Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: http://www.researchgate.net/publication/283278961
READS
51
5 AUTHORS, INCLUDING:
Yves Aurgan
Vincent Pagneux
Universit du Maine
SEE PROFILE
SEE PROFILE
RAPID COMMUNICATIONS
Slow sound in a duct, effective transonic flows, and analog black holes
Yves Aurgan,1,* Pierre Fromholz,2, Florent Michel,3, Vincent Pagneux,1, and Renaud Parentani3,
1
I. INTRODUCTION
Engineering flows that are transonic and regular offers
the possibility to test well-known predictions concerning
astrophysical black holes [1]. Of particular interest is
Hawkings discovery that black holes should spontaneously emit a steady thermal flux [2]. Although this effect
was originally phrased in the context of quantum relativistic fields, it rests on the anomalous mode mixing
occurring near the black-hole horizon [3]. This mixing,
which is stationary and conserves the wave energy, is called
anomalous because it leads to a mode amplification and
involves negative energy waves. Because of the precise
analogy between the equation governing sound propagation and that used by Hawking, these key elements are
recovered in a stationary transonic flow. Indeed, in the
acoustic approximation, for long wavelengths, the mode
mixing possesses the main properties of the one responsible
for the Hawking effect [4,5].
To complete the comparison, one should take into
account the dispersive properties of sound waves, which
have no counterpart in general relativity. (Note, however,
that dispersive terms appear in certain theories of modified
gravity where Lorentz invariance is broken [68].)
Analytical and numerical studies have established that
the correspondence is quantitatively preserved provided
the two relevant scales are well separated [4,5,912],
namely, when the dispersive length is sufficiently smaller
than the typical length scale associated with the inhomogeneity of the flow (which then plays the role of the
inverse surface gravity of the black hole). Therefore, there
is no conceptual obstacle preventing the testing of the
*
yves.auregan@univlemans.fr
pierre.fromholz@ens.fr
florent.michel@th.upsud.fr
vincent.pagneux@univlemans.fr
renaud.parentani@th.upsud.fr
1550-7998=2015=92(8)=081503(5)
081503-1
RAPID COMMUNICATIONS
0 Dt v p ; 1
where
c2S b
1
;
1b
2b
31 b3
:
b2
tanh
db
2
2
We then adjust the flow speed M to obtain
1
1
cS b1 p < jMj < p cS b2 :
1 b1
1 b2
10
081503-2
RAPID COMMUNICATIONS
12
Moreover, when the flow is also asymptotically homogeneous, for every asymptotic plane wave k
coshk yeikxk t , the sign of H is that of k k . This
relation will allow us to identify the negative energy waves
without ambiguity.
We can now proceed following the hydrodynamic treatment of [24]. As a first step, it is useful to derive a (1 1)dimensional equation from which an effective space-time
metric can be read out. When the (adimensional) wavelength in the x direction is much larger than 1, we can
assume that 2y is independent of y. As y 0 at y 0,
we write the field as
x; y; t x; t y2 x; t:
13
Plugging this into the action Eq. (10) and varying it with
respect to and , we get two coupled equations.
2O
4 0, where O
n
Combining them, we obtain O
is an nth-order operator in t and x . The quadratic term is
2 F x , where
O
F x
c2S bx M2
;
14
081503-3
RAPID COMMUNICATIONS
15
16
M3
:
bj
2 x cS M
17
V. SPECTRAL ANALYSIS
We numerically solved the set of coupled equations on
the 1 1-dimensional fields and , using the method
of [26] adapted to the present case. The results concerning
the incoming mode of Eq. (15) propagating in a transonic
flow described by Eq. (7) are shown in Fig. 3.3 We stopped
the integration for slightly below the critical frequency
max , where and A both vanish. We tuned the various
3
081503-4
RAPID COMMUNICATIONS
We thank Scott Robertson for his remarks on a preliminary version of this paper. P. F. is grateful to the LPT for its
hospitality during an internship sponsored by the cole
Normale Suprieure. We acknowledge partial support from
the French National Research Agency under the Program
Investing in the Future Grant No. ANR-11-IDEX-0003-02
associated with the project QEAGE (Quantum Effects in
Analogue Gravity Experiments).
VII. CONCLUSIONS
081503-5