Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 727

Course:

Research Methodology
( MGT 602)

Introduction
Overview of the course :
Business research is an organized and deliberate
process through which organization effectively learn
new knowledge and help improve performance.

Business Research Scenarios


A. A manager observes that the customers are not pleased
Are my customers satisfied from my product/service ?
B. It is observed that hydro construction projects tend to
have a low successes rate.
What could be reasons behind it. ?
C. The new product introduced is not doing so well.
Have we selected the right market, features or price ?
For all the above scenarios management needs to find
reliable and creditable information to understand the issue
and then take appropriate decisions in order to achieve
performance

Information
Reduces
Uncertainty

I dont know
if we
should
reduce our
product prices?

Define Business Research


Business research is defined as the systematic and
objective process of gathering, recording and
analyzing data for aid in making business decisions.
Research information is neither intuitive nor
haphazardly gathered.
Literally, research (re-search) -search again
Business research must be objective
Detached and impersonal rather than biased
It facilitates the managerial decision process for all
aspects of a business

Research Methods
Is the way in which research studies are
designs
procedures
by which data is collected are analyzed.
We would be focusing on the survey methodology
in which the research is conducted by collecting
data and analyzing them to come up with answers
to various issues of interest.
The different areas of problem could be related to
Finance, Accounting, HR, Marketing etc.

Types of Research
Two purpose of research are
To solve a currently exiting problem in the work
setting
(Applied Research )
To add to the general body of knowledge
(Basic Research)

Applied research is when research is done with the


intention of applying the results of its findings to
solving specific problem currently being experienced
in the organization
e.g.
To improve the attendance at an X organization
A transport service can be introduced, Has
flextime improve the employee performance at a
university)

Basic research done mainly to improve our


understanding of certain problems that are
commonly occur in organizational setting and how to
solve them
e.g.
increase the productivity of clerical workers in
service industry,
increase the effectiveness of project oriented
business

Research Philosophy and Choices

Important assumptions about the way in which one


views the world.
These assumptions effect the research strategy and
the methods you choose and practical
considerations.
Researcher concerned with facts, such as the
resources needed for manufacturing will have
different view on the way research

Researcher concerned with the feelings and attitudes


of the workers towards their managers in that same
manufacturing process.
Their strategies and methods probably will differ
considerably and what is important and significant

Philosophy of Choices
Deductive
Develop a theory and hypothesis (or hypotheses)
and design a research strategy to test the
hypothesis
Inductive
Collect data and develop theory as a result of your
data analysis

Characteristics of Good Research


Purposive: Definite aim (Help reduce turnover,
absenteeism, complete projects on time )
Rigor: Sound methodological design, systematic and
scientific. Avoid individual biases. (Manager
interviews few employee on their preference for flexi
time and device policy)
Testability: After properly selecting the
cases/respondents and collection of data logically
developed hypothesis statements can be tested
using statistical tests.

Replicability: Applying the same method the finding


from more than one study suggest the same results.
Precision and Confidence: Study of the whole
universe of item, events or population of interest is
not possible. But we try to come close to reality as
possible (precision)and also be confident of our
findings that they are correct (confidence).
Objectivity: The interpretation of the results should
be based on facts, not on our own subjective feeling

Generalizability: Applicability of the finding on a


variety of firms/organization
Parsimony: Simplicity in explaining the phenomena is
preferred, rather than managing many factors and
their effect (45% variability is explained by 4
variables and 48% variability is explained by 10
variables)
Management and Behavioral science result are not
100% scientific or exact. We deal with measuring
subjective feelings , attitudes, perceptions. Meeting
all the characteristics of good research is difficult

Hypothetic-Deductive Method of Research


1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.

Observation
Preliminary Information gathering
Theory formulation
Hypothesizing
Further data collection
Data Analysis
Deduction

Observation
One senses certain changes are occurring
New behaviors are surfacing in an environment
When one considers the situation important then
move to the next step
E.g. Customers are not pleased as they used to be.
Are customers at the store are grumbling or
complaining.

Preliminary Information Gathering


Know more about what has been observed
Talk to more people about it( other employees,
customers)
Know what is happening is happening and why.
E.g. Talk to customers if they are happy with the
product or service. The customer might be happy
with the products but the problem is that the
required products are out of stock and sales
person are not helpful. The salesman input on this
issues reveals that the factory does not deliver on
time so in order to satisfy the customer the
salesmen communicates different delivery dates.

Hypothesizing
Some testable or educated supposition are made
E.g.
If sufficient inventory is made customers would
be less dissatisfied customers
Accurate and timely information of the delivery to
the sales person can also reduce the dissatisfied
customer.

Further Scientific Data Collection


Data with respect to each variable in the hypothesis
need to be obtained.
E.g.
Measure the current level of customer satisfaction
and measure the satisfaction level when the stocks
are made readily available.
Measure the current level of accuracy of
information to sales person on the stock and the
satisfaction level of customer and then measure
them again once the level of information has
increased.

Data Analysis
Data gathered statistically is analyzed and see if the
hypothesis have been supported or not.
E.g.
Do an correlation analysis of the tow factors
like level of information and satisfaction.

Deduction
Arriving at a conclusion by interpreting the meaning
of the results of the data analysis.
E.g.
If the customer satisfaction has increase by certain
amount when the availability of information and
the stock.
We could recommend that these two factors
influence the satisfaction of the customers

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 2

Research Process Steps


1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.

Observation
Preliminary Data collation
Problem definition
Theoretical Framework(variables identification)
Generation of Hypothesis
Research Design
Data Collection & Interpretation
Deduction
Report writing (or other wise)

The Research Process for Applied and Basic


Research
Step 1 to 5 are part of the process to identify the
Broad Problem Area, literature review, problem statement,
conceptual framework and the hypothesis generation.
Step 6 and 7 are part of the design which involves planning of
the actual study , location, how to select sample, collect data,
and analyze data.
Step 8 and 9 denote the final deductions from the hypotheses
testing.
If all hypothesis are substantiated and research questions
are fully answered we would try to find different ways to
solve the problem.
If not all hypotheses not support we try to examine the
reasons for this

Broad Problem Area


Identify the broad problem area( observation / focus)
The broad problem area refers to the entire situation
where one sees as a possible need for research and
problem solving e.g.
Training programs are perhaps are not effective as were
anticipated.
An increase in the dis-satisfaction of Customers
Minority groups not making career progress

Broad Problem Area (cont..)


The specific issue might not be very clear.
The issue could pertain to
Problems currently existing in an organization
Areas where the managers believes can have
improvements
For better understanding of a Phenomena
Some empirically research is needed.

Example(s):
Current existing problem: (The removal is essential as it can
effect the routine operations of the organization)
People are not regularly attending their work.

Require Improvement: (The situation needs to enhanced to


ensure a better performance of the organization)
People might come but do not always show a 100% commitment to
their work

Conceptual Issue: (Define the concept, performance)


What is performance (org performance / Employee performance
.
How to measure )

Empirical: (Test empirically )


Attendance and performance related.

Broad Problem Areas


Flexi
Time

Career
progress

Management
of complex
project

Attendance

Sales

Preliminary Information Collection


The broad problem area is narrowed down to specific
issues for investigation after some preliminary
information gathering.
This may take the forms of interviews and library
research
i.e. we try understand the problem in more detail and
and develop a theory in which we try to illustrate the
possible variables that might influence the problem.

Nature of preliminary information collected


The preliminary information collected can be collected
from
Background info of the org/secondary information
Prevailing Knowledge on the Topic

Background Info of the org/secondary Info

Before conducting the first interview


Origin and history of the company -Size
Charter
- Resources
Charter
- Financial position etc
For example information gathered on the financial status of
organization can help identify if the organization cash flow are
bad that might indicate a high rate of return of the products.
This information could be used to gather further information
and discussion while interviewing .

We need to use good judgment as to what kind of


preliminary data is needed
Main idea is to identify the real problems
After the interviewing the researcher needs to tabulate
the various types of information and determine if there
are any patterns to the responses.

Prevailing Knowledge on the Topic


Certain factors are frequently mentioned e.g. untrained
personnel , un safe work environment etc
This gives the researcher a good idea about how to
proceed to the next step of surveying the prevailing
knowledge on the topic through literature review
The literature can help see how other have perceived
these factors in other work settings.

Literature Survey

Literature survey is the documentation of a


comprehensive review of the published and unpublished
work from secondary sources of data in the area of
specific interest to the researcher.
Library, books, WWW, magazines, conference
proceedings, thesis, government publications, and
financial reports.

Why have Literature Survey


A good literature survey ensures that:
Distinction between symptoms and real problem
Important variables are identified
Develop theoretical framework and hypothesis
Problem statement can be made with more precision.
Avoid in reinventing the wheel.
Recognition in the scientific community

Conducting the literature Survey


1. Identify the relevant sources
2. Extracting the relevant information
3. Writing up the literature review

Relevant source
Bibliographic database (article name, date, author..)
Abstract Database (all above + summary)
Full

Evaluating the Literature


Searching might exhibit hundreds of articles and books
Careful selection is needed
We need to find (A)Relevance (B) Quality of the
literature
(A) Relevance
Titles of articles/books
Abstracts of an article

Overview of the purpose


General research plan
Findings
Conclusion

Introduction in an article
Overview of the problem addressed
Specific research objectives
Ends with the summary research questions

Table of contents in a book

Quality
You need to ask
Is the research question / problem clearly stated
Does this study build on previous research
Used appropriate quantitative and qualitative tool etc.

You need to also check if it has been published in good journal


i.e peer reviewed , impact factor

Extracting the Relevant Information


From the articles extract these following information
Problem
Variables
Sample
Data collection
Data analysis
Results
Conclusion

Writing up the literature Review


Documenting of relevant studies citing the author and
the year of the study is called literature review.
Reference key studies , Reference books and article
which are latest
The literature survey is a clear presentation of relevant
research work done thus far in the area of
investigation.
All relevant information should be in a coherent and
logical manner instead of chronological manner

Writing up the literature Review(Cont..)


Introduce the subject (Importance + Purpose of the study
+ define the key concepts)
Identify the major research literature and the gaps
Finally discuss the variables and their relationship to
help you to formulate your frame work and hypothesis.
Article Effects of Flexi Time on Employee Attendance
and Performance

Examples of Bibliography and References


(APA)
Lehsin, C. B. (1997). Management on the World wide
Web. Engle wood Cliff, Prentice Hall.
More examples on pg 61

Referencing and Quotation in Literature review


Todd (1998) has show
In 1997, Kyle compared the dual careers and dual
Perter Drucker (1986) staff work should be limited to
few tasks of high priority.
More examples on page 64

Defining Problem Statement


After interviews and literature review the researcher are
in better position to narrow down the problem from the
broad problem area to more specific problem.
A problem statement is a clear, precise statement of the
specific issue that research intends to address.
A problem could be an interest in a issues where finding
the right answer might help to improve the existing
situation.
We need to be care full that we do not define Symptoms
as problems

Symptom Problem v.s. Real Problem


Symptom Problem: Low Productivity
Real Problem : Low moral
Solution to Symptom is increase in piece rate
Solution to Real Problem : Recognition

Examples of Well defined Problem Statements


To what extent has the new advertising campaign been
successful in creating a high quality , customer centered
corporate image?
How has new packaging affected the sales of the
product?
How do price and quality rate on consumers evaluation?
Does better automation lead to greater investment ?

Example of Broad Problem Area, Lit Review, Problem


Statement.

Broad Problem Area: Low productivity of employee.


Lit Review: faulty machines, low pay rate, low moral
Problem Statement: Is the low moral of employee at
plant x the cause of low productivity?

Exercise
Identify the Broad Problem area, define the problem,
and how would you proceed further.
Pioneers minivans and pickup take a big share of the
truck market , while its cars lag behind those of its
competitors. Quality issues like faulty electrical system,
and head lights are a major concern to the management.

Summary
Identify the first three steps in the research process
Identification of the broad problem area
Preliminary information gathering through interviews and
literature survey
Problem definition

APA format of referencing


Next lecture we would cover the next two steps of the
research process
Framework
Hypotheses

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 3

Purpose of Literature Review


Every research study requires the researcher to
review pertinent literature on the topic.
1. To avoid unnecessary duplication of research.
2. To identify variables that may influence the
problem
3. To identify promising procedures and
instruments
4. To limit the problem.

Two steps in conduction literature review


Survey of literature (search)
Documenting of the literature (write)

Survey of literature
Survey different sources
Books
Research Articles
Theses
Conference preceding
You can obtain them from
Libraries
Internet
Online databases (Full text, abstract)

Documenting the literature


Three activities are involved while
documenting the literature which you have
surveyed
Method of documenting the list of reviewed
articles. (Modes)
Referencing and quoting the studies (Cite)
Organizing and documenting the contents of the
reviewed articles (writing the review)

Method of documenting the list of


reviewed articles.
References / Bibliography is a list of work that is
relevant to the main topic arranged in an
alphabetical order.
The difference between reference list and
bibliography is that reference list is a subset of
the list of articles which have been referenced in
the research.
Bibliography is a list which includes all the
referenced and non referenced articles in your
research but are relevant to your research

Examples of Modes of Reference listing


There are different modes of referencing in business
research. For example the APA (Publication of Manual
of the American Psychological Association), Chicago
Manual Style, Harvard style, Turabian Style.
Each manual specifies with examples how books,
newspaper, research journal are to be referenced in
your research. Following are the example in APA style

Referencing and quoting the studies


Cite the references in the body of the paper
using author-year method of citation; i.e.
surname of author(s) and the year of
publications
E.g. Kaleem(2004) has shown.
In the recent studies of employee motivation
(Freeman,2007 ;Mitnzberg, 2007) it has
In 1997, Kyle compared the different models of
motivation..
As pointed out by (Tucker & Snell, 1989),..

Referencing and quoting the studies


(cont )

Organizing and documenting the


contents of the reviewed articles
While writing the review the text needs to arranged
in the following manner
1. Introduction -

Importance of the subject ,


states the purpose or scope of the review
2. Define the key concepts
What are the different definitions found in the
literature. Which definition is better or much closer
your research objective.

Organization of a Literature
Review:
3. Critical review Describe the relationships between the different
variables identified in the previous studies

Do not list one study after another, but rather


classify, compare & contrast as they relate to your
problem statement.
Organize the review around different themes.

4. Summarize
states the status of what exists on the topic and
identifies the gaps which provide the rationale for
your study.

Example of a short Review


Pg 44

Example of a short review


Introduction to Organization effectiveness
Identified the problem and the purpose
No consensus on the how to conceptualize
and measure OE
Summarize the previous work and identify the
gaps in the literature
Variables from different streams related to the
OE uncovered
Leading to the forming of the research
questions

Questions
What could be the dimensions used for
measuring OE ?
What factors effect the OE ?
Once the research questions have been stated
then one is ready to develop a theoretical frame
work of their research

While developing your theoretical frame work


you basically
Theorize on the bases of your belief that how
are certain phenomena's are related.
So theoretical framework is a representation of
your beliefs on how certain phenomena ( or
variables or concepts ) are related to each
other(model) and an explanation of why you
believe that these are associated with each
other (theory)

Theoretical Framework
So there are two components to theoretical
frame work
Identification of variables and their
relationship
Describing the relationship with arguments
While identifying the different variables we need
to differentiate between the different kinds of
variables

Variables
Any thing that can take on different or varying
values is a variable
Values can be different at various times for the
same object or person or at the same time for
different objects or persons E.g.
Production units (Employee 1 (10 units on Monday) Production
units (Employee 1 (11 units on Tuesday)
Production units (Employee 2 (12 units on Monday)
Production units (Employee 2 (10 units on Tuesday)
Attendance at department x on Monday(10), Tuesday(2)

Types of Variables

Independent
Dependent
Moderating
Mediating

Types of Variables
Dependent
(Criterion Variable)
primary interest
Describe or explain the variability or predict it.
We study what variables influence dependent
variable
So by studying these we might able to find a
solution of the problem
E.g. Sales are low , employee loyalty is
dropping

Independent
(Predictor variable)
Which influences the dependent variable
The influence might be positive or negative
When independent variable is present the
dependent variable is also present.
With each unit of increase in independent
variable there is an increase or decrease in
the dependent variable
E.g. Advertising on sales, recognition on
loyalty

Moderating (surfaces in between the


independent and dependent at a given time)
Mediating (Effects the relationship between
independent and dependent)

Exercise : List the independent variable


A manager believes that good supervision and
training would increase the production level of
the workers.

Recap
Literature Review involves searching and
documenting
There are different formats of Documenting
(APA)
There is a structure of review (importance,
objectives, definitions, relationships identified,
gaps)
Theoretical framework is representation of your
belief on how variables related and why
Variables are of 4 different kinds

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 4
(Theoretical Framework)

Recap
Literature Review involves searching and
documenting
There are different formats of Documenting
(APA)
There is a structure of review (importance,
objectives, definitions, relationships identified,
gaps)
Theoretical framework is representation of your
belief on how variables related and why
Variables are of 4 different kinds

Theoretical Framework
After conducting literature review, survey and
defining the problem (research questions)
We develop our theoretical framework
Theoretical framework is a conceptual model of how
we theorarize the relationships among several
factors that have been identified to the problem.
Problem is depleting sales
Factors influencing are quality of products, price,
competition etc ( based on the literature)

Based on the previous literature we discuss the


interrelationship between the different variables
which are of interest to us and concerns the
problem.
By developing this kind of conceptual framework
would help us claim and test certain relationships.
i.e. From this framework we develop hypothesis
statements which are then tested to find out if our
theory was valid or not

Quality
Price

Competition

Sales

Types of Variables
Dependent
(Criterion Variable)
primary interest
Describe or explain the variability or predict it.
We study what variables influence dependent
variable
So by studying these we might able to find a
solution of the problem
E.g. Sales are low , employee loyalty is
dropping

Independent
(Predictor variable)
Which influences the dependent variable
The influence might be positive or negative
When independent variable is present the
dependent variable is also present.
With each unit of increase in independent
variable there is an increase or decrease in
the dependent variable
E.g. Advertising on sales, recognition on
loyalty

Exercise : List the independent variable


A manager believes that good supervision and
training would increase the production level of
the workers.

Moderating Variables
Moderating Variables have strong contingent
(conditional) effect on the independent dependent
variables relationship.
i.e. in the presences of the a third variable the
relationship between the independent and
dependent is modified

Distinction between Independent and


Moderating Variable

Some times one gets confused as to when a variable


is to be treated as independent variable and when it
becomes a moderating variable

Situation A

Quality of
Training
Programs
Growth
Need of
employee

Willingness to
learn new ways

Situation B

Willingness
to learn
new ways

Quality of
Training Prog
High/Low

Growth
Need

Both the scenarios have 3 variables


First scenario training programs and growth
needs are independent variables that
influence the dependent variable
Second scenario dependent variable stays the
same growth need becomes the moderating
variables

i.e. only those who have high growth need will


become more willing to learn new things
when quality of the trainings is increased.
Hence the relationship between dependent
and independent variable become contingent
(conditional) on the existence of the
moderator.

The linear effect of training and growth need on


willingness

The effect of training is contingent on high/low growth


need (slope/intensity)

Mediating/Intervening
A variable which surfaces between the time the
independent variable operates to influence the
dependent variable.
Temporal /sequential quality
Surfaces as a function of the independent variable

Exam diff

Exam
Performance

Exam
Difficulty

Stress

Exam
Performance

Workforce
Diversity

Organization
Effectiveness

Integrating Moderating, Mediating Variables

Theoretical Framework
Is a conceptual model
Foundation of the research
Logically developed, described and elaborated
network of association as a result of interviews,
observation and literature survey.

So we identify a problem
Identify the important variables from literature etc.
Logically developing network of associations and elaborate
Generate hypotheses and later tested

Components of Theoretical Framework


Identification of variables ( name and type)
Discussion how and why these variables are related
Direction of the relationship need to be theorized
and discussed (positive/negative)
Discussion on why these relationships exists, support
from previous research.
A schematic diagram
Note: Must read example on page 93

Recap
Types of Variables
Independent, Dependent, Moderating, Mediating(
Intervening)

Examples of their relationships with each


other
Developing of Theoretical Framework
Variables, logical Relationships, Directions,
Explanations

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 5

(Theoretical Framework - Hypothesis Development)

Recap
Types of Variables
Independent, Dependent, Moderating, Mediating(
Intervening)

Examples of relationships with each other


Developing of Theoretical Framework
Variables, logical Relationships, Directions,
Explanations

We wanted to break down a problem into


easily measurable into testable cases.

Exercise
A production manager is concerned about the low
output levels of his employee. The articles that he
reads on job performance frequently mentioned
three variables as important to job performance: skill
required by job, rewards and satisfaction. In several
of the articles it was also indicated that only if the
rewards were attractive to the recipients, did
satisfaction, and job performance increase not
otherwise.

Theoretical Framework
( Description and Discussion of the Variables)
In this section of theoretical framework we need to
provide the description of the variables and their
relationships with different variables. For example..
Rewards are two types, intrinsic and extrinsic ..,
where as job enrichment is making the job more
challenging and utilizes all the skills of the
employeewhen the.. . Rewards are known to
enhance the satisfaction of employees which leads to
higher organization performance But for some
employees the rewards are not attractive hence does
not contribute to the satisfaction of employee .etc

Theoretical Framework
(Schematic Diagram)
Job
Enrichment
Employee
Satisfaction
Rewards
Attraction
for
rewards

Organization
Performance

Research Questions
Does job enrichment and rewards influence the
performance ?
Does the satisfaction intervenes the relationship
between rewards and performance?
Does the satisfaction intervenes the relationship
between job enrichment and performance?
Does attractiveness of the rewards moderate the
relationship between rewards and satisfaction.

Hypotheses Development
The research problem could be better solved when
we formulate the appropriate research questions.
The logically placed relationships need to be tested.
So we develop statements which would be easily
testable
Formulating such testable statements is called
hypothesis development.

Hypothesis Statements
A hypothesis can be defined as a logically speculated
relationship between two or more variables
expressed in the form of a test able statement.
Different Hypotheses statements can be drawn from
the theoretical framework developed earlier.
E.g.
Ha1: Job Enrichment leads to higher job satisfaction
Ha2: If rewards are offered the job satisfaction level be high
Ha3: Organization performance is effected by job enrichment
through satisfaction

The logical relationships have been now stated in a


testable format.
We need to statistically examine the relationship
between the variables Rewards and satisfaction
or Job Enrichment and Satisfaction
We need to also statistically establish that the
satisfaction mediates the relationship between
rewards , job enrichment and organization
performance

We need to statistically see if there is positive


correlation between these variables is significant
(large enough) then we would state that the
hypotheses have been substantiated(proved)
In social sciences we call a relationship statistically
significant when we are confident that 95 times out
of 100, the observed relationship will hold true.

It is through data analysis our logical relationships


are tested.
In case our hypothesis are not proved then we would
search for possible reasons. May be some other
variables which influence the relationship e.g. some
moderating variables.
It is again the literature which can provide us with
the directions. Hence a good literature review is
important.

Hypotheses Statement Formats


Hypotheses statements could be to test
Difference between groups
Relationship between variables

The statements could be in the shape of


Proposition (suggestion)
If-then Else statement

Theses statements could be direction or non


directional

Examples of different formats of Hypotheses


statements
Difference between groups
There is difference between the motivation level of men
and women

Relationship between variables


There is a relationship between age and job satisfaction

Proposition style
Employees who are more healthy will take sick leaves less
frequently

If-then else style


If employees are more healthy, then they will take sick
leave less frequently

Directional
The greater the stress experienced on the job , the lower
the job satisfaction of the employees
The motivation level of women is more then motivation
level of men
The age and job satisfaction are negatively related

Non Directional
There is a relations between stress and job satisfaction
There is a difference between motivation level of men and
women.

The way the statements are formulated is dependent


on the state of the research.
When little support from the previous research is
available then a more guarded approach is used to
form the hypothesis statements.
i.e. the direction of the relationship or the statement
on the clear differences are avoided.
But where ever direction is known from the previous
literature it is better to state the directional
hypotheses.

Null and Alternative Hypotheses


Null hypothesis is a proposition that states a definite,
exact relationship between two variables. i.e. it
states that the population correlation between two
variables is equal to zero or some definite number or
the difference between the two groups is zero
The alternative hypothesis is the opposite of the null
hypothesis. It is a statement expressing a relationship
between two variables or indicating difference
between groups.

Null is stated as no significant relationship between


the variables or no significant difference between
the groups exists.
Alternate is stated as there is a significant
relationship between variables or significant
difference exists between the groups.

The null hypotheses are formed with the objective of


rejection.
As when we reject the null hypothesis then all other
alternate hypotheses can be supported.

It is the theory which gives us the faith that the


alternative hypotheses are true.
Therefore we need to have strong literature support
for developing our theory on which are alternate
hypothesis are based

Exercise

A fourth and fifth hypothesis can be developed that is


HA4: Motivation mediates the relationship between need for
achievement and job involvement
HA5: Motivation mediates the relationship between work
ethic values and job involvement

RECAP
Keeping in view the literature review we develop
research questions to address the research problem.
In order statistically respond to the research
questions we develop the Hypotheses statements.
These statements are stated in such way that they
can be easily testable
Hypotheses statement are written in directional, non
directional formats for testing group differences,
relationship between variables.
We develop null and alternate hypotheses

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 6
(Hypothesis Development)

Recap
We learned to develop Hypotheses
statements
Directional ,non Directions
Relationship or Group Difference type
Null and Alternate statements

Statistical Notations
When testing the group differences we need to
Obtain the Mean of the focus variable by each group.
Example:
Mean Motivation Level of a group is obtained and it
is denoted by
(Motivation of a group)
We need to compare the Mean Motivation Level of
Men vs Women
(Motivation-Men) Vs (Motivation-Women)

First we state our Null Hypothesis


i.e. There is no difference between the mean
motivational level of men vs the mean motivation of
women
So the for the Null Hypothesis we use the following
notations
Ho: (Motivation-Men) - (Motivation-Women)=0

Based on the prior knowledge/ literature we can


develop different types of variables
So the for the possible Alternative Hypothesis we
have one of the following statements and its
notations
(a) The mean motivational level of men more then
mean motivation of women
Ha: (Motivation-Men) > (Motivation-Women)

(b) The mean motivational level of men is less then


mean motivation of women
Ha: (Motivation-Men) < (Motivation-Women)
(c) There is no difference between the mean
motivational level of men vs the mean motivation
of women
Ha: (Motivation-Men) (Motivation-Women)

When testing the relationship between two variables


We find the Correlation between the two variables
It is denoted by
Either >0 <0 =0
For the Null Hypothesis statement we state that
There is no relationship between stress and
satisfaction

Ho: =0

Based on the available literature we can have


different alternate statements
The possible Alternative Hypothesis we can have
notations
(a)There is a positive relationship between stress and
job satisfaction.
Ha: >0

(b) There is a negative relationship between stress


and job satisfaction.
Ha: <0
(c) i.e. The is a relationship between stress and job
satisfaction
Ha: 0

Summarized Table of Statistical Notations for


Hypotheses
Relationship

Group Difference

Ho:

Ha:

Ho:

Ha:

Directional

=0

>0
OR
<0

a=b

a>b
OR
a<b

Non-Directional

=0

#0

a=b

a # b

Example 1:

In this example we identified that workforce diversity


is transformed into creative synergy which leads to
organizational effectiveness. We also said that the
synergy would be possible when the organization
have experienced managers to handle diverse
workforce.
Based on this information we just develop the
hypothesis statements

Ha1: The workforce diversity is related to creative


synergy.
Ha2: The higher the creative synergy the more the
organization effectiveness
Ha3: The creative synergy mediates the relationship
between workforce diversity and organization
effectiveness.
Ha4: The relationship between workforce diversity
and creative synergy is moderated by managerial
expertise.

Example:2

Different Hypotheses statements could be generated


Ha1:The more the loyalty the higher the organization
commitment
Ha2:Loyality acts as an intervening variable between
job level, age, length of service, pride of working for
the organization.
Ha2.1: Loyalty mediates the relationship between age and
organization commitment
Ha2.2: Loyalty mediates the relationship between length
of service and organization commitment

Ha2.3: Loyalty mediates the relationship between job level


and organization commitment.
Ha2.4: Loyalty mediates the relationship between pride
working for organization and organization commitment.

Ha3.: Only employees who do not have lust for job


hopping, would job level, age, length of service, pride
working for organization be related to Loyalty for the
organization .
Ha3.1: Lust for job hopping would moderate the relationship
between job level and Loyalty.
Ha3.2: Lust for job hopping would moderate the relationship
between age and Loyalty.
Ha3.2: Lust for job hopping would moderate the relationship
between length of service and Loyalty.
Etc

An other research question might be poised


Does the blue collar worker are more loyal or white
collar ?
To find the answer to this question a hypothesis
statement could be generated as follows
Ha4: There is difference between the loyalty level between
the blue collar workers(labor) and white collar
workers(officers)

Steps Following the Hypothesis testing

State the null and the Alternate hypotheses


Choose appropriate test based on the data collected
(parametric like Pearson correlation, t test, ANOVA)
non parametric like spearman s rank correlation,
Kendalls X2)
Determine the level of significance desired
Usually set to 0.05 can be more or less

See the output results of generated from the


software. See if the differences are significant or the
relationship significant.
If the differences/relationship are not significant
then we accept the null hypotheses other wise
accept the alternate
In case the you are using tables check if the
calculated values larger than the critical value, the
null hypotheses is rejected and alternate accepted
( More practice would be covered in later sections of the course)

Deductive and Inductive Hypothesis


The hypothesis generating and testing can be done
both through Deduction and Induction.
In deduction we first develop the theoretical model,
then generate hypothesis statements, data is
collected and then hypothesis are tested.
In induction new hypothesis are generated based on
the data already collected, which then is tested

In the initial session we discussed the case of the


Hawthorne experiments, where new hypothesis
were developed after the data already collected did
not substantiated any of the original hypotheses.
New Hypotheses might be developed after the data
is collected.
Creative insights might compel researchers to test a
new hypothesis from exiting data which when
substantiated would add to new knowledge and help
build theory.

Hypothesis testing with Qualitative Research:


negative case analysis
Hypothesis testing can also be tested with qualitative
data.
Example:
After interview we develop the theoretical
framework that unethical practices by employees are
a function of their ability to discriminate between
right and wrong, or due to need for money, or the
organization indifference to such practices.
Search for data prove the hypothesis to be false

When no support is found an there is this case where


an individual is deliberately engage in the unethical
practices even though he is able to discriminate from
right from wrong, and is not in need for money, and
the organization would not be indifferent to his
behavior.
He simply wants to get back to the systems because
the system would not listen to his advice.
This new discovery is different from the previous
hypothesis is know as negative case method and
enables to revise their theory.

RECAP

Hypothesis notations
Examples on how to develop hypothesis statements
Steps to test the hypothesis statements
Hypothesis testing through inductive method
Hypothesis testing with qualitative research

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 7
(Research Design)

RECAP
Hypotheses statements are stated in such way that
they can be easily testable
Hypotheses statement are written in directional, non
directional formats for testing group differences,
relationship between variables.
We develop null and alternate hypotheses
We now want to design the research in such a way
that the data can obtained and analyzed in away that
we arrive at a solution
2

Elements of Research Design


Refers to the outline, plan, or strategy specifying the
procedure to be used in answering research
questions
It encompasses many issues.
We need to decide on the different choices.

To decide for any given situation


the type of investigation needed,
the study setting,
the extent of researcher interference,
the unit of analysis,
the time horizon of the study
To identify whether a casual or a correlation study
would be more appropriate in a given situation
4

The Research Design


Purpose of the
study

Exploratory
Description
Hypotheses
Testing

Types of
Investigation

Establishing:
-Casual
relationship
- Correlation's
- Group
difference
ranks, etc.

Extent of
Researcher
interference

Minimal: studying
events as they
normally occur
Manipulation

Study setting

contrived
non-contrived

Measurement
& Measures

Operational
Definition
scaling
categorizing
coding

1. Feel for
data

2.Goofiness
of data
Units of analysis
(population to be
studied)

individuals
dyads
groups
organizations
\machines
etc

Sampling
design

Time horizon

Data collection
method
3. Hypothesis
Testing

Probability/
Non-probability
Sample size (n)

one-shot
(cross-sectional)
Longitudinal

Observation
Interview
Questionnaire
Physical
measurement
Un-obstructive

THE PURPOSE OF THE STUDY


Studies can be either exploratory in nature, or
descriptive, or they can be conducted to test
hypotheses.
The nature of the study - whether it is exploratory,
descriptive or hypothesis testing - depends on the
stage to which knowledge about the research topic
has advanced.

The Case Studies, which is an examination of studies


done in similar organizational situations, is also a
method of solving problems, or for understanding
phenomena of interest and generating additional
knowledge in that area.

Exploratory Study
Exploratory studies are undertaken to better
comprehend the nature of the problem, since very
few studies might have been conducted in that area.
Extensive interviews with many people might have to
be undertaken to get handle on the situation and to
understand the phenomena.
After obtaining a better understanding, more
rigorous research proceed.

Some qualitative studies (as opposed to quantitative


data gathered through questionnaire, etc.) where
data are collected through observation or interviews,
are exploratory studies in nature.
When the data reveals some pattern regarding the
phenomena of interest, theories are developed and
hypotheses formulated for subsequent testing.

Example: Managers of firm wants to explore the nature


of managerial work (Mitnizberg in 1970)
Based on the analysis of his interview data, he
formulated theories of managerial roles, the nature
and types of managerial activities, and so on.

10

Example : What is the role of virtual markets for e commerce ? (in 2005)
The recent development of the internet and the busy
life style of the people in the west, lots of the
individuals are showing interests in accessing
internet .

11

Descriptive Study:
A descriptive study is under taken in order to
ascertain and be able to describe the characteristics
of the variables of interest in a situation.
For instance a study of class in terms of the
percentage of members who are in their senior and
junior years, gender composition, age groupings,
number of semesters until graduation, and number
of business courses taken, can only be considered as
descriptive in nature
12

Descriptive studies that present data in a meaningful


form help to:
1. Understand the characteristics of a group in a
given situation.
2. Think systematically about aspects in a given
situation.
3. Offer ideas for further probe and research
4. Help make certain simple decisions (such as how
many and what type of individuals should be
transferred from one department to another
13

Example:
A bank manager wants to have a profile of the
individuals who have loan payments outstanding for
six months and more. It would include details of their
average age, earnings, type of occupation they are
in, full time/part time employment status, and the
like.
This information might help to ask for further
information or make an immediate decision on the
types of individuals to whom he would not extend
loans in future.

14

Example:
The ministry of science and technology wants to
know how many projects have failed, what were the
reasons. Out of the triple constraints (cost, time,
scope) how many failed due to scope constraint.
The information received can help tighten the scope
definition process at the MOST technology projects.

15

Hypotheses Testing:
Hypothesis testing is undertaken to explain the
variance in the dependent variable or to predict
organizational outcomes.
Similar to the kind of examples we had discussed in
the theoretical framework chapter

16

Example:
A Marketing manager would like to know the sales
of the company will increase if he doubles the
advertising dollars.
Here, the manager wants to know the nature of the
relationship between advertising and sales that can
be established by testing the hypothesis:

17

H0: There is no relationship between sales and


advertisement
Ha: If advertising is increased, then sales will also
increase
Ho: =0
Ha: >0

18

Example: The manager of a manufacturing firm


believes that the voluntary turn over is more of with
its female employees. The manager would like to
test the difference between the turnover rates of
male and female.

19

Ho: There is no difference between the turn over


rate of men and women
Ha: There is a difference between the turn over rate
of men and women
Ho:turn-over-men = turn-over-men
Ha:turn-over-men turn-over-men
20

So exploratory studies are focused on understanding


the characteristics of a phenomenon of interest.
A pilot study on small scale interviewing individuals is
done. ( What is an internet club)
A Descriptive study is when characteristics of the
phenomenon are known and we want to describe it
better ( How many internet clubs are in the city,
how many are open for 24 hrs etc)
A hypothesis testing is when we try test certain
theories. (Internet clubs have a cased a decline in the
social values )
21

Types of Investigation: Causal versus


Correlation
When the researcher wants to define the cause of
one or more problems, then the study is called a
Causal Study.
When the researcher is interested in outline the
important variables that are associated with the
problem, it is called a Correlational Study.

22

Example:
A causal study question:
Does smoking cause cancer?
A correlational question:
Are smoking, chewing tobacco related to cancer ?
A causal study hypothesis:
Smoking causes cancer.
A correlational hypothesis:
Smoking and cancer are related
Chewing and cancer are related
23

Extent of Researcher Interference with the


Study
The extent to which the researcher interferes with
the normal flow of work at the workplace has direct
bearing on whether the study undertaken is casual or
correlational.
A correlational study is conducted in the natural
environment of the organization, with the researcher
interfering minimally with the normal flow of work.

24

For example,
if a researcher wants to study the factors
influencing training effectiveness
(a correlational study),
the individual simply has to develop a
theoretical framework, collect the relevant
data, and analyze them to come up with the
findings.
25

Although there is some disruption to the normal flow


of work in the system as the researcher interviews
employees and administers questionnaire at the
workplace, the researchers interference in the
system is minimal compared with that in causal
studies.

26

In case of causal study the researcher would try to


manipulate certain variables so as to study the effect
on the dependent variable
Example.
Effect of lighting on employee performance
The researcher's interfere is high

27

Recap
We covered some of the research design elements
We talked about the research purpose
(exploratory, descriptive, hypothesis testing)

Type of investigation
(causal, correlations)

Extent of researcher's interference


(High,moderate,low)

28

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 8
(Research Design-continue)

Recap
We covered some of the research design elements
We talked about the research purpose
(exploratory, descriptive, hypothesis testing)

Type of investigation
(causal, correlations)

Extent of researcher's interference


(High,moderate,low)

Study Setting: Contrived and Non-contrived


Organizational research can be done in the natural
environment where work proceeds normally (i.e., in
non-contrived setting) or in artificial, contrived
settings.
Correlation studies are invariably conducted in noncontrived settings, whereas rigorous causal studies
are done in contrived lab setting

Correlation studies done in organizations are called


field studies
( factors influencing in a call center its employees
turn over ).

Studies to establish cause and effect relationships


using the same natural environment in which
employees normally function are called field
experiments
Example:
employees who have been given recognition and
employee who have not been given recognition.

Cause effect studies in contrived environment in


which The environment extraneous factors are
controlled are termed as lab experiments.

Example:
Select all new employees with the same scores in the
entry test and provide one group training and the
other no training and controlling that they are not
exposed to any senior employee who could guide
them.)

Unit of Analysis: Individuals, Dyads, Groups,


Organizations, Cultures
The unit of analysis refers to the level of aggregation
of the data collected during the subsequent data
analysis stages.

Individuals: If the problem statement focuses on how


to raise the motivational levels of employees in
general, then we are interested in individual
employees in the organization and would like to find
out what we can do to raise their motivation.

Here the unit of analysis is the individual.(managers


perception on the factors which influence the
success of the project)

Dyads: If the researcher is interested in studying twoperson interactions, then several two-person groups,
is known as dyads and will become unit of analysis.

For example, analysis of husband-wife(are they


satisfied with the education provided by the school)
in families and mentor-mentee (perception on the
benefit of mentoring).

Groups: If the problem statement is related to group


effectiveness, however, then obviously the unit of
analysis would be at group level.

For example, if we wish to study group decisionmaking patterns, we would probably examining such
aspects as group size, group structure, cohesiveness,
and the like, in trying to explain the variance in group
decision making.
In such cases the unit of analysis will be groups.(use
of I.T by the different department)

Organizations: If we compare different departments


in the organization, then the data analysis will be
done at the departmental level - that is, the
individuals in the department will be treated as one
unit and comparison made treating the department
as the unit of analysis.
(Conservation of energy initiatives by public and
private organization)

Cultures: If we want to study cultural differences


among nations, we will have to collect data from
different countries and study the underlying patterns
of culture in each country, here the unit of analysis
used will be cultures.
(Moral values of Eastern vs Western cultures)

Time Horizon: Cross-sectional versus Longitudinal


Cross-Sectional Studies
A study can be done in which data are gathered just
once, perhaps over a period of days or weeks or
months, in order to answer a research question. Such
studies are called one-shot or cross-sectional studies.
(data collected from project managers and their
psychological well being between October till
December)

Longitudinal Studies
In some cases, the researcher might want to
study people or phenomena at more than one
point in time in order to answer the research
question. For example, the researcher might
want to study employees behavior before and
after a change in the top management, to
learn the effects of change.

Or when data on the dependent variable are


gathered at two or more points in time to answer the
research question, are called longitudinal studies.
(use of electricity by a city in summers and then in
winters)

Scenarios
Following are some scenarios , for each indicate how
researcher should proceed, giving reasons:
1. Purpose of the study
2. Type of investigation
3. Researcher Interference
4. Study setting
5. Time Horizon
6. Unit of analysis

Recap
Research Design elements
Study setting
Time Horizon
Unit of analysis
Secnarios

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 9
(Measurement of Variables/Operational Definition)

Recap
Research Design elements
Study setting
Time Horizon
Unit of analysis

Measurement of Variables
In order to find answers to our question and in order
to test our hypothesis we need measure our
variables of concern.

Why the need for measuring


To test the hypothesis the variables need to
measured.
Finding the answers to our questions is possible
when we have some statistics/ numbers .
Some variables are easily measurable e.g. Height,
salary, hours worked.
Some are not so easily measured motivation level,
success level of projects, satisfaction, loyalty etc.

Questions like
1. How long have you been working in this
organization?
2. What is your marital status ?
3. How much is your salary ?
4. What was the cost of last project ?
But some variables are abstract and subjective e.g.
satisfaction, happiness, achievement motivation,
effectiveness of the organization.
5

One cannot simply ask what is the achievement


motivation level of your employees.
But before we start measuring the variables its
abstractness needs to be addressed.
There are ways to in which the abstractness of the
notion could be simplified into observable
characteristics.
6

For instance Thirst cannot be seen but we expect


that a thirsty person would consume lots of liquid.
Hence the behavior of the thirsty person is that he
would drink fluids.
If several individuals say they are thirsty we can
measure thirst by measuring their consumption of
liquid, although the concept itself is abstract.
7

Reducing abstract concepts so they are measurable is


called operationalizing.
Operationally defining a concept so that it becomes
measurable is achieved by looking at the behavioral
dimensions, facets , or properties represent by the
concept.

Steps to Operationalization
one needs the define component of the
concept.
Under each concept possible quantitative
measurable elements need to identified.
Against each developed concepts specific
questions could be formulated. The questions
could be supported by secondary data,
observation or self report
9

Operational Definition

10

The operational definition of Learning could be


stated as The ability to recall the lesson, it is also
the ability apply the lesson learned to practical
situation and finally it is the understanding of a
lesson.
Even though these dimension have to an extent
reduced some of the ambiguity but we still need to
further classify what is meant by understanding,
application so that we can measure learning as a
whole.
11

With some effort we can define what is meant by


understanding , i.e. the ability to answer questions
correctly and give appropriate answers. We also
define what is application, which is the ability to
solve problem by applying the lesson learned and
integrate it with other relevant material.
Now we are in better position to measure the
concept learning.
At this stage we can develop questions which
address the synthesized concepts and obtain data
on them.

12

13

14

15

16

17

What is not operational definition


It does not define the correlates of a concept
i.e. motivation and performance are two separate
concepts and they might be correlated we cannot
substitute one with the other
Motivation can lead to performance but we do not
measure performance by motivation.
We need to differentiate between the reasons
(factors/antecedents) with dimensions.
Dimensions are the sub components of a concept
and factors/ antecedents the causes of the concept
18

We operationally define concepts and ask questions


that are likely to measure the concept.
So for abstract concepts we need to define the
subjective feelings and attitudes.
For straight forward variables , objective data is used
such as salary, number of tee shirts.
A number of subjective concepts have been
opertionalized by the subject experts and we can use
them for research.
19

Recap
Measurement is necessary to give answers or to the
research question , or to test our hypotheses.
The opeationalizing of certain subjective variables
are necessary for measurement.
The abstract concepts are broken down to
dimensions and its elements.
Questions are formulated on them
Not to confuse dimensions with antecedents

20

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 10
(Measurement of Variables/Scales)

Recap
Measurement is necessary to give answers or to the
research question , or to test our hypotheses.
The opeationalizing of certain subjective variables
are necessary for measurement.
The abstract concepts are broken down to
dimensions and its elements.
Questions are formulated on them
Not to confuse dimensions with antecedents

Scales and Measurement


We have operationalized the concepts and converted
them into dimensions and elements
We also have attached questions with these
elements against which we would collect some data.
Each question needs to measured

Measurement is the process of assigning numbers or


labels to objects, persons, states of nature, or events.
Done according to set of rules that reflect qualities or
quantities of what is being measured.

Measurement means that scales are used.


Scales are a set of symbols or numbers, assigned by
rule to individuals, their behaviors, or attributes
associated with them

Types of Scales
Four types of scales are used in research, each with
specific applications and properties. The scales are
Nominal
Ordinal
Interval
Ratio

Nominal Scale:
Simply the Nominal scale is count of the objects
belonging to different categories.
Ordinal Scale:
The ordinal scale positions objects in some order
( such as it indicates that pineapples are juicer then
apples and oranges are even more juicer than
pineapples)
7

Interval Scale:
It can gives us information as to what extent(level)
one is juicer than the other.
How much better is the pineapple than the apple
and orange is better than the pine apple.
Is pine apple only marginally better than the apple .
Ratio Scale:
It is most comprehensive scale, has all characteristics
of other scales.

Nominal Scales
Nominal scales are used to classify objects,
individuals, groups, or even phenomena.
Examples of nominal variables:
Gender
State of residence
Country
Ethnicity

Nominal scales are mutually exclusive


(meaning that those items being classified will fit
into one classification).
These scales are also collectively exhaustive,
(meaning that every element being classified can fit
into the scale).

10

As it might appear on a questionnaire, examples of


nominally scaled questions included:
What is your class rank at CIIT?
1.Freshman 3. Junior
2.Sophomore 4. Senior

11

The numbers themselves do not have meaning


(we could have used letters, too),
They are used just to identify the possible
responses to the question.
Thus, in evaluating responses to this you cannot
use the mean.
Permitted statistics; frequencies (% and counts,
modes )
12

Nominal scale is always used for obtaining personal


data such as gender or department in which one
works, where grouping of individuals or objects is
useful, as shown below.
1. Your gender
___Male
___Female

2. Your department
___Production
___Sales
___Accounting
___Finance
___Personnel
___R & D
___Other (specify)
13

Ordinal Scales
These scales allow for labeling (or categorization) as
in nominal scales, but they also allow for ranking.
Example: Rate these vacation destinations in terms
of how much you would like to visit from one to five
with one your most preferred and five your least
preferred.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Bermuda
Florida
Hawaii
Aspen
London
14

This type of scale can provide information about


some item having more or less of an attribute than
others, but no information on the degree of this.
Permitted statistics: Frequencies, median, mode

15

Ordinal scale is used to rank the preferences or usage


of various brands of a product by the individuals and
to ranks order individuals, objects, or events as per
the examples below.

16

Rank the following personnel computers with respect


their usage in your office, assigning the number 1 to
the most used system, 2 to the next most used, and
so on. If a particular system is not used at all, in your
office, put a 0 next to it.
____Apple
____Compaq
____Comp USA
____Dell Computer
____Gateway

____Hewlett Packard
____IBM
____Packard Bell
____Sony
____Toshiba

17

Interval Scales
Contains the information available in ordinal scales
(ranking) but with the added benefit of magnitude of
ranking.
Interval scales have equal distances between the
points of a scale.
These scales can contain a zero point, but they are
subjective and are not meaningful (0 C = 32 F).
Temperature is an example of a interval scale
Permitted statistics; mean, median, mode, as well as
more advanced tests.
18

On a scale of one to five, with five meaning you strongly


agree, and one meaning you strongly disagree consider this
statement I believe my college education has prepared me
well to begin my career.

1
Strongly
disagree

9/28/2015

Somewh
at
disagree

Neither

Somewhat
agree

Strongly
agree

19

Ratio Scale
The most comprehensive scale
Has all of the characteristics of the other three with
the additional benefit of an absolute, meaningful
zero point.
Examples include:
Weight
Sales volume
Income
Age
Permitted statistics same as with interval data.

20

A ratio variable, has all the properties of an interval


variable, and also has a clear definition of 0.0. When
the variable equals 0.0, there is none of that variable.
Variables like height, weight, enzyme activity are
ratio variables.

21

Temperature, expressed in F or C, is not a ratio


variable. A temperature of 0.0 on either of those
scales does not mean 'no temperature'.
However, temperature in Kelvin is a ratio variable, as
0.0 Kelvin really does mean 'no temperature'.

22

Ratio scales are usually used in organization


research when exact numbers on objective as
opposed to subjective factors are called for, as in
the following question:
How many other organizations did you work for
before Date joining this system?

9/28/2015

23

Please indicate the number of children you have in


each of the following categories?
---- below 3 years
---- between 3 and 6
---- over 6 years but under 12
---- 12 years and over
How many retail outlets do you operate?

24

Comparison between scales


The researcher would like to know what is the
percentage of people who like Pepsi, 7up, Coke,
Miranda?
Choose the soft Drink you want to order.
Pepsi
7Up
Coke
Marinda

25

The researcher would like to know among the 4 soft


dinks which they prefer the most ,assigning 1 to most
and 4 to the least
Pepsi
7Up
Coke
Marinda

26

The researcher would like to know what extent the 4


drinks are liked
On a scale of one to five, with five meaning you
strongly like, and one meaning you strongly dislike
consider this statement I like/dislike this soft drink .
Pepsi
1 2 3 4 5
Coke
1 2 3 4 5
7up
1 2 3 4 5
Marinda 1 2 3 4 5
27

The researcher would like to know how many


Pepsi , Mrindia , etc you consume in a month
Pepsi: _____
7Up:
_____
Coke:
_____
Marinda:_____

28

29

Balanced or Unbalanced
How good a car is Honda?
Very bad
Bad
Neither good nor bad
Good
Very good

Poor
Fair
Good
Very good
Excellent

30

Forced or Unforced Choices


How good a car is Honda?
Very bad
Bad
Neither good nor bad
Good
Very good

Very bad
Bad
Neither good nor bad
Good
Very good
No opinion
Dont know
31

Rating Scales

32

Simple Category (Dichotomous) Scale

I plan to purchase a laptop in the 12 months.


Yes
No

33

Multiple-Choice, Single Response Scale

What newspaper do you read most often for financial news?


East City Gazette
West City Tribune
Regional newspaper
National newspaper
Other (specify:_____________)

34

Multiple-Choice, Multiple Response Scale

What sources did you use when designing your new home?
Please check all that apply.
Online planning services
Magazines
Independent contractor/builder
Designer
Architect
Other (specify:_____________)

35

Likert Scale

The Internet is superior to traditional libraries for


comprehensive searches.
Strongly disagree
Disagree
Neither agree nor disagree
Agree
Strongly agree

36

Semantic Differential

A measure of attitudes that consists of a series of seven-point rating


scales that use bipolar adjectives to anchor the beginning and end of
each scale.

37

Numerical Scale

An attitude rating scale similar to a semantic differential except that it uses


numbers, instead of verbal descriptions, as response options to identify
response positions.

38

Stapel Scales

A measure of attitudes that consists of a single adjective in the center of


an even number of numerical values.
39

Constant-Sum Scales

A measure of attitudes in which respondents are asked to divide a constant


sum to indicate the relative importance of attributes; respondents often sort
cards, but the task may also be a rating task.

40

Graphic Rating Scales

A measure of attitude that allows respondents to rate an object by choosing any


point along a graphic continuum.

41

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 11
(Goodness Of Measures)

Recap
Measurement is the process of assigning numbers or
labels to objects, persons, states of nature, or events.
Scales are a set of symbols or numbers, assigned by
rule to individuals, their behaviors, or attributes
associated with them

Using these scales we complete the development of


our instrument.
It is to bee seen if these instruments accurately and
measure the concept.

Sources of Measurement Differences


Why do scores vary? Among the reasons legitimate
differences, are differences due to error (systematic or
random)
1. That there is a true difference in what is being
measured.
2. That there are differences in stable characteristics of
individual respondents
On satisfaction measures, there are systematic
differences in response based on the age of the
respondent.
9/28/2015

3.Differences due to short term personal factors mood


swings, fatigue, time constraints, or other transistory
factors.
Example telephone survey of same person, difference
may be due to these factors (tired versus refreshed)
may cause differences in measurement.
4.Differences due to situational factors calling when
someone may be distracted by something versus full
attention.
9/28/2015

5.Differences resulting from variations in


administering the survey voice inflection, non
verbal communication, etc.
Differences due to the sampling of items included in
the questionnaire.

7. Differences due to a lack of clarity in measurement


instrument
(measurement instrument error).
Example; unclear or ambiguous questions.
8. Differences due to mechanical or instrument factors
blurred questionnaires, bad phone connections.
9/28/2015

Goodness of Measure
Once we have operationalized, and assigned scales
we want to make sure that these instruments
developed measure the concept accurately and
appropriately.
Measure what is suppose to be measured
Measure as well as possible

9/28/2015

Validity : checks as to how well an instrument that is


developed measured the concept
Reliability: checks how consistently an instrument
measures

10

11

Ways to Check for Reliability


How to check for reliability of measurement instruments
or the stability of measures and internal consistency
of measures?
Two methods are discussed to check the stability .
1. Stability
(a) Test Retest
Use the same instrument, administer the test
shortly after the first time, taking measurement in
as close to the original conditions as possible, to
the same participants.
9/28/2015

12

If there are few differences in scores between the


two tests, then the instrument is stable. The
instrument has shown test-retest reliability.
Problems with this approach.
Difficult to get cooperation a second time
Respondents may have learned from the first
test, and thus responses are altered
Other factors may be present to alter results
(environment, etc.)

13

(b) Equivalent Form Reliability


This approach attempts to overcome some of the
problems associated with the test-retest
measurement of reliability.
Two questionnaires, designed to measure the same
thing, are administered to the same group on two
separate occasions (recommended interval is two
weeks).
9/28/2015

14

If the scores obtained from these tests are


correlated, then the instruments have equivalent
form reliability.
Tough to create two distinct forms that are
equivalent.
An impractical method (as with test-retest) and
not used often in applied research.

15

(2)Internal Consistency Reliability


This is a test of the consistency of respondents
answer to all the items in a measure . The items
should hang together as a set.
i.e. the items are independent measures of the
same concept, they will correlated with one another

9/28/2015

16

Developing questions on the Concept Enriched Job

Validity
Definition: Whether what was intended to be
measured was actually measured?

9/28/2015

18

Face Validity
The weakest form of validity
Researcher simply looks at the measurement
instrument and concludes that it will measure what
is intended.
Thus it is by definition subjective.

9/28/2015

19

Content Validity
The degree to which the instrument items represent
the universe of the concepts under study.
In English: did the measurement instrument cover all
aspects of the topic at hand?

9/28/2015

20

Criterion Related Validity


The degree to which the measurement instrument
can predict a variable known as the criterion
variable.

9/28/2015

21

Two subcategories of criterion related validity


Predictive Validity
Is the ability of the test or measure to differentiate
among individuals with reference to a future
criterion.
E.g. an instrument which is suppose to measure
the aptitude of an individual, when used can be
compared with the future job performance of a
different individual. Good performance (Actual)
should also have scored high in the aptitude test
and vise versa
22

Concurrent Validity
Is established when the scale discriminates
individuals who are known to be different that is
they should score differently on the test.
E.g. individuals who are happy at availing welfare
and individuals who prefer to do job must score
differently on a scale/ instrument which measures
work ethics.

Construct Validity
Does the measurement conform to some underlying
theoretical expectations. If so then the measure has
construct validity.
i.e. If we are measuring consumer attitudes about
product purchases then do the measure adhere to
the constructs of consumer behavior theory.
This is the territory of academic researchers

9/28/2015

24

Two approaches are used to measure construct


validity
Convergent Validity
A high degree of correlation among 2 different
measures intended to measure same construct
Discriminant Validity
The degree of low correlation among varaibles
that are assumed to be different.

9/28/2015

25

To check validity through Correlation analysis, Factor


Analysis, Multi trait , Multi matrix correlation etc

26

Reflective vs Formative measure scales:


In some multi item measure where it is measuring
different dimensions of a concept do not hang
together
Such is the case of Job Description Index measure
which measures job satisfaction from 5 different
dimension i.e Regular Promotions, Fairly good
chance for promotion, Income adequate, Highly
Paid, good opportunity for accomplishment.
27

In this case some items of dimensions Income


adequate and Highly paid to be correlated but
dimension items of Opportunity for Advancement
and Highly Paid might not correlated.
In this measure not all the items would related to
each other as its dimensions address different
aspect of job satisfaction.
This measure /scale is termed as Formative scale

28

In some cases the measure dimensions and items


correlate.
In this kind of measure/scale the different
dimensions share a common basis ( common
interest)
An example is of a scale on Attitude towards the
Offer scale.
Since the items are all focused on the price of an
item, all the items are related hence this scale is
termed as Reflective Scale.
29

Recap

30

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 12
(Data Collection-Interview)

Recap

Primary Data
Primary Data = information obtained exclusively for
current research
Personal Interview
Focus Groups
Panels
Delphi Technique
Telephone Interview Computer assisted telephone
interviewing and Computer administered telephone
survey
Self-Administered Surveys

Secondary Data
Company Archives
Gov Publications
Industry Analysis

Primary Data Collection Methods

Focus Group
Panels
Interviews (face to face, telephone, electronic media)
Questionnaires (personally, mail, electronic)
Observation
Other (projective tests)

Focus Group:
Usually consist of 8 to 10 members , with a
moderator leading the discussion for 2 hours on a
particular topic, concept or product.
Member are chosen on the bases of their expertise
on the topic.
E.g Discussion on computers and computing , or
women mothers , social networking etc
Less expensive and usually done for exploratory
information. Cannot be generalized
6

Panels:
Similar to focus group but meets more than once in
order to study the change or interventions need to
be studies over a period of time.
Members are randomly chosen
E.g effect of advertisement of a certain brand need
to be assessed quickly, panel members could be
exposed to the advertisement and intention of
purchase could be assessed.
When the product is modified then the response of
the panel can be observed

Observation measures:
Methods through which primary data is collected
without the involving people.
E.g: Wear and tear of books , section of an office,
seating area of railway station which indicate the
popularity, frequency of use etc.
E.g: The number of cans in the dust bin and their
brands, the number of motor cycles vs cars parked in
the university parking lot
8

Interviewing:
Collect data from the respondent on an issue of
interest.
Usually administered at the exploratory stage of
the research.
In case large set of respondents are needed then
more than one interviewer are used , hence they
need to be trained so that biases , voice
inflections, difference in wording are avoided
Structured and Unstructured

Un Structured:
No planned sequence of questions, help in exploring
preliminary issues.
e.g. Tell me something about your unit and department
, and perhaps even the organization as a whole in
terms of work, employee and whatever else you
think is important
Compared to other departments, what are the
strengths and weakness of your department
10

In case they identify a difference you can ask


How can you improve the situation ?
Encouraging the respondent to reflect on the positive
and negative aspects of it.
Try to pleasant and see if the respondent is not
comfortable.

11

Through unstructured the different major areas


might be exposed. It from these the researcher can
pick some areas as focus variables which need
further probing.
Now the researcher can device a more focused
approach and develop a more structured interview
emphasizing on some particular issues.

12

Structured:
Know at the outset what information is needed.
Focusing on factors relevant to the problem.
The focus is on the factors which have surfaced
during the un structured interview.

13

E.g: During the previous unstructured interview it


was identified that the department needs
improvement.
Now you can focus on questions which addresses
how to improve the department, i.e. the factors
which can improve the department

14

This can be done through face to face, over the


telephone or through the computers via internet.
Specific same questions are asked from different
respondents.
The information collected is tabulated and then the
data is analyzed.

15

The result could highlight the important factors


influencing the issues.
This information is of qualitative in nature which
could be then empirically tested and verified using
other methods like questionnaires.

16

Guideline for Interviews

Listen carefully
Motivate the respondents
How to take notes
Built proper trust and rapport with interviewee
Clarification of complex issues
Physical setting
Explaining the reasons for research and criteria of
selection

Face to Face
Adv :Clarify doubts, repeating, rephrasing, getting
non verbal cues
Dis : vast resources required, cost, anonymity

Telephone:
Adv : Wider reach in short time, some time easy to
discuss personal information over the phone
Dis: Can be terminated without warning, cannot have
a prolonged interview, non verbal cue.

19

Closed vs. Open Questions


Easy.
Cost of coding is reduced.
Quicker, standardized interviews.
Can be answered without thinking.
Pre-testing is a must.
Limit the richness of data.

Recap
The Data is collected from primary and secondary
sources
The primary data collect via
Observation, panels, interviews, questionnaires etc
Interview are structure and unstructured
While interviewing there are certain guidelines
There are structured and unstructed interviews
There are some advantages / disadvantages of face
to face vs telephone interviews .
21

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 13
(Data Collection-Questionnaire)

Recap
The Data is collected from primary and secondary
sources
The primary data collect via
Observation, panels, interviews, questionnaires etc
Interview are structure and unstructured
While interviewing there are certain guidelines
There are structured and unstructed interviews
There are some advantages / disadvantages of face
to face vs telephone interviews .
2

Questionnaires
Data Collection is mechanism when the
researcher knows exactly what is required and
how to measure the variables of interest.
Types of Questionnaire:

Personally administered questionnaire


Mail Questionnaire

Personally Administered Questionnaires


Mostly local area based, org is willing to have a group
of employee respond to it.
It is Cheaper then interviews, helps remove doubts,
motivating respondents

Mail Questionnaires:
Wide geographical area can be reached, respondents
have flexibility of time , It is more cost effective but
the response rate is low,
Can improve by giving some incentives and doubts
cannot be clarified.

Guidelines for Principles

Content and purpose of question (Subjective/Objective)


Language and wording( Jargon/ Technical)
Type and Form (open ended, closed ended)
Positively and Negatively Worded
Biases ( loaded, leading, social desirable, double barreled)
Sequencing of Questions

Content and purpose of Question:


If the variables tapped are subjective feeling we
need to measure the dimension and elements ..
Use interval scales
If the variables are objectives/ facts a single
direct question may be asked.

Language and Wording of question:


The level of respondents have to be considered.
Slang and Technical jargon has to be avoided
e.g. Work is a drag, she is a compulsive worker. Tech
Jargon like organizational structure , 360 degree
appraisal

Type and Form of Questions:


Open ended vs Closed Ended
Positively vs Negatively Worded

Open ended vs Closed Ended


In open ended the respondent chooses any way they
like. E.g. any five things which interest him at his job.
In close ended the respondent have to make a
choice among the given alternatives e.g. out of the
list of 10 job characteristics rank any 5

Positively vs Negatively Worded :


Have some positive and some negative worded
questions to break the monotony.
E.g. Coming to work is great fun or coming to work is
no great fun

Biases in Questions:
Double Barreled:
Questions has more than one question within it.
E.g. Do you think that the course content is
adequate and it applicable at your work?

Ambiguous Question:
Respondent does not know what it means. E.g. To what
extent would you say you are happy?
Do you discuss you work with your boss regularly? Do
you go to movies frequently?
Frequently may mean once in a week, or once in a
month. Regularly may mean every day, or every week ,
or every month.

Recall Dependent:
Questions based on past experiences and rely on
memory.
E.g. After 30 years of work one would not
remember the first job details such as name of
the boss/ years worked in a department

Leading Questions:
Are worded in such a way that it would lead the
respondent to answer in a way that the
researcher would like to or want to give.
E.g. Dont you think that in these days of
escalating costs of living employee should be
given good pay raise?
Better.. To what extent do you agree that
employee should be given higher pay raise.

Example:
Dont you think that more women should be
promoted to decision making line positions in
organization

Loaded Questions:
Are when they are phrased in an emotionally
charged manner.
E.g. To what extent do you think management is
likely to be vindictive/(cruel) if the union decides to
go on strike.
Better. To what extent you favor strike To what
extent you fear that there would be a adverse
reaction from the management.

Did P.T.I Lose the elections in Punjab


Better P.T.I was not chosen in Punjab

Social Desirability:
Is when questions are worded such that they
elicit(draw out) socially desirable response
e.g. Do you think that older people should be laid off?
..better
There are advantages and disadvantages to retaining
senior citizens in the workforce. To what extent do you
think companies should continue to keep the elderly
on their payroll.

Exercise
If you have been in the company for fifteen years
please indicate the year of joining or the name of you
colleague.
Bad question as it is recall dependent

My colleague is good and efficient .


Bad Question: Double Barreled

Working Women should not have children.


Bad: Loaded question an emotional issue for women

Investment in children's future should be an


important goal of the administration.
Bad Question: Socially desirability

This job uses a lot of skills I have.


Okay no problem with the wordings

For this country to keep on remaining competitive


should we not spend more on research.
Bad: Leading question

Other Guide lines


Length (20 words)
Sequencing (funneling , same positive and
negative question)
Classification Data or Personal Data

Recap

Questionnaires
Personally Administered Questionnaires
Mail questionnaires
Guide line for wordings

Content and purpose (Subjective vs Objective)


Language and wording ( slang/technical)
Types of formats (open / closed ended)
Positively worded and Negatively worded
Bias/ Favoritism(Leading, loaded, ambiguous, double
barrel, socially desirable)

Length of the question


Funneling

Research Methodology

Lecture No :14
(Sampling Design)

Sampling
The process of selecting the right individuals,
objects, or events as representative of entire
population is known as sampling.
Population

Sample

Relationship between sample and


population

Reasons for Sampling


Budget and time Constraints (in case of large
populations)
High degree of accuracy and reliability (if sample
is representative of population)
Sampling may sometimes produce more
accurate results than taking a census as in the
latter, there are more risks for making
interviewer and other errors due to the high
volume of persons contacted and the number of
census takers, some of whom may not be welltrained

Population
It refers to the entire group of people, events or
things of interest that the researcher wishes to
investigate.
Example: If regulators want to know how patients
in nursing homes run by a company in France are
cared for, then all the patients in all the nursing
homes run by them will from the population.

Element
An element is a single member of a population
Example: If 1000 blue collar workers(labor
workers) in a particular organization happen to be
the population of interest to a researcher, each
blue collar worker therein is an element.

Sample
A sample is a subset or subgroup of the
population. By studying the sample, the researcher
should be able to draw conclusions that are
generalizable to the population of interest.
Example: If there are 145 in-patients in a hospital
and 40 of them are to be surveyed by the hospital
administrator to access their level of satisfaction
with the treatment received, then these 40
members will be the sample.

Sampling unit
It is the element or set of elements that is available
for selection in some stage of sampling process.
Example: Sampling units in a multistage sample
are city blocks, households, and individuals within
the households.

Subject
It is a single member of the sample, just as an
element is a single member of the population.
Example: If a sample of 50 machines from a total
of 500 machines is to inspected, then everyone of
the 50 machines is a subject, just as every single
machine in the population of total population of
500 machines is an element

Parameters
The characteristics of the population such as the
population mean, the population standard
deviation, and the population variance are referred
to as its parameters.
Example: Average weight, , of all 30 year old
women in Australia, % of voters, p, in N.S.W who
think the Government is doing a good job to
control inflation.

The Sampling Process


Sampling is the process of selecting a sufficient
number of right elements from the population so,
the major steps in the sampling include.
1. Defining the population
2. Determine the sample process
3. Determine the sampling design
4. Determine the appropriate sample size
5. Execute the sampling process

The Sampling Process

Defining the population


Sampling begins with precisely defining the target
population. The target population must be defined
in terms of elements, geographical boundaries and
time.
Example: A target population may be, for example,
all faculty members in the Department of
Management Sciences in the V-COMSATS
network,
All housewives in Islamabad,
All pre-college students in Rawalpindi,

The target group should be clearly defined if


possible, for example, do all pre-college
students include only primary and secondary
students or also students in other specialized
educational institutions?

Determining the sample frame


The sampling frame is a (physical) representation
of all the elements in the population from which he
sample is drawn. Also termed as a List.
Often, the list does not include the entire
population. The discrepancy is often a source of
error associated with the selection of the sample
(sampling frame error)
Information relating to sampling frames can be
obtained from commercial organizations

Example: Student telephone directory (for the


student population), the list of companies on the
stock exchange, the directory of medical doctors
and specialists, the yellow pages (for businesses)

Determining the sample design


Two major types of sampling
Probability sampling
The elements in the population have some known,
non zero chances or probability of being selected
as sample subjects.
Non probability sampling
The elements do not have a known or
predetermined chance of being selected as
subjects.

Factors affecting sampling design


The relevant target population of focus to the
study
The parameters
investigating

we

are

interested

in

The kind of sample frame is available


Costs and Time are attached to the sample
design and collection of Data

Determining the sample size


The decision about the how large the sample size
should be can be very difficult one. These factors
affecting the sampling decision are
The research objective
The extent of precision desired(the confidence
interval)
The acceptance risk in predicting that level of
precision(confidence level)
The amount of variability in the population itself
The cost and time constraints
In some cases, the size of population itself

Executing the sample process


In this final stage of sampling process, decision
with respect to the
the target population,
the sampling frame,
the sample technique, and
the sample size have to be implemented.

Example:

A young researcher was investigating the


antecedents of salesperson performance.

To examine his hypotheses, data were collected


from the chief sales executive in the Pakistan
(the target population) via mail questionnaire.

The sample was initially drawn from the


published business register (the sampling
frame), but supplemented with respondent
recommendations and other additions, in a
judgment sampling methodology.
The questionnaires were subsequently
distributed to sales executives of 450 companies
(the sample size).

Non response and non response errors


A failure to obtain information from a number of
subjects included in the sample
Those who do respond to your survey are
different from those who did not on (one of the)
characteristics of interest in your study
Two important sources of non response errors
are not at homes and refusals

Reducing the rate of refusals


The rate of refusals depends, among other
things, on the length of the survey, the data
collection method and the backing of research.
Decrease
in
survey
length,
personal
interviews/questionnaire
instead
of
mail
questionnaire and the sponsorship of the
research often improve the overall return rate.

Recap
Sampling is the process of selecting the right
individuals
Sample is used to represent the whole data or
population
Sampling process include defining population,
sample frame, sampling design, sample size
and sampling process

Research Methodology

Lecture No :15
(Sampling Design / Probability vs Non probility)

Probability Sampling
Unrestricted or simple random sampling
Technique which ensures that each element in
the population has an equal chance of being
selected for the sample.
The simple random sampling is the least bias
and offer the most generalizability.

Probability Sampling
The major advantage
sampling is its simplicity.

of

The
sampling
process
cumbersome and expensive.

simple

random

could

become

Example: Choosing raffle tickets from a drum,


computer-generated
selections,
random-digit
telephone dialing.

Simple random sampling

Probability Sampling
Restricted or complex probability sampling:
It is an alternate to simple random sampling
design, several complex probability sampling
designs can be used.
Efficiency is improved in that more information
can be obtained for a given sample size using
the complex probability sampling procedures.

Probability Sampling
The most common complex probability sampling
design
1. Systematic sampling
2. Stratified sampling
3. Cluster sampling
1.

Area sampling

4. Double sampling

Probability Sampling
Systematic Sampling:
Technique in which an initial starting point is
selected by a random process, after which every
nth number on the list is selected to constitute
part of the sample.

Sampling interval (SI) = population list size (N)


divided by a pre-determined sample size (n)
How to draw:
1) calculate SI, say (200/20)=10
2) select a number between 1 and SI randomly, i.e. 1-10
3) go to this number as the starting point and the item on the list
here is the first in the sample, e.g 3
4) add SI to the position number of this item and the new position
will be the second sampled item, e.g 3+10=13
5) continue this process until desired sample size is reached.

For systematic sampling to work best, the list


should be random in nature and not have some
underlying systematic pattern.
E.g: Office directory with the Senior Manager,
Middle manager .names are listed in each
department. This can create as systematic
problem

Probability Sampling
Stratified Sampling:
Technique in which simple random subsamples
are drawn from within different strata that share
some common characteristic. Within the group
they are homogenous and among the group
they are heterogeneous.

Probability Sampling
Stratified Sampling
Example: The student body of CIIT is divided into
two groups (management science, engineering)
and from each group, students are selected for a
sample using simple random sampling in each of
the two groups, whereby the size of the sample for
each group is determined by that groups overall
strength.

Probability Sampling
Cluster Sampling
Technique in which the target population is first
divided into clusters. Then, a random sample of
clusters is drawn and for each selected cluster
either all the elements or a sample of elements
are included in the sample.
Cluster samples offer more heterogeneity within
groups and more homogeneity among groups

Probability Sampling
Area sampling
Specific type of cluster sampling in which clusters
consist of geographic areas such as counties, city
blocks, or particular boundaries within a locality.
Area sampling is less expensive than most other
sampling designs and it is not dependent on
sampling frame.
Key motivation in cluster sampling is cost
reduction.

Probability Sampling
Area sampling
Example: A city map showing the blocks of the city
is adequate information to allow the researcher to
take a sample of the blocks and obtain data from
the resident therein.
Example: If you wanted to survey the residents of
the city, you would get a city map, take a sample of
city blocks and select respondents within each city
block.

Probability Sampling
Single stage and multistage cluster sampling
Single stage cluster sampling involves the
division of population into convenient clusters,
randomly choosing the required number of
clusters as sample subjects, and investigating all
the elements in each of the randomly chosen
clusters
Cluster sampling can also be done in several
stages and is then known as multistage cluster
sampling.

Probability Sampling
Example: If we were to do a national survey of the
average monthly bank deposits, cluster sampling
would be used to select the urban, semi urban and
rural geographical location for study. At the next
stage particular areas in each of these locations
would be chosen. At the third stage, banks within
each area would be chosen.
Example:

Probability Sampling
Double sampling:
A sampling design where initially a sample is
used in a study to collect some preliminary
information of interest, and later a subsample of
this primary sample is use to examine the matter
in more detail.

Probability Sampling
Double sampling
Example: A structured interview might indicate that
a subgroup of respondents has more insight into
the problems of the organization. These
respondents might be interviewed again and again
and asked additional questions.

Non-Probability Sampling
Convenience Sampling:
Sampling technique which selects those
sampling units most conveniently available at a
certain point in, or over a period, of time.

Non-Probability Sampling
Convenience Sampling:
Major advantages of convenience sampling is
that is quick, convenient and economical; a
major disadvantage is that the sample may not
be representative.
Convenience sampling is best used for the
purpose
of
exploratory
research
and
supplemented subsequently with probability
sampling.

Non-Probability Sampling
Judgment (purposive) Sampling:
Sampling technique in which the business
researcher selects the sample based on
judgment about some appropriate characteristic
of the sample members.
Example: Selection of certain students who are
active in the university activities to inquire about
the sports and recreation facilities at the university.

Recap
Simple random sampling and restricted
sampling are two basic types of probability
sampling.
Probability ( Simple Random, Systematic,
Cluster,
Single
stage/multistage,
Double
sampling)
Non Probability (Convenience, judgment)

Research Methodology

Lecture No :16
( Sampling / Non Probability, Confidence and Precision, Sample size)

Recap Lecture
Systematic ,stratified sampling, cluster, area and
double sampling are the common types of
complex sampling.
Convenience, judgment, quota and snowball
sampling are the common types of non
probability sampling.

Lecture Objectives
Non Probability Based sampling (Quota/snow
ball)
Discuss about the precision and the confidence.
Precision and Confidence
Factors to be taken into consideration for
determining sample size.
Managerial implications of sampling.

Non-Probability Sampling
Quota Sampling:
This is a sampling technique in which the business
researcher ensures that certain characteristics of a
population are represented in the sample to an
extent which is he or she desires.

Non-Probability Sampling
Quota Sampling
Example: A business researcher wants to determine
through interview, the demand for Product X in a
district which is very diverse in terms of its ethnic
composition.
If the sample size is to consist of 100 units, the
number of individuals from each ethnic group
interviewed should correspond to the groups
percentage composition of the total population of that
district.

Quota Sampling

Example: Quotas have


been set for gender only.
Under
the
circumstances, its no
surprise that the sample
is representative of the
population only in terms
of gender, not in terms of
race. Interviewers are
only human;.

Non-Probability Sampling
Snowball Sampling :
This is a sampling technique in which individuals
or organizations are selected first by probability
methods, and then additional respondents are
identified based on information provided by the
first group of respondents

Non-Probability Sampling
Snowball Sampling
The advantage of snowball sampling is that smaller
sample sizes and costs are necessary; a major
disadvantage is that the second group of
respondents suggested by the first group may be
very similar and not representative of the population
with that characteristic.
Example: Through a sample of 500 individuals, 20
antique car enthusiasts are identified which, in turn,
identify a number of other antique car enthuiasts

More Snowball Sampling


More systematic versions of snowball sampling can
reduce the potential for bias. For example,
respondent-driven sampling gives financial
incentives to respondents to recruit peers.

Issues in Sample Design and Selection


Availability of Information Often information on
potential sample participants in the form of lists,
directories etc. is unavailable (especially in
developing countries) which makes some
sampling techniques (e.g. systematic sampling)
impossible to undertake.

Resources Time, money and individual or


institutional capacity are very important
considerations due to the limitation on them.
Often, these resources must be traded against
accuracy.

Issues in Sample Design and Selection


Geographical Considerations The number and
dispersion of population elements may
determine the sampling technique used (e.g.
cluster sampling).
Statistical Analysis This should be performed
only on samples which have been created
through probability sampling (i.e. not probability
sampling).
Accuracy Samples should be representative of
the target population (less accuracy is required
for exploratory research than for conclusive
research projects).

Issues of precision and confidence in


determining sample size
Precision
Precision is how close our estimate is to the true
population characteristic.
Precision is the function of the range of
variability in the sampling distribution of the
sample mean.

Population and Sample distinctiveness


Sample Statistics( Mean, Std Deviation, Variance) and
Population parameters ( Mean, Std Deviation,
Variance)
Compare the Sample estimates and population
characteristic. Where the estimates should be the
representative of the population charactertics
Sample statistics (mean, sd, ..) should be
representative of the population parameters(mean,
sd )

Issues of precision and confidence in


determining sample size
Precision:
How close are the estimates to the population.
While expecting that the population mean would it
fall between (+,- )10 points or (+,-) 5 points based
on the sample estimates is precision.
The narrower the more precise our statement is

E.g: The average age of the a particular class


based on the sample is between 20 and 25
Or it between 18 and 28.
How close are the estimates to the population.

Confidence
Confidence denotes how certain we are that our
estimate will hold true for the population.
The level of confidence can range from 0 to
100%. However 95% confidence is the
conventionally accepted for most business
research.

The more we want to be precise the less confident


we become that our statement is going to be true.
So at one level we want to be accurate in our
statement but on the other we taking a higher risk of
proved incorrect.
In order to maintain the precision and increase the
confidence or increase the precision and the
confidence we need to have a larger sample.

Determining sample size


Roscoe (1975) proposes the following rules of
thumb for determining sample size.
Sample sizes larger than 30 and less than 500
are appropriate for most research
Where sample sizes are broken into subsamples
(males/females, juniors/seniors etc.), a minimum
sample size of 30 for each category is
necessary.

Determining sample size


In multivariate research (including multiple
regression analysis), the sample size should be
several times (preferably ten times or more)
as large as the number of variables in the
study.
For simple experimental research with tight
experimental controls (matched pairs, etc.),
successful research is possible with samples as
small as 10 to 20 in size.

Tools and mathematical equations are available


to establish the right size of the sample.
Refer to the book for the sample size calculation
equation.
Standard Tables are available
Use a software like RAO calculator available on
the internet.

Types of Sampling Designs


Sampling Designs
Probability

Non-probability

Convenience

Simple
Random

Judgmental

Systematic

Quota

Stratified

Snowball

Cluster

Other Sampling
Techniques

Managerial Implications
Awareness of sampling designs and sample size
helps managers to understand why a particular
of sampling is used by researchers.
It also facilitates understanding of the cost
implications of different designs, and the trade
off between precision and confidence vis--vis
the costs.

Managerial Implications
This enables managers to understand the risk
they take in implementing changes based on the
results of the research study.
By reading journal articles, this knowledge also
helps managers to assess the generazibility of
the findings and analyze the implications of
trying out the recommendations made therein in
their own system.

Recap
Non Probability based sampling (
Precision we estimate the population parameter
to fall within a range, based on sample estimate.
Confidence is the certainty that our estimate will
hold true for the population.
Roscoe (1975) rules of thumb for determining
sample size.
Some sampling designs are more efficient than
the others.
The knowledge about sampling is used for
different managerial implications.

Research Methodology

Lecture No :17
(

Research Paper -1 and 2 )

Recap
Non Probability based sampling (
Precision we estimate the population parameter
to fall within a range, based on sample estimate.
Confidence is the certainty that our estimate will
hold true for the population.
Roscoe (1975) rules of thumb for determining
sample size.
Some sampling designs are more efficient than
the others.
The knowledge about sampling is used for
different managerial implications.

Objective
2 Research Papers
First Review Paper
Second Empirical Study

Important Information to be noted

Title
Author(s)
Year of publication
Journal of publication
Key variables ( Independent, Dependent)
Relationships between variables
Model
Hypothesis

Method
Findings
Discussions
Implications
Future Directions
References

Research Paper/ Thesis / Research Report


Deliverables of Research
While

Qualitative Paper

Research Methodology

Lecture No :18
(Experimental Design)

Recap
Difference between
Research Paper Qualitative in nature
Research paper Empirical

Objective
Experimental Design
Causal vs Correlations
Field Experiment vs Lab Experiments

When we want to find cause ?


Such as Absenteeism and Incentives.
Some give bonus days , some give cash and some
recognition.
22% of companies said that their incentive where
effective, 66% some what effective and 12% not
effective
Question is which incentives cause 22% companies
to be effective in reducing absenteeism

Causal Vs Correlation
What factor are related to decrease in sales ?
What causes the decrease in sales ?

To establish that X cases Y three conditions


need to be meet.
(A) Both X and Y should covary
(B) X should precede Y
(C) No other Variable should possibly be
causing the change in Y

Lab Experiment:
Tight Control on the confounding variables hence
higher internal validity
Manipulation of independent variable

Field Experiment:
Less control on confounding variable but good
external validity( Generalizability)
Manipulation of independent variable

Recap

Research Methodology

Lecture No :19
(Experimental Design-Cont)

Recap

Causal vs Correlation
Field Study vs Field Experiment
Control and Treatment
Confounding variables
controllable un controllable
Factors effecting Internal Validity
(History, Maturation, Testing
,selection Biases, Mortality..)

effect,

Instrument

Objective
Factors effecting External Validity
When Experimental Design is necessary
Different types of experimental Designs

When to Conduct Experimental


Design

Control Group
Experimental Group
Expose (Treatment)
Pretest score (Instrument)
Post Test Score (Instrument)
Difference

Pretest and Posttest


(Problem Instrument Effect)

Posttest
(Problem , Matching ,Mortality Effect)

Pretest and Posttest Experimental and Control Group


Randomized hence no effect of history, maturation,
testing, instrument
(Problem of Mortaility)

Different internal validity issues are taken care


of such as
Pretest and posttest of Group 2 allows to take
care of history, maturation, instrumentation,
regression.
Group 3 remove the testing effect

Recap
When to use experimental designs
Pretest and Posttest Experimental Group
Design
Posttests only with Experimental and Control
Group
Pretest and Posttest Experimental and Control
Group Design
Solomon Four Group Design

When to have lab experiments and field


experiments
Issues of internal validity
Issues of external validity
Certain experimental design counter the
effects of internal validity

Research Methodology

Lecture No :20
(User Response to an Online Information System: A Field Experiment )

Recap
Experimental Design
When to use experimental designs
Pretest and Posttest Experimental Group Design
Posttests only with Experimental and Control
Group
Pretest and Posttest Experimental and Control
Group Design
Solomon Four Group Design

Issues of internal validity


Issues of external validity
Certain experimental design counter the
effects of internal validity

Objective
Review a research article which has applied an
experimental type of methodology

Important Information to be noted while


reviewing an article

Title
Author(s)
Year of publication
Journal of publication
Key variables ( Independent, Dependent)
Relationships between variables
Model
Hypothesis

Method
Findings
Discussions
Implications
Future Directions
References

User Response to an Online Information


System: A Field Experiment
Experimental Design Research Paper
Author(s): Charles R. Franz, Daniel Robey and
Robert R. Koeblitz Source: MIS Quarterly, Vol. 10,
No. 1 (Mar., 1986), pp. 29-42
Published by: Management Information Systems
Research Center, University of Minnesota
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/248877
Accessed: 25/06/2013 07:40

Abstract

Problem / the issue

Literature support for the problem

Literature Gap

Literature Support for the Gap

Research methodology Direction

Research Objectives / Research Problem/


Research Question

Hypothesis

Null Hypothesis
1(1.1,1.2,1.3,1.4,1.5,1.6)

Null Hypothesis 2(2.1,2.2,2.3)

Field Settings

Research Design

Measures

Measurement/Scales

Results

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 21
Data Preparation and Data Entry

Recap Lecture
In the last few lectures we discussed about:
Research Design
The purpose, investigation type, researcher
interference, study setting, unit of analysis, time
horizon, Measurement of variables
Sources of Data
Sampling
Experimental Design

Lecture Objectives
Getting the data ready for analysis
Data preparation
Coding, codebook, pre-coding, coding rules
Data entry
Editing data
Data transformation

Data Preparation and Description


Data preparation includes editing, coding, and
data entry
It is the activity that ensures the accuracy of the
data and their conversion from raw form to
reduced and classified forms that are more
appropriate for analysis.
Preparing a descriptive statistic summary is
another preliminary step that allows data entry
errors to be identified and corrected.

Getting the Data Ready for Analysis


After data obtained through questionnaire, they
need to be coded, keyed in, and edited.
Outliers, inconsistencies and blank responses, if
any, have to be handled in some way.

Coding
Data coding involves assigning a number to the
participants responses so, they can be entered into
data base.
In coding, categories are the partitions of a data set
of a given variable. For instance, if the variable is
gender, the categories are male and female.
Categorization is the process of using rules to
partition a body of data.
Both closed and open questions must be coded.

Coding Cont.

Numeric coding simplifies the researchers task


in converting a nominal variable like gender to a
1 or 2.

Code Construction
There are two basic rules for code construction.
First, the coding categories should be
exhaustive, meaning that a coding category
should exist for all possible responses.
For example, household size might be coded 1,
2, 3, 4, and 5 or more.
The 5 or more category assures all subjects of
a place in a category.

Code Construction Cont.


Second, the coding categories should be
mutually exclusive and independent.
This means that there should be no overlap
among the categories to ensure that a subject or
response can be placed in only one category.

Code Construction Cont.


Missing data should also be represented with a
code.
In the good old days of computer cards, a
numeric value such as 9 or 99 was used to
represent missing data.
Today, most software will understand that either
a period or a blank response represents missing
data.

Codebook
A codebook contains each variable in the study
and specifies the application of coding rules to
the variable.
It is used by the researcher or research staff to
promote more accurate and more efficient data
entry.
It is the definitive source for locating the
positions of variables in the data file during
analysis.

Sample Codebook

Pre-coding

Pre-coding means assigning codebook codes to


variables in a study and recording them on the
questionnaire.
Or you could design the questionnaire in such a
way that apart from the respondents choice it
also indicates the appropriate code next to it.
With a pre-coded instrument, the codes for
variable categories are accessible directly from
the questionnaire.

Sample Pre-coded Instrument

Coding Open-Ended Questions

One of the primary reasons for using openended questions is that insufficient information
or lack of a hypothesis may prohibit preparing
response categories in advance. Researchers
are forced to categorize responses after the data
are collected.

Coding Open-Ended Questions Cont.

In the Figure on the next slide, question 6


illustrates the use of an open-ended question.
After
preliminary
evaluation,
response
categories were created for that item. They can
be seen in the codebook.

Coding Open-Ended Questions Cont.

Coding Rules
Appropriate to the
research problem

Exhaustive

Categories
should be

Mutually exclusive

Derived from one


classification principle

Data Entry
After responses have been coded, they can be
entered into data base.
Raw data can be entered through any software
program.
For example: SPSS Data Editor.

Data Entry Cont.


Database
Programs

Keyboarding

Digital/
Barcodes

Optical
Recognition

Voice
recognition

Editing Data
After data entered, the blank responses, if any,
have to be handled in some way, and
inconsistent data have to be checked and
followed up.
Data editing deals with detecting and correcting
illogical, inconsistent, or illegal data and
omissions in the information returned by the
participants of study.

Editing Data Cont.


Accurate

Arranged for
simplification

Consistent

Criteria

Complete

Uniformly
entered

Field Editing
Field Editing Review
Entry Gaps Callback
Validates Re-interviewing

Field Editing Review


In large projects, field editing review is a
responsibility of the field supervisor.
It should be done soon after the data have been
collected.
During the stress of data collection, data
collectors often use ad hoc abbreviations and
special symbols.

If the forms are not completed soon, the field


interviewer may not recall what the respondent
said.
Therefore, reporting forms should be reviewed
regularly.

Field Editing Cont.


Entry Gaps Callback
When entry gaps are present, a callback should
be made rather than guessing what the
respondent probably said.

Field Editing Cont.

Validates Re-interviewing
The field supervisor also validates field results
by re-interviewing some percentage of the
respondents on some questions to verify that
they have participated.
Ten percent is the typical amount used in data
validation.

Central Editing
Scale of Study Number of Editors
At this point, the data should get a thorough
editing.
For a small study, a single editor will produce
maximum consistency.
For large studies, editing tasks should be
allocated by sections.

Central Editing Cont.


Wrong Entry Replacements
Sometimes it is obvious that an entry is incorrect
and the editor may be able to detect the proper
answer by reviewing other information in the
data set.
This should only be done when the correct
answer is obvious.
If an answer given is inappropriate, the editor
can replace it with a no answer or unknown.

Central Editing Cont.

Fakery Open-ended Questions


The editor can also detect instances of armchair
interviewing, fake interviews, during this phase.
This is easiest
questions.

to

spot

with

open-ended

Central Editing Cont.


Guidelines for Editors
Be familiar with instructions given to interviewers and coders
Do not destroy the original entry

Make all editing entries identifiable and in standardized form

Initial all answers changed or supplied


Place initials and date of editing on each instrument completed

Handling Dont Know Responses


When the number of dont know (DK)
responses is low, it is not a problem. However, if
there are several given, it may mean that the
question was poorly designed, too sensitive, or
too challenging for the respondent.
The best way to deal with undesired DK answers
is to design better questions at the beginning.
If DK response is legitimate, it should be kept as
a separate reply category.

Data Transformation
Data transformation, a variation of data coding,
is a process of changing the original numerical
representation of a quantitative value to another
value.
E.g: The data given is in per year consumption
and we need it for each month.
Data are typically changed to avoid problems in
the next stage of data analysis process.

Data Transformation Cont.


For example, economists often use a logarithmic
transformation so that the data are more evenly
distributed.
Data transformation is also necessary when
several questions have been used to measure a
single concept.
E.g: Intentions to leave is measured through 10
questions which need to be transformed into a
single value for a single respondent

Recap
Questionnaire checking involves eliminating
unacceptable questionnaires.
These questionnaires may be incomplete,
instructions not followed, missing pages, past
cutoff date or respondent not qualified.
Editing looks to correct illegible, incomplete,
inconsistent and ambiguous answers.
Coding typically assigns alpha or numeric codes
to answers that do not already have them so that
statistical
techniques
can
be
applied.

Recap Cont.
Cleaning reviews data for consistencies.
Inconsistencies may arise from faulty logic, out
of range or extreme values.
Statistical adjustments applies to data that
requires weighting and scale transformations.

Research Methodology

Lecture No : 22
Introduction to SPSS

Recap
Questionnaire checking involves eliminating
unacceptable questionnaires.
Editing looks to correct illegible, incomplete,
inconsistent and ambiguous answers.
Coding typically assigns numeric codes to
answers that do not already have them so that
statistical techniques can be applied.
Some times we need to treat the missing
values.

Recap Cont.
Cleaning reviews data for consistencies.
Inconsistencies may arise from faulty logic, out
of range or extreme values.
Statistical adjustments applies to data that
requires weighting and scale transformations.

objective
How to use SPSS for Data entry
Defining variables
Assigning them values
Assigning sizes and constraints
Data entry using data from coded Questionnaires

How to generate simple descriptive


summaries

Job
Satisfaction

Intention to
Leave

Research Methodology

Lecture No :23
(Feel of the Data)

Recap Lecture
In the last lecture we discussed about:

How to use SPSS for Data entry


Defining variables
Assigning them values
Assigning sizes and constraints
Data entry using data from coded Questionnaires

How to generate simple descriptive


summaries

Lecture Objectives
Getting the feel for the data
Frequencies
Bar charts and pie charts
Histogram
Stem and leaf display
Pareto diagram
Box plot
SPSS cross tabulation

Getting a Feel for the Data


We can acquire the feel for the data by obtaining
a visual summary or by checking the central
tendency and the dispersion of the variable.
We can also get to know our data by examining
the relationship between two variables.

Getting a Feel for the Data Cont.


Getting a feel for the data is thus the necessary
first step in all data analysis.
Based on this initial feel, further detailed analysis
may be undertaken to test the goodness of the
data.

Frequencies
Frequencies simply refer to the number of times
various subcategories of a certain phenomenon
occur,
Percentage and the cumulative percentage of
their occurrence can be easily calculated.

Frequency Cont.

Frequency and Percentage


Example: Ad Recall

Bar Charts and Pie Charts


Frequencies can also be visually displayed as
bar charts, histograms, or pie charts.
Bar charts, histograms, and pie charts help us to
understand our data.

Bar Chart
In this slide, the same data are presented in the
form of a bar chart. (Nominal Data)

Pie Chart
Data may be more readily understood when
presented graphically. (Nominal Data)

Histogram
A histogram is a graphical bar chart that groups
continuous data values into equal intervals, with
one bar for each interval. (Ratio Data)

Histogram Cont.

Stem-and-Leaf Display Cont.


The stem-and-leaf display is a technique that is
closely related to the histogram. It shares some
of the histograms features but offers several
unique advantages.
(Continuous data/ Ratio scale)
In contrast to histograms, which lose information
by grouping data values into intervals, the stemand-leaf presents actual data values that can be
inspected directly, without the use of enclosed
bar or asterisks as the representation medium.

Stem-and-Leaf Display
(e.g. Annual Purchase)

Stem-and-Leaf Display Cont.


Visualization is the second advantage of stemand-leaf displays.
The range of values is apparent at a glance, and
both shape and spread impressions are
immediate. (56,56,56) concentration and spread
Patterns in the data are easily observed.
Each line or row in the display is referred to as a
stem, and each piece of information on the stem
is called a leaf.

Pareto Diagram
Pareto diagrams represent frequency data as a
bar chart, ordered from most to least, overlaid
with a line graph
(Nominal Data)
The cumulative percentage at each variable
level is shown.
The percentages sum to 100 percent.

Pareto Diagram Cont.

Pareto Diagram Cont.


The data are derived from a multiple-choicesingle-response scale,
For multiple-choice-multiple-response scale, or
frequency counts of words or themes from
content analysis. Nominal Scale but muliresponse e.g.
Which soft drinks you consume:

Coke
Mrinda
Sprite
Amrit

Obs1
x
x

obs2
x
x

obs3..Frequency
x
3
1
1
x
1

Boxplot Components
The boxplot, or box-and-whisker plot, is another
technique used frequently in exploratory data
analysis.
A boxplot reduces the detail of the stem-and-leaf
display and provides a different visual image of
the distributions location,
spread,
shape,
tail length,
outliers.

Boxplot Components Cont.


The ingredients of the plot are
The rectangular plot that encompasses 50% of
the data values.
A center line--marking the median and going
through the width of the box.
Consists of the median, the upper and lower
quartiles, and the largest and smallest
observations.

Boxplot Components Cont.

Boxplot Comparison

SPSS Cross-Tabulation
Cross-tabulation is a technique for comparing
data from two or more categorical variables
(Nominal Data).
It is used with demographic (male/female)
variables and the studys target variables (taken
overseas assignment).
The technique uses tables having rows and
columns that correspond to the levels or code
values of each variables categories.

SPSS Cross-Tabulation Cont.


Row and column totals, called marginals,
appear at the bottom and right margins of
the table.
When tables are constructed for statistical
testing, we call them contingency tables and
the test determines if the classification
variables are independent of each other.

SPSS Cross-Tabulation Cont.

SPSS Cross-Tabulation Cont.


The figure is an example of a computergenerated cross-tabulation. This table has two
rows for gender and two columns for assignment
selection.
The combination produces four cells. Depending
on what you request for each cell, it can contain
a count of the cases of the joint classification
and also the row, column, and/or the total
percentages.

Percentages in Cross-Tabulation
Percentages serve two purposes in data
presentation.
They simplify the data by reducing all numbers
to a range from 0 to 100. (Standardize)
They also translate the data into standard form
with a base of 100 for relative comparisons.

Percentages in Cross-Tabulation Cont.

Percentages in Cross-Tabulation Cont.


One can see in the figure that the percentage of
females selected for overseas assignments rose
from 15.8 to 22.5 percent of their respective
samples. (Female and Yes)(Row %
Among all overseas selectees, in the first study,
21.4% were women, while in the second study,
37.5% were women.
The tables verify an increase in women with
overseas assignments, but we cannot conclude
that their gender had anything to do with the
increase.

Recap
Frequency refers to number of times various sub
categorizes occur in the same pattern.
Frequencies can also be visually displayed as
bar charts, histograms, or pie charts.
Histogram is graphical bar chart.
The stem-and-leaf presents actual data values
that can be inspected directly.

Recap Cont.
A boxplot reduces the detail of the stem-and-leaf
display.
Cross-tabulation is a technique for comparing
data from two or more categorical variables.
Percentages serve two purposes in data
presentation.

Research Methodology

Lecture No :24

Recap Lecture
In the last lecture we discussed about:
Frequencies
Bar charts and pie charts
Histogram
Stem and leaf display
Pareto diagram
Box plot
SPSS cross tabulation

Lecture Objectives
Getting the feel for the data
Measure of central tendency
Measure of Dispersion
Relationship Between Variables
Test

Lecture Objectives Cont.


Testing the goodness of data
Reliability
Cronbachs alpha
Split half
Validity
Factorial
Criterion
Convergent
Discriminant

Measure of Central Tendency


There are three measures of central tendency
1. The mean
2. The median
3. The mode

Measure of Central Tendency Cont.


The mean
The mean or the average, is a measure of
central tendency that offers a general picture of
the data.
The mean or average of a set of, say, ten
observations, is the sum of ten individual
observations divided by ten (the total no of
observations).
(54+50+35+67+50)/5=51.2

Measure of Central Tendency Cont.


The median
The median is the central item in a group of
observations when they are arrayed in either an
ascending or a descending order.
35,50,50,54,67------50

Measure of Central Tendency Cont.


The mode
In some cases, a set of observations does not
lend itself to meaningful representation through
either the mean or the median, but can be
signified by the most frequently occurring
phenomenon.
54,50,35,67,50-----50

Measure of Dispersion
Dispersion is the variability that exist in a set of
observations.
Two sets of data might have the same mean, but
the dispersion could be different.

mean
sdv

54
50
50

34
50
50

35

35

67

87

51.2

51.2

11.43241

21.46392

Measure of Dispersion Cont.


The three measures of dispersions connected with
the mean are
1. The range
2. The variance
3. The standard deviation

Measure of Dispersion Cont.


The range
Range refers to the extreme values in a set of
observations.
54,50,35,67,50
(35,67)

Measure of Dispersion Cont.


The variance
The variance is calculated by subtracting the
mean from each of the observations in the data
set, taking a square of this difference, and
dividing the total of these by the number of
observations.

Measure of Dispersion Cont.


The standard deviation
Another measure of dispersion for interval and
ratio scaled data, offers an index of the spread
of a distribution or the variability in the data.
It is a very commonly used, measure of
dispersion, and is simply square root of the
variance.

Relationship Between Variables


Parametric tests from testing relationship
between variables such as Person Correlation
using interval and ratio scales
Nonparametric tests are available to assess the
relationship between variables measured on a
nominal or an ordinal scale.
Spearmans rank correlation and Kendalls rank
correlation are used to examine relationships
between interval and/or ratio variables.

Pearson Correlation

Rank Correlations
To test the strength and direction of
association that exists between two
variables
The variables are using ordinal scale
E.g Students score in two different exams
i.e. English and Math
Correlations (SPSS)
Bi vitiate
Spearman
Check for value of r and P

Relationship Between Nominal Variables:


Test
Sometimes we want to know if there is a
relationship between two nominal variables or
whether they are independent of each other.
The test compares the expected frequencies
(based on the probability) and the observed
frequency.

Testing Goodness of Data


Goodness of data can be tested by two measures
Reliability
Validity

Reliability
The reliability of a measure is established by
testing for both consistency and stability.
Consistency indicates how well the items
measured a concept having together as a set.

Reliability Cont.
Cronbachs alpha is a reliability coefficient that
indicates how well the items in a set are
positively correlated to one another.
Cronbachs alpha is computed in terms of the
average intercorrelations among the items
measuring the concept.
The closer Cronbachs alpha is to one, the
higher the internal consistency reliability.

Reliability Cont.
Another measure of consistency reliability used
in specific situations is the split half reliability
coefficient.
Split half reliability is obtained to test for
consistency when more than one scale,
dimensions, or factor is assessed.

Validity
Factorial validity can be established by
submitting the data for factor analysis.
Factor analysis reveals whether the dimensions
are indeed tapped by the items in the measure,
as theorized.

Validity Cont.
Criterion related validity can be established by
testing for the power of the measure to
differentiate individuals who are known to be
different.

Validity Cont.
Convergent validity can be established when
there is high degree of correlation between two
different sources responding to the same
measure.
Example: Both supervisors and subordinates
respond similarly to a perceived reward system
measure administered to them.

Validity Cont.
Discriminant validity can be established when
two distinctly different concepts are not
correlated to each other .
Example: Courage and honesty, leadership and
motivation, attitudes and behaviors.

SPSS
Cronbach Alpha (Reliability)
Factor Analysis (Validity)

Recap
Goodness of data is measured by reliability and
validity.
Three measures of central tendency: mean,
median and mode.
Dispersion is the variability.
Three measures of dispersion are: range,
variance and standard deviation.
Correlation
SPSS Cronbach Alpha (Reliability) Factor
Analysis (Validity)

Research Methodology

Lecture No :25
(Hypothesis Testing Difference in Groups)

Recap
Goodness of data is measured by reliability and
validity.
Three measures of central tendency: mean, median
and mode.
Dispersion is the variability.
Three measures of dispersion are: range, variance
and standard deviation.
Correlation
SPSS Cronbach Alpha (Reliability) Factor Analysis
(Validity)

Hypotheses Testing
Difference between groups
Relationship between variables

Types of Hypotheses
Null
that no statistically significant difference exists between
the groups
No Statistically significant relationship exists between
variables
Alternative
logical opposite of the null hypothesis
that a statistically significant difference does exist
between groups
That statistically significant relationship exists

Choose Appropriate Tests


Based on the number of variables
i.e. two variables relationship (Univariate)and
many variables (Multivariate) statistical techniques.
The type of scales Nominal, Ordinal(Non Metric) ,
Interval and Ratio(Metric) used choose appropriate
tests
See page 338 of the text book.

Computer Outputs
See the output results of the computer generated
outputs indicating the significance level.

Testing for Statistical Significance


State the null hypothesis
Choose the statistical test
Select the desired level of significance
Compute the calculated difference value
Obtain the critical value
Usually the software now provides the standard
significance values and the f or t values. Based on the
significance level value one can interpret the test
Interpret the test

Selected Group Difference Cases


Group difference
Testing single mean
Testing two related means (ratio)
Testing two related samples when data is in
ordinal / nominal
Testing two in unrelated means
Testing when more than two groups on their
mean scores

Testing a hypothesis about a


single mean
One sample t test
Mean of the population from which a sample
is drawn is equal to comparison standard.
i.e. we known that the in general the students
on an average study for 32 hours.
Now you want to test that the students at VCIIT which are part of the student population
study less.

So the sample of V-CIIT differ from the rest of the


population needs to be tested.
Hypothesis generated would be
Ho: The number of study hours of students V_CIIT is
equal to the number of hours studied in
general.(same)(no difference)
Ha: The number of hours students of V_CIIT is less
then the number of hours studied in general (< )

SPSS
Analysis Compare means One sample T Test.
Say you set the significance level to 0.05 then
See the output results of generated from the
software. See if the differences are significant or the
relationship significant. (lecture 6-7)
If the differences are not significant then we accept
the null hypotheses other wise accept the alternate
Out Put (T value and significance level)

Testing hypotheses about two related means


Paired samples t-test
Examine the difference in the same group before and
after the treatment
Performance before training and after training
Two observation each employee
Null hypothesis
There is no difference between the performance
of before and after the training

SPSS
use pair t test and see the value of t and its
significance level
If the differences are not significant then we accept
the null hypotheses other wise accept the alternate
Meaning the before and after training there was no
change i.e. Null hypothesis is accepted
There is no difference between the performance
of before and after the training

Non Parametric Test for paired sampled


When population cannot be assumed to be normally
be assumed distributed
Use Wilcoxon singed rank test ,
Use McNemars test for non parametric and nominal
data

Testing about two unrelated means


Group difference when groups are not related
and variable of interest data is in interval and
ratio scales.
E.g: Groups MBA and Non MBA compared on
sales achieved.
SPSS Analyze Compare means
Independent samples T Test
If more than two groups use ANOVA ( sales by
different level of education(Metric, FA,
BA/BS,Masters )

SPSS excercises

Research Methodology

Lecture No :26
(Hypothesis Testing Relationship)

Recap
Null and Alternate hypotheses
Choosing the appropriate test based on
number of variables and the type of scales
Setting criteria for acceptance and rejection
(significance level)
Group difference

Objective
Hypothesis testing the
relationship/Association
Correlations
Regression

We already know
Descriptive versus Inferential Statistics
Statistic versus Parameter
Continuous(Ratio, Interval) versus Discrete
Variables (Nominal, Ordinal)
Measures of Central Tendency
Measures of Variability
Parametric (data normal distribution) Vs.
Nonparametric (no need for normal
distribution)

Measure association
Pearson correlation coefficient
r symbolized the coefficient's estimate of linear
association based on sampling data
Correlation coefficients reveal the magnitude and
direction of relationships
Coefficients sign (+ or -) signifies the direction of
the relationship
Assumptions of r
Linearity
Bivariate normal distribution

Correlations among Variables

Regression
Inferential statistics
Simple Regression
(One independent and One Dependent variable)
Lowering the salary influences the performance

Multiple Regressions
When simultaneously multiple independent
variables influence the dependent variables
Independent variables jointly are regressed
Need interval or ratio scale to use regression

R-Square is the value which indicates that the


amount of variance explained on the dependent
variable by the independent variable.
X Y
Y=f(x)
Y=a+bx1+e
Here, x is person birth year, while a and b symbolize
constants (fixed numbers).
These constants are the regression coefficients, or, to
be more exact, the a is often called the constant or
the intercept

while the b is called variable xs regression


coefficient because it determines how the
predicted y values change as the value of x
changes.
The value of R-Square is between 0 and 1
Say we receive R-Square value .11 and sign
level is 0.099 and standard error is 0.80
constant is 0.04

It means that 11 percent of variance in the


dependent variable is explained by the
independent variable and the chances of it
not to be true is 9 to 10 percent.
In case there are multiple independent
variables then we need to see their separate
contribution

Multi Regression

Stepwise Multi Regression

The independent variables are customer


perceptions of
1) cost/speed valuation,
2) security, and
3) reliability.
In model 3, reliability is added. Looking at the
R2 column, you can see that the cost/speed
variable explains 77% of customer usage.

The adjusted R2 for model 3 is .871. R2 is


adjusted to reflect the models goodness of fit
for the population.
The standard error of model 3 is .4937.

Unstandardized regression coefficients for all


three models are shown in the lower table in
the column headed B.
The equation can be constructed as
Y= -.093 + .448X1 + .315X2 + .254X3+0.497

Standardized regression coefficients are


shown in the column labeled Beta.
Standard error is a measure of the sampling
variability of each regression coefficient.

Examples
A study in behavior consider many variables
influencing the an individual intentions
The researcher is interested to test the role of
attitude , subjective norms and perceived
behavior control.
They theorize the model as attitude ,
subjective norms and perceived behavior
control effects the intentions.

They also hypothesize that attitude influence


the intentions in positive manner.
They hypothesize that subject norms have
positive effect on intentions.
They also hypothesize that perceived
intentions control effects the behavior in
positive way.

They also hypothesize that attitude, subjective


norms, perceived behavior control will
significantly explain the variability in the
intentions
Attitude, subjective norm and Perceived
Behavior control effect the intnetions of the
individual.
Model equation: Int=f(Att,Pbc,SN)

The correlations between the different


variables are
Correlations
Attitude

SubNorm

PBC

Intent

Behavior

Pearson Correlation
Sig. (2-tailed)
N
Pearson Correlation
Sig. (2-tailed)
N
Pearson Correlation
Sig. (2-tailed)
N
Pearson Correlation
Sig. (2-tailed)
N
Pearson Correlation
Sig. (2-tailed)
N

Attitude
1

SubNorm
.472**
.000
60
60
.472**
1
.000
60
60
.665**
.505**
.000
.000
60
.767**
.000
60
.525**
.000
60

60
.411**
.001
60
.379**
.003
60

**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).

PBC
.665**
.000
60
.505**
.000
60
1
60
.458**
.000
60
.496**
.000
60

Intent
Behavior
.767**
.525**
.000
.000
60
60
.411**
.379**
.001
.003
60
60
.458**
.496**
.000
.000
60
1
60
.503**
.000
60

60
.503**
.000
60
1
60

Model Summary
Model
1

R
.774a

R Square
.600

Adjusted
R Square
.578

Std. Error of
the Estimate
2.48849

a. Predictors: (Constant), PBC, SubNorm, Attitude

ANOVAb
Model
1

Regression
Residual
Total

Sum of
Squares
519.799
346.784
866.583

df
3
56
59

Mean Square
173.266
6.193

a. Predictors: (Constant), PBC, SubNorm, Attitude


b. Dependent Variable: Intent
Coefficientsa

Model
1

Attitude
SubNorm
PBC

Standardized
Coefficients
Beta
.807
.095
-.126

a. Dependent Variable: Intent

t
6.966
.946
-1.069

Sig.
.000
.348
.290

F
27.980

Sig.
.000a

SPSS and Regression

Research Methodology

Lecture No :27
(Sample Research Project Using SPSS Part -A)

Recap
Hypothesis testing the
relationship/Association
Correlations
Regression

Objective
Develop a research project from the start
Problem definition
Importance of research
Gap
Research objective/ questions
Introduction and Literature review
Theoretical framework
Methodology

Apply SPSS for Data Analysis

Research Area and Problem


Knowledge
Projects Knowledge
Senior Project Manager do not share their
knowledge

Importance of the issue


Experienced project managers can pass on their
knowledge to their juniors which allow them to
become better project managers.
Training costs in millions and yet the area focused
is seldom achieved but with senior project
managers can deliver knowledge which is very
pertinent to your customer and your
organization.
Organization can gain efficiency and have higher
success rate , etc..

Gap
A number of researcher have conducted research
to find the antecedents to knowledge sharing (ref
ref ..ref..)
Among them some also have explored the
knowledge sharing from the cognitive level (ref
., ref ..)
But just one has studied knowledge sharing from
the project management aspect and
recommends that more research is needed (ref
.)

Introduction

What is knowledge
What is a project
Role of Project manager
Specifics of project experience
Behavior and Intentions
Intentions formation
Theory of Reasoned Action

Theory of Reasoned Action

Attitude towards sharing


PROJECT knowledge
Intention to share
PROJECT knowledge
Subjective Norm for
sharing PROJECT
knowledge
(Normative Belief &
Motivation to Comply)

Intentions are influenced by attitude and


subjective norms
The subjective norms concept is
operationalized to have 2 sub dimensions
Norms Belief
Motivation to Comply

Literature Review
Knowledge sharing can be defined as a process of
conveying knowledge from a person to another and also to
collect shared knowledge through information and
technology (Hwie Seo et al., 2003)..
Riege (2005) lists three dozen of these barriers which need
to be addressed in order to implement a knowledge
management strategy. One way to understand the effect of
these barriers is through the Theory of Reasoned Action
(TRA). TRA helps us understand the cognitive process of
formation of intentions and it has been successfully used in
numerous studies to understand intentions and predict
behavior (Sheppard et al., 1998)
One study by tried to study the .knowledge sharing of
projects .. and recommended more to be conducted..

Objectives of Research/ Research


Questions
To develop a better understanding as to how knowledge
sharing behavior is formed IN THE PROJECT MANGERS.

Through the cognitive (mental)process of intentions formation


Through studying intention difference between different
demographic variables

To what extent does attitude influence intentions for


sharing of project knowledge ?
To what extent does subjective norms influence intentions
for sharing of project knowledge ?
Does attitude for project knowledge mediates the
relationship between subjective norm and intentions ?
Is there a difference between the intentions to share
project knowledge and the gender?

Theoretical Framework
The attitude towards a specific action will lead to formation
of intentions , which will lead to the behavior ..
Knowledge sharing is one such act , if you have attitude
towards sharing then you would also show intent to share.
The norms influences the behavior, individual get
influenced by the people around them specially the people
who they consider important. If the norms of the important
people is to share then and then individuals are influenced
by that but it also important that to note that individuals
motivation to comply with the norm is also important ins
determining the effect norms in an organization

So we theorize that the attitude for sharing ones


knowledge on certain ( types )projects would lead to
formation intentions to share that knowledge and
ultimately it would lead to actual sharing.
So we theorize that the norms for sharing ones
knowledge on certain (types) projects in an
organization by the important people would lead to
formation of intentions to share provided the
individual also have motivation to comply to the
norms.
Norms have direct impact on intentions and also
indirect impact through attitude as well

Schematic Diagram
Attitude
towards
sharing
project
knowledge
Subjective
Norm for
sharing projects
knowledge

Normative Belief

Motivation to
Comply

position
Nature

Intention to
share project
knowledge

Hypotheses

H1: The higher the attitude towards projects knowledge sharing the
higher the intentions to share PROJECT knowledge.

H2: The higher the subjective norm of projects knowledge sharing the
higher the intentions to share projects knowledge.

H3: The higher the subjective norm the higher the attitude to share
projects knowledge

H4: The attitude mediates the relationship between subjective norm and
intentions
H5: The women have higher level of sharing their knowledge about
projects then men
H6: The project managers permanent /temporary positions at the
company would moderate the relationship between attitude and
intentions

Methods
Population : Senior I.T project managers in the 150 software
house of Islamabad.
Sample: Randomly select 50 companies and approach
around 150 senior managers to be part of the study.
A 5-point Likert scale anchored by strongly disagree (1) to
strongly agree (5) is used. It is ensured that not more
than 3 responses per firms are obtained.
Data collection: Adapted Questionnaire from (ref )
personally administered or Mailed
Feel of data ( Descriptive Analysis- Mean, Percentage)
Goodness of Data (Reliability and Validity-Cron Bach,
Factor Analysis)
Group Difference ( Independent sample T test)
Inferential Statistics : Correlations and Regression Analysis

Instrument

Attitude Towards PROJECT Knowledge Sharing [Adapted from Bock et al(2005)]


To me, sharing PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers is harmful..
To me, sharing PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers is good...
To me, sharing PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers is pleasant.
To me, sharing PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers is worthless...
To me, sharing PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers is wise
Affect of Subjective Norm Towards PROJECT Knowledge sharing [Adapted from Bock et al(2005)]
My CEO/Head of organization thinks I should share PROJECT knowledge with my coworkers
My Boss thinks I should share PROJECT knowledge with my co-worker
My colleagues thinks I should share PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers.
Generally Speaking, I accept and carry out my CEOs policy and intentions
Generally Speaking, I accept and carry out my Boss decision even though it is different form mine .....................................
Generally Speaking, I respect and put in practice my colleagues decisions

Intentions to Share PROJECT Knowledge [Adapted from Bock et al (2005)]


If given opportunity, I would share PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers
If given opportunity, I would share my work experience with my co-workers..
If given opportunity, I would share know-how or ticks of the trade
with my co-workers.
If given opportunity, I would share expertise from education
Or training with my coworkers..
If given opportunity, I would share know-why knowledge from work with my
coworkers...
Demographic: Please provide some personal Information
1. Your gender: Male Female
2. Your age? ____ (in years)
3. Your level of your education? FA/FSc Diploma Bachelor Masters PhD
4-Nature of your Job : Software Development/Support Networking Other( Specify)____________
5- Your Name: ______________________(* optional)
6- Your Organization:__________________(*optional)
7- Your e-mail : ____________________ ( Interested in receiving the results of this study) Yes No
8- How long have you been working in Information Technology Industry?
less than 1 year 1-3 years
4-6 years over 6 years
9-. How long have you been working with this organization?
less than 1 year 1-3 years
4-6 years
over 6 years
10- Your Position at the company is permanent of contractual
Permanent Contractual
THANK YOU

Research Methodology

Lecture No :28
(Sample Research Project Using SPSS Part -B)

Recap
Develop a research project from the start

Problem definition
Importance of research
Gap
Research objective/ questions
Introduction and Literature review
Theoretical framework
Methodology

Apply SPSS for Data Analysis


Descriptive and Reliability

Objectives
Analysis using SPSS
Descriptive
Reliability (Cron Bach Alpha)
Validity ( Factor Analysis)
Correlations
Regression
Interpretations

Schematic Diagram
Attitude
towards
sharing
project
knowledge
Subjective
Norm for
sharing projects
knowledge

Normative Belief

Motivation to
Comply

position
Nature

Intention to
share project
knowledge

Instrument

Attitude Towards PROJECT Knowledge Sharing [Adapted from Bock et al(2005)]


To me, sharing PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers is harmful..
To me, sharing PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers is good...
To me, sharing PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers is pleasant.
To me, sharing PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers is worthless...
To me, sharing PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers is wise
Affect of Subjective Norm Towards PROJECT Knowledge sharing [Adapted from Bock et al(2005)]
My CEO/Head of organization thinks I should share PROJECT knowledge with my coworkers
My Boss thinks I should share PROJECT knowledge with my co-worker
My colleagues thinks I should share PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers.
Generally Speaking, I accept and carry out my CEOs policy and intentions
Generally Speaking, I accept and carry out my Boss decision even though it is different form mine .....................................
Generally Speaking, I respect and put in practice my colleagues decisions

Intentions to Share PROJECT Knowledge [Adapted from Bock et al (2005)]


If given opportunity, I would share PROJECT knowledge with my co-workers
If given opportunity, I would share my work experience with my co-workers..
If given opportunity, I would share know-how or ticks of the trade
with my co-workers.
If given opportunity, I would share expertise from education
Or training with my coworkers..
If given opportunity, I would share know-why knowledge from work with my
coworkers...
Demographic: Please provide some personal Information
1. Your gender: Male Female
2. Your age? ____ (in years)
3. Your level of your education? FA/FSc Diploma Bachelor Masters PhD
4-Nature of your Job : Software Development/Support Networking Other( Specify)____________
5- Your Name: ______________________(* optional)
6- Your Organization:__________________(*optional)
7- Your e-mail : ____________________ ( Interested in receiving the results of this study) Yes No
8- How long have you been working in Information Technology Industry?
less than 1 year 1-3 years
4-6 years over 6 years
9-. How long have you been working with this organization?
less than 1 year 1-3 years
4-6 years
over 6 years
10- Your Position at the company is permanent of contractual
Permanent Contractual
THANK YOU

Reliability

Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's Alpha N of Items
.734
5

Validity (Factor Analysis)

Correlation

Research Methodology

Lecture No :29
(Sample Research Project Using SPSS Part -C)

Recap
Develop a research project from the start
Problem definition
Importance of research
Gap
Research objective/ questions
Introduction and Literature review
Theoretical framework
Methodology
Apply SPSS for Data Analysis
Descriptive and Reliability

Recap
Analysis using SPSS
Descriptive
Reliability (Cron Bach Alpha)
Validity ( Factor Analysis)
Correlations
Regression
Interpretations

Objectives
Moderation
Mediation
Group difference (Independent Sample t Test)

Moderation
Scenario
Anxiety level effects the depression level of the
individuals. But the relationship is moderated by
Anxiety Free days.
To test the moderation we need to have develop
hierarchical regression equations and see if there is
any change in the R-square. If the change is
significant then we claim there is moderation
Step 1 : Create a new interaction variable Anxiety
level * Anxiety Free days

Step 2: Due to the multiplication of variables there is


a possibility of number of problems such as multi co
linearity.
This can be avoided by creating the Z scores of the
variables
The raw mean score is subtracted from the mean
and divided by the std
So while running the regression then the Z scores
are used instead of the raw score.

Step 3: SPSS (converting into Z scores)

Analyze
Descriptive Statistics
Select the variables
Save standardized values

Step 4: SPSS (computing the Interaction variable with


z scores)

Transform
Compute
New variable (Interaction)
Target Z score variables (*)
okay

Step 5: Regression Analysis


Linear
Dependent Variable (Depression)
Independent Variables (Anxiety , Anxiety Free Days)
Next
Block 2/2
Enter the Interaction variable
Statistic tick Change in R-square
Okay
Results
Change in R-square and F statistics and F significance

Schematic Diagram
Attitude
towards
sharing
project
knowledge
Subjective
Norm for
sharing projects
knowledge

Normative Belief

Motivation to
Comply

position
Nature

Intention to
share project
knowledge

Mediation
Barron & Kenny method
HC
Hc
b

PF
PF
a

c=PF=f(HC)=0.374,P=0.003
a=cc= f(HC)
b=Pf=f(cc)

cc
=f(HC,CC)=0.12388,P=0.2053
If becomes zero then full mediation exists other wise
it will be partial mediation.

Preacher & Hayes method


Generates confidence interval between the 2 scenarios.
If the confidence interval include zero it indicates a lack
of significance.
If zero is not included then mediation is significant.
If there exists zero between upper and lower values
then there is no mediation.

Group Difference
Independent Sample T test ( Intentions and
Gender)
Anova ( intentions and education levels)

Miscellaneous features (SPSS)


Normal Distribution
Scatter Plots
Missing Values

Research Methodology

Lecture No :30
(Research Output Discussions and Report Format)

Objectives
Findings and Discussion section of the research
Research Report Layout

Two research articles and their findings would


be discussed.
These article have already been partially
covered
Now the focus is on the Results/Findings
section, conclusion and recommendation
sections.

Research Report Layout

Title
Introduction
A brief literature review
Research Questions
Theoretical Framework
Hypothesis
Method section
Study Design (cross sectional , )
Population and Sample

Variables and measures


Their reliability and Validity
Data Collection

Data Analysis
Discussion of Results
Recommendations

Research Methodology

Lecture No :31
(Revision Chapter 1,2,3,4,5,6,7)

Introduction
Overview of the course :
Business research is an organized and deliberate
process through which organization effectively learn
new knowledge and help improve performance.

Introduction
Overview of the course :
Business research is an organized and
deliberate process through which organization
effectively learn new knowledge and help
improve performance.

Introduction

Objectives of the course :


To understand and develop a systematic
approach to business research
To emphasis on the relationship between
theory , research and practice
To Integrate different research activities in an
orderly fashion

Outcomes of the course are :


1. To formulate research questions
2. Develop theoretical framework
3. Develop hypotheses
4. Learn to select from different research
methodologies
5. Develop skills for data analysis and
interpretation.

Research is a
Systematic effort to investigate a problem
Types of research
Applied (solve a current problem of org)
Basic (improve understanding of a problem)
Research Philosophical Choice
Deduction / Induction
Why managers should know about research
Identify problems , discriminate b/w good and bad
research, appreciate the multiple influences of different
factors ,etc.

Hall Marks of Scientific Research.


Purposive, Rigor, Testability, Reliability,
Precision/confidence, Objectivity, Generalizbility,
Parsimony
Building Blocks of Scientific Research
Observation, identification of problem area,
Theoretical Framework, Hypothesis, Construct,
Concepts operations definitions, Research Design,
Data Collection , Analysis, Interpretation,
implementation/refinement of theory

Problem/Literature/Question
Identification of the broad problem area
Preliminary information gathering through
interviews and literature survey
Problem definition
Literature Review involves searching and
documenting
There is a structure of review (importance,
objectives, definitions, relationships identified,
gaps)
There are different formats of Documenting (APA)
Based on the gaps identify your research
objectives/problem definition/research questions

Theoretical Framework and Variables


Theoretical framework is representation of your
belief on how variables related and why
Variables are of 4 different kinds
Independent, Dependent, Moderating, Mediating(
Intervening)

Hypotheses
In order statistically respond to the research
questions we develop the Hypotheses statements.
These statements are stated in such way that they
can be easily testable
Hypotheses statement are written in directional, non
directional formats for testing group differences,
relationship between variables.
We develop null and alternate hypotheses

Summarized Table of Statistical Notations for


Hypotheses
Relationship

Group Difference

Ho:

Ha:

Ho:

Ha:

Directional

=0

>0
OR
<0

a=b

a>b
OR
a<b

Non-Directional

=0

#0

a=b

a # b

Research Design
We covered some of the research design elements
We talked about the research purpose
(exploratory, descriptive, hypothesis testing)
Type of investigation
(causal, correlations)
Extent of researcher's interference
(High, moderate, low)

The Research Design


Purpose of the
study

Types of
Investigation

Extent of
Researcher
interference

Study setting

Measuremen
t
& Measures
1. Feel for
data

Exploratory
Description
Hypotheses
Testing

Establishing:
-Casual
relationship
- Correlation's
- Group
difference
ranks, etc.

Minimal: studying
events as they
normally occur
Manipulation

contrived
non-contrived

Operational
Definition
scaling
categorizing
coding

2.Goofiness
of data
Units of analysis
(population to be
studied)
individuals
dyads
groups
organizations
\machines
etc

Sampling
design

Time horizon

Data collection
method
3. Hypothesis
Testing

Probability/
Non-probability
Sample size (n)

one-shot
(cross-sectional)
Longitudinal

Observation
Interview
Questionnaire
Physical
measurement
Un-obstructive

Opertionalization
Measurement is necessary to give answers or to the
research question , or to test our hypotheses.
The opeationalizing of certain subjective variables
are necessary for measurement.
The abstract concepts are broken down to
dimensions and its elements.
Questions are formulated on them
Not to confuse dimensions with antecedents

14

15

Research Question/Items
for the five Dimensions

16

Scales
Measurement means that scales are used.
Scales are a set of symbols or numbers, assigned by
rule to individuals, their behaviors, or attributes
associated with them
Nominal , Ordinal, Interval, Ratio

17

Goodness of Data
Four types of scales are used in research, each with
specific applications and properties. The scales are
Nominal
Ordinal
Interval
Ratio

18

Research Methodology

Lecture No :32
(Revision Chapters 8,9,10,11,SPSS)

Data Collection
The Data is collected from primary and secondary
sources
The primary data collect via
Observation, panels, interviews, questionnaires etc
Interview are structure and unstructured
While interviewing there are certain guidelines
There are structured and unstructed interviews
There are some advantages / disadvantages of face
to face vs telephone interviews .
2

Questionnaire Design

Questionnaires
Personally Administered Questionnaires
Mail questionnaires
Guide line for wordings

Content and purpose (Subjective vs Objective)


Language and wording ( slang/technical)
Types of formats (open / closed ended)
Positively worded and Negatively worded
Bias/ Favoritism(Leading, loaded, ambiguous, double
barrel, socially desirable)

Length of the question


Funneling

Sampling
Sampling is the process of selecting the right
individuals
Sample is used to represent the whole data or
population
Sampling process include defining population,
sample frame, sampling design, sample size and
sampling process

Sampling
Simple random sampling and restricted sampling are
two basic types of probability sampling.
Probability: Probability of selection is known
Non Probability : Probability is not known

Sampling
Precision we estimate the population parameter
to fall within a range, based on sample estimate.
Confidence is the certainty that our estimate will
hold true for the population.
Sample size.
Some sampling designs are more efficient than
the others.
The knowledge about sampling is used for
different managerial implications.

Types of Sampling Designs


Sampling Designs
Probability

Non-probability

Convenience

Simple Random

Judgmental

Systematic

Quota

Stratified

Snowball

Cluster

Other Sampling
Techniques

Experimental Design
Causal vs Correlations
Experimental Design
Field Experiment vs Lab Experiments

Experimental Design

Experimental Designs
When to use experimental designs
Pretest and Posttest Experimental Group Design
Posttests only with Experimental and Control Group
Pretest and Posttest Experimental and Control Group
Design
Solomon Four Group Design

(Data Analysis)
Getting Data Ready
Questionnaire checking involves eliminating unacceptable
questionnaires.
These questionnaires may be incomplete, instructions not
followed, missing pages, past cutoff date or respondent not
qualified.
Editing looks to correct illegible, incomplete, inconsistent and
ambiguous answers.
Coding typically assigns alpha or numeric codes to answers
that do not already have them so that statistical techniques
can
be
applied.

Cleaning data for consistencies. Inconsistencies may


arise from faulty logic, out of range or extreme
values.
Statistical adjustments applies to data that requires
weighting
and
scale
transformations.

(DATA ANALYSIS)
Hypotheses Testing using SPSS
How to use SPSS for Data entry
Defining variables
Assigning them values
Assigning sizes and constraints
Data entry using data from coded Questionnaires
Serial number the questionnaire

How to generate simple descriptive


summaries

SPSS
Frequency refers to number of times various sub
categorizes occur in the same pattern.
Frequencies can also be visually displayed as bar
charts, histograms, or pie charts.
Histogram is graphical bar chart.
The stem-and-leaf presents actual data values that
can be inspected directly.

SPSS
A boxplot reduces the detail of the stem-and-leaf
display.
Cross-tabulation is a technique for comparing data
from two or more categorical variables.
Percentages serve two purposes in data
presentation.

SPSS
Three measures of central tendency: mean, median
and mode.
Dispersion is the variability.
Three measures of dispersion are: range, variance
and standard deviation.
Correlation
Goodness of data is measured by reliability and
validity.
SPSS Cronbach Alpha (Reliability) Factor Analysis
(Validity)

SPSS-Hypotheses Testing
Hypothesis testing(Difference between
groups, Relationship)
Null and Alternate Hypotheses
Choose appropriate test
Significance
Group difference

Testing single mean


Testing two related means (ratio)
Testing two related samples when data is in ordinal / nominal
Testing two in unrelated means
Testing when more than two groups on their mean scores

Hypothesis Testing
Hypothesis testing the relationship/Association
Correlations
Regression

Research Proposal
The purpose of the study
The specific problem to be investigated/problem
statement/ Research Questions
The scope of the study/what is covered and not
covered.
The relevance of the study/importance
The research design offering detail on
Sampling, data collection methods, data analysis,

Time frame
The budget

Research Report Layout

Title
Introduction
A literature review
Research Questions
Theoretical Framework
Hypothesis
Method section
Study Design (cross sectional , )
Population and Sample

Variables and measures


Their reliability and Validity
Data Collection
Data Analysis
Discussion of Results
Recommendations

Final Words
You have by now developed basic research skills not
necessarily become an expert.
But as a managers / students should be able
differentiate between good or bad research.
You also by now recognized research is an integral
part of the organization reality and can improve the
organization.
Should be able to appreciate that for any problem a
scientific way to address is by identifying its factors
and collecting data systematically on it so that the
results would be have some credibility in the industry
and academia as well

By now you should be able to logically


conceptualize the relationships among
variables
And able to carry out a small research project
With this WISH YOU BEST OF LUCK

Вам также может понравиться