Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Introduction
Reflecting back on my adolescent days, I think about the impoverished conditions and
social inequalities that surrounded me. As a young person, I was not interested in school or
working, and my peers demonstrated similar feelings. Considering the negative direction my life
was heading, my future was uncertain. I do, however, remember the youth outreach workers
(henceforth YOWs) in my neighbourhood always facilitating programs that were geared towards
educating youth like me. The programs that were delivered by the YOWs included support with
schoolwork, employment, and life skills. This type of work was performed to encourage young
people in my neighbourhood to take an interest in their social, academic and economic
development.
This reflection upon my own experiences later led me to ask: What approaches do YOWs
use to make meaningful ties with young people so that the youth become interested in their own
development? In doing so, I argue that the strategies that these workers use are less formalized
and scripted programs that can be easily adapted to meet the needs of the youth they work with.
My research findings suggest that YOWs intentionally revealed their own vulnerability as a
practice to support marginalized youth. Vulnerability helps to build relations of solidarity which
leads to enhancing interactions between YOWs and marginalized youth, and works towards the
youths development goals.
In the social science literature vulnerability is not clearly defined. Rather, researchers
have described the characteristics of vulnerable persons. For example, education researchers
Professor Mona Gleason and colleagues suggest that vulnerable persons are physically,
emotionally, or socially susceptible to be victimized and scrutinized among others (Gleason et al
Vulnerability
By displaying vulnerability, a YOW can establish reciprocal relationships with
marginalized youth in which there is solidarity. I am using the term vulnerability to illustrate
how YOWs and youth are not morally judging or criticizing each other, and how they are able to
feel safe and free of judgment while being vulnerable with each other. Previous Anthropological
research proposes that vulnerability can bind people together to create a basis for solidarity
(Leach 2012:117). However, the literature that addresses vulnerability as it is connected to
marginalized youth focuses on how marginalized youth are vulnerable to victimization (Asdigian
and Finkelhor 1996:3). The literature does not mention how shared experiences of vulnerability
can lead to relationships between YOWs and marginalized youth.
The research on vulnerable relationships between YOWs and marginalized youth
suggests that they need to trust each other. However, it also mentions that YOWs may use
marginalized youths vulnerability to control them. Youth development researchers Cousse and
colleagues suggest that youth outreach work has a plan to civilize marginalized youth by
enforcing social control on the youths vulnerability (Cousse et al 2009:421). The work of
Methods
I conducted 17 semi-structured interviews with YOWs (6 female, 11 male) to answer the
following research questions: What strategies and practices do youth outreach workers use to
support the social development of marginalized youth in Toronto? How do youth outreach
workers create and maintain relationships with marginalized youth? How do youth outreach
workers use the relationships between themselves and marginalized youth to support and educate
youth? The practice experience of the YOWs in youth outreach programmes ranged from 2 to 20
years, most over 10 years and from three areas of Toronto.
I used snowball sampling (chain-referral sampling) to contact participants who worked in
different community organizations. Snowball sampling is an anthropological or sociological
method that is used in qualitative research. The method utilizes referrals made among people
who share characteristics of the research interest (Biernacki et al 1981:141). Biernacki et al
suggests that snowball sampling is well suited for a number of research purposes and is
particularly applicable when the focus of the study is on sensitive issues and thus requires the
knowledge of insiders to locate people for the study (Biernacki et al 1981:141). The method
was suitable for my research to extract data because I was able to locate YOWs who were willing
to share sensitive information about the marginalized youth they work with. After gaining
research participants through snowball sampling, I interviewed each of them in public settings
including libraries, coffee shops, and restaurants. During the semi-structured interviews,
participants provided their experiences of working with marginalized youth, their perceptions of
the issues faced by youth, and their specific support strategies.
10
Employment
Many of the YOWs that I interviewed support marginalized youth in seeking full-time or
part-time employment. Considering what was mentioned previously in the study, the participants
explained that assisting marginalized youth seek employment requires an understanding of the
12
13
14
15
Education
Encouraging youth to understand the importance of an education and how it can benefit
their lives can be an obstacle YOWs face. This is due to the youths perception of school and
what they have experienced in educational institutions. Throughout my conversation with
16
17
19
Reflection
Some YOWs state that they view themselves in the youth they support. For example, Jordan
stated:
21
22
23
24
25
Leach, Belinda
2012 Not the Same old Stories: Labor Anthropology, Vulnerabilities, and Solidarity Struggles.
Confronting Capital: Critique and Engagement in Anthropology. New York: Routledge
Publishing.
McWhirter, Jefferies, with McWhirter, Benedict, with McWhirter, Ellen, and McWhirter, Robert
2012 At Risk Youth. Belmont: Cengage Learning Publishing.
Nichols, Naomi
2014 Youth Work: An Institutional Ethnography of Youth Homelessness. Toronto: University of
Toronto Press.
Ortner, Sherry
2006 Anthropology and Social Theory: Culture, Power and the Acting Subject. London: Duke
University Press.
Sercombe, Howard
1997 The Youth Work Contract. Youth Studies Australia 16 (4):17-21.
U.S. National Commission on Excellence in Education
1983 Nation at Risk the Imperative For Educational Reform. The Elementary School Journal 84
(2):113-130.
26