Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 12

Federal Register / Vol. 72, No.

138 / Thursday, July 19, 2007 / Proposed Rules 39593

an EIRP of ¥10 dBm or, alternatively, consideration. Comments received after Time. Illinois and western Kentucky
a power density of 90 pW/cm2 at a that date will be considered to the observe Central Time, while eastern
distance of 3 meters. If a power density extent practicable. If the time zone Kentucky, Ohio, and the portion of
measurement is performed and 3 meters boundary is changed as a result of this Michigan adjoining Indiana observe
is not within the far field, the rulemaking, the effective date would be Eastern Time.
measurements shall be performed at November 4, 2007. Federal law provides that an
whatever greater distance is necessary to ADDRESSES: You may submit comments individual State can decide whether or
result in the measurement being in the by any of the following methods: not to observe daylight saving time. In
far field and the results shall be • Web site: http://dms.dot.gov. 2005, the Indiana General Assembly
extrapolated to a distance of 3 meters as Follow the instructions for submitting adopted legislation (Pub. L. 243–005 or
specified in section 15.31(f)(1) of this comments on the DOT electronic docket the Indiana Act) that provides that the
part. site. entire State of Indiana would observe
* * * * * • Fax: 1–202–493–2251. daylight saving time beginning in 2006.
(e) Except as specified below, the total • Mail: Docket Management Facility; In addition, the Indiana Act addressed
peak transmitter output power shall not U.S. Department of Transportation, 1200 the issue of changing the Eastern and
exceed 500 mW. Depending on the gain New Jersey Avenue, SE., Room W12– Central Time Zone boundaries.
140, Washington, DC 20590–0001. In January 2006 (71 FR 3228) and
of the antenna, it may be necessary to
• Hand Delivery: Room W12–140 on February 2007 (72 FR 6170), DOT
operate the intentional radiator using a
the plaza level of the U.S. Department completed rulemaking proceedings
lower peak transmitter output power in
of Transportation, 1200 New Jersey establishing new time zone boundaries
order to comply with the power density
Avenue, SE., Washington, DC, between that resulted in the current time zone
limits or EIRP limits specified in
9 a.m. and 5 p.m., Monday through observance. Knox, Daviess, Martin, Pike,
paragraph (b) of this section. and Dubois Counties (the Petitioning
* * * * * Friday, except Federal holidays.
• Federal eRulemaking Portal: Go to Counties), which were moved to the
[FR Doc. E7–13832 Filed 7–18–07; 8:45 am] http://www.regulations.gov. Follow the Central Time Zone in January 2006,
BILLING CODE 6712–01–P online instructions for submitting have now filed a Joint Petition
comments. requesting a time zone change back to
General Instructions: All submissions the Eastern Time Zone.
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION must include the agency name and Statutory Requirements
docket number (OST Docket Number Under the Standard Time Act of 1918,
Office of the Secretary 2007–28746) or Regulatory as amended by the Uniform Time Act of
Identification Number (RIN 2105–AD71) 1966 (15 U.S.C. 260–64), the Secretary
49 CFR Part 71 for this rulemaking. Note that all of Transportation has authority to issue
[OST Docket No. 2007–28746] comments received will be posted regulations modifying the boundaries
without change (including any personal between time zones in the United States
RIN 2105–AD71 information provided) to http:// in order to move an area from one time
dms.dot.gov. Please refer to the Privacy zone to another. The standard to modify
Standard Time Zone Boundary in
Act heading under Regulatory Notices. a boundary contained in the statute for
Southwest Indiana
Docket: For access to the docket to such decisions is ‘‘regard for the
AGENCY: Office of the Secretary (OST), read background documents or convenience of commerce and the
the Department of Transportation comments received, go to http:// existing junction points and division
(DOT). dms.dot.gov at any time or to Room points of common carriers engaged in
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking. W12–140 on the plaza level of the U.S. interstate or foreign commerce.’’ 15
Department of Transportation, 1200 U.S.C. 261.
SUMMARY: DOT proposes to relocate the New Jersey Avenue, SE., Washington,
time zone boundary in Indiana to move DC, between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m., Monday DOT Procedures To Change a Time
Knox, Daviess, Martin, Pike, and Dubois through Friday, except Federal holidays. Zone Boundary
Counties from the Central Time Zone to FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: DOT has typically used a set of
the Eastern Time Zone. This action is Judith S. Kaleta, Office of the General procedures to address time zone issues.
taken at the request of the Boards of Counsel, U.S. Department of Under these procedures, DOT will
Commissioners of each of the counties. Transportation, 1200 New Jersey generally begin a rulemaking proceeding
DOT requests comment on whether this Avenue, SE., Washington, DC 20590, to change a time zone boundary if the
change would serve the convenience of indianatime@dot.gov, (202) 493–0992. highest elected officials in the area
commerce, the statutory standard for a SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: submit a petition requesting a time zone
time zone change and whether the time change and provide adequate data
zone boundary should be changed for Current Indiana Time Observance supporting the proposed change. We ask
other contiguous counties in Indiana is divided into 92 counties. that the petition include, or be
southwestern Indiana. Persons Under Federal law, 75 counties are in accompanied by, detailed information
supporting or opposing the change the Eastern Time Zone and 17 are in the supporting the requesting party’s
should not assume that the change will Central Time Zone. There are six contention that the requested change
be made merely because DOT is making Central Time Zone counties in the would serve the convenience of
cprice-sewell on PROD1PC66 with PROPOSALS

the proposal. The final rule will be northwest (Lake, Porter, La Porte, commerce. The principle for deciding
based on all of the information received Starke, Newton, and Jasper) and eleven whether to change a time zone is
during the entire rulemaking proceeding in the southwest (Knox, Daviess, Martin, defined very broadly to include
and whether the statutory standard has Gibson, Pike, Dubois, Posey, consideration of all impacts of such a
been met. Vanderburgh, Warrick, Spencer, and change on a community. We also ask
DATES: Comments should be received by Perry). Neighboring states differ as to that the supporting documentation
August 20, 2007 to be assured of whether they observe Eastern or Central address, at a minimum, each of the

VerDate Aug<31>2005 13:52 Jul 18, 2007 Jkt 211001 PO 00000 Frm 00012 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\19JYP1.SGM 19JYP1
39594 Federal Register / Vol. 72, No. 138 / Thursday, July 19, 2007 / Proposed Rules

following questions in as much detail as currently located in the Eastern Time commerce data, DOT concluded that the
possible: Zone. The Petitioning Counties are Petitioning Counties have stronger ties
1. From where do businesses in the bordered to the west by Illinois and to to each other and to other counties to
community get their supplies, and to the south by counties in Indiana that are their south in the Central Time Zone
where do they ship their goods or currently located in the Central Time than to the counties on their northern
products? Zone. According to data from STATS and eastern borders in the Eastern Time
2. From where does the community Indiana (an information service of the Zone. DOT, therefore, granted the
receive television and radio broadcasts? Indiana Business Research Center at petitions and changed the time zone
3. Where are the newspapers Indiana University’s Kelly School of boundaries for the Petitioning Counties
published that serve the community? Business), the Petitioning Counties had from the Eastern Time Zone to the
4. From where does the community a total population of 132,842 in 2005. Central Time Zone. The change to the
get its bus and passenger rail services; The Petitioning Counties were five of Central Time Zone became effective on
if there is no scheduled bus or passenger the eight counties that moved from the April 2, 2006.
rail service in the community, to where Eastern Time Zone to the Central Time Only a few months later, on August
must residents go to obtain these Zone under DOT’s January 2006 final 18, 2006, the Boards of Commissioners
services? rule. of the Petitioning Counties jointly
5. Where is the nearest airport; if it is In the original 2005 rulemaking submitted a petition (Joint Petition) in
a local service airport, to what major proceeding, the Petitioning Counties which they enumerated the reasons that
airport does it carry passengers? submitted their petitions individually. the Petitioning Counties, as a unit,
6. What percentage of residents of the In their 2005 petitions, they enumerated should be changed back to the Eastern
community work outside the reasons for a move to the Central Time Time Zone. As compared to the original
community; where do these residents Zone based in large part on comments petitions from the Petitioning Counties,
work? made during open, local public the Joint Petition includes updated
7. What are the major elements of the meetings in the respective counties. The answers to the questions DOT considers
community’s economy; is the Daviess County petition emphasized in making time zone determinations as
community’s economy improving or Evansville (in the Central Time Zone) as well as exhibits in support of these
declining; what Federal, State, or local the place with the closest airport and answers. The Joint Petition provides
plans, if any, are there for economic the place where its residents shop, more detailed responses to DOT’s
development in the community? conduct business, and receive television questions related to community imports
8. If residents leave the community broadcasts, with ‘‘numerous citizens’’ and exports, television and radio
for schooling, recreation, health care, or employed in Gibson County (in the broadcasts, newspapers, bus and
religious worship, what standard of time Central Time Zone). The Dubois County passenger rail services, airports/airline
is observed in the places where they go petition pointed out that while many services, worker commuting patterns,
for these purposes? services are obtained within-county, the the community’s economy/economic
In addition, we consider any other decision to move to the Central Time development, and schooling, recreation,
information that the county or local Zone was supported by ‘‘60 to 70% of health care, or religious worship.
officials believe to be relevant to the the general public, by representatives of The Joint Petition requests a change
proceeding. We consider the effect on three local school districts, and by that is contrary to the Petitioning
economic, cultural, social, and civic approximately 50% of local business Counties’ positions in their original
activities, and how a change in time and industry.’’ The Knox County individual petitions. The Joint Petition
zone would affect businesses, petition stated that many of its residents claims the original petitions ‘‘were
communication, transportation, and work in the Central Time Zone, creating incomplete and conclusory, and the
education. ‘‘time zone issues during substantial information they contained was limited
portions of the year’’ and those residents and largely based on opinion and not
2005–2006 Indiana Time Zone
who leave for schooling, recreation, backed by substantial and verifiable
Rulemaking Proceedings Involving the
healthcare and religious worship go to evidence.’’ The Joint Petition states that,
Petitioning Counties
areas in the Central Time Zone. The since the January 2006 ruling, there has
On August 17, 2005, DOT published Martin County petition stated that been ‘‘a groundswell of support for
a notice in the Federal Register inviting ‘‘inclusion in the Central Time Zone is returning to the Eastern Time Zone,
county and local officials in Indiana that preferred by a majority of those which has been a product of residents
wished to change their current time responding,’’ that 40% of its residents and businesses having been
zone in response to the Indiana Act to work outside of the County (mainly in inconvenienced in ways that they could
notify DOT of their request for a change the Central Time Zone), and that the not have fully anticipated until the
by September 16, 2005, and to provide primary providers of goods and switch occurred.’’ Accordingly, the Joint
data in response to the questions recipients of products to and from the Petition claims ‘‘to contain more
identified in the previous section on County are already located in or are extensive and thorough research on this
DOT Procedures to Change a Time Zone petitioning to be in the Central Time issue.’’
Boundary. DOT received 19 petitions Zone. The Pike County petition cited The Joint Petition was accompanied
from counties asking to be changed from television and radio broadcasting, the by letters from Indiana Governor
the Eastern Time Zone to the Central interests of its mining industry and an Mitchell Daniels, the Indiana Economic
Time Zone, including the five increasing number of employees Development Corporation, and the
Petitioning Counties. commuting to counties in the Central Indiana Department of Workforce
cprice-sewell on PROD1PC66 with PROPOSALS

The Petitioning Counties are located Time Zone. Development. The Governor wrote in
between Evansville and Indianapolis, Based on these petitions and support of the Joint Petition, stating that
near the geographic center of North comments that were submitted to the putting more of the State in the same
America and the median center of the docket and made at the public hearings, time zone will provide clarity on the
U.S. population. The Petitioning as well as an analysis of Indiana time questions and advance economic
Counties are bordered to the north and economic, workforce, transportation, growth. The two organizations
east by counties in Indiana that are and education regions as well as media/ addressed regional connectivity. They

VerDate Aug<31>2005 13:52 Jul 18, 2007 Jkt 211001 PO 00000 Frm 00013 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\19JYP1.SGM 19JYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 72, No. 138 / Thursday, July 19, 2007 / Proposed Rules 39595

noted that they established their back to the Eastern Time Zone and the Huntingburg Chambers of Commerce,
respective State regions based on their information submitted by the the Joint Petition states that the major
ability to deliver services. They did not Petitioning Counties. These comments employers in Dubois County ship their
establish regions based on time zones or express the preferences of the residents products to major metropolitan areas up
‘‘convenience of commerce.’’ of the Petitioning Counties and the and down the East Coast and that ‘‘the
After reviewing the Joint Petition and views of businesses and individuals on dollar volume of commerce in the
its accompanying exhibits and letters of how a particular time zone has county is driven by customers and
support, on September 28, 2006, DOT impacted or would impact the suppliers in the Eastern Time Zone.’’
sent a letter to the Petitioning Counties Petitioning Counties. The focus of this The original Knox County petition
requesting that certain procedural Notice of Proposed Rulemaking is on stated that its businesses ‘‘obtain
concerns be addressed. Specifically, the Joint Petition and Supplemental supplies and ship goods and products
DOT requested the submission of Responses. Before making a final from and to locations in various time
amended signature pages for each determination on whether to change the zones’’ and to ‘‘all parts of the United
county, certifying that the request was time zone boundaries for the Petitioning States and the Northern Hemisphere.’’
the result of official action by the Board Counties, we will carefully review the The Joint Petition makes a similar
of County Commissioners, the vote of Joint Petition and Supplemental assertion, stating specifically that
the Board members concerning the Responses in conjunction with any Futaba Indiana of America
submission of the Joint Petition, the date additional comments received and data manufactures door frames for Toyota’s
of the vote, and the signature for each gathered during the rulemaking process. Princeton, Indiana plant in the Central
Board member. The Petitioning Time Zone and also ships products to
Counties complied with this request on DOT Determination
Toyota’s Georgetown, Indiana plant in
November 13, 2006 (First Supplemental Based on the Joint Petition and the the Eastern Time Zone. The Joint
Response). three Supplemental Responses, DOT Petition adds that another large
On November 14, 2006, the DOT sent finds that the Petitioning Counties have employer in Dubois County, Gemtron/
a second letter seeking clarification and provided enough information to justify Schott, ships products all over the
additional information from the proposing to change their boundary United States. The original Martin
Petitioning Counties before making any from the Central Time Zone to the County petition declared that the
determination on whether to propose a Eastern Time Zone. As set forth below, primary providers and recipients of its
time zone boundary change for the the Petitioning Counties addressed all of products were counties petitioning for
Petitioning Counties. In turn, on the factors that we consider in these
placement or currently in the Central
December 6, 2006, the Petitioning proceedings and overall made a
Time Zone. On the other hand, the Joint
Counties submitted to DOT a reasonable case that changing back the
Petition refers to a business manager for
supplemental response (Second Petitioning Counties to the Eastern Time
EG&G Crane Operations located at the
Supplemental Response) and appendix Zone would serve ‘‘the convenience of
Naval Surface Warfare Center Crane
to DOT’s request for this additional commerce.’’
Division (NSWC Crane) and identifies
substantive information.
Community Imports and Exports NSWC Crane as the largest employer in
Upon reviewing the Second
Supplemental Response, DOT The 2005 individual petitions from the County, and claims that although
determined that while the Petitioning each Petitioning County to move from NSWC Crane ships its products
Counties provided answers to most of the Eastern Time Zone to the Central throughout the United States, its two
DOT’s inquiries, in some instances gaps Time Zone did not include very detailed largest customers are located in the
remained, and there were analyses of community imports and Eastern Time Zone. (We note that this
inconsistencies in the responses. exports. On the other hand, in the Joint information comes from the Joint
Information provided by the Petitioning Petition and the Second and Third Petition, not directly from NSWC Crane
Counties needed to be corrected or Supplemental Responses, the or its officials.) Finally, while the
clarified. On April 2, 2007, therefore, Petitioning Counties provide additional original Pike County petition made no
DOT sent another letter to the evidence in support of the contention mention of its community imports and
Petitioning Counties requesting that, when considered as a single unit, exports, it noted that Pike County has a
additional information and verification the balance of the evidence supports significant coal mining industry. The
of the data submitted. This request was placement in the Eastern Time Zone. Joint Petition reiterates the importance
necessary in light of the lack of The original Daviess County petition of the coal mining industry in Pike
complete and accurate information stated that the largest metropolitan area County and that the bulk of coal mined
previously provided to DOT by the where its residents transact business is in the County is used by two of the
Petitioning Counties. DOT noted, Evansville. In contrast, the Joint Petition County’s largest employers (Indiana
‘‘While the clarification of particular quotes the Executive Director of the Power & Light and Hoosier Energy),
facts may not be dispositive to DOT’s Daviess County Economic Development which maintain headquarters and
determination that a time zone change Corporation as stating that businesses in generating plants in the Eastern Time
would serve the convenience of Daviess County ‘‘uniformly desire to be Zone.
commerce standard, we want to ensure on Eastern Time’’ and that the top In addition to focusing on the imports
the integrity of the data we rely upon.’’ businesses and industries there ship and exports in each of the Petitioning
On May 29, 2007, the Petitioning most of their products into the Eastern Counties, the Joint Petition takes a
Counties responded by letter (Third Time Zone. The original Dubois County broader perspective. Citing statistics
cprice-sewell on PROD1PC66 with PROPOSALS

Supplemental Response), accompanied petition stated that its businesses compiled by the Indiana Chamber of
by numerous exhibits. ‘‘acquire and ship supplies and Commerce (Chamber), it notes that over
products nationally and internationally, one-third of all Indiana’s exports are
Comments to the Docket and probably as to purchase and sales sent to the Eastern Time Zone, whereas
There are currently nearly 300 entries no time zone would have priority over only one-fourth of all Indiana’s exports
to the docket addressing the request of any other zone.’’ On the other hand, had a final destination in the Central
the Petitioning Counties to be changed citing the Directors of the Jasper and Time Zone. The Chamber’s statistics

VerDate Aug<31>2005 13:52 Jul 18, 2007 Jkt 211001 PO 00000 Frm 00014 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\19JYP1.SGM 19JYP1
39596 Federal Register / Vol. 72, No. 138 / Thursday, July 19, 2007 / Proposed Rules

also indicate that over one-half of petitioning to be in, the Eastern Time time zone differences. DOT solicits
Indiana’s imports come from a ‘‘point of Zone.’’ In fact, ‘‘over 50% of the dollar further information concerning
origin’’ in the Eastern Time Zone, volume of commerce is driven by community imports and exports that
whereas less than one-half of all Indiana customers in the Eastern Time Zone’’ for would aid in determining whether a
imports had a point of origin in the those companies. In response to DOT’s change in the time zone for the
Central Time Zone. However, DOT inquiry regarding the fact that Dubois Petitioning Counties would serve the
questioned the Petitioning Counties on County has historically been on a convenience of commerce.
whether these facts support a move to different time than its suppliers and
Television and Radio Broadcasts
the Eastern Time Zone, noting that these customers during seven months of the
statistics also reveal that two-thirds of year (before Indiana began to observe With regard to television and radio
products are exported to locations other daylight saving time in 2006), the broadcasts, the original petitions
than the Eastern Time Zone and that Second Supplemental Response notes submitted by each Petitioning County
just less than one-half come from a that the convenience of commerce made general statements about
point of origin other than the Eastern would nonetheless be even better served transmissions that each Petitioning
Time Zone. In their Second if businesses could communicate in County receives. The original Daviess
Supplemental Response, the Petitioning ‘‘real time’’ (communicating at the same County petition stated that it receives its
Counties nonetheless contend that, hour in both places) with their television broadcasts from both
although the total import/export data customers during the course of an entire Evansville and Terre Haute. The original
may not support a change to the Eastern year. They claim that this move would Dubois County petition stated that it
Time Zone, they wanted to ensure that shift resources away from coping receives radio transmissions from
they addressed all the criteria mechanisms and toward more within the county and television
considered by DOT and asserted that the productive business activities. broadcasts from Evansville, Louisville,
balance of the evidence presented in the In the Second Supplemental Terre Haute, and Indianapolis. The
Joint Petition supports a move from the Response, the Petitioning Counties original Knox County petition pointed
Central Time Zone to the Eastern Time address DOT’s questions about out that it is the second-largest
Zone. commerce in Knox County arising from television audience for Terre Haute and
The Joint Petition also points out that the Joint Petition. The Second the fourth-largest for Evansville. The
‘‘if the Petitioning Counties are put on Supplemental Response claims that a original Martin County petition noted
Eastern Time, all of the nearest Wal- move to the Eastern Time Zone would that it is served by television stations
Marts for residents in the Petitioning put Futaba Indiana of America (FIA), located in Evansville in Vanderburgh
Counties would be on Eastern Time.’’ identified as a major Knox County County and Vincennes in Knox County.
The Joint Petition claims that, although automobile parts producer, in the same Finally, the original Pike County
the majority of these stores are open 24 time zone as its two important petition stated that the majority of its
hours a day, the Jasper location in customers in the Eastern Time Zone. broadcasts originate out of Evansville.
Dubois closes during the night and has Although FIA also ships its products to The Joint Petition and Second and
a different schedule than its distribution locations in the Central Time Zone Third Supplemental Responses provide
center (located in Jackson County, in the (including Chicago and Texas), the more detailed information regarding
Eastern Time Zone), thereby adversely Second Supplemental Response asserts television and radio broadcasting in the
affecting its shipping schedule. The that harmonizing the manufacturing Petitioning Counties. The Joint Petition
Joint Petition contends this is important plant with at least two of its customers states that the majority of the Petitioning
for the counties because many located in the Eastern Time Zone would Counties (Knox, Daviess, and Martin)
‘‘[i]ndividuals and small businesses positively advance the convenience of are in the Terre Haute Designated
* * * depend on Wal-Mart Stores and commerce. DOT requested support for Market Area (DMA), in the Eastern Time
Supercenters for their goods and these assertions and, in the Third Zone. The remaining Petitioning
supplies.’’ Thus, the Joint Petition Supplemental Response, the Petitioning Counties (Pike and Dubois) are part of
concludes that the convenience of Counties cite to an FIA receptionist, the Evansville DMA, in the Central
commerce would be best served if all newspaper articles, and the Director of Time Zone.
stores and distribution centers were the Knox County Development The Joint Petition claims that every
located in the same zone, in order to Corporation in support of their position radio station with the strongest signal in
reduce confusion for just-in-time on this issue. the Petitioning Counties is currently
delivery systems and to accommodate While DOT remains unconvinced by located, or petitioning to be, in the
work schedules. the assertions of the Petitioning Eastern Time Zone. In support of this
In the Third Supplemental Response, Counties as they relate to FIA and the statement, the Joint Petition includes
the Petitioning Counties clarify that the Knox County economy, the Petitioning two charts that list the stations (both FM
Jasper Wal-Mart is open 24 hours a day. Counties have submitted sufficient and AM) with the three strongest signals
Nevertheless, the Third Supplemental information to show that many that reach each of the five petitioning
Response notes that, because the businesses and industries located in the counties. These charts also indicate the
pharmacy and automotive department Petitioning Counties have substantial city and county where the station is
operate under limited hours, it might business connections in the Eastern currently located, as well as the time
better serve the convenience of Time Zone that would justify proposing zone of the station’s location if the
commerce if the store was located in the to move the time zone boundary for the petition were granted. DOT questioned
Eastern Time Zone. Petitioning Counties to the Eastern Time the decision to include only the signals
cprice-sewell on PROD1PC66 with PROPOSALS

The Joint Petition also states that Zone. In addition, the Petitioning with the three strongest frequencies,
product manufacturers (the major Counties have submitted sufficient whether these were the strongest
employers in Dubois County) ship their information to justify proposing to move frequencies, and the choice to include
products mainly to ‘‘major metropolitan the time zone boundary based on their certain frequencies themselves in the
areas up and down the East Coast,’’ claims that the convenience of chart.
while the ‘‘majority of suppliers are commerce would better be served if In the Second Supplemental
likewise located in, or are in areas businesses did not have to adjust for Response, the Petitioning Counties

VerDate Aug<31>2005 13:52 Jul 18, 2007 Jkt 211001 PO 00000 Frm 00015 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\19JYP1.SGM 19JYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 72, No. 138 / Thursday, July 19, 2007 / Proposed Rules 39597

again claim that the chart in the Joint in the Eastern Time Zone, the signal strength is enough evidence to
Petition ‘‘demonstrates that the convenience of commerce is best served support proposing a change in time
Petitioning Counties are oriented toward by moving the Petitioning Counties to zone. In addition, the majority of
the Eastern Time Zone.’’ In order to Eastern Time.’’ television signals become aligned with
supplement that claim, the Petitioning Because the Joint Petition’s claims the Eastern Time Zone because the
Counties submitted a second set of that ‘‘these counties are served by Counties have petitioned to move as a
charts in Appendix C to the Second various cable systems and a variety of single unit. DOT seeks comments on the
Supplemental Response (not ‘‘Appendix satellite systems,’’ DOT requested that information submitted by the
B’’ as referenced in the Second the Petitioning Counties list the Petitioning Counties and requests any
Supplemental Response). Rather than channels offered by any cable providers additional information on television and
including the three strongest signals in each county that are locally generated radio broadcasting, including audience
available in each of the respective and the location and time zone of those size in the Petitioning Counties, that
counties, these charts provide more broadcasts. In the Second Supplemental would aid in determining whether a
specific information, including all radio Response, the Petitioning Counties time zone change for these Counties
stations (both FM and AM) and the provide a chart indicating the would serve the convenience of
major city of the listening audience of Designated Market Area and the commerce.
each petitioning county: Washington in significantly viewed channels for each
County with the city and county where Newspapers
Davies, Jasper in Dubois, Vincennes in
Knox, Loogootee in Martin, and the station is located as well as the Only three out of the five original
Petersburg in Pike. Based on current time zone and the projected individual petitions, Dubois, Knox, and
classifications by http://www.radio- time zone if the Joint Petition were Martin Counties, discussed newspaper
locator.com, the chart arranges the granted. The only significant change in distribution numbers within their
stations in order of strength of signal to time zone involves stations located counties. These three petitions
the listening area, with the strongest within the Petitioning Counties emphasized that the primary
signals listed first. The chart also themselves, which move from the newspapers delivered are local daily
includes the current time zone of the Central Time Zone to the Eastern Time newspapers. Nevertheless, the original
radio signal’s origin and the time zone Zone. Dubois County petition acknowledged
if the petition were granted. The only In further support of a change to the receipt of newspapers from Evansville
Eastern Time Zone, in the Second in the Central Time Zone and Louisville
difference between the chart in the Joint
Supplemental Response, the Petitioning in the Eastern Time Zone. The original
Petition and the chart in the Second
Counties state that, under the status Knox County petition also noted that
Supplemental Response is the differing
quo, ‘‘viewers in the Petitioning there is a ‘‘substantial circulation’’ of
time zone origin. Stations (both FM and
Counties may miss their news because the Evansville Courier, and that
AM) that originated in the Petitioning
it comes on at 5 a.m. in the morning and residents also receive newspapers from
Counties would move from the Central
at 4 p.m. in the evening.’’ On the other Terre Haute and Indianapolis, both in
Time Zone to the Eastern Time Zone.
hand, if the Joint Petition were granted, the Eastern Time Zone.
With such a uniform shift, it is not clear The Joint Petition expounds on the
the Petitioning Counties simply argue
that a change in time zone would serve idea that the Petitioning Counties are
that ‘‘the majority of viewers in the
the convenience of commerce. largely served by their local
Petitioning Counties who work 8 a.m. to
Furthermore, DOT questions whether newspapers. The Joint Petition states
5 p.m. (and currently receive their
signal strength is sufficient evidence to that residents of the Petitioning
programming from a station operating
support the conclusion that the on Eastern Time) will receive their local Counties rely on other newspapers
particular time zone matters for radio news before going to work in the published in or adjacent to their own
broadcasting. The Petitioning Counties morning and after they return from work counties, ‘‘all of which are already in or
have not shown how having a strong in the evening.’’ Seeking clarification of are petitioning to be in the Eastern Time
signal translates into an increased this argument and additional Zone’’ and thereby ‘‘likely serve the
audience nor have they accounted for justification, DOT wrote to the Petition advertising needs of local businesses.’’
the type of radio programming that is Counties and noted that each of the The Joint Petition acknowledges that the
being offered. Petitioning Counties receives a signal Petitioning Counties are served by both
With regard to television that originates in the Central Time Zone. the Indianapolis Star (with a total
broadcasting, the Joint Petition includes In the Third Supplemental Response, circulation of 4,251) and the Evansville
a chart listing the TV stations for the the Petitioning Counties assert, Courier & Press (with a total circulation
Petitioning Counties, the city and ‘‘Convenience of commerce is served by of 12,740). However, the Joint Petition
county where each station is located, providing viewers with better access to claims that these papers focus almost
and the time zone of the station if the the market designated to provide them exclusively on national news and the
petition were granted. In addition, the coverage’’ and refer to significantly local news particular to their cities,
Joint Petition indicates that the National viewed stations, which are the most Indianapolis and Evansville. The
Weather Service Center serving four of viewed stations. The significantly Second Supplemental Response
the Petitioning Counties (Daviess, Knox, reviewed stations in the three supports this claim by stating that
Martin, and Dubois) is in the Eastern Petitioning Counties that are in the ‘‘[t]here is very little if any advertising
Time Zone, while only one county Terre Haute Designated Market Area are by companies doing business in the
(Pike) has the National Weather Service in the Eastern Time Zone. Petitioning Counties.’’ The Second
cprice-sewell on PROD1PC66 with PROPOSALS

Center in the Central Time Zone. The The Petitioning Counties have not Supplemental Response also notes that
Petitioning Counties claim that because provided sufficient information the ‘‘vast majority’’ of businesses
‘‘most of the radio and television concerning the television/radio advertising in the Courier and Press are
stations that cover local news and broadcasting aspect of the convenience located in Evansville or Henderson,
weather in the Petitioning Counties is for commerce standard to justify Kentucky (both in the Central Time
either located within the Petitioning proposing to change the time zone Zone) to support the claim that those
Counties themselves or are in counties boundary. DOT questions whether radio newspapers primarily serve the

VerDate Aug<31>2005 13:52 Jul 18, 2007 Jkt 211001 PO 00000 Frm 00016 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\19JYP1.SGM 19JYP1
39598 Federal Register / Vol. 72, No. 138 / Thursday, July 19, 2007 / Proposed Rules

communities in the immediate vicinity block.’’ Because the overwhelming only offers transportation to western
of the city. (The Second Supplemental majority of local newspapers in and southern routes.’’ On the other
Response also corrected the Joint circulation within the Petitioning hand, the stations located in the Eastern
Petition and acknowledged that the Counties are currently on Central Time, Time Zone offer much broader service
Courier and Press is distributed in moving them as a ‘‘block’’ would simply to the Petitioning Counties. For
Martin County.) represent a universal shift of local example, the Terre Haute station offers
The Joint Petition includes a chart newspapers to Eastern Time if the connections both to southwest
that lists the names and circulation petition were granted. destinations and to Indianapolis, which
numbers of the local newspapers In the Third Supplemental Response, in turn provides service to all
serving each of the Petitioning Counties, the Petitioning Counties responded to destinations. In addition, the Louisville
as well as the County and the time zone DOT’s question on whether the station offers transportation to north,
of publication if the petition is granted. residents of the Petitioning Counties northeast, and southern destinations.
For example, for Daviess County, the might shop or use the services of Accordingly, the Joint Petition uses
chart indicates that the Washington businesses that advertise in the these bus service routes as support to
Times-Herald, with a weekly circulation Indianapolis Star or the Courier and change back to the Eastern Time Zone.
of 6,459, is published in Daviess, which Press. The Petitioning Counties With regard to rail service, the Joint
will be moved to the Eastern Time Zone admitted that discussions with Petition focuses on commercial rail
if the petition is granted. In addition, individuals in the Petitioning Counties carriers. The Joint Petition points out
the Washington Extra, another local ‘‘yielded different responses.’’ There that, because most of the existing major
newspaper identified in the chart, is were no overwhelming preferences for junction and division points for
published in Daviess County and (like either the Eastern or Central Time Zone common carriers are located in the
the Washington Times-Herald) has a shops or businesses advertising in these Eastern Time Zone, it would best serve
significantly higher weekly circulation papers. the convenience of commerce to place
in Daviess County than either the The Petitioning Counties have not all of the Petitioning Counties on
Indianapolis Star (496) or the Evansville submitted sufficient information Eastern Time. Answering DOT’s inquiry
Courier & Press (92). In total, all four concerning the newspaper aspect of the concerning the availability of passenger
local newspapers serving Daviess convenience for commerce standard to rail service to its residents and how
County are published within the justify proposing to change the time changing to Eastern Time would impact
Petitioning Counties. This pattern is zone boundary based. DOT seeks such services, the Second Supplemental
consistent with the circulation patterns comments on the information submitted Response states that ‘‘[n]one of the
in the other Petitioning Counties as by the Petitioning Counties and requests railroad companies that run through
well, where the total circulation for the any additional information on southwest Indiana provides passenger
main local newspaper published in each newspaper circulation in the Petitioning service in the area.’’ Moreover, it states
county far outweighs the circulation for Counties that would aid in determining that Amtrak, the only passenger rail
either the Indianapolis Star or the whether a time zone change for these company in Indiana, runs on
Evansville Courier & Press. Counties would serve the convenience commercial lines only through northern
There are only two local newspapers of commerce. and central Indiana (in the Eastern Time
shown in the chart that are published Zone), far from the Petitioning Counties.
Bus and Passenger Rail Service
outside of the Petitioning Counties: the As such, the Petitioning Counties assert
Paoli News Republican, which is Only three out of the five original that ‘‘[p]assenger rail schedules are not
published in Orange and has a weekly individual petitions, from Dubois, Knox, a factor here.’’
circulation of 400 in Dubois County; and Pike Counties, discussed bus and The Petitioning Counties have
and the Bedford Times-Mail, which is rail service within their Counties. The submitted sufficient information based
published in Lawrence County and has original Dubois County petition stated on the bus service aspect of the
a negligible weekly circulation in both that Dubois County is not served by convenience of commerce standard to
Dubois and Martin Counties. Both of passenger bus or rail service; however, justify proposing to change the time
these newspapers are published in the such service is available out of zone boundary. The Petitioning
Eastern Time Zone and would continue Louisville, Indianapolis or Evansville. Counties have provided information on
to be published in the Eastern Time The original Knox County petition the broader bus service available in
Zone if the Joint Petition were granted. stated that its citizens can obtain bus locations in the Eastern Time Zone.
The remaining local newspapers are all service from Evansville and Terre According to the Petitioning Counties,
published in one of the five Petitioning Haute, and that passenger rail service is passenger rail service is not at issue.
Counties. According to the Joint Petition available in Effingham, Illinois and DOT seeks comment on the information
and reiterated in the Second Indianapolis. The original Pike County submitted by the Petitioning Counties
Supplemental Response, these counties petition stated that the closest major and requests any additional information
are served by a number of papers passenger rail and bus service is on bus and rail services in the
published locally, which ‘‘likely serve generally located in Evansville. Petitioning Counties that would aid in
the advertising needs of local With regard to bus service, the Joint determining whether a change in the
businesses.’’ The Second Supplemental Petition points out that three of the four time zone for the Petitioning Counties
Response claims, ‘‘the lack of Greyhound bus stations that are closest would serve the convenience of
advertising by companies located in the to the Petitioning Counties are on commerce.
Petitioning Counties suggests a lack of Eastern Time. It states that these stations
cprice-sewell on PROD1PC66 with PROPOSALS

connection to the Evansville area.’’ are located in Indianapolis, Terre Haute, Airports/Airline Services
(Emphasis added.) The Second and Louisville in the Eastern Time The original petitions for Daviess,
Supplemental Response concludes that, Zone, and in Evansville in the Central Knox and Pike Counties stated that the
with regard to newspaper circulation, Time Zone. The Joint Petition also closest airport providing passenger
‘‘[t]his factors in favor of treating the claims that, although the Evansville service to their respective counties is
Petitioning Counties as a unit and station is relatively close to many located in Evansville. The original
moving them all to Eastern Time as a residents of the Petitioning Counties, ‘‘it petition for Dubois County stated that

VerDate Aug<31>2005 13:52 Jul 18, 2007 Jkt 211001 PO 00000 Frm 00017 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\19JYP1.SGM 19JYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 72, No. 138 / Thursday, July 19, 2007 / Proposed Rules 39599

the airport in the County serves maintains that nearly all of these concerning the worker commuting
primarily private business planes and Indiana-based local airports would be in patterns aspect of the convenience of
lists Louisville, Evansville, and the Eastern Time Zone if the Petition commerce standard to justify proposing
Indianapolis as ‘‘major airports were granted. However, the Second to change in the time zone boundary.
providing service’’ to its residents. The Supplemental Response clarifies that, DOT seeks comment on the information
original petition for Martin County although they are the ‘‘nearest airports’’ submitted by the Petitioning Counties
noted that the nearest general airport is in terms of geographic location, none of and requests any additional information
in Vanderburgh County in the Central the local airports situated in the on worker commuting patterns in the
Time Zone, and also noted that Martin Petitioning Counties provides Petitioning Counties that would aid in
County residents are served by local commercial passenger service. determining whether changing their
airports in Daviess and Dubois Counties. The Joint Petition also notes that the time zone boundaries.
The Joint Petition discusses the three two closest hubs of the largest private
major airports that could potentially express package carriers serving the The Community’s Economy/Economic
serve residents of the Petitioning Petitioning Counties, United Parcel Development
Counties for commercial passenger Service and Federal Express, are While the original Daviess County
service: one in the Central Time Zone in situated in the Eastern Time Zone, in petition did not mention anything about
Evansville and two in the Eastern Time Indianapolis and in Louisville, and that the elements of the Daviess County
Zone in Indianapolis and Louisville. air travel for cargo is thus oriented economy, each of the other original
The Joint Petition acknowledges that the toward counties that are already in the petitions discussed each County’s
Evansville Regional Airport is the Eastern Time Zone. individual economy and economic
closest geographically for many The Petitioning Counties have not development as one of the matters to
residents in some parts of the submitted sufficient information consider as part of the convenience of
Petitioning Counties. However, despite concerning the airports/airline services commerce standard. The original Dubois
this proximity, the Joint Petition claims aspect of the convenience of commerce County petition stated that the principle
that, according to ‘‘travel agents who standard to justify proposing to change element of its economy is wood
serve residents in the Petitioning the time zone boundary. DOT seeks furniture manufacturing, followed by
Counties,’’ it is more expensive to fly comment on the information submitted agriculture. The original Knox County
out of Evansville and that the Evansville by the Petitioning Counties and requests petition mentioned healthcare and
airport offers ‘‘very few direct any additional information on airport education as the major elements of its
connections.’’ The Joint Petition also and airlines services in the Petitioning economy. The original Pike County
states that Evansville offers direct flights Counties that would aid in determining petition stated that its economy is
to only six destinations: Chicago whether changing the time zone for the largely dependent on the local mining
(O’Hare), Cincinnati, Atlanta, Memphis, Petitioning Counties would serve the industry. The original Martin County
Detroit, and Dallas. In contrast, the Joint convenience of commerce. petition noted that the major elements
Petition notes that the Indianapolis of its economy are ‘‘agriculture, timber,
Worker Commuting Patterns
International Airport in the Eastern and technology connected to’’ NSWC
Time Zone services 34 destinations, The Joint Petition claims that the Crane. In addition, the original Martin
while the Louisville International majority of workers in the Petitioning petition mentioned that the local
Airport, also in the Eastern Time Zone, Counties live and work in their home economy is expected to improve with
services 28 destinations. The Joint counties. For those who work outside of the continued operation of NSWC
Petition declares that ‘‘Indianapolis is their home counties, the Joint Petition Crane, and that Martin County is
one of the top jumping-off points for air states, ‘‘Of those migrating to a working along with Daviess and Greene
travelers from the Petitioning Counties.’’ Petitioning County for work, the Counties to develop a technology park
To support this claim, the Joint Petition majority come from locations in the adjacent to NSWC Crane.
again relies on travel agents who serve Eastern Time Zone. Of those leaving a The Joint Petition provides additional
residents in the Petitioning Counties Petitioning County for work, the information about the major elements of
and have reported that ‘‘70 to 75% of majority go to locations in the Eastern each County’s economy, the state of the
their customers fly out of Indianapolis Time Zone.’’ The Joint Petition relies on economy, and economic development.
or Louisville for reasons of cost or commuting patterns data from the The Joint Petition states that
convenience.’’ The Joint Petition does Indiana Department of Revenue. In the manufacturing and agriculture are two
not offer any specific information Third Supplemental Response, the of the leading industries in the local
regarding whether these are business or Petitioning Counties explained that the economies of several of the Petitioning
leisure travelers, the destination of these basis of their statement was their Counties. Consequently, in order to
travelers, or whether the location, and consideration that the Petitioning increase their competitive edge over
therefore, the relevant time zone of the Counties were in the Eastern Time international competitors, Dubois
airport affected their choice. In addition, Zone, ‘‘as Eastern Time is the County seeks placement in the same
the Joint Petition, citing information Petitioning Counties’ desired time time zone as a significant number of its
obtained from an employee of NSWC zone.’’ The Third Supplemental goes on companies’ suppliers and customers.
Crane, points out that 80% of the to say that the commuting patterns Dubois County employers have reported
employee travelers from Crane military demonstrate the strong connection that 60–90% of their business
base (located in Martin County) use the among the Petitioning Counties and relationships remain in the Eastern
Indianapolis airport. recognizes that the commuters do not Time Zone. Moreover, the Joint Petition
cprice-sewell on PROD1PC66 with PROPOSALS

The Joint Petition also provides have a large impact on the overall refers to the President of the Knox
detailed information regarding local workforce in most of the Petitioning County Development Corporation who
service airports that are situated within Counties, with the exception of Martin anticipates that manufacturing growth
or near the Petitioning Counties, and County where commuters make up experienced in that county should
states that such ‘‘airports provide 46.9% of the Martin County workforce. continue and does not foresee a shift to
county-based business with direct air The Petitioning Counties have not the Eastern Time Zone as having a
travel access.’’ The Joint Petition submitted sufficient information negative impact. On the other hand, in

VerDate Aug<31>2005 13:52 Jul 18, 2007 Jkt 211001 PO 00000 Frm 00018 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\19JYP1.SGM 19JYP1
39600 Federal Register / Vol. 72, No. 138 / Thursday, July 19, 2007 / Proposed Rules

Pike County, local business and for intelligent and environmentally number’’ attend schools in Evansville.
industry have been tied to coal mining balanced development.’’ Moreover, the The original Knox County petition
and power generation and ‘‘the Joint Petition states that a shift to the pointed out that residents who leave the
industries that support them,’’ including Eastern Time Zone would ‘‘greatly community for school go to Illinois, or
‘‘fabricating, welding, and shipping.’’ simplify communications and improve Gibson or Vanderburgh Counties, all in
One of the main coal mine operators in the support’’ of NSWC Crane’s primary the Central Time Zone. The original
Pike County, Solar Sources, Inc., has its customers, which are located in the Martin County petition stated that the
headquarters in Indianapolis and Eastern Time Zone. The Joint Petition primary local outlets for higher
several mines in the Petitioning notes that 67% of Crane’s employees education were in the Central Time
Counties. As such, the Joint Petition commute from the Eastern to the Central Zone and include USI , IVY Tech, and
states that shifting Pike County to the Time Zone for work, causing business the University of Evansville, in
Eastern Time Zone would serve the efficiency and productivity to drop as a Vanderburgh County; Vincennes
convenience of commerce by helping to consequence of irregular business hours University with campuses in Knox and
prevent the scheduling and shipping and meetings, relying on information Dubois Counties; and Oakland City
problems that have coincided with the provided by leaders of six employee University in Gibson County. The
placement of the Petitioning Counties in organizations on NSWC Crane. original Pike petition did not mention
the Central Time Zone. Moreover, the Second Supplemental where its citizens go for higher
The Joint Petition also focuses on the Response points out that this situation education.
economy of the Petitioning Counties as has gotten worse with the Unlike the original petitions which
a block, and states that the Petitioning implementation of daylight savings time focused on higher education, the Joint
Counties have stronger economic and in Indiana, which ‘‘has moved 76% of Petition focuses on primary and
cultural connections to each other, and NSWC Crane’s workforce to the Eastern secondary education, including sporting
the Indiana counties currently in the Time Zone while the plant has events, and also on vocational students.
Eastern Time Zone, than they do with remained on Central Time.’’ The Second The Joint Petition notes that there are 15
other southern Indiana counties and the Supplemental Response quotes the school districts covering the five
Evansville-based economy in the President of Crane Technology, Inc. as Petitioning Counties. No school district
Central Time Zone. The Petitioning stating that this has created a in the Petitioning Counties is in more
Counties assert that one major economic ‘‘nightmare for scheduling and than one time zone. The Joint Petition
development project potentially shared employee productivity’’ because ‘‘the points out, however, that schools in
by all of the Petitioning Counties is the plant must operate two sets of clocks to these districts compete in athletic
proposed extension of Interstate 69 (I– complete its business’’ and ‘‘virtually all events against schools that are located
69) through central and southwestern employees strongly desire a move that in other time zones. Consequently,
Indiana. The Petitioning Counties point would bring all workers on the same ‘‘many away games have to be played in
out that the expansion of I–69 will time.’’ The Third Supplemental counties that are already in the Eastern
provide more economical and efficient Response says that EG&G Technical Time Zone,’’ which causes ‘‘time-related
access to Indianapolis, although they Services, Crane, is ‘‘a major contractor confusion of both students and
cannot ‘‘precisely quantify the economic supporting’’ NSWC Crane and states parents.’’ To support this claim, the
impact to the region of the planned that, according to this contractor, ‘‘core Joint Petition cites to the football
highway expansion.’’ Nonetheless, business hours have been reduced’’ and schedule for North Daviess High School
because traffic will be able to flow north this change ‘‘adversely impacts in Daviess County, which includes 6
from southwest Indiana to the larger workload execution and delays games in the Eastern Time Zone (or 67%
network of highways that go through meetings and decisions.’’ No of its games). In the Second
Indianapolis, the highway will provide information was provided by officials Supplemental Response, the Petitioning
‘‘a crucial link to central Indiana and from NSCW Crane. Counties provide their high school
beyond.’’ As such, the Petitioning The Petitioning Counties have basketball schedules stating, ‘‘If the
Counties contend that they should be submitted sufficient information Petitioning Counties are shifted to the
placed in the Eastern Time Zone in concerning the community’s economy/ Eastern Time Zone, there will be a
order to stay associated with the economic development aspect of the reduction in the number of games
infrastructure and markets that will be convenience of commerce standard to played in differing time zones from 27
made more accessible through the justify proposing to change in the time to 18.’’ The Second Supplemental
extension of I–69. The Second zone boundary. DOT solicits further Response explained that this would
Supplemental Response notes that information and data supporting or ‘‘reduce the games played in different
updated information on the project ‘‘has rebutting the information supplied by time zones to between 6% and 17%,’’
yet to be completed.’’ the Petitioning Counties and how it depending on the school. The Second
The Joint Petition also emphasizes the supports a change in the time zone for Supplemental Response also points out
economic impact in both Daviess and the convenience of commerce. that only one high school, Pike Central,
Martin Counties of the NSWC Crane, would play more games in a time zone
which it asserts serves as a large Schools, Recreation, Health Care, or
different from their own, if the Joint
regional employer and has entrances Religious Worship
Petition were granted. The Second
that currently span two time zones and With regard to schools, the original Supplemental Response concludes,
three counties. The Joint Petition notes Daviess County petition stated that the ‘‘Based on the significant reduction of
that Daviess County has partnered with closest State college is the University of games played outside the school’s time
cprice-sewell on PROD1PC66 with PROPOSALS

the local and county redevelopment Southern Indiana (USI) in Evansville in zone in four out of the five Petitioning
commissions of Martin County and the Central Time Zone. The original Counties, a move to Eastern Time best
Greene County, which is located in the Dubois County petition stated that the serves the convenience of commerce by
Eastern Time Zone, to create a major majority of students leaving the easing time-related confusion of both
technology park called ‘‘The West Gate community for post-high school students and parents.’’
@ Crane,’’ which is ‘‘expected to become education attend universities in the The Joint Petition states that students
Indiana’s showcase technology facility Eastern Time Zone, although ‘‘a in the Petitioning Counties who attend

VerDate Aug<31>2005 13:52 Jul 18, 2007 Jkt 211001 PO 00000 Frm 00019 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\19JYP1.SGM 19JYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 72, No. 138 / Thursday, July 19, 2007 / Proposed Rules 39601

vocational schools would also benefit Perry Counties, with its 1450 seasonal located in the Central Time Zone. The
from their counties being switched to employees many who come from the Joint Petition also states that the best
the Eastern Time Zone and provided Petitioning Counties, and its nearly and closest specialty hospitals are
statistics for vocational students in 900,000 visitors a year. In the Second located in Indianapolis and Louisville,
Martin County. The Exhibit to the Joint Supplemental Response, the Petitioning both in the Eastern Time Zone, and that
Petition indicates that 15 students must Counties state that, ‘‘Due to its lengthy ‘‘there are no comparable hospitals with
travel back and forth across time zones hours of operation, Holiday World will world-renowned specialists and
in the Shoals Community School not be negatively impacted if the facilities located in the Petitioning
Corporation in Martin County. The Petitioning Counties move to Eastern Counties.’’ In the Second Supplemental
Second Supplemental Response Time.’’ Rather, Holiday World stands to Response, the Petitioning Counties
provides information on vocational benefit, ‘‘as visitors from Petitioning correct the location of the Lawrence
students in Pike and Dubois Counties, Counties might arrive earlier in the day County Memorial Hospital, which is
but not for Daviess and Knox Counties, due to their being an hour ahead.’’ The located in Lawrence, Illinois, in the
noting an inability to obtain statistics for Second Supplemental Response did not Central Time Zone. In the Third
these Counties. The Second provide a source for these assertions. Supplemental Response, the Petitioning
Supplemental Response mentions Twin In the Second Supplemental Counties attempt to provide some
Rivers Vocational School (a cooperative Response, the Petitioning Counties justification for its assertions that
between school corporations in Knox identify the two other attractions in the patients from the Petitioning Counties
County, and Greene and Sullivan region: the French Lick Casino and seek treatment in Indianapolis or
Counties, which are already in the Resort, located in Orange County, in the Louisville. The Third Supplemental
Eastern Time Zone) as a school that Eastern Time Zone, and Patoka Lakes Response refers to a report from the
currently has scheduling difficulties located in Dubois, Orange, and Daviess County Hospital that indicates
related to the different time zones. In Crawford Counties, in both the Eastern that the majority of patients were
summary, approximately 67 vocational and Central Time Zones. In the Third transferred to another Petitioning
students are affected by the time zone Supplemental Response, the Petitioning County and more to a Central Time
differences. Counties provide more detailed Zone hospital than to a hospital in the
With regard to recreation, the original information about these attractions. The Eastern Time Zone. The Third
Daviess County petition stated that the French Lick Casino re-opened at the end Supplemental Response states, ‘‘For
largest metropolitan area where its of October, 2006 and employs 1400 many of the Petitioning Counties
citizens transact business is Evansville. workers. From its opening through (Daviess, Knox, and Martin) the majority
The original Dubois County petition March 2007, there had been 520,367 of transfers outside of the Petitioning
noted that ‘‘major recreational events’’ visitors. The fishing tournaments at Counties went to hospitals on Eastern
would be in either the Eastern or Central Patoka Lakes attract between 750,000 Time;’’ however, it does not provide a
Time Zones. The original Knox County and 1,000,000 visitors. The Third reference to support this assertion.
petition pointed out that residents who Supplemental Response adds an The Joint Petition does not mention
leave the community for recreation go to attraction not mentioned in the Joint any specific information regarding
Illinois, or Gibson or Vanderburgh Petition or the Second Supplemental religious worship, but concludes that,
Counties, all in the Central Time Zone. Response, Paoli Peaks, a ski resort in based on the numerous places of
The original Martin County petition Orange County that attracts 100,000 worship in each Petitioning County, the
listed Daviess, Dubois, Knox, and visitors annually. majority of people worship in or near
Vanderburgh Counties as the primary With regard to health care, the the same county in which they live.
recreational outlets for its citizens. The original individual petitions for Dubois The Petitioning Counties have
original Pike County petition states that County stated that the citizens of their submitted sufficient information
‘‘by far the majority of any counties receive ordinary medical care concerning the recreation aspect of the
entertainment available to the citizens within their respective county. For more convenience of commerce standard to
of Pike is located in Evansville.’’ specialized medical care, the original justify proposing to change in the time
The Joint Petition notes, ‘‘Recreational Dubois County petition stated that its zone boundary based on sporting
facilities are distributed fairly evenly citizens go to Evansville, Indianapolis, activities and area attractions. The
throughout the Petitioning Counties,’’ and Louisville. The original Knox Petitioning Counties have also
and that ‘‘residents therefore typically County petition pointed out that submitted sufficient information
do not have to cross time zones to residents who leave the community for concerning the education aspect of the
participate in a sporting activity.’’ The health care go to Illinois, or Gibson or convenience of commerce standard to
Joint Petition specifically refers to a Vanderburgh Counties, all in the Central justify proposing to change the time
variety of sporting events and Time Zone. The original Martin County zone boundary based on after school
opportunities for golfers, boaters, tennis petition stated that a vast majority of its activities and higher education. The
players, and fishers. On the other hand, residents utilize hospitals in Daviess, Petitioning Counties have not submitted
the Joint Petition states that if residents Dubois, and Knox Counties. The sufficient information concerning the
want to go to a college athletic event at original Martin County petition cites religious observance or health care
one of the State’s three major Evansville as the closest location with a aspect of the convenience of commerce
universities, they must cross into the major medical center. The original standard to justify proposing to change
Eastern Time Zone. petitions for Daviess and Pike Counties the time zone boundary. DOT questions
DOT requested comments from the did not mention where its citizens the number of residents of the
cprice-sewell on PROD1PC66 with PROPOSALS

Petitioning Counties on time zone receive medical care. Petitioning Counties that go to the more
change as it relates to recreation and The Joint Petition includes a chart specialized hospitals located in the
tourism surrounding the Holiday World indicating that, with the exception of Eastern Time Zone, especially in light of
& Splashin’ Safari amusement park in Lawrence County Memorial in the fact that, if the petition were
Spencer County because of strong Lawrence County, Indiana, all of the granted, there would be more local
economic ties between several of the hospitals located closest to the hospitals in a different time zone than
Petitioning Counties and Spencer and Petitioning Counties are currently the current alignment. DOT seeks

VerDate Aug<31>2005 13:52 Jul 18, 2007 Jkt 211001 PO 00000 Frm 00020 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\19JYP1.SGM 19JYP1
39602 Federal Register / Vol. 72, No. 138 / Thursday, July 19, 2007 / Proposed Rules

comment on the information submitted southern tip of Indiana on Central and special needs of the communities.
by the Petitioning Counties and requests Time.’’ Under IARC, none of the Petitioning
any additional information that would While the Joint Petition refers to ties Counties considered to be within the
aid in determining whether a change in to the Eastern Time Zone, the Joint Evansville region and are connected
the time zone for the Petitioning Petition also mentions the United States with other Petitioning Counties and
Counties would serve the convenience Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) in counties.
of commerce. its discussion of Martin County. It uses The Second Supplemental Response
the BEA information to explain the also refers to other connections to
Regional Connections major elements of the community’s counties already on Eastern Time.
In the original rulemaking proceeding economy. Under Region 15 Economic Area,
to change time zone boundaries from According to BEA’s Web site, ‘‘BEA Dubois and Pike Counties are paired
the Eastern Time Zone to the Central produces economic account statistics with Orange and Crawford Counties in
Time Zone, the Petitioning Counties and that enable government and business the Eastern Time Zone. The Second
commenters advocated for a move by decision-makers, researchers, and the Supplemental Response also notes that
referring to their ties to other Indiana American public to follow and Daviess, Knox, and Martin Counties are
counties currently in the Central Time understand the performance of the served by the Southern Indiana
Zone. Many referred to data from Nation’s economy * * * BEA’s Development Commission (SIDC) along
STATS Indiana, including the Indiana economic areas define the relevant with two other counties currently in the
Annual Commuting Trends Profile, regional markets surrounding Eastern Time Zone. According to the
based on Indiana IT 40 returns. metropolitan or micropolitan statistical Second Supplemental Response, SIDC
Commenters who supported the change areas. They consist of one or more counties have collaborated on Federal
to Central Time also referred to data economic nodes—metropolitan or and State grant applications. As an
from the Indiana Economic micropolitan statistical areas that serve example of these collaborative efforts,
Development Corporation, the Indiana as regional centers of economic the Second Supplemental Response
Department of Workforce Development, activity—and the surrounding counties refers to a demand-based rural transit
the Indiana Department of that are economically related to the system funded by a Federal grant. The
Transportation, the Indiana Department nodes.’’ (Emphasis added.). The Second Supplemental Response asserts
of Education, and Designated Market economic areas are based on commuting that placing all participating counties in
Areas as defined by Nielsen Media patterns, statistical areas, and on the same time zone will preserve the
Research for use in television ratings. newspaper circulation data. With the cohesiveness and viability of the
exception of Knox County, the system.
DOT carefully reviewed and used this Petitioning Counties are in BEA Another regional economic
data when it reached its prior decision economic area 54 (the Evansville, KY development project referenced in the
to change the time zone boundaries of area), along with other counties that are Second Supplemental Response is
the Petitioning Counties to the Central in the Central Time Zone. Knox County, Crane Diversification, which is
Time Zone. Recognizing the importance on the other hand, is in a BEA economic composed of six counties, including
of regional connections, the benefits of area with counties in both the Central Daviess and Martin Counties and four
similar time zones, and regional ties and Eastern Time Zones. others counties which are on Eastern
among counties, DOT stated in the DOT asked the Petitioning Counties to Time. According to the Second
January 2006 final rule, ‘‘While Daviess, address these differences in the Joint Supplemental Response, the goal of
Dubois, Knox, Martin, and Perry border Petition’s assertions of connections to Crane Diversification ‘‘is to develop an
other Indiana counties in the Eastern the Eastern Time Zone and the BEA economic diversification plan that will
Time Zone, their ties to those counties data. Despite the BEA classification, in result in an orderly transition of this
are not as strong as they are to each their Second Supplemental Response, block of counties * * * from economic
other and to other counties to their the Petitioning Counties now insist that dependence on national defense
south, which are currently in the their strongest economic connections spending to a more balanced local
Central Time Zone. Along with Pike, are among themselves and the economy with a mix of private and
these counties are located in the same surrounding counties on Eastern Time public sector employment opportunities
workforce, commerce, transportation, rather than to the other counties in BEA for the area’s citizens.’’ The Petitioning
and education regions designated by economic area 54. The Second Counties believe that projects such as
Indiana.’’ DOT also noted that, in Supplemental Response states, ‘‘A better Crane Diversification would be
general, remaining in the same time assessment of regional connectivity can negatively impacted by the current time
zone and maintaining their regional ties be seen on the State and local level.’’ zone disparity, affecting planning,
better position counties to realize The Second Supplemental Response integration, and strategic development.
advantages in economic, cultural, social, notes that State and local economic The Second Supplemental Response
and civic activities, thereby serving the development agencies may consider also mentions other projects that it says
convenience of commerce. commuter patterns and also ‘‘look to the define the economic region in terms of
Contrary to the original statements types of businesses in the area upon counties tied to each other through
about ties to the Central Time Zone and which communities rely to sustain potential business development. These
DOT’s determination, the Joint Petition growth’’ as well as funding, and include the Indiana Uplands Growth
now asserts ties to the Eastern Time transportation opportunities. More Partnership, developed under a gaming
Zone. The Joint Petition concludes, specifically, the Second Supplemental statute; Economic Growth Region 8; and
cprice-sewell on PROD1PC66 with PROPOSALS

‘‘The Petitioning Counties are on the response refers to the Indiana West Gate @ Crane Technology Park.
periphery of the regional, Evansville- Association of Regional Councils The Third Supplemental Response
based economy and have stronger (IARC), an organization that supports explains these in greater detail.
economic and cultural connections to regional planning efforts that prioritize According to the Third Supplemental
each other and the interior counties and categorize local community and Response, the Indiana Upland Growth
currently on Eastern Time than they do economic development needs and Partnership concerns the French Lick
with the relatively few counties at the projects as well as the transportation Casino and arose under State legislation.

VerDate Aug<31>2005 13:52 Jul 18, 2007 Jkt 211001 PO 00000 Frm 00021 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\19JYP1.SGM 19JYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 72, No. 138 / Thursday, July 19, 2007 / Proposed Rules 39603

The Third Supplemental Response changing the time zone for these changed time zone boundaries at the
states that ‘‘a portion of the admission counties would serve the convenience same time as the Petitioning Counties.
taxes at the casino will go towards of commerce. This may result in many comments to
supporting regional economic activity the docket. Our decision in the final
Request for Comments
for Orange County (Eastern) and the five rule will be made on the basis of
counties surrounding Orange.’’ While To aid us in our consideration of information and comments developed
the Third Supplemental response refers whether a time zone change would be during the entire rulemaking
to five counties, it only lists four and ‘‘for the convenience of commerce,’’ we proceeding. In our experience, time
states, ‘‘These counties have worked ask for comments on the impact on zone boundary changes can be
together to develop a strategic plan for commerce of a change in the time zone extremely disruptive to a community
the economic development of the six and whether a new time zone would and, therefore, should not be made
county region.’’ With regard to West improve the convenience of commerce. without careful consideration. At the
Gate @ Crane Technology Park, the The comments should address the close of the comment period, we will
Third Supplemental Response notes impact on such things as economic, analyze the comments submitted and
that it was certified by the Indiana cultural, social, and civic activities and decide whether to withdraw the
Economic Development Corporation how time zone changes affect proposal (and deny the Joint Petition) or
and developed by county and economic businesses, communication, issue a final rule.
development commissions from Daviess transportation, and education. The
comments should be as detailed as Comment Period
(Central), Martin (Central), and Greene
(Eastern) counties. The Third possible, providing the basis of the We are providing 30 days for public
Supplemental Response states, ‘‘The information including factual data or comments in this proceeding. Although
state-of-the-art facilities in development surveys. For example, with regard to we normally provide 60 days for public
are expected to serve major commercial major bus, rail, and air transportation, comments on proposed rules, we
technology companies associated with information such as the average time it believe that 30 days is an adequate
the $2 billion NSWC Crane military takes for a county resident to travel to public comment period in this instance.
technical center. Facilities are also being a transportation terminal or the average It is important to resolve this
designed for academic and training distance to the terminal for a county rulemaking expeditiously so that we can
operations.’’ As for Economic Growth resident would be useful. With regard to provide ample notice if a change to the
Region 8, the Third Supplemental the impact of the time zone on Petitioning Counties’ time zone
Response explains that the region was education, if a school district crosses boundaries is adopted. Since the
designated by the Indiana Department of county lines, the number of students in introduction and passage of the Indiana
Workforce Development ‘‘to promote each county in that district would be Act in 2005 and through DOT’s time
economic growth and serve as a means helpful. Information on school activities zone regulatory proceeding and review
for implementing the State’s Strategic such as sporting events or academic of three Supplemental Responses, the
Plan Initiative.’’ competitions that take place in other time zone boundary issue has been
The Third Supplemental Response counties or locations that are not on the actively discussed and analyzed. In this
concludes that failing to change the time same time zone as the school district regard, we expect that 30 days is
zone boundary to the Eastern Time Zone would also be useful. Similar adequate time to submit the necessary
and ‘‘cement the connection between information on community colleges data, which is based on currently
the Petitioning Counties and the State could also be beneficial. Finally, we available information.
Capitol, and between a large portion of would appreciate information on how
the business in the Petitioning Counties the different time zones affect the Regulatory Analysis and Notices
and their customer base, is likely to students and the schools. This proposed rule is not a
have a significantly negative impact on We specifically invite comment from ‘‘significant regulatory action’’ under
the already struggling economies of this neighboring Indiana counties and section 3(f) of Executive Order 12866
region.’’ counties in other States that may also be and does not require an assessment of
The Petitioning Counties’ references impacted by changing the Petitioning potential costs and benefits under
to Region 15 Economic Area and Counties’ time zone boundary. section 6(a)(3) of that Order. It has not
Economic Growth Region 8 are also Although the Petitioning Counties been reviewed by the Office of
addressed in letters from the Indiana have submitted sufficient information to Management and Budget under that
Economic Development Corporation begin the rulemaking process, the Order. It is not ‘‘significant’’ under the
and the Indiana Department of decision whether actually to make the regulatory policies and procedures of
Workforce Development. As noted change will also consider information the Department of Transportation (44 FR
above, these organizations explained submitted in writing to the docket. 11040; February 26, 1979). We expect
that they established their respective Persons supporting or opposing the the economic impact of this proposed
State regions based on their ability to change should not assume that the rule to be so minimal that a full
deliver services. They did not establish change will be made merely because Regulatory Evaluation under paragraph
regions based on time zones or DOT is making the proposal. DOT here 10e of the regulatory policies and
‘‘convenience of commerce.’’ issues no opinion on the ultimate merits procedures of DOT is unnecessary. The
Nevertheless, the Petitioning Counties of the Petitioning Counties’ request. We rule primarily affects the convenience of
have submitted sufficient information note that the Petitioning Counties and individuals in scheduling activities. By
concerning the regional connections and their residents have had only a short itself, it imposes no direct costs. Its
cprice-sewell on PROD1PC66 with PROPOSALS

ties to the Eastern Time Zone to justify time to experience the effects of impact is localized in nature.
proposing to change the time zone. DOT changing from Eastern to Central Time
seeks comment on the information and now the Petitioning Counties Small Entities
submitted by the Petitioning Counties request to change back again. We also Under the Regulatory Flexibility Act
and requests any additional information understand that this proposal may have (5 U.S.C. 601–612), we considered
concerning regional connections that an impact on surrounding Counties, whether this proposed rule would have
would aid in determining whether particularly Perry County which a significant economic impact on a

VerDate Aug<31>2005 13:52 Jul 18, 2007 Jkt 211001 PO 00000 Frm 00022 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\19JYP1.SGM 19JYP1
39604 Federal Register / Vol. 72, No. 138 / Thursday, July 19, 2007 / Proposed Rules

substantial number of small entities. 12875, Enhancing the Intergovernmental List of Subjects in 49 CFR Part 71
The term ‘‘small entities’’ comprises Partnership, (58 FR 58093; October 28,
Time zones.
small businesses, not-for-profit 1993) govern the issuance of Federal
organizations that are independently regulations that impose unfunded For the reasons discussed above, the
owned and operated and are not mandates. An unfunded mandate is a Office of the Secretary proposes to
dominant in their fields, and regulation that requires a State, local, or amend Title 49 part 71 as follows:
governmental jurisdictions with tribal government or the private sector 1. The authority citation for part 71
populations of less than 50,000. This to incur direct costs without the Federal continues to read as follows:
proposal, if adopted, would primarily Government’s having first provided the Authority: Secs. 1–4, 40 Stat. 450, as
affect individuals and their scheduling funds to pay those costs. This proposed amended; sec. 1, 41 Stat. 1446, as amended;
of activities. Although it would affect rule would not impose an unfunded secs. 2–7, 80 Stat. 107, as amended; 100 Stat.
some small businesses, not-for-profits mandate. 764; Act of Mar. 19, 1918, as amended by the
and, perhaps, a number of small Uniform Time Act of 1966 and Pub. L.
governmental jurisdictions, it would not Taking of Private Property 97–449, 15 U.S.C. 260–267; Pub. L. 99–359;
be a substantial number. In addition, the Pub. L. 106–564, 15 U.S.C. 263, 114 Stat.
This proposed rule would not result 2811; 49 CFR 1.59(a).
change should have little, if any, in a taking of private property or
economic impact. otherwise have taking implications 2. Paragraph (b) of § 71.5 is revised to
Therefore, I certify under 5 U.S.C. under E.O. 12630, Governmental read as follows:
605(b) that this proposed rule would Actions and Interference with
not, if adopted, have a significant § 71.5 Boundary line between eastern and
Constitutionally Protected Property central zones.
economic impact on a substantial Rights.
number of small entities. If you think * * * * *
that your business, organization, or Civil Justice Reform (b) Indiana-Illinois. From the junction
governmental jurisdiction qualifies as a of the western boundary of the State of
small entity and that this rule would This proposed rule meets applicable
Michigan with the northern boundary of
have a significant economic impact on standards in sections 3(a) and 3(b)(2) of
the State of Indiana easterly along the
it, please submit a comment to the E.O. 12988, Civil Justice Reform, to
northern boundary of the State of
Docket Management Facility at the minimize litigation, eliminate
Indiana to the east line of LaPorte
address under ADDRESSES. In your ambiguity, and reduce burden.
County; thence southerly along the east
comment, explain why you think it Protection of Children line of LaPorte County to the north line
qualifies and how and to what degree of Starke County; thence east along the
this rule would economically affect it. We have analyzed this proposed rule north line of Starke County to the west
Under section 213(a) of the Small under E.O. 13045, Protection of line of Marshall County; thence south
Business Regulatory Enforcement Children from Environmental Health along the west line of Marshall County;
Fairness Act of 1996 (Pub. L. 104–121), Risks and Safety Risks. This rule is not thence west along the north line of
we want to assist small entities in an economically significant rule and Pulaski County to the east line of Jasper
understanding this proposed rule so that does not concern an environmental risk County; thence south along the east line
they can better evaluate its effects on to health or risk to safety that may of Jasper County to the south line of
them and participate in the rulemaking. disproportionately affect children. Jasper County; thence west along the
If the rule would affect your small south lines of Jasper and Newton
Environment
business, organization, or governmental Counties to the western boundary of the
jurisdiction and you have questions This rulemaking is not a major State of Indiana; thence south along the
concerning its provisions or options for Federal action significantly affecting the western boundary of the State of Indiana
compliance, please call Judith Kaleta at quality of the human environment to the north line of Gibson County;
(202) 366–9315. under the National Environmental thence easterly and northerly along the
Collection of Information Policy Act and, therefore, an north line of Gibson County to the west
environmental impact statement is not line of Pike County; thence south along
This proposed rule would call for no required.
new collection of information under the the west line of Pike County to the north
Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44 Privacy Act line of Warrick County; thence east
U.S.C. 3501–3520). along the north line of Warrick and
Anyone is able to search the Spencer Counties to the west line of
Federalism electronic form of all comments Perry County; thence easterly and
We have analyzed this proposed rule received into any of our dockets by the southerly along the north and east line
under E.O. 12612 and have determined name of the individual submitting the of Perry County to the Indiana-Kentucky
that this rule does not have sufficient comment (or signing the comment, if boundary.
implications for federalism to warrant submitted on behalf of an association, * * * * *
the preparation of a Federalism business, labor union, etc.). You may
review DOT’s complete Privacy Act Issued in Washington, DC on July 16, 2007.
Assessment.
Statement in the Federal Register D.J. Gribbin,
Unfunded Mandates published on April 11, 2000 (Volume General Counsel.
The Unfunded Mandates Reform Act 65, Number 70; Pages 19477–78) or you [FR Doc. 07–3516 Filed 7–16–07; 12:13 pm]
cprice-sewell on PROD1PC66 with PROPOSALS

of 1995 (2 U.S.C. 1531–1538) and E.O. may visit http://dms.dot.gov. BILLING CODE 4910–9X–P

VerDate Aug<31>2005 13:52 Jul 18, 2007 Jkt 211001 PO 00000 Frm 00023 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\19JYP1.SGM 19JYP1

Вам также может понравиться