Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Contents
Introduction 2
About the American Leadership Forum................................................................. 7
Education 19
Genesys Works.................................................................................................... 20
Pro-Vision, Inc..................................................................................................... 22
Cristo Rey High School........................................................................................ 24
Juvenile Justice 34
Conclusion 42
Cradle to Prison Pipeline® is a federally registered mark of the Children’s Defense Fund. All rights reserved.
2
Today, in Houston, Texas, many factors channel large The Children’s Defense Fund calls this the Cradle to
segments of our population away from productive lives Prison Pipeline® crisis. The more risk factors young people
and toward prison. They include illiteracy, poverty, poor have, the greater the likelihood they will enter the Pipeline.
health care, domestic violence, mental health issues, Once in it, kids are caught in a downward spiral that makes
teen pregnancy, unemployment, lack of positive role it almost impossible to get out. This report tells the stories
models, truancy and more. of people trying to help them.
PRENATAL
PRO
Juvenile Justice BLE
Diversion Programs MS
>
>>
D Health
N >> Care
RU
ENTIO
DET
G&
E
UR
ALC
EC
OHO
S
Mental >>
>
Health Care
ABUSE
E
ENC
ENT > VIOL
PRISON
PLOYM
Internships
>>
M
Parenting
UNE
& A
Classes
BU
>
SE
EL
>
PO D
OR E MO
SCH L
OOLIN E RO
G > NO POSITIV
>>
>>
Mentoring Education
3
Social and
economic costs
Lack of education
channels young
people into the
Pipeline.
Keeping them in
school could save
immense sums
of money.
African American boys born in 2001 stand a one-in-three lifetime risk of going to prison.
83% of African-American
fourth graders in Texas
cannot read at grade level
83%
Hispanic boys stand a one-in-six risk
of the same fate.
$67,890
The cost per child for a year of incarceration
by the Texas Youth Commission
Anglo boys a one-in-seventeen risk.
4
All Photos Pages 4-5: ©2009 Steve Liss/In Our Own Backyard. All Rights Reserved.
6
Twenty-six leaders from various fields of expertise You can help by:
comprise American Leadership Forum (ALF) Class XXV. 1. Providing direct financial assistance that enables
This group chose to study the Cradle to Prison Pipeline the expansion of facilities or staff
issue and to analyze organizations that have successfully
2. V
olunteering time to agencies that need it, such as
extricated people from the Pipeline in their communities.
those who offer mentoring
We studied these organizations’ missions, systems and
tasks with the eyes and minds of doctors, police officers, 3. C
ontributing expertise that helps these
judges, lawyers, artists, activists, teachers, parents, CEOs, organizations scale up their services
and philanthropists. 4. P
roviding training, jobs or internships
In this report, American Leadership Forum Class XXV for those in need
highlights some of these successful programs and
5. R
aising awareness of the Cradle to Prison problem
their practices.
and the organizations working to dismantle it
We identified four key areas as points where the
Pipeline can be stemmed: early childhood development; 6. Encouraging others in your network to help
education; health/mental health care; and juvenile justice. 7. S
tudying the practices of these innovators and
In each area, we identified three or four organizations applying them in your community
whose practices address the Cradle to Prison Pipeline
8. A
dvocating legislative changes that focus on
crisis and can serve as templates for future success.
prevention and early intervention instead
Our goals: to educate business and community leaders
of costly incarceration.
about model programs and create the “public will” to
promote investment in preventive programs. As statistics Addressing the Cradle to Prison Pipeline crisis
throughout this report will show, pennies spent on early will significantly and positively impact the future
prevention – before children get sick, into trouble, drop of all Houstonians.
out or suffer family breakdown – can save dollars in “cure”
down the road.
You may notice the omission of some landmark
institutions whose success has changed the cultural
This is a living document. Your
landscape of our communities. Our intentions are feedback will expand our findings
not to slight them, but to draw your attention to other and help address every aspect of
organizations that define new niches. We simply did not
have the resources to explore every worthy organization.
this issue. To learn about additional
There are numerous ways to help keep people out of programs that are working to
the Pipeline. The organizations we have identified, as well dismantle the pipeline, please visit:
as others, need money, volunteers, expertise, awareness
www.zero2three.org.
and more.
7
The American Leadership Forum joins and strengthens The American Leadership Forum is a nonprofit
diverse leaders to better serve the public good. The organization with a volunteer board. To date, 26 classes
intense year-long fellows program fosters learning and of approximately 20 leaders (called Fellows) each have
trust among experienced leaders from every sector of completed the program to become Senior Fellows.
Houston. The result: a unique forum that removes barriers Each class implements a leadership initiative of the
between people, fosters open discussion of issues, and group’s choosing.
develops solutions that benefit the entire community. Benefits include a continuing supply of effective
Joseph Jaworski founded The American Leadership and enlightened leaders trained in collaboration and
Forum in Houston in 1981 to address what he saw as a consensus building and a stronger, more cohesive
crisis of leadership throughout the country. The Houston/ community in the Houston/Gulf Coast area.
Gulf Coast Chapter is now one of nine.
Healthy Families; Dads Make a Difference; Building Strong Families; Nurse-Family Partnership
u P i p e l i n e i m pa c t p o i n t s :
Up to
$
8,000 HFI programfor- peronefamily
year
could save
$
70,000
up to
Replicable programs
designed to scale upward
In its pilot programs, HFI serves more than 1,500 people
annually. These programs begin pre-natally or at the
birth of a child. And they cost significantly less than
incarceration or foster care.
Collaboration and the engagement of community
resources are keys to strengthening families. HFI works
with many local and state entities to bring the broadest
array of services to at-risk families at the earliest possible
time. The group leverages local philanthropic support and
other funding opportunities to build scale. Having started
in the Gulfton area, HFI programs now reach citywide.
Prenatal/Infant; Parenting
NFP reduces family risk factors Net return of $5.70 per dollar spent
Nationally, NFP provides nurse home-visitation services
for high-risk populations
in 22 states to low-income, first-time mothers who NFP’s approach has undergone an external cost-benefit
voluntarily participate. Reported outcomes for all analysis. In the Elmira trial, net reductions in public costs
programs include: began accruing by the time the child turned four years
old. Evidence suggests effectively targeted programs
• 46% increase in father presence in the household
produce even larger economic returns and benefits.
• 31% fewer closely spaced subsequent pregnancies In 2003, the RAND Corporation independently
• 50% reduction in language delays at age 21 months estimated that the return for each dollar invested in
Nurse-Family Partnership was $5.70 for the higher-risk
• 67% reduction in behavioral/intellectual problems
population served and $2.88 for the entire population.
at age six.
A 1998 RAND study identified at least four types of
Randomized controlled trials of NFP were conducted in
significant savings to government agencies accruing from
Elmira, New York (1977); Memphis, Tennessee (1988); and
the NFP program:
Denver, Colorado (1994). The following consistent program
effects were found in at least two of the three trials: • Increased employment and earnings by program
participants leading to higher state and federal income
How the program benefits children
tax revenues, Social Security contributions, and state
• 48% reduction in child abuse and neglect and local sales tax revenues
• 59% reduction in arrests • Decreased government assistance use including
• 90% reduction in adjudications as PINS (person in Medicaid, Food Stamps, welfare and general
need of supervision) for incorrigible behavior. assistance by counties
How the program benefits mothers • Decreased government expenditures for education,
• 61% fewer arrests health, and other services, including special education,
emergency room visits and homeless shelters
• 72% fewer convictions
• Decreased criminal justice system spending on arrest,
• 98% fewer days in jail. adjudication and incarceration.
$
1 produces
$ 70
5 in
• Reduced need for services
• Less incarceration
• Larger tax base
Prenatal Care and Early Childhood Development 14
u Program:
ChildBuilders educates children and youth about personal Educate young children to prevent
safety, healthy relationships and how to be nurturing child abuse while creating
parents in the future. Using its “train the trainer” approach, the next generation of nurturing
ChildBuilders can reach large numbers of children with a and caring parents
small staff and at a cost of less than $25 per child. Providing innovative education programs since 1974,
ChildBuilders trains teachers, nurses, counselors, and
volunteers to teach children how to be safe, to build
healthy relationships, and to be nurturing parents to future
generations via the following three programs:
• Parents Under Construction, a research-based,
award-winning program that teaches children today the
parenting skills they will need tomorrow
• We Help Ourselves, a safety education program
designed to help children and adolescents learn to stay
safe, how to handle threatening situations, and how to
get help
• Love U2, a curriculum designed to help middle- and
high-school students develop healthy relationships.
It addresses such powerful issues as attraction,
infatuation, rejection, dating, breaking up, and dealing
with a broken heart.
Prenatal Care and Early Childhood Development 16
$
25
Less than
per child
potentially
70,000
saves
$
per abused child
Prenatal Care and Early Childhood Development 17
u Program:
Parenting; Education
100
Infant Developmental Rate Improvement
25
of infants entered
the Center behind
their appropriate
developmental
stage in motor and
%
%
language skills.
of the infants in the program were at or above
developmental norms for their age after one year.
19
Education
Education plays a major role in improving children’s lives. Teaches students the way out
We observed several particularly effective models. of the Pipeline
At-risk students face many barriers to graduation. The
Organizations that make a difference:
institutions described here offer a good education and an
• Genesys Works environment that helps them thrive. The programs build
students’ self-confidence, help them set challenging goals
• Pro-Vision, Inc.
for success, and help them reach those goals.
• Cristo Rey High School Parents are key to the success of students in these
schools, as are the mentors who agree to serve as role
Each guides young people toward college instead of jail. models. Properly selecting, training, and matching these
These programs directly affect youths who don’t have role models to the students creates an effective pathway
positive role models. The programs give students exposure out of the Pipeline for many at-risk students.
to the corporate world and teach them the skills needed Exposing students to professional work environments
to survive. In doing so, these three programs help address also provides opportunities that many caught in the
the Cradle to Prison Pipeline crisis: Pipeline would not otherwise see. Internships in real
They help the most at-risk youth in our city. Their business environments help students see what they can
success relies on several factors: achieve if they work hard and finish school.
• Intensive parent involvement
• Intensive student commitment with long school hours
• Experiential activities in the community
• Active mentorship from positive role models.
u Program:
A life alternative to
the business of poverty
At 15, Hector, a high school junior, worked at a Subway sandwich shop. He was the oldest of four
siblings. His parents didn’t finish elementary school. Hector had absolutely no expectations of continuing
his education beyond high school. On the contrary, his cousins continually encouraged him to join ‘their
business’: drug dealing.
Hector enrolled in Genesys Works instead. After training, he worked in the IT department of Reliant
Energy and then at United Space Alliance in the Space Shuttle program. He discovered he could succeed
in the corporate world, but needed to go to college. He was admitted to Texas A&M University – the only
person from his high school graduating class to go there. Although most didn’t expect Hector to stick
with college, his former supervisors encouraged him to stay on every time he wanted to quit.
Today, as a senior at A&M, Hector looks forward to graduating in May. He works at Hewlett Packard
where he will likely remain after graduation with a great salary. He also convinced his younger siblings to
enroll in Genesys Works. His sister just finished the program and enrolled at the University of Houston.
Genesys Works broke the cycle of poverty in Hector’s immediate family forever. Although his cousins still
deal drugs, Hector has avoided that path and is on track to reach his full potential.
education 22
u Program:
All-Male Middle Charter School; Manhood Development Academy; Job Enterprise Academy
u P i p e l i n e i m pa c t p o i n t s :
90
Graduation Rates
versus
49% Houston Independent
School District
education 24
Health and
Mental Health Care
The lack of mental and behavioral health care contributes These organizations have proven successful in bridging the
to keeping people inside the Pipeline. If unaddressed, gap between mental health care/behavioral health care
these issues can push individuals to the margins of society and the more routine aspects of health care and social
and make it difficult if not impossible to escape the Cradle integration in general. Common features:
to Prison Pipeline problem. • Location of services with traditional primary care
provider resources
Organizations that make a difference
• Efforts to screen and intervene at earliest possible
We found three examples of programs that use effective
stages of impairment
health and mental health care programs to address the
Cradle to Prison Pipeline crisis: • Easy access within neighborhoods (as opposed to
traditional medical centers)
• The Harris County Hospital District Community
Behavioral Health Program • Services that engage the entire family and support
groups.
• The Council on Alcohol and Drugs Houston
K.i.n.d.e.rx. Clinic
These programs successfully provide mental health care
• The Baylor College of Medicine Teen Clinics. intervention and treatment within community health care
settings. They exemplify ingenuity in their creation and
implementation. All three began through philanthropic
support.
u Program:
K.i.n.d.e.rx. Clinic
u P i p e l i n e i m pa c t p o i n t s :
Located Near the Needs The program helps young fathers develop a strong family
connection and gives them tools to establish paternity,
Baylor located the seven clinics in areas of high infant
declare child support and be a good father. This helps
mortality and teen pregnancy. The clinics provide free or
provide financial security for the child. It also reduces
low cost:
child abuse and domestic violence.
• Comprehensive primary health care
To date, 588 young moms have participated in this
• Family planning services
innovative approach to maternity care. Results show
• Screening and treatment for STI (sexually transmitted
moms have fewer medical complications; more dads
infections) and HIV
establish paternity and pay child support; and both
• Health education and risk reduction
parents play active roles in the child’s life.
• Prenatal care
• Sports physicals
Male Only Clinics: To improve the health of poor
• Wellness exams
women, we provide health care to their partners. With no
• Nutritional services
appointment necessary, the clinic provides free primary
• Counseling and case management in a culturally and
and reproductive care services to 15 - 28 year old men
age-appropriate environment.
three days per week in locations that rotate. The clinic
also offers counseling, job training and case management
Innovative Programs
that helps teens avoid problems with the law. The
Maternity care for teen moms; support for dads percentage of male clients has increased from 14% in
The Clinics’ Centering Pregnancy Program provides young, 2005 to 22% in 2008.
pregnant and parenting teens (and their partners) with
prenatal care in 12 group sessions. These sessions include:
• Medical care Core Male Services:
• Support and education on pregnancy, parenting
• Testing and treatment of STIs
and relationships
• Treatment of minor illnesses
• Co-parenting lessons.
• Testicular cancer screening
• HIV testing and counseling
• Sport and job physicals
• Mental health screening.
Teen Health Clinics in Schools classes. Ninety-two percent qualify for free and reduced-
Uninsured families delay or forego medical treatment cost lunch programs.
for their children. This can impair the children’s studies.
To respond to this need, Baylor – with the support of Cesar E. Chavez High School
public and private funding – has established two clinics This school lies less than a quarter mile from four
in Houston Independent School District high schools. At chemical plants. More than eighty percent of the 2,375
both schools, the majority of students lack insurance. students are Hispanic. More than two-thirds qualify for
free or reduced-cost lunch programs. Most are below or
Lee High School near the poverty level. Nearly one-third of the Hispanic
The Lee High School Clinic opened in 2006. Of the 2,200 students report their property has been stolen or
students at Lee, most are first-generation, Hispanic deliberately damaged at school. Improving this school will
immigrants, below or near the poverty line. They come require reducing gang activity. The Chavez High School
from 72 countries and speak 40 different languages. Clinic opened in 2008.
More than a third enroll in English-as-a-Second-Language
Juvenile Justice
According to data gathered by Mental Health America The juvenile justice system’s challenges in Harris County
of Greater Houston as part of Operation Redirect, nearly include:
six out of every 10 children processed through the Harris • Inadequate facilities
County Juvenile Detention Center have behavioral health
• Limited alternatives to secure detention
issues that likely contributed to their delinquency.
According to Texas Appleseed, during the 2006–2007 • Routine prosecution of all offenses
school year 28,616 students were sent to Disciplinary • A perception in some communities of inconsistent
Alternative Education Programs (DAEPs) in the Houston enforcement by some law enforcement agencies
area. This number represents about 20% of the total regarding minorities.
statewide referrals. These alternative schools act as a
gateway into the juvenile justice system, creating what Correctional systems and programs that seem to
many call the “School-to-Prison Pipeline.” prioritize incarceration over rehabilitation compound
Special education and minority students make up the these problems.
bulk of these referrals to DAEPs. Statewide data shows that
up to 55% of children under the care of the Texas Juvenile Organizations making a difference
Probation Commission (TJPC) or Texas Youth Commission
The three programs described on the following pages
(TYC) have a significant mental health problem. Despite
channel children away from the juvenile justice system
this, TJPC reports that only 59.5% of juveniles on probation
and into better lives:
who need mental health services actually receive them.
• Harris County Stay-in-School Program
• Harris County and the Annie E. Casey Foundation
• Harris County Protective Services for Children
and Adults.
Nearly six out of every 10 children processed through the Harris County
Juvenile Detention Center have behavioral health issues
that likely contributed to their delinquency.
juvenile justice 35
u Program:
Stay-in-School Program
u P i p e l i n e i m pa c t p o i n t s :
• Relying on hard data • Identify medium-risk cases, expedite their release, and
follow up with them
• Collaborating between systems and communities
• Understand whether alternatives to incarceration are
• Developing effective alternatives to incarceration. being used
Results are well documented: • Reduce the length of time a child spends in custody
• In Cook County, Illinois, the average detention • Reduce racial disparity in the juvenile justice system
population dropped by 37% and youth arrests • Expand availability of non-secure program slots
decreased by more than half • Ensure that interventions are timely and appropriate.
• Multnomah County, Oregon, decreased its detention
population by two-thirds and decreased arrests by The Casey Foundation/JDAI experiment demonstrates
almost half how a private/public partnership can leverage national
• Bernalillo County, New Mexico, reduced its average resources with local ones to improve a problem facing
daily population in secure detention between 1999 and our children.
2003, while seeing a 26% drop in juvenile crime. JDAI works nationwide to reduce the flow through the
Pipeline. Houston’s business community can identify and
support such efforts and thereby improve the quality of
life in Houston and its labor pool.
juvenile justice 39
Systems of Hope
u P i p e l i n e i m pa c t p o i n t s :
61.4
Quantifiable and well-evaluated Expulsion/Suspension Rates
success
%
Both the DePelchin Children’s Center and the United States
Substance Abuse Mental Health Services Administration
(SAMHSA) evaluate Systems of Hope. The SAMHSA 2008
Report Card shows that participating youth:
• Spend more time in school
• Improve their school grades
• Improve their behaviors: they exhibit fewer disciplinary
problems and have fewer arrests of youth at intake
had either been
• Demonstrate improved emotional health: they show
expelled, suspended,
improved levels of emotional well-being and make
or both from school in
fewer suicide attempts. the prior six months.
Individualized systems and support
Systems of Hope abides by consistent values and
principles that promote community-based services and
supports. Their treatment plans, which involve family
members and clients during all steps, let the youth actively
participate in their own care. Flexible funding can provide
non-traditional services to support the mental health of the
youth, such as mentoring, art therapy, relocation of family
to a safer community, medication, and so on.
28.6
Systems of Hope received a grant in 2005 and began
serving youth and families in October 2006. The funding
for this six-year grant ends in September 2011.
%
juvenile justice 41
Conclusion
We can address the Cradle to Prison Pipeline crisis
successfully. Each organization highlighted in this report
– as well as many other worthy organizations – create
pathways out of it. With enough resources and your help,
they can scale up and dismantle the Pipeline completely.