Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Division of Building Science and Technology, College of Science and Engineering, City University of Hong Kong, Tat Chee Avenue, Kowloon, Hong Kong
School of Energy and Environment, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 11 September 2009
Received in revised form 20 July 2010
Accepted 10 August 2010
Keywords:
Balcony
Overhang
EnergyPlus
Energy payback period
a b s t r a c t
The provision of balcony to the living room of a residential at offers a number of merits including
improved view enjoyment, enhanced ventilation and increased planting space. In addition, a balcony
can act as an overhang and provide solar shading as well as electricity saving of the air-conditioning
system. This paper reports the ndings on the energy and environmental impact due to the provision
of a balcony. In this study, a typical residential at with balcony constructed at the living room was
modeled and the energy performance was investigated with the use of the typical weather data set of
a subtropical city, Hong Kong. The effects of balconys orientation and glazing material of window were
also evaluated. It was found that the residential ats facing various orientations (N, E, S, W, NE, SE, SW and
NW) can offer substantial energy saving in air-conditioning system due to the shading effect of balcony.
The building case with southwest facing balcony and clear glass glazed window gave the highest saving
percentage of 12.3% in annual air-conditioning consumption. In terms of cost payback period, the values
were estimated as 25.9 years (based on extra construction cost of a balcony) and over 100 years (based on
extra purchasing cost), respectively. On the other hand, the energy payback period was 22.4 years for this
building case. The provision of balcony to the living room of residential at was found environmentally
feasible in Hong Kong.
2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
In recent years, there is cooperative effort to reduce greenhouse
gas (GHG) emission all over the world. The main objective is to
pursue a blue sky under which there can be sustainable development in the society. Minimization of energy use is the key to foster
GHG reduction. Building, as one of the largest electricity consumers,
can make a marked contribution to energy conservation as well as
GHG removal and mitigation of urban heat island effect by sophisticated building design. There are various architectural features that
can inuence the indoor climate and electricity consumption of a
building such as building layout, orientation, color of opaque wall,
window size, glazing type, and shading of window. In the aspect
of window shading, either a simple overhang over a window or a
balcony can be adopted.
A balcony can provide solar shading to building at since the slab
of the balcony of the upper oor acts as an overhang to the window
of the underneath oor. The solar heat gain into building as well as
the energy consumption of the air-conditioning (A/C) unit can be
reduced. Moreover, because of the enlarged size of window open-
Corresponding author. Tel.: +852 3442 9676; fax: +852 3442 9716.
E-mail address: bsapplec@cityu.edu.hk (A.L.S. Chan).
0378-7788/$ see front matter 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.enbuild.2010.08.009
2401
95 m2
142 W/room
14 W/m2
25.5 C
4
1:00 pm to 10:00 pm
2402
Fig. 2. Cross-sectional views of a typical residential at without and with balcony in living room.
Hong Kong [16] was used as the weather input in the simulation.
The study includes investigation on the energy performance of residential ats installed with different types of glazing materials at the
window opening of the living room. Three types of glazing material, namely clear glass (clr), absorptive glass (abs) and reective
glass (ref) were used in the building cases. The thermal and optical properties of these glazing materials were listed in Table 2. The
investigation covered all seasons for the various building cases and
the year-round energy saving projection was generated. Analysis
on A/C saving of the residential ats with the effect of solar shading was carried out. Moreover, the economic and environmental
evaluation on the provision of balcony to the residential ats was
conducted and the ndings were detailed in the following sections.
3. Analysis on system performance
Hong Kong is located in subtropical region, tending to have
a hot and humid summer while the winter season is relatively
short and mild. In spring, the weather is mainly cloudy with dry
northerly winds. The monthly mean air temperature is around
18 C and the monthly mean daily total solar radiation ranges from
9.1 to 11.3 MJ/m2 day. From May to September, the climate is hot
and humid with occasional showers, thunderstorm and tropical
cyclones. The maximum air temperature often excess 31 C in the
Table 2
Thermal and optical properties of glazing materials.
Thermal transmittance
Thermal reectance
Visible transmittance
Visible reectance
Thickness (mm)
Single clear
glass
Single
absorptive
glass
Single
reective
glass
0.771
0.070
0.884
0.080
5.7
0.486
0.053
0.533
0.056
5.7
0.275
0.369
0.464
0.314
6.0
Fig. 3. Annual A/C electricity consumption and saving percentage of building cases
without and with balcony (with clear glazing type).
Fig. 4. Annual A/C electricity percentage saving of building cases with balcony with
various glazing types.
percentages (in %) were also shown in the same gure for analysis.
Comparing the eight cases as shown in Fig. 3, the case with balcony facing southwest gives the best annual saving performance at
12.3%. It is because Hong Kong is located in the subtropical zone and
the southwestern window receives much more solar radiation in
summer so that the shading effect of balcony becomes substantial
[17]. On the contrast, a northern window receives an insignicant
amount of solar radiation in summer. It is reected by the lowest
saving percentage (3.4%) in A/C consumption. As the orientation
of the balcony moves from north towards southwest, there is a
tendency of increase in saving percentage of A/C electricity consumption, with an exemption in the case at southern orientation
where the saving percentage drops to 9.3%. It is because southern
window receives less amount of solar radiation than the case facing southeast or southwest, particularly at noontime when the solar
angle is high. The same conclusions are reached for the cases with
absorptive and reective glazing window, as illustrated in Fig. 4.
Since the values of solar transmittance of the reective and absorptive glazing are lower than that of clear glazing, the amount of solar
heat gain as well as the A/C electricity consumption is smaller than
that of the case with clear glazing. The shading effect of balcony
becomes less signicant than that in the case with clear glazing.
As a result, the cases with reective glazing offer the least saving
percentages as compared to the case with clear glazing. The maximum saving of A/C consumption was found from the case with
balcony facing southwest constructed with clear glazing window.
The absolute and percentage saving are 181.9 kWh/yr and 12.3%,
respectively.
Since the southwest facing balcony offers the best performance
in A/C energy saving and clear glass is widely selected and applied as
the glazing pane of fenestration in the residential building in Hong
Kong, the monthly A/C saving of this case was plotted in Fig. 5 for
further analysis. In this case, the minimum and maximum A/C savings occur in March and October, respectively. The corresponding
electricity saving are 7.72 and 22.46 kWh. In addition to the electricity saving, there is also reduction in electric demand (with unit
W or VA) resulted from the provision of balcony to the residential
at. The maximum reduction is 200 W per at in this building case
occurred in October. Although there is no demand charge for residential buildings under the current tariff structure in Hong Kong,
the reduction in electric demand can mitigate the need for more
electric energy production, i.e. reducing the required capacity of
the power plant.
The above simulation results indicate that the savings of A/C
consumption in north, northeast and northwest facing balconies
are much lower than the cases at other orientations. However, in
order to have a thorough evaluation on the effectiveness of a bal-
2403
Fig. 5. Monthly A/C electricity saving and reduction in electric demand for a building
case facing southwest.
Quantities (kg)
Unit cost
(USD/ton)
Cost (USD)
55
23
380
649
973
786
786
73
9
8
43.2
18.1
27.7
5.8
7.8
Labor
Man-day
Unit cost
(USD/day)
Cost (USD)
Steel bar
banner/xer
Concretor
Scaffolding
Total cost (USD)
137
137
1
1
118
118
118
118
475.6
2404
last decade were used. The cost payback period was estimated as
25.9 years, as shown in Table 4, which is shorter than the life span
(50 years) of a typical high-rise residential building in Hong Kong.
However, using the extra purchasing cost of a at with balcony,
instead of the additional construction cost, in the life-cycle cost
analysis could be more appropriate. It is because the period for the
property owner to recover the extra purchasing cost paid can be
evaluated. Through private communication with local real estate
agents, it was found that the added value of market price for a
residential at with a balcony is about USD 12,000. With this information, the payback period estimated will be over 100 years which
is economically infeasible.
Evaluation on the performance of balcony also addresses the
environmental aspect. Energy payback period is an index generally used for this issue. It can be dened as the length of time a
device/system takes to payback the energy used in the manufacturing and production of a device/system. If the energy payback period
is shorter than the lifespan of a device/system, the net energy saving
can contribute towards the reduction of greenhouse gas emission.
Steel rod, cement and aggregate are the major materials used for
constructing a balcony. For production of steel, iron ore, coal and
limestone are the major feed materials in a blast furnace in which
Table 5
Embodied energy of a balcony for a residential apartment.
Material
Quantities
(kg)
Embodied
Energy
(kWh/kg)
Embodied Energy
(Subtotal) (kWh)
55
23
380
649
973
10.56
10.56
1.56
1.64
1.64
581
243
593
1064
1596
4077
Table 4
Estimation of cost payback period.
Material and installation cost
Annual saving in A/C electricity consumption
Annual saving in electricity cost (USD 0.122/kWh)
Escalation rate of electricity
Discount rate
Cost payback period (based on extra construction cost)
USD 475.6
181.9 kWh
USD 22.2
2.62%
4.25%
25.9 years
Annual energy
saving (kWh/yr)
Energy payback
period (yrs)
SW
W
SE
E
S
NW
NE
N
181.9
168.0
158.8
143.6
123.0
96.6
93.4
38.8
22.4
24.3
25.7
28.4
33.1
42.2
43.7
105.1
2405
PECenergy
Esav
(1)
References
where PECenergy is the primary energy consumed during the lifecycle phases of the balcony (kWh) and Esav is the annual A/C energy
saving (kWh/year). As evaluated in Section 3, an annual electricity
saving of 181.9 kWh was resulted from the provision of a balcony
to the building case facing southwest. The corresponding energy
payback period is 22.4 years, i.e. the energy saved during the rst
22.4 years of the lifespan can recover the primary energy required
for the production and installation of the balcony.
From the viewpoint of environmental concern, each unit of
energy consumed in buildings has an implication for GHG emission. In Hong Kong, there is almost 100% thermoelectricity power
generation. To evaluate the GHG mitigation by the provision of balcony, an emission factor of 0.7 kg/kWh for CO2 average content was
used in this study [22]. The GHG emission from the consumption
of purchased electricity can be estimated by:
GHG Emission = Quantity of purchased electricity
Emission Factor
(2)
[1] O. Wong, Hong Kongs outdated building codes. Clear The Air News (2009).
http://news.cleartheair.org.hk/2009/01/12/hong-kongs-outdated-buildingcodes/.
[2] S. Raeissi, M. Taheri, Optimum overhang dimensions for energy saving, Building
and Environment 33 (5) (1998) 293302.
[3] J. Yu, C. Yang, L. Tian, Low-energy envelope design of residential building in
hot summer and cold winter zone in China, Energy and Buildings 40 (2008)
15361546.
[4] G.A. Florides, S.A. Tassou, S.A. Kalogirou, L.C. Wrobel, Measures used to lower
building energy consumption and their cost effectiveness, Applied Energy 73
(2002) 299328.
[5] E.S. Lee, A. Tavil, Energy and visual comfort performance of electrochromic
windows with overhangs, Building and Environment 42 (2007) 2439
2449.
[6] I. Chand, P.K. Bhargava, N.L.V. Krishak, Effect of balconies on ventilation inducing aeromotive force on low-rise buildings, Building and Environment 33 (6)
(1998) 385396.
[7] E. Prianto, P. Depecker, Characteristic of airow as the effect of balcony, opening design and internal division on indoor velocitya case study of traditional
dwelling in urban living quarter in tropical humid region, Energy and Buildings
34 (2002) 401409.
[8] E. Prianto, P. Depecker, Optimization of architectural design elements in tropical humid region with thermal comfort approach, Energy and Buildings 35
(2003) 273280.
[9] P.J. Lee, Y.H. Kim, J.Y. Jeon, K.D. Song, Effects of apartment buildings facade and
balcony design on the reduction of exterior noise, Building and Environment
42 (2007) 35173528.
[10] M.J. Kim, H.G. Kim, Field measurements of facade sound insulation in residential buildings with balcony windows, Building and Environment 42 (2007)
10261035.
[11] M. Law, Measurements of balcony smoke ow, Fire Safety Journal 24 (1995)
189195.
[12] J.H. Mammoser, F. Battaglia, A computational study on the use of balconies to
reduce ame spread in high-rise apartment res, Fire Safety Journal 39 (2004)
277296.
[13] R. Huo, W.K. Chow, X.H. Jin, Y.Z. Li, N.K. Fong, Experimental studies on natural
smoke lling in atrium due to a shop re, Building and Environment 40 (2005)
11851193.
[14] HK-BEAM Society. BEAM Plus: Building Environmental Assessment
MethodNew Buildings, 2010, Version 1.1.
[15] EnergyPlus Engineering Reference Manual. Version 2.2.0. Department of
Energy, US, 2007.
[16] A.L.S. Chan, T.T. Chow, K.F. Fong, Z. Lin, Generation of a typical meteorological
year for Hong Kong, Energy Conversion and Management 47 (2006) 8796.
[17] T.T. Chow, A.L.S. Chan, K.F. Fong, Z. Lin, Hong Kong solar radiation on building facades evaluated by numerical models, Applied Thermal Engineering 25
(2005) 19081921.
[18] Quarterly Hong Kong Construction Cost Report, Rider Levett Bucknall Limited,
2009.
[19] Hong Kong Energy StatisticsAnnual Report 2009, Census and Statistics
Department, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, 2009.
[20] Hong Kong Interest Rate. Hong Kong Monetary Authority/Trading Economics.
(2010) (http://www.tradingeconomics.com/).
[21] Australias guide to environmentally sustainable homes, a joint initiative of
the Australian Government and the design and construction industries (2008)
(http://www.yourhome.gov.au/technical/pubs/fs52.pdf).
[22] Guidelines to Account for and Report on Greenhouse Gas Emissions and
Removals for Buildings (Commercial, Residential or Institutional Purposes) in
Hong Kong, Electrical and Mechanical Services Department and Environmental
Protection Department, The Government of Hong Kong Special Administrative
Region, 2008, Edition.