Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
POP emissions from a large sinter plant in Taranto (Italy) over a ve-year
period following enforcement of new legislation
Vittorio Esposito a,, Annamaria Maffei a, Donato Bruno a, Berenice Varvaglione a, Salvatore Ficocelli a,
Carmelo Capoccia b, Maria Spartera a, Roberto Giua c, Massimo Blonda c, Giorgio Assennato c
a
b
c
ARPA PUGLIA, Environmental Protection Agency of Apulia, Department of Taranto, Via Anteatro 8, 74100 Taranto, Italy
ARPA PUGLIA, Environmental Protection Agency of Apulia, Department of Lecce, Via Miglietta 2, 73100 Lecce, Italy
ARPA PUGLIA, Environmental Protection Agency of Apulia, Corso Trieste 27, 70126 Bari, Italy
H I G H L I G H T S
Sinter plant is a major emitter of PCDD/F to air due to high pollutants content and high exhaust gas ow
Drastic reduction of pollutants emission was enforced by legislation
Active carbon injection proved effective in PCCD/F removal from sinter exhaust gas
Yearly mass release of PCDD/F to air still in the multigram-per-year range for Taranto plant
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 15 November 2013
Received in revised form 14 March 2014
Accepted 14 March 2014
Available online 3 April 2014
Editor D. Barcelo
Keywords:
Dioxin
Stack emissions
Integrated steelworks
Sinter plant
Abatement techniques
Legislation
a b s t r a c t
PCDD/F in exhaust gas emission samples was determined by the Environmental Agency of Apulia for a sinter
plant located in Taranto (Italy) starting from June 2007 following an Agreement Act between plant owners
and the Regional Government with the aim to assess and improve the environmental performances of the
plant. The rst two sampling campaigns yielded results ranging between 3.42 and 8.34 ng I-TE/Nm3 that were
soon considered revelatory of a high potential impact on the surrounding environment and the public, prompting
for immediate action. As a rst outcome, a Regional Regulation (LR 44/2008) was enforced in order to reduce
PCDD/F emissions by plants operating in the metal sector, including sinter plants. After installation of a urea addition plant to the sinter mix as a process-integrated abatement technique the emissions ranged from 0.86 to
3.59 ng I-TE/Nm3. In order to reach compliance to the newly introduced emission limit value of 0.4 ng I-TE/
Nm3 the urea plant was removed in favour of active-carbon injection as an end-of-pipe technique. Subsequently,
during year 2011 emission values ranged from 0.095 to 1.97 ng I-TE/Nm3, while in 2012 the observed range was
0.058 to 0.91 ng I-TE/Nm3. As a better evaluation of the potential impact of the sinter plant emissions, a yearly
mass-ow was estimated using exhaust gas PCDD/F concentrations and plant operational parameters (3.4
M Nm3/h). Mass-ow was estimated to be as high as 165 g I-TE/year for 2007 using yearly average concentrations
or 248 g I-TE/year using the peak-value of 8.34 ng I-TE/Nm3.
2014 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Starting from mid-2007 (Esposito et al., 2012; Primerano et al.,
2007) the Environment Protection Agency of Apulia has performed
several measurements of Persistent Organic Pollutant (POP) stack emissions for a number of industrial plants located in a large industrial area
near Taranto. Although information and estimates of a signicant yearly
mass ow for dioxins and PCBs from integrated steelworks were already
available and published in relevant European inventories since year 1993
(Lahl, 1993, 1994; Kinzel et al., 1994; Broker et al., 1999; Anderson and
Corresponding author. Tel.: +39 99 9949764; fax: +39 99 9946311.
E-mail address: v.esposito@arpa.puglia.it (V. Esposito).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2014.03.077
0048-9697/ 2014 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Fisher, 2002), the actual measurements were in exceedance of those estimates and prompted the need of a more in-depth investigation of the fate
and transport of POPs from emissions and release to the various environmental compartments in the Taranto area and ultimately transfer to the
food-chain through animal farming and shery, as well as the evaluation
of available abatement techniques to be applied to the existing plant in
order to reduce the overall impact (Anderson et al., 2001; Buekens
et al., 2001).
In early 2008 high levels of dioxin and dioxin-like PCBs were found
in food samples of animal origin that were collected from farms located
in the immediate surroundings of the industrial area (Diletti et al., 2009)
causing immediate alarm among citizens and authorities. As an immediate response to the events, as soon as December 2008 a Regional
119
Table 1
Results for stack emission measurements at Taranto sinter plant.
Date
12 Jun 07
14 Jun 07
16 Jun 07
26 Feb 08
27 Feb 08
28 Feb 08
23 Jun 08
24 Jun 08
26 Jun 08
21 Jul 09
22 Jul 09
23 Jul 09
17 Nov 09
18 Nov 09
19 Nov 09
11 Jan 10
12 Jan 10
13 Jan 10
1 Feb 10
2 Feb 10
3 Feb 10
16 Feb 11
17 Feb 11
18 Feb 11
16 May 11
18 May 11
19 May 11
14 Nov 11
15 Nov 11
16 Nov 11
12 Dec 11
13 Dec 11
14 Dec 11
18 Jul 12
19 Jul 12
20 Jul 12
15 Oct 12
16 Oct 12
17 Oct 12
13 Dec 12
14 Dec 12
15 Dec 12
17 Jun 13
18 Jun 13
19 Jun 13
PCDD/Fsa
Dioxinlike PCBsb
Total PCBsc
Benzo(a)
pyrene
Sum PAHsd
pg I-TE/Nm3
pg WHO-TE/
Nm3
ng/Nm3
ng/Nm3
mg/Nm3
3421
7192
6022
4443
8344
8082
2670
4215
2428
857
711
1063
1552
1261
2103
3166
778
3591
1138
1057
1243
1639
1700
1966
1159
1019
1884
327
318
264
135
95
136
462
909
677
119
143
251
687
58
339
248
123
149
181
368
346
293
520
478
195
364
226
32
29
38
117
100
132
156
56
230
100
102
105
189
178
194
124
100
176
33
33
38
13
11
16
59
111
72
13
14
28
57
4
30
44
13
16
823
2153
1259
846
1242
1236
1184
1454
1160
633
839
1064
1452
1479
1516
1127
477
794
637
527
488
1074
713
795
309
306
525
110
100
116
73
69
104
191
264
199
73
78
86
205
44
169
178
71
103
611
1480
526
917
1338
2817
539
1299
388
257
268
367
187
250
1120
1074
708
2817
487
363
341
459
1075
748
1063
1324
3086
17
15
17
1.1
3.8
8.1
10
47
62
5.0
7.5
6.3
450
26
93
1.4
1.3
1.4
0.010
0.022
0.018
0.0096
0.019
0.031
0.010
0.021
0.0098
0.0033
0.0029
0.0043
0.0054
0.0064
0.027
0.035
0.017
0.055
0.017
0.013
0.019
0.0093
0.011
0.012
0.0099
0.011
0.024
0.00028
0.00025
0.00030
0.000035
0.000058
0.00019
0.00036
0.0017
0.0020
0.00014
0.00015
0.00024
0.0086
0.00048
0.0014
0.00018
0.00017
0.00032
All data are normalised to 16% O2 content for consistency purposes only and not for
regulatory compliance.
a
Sum of seventeen 2378-chlorine substituted congeners.
b
Sum of twelve non-ortho and mono-ortho PCBs.
c
Sum of all measurable mono- to deca-CB.
d
Sum of selected PAHs as regulated by Italian Legislation: Benzo(a)anthracene,
Benzo(b + k + j)uoranthene, Benzo(a)pyrene, Indeno(123-cd)pyrene, Dibenzo(ah)anthracene, Dibenzo(al)pyrene, Dibenzo(ae)pyrene, Dibenzo(ai)pyrene, and Dibenzo(ah)
pyrene.
120
Fig. 1. a) PCDD/Fs, bold vertical lines represent the legislative deadlines, horizontal lines represent the enforced Emission Limit Values; b) dioxin-like PCBs; and c) PAHs in sinter plant stack
emission relative to the adoption of abatement techniques (ESP = electrostatic precipitator; MEEP = moving electrode electrostatic precipitator).
121
Table 2
Estimated yearly mass ow of selected pollutants for Taranto sinter plant. Italics for year
2013 represent partial estimates including only one sampling campaign.
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
PCDD/F
Dioxin-like PCBs
Total PCBs
Benzo(a)pyrene
Sum PAHs
g I-TE/year
g WHO-TE/year
kg/year
kg/year
kg/year
165
150
37
54
26
12
5.2
8.9
10
2.2
3.7
2.7
1.3
0.7
42
35
35
20
11
4.3
3.5
26
36
12
29
19
2.3
0.041
499
500
246
775
194
50
6.6
It is possible to estimate the impact of stack emissions on the environment and the public as a yearly mass ow considering a ue gas
emission of 3.4 million Nm3/h with a continuous operation of the
plant, maintenance aside, and the average emission values calculated
for each operational year. Results are summarised in Table 2 and, together with the evident reduction of the yearly mass ow for PCDD/Fs,
they show a signicant contribution of dioxin-like PCBs to overall TEQ
(about 1:20) as well as an emission of sum PAHs still in the order of
the tenth of kg/year.
As most regulated primary sources are today adequately characterised
(Breivik et al., 2004; Fiedler et al., 2003) it is possible to compare the
actual estimates provided in Table 2 with other sources and inventories.
Thermal processes are today considered to be the main sources of
PCDD/F release compared to the chemical industry whose impact was
considered to be prevalent in the past. Within combustion processes,
iron ore sintering is at present considered the most relevant source of
PCDD/F emissions to air (Quass et al., 2004). For three sinter plants
operated in the United Kingdom a cumulative annual mass release of
27.8 g I-TEQ/year was estimated for PCDD/Fs and 1.72 g WHO-TEQ/year
for dioxin-like PCBs during the period 20022004 (Aries et al., 2006).
Similarly, four sinter plants in Taiwan have shown a cumulative annual
emission of 44.7 g I-TEQ/year (Wang et al., 2003). Compared to the
above data, the estimated PCDD/F ux for the Taranto plant was actually
very high even in recent years, up to 165 g I-TEQ/y for this single plant in
2010, while emission reduction techniques, both process-integrated or
end-of-pipe, were already available and apparently implemented in
other countries. Under these circumstances the reduction of PCDD/F
ux for the Taranto plant in years 20112012 appears signicant, and
contributes to the overall PCDD/F emission reduction that is generally
observed in Europe for the period 19902011 (EEA, 2013) for both the
industrial and non-industrial sectors, the latter being an important
contributor to the total amount of PCDD/Fs released to air, especially
for solid-fuelled residential heating (Paradiz et al., 2008; Bieser et al.,
2012). The same applies to Benzo(a)pyrene and other PAHs, were gures in the order of 500 kg/year are estimated for the Taranto sinter
plant in 2008 that decreased of one order of magnitude in 2012, although it is known that for an integrated steel plant the major emitter
of Benzo(a)pyrene are coke-oven facilities (Ciaparra et al., 2009).
4. Conclusions
In 2007 stack emission measurements performed by the Apulian
Environment Protection Agency (ARPA) revealed a high PCDD/F emission at a sinter plant. Since then a stringent monitoring programme to
prove the efciency of the new abatement techniques introduced by
plant operators and to assess the compliance to newly introduced Emission Limit Values has been carried out in the period 20082013 and a
signicant reduction of the mass ow PCDD/F, PCBs, as well as PAHs
has been achieved. Studies are still ongoing to evaluate if the improvements in stack emissions are having a concomitant positive effect on
the observed POP levels in the surrounding environment.
122
References
Anderson DR, Fisher R. Sources of dioxins in the United Kingdom: the steel industry and
other sources. Chemosphere 2002;46:37181.
Anderson DR, Fisher R, Johnston S, Aries E, Fray TAT, Ooi TC. Investigation into the effect of
organic nitrogen compounds on the suppression of PCDD/Fs in iron ore sintering.
Organohalogen Compd 2007;69:355.
Anderson DR, Fisher R, Roworth MC, Wilson DT, Southern SM, Fray TAT. Formation and
suppression of PCDD/Fs in iron ore sintering. Organohalogen Compd 2001;54:1104.
Aries E, Anderson DR, Fisher R, Fray TA, Hemfrey D. PCDD/F and Dioxin-like PCB emissions from iron ore sintering plants in the UK. Chemosphere 2006;65(9):147080.
Bieser J, Aulinger A, Matthias V, Quante M. Impact of emission reductions between 1980
and 2020 on atmospheric benzo[a]pyrene concentrations over Europe. Water Air Soil
Pollut 2012;223:1393414.
Breivik K, Alcock R, Li Y, Bailey RE, Fiedler H, Pacyna JM. Primary sources of selected POPs:
regional and global scale emission inventories. Environ Pollut 2004;128:316.
Broker G, Bruckmann P, Gliwa H. Study of dioxin sources in North RhineWestphalia.
Chemosphere 1999;38(8):191324.
Buekens A, Stieglitz L, Hell K, Huang H, Segers P. Dioxins from thermal and metallurgical
processes: recent studies for the iron and steel industry. Chemosphere 2001;42(57):
72935.
Ciaparra D, Aries E, Booth MJ, Anderson DR, Almeida SM, Harrad SAtmos Environ 2009;
43:20709.
Diletti G, Ceci R, Scortichini G, Migliorati G. Dioxin levels in livestock and grassland near a
large industrial area in Taranto (Italy). Organohalogen Compd 2009;38:2359.
EEA European Environment Agency. European Union emission inventory report
19902011 under the UNECE Convention on Long-range Transboundary Air Pollution
(LRTAP). EEA technical report no 10/2013; 2013. [ISSN 17252237].
Esposito V, Maffei A, Castellano G, Martinelli W, Conversano M, Assennato G. Dioxin levels
in soil and groundwater samples in the surroundings of a large industrial area in
Taranto (Italy). Organohalogen Compd 2010;72:736.
Esposito V, Maffei A, Ficocelli S, Spartera M, Giua R, Assennato G. Dioxins from industrial
emission to the environment. The Taranto case study. Ital J Occup Environ Hyg 2012;
3(1):428.
Fiedler H, Dioxins, FuransPart O, persistent organic pollutants. The handbook of environmental chemistryBerlin, Heidelberg: Springer Verlag; 2003. p. 125201.
Francois F, Bernaert P, Baert R. Reduction of PCDD/PCDF emission in the Flemish Region
(Belgium). Organohalogen Compd 2000;45:352.
Francois F, Bernaert P, Baert R. Reduction of the dioxin emissions from iron sintering
plants in the Flemish region (Belgium) enforcement approach of the Environment
Inspection Section. Organohalogen Compd 2001;54:115.
Kinzel J, Gebert W, Gara S. PCDD/F emissions reduction for iron ore sinter plants.
Organohalogen Compd 1994;19:311.
Kuzuhara S, Sato H, Tsubouchi N, Ohtsuka Y, Kasai E. Effect of nitrogen-containing compounds on polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxin/dibenzofuran formation through de
novo synthesis. Environ Sci Technol 2005;39(3):7959.
Lahl U. Sinter plant of the steel industry the most important thermical sources of PCDD/
Fs in industrialized regions? Organohalogen Compd 1993;11:311.
Lahl U. Sintering plant of the steel industry PCDD/F emission status and perspectives.
Chemosphere 1994;29:193945.
Ooi TC, Lu L. Formation and mitigation of PCDD/Fs in iron ore sintering. Chemosphere
2011;85(3):2919.
Paradiz B, Dilara P, Hork, Santi GD, Christoph EH, Umlauf G. An Integrated Approach to
Asses the PCDD/F Emissions of the Coal Fired Stoves Combining Emission Measurements and Ambient Air Levels Modeling. Chemosphere 2008;73:S94S100.
Primerano R, Esposito V, Angiuli L, Fanigliulo A, Ficocelli M, Giua R, et al. Dioxin emission
monitoring program from a large sinter plant. Organohalogen Compd 2007;69:966.
Quass U, Fermann M, Broker G. The European dioxin air emission inventory project
nal results. Chemosphere 2004;54:131927.
Wang LC, Lee WJ, Tsai PJ, Lee WS, Chang-Chien GP. Emissions of polychlorinated dibenzop-dioxins and dibenzofurans from stack ue gases of sinter plants. Chemosphere
2003;50:11239.
World Health Organization (WHO). Assessment of the health risk of dioxins: re-evaluation
of the Tolerable Daily Intake (TDI).WHO European Centra for Environment and Health
International Programme on Chemical Safety; 1998.