in the list of workshop
participants (Appendix 7).

Chief Secretary of the Government of Nepal, Mr Leela Mani Paudyal graciously accepted organising
committee's invitation to be the chief guest of the event.

3.8

Funding Proposal

Funding proposals were developed and submitted to ADB and MoPIT, two major sponsors of the workshop.
The proposal submitted to MoPIT is given in Appendix 8 as an example for future reference.

The workshop was estimated to cost NRs 660,000 (See Table 1). The cost of the morning session was
expected to be primarily borne by DoTM. Assurance of support was received from ADB and MoPIT for
partial funding of the delivery of the workshop. The actual amount will be confirmed after their
consideration of the funding proposals submitted by the organising committee.
Table 1: Budget Estimate
S. No.

Particulars

Amount

1.

Workshop materials preparation (workshop brochure design/ NRs. 30,000


printing, program printing etc.)

2.

Venue rental for the workshop with 65 participants of the NRs. 65,000
morning session

Tea/ Coffee (two serving)

4.

Venue rental for the workshop with 100 participants of the NRs. 200,000
afternoon session

5.

Closing reception and/or dinner

6.

Workshop logistics (PA system, mike, overhead projector NRs. 75,000


rental and pens, notepads for participants)

NRs. 50,000

NRs.180,000

NRs. 600,000

Sub-total
7.

Contingency 10%

NRs. 60,000
NRs. 660,000

Total Estimated Cost

Fund for the afternoon session is expected to come from a number of agencies such as DoR and nec.DOR
and nec each have also assured to support the workshop with NRs 50,000 each and nominate up to 10
participants.

Workshop Sessions

The workshop had the following sessions:

Opening session
Technical session
Address by chief guest
Discussion session
Closing session

These sessions are briefly described below.

4.1

Opening Session

There was no formal welcoming and opening sessions. Housekeeping matters and workshop programme
were briefly presented and proposal was introduced soon after the distinguished guests were seated without
losing any moment for formalities such as candle lighting and opening speeches.

Photo 1: Dr Parajuli introducing the proposal in the opening session


The opening session introduced the proposal and was led by Dr Parajuli. The presentation about the proposal
is available in Appendix 9. The need and rationale of the proposal, principle behind the development of road
safety management system and the team as described in the workshop brochure were briefly touched upon
with detailed technical description left for the session to follow. Summarising the proposal was essential to
set the context of the workshop and to inform distinguished guests who can't afford time to stay for detailed
presentation.

4.2

Technical Session

Four presentations were made in total in the technical session. Mr Saroj Pradhan from of RSSN provided an
overview of road safety situation in Nepal and presented the education and awareness works RSSN delivered
in the past. Mr Pradhan's presentation is included in Appendix 10. The presentation set the scene for the
development of road safety management system for Nepal and provided an opportunity to appreciate the
challenges on it.
The second session was the main focus of the workshop. It was lead by Dr. Kali Prasad Nepal of Deakin
University who was instrumental in the development of proposal. Dr Nepal went through the alarming
situation in Nepal in terms of road crashes and then presented each of the six components of the proposed
Nepal Road Safety Management System in detail. He concluded his presentation by highlighting how the
team intends to develop and implement road safety management system in Nepal to reduce the number of
fatal and serious injuries (FSIs) in Nepal. Dr Nepal's presentation is included in Appendix 10. Workshop
brochure (Appendix 4) is the summary of his presentation.

Photo 2: Dr Nepal presenting details of the proposal in the technical session

The remaining two presentations were not planned for the afternoon workshop but the last minute
cancellation of the DoTM's morning workshop provided opportunity for including these two presentations as
well in this workshop. These presentations were specifically about the development of crash database
system. Crash database system is one of the key project components of the safety management system
proposed in this very project proposal and it was good to have presentations from other experts.
Dr Jim Jarvis of Experion Australia and the consultant for TRL made the presentation on crash data
collection strategy and demonstrated with his project works elsewhere in Asian countries how a simple
locally customised questionnaire could lead to the development of useful crash database system. Subu
Kamal, Director of TRL demonstrated how crash data can be collected and displayed using modern spatial
technology and demonstrated with crash data map of Kathmandu Nepal. Both presentations are provided at
the end of Appendix 10.

4.3

Address by Chief Guest

The presentation of the proposal in detail was interrupted for about 30 minutes to accommodate address to
the workshop participants by the chief guest, Mr Leela Mani Paudyal. Some of the highlights of his address
were:
1. Short term and long term impact (especially on low income and poor people) resulting from the
death of bread winners of the family;
2. Drivers' and vehicle operators' negligence;
3. Irresponsible and indifferent attitude of government agencies;
4. Commitment to give more time to listen to the problems and to act for improving road safety;
5. Regulating and monitoring divers licensing and route permit system to be the first priority
(legislative and compliance framework);
6. Commitment to take responsibility for ongoing deterioration of road safety in Nepal;
7. Commitment to create a single government agency for managing road safety with clearly defined
role and responsibilities (institutional framework);
8. Commitment to make roads safer (Pre-crash system);
9. Role of private sector;
10. Role of transport industry; and
11. Priority to be given on solutions based on approaches which are affordable, sustainable, and
manageable with available resources and which are more cost-effective (funding framework).
The address has touched upon most of the key components of road safety management issues relevant in
Nepal. These items will be the guiding principle in finalising the proposal. Legal and regulatory framework,
institutional framework, funding framework as well as elements of pre-crash system

Photo 3: Chief Secretary Paudyal addressing workshop participants


Local media captured Mr Paudyal's speech very well emphasising the need of the work being proposed by
the Team. A copy of edited (Nepali) version of Mr Paudyal's emotional speech, which was published in
Setopati.com is included in Appendix 11 for documentation purpose. These highlights provide guidance to
the proposal team to identify focus areas and to make the proposal more responsive to the local needs. The
speech touches upon many issues that require immediate attention and that could be developed over time.
The team is pleased to note that the draft proposal recognises most of these local issues and already contains
these priority project components. The final proposal will identify actions, which could be implemented
immediately to make real visible differences, actions for implementation in the short to medium terms and
actions which can only be implemented in the long term.

4.4

Discussion Session

Contrary to the original plan to give a large chunk of workshop time for discussion on the proposal and
collect input from workshop participants, the discussion session was confined to taking a few comments/
clarifications and suggestions to the proposal. The plan was to divide the workshop participants into six
groups (based on their interest and expertise): one for each of the six different components of the safety
management system and have panel discussion. The expectation from the group discussion was, among
others, to receive feedbacks on the example projects included in the draft proposal and to identify more
projects of local needs and priorities for inclusion in the final proposal.

The group discussion as planned did not take place. It was announced that workshop participants will be
contacted by email to send their suggestions.

Photo 4: Workshop participants providing comments in the Discussion Session


There were questions about the availability of iIMAAP (Appendix 10), approach and methodology for
establishing management system and funding of the project. Suggestions were made not to invent the wheel
but use available standards, documents and guidelines to the maximum possible extent and avoid
duplication. There was also some level of concerns expressed about the proposal in its current format being

more inclined to academic research oriented than giving practical solutions which are able to address
immediate needs and save lives. Suggestion was made that the consideration be given to include more doable
projects in the final proposal and not make it a research type of project.
Relating the issue of establishing road safety management system with the broader context of transport
management system, some participants highlighted the need to strengthen the local institution to establish
and maintain road safety management system. It was advised that the consideration be given in the proposal
to undertake a closer look at the institutional capability of the Department of Transport Management in its
current state and to develop the appropriate institutional framework for managing road safety. This should be
a number one priority for any road safety management system to establish and run in a sustainable manner.
Citing the example of weak institutional framework/commitment, a participant expressed concern on the lack
of actions from the Government on finalising and releasing urban road standards which, when adopted and
implemented, could contribute to improving urban road safety significantly. The action is long overdue and
sitting in the Ministry since last six months. It is also not clear which Ministry is responsible to approve,
release and monitor the implementation of urban road standards.

Other issues brought in the discussion were on vehicle testing centre, coverage of local road network,
accessible road standards for people with disability. Suggestions were made to incorporate these items as
well in the proposal.
The discussion session was closed following the announcement that there would be more opportunities
available for informal interaction among the participants and organisers during the closing reception (to
follow after closing session) and the request to the participants to watch email inviting submissions on the
proposal.
4.5

The Closing Session

In the closing session, Chairperson, Mr Tulasi Prasad Sitaula, Secretary of the Ministry of Physical
Infrastructure and Transport (MoPIT) informed the workshop participants about the activities that have been
taking place in road safety fronts highlighting the needs and commitments to do more in the time to come.

Photo 5: Chairperson, Mr Sitaula making workshop closing remarks

Mr Sitaula at the beginning of his remarks confirmed that the Government has already started taking many
actions to improve road safety. Nepal Road Safety Action Plan (NRSAP) was completed to meet the
Government's commitment on UN Decade of Action on Road Safety. With the completion of NNRSAP, the
Government has already started a number actions and initiatives. Highlights on the initiatives include:

The initial proposal was to chair National Road Safety Council (NRSC) by the Prime Minister itself;
For practical reason this proposal has been changed and now it is proposed that the Transport
Minister chair the Council;

Change in Act is required before formalising this process; Work is on progress;


In order to continue progress works on road safety during this period, an interim arrangement has
been made and an ad-hoc committee has been formed under his chairmanship;
Before it was not clear which Ministry should take the lead for implementing NRSAP. Now it is
clear and MoPIT will take the lead;
MoPIT has already started planning many initiatives. These include, but not limited to
o Establishment of NRSC and its Secretariat
o Strengthening of Road Traffic Unit (RTU) of DoR
o Formulating Road Safety Act
o Review and amend VTMA and VTMR
o Prepare Public Road Act
o Capacity building of agencies involved in road safety
o Develop road safety database
o Piloting road safety works

Mr Sitaula opined that while these preparatory works are expected to provide solid foundation for improved
road safety, there is a need to deliver some immediate outcomes on the ground. The Government cannot wait
and watch the current situation of road safety in the country as highlighted by the Chief Secretary.
Other issues Mr Sitaula briefly touched upon in his closing remarks (requiring attention of this proposal)
included:

Stringent requirement for licensing drivers of public transport vehicles;


Review of route permit issuing system;
Management of monitoring and compliance of operating conditions (e.g., overcrowding) of public
transport vehicles;
Strengthening of DoTM's capacity;
Crash database is weak (there are no good base line figures);
Road safety research and development;
Current reactive approach / measures alone are not enough, proactive measures are required;
Need to incorporate road safety features collectively in road development plan and programs;
Raising awareness about the need to incorporate road safety measures in the design and construction
of road is important;
More funding is required to strengthen the capacity of engineers to identify and implement road
safety improvement projects;
TRL crash database;
Safety for people with disability; and
Segregation of pedestrian traffic with vehicular traffic

Commending the initiative presented in the workshop a step in the right direction, Mr Sitaula suggested to
consider implementing small doable actions first with the long term target/ vision in mind. He also expressed
that his Ministry is happy to work together with the team of international and national road safety experts
and provide full support to the initiative. He would be pleased to see the road safety management system as
envisaged in the presented proposal in place up and running as soon as possible.
5

Post-workshop Activities

A post-workshop meeting of the organising committee took place on 2 November 2014. The meeting
discussed the post -workshop action plan prepared by Dr. Parajuli and finalised it with commitment for
implementation.
The Action Plan is included in Appendix 12. The plan shows the date for delivering identified actions with
lead and support persons attached to each action. As per the announcement made in the workshop, calls for
the input from the workshop participants were made a number of times, the final call being made on
December 4, 2014 with the due date for submitting feedbacks extended to December 31, 2014.

It is expected to deliver the final proposal and its business case to MoPIT by early April 2015. Other key
milestones are:

10

Finalise Proposal: 30 January 2015


Develop business case: 30 February 2015
Deliver the final proposal and business case to MoPIT: 1 April 2015
Formal announcement of the proposal and Launch Nepal Road Safety Research Trust: 15 April 2015

It is planned to revisit and updated the action plan time to time to reflect the changed circumstances if any. In
the mean while key team members of the project may start work on low cost projects as identified by them
and/or prepare funding submissions on the projects of their interest keeping in mind the big picture
management framework established in the proposal.
A copy of the email sent out to all participants inviting inputs / feedbacks on the proposal is included in
Appendix 13.

Statement of Workshop Income & Expenses

The total expense for the workshop was NRs 214,989.55. ADB's share of support is NRs 103, 574.68 and
details are shown in Appendix 14. MoPIT's share of support is NRs 111,414.87 and its details are shown in
Appendix 14. Copies of each invoice and receipts of expenses and payments are kept in file in NTDRC's
custody and are available for inspection. ADB did not agree to pay the expenses incurred in uploading
workshop materials in NTDRC's web site, which was NRs 3000.00. This is to be borne by the fund yet to be
received from nec and DoR.
As of 20/12/2014, the date this report is written, only ADB has made payments of all agreed items of
expenditures. MoPIT is yet to release its contribution or make payment to parties. Any surplus fund from
nec and DoR, other two workshop sponsors, will go to NTDRC's Road Safety Research Fund. This spare
fund will be used to support future road safety activities as decided by the Team.

Documentation of Information

Enormous correspondences (mainly email) were made in relation to organising workshop. It is not possible to
document each and every document, nor is necessary. Additional documentation of materials, which have not
been captured as yet by the above text and appendices and which could be relevant and which could be useful
for future reference, are included in Appendix 15.

Acknowledgements

While contribution of each individual participant is greatly acknowledged, organising committee wishes to
acknowledge specifically the following distinguished guests for proving guidance, providing funding
support, accepting invitation and contributing their valuable times for the workshop. The committee also
extend its sincere thanks to all friends who provided assistance in making the workshop a great success.
Contribution of Road Safety Society Nepal (RSSN) and assistance in organising the workshop is also
specifically acknowledged.
Mr. Lila Mani Paudyal: Chief Secretary/OPMCM
Mr. Tulasi Prasad Sitaula: Secretary/MoPIT
Mr. Nabin Pokharel: Senior Divisional Engineer/MoPIT
Mr. Suman Sharma: Secretary/MoF
Mr. Yogeshwar Parajuli: Chief Commissioner/KVDA
Mr. Kashi Raj Dahal: Director General/DoTM
Mr. Sharad Adhikary: DoTM
Dr. Padma Shahi: DoTM
Mr. Devendra Karki: DoR
Mr. Arjun Jung Thapa: DoR

11

Mr. Dr Tika Limbu: ADB


Mr. Naresh Pradhan: ADB
Dr. Deepak Bhattarai: Board Member/nec
Mr. Saroj Khanal: Secretary/RSSN
Mr. Saroj Pradhan: Executive Secretary/RSSN
Mr. Kamal Pande: Member/RSSN
Mr. Rod Stickland: Freelance Transport Consultant
Mr. Dhruba Raj Regmi: KSUTP
Mr. Subhash Dhungel: KSUTP
Mr. Dushyant Thapa: KSUTP
Mr. Punya Gautam: KSUTP

Appendices

The following Appendices are included in the report.


Appendix 1: Workshop Organising Committee
Appendix 2: Workshop Organizing Committee's Meeting Agenda and Actions
Appendix 3: Sample Letter
Appendix 4: Workshop Brochure
Appendix 5: Workshop Programme
Appendix 6: Workshop Invitees
Appendix 7: Workshop Participants
Appendix 8: Sample Funding Proposal
Appendix 9: Opening Session: Presentation by Dr. Partha Parajuli
Appendix 10: Technical Session: Presentations by Mr Saroj Pradhan, Dr. Kali Prasad

Nepal, Dr. Jim Jarvis and Mr. Subu Kamal


Appendix 11: Speech by Mr Leela Mani Paudyal (in Nepali)
Appendix 12: Post-workshop Action Plan
Appendix 13: Post-workshop Email Sent to Participants Inviting Input into the Proposal
Appendix 14: Statement of Workshop Expenses: ADB's & MoPIT's Support
Appendix 15: Additional Documentation
Appendix 16: Photo Gallery

12

APPENDIX 1: Workshop Organising Committee


Workshop on the Development of Nepal Road Safety Management System
Workshop Organising Committee
Members of Workshop Organising Committee

Dr Partha Parajuli: Project Co-ordinator /NRSMS - Convener


Dr Kali Nepal: Deputy Project Coordinator/NRSMS Project - member
Er Madan Maleku: Managing Director/ NTDRC - member
Dr Chandra Shrestha: Executive Director/NTDRC - member
Dr Deepak Bhattarai: Executive Director/NTDRC - member
Dr Padma Shahi: Executive Director/NTDRC - member
Mr Naresh Shrestha: Executive Director /NTDRC - member
Er. Santosh Gupta: Engineer/ NTDRC - member

APPENDIX 2: Workshop Organizing Committee's Meeting Agenda and Actions

NEPAL ROAD SAFETY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (NRSMS) DEVELOPMENT


WORKING GROUP MEETING
Date:
Wednesday 8 October 2014
Time:
5:15PM 7:00PM
Venue: Hotel Greenwich Village Meeting Room
Lalitpur Nepal

AGENDA
CHAIR

Dr. Partha Parajuli


Project Coordinator - nominee

1. 17:15 - 17:20

WELCOME/ INTRODUCTION

2.

APOLOGIES

3. 17:20 - 17:25

MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING


None
NTDRC members to review and endorse minutes as true records of discussion

4. 17:25 17:30

ACTIONS FROM PREVIOUS MEETING


Actions arising from the previous RTIG meeting are listed in the attached Table.
NTDRC members to note the status and progress of actions/ decisions and continue
works for progressing with the implementation of actions

5. 17:30 18:30

PREPARATION FOR INTERACTION PROGRAM


Progress update: Partha to provide update.

Project Proposal:

Proposal Brochure:

Date Time Venue:

Fund:

List of Participants:

Program Items:

Discussion on issues: All members to speak in rotation precisely to the point

Project Proposal:

Proposal Brochure:

C:\Users\P\Desktop\RSMSN\Meetings\Meeting 01.doc

Date Time Venue:

Fund:

List of Participants:

Program Items:

Developing Action Plans: Partha to lead the discussion item.

Funding: XX in lead YY in support

Brochure:

List of participants:

Venue and logistics:

Meeting with officials:

Invitations to participants:

Program of the day:

NTDRC members agree to the above action plan and work off line with ongoing
communication through emails and telephone.
6.

18:30 -18:45 BuS ENDOWMENT FUND


This is most likely perceived as nec issue but the NRSMS development project may benefit
from its new direction of operation. Not all members may be aware of Bus Fund nec is
managing. Partha will provide a brief update.
Members to note and suggest ways of its improved operation and best use

18:45 19:00 SIDRA SOFTWARE


This is most likely perceived as a nec issue but availability of software may have positive
impact on NRSMS development project. Not all members may be aware of this software nec
has acquired. Partha to provide a brief update
Members to discus and suggest ways of collaborating with nec, ntdrc and this work
within the limitations of software use license agreement

8.

19:00

OTHER BUSINESSES AND CLOSING.


Next Meeting:

C:\Users\P\Desktop\RSMSN\Meetings\Meeting 01.doc

NEPAL ROAD SAFETY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (NRSMS) DEVELOPMENT


WORKING GROUP MEETING
Date:
Wednesday 27 October 2014
Time:
5:30PM 7:00PM
Venue: Hotel Greenwich Village
Lalitpur, Nepal

AGENDA
CHAIR

Dr. Partha Parajuli


Project Coordinator - nominee

1. 17:30 - 17:35

WELCOME/ APOLOGIES/ INTRODUCTION


KPN will join us the meeting

2. 17:30 - 17:35

MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING


No formal minutes were made but the actions were distributed. Most actions are in progress.
Members to note and endorse notes of the discussion.

3. 17:35 17:40

ACTIONS FROM PREVIOUS MEETING


All actions arising from the previous WG meeting are in progress and informed by email or by
phone on regular basis. PP to update
Members to note the status and progress of actions/ decisions and continue works for
progressing with the implementation of actions.

4. 17:40 18:40

PREPARATION FOR WORKSHOP


Progress update: Partha / Kali to provide update.

Project Proposal and Presentation Materials: Kali

Workshop Brochure and Banner: Partha

Date Time Venue: Partha

Fund: Partha

List of Participants: Partha

Format and Program of the Workshop: Partha

Discussion on issues: All members to speak in rotation precisely to the point

Project Proposal and Presentation Materials:

Workshop Brochure:

C:\Users\P\Desktop\RSMSN\Meetings\Meeting 02.doc

Fund

List of Participants:

Format and Program of the Workshop:

Developing Action Plans: Partha to lead the discussion item.

Funding:

Invitation to Participants:

Phone calls to participants:

Meeting with officials in person for maximising participation:

Format and the program and of the workshop:

Decision on panel chairs and request

Members to agree to the above action plan and work on-line with ongoing
communication through emails and telephone.
5.

18:40 -18:50 BuS ENDOWMENT FUND


This is most likely perceived as nec issue but the NRSMS development project may benefit
from its new direction of operation. Not all members may be aware of Bus Fund nec is
managing the Fund.
Members to note and suggest ways of its improved operation and best use

18:50 19:00 SIDRA SOFTWARE


This is most likely perceived as a nec issue but availability of software may have positive
impact on NRSMS development project. Not all members may be aware of this software nec
has acquired. nec /NTDRC may propose SIDRA Solutions to lead and work together for local
customisation of the software for use in Nepal.
Members to discus and suggest ways of collaborating with nec, ntdrc and this work
within the limitations of software use license agreement

7.

19:00

OTHER BUSINESSES AND CLOSING.


Next Meeting: After the workshop (to be determined in the meeting to review on how the
workshop went and what actions plans are to be developed).

C:\Users\P\Desktop\RSMSN\Meetings\Meeting 02.doc

APPENDIX 3: Sample Letter


Dear .
Thanks for your time yesterday to discuss the matters of common interest, in particular, our
proposal on the development of Nepal Road Safety Management System.
We area a team of like-minded specialists working in the field of road safety overseas having
strong desire to contribute something back to the community we belong to. Having heard the
news of road carnage in Nepal frequently, we thought we should do something to contribute to
reduce, and hopefully to eliminate, this sort of mass killings. No words can explain the
importance of works we propose to do than the attached paper cut. You might have read / heard
the news of the recent carnage on our roads today. Thirty innocent lives were lost and over 40
were seriously injured in Doti District in a bus accident. More deaths are expected at hospital.
Can we imagine the extent of trauma this has brought to the families of crash victims? This is
unacceptable for any civilized community to watch and not to act against these mass killings on
the roads built for the purpose of national development using scarce resources of the country
and international assistance. We must do something on this front.
I am delighted to let you know that we have started a new initiative on the development and
implementation of a sustainable Road Safety Management System (RSMS) in Nepal in response
to the urgent need to reduce such unwarranted and unacceptable level of road death in Nepal.
With over one year of research and hard work since we launched the Road Safety Unit at Nepal
Transportation Research and Development Centre (NTDRC), our local partner, we have so far
prepared a comprehensive draft proposal and it is now ready for sharing our hard work with you.
Attached draft workshop brochure describes briefly about our initiative and the way forward as
we see it. We are planning to present our final proposal to the Government of Nepal for its
consideration. Before finalizing the proposal, we are planning to present the proposal to key
stakeholders in Nepal on road safety with a view to collecting feedback from them and not
repeating, or competing with the efforts already made but complementing these efforts and
building on the blocks that have already laid the foundation in course.
We are planning to organize a half day presentation/ workshop for this purpose on October 31,
2014. We have contributed all our times and resources voluntarily for this good cause and we
will continue to do so in future to the possible extent. We need, however, your support at this
stage to be able to organise a workshop of October 31, 2014. This email is to seek your financial
assistance to support the organization of the workshop to the tune of US $2500. Also please
note that we are concurrently working with other government bodies (such as National Road
Safety Council and Department of Transport Management) and private agencies (such as Nepal
Engineering College, Institution of Civil Engineers UK, Nepal Chapter) to sponsor the workshop.
If we would be successful in garnering support from these agencies, the surplus money will go to
the road safety research fund that we plan to establish as one of the actions of this initiative.
Every cent contributed to this fund will be accounted and used in researching and implementing
one or more projects on road safety under the proposed proposal. We will have the opportunity
to discuss about these matters in the workshop in detail.
Please contact me at 9818635071 if you want to discuss any aspect of the proposal.
Thanking you for your kind consideration
Regards
Dr. Partha Parajuli MIEAust CPEng RPEQ
M Sc Civil Engg (Highways) (Former USSR), Ph D (Transportation) (Canada)
MITE (USA), MIRC MIUT FIE C Eng (India)
Principal Engineer (Safety), Department of Transport and Main Roads, Brisbane, Queensland,
Australia (currently in Kathmandu)
Visiting Professor and Honourary Queensland Representative, Nepal Engineering College,
Pokhara University, Nepal
Visiting Professor and Honourary Queensland Representative, Kathmandu Engineering College,
Tribhuvan University, Nepal
"Integrity without knowledge is weak and knowledge without integrity is dreadful and dangerous"

Dr. Partha Mani Parajuli MIEAust CPEng RPEQ


M Sc Civil Engg (Highways) (Former U.S.S.R)
Ph D Civil Engg (Transport and Traffic) (Canada)
MITE (USA), MIRC MIUT FIE C Eng (India)

Date: October 21, 2014


Mr Arjun Jung Thapa
Deputy Director General,
Department of Roads,
Kathmandu, Nepal
Sub: Request for Attendance Participants
We are a team of like-minded specialists working in the field of road safety overseas having strong desire to contribute something
to the community to which we belong. Having heard the news of road carnage in Nepal frequently, we thought we should do
something to contribute to reduce and hopefully to eliminate this sort of mass killings. No words can explain the importance of
works we propose to present and discuss than the recent past news clips in the media. This is unacceptable for any civilized
community to watch and not to act against these mass killings on the roads built for the purpose of national development using
scarce resources of the country and international assistance.
I am delighted to let you know that we have started a new initiative on the development and implementation of a sustainable
Road Safety Management System (RSMS) in Nepal in response to the urgent need to reduce such unwarranted and
unacceptable level of road death in Nepal. With over one year of research and hard work since we launched the Road Safety
Unit at Nepal Transportation & Development Research Centre (NTDRC), our local partner for this initiative, we have so far
prepared a comprehensive draft proposal and it is now ready for sharing our hard work with you.
Attached draft workshop brochure describes briefly about our initiative and the way forward as we see it. We are planning to
present our final proposal to the Government of Nepal for its consideration. Before finalizing the proposal we are planning to
present the proposal to key stakeholders in Nepal on road safety with a view to collecting feedback and not repeating, or
competing with the efforts already made but complementing these efforts and building on the blocks that have already laid the
foundation in course.
We are planning to organize a half day presentation/ workshop for this purpose on October 31, 2014. We have contributed a lot
of our times and resources voluntarily for this good cause and we will continue to do so in future to the possible extent. We need,
however, your support at this stage to be able to conduct the workshop of October 31, 2014. This letter is to seek your active
participation and support by sponsoring/ nominating about 10 participants from your esteemed organization. Also note that we
are concurrently working with other government bodies (such as National Road Safety Council and Department of Transport
Management) and donor agencies (such as ADB) and private institutions (such as Nepal Engineering College, Road Safety
Society Nepal) to sponsor the workshop. If we would be successful in garnering support from these agencies, any surplus fund
will go to the road safety research fund that we plan to establish as one of the actions of this initiative. Every cent contributed to
this fund will be used in researching and implementing one or more projects on road safety under the proposed proposal. We will
have the opportunity to discuss about these matters in the workshop in detail.
Attached is the list of participants we have identified from the DoR who, we expect, are related to planning, programming, policy
making, designing and delivering road safety initiatives and who could contribute most to the development of Road Safety
Management System in Nepal. However, please feel free to make any changes and suggestions in the nomination.
Thanking you for your kind consideration
Yours sincerely

Partha Parajuli
Project Coordinator (NRSMS)
Registered Professional Engineer of Queensland (Registration Number 6087)
Member National Professional Engineers Register Civil (Membership Number 2207566)

APPENDIX 4: Workshop Brochure

APPENDIX 5: Workshop Programme

Government of Nepal

Ministry of Physical Infrastructure and Transport

NATIONAL ROAD SAFETY COUNCIL

WORKSHOP ON THE DEVELOPMENT


OF

NEPAL ROAD SAFETY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM


October 31, 2014
The Everest Hotel, New Baneshwore, Kathmandu, Nepal

Jointly organized by:

NRSC

NTDRC

Sponsors

DoR/ DoTM

nec

RSSN

ADB

Programme
Chief Guest: Mr Leela Mani Paudyal, Chief Secretary, Office of the Prime Minister & Council Minister
Chair: Mr Tulasi Sitaula, Secretary, Ministry of Physical Infrastructure & Transport
Pre-workshop Lunch: 12:30PM
Request for taking seat to Chief Guest, distinguished guests and workshop participants: 1:30PM
Technical Presentations
Introducing proposal on the development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal by Dr Partha Parajuli: 15min
Recent Works on Road Safety Education and Awareness in Nepal by Mr Saroj Pradhan: 15min
Presentation of the proposal by Dr Kali Nepal
Presentation by Mr. Kamal Subu and Jim Javis/TRL: 4:00PM
Floor open for discussion 4:30PM
Addresses by guests 5:00PM
Concluding remarks by the Chair and workshop closes 5:30PM
Closing reception 5:30PM

APPENDIX 6: Workshop Invitees


Workshop
on
Development of Nepal Road Safety Management System
List of Invitees (Master Copy)
October 31, 2014
8:30AM - 12:30PM (Development of Road Accident Information Management System)
12:30PM - 16:30PM (Develoment of Road Safety Management System)
Venue: Everest Hotel

Date:
Time:

S. No.

Name of the Participants

Organizations / Firms

Designation

Phone / Fax No.

Cell No.

Email address

Morning
Session

Afternoon
Session

Dr. Govinda Pokharel

NPC

Vice Chairman

9851100407

gpokharel@npc.gov.np

Mr. Gopi Mainali

NPC

Joint Secretary

9841353982

mainaligopi@gmail.com,
gnmainali@npcnepal.gov.np

3
4

Dr. Jagdish Chandra Pokhrel


Er. Tulasi Prasad Sitaula

NPC
MoPIT

Former Vice Chairperson, NPC


Secretary

Er. Madhav K. Karki

MoPIT

Joint Secretary

6
7
8
9
10

Er. Bishnu Om Bade


Dr. Mahendra Subba
Mr. Gopi Khanal
Dr. Babu Ram Marasini
Dr. Ashok R. Bajracharya

MoPIT
MoUD
MoFALD
MoHP
National Trauma Centre, Bir Hospitial

11

Dr. Sunil K. Joshi

Kathmandu Medical College Teaching


Hospital

9851056859

12

Dr. Ram Kebal Shah

NMC

Joint Secretary
Joint Secretary
Joint secretary
Senior Health Administrator
Senior Orthopedic Surgeon
Professor of Community
Medicine/Injury Violence Prevention
Consultant
Orthopaedic Surgeon

9851036088
9851091938
9803338862
9803339962
9841826827
9851046253
9851108064
9857066412
9851020107

13

Er. Suman Sharma

MoF

Secretary

14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22

Er. Arjun Karki


Mr. Bala Ram Rijal
Er. Devendra Karki
Er. Arjun Jung Thapa
Er. Keshab K Sharma
Er. Sanjaya K Shrestha
Er. Arati Shah
Er. Kiran Subedi
Er. Hari Ram Acharya

MoUD
MoF
DoR
DoR
DoR
DoR
DoR
DoR
DoR

Secretary
Under Secretary
Director General
DDG
DDG
DDG
RTU
RTU
DDG

23

Er. Saroj Pradhan

DoR

SE

24
25
26
27
28
29
30

Er. Bhim Upadhaya


Er. Krishna P. Bhandari
Er. Rabindra N Shrestha
Er. Ram Krishna Sapkota
Er. Nabin Kumar Pokharel
Mr. Reshmi Raj Pande
Mr. Yogeshwor Parajuli
Dr. Bhai Kaji Tiwari or other KVDA
Representative
Mr. Kashi Raj Dahal
Er. Sharad Adhikari
Ms. Indra Kumari Thapaliya
Mr. Mukti KC
Mr. Basanta Adhikari
Dr. Padma Shahi
Mr. Mohan Bahadur Thapa
Er. Raj Kumar Maharjan
Er. Keshav Gautam
Er. Gogan Hamal

DoR
DoR
NRSC
NRSC
NRSC
NRSC
KVDA

Joint Secretary, MoFALD


Road & Traffic Unit Chief, SDE
Joint Secretary MoPIT member
DDG DoLIDAR
Under Secretary MoPIT
Joint Secretary, MoFALD
Chief Commissioner

KVDA

Chief KVDA Kathmandu

9851075756

bhaikajitiwari@gmail.com

DoTM
DoTM
DoTM
DoTM
DoTM
DoTM
DoTM
DoTM
DoTM
DoTM

Director General
Director
Director
Director
Director
Technical Adviser
Chief Accountant
Computer Engineer
Computer Engineer
Mechanical Engineer

9851141059
9851081781
9841217624
9841373067

dahalkashi@yahoo.com

31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41

4211696

4476152 x3513

tpsitaula@hotmail.com

Y
Y

Y
Y

bishnuombade@hotmail.com

Marasini2@yahoo.com

ashokbaj@gmail.com

Y
Y

Y
Y
Y
Y
Y

drsunilkj@gmail.com

9851023999
9851059948
9851059948
9802012505
4211381
4262675
4258154
4216317

4262510

4200309

4211796

9851100475
9841673588
9841294884
9841284146
9846039464
9846039464
9845404848
9851166615
9841444615
9851104057
9847045458
9841263985
9851198164
9851021978

9851091057
9841331437

spsharma77@gmail.com,
spharma@mof.gov.np
secretary@moud.gov.np
erdevendrakarki@hotmail.com

planning@dor.gov.np

Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y

dormechb@dor.gov.np
pradhansaroj70@gmail.com

gholirabindra@yahoo.com
nkpokharel@gmail.com
reshmipandey@hotmail.com
info@kvda.gov.np

sarad_abu@hotmail.com
pandeyindra79@yahoo.com

mukti_2@hotmail.com
pb_shahi@yahoo.com

mohan_b_thapa@yahoo.com
rkmaharjan@dotm.gov.np
krgautam@dotm.gov.np
goganhamal@gmail.com

Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y

Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y

Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y

Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y

Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y

S. No.

Name of the Participants

42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80

Er. Mohan Bhattarai


Mr. Birendra Swar
Mr. Karna Timilsina
Mr. Rudra Bhusal
Mr. Sammyak R Bajracharya
Ms Sabita Pradhan
Er. Sagar Gyawali
Er. Ramesh Nath Bastola
Er. Jivan K. Shrestha
Er. Ganga B. Basnet
Er. Maheshwor Ghimire
Mr. Girija Gorkhaly
Mr. Purna Singh Khadka
Mr. Keshav Adhikari
Security Guard 1 (w/ DIG)
Mr. Basant Pant
Mr. Narottam Lal Pradhan
Mr. Prem Joshi
Security Guard 2 (w/ DIG)
Takuya Kamata
Mr. Farhad Ahmed
Er. Deepak Man Singh Shrestha
Mr. Kenichi Yokoyoma
Dr. Tika Limbu
Er. Naresh Pradhan
Mr. Hiroyuki Fushimi
Er. Suman Baidhya
Mr. Sushil Gyawali
Mr. Kanak Mani Dixit
Mr. Narayan Wagley
Mr. Lambodar Neupane
Dr. Ram Ratna Upadhaya
Prof. Shova Kanta Dev
Dr. Thusitha Shahi
Dr. Bhakta Ale
Dr. Vishwa Khanal
Er. Anil Marasini
Er. Ramesh Pokharel
Dr. Jagat Shrestha

81

Mr. Bhusan Tuladhar

82
83
84
85

Er. Satya Narayan Shah or


Er. Binod Neupane
Mr. Dinesh Bhandari

Organizations / Firms

Designation

DoTM
DoTM
DoTM
DoTM
DoTM
DoTM
RBN
RBN
DoLIDAR
DoLIDAR
DoLIDAR
DUDBC
Traffic Police Directorate
MTPD

Mechanical Enginer
Section Officer
Section Officer
Section Officer
Section Officer
Project Assistant
Technical Director
ED
DG
SDE
SDE
Project Coordinator
DIG
DIG

MTPD
Nepal Police Headquarter
Traffic Police Directorate

SP
SP
Inspector

WB
WB
WB
ADB
ADB
ADB
JICA
DFID
TDF
Sajha Yatayat/ Media
Media
nec
nec
nec
nec
IoE
IoE
IoE
IoE
IoE

Country Director
Sr. Transport Specialist
Sr. Transport Specialist
Country Director
Portfolio Manager
Programme Officer, Transport
Senior Adviser
Infrastructure Adviser
Chief Executive Officer
President
Journalist
Chairman
Academic Director
Principal
Associate Professor
Professor /CARD
Head, Dept of Civil Engg
Transport M Sc Program/IoE
Lecturer, Transport/ IOE
Lecturer Transport / IOE

UN-Habitat

Regional Tech. Advisor, South Asia

NEC/
NEC/TDF
FNNTE
FNTTE
FNTTE

Chairman or
Binod Neupane
President
Vice President
General Secretary

86

Mr. Shekhar Golchha

NADA

President

87
88
89
90
91
92

Mr. Bigyan Sharma


Mr. Rameshwore Khanal
Er. Kamal Pande
Mr. Rajendra Khanal
Mr. Saroj Khanal
Er. Sanjaya Upadhyaya

RSSN
RSSN
RSSN
IUCN
RSSN
KMC

Vice President
Executive Member
Executive Member
Adviser.RSSN
Secretary
Senior Engineer

93

Er. Rudra Gautam

LSMC

Senior Engineer

94
95

Er. Bimal Rijal


Mr. Kiran Shilpakar

KMC
NAPD- Nepal

Senior Planner

Phone / Fax No.

Cell No.

Email address

bhattaraim58@yahoo.com
swarbb@gmail.com
karnats@gmail.com

5526620
4200099

9851055590
9851128462
9851045085
9841206537
9849732828

sagargnawali@yahoo.com

gbb4799@yahoo.com

Morning
Session
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y

gp.gorkhaly@gmail.com
9851069393
98510393393

keshavad50@yahoo.com

9841260460

bpant747@gmail.com

9849626098
9841328050

tkamata@worldbank.org
fahmed8@worldbank.org
dshrestha@worldbank.org

Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y

kyokoyoma@adb.org
9801087201
9851060463
9843148933

tlimbu@adb.org
npradhan@adb.org
fushimi@hcn.zaq.ne.jp

4471227
5552141

9843130360
9851053209

tdf@tdf.org.np

5090744
5000213
5090744

9818645412
9851070796
9849249501
9741030778
9841227274

neccps@nec.edu.np

9851013963
9851167114

tc_shahi@yahoo.com

bhaktaale@hotmail.com
anilmarsani@ioe.edu.np

Y
Y

9851017819

bhushan.tuladhar@unhabitat.org.np

Afternoon
Session

Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y

9851042727
9851016202

Y
Y
Y

9851020682

shekhar@golchha.com;
shekhar@gmail.com

9840051295
9851055999
4476054

9841311166
9851059214
9841453055
9851062110
9851100993

Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y

napdnepal@gmail.com

Y
Y

S. No.

Name of the Participants

Organizations / Firms

Designation

Phone / Fax No.

Cell No.

subhash_dhungel@yahoo.com

96
97

Er. Subhash Dhungel


Er. Laxman KC

Transport and Traffic Consultant


Transport and Traffic Consultant

98

Er. Dhruba Regmi

Transport and Traffic Consultant

5524077

9851081222

drregmi@wlink.com.np
pmcbcksut@gmail.com

99

Er. Fredrick Gustafsson

Consultant ADB Regional TA Project

4495045

9808283461

f.fredricgustafsson@gmail.com

100

Mahesh Raj Timilsina

Coordinator, NIRTTP

101

Er. Sunil Poudyal

MOCS NIRTTP NITB

Technical Advisor

102
103
104

Er. Bindu S. Rana


Er. Rod Stickland
Dr. Kamal Rijal

JICA

JICA Expert- SRMU


Transport and Traffic Consultant

105

Er. Soorya Acharya

106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114

Mr. Niranjan Shrestha


Dr. Deepak Bhattarai
Er. Madan Maleku
Dr. Chandra Shrestha
Mr. Naresh Shrestha
Er. Santosh Gupta
Mr. Saujanya Shrestha
Dr. Kali Nepal
Dr. Partha Parajuli

115

Office incharge
Ram Dutta Bhatta

DoTM

116

Office incharge
Basanta Adhikari

DoTM

117

Office incharge

DoTM

118

Office incharge
Narayan Subedi

DoTM

119

Office incharge
Mukti Ram Aryal

DoTM

SweRoads

9851074844
9851091057

Email address

Afternoon
Session

Y
Y

Y
Y

Y
Y

Y
9741042709
4462008

Transport and Traffic Consultant


Environmental Service Nepal
nec/ NTDRC
NTDRC
NTDRC
NTDRC
NTDRC
NTDRC
Deakin University
QDTMR

Morning
Session

Chief Environmental Officer


EC member/NTDRC
EC member/NTDRC
EC member/NTDRC
Member/NTDRC
Member/NTDRC
Member/NTDRC
Senior Lecturer
Principal Engineer

Bagmati Zonal Transport


Management
Office, License
Bagmati Zonal Transport
Management
Office, Motorcycle
Bagmati Zonal Transport
Management
Office, Sanathula
Bagmati Zonal Transport
Management
Office, Service Center,
Sallaghari
Bagmati Zonal Transport
Management
Office, Service Center,
Sanobharayang

5011255
4413089

9851048647
9851012717
9851038656
9851182028
9801038279
9851072623
9851021544
9741076807
9841298970
9841397885
9851122793
9849193295
9818635070
9818635071

emailpoudyal@gmail.com
herzlichst@gmail.com
Bindurana2011@gmail.com

Y
Y
Y
Y

rjstickland@gmail.com

Y
info@esn.com.np
deepakbhattarai51@gmail.com
madanmaleku@gmail.com
c-sherstha@ntdrc.org
snaresh129@gmail.com
skmgupta@yahoo.com
s-shrestha@ntdrc.org
kpnepal@hotmail.com
pmparajuli@gmail.com

Y
Y

Y
Y

5001793

tmo.lc@dotm.gov.np

5547037

tmo.mc@dotm.gov.np

Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y

6619564

4272325

Y
70

102

APPENDIX 7: Workshop Participants

APPENDIX 8: Sample Funding Proposal


Funding Proposal for undertaking
Stakeholder's Workshop
on

The Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal


(A comprehensive approach for developing Road Safety Management System)

Number of Persons Involved in Road Crashes in Nepal


16000
Slight Injuries

14000

Serious Injuries

12000

8000

1734

1689

1837

1816

2009/10

2010/11

2011/12

2012/13

3986

1356

2008/09

4018

1131 2663

2007/08

4701

735 2583

2006/07

4130

815 1866

2005/06

3609

3655

685 1795

2004/05

4039

654 1659

2003/04

3925

4442
623 785

2002/03

458 4138
603

2001/02

2000

5331

6000

5245

8000

4000

7813

6457

7383

10000

8503

Fatalities

Submitted to:

Ministry of Physical Infrastructure and Transport, Kathmandu,


Nepal
Submitted by:
A Team of International Road Safety Specialists
in collaboration with
Nepal Transportation and Development Research Centre Kathmandu Nepal

Preamble
This proposal is prepared in order to seek partial funding support from the Ministry of Physical Infrastructure
and Transport (MoPIT) to conduct an interactive workshop on the development of Road Safety Management
System in Nepal. Preliminary consultations were held between the members of the organising committee and
selected Government officials towards the preparation of the workshop. Officials from funding agencies
such as World Bank and Asian Development Bank have also been consulted and support has been received
for conducting workshop from agencies such as Asian Development Bank, Department of Transport
Management (DoTM) and Department of Roads (DoR). Willingness to work together for organising the
workshop has also been received from non-governmental organisations such as Nepal Engineering College
(nec) and Road Safety Society of Nepal (RSSN).

Road Safety Management System in Nepal


In Nepal, every day on average 5 persons are killed 11 are seriously injured and 22 sustain minor injury in
about 25 road crashes. Until recently, in spite of repeated alarms raised by several sectors of society, a
reduction in road trauma has not been a key national objective. Road safety has not been considered as a
major strategic component of Nepals road sector development programme. Interest in the road safety
epidemic has however increased significantly during the last few years in accord with the UN Decade of
Action for Road Safety 2011-2020. A National Road Safety Council (NRSC) has been recently established
and actions are being taken on several fronts, albeit on isolated and fragmented ways.
Road Safety Management is a complex, integrated, dynamic and multi-dimensional problem. Improvement
in road safety requires actions on several fronts: engineering and social science, education and public
awareness, law and enforcement, health and emergency services, and media and publicity campaigns, to
name just a few. Actions on multiple fronts are required in a complex environment often with conflicting and
competing interests. A well coordinated and concerted effort from all agencies working on these fronts is
essential. This is possible only by implementing a holistic Road Safety Management System with vision.
Road safety is a shared responsibility. Every member of society can contribute to improve road safety.
This collaborative proposal is developed for widespread discussion and application for possible contributions
to help develop this holistic Road Safety Management System in Nepal. A Safe System approach, which
makes allowance for human error and minimises the consequences, especially the risk of death and serious
injury, has been accepted internationally as an approach to manage road safety. This proposal is developed
making this approach a core principle.
All stakeholders, who have interests in road safety in Nepal, can be part of this initiative and their
involvement will always be welcome. Contributions will be requested from national and international
institutions, and bilateral and multilateral funding agencies in order to initiate, conduct and complete the road
safety project activities identified in this proposal. It is expected that a full-scale Road Safety Management
System will be institutionalised, implemented and sustained once these project activities are completed.
This proposal covers a wide range of issues related to road safety. After the review of existing information
and international best practices, it is proposed to develop the system with the following six components:
Component 1 Governance& Planning: Institutional, funding, legal and technical frameworks; road safety
evaluation and improvement process and road safety strategies
Component 2 Database System: Road safety database system- population, vehicle, drivers, traffic and roads
Component 3 Pre-crash System: Crash prevention system- road users, speed, vehicles, roads
o Safer Road Users: Road use rules, driver licensing system, public awareness and education campaigns, law
enforcement
o Safer Speeds: Speed limits and speed management system
o Safer Vehicles: Road worthiness- national car assessment program (NCAP), vehicle standards compliance,
vehicle inspection and maintenance system
o Safer Roads: Road design and maintenance, traffic control devices, road safety audit, roadside hazard
management

Component 4 Post-crash System: Post-crash management system such as emergency response and treatments
Component 5 Crash Investigation System: Road crash investigation, data collection, coding, recording and
creation of road crash database system
Component 6 Research and Development: Road safety research, crash data analysis and countermeasures

These components will be finalised in consultation with the relevant stakeholders. A list of projects under
each component is provided at the end of this brochure to demonstrate the extent and nature of works we
envisage.
It is considered that the current road safety activities in Nepal do not capture all these components. The first
step of this comprehensive approach is to bring together all these components into one management system
taking into account both national and international practices, supported by scientific research. The best
practices around the world will be used as far as possible. However, site and context-specific information
must also be collected, analysed and utilised.
A number of specific projects that help develop a comprehensive Road Safety Management System in Nepal
have been identified. These projects will be discussed and more will be identified as a result of the workshop
discussions and deliberations. Each project will be scoped, costed and project submitted to interested
agencies for funding. This will be done after the completion of the workshop, taking into account the
feedbacks collected from the workshop participants.
The development of Road Safety Management System has the key objective of bringing all these efforts into
one single holistic system management framework and moving these efforts forward in order to reduce road
deaths in Nepal. The proposed workshop aims to discuss the various components of the system and the
action plan for its development and implementation.

Approach for developing Road Safety Management System


The system will be developed in stages. It is essentially a building block approach involving several
activities. Each component of the system can be developed concurrently and mostly independently. When all
the sub-systems or components are delivered a full-scale safety management system will eventually be
established. For example, the crash database system needed for safety management will have to be developed
in the first stage. This system uses data collected from the crash investigation system which would contain
data from crashes duly coded using an acceptable crash coding system by severity and by type. Crash data
obtained from a well maintained central crash database system will then be used to identify black spots and
corresponding types of treatment. Targeted road safety initiatives can then be suggested to reduce road
crashes on that particular location.
Five year crash data are generally used internationally to identify black spots in a formal sense. The
development of the crash database system will be a one-off project with periodic improvement but
populating the database with data is an ongoing implementation activity for the Road Safety Management
System.
The above is an example of one component/sub-system. Each sub-system or component will be developed
with the same approach. We have a long-term vision for the system. A prerequisite to realise this vision and
deliver the system is a robust institutional, legal, funding and technical framework. This is proposed as a part
of governance component. This framework needs to be developed in tandem in order to sustain the above
system and sub-systems.

Introduction to the Team


We are a team of people spread around the world having desire to contribute something to the community to
which we belong. Having developed expertise in varied sectors (mainly in traffic, transport and allied fields)
nationally and internationally, we know the problems, peoples and places on both sides of the world and we
are able to see clearly prospects for solutions. We are aware that what works overseas might not work in
Nepal. Also, what is required in Nepal may not be available overseas. But when we blend the basic
principles and policies required for solutions available overseas with the real needs and environment in
Nepal, the inefficiencies in reinventing an entirely new wheel for developing potential solutions for problems
dominating the country can be significantly reduced. One of the potential problems, which has been well
3

recognised nationally and globally, is how to reduce the burden of road crashes on public health and
resulting negative impacts on Nepals economy.
Thousands of people are getting killed in Nepal for no fault of their own. With the expansion of road
network and increase in the number of vehicles across the country, the problem of road safety has been
clearly felt by everyone concerned. Roads built for the sake of national development using the scarce aid
resources from around the world are becoming death traps. The dangers and potential risks can be removed
or reduced by applying simple but sustainable solutions. We are a team of like-minded people, who have the
similar feelings and common interests to contribute to develop such solutions. The team moves forward with
the vision that no one should be killed or seriously injured on the roads in Nepal. The team aims to work
together with National Road Safety Council (NRSC) which advises solutions to the Government of Nepal. It
will collaborate with all relevant government and non-government agencies as well as multilateral and
bilateral aid agencies, overseas and local road safety research agencies, local and international businesses
and industries who have a stake in road safety.
The following members have expressed their interest to work as a team and contribute to this work at the
time of developing this concept proposal. The team can be expanded as and when more interest to contribute
is received. In fact, contributions are open to everyone. Each team member identified below is expected to
lead a key strategy area for potential solutions. Over time, more professionals can be included in the project
team attached to one or more of the relevant components. This is a loose and flexible association of
individual professionals, who are bound together with the desire to collaborate and deliver meaningful
outcomes, which will help to reduce road trauma and the burden on the public health system and economy of
Nepal. Key team members include:

Dr. Kali Prasad Nepal (Australia)


Dr. Partha Parajuli (Australia)
Dr. Chandra Shrestha (Nepal)
Dr. Prem Chhetri (Australia)
Dr. Prakash Ranjitkar (New Zealand)
Dr. Nirajan Shiwakoti (Australia)
Dr. Shyam Sharma (USA)
Dr. Ganesh Karkee (USA)
Dr. Shovakar Dhakal (Thailand)

Local support is expected to be provided by NTDRC, Nepal.

Program of the Workshop


A half day workshop has been scheduled jointly by National Road Safety Council (NRSC), MoPIT and
NTDRC in the second half of Friday October 31, 2014. This workshop is planned to follow another related
workshop being scheduled by DoTM in the first half on the Development of Road Crash Information
Management System, which represents one of the six components of Road Safety Management System
described above.
While the actual program of the work will be determined after receiving confirmation from the proposed
chief guest and other dignitaries, the indicative program of the workshop is planned to be as follows:

Workshop Chair: Mr Tulasi Sitaula, Secretary, MoPIT


Welcome: Madan Maleku/ NTDRC
Workshop Facilitator: Dr. Deepak Bhattarai/NTDRC
Pre-workshop Lunch
Workshop Sessions:
o Presentation of Proposal
o Open for Discussion
o Addresses by Guests
o Concluding Remarks by the Chair
Reception/ Dinner (TBA)

Cost Proposal for Workshop


The workshop is estimated to cost NRs 660,000 (See Table 1). The cost of the morning session will be
primarily borne by DoTM and partial funding for the afternoon session is expected to be received also from
a number of agencies such as DoR and nec. Words of commitment have also been received from ADB for
partial funding.
Table 1: Cost Estimate
S. No.

Particulars

Amount

1.

Workshop materials preparation (workshop brochure design/ printing, program NRs. 30,000
printing etc.)

2.

Venue rental for the workshop with 65 participants of the morning session

NRs. 65,000

Tea/ Coffee (two serving)

NRs. 50,000

4.

Venue rental for the workshop with 100 participants of the afternoon session

NRs. 200,000

5.

Closing reception and/or dinner

NRs.180,000

6.

Workshop logistics (PA system, mike, overhead projector rental and pens, NRs. 75,000
notepads for participants)

Sub-total
7.

NRs. 600,000
Contingency 10%

NRs. 60,000

Total Estimated Cost

NRs. 660,000

11/3/2014
APPENDIX 9: Opening Session

Our stakeholders and partners..

House Keeping Matters

Workshop Programme

Location of toilets
Lunch and coffee/tea arrangements
Evacuation procedure
Mobile phones
Parking irrelevant issues

Workshop on the Development


of
Nepal Road Safety Management System

Introducing the Proposal


Dr. Partha Parajuli MIEAust CPEng RPEQ

M Sc Civil Engg (Highways) (Former USSR) Ph D (Transportation) (Canada)


MITE (USA) MIRC MIUT FIE CEng (India)

Principal Engineer Department of Transport and Main Roads Queensland

Visiting Professor and Honorary Queensland Representative, Nepal Engineering College Pokhara University and
Kathmandu Engineering College, Tribhuvan University Nepal
Formerly Associate Professor Institute of Engineering Tribhuvan University Kathmandu Nepal Executive Director
TAEC Consult Pvt. Ltd Kathmandu Nepal

Enough is Enough It is time to act to-day, now

Enough is Enough.How traumatic it is?

Enough is Enough.mpg

11/3/2014

Type of Crashes: Fatal Five Cs

Contributing Factors: Fatal Five Ds


In Australia 5Ds
Driving over the speed
limit
Driving under the
influence
Driving unbuckled
Driving detracted
Driving tired

In Nepal (3 Os?):
Over-speeding
Over-taking
Over-loading

Crash - Run off Road (ROR)


Crash - Head on (HO)
Crash - Intersection related (IR)
Crash - Pedestrian Hit (PH)
Crash - Mid-Block Rear End
KSI Crashes in Queensland-2001-2010

What about others?

Others
17%

Intersection
39%

Intersection
MBRE
HO
ROR

ROR
30%

How confident are we to say so?

Others

HO
6%

Fatal Five Types of Crashes Closer Look

MBRE
8%

Safe System Approach of managing Road Safety

Safer Users
Do we blame these users or bus
operators?

KSI Intersection Crashes by DCA Codes-Queensland

KSI Intersection Crashes -DCA Codes Vs Speed-Queensland


5000

3500

4500

Safer Roads

3000
4000

0 - 50 km/h
60 km/h

2000

70 km/h
1500

80 - 90 km/h
100 - 110 km/h

1000

Number of Crashes

No of Crashes

2500

3500
3000

Do we blame road asset owners


or drivers not driving to road conditions?

2500
2000
1500
1000

500
500

0
DCA Codes

904

808

804

800

705

701

608

601

504

500

404

309

305

301

204

200

106

102

008

202

004

104

000

101

DCA Codes

202: Vehicles from opposite direction (Thru-Right)


101: Vehicles from adjacent approaches (Thru-Thru)
104: Vehicles from adjacent approaches (Thru-Right)

A Blame Game
Our commitments
Let us stop playing this blame game

Drivers fault?
Bus operators fault?
Road owners fault?
Enforcement agencies fault?
Pedestrians fault?
List goes on and on..

Let us accept responsibility for road carnages


It is a fault in the System Road Safety
Management System - We should fix this system

Safer Vehicles
Do we blame manufactures?

Safer Speed
Do we blame drivers for speeding or enforcing
agencies or road operators?

Safe System Principles

Crash or accidents?
No blame game
People can make mistakes
Forgiving roadside environments
No one should get killed or
seriously injured because of their mistakes

Road Safety is a shared responsibility

11/3/2014

It is doable...

It is doable

Road Safety Management Systems Components

Where to from here..?

APPENDIX 10: Technical Session


Workshop on the Development of Nepal Road Safety Management System

Technical Session

Setting the Scene and Recent Works on Road Safety Education and Awareness

Presenter

Saroj Pradhan
Executive Secretary
Road Safety Society Nepal

Road Safety Problem in Nepal

Road Safety in Nepal

Development of Road Safety Management System

Crash risk is the product of exposure, probability and severity

Kali Prasad Nepal, Ph.D., MIEAust


(Senior Lecturer in Traffic and Transportation Engineering)

(Road safety news from Nepalese online Newspapers during Dashain)


Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Road Safety Problem in Nepal

Road Safety Problem in Nepal

Limited available data shows that, over the last three years since 2010/11, approximately 5
people were killed, 11 people were seriously injured and 22 people were slightly injured in
about 25 road crashes every day on Nepalese roads (1:2:4:5 ratios)

(Road safety news from Nepalese online Newspapers during Dashain)


Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

Topics for Presentation/Interaction

What This Presentation is About


What external road safety professionals (academics and
practitioners) see about road safety in Nepal

What this presentation is about


Who we are and what we are proposing

Renewed interests in line with UN Decade of Action for Road Safety 2011-2020

Presentation/discussion sequence:

National Road Safety Council (NRSC)

Overview of road safety situation in Nepal

Actions (for example, World Banks $7.863 million for Nepal Road Safety

Support Project) are being taken on several fronts

Development of road safety database system

There may be several other works/studies in Nepal we do not know about

Development of institutional/funding/legal/technical frameworks

Preliminary proposal for Road Safety Management in Nepal:

Development of crash prevention system (safer traffic components)


Development of post-crash management system

Discussions and improvements

Development of crash investigation system

Possible contributions

We are expecting contributions from all stakeholders

Nepal road safety research and development (R&D)

Levels of Nepal government (MoF, DoTM, DoR, DoLIDAR, Traffic Police, Road

Development of road safety evaluation and improvement process

Boards Nepal, MoF, NPC etc.)

Development of Nepal road safety strategies

National/International non-governmental organisations (United Nations,

World Bank, ADB, JICA etc.)

Others (civil society, local road safety consultants etc.)


Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

What This Presentation is About

What This Presentation is About


Component 1: Governance & planning

As this proposal covers a wide range of issues on road safety:


It is not expected that all items in this proposal can be completed

within a foreseeable future (0-5 years). Rather, it will provide


direction and help build the system step-by-step

Institutional, funding, legal and technical frameworks

Road safety evaluation and improvement process

Road safety strategies

Component 2: Road safety database system

While some low-cost high-benefit project activities will be initiated

soon after the finalisation of this proposal, the establishment of full


scale RSMS can be materialised only in the medium (5 to 10 years)
to long-term (>10 years) horizon

Population, vehicle, drivers, traffic, roads and crashes

Component 3: Pre-crash (crash prevention) systems

Potential projects are listed (grouped into 6 components):


these projects are neither sequential nor complete
the details of these projects (including benefits and costs) are not

Safer road users: road use rules, driver licensing system, public awareness and
education campaigns, law enforcement

Safer speeds: speed limits and speed management system

Safer vehicles: crashworthiness/roadworthiness (vehicle inspection and maintenance)

Safer roads: road design and maintenance, traffic control devices, road safety audit,
roadside hazard management

Component 4: Post-crash (management) system

presented (will be expanded as and when required)

It is believed that:

Emergency response and treatments

Component 5: Crash investigation system

the current road safety activities in Nepal do not capture all these

Dr KP Nepal

Road crash investigation, data collection, coding and recording

Component 6: Road safety research and development

components (again, we are not completely sure of)

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

Crash data analysis and countermeasure development

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

What This Presentation is About


We purpose two ways to tackle road safety problem in Nepal

We are a team of professionals spread around the world: want to


contribute to the community we belong

1. Develop the basic road safety foundations aiming at longer term

Develop databases

Develop institutional/technical/legal/funding frameworks

Conduct road safety research

We have developed expertise in varied sectors (mainly in traffic,


transport and allied field) overseas: we think we know problems/
solutions
We are aware that what works overseas might not work in Nepal
and what is required in Nepal may not be available overseas

2. Based on available information, start solving the problems

Start implementing behavioral control measures

Start focusing on vehicle roadworthiness system

Start applying known road safety measures e.g., crash


barriers, centre-lane treatments, delineations

We are not interested to reinvent a new wheel, we want to


transfer what we know and apply in Nepalese context with some
modifications
We believe current Nepalese road traffic system- the death trapneed simple but sustainable solutions

We do not propose to reinvent the wheel, rather:


1. utilise best international practices available

We aim to work closely with Nepalese Road Safety Authorities


and Stakeholders (including interested international bodies)

2. conduct research only for the local validity and modifications

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Who We Are

Dr KP Nepal

Team Structure/Responsibilities (Preliminary)


Project
Coordinator

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

10

Who We Are: Additional Notes


The team can be expanded as and when more interests for
contributions are received

Dr P Parajuli

Local Support
(NTDRC)

In fact, the contribution is open to anyone interested

Deputy Project Coordinator


(Governance)

Deputy Project Coordinator


(Technical)

Governance &
Planning

Database
System

Dr P Parajuli & Dr C
Shrestha

Dr P Chhetri

Over time, more professionals can be included as associates

Dr. K Nepal

Dr C Shrestha

Pre-Crash
Systems

Post-Crash
Management
System
Dr S Sharma

Crash
Investigation
System

Research &
Development

Dr P Parajuli

Dr K Nepal

Safer Road Users


Dr N Shiwakoti

Dr. Kali Prasad Nepal (Senior Lecturer, Deakin University, Australia)


Safer Vehicles
Dr S Dhakal

Dr. Partha Parajuli (Principal Engineer, Queensland Department of Transport &


Main Roads, Australia)
Dr. Chandra Shrestha (Professor, Nepal Engineering College, Nepal)

Safer Roads
Dr G Karkee

Dr. Prem Chhetri (Professor, RMIT University, Australia)


Dr. Prakash Ranjitkar (Senior Lecturer, University of Auckland, New Zealand)

Safer Speeds
Dr. P Ranjitkar

Dr. Nirajan Shiwakoti (Senior Lecturer, RMIT University, Australia)

This is a loose and flexible association of professional


individuals, who are bound together with the desire to
collaborate to deliver meaningful outcomes, which will help to
reduce road trauma and burden on public health system
We are planning to register as an independent business entity
(separate to our current affiliations) to authenticate our
activities

Dr. Shyam Sharma (Region Traffic Engineering Manager, Oregon Department of


Transportation, USA)
Dr. Ganesh Karkee (Sr. Operations Engineer, Metropolitan Transportation
Commission, USA)
Dr. Shovakar Dhakal (Associate Professor, Asian Institute of Technology,
Thailand)

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

11

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

12

1. Road Safety Situation in Nepal


Until now, the reduction in road trauma has not been a key national
objective and road safety has not been considered as a major strategic
area in Nepal
Interests have, however, increased significantly during the last few years in
line with the UN Decade of Action for Road Safety 2011-2020

Nepal Road Safety Divisions (N-RSD)


The challenges posed
by road safety are
different for different
regions or for different
types of roads of
Nepal
Are the administrative
boundaries (or
SRN/LRN
responsibility) enough
for road safety
management
system?
Should we develop
separate Nepal road
safety divisions (NRSD) specifically for
road safety in Nepal?

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

13

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

14

Population Database

Nepal Road Safety Divisions (N-RSD): Example

(Source: CBS, 2011)


(Source: Queensland
Department of Transport
and Main Roads)

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

15

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

16

Population Database

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

17

Expansion of Road Network in Nepal

Expansion of Road Network in Nepal

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

18

Transportation Network in Nepal

(Source: CBS, 2011)


Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

19

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

20

Road Inventory and Traffic Stream Database

Vehicle Registrations and Annual Changes

There is no system of recording the aging vehicles which are


phased out or scrapped (Government of Nepal, 2013)
Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

21

Vehicle Registrations and Annual Changes

There has been high growth-rate for motorcycles and light


vehicles (car/jeep) in recent years
Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

22

Vehicle Registrations and Annual Changes

Motorcycles growth rate is consistently higher than other modes


23

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

24

Vehicle Registration

Motorcycles are nearly 80% of registered vehicle


population
Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

Vehicle Registration/Ownership

Vehicle ownership (total registered vehicles) is very low


25

Vehicle/Driver Registration

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

26

Vehicle Registration/Ownership & Driver Licences

Motor Vehicles and Transport Management Act, 2049 (1993)


Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

27

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

28

Nepal Road Crash Statistics

Nepal Road Crash Statistics

There seems to
be confusion
across different
data sources
regarding:
the number of

accidents

number of

vehicles
involved

number of

people
involved

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

29

Nepal Road Crash Statistics

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

31

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

30

Nepal Road Crash Statistics

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

32

Nepal Road Crash Statistics

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

33

Road Crash Statistics: Australian Example

Nepal Road Crash Statistics

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

34

Nepal Road Crash Statistics

24.2 deaths per 100,000 people

6.8 deaths per 100,000 people

Source: National Road Safety Strategy 2011-2020, Australia


Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

35

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

36

Nepal Road Crash Statistics

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

37

Monitoring Road Safety Progress: Comparisons

Nepal Road Crash Database for Public Use

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

38

Monitoring Road Safety Progress: Australian


Example

In order to evaluate the road safety situation, it is important to


compare the road safety statistics with other countries (highincome, middle-income and low-income economies)

(Source: National Road Safety


Strategy 2011-2020, Australia)

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

39

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

40

Privatisation?
To explore options to strengthen Nepal Road Safety Information
Management System

Institutional Framework
Who are involved in
managing road safety in
Nepal now? (National
Road Safety Council?)
Department of Roads

(DoR) for Strategic Road


Network (SRN)

DoLIDAR for Local Road

Network (LRN)

Roads Board Nepal (note:

does not specify


categories of roads)

Department of Transport

Management
(database?)

Traffic Police (law

enforcement)

Others?
Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

41

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

42

Funding Framework:

Funding Framework

Financing Road Safety (Global Road


Safety Partnership)

What is the current funding


model?
What is the best funding
model for Nepal?

National/local government support (taxpayers)

Fees for selected road safety services/traffic fines

Safety funds (e.g., New Zealand)

Can we have sufficient


funding?

Levies on licences and insurance premiums

Private sector contributions

Community involvement

Financing Road Safety (Global


Road Safety Partnership)

National and local government


support

Fees for selected road safety


services and traffic fines

Safety funds (e.g., New Zealand)

Levies on licences and insurance


premiums

Private sector contributions

Community involvement

New Zealand Example

Funding sources for Low Income Countries

Source: gtz (2006) The Road Safety Cent


Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

43

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

44

Legal Framework
What are existing legal
documents related to
road safety in Nepal?

Technical Framework
What are existing
technical documents
related to road safety
in Nepal?

Who is responsible for


developing Acts,
Rules, Regulations and
Guidelines?

Who is responsible for


developing and
maintaining these
documents?

How are these


documents legalised?

How can we make


sure the consistency
across different
documents
developed by
different
organisations?

What are the


mechanisms for
amendments?
How can we make
sure the consistency
across different
documents?

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

45

Crash Prevention System: Nepal Road Rules

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

46

Crash Prevention System: Nepal Road Rules

Road Users Guide ( ) is available


This guide needs to be revised and updated (make it free and easy!)

Source: from Subash (2014)

Source: Pradhan (2011)

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

47

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

48

Crash Prevention System: Graduated Licencing System


Existing licencing system

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Crash Prevention System: Graduated Licencing System


Existing licencing system needs to be reviewed, revised & updated

Dr KP Nepal

49

Crash Prevention System: Public Awareness &


Education

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

50

Crash Prevention System: Law Enforcement


Motor Vehicles and Transport Management Act, 2049 (1993)

Source: Poudyal (2013)

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

51

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

52

Crash Prevention System: Law Enforcement

Crash Prevention System: Speed Management

Enforcement of the laws and regulations is also essential for


behavioural change of road users

Design speeds information along SRN available


Operating speeds by vehicle type is also available

A rigorous system to enforce road traffic laws required

There is no comprehensive speed signage and speed


management system

Note: Traffic fine should be set to a deterrent level


(can we introduce variable fines system for Nepal?)
Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Source: ekantipur.com

Dr KP Nepal

53

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

54

Crash Prevention System: Vehicle Inspection &


Maintenance

Crash Prevention System: Speed Management

Vehicle factor contributes to crashes due to unsafe vehicles, worn tyres &
brakes (about 5-15%). Initial and periodic vehicle inspections help to
reduce road crashes. These inspections include:

Roadworthiness: development of vehicular safety checking and rating system


(brakes, lights, tires, crash avoidance systems: ESC, ABS, alerting systems)

Mass, size and other safety compliances e.g., licence to carry passengersetc.

Source: ekantipur.com

Source: Metropolitan Traffic Police Division


55
Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal
Dr KP Nepal

Source: Metropolitan Traffic


Police Division
Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

56

Crash Prevention System: Vehicle Inspection &


Maintenance

Crash Prevention System: Vehicle Inspection &


Maintenance

Motor Vehicles and Transport Management


Act, 2049 (1993)

Source: from Subash (2014)


Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

57

Crash Prevention System: Road Design and


Maintenance Standards

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

58

Crash Prevention System: Road Design and


Maintenance Standards

Road factor contributes to crashes due to poor delineation, unsafe and


substandard road geometry (steep downgrade, severe curves), poor
pavement surface condition (polished aggregate, wet pavement) and
visibility (poor sight distance, lighting conditions) (about 25-35%):

Source: Photos of Nepal (online)


Source: from Subash (2014)

Source: Poudyal (2013)


Source: Decoded Stuff (online)
Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

59

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Source: Creation Umesh (online)


60
Dr KP Nepal

Crash prevention System: Traffic Control Devices

Crash prevention System: Traffic Control Devices

Traffic Signs Manual (1997) was prepared and approved in 1997

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

61

Crash prevention System: Traffic Control Devices

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

62

Crash prevention System: Road Safety Audit


Road Safety Audit Manual was published in April 1997
How is this manual used?

Safety at Road Construction Zones

Source: Photos of Nepal (online)

Source: Indiana DOT (online)


Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

63

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

64

Crash Prevention System: Roadside Hazard


Management

Crash Prevention System: Roadside Hazard


Management

A particular type of crashes can be reduced by managing roadside


hazards (for example, run of the road crashes)
Access control, delineation measures, roadside safety barriers are
some of the measures that help reduce the road crashes

Source: from Subash (2014)

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Source: Austroads (2008)


65
Dr KP Nepal

Post-Crash Management System

Source: Austroads (2008)


Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

66

Post-Crash Management System

The objective of developing post-crash management system is to reduce


the damage or injury through improved emergency management, to
treat injuries and save lives
It can be done by formulating robust post-crash management system
The system should use advanced technologies and healthcare system

(Source: Queensland Department of Transport


and Main Roads)

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

67

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

68

Nepal Road Crash Investigation and Recording


System

Nepal Road Crash Investigation and Recording


System

Existing System (both in English & Nepali)

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

69

Nepal Road Crash Investigation and Recording


System

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

70

Nepal Road Crash Database System


Investigation of crash data
requires a centralised,
verified, detailed and
audited crash data
Currently, Traffic Police keep
the hardcopy database (not
easily accessible from
general public)
It is important to make these
verified database public

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

71

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

72

Nepal Road Crash Database System

Nepal Road Safety Research and Development


Road safety research is a
must for all aspects of road
safety
Decision concerning the
road safety measures
need to be based on
information about:
the number of accidents
when and where accident

occurred

the road user groups that are

involved

the factors that contribute to

accidents and

the measures that can be

Use of Crash Database for Road Safety Program


Development: Example from Queensland, Australia

taken to reduce the number


of accidents or injury
severities

Information should be based


on scientific research
Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

73

Nepal Road Safety Countermeasures

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

74

Nepal Road Safety Countermeasures

In order to
develop Nepal
road safety
countermeasur
es, the all
contributing
factors (the
human factor,
vehicle and
road
environment)
should be
taken into
account

Treatment of crash location


Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

75

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

76

Road Safety Evaluation and Improvement Process


Network
A comprehensive
Screening
road safety
improvement and
evaluation process
should be
Safety Effectiveness
established in order
Evaluation
to tackle existing
site specific road
safety issues in a
Project
systematic way

References:

Prioritisation

Road Safety Evaluation and Improvement Process

Problem
Diagnosis

Source: ND LEA Inc. (2008)

Select
Countermeasures

Highway Safety

Manual (2010)

Source: BITRE, Australia (2009)

Economic
Appraisal

Guide to Road

Safety (2009)

An Australian human life is


valued 500 times a Nepalese life!

Highway Safety Manual (2010)


Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

77

Road Safety Evaluation and Improvement Process

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

78

Nepal Road Safety Strategy and Evaluation


Guides the efforts to reduce road deaths and injuries
Should be
scientifically modelled,
continually revised
closely monitored, and
objectively evaluated

Four terminologies
Vision: desired direction of future road safety
target or mission: an outcome expressed in quantitative terms
strategy: a coordinated set of actions (plans) designed to achieve

a specific result or set of results in a specified period

(action) plan: an expression of the strategy over a shorter period

Government of Nepal (2013)

Queensland Example: Performance Evaluation

Nepal Road Safety Action Plan 2013-2020


Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

79

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

80

Nepal Road Safety Strategy and Evaluation

Mission

Nepal Road Safety Action Plan 20132020

International
Examples

Safe road-infrastructures and services backed


with effective post-crash response and conducive
environment resulting in little or no casualties from
the road crashes

no person should be
killed or seriously
injured on Australias
roads Australia

National Road Safety Strategy, Australia

avoiding an increase in
road fatalities- Norway
sustainable safetyThe Netherlands
vision zero- Sweden
Targets/
Missions

i. To mitigate the loss of life, properties and


economic loss from road crashes
ii. To complement the broader mission of the
National Strategy on the Prevention and Control
of Violence, Injuries and Disabilities
iii. To meet the targets of the UN Decade of Action
iv. To provide a common framework for
stakeholder agencies to implement the various
interventions required to mitigate road crash
outcomes

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

i. to reduce the annual


number of road
crash fatalities by at
least 30%
ii. to reduce the annual
number of serious
road crash injuries
by at least 30%
- Australia

Source: National Road Safety Strategy 2011-2020


Dr KP Nepal

81

Nepal Road Safety Strategy and Evaluation

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

83

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

82

Nepal Road Safety Strategy and Evaluation

Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

84

Concluding Remarks
Use of terminologies:
Crash NOT Accident

Approach to road safety


Proactive approach NOT Reactive approach

We believe:
If we fight road safety problem in Nepal from all 6 fronts, we will

reach somewhere

We would like to receive your comments and feedback,


documents and resources to:
Dr Kali Prasad Nepal (Deakin University, Australia)
Web-email: kpnepal@hotmail.com
Workplace-email: knepal@deakin.edu.au
Other team members
Development of Road Safety Management System in Nepal

Dr KP Nepal

85

Content

Crash
Data
the
Insert
theBases
title of
your
need
and some here
presentation
observations

My background

Need for crash databases

Observations on potential database responses

Implementation of a good database

Presented by Name Here


JimJob
Jarvis
Title - Date
Kathmadu 31st October 2014

Page 2

My Background
Worked in road safety for over 40 years
Last 10-15 years interest and work in RS in motorising
countries
Institutional strengthening
crash data bases
Linked for benefit

Worked in 12 international jurisdictions


Developed crash data bases in:

China Province level


India 3 at State Level
Thailand National level
Vietnam National level

Page 3

The need for Road Safety Action


300,000 killed over 10 million injured world wide
In 2010 nearly 2,000 reported killed killed in road
accidents in Nepal
Likely under-reporting, still 17 deaths per 10,000
vehicles, one of the highest in the region
Nepal has a reported crash rate that is 6 to 8 times
worse than many motorised countries
As well as suffering, substantial financial loss (3-4% of
GDP)
Entering second phase of risk (exploding
motorisation)
Urgent need to generate systematic countermeasure
program
Page 4

Countermeasures

The three Es of Road Safety


Education

Some self selecting silver bullets


Most need to be determined from information
available to best suit problems
Road safety presents complex problems
Problems in many areas - require solutions in
those areas
The three Es (+ 1)

Engineering

Enforcement

(Evaluation)

Page 5
22 December
2014

Copyright IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

Who we are

Our contribution to this forum

The Tamil Nadu Project

Road Safety Seminar 2009


GRSP Asia
Singapore
Subu Kamal
Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

22 December 2014

airlines, airports, seaports, oil & gas companies, road


& government authorities

2500+ employees
Our partner-Transport Research Laboratory (TRL), UK
13 Business Centres globally Atlanta, Washington DC, Boston, Denver
London, Rotterdam,
Dubai,
Trivandrum, Cochin, Bangalore
Tokyo, Hong Kong
Sydney

22 December 2014

Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

One of the largest states in southern India

Capital: Chennai

Population :66,396,000 (~ 3 times of

Malaysia)

Nearly 10,000 people are killed in about

Processes

Studied approaches to accident data


management in several countries

This includes several states in Australia,


United Kingdom, United States, Eastern
Europe, Middle East, Africa, Asia, plus
several other countries.

Hands-on, on-the site, involved study to


understand the key issues involved

Recent experience of a large-scale data


system project in Tamil Nadu State, India

We look forward to share some of these


experiences

Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

Accident Data system identified as a key need of


the State and procurement planned under the
World Bank Aided Tamil Nadu Road Sector Project
The strategy adopted was to implement a proven
solution for quicker results rather than develop a
solution from scratch.

Contract awarded to IBS Software Services in JV


with VicRoads International, Australia and IIT
Madras
Commencement of service on 25th October 2008

Vehicle population growth 10 to 11%

Project Period 9 months (on time, on budget


delivery)

annually

Tamil Nadu
22 December 2014

Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

Key Stakeholders - Highways Department,


Transport Department, Police Department

People

Area 130,058 km2 (50,216 sq mi)

51,000 accidents annually.

Recent trends

22 December 2014

Software

Key Success Factors

our contribution

who we are?
3

Performance Indicators for data quality

Certified at the highest quality standards

The solution adopted - RSMS

22 December 2014

A global transportation software specialist


Specialising in new generation, mission critical
solutions for air, land and marine transportation
World leading customers (150+)

preview

Jim Jarvis & Subu Kamal

The State
Accident Data System Project
Before & after results

potential solutions
Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

22 December 2014

Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

Before

No. of Installations: 1350 police stations, 600+


other users (engineers, other stakeholders)
Software

Multi-language
Interfaces - GIS Systems, Driver License data
system, Vehicle Registration data system

Security features Roles, User groups,


departments based access

People

Processes

Strong analysis and in-built data quality and road


safety management capabilities

potential solutions
7

Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

After

One year delay in using


accident data
No useful analysis done only
used for reporting in
assembly/parliament queries
Some systems not working,
data not matching, no
validations
Some systems using maps,
some not.
No support & recognition for
doing a good data collection job

22 December 2014

22 December 2014

Copyright IBS Software Services.


All Rights Reserved

22 December 2014

22 December 2014

Copyright IBS Software Services.


All Rights Reserved

22 December 2014

Road Safety Management System (RSMS) - Enterprise

Single comprehensive web-based, GIS enabled, online system that facilitates


end to end crash data management

Accident data keyed in from various locations by the police is available readily
for all authorized users (Transport, Police, local authorities, key stakeholders
in road safety etc.) from any PC connected to the net

Proven, field-tested flexible solution; 3+ years of actual field operation &


development.

Keyed in accident data is centralized, secure and easy to back up

Multiple language support

Cross platform compatibility (can work in Windows, Linux)

Lower operating costs

the software

Copyright IBS Software Services.


All Rights Reserved

Reduced to 1-3 days


Accident data being used for road
safety interventions
Single set of data for all users.
Patterns being identified, simple,
effective, timely actions yielding
good results
Single, integrated map to plot
accident locations.
More recognition and focus, more
central and other funding
expected for specific problems.

case study - results


8

22 December 2014

Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

Accident Analysis in RSMS


Cluster Analysis

vehicle registration systems

Stick Analysis

100+ Standard reports

Grid Analysis

Unlimited user definable reports

Monitor Site Analysis (Before /After


analysis)

Future
Modules
that may
reduce
under
reporting

Other key features


Interfacing capability with driver licensing &

Kilometer Analysis

Batch Reports Prepare Annual Quarterly


reports within seconds

Corridor Analysis

Role based User Access management

Collision Diagram Analysis

Powerful Auditing capabilities

Intelligent Accident Analysis

Validation and workflow for data quality

Safety benefit Analysis

assurance

Spatial Queries

Powerful, customizable dashboard for police

Dynamic Queries

managers

Collision Diagram Analysis

Audio/Video recording capabilities


Multiple language support

13

22 December 2014

Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

Copyright IBS Software Services.


All Rights Reserved

Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

16

22 December 2014

The program management functionality


Safety Management Life-cycle
Works at Country & State
levels
Helps bring in focus on
results and accountability
Can be adopted to use
evaluation and monitoring
models like DEE
(Disaggregated Effectiveness
Evaluation) for strategic
management

the key issue

management
15

22 December 2014

22 December 2014

1. Clear objectives with fairly well defined, detailed project requirements before
the project

Move towards one single solution for multiple


stakeholders

2. Adoption of a proven commercial off the shelf (COTS) solution with a short
implementation period

Low risk to client, result oriented, short-term


implementation

4. Instituionaling the solution between stakeholder departments - with well defined


roles, responsibilities and governance mechanisms

Increasing adoption of open standards and


enterprise open source technology by
governments

Highly user friendly, simple to use solutions but


complex technology running behind

5. Identifying the right vendor - Long term commitment to the solution, quality
standards and delivery capabilities

Systems with strong monitoring and evaluation


capabilities

6. Support & maintenance - 24x7x365 with Service Level Agreements (SLAs)

Solutions with Project Management capabilities


to plan, implement, monitor and evaluate road
safety interventions

Greater project size and complexity demanding


scalable solutions

3. One single solution for multiple stakeholders

7. Comprehensive training component - short, medium and long term


8. Complete ownership from police.

Why? Helps the officer on the field, his manager and at HQ .

recent trends

success factors
17

Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

22 December 2014

Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

18

22 December 2014

Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

Open architecture high level of modularity

Data Warehousing and Business Intelligence


capabilities

Web-enabled but technology and database


independent solutions

Having clear objectives and detailed


requirements fundamental to success of project
Assisting police to benefit from data is key to

Complex spatial capabilities, without any 3rd


party GIS software

SOA enabled solutions future proofing


investment

Interfaces to multitude of legacy and disparate


systems

Adoption of proven solutions, instead of


development from scratch (7 out of 10
Government IT projects fail)

New modes of delivery SAAS, rental, BOT

data quality
New technology can reduce complexity of crash
data systems

Low risk solutions preferable, with committed


vendors providing continuing support

recent trends
19

22 December 2014

summary
Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

rsms@ibsplc.com

IBS Software Services Americas Inc.

21

900 Circle 75 Parkway, Suite 550


Atlanta, GA 30339, USA.
Tel: +1(678)391-6080 | Fax: +1(678)391-6099
More info about IBS
is available
Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved
22 December
2014 at | http://www.ibsplc.com

20

22 December 2014

Copyright @ IBS Software Services. All Rights Reserved

APPENDIX 11: Speech by Mr Leela Mani Paudyal (in Nepali)

APPENDIX 12: Post-workshop Action Plan

Workshop on the Development of Nepal Road Safety Management System

Post-workshop Action Plan


S.
No.
1
2
3

4
5
6
7

8
9
10
11
12

13

Description of Actions
Prepare post-workshop action plan
Send invitation for post-workshop
meeting of the organizing committee
Send out "Thank You" email or text
messages to all workshop participants
stating commitment to finalise project
proposal along with action plan
Send out email requesting written
comments / feedbacks within
December 15, 2014 as due date
Prepare workshop report
Establish a separate account (called
Nepal Road Safety Research Fund NRSRF) within NTDRC
Pursue to collect contribution by DoR,
nec and other workshop sponsors and
deposit the collected money in NTDRC's
NRSS Fund
Ensure coordination/ follow up with
sponsors for the payment of invoices of
The Everest Hotel and other creditors
Incorporate comments/ feedback from
workshop participants and finalise the
proposal
Review proposal by all key members of
the team and other safety experts
Develop business case of the proposal
Receive comments from all team
members on business case ,
incorporate comments, finalise it with
technical proposal as attachment
Submit the business case of the

Lead
PMP
PMP

Responsibilities
Support
MGM
-

Due Date

Status

08/11/2014
02/11/2014

completed
completed

MGM

NS

15/11/2014

completed

MGM

SKG/ NS

15/11/2014

PMP
MGM

KPN
NS

15/12/2014
30/11/2014

NS

PMP/MGM

13/11/2014

completed
(reminder to be
sent by PMP)
under preparation
under consideration
by NTDRC Executive
Board
ongoing to
completion

NS

PMP/MGM

13/11/2014

ongoing to
completion

KPN

PMP

30/01/2015

in progress

PMP

All members of the


team
KPN
All Team members
and NTDRC/RSSN

30/02/2015

yet to be started

30/02/2015
15/ 03/2015

yet to be started
Yet being processed

NTDRC /RSSN

01/04/2015

yet to be discussed

PMP
PMP

PMP

proposal to MoPIT seeking funding


support
14
Develop action plan for follow up with
MoPIT, NPC, MoF etc. on the business
case submitted for funding
15
Follow up with MoPIT, NPC (if
relevant), MoF and other government
agencies (Health, Education, MTPD,
Media etc)
16
Register business entity in Australia to
enable undertake overseas jobs
17
Proposal partially or fully funded
18
Explore options on inviting other safety
experts such as TRL, ARRB to associate,
specialized traffic and transport
consultants, universities and industries
19
Launch Nepal Road Safety Research
Fund
Updated 30/11/2014

members
PMP

MGM

15/04/2015

yet to be
programmed

PMP

NTDRC/RSSN
members

02/04/2015

yet to be discussed

PMP

NS

03/04/2015

under investigation

PMP
PMP

Funding Agencies
KPN

15/04/2015
-

yet to be done.
ongoing

PMP

KPN/ CBS and other


founder members

Abbreviations:
NTDRC: Nepal Transportation and Development Research Centre
RSSN: Road Safety Society Nepal
PMP: Partha Mani Parajuli
KPN: Kali Prasad Nepal
MGM: Madan Gopal Maleku
NS: Naresh Shrestha
SKG: Santosh Kumar Gupta

15/04/2015

APPENDIX 13: Post-workshop Email sent to Participants inviting Input into the Proposal
First Email Sent to Participants inviting Input on Project Proposal
Dear workshop participants,
Thank you very much for your precious time in participating the workshop on the development of Road
Safety Management System in Nepal we have organized jointly with Nepal Road Safety Research
Council, which was chaired by Mr. Tulasi Sitaula, Secretary, Ministry of Physical Infrastructure and
Transport. The significance of the workshop was further enhanced by the gracious presence of our Chief
Secretary Mr. Leela Mani Paudyal, Chief Guest of the event and concern for the solution shown by him.
We consider the workshop was a huge success attended well over by 85 dignitary participants. In light of
the recent frequent cases of road crashes, the issue of road safety has drawn attention of all
stakeholders in Road Safety and our initiative aimed at contributing to reducing these crashes is very
timely.
The original format of the workshop involving the formation of six panels (for six components) for
discussion on our proposal and to come up with the suggestions on the proposal did not materialize due
to the last moment cancellation of the DoTM workshop scheduled in the morning and the need to
accommodate two more presentations from Transport Research Laboratory of UK.
This email is therefore to request you to send out your comments/ feedbacks/ input on the proposal we
presented in the workshop so we can finalise it and submit to the Government of Nepal for its
consideration. The due date for sending your comments is December 15, 2014.
While all types of comments will be appreciated, we request you to particularly focus on listing out the
projects under each of the six components of Road Safety Management System we have presented in
the workshop (Also refer to our workshop Brochure).
Can I suggest that you focus on identifying projects, which need to be undertaken immediately, which
can be implemented in the short to medium term (5 - 10 years) and long term (10 - 20 years)? Some
projects could be of "aspirational" type requiring extensive research. These projects can be planned for
distant long term (beyond 20 years of time) for delivery.
Please be assured that this is not the workshop that will stop with the delivery of the workshop. We
have already developed post-workshop action plan to give continuity to the works we have been
undertaking since last one year. We have also attached our post-workshop action plan for your
information.
Regards

Madan Maleku
Managing Director
NTDRC

Last Email Sent to Participants inviting Input on Project Proposal


Thank you for all who have responded to our request for providing local input into the project proposal
for the development of Nepal Road Safety Management System (NRSMS).
This is the final call to "Have Your Say".
You have been receiving these emails from Mr Madan Maleku, Managing Director of NTDRC, our
designated local partner. Apology for flooding your inbox with unsolicited emails! As you appreciate, this
is an important piece of work we are committed to deliver and your local input is very important for us.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Dear Workshop Participants
Thank you very much for your precious time in participating the workshop on the development of Road
Safety Management System in Nepal we have organized jointly with Nepal Road Safety Research
Council, which was chaired by Mr. Tulasi Sitaula, Secretary, Ministry of Physical Infrastructure and
Transport. The significance of the workshop was further enhanced by the gracious presence of our Chief
Secretary Mr.Leela Mani Paudyal, Chief Guest of the event and concern for the solution shown by him.
We consider the workshop was a huge success attended well over by 85 dignitary participants. In light of
the recent frequent cases of road crashes, the issue of road safety has drawn attention of all
stakeholders in Road Safety and our initiative aimed at contributing to reducing these crashes is very
timely.
The original format of the workshop involving the formation of six panels (for six components) for
discussion on our proposal and to come up with the suggestions on the proposal did not materialize due
to the last moment cancellation of the DoTM workshop scheduled in the morning and the need
to accommodate two more presentations from Transport Research Laboratory of UK.
This email is therefore to request you to send out your comments/ feedbacks/ input on the proposal we
presented in the workshop so we can finalise it and submit to the Government of Nepal for its
consideration. The last date date for sending your comments is December 31, 2014 (extended by 15
days over the scheduled date due to delay in making this final call).
While all types of comments will be considered, we request you to particularly focus on listing out the
projects under each of the six components of Road Safety Management System we have presented in
the workshop (Also refer to our workshop Brochure distributed in the workshop). If you would like to
have a copy of workshop presentation please send email to me. Due to the file size I have not attached
these presentations in this email.
Can I suggest that you focus on identifying projects, which need to be undertaken immediately, which
can be implemented in the short to medium term (5 - 10 years) and long term (10 - 20 years)? Some
projects could be of "aspirational" type requiring extensive research. These projects can be planned for
distant long term (beyond 20 years of time) period for delivery.

Please be assured that this is not the work that will stop with the delivery of the workshop. We have
already developed post-workshop action plan to give continuity to the works we have been undertaking
since last one year. We have also attached our post-workshop (updated) action plan for your
information.

Partha Parajuli
Project Coordinator
NRSMS Project

APPENDIX 14: Statement of Workshop Expenses

Workshop on the Development of Nepal Road Safety Management System

Expenditure Items for ADB's Support


Summary Sheet

Description
Note Book and Ball Pen for Workshop Participants
Workshop Program Printing and Photocopying
Workshop Brochure Design with Page Flipping
Feature to enable ease in read from NTDRC
website (to be uploaded)
Conference Hall Rental and Audio Visual Aids
Workshop Brochure Printing and Banner Making
Creation of NRSMS Section in NTDRC's current
website and uploading of workshop brochure,
proposal and other reference materials on road
safety for wider dissemination and sharing of
knowledge to all workshop participants and road
safety stakeholders
Total

Prepared by:

Partha Mani Parajuli


Coordinator
NRSMS Workshop Organizing Committee / NTDRC

Amount (NRs)
3,300.00
280.00
10,000.00
67,534.68
19,460.00
3,000.00

103,574.68

Status
Paid
Paid
Paid
Yet to be paid
Yet to be paid
Quote received

Workshop on the Development of Nepal Road Safety Management System


Expenditure Items for MoPIT's Support
Summary Sheet

Description
Conference Hall Rental and Audio Visual Aids
Meeting Room Hire Charge at different dates
(Total number of meetings of the Organizing
Committee)
Total

Prepared by:

Partha Mani Parajuli


Coordinator
NRSMS Workshop Organizing Committee / NTDRC

Amount (NRs)
101,414.87
10,000.00
111, 414.87

Status
Yet to be paid
Paid

APPENDIX 15: Additional Documentation


Mr Tulasi Prasad Sitaula
Secretary
Ministry of Physical Infrastructure and Transport
Singha Durbar
Dear Mr. Sitaula
We area a team of like-minded specialists working overseas in the field of road safety having strong desire to
contribute something to the community to which we belong. Having heard the news of road carnage in Nepal
frequently, we thought we should do something to contribute to reduce and hopefully to eliminate this sort of mass
killings. No words can explain the importance of the works we propose to do than the attached paper cut. This is
unacceptable for any civilized community to watch and not to act against these killings on the roads built for the
purpose of national development using scarce resources of the country and international assistance.
I am delighted to let you know that we have started a new initiative on the development and implementation of a
sustainable Road Safety Management System in Nepal in response to the urgent need to reduce such unwarranted
and unacceptable level of road death in Nepal. With over one year of research and hard work since we launched the
Road Safety Unit in Nepal Transportation Research and Development Centre (NTDRC), our designated local partner
in Nepal, we have so far prepared a comprehensive draft proposal and it is now ready for sharing our hard work with
all the stakeholders on road safety.
Attached draft workshop brochure describes briefly about our initiative and the way forward as we see it. We are
planning to present our final proposal to the Government of Nepal for its consideration. Before finalizing the proposal
we are planning to present the proposal to key stakeholders in Nepal on road safety with a view to collecting
feedback from them and to avoid repeating, or competing with the efforts already made but complementing these
efforts and building on the blocks that have already laid the foundation in course.
We are planning to organize a half day presentation/ workshop for this purpose on October 31, 2014. In this
connection we would like to request National Road Safety Council, as a peak coordinating authority on road safety
matters to kindly provide necessary support and kindly agree to lead the workshop. Also please note that we are
concurrently working with other government bodies such as Department of Transport Management (DoTM) and
private agencies such as Nepal Engineering College (nec), Nepal Road Safety Society (NRSS) to sponsor the
workshop. DoTM has kindly agreed to work in this esteemed effort together for the workshop. The morning session
will be about the establishment of Road Crash Information Management System, the excellent piece of DoTM has
commenced. DOTM is expected to lead this morning workshop. The afternoon session will be about the "BIG
PICTURE" Road Safety Management System which we are proposing to develop together with all relevant agencies
working in this sector. We will have more opportunity to discuss about these matters with you in the meeting and
further in the workshop. The workshop is also expected to raise awareness on the extent of works that need to be
done to improve road safety in Nepal.
I attach herewith the list of participants we have developed so far with input from DoTM, NTDRC, NRSS and other
individuals who are keen to support our initiative for your review and final consideration. NTDRC will facilitate
sending out invitation request and do necessary follow up with the prospective participants.
We once again would like to request for your kind consent to lead the proposed workshop and extend necessary
cooperation.
Thanking you,
Yours Sincerely

Dr. Partha Parajuli MIEAust CPEng RPEQ


Project Co-ordinator Nominee NRSMS
CC
Mr. Kashi Raj Dahal, Director General, DoTM
Mr. Madan Maleku, Executive Director, NTDRC

Ref: NRSMS/03

Date: November 5, 2014

Naresh Pradhan
Project Officer (Transport)
Nepal Resident Mission
Asian Development Bank
Metro Park Building, Lazimpat
Tel (977) (1) 400 5120

Ref: Workshop on the Development of Road Safety Management System in


Nepal - Request for Reimbursement of Workshop

Dear Mr Pradhan,
Thank you for your email dated October 28, 2014 about ADB's support for
conducting workshop on the Development of Road Safety Management System in
Nepal in the Everest Hotel, Baneshwore on October 31, 2014. The workshop was
jointly organized by the Ministry of Physical Infrastructure and Transport (MoPIT)
and Nepal Transportation and Development Research Centre (NTDRC) and well
attended by over 85 participants including high level officials from the Government
of Nepal, representatives from funding agencies, media and other stakeholders of
Road Safety in Nepal. Presentations were also made by two participants from
Transport Research Laboratory of UK on Crash Database Management System.
Attached are the original receipts and/ or invoices for the workshop under the
expenditure items approved by you. Remaining cost of the workshop as per the
budget shown in the funding proposal is expected to be covered by other sponsors.
Thanking You,
Yours Sincerely,

Partha Mani Parajuli


Coordinator
Workshop Organizing Committee/ NTDRC

Ref: NRSMS/04
Date: November 6, 2014
Mr. Tulasi Sitaula
Secretary
Ministry of Physical Infrastructure & Transport
Singha Durbar
Kathmandu, Nepal
Ref: Workshop on the Development of Road Safety Management System in
Nepal - Request for Reimbursement of Workshop Expenses

Dear Sir,
Thank you for chairing the workshop on the Development of Road Safety
Management System in Nepal in the Everest Hotel, Baneshwore on October 31,
2014. The workshop, which was organized jointly by the Ministry of Physical
Infrastructure and Transport (MoPIT) and Nepal Transportation and Development
Research Centre (NTDRC), was well attended by over 85 participants including
high level officials from other Ministries and Departments, representatives from
funding agencies such as World Bank and Asian Development Bank, Media and
other stakeholders of Road Safety in Nepal. Presentations were also made by two
participants from Transport Research Laboratory of UK on Crash Database
Management System.
As per our discussion and understanding, I am attaching herewith the original
receipts and/ or invoices for the part workshop expenditures for your kind
consideration. I humbly request for the reimbursement of the expenditures as per
the attached invoices and receipts. Remaining cost of the workshop as per the
budget shown in the funding proposal is expected to be covered by Asian
Development Bank and other sponsors.
Thanking You,
Yours Sincerely,

Partha Mani Parajuli


Coordinator
Workshop Organizing Committee/ NTDRC

Ref: 56-01-2014

Date: October 26, 2014

Mr Arjun Jung Thapa


Deputy Director General
Planning and Design Branch
Department of Roads
Babar Mahal, Kathmandu, Nepal

Ref: Workshop on the Development of Nepal Road Safety Management


System in Nepal (NRSMS)

Dear Mr Thapa
Thank you for accepting our proposal to nominate 10 participants for the workshop
of October 31, 2014 on the development of Road Safety Management System in
Nepal.
We kindly request you to nominate the participants from DOR in the workshop
being organized on October 31, 2014 (12.30-16.30 pm). As discussed with you on
October 21 and 26, we confirm that the fee for participating in the workshop is NRs.
5000 per person and the venue of workshop is Hotel Everest, Baneshwore
Kathmandu.
We are also enclosing herewith the brochure and the program of the workshop for
your information.
Thanking you,
Yours Sincerely

Partha Mani Parajuli


Project Co-ordinator (NRSMS)
On behalf of NTDRC

APPENDIX 16: Photo Gallery


Workshop on the Development
of
Nepal Road Safety Management System, Kathmandu
October 31, 2014

Вам также может понравиться