Groupe Ariel S.A. Case Study for Multinational Finance.
NPV's are calculated and all questions are answered.

© All Rights Reserved

Просмотров: 7.2K

Groupe Ariel S.A. Case Study for Multinational Finance.
NPV's are calculated and all questions are answered.

© All Rights Reserved

- Hedging Currency Risk at AIFS
- Group Ariel Case
- Groupe Ariel case
- Groupe Ariel Project Analysis
- Midland Energy Case Study
- Working Capital Simulation Harvard Case Study Solution, SunFlower Nutraceuticals, Managing Growth
- Ariel
- Case Ariel
- Hedging Strategy for GM to manage competitive currency exposure
- Risk Management at Wellfleet Bank: "Megadeals"
- Group Ariel
- Groupe Ariel - Questions.pdf
- Dell Working Capital Solution
- CARREFOUR S.A. - Euro bonds
- Harmonic Hearing (Version 1)
- Session 10 - Simulation Questions.docx
- Ariel
- Working Capital Simulation: Managing growth V2
- BMW
- Capital Budget Structure for Aes Corp

Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 5

Introduction

Groupe Ariele S.A. is considering a complete overhaul of their company process. The Mexican

investment called for the purchase and installation of new automated machinery to recycle and

manufacture toner- and print cartridges. For this case, it was necessary to analyze the net present

value of the project. Groupe Ariel S.A. would only go forward with the project if the NPV is

positive. A distinction was also made between the Euro and Mexican peso in order to determine

which currency Groupe Ariele should choose to go with in order to maximize their return. Last,

we also considered the possible inflation and risk that are undoubtedly involved in a project of

this magnitude.

Question 1: Compute the NPV of Ariel-Mexico's recycling equipment in pesos by

discounting incremental peso cash flows at a peso discount rate and translate this into Euro.

Groupe Ariele is willing to invest in a new company process, going from a manual process to an

automatic process. To assess the impact of this whole project, the cash flows were calculated to

determine in what way this project would impact their financials.

We calculated the Net Present Value of this project using the NPV function in Excel (Exhibit 1).

First of all, we calculated the difference in operating costs by subtracting the cost of the old

equipment by the cost of the new equipment. Afterwards the depreciation old the equipment and

new equipment were added to the formula. Lastly, the tax rate and shield were added to compute

the incremental cash flows which in this case are positive because the reduced cost equals the

cash flows. Afterwards, these incremental cash flows were added to the NPV function in Excel

1+ Mexico

( 1+i Ariel )1 ) to

using a 12.19% discount rate (which was calculated using i MXN = 1+

France

arrive at the Project Net Present Value in Mexican pesos (MXN 1,478,998). Last, this number

was divided by the spot exchange rate of MXN15.99/EUR to arrive at 92,495.18 as the project

NPV in euro.

Compute the NPV in Euros by translating the project's future peso cash flows into Euros at

expected future spot exchange rates. Assume that inflation rates are expected to be 7% in

Mexico and 3% in France.

As mentioned before, the NPV was calculated using the Project NPV and dividing this by the

spot exchange rate. Another method that can be used is to use the expected future spot exchange

rates. For this method, a derivation of the PPP equation was used to compute the projected future

EUR

MXN /

EUR

MXN /

exchange rates (

. The present value of the net cash flows were calculated

1+ Mexico t

S t =

S

1+ France 0

E

in euros and afterwards the net investment was subtracted. The value of the Project NPV was

equal to the one computed using the spot exchange rate because of the presumption of the PPP

equation, 92,495.18.

Compare the two sets of calculations and the corresponding NPVs. How and why do they

differ? Which approach should Ariel's financial analyst use?

In this case, the NPVs that were calculated are the exact same number. Basically, if purchasing

power parity holds for the entire period of the investment there will be no difference between

either of the approaches. If the PPP assumption would not exist and interest rates stay the same,

depending on whether the euro depreciates or appreciates against the peso, the euro value NPV of

the project would be greater or respectively less than the peso value.

inflation remains 3%). How does this affect the NPV calculations?

Groupe Ariele S.A. would like to know what happens when the Mexican inflation is projected at

3% instead of 7% per year. For this question, the incremental cost savings were calculated at the

lower Mexican inflation rate of 3% (materials, direct labor and overhead) for both processes.

1+ Mexico

( 1+i Ariel )1 )

Afterwards, a new discount rate was calculated using the i MXN = 1+

France

formula, which made the discount rate arrive at 8%. The NPV of the project were then calculated

in Mexican Pesos (MXN 1,770,028.70). Using the spot exchange rate of MXN15.99/EUR this

ended up being 110,695.98. The peso/euro exchanges rates will stay the same if PPP holds and

inflation rates stay the same.

Suppose Groupe Ariel expects a significant real depreciation of the peso against the Euro.

How should its financial analyst incorporate such an expectation into his NPV analysis?

What is the peso depreciation effect on the NPVs under each of the two approaches?

Groupe Ariel seems to be expecting a real depreciation of the peso against the Euro, and needs to

account for this. For this case, one would have to know what the peso deprecation effect on the

NPVs will be for questions 1 and 2. To calculate the answer, the new cash flows were calculated

based on an exchange rate of MXN22.00/EUR in 2009 and MXN25.00/EUR for years 20102018.

If the peso realistically depreciates against the Euro in this way, the resulting NPV in euros will

be reduced to -690.26. And as mentioned at the start of this case report, if an NPV is negative,

one should not go forward with a project.

Should Groupe Ariel approve the equipment purchase? How should Groupe Ariel finance

the project? In pesos or in Euros? Will this affect your conclusions on whether Groupe

Ariel should approve the project?

The question is whether Groupe Ariel S.A. should approve this project and purchase the

equipment. To assess this problem, the NPVs of every section were analyezed. In almost every

case the NPVs were positive, which means that Groupe Ariel should go ahead with the project.

However, if Groupe Ariel was expecting depreciation of the peso against the euro, the NPV

turned negative. If that would be the case, the project should not be undertaken. However, we

believe that financing the project is the right way to go because the risk of possible depreciation

can be offset by using a hedging option.

We now have to decide whether to finance the project in pesos or euros. To assess this issue, we

have taken a look at the volatility of the peso against the euro in the following graph. This shows

the value of the peso against the euro for the last 3 years.

We also considered the current economic situation in the area that these currencies are used. Even

though both Mexico and the EU are not excelling, the EU is trailing. They currently have issues

with refugees, went through a lot of hardship with Greece and are still in doubt how to ensure

economic prosperity. We believe the euro might keep losing value as more and more countries are

given bailout packages and countries are considering leaving the EU. For that reason, we believe

it might be more interesting to finance the project in pesos.

In conclusion, we believe Groupe Ariel S.A. should go ahead and finance the project because of

the positive net present values that we established and because the risk of depreciation can be

hedged. The currency we decided Groupe Ariel S.A. should go with is the euro because of the

current economic situation in Europe and the fact that the value of the euro might go down.

- Hedging Currency Risk at AIFSЗагружено:bssilver123_52672484
- Group Ariel CaseЗагружено:mibebradford
- Groupe Ariel caseЗагружено:Paco Colín
- Groupe Ariel Project AnalysisЗагружено:Giorgi Kharshiladze
- Midland Energy Case StudyЗагружено:run2win645
- Working Capital Simulation Harvard Case Study Solution, SunFlower Nutraceuticals, Managing GrowthЗагружено:alka murarka
- ArielЗагружено:memfida
- Case ArielЗагружено:Badr
- Hedging Strategy for GM to manage competitive currency exposureЗагружено:Abhineet Gaurav
- Risk Management at Wellfleet Bank: "Megadeals"Загружено:Rishi Bajaj
- Group ArielЗагружено:Sumit Sharma
- Groupe Ariel - Questions.pdfЗагружено:Debbie Rice
- Dell Working Capital SolutionЗагружено:IIMnotes
- CARREFOUR S.A. - Euro bondsЗагружено:Sittipon'Seng'Samakkeenitch
- Harmonic Hearing (Version 1)Загружено:Nisha Kohli
- Session 10 - Simulation Questions.docxЗагружено:Chetan Duddagi
- ArielЗагружено:Sumit Kumar
- Working Capital Simulation: Managing growth V2Загружено:Abdul Qader
- BMWЗагружено:minju0930
- Capital Budget Structure for Aes CorpЗагружено:Arpita Gupta
- Walt Disney Yen Financing I_Group 8Загружено:Sonal Choudhary
- AES Case FinalЗагружено:whaza789
- Cost of Capital at AesЗагружено:harsh2989
- Capital Budgeting at AESЗагружено:Abhishek Anand
- ArielЗагружено:amit
- Working Capital Simulation PaperЗагружено:Debra Rogers
- AES SpreadsheetЗагружено:Brian Tran
- Focus Group ArielЗагружено:SidraSarfraz
- arielЗагружено:ManojMeena
- FIN571 Working Capital Simulation WK6Загружено:Dina

- QIMacros Test ResultsЗагружено:mlefcowitz
- Theory of ErrorsЗагружено:jaybh575
- The Scheme of Three-level Inverters Based on Svpwm Overmodulation TechniqueЗагружено:IAEME Publication
- Treyball, HumidityЗагружено:Andina Indah Sekararum
- Els&CommunicationЗагружено:api-3827000
- Curved+Beam+by+B.C.+PunmiaЗагружено:Alaa Salim
- C++ Control StructuresЗагружено:josefalarka
- Nonlinear Modeling and Control of Hydraulic ActuatorsЗагружено:Nachiket
- Class M Planet PredictionsЗагружено:Reginald L. Goodwin
- Px c 3882498Загружено:Sivagowry Shathesh
- Articol 2 Warehouse DesignЗагружено:Gabriela Uretu
- rsaЗагружено:Marco Wong
- CMOS Sequential Circuit Design Lec.-1Загружено:Parag Parandkar
- Structural ReviewerЗагружено:berolyan06
- Coriolis AccelerationЗагружено:lauravbleediote
- BCOM-CBCS-2014-15Загружено:Ramanji Anji
- Exercise2 LGЗагружено:andrew
- Origin6 TutorialЗагружено:Raphael Gomes
- A Model for Biomass Screw FeedingЗагружено:Ashnek
- On Migration and Risk in LDCsЗагружено:Thanh Nam
- Compound Interest _ CRACK SSC.pdfЗагружено:Sai Swaroop Attada
- TextBooks for 2014Загружено:Yes
- Potential FlowsЗагружено:Juan Gonzalez
- acceleraion of a laboratory cartЗагружено:Ugur ASİT
- Module 1Загружено:Arun Goyal
- Eternal Black Holes in Anti-De-Sitter by j MaldacenaЗагружено:J. Yahir A. Gálvez
- 11 SBST1303 T7 (WM)Загружено:Frizal Rahim
- Cpp Lab AssignmentЗагружено:Shaswata Dutta
- Role of Friction in RollingЗагружено:Amanda Bolton
- Qian Et Al-2003-European Journal of BiochemistryЗагружено:Reza Mahoor

## Гораздо больше, чем просто документы.

Откройте для себя все, что может предложить Scribd, включая книги и аудиокниги от крупных издательств.

Отменить можно в любой момент.