Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Research Methodology
Objectives of the Project
The primary objective of the report is categorized into following sub-topics:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Data sources
Primary sources
Primary data has been collected through the structured questionnaire
consisting mainly of the closed ended questions.
Secondary sources
Secondary data has been collected from the internet, journals, reference books
etc.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The study is based on primary data, which has been collected from the credit
card users with the help of a well drafted and structured questionnaire (see
annexure). For the collection of primary data, we have confined ourselves to
Ahmedabad, India. Our sample consists of a total of 150 respondents. The
respondents are basically credit card users, who have been selected by
following the non-probabilistic sampling, simple purposive sampling and
convenience sampling techniques.
Further, it is essential to mention two things: firstly, in convenience-sampling,
respondents (who were seen using/have possession of credit cards) were
selected because they happened to be in the right place at the right time and
secondly, convenience sampling technique is not recommended for descriptive
or casual research, but they can be used in exploratory research for the
generation of ideas (Malhotra, 2005). The questions inquired the choice of
credit card, and the users were given 28 statements. In addition, the
respondents had to rate the credit cards according to the importance, on the
`five-point Likert scale.
Sampling Plan
Target Population: Credit Card holders
Sample Size: 100 respondents
Sampling technique: Convenience sampling
Beneficiaries
1. Banks
Banks may come to know about the usage pattern of the credit card holders
based on the demographics, purposes and consumption pattern and may aim to
target new customers based on the derived facts.
2. Probable subscribers
New prospects may find it helpful in selecting the credit card company and
the bank issuing the credit based on the satisfaction level of the existing
credit card holders.
3. Researchers
Study gives the researchers the insight about the credit card system prevailing
and the usage pattern and satisfaction level of the existing credit card holders.
Research Design
The research design that has been used is Descriptive Research.
Involves gathering data that describe events and then organizes,
tabulates, depicts, and describes the data.
Uses description as a tool to organize data into patterns that emerge
during analysis.
Often uses visual aids such as graphs and charts to aid the reader
Description Research takes a what if approach
Refers to the nature of the research question
The design of the research
The way that data will be analyzed for the topic that will be researched
There are four methods of data collection under descriptive research. They
are:
Surveys
Interviews
Observations
Portfolios
The methods used for this research would be mainly by the response to the
questionnaire by the credit card holders.
CHAPTER 2
INTRODUCTION TO BANKING
INDUSTRY
Banking in India originated in the last decades of the 18th century. The oldest
bank in existence in India is the State Bank of India , a government-owned bank
that traces its origins back to June 1806 and that is the largest commercial bank
in the country. Central banking is the responsibility of the Reserve Bank of
India , which in 1935 formally took over these responsibilities from the then
Imperial Bank of India, relegating it to commercial banking functions. After
India's independence in 1947, the Reserve Bank was nationalized and given
broader powers. In 1969 the government nationalized the 14 largest commercial
banks; the government nationalized the six next largest in 1980.
The Indian Banking industry, which is governed by the Banking Regulation Act
of India, 1949 can be broadly classified into two major categories, nonscheduled banks and scheduled banks. Scheduled banks comprise commercial
banks and the co-operative banks. In terms of ownership, commercial banks can
be further grouped into nationalized banks, the State Bank of India and its group
banks, regional rural banks and private sector banks (the old/ new domestic and
foreign). These banks have over 67,000 branches spread across the country.
The first phase of financial reforms resulted in the nationalization of 14 major
banks in 1969 and resulted in a shift from Class banking to Mass banking. This
in turn resulted in a significant growth in the geographical coverage of banks.
Every bank had to earmark a minimum percentage of their loan portfolio to
sectors identified as priority sectors. The manufacturing sector also grew
during the 1970s in protected environs and the banking sector was a critical
source. The next wave of reforms saw the nationalization of 6 more commercial
banks in 1980. Since then the number of scheduled commercial banks increased
four-fold and the number of bank branches increased eight-fold.
After the second phase of financial sector reforms and liberalization of the sector
in the early nineties, the Public Sector Banks (PSB) s found it extremely difficult
to compete with the new private sector banks and the foreign banks. The new
private sector banks first made their appearance after the guidelines permitting
them were issued in January 1993. Eight new private sector banks are presently
in operation. These banks due to their late start have access to state-of-the-art
technology, which in turn helps them to save on manpower costs and provide
better services.
During the year 2000, the State Bank of India (SBI) and its 7 associates
accounted for a 25 percent share in deposits and 28.1 percent share in credit. The
20 nationalized banks accounted for 53.2 percent of the deposits and 47.5
percent of credit during the same period. The share of foreign banks (numbering
42), regional rural banks and other scheduled commercial banks accounted for
5.7 percent, 3.9 percent and 12.2 percent respectively in deposits and 8.41
percent, 3.14 percent and 12.85 percent respectively in credit during the year
2000.
The RBI has been affecting bank rate and CRR cuts at regular intervals to
improve liquidity and reduce rates. The only exception was in July 2000 when
the RBI increased the Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR) to stem the fall in the rupee
against the dollar. The steady fall in the interest rates resulted in squeezed
margins for the banks in general.
Government initiatives
During 2008-09 (as per data up to November 18, 2008), as per RBI guidelines,
scheduled commercial banks (SCBs) increased their deposit rates for various
maturities by 50-175 basis points. The interest rates range offered by public
sector banks (PSBs) on deposits of maturity of one year to three years increased
to 9.00-10.50 per cent in November 2008 from 8.25-9.25 per cent in March
2008. On the lending side, the benchmark prime lending rates (BPLRs) of PSBs
increased to 13.00-14.75 per cent by November 2008 from 12.25-13.50 per cent
in March 2008. Private sector banks and foreign banks also increased their BPLR
to 13.00-17.75 per cent and 10.00-17.00 per cent from 13.00-16.50 per cent and
10.00-15.50 per cent, respectively, during the same period.
Accordingly, the weighted average BPLR of public sector banks, private sector
banks and foreign banks increased to 13.99 per cent, 16.42 per cent and 14.73
per cent, respectively. The number of automated teller machines (ATMs) has
risen and the usage of ATMs has gone up substantially during the last few years.
Use of other banks ATMs would also not attract any fee except when used for
cash withdrawal for which the maximum charge levied was brought down to US$
.409 per withdrawal by March 31, 2008. Further, all cash withdrawals from all
ATMs would be free with effect from April 1, 2009.
Bank initiatives
Since December 2008, the government has announced series of measures to
augment flow of credits to around US$ 2, 66,274 to SMEs. To improve the flow
of credit to industrial clusters and facilitate their overall development, 15 banks
operating in Orissa including the public sector State Bank of India (SBI) and the
industry is thereby now lending both strength and support in form of cash and
policies majorly in putting back the economy into track.
and thus
provided
some
response
to
competitive
pressures.
Some of the other regulatory initiatives relevant to Basel II that have been
implemented by the Reserve Bank are:
Ensuring that banks have a suitable risk management framework oriented
towards their requirements and dictated by the size and complexity of their
business, risk philosophy, market perceptions and expected level of capital.
Introducing Risk-Based Supervision (RBS) in select banks on a pilot basis.
Encouraging banks to formalise their CAAP in alignment with their business
plan and performance budgeting system. This, together with the adoption of
RBS, should aid in fulfilling the Pillar II requirements under Basel II.
Expanding the area of disclosures (Pillar III) so as to achieve greater
transparency regarding the financial position and risk profile of banks.
Building capacity to ensure the regulators ability to identify eligible banks and
permit them to adopt IRB/Advanced Measurement approaches.
With a view to ensuring migration to Basel II in a non-disruptive manner, a
consultative and participative approach has been adopted for both designing and
implementing the New Framework. A Steering Committee comprising senior
officials from 14 banks (public, private and foreign) with representation from the
Indian Banks Association and the Reserve Bank has been constituted. On the
basis of recommendations of the Steering Committee, draft guidelines on
implementation of the New Capital Adequacy Framework have been issued to
banks.
In order to assess the impact of Basel II adoption in various jurisdictions and recalibrate the proposals, the BCBS is currently undertaking the Fifth Quantitative
Impact Study (QIS 5). India will be participating in the study, and has selected
11 banks which form a representative sample for this purpose. These banks
account for 51.20 per cent of market share in terms of assets. They have been
advised to familiarise themselves with the QIS 5 requirements to enable them to
participate in the exercise effectively. The Reserve Bank is currently focusing on
the issue of recognition of the external rating agencies for use in the
Standardised Approach for credit risk.
As
well-established
risk
management
system
is
pre-requisite
for
the Framework and draw up a roadmap for migration to Basel II. The feedback
received from banks suggests that a few may be keen on implementing the
advanced approaches. However, not all are fully equipped to do so straightaway
and are, therefore, looking to migrate to the advanced approaches at a later date.
Basel II provides that banks should be allowed to adopt/migrate to advanced
approaches only with the specific approval of the supervisor, after ensuring that
they satisfy the minimum requirements specified in the Framework, not only at
the time of adoption/migration, but on a continuing basis. Hence, banks desirous
of adopting the advanced approaches must perform a stringent assessment of
their compliance with the minimum requirements before they shift gears to
migrate to these approaches. In this context, current non-availability of
acceptable and qualitative historical data relevant to internal credit risk ratings
and operational risk losses, along with the related costs involved in building up
and maintaining the requisite database, is expected to influence the pace of
migration to the advanced approaches available under Basel II.
Exposure Norms
The Reserve Bank has prescribed regulatory limits on banks exposure to
individual and group borrowers to avoid concentration of credit, and has advised
banks to fix limits on their exposure to specific industries or sectors (real estate)
to ensure better risk management. In addition, banks are also required to observe
certain statutory and regulatory limits in respect of their exposures to capital
markets.
Asset-Liability Management
In view of the growing need for banks to be able to identify, measure, monitor
and control risks, appropriate risk management guidelines have been issued from
time to time by the Reserve Bank, including guidelines on Asset-Liability
Management (ALM). These guidelines are intended to serve as a benchmark for
banks to establish an integrated risk management system. However, banks can
also develop their own systems compatible with type and size of operations as
well as risk perception and
put in place a proper system for covering the existing deficiencies and the
requisite upgrading. Detailed guidelines on the management of credit risk,
market risk, operational risk, etc. have also been issued to banks by the Reserve
Bank.
The progress made by the banks is monitored on a quarterly basis. With regard to
risk management techniques, banks are at different stages of drawing up a
comprehensive credit rating system, undertaking a credit risk assessment on a
half yearly basis, pricing loans on the basis of risk rating, adopting the RiskAdjusted Return on Capital (RAROC) framework of pricing, etc. Some banks
stipulate a quantitative ceiling on aggregate exposures in specified risk
categories, analyse rating-wise distribution of borrowers in various industries,
etc.
In respect of market risk, almost all banks have an Asset-Liability Management
Committee. They have articulated market risk management policies and
procedures, and have undertaken studies of behavioural maturity patterns of
various components of on-/off-balance sheet items.
NPL Management
Banks have been provided with a menu of options for disposal/recovery of NPLs
(non-performing
loans).
Banks
resolve/recover
their
NPLs
through
In the case of increasing net NPAs, structured actions will include, among other
things, undertaking a special drive to reduce the stock of NPAs and containing
the generation of fresh NPAs, reviewing the loan policy of the bank, taking steps
to upgrade credit appraisal skills and systems and to strengthen follow-up of
advances, including a loan review mechanism for large loans, following up suit
filed/ decreed debts effectively, putting in place proper credit risk management
policies/processes/procedures/prudential limits, reducing loan concentration, etc.
Discretionary action may include restrictions on capital expenditure, expansion
in staff, and increase of stake in subsidiaries. The Reserve Bank/Government
may take steps to change promoters/ ownership and may even take steps to
merge/amalgamate/liquidate the bank or impose a moratorium on it if its position
does not improve within an agreed period.
Technological Infrastructure
In recent years, the Reserve Bank has endeavoured to improve the efficiency of
the financial system by ensuring the presence of a safe, secure and effective
payment and settlement system. In the process, apart from performing regulatory
and oversight functions the Reserve Bank has also played an important role in
promoting the systems functionality and modernisation on an ongoing basis.
The
consolidation
of
the
existing
payment
systems
revolves
around
funding volatility ratio at -0.17 per cent as compared with a global range of
-0.17 to 0.11 per cent. The overall capital adequacy ratio of banks at end-March
2005 was 12.8 per cent as against the regulatory requirement of 9 per cent which
itself is higher than the Basel norm of 8 per cent. The capital adequacy ratio was
broadly comparable with the global range. There has been a marked
improvement in asset quality with the percentage of gross NPAs to gross
advances for the banking system declining from 14.4 per cent in 1998 to 5.2 per
cent in 2005. Globally, the NPL ratio varies widely from a low of 0.3 per cent to
3.0 per cent in developed economies, to over 10.0 per cent in several Latin
American economies. The reform measures have also resulted in an improvement
in the profitability of banks. RoA rose from 0.4 per cent in the year 1991-92 to
0.9 per cent in 2004-05. Considering that, globally, RoA was in the range -1.2 to
6.2 per cent for 2004, Indian banks are well placed. The banking sector reforms
have also emphasised the need to review manpower resources and rationalise
requirements by drawing up a realistic plan so as to reduce operating cost and
improve profitability. The cost to income ratio of 0.5 per cent for Indian banks
compares favourably with the global range of 0.46 per cent to 0.68 per cent and
vis-a-vis 0.48 per cent to 1.16 per cent for the worlds largest banks. In recent
years, the Indian economy has been undergoing a phase of high growth coupled
with internal and external stability characterised by price stability, fiscal
consolidation, overall balance of payments alignment, improvement in the
performance of financial institutions and stable financial market conditions and
the service sector taking an increasing share, enhanced competitiveness,
increased emphasis on infrastructure, improved market microstructure, an
enabling legislative environment and significant capital inflows. This has
provided the backdrop for a more sustained development of financial markets
and reform.
CHAPTER 3
concept of paying merchants using a card was invented in 1950 by Ralph Schneider and
Frank X. McNamara in order to consolidate multiple cards. The Diners Club, which was
created partially through a merger with Dine and Sign, produced the first "general
purpose" charge card, which is similar but required the entire bill to be paid with each
statement; it was followed shortly thereafter by American Express and Carte Blanche.
Western Union had begun issuing charge cards to its frequent customers in 1914.
Bank of America created the BankAmericard in 1958, a product which eventually
evolved into the Visa system ("Chargex" also became Visa). MasterCard came to being
in 1966 when a group of credit-issuing banks established Master Charge. The fractured
nature of the US banking system meant that credit cards became an effective way for
those who were travelling around the country to move their credit to places where they
could not directly use their banking facilities. In 1966 Barclaycard in the UK launched
the first credit card outside of the US.
There are now countless variations on the basic concept of revolving credit for
individuals (as issued by banks and honored by a network of financial institutions),
including organization-branded credit cards, corporate-user credit cards, store cards and
so on.
In contrast, although having reached very high adoption levels in the US, Canada and the
UK, it is important to note that many cultures were much more cash-oriented in the latter
half of the twentieth century, or had developed alternative forms of cash-less payments,
like Carte bleue, or the EC-card (Germany, France, Switzerland, among many others). In
these places, the take-up of credit cards was initially much slower. It took until the 1990s
to reach anything like the percentage market-penetration levels achieved in the US,
Canada or UK. In many countries acceptance still remains poor as the use of a credit card
system depends on the banking system being perceived as reliable.
In contrast, because of the legislative framework surrounding banking system overdrafts,
some countries, France in particular, were much faster to develop and adopt chip-based
credit cards which are now seen as major anti-fraud credit devices.
The design of the credit card itself has become a major selling point in recent years. The
value of the card to the issuer being related to the Customer's usage of the card. This has
led to the rise of Co-Brand and Affinity cards - where the cards design is related to the
"affinity" (a university, for example) leading to higher card usage. In most cases a
percentage of the value of the card is returned to the affinity group.
helps earn income by way of commission from its merchant establishments; the scheme
provided large scope for sale and increased turnover with assured and prompt payment.
In 1951, the Franklin National Bank in New York issued the first modern credit card.
Unsolicited credit cards were sent to prospective card-holders who were not subject to
credit screening prior to being sent a card. Merchants signed agreements to accept the
cards. When a purchase was made, the card-holder presented the card to the merchant,
who would copy the information on the merchants account at Franklin Bank in the
amount of the transactions, less the discount rate. If a purchase exceeded the merchants
floor limit, the merchant was required to call the bank for approval. Franklin National
Banks Credit Card programme was copied by hundreds of other banks in the late 1950s
and early 1960s.
The Bank of America issued Bank Americard in 1958 and eight years later, in 1966, the
banks comprising the Western State Bank Card Association issued the Master Charge
Card. Bank America and Master charge card became the focal points for the eventual
groupings of all bank cards throughout the world. The VISA and the MASTER the
largest credit cards today appeared in market in 1966. These two international cards are
very popular and are accepted and honored all over the world in 170 countries. These
two independent card companies led to latest innovations in the credit card business.
Now the credit card system has become universally popular throughout the world
including the Communist countries. At the end of 1995 and 1980 a million cards were
used in the world. The total number of credit card users in India is currently in excess of
80 lakh and now more than 30 banks are chasing customers with their cards.
A credit card allows consumers to purchase products or services without cash and to pay
for them at a later date. To qualify for this type of credit, the consumer must open an
account with a bank or company, which sponsors a card. They then receive a line of
credit with a specified dollar amount. They can use the card to make purchases from
participating merchants until they reach this credit limit. Every month the sponsor
provides a bill, which tallies the card activity during the previous 30 days. Depending on
the terms of the card, the customer may pay interest charges on the amount that they do
not pay for on a monthly basis. Also, credit cards may be sponsored by large retailers
handling the counter swipes the card into the system to check the details of the card and
you need to sign on the bill. The payment is done electronically. With only a signature
your payment is taken care of. Isnt it very simple?
Yes it is, but everyone isnt eligible for a credit card. There are certain requirements,
varying across banks, to get a credit card. Typically credit card companies (or issuing
banks, as they are known) require the applicant to have a minimum income level before
he can apply for the card. Proof of income is given by way of documents. These
documents could be a copy of tax return filed; salary slips if applicable, balance sheet
and profit and loss account detail if you are self-employed. These serve as the starting
point while applying for a card. The minimum income level varies from bank to bank
and fluctuates between Rs 60,000 - 150,000 per annum depending upon your risk profile
and the type of card. This requirement helps the issuing bank to assess whether or not
you will be able to repay the expenses incurred through your credit card. In addition to
income eligibility, you need to be at least 21 years of age (maximum 65 years).
There is no doubt that credit cards are very convenient, especially in case of daily
expenses. In addition you earn bonus points while you spend via the card. It is because of
these reasons that in the recent past card usage has increased dramatically. In fact, plastic
currency has almost wiped off hard currency from the US, resulting in far less
expenditure associated with cash transactions.
Currently, four major bishops are ruling the card empire - Citibank, Standard Chartered
Bank, HSBC and State Bank of India (SBI). The industry, which is catering to over 3.8
million1 card users, is expected to double by the fiscal 2003. According to a study
conducted by State Bank of India, Citibank is the dominant player, having issued 1.5
million cards so far. Standard Chartered Bank follows way behind with 0.67 million,
while Hongkong Bank has 0.3 million credit card customers. Among the nationalized
banks, SBI tops the list with 0.28 million cards, followed by Bank of Baroda at 0.22
million.
The credit card market in India, which started out in 1981, is on the verge of an
unprecedented boom. Between 1987 and 2000, the market has virtually grown to over
3.8 million cards with almost 25-30 per cent growth in new card-holders.
India is generating more credit card spenders than spending places. While card-base and
appends are growing at a spiffy 25-30 per cent2 annually, the number of merchant
establishments which accept cards is growing selectively sluggish. The figure was put at
75,00080,000 a couple of years ago, and now stands at 100,000 on both the Visa and
MasterCard loops. As opposed to that, there are 2.5 million card-holders and 3.3 million
cards (some, obviously, have more than one) and the numbers are growing very strongly.
The seven million Indian credit card industry has been growing over 25 per cent3
annually and has now more than 30 banks chasing customers with their cards. Still, credit
cards in India have made business sense only to a few.
The annual growth rate is good, but it is only 20 per cent of the card base, that is
generating revenue, says Roopan Asthana, manager, Card Products Division of HSBC.
Nearly 45-50 per cent of the card-holders are estimated to be inactive, while another 30
per cent use the card as a charge card without using the revolving facility cards are
expected to account for 33 per cent of all purchases by 2000 and 43 per cent by 2005.
The credit card embodies two essential aspects of the basic banking function - the
transmission of payments and the granting of credit. Therefore, in its true sense, a credit
card must offer the opinion of revolving credit. This is very akin to the overdraft facility
offered by banks to their account holders. A credit card holder does not necessarily have
to settle his entire account at the end of the month for he has the option to make partial
payment in subsequent months. In fact, when the card-holder makes the full payment at
the end of the month he is said to be using his credit card as a charge card. Incidentally,
the interest paid by the card-holder on the credit utilized by him is what makes the
business of credit cards profitable from the point of view of the bank issuing the card.
Indians are still not sure of the plastic money. Credit cards spend as a proportion of the
total expenditure by Indians is one of the lowest in the world. While Indians swiped
plastic money worth $6 billion in 2006, credit card users in Korea cumulatively spent
$136 billion.
Indians spend just 1% of their total purchases through credit cards while the Koreans
make one-fifth of their total purchases through credit cards. The world average hovers
around 9%.
The very low levels of penetration in India offer immense potential for credit card
companies. Also, there are fewer credit card companies than those in other parts of the
world. The high growth in spending is attracting a lot of entrants into the segment. What
is drawing a large number of companies and financial institutions including Life
Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) to India is the 61% year-on-year growth being
witnessed in retail spending, the highest in the world.
Interestingly, even among the rich, credit card ownership in India is the lowest in the
world. While 90% of the affluent in Hong Kong have credit cards and the corresponding
figure for Sydney stands at 87%, in India, only 28% of the affluent have credit card.
Manila, Jakarta, Taipei , Hong Kong have 48-76% of the affluent population owning
credit cards, according to Visa research in Asia. Seoul has 84% of its affluent population
owning a credit card. Korea, however, has a history of defaults on credit cards where the
government had to bail out the credit card companies.
Sources in the industry say with such low penetration levels there are at least half a
dozen companies that are looking to roll out credit card operations in India. AIG,
Barclays, and LIC are some of the companies eager to enter the Indian market. Punjab
National Bank (PNB) is also learnt to be in negotiations to launch another credit card.
Banks / NBFCs should independently assess the credit risk while issuing cards to
persons, especially to students and others with no independent financial means. Add-on
cards i.e. those that are subsidiary to the principal card, may be issued with the clear
understanding that the liability will be that of the principal cardholder.
b. As holding several credit cards enhances the total credit available to any consumer,
banks / NBFCs should assess the credit limit for a credit card customer having regard to
the limits enjoyed by the cardholder from other banks on the basis of self declaration/
credit information.
c. The card issuing banks / NBFCs would be solely responsible for fulfilment of all KYC
requirements, even where DSAs / DMAs or other agents solicit business on their
behalf.
d.
While issuing cards, the terms and conditions for issue and usage of a credit card
should be mentioned in clear and simple language (preferably in English, Hindi and the
local language) comprehensible to a card user. The Most Important Terms and
Conditions (MITCs) termed as standard set of conditions, as given in the Appendix,
should be highlighted and advertised/ sent separately to the prospective customer/
customers at all the stages i.e. during marketing, at the time of application, at the
acceptance stage (welcome kit) and in important subsequent communications.
this would not be applicable to charges like service taxes, etc. which may subsequently
be levied by the Government or any other statutory authority.
d. The terms and conditions for payment of credit card dues, including the minimum
payment due, should be stipulated so as to ensure that there is no negative amortization.
e. Changes in charges (other than interest) may be made only with prospective effect giving
notice of at least one month. If a credit card holder desires to surrender his credit card on
account of any change in credit card charges to his disadvantage, he may be permitted to
do so without the bank levying any extra charge for such closure.
Wrongful billing
a. The card issuing bank / NBFC should ensure that wrong bills are not raised and issued to
customers. In case, a customer protests any bill, the bank / NBFC should provide
explanation and, if necessary, documentary evidence to the customer within a maximum
period of sixty days with a spirit to amicably redress the grievances.
b. To obviate frequent complaints of delayed billing, the credit card issuing bank / NBFC
may consider providing bills and statements of accounts online, with suitable security
built therefore.
c. The bank / NBFC should have a system of random checks and mystery shopping to
ensure that their agents have been properly briefed and trained in order to handle with
care and caution their responsibilities, particularly in the aspects included in these
guidelines like soliciting customers, hours for calling, privacy of customer information,
conveying the correct terms and conditions of the product on offer, etc.
Redressal of Grievances
a. Generally, a time limit of sixty (60) days may be given to the customers for preferring
their complaints grievances.
b.
The card issuing bank / NBFC should constitute Grievance Redressal machinery within
the bank / NBFC and give wide publicity about it through electronic and print media.
The name and contact number of designated grievance redressal officer of the bank /
NBFC should be mentioned on the credit card bills. The designated officer should ensure
that genuine grievances of credit card subscribers are redressed promptly without
involving delay.
c. The grievance redressal procedure of the bank / NBFC and the time frame fixed for
responding to the complaints should be placed on the bank / NBFC's website. The name,
designation, address and contact number of important executives as well as the
Grievance Redressal Officer of the bank / NBFC may be displayed on the website. There
should be a system of acknowledging customers' complaints for follow up, such as
complaint number / docket number, even if the complaints are received on phone.
d.
If a complainant does not get satisfactory response from the bank / NBFC within a
maximum period of thirty (30) days from the date of his lodging the complaint, he will
have the option to approach the Office of the concerned Banking Ombudsman for
redressal of his grievance/s. The bank / NBFC shall be liable to compensate the
complainant for the loss of his time, expenses, financial loss as well as for the
harassment and mental anguish suffered by him for the fault of the bank and where the
grievance has not been redressed in time.
With a view to ensuring that the quality of customer service is ensured on an on-going
basis in banks / NBFCs, the Standing Committee on Customer Service in each bank /
NBFC may review on a monthly basis the credit card operations including reports of
defaulters to the CIBIL, credit card related complaints and take measures to improve the
services and ensure the orderly growth in the credit card operations. Banks / NBFCs
should put up detailed quarterly analysis of credit card related complaints to their Top
Management. Card issuing banks should have in place a suitable monitoring mechanism
to randomly check the genuineness of merchant transactions.
2.
EMV chip
3.
Hologram
4.
Card number
5.
6.
Expiry Date
7.
Cardholder's name
Magnetic Stripe
2.
Signature Strip
3.
number (PIN). Also, many merchants now accept verbal authorizations via telephone and
electronic authorization using the Internet, known as a Card not present (CNP)
transaction.
Electronic verification systems allow merchants to verify that the card is valid and the
credit card customer has sufficient credit to cover the purchase in a few seconds,
allowing the verification to happen at time of purchase. The verification is performed
using a credit card payment terminal or Point of Sale (POS) system with a
communications link to the merchant's acquiring bank. Data from the card is obtained
from a magnetic stripe or chip on the card; the latter system is in the United Kingdom
commonly known as Chip and PIN, but is more technically an EMV card.
Other variations of verification systems are used by ecommerce merchants to determine
if the user's account is valid and able to accept the charge. These will typically involve
the cardholder providing additional information, such as the security code printed on the
back of the card, or the address of the cardholder.
Each month, the credit card user is sent a statement indicating the purchases undertaken
with the card, any outstanding fees, and the total amount owed. After receiving the
statement, the cardholder may dispute any charges that he or she thinks are incorrect (see
Fair Credit Billing Act for details of the US regulations). Otherwise, the cardholder must
pay a defined minimum proportion of the bill by a due date, or may choose to pay a
higher amount up to the entire amount owed. The credit provider charges interest on the
amount owed (typically at a much higher rate than most other forms of debt). Some
financial institutions can arrange for automatic payments to be deducted from the user's
bank accounts.
Credit card issuers usually waive interest charges if the balance is paid in full each
month, but typically will charge full interest on the entire outstanding balance from the
date of each purchase if the total balance is not paid.
For example, if a user had a $1,000 outstanding balance and pays it in full, there would
be no interest charged. If, however, even $1.00 of the total balance remained unpaid,
interest would be charged on the $1,000 from the date of purchase until the payment is
received. The precise manner in which interest is charged is usually detailed in a
cardholder agreement which may be summarized on the back of the monthly statement.
The general calculation formula most financial institutions use to determine the amount
of interest to be charged is APR/100 x ADB/365 x number of days revolved. Take the
Annual percentage rate (APR) and divide by 100 then multiply to the amount of the
average daily balance divided by 365 and then take this total and multiply by the total
number of days the amount revolved before payment was made on the account.
Financial institutions refer to interest charged back to the original time of the transaction
and up to the time a payment was made, if not in full, as RRFC or residual retail finance
charge. Thus after an amount has revolved and a payment has been made that the user of
the card will still receive interest charges on their statement after paying the next
statement in full (in fact the statement may only have a charge for interest that collected
up until the date the full balance was paid...i.e. when the balance stopped revolving).
The credit card may simply serve as a form of revolving credit, or it may become a
complicated financial instrument with multiple balance segments each at a different
interest rate, possibly with a single umbrella credit limit, or with separate credit limits
applicable to the various balance segments. Usually this compartmentalization is the
result of special incentive offers from the issuing bank, either to encourage balance
transfers from cards of other issuers, or to encourage more spending on the part of the
customer. In the event that several interest rates apply to various balance segments,
payment allocation is generally at the discretion of the issuing bank, and payments will
therefore usually be allocated towards the lowest rate balances until paid in full before
any money is paid towards higher rate balances.
Interest rates can vary considerably from card to card, and the interest rate on a particular
card may jump dramatically if the card user is late with a payment on that card or any
other credit instrument, or even if the issuing bank decides to raise its revenue. As the
rates and terms vary, services have been set up allowing users to calculate savings
available by switching cards, which can be considerable if there is a large outstanding
balance (see external links for some on-line services.
Because of intense competition in the credit card industry, credit providers often offer
incentives such as frequent flier points, gift certificates, or cash back (typically up to 1
percent based on total purchases) to try to attract customers to their program.
Low interest credit cards or even 0% interest credit cards are available. The only
downside to consumers is that the period of low interest credit cards is limited to a fixed
term, usually between 6 and 12 months after which a higher rate is charged. However,
services are available which alert credit card holders when their low interest period is due
to expire. Most such services charge a monthly or annual fee.
Grace period
A credit card's grace period is the time the customer has to pay the balance before interest
is charged to the balance. Grace periods vary, but usually range from 20 to 30 days
depending on the type of credit card and the issuing bank. Some policies allow for
reinstatement after certain conditions are met. Usually, if a customer is late paying the
balance, finance charges will be calculated and the grace period does not apply. Finance
charge(s) incurred depends on the grace period and balance, with most credit cards there
is no grace period if there's any outstanding balance from the previous billing cycle or
statement (i.e. interest is applied on both the previous balance and new transactions).
However, there are some credit cards that will only apply finance charge on the previous
or old balance, excluding new transactions.
Parties involved
Cardholder: The owner of the card used to make a purchase; the consumer.
Card-issuing bank: The financial institution or other organization that issued the credit
card to the cardholder. This bank bills the consumer for repayment and bears the risk that
the card is used fraudulently. American Express and Discover were previously the only
card-issuing banks for their respective brands, but as of 2007, this is no longer the case.
Merchant: The individual or business accepting credit card payments for products or
services sold to the cardholder
Acquiring bank: The financial institution accepting payment for the products or
services on behalf of the merchant.
Merchant account provider: This could refer to the acquiring bank or the independent
sales organization, but in general is the organization that the merchant deals with.
Transaction network: The system that implements the mechanics of the electronic
transactions. May be operated by an independent company, and one company may
operate multiple networks. Transaction processing networks include: Cardnet, Nabanco,
Omaha, Paymentech, NDC Atlanta, Nova, Vital, Concord EFSnet, and VisaNet.
Affinity partner: Some institutions lend their name to an issuer to attract customers that
have a strong relationship with that institution, and get paid a fee or a percentage of the
balance for each card issued using their name. Examples of typical affinity partners are
sports teams, universities and charities.
The flow of information and money between these parties always through the card
associations is known as the interchange, and it consists of a few steps.
Transaction steps
Authorization: In the event of a chargeback (when there's an error in processing the
transaction or the cardholder disputes the transaction), the issuer returns the transaction
to the acquirer for resolution. The acquirer then forwards the chargeback to the merchant,
who must either accept the chargeback or contest it.
at the request of the customer or due to severe delinquency (150 to 180 days). This
means that an account which is less than 150 days delinquent will continue to accrue
interest and fees, and could result in a balance which is much higher than the actual
credit limit on the card. In these cases the total debt may far exceed the original deposit
and the cardholder not only forfeits their deposit but is left with an additional debt.
Most of these conditions are usually described in a cardholder agreement which the
cardholder signs when their account is opened.
Secured credit cards are an option to allow a person with a poor credit history or no
credit history to have a credit card which might not otherwise be available. They are
often offered as a means of rebuilding one's credit. Secured credit cards are available
with both Visa and MasterCard logos on them. Fees and service charges for secured
credit cards often exceed those charged for ordinary non-secured credit cards, however,
for people in certain situations, (for example, after charging off on other credit cards, or
people with a long history of delinquency on various forms of debt), secured cards can
often be less expensive in total cost than unsecured credit cards, even including the
security deposit.
Sometimes a credit card will be secured by the equity in the borrower's home. This is
called a home equity line of credit (HELOC).
The main advantage over secured credit cards is that you are not required to come up
with $500 or more to open an account. Also most secured credit cards still charge you
interest even though you are not actually "borrowing" any money. With prepaid credit
cards you are not charged any interest but you are often charged monthly fees after an
arbitrary time period. Many other fees also usually apply to a prepaid card.
Prepaid credit cards are often marketed to teenagers for shopping online without having
their parents complete the transaction.
Because of the many fees that apply to obtaining and using credit-card-branded prepaid
cards, the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada describes them as "an expensive way
to spend your own money". The agency publishes a booklet, "Pre-paid cards", which
explains the advantages and disadvantages of this type of prepaid card.
Features
As well as convenient, accessible credit, credit cards offer consumers an easy way to
track expenses, which is necessary for both monitoring personal expenditures and the
tracking of work-related expenses for taxation and reimbursement purposes. Credit cards
are accepted worldwide, and are available with a large variety of credit limits, repayment
arrangement, and other perks (such as rewards schemes in which points earned by
purchasing goods with the card can be redeemed for further goods and services or credit
card cashback).
Some countries, such as the United States, the United Kingdom, and France, limit the
amount for which a consumer can be held liable due to fraudulent transactions as a result
of a consumer's credit card being lost or stolen.
Security
A smart card, combining credit card and debit card properties. The 3 by 5 mm security chip
embedded in the card is shown enlarged in the inset. The gold contact pads on the card enable
electronic access to the chip.
The low security of the credit card system presents countless opportunities for fraud.
This opportunity has created a huge black market in stolen credit card numbers, which
are generally used quickly before the cards are reported stolen.
The goal of the credit card companies is not to eliminate fraud, but to "reduce it to
manageable levels", such that the total cost of both fraud and fraud prevention is
minimized. This implies that high-cost low-return fraud prevention measures will not be
used if their cost exceeds the potential gains from fraud reduction.
Most internet fraud is done through the use of stolen credit card information which is
obtained in many ways, the simplest being copying information from retailers, either
online or offline. Despite efforts to improve security for remote purchases using credit
cards, systems with security holes are usually the result of poor implementations of card
acquisition by merchants. For example, a website that uses SSL to encrypt card numbers
from a client may simply email the number from the web server to someone who
manually processes the card details at a card terminal.
Naturally, anywhere card details become human-readable before being processed at the
acquiring bank, a security risk is created. However, many banks offer systems such as
Clear Commerce, where encrypted card details captured on a merchant's web server can
be sent directly to the payment processor.
Controlled Payment Numbers are another option for protecting one's credit card number:
they are "alias" numbers linked to one's actual card number, generated as needed, valid
for a relatively short time, with a very low limit, and typically only valid with a single
merchant.
The Federal Bureau of Investigation and U.S. Postal Inspection Service are responsible
for prosecuting criminals who engage in credit card fraud in the United States, but they
do not have the resources to pursue all criminals. In general, federal officials only
prosecute cases exceeding US $5000 in value. Three improvements to card security have
been introduced to the more common credit card networks but none has proven to help
reduce credit card fraud so far. First, the on-line verification system used by merchants is
being enhanced to require a 4 digit Personal Identification Number (PIN) known only to
the card holder. Second, the cards themselves are being replaced with similar-looking
tamper-resistant smart cards which are intended to make forgery more difficult. The
majority of smartcard (IC card) based credit cards comply with the EMV (Europay
MasterCard Visa) standard. Third, an additional 3 or 4 digit code is now present on the
back of most cards, for use in "card not present" transactions. See CVV2 for more
information.
The way credit card owners pay off their balances has a tremendous effect on their credit
history. All the information is collected by credit bureaus. The credit information stays on
the credit report, depending on the jurisdiction and the situation, for 1, 2, 5, 7 or even 10
years after the debt is repaid.
Costs
Credit card issuers (banks) have several types of costs:
Interest expenses
Banks generally borrow the money they then lend to their customers. As they receive
very low-interest loans from other firms, they may borrow as much as their customers
require, while lending their capital to other borrowers at higher rates. If the card issuer
charges 15% on money lent to users, and it costs 5% to borrow the money to lend, and
the balance sits with the cardholder for a year, the issuer earns 10% on the loan. This 5%
difference is the "interest expense" and the 10% is the "net interest margin".
Operating costs
This is the cost of running the credit card portfolio, including everything from paying the
executives who run the company to printing the plastics, to mailing the statements, to
running the computers that keep track of every cardholder's balance, to taking the many
phone calls which cardholders place to their issuer, to protecting the customers from
fraud rings. Depending on the issuer, marketing programs are also a significant portion of
expenses.
Charge offs
When a consumer becomes severely delinquent on a debt (often at the point of six
months without payment), the creditor may declare the debt to be a charge-off. It will
then be listed as such on the debtor's credit bureau reports (Equifax, for instance, lists
"R9" in the "status" column to denote a charge-off.) It is one of the worst possible items
to have on your file. The item will include relevant dates, and the amount of the bad debt.
A charge-off is considered to be "written off as uncollectable." To banks, bad debts and
even fraud are simply part of the cost of doing business.
However, the debt is still legally valid, and the creditor can attempt to collect the full
amount. This includes contacts from internal collections staff, or more likely, an outside
collection agency. If the amount is large (generally over $1500 - $2000), there is the
possibility of a lawsuit or arbitration.
In the US, as the charge off number climbs or becomes erratic, officials from the Federal
Reserve take a close look at the finances of the bank and may impose various operating
strictures on the bank, and in the most extreme cases, may close the bank entirely.
Rewards
Qantas Frequent Flyer co-branded credit cards
Many credit card customers receive rewards, such as frequent flier points, gift
certificates, or cash back as an incentive to use the card. Rewards are generally tied to
purchasing an item or service on the card, which may or may not include balance
transfers, cash advances, or other special uses. Depending on the type of card, rewards
will generally cost the issuer between 0.25% and 2.0% of the spend. Networks like Visa
or MasterCard have increased their fees to allow issuers to fund their rewards system.
However, most rewards points are accrued as a liability on a company's balance sheet
and expensed at the time of reward redemption. As a result, some issuers discourage
redemption by forcing the cardholder to call customer service for rewards.
On their servicing website, redeeming awards is usually a feature that is very well hidden
by the issuers. Others encourage redemption for lower cost merchandise; instead of an
airline ticket, which is very expensive to an issuer, the cardholder may be encouraged to
redeem for a gift certificate instead. With a fractured and competitive environment,
rewards points cut dramatically into an issuer's bottom line, and rewards points and
related incentives must be carefully managed to ensure a profitable portfolio. There is a
case to be made that rewards not redeemed should follow the same path as gift cards that
are not used: in certain states the gift card breakage goes to the state's treasury. The same
could happen to the value of points or cash not redeemed.
Fraud
Where a card is stolen, or an unauthorized duplicate made, most card issuers will refund
some or all of the charges that the customer has received for things they did not buy.
These refunds will, in some cases, be at the expense of the merchant, especially in mail
order cases where the merchant cannot claim sight of the card. In several countries,
merchants will lose the money if no ID card was asked for, therefore merchants usually
require ID card in these countries.
The cost of fraud is high; in the UK in 2004 it was over 500 million. Credit card
companies generally guarantee the merchant will be paid on legitimate transactions
regardless of whether the consumer pays their credit card bill.
"Soft fraud" is fraud committed by the customer himself: getting a card and using it with
no intention ever to repay the balance. Such customers are called "diabolicals" by the
credit card companies that try to avoid them at all cost.
Security
An additional feature to secure the credit card transaction and prohibit the use of a lost
credit card is the MobiClear solution. Each transaction is authenticated through a call to
the user mobile phone. The transaction is released once the transaction has been
confirmed by the cardholder pushing his/her pin code during the call.
Revenues
Offsetting costs are the following revenues:
Interchange fees
Interchange fees are charged by the merchant's acquirer to a card-accepting merchant as
component of the so-called merchant discount rate (also referred to as "merchant service
fee"). The merchant pays a merchant discount fee that is typically 2 to 3 percent (this is
negotiated, but will vary not only from merchant to merchant, but also from card to card,
with business cards and rewards cards generally costing the merchants more to process),
which is why some merchants prefer cash, debit cards, or even cheques. The majority of
this fee, called the interchange fee, goes to the issuing bank, but parts of it go to the
processing network, the card association (American Express, Visa, MasterCard, etc.), and
the merchant's acquirer. With a corporate card, the interchange is also often shared by the
Company in whose name the card is issued as an incentive to use that issuer's card
instead of someone else's.
The interchange fee that applies to a particular merchant is a function of many variables
including the type of merchant, the merchant's average transaction amount, whether the
cards are physically present, if the card's magnetic stripe is read or if the transaction is
hand-keyed or entered on a website, the specific type of card, when the transaction is
settled, the authorized and settled transaction amounts, etc. For a typical credit card
issuer, interchange fee revenues may represent about fifteen percent of total revenues, but
this will vary greatly with the type of customers represented in their portfolio. Customers
who carry high balances may generate low interchange revenue due to credit line
limitations, while customers who use their cards for business and spend hundreds of
thousands of dollars a year on their cards while paying off balances every month will
have very healthy interchange revenues.
Note that for some banks, even if you had paid it off an outstanding balance along with
interest fees, for the next two months, they will also charge you interest rates for
anything you had purchased.
Late payments
Charges that result in exceeding the credit limit on the card (whether done deliberately
or by mistake), called over limit fees
Returned cheque fees or payment processing fees (e.g. phone payment fee)
Purchase products or services whenever and wherever you want, without ready cash
centres.
Enjoy a revolving credit limit without any charges for a limited period (mostly 20 to
50 days)
Transact money of more than one currency, from one country to another.
Other facilities afforded on a credit card include reward points on card usage,
insurance cover against air and road accidents, loss of baggage, and so on. All credit
cards have built-in safety features like signatures and personal identification numbers.
International credit cards you financial flexibility when you travel abroad.
Advantages:
They allow you to make purchases on credit without carrying around a lot of cash.
statement.
They allow convenient remote purchasing - ordering/shopping online or by phone.
They allow you to pay for large purchases in small, monthly instalments.
Under certain circumstances, they allow you to withhold payment for merchandise
Disadvantages:
You may become an impulsive buyer and tend to overspend because of the ease of
using credit cards. Cards can encourage the purchasing of goods and services you
carefully, especially because of the high interest rates and other costs.
Lost or stolen cards may result in some unwanted expense and inconvenience.
The use of a large number of credit cards can get you even further into debt.
Using a credit card, especially remotely, introduces an element of risk as the card
details may fall into the wrong hands resulting in fraudulent purchases on the card.
Fraudulent or unauthorized charges may take months to dispute, investigate, and
resolve.
CHAPTER 4
CURRENT SCENARIO
Banking scenario
The industry is currently in a transition phase. On the one hand, the PSBs, which are the
mainstay of the Indian Banking system, are in the process of shedding their flab in terms
of excessive manpower, excessive non Performing Assets (Npas) and excessive
governmental equity, while on the other hand the private sector banks are consolidating
themselves through mergers and acquisitions.
PSBs, which currently account for more than 78 percent of total banking industry assets
are saddled with NPAs (a mind-boggling Rs 830 billion in 2000), falling revenues from
traditional sources, lack of modern technology and a massive workforce while the new
private sector banks are forging ahead and rewriting the traditional banking business
model by way of their sheer innovation and service. The PSBs are of course currently
working out challenging strategies even as 20 percent of their massive employee strength
has dwindled in the wake of the successful Voluntary Retirement Schemes (VRS)
schemes.
The private players however cannot match the PSBs great reach, great size and access to
low cost deposits. Therefore one of the means for them to combat the PSBs has been
through the merger and acquisition (M& A) route. Over the last two years, the industry
has witnessed several such instances. For instance, Hdfc Banks merger with Times
Bank, Icici Banks acquisition of ITC Classic, Anagram Finance and Bank of Madura.
Centurion Bank, Indusind Bank, Bank of Punjab, Vysya Bank are said to be on the
lookout. The UTI bank- Global Trust Bank merger however opened a pandoras box and
brought about the realization that all was not well in the functioning of many of the
private sector banks.
Private sector Banks have pioneered internet banking, phone banking, anywhere
banking, mobile banking, debit cards, Automatic Teller Machines (ATMs) and combined
various other services and integrated them into the mainstream banking arena, while the
PSBs are still grappling with disgruntled employees in the aftermath of successful VRS
schemes.
According to a report by McKinsey and NASSCOM, India has the potential to process
30 per cent of the banking transactions in the US by the year 2010. Outsourcing by the
BFSI to India is expected to grow at an annual rate of 3035 per cent.
According to a study by Dun & Bradstreet (an international research body)"India's Top
Banks 2008"there has been a significant growth in the banking infrastructure. Taking
into account all banks in India, there are overall 56,640 branches or offices, 893,356
employees and 27,088 ATMs. Public sector banks made up a large chunk of the
infrastructure, with 87.7 per cent of all offices, 82 per cent of staff and 60.3 per cent of
all ATMs.
According to the RBI, Indian financial markets have generally remained orderly during
2008-09. In view of the tight liquidity conditions in the domestic money markets in
September 2008, the Reserve Bank announced a series of measures beginning September
16, 2008. Thus, the average call rate which was at 10.52 per cent declined to 7.57 per
cent in November 2008 under the impact of these measures.
Measures aimed at expanding the rupee liquidity, included significant reduction in the
cash reserve ratio (CRR), reduction of the statutory liquidity ratio (SLR), opening a
special repo window under the liquidity adjustment facility (LAF) for banks for onlending to the non-banking financial companies (NBFCs), housing finance companies
(HFCs) and mutual funds (MFs), and extending a special refinance facility, which banks
could access without any collateral.
Banking capital (net) amounted to US$ 4.8 billion in April-September 2008 as compared
with US$ 5.7 billion in April-September 2007. Among the components of banking
capital, non-resident Indian (NRI) deposits witnessed a net inflow of US$ 1.1 billion in
April-September 2008, a turnaround from net outflow of US$ 78 million in AprilSeptember 2007.
The reserve money lying with the RBI as on November 21, 2008 as per the January 2009
bulletin, is a total amount of US$ 179.28 billion and RBIs credit to the commercial
sector stood at US$ 3.65 billion. Further, banks in India put up strong growth and profit
numbers in the October-end-December 2008 period owing to high credit growth and
easing of yield on government bonds. Top Indian banks have increased their earnings by
almost 40 per cent year-on-year for the same period. According to latest Reserve Bank of
India (RBI) data, bank credit grew by 24.6 per cent year-on-year as of December 19,
2008. The resulting credit growth was even better at 41 per cent during the April-endDecember 2008 period. Deposits grew by 20.6 per cent as of December 19, 2008.
The growth in advances reflects that the net interest income (NIM) too would indicate
higher growth rate. RBI has taken a number of steps to lower the cost of credit in this
quarter like cutting cash reserve ratio (CRR), the amount of funds banks have to keep on
deposit with it, repo and reverse repo rate. The CRR rate, which had been reduced in
December 2008, to 5.50 per cent, repo rate to 6.50 and reverse repo rate to 5.00, were
further reduced CRR to 5 per cent, (its lending rate) repo rate to 5.5 per cent and
reverse repo, at which it absorbs cash from the banking system, to 4 per cent in January
2009.
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI), as the central bank of the country, closely monitors
Higher provisioning norms, tighter asset classification norms, dispensing with the
concept of past due for recognition of NPAs, lowering of ceiling on exposure to a single
borrower and group exposure etc., are among the important measures in order to improve
recommendations.
Retail Banking is the new mantra in the banking sector. The home loans alone account
for nearly two-third of the total retail portfolio of the bank. According to one estimate,
the retail segment is expected to grow at 30-40% in the coming years.
Net banking, phone banking, mobile banking, ATMs and bill payments are the new buzz
credit institutions. SBI and Hdfc are the promoters of the Cibil.
The RBI is now planning to transfer of its stakes in the SBI, NHB and National Bank for
Agricultural and Rural Development to the private players. Also, the Government has
sought to lower its holding in PSBs to a minimum of 33 per cent of total capital by
Growth of Banks
HDFC Bank and Axis Bank continue to remain as leaders of the private sector banks.
Both the banks have maintained the advances growth and NIM. SBI, Punjab National
Bank, Bank of India and Union Bank are expected to lead among PSU Banks.
The State Bank of India is planning to open 1,000 new branches across the country to
cover 100,000 villages in the coming FY 2009-10, according to the bank Chairman, Mr
O P Bhatt. The bank had decided to rope in 300 new customers every year for each
branch using initiatives. According to Mr Bhatt, the bank could get a record US$ 5.54
billion during December 2008, the highest amount collected by any bank in the country.
Further, public sector banks (PSBs) on January 12, 2009 also decided to lower interest
rates on bulk deposits and to offer a maximum rate of 7.5 per cent for one-year maturity.
Earlier, on January 1, banks had lowered the interest rates on bulk deposits from 9.5 per
cent to 8.5 per cent. According to the latest RBI data, growth in broad money (M3), yearon-year (y-o-y), was 19.6 per cent (US$ 151.04 billion) on January 2, 2009 lower than
22.6 per cent (US$ 141.82 billion) a year ago. Aggregate deposits of banks, year-on-year,
expanded 20.2 per cent (US$ 133.08 billion) on January 2, 2009 as compared with 24.0
per cent (US$ 127.49 billion) a year ago.
The growth in bank credit continued to remain high. Non-food credit by scheduled
commercial banks (SCBs) was 23.9 per cent (US$ 102.78 billion), year-on-year, as on
January 2, 2009 from 22.0 per cent (US$ 77.79 billion) a year ago. Scheduled
commercial banks credit to the commercial sector expanded by 27.0 per cent (year-onyear) as on November 21, 2008, as compared with 23.1 per cent a year ago. Non-food
credit of scheduled commercial banks expanded by 26.9 per cent, year-on-year, as on
November 21, 2008, higher than 23.7 per cent a year ago.
According to earlier RBI data, for the third quarter (September 26-December 27, 2008),
total bank credit was up US$ 21.91 billion compared with a growth of US$ 22.91 billion
in the same period a year ago. In the preceding quarter, credit had risen by US$ 26.50
billion.
RBI data for deposits shows that for the Oct-end December 31, 2008 period, although
deposit growth has slowed to US$ 25.99 billion against US$ 33.18 billion in the April-
end to September, 2008 period, it was still stronger in the December 31 quarter period,
2008, as compared to the year-ago quarter when absolute growth was US$ 16.37 billion.
Net banking capital amounted to US$ 4.8 billion in April-September 2008 as compared
with US$ 5.7 billion in April-September 2007. Accounting for a part of banking capital,
non-resident Indian (NRI) deposits showed a net inflow of US $ 1.1 billion in AprilSeptember 2008, increasing from net outflow of US$ 78 million in April-September
2007.
Lending by banks also rose more than 76 per cent to Rs 2,80,000 crore (US$ 57.26
billion) during April-November 2008-09 from the same period a year ago, according to
data available with the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). The Reserve Bank of India on
January 21, 2009 fixed the Reference rate for the US currency at Rs 48.93 per dollar and
the single European unit at Rs 63.70 per euro from Rs 49.12 per dollar and Rs 63.61 per
euro, respectively.
Industry Spend
With over 141 lakh credit cards in use in India, the pattern of usage is also undergoing a
sea change. The total spends in the payment industry for the year 2004-05 crossed Rs.
33,000 crores at the POS. This reflects a growth of 53% over the previous year. ICICI
Bank is the leader in capturing maximum spends with 32% market share, followed by
Citibank at 20% market share. The combined share in terms of spends of the MNC
Banks is about 43%.
ICICI Bank saw its spends shoot up since 2004 end, pointing out that a combination of
factors are responsible for the jump - the high spending festival season and three
simultaneous promotional programmes.
India currently has over 141 lakh credit cardholders, who make purchases totalling Rs.
33,000 crores per annum. Compared to the Asian market, the card market in India is at a
nascent stage. Total card spending in India is only at around 1.22% of Asian spending.
ABN Amro
HDFC
American Express
ICICI Bank
Axis Bank
SBI
Bank of Baroda
Canara Bank
Citibank
Visa
HSBC
MasterCard
Deutsche Bank
Amex
Barclays Bank
Diners Club
Standard Chartered
Kotak Mahindra
Citibank
Citibank is issuing 26 credit cards in India. They may be named as below:
HDFC Bank is bringing out eleven credit card products in India. These cards
offer a wide range of benefits and rewards for cardholders.
Cardholders can earn 1 reward point for every INR 150 they spend with the card.
Cash advance fee is 2.5%. Minimum cash advance fee is INR 300.
Issuer is MasterCard.
Cardholders receive a maximum of 5% cash back. This offer is applicable for train
And air tickets.
Cash advance fee is 2.5% per month. Minimum cash advance fee is INR 300.
Cardholders earn 2 reward points in case of every INR 150 spent with the card.
Issuer is VISA.
Cash advance fee is 2.5% per month. Minimum cash advance fee is INR 300.
There is an accelerated reward program that is based on expenses made with the card.
Issuer is MasterCard.
Cash advance fee is 2.5% per month. Minimum cash advance fee is INR 250.
Regular interest rate and cash advance fee are both 2.5% per month each. Minimum
cash advance fee is INR 300.
Issuer is VISA.
Rate of interest is low and there are balance transfer options as well.
Following are some other credit cards provided by HDFC Bank in India:
ICICI Bank is issuing 29 separate credit cards in India. These cards cater to a wide
client base including sports lovers and businessmen for example.
Cardholders receive Free Welcome gifts of INR 35,000. Prizes could be Tag Heuer
watches, Travel Points or Travel Vouchers.
Regular interest rate and cash advance fees are 2.75% per month.
Cardholders get 2 points for spending INR 100 with the card for dining purposes.
Issuer is VISA.
Cardholders receive 4 points for spending INR 100 with the card for travel purposes.
Issuer is VISA.
Issuer is VISA.
In Indian credit card market there are 12 major types of credit cards being
provided by banks and financial institutions. These cards provide a wide variety of
financial benefits to holders.
Rewards
There are some additional credit cards that are available in India as well. Rewards credit
cards available in India can be subdivided into six categories Points, Hotels and
Travels, Retail, Auto and Fuel.
A number of banks are offering low interest credit cards in India in order to
help the cardholders manage their finances in a better way. These cards are
highly availed by Indian consumers on account of their low interest rates.
The cardholders receive 10% discounts on business class flights and 15% discounts
on economy flights.
There are 0% fuel surcharge facilities that can only be availed at HPCL outlets.
Cash advance fee is 2.5% per month. The minimum cash advance fee is INR 300.
There are accelerated rewards programs that are provided on the basis of expenditure
with the card.
Issuer is MasterCard.
Scared by the ever increasing cases of credit card fraud, the affected companies and
banks have taken various steps to minimize it. Manual reviews of the transactions on the
card are undertaken, but this requires a high level of human intervention and increases
costs. In the USA, Address Verification System (AVS) has been developed for use in the
card not present scenario
The system is designed to check whether the address given by the buyer matches with
the one on record. Visa has devised a Payer Authentication System based on PIN similar
to the system used on ATM cards. This is a channel between the bank and the customer
used to authorize online transactions. With the increase in cross border ecommerce the
issuers in India will have to update their arsenal to combat the forgers on the same lines
as their Western counterparts.
The Information Technology Act and Rules, passed in 2000, provide penalties for the
tampering of computer source documents and hacking of computer systems. No specific
mention has, however, been made of Credit cards or financial transactions. The RBI has
formed the Credit Information Bureau of India (CIBIL) in collaboration with Dun and
Bradstreet who will maintain the records of all individuals who want to avail of finance
from banks and credit card companies in India.
Protect yourself from credit Card fraud by following the simple suggestions given below:
Do's
If you lose your credit card, please report the loss immediately.
When you dispose of a card at the time of renewal/up gradation, please make sure
to cut it diagonally before disposal.
Please keep your card in a safe place. Treat it as carefully as you would treat your
cash.
Please make sure you conduct any ATM transaction in complete privacy.
If your card is held back by the ATM, please inform the concerned Call
Center/Branch personnel immediately.
Before you use an ATM, please ensure that there are no strange objects in the
insertion panel of the ATM.
Please remember to take your Debit/Credit Card back after completing your ATM
transaction.
If you spot any suspicious looking people at or around any ATM, please inform the
security guard immediately.
When you make any transactions, please make sure that the charge slip is complete
before signing.
Please pay attention to your billing cycles. Please follow up with Banks Credit
Cards Customer Care if your bills don't arrive on time. A missing credit card bill
could mean an identity thief has taken over your account and changed your billing
address to cover his tracks.
Please be wary of promotional scams. Identity thieves may use phony offers to get
you to give them your personal information.
Please secure all personal information in your home, especially if you have
roommates, employ outside help or are having service work done in your home.
Please check your cards periodically to make sure none are missing.
Please destroy and dispose of copies of receipts, airline tickets, travel itineraries
and anything else that displays your card numbers.
Please keep items with personal information in a safe place. Please keep a list of all
credit cards, account numbers, expiry dates, and the customer service phone
numbers in a secure place so that you can quickly contact Banks Credit Cards
Customer Care in case your cards are lost or stolen.
Donts
Please do not hand over the card to anyone, even if he/she claims to represent the
Bank.
Never get carried away by strangers who try to help you use the ATM machine.
Please do not write the ATM PIN on the card or on a paper which you carry along
with the card.
Always Bank's Netsafe feature for making online transactions. It is safe and secure.
If you have not registered for it, please visit the Netsafe page.
Preferably transact on sites which mandate validation of CVC2 value (the last 3
digits after the card number, mentioned on the signature panel at the back of the
card) or at websites that are certified by Verified-by-Visa or MasterCard Secure
Code.
Please be careful when providing personal information online. Never give out your
personal or account information to anyone you do not trust. Please make sure that
you verify a business's legitimacy by visiting its web site, calling a phone number
obtained from a trusted source, and/or checking with a reliable resource.
Please keep your passwords secret. Some online stores may require you to register
with them via a username and password before buying. Online passwords should
be kept secret from outside parties the same way you protect your ATM PIN.
Please look for signs of security. Identify security clues such as a lock image at the
bottom of your browser, or a URL that begins with https://. These signs indicate
that only you and the merchant can view your payment information.
Never send payment information via email. Information that travels over the
Internet (such as email) is not fully protected from being read by outside parties.
Most reputed merchant sites use encryption technologies that will protect your
private data from being accessed by others as you conduct an online transaction.
Please keep a record of your transactions. Just as you save store receipts, you
should keep records of your online purchases. Back up your transaction by saving
and/or printing the order confirmation.
Please be wary of promotional scams. Identity thieves may use phony offers to get
you to give them your personal information.
In case you use your Credit Card for online transactions in Internet cafes or publicuse computers, please ensure that you erase the history of websites
visited/accessed.
Please open and respond only to emails that pass some basic tests, such as:Is the email from somebody you know?
Have you received emails from this sender before?
Are you expecting email with an attachment from this sender?
Does email from this sender with the contents described in the subject line and the
name of the attachment make sense?
CHAPTER 5
INDUSTRY ANALYSIS
Porters FIVE FORCE analysis for Indian Credit Card Industry
BARGAINING POWER OF
SUPPLIERS
-low supplier bargaining
power
- few alternatives available
-subject to RBI rules &
THREAT OF NEW
ENTRANT
-LOW BARRIERS TO
ENTRY
INDUSTRY
RIVALRY
Intense
competition
-Globalization and
liberalization policy
BARGAINING POWER OF
CUSTOMERS
-High bargaining power
- Low switching cost
- Large no. of alternatives
-Homogenous services by banks
THREAT OF
SUBSTITUTES
High threat from
substitutes
KEY POINTS:
Supply:
Credit policies are decided by banks in consultation with the Reserve Bank of India(RBI).
Demand:
India is a growing economy and demand for household credit is high though it could be
cyclical.
Barriers to entry:
Licensing requirement, investment in technology and branch network.
Bargaining power of suppliers:
Few suppliers available such as Mastercard, Visa, Amex etc.
Bargaining power of customers:
For good creditworthy borrowers bargaining power is high due to the availability of large
number of banks and credit card providers.
Competition- High
There are public sector banks, private sector and foreign banks competing in similar business
lines.
CHAPTER 6
The pie chart drawn above suggests that MasterCard leads the competition in the Ahmedabad
city. 38% of the respondents use the MasterCard. It is followed by visa which is being used
by 30% of the respondents. The two are followed by classic, gold & diners and platinum
respectively.
Majority i.e. 28% of the respondents have credit card facility from the SBI. There is stiff
competition between HDFC and ICICI for the second position, where HDFC has slight edge
over ICICI. HDFC is being used by 22% of the respondents whereas ICICI is being used by
21% of the respondents. HSBC is being used by 16% of the respondents and the rest 13%
percent used credit card from various other banks such as Standard Chartered, American
Express, Citibank etc.
Since how long you have been using the credit card?
< 2 years
2 4 years
4- 6 years
Above 6 years
Above pie chart suggests that 59% of the respondents has been using the credit card for more
than 4 years but less than 6 years. 26% of the respondents fall in the category of 2 4 years,
13% percent of them have been using the card for more than 6 years. Only 2% of the
respondents are such who have used credit card for less than 2 years.
How much satisfied you are with your existing credit card?
Highly satisfied
Satisfied
Neutral
Dissatisfied
Highly dissatisfied
Majority of the respondents had not much to comment on how satisfied they are. It can be
seen from the pie chart above. 43% of the respondents are neither satisfied nor dissatisfied
with the card that they are using i.e. they are neutral. 36% of the respondents says that are
satisfied with their credit card facility. Only 11% says they are highly satisfied and 9% says
that they are dissatisfied with the facility that they have. 1% of the respondents are highly
dissatisfied with the credit card facility.
What percentage of income do you save monthly?
< 10%
10% - 20%
20% - 30%
Above 30%
Saving level of the respondents has turn out to be largely in the range of 20% - 30%. 63% of
the respondents claims that they save 20% - 30% of their monthly income. 24% of them
saves between 10% - 20% and 13% of them saves above 30% of their monthly income. None
of them saves less than 10%.
What are the major purposes for which you use credit card?
Shopping
Hotels
Health
Petrol Pump
Travel and others
The main use of credit card if for refueling vehicles and for shopping. 32% of the card usage
is at petrol pumps and for shopping. For hotels and restaurants bill payments the card usage is
15%, for travelling and others its 11% and for health related payments card usage is merely
10%.
Occupation:
Self Employed
Business
Private Sector
Professional
Govt. Sector
From the sample surveyed , 37% of the respondents were from the private sector, 21% were
professionals, and 14% each from govt.sector, business and self employed. It shows people
working in the private sector are the major target audience of the credit card companies.
Sex:
Male
Female
The chart shows that more than 2/3 rd of the respondents were male. The major reason for this
could be that male have regular source of income. 76 % of the respondents were male
compared to just 24% of the female respondents. This Many of the housewives who uses the
credit card are those which are been issued as free card along with existing card.
TEST OF HYPOTHESIS
ISSUING BANK AND THE SEX OF THE CARD HOLDER
GENDER
FEMALE
MALE
SBI
17
HDFC
20
ICICI
18
HSBC
13
OTHERS
24
76
The above table shows the relationship between the credit card issued by different bank such
as SBI, HDFC, ICICI, HSBC and Others and the sex of the card holders.
Null Hypothesis: There is no significant association between the issuing bank and the sex of
the cardholder.
More than 75 % of the cardholders are male because they stable source of income. Most of
the females, who are housewives, use the additional cards which are issued at concessional
fee for family members. 71% of the cardholders use SBI, HDFC and ICICI.
Conclusion: The Null hypothesis is accepted as the calculated value = 3.159 and the table
value is 9.488.
18 - 25 YEARS
25 - 40 YEARS
40 - 60 YEARS
YEARS
SBI
HDFC
15
ICICI
10
HSBC
OTHERS
The table and the graph have been drawn to show if the issuing bank varies among the card
holders of different age group. It is clear from the table that nearly 52% cardholders belong to
the age group of 18 40 years. This category consists of students who are using add on cards
or youngsters who are yet to settle in life; these people have a greater need for credit cards.
On the other hand, the number of cardholders in the age group of above 40 years is low
comparatively. These people are settled in life, they have the propensity to save more than
spend.
Null Hypothesis: There is no significant association between the issuing bank and age of the
cardholder.
Calculated Value = 15.243, Table Value = 21.026
Conclusion: Since the calculated value of chi-square is less than the table value, the
hypothesis that the credit card chosen by the cardholder does not depend on the age is
accepted.
CC_BANK
PRIVATE
EMPLOYED
BUSINESS
SECTOR
SBI
HDFC
15
ICICI
HSBC
OTHERS
From the table it can be seen that more than 50 % of the cardholders belong to the salaried
class i.e. the private and government sector employees, as they have a limited source of
income whereas the other 49% cardholders belong to the self employed and professional
group. The credit card helps the cardholders to meet sudden expenses in case of nonavailability of cash.
Null Hypothesis: There is no relationship between the issuing bank and the occupation of the
card holder.
Conclusion: Calculated Value = 31.779 Table Value = 26.296. Therefore the null hypothesis
that there is no relation between issuing bank and the occupation of the cardholder is rejected.
CC_BANK
15000
20000
ABOVE 20000
SBI
14
HDFC
22
ICICI
11
HSBC
OTHERS
10
The above table and graph has been drawn to determine the relationship between the different
banks issuing credit cards and the monthly income of the card holders. Most of the people
who have taken credit cards are those whose income is greater than 10000 pm. Those with
higher income are more willing to avail the type of services offered by banks. Also banks take
all precautions in selecting the cardholders; they generally do not issue cards to a person
unless they are satisfied about the credit worthiness of the applicants.
Null Hypothesis: There is no association between the issuing bank and the monthly income
of the card holders.
Calculated Value =
Table
15.507
SAVINGS
CC_BANK
11.987,
< 10%
10% - 20%
20% - 30%
ABOVE 30%
SBI
13
Conclusion:
HDFC
18
Chi-square value is
ICICI
16
HSBC
value.
OTHERS
The
The
is no association between the credit card selected and monthly income of the card holder is
true.
The table shows the relationship between bank issuing credit cards and savings of the
cardholders. Savings is shown as a percentage of the monthly income. Approximately, the
tendency of the people is to above something in between 20% - 30% of their monthly
income. Credit cards not only help the cardholders to acquire purchasing power, but also help
in rotation of funds.
GENDER
Null
The
MALE
YES
11
19
NO
13
57
issuing
monthly savings
cardholder
are
Hypothesis:
FEMALE
bank
and
of
the
independent of
each other.
Calculated Value: 14.696, Table Value = 15.507
Conclusion: The calculated value of chi-square is less than the table value, hence it can be
inferred that the basis on which the cardholders selects the issuing bank doesnt depend on
their monthly income.
This table is drawn to show if the change in buying behaviour of a credit card holder is
INCOME
RS. 10000 - RS.
15000
20000
ABOVE 20000
< 5000
5000 - 10000
15000 - 25000
18
20
ABOVE 25000
41
associated with sex. Respondents were asked to tick either Yes or No to show if credit
cards have brought a change in their buying pattern and the data collected was tabulated.
About 30% of them feel that credit cards have changed their buying behaviour significantly.
They go for instant purchases or meet sudden cash shortage with the help of cards.
Comparatively, 84% of females feel that there is a change in their buying behaviour.
Null Hypothesis: The change in buying behaviour is not related to the sex of the card holder.
Calculated Value = 3.770, Table Value = 3.841
Conclusion: Since the calculated value is less than the table value, the hypothesis that
changes in buying behaviour are not related to the sex of the card holder is accepted.
The above table and graph would help us draw an inference about the relationship between
the average monthly spending limit using credit cards and the monthly income. The figure
says that those with income level above 20000 pm have been availed spending limit above
25000 to large extent. Therefore the distribution for this would be skewed, in the sense that
those who have higher income would have higher spending limit.
Null Hypothesis: The monthly spending limit of the cardholder is not related to the monthly
income. Calculated value = 33.609, Table Value = 12.592
Conclusion: The Calculated value is greater than the table value which means that the
hypothesis that monthly spending limit of the cardholder is not related to the monthly income
is rejected.
25 - 40 YEARS
40 - 60 YEARS
YEARS
SHOPPING
11
10
HOTELS
22
18
HEALTH
PETROL PUMP
TRAVEL & OTHERS
The table and the graph above determines the relationship between purpose for which the
credit card is used and the age of the card holder. The early nester-first time user, 18 45
years of age, just married, new to his career, has greater need for consumer finance to buy
durables, clothes etc. The cardholders above 40 years are more prudent and cautious when
they purchase as they dont want to get in heavy debts.
Null Hypothesis: The purpose of credit card usage doesnot depend upon the age of the card
holder.
Calculated Value: 10.966, Table Value = 21.026
Conclusion: The value of chi-sqaure is less than the table value, the hypoyhesis that there is
no association between the age of the cardholders and the purpose for which cards are used
holds good.
20000
ABOVE 20000
SHOPPING
16
HOTELS
35
HEALTH
PETROL PUMP
TRAVEL & OTHERS
The above table determines the relationship between the purpose for which the credit card is
used and the income of the cardholders. If a person wants to make purchase, he needs money;
OCCUPATION
SELF
PRIVATE
PROFESSION
GOVT.
EMPLOYED
BUSINESS
SECTOR
AL
SECTOR
< 2 YEARS
2 - 4 YEARS
14
4 - 6 YEARS
10
22
12
ABOVE 6 YEARS
otherwise he has to postpone the purchase. But credit cards help him to purchase whatever he
wants and pay later.
Null Hypothesis: The purpose for which the credit card is used is independent of the card
holders income.
Calculated value = 12.239, Table Value = 15.507
Conclusion: The value of chi-square is less than the table value, hence the hypothesis is
accepted.
The above table shows the relationship between the duration of the membership and the
occupation of the cardholder. Nearly 60% of them have been using the credit card for the
period greater than 4 years and less than 6 years.
Null Hypothesis: There is no significant difference between membership duration and
occupation Value: 28.739, Table Value: 21.026
Conclusion: The calculated value is greater than the table value hence the null hypothesis is
rejected. This means that there is significant relation between membership duration and the
occupation of the cardholders.
CORRELATION ANALYSIS
GENDER * SPD_LIMIT Cross tabulation
Count
SPD_LIMIT
< 5000
GENDER
Total
5000 - 10000
15000 - 25000
ABOVE 25000
Total
FEMALE
10
24
MALE
37
35
76
44
45
100
From the above we can infer that 76% of the respondents are male which more
than 2/3 rd of the sample size. 41% of the females have credit limit above 25,000
whereas 46% of the males have credit limit above 25,000. This is obvious as
males have stable source of income and again all the females using credit card
are not working women. Many housewives uses credit card which are issued at
concessional fees along with card hold by the male. Overall figures reveal that
majority of the cardholders have the credit above 15,000.
5000 - 10000
15000 - 25000
ABOVE 25000
Total
10
18
27
ABOVE 20000
20
41
63
44
45
100
Total
The above table and graph clearly shows that their direct correlation between the
income of the card holder and the spending limit allowed to the card holder. As
the income of the card holder increases the spending limit on the card also
increases. This is obvious as bank cannot grand higher credit limit to those who
doesnt have repayment capacity and doing so increases the chances of default.
From the figures can derive that more than 90% of the credit card holders have
credit limit above 15,000 and almost 90% of them have income above 15,000 per
month.
5000 - 10000
15000 - 25000
ABOVE 25000
Total
SELF EMPLOYED
14
BUSINESS
14
PRIVATE SECTOR
22
10
37
PROFESSIONAL
16
21
GOVT. SECTOR
14
44
45
100
Total
The figure gives clear indication that more than 50% of the cardholders are
salaried class people and this category is scattered over all the categories of
spending limit i.e. depending on the salary of the person the credit is granted.
Whereas on the other hand the figures of the professionals and business class
people show that they have credit limit above 15,000. This is so because banks
generally issues credit cards to those professionals and business people who are
well established.
TOTAL
SHOPPING
HOTELS
HEALTH
PETROL
PUMP
11
27
11
31
26
11
25
10
81
17
15
47
32
SELF
EMPLOYED
BUSINESS
PRIVATE
SECTOR
PROFESSIONAL
GOVT. SECTOR
The statistics shows that private sector employees makes the most use of the
credit card. They use the card to cover up the cash shortage at the month end.
The two main purpose for which the credit card is used are for fuel and
shopping. Almost 63% of the private sector people use credit card these two
purpose. These two purpose dominate the credit card usage in all categories.
HOTELS
HEALTH
PETROL
PUMP
TRAVEL
&
OTHERS
TOTAL
RS.
10000 RS.
15000
18
RS.
15000 RS.
20000
23
19
61
ABOVE
20000
43
21
16
43
16
139
The respondents having income of above 20000 are the highest user of the credit
card. In all the categories these people dominate the credit card usage. This is so
because they have higher capacity to repay the credit and also they have higher
credit limit. Income group of 15000 to 20000 mostly use the credit card for
shopping and fuel.
HOTELS
HEALTH
PETROL
PUMP
TRAVEL
&
OTHERS
TOTAL
18 - 25
YEARS
20
25 - 40
YEARS
34
11
31
12
96
40 - 60
YEARS
25
16
25
80
ABOVE
60
YEARS
22
This correlation table shows that people falling in the age group of 25 60 are
the major user of the credit card holders. This class constitute of those who are
settling in the life, who have spend for the domestic needs, for education of the
children. In short we can say that this group have higher obligation. Again in this
usage pattern the is widely used for shopping and fuel refilling. The usage of the
people within 25 to 60 years accounts for more than 80% of the card usage.
Total
5000 - 10000
15000 - 25000
ABOVE 25000
Total
18 - 25 YEARS
10
25 - 40 YEARS
24
16
43
40 - 60 YEARS
25
37
ABOVE 60 YEARS
10
44
45
100
The picture which emerges from the above chart is that age group of 25 40
years mostly have credit limit of 15,000 to 20,000 whereas age group of 40 -60
years have credit limit of above 20,000. The major reason for this can be the age
group of 25 40 years is still not yet settle or not as well settled as age group of
40 -60 years. Hence banks are more liberal on granting credit limit to age group
of 40 60 years than to 25 40 years of age group.
Total
20% - 30%
ABOVE 30%
Total
18 - 25 YEARS
10
25 - 40 YEARS
13
30
43
40 - 60 YEARS
24
11
37
ABOVE 60 YEARS
10
24
63
13
100
The above table show the relationship between the age group and the percentage
savings of the respondents. The trend is very clear. More than 63% of the
CHAPTER 7
FINDINGS AND
RECOMMENDATIONS
Findings of the Study
The following are the major findings with regard to the study on the usage pattern of the
credit card holders.
1. Most of the respondents are male cardholders, because they are employed and have a
good source of income. (76%)
2. Most of the respondents are in the age group 25 40 years. The tendency and need to
purchase is more at this age. (43%)
3. Majority of the cardholders belong to the salaried class of the Government and Private
Sector, when their salary is exhausted at the end of the month, the credit card helps
them to overcome a temporary cash crisis. (51%)
4. Respondents with higher salary utilize the cards to the maximum whereas those with
lower salary are more cautious.
5. Lower the savings, higher is the requirement for the use of cards. Purchases can be
made through cards and can be paid from next months salary because the limit is 45
days for settling the dues.
6. Male respondents feel that there is a definite change in their consumption behaviour.
Credit cards can be used for both personal and business purpose. There is no need for
postponement of purchases due to cash shortage.
7. Credit cardholders with higher income feel that credit cards have changed their
consumption pattern. The credit card purchase is not always a rational buy; some part
of it is also impulse buying.
8. Consumers are catching on the convenience of plastic. The number of card holders
has increased in the recent as it is evident from the rise in the number of members in
two years.
9. Salesmen of the banks are the main source of awareness to the cardholders.
10. Master and visa cards are two of the leading card brands in India. One of the main
reasons for MasterCards dominance is its advertising which is appropriately
Indianized.
11. HDFC bank cards are more popular and widely accepted. On the main reasons for
HDFC dominance is its advertising. The bank has done really good job by attracting
the number of customers through personal contacts and advertisements. HDFC
provide a lot of additional benefits like phone banking, bonus points and internet
banking etc to meet the needs of the different class of people.
12. In recent years, the number of member establishments accepting credit cards has
increased which induces the customer to avail the credit facility and increase their
purchasing power.
It is seen from the finding of the study that credit cards are mostly used by cardholders for
purchase. Hence credit cards help the conscious consumers of the largest group of salary
class to enhance their purchasing power.
SUGGESTIONS
With the multiplying volumes and the contest for efficiency, marketers vie with each
other out to the existing and potential card holders. A shakeout is inevitable in this field of
marketing. The card issuers face many difficulties and the credit card service market also
suffers from certain bottle necks which can be outlined below.
1. The banks must reduce the service charge which is to be paid by the card holders
for ticket booking, petrol fills and certain establishments that charge 2 to 3% on
the total price.
2. Women should be induced to use credit cards by creating awareness on the
benefits derived from them. New schemes should be introduced to cater to their
specific needs.
3. The methods should be adopted to bring degree of popularization through mass
media channels like Television, Radio, Airports Centres, Star Hotels, Railway
Centres, and Super Markets etc.
4. Customer education is needed for increased awareness, facility derived and ways
to make the best use of the card.
5. The credit card holder should sincerely and honestly repay the balances in time
and facilitate the system to work out smoothly.
6. The credit cardholders should plan their economic affairs i.e. they should not buy
unnecessary or unwanted things simply because they have credits which does not
require immediate payment. They should always think about the future
commitments and arrange funds for in time.
7. The Admission fees and renewal fees should be reduced so that it can attract more
customers.
8. The interest charged by the credit card agencies is much higher than the normal
lending rates by the bankers and it should be reduced.
9. The only way banks are going to survive in the credit card business is by
improving their overall functioning and infrastructural systems. This especially
true of some nationalized banks that delay billings due to a lack of adequate
informational systems and trained persons.
CHAPTER 8
CONCLUSION
The liberalization of the economy, boost to exports and the increased business
travelling and spending in India favour the credit card industry. The present
environment needs to be matched by increased awareness about credit cards
among retailers and should be fool proof for preventing misuse. Credit cards are
catching up with the middle class despite its late entry in the Indian market.
They are no longer a status symbol as it is only a mode of convenience and
integral part of the busy life style of the people, matching with the pace of
development. Credit cards all set to make a definite impact on the buying
behaviour of people. In present days, the credit card is mostly used by urban
people but it is not easily available to rural people. Hence, all commercial banks
should take necessary steps to provide credit cards to rural people. It leads to
increasing the personal income, business development of bank as well as
economic development.
From the analysis of the individual questions we can come to the conclusion that
most preferred bank by the credit card holders is HDFC bank followed by ICICI
bank. MasterCard is the widely preferred card company. Majority of the
respondents approached were using credit card for the period of 4 6 years.
Almost 80% of the respondents are in the range of neutral to satisfied level with
their credit card service. Credit cards are widely used by respondents for mainly
two purposes viz. Fuel and shopping. Savings as percentage of monthly income
is largely in the 20% to 30%.
From the analysis of the individual questions we can come to the conclusion that
most preferred bank by the credit card holders is HDFC bank followed by ICICI
bank. MasterCard is the widely preferred card company. Majority of the
respondents approached were using credit card for the period of 4 6 years.
Almost 80% of the respondents are in the range of neutral to satisfied level with
their credit card service. Credit cards are widely used by respondents for mainly
two purposes viz. Fuel and shopping. Saving as percentage of monthly income is
largely in the range of 20
Majority of the null hypothesis has been accepted except relationship between
occupation of the cardholder and monthly spending limit and monthly income of
the cardholder. This clearly means that there is no explicit relationship between
other variables other than occupation and monthly income and spending limit
monthly income of the card holders. This is obvious as banks do consider the
occupation and the income level of the card holders while granting the spending
limit for each card holder.
Correlation analysis reveals that the correlation exists between spending limit
and the gender and also with the income level of the respondents. Also the usage
pattern and the occupation of the card holders are correlated as private are more
in need of the credit at the end of the month.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Ausubel l (1991), The failure of competition in the credit card
m a r k e t s , A m e r i c a n E c o n o m i c R e v i e w , Vol . 8 1 , N o . 1 p p . 5 0 - 8 1
2 . B r i t o D L a n d H a r t l e yp ( 1 9 9 5 ) C o n s u m e r r a t i o n a l i t y a n d C r e d i t
c a r d s , J o u r n a l o f p o l i t i c a l e c o n o m y, Vol . 1 0 3 , p p . 4 0 0 - 4 3 3
3. Calem P S and Mester L J (1995) Consumer behavior and
stickiness of credit card interest rates,
American Economic
R e v i e w , Vol 8 5 , N o . 5 , P P. 1 3 2 7 - 1 3 3 6
4. Berlin M and Mester J (2004), credit card rates and consumer
s e a r c h , R e v i e w o f f i n a n c i a l E c o n o m i c s Vol . 1 3 , p p . 1 7 9 - 1 9 8
Journals
ICFAI journal of service marketing. Vol 6 no 1 2008
ICFAI journal of service marketing. Vol 4 2008
Indian journal of finance April 2009
Websites
www.RupeeTalk.in
www.creditbhai.com
w w w.a n s w e r s . c o m
w w w.h s b c . c o . i n / 1 / 2 / p e r s o n a l / c r e d i t - c a r d s
w w w.i c i c i b a n k . c o m / p f s u s e r / c a r d s / c r e d i t c a r d / c c _ h o m e . h t m
w w w.c yb e r c e l l m u m b a i . c o m / c y b e r - c r i m e s / c r e d i t - c a r d - f r a u d
www.hdfc.com
ANNEXURE
Note:
We, the students of N. R. Institute of Business Management, have undertaken the
project to study the usage pattern of credit card holders of Ahmedabad city.
The details provided in this questionnaire would be kept confidential and would
be used purely for the academic purpose.
Name: ______________________________________________
Sex:
Male
Female
Age:
< 18 years
18 25 years
25 40 years
40 60 years
Above 60 years
Occupation:
Self Employed
Business
Private Sector
Professional
Govt. Sector
MasterCard
amex
OTHERS
Gold
Platinum
Others
3. Which is the issuing bank of credit card?
SBI
HDFC
ICICI
HSBC
Others
Specify: _____________________
4. Since how long you have been using the credit card?
< 2 years
2 4 years
4- 6 years
Above 6 years
5. How much satisfied you are with your existing credit card?
Highly satisfied
Satisfied
Neutral
Dissatisfied
Highly dissatisfied
6. From where did you have the information about the credit
card?
Print Media
Sales Person
Friends
Internet
Television
10.
spending?
Yes
No
11. What are the major purposes for which you use credit card?
Shopping
Hotels
Health
Petrol Pump
Travel and others
Output Created
20-Mar-2010 21:56:30
Comments
Input
Data
C:\Users\compaq\Desktop\GRANDPROJEC
T.sav
Active Dataset
DataSet1
Filter
<none>
Weight
<none>
Split File
<none>
100
Syntax
CTABLES
/VLABELS VARIABLES=CC_BANK
GENDER DISPLAY=LABEL
/TABLE CC_BANK [COUNT F40.0] BY
GENDER
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=CC_BANK
GENDER ORDER=A KEY=VALUE
EMPTY=INCLUDE
/SIGTEST TYPE=CHISQUARE
ALPHA=0.05 INCLUDEMRSETS=YES
CATEGORIES=ALLVISIBLE.
Resources
Processor Time
0:00:00.016
Elapsed Time
0:00:00.012
GENDER
CC_BANK
FEMALE
MALE
Count
Count
SBI
17
HDFC
20
ICICI
18
HSBC
13
OTHERS
Chi-square
df
Sig.
3.159
4
.532a
Notes
Output Created
20-Mar-2010 22:00:19
Comments
Input
Data
C:\Users\compaq\Desktop\GRANDPROJEC
T.sav
Active Dataset
DataSet1
Filter
<none>
Weight
<none>
Split File
<none>
100
CTABLES
/VLABELS VARIABLES=CC_BANK
OCCUPATION DISPLAY=LABEL
/TABLE CC_BANK [C][COUNT F40.0] BY
OCCUPATION [C]
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=CC_BANK
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
/CATEGORIES
VARIABLES=OCCUPATION ORDER=A
KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
TOTAL=YES POSITION=AFTER
/SIGTEST TYPE=CHISQUARE
ALPHA=0.05 INCLUDEMRSETS=YES
CATEGORIES=ALLVISIBLE.
Resources
Processor Time
0:00:00.000
Elapsed Time
0:00:00.018
OCCUPATION
GOVT.
SELF EMPLOYED
BUSINESS
PRIVATE SECTOR
PROFESSIONAL
SECTOR
Total
Count
Count
Count
Count
Count
Count
CC_BAN SBI
K
22
HDFC
15
28
ICICI
21
HSBC
16
OTHER
13
Chi-square
31.779
df
Sig.
16
.011*,a
Notes
Output Created
20-Mar-2010 22:01:54
Comments
Input
Data
C:\Users\compaq\Desktop\GRANDPROJEC
T.sav
Active Dataset
DataSet1
Filter
<none>
Weight
<none>
Split File
<none>
100
CTABLES
/VLABELS VARIABLES=CC_BANK
INCOME DISPLAY=LABEL
/TABLE CC_BANK [C][COUNT F40.0] BY
INCOME
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=CC_BANK
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=INCOME
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
TOTAL=YES POSITION=AFTER
/SIGTEST TYPE=CHISQUARE
ALPHA=0.05 INCLUDEMRSETS=YES
CATEGORIES=ALLVISIBLE.
Resources
Processor Time
0:00:00.031
Elapsed Time
0:00:00.024
INCOME
CC_BANK
15000
20000
ABOVE 20000
Total
Count
Count
Count
Count
Count
SBI
13
22
HDFC
22
28
ICICI
10
21
HSBC
16
OTHERS
10
13
Chi-square
12.808
df
Sig.
Results are based on nonempty rows and
columns in each innermost sub table.
8
.119a
Notes
Output Created
20-Mar-2010 22:03:02
Comments
Input
Data
C:\Users\compaq\Desktop\GRANDPROJEC
T.sav
Active Dataset
DataSet1
Filter
<none>
Weight
<none>
Split File
<none>
100
CTABLES
/VLABELS VARIABLES=CC_BANK
SAVINGS DISPLAY=LABEL
/TABLE CC_BANK [C][COUNT F40.0] BY
SAVINGS
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=CC_BANK
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=SAVINGS
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
TOTAL=YES POSITION=AFTER
/SIGTEST TYPE=CHISQUARE
ALPHA=0.05 INCLUDEMRSETS=YES
CATEGORIES=ALLVISIBLE.
Resources
Processor Time
0:00:00.016
Elapsed Time
0:00:00.019
SAVINGS
CC_BANK
< 10%
10% - 20%
20% - 30%
ABOVE 30%
Total
Count
Count
Count
Count
Count
SBI
13
22
HDFC
18
28
ICICI
16
21
HSBC
16
OTHERS
13
Chi-square
14.696
df
Sig.
Results are based on nonempty rows and
columns in each innermost sub table.
8
.065a
Notes
Output Created
20-Mar-2010 22:04:24
Comments
Input
Data
C:\Users\compaq\Desktop\GRANDPROJEC
T.sav
Active Dataset
DataSet1
Filter
<none>
Weight
<none>
Split File
<none>
100
CTABLES
/VLABELS VARIABLES=CHANGE
GENDER DISPLAY=LABEL
/TABLE CHANGE [COUNT F40.0] BY
GENDER
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=CHANGE
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=GENDER
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
TOTAL=YES POSITION=AFTER
/SIGTEST TYPE=CHISQUARE
ALPHA=0.05 INCLUDEMRSETS=YES
CATEGORIES=ALLVISIBLE.
Resources
Processor Time
0:00:00.016
Elapsed Time
0:00:00.015
GENDER
CHANGE
FEMALE
MALE
Total
Count
Count
Count
YES
11
19
30
NO
13
57
70
Chi-square
3.770
df
Sig.
Results are based on nonempty rows and
columns in each innermost sub table.
1
.052
Notes
Output Created
20-Mar-2010 22:06:04
Comments
Input
Data
C:\Users\compaq\Desktop\GRANDPROJEC
T.sav
Active Dataset
DataSet1
Filter
<none>
Weight
<none>
Split File
<none>
100
CTABLES
/VLABELS VARIABLES=SPD_LIMIT
INCOME DISPLAY=LABEL
/TABLE SPD_LIMIT [COUNT F40.0] BY
INCOME
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=SPD_LIMIT
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=INCOME
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
TOTAL=YES POSITION=AFTER
/SIGTEST TYPE=CHISQUARE
ALPHA=0.05 INCLUDEMRSETS=YES
CATEGORIES=ALLVISIBLE.
Resources
Processor Time
0:00:00.016
Elapsed Time
0:00:00.027
INCOME
SPD_LIMIT
15000
20000
ABOVE 20000
Total
Count
Count
Count
Count
Count
< 5000
5000 - 10000
15000 - 25000
18
20
44
ABOVE 25000
41
45
Chi-square
33.609
df
Sig.
6
.000*,alb
20-Mar-2010 22:10:26
Comments
Input
Data
C:\Users\compaq\Desktop\GRANDPROJEC
T.sav
Active Dataset
DataSet1
Filter
<none>
Weight
<none>
Split File
<none>
100
CTABLES
/VLABELS VARIABLES=PURPOSE1 AGE
DISPLAY=LABEL
/TABLE PURPOSE1 [COUNT F40.0] BY
AGE
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=PURPOSE1
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=AGE
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
TOTAL=YES POSITION=AFTER
/SIGTEST TYPE=CHISQUARE
ALPHA=0.05 INCLUDEMRSETS=YES
CATEGORIES=ALLVISIBLE.
Resources
Processor Time
0:00:00.031
Elapsed Time
0:00:00.036
18 - 25 YEARS
25 - 40 YEARS
40 - 60 YEARS
ABOVE 60 YEARS
Total
Count
Count
Count
Count
Count
PURPOS SHOPPING
E1
11
10
26
HOTELS
19
HEALTH
PETROL PUMP
22
18
46
TRAVEL &
OTHERS
AGE
Chi-square
df
Sig.
10.966
12
.532a,b
Notes
Output Created
20-Mar-2010 22:12:04
Comments
Input
Data
C:\Users\compaq\Desktop\GRANDPROJEC
T.sav
Active Dataset
DataSet1
Filter
<none>
Weight
<none>
Split File
<none>
100
CTABLES
/VLABELS VARIABLES=PURPOSE1
INCOME DISPLAY=LABEL
/TABLE PURPOSE1 [COUNT F40.0] BY
INCOME
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=PURPOSE1
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=INCOME
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
TOTAL=YES POSITION=AFTER
/SIGTEST TYPE=CHISQUARE
ALPHA=0.05 INCLUDEMRSETS=YES
CATEGORIES=ALLVISIBLE.
Resources
Processor Time
0:00:00.031
Elapsed Time
0:00:00.031
[DataSet1] C:\Users\compaq\Desktop\GRANDPROJECT.sav
Table 1
INCOME
PURPOSE1
15000
20000
ABOVE 20000
Total
Count
Count
Count
Count
SHOPPING
16
26
HOTELS
19
HEALTH
PETROL PUMP
35
46
Chi-square
df
Sig.
12.239
8
.141a,b
Notes
Output Created
20-Mar-2010 22:13:39
Comments
Input
Data
C:\Users\compaq\Desktop\GRANDPROJEC
T.sav
Active Dataset
DataSet1
Filter
<none>
Weight
<none>
Split File
<none>
100
CTABLES
/VLABELS VARIABLES=CC_DURA
OCCUPATION DISPLAY=LABEL
/TABLE CC_DURA [COUNT F40.0] BY
OCCUPATION
/CATEGORIES VARIABLES=CC_DURA
ORDER=A KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
/CATEGORIES
VARIABLES=OCCUPATION ORDER=A
KEY=VALUE EMPTY=INCLUDE
TOTAL=YES POSITION=AFTER
/SIGTEST TYPE=CHISQUARE
ALPHA=0.05 INCLUDEMRSETS=YES
CATEGORIES=ALLVISIBLE.
Resources
Processor Time
0:00:00.016
Elapsed Time
0:00:00.017
OCCUPATION
PRIVATE
SELF EMPLOYED
BUSINESS
SECTOR
PROFESSIONAL
GOVT. SECTOR
Total
Count
Count
Count
Count
Count
Count
2 - 4 YEARS
14
26
4 - 6 YEARS
10
22
12
59
ABOVE 6
13
YEARS
Chi-square
28.789
df
Sig.
12
.004*,a,b