Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Creating
& ECONOMIC
Customer
in Luxury
S'T'UDIES
2009
NO. 44
Experience
Brands
approaches required to develop new brands, to compare and analyze the luxury brands of
Hermes and Louis Vuirton, whose yearly turnover is always highly ranked in the import
market, along with Coach, which has experienced rapid. progress in recent years, to
ascertain the "customer experience creation" of each brand. Ihe results obtained arc as
follows: Hermes's ways of creating customer experience are helpful to companies which
have traditional arts and produce high-class products. Louis Vuitton sets a good example
of more aggressive customer expansion strategies. Coach's ways of creating customer
experience provide useful information for companies which are rather new and actively
trying to develop a market for products
positioned
1. Introduction
In the "Kansei Value Creation Initiative," which the Ministry of Economy, Trade
and Industry is promoting, the promotion of management
methodology is proposed in
order to develop Kansei value in fashion. Through this paper, we aim to understand the
present state of value creation of luxury brands in the field of fashion as well as aiming to
26
Tab Table
I Total sales
of imported
Rank
Louis Vuitton
650.0
Coach
657.2
1175
FlemP5
620 C
1 n02
4 _ Tiffany
525.1
100,0
520.0
97.2
Gucci
Cartier
3.1
509 C
97.9
423.C
100.7
100.8
Chanel
380.0
Bvlgart
330.0
Prada
216.0
Source
103.4
yCAP
10
3. Four
Brand ~~ Tara,
SalesGrowthyear(')from last
99.1
IC
I 101
A
extracted from Yano Kebal Kenkyusho (2008) Import Market & Brands Yearbook 2008
p.18
Ps of Each
Brand
Hermes
Photo
I shows Hermes's
Table 2 introduces
representative
products,
scarf and
"K
elly
bag.
Hermes's
representative
Source: Nagasawa, Shln'ya ed, (2006), with Nagasawa's Laboratory in the Waseda Business School , Creating
Customer Experience in LongStendhg Brand Companies: Design Management of Encounters with
Customers, Doyukan, p.215 and p.217, Photos.
27
Table
Analysis
HermS's
4P
Product
Carro
representative
products,
its "Cam"
sea,'.
scarf
and "Kelly"
bag
-Kelly" bag
Precisely
materials,
drawing
"product'
element
Super-high
priceof42,000
yen(themost
per uos highpriceof700,000
yen(themost
Price
expensive of scarves)
expensive of bags)
Place
Soldmainly
atdirectly
managed
stores Soldmainly
aldirectly
managed
stores J
Promotion
Source: Negasawa, Shinya ed (2006), with Nagasawa's Laboratoryin the Waseda Business School, rbid ,0.210
exhibitionSupplemen63.
28
m
~~~
:z
w`
'~a
a~.
rry,
~~
4
f..
~',*~~I
~ ~~,
y
`~~~ ~
dt4i
k
~?
"r~:<~
.
~,
^E~;vJS
.t}~~4
x~.
Photo 2 Antique trunks of Louis Vuitton displayed at Matsuya Ginza in-shop store
Source Nagasawa,Snm'yaed (2007),withK Ohizurriand K Maeoa,ThePrinciplesofLouisWittonThe
StrongestBrandStrategy ToyoKeizeiShmposha,p 39, Photo(Jiji)
3.3 Coach
Coach is a rising company of constant
introduced
remarkable breakthrough
of marketing,
of Coach Japan.
Coach began its business as a family-mn workshop in a Now York Manhattan loft
operated by Miles Khan, his wife Lillian and some friends m 1941. The founders of
Coach were first inspired by a baseball glove when they saw its distinctive markings and
how supple it became with use. They created Coach's first handbag in the early 1960s
while keeping the leather's feature. Since then, the texture of Coach's handcrafted leather
and its excellent durability and functionality have fascinated fans mainly among business
people. The company went into the fashion field selling not only leather goods but also
bags and other products.
Coach made inroads into Japanese markets in 1988, and established a subsidiary
company by cooperating with Mitsukoshi. The number of shops was increased mainly in
29
branches of the department store. Sales, however, slowed down in the mid-1990s,
restricting growth. Then, Lew Frankfort became the Chairman and CEO of the company
in 1995 and started m revive the brand. Coach's image in the mid-nineties might be as
follows: although the quality, durability and functionality were reliable, the mode lacked
something. In order to sweep the image away, Reed Krakoff was chosen as a new designer
of the company.
Reed Krakoff, the present president and executive creative director of Coach, was
born in Boston, and went to Parsons School of Design in New York hoping to become a
painter. He joined Coach in 1997 after working for Ralph Lauren and Tommy Hilfiger.
The new concept of the brand was "Fun, Feminine and Fashionable ." The product
designs and the brand image were unified worldwide to develop Coach as a "Lifestyle&
Accessory" brand. the debut of the signature line items embroidered with the brand's
logo "C" in 2000 firmly revived the company, and gave impetus to a new era of the
brand.
In August 2001, Coach in the United States established Coach Japan with
Sumitomo Corporation on a 50-50 basis, and the new company achieved a great growth
with roughly three-fold sales within three years. In the imported bag and accessory
market, Coach ranked second in terms of market share following Louis Vuitton after
overtaking Gucci. The retail outlet was largelyextended, and its flagship shop was opened
in Ginza in May 2002. The second flagship shop in Shihuya and the Roppongi Hills
branch were opened in April 2003. The third flagship shop was opened in the
Marunouchi area in April 2004, followed by the opening of the fourth one in August
2004, far from the Kanto region, in Sapporo, Hokkaido.
What Coach is advocating is "AccessibleLuxury." the United States, which was
built on a new continent, has no history and class-basedsociety like in Europe, and no
aristocracies and nobility exists. Therefore, it is unreasonable for U.S. companies and
brands to follow Louis Vuitton's top-of-the-line direction and palace-like shops. It would
be pointless if excellent direction were not followed by true value. Through calm analysis
based on the "Logic & Magic" policy centering on logic and sensitivity, Coach decided to
offer not extreme luxury, which Louis Vuitton presents, but the sophisticated feeling of
luxury for middle-income people. In America where there is no class system, but gaps in
income levels are wide, the items for luxury, which encouraged people to buy the
products, steadilywon the hearts and minds of middle-income consumers. SinceJapan is
not a class-segregatedsociety and has narrower income differences than in the United
States, the middle-income market is large. It is therefore no wonder that Coach attracts
30
attention,
results.
3.4 Summary
the
comparison
It is really interesting
even concerning
capital-based
marketing.
although
than
faster
strength.
Coach,
than
founded
with an elaborate
pricing
A promotional
fresh memory.
three large
screens
satisfactory
Vuitton's
scheme
despite
produced
Louis Vuitton
marketing
being
keeps
strategy,
marketing
Louis
Vuitton's
on growing
is more
strategy
greatest
at a fast pace
which
opened
policy.
of Shihuya
the whole
mainly
and Hermes
in strategy between
Coach's
of marketing,
and promotional
Luxury"
results,
Furthermore,
in the birthplace
in front
sites. In addition,
achieves
Videos
is shown in Table 3.
Louis Vuitton
houses.
at the moment.
Louis
fashion
Hcrmes
Hermes
exploded
elements
between
and a self-funding
As a result,
successful
product
town
around
were televised
Station,
of Shibuya
Koen-dori
and billboards
were established
was enveloped
and ad-wrapped
in Coach
buses
with
running
at two
268 flags
through
the
and to working
out
town.
Each brand
devotedd themselves
to capitalizing
on their strengths
their strategies.
Table
Item
Comparison
of the three
companies'
product
Louis Vuitton
Hermes
Established
1837
t 854 _ ----_
Production
Handiwork by craftsman
Handiwork by craftsman
(graduate of Hermes
leather school)
(graduate of Asnieres
school)
Leather,
Leather,
Material
Amount
of
silk
Lesin
Coach
11941
Handiwork by craftsman
and machine, overseas
production
Leather,
Limited bases
Capability
bases
Jean-Paul
Marc Jacobs
Reed
production
Designer
elements
Goultier
textile
and number
of
Krakoff
Source. Nag
L asawa, Shin'ya (2007), Creating Customer Experience in Luxury Brands - Comparison of Hermes ,
ouis Vuittonand Coach -, Proceedings of International Conference on Kansas Engineering and Emotion
Research 2007, C-12, p.3, Table 3.
31
'Carte'scarf
"Kelly"bag
SENSE Smooth
touch
ofsilk
l
Very colorful
artistic
FEEL
' Design
ride
Design
THINK
designs
] ' Smooth
touch
ofsuperior
leather
of extremely
high
' sewing
by precise
handiwork
quality
evoking
horse
ccarriage
and
horse
' Name
Design
evoking
evoking
actress
horse
Grace
Kelly
ride
with story
Many variations
Producinghowto tie
of color, material,
size
' "Memorial
bag"succeededfrommotherto j
daughter
ACT
body
' Suitable
' Stability
shape of handle
with low gravity
-- ~I
for use I
I nobles society
Sponsorship of horse ride opera
j "Zingaro"
Source'. Negasawa, Shin ya ad, (2006), with Nagasawa's Laboratory in the Waseda Business School, Creating
Customer Experience i Long-Standing Brand Companies: The Design Management of Encounters with
Customers, Doyukan, p,213, ExhlbnlonSupplement -10.
32
Table
of the three
. Smooth
. Design
touch of superior
and shop
display
and
material, size
. Collection of Monograms
evoking horse
horse ride
THINK
carriage
. Many variations
taro"
ACT
customer
experience
_ouisuittoc
materials
Production and fabrication
by precise handiwork
FEEL
companies'
He
Module
SENSE
5 Comparison
of color ,
Coach
Coach's "C" marks
not to define the
is used
Jsed
manufacturers
but to
smarten the product.
Accessible
luxury
material. size
. Collection of Signature
Line (uniformity)
atmospher
of
workin
Expression of active
elegance
woman
in U.S.A.
(1) SENSE: Louis Vuitton's monogram "W" and Coach's "C" marks are used not to define
the manufacturers but to socialten the products by decorating them with marks.
(2) FEEL: Each product
and the
33
Sales
He
''
Lokis Vuitrnn
C1 e
B
a mY
.'
7
R
a
a
Coach
Marketing
Figure 1 Schematic diagram for comparison of Hermes, Louis Vuitton and Coach
experience based on their own traditions.
(4) New enterprises, such as Coach, adopt rational product making methods and ways of
selling based on the fundamental marketing principle, and present a modern and
tradition-independent
Figure I shows the schematic diagram for comparison of Hermes, Louis Vuitton
and Coach.
Methods of practical application learned by these processes of customer experience
are as follows:
(a) Hermes's ways of creating customer experience are helpful to companies which have
traditional arts and produce high-class products. Louis Vuitton sets a good example of
more aggressive customer expansion strategies.
(b) Coach's ways of creating
customer
experience
provide
useful information
for
companies which are rather -new and actively trying to develop a market for products
positioned halfway between the high and moderately priced products.
As for present-day Japanese companies, local established companies located in
traditional
35
Aclmowledgment
It should be added that' this paper is based on a chapter witten by Mr. Teppei
Tsuchida (engineer of a manufacturer) and Mr. Kenji Ohizumi (buyer of retailer) for the
books the author edited, and the results of their research which were noted down while
they were at Waseda Business School, and the anchor would like to express his deep
gratitude to them.
36
References
Hata, Kyojiri (2003), Shitekl Brand-ron: Louis Vritton to Deatte (Private Thoughts on
Brand Theory: Encounter with Louis Vuirton), Nihon Keizai Shimbunsha. (in
Japanese), and Plon. (translated in English, 2003)
Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry, Japan (2007), KANSEI Value Creation
Initiative: Proposal of the fourth axis ofvalue. (in Japanese)
Nagasawa, Shin'ya (2002), Brand 7eikoku no Sugao: LVMH Moe"t Hennessy Louis
Vuitton (An Unpainted Face of the Empire of Luxury Brands: LVMH Meet
Hennessy. Louis Vuitton), Nihon Keizai Shimbunsha (in Japanese), and Taiwan
Business Weekly(Taipei). (translated in Chinese, 2004)
Nagasawa, Shin'ya ed. (2003), Kansei S'hohin Kailiatsu no Jissen: Shobin yoso e Kansei
no 7enkan (Practice of Kansci Product Development: Featuring Kansei as Product
Elements),Japan Publishing Service. (in Japanese)
Nagasawa, Shin'ya ed. (2005), with Nagasawa'.sLaboratory in the Waseda BusinessSchool
(F. Yamamoto, M. Yoshida, Y. Irisawa, N. Yamamoto, S. Enoki), Hit wo Ulna
Keiken-Kati Souzou: Kansci wo Yusaburu Monodulcuri (Creating Customer
Experience that Brings Hot Seller: Manufacturing which appeals to Kansei),
Nikkagiren Shuppansha QUSE Press. Ltd.). (in Japanese)
Nagasawa, Shin'ya ed. (2006), with Nagasawas Laboratory in the Waseda BusinessSchool
(Y. Irisawa, T. Someya, and T. Tsuchida), Shinise Brand Kigyo no Keiken-kati
Souzou: Kokyaku tono Deal no Design Management (Creating Customer
Experience in Long-Standing Brand Companies: Design Management of
Encounters with Customers), Doyukan. (in Japanese) and Corporate Synergy
Development Center (Taipei). (translated in Chinese, 2008)
Nagasawa, Shin'ya ed. (2007), with Nagasawa'sLaboratory in the Waseda BusinessSchool
(T. Fujiwara, and N. Yamamoto), Keiken-kad Monodukuri: Brand-,kid to Hit wo
Umu `Koto' Dukuri (Manufacturing and Fabrication through Customer
Experience: Creating 'Events' that Brings Brand Value and Hot Seller), Nikkagiren
37
39