Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
to turn
ideas into
action
Case studies in social change
from the RSA Fellowship
October 2013 by Sam Thomas
www.thersa.org
Contents
Introduction
2. Connect online
10
14
18
Conclusion
25
26
Acknowledgements
27
28
Introduction
The RSA was founded in 1754, and during its long and busy
life has achieved many things. Common to all of them is one
consistent principle: that ordinary people are capable of changing
the world around them for the better, by developing and acting
ontheir ideas. Our mission today is to seek out enlightened
thinking and put it to work in practical ways.
One of the most important ways we do this is through
our27,000-strong Fellowship: a diverse group of people from
awide range of backgrounds, united by a desire to build a better
society. One of the things weve learned working every day with
this extraordinary group of people is that when addressing
complex social issues, having a good idea alone isnt enough.
People come up with new ways to solve problems all the time,
butmost of them never come to fruition and those that do
usually follow a long, difficult path before they can have a real
impact on theworld.
At the RSA, we work hard to support our Fellows in
developing and growing their ideas, and weve learned a lot
aboutwhat helps turn them into practical action. In what follows,
youll learn about ten very different ideas that RSA Fellows have
developed, and some of the ways in which we and others have
supported them. Weve grouped these into four sections, to
correspond with the four ways that we encourage our Fellows
tohelp contribute to our charitable mission:
2
2. Connect online
The web and social media make it possible for people whove never
mettowork together. These tools can help spread ideas and help people
participate in them more easily but technology itself isnt enough: it has
to be used effectively. Well explore two projects from the Fellowship that
have used social media in different ways to engage people in debate and
action on social issues.
Not everything these projects tried was successful, and theres a great
dealto be learned from both the things that went well and those that
didnt. In all of the examples that follow, though, youll find three things:
a commitment to work collaboratively with others, the confidence to try
things out, and a shared aim to change society for the better.
Introduction
The RSAs Fellows met for the first time in 1754, at Rawthnells coffee
house in Covent Garden. They came together because of their common
interests and concerns, but from the outset they were determined to
workfor the benefit of others in society.
The idea of people meeting for the common good is nothing
new: think of civic associations, trade unions or political parties.
Many of these forms of association have struggled in recent years,
with membership of the main political parties declining rapidly over
the last thirty years.1 However, the impulse is still there for people
to cometogether andshare ideas for making things better and
the scaleand severityofthesocial problems we face today makes
itevenmoreimportant that we do.
A good place to start is by bringing together a group of people, and
exploring what they have in common. The RSAs Regional Programme
Team supports Fellows in organising events and workshops to explore
issues facing their communities, and provides advice on how to organise
and facilitate them effectively. In this section, well give some examples
of Fellows coming together, and how they make the time they spend
witheach other productive and enjoyable.
OpenDinner
RSA Fellows debate topical social issues over aninformalmeal
1.See Participation: trends, facts and figures, NCVO, March 2011 (bit.ly/ncvoparticipation)
When focusing on serious issues, its easy to forget that people also want
to enjoy themselves. The things that we look for when we spend time with
our friends and family good conversation, laughter, food dont cease
to matter when the focus shifts to solving a problem. In fact, sometimes
thebest work gets done when people forget that theyre working and
enjoy themselves.
Longstanding RSA Fellow Kevin Donovan is firmly of the opinion
that discussing important issues shouldnt mean adopting a serious tone.
Through the OpenDinner events hes been organising in Liverpool for
the last couple of years, he sets out to create an alternative to the stuffy
atmosphere of the formal dinner. My approach as chair of the meeting
is to get people to relax and realise that were having some fun some
serious fun together, Kevin says. Its being an MC more than a chair.
Its informal, its friendly and its collegiate.
The Liverpool OpenDinners take place at Delifonseca, a restaurant
in the city centre owned and managed by an RSA Fellow. They aim to
provide an entertaining, informative evening of debate and discussion.
Topics discussed at the meetings have ranged from criminal justice to
education, with a speaker sharing their personal experience in order to
provoke discussion. One of the best, says Kevin, was education writer
andcampaigner Fiona Millar: her delivery and style were obviously
very,very good, he says. Experienced, professional and political:
sheknew how to provoke questions.
The success of an event isnt just down to an engaging talk, though:
theres also careful planning involved. Whenever possible, Kevin meets
with the speakers in person ahead of the evening, to discuss what theyre
going to talk about and put together some prompts to get others talking.
These are particularly important: a set of questions or provocations,
shared with attendees on the night, which help give the evening some
focus. This ensures that as well as being sociable occasions, the dinners
provide plenty of opportunity for debate, with everybody encouraged
tocontribute.
Sometimes this preparation can be quite involved. At the most recent
event, RSA Fellow Michael King gave a talk on an unusual and perhaps
unpromising subject: heavy trains. Drawing on his PhD research, Michael
had prepared a Cluedo-style game that challenged diners to think about
an engineering puzzle: why are British trains heavier and hence less
energy efficient than those of other countries? By inviting attendees to
consider all the economic, organisational and engineering factors that
might be responsible, as well as the key characters from John Major to
Richard Branson he prompted a wide-ranging debate on the complexity
of addressing climate change.
The dinners are always lively and spirited, but Kevin reflects that
sofarthey havent sparked off any activities that go beyond the evening.
It hasnt made that little important click in peoples heads, Kevin
observes, to see that they can now use or be involved in the RSA in more
active ways. I find it frustrating that it still isnt happening. Perhaps it need
not perhaps Im trying too hard.
Nonetheless, hes already making plans for the next dinner, which
willbe the last he organises, featuring Gemma Bodinetz, artistic director of the Liverpool Everyman and Playhouse theatres. The reason for
having her is that later this year the work will be completed on the new
theatre, so we plan to dedicate a seat to the RSA.
Kevin has no doubt that itll be a memorable way to cap off his time
organising these events, and is pleased to have already found two volunteers
to organise future events. Hes challenged them to develop the events further,
and build on the relationships that have already formed around the evenings.
Key learning: People learn more and make lasting connections when theyre
enjoying themselves
Find out more about the philosophy behind OpenDinners in Kevins
RSAComment piece: bit.ly/opendinner
Unleashing Potential
Connecting community organisations and RSA Fellows in the
eastofEngland
rewardingdiscussions
Read the follow-up report from the conference:
bit.ly/eeconference
2. Connect online
Its never been easier to share your idea with the world. The web and
social media provide a way of communicating with people thats both
quick and inexpensive, and RSA Animate videos have shown how challenging ideas can reach a worldwide audience. However, people are
quickly realising that as useful as the new tools we have are, they remain
just that: tools. Theres a craft to getting your message across well online,
just as there is when youre talking to a room full of people.
In the last section, we saw how bringing people together in person can
help generate excitement about an idea. Not everyone, though, is able or
willing to spend time at events or meetings and if the focus of what youre
doing is wider than the immediate community, there may be people with
insights to offer from further afield. For this reason, people are increasingly
turning to social media online tools that allow people to communicate
easily and quickly, such as Twitter and Facebook as an alternative way
ofpromoting causes and projects in which theyre involved.
RSA Fellows are a vocal presence on social media, as youll see if you look
at one of the many places where theyre talking about their work together.
Increasingly, RSA events and meetings have a second, parallel life on Twitter,
with people commenting, sharing and contributing their own knowledge.
The Fellowship has a group of voluntary digital champions who help others
to get involved online, and theres also plenty of free advice available to get
started. In this section, well look at two examples of Fellows projects that
have used the web to engage with two very different communities.
Leeds Empties
A Fellow-led campaign to bring empty houses in Leeds back into use
10
Leeds Empties started with a simple, stark fact: more than 5,000
homesinLeeds have been empty for over six months. To Rob Greenland,
a social entrepreneur whos been working in the city for over a decade,
itdemanded a response. Theres nothing more basic than needs around
food and shelter, Rob says. It felt like an issue where theres a gap to do
something different, and we thought itd engage people. You can point
toan empty home, and just ask: why?
It turns out, in this context, that why? is a difficult question to answer.
Nine out of ten empty homes in Leeds are privately owned, whichmeans
the city council although keen to address the issue doesnt have the
power to solve it on its own. And the reasons that homes lie empty are
numerous, ranging from poor maintenance or lack of finance to family
disputes. Rob and his business partner Gill Coupland took to the web
to raise awareness about the issue, and the result was Leeds Empties,
acampaign working with property owners to help emptyhouses
becomehomes again.
I have no doubt at all that we would never have got to the point of
action without social media, says Rob. It allows you to find a critical
mass of people quite quickly. By focusing on a single issue in a single
city, he and Gill were able to generate a real buzz around Leeds Empties.
Partly this was down to Robs strong network of local Twitter followers, many of whom were also RSA Fellows, who helped get the message
out wethought RSA Fellows could be a good network, whether its
academics, architects, local community activists, he says.
Sparking a debate also helped. It was more about asking questions
than saying we have solutions to problems, he says. Wed say did you
know there are 5000 empty homes in Leeds? People respond to that,
andconversations begin there.
These conversations came together at a face-to-face event. Rob created
an Eventbrite page to allow people to register, and 100 people signed
up a huge turnout for a brand new campaign. At the event, people were
encouraged to pledge support for bringing empty homes back into use,
and the team followed up these promises afterwards. On a very basic
level, there was an energy to that day that came from there being 100
people who all saw other people being quite generous, hesays.
Rob is also clear that keeping up momentum following this event was
the hardest part of the project. After six months of donating their time
and pulling in favours, he and Gill found they were hitting a wall. Its
easy to get people to explore ideas, he says, but to go back to them a
week or two later and say that was really interesting, lets get together
and explore how it might work as a business theres a need for someone,
in most cases, to be paid to work with people to do that stuff.
Rob and Gill started to seek financial support for the project, and secured
funding from the RSAs Catalyst fund and subsequently Leeds City Council.
Theyve been able to trial a number of initiatives, including an Empty
Homes Doctor service that provides intensive support for owners of vacant
properties who want to bring their home back in to use. This scheme was
so well received that the council has now committed a further 100,000
toexpand it a huge vote of confidence in Rob and Gills hardwork.
Social media will continue to play an important role, not just in promoting this scheme, but letting people know about its impact. Hopefully
2. Connect online
11
One of hundreds of
submissionsto the project,
fromMakia, aged 10
Theres plenty of potential to use social media to get across a message, but
its real strength is that it works in both directions. The ease of connecting
using these new tools gives them the potential to amplify peoples voices,
and uncover those that might otherwise not be heard. If youre trying to
work with a community of people, theres no better way to involve them
in what youre doing than letting them speak for themselves.
In July 2012, the RSA and Suffolk County Council launched an inquiry
into how to improve education in the county, which is underperforming
compared to the national average. The project brought together school
leaders, teachers, parents and educational experts from other parts of
the country to create a response to this huge challenge. RSA Fellows in
Suffolk also lent their time and ideas, and firmest among these was a
commitment to help make sure young peoples voices were represented.
Dr. Emma Bond, a senior lecturer in Childhood and Youth Studies at
University Campus Suffolk (UCS), worked with other Fellows, including
local RSA Fellowship councillor Suzanna Pickering, to design an online
research project that encouraged young people across the county to
share their views about education using social media. If we are really
going to grasp why Suffolk is failing to meet the educational needs of
young people, Emma explained at the time, we need to understand
what theireducational experiences are like and we need to listen to
theirviews,as they are the very people who are going to be affected.
12
The project received support both financial and in-kind from RSA
Catalyst and UCS, which made it possible to make progress very rapidly.
Young people were encouraged to submit their ideas which could be
inthe form of drawings, text or videos to Pinterest (an online pinboard
tool that makes it easy to collate different media). These were then shared
with a wider audience through a Twitter account for the project.
Emma and others produced an engagement guide that they sent out to
schools, young peoples organisations and RSA Fellows, which explained how
young people could make their contribution to the project. It was important
to ensure that as many young people from as broad a range of backgrounds
as possible were able to join in. The project accepted submissions through
arange of tools including Facebook, Twitter and email and worked with
the Widening Participation team at UCS to engage students from disadvantaged backgrounds. The team also used targeted advertisements to reach
more of the 40,000 Facebook users under the age of 20 in Suffolk.
The project involved an incredible 568 young people, and their contributions covered subjects ranging from bullying to the pressure of GCSE
choices. Many submissions were illustrated, and one group of students
produced a YouTube film with the support of a theatre company. Emma
was struck by the range and quality of the contributions, and produced
adocument collating the young peoples views for the inquiry to consider
alongside evidence from teachers, the public and RSA Fellows.
The team involved in the project are keen to ensure that it has a legacy
beyond the publication of the final report in May 2013, which drew on
the projects work. They plan to seek further Catalyst funding to develop
the project so that it can be adapted elsewhere in the country, and have
published an evaluation report that explains how they designed the
project tohelp others learn from the experience.
Key learning: Social media can help you to capture voices that would
2. Connect online
13
A Social Entrepreneurs
Networkbreakfast meeting
(photo: Anthony Epes,
www.anthonyepes.com)
14
15
difficultquestions
Join the Social Entrepreneurs Network online: rsafellowship.com/group/
socialentrepreneursnetwork
16
17
Weve explored some of the ways that ideas are strengthened through
being discussed, shared and improved by the skills and experience of
others. At some point, these ideas need to prove that they can work in
practice. This can demand a lot of things funding, persistence, luck
but its also about making sure that the right support and guidance
isinplace to help an idea take root.
For the last couple of years, RSA Catalyst has been supporting Fellows
ventures and helping them to achieve social impact. Through it, weve
given nearly 300,000 in small grants to projects, and made hundreds of
connections between projects and individuals or organisations that help
them meet their goals. Catalyst aims to support ventures that gobeyond
the community of RSA Fellows.
In this last section, youll see how three projects led by RSA Fellows
have come to play an important role in improving their communities.
Changing Chelmsford
A group of RSA Fellows who helped their town to become a city
18
19
Vertical Allotments
Bringing urban gardening to sheltered housing schemes
Lynette Warren and Mike Anstey have turned Vertical Allotments their
idea for growing vegetables upwards, not outwards into a promising
social business. Mike and Lynettes journey started when they took the
decision to leave their jobs at the University of Bedfordshire, and strike
out on their own.
We went a bit demob happy, and had so many ideas bouncing
around, Lynette recalls fondly. At the university, the pair had managed a
programme which created spin-off companies to adapt academic research
for profit. Its therefore hardly surprising that they started to think about
how they could make a living from some of their own interests.
We picked up the feeling that grow your own initiatives were well,
growing! And that there was a shortage of allotment space. Looking
at the high rise flats, we thought: wouldnt it be nice to green the
environment there as well? They were interested in working with older
people, especially those in sheltered housing, to tackle the problem of
20
21
Plan Zheroes
Helping fight food waste and food poverty in London
Every year in the UK, 1.6 billion tonnes of surplus food is sent to landfill
sites by retail outlets. And at the same time, in the same country, four million people are in food poverty. In 2009, three campaigners Lotti Henley,
Maria Ana Botelho Neves, and Chris Wilkie decided they wanted this
tochange. The impulse came from Lotti, whose experiences of food
shortages during the Second World War left her appalled by the idea of
good food going to waste. Their response was Plan Zheroes (short for
zero food waste heroes): a project to raise awareness about food waste
and food poverty and help tackle the two together.
From talking to small businesses, they realised there was a need for a
simple way to link businesses with food to spare and charities who could
give it to those in need. Initially, this seemed a straightforward goal.
Atthe beginning we were nave, full of enthusiasm, Maria Ana recalls.
Wejust had a vision, we knew where we wanted to be, and had no clue
how difficult it is. What the team hadnt counted on was the complexity
of thesurplus food problem.
What works for a hotel doesnt necessarily work for a shop or a
supermarket, Maria Ana explains. Sometimes you have food that is only
surplus for 12 hours, and you need to quickly find a place that will consume
it, while at other times it might be packaged and fine for three months.
And charities needs are very different too, from the soup runs on the
Strand where theres no phone contact, its just something that happens
toorganisations like the Salvation Army, who have fully-equipped kitchens.
Theres also the question of health and safety regulations, often given as
the reason that food must be thrown away. According to Maria Ana, this is
often an excuse: in most circumstances, safety shouldnt be an impediment.
The more they learned, the more the team realised that the biggest
role they could play was learning from organisations like FareShare and
companies such as Pret a Manger, who have already done the groundwork
and found out what works, and inspire smaller businesses to do the same.
We [felt we should] focus on whos doing it those are the real heroes
and then learn from them and become gossipers, Maria Ana says: just
tell others whats possible.
22
The project received funding from RSA Catalyst and support from
the campaigning organisation London Citizens, and was launched at
Londons City Hall in February 2012. Its not all been plain sailing,
though, and Maria Ana is all too aware of the costs of seeing an idea
through to completion. She explains that from the start everyone involved
saw the project as a collaborative one between equals with shared ownership, and shared leadership. That meant that as the campaign gathered
pace, it became difficult to make decisions: everybody the co-founders
felt this is my project.
This open approach extended to working with volunteers. Maria Ana
explains the format of early meetings: we would say okay, introduce
yourself, and the next thing we would say was now, do whatever you
think you can do. This is the worst way to engage volunteers! There isnt
a single person that wants to be thrown a huge opportunity and not know
where they fit.
These challenges became so severe that Plan Zheroes success became
impossible to manage and several people involved having to step back
from the project due to the pressure of keeping everything afloat with
little funding or structure. As a result, they decided to put together a business plan and budget, create proper procedures for managing volunteers
and are now registering as a charity. However, Maria Ana is adamant that
they had to decide to do these things the hard way, and that the initial
freedom or chaos, as she puts it was necessary. If wed been very
structured, you know what would have happened? Wed have given up,
she says. The reason we didnt is because there was a lot of enthusiasm
more than that, determination.
Its a real dilemma: a campaign like Plan Zheroes needs to be inclusive
and exciting enough to inspire people and get them on board, but structured enough to survive in the long term. How to get that balance right
will differ for every project. One important lesson, Maria Ana explains,
was to learn to say no to new ideas. People will throw you fantastic,
fantastic suggestions, and youre not ready, she says. Stop being overwhelmed and panicked because its not the right time but put those
ideas in a place where you can visit them as the journey progresses.
Theres little doubt now that it will. Maria Ana and the Plan Zheroes
team have recently worked with the Greater London Authority and other
partners to design the London Food Map, a new tool allowing anyone in
urgent need of food to find the nearest provider that can help whether
thats a food bank, a soup kitchen, or a caterer or sandwich shop with left
over stock. This has encouraged the team to start thinking about how they
offer their model to other local authorities. However, Maria Ana insists that
the focus has to remain on the social impact of what theyre doing. What
we cant do, because it will kill the project, it will kill the culture and why
were doing it, is just look for ways of making money, she says. Because
its not about making money, its about solving a problem.
That sense, that the project is tackling a real and pressing issue, is
never far from the teams minds. We feel special every day we receive
an email from a charity to say what they achieved by being part of Plan
Zheroes, she says: that they can help another 50 people now, or they
cansave the money they have spent on food.
23
24
Conclusion
The path from having an idea to making it happen might be a long one,
but as weve seen, there are ways to make it much easier. These projects
diverse as they are point to the potential of good ideas when developed
in the right kind of environment, and where people work together and
pool their expertise to improve and act on them.
The first step in developing an idea is to meet with others to discuss
it, and draw on their knowledge to improve and refine it together. These
meetings neednt be stressful or glum indeed, they should be some of
the most inspiring and enjoyable time you can spend with others. The key
is making sure that the conditions are right: plenty of support, a relaxed
atmosphere, and strong facilitation to make sure that everyone is able to
make their views heard.
Next, put it out into the world. Its never been easier to tell the story of
something youre working on to others including those youve never met
who might share your interests. Creating excitement around an idea will
enlist others to your cause, but new technology also gives you the opportunity to seek others views, and get them to critique what youre doing.
At this stage, its time to draw on the skills and experience of others.
You may be sure that your idea is a good one, but its highly doubtful you
are able to realise its potential alone. This might mean asking for help
to make your idea happen, or it might mean finding the people who will
benefit from it. Either way, networks like the RSA Fellowship are a fantastic place to find willing volunteers.
Finally, test your idea and make sure it works. At this point, difficult
questions start to arise: how do you persuade others to take notice? What
kind of scaffolding do you need to make your idea stand up? And perhaps
most crucial of all, whos going to pay for it? None of these have easy
answers, but the support is there if youre willing to look for it.
Perhaps this makes solving social problems seem like hard work. If
so, thats because it often is: none of the people featured in this booklet,
whether theyre rescuing empty homes or tackling food poverty, would
describe their achievements as easily won.
All the same, we hope theyd agree that discussing ideas, sharing
themand putting them into action is time well spent. We hope their
example inspires you to go out and do the same with your idea
whateverit may be.
Conclusion
25
OpenDinner (page 4)
Find people and organisations that share an interest, and let them
sparkoff each other
Leeds Empties (page 10)
Use your own networks on social media, and ask questions that
drawpeople in
Shout Out Suffolk! (page 12)
Social media can help you to capture voices that would otherwise
beleftout
Social Entrepreneurs Network (page 14)
Finding the right partners is crucial in helping your idea take off
Plan Zheroes (page 22)
26
Acknowledgements
Huge thanks to all of the RSA Fellows whose work is featured in this
publication, and especially the nine who generously gave their time to
speak to me over the spring and summer of 2013:
Lilian Barton
Maria Ana Botelho Neves
Kevin Donovan
Rob Greenland
Peter Johnson
Malcolm Noble
Robert Porrer
Bruno Taylor
Lynette Warren
Acknowledgements
27
How to apply
Fellowship is open to anyone anywhere in the world who shares
or demonstrates a commitment to positive social change in their
professional, civic or personal life.
To request a joining pack, email fellowship@rsa.org.uk, telephone the
Fellowship team on 020 7451 6904, or visit our website:
www.thersa.org/fellowship
28
www.thersa.org
Designed by www.soapbox.co.uk