Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
I. BACKGROUND
1.1 Terminologies
YNTHESIS, Synthesis Gas(or Syngas) means a gas mixture
that contains varying amounts of carbon monoxide (CO)
and hydrogenH2. The production methods include steam
reforming of natural gas or liquid hydrocarbons to produce
hydrogen, the gasification of coal,[1] biomass, and in some
types of waste-to-energy gasification facilities.
Propylene also known as Propene, is an unsaturated organic
compound having the chemical formula C3H6. It has one
FINANCE RESEARCH
LG Group
265
BASF
263
1.2Introduction
According to SRI statistics, the world largest n-butyl alcohol
manufacturer now is BASF, the largest diversified chemical
company in the world and being headquartered in Germany.
With the rapid downstream development of OXO in China over
the years, the supply of OXO falls short of demand. In the
recent years, the high profit margin of OXO products stimulate
the investment enthusiasm to OXO device in domestic market.
As one of the main materials, propylene has extensive sources.
As another main material, synthesis gas has mature production
technology. The supply of propylene and synthesis gas
provides material guarantee for the construction of OXO
device. The obtaining of process technology is not exclusive,
which offers feasibility technically. Under the combined
influence of these factors, several sets of OXO devices are
about to be put into operation, built or planned in China now.
Combining with the development history [1] of OXO at
abroad especially in America and Germany, the author thinks
that it is impossible for the chinese OXO industry to keep such
a rapid growth continuously and it is also impossible to
maintain such a high profit margin on OXO products in the
long run. This paper will analyze and evaluate the construction
of OXO device from the relation of market supply and demand,
investment economic benefit and many other aspects, hoping to
get more insights.
252
190
170
146
Gazprom
131
10
Perstorp
125
All others
1128
TOTAL
3330
SINOPEC
360
Oxea Group
300
FINANCE RESEARCH
kmt/y
capacity
No.
n-Butyl Alcohol
2-Ethylhexyl Alcohol
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Table 2-4 OXO Production Capacity [1] [4] [5] in China in 2010 kmt/yr
n-butyl 2-ethylhexy
manufactures
total
alcohol
l alcohol
OXO
550
875
1425
Sinopec Qilu Co.
50
255
305
Sinopec Yazi-BASF
100
110
210
Sinopec Yanshan Co.
20
50
70
CNPC Jilin
170
70
240
ChemicalCo.
CNPC Daqing Co.
25
55
80
Shandong Lihuayi
85
140
225
Group
Tianjin Soda Plant
80
145
225
Shandong Jianlan
20
50
70
biological fermentation
215
0
215
process
Total
765
875
1640
CNPC
Others
500
400
kmt/yr
5.0
4.0
G ro w th R a te % /y r
demand
4000
3500
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0
3.0
300
200
100
2.0
1.0
n-Butyl Alcohol
0.0
2005-2010
2010-2015
2-Ethylhexyl Alcohol
capacity
2015-2020
-1.0
-2.0
Figure 2-2 Forecast of the Variation Trend of World OXO Supply and
Demand Growth Rate
FINANCE RESEARCH
kmt
product
self-sufficiency rate
1000
900
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
consume
self-sufficiency rate
1000
80%
900
70%
800
60%
kmt
700
600
50%
500
40%
400
30%
300
20%
200
10%
100
0
0%
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Co.
Total
635
500
1135
FINANCE RESEARCH
Unit
10,000
10,000
10,000
10,000
10,000
%
10,000
Year
From the data above we can see that OXO device is sensitive
to product price. If product price falls 10%, the internal rate of
return will fall to 7.3%.
As for the degree of sensitivity, the price of raw material
ranks the 2nd place. If the price of raw material rises 10%, the
internal rate of return will fall to 10.6%. The author draws the
benefit situation of OXO device under different materials and
product prices in Table 3-3.
Table 3-3 shows: when the price of propylene is certain, the
variation of OXO price will cause benefit change; the multiple
slant lines show: when both the prices of propylene and OXO
change, the benefit will change. For instance: if the price of
propylene is 7,000 Yuan/ton, the price of n-butyl alcohol is
higher than 8,000 Yuan/ton and the corresponding price of
2-ethylhexyl alcohol is higher than 8,560 Yuan/ton, the internal
rate of return will be higher than 13%; if the price of propylene
doesnt change, the price of n-butyl alcohol is higher than 8,520
Yuan/ton and the corresponding price of 2-ethylhexyl alcohol
is higher than 9,110 Yuan/ton, the internal rate of return will be
higher than 18%; if the price of propylene is 6,000 Yuan/ton,
the price of n-butyl alcohol is 8,290 Yuan/ton and the
corresponding price of 2-ethylhexyl alcohol is 8,870 Yuan/ton,
the internal rate of return will be higher than 23%.
Table 3-3 The Impact of Material and Product Price Variation on Benefit
proplene price
Quantity
125630
210600
4000
179050
23710
17780
19.27
5000
41770
6.64
The internal rate of return of this project is higher than the set
base rate of return. It shows that project economy is feasible
under basic estimate conditions, or the investment is
economical.
6000
7000
8000
9000
Internal Rate of Return (%)
19.27
17.34
21.52
IRR
n-Butyl Alcohol
2-Ethylhexyl
Alcohol
13%
6150
6580
18%
6550
7010
23%
7000
7490
13%
6750
7230
18%
7200
7720
23%
7660
8200
13%
7370
7890
18%
7860
8410
23%
8290
8870
13%
8000
8560
18%
8520
9110
23%
8970
9600
13%
8630
9240
18%
9240
9880
23%
9690
10370
13%
9350
10010
18%
9960
10660
23%
10420
11150
16.04
18.11
10.60
26.78
28.85
7.30
FINANCE RESEARCH
2000
10000
gold
1800
8000
1600
7000
1400
6000
1200
5000
1000
4000
800
3000
600
2000
400
1000
200
rhodium
9000
2011-5-31
2010-1-29
2008-9-30
2007-5-31
2006-1-31
2004-9-30
2003-5-30
2002-1-31
2000-9-29
1999-5-1
1998-1-1
1996-9-1
1995-5-1
1994-1-1
1992-9-1
1991-5-1
1990-1-1
Figure 3-1 Price Trend Curves of Rhodium and Gold Since 1990
5.1 Conclusion
To conclude, the supply and demand of world OXO in next
5~10 years will further focus on Asia; it is the peak time to
invest and construct OXO devices in China in the past 3 and
next 5 years with large increase of production capacity in short
term; the market demand in China will change from supply
falls short of demand now to both supply and demand are
basically balanced in about 2015; it is predicted the fat profits
during 2007~2008 are hard to reappear in short term, but there
is still certain feasibility for investing OXO devices
economically; the benefit of OXO device is very sensitive to
product price. If product price falls and other adverse factors
occur, the benefit of OXO device will fall significantly.
5.2 Suggestions
In view of the benefit of OXO device is very sensitive to
product price, the investors should keep close watch on the
relation of market supply and demand as well as the variation of
material price. During 1999~2008, the price of OXO in China
experienced a complete price cycle. Now it is at a relatively
high price and then it may goes into the falling period. The
investors are advised to rationally analyze their own investment
conditions and then invest prudently after evaluating following
integrated factors, including the supply of main material
propylene, whether to newly build gas-making device,
technical source, capital source, proportion of owned fund,
whether public works have dependence, the distance from
target market and transportation condition, investment phase
etc.
If it is confirmed to invest OXO plant, we should pay much
attention on the price of rhodium and purchase it at proper time.
Meanwhile, in view of the commercial operation [20] of China
Shenhua Group Baotou MTO Project is started, Shenhua
Ningxia Coal Industry Group MTP device has produced
qualified products [21], which marks large-scale MTO/MTP
technological industrialization is basically successful. For
OXO devices with propylene and synthesis gas as main
materials, OXO program is considered in MTO/MTP project
with advantaged conditions. While the disadvantage lies in that
FINANCE RESEARCH
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
[6]
[7]
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12]
[13]
[14]
[15] Chemical Engineering WorldDammam 7 Petrochemical selects Oxo
Selector 30 technology2007vol.42, 01.
[16] ICIS chemical businessDPT licenses its technology for Saudi n-butanol
project2007 ; vol.2 ; no.49.
[17] PTQ Catalysis Normal-butanol technology selected1362-363X ;
2007 ; vol.12 ; no.3.
[18] Chemical WeeklyDavy Process Technology to supply technology for
n-butanol plant in Saudi Arabia2007 ; vol.52 ; no.23.
[19] PetroChemical News Nan Ya Chooses Dow/Davy Technology To
Retrofit and Expand Taiwan Unit2008 ; vol.46 ; no.46.
[20] www.xinhuanet.com.
[21] Chen Jijun, The 1st Batch of Polypropylene for Shenhua Ningxia Coal
Industry Group MTP Device Reaches the Standard, China Chemical
Industry News, June, 22, 2011.
10