Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
LBC Express, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals
*
G.R.No.108670.September21,1994.
603
VOL.236,SEPTEMBER21,1994
603
604
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
LBC Express, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals
PETITIONforreviewoncertiorariofadecisionoftheCourt
ofAppeals.
ThefactsarestatedintheopinionoftheCourt.
Emmanuel D. Agustinforpetitioner.
Bernardo P. Conchaforprivaterespondents.
PUNO,J.:
In this Petition for Review
on Certiorari, petitioner LBC
1
questions the decision of respondent Court of Appeals
affirming the judgment of the Regional Trial Court of
Dipolog City, Branch 8, awarding moral and exemplary
damages, reimbursement of P32,000.00, and costs of suit;
butdeletingtheamountofattorneysfees.
PrivaterespondentAdolfoCarloto,incumbentPresident
Manager of private respondent Rural Bank of Labason,
alleged that on November 12, 1984, he was in Cebu City
transactingbusinesswiththeCentralBankRegionalOffice.
He was instructed to proceed to Manila on or before
November 21, 1984 to followup the Rural Banks plan of
payment of rediscounting
obligations with Central Banks
2
mainofficeinManila. Hethenpurchaseda
_______________
1
Angelina,JJ., concurring.
2Rollo,CourtofAppealsDecision,p.78.
605
VOL.236,SEPTEMBER21,1994
605
onDecember15,1984lesstherevenuecharges.
RespondentCarlotoclaimedthatbecauseofthedelayin
the transmittal of the cashpack, he failed to submit the
rediscounting documents to Central Bank on time. As a
consequence, his rural bank was made to pay the Central
Bank THIRTYTWO
THOUSAND PESOS (P32,000.00) as
4
penaltyinterest. Heallegedlysufferedembarrassmentand
humiliation.
Petitioner LBC, on the other hand, alleged that the
cashpackwasforwardedviaPALtoLBCCebuCitybranch
5
onNovember22,1984. Onthesameday,itwasdeliveredat
respondent Carlotos residence at No. 2 Greyhound
Subdivision, Kinasangan, Pardo, Cebu City. However, he
was not around to receive it. The delivery man served
insteadaclaimnoticetoinsurehewould
______________
3Ibid.
4Ibid.,p.79.
5Ibid.
606
606
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
LBC Express, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals
SOORDERED.
Lachica.
607
VOL.236,SEPTEMBER21,1994
607
Wefindmeritinthepetition.
Therespondentcourterredinawardingmoraldamages
totheRuralBankofLabason,Inc.,anartificialperson.
Moral damages are granted in recompense for physical
suffering, mental anguish, fright, serious anxiety,
besmirched reputation, wounded feelings,
moral shock,
7
socialhumiliation,andsimilarinjury. Acorporation,being
an artificial person and having existence only in legal
contemplation, has no feelings, no emotions, no senses;
therefore, it cannot
experience physical suffering and
8
mentalanguish. Mentalsufferingcanbeexperiencedonly
byonehavinganervoussystemanditflowsfromrealills,
9
sorrows,andgriefsoflife allofwhichcannotbesuffered
byrespondentbankasanartificialperson.
We can neither sustain the award of moral damages in
favoroftheprivaterespondents.Therighttorecovermoral
damagesisbasedonequity.Moraldamagesarerecoverable
onlyifthecasefallsunderArticle2219oftheCivilCodein
10
relationtoArticle21. Partofconventionalwisdomisthat
he who comes to court to demand equity, must come with
cleanhands.
In the case at bench, respondent Carloto is not without
fault. He was fully aware that his rural banks obligation
wouldmatureonNovember21,1984andhisbankhasset
11
aside cash for these bills payable. He was all set to go to
Manila to settle this obligation. He has received the
documentsnecessaryfortheapprovaloftheirrediscounting
applicationwiththeCentralBank.Hehasalsoreceivedthe
planetickettogotoManila.Nevertheless,he
________________
7CivilCode,Article2217.
8Tamayovs.UniversityofNegrosOccidental,58OGNo.37,p.6023,
September10,1962.
9Supra.,atp.6032.
10 Garciano vs. Court of Appeals, G.R. No. 96126, August 10, 1992,
212SCRA436.
11Rollo,p.214.
608
608
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
LBC Express, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals
13 See
Peoples Bank and Trust Co. vs. Syvels Inc., No. L29280,
August11,1988,164SCRA247.
14 See China Airlines Limited vs. Court of Appeals, G.R. No. 94590,
July29,1992,211SCRA897.
609
VOL.236,SEPTEMBER21,1994
609