Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Original Article
Nutrition Program and the Tropical Health Program Australian Centre for International and Tropical Health and
Nutrition, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
3
Department of Pediatrics, Faculty of Medicine, Khon Kaen University, Khon Kaen, Thailand
Childhood obesity is a serious public health problem because of its strong association with adulthood obesity and the
related adverse health consequences. The published literature indicates a rising prevalence of childhood obesity in
both developed and developing countries. However no data exists on the prevalence in Northeast Thailand, one of the
poorest regions of the country and one that has experienced a recent economic transition. The objective of this study
was to estimate the prevalence of obesity in seven to nine year old children in urban Khon Kaen, Northeast Thailand.
A cross-sectional school based survey was conducted to determine the prevalence of obesity in children of urban
Khon Kaen, Thailand. Multi-staged cluster sampling was used to select 12 school clusters of 72 children each
between the ages of 7 and 9 years, in primary school grades 1, 2 and 3 from government, private and demonstration
schools. A total of 864 seven to nine year old school children were studied. Anthropometric measurements of standing
height and weight were taken for all subjects to the nearest tenth of a centimetre and tenth of a kilogram respectively.
Childhood obesity was defined as a weight-for-height Z-score above 2.0 standard deviations of the National Center
for Health Statistics/World Health Organisation reference population median. The prevalence of childhood obesity
was 10.8% (95% CI: 7.6, 13.9). Obesity was significantly more prevalent in boys than girls. The biggest difference
was observed between the three school types, with the highest prevalence of obesity found at teacher training
demonstration schools and the lowest at the government schools. This study provides the first data on childhood
obesity prevalence in Northeast Thailand. The prevalence of 10.8 per cent is lower than that found in two other urban
areas of Thailand but slightly higher than expected for this relatively poor region. If this prevalence rate increases, as
observed in other countries in economic transition, the incidence of non-communicable diseases associated with
obesity is also likely to increase, thus raising cause for concern and reason for intervention to both control and prevent
obesity during childhood.
Key Words: prevalence, childhood obesity, Southeast Asia, Thailand, Khon Kaen, school children.
Introduction
There is currently a global epidemic of obesity. Obesity
prevalence figures as high as 70% in adults and 30% in
1,2
children have been reported for some countries.
However
the seriousness of the problem has only recently been
recognised, with obesity only being defined as a disease since
3
1997. In adults, obesity is associated with increased
morbidity and mortality from chronic diseases including
hypertension, coronary heart disease, gall bladder disease,
gallstones, kidney stones, digestive diseases, certain cancers
4,5
and social or psychological problems.
The economic cost
of adult obesity to society is high with an estimated 2% to 8%
of total national health care costs in the West being
6
attributable to obesity. If indirect costs such as loss of wages
and productivity reduction are included, the estimated cost of
obesity is even higher. In children, obesity can cause hyper-
67
Author/Year
Age range
Thailand: southern
Thailand: Hat Yai
Thailand: Bangkok
Indonesia: Jakarta
Taiwan
Kuwait
Italy
USA: New York City
USA: Florida
USA: Alabama
Tontisirin 1999
9
Mo-suwan et al. 1993
7
Suttapreyasri et al. 1990
11
Droomers et al. 1995
12
Chen 1997
13
Al-Isa 1998
14
Maffeis et al. 1998
15
Melnik et al. 1998
16
Hernandez et al. 1998
17
Figueroa-Colon et al. 1997
10
18
Result
Prevalence (%)
14%
15.6%
14.3%
16.1%
9%-14%
8.2%
22.3%
17.8%-19.9%
32%
12%-22% (whites)
20%-33% (blacks)
13.8%
30%
68
69
Table 2. Summary measures of height and weight for the sample population
Variable
Heights (cm)
Mean SD
Weights (kg)
BMI
Median
Range
Mean SD
Median
Range
Mean SD
109.3 150.0
104.8 149.4
26.6 6.9
24.9
16.4 2.8**
15.6
27.1 7.3
25.1
15.659.6
16.065.4
16.8 3.2**
15.8
104.8 136.3
109.4 147.6
114.7150.0
104.8 150.0
24.3 5.8*
23.0
16.1 .8***
15.4
26.9 6.4*
25.0
16.5 2.9***
15.6
31.2 7.9*
29.4
17.5 3.3***
16.5
26.9 7.1
25.0
15.750.2
15.657.0
17.565.4
15.665.4
16.6 3.0
15.7
Median
Range
Gender
Girls
435
126.5 7.6
125.7
Boys
429
126.2 6.7
126.8
358
122.0 5.4*
121.9
297
127.1 5.9*
127.2
209
132.8 6.2*
132.2
864
126.4 7.2
126.4
11.829.0
12.633.2
Total
Sample
11.827.5
12.629.6
12.433.2
11.833.2
Significantly different from means of other age groups and genders (ANOVA) *P<0.001, **P<0.01, ***P<0.05.
40
Body Mass Index (BMI) measures have been provided for the readers interests as BMI child growthcharts have been published since the survey.
Table 3. Summary measures of WHZ of the sample population with obesity prevalence by gender, age and grade
Groupings
Mean
SD of
WHZ
Median
of WHZ
Range of
WHZ
Obesity prevalence of
total sample (95% CI)
Girls
Boys
0.1 1.2
0.4 1.6
0.0
0.0
-2.8 4.8
-2.4 6.5
7 year olds
8 year olds
9 year olds
0.2 1.5
0.2 1.4
0.4 1.3
0.0
0.0
0.1
1 graders
2nd graders
rd
3 graders
0.2 1.4
0.2 1.5
0.2 1.3
Total sample
0.2 1.4
st
Obesity prevalence of
820 non-flagged children
Obesity
prevalence
based on
BMI
10.1%
15.6%
-2.8 6.2
-2.4 6.5
-2.2 6.1
12.6%
11.8%
14.8%
-0.0
-0.0
0.1
-2.8 6.2
-2.4 6.5
-2.2 6.1
n/a
n/a
n/a
0.0
-2.8 6.5
12.8%
Significantly different from obesity prevalence in other sex (t test) * P<0.01. CSAMPLE analysis in Epi-Info version 6c taking into account
th
40
the
design effect caused by clustering. The BMI cut-off for obesity is the 95 percentile curve on the CDC growth charts.
Obesity prevalence is not available by grades as the BMI measure is based on age and sex
70
Discussion
Khon Kaen municipality is an urban centre located in a
relatively poor area of Thailand, which is more likely to have
experienced greater economic transition than the adjacent
rural areas. The prevalence of 10.8 per cent found in this
study in urban Khon Kaen was slightly lower than the prevalence of childhood obesity reported in other urban studies
10,30
7
carried out in southern
and central Thailand where the
prevalence was around 14 per cent. Increasing economic
development in a region is often associated with increasing
prevalence of obesity, not only in industrialized countries but
33-35
also in newly developed nations such as Brazil.
The
international literature has portrayed developing countries as
having relatively low levels of obesity coexisting with high
1
prevalence of wasting. In contrast, this study shows a developing country region with a relatively high prevalence of
childhood obesity (10.8%) coexisting with a low prevalence
(1.2%) of wasting. This pattern of nutritional status is similar
to that observed in Brazil and supports the observation that
the Khon Kaen region of Thailand is in a transitional phase of
21
its economic development. It also demonstrates the degree
of heterogeneity in health and nutrition problems in developing countries.
As this study was cross-sectional and no previous obesity
prevalence studies have been carried out in Khon Kaen,
changes in the prevalence of childhood obesity over time
could not be ascertained. However, preliminary qualitative
research in Khon Kaen shows that most child caregivers
(primary school teacher, parent or grandparent) interviewed
believed that the proportion of children carrying excess
24
weight had increased over a 20-year period. In a study on
12
childhood obesity in Taiwan, Chen (1997) reported that in
1954 no primary school children were found to be obese, in
1970 he found a 2% obesity prevalence, and 16 years later
in1986, the prevalence of obesity in school children had risen
to 17.4%. This increase of childhood obesity coincides with
Government
Private
Demonstration
Total
576
144
144
864
Obesity prevalence
8.3%
(6.1% - 10.6%)
13.2%
(7.7% -18.7%)
18.1%*
(11.8% - 24.3%)
10.8%
(7.6% - 13.9%)
11.1%
(6.5% - 15.7%)
18.5%
(10.5% - 26.6%)
57.5%**
(47.3% - 67.7%)
20.5%
(9.3% - 31.6%)
45.3%
(34.0% - 56.6%)
56.3%
(56.1% - 56.4%)
82.8%**
(77.7% - 87.9%)
53.7%
(42.4% - 65.0%)
51.3%**
(43.9% - 58.8%)
75.2%**
(74.2% - 76.2%)
85.1%**
(84.2% - 86.0%)
61.2%
(51.4% - 71.0%)
Significantly different from other categories reading across (Chi squared test) *P<0.01, **P<0.001.
71
http://www.who.int/nut/malnutrition_worldwide.htm#oao
UNICEF Statistics: http://www.unicef.org/statis/ Apr 1998
72