Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Changes in
the way people relate or respond to civic events
rituals and symbols
public consciousness
how its shaped, constructed and transformed
how it shapes and transform events, perceptions, subjectivities
We cannot predict how things will turn out; our hermeneutic/genealogical goal
is more modest.
Benevolent Assimilation
issued on December 21, 1898
by President McKinley
Alfred W. McCoy
the United States quickly decided that it was not really
interested in making the islands a permanent
possession.
the United States established a tutelary colonialism
aimed at preparing the Filipinos for the governance of
an independent nation.
Tutelary Colonialism
ultimate goal was the creation of an independent nation-state.
P.W. Preston
Having acquired this territory in pursuit of the status of great nationhood. The
US promptly determined to adhere to its espoused democratic ideal and to
prepare the territory for the independence included the tying of the
Philippines economy tightly to that of the US.
Charles Briggs
The establishing of American sovereignty in the Philippines as a guaranty
before the world that the Philippines are for the Filipinos, is by far the most
revolutionary dynamic ever yet introduced into oriental politics. It has released
the pent-up protest of the millions of exploited orientals.
Filipinos ended up thinking that loving America and loving the Philippines
amounted to the same thing.
Bi-nationalism
dual loyalty
Under the US, Philippine nationalism evolved through the sponsorship of the
metropolis.
Compared to the Spanish, American rule was benign and enlightened.
Spanish rule produced poets and revolutionaries while American rule produced
orators and lawyers.
The state plays a vital role in producing the people. The state,
thus, creates its own imagined community that Balibar
explicates is that a community which recognized itself in advance
in the institution of the state, which recognizes its own in
opposition to the other states and in particular inscribes its
aspirations for within the horizon of the state - by formulating its
aspirations for reform and social revolutions as projects of
transformation of its national state.
What happened under American rule was the creation of a new nation-state
that could best further the agenda of the emergent American empire in the
Asia-Pacific region.
The Philippines had to be free and self-governing; as a colony it would be less
useful, if not altogether a liability.
The creation of a new homo nationalis - who would be attached to the socalled American-style values while remaining Filipino
symbol
of
resistance
Campbell Dauncey
-an Englishwoman
-arrived in the Philippines on
27 November 1904
-stayed in the country for
nine months
An Englishwoman in
the Philippines (1906)
unbiased impression of
the Philippines as they are in
the form of letters to family
and friends in England
LETTER 7
(Iloilo, 31 December 1904)
Mrs. Dauncey characterized the Filipino not only as a fun-loving lazy fellow who
knocks off what little work he does to join the merriment of the fiesta, but also
as unhygienic chap who spits in the street.
LETTER 39
(Iloilo, 11 August 1905)
Mrs. Dauncey describes the excitement that surround the return visit to Iloilo of
William Howard Taft, the first civil governor (1901-1903) of the Philippines
under the American regime and now revisiting SecWar of the United States.
LETTER 40
It describes in detail the preparations in Iloilo of the arrival of Taft, and contains
perhaps the most revealing passage in Mrs. Daunceys quaintly instructive, if
Orientalizing, account of her Philippine sojourn.
Katherine Mayo
- American journalist
- known for denouncing the
Philippine Declaration of
Independence on racialist
and religious grounds
so that a much needed ideal might, in time, grow up around that name.
Rizal Day
Dauncy
to give relief to
some of their
patriotic emotions
Mayo
to demonstrate
against subservience
to America and
against General
Wood
2)
The conservative ilustrados view of Rizal
as a
symbol of both opposition of supremacy of
friars and, as Ileto puts it, evolutionary [as
against revolutionary] change.
Development of a Pro-American
modern Filipino consciousness:
Two Factors:
The patronage politics instituted by Americas colonial
functionaries
Imperial Collaboration
Explanation of Philippine colonial politics under the American
regime as the result of an intricate web of patron-client ties
between the local elite.
Colonial Democracy or Compadre Colonialism
- the development of Philippine politics down to contemporary
times
Colonial Education
Fostered a complementary ideology of a lasting special
relationship between the Philippines and the United States
American colonial education did not deny Philippine nationalism
Submit a
recommendation to the
US President
Arrived in 1899
Establishment of a bicameral
legislature (lower house to be
elective; upper house to be halfelective and half-appointive)
Organization of autonomous
municipal and provincial
governments
Appointment of distinguished
Filipinos to important
government offices
Although there is no
mention of it in its
policy and
recommendations, one
of the things the
commission discovered
was Rizal.
Discovery of Rizal
Discovery of Rizal
Through interviews with Prominent
Filipinos particularly Dr. Trinidad
Pardo de Tavera
Sanskrit scholar
Ethnohistorian
One of the first ilustrados who offered
their services to the Americans as
soon as the Spanish regime collapsed
Although it had not been proven that he had anything to do with it, he was
still sentenced and shot by the Spaniards as they demanded it
Discovery of Rizal
Through the works of the
British writer John Foreman
John Foreman
Long-time resident of the Philippines
Published The Philippine Islands in 1890
Revised it in 1899 and 1906
Discovery of Rizal
Through the works of the Spanish
journalist-cum-historian Wenceslao
E. Retana
Wenceslao E. Retana
Pro-friar journalist
Antagonist of Rizal and Blumentritt
Had a change of heart after Spains
defeat
Discovery of Rizal
All 3 writers shared a common view of Rizal as:
Multitalented
Liberal
Reformist intellectual who opposed Bonifacios uprising
Luneta
From Pardo de Tavera
The Americans learned about the centrality of Luneta in the Filipinos
political life. The questions raised by the commission foretell the new
regimes subsequent use of Luneta as the center of national celebrations
and the site of Rizals monument.
Questions Raised
Where was he shot?
Bagumbayan, Luneta
Rizal showed a great deal of selfpossession
Questions Raised
Was there a large crowd present?
Enormous
Spanish National Fiesta
La Marcha de Cadiz
Questions Raised
Was he the only man shot on that
occasion?
Questions Raised
And was that done?
All executions were done by
Spanish soldiers except that
one of Rizal
Questions Raised
Were executions generally made in
Luneta?
Always
Questions Raised
Did they make it an occasion of
rejoicing?
Spanish people went there
believing that it was a just act
Carrying of justice
Questions Raised
Was it habitual for the ladies and
gentlemen to go to see all these
executions, or only occasionally?
Yes, in political executions
Quezon disagreed
Worcesters Conclusion
From annotations of Morga and Rizal
Slavery did exist and continues to exist in the Philippines
Rizals Argument
The type of slavery practiced in Europe and Spain does not
and never did exist in the Philippines, and that it was the
Spanish chroniclers and missionaries who pinned the label
of slavery on certain social practices in the Philippines
that they did not fully understand, and which were not
identical to those practiced in Europe.
Quezons Rebuttal
Published in New York Evening Post
Since there is not, and there never was, slavery in the
territory inhabited by the Christian Filipinos, which is part
of the Islands subject to the legislative control of the
Assembly, this house has refused to concur in the antislavery bill passed by the Philippine Commission
Worcester
Whom will the American public believe, Morga, the
historian; and Rizal, the Filipino patriot, or Quezon, the
Filipino Politician?
He had dramatically shown Rizals uses for the American
regime:
To discredit Filipino nationalists who upheld the aims of
the Revolution or advocate independence. Quezon did
not fit into this mold.
Uses of Rizal
Negation of national independence and revolution
Downgrading of the Spanish colonial heritage and the
affirmation of American institutions and values
Schumacher (1991)
Taft Commission
Second Philippine Commission
Established by William McKinley on March 16, 1900
Legislative and Executive Arm
William Howard Taft
Replaced the Military government that controlled Philippines
since August 1899
Americanized Rizal
Tangible Effect of the American Colonization
American sponsorship and the enthusiastic Filipino Elite.
Act No.
Duty-free entry of all
materials necessary for
construction of the Rizal
monument.
Rizal Day
December 21 1906
February 1, 1902
American Holidays
February 22
July 4
Thanksgiving day
Philippine Legislature
American Colonial Regime
and the Filipino Elite
Philippine Assembly later
called the Philippine
Legislature
1907
However...
Macario Sakay
- Filipino general
- took part in the 1896 Philippine
Revolution against the Spanish Empire
and in the Philippine-American War
- Executed after he surrendered (on
account of a promised amnesty that the
government did not honor)