Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 36

Joining composites

14/11/2013

Composites

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Introduction
Jointsshouldbeavoidedasmuchaspossible,italways
causesstressconcentrationsandquiteoften,failure
occurs at the joint or close to it
occursatthejoint,orclosetoit.
Withcomposites,itispossibletomanufacturevery
complexstructuresinonepiece.However,insomecases,
thisisnotpossible,ordissassembly isnecessary
Forcomplexjoints,with3Dloads,ametalconnection
elementcanbepreferred,becauseofitsisotropicnature.
Whyaremechanicalfastenersused?
Usuallytojoincompositepartswithother(metal)parts
Whenitisabsolutelynecessarytoallowdisassembly
14/11/2013

Composites

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Possibilities for connecting composite parts


Mechanical fastening
Bolts
rivets

Adhesive bonding
Combined mechanicaladhesive bonding
Fusion bonding(thermoplastics only)

14/11/2013

Composites

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Typesofmechanical fasteners
Bolts
With or withoutchamfered head (countersunk)

14/11/2013

Composites

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Example ofbolts in(segmented)turbineblades

Composites

14/11/2013

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Example ofbolts in(segmented)turbineblades


Carrot

14/11/2013

Tbolt

Composites

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Example ofbolts in(segmented)turbineblades


Connection using imbedded bolts

Bron:SANDIAREPORT
SAND20084648
UnlimitedRelease
Printed July 2008
Blade SystemDesignStudiesPhase II:
Final ProjectReport
DerekS.Berry

Composites

14/11/2013

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Mounting aturbineblade,using theTbolts

http://youtu.be/xFI3Dy2k6oQ
14/11/2013

Composites

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Typesofmechanicalfasteners
Rivets
Normalrivets
(accesstobothsidesisnecessary)
Blindrivets
(accesstoonlyonesidesuffices)

14/11/2013

Composites

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Rivetstoattachstiffenersinanairplanewing

14/11/2013

Composites

10

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Mostcommontestmethodsformechanicalfastening
a)Unstabilized singleshear b)doubleshear test c)Stabilized singleshear

14/11/2013

Composites

11

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Mechanical fastening:other possible geometries

14/11/2013

Composites

12

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Mostcommonfailuremodesformechanicalfastening

14/11/2013

Composites

13

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Mostcommonfailuremodesformechanicalfastening

14/11/2013

Composites

14

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Mostcommonfailuremodesformechanicalfastening

14/11/2013

Composites

15

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Mostcommonfailuremodesformechanicalfastening

14/11/2013

Composites

16

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Mostcommonfailuremodesformechanicalfastening

Composites

14/11/2013

17

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Mechanicalconnections
Advantages
Higherresistanceagainsttheenvironment
(temperatureandmoisture)
Higherresistanceagainstfatigue(lowerstress
concentrations)
Highreliability
Possibilityforrepetitiveassemblyand
disassembly
Highreproducibility
Easytoinspect
Nospecificsurfacepreparationsnecessary
14/11/2013

Composites

18

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Mechanicalconnections
Disadvantages
Necessitytodrill/provideholes
Specifictoolstodrill
Significantwearonthedrillingtools(unlesswaterjet or
lasercutting isconsidered)
Possibilityofinducing(significant)damageinthevicinityof
theholes(bothdrillingandwaterjet)
Creatingextrafreeedges(delaminations)

Stressconcentrationsinthevicinityoftheholes
orthotropic material and isotropic
Combining
Combiningorthotropicmaterialandisotropic
materialresultsinstressconcentrations
Differentthermalexpansion
Possiblegalvaniccorrosion
14/11/2013

Composites

19

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

What about sandwichmaterials?


Inserts,embedded during or after manufacturing

14/11/2013

Composites

20

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

10

Sandwichmaterials:Blindinsert

Composites

14/11/2013
19/01/04

21

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Sandwichmaterials

19/01/04
14/11/2013

Composites

22

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

11

Possibilities for connecting composite parts


Mechanical fastening
Bolts
rivets

Adhesive bonding
Combined mechanicaladhesive bonding
Fusion bonding(thermoplastics only)

14/11/2013

Composites

23

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Adhesive bonding
Advantages
Fairlyhighratioofstrengthtomass
Possibilityofsmoothsurfaces(dependingonthegeometry)
Possibility of smooth surfaces (depending on the geometry)
Lownumberofparts(two+adhesivelayer)
Noneedtoprovideholes
Nostressconcentrationsduetoholesorresultingdamageare
present
Galvaniccorrosionofmetalfastenersisnotpresent
When
Whencompositepartsarejoinedwithmetalparts,thisoffcourse
composite parts are joined with metal parts this off course
remainsanissue

Canbequitecheap(butnotnecessarily)
Tolowertheproductioncost,theadhesivecanbecocuredwiththe
precuredparts
14/11/2013

Composites

24

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

12

Adhesive bonding
Disvantages
Sometimesextensivesurfacepreparationnecessary
Roughening/grinding/sandblastingofthesurfaces
Roughening/grinding/sandblasting of the surfaces
Cleaning/degreasingofthesurfaces
Applyingextrachemicalagents

Largestressconcentrations,dependingontheused
geometry
Curing/hardeningcanbetimeconsuming
N t l
k
h th
h i l
ti
ill
Notalwaysknownhowthemechanicalpropertieswill
changeovertime
AgeingduetoUVlight,temperature

Canbesusceptivetocreep
14/11/2013

Composites

25

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Commonlyusedadhesivejointgeometries

14/11/2013

Composites

26

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

13

Somedesigncriteriaforadhesivejoints
Mainobjective:
Adhesivejointshouldhavelongerlifethanits
constituents

Consequences
Surfaceoftheelementsshouldbeprepared
properly
Failureduetocreepintheadhesiveisnot
Failure due to creep in the adhesive is not
tolerated

Composites

14/11/2013

27

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Somedesigncriteriaforadhesivejoints
Consequences(cont.)
Avoidorlowerthenumberofdiscontinuitiesin
the construction (stress concentrations)
theconstruction(stressconcentrations)
Staticloadingshouldnotexceedtheyieldstress
oftheadhesivefilm
Fatigue:adhesive layershouldonlytakeelastic
loads
Avoidnormalstresses,loadtheadhesiveinshear
,
Incaseofametalconstituent: assoonasthe
metalyields,considerfailureofthe
adhesive/joint
14/11/2013

Composites

28

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

14

Stressanalysis inadhesive joints


Theory ofVolkersen
Theory ofGoland andReisner
Finite elementmodelling

14/11/2013

Composites

29

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

StressanalysisaccordingtoVolkersen
Simpleelasticanalysis
Joiningelementsareconsideredas
membranes,sotheycannottakeabending
moment
Tensilestressesnormaltotheadhesivelayer
(=peelstress)isnotconsidered.
p
Maximumshearstressareexpectednearthe
ends.However,thesearefreesurfaces,so
stressmustbezero singularity
14/11/2013

Composites

30

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

15

Volkersen doublelapspecimen(nobending)
y

t1

ta

t2
P

2P

P
x

1
2

gem sinh

.K

1
2

.
with G a
Et 2.t a

and

.K

k 1. cosh

K t1

1
2

.K

x
. cosh

1
2

x
.1

t2

Ref. :VOLKERSEN,O., DieNietkraftverteilunginZugbeanspruchtenNietverbindungenmitkonstantenLaschenquerschnitten.


Luftfahrtforschung,15,pp.41 47,(1938)

14/11/2013

Composites

31

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Influenceoftheoverlaplengthoftheadhesivelayer(Volkersen)
(x)[MPa]

SCF

max
min

Increasingtheoverlaphardlyincreasesthemaximumshearstress,butthe
stressconcentrationfactor(SCF)increasesalmostlinearly
14/11/2013

Composites

32

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

16

Influenceoftheshearmodulusoftheadhesive(Volkersen)
(x)[MPa]

Increasingtheshearmodulusoftheadhesiveincreasestheshearstress
andtheSCF
14/11/2013

Composites

33

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Influenceoftheadhesivethickness(Volkersen)
(x)[MPa]

IncreasingtheadhesivethicknessresultsinalowerSCF
14/11/2013

Composites

34

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

17

Volkersenfor singlelapshear
With

Where

LucasF.M.daSilva,PauloJ.C.dasNeves,R.D.Adams,A.Wang,J.K.Spelt.Analyticalmodels
ofadhesivelybondedjoints PartII:Comparativestudy.int.J.Adhes
CompositesAdhes 2009;29:331
14/11/2013
35
341.
IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

StressanalysisaccordingtoGolandReissner
Limitations:
Thicknessoftheadhesivelayershouldbesmallwith
respect to the thickness of the adherends
respecttothethicknessoftheadherends
Viscoelasticbehaviour

Hypotheses:
Stressesintheadhesivelayerareconstantthroughthe
thickness
Planestrainassumption,deformationsperpendicularto
the loading direction are allowed
theloadingdirectionareallowed
Actingloads:axialload+bendingmoment

14/11/2013

Composites

36

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

18

GolandReisner:adhesive shear stress


z

ta
t

P
2c

With

14/11/2013

Composites

37

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

GolandReisner:adhesive Peelstress

With

Where

LucasF.M.daSilva,PauloJ.C.dasNeves,R.D.Adams,A.Wang,J.K.Spelt.Analyticalmodelsof
Composites
14/11/2013
38
adhesivelybondedjoints
PartII:Comparativestudy.int.J.Adhes
Adhes 2009;29:331341.
IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

19

Stressdistributionforalow shearmodulus(Goland Reissner)

avg
Ga =10,55MPa
Ea=35,85MPa
ta =0,18mm

Composites

14/11/2013

39

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Stressdistributionforahigh shearmodulus(Goland
Reissner)

Ga =1,24GPa
Ea=3,45GPa
ta =0,08mm

avg
14/11/2013

Composites

40

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

20

Finite elementsimulation
2mm
1mm

2Dmodel,toreduce
calculationtime
Simpleelasticsimulation
withnonlinear
deformations
Nocohesivelayers
necessarytoillustrate
thestressdistribution
Averydensemesh is
necessarytocapturethe
behaviour,especially
nearthefreeedgesof
theadhesivelayer

Composites

14/11/2013

41

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Finiteelementsimulation

BothVolkersen andGolandReisner areaccuratepredictions


OnlytheFEM cancapturetheshearbehaviouronthefreeedge
14/11/2013

Composites

42

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

21

Criticallengthofanadhesivejoint
Double

Jointstrength
h

overlap

Single
overlap

Suchacriticallenghtexits
Such
a critical lenght exits
foreveryjoint
configuration
foreverymaterial
combination

Overlaplength
14/11/2013

Composites

43

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Influenceoftemperatureontheadhesive
a [MPa]

a [mm/mm]
14/11/2013

Composites

44

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

22

Generalremarks
The(shear)stressdistributionwillhavehigherstress
concentrationswhen:
Theadhesivelayeristhinner
Th dh i l
i hi
Theadhesivelayerislonger
Theadhesiveisstiffer

Ageingingeneralwillhaveanimportantinfluence
Thereisacriticallength
Assessmentofthedifferentparameters:
http://users.ugent.be/~sfjacque/FlandersDrive

14/11/2013

Composites

45

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Commonerrorsinadhesivejoints

Strokes(byhand)ontheadhesivesurface
Coldareasduringcuring
Curingtimetooshort
Porosities inclusionsandotherforeigncontents
Dryspots
Discontinuitiesintheadhesivelayer
Kissing
Kissingbond
bond
surfacestoucheachotherorthe
surfaces touch each other or the
adhesivelayer,butnoeffectivebondhasformed.
Verydangerous,asthisisverydifficulttodetect.

14/11/2013

Composites

46

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

23

Possibilities for connecting composite parts


Mechanical fastening
Bolts
rivets

Adhesive bonding
Combined mechanicaladhesive bonding
Fusion bonding(thermoplastics only)

Composites

14/11/2013

47

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Combined mechanicaladhesive bonding


Themechanicalfasteners takesthegeneralload
Theadhesive layerprovidesamarginagainstshear
failure
Designsothattheadhesivefilmintroducestheforces
intothejoint,beforetheconstituentsdeform/move
toloadthemechanicalfastener difficult
Whenproperlydesigned,theyareusuallybetter than
bothmechanicalandadhesivejoints:
Failuremodes
Failureintensionoftheconstituents
Interlaminar failureoftheconstituent

14/11/2013

Composites

48

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

24

Possibilities for connecting composite parts


Mechanical fastening
Bolts
rivets

Adhesive bonding
Combined mechanicaladhesive bonding
Fusion bonding(thermoplastics only)

14/11/2013

Composites

49

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Fusion bonding
Only for thermoplastics (atleast one part)
Consists of
Surface preparation (if necessary)
Heating thepolymer toaviscous state
Physically causing polymer chains tointerdiffuse
Cooling ofthejointfor consolidation

Classification
Usually based on theheatgeneration (friction,
thermal or electromagnetic)
14/11/2013

Composites

50

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

25

Fusion bondingtechniques
Thermal
Welding

Friction Welding

Electromagnetic
Welding

HotToolWelding

SpinWelding

Induction Welding

Vibration Welding

Dielectric Welding

Infrared Welding

Ultrasonic
Welding
ldi

Microwave
Welding
ldi

LaserWelding

Stir Welding

Resistance
Welding

HotGaswelding
Extrusion Welding

14/11/2013

Composites

51

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Friction Welding
Generation ofheatatajointinterfacefrom
frictional work under pressure,followed by
cooling andconsolidation

14/11/2013

Composites

52

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

26

Linear vibration welding


Main advantages
Highproduction rates
Shortcycle times
Ability toweld
to weld anumber
a number ofcomponents
of components
simultaneously
Small tomediumsized parts
Weld interface
Easyprocess control
Insensitive tosurface preparation

Disadvantages
Not suitable for notflat specimens
distortion/displacement at the
Causes fibre distortion/displacementatthe
interface
Expensive machinerie

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iG3t0Q7UuCU

Applications

Automotive (light assembly,spoilers,


instrumentpanels,reservoirs,)

Composites

14/11/2013

53

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

SpinWelding
Main advantages

Highweld quality
Highspeed
Simplicity
Highreproducibility
Little surface preparation necessary

Main disadvantage
Nonuniformheatdistribution
(heating depends on relative linear
velocity V=Rx ),thus yielding
residual stresses

Appliciations
Tubesandcircular parts (e.g.sealing
awaterfilled compass)
Attaching studs toplasticparts
14/11/2013

Composites

54

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

27

UltrasonicWelding
Usesahigh(ultrasonic,e.g.20to40kHz)
frequencymechanicalvibrationtoweld.
Verticalorparalleloscillationispossible
Heatgeneration:surfaceandintermolecular
Energydirectorsareoftenused/necessary
Designisimportantforthequalityoftheweld

Composites

14/11/2013

55

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

UltrasonicWelding
Mainadvantage
Fastandcleanprocess
Fast and clean process

Maindisadvantage
Needforenergydirectors(notalways
possibleonsheetcomponents)
Riskoffibredisruptionatinterfaces
Heatconductionincarbon,resultingin
longweldtimes
Itisspotwelding(difficult,butnot
It is spot welding (difficult but not
impossible,toweldlargerareas)
Expensiveequipment

Application
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A2uFi65IWxM
14/11/2013

Automotiveparts,floppydisks,medical
devices

Composites

56

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

28

FrictionStirWelding
Originallydevelopedforaluminium(1991),butalsosuccesfully
appliedforcomposites.
Twopartsarefirmlypushedtogetherandametaltooldrillsand
plunges into the parts The softened polymer is stirred and
plungesintotheparts.Thesoftenedpolymerisstirredand
forgedbehindthetrailingfaceoftheheadpin(HP)
Greatpotentionforparticlefilledandshortfibrereinforced
thermoplastics
Careful designoftheHP
andaccuratecontrolof
theprocesscouldimprove
fibrebreakageatthe
interface
more researchneeded
Composites

14/11/2013

57

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

ThermalWelding
Consistsoftwostages
Anexternalheatingstage
Aforgingstage

Aheatsourceappliesheatdirectlyonboth
surfacestomeltthematrix.Then,theheat
sourceisremovedandthebondingsurfacesare
broughtincontactunderaforgingpressure.
Limitationslieinthesizeofthecomponents
(entireweldingsurfaceheatedinonestage),long
heatingtimeandhighweldingpressuresneeded.
14/11/2013

Composites

58

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

29

HotTool(orplate)Welding

Mainadvantages
Surfacetemperaturecanbeaccuratelycontrolled
Surfaceinaccuraciescantakenintoaccount
Itcanhandlecomplexgeometries

Main disadvantage
Maindisadvantage
Meltedpolymerislikelytosticktothetoolandnonstickmaterials
(teflon)tendtobreakdownathightemperature(teflon:200C)

Appliciations
Automotive(batterycases,fueltanks,)
Composites
14/11/2013
Infrastructure(gasandwaterpipelines,)
IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

59

Infraredwelding
Surfacestobebondedareexposedtointense
infraredradiotion,usuallyproducedbyhigh
intensity quartz lamps
intensityquartzlamps.

14/11/2013

Composites

60

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

30

Infraredwelding
Mainadvantage
Fastprocess
Canjoincombinations
Can join combinations
offlatandcurvedparts
Strongweldsare
possible
Automizationispossible

Maindisadvantage
Possible
Possible
deconsolidation
Warpageofsubstrates
duringheating
14/11/2013

Composites

61

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Hotgasandextrusionwelding

Similartogasweldingofmetals
Thermoplasticfillerrodispushedintothegroove
Extrusion:moltenfillerisextrudedintothejoint
Slow process not suitable for high production
Slowprocess,notsuitableforhighproduction
rates
Onlysuitedforparticlefilledorshortfibre
composites

14/11/2013

Composites

62

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

31

LASERwelding

Mostlyusedformetals,butcanbeusedfor
composites
Lasertransmissionweldingisalsopossible
Usuallyonly consideredforthetapelaying
process
Composites

14/11/2013

63

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Electromagneticwelding
Ahighfrequencymagneticfieldcauses
magneticmaterialsattheweldinterfaceto
get hot and start melting the surrounding
gethotandstartmeltingthesurrounding
matrix.
Then,moltenpolymerdiffusesunderthe
appliedpressuretoformabond.
Whennecessary,insertsorpowderssuchas
ironoxide,stainlesssteel,ferriteandgraphite
areaddedinthepolymermatrixbetweenthe
partstobejoined.
14/11/2013

Composites

64

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

32

Inductionwelding

Highfrequencyelectromagneticfield(200500kHz)
heatsupanimplantinthejoint
Implantcanbeafoilorparticles,typicallycontaining
somepolymerforadequateflowandconsolidation,
e.g.apolymerimpregnatedmetalmesh

14/11/2013

Composites

65

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Inductionwelding

Weld
Welddependsonuniformheating,whichdependson
depends on uniform heating which depends on
theuniformityofthemagneticfield.Hence,thecoil
designisveryimportant.
Single:magneticfieldaroundtheinnerdiameter
Multiturn:forremoteareas
Pancake:forlargeflatareas
Pancake: for large flat areas

14/11/2013

Composites

66

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

33

Inductionwelding
Mainadvantage
Fastandcleanprocess
Complexgeometries
Weldcanbereopenedbyinductionreheating

Maindisadvantage
Highcostofinsertmaterials
f
h
d
b
h b dl
Nonuniformheatdistributioninthebondline
Difficulttoweldlargeparts

14/11/2013

Composites

67

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Dielectricwelding

ElectricfieldintheMHzregion
Polymerswithhighdielectriclossfactor convertsome
ofthefieldenergyintoheat
Mainproblemisbulkheatingoftheentireelement
Mostlyusedforheatingandmeltingof
thermoplasticsandcuringofthermosets
14/11/2013

Composites

68

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

34

Microwaveheating

IntensemicrowaveenergyinGHzregionapplied
toelectromagneticabsorbentmaterial
Canalsobemadeascontionuousprocess,but
p
,
shieldingisrequired.
Itiscleanandfast,butforsmallersizeparts
(dimensionsoftheoven)
Composites

14/11/2013

69

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

Resistancewelding

Usesanelectricallyresistiveelement(metalmeshor
carbonmesh)
b
h)
Electricalcurrentisapplied,togenerateJoulesheat
Insulationofthemeshimprovestheweldquality,asit
preventscurrentleakage
14/11/2013

Composites

70

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

35

Resistancewelding
Mainadvantages
Fast,simple,cleanandcheap
Applicableforlargerstructures
A li bl f l
t t

Maindisadvantages
Becauseofpowerlimitations,onlynarrowweldsare
possible
Implantremainsinsidetheweld(cancausestress
concentrations))

Applications
Automotive
Aerospace(leadingedgeofAirbusA340andA380)
14/11/2013

Composites

71

IvesDeBaereandJorisDegrieck 20132014

36

Вам также может понравиться