Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Margt H. Ne son
Chair
Distribution:
James L. Kruse, Assistant Disciplinary Counsel
Michael Delaney, Esquire
File
Edwards, Anne M.
advs.
John P. Brown, Jr., Ph.D.
#02-120
2.
4.
I. Background Facts
5.
6.
9.
10.
11.
12.
14.
15.
On April 24, 2000, the Board denied Dr. Brown's Motion for
Reconsideration. On the following day, the Board found that Dr.
Brown had failed to comply with the supervision restriction.
Accordingly, his license was suspended again, pending satisfactory
compliance with conditions of the February 22, 2000, order.
16.
On May 18, 2000, Dr. Brown filed a Notice of Appeal with the New
Hampshire Supreme Court, challenging the Board's orders of
February 22, April 24, and April 25, 2000.
17.
18.
19.
20.
Dr. Brown filed his initial brief on August 20,2001. Over Dr.
Brown's objection, Respondent Edwards obtained an extension of
the briefing deadline, and filed her brief on behalf of the Board on
In his appeal, Dr. Brown addressed issues raised in his Motion for
Reconsideration before the Board. In Respondent's brief, she
included a series of representations of fact, for which she cited
supporting references to the transcript below. Among those
representations were the following:
Dr. Brown admitted that during his sessions
with Ms. B., he discussed his own personal
matters including his marital discord, his
divorce (Tr. 11/6/95, p. 113), his need for sex,
and other patients (Tr. 11/6/95, p. 105).
Following his divorce, he stated on the record
that he requested to date various friends of Ms.
B.'s and asked her to give his name to her single
friends. Tr. 11/27/95, pp. 34-35; Tr. 11/6/95,
p. Ill. Dr. Brown acknowledged giving Ms. B.
flowers. Tr. 11/6/95, p. 215. Ms. B. gave Dr.
Brown numerous gifts. Tr. 11/6/95, pp. 92-93.
In addition, Ms. B. performed personal services
for Dr. Brown, such as laundry, ironing,
bringing him meals (Tr. 11/6/95, pp. 89-90),
and driving him and his son to various places.
Tr. 11/6/95, pp. 91-92. On one occasion, Ms.
B. hemmed Dr. Brown's pants. Tr. 11/6/95, p.
90.
Brief for the State of New Hampshire, In re: Appeal of
John P. Brown, Jr., Ph.D., No. 2000-322, November 1,
2001, p. 5-6.
22.
In his Reply Brief of November 14, 2001, Dr. Brown claimed that
Respondent's brief misrepresented facts in the record. For
example, he asserted that the 1995 transcript contained no
admissions regarding his alleged comment about needing sex and
no evidence Dr. Brown accepted ironing and laundry services from
his client. See Reply Brief of the Appellant, November 14, 2001, p.
2-3.
23.
24.
even hint of crossing sexual boundaries, use her for financial gain,
or demonstrate psychopathological behavior."
25.
The hearing transcript revealed that Dr. Brown had not taken
advantage of other opportunities to contest Ms. Barton's testimony
regarding his alleged inappropriate comment about "needing sex."
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
33.
10
34.
The Supreme Court decided not to remand the case for any further
proceedings before the Board. According to the Court, itwould
serve no purpose to have the Board consider this matter for a third
time. By the time of its order, Dr. Brown had satisfied all
sanctions and his certificate to practice had been restored.
36.
37.
38.
40.
The Sullivan County Superior Court was persuaded that the issues
before it were the same or similar to those raised in the earlier
Merrimack County Superior Court proceeding brought by Dr.
Brown, which was dismissed. Accordingly, by order of January 16,
2004, the Sullivan County Superior Court action was dismissed.
41.
12
II: Analysis
(AI
43.
44.
13
46.
14
47.
48.
All issues raised by Dr. Brown under RSA 91-A have been fully
pled, litigated, and disposed of in the referenced Merrimack County
and Sullivan County equity actions. There is no indication in
either case that Respondent did anything but properly represent
the Board. Dr. Brown establishes no cognizable basis for finding
misconduct.
(B)
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
54.
55.
16
57.
17
58.
59.
60.
61.
18
62.
64.
65.
66.
19
(B)
B~~~
L,~
J
es L. Kruse
:stant Disciplinary Counsel
CERTIFICATION
~~~-~
~- ~.
.
~~
~ames
L. Kruse
20
EXHIBIT
certificate Holder: John P. Brown, Jr.
certificate Number:
378
APU File No.: U-94-00l7
DOR: 11/3/94
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION
I.
SUMMARY OF COMPLAINTS:
SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATION:
- 3 -