Minutes of 73-EA - QEC

1
Annex-A
to the Minutes of 73-EA&QEC/EAB Meeting held on July 10, 2015 at PEC HQ Islamabad.
Agenda Item No. 03(a) Consideration of PEC Visit Reports

[Accreditation/Re-accreditation, Confirmatory, Review, Re-visit]
S#
01.
02.
03
04
a.
b.
Name of University/Program Profile
University of Engineering and Technology, Taxila (Main Campus)

Program
B.Sc. Industrial
Re-accreditation is granted for three
Engineering
years i.e., Intake of Batches 2011 to
2013.
Current Status Intake of Batch 2010
only
Further, the detailed decision shall be
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
communicated officially to the Head of
Date of Visit
April 29-30, 2015
Institution/all concerned of the HEI.
Shaheed Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science & Technology, Karachi
Program
B.E. Mechatronics
Re-accreditation is granted for two years
Current Status Intake of Batch 2010 i.e., Intake of Batches 2011 to 2012.
only
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
April 28-29, 2015
University of Engineering and Technology, Lahore (Main Campus)
Program
B.Sc. Computer
Re-accreditation is granted for Two Years
Engineering
i.e., Intake of Batches 2011 to 2012.
Current Status From Intake of Batch
2003 upto 2010
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
April 27-28, 2015
Swedish College of Engineering and
Engineering and Technology, Taxila)
Program
B.Sc. Civil
Engineering
2009 upto 2010
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
May 12-13, 2015
Technology, Wah Cantt. (University of
Program

Current Status
c.
Decision of 73-EA&QEC/EAB
Visit Type
Date of Visit
Program
Current Status
B.Sc. Electrical
Engineering
From Intake of Batch
2009 upto 2010
Re-accreditation
May 13-14, 2015
B.Sc. Mechanical
Engineering
2009 upto 2010
Re-accreditation is granted for one year

i.e., Intake of Batch 2011 only.

S#

Visit Type
Date of Visit
05
06
07
08
a.
b.
09
a.
Re-accreditation
May 14-15, 2015
Army Public College of Management

Engineering and Technology Taxila)
Program
B.Sc. Electrical
Engineering
Current Status From
Intake
of
Batches Spring-2009
upto Fall-2010
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
May 7-8, 2015
and Science, Rawalpindi (University of
Quaid-e-Awam University of Engineering, Science and Technology,

Nawabshah
Program
B.E. Electronics
only
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
March 20-21, 2015
NFC Institute of Engineering and Fertilizer Research, Faisalabad (University of
Engineering and Technology, Lahore)
Program
B.Sc. Chemical
Engineering
1998 upto 2010
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
April 29-30, 2015
Mehran University of Engineering and Technology-Shaheed Zulfiqar Ali
Bhutto, Campus Khairpur Mirs (Mehran University of Engineering and
Technology, Jamshoro)
Program
B.E. Civil
only
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
May 15-16, 2015
Program
B.E. Electrical
Current Status Intake of Batch 2010 i.e., Intake of Batch 2011 only.
only
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
May 15-16, 2015
University of Engineering and Technology, Lahore (Main Campus)
Program
B.Sc. Environmental
Engineering
2005 upto 2010
S#
b.

Visit Type
Date of Visit
Program
Current Status
Visit Type
Date of Visit
Re-accreditation
May 26-27, 2015
B.Sc. Petroleum &
Gas Engineering
Upto Intake of Batch
2010
Re-accreditation
May 25-26, 2015
10
City University of Science and Information Technology, Peshawar

Program
B.Sc. Electrical
Engineering
(Telecommunication)
Current Status From Intake of Batch Further, the detailed decision shall be
2008 upto 2010
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
April 27-28, 2015
11
University of Agriculture, Faisalabad

Program
B.Sc. Agricultural
Engineering
Current Status Upto Intake of Batch
2009
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
May 18-19, 2015

i.e., Intake of Batches 2010 and 2011.
12
The University of Lahore, Lahore (Main Campus)

Program
B. Sc. Mechanical
Engineering
2008 upto 2010
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
May 7- 8, 2015
13
Pakistan Air Force-Karachi Institute of Economics and Technology, Karachi

Program
B.E. Electronics
Current Status From Intake of Batch i.e., Intake of Batch 2011 (Spring & Fall)
only.
Fall-2003 upto 2010
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
April 30 & May 1,
2015
Hamdard Institute of Engineering and Technology, Karachi (Main Campus)
Program
B.E. Bio-Medical
only
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
May 28-29, 2015
14
a.
S#
b.

Program
Current Status
16
17
a.
b.
not inducted
university).
Visit Type
Date of Visit
18


NUST-Institute of Geographical Information Systems, Islamabad
Program
B.E. Geoinformatics
only
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
May 25-26, 2015
University of Engineering and Technology, Lahore (Kala Shah Kaku Campus)
Program
B.Sc. Chemical
Re-accreditation is granted for three
Engineering
years i.e., Intake of Batches 2011, 2012
Current Status From Intake of Batch and 2013.
2007 upto 2010
Visit Type
Re-accreditation,
Date of Visit
May 29-30, 2015
University of Engineering & Technology, Taxila (Chakwal Campus)
Program
B.Sc. Mechatronics
Engineering
i.e. Intake of Batch 2011 only.
From
Intake
of
Batch
FallCurrent Status
2005 upto 2010 (excluding Further, the detailed decision shall be
Intake of Batch 2006,
which was not inducted by
the university)
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
May 27, 2015
Program
B.Sc. Electronics
Engineering
i.e. Intake of Batch 2011 only.
From
Intake
of
Batch
Current Status
Fall-2005 upto 2010, Further, the detailed decision shall be
excluding
Intake
of communicated officially to the Head of
Batch 2006, which was Institution/all concerned of the HEI.
Visit Type
Date of Visit
15
B.E. Electronics
2004 upto 2010
Re-accreditation
May 29-30, 2015
by
the
Re-accreditation
May 28, 2015
Sarhad University of Science & Information Technology, Peshawar

Program
B.Sc. Electrical
Engineering
2005 upto 2010
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
May 28-29, 2015
S#
19
University of Gujrat, Gujrat

Program
B.Sc. Electrical
Engineering
2007 upto 2010
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
May 28-29, 2015
20
a.
b.
Sharif College of Engineering and Technology, Lahore

Program
B.Sc. Electrical
For Both Engineering Programs:
Engineering
Accreditation is deferred at this stage.
Current Status Under Process
Visit Type
First Accreditation
The decision will be made by Chair/
Date of Visit
May 29-30, 2015
Convener EA&QEC/EAB after examining
rejoinder and expert reports.
Program
B.Sc. Chemical
Engineering
Visit Type
First Accreditation
Date of Visit
May 28-29, 2015
21
National University of Computer and Emerging Sciences, Islamabad (Karachi

Campus)
Program
B.S. Electrical
(Electronics)
i.e., Intake of Batches 2011 and 2012
Engineering
only.
2009 upto 2010
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
June 2-3, 2015
22.
Mehran University of Engineering and Technology- Shaheed Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto,

Campus Khairpur Mirs (Mehran University of Engineering and Technology,
Jamshoro)
B.E. Mechanical
Program
Current Status Intake of Batch 2010 i.e., Intake of Batches 2011 and 2012.
only
Re-accreditation
Visit Type
June 9, 2015
Date of Visit
a.
b.
Program
Current Status
Visit Type
Date of Visit
23
a.
B.E Petroleum &

Natural Gas
Intake of Batch 2010
only
Re-accreditation
June 10-11, 2015

University of Engineering and Technology, Taxila (Main Campus)

Program
B.Sc. Electronics
Engineering
S#
b.

Visit Type
Date of Visit
Program
Current Status
Visit Type
Date of Visit
24
25
26
only
Re-accreditation
July 2-3, 2015
B.Sc. Environmental
Engineering
Intake of Batch 2010
only
Re-accreditation
July 3-4, 2015
University of Gujrat, Gujrat

Program
B.Sc. Chemical
Engineering
2007 upto 2010
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
May 27-28, 2015
Hamdard Institute of Engineering
(Hamdard University, Karachi)
Program
B.Sc. Electrical
Engineering
2007 upto 2009
Re-accreditation
Visit Type
April 27, 2015
Date of Visit
and Technology, Islamabad Campus
School of Engineering, University of Management and Technology, Lahore

(Formally School of Science and Technology, University of Management and Technology, Lahore)
Program
B.Sc. Electrical
Engineering
Current Status
(From Intake of Batch

2009
upto
2010).
(From Intake of Batch
2005 upto 2008 with
School of Science and
Technology, University of
Management
and
Technology, Lahore)
Visit Type
Date of Visit

Re-accreditation
May 27-28, 2015
27
National University of Modern Languages, Islamabad (Main Campus)

Program
B.E
Telecommunication
i.e., Intake of Batch 2011 and 2012.
Fall-2006 upto Spring- Further, the detailed decision shall be
2010
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
Date of Visit
May 6-7, 2015
28
Dawood University of Engineering and Technology, Karachi
S#
Program
Current Status
29
B.E. Chemical
From Intake of Batch i.e., Intake of Batch 2011 only.
2005 upto 2010
Visit Type
Confirmatory
Date of Visit
April 30, 2015
COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, Islamabad (Abbottabad
Campus)
Program
B.Sc. Electrical
Based on the substantial progress on the
(Power) Engineering
observations against the decision of 71st
Current Status From Intake of Batch EA&QEC and the commitment by the
Fall-2007 upto Fall- Rector COMSATS to adopt PEC policy
on single intake, the re-accreditation is
2010
granted for Intake of Batch 2011 (Spring
Visit Type
Re-accreditation
and Fall) only.
Date of Visit
Annex-B
to the Minutes of 73-EA&QEC/EAB Meeting held on July 10, 2015 at PEC HQ
Islamabad.
Agenda Item No. 03 (b)
S#
01.
02
Consideration of PEC Visit Reports

[Zero, Interim, Change of Scope (Nomenclature/Increase in
Intake]
Bahria University, Islamabad (Main Campus)

Program
Bachelor of Software
The program is not recommended as
Engineering
such for increase in intake at this stage
based on the following deficiencies/
Current Status Upto Intake of Batch
grounds:2010
Visit Type
Change of Scope
a. Lack of required/enhanced qualified
(Increase in Intake)
and experienced faculty to cater the
Date of Visit
March 3-4, 2015
increased student strength inline with
prescribed student teacher ratio.
b. Lack of required/enhanced no of
workstations in various dedicated labs
to accommodate proposed strength of
student.
University may apply afresh after
enhancement of resources (faculty and
labs etc) as mentioned in the visit report.
Intellectual Unique Superior Entrepreneurial-School of Engineering and
Management Sciences, Rawalpindi
Program
B.Sc. Electrical
Permission is granted to continue the
Engineering
program. Further, the following conditions
to rectify before submission of application
for 1st accreditation visit:Visit Type
Interim
Date of Visit
April 2, 2015
a. The present Campus is presently
located at the top of a commercial
plaza which is absolutely not
conducive for imparting quality
engineering
education
as
per
PEC/HEC guidelines. Therefore it is
advised that the program be shifted to
a purpose built campus with sufficient
allied
available
facilities
and
conducive environment as per the
PEC guidelines.
b. It is observed that the program faculty
is heavily biased towards Avionics
Engineering background with PhD in
S#
03
04
05
relevant
area
of
Electrical
Engineering. It is therefore advised
that the Institute should have a
balance
faculty
in
various
specializations/areas with Electrical
Engineering background registered
with PEC as such.
National University of Sciences and Technology, Islamabad - Military College
of Signals, Rawalpindi Campus
Program
B. E. Electrical
Existing annual intake of 160 be splitted
Current Status From Intake of Batch into two streams i.e., Telecommunication
1993 upto 2012 as and Electronics, within the domain of
B.E.
Electrical Electrical Engineering, as:(Communication)
a. B.E. Electrical (Telecommunication)
Visit Type
Change of Scope
b. B.E. Electrical (Electronics)
(Nomenclature) visit
report For B.Sc.
Current and previous observation/
Electrical
improvements highlighted in the visit
(Communication)
report should also be addressed.
Engineering
Date of Visit
December 8, 2014
Iqra National University, Peshawar
Program
B.Sc. Civil
Engineering
only
Visit Type
Change of Scope
Date of Visit
April 13, 2015
Based on the enhanced faculty and

resources, permission is granted to
increase in intake from 40 to 80 students
per year.
However, the university has violated the

intake in the past which will not be
accepted in future at any cost. Adherence
to the PEC policies, rules and regulations
must strictly be ensured, failure to which
may lead to discontinuation of the
program.
NED University of Engineering and Technology, Karachi
Program
B.E. Bio-Medical
The "Change of Scope (Curriculum and
Current Status From Intake of Batch duration from 5 years to 4 years)" is not
2005-06 upto 2008-09 recommended for all batches as such
due to the following reasons (Batch-wise
Visit Type
Change of Scope
analysis):(Curriculum and
duration from 5 years
a. No prior consent was obtained from
to 4 years)
the students that if they were willing to
Date of Visit
April 16-17, 2015
take a four years degree program
instead of five years, which they were
admitted for.
b. Change of scope has already been
10
S#
implemented without prior permission
of PEC.
c. The visiting team feels that the
change of scope is done haphazardly
without prior planning what the
students of different semesters would
lose in terms of theory and practical
learning.
d. Currently, the students of semester
VII (batch 2011-12) were supposed to
study three more semesters (five
years degree). Suddenly, now the
next semester will be their final
semester. It is not possible to taper off
the courses and teach the work load
of three semesters in just one
semester.
Therefore, "Change of Scope" is not
recommended at the moment for batch
2011-12. However, an application can be
made for confirmatory visit after the
teaching of the following remedial
courses in next six months. The
examination result of these courses must
also be reflected in the students'
transcript and the batch may then be
considered for grant of accreditation by
the EA&QEC.
a. Microprocessor and interfacing (3+1)
b. Neuroscience and network
engineering(2+1)
c. Physiology II(2+1)
d. Signal and systems(2+1)
e. Modeling and simulation(2+1)
For 2012-13 and onwards batches, the
"Change of Scope" is recommended
subject to the changes in the curriculum
as mentioned in the Section-11:
"Academic Program and Curriculum" of
the
re-accreditation
report.
Implementation of these changes will be
assessed in the confirmatory visit which
is to be carried out for 2011-12 batch, as
mentioned above.
11
S#
06
07
08
a.

University of Central Punjab Lahore
Program
B.Sc. Civil
Engineering
Visit Type
Interim
Date of Visit
May 21,2015
Based on the satisfactory progress,
permission is granted to continue the
program.
All the observations/weak areas identified

by the PEC visitation team must be
addressed and be intimated to PEC
before applying for the first accreditation
visit.
Army Public College of Management and Science, Rawalpindi (University of
Engineering and Technology Taxila)
Program
B.Sc. Electrical
The case of increase in intake may be
Engineering
deferred at this stage till the approval
from UET Taxila.
Current Status Accredited
Visit Type
Change of Scope
Date of Visit
May 7-8, 2015
PAF-Karachi Institute of Economics and Technology, Karachi
Program
B.E. Avionics
The observations (deficiencies & weak
areas) from the zero visit have been
addressed partially, the program may
Visit Type
Interim
proceed further with the following
Date of Visit
February 13, 2015
conditions to rectify:a. The department must be headed by a
dedicated HoD and there must be
dedicated faculty for the B.E. Avionics
program as per the PEC guidelines.
b. In addition to the faculty list provided
during the PEC visit (attached with the
report), atleast one PhD and two MS
qualified faculty members in the
relevant discipline be inducted within
six months and the progress with
evidence be intimated to PEC.
c. The weak areas mentioned in the
report must be addressed accordingly
b.
Program
Current Status
Visit Type
B.E. Mechatronics
Under Process
Interim

addressed and compliance be intimated
to PEC before applying for the first
accreditation visit.
The observations (deficiencies & weak
areas) from the zero visit have been
addressed partially, the program may
12
S#

Date of Visit
February 12, 2015
proceed further with
conditions to rectify:-
the
following
a. The department must be an

independent
administrative
unit
headed by a dedicated HoD.
b. In addition to the faculty list provided
during the PEC visit (attached with the
report), atleast two MS qualified
faculty members in the relevant
discipline be inducted within six
months and progress with evidence
be intimated to PEC.
09
10

addressed and compliance be intimated
to PEC before applying for the first
accreditation visit.
National University of Computer and Emerging Sciences, Islamabad (Karachi
Campus)
Program
B.S. Electrical
a. Change of Scope (Increase in
(Electronics)
Intake):
Engineering
Not recommended due to higher students
teacher ratio and other weaknesses etc.
Current Status Accredited
Visit Type
a. Increase in Intake :
b. Change of Scope (Nomenclature):
from 120 to 160
Change of Nomenclature i.e. B.S.
students per year
Electrical (Electronics) Engineering to
b. Change of
B.S. Electrical Engineering is granted
Nomenclature:
w.e.f. Intake of Batch Fall-2013 and
from Electrical
onwards.
(Electronics)
Engineering to
Electrical
Engineering
Date of Visit
June 1, 2015
NED University of Engineering and Technology, Karachi
Program
B.E. Food
The program was started without prior
approval/zero visit of PEC, the 1st batch
has reached to final year and the interim
Visit Type
Interim
(Zero
visit
not visit is being conducted at the stage
where the first accreditation visit is
conducted)
usually executed for the final assessment
Date of Visit
June 08,2015
of the batch/program.
The program in its present shape does
not satisfy the major decisive quality
13
S#
parameters as per the PEC guidelines/
criteria.
Based on the information submitted and
serious observations notices during the
physical inspection of required facilities,
faculty and other resources, the ongoing
batches (2011-12, 2012-13, 2013-14 and
2014-15) have not been imparted quality
education as per PEC/HEC guidelines
and criteria.
NED University is advised to fulfill the
compliance regarding all deficiencies/
weaknesses mentioned in the report,
otherwise
the
program
may
be
terminated/stopped for taking further
admissions.
11
12
The Convener EA&QEC/EAB will also

discuss this matter with the Vice
Chancellor NED UET, Karachi in order to
resolve/seek compliance on all raised
issues as per expert reports. The
EA&QEC/EAB will review the grant of
accreditation based on the visible
progress made by NED in its subsequent
meeting.
COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, Islamabad (Wah Campus)
Program
B.Sc. Electrical
After thorough review of the last change
Engineering
of scope visit report by the Moderation/
(Computer,
Review sub-committee, the house
Telecommunication)
endorsed the following decision of 71st
EA&QEC:Current Status Accredited
Visit Type
Change of Scope
"Permission is granted to add Electronics
(addition of
stream under Electrical Engineering
Electronics stream)
program within the same limit of allowed
Date of Visit
intake of 200 students per year w.e.f.
Fall-2014 (single intake only)".
Riphah International University, Islamabad (Faisalabad Campus)
Program
B.Sc. Electrical
Green Signal/Permission is granted to
Engineering
launch the program w.e.f. Fall-2015 and
onwards.
Current Status Visit Type
Zero
The intake must be restricted to 40
Date of Visit
students per year.
14
S#
13
14
Observations of the visiting team must be

addressed accordingly for onward
verification during interim visit by PEC in
the 2nd Year, particularly preparation of
labs development, faculty hiring and
other associated resources availability for
next two years.
Institute of Engineering and Technology, Gomal University, Dera Ismail Khan
Program
B.Sc. Computer
Permission is Not granted to start the
Engineering
program at this stage due to following
serious deficiencies/ weaknesses:Current Status Visit Type
Zero
a) Availability of required dedicated
Date of Visit
relevant
experienced
faculty
(Including
HoD
with
Ph.D
qualification
and
required
experience).
b) Availability of dedicted Labs and
Lab staff.
c) Allocation/utilization of separate
budget for Computer Engineering
Program.
The university must also address all other
observations as mentioned in the report
before applying for re-zero visit to start
program in future, if desired so.
COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, Islamabad (Sahiwal Campus)
Program
B.S. Computer
Permission is Not granted to start the
Engineering
program at this stage due to following
serious deficiencies/weaknesses:Current Status Visit Type
Zero
a) Availability of required dedicated
Date of Visit
relevant Ph.D faculty.
b) Availability of sperate dedicted labs
and lab staff.
c) Dedicated
space/infrastructure
required for the subject program.
d) Availability of sufficient books/journals
in the library.
The university must also address all other
observations as mentioned in the report
before applying for re-zero visit to start
program in future, if desired so.
15
S#
15
Hamdard Institute of Engineering and Technology, Karachi (Main Campus)

Program
B.E. Mechanical
Green Signal/Permission is granted to
launch the program w.e.f. Fall-2015 and
Current Status onwards.
Visit Type
Zero
Date of Visit
The intake must be restricted to 40

students per year.
Observations of the visiting team must be
addressed accordingly for onward
verification during interim visit by PEC in
the 2nd year, particularly preparation of
labs development, faculty hiring and
other associated resources availability for
next two years.

Minutes of 73-EA - QEC

Загружено:

Сведения о документе

Оригинальное название

Авторское право

Доступные форматы

Поделиться этим документом

Поделиться или встроить документ

Параметры публикации

Этот документ был вам полезен?

Это неприемлемый материал?

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

Minutes of 73-EA - QEC

Загружено:

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

1

Agenda Item No. 03(a) Consideration of PEC Visit Reports

Name of University/Program Profile

University of Engineering and Technology, Taxila (Main Campus)

Technology, Wah Cantt. (University of

Re-accreditation is granted for two years

Re-accreditation is granted for one year

Further, the detailed decision shall be

Name of University/Program Profile

Army Public College of Management

Quaid-e-Awam University of Engineering, Science and Technology,

Name of University/Program Profile

City University of Science and Information Technology, Peshawar

University of Agriculture, Faisalabad

Re-accreditation is granted for two years

The University of Lahore, Lahore (Main Campus)

Pakistan Air Force-Karachi Institute of Economics and Technology, Karachi

Name of University/Program Profile

Re-accreditation is granted for one year

Further, the detailed decision shall be

Sarhad University of Science & Information Technology, Peshawar

Name of University/Program Profile

University of Gujrat, Gujrat

Sharif College of Engineering and Technology, Lahore

National University of Computer and Emerging Sciences, Islamabad (Karachi

Mehran University of Engineering and Technology- Shaheed Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto,

B.E Petroleum &

Re-accreditation is granted for two years

University of Engineering and Technology, Taxila (Main Campus)

Name of University/Program Profile

University of Gujrat, Gujrat

School of Engineering, University of Management and Technology, Lahore

(From Intake of Batch

Re-accreditation is granted for one year

National University of Modern Languages, Islamabad (Main Campus)

Dawood University of Engineering and Technology, Karachi

Name of University/Program Profile

Consideration of PEC Visit Reports

Name of University/Program Profile

Bahria University, Islamabad (Main Campus)

Name of University/Program Profile

Based on the enhanced faculty and

However, the university has violated the

Name of University/Program Profile

Name of University/Program Profile

All the observations/weak areas identified

All the observations/weak areas identified

Name of University/Program Profile

February 12, 2015

a. The department must be an

All the observations/weak areas identified

Name of University/Program Profile

The Convener EA&QEC/EAB will also

Name of University/Program Profile

Observations of the visiting team must be

Name of University/Program Profile

Hamdard Institute of Engineering and Technology, Karachi (Main Campus)

The intake must be restricted to 40

Вам также может понравиться