Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
If the Custodian fails to complete this form completely and accurately (responding to each numbered
item specifically as directed and providing a document index in table format), this form will be
returned to the Custodian for proper completion thus prolonging the adjudication of the complaint.
Signature:
Printed Name:
Job Title:
Date:
/E_RititA/v4)
tikes/ct_pa-7/1 - d-3
(4-0/s ./
17'grLd2g .7W
f bEKA/ww1}
/7/4 LP
2. Name of Complainant:
T/g,
a,- 5) Je
/vie cvjeis-7 f
S7e;v1)
I
/ue,,
qoo
Phone:
Fax:
E-mail:
Phone:
`7 3 )-
'71
Fax:
E-mail:
INDEX Amarked "A"- 1 page -An email from Harry B. Scheeler, Jr dated 9/11/15 at 2:09 PM
" Please provide me a copy of the NJSPCA Facebook page which lists all persons blocked and or
banned from the page. Please e mail this record in pdf form."
Custodian's response was a hand typed list of names marked "B" 5 pages as supplied from Rick YocumPresident of the NJSPCA. Response was provided 9/11/16 2:19 PM
Assorted e mails marked "C" through "G" clarifying what the requestor wanted. 8 pages
E mail marked "H" from requestor where the requestor indicates he has received 3 responses to his
request but wants to challenge the authenticity of the document.- 1 page
Item marked "H" supplied by Rick Yocum of NJSPCA printed directly from Facebook- 7 pages
INDEX B
Records are not required to be kept as they are part of the Community Services Division of the NJSPCA
Volunteer program.
INDEX C
Provided in Index A
INDEX D
No redactions
INDEX E
Request fulfilled
INDEX F
Request was not denied requestor wants to challenge authenticity of document supplied
-
10
A request was made by Custodian to Rick Yocum president of NJSPCA for input. Yocum reportedly
supplied a complete and accurate listing.
11
Documents were never destroyed on this matter.
12
Request was fulfilled in its entirety but requestor disputes authenticity of documents.
It is the opinion of the Custodian the GRC complaint has been filed in error or in an attempted harassing
manner in an attempt to intimidate and exploit the complaint system. The request was very simple and
eventually completed in a manner that the requestor was willing to accept.
The President of the NJSPCA, Rick Yocum, is willing to certify the document provided is authentic and
has not been altered in any manner. Yocum contends the Facebook page site is the Cummunity Services
volunteers pages and is not an official, sanctioned or approved site of the NJSPCA and is exempt from
OPRA but was provided in a spirt of cooperation.
10/8/2015
Please provide a copy of the NJSPCA Facebook page which lists all persons blocked and or banded from the
page. Please email this record in pdf format.
https://m ail.googl e.com/m ail/u/OPui= 28j k= e23998bec38,vi ew= pt&q. spca&qs= tr ue&sear ch= query&m sg= 14fbd99146b4c1587&si ml= 14tbd99146bad587
1/1
Page 1 of 5
Subj.
Date:
From:
To
Daniel lnnj
Pottimus Prime
Larry Vincent DeMaria
Heather Cam pione
Brogan Ellington
Peter Nicholas
Collin Gorman
Bob Cogswell
Muhammed Khan
Shanon Dunn
Steven Wronko
If
MaryAnn EA
Kim Zsamba
Peter Ashmead
Barbi Twins
Steve Butler
Scott Landis
Lisa Wolf
Sissy Liars
Jane Seltzer
Hailey Cowan
Joyce Chiro Moyer
Priscilla Ponte
Page 2 of 5
Diane M Redling
Pao Pinkert
Ashley Noble
Danielle Demchak
Mj Krasnoff
Katrina Elliott Vitale
Cat Needham
Claire Scarlett Smedley
Stephanie Ann
Dominique StLaurent
Cassandra Alyssa Kistler
Donna Zdepski Ripley
Victoria Lewis
Page 3 of 5
Emily Peirone
Mary Roman
Pat Gilleran
Rhonda Pickering
Cathy Rivera
Denise Rubright
Alexandra Somics
Maria Angelina Grasso
Pattie Moran Bonnett
Brianna Lynn
Jasm in Fisher
Karen Orlowski
Daniel Jordan
Kelley Brennan
Catherine Larose
Camille Delisle-Carrigan
Gino Mattucci
Hugh Liarson
Tiffany Raschka
Melanie Miley Glover
Mike Pravec
Collene A Freda-Wronko
Steve T. Farangelo
Rick Jocum
Lou Kenny D
Michael Destider
Craig Saltarelli
Amy Beth Guidroz
Jerry Gowen
Brad V. Arands
Patricia McMahon
Page 4 of 5
Michael Pucciarelli
Cody Buck
Russell Dale
John Micklewright
Nancy Beall
Regine Regy U
William Goble
Jeremy Heiser
Adam Sampson
Nj Quirke
Shelby Miller
Donald Sullivan
Thomas Mclaughlin
Kenny Schweighardt
Ed Baumbarger Sr
Karen Banda
Garrett BugaBoo Flagg
Ferenc Helyes
Jason Stanley
Anthony Donofrio
Carrie Lynn
Joey Guadagno
Nick Downhill
Nate Chambers
Tammy Bangoura
Sylvia Wells
Corazon Tiongson
Daun Simpson-Graham
Puja Banerjee
Sandy DeShay-Hickman
Page 5 of 5
Lynne Morgan
Ken Owner
Francisco "Francisquinho"
Julie Wiley
Tracey Bradshaw
Alex Gruenfeld
Mark Happe
Carlos Dougie Gutierrez
On 2015-07-24 18:27, BIERMANNJB@aol.com wrote.
> Please advise
>
> From: tipsterforanimals@gmail.com
> To: BIERMANNJB@aol.com
> Sent 7/24/2015 72413 P M Eastern Daylight Time
> Subj: Opra Request
> Please provide me with all individuals that are banned from the NJ
> SPCA facebook page, as of today July 24, 2015. This is an OPRA request
> pursuant to New Jersey State Law.
> Thank You for your time
Page 1 of 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
CC:
BIERMANNJBaol.com
harrvrescue911qmail.com
rvocumnispca.orq, biermannib(aaol.com
e_ tApeilli/Jj
pi/N- 1
F R, eLi7
em u
-r-,
1018/2015
That is a list created on 7/24. I would like a copy of the actual record from today's date. Please print out directly
from the FB page.
[Quoted text hidden]
by4-
710P3
fskfured
1/1
10/8/2015
The NJSPCA states this is the current list for the data you requested and it is current as of this e mail.
In a message dated 9/11/2015 2:21:00 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, harryrescue911gmail.com writes:
That is a list created on 7/24. I would like a copy of the actual record from today's date. Please print out
directly from the FB page.
On Fri, Sep 11, 2015 at 2:19 PM, <BIERMANNJBaol.com > wrote:
In a message dated 9/11/2015 2:09:31 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, harryrescue911@gmail.com
writes:
Please provide a copy of the NJSPCA Facebook page which lists all persons blocked and
or banded from the page. Please email this record in pdf format.
-e-7100,1)5e
https //m ail. google.com/m ail/u/0/?ui= 2&i k= e23998bec 3&vi ew= pt&q=spca&qs=true&search= query&msg=14thda5aefdad967&sim1=14fbda5aefdad967
1/1
10/8/2015
That's fine but I want the original record not one recreated. There is a GRC decision on this issue.
On Fri, Sep 11, 2015 at 2:23 PM, <BIERMANNJB@aol.com > wrote:
The NJSPCA states this is the current list for the data you requested and it is current as of this e mail.
In a message dated 9/11/2015 2:21:00 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, harryrescue911@gmail.corn writes:
That is a list created on 7/24. I would like a copy of the actual record from today's date. Please print
out directly from the FB page.
On Fri, Sep 11, 2015 at 2:19 PM, <BIERMANNUBaol.corn> wrote:
1 T/4-cy
1/1
10/8/2015
I've attached a print out from my own Facebook page blocked list. This is what the record I requested should
look like.
On Fri, Sep 11, 2015 at 3:37 PM, <BIERMANNJB@aol.com > wrote:
We are unfamiliar with the source of the list. Please advise on what you would like to do next.
Rick- please respond to the NJSPCA account for me as there appears to be issues between that account and
the JBBMI account.
Thank you.
In a message dated 9/11/2015 2:24:40 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, narryrescue911@gmail.com writes:
That's fine but I want the original record not one recreated. There is a GRC decision on this issue.
On Fri, Sep 11, 2015 at 2: 23 PM, <BIERMANNJB@aol.com > wrote:
The NJSPCA states this is the current list for the data you requested and it is current as of this e
mail.
In a message dated 9/11/2015 2:21:00 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, harryrescue911@gmall com
writes:
That is a list created on 7/24. I would like a copy of the actual record from today's date.
Please print out directly from the FB page.
N"
Cs2'
c.-
Please provide a copy of the NJSPCA Facebook page which lists all persons
blocked and or banded from the page. Please email this record in pdf format.
https://m I.googl e. com/m ail/u/0/2ui= 2&k=e23998bec3&view= pt&q= spca&qs= tr ue&sear ch= query &msg= 14tbe16aedc ad257&ds qt= 1&si m I= 14tbe16aedcad257
1/2
ww
45
0
3
0
-t)
ssff General
fr i ends
Manage Blocking
Security
Restricted List
Block users
I parse:, :an no forger 1.o things you p ,ist on your tureline lad yo,.
a ,,O,IversaStol wItil you. or add you as a fnend Note: Does not incLade sops.
13(ipate in
Privacy
Timeline and Tagging
Melting
y Language
Notifications
:lame or ernaii
Mock
t Mobile
Followers
Apps
:4
Ads
n. Payments
pi
.
.
videos
.
.
.
!;ean!..ri
Block apps
ou block an app
,ce book. Learn more
,:1 ,01 rit for-ger .2-...:otaz,liuu or oat nun-puUic information about you :hiou-gh
Block apps
FarmVille Unblock
Yo%MDdd Unblock
Social Interview Unblock
Vthat Eye Your Eye Says Unblock
Block Pages
112
Page 1 of 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
CC:
Fwd: Mediation withdraw Scheeler v. NJ State SPCA, GRC Complaint No. 2015-316
11/6/2015 10:09:17 A.M. Eastern Standard Time
BIERMANNJBael corn
harnilevinlevincvphers corn
rvocurn(a.nispca orq, biermannibaoi corn
Rick and Harry- FYI- if memory serves correctly, this was all over "who was banned on Facebook page".
Initially he received a hand typed list and was unhappy. A follow up Facebook print out was supplied by Rick
and that did not meet his needs.
FYI
From: harryrescue911@gmail.corn
To: John.Stewart@dca.nj.gov
CC: Dawn.SanFilippo@dca.nj.gov , Samuel.Rosado@dca.nlgov, BIERMANNJB@aol.com
Sent: 11/6/2015 2:49:04 A.M. Eastern Standard Time
Subj: Mediation withdraw Scheeler v. NJ State SPCA, GRC Complaint No. 2015-316
Mr. Stewart,
In light of our previous emails regarding the past disputes between you and 1, I have
determined that mediation will not resolve this matter.
On October 28, 2015 the NJSPCA custodian contacted me to provide a 3rd response to my
request. I have concern with the authenticity of the records again provided as they do no match
the record / can create from printing a facebook blocked page.
It was my intention to question the custodian during mediation as to records authenticity. As
you are aware, I have been participating in past mediation without fully understanding the
confidentiality requirements. Due to the number of government officials I have caught lying in
their official capacity, its also ways been my intention to take action on intentional
misrepresentation of facts. If I can not hold a custodian to what they claim nor keep a record of
it, mediation is of no use.
its better for me to get an adversary to file a certification. That way if they are misrepresenting
the truth I can file criminal charges. In several recent superior court cases, adversaries
suddenly came up with records when we demanded certification they had none.
Therefore I am withdrawing my consent to mediation and look forward to what the custodian
will certify to in their statement of information.
Respectfully,
Harry B. Scheeler, Jr.
eA9-12-61m
Irl
In
Priscilla Ponte
NI Diane N Redling
Pao Pinkert
Ashley Noble
II
! Danielle Demchak
Mj Krasnoff
uolguitt3 ueBova
auoy:ueo JayieaH
augJd sniumod
full!
ialuea
poormiewv oponit
avail el euuean
Page
Messages
General
Notifications
Insights
Pubhstlrng Tools
Post Attribution
Mary Smith
Notifications
Nicole Santomauro
Page Roles
Apps
Eric Maak
Instagrarn Ads
Maria Stanley
Featurec
Banned Users
Debra Honan
Page Support
Judy Perkins
Activity Log
James Linden
In
James Linden
Beth Goldstein-Locascio
Denise Breslin
Deanna La Bella
Yvette Greenwood
Daniel Inn)
Pottimus Prime
Heather Campione
Brogan Ellington
Peter Nicholas
Collin Gorman
NJ SPCA
Settings
Help
Karen Banda
Ferenc Helyes
Jason Stanley
Anthony Donofrio
Carrie Lynn
Joey Guadagno
Nick Downhill
Nate Chambers
Tammy Bangoura
Sylvia Wells
Corazon Tiongson
Daun Simpson-Graham
Puja Banerjee
Sandy DeShay-Hickman
Lyr, M re
Francisco - Francisquinho"
Julie Wiley
Tracey Bradshaw
Alex Gruenfeld
Mark Ranee
Steve T. Farangelo
4.21
Rick Jocum
Michael Destider
W4-Flg
V.
Jerry Gowen
Brad V. Arands
r a
Lik
r
Patricia McMahon
Mic
el Puc
relli
r-"--
r 11
Cody Buck
Russell Dale
John Micklewright
Nancy EleaII
Regine Regy U
William Goble
Ii
Adam Sampson
NI Quirks
Shelby Miller
Donald Sullivan
Thomas Mclaughlin
Kenny Schweighardt
Sr.
Ed Baumbarger.
Cat Needham
tw
)1
II
Stephanie Ann
Dominique StLaurent
..
Victoria Lewis
L-1
al
Kathy McGuire
Deanna Terminiello
Anouk Busch
ir
Tammi Cole-Norman
Lisa Constantino
Am
Michelle Robertson
Maggie Burroughs
Sher Kirk
Emily Peirone
Mary Roman
Pat Gilleran
Rhonda Pickering
Cathy Rivera
Denise Rubright
Alexandra Somics
f.
yik
in
Bnanna Lynn
III ..
Jasmin Fisher
Karen Orlowski
Daniel Jordan
Kelley Brennan
Catherir t -
Camille Deltsle-Carrigan
Hugh Liarson
Tiffany Raschka
Mike Pravec
Collette A F reda-Wronko