Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
A Randomized Double-Blind,
Placebo-Controlled Study to Establish
the Effects of Spirulina in Elderly Koreans
Hee Jung Park a Yun Jung Lee b Han Kyoung Ryu b Mi Hyun Kim c
Hye Won Chung d Wha Young Kim b
a
Foods R&D, CJ CheilJedang Corp., Seoul, b Nutritional Science and Food Services, Ewha Womans University, Seoul,
Food Science and Nutrition, Kyungpook National University, Daegu, and d Obstetrics and Gynecology,
Ewha Womans University School of Medicine, Seoul, Korea
Key Words
Spirulina supplementation Antioxidant status Lipid
profile Immune response Aging
Abstract
Aims: This study was conducted to determine the antioxidant capacity, immunomodulatory and lipid-lowering effects of spirulina in healthy elderly subjects and to document the effectiveness of spirulina as a functional food for
the elderly. Methods: A randomized double-blind, placebocontrolled study was performed. The subjects were 78 individuals aged 6087 years and were randomly assigned in a
blinded fashion to receive either spirulina or placebo. The
elderly were instructed to consume the spirulina or placebo
at home, 8 g/day, for 16 consecutive weeks. Results: In male
subjects, a significant plasma cholesterol-lowering effect
was observed after the spirulina intervention (p ! 0.05). Spirulina supplementation resulted in a significant rise in plasma interleukin (IL)-2 concentration, and a significant reduction in IL-6 concentration. A significant time-by-treatment
intervention for total antioxidant status was observed between spirulina and placebo groups (p ! 0.05). In female subjects, significant increases in IL-2 level and superoxide dis-
Introduction
Spirulina is a microscopic and filamentous cyanobacterium (blue-green alga) that has a long history of use as
food. Spirulina is a rich source of vitamins, especially vitamin B12 and provitamin A (-carotene), minerals, carotenoids, and phycocyanins [1]. Its safety for human
consumption has been established through numerous
toxicological studies [24].
Recently, spirulina has received attention regarding its
association with cholesterol-regulatory properties, modulation of the host immune system, and antioxidant capacity [510]. In a spirulina supplementation study involving 15 diabetic patients, Mani et al. [11] found a sigWha Young Kim
Department of Nutritional Science and Food Services, Ewha Womans University
11-1 Daehyun-dong, Seodaemoon-gu, Seoul (Korea)
Tel. +82 2 3277 3093, Fax +82 2 3277 2862
E-Mail wykim@ewha.ac.kr
323
Table 1. Baseline characteristics (mean 8 SE) of the subjects enrolled in the intervention study
Male (n = 43)
Age, years
Cigarette smoking, yes %
Alcohol drinking, yes %
Anthropometric values
Weight, kg
BMI, kg/m2
WHR
TSF, mm
Body fat, %
Diet intakes
Energy, kcal/day
Protein, g/day
Fat, g/day
Carbohydrate, g/day
Plasma values
Fasting blood sugar, mg/dl
Total cholesterol, mg/dl
LDL cholesterol, mg/dl
HDL cholesterol, mg/dl
Triglyceride, mg/dl
Blood pressure
SBP, mm Hg
DBP, mm Hg
Female (n = 35)
spirulina (n = 24)
placebo (n = 19)
spirulina (n = 17)
placebo (n = 18)
66.181.2
12.5
66.7
66.681.1
21.1
78.9
65.681.4
5.9
29.4
65.481.6
0
5.7
62.783.2
24.880.7
0.9480.01
22.381.8
25.481.1
63.682.7
24.680.5
0.9380.01
17.881.5
25.580.9
63.582.4
23.980.5
0.9380.01
30.981.6
32.681.0
63.282.6
24.180.7
0.9380.01
29.981.6
33.081.0
1,575.9886.1
64.084.2
32.582.6
256.3815.2
1,501.58116.4
60.585.8
31.684.0
243.7818.1
1,583.38110.9
67.185.8
40.285.2
223.9814.5
1,579.18115.5
62.885.3
34.284.3
243.5815.9
106.0482.8
181.587.1
109.387.9
50.584.1
108.2813.8
106.185.3
179.187.9
112.987.6
46.183.8
100.6810.1
103.883.6
200.589.4
126.788.3
46.881.8
135.5823.9
95.682.0
213.788.0
139.8810.9
52.684.0
106.7814.7
139.083.4
85.382.0
143.783.7
89.581.8
130.882.9
80.482.5
128.783.5
80.381.4
BMI = Body mass index; WHR = waist-to-hip ratio; TSF = triceps skin fold thickness; SBP = systolic blood pressure; DBP = diastolic blood pressure.
after treating ultracentrifugation infranatants with phosphotungstic acid-Mg. LDL cholesterol and atherogenic index (AI)
were calculated as using the Friedewald [25] and Lauer [26] equations, respectively.
Determination of Plasma Immunological Parameters
Plasma levels of IL-2, IL-6, TNF- , and monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1) were determined by enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay (ELISA) techniques (Quantikine, R&D
Systems, Inc., USA) read using an ELISA reader (Spectra Max 340,
USA). C3 concentration was determined using radial immunodiffusion plates (Norpartigen, Behring Co., Germany).
Plasma Levels of Antioxidant Parameters
Plasma thiobarbituric acid-reactive substance (TBARS) concentration was determined by the Yagi method [27] using a luminescence spectrometer (PerkinElmer, LS50, USA) with excitation
at 515 nm and emission at 553 nm. A standard curve was constituted from serial dilutions (01.0 nM) of a 1,1,3,3-tetra-methoxypropane[malonaldehyde bis(dimethyl acetal)] standard solution. The total antioxidant status (TAS) of plasma samples was
assessed using a commercial TAS kit (Randox Laboratories Ltd,
UK). Plasma superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity was measured
by the Maklund and Sheri method [28, 29], and the level of gluta-
324
Results
Table 2. Plasma lipid profiles (mean 8 SE) of the subjects during the intervention period
Male
Female
spirulina (n = 24)
placebo (n = 19)
baseline
baseline
4 months
4 months
179.187.9 184.589.7
112.987.6 115.989.6
46.183.8
47.783.9
2.7280.26
2.880.29
100.6810.1 104.2814.9
3.2180.29 3.2580.31
spirulina (n = 17)
placebo (n = 18)
baseline
baseline
0.0292
0.2034
0.4375
0.1478
0.2222
0.1891
200.589.4 184.886.4*
126.788.3 112.186.7*
46.881.8
47.182.9
2.7880.22 2.6480.28
135.5823.9 128.2823.2
3.3980.27 3.0580.30
4 months
4 months
213.788.0 210.489.3
139.8810.9 135.3810.9
52.684.0
53.683.7
2.9780.3
2.2980.27
106.7814.7 107.2815.8
3.480.31
2.880.35
p
0.0387
0.0541
0.6944
0.3855
0.9249
0.5263
AI = Atherogenic index. p = Pr > F by repeated measures ANOVA between spirulina and placebo groups of the same gender.
* Significantly different according to paired t test values between baseline and 4 months in the same group by gender (p < 0.05).
Table 3. Plasma immune variables (mean 8 SE) of the subjects during the intervention period
Male
IL-2, pg/ml
IL-6, pg/ml
TNF-, pg/ml
MCP-1, pg/ml
C3, g/l
Female
spirulina (n = 24)
placebo (n = 19)
baseline
4 months
baseline
4 months
9.4380.21
2.6481.10
3.3981.03
77.684.80
0.6780.03
13.680.32*
1.9480.91
1.0380.05
77.684.57
0.6780.02
13.280.53
1.0780.25
1.8580.78
91.188.35
0.6680.02
13.080.25 <0.0001
1.9980.65 0.0480
1.0380.05 0.2497
84.385.05 0.4149
0.7380.02* 0.0604
spirulina (n = 17)
placebo (n = 18)
baseline
4 months
baseline
4 months
9.3980.28
1.0280.17
1.8780.60
78.285.41
0.7880.02
13.880.32*
1.8080.65*
1.2080.20
69.583.92
0.7780.02
10.980.63
1.5280.46
2.8280.96
70.287.36
0.6780.03
13.380.28*
1.6580.65
1.0380.06
69.784.46
0.7480.03
0.0472
0.6287
0.4942
0.6066
0.0878
p = Pr > F by repeated measures ANOVA between spirulina and placebo groups of the same gender.
* Significantly different by paired t test between initial and 4-month values in the same group by gender (p < 0.05).
325
Table 4. Plasma antioxidant status (mean 8 SE) of the subjects during the intervention period
Male
TBARS, nmol/ml
TAS, nmol/l
SOD, U/mg
GPx, ng/ml
Female
spirulina (n = 24)
placebo (n = 19)
baseline
baseline
4 months
7.880.5
5.680.5**
1.680.1
2.280.2**
1.880.3
2.580.2
97.3814.4 107.985.4
4 months
5.980.2
5.480.2
1.980.1
2.080.2
1.980.3
2.480.3
106.6815.1 123.9813.3
spirulina (n = 17)
placebo (n = 18)
baseline
baseline
0.0966
0.0316
0.6845
0.1115
6.580.4
5.980.6*
1.780.1
2.180.2
1.680.2
2.780.3**
129.2810.5 114.987.2
4 months
4 months
7.480.7
6.580.4
1.780.1
2.180.2
1.980.3
2.580.2
96.6812.3 99.384.5
p
0.8996
0.4195
0.0347
0.8676
Significantly different by paired t-test between initial and 16-week values in same group by sex (* p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.0001).
p = Pr > F by repeated measures ANOVA between the spirulina and placebo groups of the same gender.
TBARS = Thiobarbituric acid response substance; TAS = total antioxidant status; SOD = superoxide dismutase; GPx = glutathione peroxidase.
Discussion
weeks resulted in a significant reduction in LDL cholesterol and AI; however, LDL cholesterol increased back to
its baseline value 4 weeks after discontinuing spirulina
administration. De Rivera et al. [32] measured liver levels
of triglycerides and phospholipids in rats fed a 60% fructose diet supplemented with 5% spirulina. Rats fed the
spirulina diet had lower levels of liver triglycerides and
phospholipids compared to rats fed 60% fructose diet
without spirulina supplementation. In addition, rats fed
20% water-soluble spirulina fraction showed raised HDL
to LDL ratios and lower fasting serum glucose levels
[33].
Spirulina has several antioxidant components, such as
vitamin B12, -carotene, tocopherol, carotenoids, and
phycocyanin. We examined the plasma levels of TBARS,
TAS, SOD, and GPx as antioxidant capacity biomarkers.
We observed that antioxidant capacity improved, as
shown by an increasing level of TAS and decreasing
TBARS after spirulina supplementation. An in vitro
study by Miranda et al. [34] revealed that peroxidation of
rat brain homogenates was inhibited by almost 95% following treatment with 0.5 mg of methanolic spirulina extract. In vivo antioxidant capacity was evaluated in the
plasma of animals receiving a daily dose of 5 mg spirulina
extract for 2 and 7 weeks. Upon treatment, the antioxidant capacity of the plasma was 97 and 71% in the experimental group and 74 and 54% in the control group
after 2 and 7 weeks, respectively [34].
Cytokines are proteins produced by lymphocytes that
control the behavior of immune cells. As cytokines are
typically multifunctional, analysis of several cytokines
allows a more fundamental understanding of the immune system. A group of researchers [35] using human
peripheral blood mononuclear cells demonstrated that
Park /Lee /Ryu /Kim /Chung /Kim
Acknowledgments
The financial support from the Korean Research Foundation
Fund (BK 21 project, grant No. R04-2003-000-10119-0) and ES
Biotech is gratefully acknowledged. The authors would like to
thank the elderly subjects who participated in this study, as well
as the staff of the Ewha Womans University for their invaluable
efforts in making this double-blind study possible.
References
1 Belay A, Ota Y, Miyakawa K, Shimamatsu H:
Current knowledge on potential health benefits of spirulina. J Appl Phycol 1993; 5: 235
241.
2 Salazar M, Chamorro G, Salazar S, Steele C:
Effect of Spirulina maxima consumption on
reproductive and peri- and postnatal development in rats. Food Chem Toxicol 1996;34:
353359.
3 Chamorro G, Salazar S, Castillo L, Steele C,
Salazar M: Reproductive and peri- and postnatal evaluation of Spirulina maxima in
mice. J Appl Phycol 1997;9:107112.
4 Salazar M, Martinez E, Madrigal E, Ruiz LE,
Chamorro G: Subchronic toxicity study in
mice fed Spirulina maxima. J Ethnopharmacol 1998;62:235241.
5 Kato T, Takemoto K, Katayama H, Kuwabara
Y: Effects of spirulina (Spirulina platensis)
on dietary hypercholesterolemia in rats. J Jap
Soc Nutr Food Sci 1984;37:323332.
6 Ishii K, Katoh T, Okuwaki Y, Hayashi O: Influence of dietary Spirulina platensis on IgA
level in human saliva. J Kagawa Nutr Univ
1999;30:2733.
7 Qureshi MA, Kidd MT, Ali RA: Spirulina
platensis extract enhances chicken macrophage functions after in vitro exposure. J
Nutr Immunol 1995; 3:3544.
8 Dainippon Ink & Chemicals, Inc (DIC): Antitumoral agents containing phycobilin. Japanese Patent #58-65216, 1983.
9 Pinero Estrada JE, Bermejo Descos P, Villar
dell Fresno AM: Antioxidant activity of different fractions of Spirulina platensis extract. Farmaco 2001;56:497500.
327
26 Lauer RM, Lee J, Clarke WR: Factors affecting the relationship between childhood and
adult cholesterol levels: the Muscatine Study.
Pediatrics 1988;82: 309318.
27 Yagi K: Assay for blood plasma or serum; in
Methods in Enzymology. New York, Academic Press, 1984, vol 105, pp 328331.
28 Marklund S, Marklund G: Involvement of
the superoxide anion radical in the autoxidation of pyrogallol and a convenient assay for
superoxide dismutase. Eur J Biochem 1974;
47:469474.
29 Sheri ZC, Keen CL, Hurley LS: Superoxide
dismutase activity and lipid peroxidation in
the rat: developmental correlation effected
by manganese deficiency. J Nutr 1983; 113:
24982504.
328
34 Miranda MS, Cintra R, Barros SBM, Mancini-Filho J: Antioxidant activity of the microalga Spirulina maxima. Braz J Med Biol
Res 1998;31:10751079.
35 Mao TK, van de Water J, Gershwin ME: Effect of spirulina on the secretion of cytokines
from peripheral blood mononuclear cells. J
Med Food 2000;3:135140.
36 Adler WH 3rd: Immune function in the elderly. Geriatrics 1989:44(suppl A):710.
37 Thoman ML, Weigle WO: Lymphokines and
aging: interleukin-2 production and activity
in aged animals. J Immunol 1981: 127: 102
106.
38 Rabinowich H, Goses Y, Reshef T, Klajman
A: Interleukin-2 production and activity in
aged humans. Mech Ageing Dev 1985: 32:
2113216.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.