MOGERE: Punish those who looted Mumias Sugar - Opinion | Daily N... http://www.nation.co.ke/oped/Opinion/Punish-those-who-looted-Mumi...

1 of 3

Print this page

26/3/2015

Punish those who looted Mumias Sugar

Although the cases of Mumias and CMC bear striking similarities, the responses of the
authorities have been very different.

Freshly harvested sugarcane. Although the cases of Mumias and CMC bear striking similarities,
the responses of the authorities have been very different. PHOTO | FILE
In Summary

The external auditors who abdicated their duty of giving a fair picture of the financial health of
the company must be held responsible for the mess that has brought Mumias to the brink of
collapse.

However, this does not augur well for the industry, because, as the capital markets grow, the
CMA will need to transform itself into an independent regulatory body with the necessary
prosecutorial powers to effectively regulate the markets.

The company and its CEO got top honours at that years COYA awards. Mumias won several
marketing and public relations awards, enjoyed Super Brand status, was ISO certified, and
received an A+ credit rating from the Global Credit Ratings Company a FiRe award for

10/12/2015 17:55

MOGERE: Punish those who looted Mumias Sugar - Opinion | Daily N... http://www.nation.co.ke/oped/Opinion/Punish-those-who-looted-Mumi...

2 of 3

excellence in financial reporting.

CLIFF MOGERE
Around the time that a damning forensic audit report shows that Mumias Sugar Company was

embroiled in fraudulent accounting and corporate governance contraventions, it stood tall as a

model of astute management.

The company and its CEO got top honours at that years COYA awards. Mumias won several
marketing and public relations awards, enjoyed Super Brand status, was ISO certified, and
received an A+ credit rating from the Global Credit Ratings Company a FiRe award for
excellence in financial reporting.

In the wake of what has happened at the company in the past few years, one would expect that
these plaudits should be recalled because, clearly, they were fraudulently obtained. Cases of

corporations using creative accounting to cover up fraud are not uncommon. US conglomerates
Enron, WorldCom, AIG, and Lehman Brothers did it for years.

The external auditors who abdicated their duty of giving a fair picture of the financial health of
the company must be held responsible for the mess that has brought Mumias to the brink of
collapse.

In 2006, when the directors and executives of CMC Holdings were found culpable for several

corporate governance contraventions, the Capital Markets Authority (CMA) was quick to crack
the whip.

Trading of CMC shares was suspended and the officials who were adversely mentioned were

disqualified from holding directorships in listed firms. A complaint against the external auditor
was filed with the disciplinary committee of the Institute of Certified Public Accountants of
Kenya (Icpak).

Although the cases of Mumias and CMC bear striking similarities, the responses of the

authorities have been very different. The CMA and Icpak have been strangely silent on the
contraventions at Mumias.
INDEPENDENT BODY
The CMAs inaction may be interpreted as a desire not to be seen as taking a stand contrary to
the official government position as the authority is, after all, an arm of the government.

However, this does not augur well for the industry, because, as the capital markets grow, the
CMA will need to transform itself into an independent regulatory body with the necessary
prosecutorial powers to effectively regulate the markets.

The Icpak does not have the capacity to discipline persons or entities that do not adhere to its

code of conduct. This undermines the quality of the markets financial reporting, casting doubts
on the reliability of the financial statements of listed companies.

10/12/2015 17:55

MOGERE: Punish those who looted Mumias Sugar - Opinion | Daily N... http://www.nation.co.ke/oped/Opinion/Punish-those-who-looted-Mumi...

3 of 3

If those responsible for Mumias woes are not brought to book, the culture of corporate

impunity will continue unabated, threatening the structure of Kenyas capital markets and
hampering the push to turn them into a global trading hub.

To echo the words of a former commissioner of the US Securities Exchange Commission, Mr

Arthur Levitt: If a country does not have a reputation for strong corporate governance

practices, capital will flow elsewhere. If investors are not confident with the level of disclosure,
capital will flow elsewhere.

If a country opts for lax accounting and reporting standards, capital will flow elsewhere. All

enterprises in that country, regardless of how steadfast a particular companys practices, may
suffer the consequences.

The writer is an author and the executive director of Clan Consulting Ltd.
cliffmogere@gmail.com.

10/12/2015 17:55